EP 287: Wendolyn Holland - From Yale to Sun Valley Chronicler: Preserving Idaho's Mountain Magic
29 minAudio
Welcome back to Finding Your Summit! Host Mark Pattison sits down with Wendolyn Holland, a Yale-educated historian, author, and newly appointed chair of the Historic Preservation Commission in Ketchum, Idaho, for a fascinating deep dive into the rich and surprising history of Sun Valley - one of America's most iconic mountain communities. In this captivating conversation, Wendolyn shares the remarkable story behind her monumental coffee table book that chronicles Sun Valley's evolution from mineral exploration outpost to the first destination ski resort in the United States, and why this remote Idaho valley continues to be voted best resort in North America year after year despite having no interstate highway, no nearby major city, and no massive hotel chains at the base of the mountain. This episode offers a masterclass in Western expansion, geographic destiny, and conscious community preservation, demonstrating how a combination of railroad ambition, volcanic geology, and deliberate planning created a place that has retained its essential charm while other resort towns succumbed to overdevelopment. Wendolyn opens up about her journey from Yale history major to local historian, the treasure trove of original source material she discovered in Ketchum's community library, and why she's now fighting to preserve the human-scaled buildings and authentic character that make Sun Valley special as capitalism and development pressure intensify. Key Topics Discussed: The Yale Thesis That Became a Masterpiece: Justifying Sun Valley as Serious History Wendolyn reveals how she had to convince her professors at Yale - including legendary historians of the American West like Howard Lamar, William Cronin, and Jay Gitlin - that the history of a ski resort in Idaho was worthy of academic pursuit. Discover how she framed Sun Valley's story as part of the larger patterns of Western expansion, railroad development, and how remote communities retain relevance in global economic systems. Learn about the lineage of Western historians at Yale, from Frederick Jackson Turner to modern scholars like Ned Blackhawk and Justin Farrell, and how this intellectual tradition shaped her approach to understanding Sun Valley's place in American history. The Treasure Trove: Original Source Material Nobody Had Touched Discover the moment Wendolyn found the holy grail for history majors - original source material that hadn't been picked over by generations of researchers. At the regional history department of Ketchum's community library, she uncovered handwritten letters, daily journals, and corporate correspondence that told the complete story of how Sun Valley came to be. Learn why she considers this small-town library her favorite in the world, how it was started by a group of women on land donated by the Union Pacific Railroad, and why preserving these archives remains critical to understanding the community's identity. Not Gold Rush but Mineral Extraction: Why Settlement Came Late to Idaho Wendolyn breaks down the geological and economic forces that shaped Idaho's development differently from California, Colorado, and other Western states. Learn about the 1849 California Gold Rush, the 1869 Golden Spike connecting the transcontinental railroad, and how the Oregon Short Line finally reached Hailey in 1882 and Ketchum in 1883. Discover why Idaho didn't experience the massive settlement rushes of neighboring states - the rocks here contained silver, lead, and uranium rather than gold, and the Snake River Plain created a harsh volcanic barrier that slowed westward migration. Wendolyn explains how Lewis and Clark's 1804-1806 expedition passed far to the north, and the first recorded white man to reach the Wood River Valley was Alexander Ross with the Pacific Fur Company in 1824, seeking furs rather than settlement. Count Felix Schaffgotsch: The Austrian Who Found America's Perfect Ski Mountain In one of the episode's most entertaining stories, Wendolyn reveals how Sun Valley was born from the vision of Averell Harriman, the young playboy chairman of Union Pacific Railroad who wanted to boost winter passenger revenue by creating a grand European-style ski resort in America. Learn how Harriman hired Count Felix Schaffgotsch, gave him a free pass to travel the entire Union Pacific line, and sent him on a Goldilocks quest to find the perfect ski mountain. Discover why Aspen was too high, Jackson Hole too remote (Wyoming wouldn't keep Teton Pass open in winter), and Oregon too far from the main line. Hear about the night in 1935 when the Count arrived in Ketchum, stayed at Bald Mountain Hot Springs Hotel, and woke up to see Baldy bathed in brilliant morning light - the moment he declared this the perfect location for America's first destination ski resort.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
All right, everybody, today I've got an amazing guest on the show. Her name is Wendelin Holland and she is a woman of many talents. I'm so blessed to have her on. But it's also a blessing, even though we haven't met for coffee, which we will do that.
