Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Field Notes

Field Notes artwork

Ep 64: Debra Rienstra – The significance of surviving remnants

Sep 1, 202647 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In a time of mass ecological collapse, the ecological concept of refugia offers a lifeline of hope and gives meaning to even small-scale effort. First coined in the mid-19th century by naturalist Edward Forbes, it describes how entire landscapes can recover from surviving pockets of habitats and their creatures. In this episode we talk with Debra Rienstra, author of Refugia Faith: Seeking hidden shelters, ordinary wonders and the healing of the Earth about how we can become people of refugia, finding and nurturing places of safety and health for biodiversity, human culture and faith. Debra is professor of English at Calvin University, where she has taught since 1996, specializing in creative nonfiction, early British literature, and environmental literature. She and her husband have three grown children. She lives in Michigan in the Grand River watershed. Find out more at https://debrarienstra.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello, and welcome to the Field Notes Podcast from Arosha. I'm Joe Swinney and I'm Director of Communications for Orosha International.

SPEAKER_04And I'm Rick Fah, and I've been with Arosha for 20 years as part of the Arosha Canada team.

SPEAKER_00For many of us, the rapid loss of our planet's biodiversity, increasing inequality and poverty, and the changing climate can feel overwhelming.

SPEAKER_04So it's our hope that in this podcast you will hear some remarkable and original perspectives from people we know who are working to care for creation around the world.

SPEAKER_03And I started thinking about scripture and thinking about how much God seems to love working with small, hidden, unimportant things.

SPEAKER_04Welcome to the next episode of the Field Notes Podcast. Today we have another uh delightful guest that we got to interview. Uh, her name is Deborah Reinstra, and she is an English professor at Calvin University. Uh, and it may seem a little unlikely, hey, we're we're a podcast about um earthkeeping and creation care and and biology and such. How come we're interviewing uh an English professor? And yet I found this quite a stimulating and uh encouraging actually conversation.

SPEAKER_04Uh Joe, I'm curious what uh how it struck you, what what stood out?

SPEAKER_01Well, I was fan girling a bit embarrassingly at the beginning before we hit record, I'm glad to say, because I have known about Deborah, specifically about a book she's written dealing with this concept of um refugia. And she's written a book about it as a metaphor for faith, but also earthkeeping. And I have to confess I haven't read the book, but just the metaphor itself has been one of the most hopeful stories that I've come across in latter years because well, I don't want to steal her thunder.

SPEAKER_01It's it's to do with yeah, I I'm not even gonna say I'm not gonna, I'm not gonna spoil the fun for everybody, just to say she's great, she's very articulate. It's uh an immensely powerful concept that she's sharing with the world. She'd be she's keen to say it's not her original thinking, but she's done a lot to to make it accessible.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, I love the way that it can connect uh her ideas and the the concepts that she's been working on. They help to motivate and inspire even people who may feel like I'm plugging away here in some like corner that nobody notices. And it's does this does this matter? Does this matter? And there's there's a way in which the refugia and idea and how she applies it, it gives a a kind of momentum and a a kind of I want to say almost like it houses all those unseen efforts in a way that um brings cohesion to them and and a feature to them.

SPEAKER_04It kind of brings, it brings, I see the future uh with of those unseen actions in light of this metaphor. And that's that's quite a remarkable say thing to say about just a metaphor. Like um, and yet that's that's what it's done for me. So um we'd love to share it with with you all now. Every time we do the Field Notes podcast, we get to speak to different people all around the world.

SPEAKER_04And today we have Deborah Rienstra. And Deborah I'm we want to give our listeners a bit of a sense of where you're coming from today. So if by chance I ever am fortunate enough to come and visit you where you are today, and we had like an afternoon to go to one of your kind of favorite haunts, a place where we're like, oh, this is uh a local, a local patch that I really like. What are some of the local creatures that we might see, or what why is this space particularly meaningful to you?

SPEAKER_03Oh, thank you for that question. It's very fun to have this uh conversation with you today, Rick. Um, well, we probably start in my yard and I would show you around my very tiny scruffy yard and show you all the little plants that I've grown from seed, all the native plants. I would point out the swamp milkweed and rattlesnake master, which is one of my favorite. And um I would be a little embarrassed because it does look awfully scruffy, but it's full of life.

