Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Films and Fermentation-- Strong reviews. Stronger drinks.

Films and Fermentation-- Strong reviews. Stronger drinks. artwork

THE PEOPLE vs. ROGER EBERT: THE ROGER EBERT ZERO STAR FILM LIST

Sep 22, 20261 hrAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail Tonight, we’re celebrating one of the rarest achievements in cinema: making a movie Roger Ebert believed deserved absolutely nothing. Mike and Kev will try to identify twelve movies that earned the dreaded ZERO STARS, ranging from infamous cinematic disasters to a few choices that may cause us to question Roger’s usually impeccable judgment. Along the way, we’ll revisit some of Ebert’s most gloriously savage reviews, because nobody could professionally tell a filmmaker they’d wasted everyone’s time quite like Roger. There will be bad movies, questionable taste, wounded childhood nostalgia, and at some point we’re going to have to address the unforgivable fact that he gave zero stars to a Films and Fermentation Cult Favorite. So grab a beer, put your thumbs firmly down, and remember: even half a star would have been an act of mercy. 🍺⭐🚫 Don’t forget to drop us an email at filmsandfermentation@gmail.com or visit linktree.com/filmsandfermentation to find all our social media and podcast links. Become part of the Films and Fermentation Family. We are an Independent Podcast, which means we are listener supported. So please consider joining our Patreon for as little as a dollar a month to receive members only content. https://fermentedfilms.creator-spring.com/ You can now text us at: 904-867-4466 Beer News LINKS Shock Top and Spirit Halloween Brew Up Shock Top Candy Corn Wheat Exclusive Labatt Beer Horn to be sold at Highmark Stadium for 2026 season Love Horror Movies? Meet Fright Night Flicks 🤘 Twin brothers, horror movie deep dives, hilarious debates, and killer trivia. Listen now! Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify The Steve & Jeff Show Comedy, improvisation, interviews you won't believe, political satire, and music! Listen on: Apple Podcasts Spotify Support the show A member of the Podnation Media Network. linktree.com/podnationpods Find all our social media and Podcast links at: linktree.com/filmsandfermentation Become part of the FIlms and Fermentation Family by supporting us on Patreon or buying our Merch at teespring.com CHEERS!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hey everybody, welcome back to Films and Fermentation. This is a uh special episode. Every week it's a special episode. What am I saying? But this is a fun one I put together for tonight. I think we'll have some fun with this. Uh, Roger Ebert, the uh legendary film critic, probably one of the most famous film critics of all time, has a list of films that he once gave zero star reviews to in the uh Chicago Sun Times that he used to write for. And uh of the 67 films that he gave zero-star reviews, I picked out 10 that uh these guys are gonna try to guess tonight and uh we'll see how it goes.

SPEAKER_01So we're calling tonight's episode The People versus Roger Ebert, the zero-star film list game show. Again, this is Films of Fermentation Movie Now Call Podcast, number one beer podcast on Good Pods. I'm Leah. I'm Kevin. I'm Mike. Three friends who like to talk shit about movies while getting shit faced. Tonight we're celebrating one of the rarest achievements in cinema, making a movie Roger Ebert believed deserved absolutely nothing. Mike and Kev will try to identify 12 movies. Um sorry, it's 10 movies. I took a couple off the list.

SPEAKER_01So it's 10 movies that earn the dreadit zero stars, ranging from infamous cinematic disasters to a few choices that may cause us to question Roger's unusual or usually impeccable judgment. Along the way, we'll revisit some of Ebert's most gloriously savage reviews because nobody could professionally tell a filmmaker they wasted everybody's time, quite like Raj. There will be a bad movies, there will be bad movies, questionable taste, wounded childhood nostalgia, and at some point we're going to have to address the unforgivable fact that he gave zero stars to a film and fermentation cult favorites.

SPEAKER_01So grab a beer, put your thumbs firmly down, and remember, even half a star would have been an act of mercy. Don't forget to drop an email at films and fermentation at gmail.com or visit linksree.com slash films and fermentation to find all of our social media podcast links. Uh become part of the Films and Fermentation family by supporting us on Patreon. We are an independent podcast, which means we are listener supported. So please consider joining our Patreon for as little as a dollar a month. Receive members-only content for a dollar a month. We'll give you two thumbs up.

SPEAKER_01Uh or you can text us at 904-867-4466. What are we drinking tonight, my friends? Uh, I am I'm gonna go first tonight because I had some drink envy last week. Kevin broke out some beers from the Sam Adams Fall Pack last week, and I was disappointed that I didn't have any myself. So I went out and I bought a Sam Adams Fall Pack. So tonight I am drinking the Jacko pumpkin, and here you go, and I have an Oktoberfest as a backup because Sam Adams Oktoberfest is my favorite Oktoberfest.

SPEAKER_01If I need a third beer, I have cherry wheat as well. But I don't know how that would go with the pumpkin and the caramel.

SPEAKER_02So I'll just piggyback on you then because I am also in um in enjoying a Sam Adams Jacko from my variety pack. But I also purchased an Elasian Elysian, yeah. And uh tonight I'm trying the Great Pumpkin Imperial Pumpkin Ale. Uh this one in particular is is I like the Elysians.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, they're very good.

SPEAKER_02I like Elysian too, yeah. Come on, come on, give me the ABV. Um eight point four, it looks like it's pretty strong for an Oktoberfest or Buffalo. Yeah, well, it's either 8.4 or 0.4. I can't. It's too tiny.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm almost 50 and my eyes can't read. It's 4.4 on the Sam Adams Jack O, so maybe it's a four you're seeing.

SPEAKER_02No, no, I'm now now it's an eight.

SPEAKER_01Oh wow. Yeah, I definitely am not gonna be able to see that on camera.

SPEAKER_02Oh no, you can't see that?

SPEAKER_01Not at all. No, I could barely see it in person.

SPEAKER_03I had to put my readers on. I see the write up about it. I don't see anything about ABV.

