Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Fireside chat with Cage

Fireside chat with Cage artwork

Roy DeMeo: The butcher of Brooklyn

Nov 2, 202611 minAudioSeason 2, Episode 79
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Gemini Lounge, Flatlands Avenue, Canarsie. DeMeo owned it. Crew: Anthony Senter (19), Joseph Testa (19) - "Gemini twins" - Chris Rosenberg, Henry Borelli, Patrick Testa, Dominick Montiglio, Anthony Gaggi, Joseph Guglielmo. The Gemini Method: Lured through side door, shot in head with silenced pistol, towel wrapped around wound, disrobed, hung in bathtub to drain, dismembered on plastic sheets, sent to Fountain Avenue Dump, Brooklyn. Tool kit: guns, ropes, knives, ice picks. Estimates: up to 200 murders for Gambinos 1970s-early 1980s.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Before he was anything else, Roy DeMeo was a butcher's apprentice, a boy in a blood -stained apron learning how a carcass comes apart along its natural seams, which joints give and which must be forced. He worked the counter of a Brooklyn grocery between the ages of 15 and 22, and whatever else he carried out of that trade, he carried out an intimacy with meat, with the mechanics of a body once the animating thing inside it has stopped. It would serve him later, in rooms that had nothing to do with groceries. He came

up loan -sharking as a teenager, pocketing hundreds of dollars a week off men who couldn't get credit anywhere decent. And by the time he graduated James Madison High School, he already understood the only lesson that mattered in that part of Brooklyn. Money bought respect, and respect bought immunity. Roy Albert Domeo was born to Italian -American parents in Bath Beach, Brooklyn, and started his criminal career in his teen years. involving himself in petty theft and loan sharking, the quick profits luring him deeper into organized

crime. In 1966, Anthony Nino Gaghi, a soldier in the Gambino crime family, noticed him and told him he could make even more money if he shifted his allegiance to the Gambinos. And through the late 1960s, Dimeo's prospects increased on two fronts, loan sharking with Gaghi and a crew of young men he was building around car theft. He built up his loan -sharking business further with funds stolen from credit union reserves, laundering the dirty into the clean and back again until the lines between them meant nothing

at all. The stolen cars were the real engine. What federal agents came to call the Empire Boulevard operation shipped hundreds of stolen vehicles out of the Port of Newark to Kuwait and Puerto Rico, and alongside the cars went cigarettes and pornographic magazines bound for the Middle East. There was a rhythm to it, assembly line and indifferent. The same patience he'd learned behind the butcher counter applied now to Cadillacs and Lincolns instead of sides of beef. At its peak, the stolen auto operation alone was paying off as much as $30 ,000 a week. And money like

that, flowing up through Goggi to the Gambino hierarchy, bought de Mayo a patience of his own from men who might otherwise have found him too wild to tolerate. Because he was wild. In the summer of 1975, a dispute with a young partner named Andre Katz a man tangled up with DeMeo in the stolen car business, ended in Katz's murder, the first the fledgling crew had committed together. A crew member turned government witness later testified that the killing drove DeMeo and his

men to decide that any future conflict would be settled the same way, through dismemberment, so the problem simply disappeared. No body, no crime. It was less a philosophy than an engineering principle. and Dimeo set about perfecting it with the same cold attention he'd once given a cut of meat. They called it the Gemini Method for the place where it was practiced, a blue -collar neighborhood bar on Flatlands Avenue in Canarsie, a joint called the Gemini Lounge that Dimeo kept quietly in his own name. The

duo, Anthony Center and Joseph Testa, 19 years old when they joined Dimeo's crew in 1974, became known as the Gemini Twins for how much time they spent there. and around them gathered the rest of it. Chris Rosenberg, Henry Borelli, Patrick Testa, men who drifted in as associates and came out the other side as killers. The crew in full ran to Roy DeMeo, Anthony Center, Joseph Testa, Chris Rosenberg, Henry Borelli, Dominic Montiglio, Patrick Testa, Anthony Gaggi, and Joseph Guglielmo.

The method itself had a terrible simplicity. Victims were lured in through a side door. And once inside, DeMeo would shoot them in the head with a silenced pistol and quickly wrap a towel around the wound, after which the body was disrobed and dismembered in a bathtub at the back. The body hung in the tub until the blood had drained from it, then went out on plastic sheets, dismembered, and sent on to the Fountain Avenue dump in Brooklyn. DeMeo kept a murder toolkit inside the apartment. Guns, ropes, knives, ice picks, the accoutrements

of carving and sawing. And the ritual began. almost without exception, with a suppressed gunshot to the head. Nobody knows the true count. Estimates run as high as 200 murders committed by DeMeo's crew for the Gambino family across the 1970s and into the early 80s. A number too large to be anything but an approximation. A rounding off of a decade's worth of men who simply stopped existing. Into this arrangement walked a very large, very quiet man from New Jersey. A man

with a face like a closed door. Richard Kuklinski came to the Gambinos through his relationship with DiMeo, which began when Kuklinski fell into debt with a member of DiMeo's crew, and DiMeo and several of his men went out to collect, beating and pistol -whipping him until the debt was settled. It should have ended there, a cautionary bruise and nothing more. Instead, once the money was paid, Kuklinski stayed in the orbit. He began staging robberies and other assignments for DiMeo and the Gambinos. among them the pirating of

pornographic tapes, and he earned, in his plodding, unhurried way, a reputation for reliability that DeMeo decided to test properly. One day, DeMeo took him out in the car and parked on a city street, selected an apparently random target, a man out walking his dog, and told Kuklinski to kill him. Without a word, Kuklinski got out, walked up on the man, and shot him in the back of the head as he passed. From that afternoon forward, Kuklinski was De Meo's favorite enforcer,