SPEAKER_03I write about my yard all the time. And I imagine when people read what I've written, they think it's some glorious estate. It is not, it's just a regular old yard.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03But I've got to know it know the the trees in it, and I've done so much work. Um, Ron and I, my spouse and I have done so much work on it, getting rid of invasives. So we would have a little lecture on invasives and natives and pollinators, and then we would get in my electric vehicle and drive out to the lake, by which we always mean in West Michigan. When you say the lake, that means Lake Michigan. We would drive out to my very special place on the shore where um Ron's family has had a cottage for 40 years.

SPEAKER_03It's in 19 or an 1890-something built cottage on the shoreline. So that too is fairly scruffy, but it's a beautiful spot. And we would um look at the lake itself, which is always changing. The colors, the motion, the sounds of the lake are so amazing. And we would um walk along the dunes. Freshwater coastal dunes are rare on the earth, and Michigan has one of the most beautiful, spectacular coastal freshwater dune systems in the world.

SPEAKER_03So we would look at the plants there and probably see a lot of seagulls and a lot of dead fish.

SPEAKER_04Seagulls would be happy about that. That sounds lovely. Yeah. 1890 uh cottage. I the one of the things that struck me is like here in my part of the world, kind of the west coast of Canada, that's a very old building. But in Joe's part of the world, that's just like the newcomer to the lot or to the street. Yeah. So our sense of history is very different.

SPEAKER_03Well, they have updated it since the 1890s, of course. It has modern plumbing and so on.

SPEAKER_04Yes, indeed.

SPEAKER_01So, and so you're an English professor, and um, I studied English at in undergrad, and um, so and you would have been my favorite professor, no doubt. But uh and you've also written a book called Refusia Faith, as I understand that refusal is um an ecological concept or a kind of biological phenomena, but you've taken it and it's um your book is about how it is a beautiful metaphor for for Christians in the church, but also um gives an enormous amount of hope for earth keeping.

SPEAKER_01And we'd love to dig more into that. I know that you've you've had a lot to say, not just this one book, another book coming and the podcast, and we will put all the links to those things in the notes. But could you help us um draw the lines between you as an English literature professor and you as an earthkeeper and inspirer of people in ecology around the world?

SPEAKER_03Oh, thank you for that question, Joe. Well, you know yourself that English is the queen of all the disciplines. Yes. Everything, everything is text, everything is English. Uh everything is story. Everything is story, everything is language. Um this was this development in my career came as a surprise to me. Uh, I really got into ecological interests and science um through books, no surprise there, and through Calvin University's festival of faith and writing.

SPEAKER_03I've been involved with that for a long, long time, and started reading Nature Writers. Uh, I've been teaching creative nonfiction at Calvin for a long time, and started reading Nature Writers by way of figuring out who to invite to the Festival of Faith and Writing. And it was through reading Kathleen Dean Moore that I came across the idea of Refugia, which we can talk about a little more. Um, and also Bill McKibben. So it was really when I read Bill McKibben's books in order to invite him to Calvin University, that I thought, you know what?

SPEAKER_03I need to be working on this. I need to be contributing to this moment of historical transition to a more just and sustainable way to live on this planet. So reading eco-theology just felt like this amazing missing piece. And that has changed the trajectory of my scholarship and writing entirely.

SPEAKER_04I mean, if that's how you got started, which is sounds very akin to some of my uh my story too, which actually my story around this begins in Michigan as well. It's just at the Asabble Institute, which I'm sure you're familiar with.

SPEAKER_03Oh, yes, of course.

SPEAKER_04Um, so I I got to visit some of the dry sand um ecosystems when I was there years and years and years ago. But uh if that's how it got you started, that doesn't necessarily mean that's what keeps you going. Um, so I'm curious, like in the face of you know the litany, climate, biodiversity loss, pollution, you know, and so on and so forth, what why is it worthwhile to invest uh what you're doing now, which is a lot of time and energy into this?

SPEAKER_04Uh what compels you uh at this point? It might have started with nature writers and eco-theologians, but what about now?