SPEAKER_02I see is the only word I can make out. Oh, okay. Well, you've got you guys are closer to 50 than I am, and we're all blind.

SPEAKER_01Mike's over 50. I'm I'm riding the cusp right now. Uh I do like Elysian. They they're they're a really good brewery. So and uh Mike, what you got going on?

SPEAKER_03Uh I have not yet got my fall beers yet. So I just went with uh Kona Big Wave, a liquid aloha, because I'd rather be a little, you know, in Hawaii right now.

SPEAKER_01Be in Hawaii right now, yeah. Who wouldn't? I think I gotta save one of the Jack O's uh for uh a beer bread. They'll make a good beer bread. I would make a very good beer bread. Yeah. All right. Let's uh listen to a song.

SPEAKER_06This week in film history with mine.

SPEAKER_04This week in film history with Mike.

SPEAKER_031932, British actress Peg Entwistle, 24, commits suicide by jumping off the letter H of the Hollywood land, now Hollywood sign in Los Angeles, California.

SPEAKER_01I've heard this story before, like it's it's a fact that I'm familiar with. I don't know anything really about her career. Um she was in one film in 1932. She was in a film called Thirteen Women. So makes you wonder what happened to her to make her want to do that, you know. She was the 13th.

SPEAKER_03She wasn't even the first one.

SPEAKER_01That's terrible. It's not uh it's it's an interesting fact, but a terrible one.

SPEAKER_03Yes.

SPEAKER_01Uh next one, sir.

SPEAKER_031953. First movie in Cinema Scope, The Rope, based on a book by Lloyd C. Douglas, directed by Henry Coster, and starring Richard Burton and John Simmons at premieres.

SPEAKER_01Gene Simmons, the female version. John Dean, Dean Simmons. Um we talked about this, I think, in the past because we did like an episode, uh like an Easter episode where we talked about like movies that weren't you know uh Ten Commandments at Easter time, yeah. A little bit of a slow film, you know. It's it's an older film, but yeah.

SPEAKER_03Uh next time, sorry. 1964, Watt Disney is awarded the Presidential Medal of Freedom at the White House by President Lyndon Johnson.

SPEAKER_01Shortly after that, he had his head frozen. Speaking of Disney.

SPEAKER_03Well, I I had to put this one on because I want to I want to trash it. Uh 1986, 3D short film Captain EO with Michael Jackson premieres at Disney theme parks. My biggest problem with this when I finally got to see it was who the fuck in the right mind's gonna follow Michael Jackson's like Starship Captain.

SPEAKER_01I saw it. I liked it. I thought Captain Eo was fun.

SPEAKER_02No, Bubbles, don't touch that control. No, Bubbles.

SPEAKER_01This is this the one is this the one where Joe Pesci was the villain? What's the one that's Moonwalker? Moonwalker, yeah. There's I know there's one with Joe Pesce, because that's the one that's got um with criminal in it.

SPEAKER_02Personally, I'm a little surprised Joe Pesci played a criminal, you know, played the villain because you know, Michael James in Disney film. Um this was the one that Nebcot, though, wasn't it? Wasn't there okay?

SPEAKER_03The imagination. Imagination, yeah. Yeah. Uh family films. Uh yes. 1987, the thriller, Fail Attraction, directed by Adrian Lynn and starring Michael Douglas and Glenn Close is released. That poor rabbit.

SPEAKER_02Poor rabbit.

SPEAKER_01All I know is that uh extramarital affairs went down uh by a significant percentage in 1987 after this film came out.

SPEAKER_02That's a topic we'll have to address sometime on the show is uh movies about movies movies about stalkers.

SPEAKER_01I was gonna say I don't have enough energy for my own wife, let alone a second woman.

SPEAKER_03All right, 1990 American gangster film Good Fellas, directed by Martin Scorsese, starring Robert De Niro, Joe Pesci, and Ray Leota premieres.

SPEAKER_02This is a second movie where Joe Pesci plays a villain.

SPEAKER_03I mean, that we talked about the first one. He wasn't actually in the first one we talked about.

SPEAKER_01This is um Joe Pesci, of course, won the Oscar for best supporting actor for this film, and had given the greatest Oscar speech in the history of the Oscars when he received his award. Walked up on stage, lifted it up in the air, went, thank you, and walked off the stage. To this day, the greatest Oscar speech ever given. Wow. Uh, one of the podcasts I listen to that does like the director filmographies all the time are doing Martin Scorsese right now.

SPEAKER_01It's going to take them, and they've said this on the show, five and a half months to cover every movie because they do a movie a show. Wow. And they're they're only in their fourth week. They haven't got out of the 70s yet. So wow.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_02And they're not doing anything that he that's affiliated with him with television, like Boardwalk Empire or uh No, it's only films he directed.

SPEAKER_01So not things that he like produced or wrote or directly appeared in or whatever. It's only films he directed, and then short films and documentaries that he done he's done, they're doing on the Patreon separate feed. Uh so their main feed is just his like feature films. So Goodfellows, Taxi Driver, and stuff like that. Gotcha. He is by far like one of the most influential filmmakers of the last like 50 years. So speaking of influential filmmakers.

SPEAKER_031995, Crime Thriller Film 7, directed by David Fincher, and starring Morgan Freeman, Brad Pitt, and Kevin Spacey premieres in New York.

SPEAKER_01We should do a whole episode on movies with uh knife-edged dildos.

SPEAKER_02I think that list is rather limited, don't you?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, seven. We should do an episode seven. Such a great movie, man. So bizarre, so bizarre.

SPEAKER_02One of my favorite trivia facts about that is the uh guy who was um uh strapped to the bed for sloth. Uh nobody knew that he was an actual actor, that he was living, breathing, and they thought it was just a prop. And when he started to convulse and move and sh- and it scared the shit out of everybody in the room.