She lives here in some valley, which is my home residence now for the last eight, going on nine years. And to me, it's such a blessing. But first of all, Wendelin, how are you doing? I'm doing great. I've just come home. It's so good to be back in the bubble. It's been a couple of weeks away with family in Ohio and so coming home is always such a blessing. No, we need some snow. I did bring a suitcase full of snow back from Ohio with me. So I'm going to head out to the mountain later and put my pile of snow there.
Yeah, I know that's all good. And certainly throughout the west, we're having very contrasting climates between the west really a very warm or temperatures and dry compared to the east coast, which is this atomic bomb of cold and everything else that's dropping on either the south, which is I'm sure having a lot of damaging effects on the different, you know, oranges and different produce that they, that they crank out down there. So I want to talk to you today because on New Year's Eve, I was over at a friend's house
and there was a book, a gigantic book, actually, I've never seen a book that big that was on the coffee table, which is what this is designed to do. It's really an art piece, but you decided to dig back in history and go back. And I'm so fascinated because every year, some value or a little resort town of maybe 5,000 people when it's not flooded during the main holidays, it's voted best resort in
the US or North America. And that's, this happened multiple times. I mean, there's got other conventions, Alan Company and so on and so forth that come here and they, you know, they could go anywhere that they chose and I've been all over the world and I've been on all these little ski towns and they choose to come to some value because of the magic, the energy and the vibe that we have here. So you are the author of this beautiful Sun Valley book and I want to dig into why you wanted to just endeavor this because this sucker is thick and big and it's got the most
beautiful pictures and the historical aspect of it. So let's just go back to the why. The why. Thank you so much and thank you so much for having me, Mark. I'm really excited about this. How auspicious that you ran into it on New Year's Eve. That's a great sign. So I wrote this book because first of all, I was in school. I was in college. I was a history and environmental studies major at Yale and had to write a thesis as required for both of those majors and the big brass ring, the thing that all history majors had to
go for the one thing that was just so elusive was to find original source material, which in a lot of areas and most areas of history, it's already been gone over. But in this area, it wasn't and I found here at our the regional history department of the community library in Ketchum, which is still to this day my favorite library in the world found an amazing treasure trove of original source material on the history of the town,
the history of the resort, the first destination ski resort in the US, but I had to overcome some things. I really had to justify to my professors and my advisors at the time working on a topic that wasn't quite so serious enough for Yale, right? The history of skiing, the history of a ski resort in Idaho, a little obscure and I had to justify to them why this was a worthy topic and to me, it's entirely clear, it's
the pattern of Western expansion, of settlement, of the relationship of the larger economic systems in our country and now in global systems in our world and how these remote isolated still, these remote communities retain their relevance, their charm and why they are so special to the larger economy and how this was just part of the patterns of westward expansion, railroad
expansionism. I was very lucky at Yale to study under Howard Lamar, under Bill Cronin, actually right behind me, that's my Bill Cronin map, my map, his history of the American West class and my essay advisors, he, Jay Gitlin, he is currently the head of the undergraduate program, the undergraduate history program at Yale and this is a long line of historians of the American West, Ned Blackhawk is part of that lineage, Justin Farrell, the author of Billionaire
Wilderness, which talks of a great deal about Jackson Hole and another gentleman who's part of this lineage, Daniel Grant, he's part of the Ivan Doig Center up at Montana State, I'm speaking at a lecture at his event in a couple of months, so there's this lineage of historians of the American West based at Yale, Frederick Jackson Turner, part of that scene, and so to justify to them, to go to the Oracle and say this is a worthy
topic, that was my first hurdle in overcoming fear, frankly, and I really wanted to pursue this topic and I had a buddy who was one year ahead of me, dear friend, a gal named Eleanor, was one year ahead of me and she had written her senior thesis for the same two departments, history of the American West and environmental studies. She had written her senior thesis on the history of her family compound, a pedicadia national
park, so she kind of paved the way for me a little bit, so I'm always grateful to Eleanor for that, but once I got the thumbs up, it was just diving into the original research that was here, and so I was able to spend my first summer living here in between junior and senior years at Yale, some of 1990, you can do the math and figure out how I am, and dive in with the research, so it was really all about the treasure trove of original
source material and the amazing library that we have here, and I could go on and on about our libraries, it was started by a group of women, land donated by the Union Pacific Railroad, I was lucky enough to serve on the board of the library a number of years ago and still strongly support the library. Love it, love it. Okay, so let's go into some juicy details and a lot of it, you know, you were starting to dive into the Western expansion and of course way back,
Lewis and Clark and others who were making their way and ultimately out to California and places like that, but I can't even begin to imagine the conditions and just the brutal environment, especially when you start dropping down into Wyoming, Montana, Idaho, where the temperate climate, it's as you know, because we built live here, can get unbearable during the winter time, and so in a covered wagon and things like that, of course we have wagon days and other things.