SPEAKER_03Well, one of the ways we deal with our anxiety and our um sense of grief is by doing something. And I have found that to be true in my own life. Um I thought a lot lately about virtue ethics, which is to say we do things not necessarily because they will have the perfect outcome. We do things not necessarily just because it's our duty, even though I think it is, and I think we could find plenty of biblical backup for that.

SPEAKER_03Um, but we do it because uh it is the kind of person we want to be. It is a virtuous thing to do. And I I think this is uh a wisdom found in all faith traditions, that at some point you have to let go of the outcome and do things because they are right, and right in a way that's even deeper than like law and duty. Right in the sense of this is the kind of human being we are meant to be.

SPEAKER_03People who care for the earth, people who care for their neighbor in whatever way. And in in my case, I'm trying to love my neighbor by gathering us all together, um, especially people of faith, into this beautiful project of being connected to each other and to this planet in ways that are reciprocal. It's about reciprocity, as Robin Walkimmerer says, that are generous, that are kind.

SPEAKER_03Um, this is the kind of person I want to be. It's the kind of world I want to live in. And so I'm just trying to do that every day. It's not like I don't care about outcomes. I mean, the outcome consideration here is everything we do mitigates how bad this crisis can get. Biodiversity, habitat loss, climate change, temperature, extreme weather, everything we do mitigates that. Um, but I think especially those of us who have have been used to agency and influence, even in our own small worlds.

SPEAKER_03Um, those of us with a certain amount of power and privilege are used to seeing a problem solving a problem. And we get very impatient, but can't solve the problem, right? Well, we've got a problem here we're not going to fix. We can make it better and we can make it less worse, and that's what we have to do. I just find that very compelling. And the other thing that keeps me going is meeting people like you who are doing the same work. And um, that has been such a rich source of joy, even amid the the grief of what we're going through.

SPEAKER_03That has been such a source of joy.

SPEAKER_01Deborah, could you could you talk to us about this refugia concept? And a fair number of our listeners might well not have come across it at all. So if you could if you could tell the story of the place where it was identified as a phenomenon, and just tell us before you, before any sort of application or or metaphorical overlays, if you could just tell us how it works, what it is. Sure.

SPEAKER_03Sure. Um I came across this reading Nature Writers. Um I came across it in Kathleen D. Moore's book, Great Tide Rising, which is a uh, she's a moral philosopher, nature writer, and she makes a moral case for why people should care and work um in mitigating and adapting to climate change. It's a beautiful book. And just in a few pages in the middle, she describes the eruption of Mount St. Helens volcano in Washington State in the United States, and the way that that enormous eruption in 1980 devastated that hillside.

SPEAKER_03Um, well, it's a mountainside and covered it with ash, and it looked like the moon, basically. And people thought, oh, you know, we're not going to see any growth there for ages. And it turns out within five, 10 years, 20 years, the whole mountainside greened up again. And they scientists, as they will do, went up there, biologists went up there and thought, what's going on? And they realized that even under the ash, some little tiny pockets of life survived. There was already a term for that, and the term is refugia.

SPEAKER_03Um, it was a term developed in paleobiology for describing how anything survived the ice age, the last ice age, and or any ice age, but the last one especially. And the idea was there were pockets of life that survived, and those pockets of life became the seed beds for renewal. Um, so I was immediately struck by that, and I read up more about it. There's a whole uh area of management, um, wild, wildplace management, refugial conservation biology.

SPEAKER_03So it's it's really the idea, the definition is habitats where biodiversity can retreat to, persist in, and potentially expand from under changing environmental conditions. So it's a recognized phenomenon. It's interesting to me how many biologists haven't even heard of it. Sometimes I'll meet science, you know, heavily involved science people and they'll say, Oh, well, I don't know. Uh, or, oh yeah, I heard about that. But it immediately struck me, because once again, English professor as a great metaphor.

SPEAKER_03Um, and I've just been sort of fascinated by it ever since.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, it is a great metaphor. And um uh can you help us expand the layers of that? What how have you found it to be uh connecting to earthkeeping and and particularly to scripture?