SPEAKER_01It was it was a very like alien moment because it was a natural reaction to something that they weren't expecting. And first time I saw it, I think I peed a little because that is one of the like the scariest jump scares I've ever seen. And it's not even like a like a slasher horror film, jump scare. It's yeah, just not expecting it. I love seven, such a great movie. Yeah, uh next one, sir.

SPEAKER_031996 Paramount Pictures released the cult revenge comedy, The First Wise Club, directed by Hugh Wilson, historic Bette Midler, Gody Hahn, and Diane Keaton.

SPEAKER_01A movie I know my wife is fond of, and a movie I can care less about.

SPEAKER_03Uh next one, sir. 1998. Rush Hour, directed by Brett Ratner, and staring Jackie Chan and Chris Tucker, is released. It is Jackie Chan's Hollywood breakthrough.

SPEAKER_01It's funny that it's his Hollywood breakthrough and he's been making movies since like 1968.

SPEAKER_03It's just not through Hollywood. Yeah, China.

SPEAKER_01He was already like a monster star. He was also a uh chart-topping uh musician as well in China. Uh and the last one we got there.

SPEAKER_03He's the he's the Chinese David Hasselhoff.

SPEAKER_01Oh no, he's way more successful. It's more like I guess the I guess the equivalent, the first one that pops in my head would be like Jennifer Lopez, who is a successful actress as well as like a number one selling artist. Like that's what he was in China. He wasn't just you know popular in Germany. Okay.

SPEAKER_032011, the critically acclaimed film Drive, starring Ryan Gosling, is released.

SPEAKER_02I never saw this one. I keep uh confusing it with Baby Driver, you know, which I know are two different movies, but so there was like there's a bunch of movies that came out like within 10 years of each other.

SPEAKER_01There's this one, Drive, there's another one called Driven, there's Baby Driver, and then there's a Nick Cage movie called Drive Angry. They all kind of came out around the same time. This is by far the the best of the four of them. And none of them are Fashion and Furious. Oh no, this is a really good movie. Ryan Gosling is greatness. Uh Carrie Mulligan's in it, she's really good. Uh Albert Brooks is in it playing a villain, and it's a role that he's not really known for. He's really like scary in it.

SPEAKER_01And um, it's a good movie, man. And it there's a brutal scene where he uh where Gosling kills this guy in an elevator. I'm not gonna describe it. It's fucking brutal. But it's a really good movie, a very good movie. Uh yeah, all right. So we do have some fear news this evening.

SPEAKER_02And one big one of those uh breweries that we've often drank from is from Shock Top. And Shocktop and the Spirit Animal uh oh spirit animal spirit Halloween uh brand. Shocktop is my spirit animal. They are brewing up a shocktop candy corn wheat beer. I don't know how do you guys fall on the candy corn thing?

SPEAKER_01I love candy corn. I like candy corn. Okay. Dude, I'm not a big candy eater, but put a bowl of candy corn in front of me, and that fucker's done.

SPEAKER_02I can I enjoy it as well. Megan hates it, and a lot of people I know think it's vile, but um, that's not me. I'm I'm okay with that.

SPEAKER_03I will tell you this. I've already finished the first bag of the harvest mixed here.

SPEAKER_01That's the guy that's diabetic on the show. Eating a bag of basically hardened sugar.

SPEAKER_03I did not eat it in a day. It took me like two weeks, but all right.

SPEAKER_02So, one beer brand that'll push the boundaries of beer flavors back for its the upcoming Halloween season, the Portland, Oregon-based Shock Top is introducing a one-of-a-kind collaboration with Spirit, North America's premier Halloween retailer, for two limited edition collaborations for spooky season ahead. First up is the beer, Shock Top Candy Corn Wheat Ale, that also includes a great new Halloween Wedge Head costume sold exclusively at Spirit Halloween.

SPEAKER_02That brings parties to life. The collaboration invites uh fans to sip, suit up, and celebrate Halloween with a little more flavor and a lot more fun. The collaboration debut Shock Top Candy Corn Wheat, a limited edition beer inspired by the playful spirit and larger-than-life energy that Spirit Halloween brings to fans every fall. Blending Shock Top's signature wheat beer with the unmistakable flavor of Halloween's most iconic candy, the 5% ABV seasonal release, is brewed for costume parties, haunting gatherings, and collab and celebrating spooky season one sip at a time.

SPEAKER_02Shocktop is known for celebrating bold flavor, spirited gatherings, and moments that catch people by surprise. And there's no better occasion for that than Halloween, says Jacob Nielsen, senior brand manager at Shock Top. Partnering with Spirit, the most iconic name in Halloween, gave us the chance to dream up something hauntingly good that celebrates everything fans could love about the season. If Spirit Halloween is where fans become their favorite characters this year, they'll have a chance to step into the iconic orange slice of one of Beer's most recognizable mascots.

SPEAKER_02Available exclusively online at spirithalloween.com. The all-new Wedgehead costume. Transform Shock Top Legendary mascot into an easy-to-wear jumpsuit, retailing at$70. That's perfect for Halloween parties, bar crawls, costume contests, and anyone looking to squeeze a little extra personality into the spooky season. Spirit fans don't just have to celebrate Halloween, they can live for it. They are always looking for new ways to surprise them. Kim Sarkos, Executive Vice President of General Merchandise Manager at Spirit Halloween.

SPEAKER_02Pairing the launch with Shock Top's Candy Corn Weedale with our exclusive wedge head costume delivers the exact kind of head-turning, unexpected fun our fans are obsessed with. The limited edition beer and exclusive costume bring uh together two brands that are known to make the season more memorable. Shocktop Candy Corn Weedale is available at retailers nationwide, and the iconic there it is, Wedgehead costume is available at spirithalloween.com. So, I mean, not that you can find a Spencer's or a uh hot topic anymore, but you know, somebody's gonna make a ripoff of that.

