The farm vet is critical for farmers navigating the transition to food and ecological security. In this programme we find out what that means in practice. How is the veterinary profession changing? Can a business model built on meds and emergency care pivot to preventative health and farm system advice? ffinlo Costain is joined by The Regenerative Vet, Claire Whittle - by Lee-Anne Oliver from Ruminant Revival - and by Helen Rogers, a regenerative farmer and a director of Friars Moor Livestock Health.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello and welcome to Farm Gate. I'm Finlay Costain, the editorof8.9.com. One of the primary characters linked to the average farm is the farm vet. But while many farms are still stuck on an annual treadmill of births, deaths, vaccinations, and wormers, there are an increasing number who are rarely seeing their vet at all. But how do farmers reach that level of resilience? Well, the role of the farm vet is critical in navigating the transition to food and ecological security. And today I'm going to find out what that means in practice.
How is the veterinary profession changing? Can a business model built on meds and emergency care pivot to preventative health and farm system advice? So in this program, I'm joined by the regenerative vet, Claire Whittle, by Leanne Oliver from Ruminant Revival, and by Helen Rogers, a regenerative farmer and a director of Friars Moor Livestock Health. Claire, you've called yourself the regenerative vet. What does that mean? Hopefully exactly what it says on the tin fin though. But I guess for me, regenerative farming means sort of farming as close to nature as possible. So I want for me and other
farmers to have healthy animals that form sort of part of a healthy ecosystem. And I guess by an ecosystem, what I would mean is that farm being made-up of all of the sort of biological organisms that are there. So from the farmer who's obviously very, very important in that situation to the soil, the wildlife, the trees, and then how they sort of interact with that physical environment. So for me, I think sort of reducing the need for or external inputs, whether that's feed or veterinary bills or any other sort of pharmaceutical inputs, for example, that sort of improves the resilience of those farms and hopefully their bottom line as well. So Liam, you're working in a
similar way to Claire, I think, but you're sort of worried that the word regenerative can scare some farmers away, that it's sort of preaching to the converted, providing services for the converted, I suppose. So why do you think that and what are the outcomes that you're working to achieve on the farms that you're working with? Yeah, I think the term regenerative to some of the farmers that haven't engaged with that terminology from an early stage, it's maybe misconstrued a little bit and being seen as an environmentalist or eco warriors and and there's some farmers I feel are quite averse to being labeled as such. Although many farmers will be adopting principles of, of
regenerative agriculture and they will be improving their soil health and as a result they will be more profitable and have better animal health welfare outcomes, but they probably don't see themselves as as labeled as, as regenerative farmers. And that's OK. And I think that's the beauty of regenerative agriculture that you're not all in or all out. As long as you understand what you're doing and the what actions you're undertaking on your farm maybe have positive or negative effects, you can work towards an outcome. But we're doing that by making informed decisions. So what sort of words are you tending to use instead of regenerative?
I will probably use soil health and and ecosystems rather than necessarily using the word regen or regenerative. I don't know. I mean, we, this has been debated wildly and, and during your pocket as well. How do you define it? You know, it means something different to different people. And I think Claire's just given me a lovely description about breaking it down actually what it means. And until we get that word out there in the mainstream a bit more broadly and it maybe is going to have some negative connotations to different people. So bearing in mind what Leanne said there, Claire, are you worried that, you know, using the word regenerative that you were sort of almost limiting the
market that you're available to? Yes, potentially. And I have queried the name several times. I suppose we launched quite a long, launched quite a long time ago now, about 3 years ago where that word was, I suppose I could have called myself the agroecological vet. The word holistic vet was already taken. I don't mind being labeled as an eco warrior or an environmentalist because I think I would probably class myself as both of those things. And it also means I get to kind of pick the farmers that I want to work with who are coming to me with those ideas in mind. But yeah, Leanne's exactly right. Like, and you'd just given her a really awkward question there for like based on my, yeah,
based on my business. I like that. But yeah, no, I would say it doesn't it, I don't think it's had any effect necessarily. And but the soil health point is obviously the most important bit. And however people are getting to that, and I think what Leanne said as well, there's different people on that spectrum. You know, it's, I think one of the things, the groundswell definition of regen is that it's a journey, not a destination. So it's wherever you are on that journey, happy to engage in that. And it's just it's great that there's there's vets really involved in it as well. Well, I'm not sure if this as a follow up is going to be more difficult or less difficult, but you mentioned that the word
regenerative, you know, you it was three years or so ago that you chose the name and certainly you know, regen at that time it was much more of a new idea that there hadn't sort of there was no backlash to it at that point. Have you recognised that there is some kind of a backlash and and do you have any sense of why that backlash has occurred? I think people are generally a bit concerned about not being, you know, not the, it's like not the status quo. And like I think there's this sort of hard that feels like there's sometimes a hard line between what you would call conventional farm and I think
that can actually sound quite derogatory in a sense and regenerative sounds like you're sort of heading up towards the next level of something. And that's not a great place to sort of be in. And I feel like there's people who are very, very much hard lined on both sides that disagree somewhere in the middle. Whereas actually, like I say, if we start thinking about it as a journey and a movement towards from the soil health principles and sort of nature based recovery and that kind of thing, it's a very different world. And I think a lot of farmers have so much more in common than they do apart. So, yeah, so I do think there is a, it's tricky for people to engage age with the other side when they're very much in a
know. And I'm guilty myself of getting caught in an echo chamber as well. You know, you can start hearing things and you believe that and you can find things that suit your own opinions. I think social media has a role to play in that as well. So yeah, I think we just need to be careful. And I'm, I'm be very open to all different kinds of farming because I think that diversity is probably key. And back to you, Leanne, on that, because clearly, you know, you've chosen your name a couple of years after Claire, I suppose. And so you must be aware of that backlash. How is it manifesting, you know, in the farmer community around you? Yeah, I suppose we chose the name Ruminant Revival because it
was very much focused on integrating livestock into farming systems and making a point that that is a huge part of where we need to go in terms of soil health and climate change and and the biodiversity that we're trying to create. And I, I suppose we will work with farmers that aren't regenerative farmers. So our our spec is a little bit broader potentially. So our big focus is removing inputs from systems and a lot of that advice is focused on soil health because the two run side by side, especially when you're talking you'd be circular and sheep systems, but you know, we
would work with, you know, calf health and cluster management and all that kind of stuff, which maybe wouldn't be classed as regenerative. So I suppose our business focus is a little bit broader in terms of being more preventative and reducing the reliance on inputs by changing systems into terms of nutrition management and genetics. Thank you. Thanks. And just before I go across to Helen, and without getting the sense that the veterinary profession is in any way incestuous, I believe you cut your teeth early with Friars More where Helen works. I like Helen's, like laughing at this. Yeah, my first two years so out of vet school at Fry's Moor, which was one of my favorite two
years of vetting of my entire life. I think in my first year I won the golden syringe, which was the syringe. the IT was the award for like the most stupid thing on farm. And I think I'd replace a prolapse with another vet. So yeah, I was another one of the vets there and I put this prolux back in. And often when you do that, so you put the whole uterus, which is massive outside of a cow, back in through a very small opening and you often release the pressure on their urethra, which means they urinate. And I had the on call phone in my pocket at the time and I got up and I washed off at the end.