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, those those are kind of two different questions, two different related questions. So maybe we'll start with scripture. It struck me right away. I mean, I remember sitting in a lecture. Kathleen Dean Moore came to Calvin and she was uh giving a lecture, and uh she might not have even been talking about refugee at the time, but it just struck, I mean, remember the moment when I was sitting in that lecture thinking, oh, this is this is the church, you know. Um, and I started thinking about scripture and thinking about how much God seems to love working with small, hidden, unimportant things.

SPEAKER_03I was thinking about Abraham, you know, the story of Abraham. He's like nobody, just some dude from Ur of the Caldees. But God says, I choose you. Um, and it's through your family that all nations will be blessed. Uh, or even the the people of Israel, you know, they're they're just this tiny little mini kingdom, usually being harassed by their enemies. Yeah. Even in their heyday, they were like this tiny little thing under the machinations of huge empires, and yet God uses them.

SPEAKER_03Um, the story of Jesus. I mean, think about Mary, small, hidden, um, unimportant seemingly, and yet this is how God works. The the parables of the mustard seed, the parable of the pearl of great price. So it just struck me that God loves small, unlikely things that then become amazing. Um, yeah. So I I thought, is that maybe a way to think about the church? And the way to think about our role.

SPEAKER_03Um, our role is not the church of empire, right? Our role is to be the people who find and nurture and even maybe create these small hidden, maybe not even hidden, these small places where life-giving capacities can strengthen and renew. They're not necessarily, they're not necessarily entirely safe. They're just sort of relatively safe. And their purpose is not to hide, their purpose is to spread and connect.

SPEAKER_03And that's actually how refugia in nature connect. They connect through corridors. They they spread if they work. Sometimes they don't. You know, that's the other thing about refugias, they don't always work. And a refugium for one creature may not be a refugium for another. They're very local, they're very specific. So all of this struck me too as a way to marvel at the resilience of the natural world and to think about it in terms of biomimicry, um, which is the sort of science of looking at how natural systems work and thinking how we can model technology or human systems on those natural systems.

SPEAKER_03So combining this idea of this already built-in form of nature's resilience with the scriptural witness that seems to suggest this is how God likes the people of God to work too, right? We don't conquer. Yeah, we we are life-giving seed beds. Um, so it just seemed to me this is a great approach to creation care or climate justice. And it turns out it kind of um comports really well with systems theory.

SPEAKER_03Uh, the idea that, you know, unlike say McDonald's, where you franchise the very same exact thing um across uh the world, basically. No, um, this refugee model is like every local place has its own unique properties. And you don't just franchise it everywhere, but you sort of seed it so that it adapts in its own local places. So it's a way of of dealing with the scale of the challenges that we face.

SPEAKER_03Um because they are so overwhelming, the climate crisis is so overwhelming, all of it, environmental injustice, biodiversity loss, it's so overwhelming, um, it becomes paralyzing. But the fact is, all these global problems are felt on a local scale and they have local solutions, not like we don't learn from each other. We should do that. But to think about, okay, well, what can I do right here, right now, with what we've got?

SPEAKER_03Refugee are not necessarily high resource spaces, they can be low resource spaces. And rather than trying to uh make everybody do exactly what I'm doing, just do what's right for here and then communicate, you know, communicate, link up to other places that are doing their own thing.

SPEAKER_01It's just a phenomenally hopeful, a hopeful story, a hopeful aspect of how God's designed creation. And just a tiny detail I remember catching as well in reading around this idea, um, and your blog and things like that was. Even the redemptive part of where an animal had died would become even more nutrient intense, and what had been sheltered beneath that animal in its place of death would do perhaps even better.

SPEAKER_01And sometimes like you just feel you can feel looking around, reading the news and or or being in a place you really love that has been absolutely decimated, that it's gone forever, and you can't conceive of it coming back. And but just the tiniest crevices of surviving life. And it will come back and it will come back stronger. Sometimes I feel it's not even that we have to do anything to repair it, it's inherently woven in to how it was made.

SPEAKER_01We just have to stop actively destroying it. We just stop bashing it for one minute and it will start to be what it was supposed to be. I mean, we saw that in COVID, even in the way that the skies turned clear again very quickly when the planes were grounded and things like that. But I wonder if you could tell us a bit more about how this has shaped your life. You you mentioned in the first question your backyard.