SPEAKER_01I seriously doubt I seriously doubt anybody would make a onesie big enough to fit me, though. So um, I like shot top. They have uh a really good October fest and a really good pumpkin as well. All beers are good. I would try the candy corn. Yeah, I would give it a go. If I like candy corn enough, I'd give it a shot.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'll give it a shot. And it's also football season, gentlemen. I'm not sure if you're aware, but they're playing the footballs again. They have started with the footballs.

SPEAKER_01Uh Mike and I both both spent our Sunday watching red zone in the early afternoon and the Eagles game later in the afternoon. No, texting each other the entire time. And then watch a Dallas game at night. Texting each other the entire time.

SPEAKER_02Um if you are, and not that we necessarily are, but we're not against, uh, a fan of the uh uh Buffalo Bills, they are having exclusive Labat beer horns being sold at the High Mark Stadium this season. Bill Mafia will have even more to celebrate. Bill's Mafia will have even more to celebrate when the Bills host the Detroit Lions on September 17th. Marking the Hey, check that out. First, I have a regular season game at Hallmark Stadium.

SPEAKER_02To commemorate this historic occasion, fans can purchase an exclusive Labat beer horn, a reusable bison horn inspired drinking vessel created specifically for the Bills Mafia and available only at High Mark Stadium. There it is.

SPEAKER_01Apparently the that's good for pissing in afterwards.

SPEAKER_02The Labat beer horn includes a 16 ounce Labat blue light or labat blue can and is available for thirty dollars, which is kind of on par for what you'd pay for beer at a stadium, anyway.

SPEAKER_03I uh I have a question. Why would it be a horn in Buffalo? Wouldn't it be better in Minnesota with the Vikings.

SPEAKER_02Buffaloes have horns. Buffaloes have horns.

SPEAKER_03Yes, but Vikings tweak out of horns.

SPEAKER_01I have nipples, Greg.

SPEAKER_02Could you milk me?

SPEAKER_01It's perfect too, because like I said, like you can piss in it afterwards, and and men in Buffalo are notorious for their left-leaning dicks.

SPEAKER_02Um, every regular season home game. They will be up for sale until kickoff. Uh, fans can purchase the beer horn at the following locations, which are a series of locations at um the stadium. There are two Labat beer and gear stations located outside of Hallmark Stadium inside the secure gated perimeter. Uh, one is being located between Gates B and C. Uh, fans must be 21 years or older to purchase.

SPEAKER_02The collectible beer horn is reusable, and fans will be permitted to bring it back to Hallmark Stadium. I'm sorry, Highmark Stadium, throughout the season, provided it is empty when entering the stadium. Be sure to arrive early, secure your beer horn before kickoff.

SPEAKER_01I remember you did an article a week or two ago, or you're talking about one of the stadiums was going to do like a lower price day or something. Because people were complaining, and like it's it's crazy the price of shit at the stadiums now. Because Katie and I went to a Phillies game a couple weekends ago, and it was$107 for two tickets all the way at the top,$30 for parking. She got uh two pretzel twists, two sodas, and uh hot dog was like sixty dollars. You didn't go on dollar dog night.

SPEAKER_01No, it was fucking ridiculous. Uh yeah, anyway.

SPEAKER_02That's all the news.

SPEAKER_01There you go. Uh I only have one little bit of movie news, but I'm gonna play my song anyway because it's the first time in like eight weeks that I didn't have an obituary to read, and I want to hear my song.

SPEAKER_04So movie updates with Leo, movie updates with Leo, movie updates with Leo, movie updates with Leo.

SPEAKER_01So, as you guys know, the popcorn bucket tie-in is like a really big thing nowadays with all the movies. Uh, you had the Dune popcorn bucket that looked like a fleshlight, and you had um I'm trying to think of some other ones. Like just so many like crazy ones that have come out recently. You have the uh the uh one that look like a flashlight. Uh yeah. So I should my wife showed you the one she got from Practical Magic 2 before the show is a uh a margarita mixer thing because of midnight margaritas.

SPEAKER_01So it's like a big deal now. So I don't know if this is true. I've seen this on multiple sites now, and um I I haven't figured out the validity of it or not yet, but I really hope this is true. The tie-in bucket for Street Fighter is supposedly Guile's hair, and you can wear it, and there's the picture.

SPEAKER_01Cody Rhodes, uh WWE wrestler who's playing Guile in the film, wearing a plastic popcorn bucket shaped like Guile's hairdo, filled with popcorn that you can wear on your head and eat right out of your head. I'm hoping it's true because Cody Rhodes is wearing it in the picture, but who knows if that's AI or Photoshopped or whatever. So, but that yeah, it'd be like eating your own brains. I really hope that's true. That's my beer, that's my uh my movie update.

SPEAKER_01Like you have a must-track cramp for us?

SPEAKER_03I do. I have Pike Old Body is an American barley wine brewed in Pike Brewing Company in Seattle, Washington, USA. Known for its high strength and rich multi-complex. Most vinages sit around 9.9 ABV, though some releases reach 10% ABV. The beer is characterized by deep amber color, biscuity malt richness, and layers of caramel, brown sugar, and dark fruit.

SPEAKER_03Depending on the vintage, drinkers report notes ranging from sweet malt with minimal bitterness to a more hoppy, to a more hoppy forward profile with columbus, magnum, chinook, and centennial hops, contributing herbal and citrus notes, including a grapefruit tinged finish.

SPEAKER_03Older bottles often mellow into smoother, sweet, sweeter expressions with reduced hop bite, while fresh release show a powerful, complex balance of sweet malt, boozy warmth, and assertive hop bitterness.

SPEAKER_01Actually sounds good. I would try that. Um because it's a barley wine, of course, it's it's it's mixed with wine, so it's gonna be a little stronger anyway. But actually sounds pretty good. Yeah. All right, we're gonna take a go ahead together.

SPEAKER_02No, I just agreed with you. I won't do it again, sorry.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, well, that it's not un uncommon with a nine to ten percent ABV, you know, for a barley wine. So uh we're gonna take a quick break when we come back with our main segment tonight. We're gonna be playing the Roger Ebert Zero Star Review Game. Be right back. As has been my want, the last few episodes. Here is our promo poster for this week, and here is the theme song to go with it.