But let's go back to, where did this town really take shape? And I'm guessing when I say this, and I haven't done the research like I should do, but for some reason, you know, what's popped in my mind is 1923 is when things started to pop here. So give me a way later than that. Okay, way later than that. So we've got, you know, you're into football, right? Got our 49ers, right? That was bold as discovered in California, so keep that in your mind. So it was all about mineral exploration, right? And then we've got the Golden Spike Railroad
of the crossing of the two lines coming from East and West, just north of Salt Lake and Promotory, Utah. That's 1869. So we look at 1869 as the beginning of that era, where corporate, it influences very much New York, San Francisco, these corporate influences were trying to get the transportation resources to the West. A lot of that meant displacing the Indigenous peoples who had been here for time in memorial, getting the transportation resources here so that
we could extract the minerals. So it was all about mineral exploration. And along with that comes land speculation as well. The railroads, of course, were able to acquire incredibly extensive land resources for the rights of way that adjoining all the lands that they were crossing. So we've got the railroad, the main part of the railroad crossing 1869.
And then these little spur lines headed north and south into the valleys, happening in the successive decades following that. And we've got the first, the Oregon Shortline small company that was later acquired, Oregon Shortline company making its way to Haley in 1882 and then up to Ketchum in 1883. But it wasn't until 1879, no railroad here yet,
but 1879 that the first group of speculators, individuals, individual entrepreneurs, Dave Ketchum among them, came up to Ketchum and discovered lead and Galena around here. You harken back though to Lewis and Clark, Lewis and Clark, of course, is 18456. They're making their way across in an incredible expedition, very much enabled by the native populations going across the country. And there's an incredible book that I cannot recommend enough to readers about
this, called Lewis and Clark from Indian eyes. And that book has a really good connection to our valley here, because of course Lewis and Clark were nowhere near here. They're further up north like Lolo Pass, some great scary, scary areas up there. But Diane Josephi PV, an amazing woman married into the PV family. Her father, her late father, Alvin Josephi was the anthologist who compiled Lewis and Clark through Indian eyes, amazing book. Okay, so Lewis and Clark
18456. And then the first recorded white man to have made his way down here into the valley, into the Wood River Valley, was 1824 Alexander Ross with the Pacific Fur Company. But again, it's the similar idea of these corporate interest Pacific Fur Company, of course, on their way, looking for beaver and other furs. But it was the corporate interest looking to extract furs, minerals, and getting into the area. So they weren't really looking for land. They weren't
looking for land to settle. They weren't looking to make their way in the wilderness. They were really looking for resource extraction. So I get that. So and that was what was going on at that time, right? And the lady, 1800s, right? And so I want to get more into the development where there's this big idea, right? Where somebody comes in behind all these people who have been coming, and it was more for just actual resources, right? And things that people need to, you know,