SPEAKER_01Is is that tended with refusal in mind? Are you hoping you're like if the whole of Michigan goes that you you've got enough diversity in your plot to be the wellspring of its recovery?

SPEAKER_03Oh, absolutely not. We would perish instantly. Um, yeah, we're not growing food. I mean, the pollinators would be fine. We would probably perish, but the pollinators would be fine. Um I think we we tend our little yard probably with we call our native pollinator gardens the refugia, you know. I mean, it's kind of ridiculous. Uh I think we tend it more as partly, you know, a kind of stewardship.

SPEAKER_03Like, look, this tiny little one-third acre, we are in charge of making this a place where life can thrive. Okay. Uh, we don't know what we're doing, we're learning. So part of it is just fun science experiment. Part of it is just the pleasure of watching flowers grow. Um, I wouldn't say we're all that virtuous about it, but the the thing that um people seem to appreciate about the refugia model is this idea that small is not insignificant.

SPEAKER_03And I appreciate what you said about, you know, death to life. I think that's very important, especially for Christians to remember. I don't want to say that there's not grieving and loss involved. I think we have to acknowledge that. And fortunately, as Christians, we have we have ways of practicing lament that are scriptural and beautiful and consoling. And it's a spiritual gift that we can give to others who don't have that gift.

SPEAKER_03Um, we understand about repentance. We know how to, well, at least we should know how to repent. But we also understand the crux of death and life. I mean, that's what the cross is, right? That's what the resurrection garden is. It is where death and life intersect. That is the heart of the Christian faith. Baptism, dying and rising. Um, so I don't want to take away from the grief that we feel about habitat loss and the places that we are losing, the species that we are losing.

SPEAKER_03But I do think we we want to celebrate, as you say, celebrate the resilience of the natural world. And yes, sometimes we we just have to leave it alone. I will say in my own yard, if you leave things alone, nasty things grow. So you really, I think there's a wonderful combination, a wonderful role for human ingenuity and art.

SPEAKER_01That's well said. It's like I I did imply there that if we just go away, it's all much better. And that's the Genesis story. The genesis story is that we're really good gardeners. Naturally, we have an important role.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03But it's true. What you said about COVID is absolutely true. And when we stop doing our extractive damaging things, nature will meet us halfway. And actually, there's a wonderful documentary about that time. Um, and one of the things in the documentary that's really helpful is watching what happened during COVID allowed people to learn, for example, I wish I could really had a good example to hand here, but to learn, for example, where the turtles, where the sea turtles would come up on the beach if we just left the beach alone for a little while, where they would come up and hatch their eggs.

SPEAKER_03Okay, so we're going to uh fence off that part of the beach during their hatching season to help them, right? We didn't know that when the whole beach was covered with people or whatever. Um to use our big brains and our opposable thumbs and our science and technology to know where to hold back and to know where to go in and heal. That's one of the things I think about a lot is the the calls, the vocational call of Genesis to tend and keep, serve and observe.

SPEAKER_03There's different ways to interpret those beautiful Hebrew words in Genesis 2.15. Um, that's beautiful, that's right. That's our primary vocation. But we are not in pre-Genesis 3 land, right? We are after that and we have done a lot of damage. So I think we have to update that vocation with healing. So we are we are the people called to heal as well. And sometimes healing is leaving well enough alone. Apparently, right now in Chernobyl, the wildlife is doing great.

SPEAKER_02Like what?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Chernobyl was like just drenched in radiation. And I'm sure, you know, those animals will be doing better without the radiation. But so leaving things alone, but but yes, also healing damage and mitigating damage that continues to be done, those are also, I think, our sort of extended genesis vocation.

SPEAKER_04An example of that for me in my life is uh the effort. And I spend a lot of hours dealing with invasive plants.

SPEAKER_03Yes, right.