And it was one of those like old Nokia's. And I think I thought I could save the phone by sucking the water out of it. And it wasn't full of water. It was absolutely full of urine. So I just, yeah. So I despite the fact I'd stood by the vet code of keep your mouth shut, which is usually a very good thing to do when you're at the back end of a cow, it wasn't a pleasant experience. Yeah, Helen, do you remember those days? I do. They're, yeah, they were very fun days, really. A lot of stories you could tell. Yeah, yeah. Well, maybe we'll come back and just do a podcast of stories in the future, but Friars Moore has
been trying to adjust its model from emergency care to preventative health management for livestock for several years now. Why have you been trying to do that? Why is that important? I think. We recognised a long time ago that in order to contribute to both our farms and society, I guess as a whole, we needed to create and help create really resilient, successful farms. And to do that we needed to move away from that historical model of providing emergency care to really contributing to the whole ecosystem on the farm and and
facilitating change on the farm as a whole. Ultimately, that allows us to continue to have a successful business and it means that we have farmers who are motivated and positive and moving forward, which is really motivating for us in itself. And as you've gone through that transition, have you found that, you know, the farmers around you have been quite happy to follow that? I mean, it's always been in their best interest and the industry has moved forward too. So ultimately it's all about the health. Our animals are the less money and the less inputs that they'll need, like Leanne said. So ultimately that's going to be beneficial to the farm and the farm profit at the end of the day.
So yeah, they've been, as long as we can demonstrate that that change will make improvements, then yeah, they've been really keen to to move with us. And how have you engaged with that conversation? How have you achieved the shift from essentially the NHS model to something which is much more, you know, about preventative healthcare, healthcare planning, that sort of thing? What are those sort of key elements? I think understanding like the motivation behind our farmers and their characters is really important. So we act essentially as a facilitator. But then also, you know, we've come back to looking at benchmarking of data, going back to genetics, nutritional advice, all of those things that really,
so you have to identify what actually motivates the farmer and what's going to create change. So a lot of that has started from looking at data, working out how to have conversations with the farmers and then how to initiate change after that. And when you talk about data, those sort of the benchmarking that you're talking about, what are the sort of things that you're benchmarking? So it depends on the system, but you kind of need to strip it down to relatively simple things to start off with. So if you had beef or sheep farms, you could look at the kind of total weight of products sold at the end, whether that be lamb or beef relative to the number of cows or sheep that are
put to the ram or the bulls. That's essentially looking at efficiency. And in the dairy industry, there's oodles of data that we can look at, but most of it needs to focus on efficiency and where there are losses and how you can make that far more resilient off the back of it. And when you talk about benchmarking, is that benchmarking within the farmer group, within the fryers more a sort of client base or you sort of benchmarking more broadly across the country? So it tends to be within the farmer client base because farmers are really good at taking loads away from farmer meetings when they talk to other farmers. So they might not take very much away from you, but they'll take a lot away from their neighbors.
Say benchmarking within our our client database is really how we've started doing that. And that always started anonymously. And then as the groups that we share that data with have and become more familiar and more confident, we then lose that anonymity and we share really openly how people have made changes and what they think's been successful or what hasn't worked. And when we're thinking about that sort of benchmarking approach, I guess, you know, an old fashioned way of looking at it would be that it's just kind of, it's looking over the hedge, but you're looking over the hedge at a lot more farms and doing it more efficiently and more, you know, effectively that
the information is quite precise. Everyone loves looking over the hedge innately nosy, aren't we? And you can do that unattractive really effectively. So yeah, it's real a really nice motivator I think for farmers to see how other people in the area are getting on. One of the things that I'm sort of aware of, perhaps because of the work that that I was doing at Farmwell before, before even Farmgate started, let alone 8.9, was the work that we were doing with government in the post Brexit period, looking at farm animal health and welfare outcomes. Specifically trying to look at what George Eustace, the
minister at the time, was calling Iceberg Metro. So we've sort of been looking, for example, you know, it's sheep, you know, is there a particular metric, a particular measure that can give you a really good sense of that system? And with pigs, we felt that there, you know, there was one metric that you could do that with and it was, you know, an intact curly tail at point of slaughter gives you an awful lot of information. But with most other species with sheep or cattle, you need a combination of metrics to get that information across. There isn't a sort of single silver bullet that will tell you
whether a farm system is doing well or not. And so I think with sheep, it was something like a low level of anthelmantic use. It was a low level of lameness and a low worm burden at point of slaughter. So we were sort of looking at that grouping as a way of being able to tell an awful lot about the system, not only in terms of the health and welfare of the animal, but actually probably the farm system, the ecology that it was living within. Have you found a sort of similar thing where you know, there are key benchmarks but you can't look at them in isolation? Helen. Yeah, no, absolutely. So I, we always start with quite broad marking.
So I think as an example, it would be the number of empty cows in a suckler herd. If you put 100 cows to the bull, but you've only got 80 in calf, you know, we start with that broad brush stroke and then we need to drill down into, you know, which groups of animals have particularly suffered. So then you start looking at empty rate in your first lactation animals. So you do need to make it a cumulative kind of benchmarking experience because, and also there'll be some things that people do really well and other things that they don't do as well. So if you're going to engage with farmers, you need we need to identify the good and the bad in all of their systems. And there will be those good and bad things in everyone's system.