food, clothing, and shelter, those are the kind of the three big essentials. But now somebody comes here and they stand in the middle of this valley and they're looking around and looking up at the top. And there's this light bulb that goes off about, let's turn this thing into a ski resort. Okay. Slightly different the way that happened. So the railroad was already here, making its way successive improvements over the decades. And then a different story back in New York, young, very young, in his 20s, Avril Haramon, Chairman of the Union Pacific Railroad. His
father had passed away when Avril himself was quite young. So he really headed into corporate leadership at a quite a young age in his 20s and 30s. It was a bit of a playboy as sort of the old term of the way that is described. Modern times we describe that behavior a little differently. But he certainly saw the trends in the passenger revenue dipping in the winter. And he saw that the central, the central Pacific, the rail, the railroads to the south were doing much better with
their winter passenger revenue. passenger revenue had dropped after World War One. And he was really looking for a way to boost winter passenger revenue. He was hanging out in Europe. He had friends who were in Europe. He was part of European financial circles. So he was aware that there were already groups of British who were headed to Switzerland and Austria to ski in the winter. That was already a thing. There were already clubs headed to Kitsbule, St. Anton,
those areas. So he saw that culture, that very elite culture, where it seemed to define nature that we could go out and recreate in the middle of the winter. And that's a climatic thing, right? To have that super dry, dry air in the mountains where we can be perfectly comfortable in just a t-shirt, recreating out in the mountains. He saw that behavior, wanted to replicate it in the US. Now it already started just a little bit going north from Grand Central Station in New York,
going up to New Hampshire, Vermont, and Maine. There were already some tiny little resorts, but they weren't grand resorts. And his vision was, hey, let's make this grand resort. So he hired this guy. It's called a count. The titles are free and titles are very free in Austria. So was he of actual royalty? Who actually knows? A lot of people have that moniker count even to this day in Austria. So he hired this guy, who he knew through social circles, gave him a pass on the
Union Pacific Railroad. I would love to have a pass like that. Gave him a pass to travel all over the Union Pacific line in the West. Nobody else's line, only the Union Pacific line, and find the best ski mountain. So Count Felix Saf got, went around to a whole bunch of places that we know of now as being excellent ski mountains. Oregon, Jackson Hole, Colorado, you want to veil. He went to Aspen and every place was a little like Goldilocks, right? Kind of going to all these places. And, you know, Aspen was too high. Jackson was too far away from the main line and the
state of Wyoming was unwilling to keep Teton pass open. There was already road over Teton pass, but state of Wyoming was unwilling to keep it open over the winter. Obviously Teton pass had a rough time last winter with a pretty serious collapse. And when he made, by the time he made it here, he kept a really good journal. It's great. We have a lot of the archives from Avril Hariman, with these individual handwritten letters from the Count back to Hariman,
New York, keeping him updated on his daily diary of looking at all these places. He had almost given up. Until one of the railroad engineers said, hey, you should really check out this place up around Ketchum and Haley, the Oregon short line going straight up north from Shoshone. And he came in at night, the line came in at night and he was pretty grumpy about it, was not terribly optimistic. Thought the valley was too wide because he was really looking for it to be more hemmed in, like a European valley, like a European ski valley, like Korshival and such.