SPEAKER_04Particularly in in my part of the world, Himalayan Blackberry is one of those, but there's there's a whole list of them.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Uh and it's an example to me of this like per like it takes a l effort, takes time, it takes a somewhat some like big brain, use your intelligence. Okay, how are we gonna do this? But it also takes a kind of will, like a bit of the virtue of like, I'm not sure if this is gonna work, but I actually think this is just probably the thing to do here.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_04But then when I have done that or been a part of people who are doing that, if if we persist, I can see often like the difference it makes. Um, oh wow. This section of the river used to just be a whole bunch of reed canary grass.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_04Now there is like plants of all different sorts thriving there, and like the the fish are back to spawn, and you know, like the it it can it can happen. Um there's uh what is the Hopkins? Um there's a deeper, uh deepest fresh down things. Oh, I gotta feel the core grandeur, but but like there's this kind of this kind of core of life that is sort of waiting to spring out, if only we give it a chance. And sometimes getting it a chance means, like you say, holding off, but sometimes it means like being really assertive.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um and then fill in the blank of whatever, whatever the the invasive species is that's trying to that that prevents the other biodiversity that would want to live there to to thrive. And but some but the the effects can be seen.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Which makes me wonder as you use this term refugia and apply it to church, like what are some of the fruits of doing that?

SPEAKER_03One of the things I've noticed as I go around speaking and talking to people about this, it often the refugia metaphor often names what they're already doing. And that naming is so validating. They feel like they somehow they have more energy and motivation to do the work because they have this metaphor. Metaphors are powerful, right? They're vivid ways to say a lot with a few words.

SPEAKER_03That's why we love metaphors. Um, so just to have a way to name what they're already doing helps a lot. And there have been organizations, um, the BTS Center and Creation Justice Ministries, I'm just naming a couple here in the United States, who have uh taken this metaphor as sort of a useful way to teach others. And I'm so grateful for that. That's great. Um, but a lot of times, as I say, they're the metaphor just names what they're already doing.

SPEAKER_03So I'll tell you a few stories. Um I have many in the new book that's coming out soon. So I'll give you a few examples. Uh, I was just talking this week with the beautiful people at Glad Tidings, Church of God in Christ in Hayward, California. It's in the Bay Area, San Francisco Bay Area in Oakland or near Oakland. And they, this is a very economically stressed neighborhood, uh, a lot of injustices of all kinds, um, went through a really rough period in the 90s with drugs and they struggle with incarceration.

SPEAKER_03Anyway, there's this powerhouse church there that has slow sort of slowly been buying up land. They they literally have a campus. They've built housing, they've done a million things. But what they're working on right now is to become a resilience hub. So they have installed solar, they have EV chargers, they have like a community space. And in, you know, sort of normal times, it's a community center. People can go there, there's a gym. Uh, if there is to be a crisis, like a wildfire, which is pretty likely in Northern California, um, terrible air quality, people can go there.

SPEAKER_03They can they can house hundreds of people, like they could be a shelter for hundreds of people. They have trained a bunch of people from the church to do this. They have staff. I mean, it's an incredible example of this sort of refugia work. Totally different one over on the other side of the United States along the East Coast. There's a guy called Heber Brown, who um is a pastor, Baptist Church pastor. And it all started for him with his congregation's health concerns.

SPEAKER_03He kept going to the hospital and visiting people with health concerns, and he realized it's because their diet's not good. It's a food apartheid issue. They can't get cheaper or you know, inexpensive fresh food. And uh he thought, all right, well, let's plant a garden. And he didn't know anything about gardening, but somebody in the church did, Sister Maxine. And so they planted this tiny little garden, and other churches got jealous and started planting gardens.

SPEAKER_03And one thing led to another, and now there's this Black church food security network all up and down the East Coast. Uh 250 churches, 100 black farmers. They've created a food shed. I mean, it's a perfect refugia example because his tiny little itty-bitty garden. I shouldn't say his, he would not say that. His churches, tiny little garden, inspired other churches to do it in their own way. One thing led to another, connections, there's a whole organization, and now it's a local food shed.

SPEAKER_03Um, another example, there's a church in on Oahu in Hawaii. And they, long story, but they wound up owning a golf course. So they moved their church to the golf course. They uh sort of, you know, remade the clubhouse into their one of the ballrooms as their sanctuary, and uh they rented out as an event space, but they were trying to figure out what to do with this golf course that wasn't making money, it wasn't really functional, it was sold to them because the developer couldn't make a profit on it.