Leanne, just sort of coming across to to you and ruminant revival. Obviously you're sort of focused on ruminants, on livestock and there's a sort of sense within your name that you're trying to revive the the popularity that the recognition that ruminants have a role in the landscape, a role as livestock within Britain where there has been so much bad press that's been taking place over the last few years, particularly towards cattle and methane. But do you see your role as being merrily to support that transition? And then if that's the case, is
that a business model that's really sustainable for a vet? Yeah, that's an interesting question. And we, I've been asked that before as much as vets traditionally make their money out of time on farm and and a high percentage of that time is, is sorting out disasters. There are problems that have happened that we get called in at the end stage to sort out and sell them products. Let's not get away from that. That vets you sell antibiotics and vaccines and all that kind of stuff. So I view our role as vets as changing and I think not only are we making our farmers more sustainable and resilient, we're
also making those changes in the vet profession as well. So if you look at some of the data that's come out, there was a Zoetis did a study in the summer and it was a white paper released to industry that suggested that 46.5% of farm vets had considered leaving the profession and that was through burnout. So if we can turn that around and we can give our vets consultancy rules, advisory rules, if they can have the knowledge and ability to get in there and prevent problems before they happen, we wouldn't have burnout, exhausted vets that run around like hazards, chickens trying to fight fires. So not only we're going to be
improve our farmers, make them more resilient and future proof and do all the good that we can do there, we're going to have farmers that have better mental well-being because they're not doing the disaster management day after day and dealing with all the problems. They'll be in a better headspace. And also, you're going to have vets that are happier in their work and they're going to stay in the profession for longer. But if you're sort of working with farmers across that transition and, and at the end of the transition, really you're hoping that they're going to be in a position where they hardly ever need to see the vet. Are you confident that there's enough work for you across the next 20 years? Yeah, I think so.
And, and I think that's a success story if we can. It's like giving a guy a fishing rod rather than giving him a fish, isn't it? If you can teach him the skills that enables him to problem and solve himself and set up that farm in a way that they they can problem solve. And, and, and, and every year is not the same as we know of different climatic conditions or provide different parasite challenges and and different nutritional challenges to that farmer. But if you can provide that skill set and that training and then set that farmer on his way and, and be there at arm's length in a supportive role, then, you know, we've, we've done our job. We don't want to create a system that is completely reliant
because our veterinary skill is also an input to that farm and it's a cost to that farmer. So if we can minimize that and, and, and do a good job at having a, a self-sufficient system where we still have some knowledge of what's going on and where some data collection and we, we oversee that system, then that is a really good place to be. And thinking about that, that you were obviously, you know, vets traditionally have worked very much, you know, it's with medicines, with the livestock, where what you're talking about within a regenerative approach is around the Land Management as well. Do you find that you're you're
giving Land Management advice that you've had to sort of learn more and find out more about Land Management in order to be able to deliver some of that resilience? Yeah, massively so. All our vets have worked for us and many vets around the country have engaged in in soil health workshops. They've travelled abroad to see and have different fits farming systems work and it's really, really common to see vets at farmer walks and things like that now where they just want to see different systems and how things different work for different people and collect new ideas. So I think that has been a
massive area of expertise that we have profession have had to tap into. But I also think business skills as well that actually ultimately, you know, with we're there to deliver a benefit to that farmer and that that farmer has a business to run. And we have to understand fixed costs and variable costs and, and where we're coming from to help that farmer achieve pays mortgage and look after his kids. Ultimately, it's a business and we'd never forget that. And that's quite a different thing for a lot of farmers. I'm still surprised the number of farmers that I go to and they don't have a sort of sense really of their margin of their, their profitability, those, you
know, the cost of inputs versus outputs, et cetera. Do do you find again that you're you're giving business advice around that as you go? Yeah, to a degree. I, I think that certainly the farmers I've worked with aren't as open to share and that information is what I would never have liked them to be. And some of the, maybe some of the benchmarking groups that Helen's work with, they've got to that level of trust where they can share that information. So it's all well and good saying that this worked or that worked, but actually putting a, a financial cost to that or financial benefit to that would really sing home and probably
maybe help implement a bit more change because they could, they'd see that it worked and it, it cost X and it returned Y. And I think we could be a little bit more open in how we shared some of that information. I think that would benefit a lot of people. And Helen, that is a good question, isn't it, around that sort of level of trust in sharing that amount of information. You're quite, you know, what often feels like quite personal information around finances. How have you been able to establish that level of trust? It's really important I think, and having a group that gets to know one another, like we haven't achieved it in all of our groups at all just because
of the characters that are involved. So it does tend to be more of a conversation you have individually on farm when the farm is in the safe environment and and feels like they won't be under scrutiny if they say something silly. So sometimes it does have to come down to an individual farm conversation rather than being shared within a group. Yeah, OK, interesting. And we talked about resilience and and resilient farming at various different points. And I've used the word frequently already in the podcast. But Claire, I wonder if you could help us with the definition because we probably ought to have a sense of what a resilient farm looks like. What? What is it from your perspective? Yeah. I suppose the other bit, I just
want to answer on that question, is it like resilient vet business as well? So just think about what Leanne was saying, like my work is so much more varied now I think than it was as a vet in terms of the things that I do and where that money comes from. So in terms of like, I mean, I do, I teach hedge laying now and that might sound like a random thing from a veterinary perspective, but actually is it like, you know, teaching hedge laying on something that's ultimately going to benefit health and welfare on farms for livestock for me, maybe that's part of it. Maybe, you know, we can be even wider in terms of the sort of things that we offer. So yeah, for my business resilience, me having doing lots of different things, whether
it's writing or whether it's doing hedge laying, whether it's actually going out and doing that work, working with individuals, working with groups, it's massively different now. So that's a that's a really nice part to it. And I think farms as well need to potentially have some of that diversity in their business from a resilience perspective. But for me, a resilient farm, I think the main thing I think to be thinking about the moment is sort of climate resilience. So I think and and Leanne alluded to earlier, we're going to see big changes in sort of weather, in sort of seasonality, in parasite patterns. So that includes things like looking like things like soil compaction, you know, water infiltration, water availability
in terms of drought. You know, I think again going back to that root cause of problems, you know. You know, if we're going to see cows that have dropped yield because there's a drought problem and there's no grass on that farm, for me, we're far too far down the line of that issue, whereas we need to be going back to sort of basic soil health principles to pick up on those situations. And landscape design is obviously one of those things which I think is really important. And I've said it before, but I think we're pretty good at designing sheds in the UK. We think we're good at designing sheds in the UK, but the reality is nobody really thinks about their outdoor environment, what that looks like for a farm. And, and 90%, you know, even 90% of dairy farms, although we're
led to believe otherwise, still use grazing in some capacity. So how are we looking at those environments for the future, looking at those root causes of problems and, and profitable, that's like 3 legged stool, isn't it? So there's environmental, I think economic or profitability or, you know, by profitable, I mean, I guess at least economically viable and probably without subsidy. I think that's another thing to, to consider. And I know, you know, for dairy farmers, even, I think it was Anderson's that did that work. But one of the key drivers of profitability is maximising yield from homegrown forage, you
know, getting people who are less reliant on external inputs. And that makes you sort of less reliant on external forces. So whether that is war, whether it's climate change, whether it's energy prices, all of those kind of things as well. And the social aspect, I think I think we can get carried away. And again, Helen mentioned earlier is people, what we're looking at on farm, what's driving that farmer and what those motivations are in terms of their own farming context. I think being a happy farmer, it's probably one thing that gets underestimated. And one of my first questions to farmers on farm now is what is what?