SPEAKER_03It's a little more aggressive than it did in the first time I want to think that you're a little smarter than this than putting the names of all the movies that you're gonna have to talk about on the It is not the name of the movies I'm gonna be talking about, motherfucker.

SPEAKER_01I made sure it wasn't any of the movies we're talking about. I hope you're smart enough to not do that. I am better than that. Yeah, it's not the movies that we're talking about. All right. So what we are doing tonight is a uh game that I threw together. Uh taking the legendary film critic Roger Ebert's zero-star reviews, whittling it down to 10 films, and uh seeing if these guys can guess what those movies are. Roger Ebert was an influential American film critic, journalist, and screenwriter who wrote for the Chicago Sun-Times from 1967 until his death in 2013.

SPEAKER_01Uh he has a degree from the University of Illinois and the University of Chicago. He won the Pulitzer Prize in 1975, becoming the first film critic to do so. Uh, Siskel and Ebert, alongside the Chicago Tribune critic Gene Siskel, they co-hosted a popular national movie review show called Sneak Previews and at the movies, popularizing the two thumbs up rating system. He is the first film critic to get a Hollywood star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame.

SPEAKER_01And he championed independent and foreign films, viewed cinema as a machine for generating empathy, and his legacy continues through Rogerebert.com, which is still active. There are uh film critics for the Chicago Sun Times who still write for Rogerebert.com. Uh, he has reviewed thousands of movies in his life. And in his articles that he wrote, he would often give it a uh one to four star review. One, of course, being a pretty bad film, four stars being a film that was pretty much perfect.

SPEAKER_01Uh, if he really liked the film, it usually got somewhere around three to three and a half stars. The average film was like two stars. But only 67 films of the thousands that he reviewed received zero stars. These are them. I'm gonna give you guys uh clues. Um, just guess it's not we're not gonna like take turns or whatever, you just throw it out and answer if you think you know it. I'll give you three clues. If you can't get it after the three clues, I will give you the name of the people who are in the film.

SPEAKER_03Okay.

SPEAKER_01Uh, in some cases, that should give it away, in others, even I don't know who these actors are. Um, but then after we figure out what the movie is, I'm gonna read you one or two lines from the actual review, which are pretty funny.

SPEAKER_03Sounds good.

SPEAKER_01So the first movie is actually a film that uh Cthulhu Jack brought to us on Films That Time Forgot. It's a 1986 uh horror/slash thriller uh that takes place largely on the highways and back roads of the American Southwest. Maxim overdraft? It's a good guess, not right, but it's a good guess. Uh, the protagonist is a young man doing a seemingly ordinary favor for a stranger, a decision that becomes increasingly catastrophic.

SPEAKER_01The villain seems almost supernaturally capable of appearing wherever the hero goes, turning the movie into an extended psychological cat and mousey. Highway villain, mid-80s, thriller involves a car and a young guy driving it, and a person in the car with him, who shouldn't be there.

SPEAKER_03No, I would say speed uh no, not speed, but the fucking phone. But it's not that one though.

SPEAKER_01So uh the villain is played by Rucker Howard. There was actually a remake with Sean Bean in the 2000s. Buffy the vampire slider. That'd be great. I would love a Sean Bean vampire.

SPEAKER_03Uh only there are like three or four of his movies. And none of them are that ones you know.

SPEAKER_01All right, so you give up. Yeah, the movie is called The Hitcher. Jack has actually brought this up on the show before. I remember guessing it because I couldn't get it until he said Rucker Howard's name. Uh so he objected especially strongly to the film Sadism and what he saw as an unacknowledged psychological bond between a hero and villain. Uh, his review contained this phrase This movie is diseased and corrupt.

SPEAKER_03Wow.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Okay, let's see if we can get some other ones here. This movie came out in 1979. It's an extremely controversial historical epic historical biography that had an unusually distinguished cast for a movie that became notorious for other reasons. One of those reasons being that it was produced by Penthouse Magazine, but is considered a mainstream movie.

SPEAKER_01The subject is about one of ancient Rome's most infamous emperors.

SPEAKER_02Caligula.

SPEAKER_01It is Caligula right here, starring Malcolm McDowell and Helen Miren. Peter all clearly, yeah. I remember for the longest time the only way you can get Caligula is to order it through Penthouse magazine. There is actual unsimulated sex scenes in the film, not involving the main cast, like it's like a cast of like penthouse models and stuff in the background.

SPEAKER_01It's a crazy fucking movie, man. Okay. Ebert said that this film was sickening, utterly worthless, and shameful trash. He actually walked out of the film. He did not finish the film's runtime. He felt that it was disgusting and utterly unspeakable and depressing.

SPEAKER_02Have you guys ever walked out of a movie? No, I've fallen asleep during movies. I didn't walk out of one. I was with somebody who walked out of one. And it wasn't a bad movie. She was just scared. Oh wow.

SPEAKER_01I mean, yeah, I could see that.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And then she was upset with me because I stayed for the rest of the movie. I paid for the ticket.

SPEAKER_01I got my my paid for two tickets. Like fleshlight popcorn bucket.

SPEAKER_02It was uh the gift with um with Katie Holmes?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. That's not even a scary movie. It's not. Admit it, you stayed to see Katie Holmes boobs. Like the two guys in Harold and Kumar. Um that's not even a scary. I fell asleep during uh Scanner Darkly, which is a Keanu Reeves movie based on a Philip K. Dick novel.

SPEAKER_02He was also in the gift.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, he was, yeah. It was a really boring movie, and I fell asleep during there was a non-musical version of Leh Mazarab starring Jeffrey Rush and Liam Neeson that came out in the 90s. It was boring as fuck. I fell asleep during that. You love and I love well, my favorite musical, but the move without the music, it was kind of boring. Uh next one here. This is a sequel. Uh-oh.

