Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

FLF, LLC

FLF, LLC artwork

Worldview, Education & the Stories We Tell [The Ezra Institute Podcast for Cultural Reformation]

Nov 18, 202627 minAudio

In this episode of the Podcast for Cultural Reformation, Dr. Joe Boot is joined by Sarah-Jane Bentley, the Ezra Institute’s Fellow for Education & English Literature. They start with education. Every classroom passes on a culture, so the real question is which one. Sarah-Jane explains how worldview shapes why we teach, what we teach and how we teach it. She makes the case that there is no neutrality in education, because every subject belongs to Christ, in whom all things hold together. The conversation then turns to literature. Sarah-Jane walks through how the great genres echo the story of Scripture. She covers tragedy in Macbeth, Coriolanus and Marlowe’s Doctor Faustus, and comedy’s movement toward a wedding feast, with Mr Darcy as an imperfect type of Christ in Pride and Prejudice. She also explains why Lewis and Tolkien’s modern myths keep their hold on us generations later. Her conclusion, following Flannery O’Connor, is that finding Christ in a story doesn’t shrink it: it gives it more weight and depth.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show.

Welcome back everyone to the podcast for cultural reformation. That brought to you by the Ezra Institute. Today on the show we are going to be interviewing our fellow for education and English literature. Sarah Jane Bentley. So stay tuned. Welcome back everyone to today's podcast. This is one of the digital resources of the Ezra Institute. We are a Christian world and life you think tank and cultural apologetics organization that seeks to engage the culture with the claims of Christ and to equip Christians early to think Christianly about every area of life. And so we are currently in a series as many of our regular listeners will know interviewing and talking to our fellows in their area of specialization. And today we've got the privilege of being joined as I mentioned by our fellow for education and English literature Sarah Jane Bentley. I think it's been quite some time SJ since you've been on the show but thank you for joining us today. Thank you Joe. If I remember right here I think it would have been six years ago in Canada when I last spoke to your podcast. Now that's embarrassing and so today we've I think we've got a great opportunity to dive into something that is very often not something that's at the top of people's agenda as it should be within the context of the Christian church. So just in terms of brief introductions SJ has been teaching for many many years. She's an English prof and she's also as you've heard a fellow of the ESR Institute. She writes, she speaks, she goes on a guest podcast and so forth. Currently she is teaching at Eton College and we are very excited about this conversation. Let's dig right into this and kick off with a fairly general question I think about education because education is one of the areas of culture. We often say at the institute that if you want to understand a culture, if you were an alien visiting planet earth and you were trying to understand the culture of the western world for example or the United States or Great Britain. The two things you would need to look at to understand the culture primarily would be its law and education. Education is one of the ways that a culture passes on its worldview whether that's implicitly or explicitly to the next generation. So I wonder if you could just kick us off by talking at that sort of macro level. What are some of the ways in which worldview paradigms actually affect the teaching of the core subjects that most people have done in school in the western academy today whether it's in high school or at the university. What are the ways these worldview paradigms actually affect the way we teach? Thank you Joe for this important question. I'm just going to reiterate that I am speaking in a personal capacity and so I'm referring to about two decades worth of teaching in a variety of different contexts and also as a Christian homeschool mom as well. So I'm not speaking particularly about the work that I do at Eton today. To your question, worldview completely permeates teaching. It is passing on culture as you inferred in your question and the question is not whether a child is going to receive a culture but which culture is a child going to be inculturated into through education. So worldview completely affects this. It affects the philosophy. Why do we teach? What is the purpose of the thing we're teaching? It affects the curriculum. What should be taught? And it also affects the method. How should it be done? Well do you informs all of those things? And so a thoroughly Christian worldview will acknowledge that there's no neutrality in education. So as soon as we ask this question, we're very quickly into the antithesis because every subject, every core subject in Western education belongs to the Lord Jesus Christ. He's the first one of all creation. And so because he is before all things and he is the end of all things and because all things subsist in him, then a Christian worldview necessarily permeates every aspect of teaching because education begins and ends in Christ in a Christian school. But God-centered education is teaching the child that he lives core amdeo before the face of God. And it operates on the basis that all of knowledge is revealed by God who is the creator of an ordered and knowable cosmos. So God is the creator of man. He knows us. He knows the student better than he knows himself. And Scripture is the light by which we walk. It's the lamp unto our feet and the light unto our path. Whereas the Christian admits that we can know nothing outside of the influence of the Lord. There is no knowledge. There's no brute facts. Everything is given. Everything is revealed. Whether that's the laws of mathematics, the rules that govern language, what color is, what music is, why we are pleased by harmony and why we feel tension when we hear discord. The whole story of the world from the