What are you trying to achieve? What are you aiming to achieve? And I think it's really important that we understand that so we know what we're actually working towards. Yeah, fantastic. I, I, I'm really interested in your hedge laying and that that's sort of almost part of your, your veterinary business because it contributes so much to that resilience on farm and that sort of landscape scale approach. And I want to drill into that a little bit more just to put you on the spot. You know, I, I'll give you all the difficult questions. So so thinking of your 3 legged its stall, how does the hedge laying sort of help with that? Everything so environmentally, so obviously great environmental for in terms of I should talk
about the livestock first, but I'm going to talk about the wildlife. So if we're laying hedges as opposed to cutting them, you know, taking out the bottoms of those very sort of empty bottoms that we often see in hedgerows and those very, very file tops which don't provide any level of shelter or shade. If we're from a climate resilience perspective, if we're going to see temperatures where we're getting 35° C and over for, you know, potentially weeks in a row, we're going to have to have areas on the farm where these animals are able to be and be comfortable. And, you know, you can get reduced, you know, your temperature drops by 5° under a hedgerow, for example. The difference for, you know, a dairy cow, which might start
with heat stress around 22° C, you know, it's relatively low. If you can reduce that temperature by having trees and hedges, if you can improve the shelter that's on the farm for very young animals that maybe struggle to actually regulate their temperature. So you've got the wildlife. So you've got the sort of environmental side, you've got that economic side in terms of reducing issues like heat stress, and then the social side. I mean, I, I, you know, edge laying for me is just a really nice thing to do. It's finding it very relaxing. There's not many things in vetting. And surely Ellen Helen would agree, where you feel like you've reached an end point. You know, even if you go and see a sick cow and you treat it, sometimes, you know, you might
call the power back, but they don't answer their phone and you never actually find out how they're doing. Whereas you've got this finished product and it's done and, you know, getting people into health. And I like the training side of it. It's a different side to training vets on on disease, but you know, it's often more, it's often more engaging in a lot of ways because it's physical and it's practical. Brilliant. Well and you've got, you know, on your farm because you're a dairy farmer as well as a vet at Longmore in Dorset and you've got so many great big wild hedges as well as ponds and agroforestry going in. Do you get involved in the planting and and the the sort of
management decisions on the farm as well? Yeah, No, we do. And it's, it is really lovely to do planting, like hedge planting with a group of other like really motivated individuals. It is a really fun thing to do, less fun in the middle of winter with the kids taking off. But the benefits are massive. And as Claire was saying, like there's such a human element to this. And as soon as you increase the diversity on your farm, your observations increase and you know, your happiness increases and there's so much more to think about rather than just like the day-to-day grind of milking and scraping up the slurry and feeding the cows. So all these things are so good
for like how healthy our minds are and how happy we are on farm. It's interesting because there's, you know, when we talk about regenerative farms or agroecological farms, I think very often, you know, within this podcast we're sort of thinking about particular types of farms often where livestock are outwinted. Obviously not all always and you know, they're often smaller farms. Often those regenerative farms are selling into direct sort of cooperative supply chains. And then you've got kind of the other, the other end of farming, which is these fully housed systems, lots and lots of of animals within them. But your farm is something
really interesting, isn't it? Very much within the middle where you are very, very much a regenerative farm. You're getting remarkable regenerative outcomes, but you're also a high yielding dairy farm. We've got holstings there. And so I guess the question is sort of looking across the board from those, those smaller agroecological farms working in independent supply chains through to farms like yours that are yielding, you know, lots of nature as well as lots of food to those fully housed systems. Do you think that regenerative veterinary outcomes can be delivered across the board? I definitely think they can.
It is quite a long journey and you have to be prepared to make some mistakes and act on the back of those along the way. But it is really, really rewarding to do. I think the challenge we have is making sure that we identify things that people are already doing within their system in order to engage them. So, so like hedge laying is a really nice example. Like everyone could, all farmers can talk about hedges and how often they cut their hedges. Do they make an A-frame? Do they absolutely obliterate it to the same level each year? Like you can have all these conversations on farm. So we need to connect with the farmers and workout what motivates them.