SPEAKER_01It's a 2005 comedy sequel. The predecessor had come out six years earlier. It takes the star of the movie and relocates him to a couple of European cities overseas, where he becomes involved in a murder investigation. He makes his living servicing extremely unusual clientele of women. I think like uh male prostitute.

SPEAKER_02Deuce Bigelow, male gigolo.

SPEAKER_01So that's the first film. What's the sequel? Deuce Bigelow. He's in Europe, so he is a European gigolo? He is a European gigolo. That's the sequel.

SPEAKER_03I didn't even know they made a sequel to that movie.

SPEAKER_01I didn't. I didn't see the sequel. I saw the first one, which I actually chuckled at a little bit. Um, but it wasn't funny enough for me to want to see European gigolo. And Rob Schneider wonders why he's not getting work anymore. Yeah, right. Uh this had one of the greatest critic versus filmmaker mic drops ever written. After Rob Schneider publicly attacked another critic for not being qualified to criticize the movie because he hadn't won a Pulitzer, Pulitzer Prize winning critic Roger Ebert responded, Mr.

SPEAKER_01Schneider, I have a Pulitzer, and your movie still sucks. And that wasn't even a paraphrase, that was the entire review. Wow. Oh man. Uh the next one is one that I have mentioned multiple times on this show as a joke. Uh, it is a 2001 comedy written and directed by the star. The protagonist is an inspiring artist whose ambitions create an increasingly hostile relationship with his father.

SPEAKER_01The movie's humor includes bodily fluids, injured animals, bizarre sexual material, and behavior that would probably result in several criminal investigations in reality, including an infamous scene where he plays a piano with a bunch of sausages hanging from the ceiling tied to the piano. Where he sings a song called Daddy, would you like some sausages? He was an MTV personality at a talk show on MTV. Tom Green. Why can't I think Tom Green? Yeah, the movie that Tom Green.

SPEAKER_01Freddie Got Fingered. Freddie Got Fingered. This movie is awful, and that is from somebody who watches a lot of awful films. Um, also, I think that around the time he was married to Drew Barrymore, which is also inexplicable. She was slow as much. I would say that this film is bottom of the barrel, but this movie doesn't even deserve to be mentioned in the same sentence as barrels.

SPEAKER_01Oh man. Uh really bad movie. So, Mike, this one's for you. He went the way of Andy Dick. I think I will get this one. He actually recently released a country album, Tom Green. And like serious country songs, not Tom Green being a uh a nut job country songs. He's actually a pretty decent singer. Uh yeah, Mike, this one's for you. It's gonna be a really hard guess, I think, but I think you can get this one because I'm gonna give you the actor as a clue, even though it's one of the things I was I was trying to save to the end.

SPEAKER_01But I think giving the actors the clue is the important part of this. This movie came out in 1968, the earliest film on this list. Uh, it is about real-world events happening at that time. Uh the actor of this film was also a co-director on it. It identified with political viewpoints he had at the time. Uh, the star and co-director of the film is the Duke, John Leen. Oh, that would be the Green Berets.

SPEAKER_01It is the Green Berets. This is one of Ebert's earliest reviews. Uh Ebert reduced this to an extraordinarily complicated contemporary conflict that was turned into a simple good guy, bad guy story. He didn't like that. Uh, he says, this is a cruel and dishonest and unworthy of the thousands who have actually died in Vietnam. It's uh it's actually one of my dad's favorite John Wayne films.

SPEAKER_03Probably one of my least favorites.

SPEAKER_01I think it's it's most people's like on like the bottom, most people's it's not as bad as The Conqueror or The Conqueror at the Genghis Khan film. That bad it's definitely not the searchers or True Grit or the Quiet Man.

SPEAKER_03No, no, it's not that. No.

SPEAKER_01Uh he fundamentally didn't like the film because he said it reduced Vietnam to a cowboys and Indians type movie. Which I mean, in there at least it was something like uh political point. It wasn't so much like just not liking the film. Right. The next one on the list is definitely not uh hate it because of politics, it's hated because it fucking sucks. This is a sequel that came out in 1987. It is a sequel involving an animal. It is the fourth sequel in an increasingly uh like decreasing in value way from where the movie the franchise started.

SPEAKER_01Free Willy. You're close, it is an aquatic-based animal. Okay. Flipper the fourth film in the franchise, which started with a major blockbuster. Um, the the Voyage Home. No. Well no. No, you're thinking of Final Frontier. That's the bad star track.

SPEAKER_02Oh, that's right. That's right.

SPEAKER_01Uh, but no, it's not that. This is brings back characters from early installments. The premise is really weird because it requires the audience to accept that the revenge villain animal is the revenge. Yes.

SPEAKER_03Yes, yes, there we go.

SPEAKER_01The the last clue is gonna be stars Michael Cain, who bought a house with this film's money, you know, the money got paid for it. Uh, so yeah, the last clue was it its premise requires the audience to accept that the antagonist has apparently developed not merely intelligence, but something resembling a personal vendetta against that family.

SPEAKER_03We make fun of these, but I always just forget there's anything besides the original Jost.

SPEAKER_01Just two is not bad. Just three is like where it starts to fall off the cliff, and Jost 4 is just ridiculous. Um, his review said, This is not simply a bad movie, it's also a stupid and incompetent one, too. He genuinely is a really good writer, he's a really good writer, and his reviews are are actually like fun to read and listen to and listen to him on the show and all. Like he's he's pretty good. But when he writes a bad review, man, he is he is scathing in his bad reviews.

SPEAKER_01Uh Kane missed accepting his Oscar for Hannah and her sisters because he was filming this movie. All right. The next one is a horror film, came out in 2011. It is a sequel to a film that Mike uh likes to make fun of me for watching. Uh a really gross horror film. Human centipede. Yes, but this is the sequel.