beginning to now, all of it is created and revealed by God. And so we can see that there are two completely different approaches to education in these two different realms. But I'd also like to say that the worldview of Christianity in education, it's more than just a hermeneutic. It's not just a way of interpreting reality. Although it is that. But it is a person. He is the ultimate personality. He is absolute personality. So everything about Christian teaching also is about bringing a child into relationship with God. And so that the child's personality can be developed and that child can become who God has made him to be. It's the whole thing of neutrality. You started there and then you ended there with that particular question. And we talk about that a lot as a ministry. You know, Cornelius Vantill famously talked about two plus two making four. And that the Christian and the non-Christian have formal agreement that two plus two is four. But when you start to ask the most basic question about that statement, the agreement starts to evaporate about what numbers are and so on. And the non-believer uses two plus two equals four to get further away from God. Whereas Vantill says that the Christian is using two plus two equals four to further integrate their understanding under God and get closer to God. So there's two completely different ways of looking at the question. Let's just talk quickly about a worldview in the context of story because you'll be familiar with that expression. Meta narratives, you know, big stories, especially as it comes up in the whole debate around modernity and post-modernity. And the role that story plays in our lives, in many respects, you could think about worldview. And I do talk about a worldview frequently as a big story about reality. What is the story that you really believe about the world? What is the big story? The postmodernist claim that they've rejected metanarratives, but actually it's just the assertion of their metanarrative that they has absolute intent even when they are denying absolute. So we can talk about worldview in the context of big stories. So you're a specialist in literature. What are some of the ways in which, I think a way I put it here is in which some of these great stories can communicate values to the reader. The way stories are actually in fact conveying or communicating worldviews. I mean, perhaps the obvious thing that leads to my mind immediately is the way in which very cleverly, because of course, again, it's back in the press. C.S. Lewis's work, you know, the whole Narnia Chronicles and of course Tolkien's famous Lord of the Ring series, the way that they manage to communicate worldview and value and virtue, but through story that kind of sneaks past people's guardrails in a way that if, you know, me arriving as a Christian apologist to give some sort of lecture on truth, wouldn't get past those guardrails. So just talk a little bit. Tell us a little bit about how you think story is so important and how it can and does communicate worldview in the modern world. So yes, it's a, it's a, it's a story is a great gift because they're showing, not telling. And if we start with genre, that can really help us to see how stories work. So great stories have a genre. It's kind of like a pattern or a shape that the story will follow. So if we look at tragedy in a tragedy, you have a man who's neither holy god, a bad nor holy god who, who commits some kind of mistake and falls and his entire life is turned upside down. And at some point he's going to realize it either immediately or bit later on. And when he realizes it, he really suffers for that. He knows what he's lost and then he's punished. If we're in the Renaissance and you watch Renaissance tragedy, there'll be bodies piling up on the stage at the end. And the audience is a filled with a kind of fear. There's a terror and pity. Maybe they leave the audience, they leave the theatre thinking, you know, I really don't want that to happen to me. How can I, how then should I live? Or maybe they think, oh, the world is just this really cruel, random collision of events, you know, what does, what does that mean? How do I live in that context? So tragedy is, is really provocative. And tragedy we see man, man striving against the state or the gods and he strives and he's killed. And when we really think about that arc of that story, the greatest story ever told is there. Because tragedy has, at its heart, a man's life, a man wrestles with God and he dies and either justly or unjustly. And the thing about tragedy, though, is it's kind of incomplete. So there's no forgiveness or redemption usually at the end of a tragedy. It ends in terror and it leaves many questions for the audience. Questions like, what is justice? Who is the author of justice? So if we think of the genre of tragedy in the context of the story of Adam, Adam is the perfect man. He falls. But before he's cast out of the garden, before he loses everything, he's given the promise of the proto-avangel that there will be redemption that things will be put right. So tragedy is an incomplete version of that story. If we think of the story of Jesus, he's perfect. He doesn't fall but he comes down to, he's killed by a tyrannical state, by the religious rulers of the day. But then, of course, that's not where it ends. He rises again. And so these amazing patterns of these grand narratives, as they're called, are at work all the time in tragedy, making these stories dramatically interesting and significant. I don't know if you know the story of Correlinas, but in that, you have a Roman general who fights for Rome. He banishes Tarkwyn. He helps to set up the early Roman Republic. And then the people turn on him because he won't do what they want. And he is sacrificed outside the city walls. He dies a sacrificial death to save Rome. And it's a very moving story. But it's not an original story. Well, if we think of the story of Macbeth, another Shakespearean tragedy. Macbeth is kind of possessed by the devil. He kills a fairly good king. He becomes a bloody tyrant who's ruling for a time. And under his