It may be sort of like compost, which is a random topic that I know like talk about, which I never thought I'd talk about as a vet, but there are lots of farmers who love composting. Their FYM really affected actively so it's just working out like what little things we can engage on each farm which then eventually builds into the bigger picture thinking. And I guess, you know, within all farms, we, we're talking about water and water, you know, if there's too much water there, then that can be sort of holding and carrying disease and parasites, that sort of thing. And so it's about making sure that the management of that land is functioning. And if the animals are out there that there's enough grass for
them that that soil is covered as much of the year as possible. I mean, those are all things that you'd have thought if if farmers have got livestock outside, those are all things that all farmers ought to be interested in to 1 extent or another. Yeah. And I think they are sometimes they just need the time to stop and think about it because they have really, really busy days as dairy farms, you know, their phones going off all the time, they're being asked lots of questions by their team. So sometimes they just need the opportunity to stop and think about what they're doing. And we can all facilitate that. And I think it is just does just come back to engaging in what
drives them and then working on developing that and creating that really strong ecosystem within the farm. And I think as a vets, you know, we need to recognize that there are lots of people feeding into that team and they'll have lots of different advice from different people. So, you know, we need to work out who we can point them in the direction of like, say, can I recommend them that they go and see Claire laying hedges or talk to Leanne? Like, you know, we need to be open to involving more people and broadening the discussions to help those farms. Yeah, it's really interesting. I was laughing, sorry, sorry Philo, I was laughing yesterday. So I rang Helen and I've
obviously have a new entrant farmer this year and I said to Helen, I used to think I was the most important part of a farmers day. Like if I not like I was picking myself up, but I was like, if I'm going to see the routine, I'm the most important part. And I think farming has made me realise what a tiny, tiny part or a tiny bit of influence you can actually have on a day-to-day basis because there's so much more going on. But but as Helen was sort of indicating there, there is a role, isn't there from these sort of outside practitioners like vets that come on farm in in finding ways to facilitate those conversations. So, you know, as, as you know from your past, so many farm
walks where you're looking at earthworms and, you know, doing worm counts and that sort of thing. And, and if vets are sort of involved in going to lots of farms in a particular area and they start to hear that there are questions that that the majority of farmers are starting to ask, then there's a role that, you know, vets can play in bringing farmers together to have that discussion on a farm that's really succeeding with that particular outcome. Yeah. I think and and what what both Helen and have alluded to is the trust part of it. And I think vets have that role. I mean, we are in a lot of ways bound by confidentiality that is our So people often I think feel
they can have some of those conversations with us, whether it's about some things that they're interested in. Often I've found it's been previously about things like mental health as well. You're a trusted person. You're probably not going to tell anyone, but having, but we do. And I think as vets, we've got better at that, is having the ability to signpost people to the help that they need, regardless of what situation that they're in because of that relationship that you have with people, which is really valuable. Yeah. And a lot of those things that we've been talking about today, whether it's reducing medications or, or, you know, thinking about managing the land differently, managing your business differently, that can
save farmers a lot of money. And so in terms of sort of thinking about this change in livestock management, Leanne, why would you think more of farmers aren't working like this? There's the chance to save money and have better herd health. Why isn't everyone doing it? That's a really good question. I, I think a little bit of uncertainty and, and a fear of change, a little bit of apprehension. And I think from conversations I've had with, with farmers about exactly that. When you almost get to the point of frustration of, you know, this is what we're doing and this is what we could do. This is all the positive things that could come out of it.
But some of it's peer pressure, you know, that they getting back to Helen's analogy of looking over the hedge, you know, they, they get criticised why they've got, you know, 3 foot high pastures and why their cows are only in there for a day at a time. And why is all those electric fences out there? There's a certain amount of that. And I think you also get that interesting dynamic on farms, which can be very beneficial, but also can be quite difficult to manage between succession between generations. So you've maybe got potentially older generation that wants to change and there's reluctance from the younger generation or quite often the other way
around. So I think there's lots of reasons which hold back the changes that need to happen. In my experience, there usually has to be a disaster on farm to actually make that change, which is, is really sad. And and sometimes that is, for example, you know, triple resistance to ample Mintex and sheep. So they, you know, they almost get to the stage where they're like, when I can't, I can't keep sheep anymore because I can't, I can't manage my wearing burdens. And we know there's other ways round of that, but that that makes them make that change or, you know, very, very difficult carving during the spring when
there's a lot of veterinary interventions or caesareans or carnage mortality that didn't, you know, induces change or just that the bank manager turns around and says, right, no stop, you know, you've gone too far. So I suppose our role as as vets is to get in there and maybe try and facilitate that change and support them through that change before we get to the disasters, because that really is when there's there's nowhere else to go. And I think we alluded it to it before, during some of those change processes. We need to learn and we do make mistakes and mistakes happen and that's how we learn. But there needs to be a buffer financially to allow those mistakes to happen.
