Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Farm Gate

Farm Gate artwork

Wheat from the Chaff: War-scale transformation needed

Nov 4, 20251 hrAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

ffinlo Costain (8point9.com) and Joe Stanley (GWCT Allerton Project) meet for Farm Gate's monthly discussion programme. This time: They discuss: Radical war-scale transformation needed in UK food system How food security depends on geopolitics Prof. Sir Dieter Helm's new paper: The Future of British Farming Lloyds report aims to help farmers reduce climate and nature risks "Extreme weather is making our bread less British" Class action style legal claim on the River Wye Using nature to help tackle mental health issues More land use news at 8point9.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, welcome to Wheat from the Chaff on the Farm Gate podcast channel. I'm Finn Loca Stain, the chief editorof8.9.com. And I'm Joe Stanley, writer and head of sustainable farming at The Allerton Project. Today we're going to discuss a report calling for a radical war scale change in the UK food system. We'll consider Dieter Helms proposals for the future of UK farming. Well, look at a recent Lloyds report on helping farmers address climate and nature risk

and talk through the virtues or otherwise of introducing US style class actions to the UK to address environmental degradation. But let's start with the road map to resilience, which is a report from the AFN network. Plus now Joe, we put a headline here which was taken from a quote within the article on 8.9 and it was radical war scale transformation needed in the UK food system. Now I'm off even a bit reluctant to kind of use phrases like this war scale because it, you know, it's, it's all a bit

militaristic and not always helpful. But at the same time, it does give us a sense of the, the scale of the challenge that they're talking about. But at the same time, I'm not entirely convinced that they quite got the challenge right. So let's start off by putting it in context. So we've got here the road map for resilience. AUK food plan for 2050 calls for radical transformation at a pace and scale not seen since the Second World War. It says if we do not act now, then change will be forced upon us by increasing pressures and

the UK will lurch from crisis to crisis, including from food price shocks, climate disasters and weakening economic productivity. The report states the UK food system faces pressures that make transformation inevitable. Our food and farming landscapes will change radically over the next half century, whether we like it or not. And the question is whether we actively manage change for the public good or respond haphazardly as changes are forced upon us. We only have a brief window. It says. Now the point really that I wanted to pick up here in terms of that statement that I made

early on, that, yes, this is a massive food system transformation that we're looking at. Yes, they have articulated this change is necessary. They've highlighted 3 sort of core areas of change and 10 points within that. But I always feel that conversations about food security start to low down this sort of pecking order. It feels to me that food security in and of itself is a secondary challenge and we need to understand the primary challenge before we then start addressing the food security element. And my feeling is that yet again, there is a report that

doesn't quite get this. And I guess what I'm talking about is the need to have a cold assessment of the security threat. What is the security threat globally? I've never seen one in relation to food that really accounts for geopolitics. Looks at terrorism and war, cyber attacks, all that sort of stuff, but then looks at the pressures on fuel and fertilizer use, on pesticide, etcetera, on how that geopolitics might impact on these things. At the same time as then assessing how climate change and weather is going to change

things as we move forward, How biodiversity, you know, fits in with that, the skills gap, food distribution, a whole range of different things. So we're looking at the security landscape before we then start sort of fitting food within it. So we're making the case properly for change. Well, I think what you've just done F and now is to highlight the immensity of the challenge, the immensity of the topic when we're talking about this issue and this report in and of itself is really wide reaching. As you say, there's three kind

of key calls for transfer, you know, three key areas that it highlights stronger, more resilient farming, smarter, more integrated land use and healthier diets made easier. Now any one of those is a huge topic in and of itself. And then it's got 10 key recommendations following on from that. But yeah, you're right, Phil. I mean, look, we consistently underplay the, a, the importance of this whole kind of food security, food self-sufficiency issue. And then we sort of consistently continue to, to treat individual bits of it in, in isolation.

