Click to send R.B. thoughts on this episode This week’s episode started with a simple moment on a flight from Chicago to Cleveland. Looking down over a calm, beautiful Lake Michigan, I was reminded of something every captain eventually learns: you cannot judge what water is capable of based only on what it looks like right now. That thought led me back to the story of the Rouse Simmons - the legendary Christmas Tree Ship that left Michigan in November 1912, loaded with evergreens and headed for Chicago. She never arrived. What makes the story powerful is not simply that a ship was lost. It is the lesson behind it. Captain Herman Schuenemann had experience. He knew the water. He had made the crossing before. People were depending on him. But conditions had changed. And that is where this story intersects with something I talk about all the time: Follow the plan. Discipline matters. Consistency matters. Execution matters. But following the plan does not mean blindly ignoring new information. A good plan requires awareness. Sometimes the destination is still right, but the course has to change. In this episode, we talk about the difference between fear and awareness, why experience can sometimes make us too comfortable, and why changing course is not always quitting. Sometimes it is leadership. Sometimes it is wisdom. And sometimes it is exactly what gets you to the destination.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00This past week, I took my normal trip to Cleveland. I go to Cleveland two or three times a month, and I usually leave from Wilmington. I either go through Chicago, Atlanta, LaGuardia. Not a direct flight, right? So this past week, though, I ended up going through O'Hare in Chicago. When I left Chicago to go to Cleveland, we we crossed Lake Michigan. As I looked out the window, I gotta be honest with you, it was beautiful. It was calm, it was blue, it was peaceful.
SPEAKER_00I could see it just miles and miles of blue water. It was peaceful enough that from 30,000 feet, you forget what a body of water like Lake Michigan is absolutely capable of. And I was sitting there thinking, as a captain, I've learned some things about the water, right? You never judge what it is capable of based only on what it looks like right now. I've been offshore numerous days when the ocean was slick as glass when I left.
SPEAKER_00And throughout the excursion, I've watched the conditions change, the winds come up, the seas and the waves build. Something that was completely manageable a few hours earlier suddenly demands every bit of your attention. Water has a way of reminding you that just because you've crossed it before doesn't mean you can stop respecting it. As I was looking across Lake Michigan, it reminded me of a story from a long time ago. A story about a captain, an old wooden schooner, thousands of Christmas trees, and a trip to Chicago that didn't end the way it was intended.
SPEAKER_00That was back in 1912 when the ship was called Ralph Simmons. It was a three-masted wooden schooner that was built in Milwaukee in 1968. By 1912, she had spent 44 years working the Great Lakes. Think about that, 44 years. Not a new boat. She'd hauled lumber, she had seen weather, she had crossed those waters again and again. One of the men aboard the boat was Captain Herman Schoonman.
SPEAKER_00Around Chicago, people knew him by another name, and that was Captain Santa. You see, for years Skoonaman had been bringing evergreen Christmas trees south to Chicago and selling them directly from the ship. And apparently Captain Santa did more than just sell the Christmas trees. He became known for giving some away to churches and families who could not afford one. His arrival became part of Christmas in Chicago. I mean, think about it. Just imagine this, right? An old schooner coming across the lake, coming into the city.
SPEAKER_00Imagine that the masts were decorated, Christmas trees were stacked aboard, people were waiting, families were waiting. And for a lot of people, when Captain Santa arrived, Christmas had arrived. But there was a problem with the business that he was in. If you're delivering Christmas trees, you've got to set sail close to Christmas. And on Lake Michigan, that means November, right? Every experienced captain on those waters knew what November could bring.
SPEAKER_00Cold. Gale force winds. High waves, conditions that could deteriorate very quickly. Schoonerman knew that, right? He was not experienced. I mean, he's made these trips for years. And maybe that is part of what makes his story so interesting. You see, late in the afternoon on November 22nd, 1912, the Ralph Simmons left Thompson, Michigan, loaded with evergreens and headed to Chicago.
SPEAKER_00The barometer was falling, the winds were increasing. The old schooner headed out. There were crewmen aboard along with passengers believed to be some lumberjacks that were trying to get back to Chicago for the holidays. The exact number is really not as uncertain, but most historians estimate there were 16, 17 crew members in pastures. None of them ever made it to Chicago. The next afternoon, the Ralph Simmons was caught in a northwest gale.
SPEAKER_00And about 3 o'clock, a lookout at the Kowani lifesaving station spotted a schooner several miles offshore. It was headed south. And she was flying a distress signal. I want you to think about that. At some point during the crossing, this experienced crew and this old ship had got into some trouble badly enough that they were asking for help. The Kowani crew could not catch her. So they sent word south to the life-saving station, I think it was two rivers, at two rivers.
SPEAKER_00Those men launched into the same exact conditions that the Ralph Simmons is in, tried to intercept her. But when they reached the area where the ship or the schooner was supposed to be, she was gone. No final message home, no survivors that could ever explain what happened. Captain Santa, the crew, the passengers, thousands of Christmas trees. Gone. For years afterwards, Lake Michigan gave pieces of that story back, right?
SPEAKER_00Christmas trees would wash ashore. But the ship itself was still missing. And for nearly 60 years, nobody knew exactly where the Christmas tree ship rested. But in 1971, a diver by the name of Kent Bell Richard found a wreck northeast of Two Rivers, Wisconsin. It was about 12 miles off of shore and roughly 160, 65 feet beneath the surface.