a man so unbothered by the taking of a stranger's life that even killers found him unsettling. In time, the newspapers and the documentary cameras would give him a nickname of his own, the Ice Man, for the frozen calm he wore like a second skin. And he would go on in later years, from behind prison glass, to tell interviewers that he had killed hundreds, among them, eventually, De Meo himself. It makes for a tidy ending. It is also, by the honest accounting of the people who have studied him longest, not a claim that

can be trusted. Kuklinski later claimed to have killed DeMeo himself, but, as with many of Kuklinski's claims, it is impossible to verify, and the men who actually knew how DeMeo died told a different story, one with no room in it for an outsider. DeMeo's climb through the family was slower than his climb through bodies. Castellano, who had taken the Gambino throne, did not want him made. Twice refused Gaggy's request on his behalf, a butcher's boy with too much blood on him even

for that circle. What changed his mind was not murder, but diplomacy. The Westies, an Irish gang running wild on Manhattan's west side under Mickey Spillane and later Jimmy Coonan, had become a problem for Gambino business in the city. and Dimeo, of all people, proved himself capable of brokering the peace between them. It was his pivotal role in the Gambino -Westie alliance that reportedly convinced Castellano to give Dimeo his button, and Dimeo was made in mid -1977,

put in charge of all family business with the Westies. He had earned, at last, the thing he had been earning toward his whole life, a formal place inside the only family that had ever really wanted him. It did not buy him safety. The same violence that had made him useful made him, eventually, a liability. In April 1979, DeMeo mistook an innocent 18 -year -old door -to -door salesman for an assassin and ran him down in a seven -mile car chase through Amityville and Farmingdale

before shooting him dead. The kind of mistake that draws precisely the attention an organization like Castellanos could not afford. By the early 80s, the FBI had a task force built around nothing but DeMeo and his crew. His international auto theft operation had already led to his arrest in 1981, and federal agents were investigating the crew in conjunction with a string of missing and murdered people, as well as the car thefts. And somewhere in the gathering weight of all that scrutiny, Paul Castellano a businessman

first and a gangster second, decided that Roy DeMeo had become more dangerous alive than any amount of money he could bring in. Castellano was worried that DeMeo might cooperate with the government, and he ordered his murder. It is said Castellano first asked John Gotti and his brother Gene to carry out the hit, and only after they balked did he turn to DeMeo's own crew to finish the job, a detail that carries its own quiet horror. The men he had raised, trained, and trusted inside the back room of the Gemini

Lounge handed the job of ending him. He was shot to death on January 10th, 1983, most probably by two of his original recruits, Joey Testa and Anthony Center, the Gemini twins themselves, closing the circle they had opened as teenage car thieves nine years before. DiMeo had sensed it coming. His son later wrote that in his final days, DiMeo was depressed and paranoid. aware that he would soon be killed, and had even considered faking his own death by having his son shoot him so he could lay low. None of it saved him.

On January 10th, 1983, DeMeo went to a meeting at Patty Testa's house and never came home. Ten days passed before anyone found him. His body turned up in the trunk of his own Cadillac, parked and abandoned at the Verona Boat Club in Sheepshead Bay, partially frozen. with a chandelier set on top of him like some grim final joke. The man who had built an entire apparatus for making other men disappear without a trace had been found exactly the way he had always promised

his own victims they never would be, in a trunk, in the cold, waiting to be discovered. There is a kind of justice to it, though nobody in that world would ever call it that. The architect of the Gemini Method, The man who believed that without a body there was no crime ended up as a body himself, delivered whole for the police to find, his killers close enough to have learned every lesson he'd ever taught them. Castellano got two more years of quiet before his own debts came due outside a steakhouse on a December night,

shot down by men he'd also once trusted. The lounge on Flatlands Avenue stayed open a while longer. It's back apartment empty now. The bathtub scrubbed, the ledger of the missing closed, but never, in any real sense, settled. As always, stay curious, my friends!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The called him The Oddfather…

    Nov 20, 202613 minAudio

    They called him Chin. Vincent Louis Gigante, born March 29, 1928, in New York City, grew up poor in a neighborhood that manufactured more wiseguys than the docks manufactured longshoremen. His people were working...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. THE DAPPER DON'S LEDGER: John Gotti

    Nov 9, 202610 minAudio

    Courts finally caught Gotti on ledger they could prove: murders of Castellano and Bilotti, racketeering, tax evasion that finally made Teflon peel. But entry for John Favara was never balanced by any court in this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. My Father Had Soulless Eyes — Barbara Kuklinski

    Nov 6, 20268 minAudio

    1941: Age 5. Father's beatings caused death of older brother Florian Kuklinski, age 7. Covered as accident - fell down stairs. Decades later when asked about brother Joseph's crimes, Kuklinski said only: "We come from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. JIMMY COONAN: The Kid Who Never Forgot

    Oct 30, 202610 minAudio

    Coonan's father never told it straight. He told it the way a man tells a thing that still hurts: flat, fast, no color in it. They came for him on a street he'd walked for twenty years and they worked him over with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. MICKEY SPILLANE: The Gentleman Gangster Murdered by the Westies

    Oct 19, 202616 minAudio

    Hell's Kitchen never smelled like roses. It smelled like river fog and diesel and the inside of a fist. And for 17 years, one man owned it. Michael J. Spillane. Born July 13, 1933, Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan. Irish...

    Credit the people on this episode