So, you know, for me, this, this report is, you know, it's, it's really good. I mean, it's, it's, it's repeating much of what we've seen in reports for years now. I think the striking thing about it is that frankly, it's largely just repeating things that we, that we kind of already know. Yeah, yet again, I, I completely take your point, Finlow. The the even in and of itself, it doesn't go far enough to look at those kind of wider, more underlying challenges to our food security. And yeah, I mean a radical war

scale transformation of how we look at our food system. I suppose what that is saying is that ultimately, until we get to some of a war situation as society, we tend to ignore the big issues. We tend to ignore those intractable problems that we face. It's kind of a, a handy short term shorthand way of saying how important it is that we, we put resource into this. But you know, the, the question, I guess I would ask at this point is what therefore continue to be the blockers to actually taking all of these myriad reports that we get and actually

implementing them into both government policy, supply chain policy and social consciousness. Why do we continue to not act on these reports? And I think the Cliff edge is that again, you know, this report highlights, you know, lead author, I think was Tim Benton, who's only too aware of those kind of geopolitical and climate issues, you know, that that you talked about there. Finlay, through his current work at Chatham House. What continues to be the thing that gets us closer to that Cliff edge that we're

continually warned about without really doing anything to address the issues? And I think it really is, it's a failure to address and expand upon to explain that higher level element, because I think there is a real sort of tendency within government. I mean, government, we keep hearing this phrase, don't we? Food security is national security without any kind of sense of, of what that means. And, and it's a it's a drum that I've been banging for a long time. I completely agree that food is fundamental to national security, but we need to

understand that in a global context and. Either the country's leading food security podcast. This is this is indeed, Yeah. Farmgate has become the world's leading food security podcast. The world. There we go. Yeah. Highest ranking. So. So I, I mean, quite far from anything else. I thought we probably ought to discuss it, but there is this sort of sense, I think, you know, within government that if push comes to shove, then we can simply produce more food. We kind of reference back as human beings, as individuals to the last time that we faced A comparative challenge in this

way. And I think, you know, a lot of people look back at the Second World War and they say, well, we coped then. That wasn't, you know, we had to make some changes, but ultimately we got through it. That was OK. And the kind of challenges that we're expecting to face as a result of human response to environmental degradation, I don't want to just say that it's environmental degradation. It's how humans respond to that and to the migration greatly pressures that are likely to to come from that. I think it's going to be really challenging. And so if you look back at the Second World War, I think we kind of need to be stop being

quite so starry eyed about the way that society is in comparison with them. Our population is more than doubled in terms of what it was in 1940. The way that we use land is entirely different. The way that we distribute food is different. The way that people, people's experience, people's knowledge of how to use their own gardens is different. But apart from the fact that an awful lot of people simply don't have gardens, you know, they live in very, very dense urban populations. And so actually the challenge,

even if we're just talking about, you know, producing food in the UK, it's really very different. And I've not seen an analysis of that. I don't know if you have. No, and it scares the, the, the concept of shortages within the economy scares the hell out of me because I think, you know, we, we know enough about human behaviour kind of at the that kind of macro level to know that, you know, we they are humans are panicky and, and largely self interested beasts, right? We, we saw what happened during COVID when there was even the suggestion and there might be shortages of things.

And then all of a sudden there's panic buying, hoarding and the food system couldn't cope with that, with that level of strain. And that was when there wasn't a supply side issue. If there is a genuine supply side issue, expect that to be significantly magnified. So, yeah, I mean, look, it really does, it scares me the, the, the thought that that we could start to see these significant shortages that we're still continuing to just ignore that this is even a possibility. And, and look, you know, again, this report is calling for again, placing food security in a power of energy security.

