Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

FLF, LLC

FLF, LLC artwork

Has Evangelicalism “Fallen from Grace” Into Either Partisan Politics or Political Silence? [God, Law, and Liberty]

Nov 13, 202618 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Today David considers whether evangelicalism has “fallen from grace” by looking at two post-election podcasts sent to him in which two prominent evangelical megachurch preachers (15,000 or more members) offered the “spiritual reasons” behind the recent “Blue wave." He subjects the “biblical worldview” espoused in those podcasts to thoughts on preaching Christ from Sinclair Ferguson’s book, ”The Whole Christ.” And he describes the two most notable political consequences of preaching the “biblical worldview” they seemed to espouse. He asks: Is this what Herman Bavinck meant when he said "our religion is done for" in the early 1900s?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Thank you for joining me for today's episode of God Law and Liberty and I'm your host, David Fowler. Before I launch into today's topic, which may be controversial, let me advise you that there are some helpful footnotes and some important scripture verses on my sub-stack page related to today's episode that you may find helpful. That's at Senator Fowler 94, Senator Fowler 94 at dot sub-stack.com. And if you appreciate today's podcast, think it might be helpful to another friend of yours, a person, please share it with them. There's no budget that I have to hire people to promote clips and promote the podcast. So it is what it is and you can help spread the word. But whether you do or not, I hope you will find today helpful and insightful. And the question is whether evangelicalism has fallen from grace into either partisan politics or political silence. Now until this week, just to be honest, I don't think I really appreciated the breadth and depth of early 20th century theologian Herman Boving's statement, which I quoted many times back last week. That Christianity was done for when Christians began to substitute doing the will of God for thinking about the nature of reality, called metaphysics, and about what makes the cosmos go round, called cosmology. But now, after the recent blue wave and particularly what I heard in certain post-election podcast analysis by two prominent evangelical leaders. I believe that if they represent the dominant way in which the gospel is preached or we understand our culture, then evangelicalism has fallen from grace, Galatians 5.4. And here are the two theses on which I will build my case. The first is that the nature of reality and how the world works can only be rightly understood in relation to our knowledge of Jesus Christ. The more we know of Christ, the more we rightly understand these two things. I've discussed this previously in multiple occasions. So I'll let those podcasts suffice for now. You can find them if you want, but there are scripture verses on my sub-stack page that would make the point for those who are spiritually minded. Second, evangelical preaching is not regularly and consistently focused on the knowledge of Christ's person and work on the cross and the necessity of growing in that knowledge. In a moment, I'll disclose who I rely on for that thesis. But when that is the case and consistent with Bobbi's description of the relation between the death of metaphysics and the death of religion, one of two things seems to have occurred or happened. Either conduct itself becomes a barometer of one's Christianity and increasingly it is measured only by one who you vote for or what one thinks on a particular political issue or alternatively we find that preachers and therefore those in the pews become increasingly silent in the sphere of politics because they don't know how to relate Christ and therefore really Christianity to politics. Now, the four going words are strong, so I will explain them using the same assessment about not preaching Christ made by a wonderful Scottish born theologian in our day very well respected, Sinclair Ferguson. And they're taken from his helpful book written mostly for preachers own legalism and antinomianism called the whole Christ. But please understand that the Holy Spirit first applied what follows from his book to me in terms of what I focused on in my spiritual life since I'm not a preacher. But the relevance of his words about preaching and their relation to politics came home to me this week like a thunder clap after I listened to those two post-election podcast and they were sent to me by evangelicals who liked them. They wanted my thoughts on the spiritual analysis of the election that those pastors provided. And Dr. Ferguson's observations about preaching hit home powerfully with me Thursday morning actually because not one issue these evangelical leaders thought Christians needed to stand up for in obedience to Christ if they were going to be Christ followers or follow Christ was in any way related to any knowledge of the glories of God resident in the person and work of Christ on the cross that we find in scripture. Now before I give you the text that I'm relying on note that I've modified the quotes in a few places to simplify the vocabulary. I've merged two footnotes into the main text and I've added some language and brackets that you could see on the sub-step page for the sake of clarifying certain transitions and Dr. Ferguson's thoughts. And if you'll email me or message me in some way I'll send a reply with a copy of the pages as written. Now, on to how Dr. Ferguson talked about how Christ just preached today and he begins with and then expands on an example in preaching that I've witnessed for decades but never previously appreciated. Quote, and it's a long one. Wherever the benefits of Christ are seen as separable from the preaching of Christ Himself there is a decreasing stress on His person and work in preaching and in the books that are published to feed that preaching. This is accompanied by an increased stress on our personal and subjective experience of salvation rather than on the grace majesty and glory of the Lord Jesus Himself. This might be illustrated by the way in which, for example, John Owen's work of the mortification of sin has undoubtedly been read by many more younger ministers than either his glory of Christ, properly titled Meditations and Discourses on the glory of Christ or his communion with God. That may be understandable because of the deep pastoral insight in Owen's short work but it may also put the practical cart before the theological horse. Owen himself would not have been satisfied with heirs or readers who learned mortification without learning Christ. A larger parodomatic shift needs to take place. What is required is a radical re-centering in a richer and deeper knowledge of Christ understood in terms of His person and work. In this context, note that the vast preponderance of New Testament passages speak of our getting into Christ and not of getting Christ into us. There is a massively greater stress on being in Christ than there is on how Christ indwells us, even though this latter emphasis is important. The New Testament emphasis, and our being in Christ rather than Christ being in us, gives rise to the suggestion that the undergirding theological emphasis is that our need is to get