rule, Scotland becomes a place of pestilence, of famine. And then what happens at the end is that an army, basically an army of trees march upon his castle. So the imagery of the root and the branch of Jesse is there. And Macbeth is killed by one of supernatural birth, essentially, this character who hasn't been born in normal way. So there are, again, these echoes of the great stories of Scripture coming through all the time. And then at the end of the play, the Christian king, Edward the Confessor comes in with healing and cleansing of the land and things are restored. So I think also that Christianity has contributed a huge amount to stories in terms of enriching them. If we think back to pagan tragedy before Christianity had dawned on the West, the tragedy doesn't really have as much meaning. It's more like emotional manipulation. In classical tragedy, you have characters who are subject to capricious gods. The underworld is also a capricious place. You may end up in a lissium. You may not. And so in a way, the actions of the main character, the tragic protagonist are somewhat kind of arbitrary. And then a lot of the violence and the terror and the death becomes quite gratuitous. Why would we watch such a chaotic thing other than to excite our own perhaps sick fascination or curiosity with pain? But when Christianity dawns on the West, tragedy in a way gets redeemed, the very nature of tragedy changes because suddenly it's improved. The hero's conduct is no longer just arbitrary or a case of fate. It's not a gamble. Actually, the stakes now are infinitely higher. He stands to lose out on eternal bliss or to enter into eternal damnation. And so when you get a play like Christopher Marles, Dr. Faustus, another Renaissance tragedy, you have a doctor of philosophy who by his intellect kind of ascends all the way up close to divinity and realizes he can't quite get there. And so sells his soul to the devil to have divine power for a time. And at the end of the play, the tragedy is intense because even one of the devil's minions has begged him not to do this. He says this character, Mephistopolis says to him, I think thou Faustus that I who tasted the eternal joys and bliss of heaven, I'm not now tormented with 10,000 hells. And he says to him, for this is hell, nor am I out of it. There's no escaping from hell. And so at the end of that play, it's incredibly powerful because the clock is chiming and Faustus is going to be damned eternally. And there are no doubts there about the eschatology of his soul. So actually the antithesis, which Christians brought to light, really intensifies the effects of tragedy. And if we have time, I'll say how also comedy works in a way in this light. So in a comedy, stories that are comedy, essentially have a younger generation falling in love and then there's some kind of obstacle to this love, which usually comes from the older generation, or maybe it's something arbitrary like a law. And then there are these scenes of confusion and chaos as the young people work through these obstacles. And suddenly and supernaturally, the plot unfolds and the right people end up married and it ends with a feast and a wedding and dancing and laughter. And again, you can see that. It's been like a lot of modern Hollywood movies, in other words. Hopefully. So if they're good ones, yes. Well, at least the ideal of the romantic comedy is that the young couple are backling against some form of hostility or problem or difficulty. There's usually a moment in the story arc where there seems to be an insurmountable problem. It's going to keep them apart. And then in the best days of at least the filmmaking, the better stories, they usually end in marriage and happiness and so on. Is that what you're saying a comedy looks like in a sense? That's right. Through the ages. Yes, that this is the picture of human history. If we look at the night of the Bible, the whole arc, it begins with two young, phallian experienced people who fall in love and essentially get married. And then there attacked. There's a huge obstacle to their marriage. And the rest of history that's getting worked out, there's things descend very close to tragedy. And then at the end, all of history will end with a marriage supper of the lamb, which will be when Christ comes and redeems his bride, the church. And so comedy is thriving on the symbolic meaning of marriage, which is an entirely Christian idea. So you can see in comedy in a way when young people get married, there is a sense in which the old self has to die. They are too closely tied to their parents. There's a struggle. They have to mature and become young man has to become more Christ-like to be a husband. Young woman has to become more like a picture of what the church should be. Perhaps if I talk about Pride and Prejudice, it will illustrate this well. So one of my favorite stories, go for it. Yes, Mr. Darcy. So Mr. Darcy is a type for Christ. And just like throughout the Old Testament, the types of Christ are not perfect. They have flaws. Mr. Darcy is very prejudiced against the older generation of Elizabeth Bennett's family. She doesn't have very good connections. And he's very proud of his own heritage and the name, the old name of his family and the previous generations of his family. But what he has to do is lay down his life for someone completely unlovable, like Lydia. And risk metaphorically risk his life, his entire name and family reputation, to rescue Lydia from this devilish character, Wickham, in order to save his bride from shame. And this humble sacrifice that he makes that transforms him, then means that he gets to marry Lizzie Bennett, and it's an excellent marriage. So in this way, good stories, they can't be reduced. They can only be expanded. One of my favorite writers, Fannie O'Connor, says that. So if our opponents were to say, if you're just looking for Christian themes all the time in books, you're just reducing everything down to just the Bible. It's actually the opposite. If you're encountering Christ or the stories of history in a fictional text, then suddenly the book has gained a lot more