And we now have a food security minister. You know, the the New Labour government, when it came in it, it changed the farming minister to a food security minister. And yet, and yet, Finlay, we've talked enough about this in the last year or so. This government really couldn't have done any more to undermine food security in the last 12 months or so. So we are absolutely still nowhere on this. So again, for me, why do we continue to to completely ignore this as an issue despite the number of very well meaning, very detailed reports that come out? You know, fundamentally, I don't think society and I don't think politicians and I don't think

the food supply chain even is is is really fundamentally taking this seriously. And I don't know how much we can continue to bang that drum. And I think part of it again is, is this sort of the phrase food security because I think there's a food security's existed throughout my lifetime. I'm 53 now, but it is every decade of my lifetime. I think that what food security means has changed to a certain extent. And certainly in the 70s and the 80s, there really was this sense the food security meant being able to produce loads of food at home, you know, as and when that that time came. And I don't think that, I mean,

although when you, you think within groups like the AFN network plus, you know, and in conversations that we've had in, in various different sort of think tanky type things that we've been involved in, there is an understanding that food security is, is about more than this. But there's a need for phrases that genuinely kind of elicit the response from policy makers that don't think about it regularly to understand what it means. And I think the food resilience, in the same way that we talk about farm resilience, is a much better way of talking through

what we're talking about. Because if there was a global war, global conflict of some kind, you know, no matter how that arises, and there are interruptions to fuel and fertiliser and, you know, various other things that we import, let alone the food that physically comes in, how would we address that? And, and I don't think that we can just, you know, currently assume that we're going to be able to grow our way out of that because of the skills gap, because of the fertility gap, because of the fact that we have

this hugely variable weather now that we haven't been used to in the past. And so it, it feels to me, and I'm, I'm jumping ahead to a conclusion. And actually, I think there's, you know, a job of work to be done to look at, you know, what different people think that food resilience or food security might look like. And then to start addressing those thinking about those scenarios seriously, breaking them down, testing them to see whether they actually hold up. But ultimately, it seems to me that you cannot have food security and food resilience without a regenerative approach and agroecological approach,

which is a fundamentally enormous change in the way that the system works. And without greater distribution diversity within that as well. So you're addressing the skills gap really rapidly. You're addressing soil utility and biodiversity loss, the importance of of mycorrhizal fungi, and everything else within the soil. You're addressing the fact that you need to be able to produce food regardless of the weather and therefore that water holding capacity is so important within the soil. You know, at the same time as as having a, a clearview of, of

what that that world looks like. And if we're thinking about having to produce food for our own population without any imports, without the fuel and fertilizer that we currently import, what does that look like? Because it's only when we have a sense of what that looks like and we can be honest in that assessment that we can start building towards it. Absolutely. And and there are so many points of failure in that resilient food. You know, we, we have an incredibly unresilient food system at the moment. And, you know, This is why when I was, you know, farming back

home, I really seriously looked at shifting to organic production because again, what scared me was the thought of, and this was, you know, this was pre Ukraine, what scared me was the thought of fertilizer quadrupling in price. And what would that do to the resilience of my farm business? And of course, that is the benefit of moving towards an organic system, right? You are divorcing yourself from a requirement to actually depend on those external inputs. Now, of course, for me, there's lots of problems with an organic system, but that's one of the huge benefits of that system.

And it is that resilience that you talk about that again, I think is fundamentally misunderstood by people all across kind of, if you like the food system. And, and certainly especially, you know, policy makers who don't realize that we are almost entirely dependent on that flow of external to the UK inputs, machinery, labour, fertilizers coming in Agri chemicals and absolutely everything we can do to reduce that, that dependence is, is, is incredibly valuable. But again, look that I, I agree with 9 1/2 out of 10 of the

recommendations of this report, but when are we going to start to take this take this seriously? Coincidentally, the one I I have a question mark about as usually with these reports is as always, the requirement for dietary change and for less, less cattle. Basically as as seems to be just do rigor with anything. When we talk about the food system, there's this automatic assumption that we need to just have less, less ruminants. And again, I think in a regenerative farming system, I would love to see the piece of work done that tells us in a

genuinely regenerative farming system, do we need less cattle and sheep, more cattle and sheep, or about the same number in order to regenerate our soils. I would love in in a changing climate where grass and swords are going to be the most resilient land use that we can have. I would love to see that piece of work done. Yeah, one of the, one of the priority actions I'm not sure that I agree with is creating a National Food System transformation committee. Because the idea of just yet another committee when actually we just need to be mobilizing sort, you know, and, and, and,

and consciousness within the committees that we have and getting them to work together very often on these these various different things. Was was. Got a lot done Finlay back in the day. The war anks got a lot done. Fair enough, Fair enough. Just on that, on that sort of second priority action targets for dietary change and animal numbers, did it specifically say further into the report that it was talking about ruminants or is that an assumption on your part, Joe? I mean, I'm guessing when we start talking about livestock numbers, we're always talking about cows and sheep basically.