out of ourselves and into Christ rather than get Christ into ourselves. While there is a proper duality to be maintained, we are in Christ and by the Spirit Christ indwells in us, the fundamental dynamic in Scripture is centrifugal, that is the Spirit getting us out of ourselves and into Christ rather than centripetal, that is looking in at ourselves to see how we can get Christ into us. In light of this, it is probably a fair criticism of post-17th century evangelicalism that the Christ in us motive played a greater role than the we are in Christ perspective. This switch in emphasis contributed to an imbalance of the subjective personal orientation over the objective who is Christ orientation and an imbalance in the indwelling of Christ over the fundamental union with Christ. Paradoxically, therefore, evangelicalism on its pietistic inward-looking side became fertile soil for elements reminiscent of schlamokers, emphasis on the importance of the subjective feeling of the Christian in distinction from the rational and intellectual aspects of the gospel. What was sometimes often lost sight of in this subjective feeling-oriented context of evangelical preaching was the biblical, not merely academic or intellectual, principle that spiritual transformation takes place through the renewal of their mind. In the quote, let me just note here that he notes that there is a biblical principle about transformation through the renewal of the mind, and he says, but it's not merely academic or intellectual. I believe he's speaking to exactly what Abraham Kuiper said, and I've talked about the last two weeks, that reform theology has been reduced to dogmatics and to ecclesiology. It's become an intellectual thing as a counterpoise, I think, to the subjective emotive feeling side of things, but both, I believe, are errors. Anyway, how do we spot the move away from preaching Christ in a evangelicalism? Well, Ferguson provides two examples of how ministers, evangelical ministers, may not be preaching the knowledge of the person in the work of Christ. He begins with, again, the focus on benefits. He says, quote, this focus on benefits has a profound impact on how we understand and preach the gospel, and almost imperceptively, Christ Himself ceases to be central, and becomes a means to an end. This is why it's even possible to preach through one of the gospels with a focus on how we share the experience of the various characters and the narratives. And while this is proper in its place, it can easily divert us from the central question, who is the Christ, who is the gospel, and how is He equipped to save us? And here's the second example. We should also notice that knowing how to preach Christ from the Old Testament, or understanding biblical theology, or seeing the flow of redemptive history, or knowing how to get to Christ from any part of the Scripture, does not necessarily result in actually preaching the person of Jesus Christ Himself. Seeing Christ as the solution to a series of clues embedded in the Old Testament is not actually the same as proclaiming Jesus Himself in our flesh, bearing our sins, dying our death, and rising for our justification. The formula for preaching Christ is not identical to the persona of Christ, and we must never confuse hermeneutical principles with Christ Himself. The former did not die for us on the cross. The latter did, in quote. Now, Dr. Ferguson concludes this section with a couple of searching questions for preachers that really every layperson needs to ask and ask them of myself. And here are the questions. Is it possible that most preachers reading these pages own more books on preaching, and even on preaching Christ, than they own on Christ Himself? We should probably ask a further question. Is it obvious to me, keep in mind he's speaking to preachers, and to have been grossing concern that the chief focus, the dominant note in the sermons our preach, or here, is Jesus Christ and Him crucified? Or is the dominant emphasis, and perhaps the greatest energies of the preacher, focused somewhere else, perhaps on how to overcome sin, or how to live the Christian life, or on the benefits to be received from the gospel? All are legitimate emphasis in their place, but that is never center stage. Is the dominant theme, the lasting impression, the most natural word association, in relation to the preaching I hear, Jesus Christ and Him crucified, or something else? Now, let's come back to Galatians. When we depart from preaching the knowledge of Christ, who He is, and its vital importance, I submit that we have fallen from grace, because Christ Himself is what grace is. Knowing the fundamental importance to us, of the person of Christ, for understanding everything, whether you're a preacher or a layperson like me, allows Christians to move or transition a mere political argument about this or that policy or behavior, to who is Christ, and to ask, isn't that knowledge what Christians most treasure, what they most glory in, and what, or I should say who, here she most wants the other person to really know. But when Christ becomes secondary or even irrelevant in these discussions, then I think we must consider Paul's series of haunting questions in Galatians 3, 1, 3, that I've modified and supplemented a bit for the sake of our present consideration. Oh, foolish Galatians, who has bewitched you that you should not obey the truth, which is in Jesus as I wrote to the Ephesians in chapter 4, verse 1 of my epistle. I say that because before your eyes, Jesus Christ was clearly portrayed among you as crucified, Christ and Him crucified. This only I want to learn from you. Did you receive the Spirit by works of the law? That is by anything of your own self that you brought to God or by the hearing of faith. Oh, are you so foolish, having begun in the Spirit, are you now being made perfect by the flesh? That is by your conduct grounded in a continuing promise to yourself and to me, to God to do better? Well, personally, I might ask it this way. Is our righteousness measured by who we vote for, how we vote in comparison to the nasty and vile publicans among us, or how we think about this or that issue? Or is it only measured by the righteousness of Christ that we have only in Christ, and such righteousness as He, by the Holy Spirit, produces in us as we mortify sin, so that that surpassing greatness of the power will be of God, and not from ourselves, quoting 2 Corinthians 4, 7, the New American Standard. I believe that when Christians' political thoughts flow from their meditations on the person and work of Christ, not just how Christ has helped me, the imagination of those Christians will not be taken captive, Colossians 2.8, by the false Christ of Senator Terrell Areko, another like Him, or by the our morals are better than their kind of evangelical preaching. And it will also rightly center the political conflict on who we believe Jesus Christ is, because He's the center of everything, and is to have pre-eminence in all things. And when that happens, the knowledge of Christ will begin again to become that in which Christians glory, and that glory alone changes things. It actually changes everything. Thank you for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Once in a Lifetime Hike + Thanksgiving Concussion in China + Shenzhen Smuggler [China Compass]