And certainly in England, you know, we've, we've had that BPS payment coming in and that's now in effectively gone, you know, so that the profit marginals are on certainly on asset clue and sheet farms have absolutely plummeted. And those guys are now wanting to, you know, change and they're almost up against it because it's, it's almost a little bit too late. They haven't got that safety margin that they had before. So again, the pressure's on and it's getting harder and harder. There is a degree to which, you know, it's just a conversation that we've been having, you know, within the regenerative movement over the last few years that very often people come to regenerative agriculture because
there's been a crisis. And so how can we help people get there without that crisis? And I guess when it comes to sort of regenerative farming more broadly, looking at those sort of farm system changes, it's about trying to find ways of not having to do that full transition, but but making sort of tweaking changes, small changes on the road to that sort of broader transition. Are there things that you think people can think about within their their hood health plans, within their sort of approach, which is more incremental? They're sort of easy things that all farmers can do without
having to change everything. Yeah. And I think that what, what I was getting to alluding to at the beginning is when we, you know, as a farmer, generative or not, you know, some of these little changes, does that class him as a regenerative farmer? You know, but he is applying some principles to improve soil health. I think our, our golden wishes bets really is, is to get livestock into some kind of rotation. So it's a lot to ask a farmer to go from a set stock system on to 12 hourly or 24 hourly moves. That's a huge, huge step to make. But even if we can get them into, you know, thinking about moving their livestock every
fortnight or, and then reduce that to every week and then every four days. And then if we can just try and get that, that mind. And then, and then they will see that their, their grass growers and they will see that their lambs do better and that they need less parasite treatments and they have less lameness and, and their yowls are in better body conditions. Score pre tipping. And all of a sudden then things start to change and you get positive outcomes and, and that, you know, kind of fuels the fire. And so I think any kind of rotation on farm is great. And also from a parasite point of view, just you're raising those pastures a wee bit longer,
you know, not nailing them back down to how sometimes they get in a set stock system. And we saw that this summer when the ground was burning up, we killed all biology within the soil. We had dung and fecal paths everywhere because there was there was no biological activity to get rid of that fecal material. And it all just compounded. And getting back to Claire's point before where, you know, it's almost too late when, you know, you get to a system and the farmer's got no grass and there's nowhere to go. Sometimes that is not where the farmer is going to be receptive to your advice. So all of a sudden you turn around and say, Oh, well, we
need to improve soil health to improve drought resistance and we need to have more diversity in our support boards. And Plantain is drug resistant and all this kind of stuff. He's gone past that point. He can't handle that at that time to be given all that information. He's that crisis. So I suppose that comes back again to, you know, education and knowledge transfer to make sure folk that know there's another way and building those resilient systems before we get to that crisis point. Integrating parasite management plans is a really nice inn for farmers. So you know loads of them struggle with young stock management and are relying on
traditional wormers and and relatively intensive worming methods. But that's a really nice in in terms of discussing, then discussing wider region ideas and principles because there's clearly a direct financial advantage to them engaging with us on these conversations. And actually it's really interesting, like it's really stimulating for farmers to think in a slightly different way about how they rotate their animals and which animals they use to make pasture cleaner and how long they leave this ward. And, you know, we've got really intelligent people that we're working with and you can see them, you know, you can see their minds being like, Oh yeah, that's cool. Like we can do this and that. And it's really nice way of
starting to engage them and. Of course, having trusted professional like of that who's sort of asking those questions within that sort of confidentiality approach that Claire was mentioning as well, I guess that's really important. And and as you say, to sort of inspire those conversations. Now over the next few months, partly because of sponsorship, which is going to be coming in from Friars more livestock health, which we're really grateful for, Helen, we're going to be dipping more deeply into a range of veterinary topics. But today I really just want to scratch the surface, and I wonder if we could talk through a few of the areas in which a
more generative veterinary approach can help. So perhaps Leanne, we could start with sheep and liver fluke. How can Land Management, how can different sort of farm management reduce or eliminate the need for anthem intakes? Great topic and and very timely I would say at this time of year as well. So the big benefit we have for Fluke is that we can test very accurately for it. So we've got blood tests that will pick up infection a couple of weeks after an animal ingests the the immature stages. And we've got fecal testing so we can actually get a good idea on farm where the high risk
areas are. So as we know, the, the fluke parasite requires a mood sail as its intermediate host. So no snail, no parasite. So if we can work out where those mood sail populations are and avoid them through strategic grazing at high risk times of year, we're not going to pick up that fluke infection. So that takes a little bit of work. And again, it, it may vary year on year a little bit, but we can use some of the testing to map the farm, avoid those parasite areas at high risk times, which is great. And again, when we come back to almost conventional veterinary medicine, as much as with the
good tests that we've got, you can test and then treat. We know when we need to treat. And rather than just having to blanket so we can preserve those pharmaceuticals for greater use. If you want to be all holistic about it, then ducks eat the mud snail. So we, we could, we could integrate ducks into our stack and enterprise in our regenerative farm if we wanted to, to go that way. I've been asked many times before whether geese do the same thing, but unfortunately not. Geese are grazers. They're not, they're not mud sail eaters, unfortunately. Otherwise we probably wouldn't have fluke on many farms and on
the West of the of the British Isles. So, so yeah, that that's an example how through grazing management avoidance and mapping your farm and knowing your farm can reduce unnecessary food treatments. Yeah, I was, I was actually, I was thinking about the ducks even just as you mentioned them and the way in which actually if you're fencing off some of those areas that that are wet and they're going to remain wet, then you can sort of develop ponds and actually start attracting wildfowl. And so on to there. You're building up those populations of things that that make a meal out of the the problem that you've got on the farm. So really interesting. Thanks for that. Now, Claire, flies are another issue, of course, both for cows
and sheep. So how can farmers deal with these? Through change management? It's interesting in flies, isn't it? So like Leanne said, the great thing about things like fluke or like worms is you can test for them, but often it's flies are there and they're either causing disease or they're not. So I think that's a first really important question to answer. Are the are the flies causing disease? Are they causing significant levels of fly worry where you are getting production losses, New Forest eye mastitis, etcetera? If they're not, it's a question of whether or not how much of a problem are they? Uh, you know, our cows have really long eyelashes. They have really long tails for flicking flies off those kind of things as well. And I think one of the things as
well, whether you're talking about any kind of parasite is probably thinking about resistance. And it's like going back to what Helen said is getting farmers engaged in that from a financial perspective and talmintic and umm, sort of synthetic, probably resistance and all those kind of things are real concern. And particularly in areas like so S like South Africa, for example, where they, if you get bitten by a tent, see fly and you get, you know, a problem with it, like forgetting what it's called an altrapanosomeiosis or something, which is spread by the fly that's going to cause potentially disease and more often death in livestock. So obviously a lot of products
are used there and there's more and more evidence coming out, particularly from those sort of areas where there is resistance supply products. So thinking about that and trying to remember to use them only when necessary if they're causing a problem, thinking about diversity as well. So the thing with these products is what we know is they kill everything. So they kill the good stuff and they kill the bad stuff, and they come out pretty much unchanged in their feces as well. So there is lots of evidence that show that biodiversity breeds resilience in terms of if there's more things there, there's less things that are likely to cause a problem from a pest control perspective. So I think that's another thing
to think about. Trees are an interesting one that come up and there's now differing views. So I used to be of the belief that more trees would just always be a good thing. Some evidence shows that there's more flies under certain trees. But again, if you have one tree in a field for me and you have 100 cows under that tree, that is very different to having 10 or 20 trees in that field or more places they can go. Because if you have just that one tree, yes, it will be good, but you'll get that build up of sort of fecal contamination under there, more flies. So again, going back to what Leanne's saying, having some rotation, keeping your animals moving, keeping them away from those paths, thinking about what their landscape looks like.