But when he woke up here in the morning, stayed at what used to be Bald Mountain Hot Springs Hotel, he saw the bright light, he saw a balladie, and he said, this is our place. He found the perfect mountain. And I still believe that we do have the best ski mountain in all of North America. We need a little snow this year. This is our down year. This is our year to get work done. So question for you. So going back when he was at the Bald Mountain, there's old log cabin that used to stay in him way back when they were amazing. And there's
so old school and nostalgic and all those things. But again, what year was he standing where he woke up in the morning and looked up in the mountains and probably the sun was coming in, where he had this awakening, where this is where I want to expand this idea. 1935. 1935. Early in 1935 is when that happened. Okay, cool. I think, you know, for people who don't know, so Haley, again, is about 10, 12 miles away from Ketchum. Ketchum is about a two and a half hour
car ride from Boise, Idaho, which a lot more people know about. And I think one of the things in the context of all these other resorts that you're talking about now will develop in Colorado, Aspen, Telluride, Vale, places like that. Then you go down to Wyoming and you're talking about Jackson Hole and over in Montana, you've got a couple mountains there, big sky and big mountain and things like that. But one thing that's really been unique is that the, especially more than
anything that what's closest to us is down Park City. And they're all good. They're just different. And one of the things that's been here is really they've retained that culture and the discipline of not sucking up to gigantic hotels, the montages, the four seasons. So we don't have any of that here. And that's starting. I know a little bit starting just a little bit. But at the end of the day, I mean, that took what 12 years to, like it was a big hole for a long time. But at the end of the day,
you know, I doubt that's going to happen at the base of the mountain. And just a lot of the charm of the character, you know, with many, many structures around here, I know there's redeveloping and people are, are improving all the time. But there's still a heck of a lot of cabins around here that we're probably sitting here for the last 50, 60 years. And so that's one of the things that I have found that have been, you know, one of the charming things that people have never been here before, like, oh, wow, this is a really cool spot. The charm. And it's actually charm worth preserving. I can tell you why we've retained this, we call it the essential funk. Why we've been
able to retain it and why it's critical to keep on with those efforts to do so. So I'll just take Vale. Interstate 70 runs through Vale. There's so much traffic going to those places. Jackson Hole had the benefit of having the giant national parks right nearby and the massive, massive traffic that comes in in the summer. Park City, of course, and all the other resorts in the Wasatch down around Salt Lake have the proximity of Salt Lake in a major metropolitan
area. We don't have that in Idaho. Our population is more sparse. And what I described it in the book as a geographic barrier that really was created by the Snake River Plane, created by, if you will, there's a there's a stable stationary hotspot in the earth's magma and the plates drift, not drift, they shift on top of it. And it's created this kind of a smiley face, if you will,
the Snake River Plane, which has some really interesting hot springs and geologic activity that currently sits under Yellowstone. It's why we have all the amazing, you know, the mud pots and the geysers and everything that's happening under Yellowstone. That activity occurred all along the Snake River Plane and it created some really ugly harsh, uh, craggy rocks that you can't walk with bare feet over and you can imagine how harsh it would be for wagon wheels and horse hooves
to try and cross. And that evidence of that is down at Creators of the Moon National Monument just to the east of Blaine County, to the east of Kerry, Idaho. And that's, you know, 10,000 and 100,000 years from now, that's what that's what Yellowstone is going to look more like. But that actually caused a really big barrier to get beyond, to go explore. So, so we don't have as much settlement in those areas. Another reason why our settlement is sparser here is literally because
of it being slightly more to the west, being in the inner mountain west. So Oregon trail travelers when they were coming in the hundreds of thousands in the 1850s, 1860s, they would reach Idaho, the portions of the Oregon Trail, California Trail that passed through Idaho. They would reach here so late in the season coming up in like August, September, that they were already tired, they were already, you know, they weren't ready to settle there. It was really about a
seasonality to it. So we don't have a ton of settlement further up in the Idaho areas. In addition, north of us, we have the largest roadless area in the lower 48. So we're not having that settlement pressure here in the Ketchum Sun Valley area. We don't have that settlement pressure coming in from the north either. So we're really this kind of isolated community, isolated by so much geography and what put on top of that is the fact that the quality of the rocks here, what's in the rocks,
the geologic substrate, we didn't have a big gold rush here. There's some gold pockets off to the smokey mountains to the west of us, but our mineral rush is here. We're more about silver lead later uranium. So the gold rush, gold rushes that hit in California and Colorado and such, we didn't have those rushes. So we just didn't have the masses of settlement that other areas did, and it's those masses of settlement then that give rise to the larger communities, the concentrations