I mean, that's, that's, that's just, that's the way it always goes, right? We're we're too much, you know, because one of the big focuses of this report is also the environmental impact of this. It's not a food security report, which perhaps we've, we've given a slightly misleading, you know, the, you know, it's also report, yeah, it's a food system, but it's also talking significantly about the environmental impact of British agriculture. So, yeah, look, I mean, yes, there is, there is a big piece of work to be done there as well around reducing the environmental impact of farming. Of course there is. And yes, this report is correct

when it says that by the middle of the century, agriculture is currently projected to be the single biggest contributor to our, you know, to our carbon emissions in the UK because we're not currently doing enough to decarbonize. But again, of course, a huge proportion of that is the way that we're farming at the minute, not necessarily what we're producing. And we've, we've talked about that before. I know you talk about this in many other places, Finlay, but again, I just, I'd like to see that kind of again, that more integrated approach to the best way that we could go about farming, farming rather than just saying, well, you know what, the simplest thing to do

is just to have less cows, less cows, less than saying good outcome. I'd like to think, I mean, my, my go to assumption is exactly what you've just said. But I, I'd like to think that there is more of a focus going on these days on chickens and pigs. And, and that there is a recognition that the impact of chicken and pig systems and the enormous, you know, numbers of chickens in particular that we, we eat in the UK on a, on a weekly basis, that that is actually where we want to see the reduction in numbers. And I have seen more reports

dwelling on the idea that there are too many chicken produced and too many pigs produced. And I've started to see, and I've started to sort of feel, it's almost sort of feeling in my waters with my dousing sticks rather than necessarily seeing it, you know, on the page too frequently. But I, I'm, I do feel that that conversation about Catalyst starting to change because as you say, I would really like to see that assessment. And my own instinct is that we certainly don't need to see a reduction. We potentially need to see an increase. But what we really need is a redistribution of livestock so

that in those areas where livestock are more intensively grazed or more intensively housed, that actually there's a redistribution across the country so that we have livestock integrated within within other systems, arable and horticultural. But on that, that massive increase in, in poultry consumption in, in the UK in the last 30 years, yeah, that there has been a decrease in red meat consumption, but it's not been driven by environmental concerns or even health concerns. It's been driven frankly by people who know less and less how to cook the majority of, of

the carcass of a lamb or a or or a cow, right. That that's the so it's, that it's that fundamental kind of loss of skills and knowledge around how to cook good food. That's, it's really driven that, that Now, look, you can argue whether, you know, which livestock is better from an environment, you know, we, we can have that, that conversation, right? But fundamentally, again, I think there's that kind of misconception more widely that that reduction in red meat consumption is driven by this big sort of climate concern. I think the public just haven't been buying that. Yeah, but it is around the

skills and the knowledge and the confidence and of course the affordability of red meat. And that is a really important question mark alongside much more, let's be honest, you know, economically efficient white meat production. But yeah, it's, it's a fascinating subject, right? Yeah, absolutely. And as you say, economically efficient, efficient in terms of emissions, white meat production. But when we're looking at the sort of broader overall impacts, then there's no doubt that you can, you can produce the cattle in the UK that we, that we need,

that we have in really good ecological ways that can be highly beneficial, not just from a climate perspective, but from a biodiversity in soil and water and everything else perspective as well. Yeah, and, and just being more honest about getting people to update their knowledge on these things. And you mentioned there that the, the knowledge gap, the skills gap and I, I talked about that earlier as well. And it's not just as you say about the knowledge that exists this within farming, but the knowledge that exists within society.