I mean, and I going back to nature again, I always think you're like, swallows always tend to arrive when the flies do. And you know, a single, there's even more recent work showing that a swallow pair will eat 6000 flies a day. Now, if we're not encouraging those animals and things onto our farms by what our landscape looks like, by providing nest boxes, all of those kind of things, I think we're going to potentially lose out. And you know, there's, there's anecdotal evidence on a lot of things. So walnut trees would be one that they reduce fly burden. So they used to be put around Parklands, around benches and things like that, and then they
were actually using people. So people used to use Jug Loan, which is from Walnut, to reduce sort of lice and mites. I mean, as a thought of having lice and mites myself makes me a bit cringing. But then alternatives are a tricky 1 and they're a tricky one for vets. I think both Leanna and Helen would agree. So there are things like neem oil. Eucalyptus soil, So Nemo does actually reduce sort of tick burdens, for example. So any of these sort of ectoparasites or the parasites on the outside of their body. But we're very limited in terms of how we can advise their use of them as vets because unless they're licensed for preventative or their license for treatment, it's really hard
for us to actually advise using those in livestock. Now, you could, you could argue we're not necessarily prescribing them. So it's a slightly different topic, but we don't have a lot of the research behind it in terms of those products. So there's a lot of research that says things like it highlights the potential of, of this as a treatment. So like chrysanthemum, for example, but there's not a really evidence behind it or any of the decision making there or not enough research. I would say about it as well. And things like knowing there's a vaccine is vaccine available for New Forest eye. So lots of people who've had a New Forest eye, eye problems this year. There hasn't historically been a
vaccine that has to be imported and it's under SPC, but there are definitely preventative ways you can go about it. Now I'm not saying again, like, you know, you can't ever use a flight treatment because if you're having issues, like Leanne said, when you're in crisis mood, you have to treat that problem. And that problem is probably going to be a pharmaceutical based product. So it's, it's finding the times when you can talk about those things easier. And yeah, and, and working with your system. But yeah, I think for me there's, there's lots of things we can think about that aren't just based around just just put, instead of just putting the fly treatment on. It's like, OK, what are we going to do about it next year? So you know, yeah, your fly
treatment's gone on now. Let's have a think about it for the future. Yeah, when you were talking about the trees, it reminded me that certainly when I was younger, if I would go on a walk on a hot day, you end up with loads of flies buzzing around you, especially when you got a bit sweaty. But I always find that if I if I could find an oak tree and just rub my head in, that the flies were much more interested in the oak tree than they were in me. And so they stay, you know, which was, which was good. Is there something about sort of herd management as well in sort of mob grazing systems where you're moving the the cattle on quickly enough that the eggs in the in the dung just don't have
time to hatch? I think if you're moving them daily and you've got big herds potentially, I mean flies don't actually very go that far away from their feces. But I suppose the point that they're not just on top of dirty pastures all the time is probably a good thing. Now in the summer, the fly, you know, the, the time it takes from a family to go into a pat and come out is days, whereas in the winter months it might be weeks. So, and the hotter it gets potentially the more difficult that is. But moving on and just keeping them away from their faeces, not only from a fly perspective, but also from a worm perspective as well, is also a really good way of thinking about it. And those longer rest periods, leaving that longer grass structure there, you know, your,
most of your worm eggs are found in the very low in the bottom of that sword, like Leanne said. So all of those things can contribute towards it as well. And I think, yeah, I, I think unless flies are a particular issue and they're causing a problem, our livestock are pretty well designed to cope with it. Or certain breeds and genetics and things like that as well will also play a role in that too. Lovely. Thank you. Helen, Thinking about seasonally grazed dairy systems like your own, especially with higher yielding Holsteins where you know, there's sort of big others, how does management affect issues like lameness and
mastitis? So ultimately we need our cows to be able to walk to our grazing paddocks and we need them to produce clean milk. So it comes back to that three legged stool that Claire was talking about, but with slightly different legs I suppose. So we need to think about genetics. That's incredibly important in terms of management so we can build real resilience into our herds through our genetic choices, particularly with cell count and mastitis and lameness. So that's one feature. We need to think about the environment that the animals are lying in. So ultimately we need our animals to lie down and ruminate and produce milk. So whether they're housed or grazed, that environment needs
to be clean. That returns to that conversation about mob grazing and moving our animals on and leaving highest ward length. Nutrition is obviously really important and the team that you have and how you manage your team, which again, sounds not very bad and related, but motivating your team to create a really good environment from for your animals, whether they're housed or grazed, and it's incredibly important. Making sure that they're consistent in their milking parlor routine to prevent the spread of infection. Motivating them to create routine trimming protocols to ensure that our feet on our cows
are in as good shape as possible. All those things are really important, but they rely on a team approach to make them work. And there's lots of data coming from the AIR tags now as well. Yeah, there is. And there's so much data available on farms and it's becoming much, much more widespread. Say quite often now I'm just pinged a picture of a cow's rumination activity and you can tell loads from that. And that data is actually really important because, umm, say, for example, if you use lameness, we do a lot of mobility scoring on farm, which is a snapshot of how those cows are walking on the day. And we can obviously look at the
trends of those, but they're relatively subjective. So although there's a standardized training course for those mobility trainers, those mobility scorers, you know, we're all still human. So there's going to be a level of subjectivity, but obviously see, now we can use cameras to monitor cow cows walking out the parlor and we can look at their body conditions through that. And all those things make the data much more accurate. And then the advice that we can give them is much more useful. Brilliant. Now Helen talked about genetics there as sort of one part of that three legged story and but I want us to touch on genetics
just a little bit more and think about how active breeding and presumably an active culling program can improve health and welfare outcomes. Yeah, I think there's a lot of a move to making sure that the livestock are adapted to your farm rather than adapting your farm to the livestock. So we could take, for example, an upland sutler farm as an example. So this year's straw's an absolute fortune. You know, these guys don't have any arable, they're buying all their straw in. So we're looking at potentially changing genetics to allow the cow sites to be reduced so that we can actually out winter for
longer. So every day or every week that those cows can be outwintered and don't have to be housed is a is a massive financial gain for those farmers. So that's an example where we're changing the genetics of the animals over time to make that farm more resilient and sustainable into the future. Because he can't stomach a £50,000 straw Bale every year. So, and I think there can be more subtle than that. It doesn't have to be a massive dramatic change. I think the beauty of being able to breed your own animals and have home bread replacements and select animals that are suited to your system is a huge, huge