weight and it has increased in depth. And so it brings us then into a closer relationship with the source of truth, who is Jesus. Yeah. So would it be in your view fair to say then that in some respects, in terms of the sort of redemptive arc of the Bible, and we've already covered it in that sense, like William sometimes summarizes it as, you know, slay the dragon, get the girl, that there is both the comic and the tragic element in the biblical account of reality. The biblical story of the age has both the comic and the tragic in it. But it all works out to, as you said, redemption and the reconciling of the things that stood in the, or the overcoming of all that stood in the way and was preventing the final marriage, the final eschatological goal of history, really, which is of course what the image that Pride and Prejudice wants to leave you with, which is after overcoming that problem and these moments where you just don't know how this is ever now going to work, how are they going to be forever separated by this situation? And then at the end, of course, Jane Austen doesn't go on to try and expand. There's no sequel, you know, looking at the domestic challenges of life, even in the Darcy household. But there's the sense that there's, I think the book ends, you know, with this sort of a moment of thankfulness in the parents that their children have made these good marriages and how blessed they are. So is there that, is there the both, you're saying that the comic and the tragic, really the great inheritance of Western storytelling are fundamentally abscriptural concepts? Is that basically what you're saying? Yes, absolutely. That, that, absolutely. And tragedy is an incomplete comedy. Tragedy stops before we get to the reconciliation and the redemption. And, you know, Renaissance writers, medieval writers, they were not interested at all in originality. They were just trying to retell the best stories in a new way to show it to us again in the same way that a musical symphony will take a sound and play that sound over and over again so you can really, really hear it. Yeah. So would you, would you put the, I don't want to put words in your mouth, but how would you account for the success of sort of modern myths like Narnia and Tolkien's Lord of the Rings that, you know, a century on, nearly, or at least they were probably writing to some degree about some of their experience in World War One, at least that's been some of the speculation. But 60, 70, 80 years on, Hollywood's making, you know, another round of movies out of whatever we think about the, what the, the, this latest version, how it might be butchered. The point is that there's this sort of irrepressible fascination with these stories. How would you account for the success of it of a children's stories like Narnia, even in the adult world, and really a modern, a modern myth like the Lord of the Rings, which would be, you know, perhaps more so than some of the amazing Renaissance works that you've mentioned or even one of my favorite authors, Jane Austen, let's face it, there's not all the people get into those stories in the way that perhaps they should to benefit from them. But they would have familiarity with those modern myths of those great Christian writers. How do you, how would you account for the success of those? Is there something fundamental to the human experience that makes those stories resonate with us in a particular way? Yes, definitely. Those modern myths are drawing from the well source of eternal myths, if you like, of timeless myths. And certainly Lewis and Tolkien were actually kind of in a pact with one another to try and through their stories prove that myths were true to make people look again at Christianity, not as some outdated kind of old-fashioned idea that were too clever to believe in now, but but something that was really of weight and something that had roots in absolute reality. So the stories that are true can just be retold in so many different ways and they're never going to die. They're always going to excite the imaginations of readers. And so if our children know their own story really well, if they are in, if they're kind of implemented into God's interpretation of history, then they're well equipped to read. I suppose whether a story is good or not, whether a story is drawing on all of the great things that reality is willing to lend to it, or whether it's, it's trying, whether a writer is trying to write intention against those things to try and redefine reality according to his own ideas? Yeah. Yeah. And I think, you know, even if you bring it up to the, even bring it up to the popular level of super heroes, the fascinating to seven degree at the popular level with the story of Superman, you know, in his, his, his parents, sort of Mary and Joseph type figures, he's disguised, he's super human, but he's disguised in humanity as Clark Kent. He's on this particular mission. I think his parents were El Jorral or they're basically drawn from the names of them for the Hebrew names for God. You can look at things like the world of the popular world of super heroes. And then you, and I think even about some of the movie writing of men like Clint Eastwood and the tremendous success of their filmmaking, they contain this same, the really successful ones, the really powerful ones contain this same sort of arc in my view. And so SJ, all that remains really is for me to say thank you to you. And also a personal thank you to you from the whole family, really, of the Ezra Institute, because you're not only a fellow of Ezra who contributes with articles and podcasts and behind the scenes support at events and programs that you come to and you input into for us, but also as a board member here in the UK, we're deeply thankful to you for your service to this organization and this ministry. And let me remind us all as we sign off that from him and through him and to him are all things to Godly the glory and we will see you next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Once in a Lifetime Hike + Thanksgiving Concussion in China + Shenzhen Smuggler [China Compass]