Gone are the days when everybody used to produce a few veggies in their back garden. You know, that's that has gone. But it's going to have to come back and and quite apart from the ability to cook and to know what to do with the bits that most people are just throwing away these days. Well, should we move on to, to Dieter Helm and his analysis of the future of farming, yes, into context or should I just, should I just sort of put this, just start us off on this? So our, I, I tried to put a positive spin on, on Dieter's

comments. And I should say that in a week's time, Dieter Helm is going to be on the podcast talking about this along with Patrick Holden from the Sustainable Food Trust. So we're not going to spend forever on it. But at the same time, the rapid scaling of regen depends on pollution pricing. And I thought that was probably, you know, one of the more positive elements. Within there, Professor Sedita Helm, of course, is the the kind of godfather of natural capital in the UK has produced a new paper, The Future of British Farming. While recognizing the benefits of regenerative low input agriculture, Helm says that the

trajectory for low input farming depends heavily on pollution pricing. He says with comprehensive pollution pricing, charging for carbon emissions, water contamination and biodiversity damage, the economic landscape transforms entirely. What government should do is to focus on the pollution and therefore closing the gap between high and low pollution production techniques. That farmers should pay for the nutrient load going into rivers and they should face the same pressures as water companies. They should not be paid to reduce the nutrient levels, they

should pay for not doing it through pollution charges. What do you think I? Think that what we see here is another very narrow take on the food system. You know, we've basically got an economist's view on the food system. Now. I listen to Professor Sir Dieter how I'm talking on, you know, a wide range of subjects, just as you do Finlay. You know, you turn on Radio 4 and you'll be talking about the water industry or the transport sector and it's always fascinating and you think, wow, this guy's got such a fantastic

grasp of the issues and then really cuts through. And then when you you listen to such individuals sometimes then talk about your sector, you go, I see a lot of holes in the arguments and a lot of selective use of, of arguments. Which then rather undermines the the way that you you listen to him on other subjects. Yeah, it. It, but this is a pure economics view of agriculture. It, it's, you know, some of the claims are frankly just fantastical. The fact that, that, that, you know, AI is going to do more for yields than the, the, the, the

previous agricultural revolutions all put together have, you know, fundamentally we're talking about biological systems outside in the weather. We're not gonna see fundamental shifts in things like yields. We're we're gonna see, you know, you know, some marginal gains and, and that sort of thing. So Dita here, he's talking about essentially every acre of British farmland having data pouring out of it in Torrance going into clouds, farmers going out of, you know, basically becoming extinct and farmers becoming laptop wielding mathematicians. I mean, it's nonsense.

You know, anyone who has any actual kind of grasp, I believe of actually what it takes to to to grow food on the land would, would be able to tell you it's nonsense. You know, again, we're we're seeing odes to vertical farming and vertical farms are going out of business left, right and center across the world, but even here in the UK because they fundamentally don't work as an economic model. And one of the quotes from this piece was given where British farming is very low productivity, having relied on cheap migrant labor, highly polluting and creating a very low total economic value. Again, it's a pure economic, you

know, just because the UK agriculture is only producing .6% of GDP, it's to completely ignore the fact that we produce so much else and that we can produce food at the same time as providing for nature. We don't have to, I think as, as Dita is suggesting, basically far, you know, land sparing, he's suggesting that we should rewild large parts of the countryside or put solar panels over large parts of the countryside and farm a much smaller area much more intensively. That's essentially what he's saying. And to describe regenerative farming as glyphosate enabled no till and kind of to leave it

there again is to completely misunderstand what regenerative farming is, can be, and what it provides for society. You know, for me, it's almost an absurd of you as that of your favorite Guardian columnist, who I won't bother to mention. And one kind of personal experience does spring to mind when we're talking about this, which is I once went to an event where Sadita was talking, and this was back when we were looking at trying to get rid of of direct payments, the old European style subsidy payments. You know, Sedita was a big

proponent that they were artificially inflating land values and rental values. And if all we had to do was get rid of subsidy payments and they would all fall. And he used as a, as a, as an anecdote, the fact that he had just been in a bidding war for a, a small holding, I think in Dartmoor. And he was appalled by the cost of this small holding. And he put the blame entirely at the at the door of BPS for overinflating the value of this farm he was trying to buy. And I just sat there thinking

you couldn't see the fundamental sort of irony of what you were saying, that I think what you had was two people of independent means in a bidding war for lifestyle property. And that's what was inflating the land value, not the fact that you were getting what, 80 lbs an acre from a, an asset that's worth £8000 an acre. You know, nobody was buying land up in order to claim the BPS, which is what at the time Sedita was saying, you know, there were external factors here associated with keeping those land values vastly inflated.