SPEAKER_01The human centipede 2, which is called the Human Centipede 2 full sequence. Let me tell you about this. I can't believe Ebert ever even looked at this film. What's the thing is like, because as a movie critic, you pretty much see everything, just about like you know, there you get invited to premieres and stuff. So like a lot of times he's kind of like forced to see it against his will, which probably makes it even worse. There's actually three movies in this human centipede uh canon.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, and each each one is a meta take on the previous one. So, like the first one is an evil doctor who creates a centipede out of three humans connected mouth to ass. The second movie is a black and white film about a uh mentally handicapped man who is obsessed with the human centipede film and decides he's gonna create his own human centipede with a hundred people, and then the third film is about a warden at a prison who likes using human centipede punishment on the prisoners.

SPEAKER_01It's like it just keeps getting worse and worse. This film, though, uh Roger Ebert said is an affront to any notion, however remote, of human decency. It is reprehensible, dismaying, ugly, and artless. Yes, I agree with all that, Raj. Uh, the next one is one we've actually talked about on the show before when we did our Rob Reiner special. Because Rob Reiner directed this film.

SPEAKER_01Came out in 1994. I keep forgetting to put the posters up on the screen that I have for this. So, like here's Jaws the Revenge. Here is the Green Berets. Here is the human centipede 2, which the only thing good good about the movie is how creepy the poster is. Here is European Gigolo. I think that's all the ones we've done so far. Yep. Alright. Um, this one uh a 1994 family comedy from Rob Reiner, who had already made several enormously successful and critically came claimed movies before this.

SPEAKER_01A young protagonist travels around the world encountering increasingly exaggerated cultural scenes. It isn't Norse. Norse. Look at the fucking cast, man. So it stars Elijah Wood, and then in cameo roles, uh, you have I can't see the names, it's too small. Hold on. You have John, John Lovitz, Bruce Willis, Jason Alexander, Dewey Louis Dreyfus, Dan Aykroyd, Faith Ford, Reba McIntyre, John Ritter, uh Kathy uh Bates. I think James Conn is in it.

SPEAKER_02The cast assigned for basically, yeah.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it's a stacked case. The entire journey begins because the boy decides his ordinary parents aren't paying enough attention to him and he searches for replacements. I think my parents own this on BHS. I so the uh review became so infamous that at a uh uh uh uh ceremony honoring Rob Reiner, uh the comedian Richard Belzer brought Rob Reiner on the stage to read the review of North.

SPEAKER_01And it starts with this line I hate it this movie, hate it, hate it, hate it, hate it, hate it this movie. And Rob Reiner uh said after reading that, you know, if you read between the lines, it really isn't that bad a review. But yeah, apparently he hated this movie. He said it was unpleasant, contrived, artificial cloying.

SPEAKER_01All right, I got two more. Uh the second to the last one I have here is a remake of a horror classic. Came out in 2003. The remake of a 70s horror cult classic. Halloween. You're you're you're in the right track. It's not Halloween, you're on the right track, though. Uh this remake Texas Chainsaw Massacre. You got it, sir.

SPEAKER_01This is the remake of Texas Chainsaw Massacre starring Jessica Beale. Uh so the poster I have is actually the uh original one, I think. I don't think this is the new one, but yeah, it's the remake of Texas Chainsaw Massacre. Uh landmark horror film. Uh his review said simply this uh there is not a shred of reason to see it.

SPEAKER_03Isn't that the same review we gave to uh the uh the what the thousand corpse the Rob Zombie movie?

SPEAKER_01Oh, the Rob Zombie movie. My review of that film was I hated this movie, hate it, hate it.

SPEAKER_02I thought that was our review of the psycho remake.

SPEAKER_01The psycho remake review is more like, why did you even bother making this? It's a shot for shot remake, but it's not even that's not acted as well as the original. And you got the guy from Dodgeball playing Norman Beats. Like it's just all right, Mike. This is the last one I have. I know you and I like this movie a lot, and this is gonna hurt us to hear this. Kev, I know you know this movie. I don't know if you like it as much as Mike and I do. If they were you no, I know you find the sequel to this film a lot funnier because you mentioned it a few times.

SPEAKER_01This movie came out in 1984. Let's see. Films and Fermentation Cult Classic. Uh, a comedy that was very successful despite its critical reception. Its premise depends upon new rules that result in a collection of wildly unsuitable people entering a profession for which many of them are spectacularly unqualified. It spawned six sequels. The main character only appeared in the first three police academy.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it is police academy. Roger Ebra gave zero stars police academy. It's a four-star masterpiece.

SPEAKER_02Oh, the goot was sad that day.

SPEAKER_03It it was it was it was the goot was the 80s golden child.

SPEAKER_01I mean, the first I mean it it was good until Guten left. That's why I said I know Kevin likes the second one because that's the one got Bobcat in it. We've mentioned that a few times. But I love Police Academy, I think it's very entertaining. Is it a perfect film? Hell no. Oh, does it have some bad performances in it? Yeah, but that's kind of the charm of like an 80s comedy like this. It's a sex comedy. Uh his line uh from his article was the least funny movie that could possibly have ever been inspired by airplane.

SPEAKER_01So he kind of looked at it as like a Zucker Brothers movie, like rip-all, which I don't see that. I mean, it's it's a campy comedy, it's a send up of like you know, police movies. The airplane film was straight satire and and you know, a lot of like punny jokes, you know, whereas Police Academy was just a uh you know a slapstick sex comedy. I don't know. It's it's probably the one on this list that I disagree with the most. Oh yeah. That enjoys the revenge.

SPEAKER_01That one's fucking classic. Uh so the last thing I have here is a bonus one. The uh bonus one is for the uh probably notoriously bad movie, The Room with Tommy Wisseau. It is this movie right here. There's the there's the there's the fucking promo for it. Jesus Christ, he's so creepy looking. I bet it's in this movie, so oh you don't have to, don't worry about it.

SPEAKER_01And it has this classic scene in it.

SPEAKER_00I did not hit her. It's not true. It's bullshit. I did not hit her. I did not. Oh, hi Mark.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, you've you've played that clip like a hundred times.