SPEAKER_00It was sitting there on the bottom of Lake Michigan, and it was the Rouse Simmons. Amazingly, most of the hull was still intact. Her cargo was still there. There were remnants of the Christmas trees that she had been carrying to Chicago inside the wreck. Sixty years earlier, families had been waiting for those trees that never came. Archaeologists later studied the wreck and found clues about her final moments, right? The ship rests facing Wisconsin's shoreline rather than continuing south towards Chicago.
SPEAKER_00That tells you it was trying to alter the course. It was trying to get to Wisconsin. Her crew had been working with the anchor gear. The port anchor was found away from the bow. So the evidence suggests that something had gone seriously wrong, and the crew, they may have actually been trying to hold the ship into the wind. But she eventually went down bow first. She struck the lake bottom so hard that it actually dug deeply into the sand. Rigging was thrown forward, masts were dislodged and broken.
SPEAKER_00We're never going to know every detail of what happened aboard the Ralph Simmons during those final minute minutes. And I think that matters. He should have waited. Maybe. But I'm always cautious about judging a decision from the comfort of knowing how the story ended.
SPEAKER_00You see, Schoonerman, he knew Lake Michigan. He knew the business. He's made that journey before numerous times. There were customers waiting in Chicago. There were people depending upon him. There was a season that did not give him an unlimited time. You see where this is going? Because in his mind there were probably a dozen reasonable reasons to leave. That's the part of the story I haven't been able to stop thinking about.
SPEAKER_00You see, most bad decisions in our lives do not announce themselves as bad decisions. They usually come wrapped in reasonable explanations. Hey, I've done this before. It would be fine. We don't have much choice. People are counting me, I've handled worse. We're committed. We have too much invested to turn around now. Does that sound familiar? Because we do this in business with our money, with our relationships, our health, our calendars. We keep going because we've gone this way before.
SPEAKER_00And sometimes experience, which should make us wiser, can quietly make us comfortable. And my friends, that's dangerous. Experience is valuable, but experience does not give us the authority over conditions. I've run boats long enough to know that, right? The ocean does not care how many hours I have in the helm. It doesn't. A storm doesn't look at a captain's resume. Conditions are conditions. It's a good captain's responsibility to continually reassess them.
SPEAKER_00What's the wind doing now? What are the seas doing now? What's the boat telling me? What has changed since I made the original plan? That is not fear. That is awareness. There is a huge difference between the two. Fear is going to tell you, do not leave the dock because something might happen. Where awareness is understand what is happening before you decide whether you're going to leave the dock. They are not the same thing. And that's where the story intersects with something I talk about constantly, right?
SPEAKER_00I tell you to follow the plan. I believe that. Discipline matters. I believe that. Consistency, execution, they matter. You can't abandon a plan every time the wind changes direction, but following the plan does not mean blindly ignoring new information. A good plan requires awareness. It requires us to look up from what we're doing long enough to ask whether the conditions have changed. Maybe the destination is still right. Maybe the goal hasn't changed at all.
SPEAKER_00But the course might need to. Maybe you slow down, maybe take another route, maybe you wait. And yes, sometimes you return to the dock. Changing the course is not always quitting. Sometimes it's seamanship, right? Sometimes it's leadership, it's wisdom. This week I was sitting safely inside an airplane looking down at a beautifully calm Lake Michigan. There was no November gale, no distressed schooner, no Christmas trees floating in the water.
SPEAKER_00Just miles and miles of blue. And somewhere beneath that water rests an old wooden ship that left port more than a century ago. A captain had a destination and he had experience. He had people depending on him. He's made this trip before, but that day the conditions were different. There's probably something in your life right now that you've crossed a hundred times before. A relationship, maybe a business or financial decision, a leadership problem.
SPEAKER_00Maybe even something as simple as the way you're spending your time. Do not assume today's crossing is safe simply because yesterday's was. Look at the conditions. Pay attention to what changed. Respect what is in front of you. Follow the plan. But never become so committed to the plan that you stop being aware of the water around you, being aware of your surroundings. Being committed to the destination does not require you to ignore the weather.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes the strongest decision that captain makes is not pushing forward. Sometimes it's changing course. I I hope that this made sense, and I hope you don't mind me doing something a little different and taking an old story that I remembered while I was sitting on an airplane to bring home to you, hopefully, a point that makes sense, right? There's a difference between fear and awareness. Follow your plan, but guys, be aware.
SPEAKER_00Be aware. I want you to get to your destination. You may have to order the course, but I want you to get there. I tell you every week I believe there's greatness inside of you because I do believe that. I believe that. I hope this helped. If you know somebody that could use this, send it to them. Share it with them. I appreciate the comments. I appreciate the subscriptions that many of us subscribers. I appreciate all of that. And at the end of the day, my number one goal was that you get it.
SPEAKER_00That you get it. I hope your week is great. Stay the course, be aware. And I look forward to seeing you next week. Thanks, guys.
Click to send R.B. thoughts on this episode Some mentors sit across the table from us. Others influence us through the words they leave behind. Brian Tracy was someone I never met, but his work helped shape the way I...
Click to send R.B. thoughts on this episode A canceled flight changed our plans and put us 24 hours behind schedule. At 6:06 that morning, I had a choice: spend the time fighting the change - or use it to record this...
Click to send R.B. thoughts on this episode The person you’ve been postponing may be the very person someone else is waiting to meet. In this episode, Captain R.B. Wright shares how a recent experience teaching in...
Click to send R.B. thoughts on this episode What happens when someone else's confidence depends on yours? Twelve miles offshore, the weather turned ugly. The seas were building, the wind was picking up, and lightning...
Click to send R.B. thoughts on this episode What if the next stage of your growth begins with admitting that what got you here may not be enough to take you further? During a week in Cleveland with nearly 1,000 UHM...