SPEAKER_03Well, it turns out it's in a very wet area that wants to be tropical rainforests. So, right, it's really gonna be hard to maintain a golf course.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_03So they're rewilding nine holes of this golf course. And as you say, it takes enormous persistence and time. They they are on 30-year horizons. Uh, they're removing invasive species. Albezia trees is an invasive species. Um, but all of those, all of those groups are practicing what I would call refugia work. They are doing the right thing in a way that they hope is both the right thing for them, but also inspires others.

SPEAKER_01So I imagine that um you get asked to speak in on this in a couple of different contexts, maybe. I imagine you are invited into Christian places where people care already for creation and earthkeeping, and probably also into churches that want to see it as a purely kind of spiritual Christian biblical metaphor and aren't really receptive at all to the earthkeeping side of it, other than that, oh, it's a nice picture for the Christian life.

SPEAKER_01Um, have has am I right in assuming that there might be some resistance? Um, it's been some circles.

SPEAKER_03I mean, those people are not necessarily inviting me. So I don't, you know, I think my the people who are interested in what I do are from places where they at least have a sense probably we should be doing something. Now, that's not to say that there aren't people who within their same congregations or groups who are resistant. You're right about that. Those people don't show up to my talks usually. Um but they are there, and I would say the people I talk to are concerned with talking to those who are resistant.

SPEAKER_03Right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And would would your take be that there is still within Christian communities a desire to shut out the concern for the earth from the on the church?

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. In the United States for sure. Uh probably much more so. And I I don't know about that specifically, churches and other cultures or other countries. Um, in the United States, the research is very clear that the majority of people, it's true, the majority of people of faith across faiths, are worried about climate, but don't talk about it. They also, the majority of pastors, clergy, the research shows, uh accept climate change as real.

SPEAKER_03Now, there's some quibbles in more conservative circles about whether it's human-caused or for sure human-caused. So that's a little bit of an issue. But um even so, the majority believe it's of clergy believe it's real and human-caused, but they don't talk about it. So there's sort of this cone of silence over it. And this is the result, I think, especially in the US, of a lot of generations of disinformation and deceit from the fossil fuel industry.

SPEAKER_03We just have to name it. We have the receipts, we know the fossil fuel industry knew that their products would cause this exact. I mean, the science from Exxon was even more precise than the science from NASA uh back in the 90s, the 80s and 90s. And we know about this determined disinformation campaign and misinformation campaign. Unfortunately, that has been very effective in especially uh white evangelical circles, according to the research.

SPEAKER_03And, you know, we have this sort of long history of ideas that have been baptized by Christianity that in fact serve industry, um the empire, you know, extractive industry. And I would say some of those ideas are, for example, dualism, the division of the spiritual and the material, and the um the sense that the church is about the immaterial and the spiritual, and everything else is uh out of our out of our lane.

SPEAKER_03Um you know, I so we have to name those things. It's really uncomfortable to name those things. I think we all are sort of drenched in it here in the US.

SPEAKER_04So it's Yeah, I mean it seems to me um one of the uh foundations is the our understanding of hope. Um, which uh I'm keen to make a distinction between our our faith or a biblical understanding of hope and and optimism. Um those things aren't synonymous, and yet often they are treated that way, I find, in in the discourse around these topics in in our in our in my society at least.

SPEAKER_04Um but I'm curious, uh hope I think ultimately uh is rooted in Christ for those of us that are Christ followers, but but it also is built through doing things that we do. Uh and I'm curious what it looks like in your life to embody hope by various practices. Um what what are some things that you do that help you to uh build hope in your life and for those that are kind of connected to your sphere of influence?

SPEAKER_04Um how does that work out for you?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you for that. Um one of the things uh people have so many beautiful things to say about hope. Hope is a discipline, hope is a duty, you know, uh hope is action. Yes, that's a very common one, and I agree with it. I've experienced that. Uh Rick Lindroth, who's on the board of Russia USA and a biologist, uh entomologist, I think, retired from the University of Wisconsin at Madison. He has a little talk he gives that distinguishes ultimate hope and proximate hope.