SPEAKER_01Uh it's it's it's probably the most infamous scene in the film. That and you're telling me the desire. Now, Roger died in 2013. This movie uh came out in 2002, I want to say, and he never reviewed it, which I thought was a shame. I would love to have heard like his actual review. So I went to Chat GPT and I said, hypothetically speaking, if Roger Ebert reviewed the room, what do you think he would have given it star wise?

SPEAKER_01And what would he have said about it? Uh he said or Chat GPT said that it believes Roger Ebert would have given this a half a star. He wouldn't have thinking it was bad enough or zero stars because he kind of appreciated quirky films like this. But the review says the room is a movie in approximately the same sense that a child's cardboard box is an automobile. It has many of the recognizable features and considerable enthusiasm has gone into its construction, but questions arise as to whether or not you should attempt to drive it.

SPEAKER_01And I'm like, That's that GBT, but that pretty much sounds like Roger Efer. And it goes into like a little uh like uh summary of the film. I have seen performances that are wooden. Wisseau's transcends wood. His line readings arrive from some unexplored region beyond conventional human speech where emphasis and emotion have been randomly reassigned. When Johnny laughs, I am uncertain whether Johnny is amused, whether Wiseau is amused, or an entirely different person somewhere off camera is amused.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it just keeps going, but it's really it's really pretty funny because it it sounds really very much like a Roger Ebert review. Uh he gave zero stars to notoriously bad films. Uh so you know that's kind of like where I was trying to go with this. I thought it would be fun just to kind of guess these movies a little bit. Um, there are, of course, 67 movies on the full list. Many of them I have not seen. There's some like foreign films on there, so I tried to like stick to movies that I've I felt like we'd be able to guess.

SPEAKER_01Okay.

SPEAKER_02Uh so you did remarkably well.

SPEAKER_01You did very well, sir. Yeah. You did very well. Uh, you have any beer career before you're tonight, Mike?

SPEAKER_03I do. This is the accidental sh accidental champagne beer. And night in 1890, a French brewer accidentally used champagne yeast in a lager. The result: a hyper-dry, sparkling beer that confused drinkers and was banned by local guilds for blurring beverage identity. We can't have gender fluid beer. Yeah, I think I think the the barley beers nowadays would have been uh banned then, too.

SPEAKER_01Oh, the barley wines, the uh the uh the bourbon kisk uh uh wines, yeah. I would have drank that shit. Champagne beer. Uh we have a cinema quote week.

SPEAKER_02I cried one on set once because craft services ran out of donuts. That was from Zendaya. She looks like she enjoys a good donut, doesn't she?

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, yeah. I think she eats them all the time. Yeah. I enjoy a good donut. It goes right to nowhere. It goes right to Kevin's hips. Pretty much. I eat a donut and my ass gets batter immediately. Uh, so my uh drink envy has been quenched tonight. I had two Oktoberfests and a Jacko pumpkin from Sam Adams, so I'm happy.

SPEAKER_02This was amazing. It goes in easy and it is um 8.4 man. I'm just I'm happy.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that that looks good. Like I'm I'm a little jealous. I might have to go and get that now, too. The Elysium pumpkin beer. Mike, you're drinking your your your can of Hawaii right there, right?

SPEAKER_03Yes, yes, yes, yes.

SPEAKER_01So now Cone is great. I mean, everything from Cone is amazing, too. Even like your IPA.

SPEAKER_03So I'm not complaining about mom, but I'm getting I'm killing that pumpkin.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, it's the it is the season. It is the season. I actually still have some summer ales in my fridge too from Sam Adams. I gotta kill those all too. Uh so thank you for joining us tonight for episode 254, the people versus Roger Ebert. We hope you enjoyed listening to the podcast as much as we enjoyed recording it for you. Remember, you can email us to filmsofertation at gmail.com or visit linktree.com slash films of fermentation. Find all of our social media podcast links. You can watch us on YouTube, you can watch us on Rumble, or you can join our Patreon, patreon.com slash films of fermentation.

SPEAKER_01Or text us at 904-867-4466. We'd love to hear from you. Did any of these movies surprise you? Uh, did you agree that police academy did not deserve zero stars as well? Let us know. And don't forget to stop by the crossroads between pickle and every minute next time around for episode 255. We're gonna do another draft episode. This one should be really fun. We're gonna be drafting our favorite movies that have practical effects. The three of us have always talked pretty extensively about how much we love practical effects, and this will be a good way to celebrate that.

SPEAKER_01This should be a really fun episode. So join us next time around. In the meantime, I'm Leo, I'm Kevin, I'm Mike. This has been the Films and Fermentation podcast. Cheers, everybody. Cheers.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. This Year in Film History (1990)

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 29 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Tonight on Films & Fermentation, we're firing up the DeLorean and heading back to 1990, when VHS ruled, movie tickets were cheap, and nobody needed six streaming subscriptions to watch a damn movie....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. My Captain, My Professor, The Great Sir Patrick Stewart

    Nov 10, 20261 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Tonight on Films & Fermentation, we raise a glass to the incomparable Sir Patrick Stewart, a legendary actor whose extraordinary career took him from the Shakespearean stage to the bridge of the USS...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 60th Anniversary of "It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown"

    Nov 3, 20261 hrAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Tonight on Films & Fermentation, we're celebrating the 60th anniversary of It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown, the beloved Halloween classic that taught generations of children about friendship,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Films that Time Forgot (Halloween Edition)

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail October is Breast Cancer Awareness Month. Breast cancer affects millions of individuals and families, and early detection, research, and support can make a real difference. If you'd like to learn more...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Halloween Movie Recasts: Humans, Muppets & Horrible Decisions

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 3 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Tonight on Films & Fermentation, we're celebrating Halloween by doing what Hollywood does best: taking perfectly good movies and replacing the actors with people who have absolutely no business being...

    Credit the people on this episode