benefit. And everybody, the epigenetics comes into everybody talks about epigenetics, which very simply is the ability of an animal to express genes based on its environment that it's within. So if your environment suits that animal's genetic makeup, then it will thrive in your environment. And it can be a whole range of things that can be how they get their grazing pattern. So for example, if you're more grazing, do they go into how they get their head down and get their feed? Or do they wander around, look at the scenery and everybody else has eaten their grass? Do they breakthrough the electric fence? How do they select the pasture
of their so do they always choose the really proteinaceous herbage? And therefore they they scour and they get data perineums, then they're attracted to flies and we don't want those animals in the system. So when we we talk about data, some of this data collection can really basic. It's just observations for characteristics that you don't really want in your in your herd and flock. And therefore, when you're making your breeding decisions, we can select animals that we want to keep heifer replacements out of or yeah, lamb replacements out of to get that genetic gain over a long period of time. And it depends on inheritability
of those traits, how quick we get that genetic game. But there's certainly massive advancements that can be made without massive investment or a lot of data collection in terms of technology, just using your eyes and be able to record that information and interpret it. Really, really interesting. Claire. We're coming towards the end of the program and I just wonder if you could sort of help us to start summing up. And what do you think are the most important starting points for farmers wanting to reduce their vet bills and their use of medications? I think as Helen said earlier, I think that parasite control is still like it. It's still really low hanging
fruit for a lot of farms. So I think often the reason is it doesn't involve your vet. So it's really easy to go into a country store and just pick up a Weimar or a product or whatever without having that conversation. So I think if you can just sit down with them and have a conversation, you know, you can move away. We've moved away very much so from like blanket treatment of antibiotics and livestock. But I think sometimes with, with sort of parasite control, that still happens. So if we can move away from that by using things like fecal egg counts, by just starting to look and observe a bit about what's going on within your herd or your flock, that's a really, really good way of starting it. And I think just having a
conversation with your vet. So what percentage, look, you're thinking about things like what percentage your vet, your vet spend is on like sort of preventative versus treatments. You know, if, if you, if both 2 farms have exactly the same vet spend and one is 90% on treatments and 10% on preventatives. And the other way round, for another farm, you can potentially almost kind of get an idea about who's going to be the most profitable or who's going to have the better outcome within those farming systems. So I think looking at what those spends are, and one of the things I'll hear from the more regenerative side is our vets don't understand what we're trying to do. They don't get it. And I would say like, have a
conversation with them like that relationship, build that relationship with your vet and say, this is what we're trying to achieve. Show them, tell them what you're doing. Ask them how you can plan ahead for some of those those things or you don't want to do. If you, if you say you want to be using less antibiotics, I guarantee your vet will be really, really interested in that conversation. And I think it's that thing about working with like ask them a question. You know, the thing, a lot of the work that I've done, obviously from like dung beetle talks, etcetera, has come off like parasite control. And that's meant, I meant I've ended up with working with all different kinds of farms from very, very, what I would call conventional farms right through
the spectrum to regenerative farm. So, and in terms of things like people might see a dung beetle and think that is, that's something I want to know more about. And then you'll get out to a farm that you realise that they're using a hell of a lot of product that they probably don't really need. And getting them to engage on something that's like such a such a such a win win to be able to do something like that on a farm where inputs might be quite a big cost in that system and you can make a significant difference just by changing that one little thing. Fantastic. I've just realised that I made a massive faux pas earlier in the program when I was talking about you doing lots of sort of worm conversations and of course it wasn't, it was dung beetles.
Fantastic. So, so Helen, just I, I appreciate there's a degree of repetition here, but thinking about those farmers in more mainstream systems, particularly perhaps who are pretty inherently skeptical of regen or agroecology and these these sort of faddy type things that they'd see it, what should their livestock health priorities be? Probably the most important topic that we are talking to our farmers about at the moment is just making sure that they're resilient to climate change and heat stress. And, and that feeds into lots of different things in terms of livestock health priorities. That means that we can tick off
those low hanging fruit that Claire mentioned, like parasite control, heifer rearing, how we make the most of the genetics that they've invested in, like those are really simple priorities, which will ultimately help them in improving their farm resilience. So, so I think we need to focus on those low hanging fruit if they are skeptical of regen and and also identify what they're already doing, which they may not necessarily relate directly to regen principles. And Leanne, just finally, resilience, as we've said, is key for ecological and food security. Did you get a sense that a change is taking place across
the veterinary industry more broadly? Or are the approaches that we've been talking about today, you know, sort of bearing in mind the fact that you 3 are, of course, sort of leaders within your profession in this way, Are they still a bit out there and avant-garde so far as most farmers and vets are concerned? I think there's a huge following of vets very similar to ourselves that are working away, talking to their farmers right now as we sit here doing a great deal of work to change systems. And I think we've got to remember that our priority as vets, as animal health and welfare, it's not, it's not making money.
We signed an oath and that's why we all became vets. So I think there's a lot to be done and I think the vet schools are catching on. There's now sustainability modules and some of the veterinary degrees. And I think older members of the profession, I was going to say, which includes myself, Claire and Helen, have a responsibility to to coach those younger vets and not for them to fear the word regenerative and the regenerative farms and long grass breeze. And you know, they need to embrace that. Ultimately what we're trying to do is integrated parasite management and antibiotic reduction and, and all the things that we talk about
ultimately do help soil health as well. So I would embrace any young vet that wants to be a bit more in this field to listen to some of the podcasts that are available and get on YouTube, speak to other vets, engage in CPD. But I think there has been a big change over the last 10 years possibly. And, and you know the, you know the Sky's the. Limit. Fantastic. Thanks so much Leanne. That's been so interesting and that is sadly all we have time for. I'd like to thank my guests, Helen Rogers, Leanne Oliver and Claire Whittle. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us,
review us and share our links. Farm Gate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast and farm Gate leaders Martins Farm and Wheat from the Chaff are all available on the Farm Gate channel if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. Farm Gate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is supported by First Milk, Pelican AG, Rural Solutions, the Nature Friendly Farming Network, Friars Moore Livestock Health Agrolo and individual donors. I've been fin loca staine bye for now.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...