SPEAKER_03And those two terms have been so helpful for me. My ultimate hope is my faith. It's entirely secure. Uh, I believe in this beautiful vision of redemption, the reconciling of all things in Christ. I believe in that. That is my ultimate hope. Um, and that gets me through, you know. But there's also proximate hope, which is like, what's going to happen tomorrow? It's tomorrow gonna be okay. And to embody that hope, I think it is, it's doing the work. And I'm so grateful that I have the sort of time and capacity to do that right now.

SPEAKER_03It does keep me going. I think the people that I meet that are most anxious and grieving are the people who have a vague understanding of what's going on and not a big sense of agency. So ironically, the more I learn, the more I listen to uh experts and read climate news and all that, the better I feel. And it's maybe that's not quite a you know direct relationship there, but yes, I read all the things about the Atlantic meridian overturning current, and I read about the threats to whales, and I read about the glaciers and uh temperatures in Europe and all that.

SPEAKER_03But I also listen to listen to and meet and read about so many people who have this hopeful spirit in the sense that they are doing the work to figure out how to make the grid more efficient, how to get more batteries on the grid, uh you know, like how to save um a certain forest, how the activists, the scientists, the entrepreneurs, the people of faith working so hard to inspire each other to do the simplest things.

SPEAKER_03You know, it's it's amazing what it takes to get your church kitchen to recycle. Um and yet all of that is beautiful, hopeful work.

SPEAKER_01And we have an artist staying with us at the moment called Heidi Chang, and she is a beautiful watercolor artist and a Russia person at heart, and she paints butterflies and she and flowers, and she shows she just shows beauty, she points people to the beauty, and that as well is I don't know.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you for mentioning artists. I I think artists often feel like what can I do? I don't I don't know anything about cooking up solar panels. Uh but she's teaching us to see, I think. Yes, the imagination, right? Yeah, let's go back to English majors. The imagination is so important. If we don't have a vision of what we're going for, how do we get there? And there too, I think faith is so crucial. We have a vision of the beloved community, of a flourishing community of creation.

SPEAKER_03We know that's God's longing. So we witness to that divine longing by doing this work. Um, in whatever little capacity we have, big or small, artistic or electrical or uh or whatever it is, we witness to that beautiful longing. And sometimes I think just trying to practice hope itself, whatever the outcome, is what makes us the most human, that we can envision what we long for.

SPEAKER_03And even if we suffer and don't get there, that vision itself is a beautiful human capacity, uh, God-given human capacity that we need to be doing our best to live out.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. It's been a great joy to have this time with you. And um, I'm very glad you're spreading this story for many people and looking forward to reading your next book as Follows your first.

SPEAKER_04Yes, thanks, Sarah.

SPEAKER_03Well, thank you. It's been a pleasure. It's been a joy.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to the Field Notes podcast. If you enjoyed this podcast, please leave a review and subscribe.

SPEAKER_04And there's more information about this podcast and Arasha at Arasha.org. So do join us next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 65: Júlio Reis – Hopeful stories from the Friends of A Rocha Network

    Oct 6, 202631 minAudio

    When A Rocha began back in 1983, environmentalism was considered a slightly geeky niche interest by the world at large, and in the Church, if considered at all, as a distraction from ‘The Gospel.’ A Rocha is now a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 63: Simon Stuart – A life in conservation

    Jul 7, 202640 minAudio

    Dr Simon Stuart is one of the world's leading conservation scientists, best known for leading the development of the IUCN Red List of Threatened Species into the world's most authoritative assessment of species'...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 62: Autumn Ricksecker & Flo Wright – Life-building in a time of ecological crisis

    Jun 4, 202646 minAudio

    What is it like to be in your late 20s and making major life decisions in today’s world? Studies show young people understand themselves to be living in a highly unstable world where biodiversity collapse, climate...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 61: James Khoo – Bug-eyed wonder

    May 7, 202638 minAudio

    For many people, a close encounter with an insect leads to a quick departure by one or both or a summary execution, most often of the non-human party. If you recognise these scenarios from your own life, you may find...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 60: Anita George – In praise of the sponge

    Apr 7, 202629 minAudio

    Sponges are not only a great help in the shower, but some of the oldest, simplest animals on earth. If you haven’t yet discovered how fascinating and vitally important to a healthy planet they are, Dr Anita George is...

    Credit the people on this episode