    Nov 21, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Welcome to China Compass on the Fight Laugh Feast Network! I'm your China travel guide, Missionary Ben. Follow me (@chinaadventures) on Twitter/X where I post new/unique Chinese city prayer profiles every single day....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. A Plea To Wes Huff [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 20, 202611 minAudio

    Wes Huff's plagiarism controversy has raised serious questions about Christian integrity, accountability, and public repentance. In this special episode, Pastor George Sayour examines the allegations against Christian...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are Christians Thinking about U.S. Policy in the Middle East in Relation to the Person of Christ? [God, Law, and Liberty]

    Nov 20, 202625 minAudio

    Today David examines what “Biblical worldview value,” if any, Christians would place on the present nation of Israel in determining the United States' policy for Israel and the Middle East if objective knowledge of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 248. What Hinders Maturity in Men? [Leadership Now Podcast]

    Nov 19, 20261 hrAudio

    Tune into this episode of Leadership Now with Dr. Aaron Rock where Aaron provides some wisdom and insight into some of the things preventing men from growing in maturity. More Resources: More resources at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Should Government Enforce God's Law? Responding to Todd Friel [Eschatology Matters]

    Nov 19, 202642 minAudio

    Should Christians support laws that force unbelievers to behave morally? Or does God forbid the government from enforcing biblical morality? In this episode of *The Magistrate*, James Baird and Josh Howard respond to a...

    Credit the people on this episode