of wealth. So we've been, we've been able to keep just a little bit under the radar here, and I think that leads to our charm. I think that helps explain why it is we don't have just the massive populations that the other places do. It really comes back to rocks. Yeah, well, you talk about in Salt Lake City, you're talking about international airport, you're talking about a whole lot of convenience that from LA to Salt Lake City, you can be there an hour or 20 minutes and 20 minutes later, 30 minutes later, you're at the resort skiing. So and here it takes effort and that's that,
okay, we have about five more minutes and I want to make sure that we don't mess taking like let's, we've talked about the 1800s and 1934 and kind of like why and how this whole region evolved, and I want to go to today, okay, and the relevance of today as opposed to the original goals way back when. And let's talk about that for a minute. Great, thank you. I am so fortunate to have the support of our previous political leadership as well as our current political leadership here in the
Ketchum area. And I was just named voted by my peers last night as chair of the Historic Preservation Commission in the city of Ketchum. And we're at a really incredible inflection point here. The forces of capitalism are coming in and they're coming in hard. I'm a capitalist, but I also know capitalism can be conscious and we can make decisions in our community about the kinds of
building structures, districts we want to retain and where we're willing to let capitalism run more freely. Planning and zoning has a really big role in all of this to make sure that we are retaining the charm, the culture, the character of our town. And we talk about the character of our town being composed of both the people as well as the structures. And we've got some amazing
buildings in downtown Ketchum in the community core as well as out beyond. And I believe it is these tiny structures that are really built at the human scale before masses of metal were coming in and all that really lend the charm to our communities. I believe these buildings are worth saving because they help retain our charm. A lot of people have said that they've seen more changes in Ketchum in the last five years than they have in the last 30. COVID pandemic 2021 was and let's
hope we're done. Had a pretty big impact on our community with massive influx of population. And so I believe now it is incumbent on us to make decisions as a community about which structures, which district, which areas are worth retaining so that we retain our charm. Love it. Love it. Okay. The final question for you again. I want to go back to the first thing that came out of my mouth about how spectacular all this detail and and people you haven't seen it
in them describing this to you right now. But the pictures and the photos and the descriptions. I mean it's really a work of art. Here it comes. There it is gigantic extraordinary history. And that's what it is. And where can people find that book? They can find that book right now two places. First of all it's in a lot of libraries. It's also in some very beautiful homes as you found on the copy table on New Year's Eve. It's for sale in two places right now. One is our favorite bookstore
chapter one. Yep. And another is the Willow Papers store that's also in Ketchum right down the street from the library on Sun Valley Road. Right. Well that's here and that's to a local audience. But this podcast goes up to people all over the US and North America and worldwide. And so for those people who may call I can I can be reached at W at Wendelin.com sometimes they come up on Amazon but they end up being really expensive. So give me a call. One of these days I'll get around to
reprinting or doing another book. But right now I'm more focused on the community service aspect of this. Well I'm going to be your first customer. So I will for sure be reaching out to you to get that book. Okay. Awesome. Thank you so much Mark. Yeah well you are just a walking encyclopedia of certainly a lot of things but you know specifically about this region and I love it and you love it and and for the probably different reasons and all the right reasons and all the same reasons. And so for that reason you know I'm blessed that you were able to come on and give some contacts
to this area that we call Sun Valley. I'm so honored to share this time with you Mark. It's been great to meet you. Look forward to meeting you in person someday soon. All right there she is the one the only Wendelin Holland. Thank you so much. Thank you Mark.
Host Mark Pattison sits down with Susie Hall, bestselling author of Blessed Disruption: Transforming Trauma into Triumph, successful interior designer, entrepreneur, and international speaker who grew up as the daughter...
Host Mark Pattison sits down with Duff McKagan, founding member of Guns N' Roses, Rock and Roll Hall of Famer, author, entrepreneur, and father who grew up in the same Seattle neighborhood as Mark before becoming one of...
Host Mark Pattison sits down with Bart Barkley, founder of Most People Don't, former hospitality executive with 16 years at Ritz Carlton and 10 years at Hyde Hotel, and international speaker who travels the world...
Host Mark Pattison sits down with Andrew Brandt, a former NFL agent, Green Bay Packers Vice President, Villanova Law professor, and author of Smarter About Sports who spent nine years managing the salary cap and player...