    Nov 21, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Welcome to China Compass on the Fight Laugh Feast Network! I'm your China travel guide, Missionary Ben. Follow me (@chinaadventures) on Twitter/X where I post new/unique Chinese city prayer profiles every single day....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Plea To Wes Huff [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    Wes Huff's plagiarism controversy has raised serious questions about Christian integrity, accountability, and public repentance. In this special episode, Pastor George Sayour examines the allegations against Christian...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are Christians Thinking about U.S. Policy in the Middle East in Relation to the Person of Christ? [God, Law, and Liberty]

    Nov 20, 202625 minAudio

    Today David examines what “Biblical worldview value,” if any, Christians would place on the present nation of Israel in determining the United States' policy for Israel and the Middle East if objective knowledge of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 248. What Hinders Maturity in Men? [Leadership Now Podcast]

    Nov 19, 20261 hrAudio

    Tune into this episode of Leadership Now with Dr. Aaron Rock where Aaron provides some wisdom and insight into some of the things preventing men from growing in maturity. More Resources: More resources at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Should Government Enforce God's Law? Responding to Todd Friel [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    Should Christians support laws that force unbelievers to behave morally? Or does God forbid the government from enforcing biblical morality? In this episode of *The Magistrate*, James Baird and Josh Howard respond to a...

    Credit the people on this episode