And of course, what we've seen is, yes, we've got rid of BPS and land values have continued to rise. So I, I just fundamentally worry that again, as you say, you know, Sedita and, and, and similar people are very close to the center of power when we talk about what treasury is doing and, and how it's viewing the countryside and agricultural policy. And you cannot just look at this through this completely narrow prism of what does GCSE textbook economic tell us about agriculture. Because yes, if that's the way we look at it, it makes

absolutely no sense to produce food in this country. Yeah, it's a high cost economy with very low cost or very low value food essentially. But that that's to completely ignore all the context we've just been talking about earlier on in this podcast about the importance of domestic food production and the other things that farming can provide. Yeah, I struggled through GCSE and A level economics and and I hated it. I hated it, not least because it didn't ever, it didn't ever seem to sit within or certainly back

in, in those days, in the sort of late 80s that the economics never sat within the social reality of how people actually function. It was, it was bizarrely detached from the rest of the world, which is why I never did particularly well because I always wanted to attach the economics to the societal elements as well. And, and the teachers weren't happy with that at the time. I think they would be these days. I think there's a, you know, there's a lot more scope for that kind of conversation. It's interesting listening to the way that you've responded to the article from Dieser or the essay and the way that I've written it up.

As I say, I've written it up as, as you know, sort of trying to pull out the positive strands of what's there where, you know, you've sort of responded to some of the rhetoric and, and my own feeling. And I wonder, you know, what what you think about this, Joe, is that 80% of what he says is a reasonable analysis. It's then some of the rhetoric and some of the conclusions on top of it. So, So what he's saying, you know, is I sort of written down his analysis is that there is a technical revolution that digitalization, AI, genetic, synthetic biology, those are all

going to have an impact. And we can discuss the scale to which they're going to have an impact, but they are already having an impact. Farm financialization, the way that land and machinery and buildings are financed, the way that, you know, tractors are so expensive that you know, you've you've got to have them on HP very often in order to sort of cope with that. So that sort of loads debt onto farmers in in ways that, you know, didn't happen so much in the past, quite apart from the tax landscape that exists, which although it's it's in flux at the moment. You know, people have been buying up large tracts of land

for tax purposes for a long time. Corporate factory scale, agriculture, land competition for different things, the lack of food security, ecological reckoning. I mean, these are all things that I don't think we would necessarily disagree with that much. The question is then what we do with this information. And, and his conclusion is that there are three approaches for the future of land use. And I'm not sure that he's necessarily, you know, in reading and rereading and rereading, I'm not sure that he's necessarily promoting one over and above the other. But he's saying there's either the large Agri business sort of

future, which is essentially business as usual, possibly on steroids a little, or there's natural capital delivery and now, which I would say needs to be in support of food. I'm not sure that Dieter actually says that within that. And then there's the regen and the organic approach. And and what I was wanting to sort of focus on a little just for a couple of minutes is, is the idea of pollution pricing, whether pollution pricing, whether charging for nitrogen use, for example, increasing the the fuel duties, so there is a

carbon tax on on oil and diesel that's imported, whether that would be a sensible approach to changing the way that we manage land? No, I mean I, I think again it, I understand how economically that seems to make sense. We have, we have environmental pollution and therefore yes, polluter pays principle, you tax the pollution and therefore the pollution stops. But fundamentally the problem I have with this argument is why do farmers produce food the way they produce food? Because they are being forced in a very high cost economy to produce food to the absolutely

lowest possible, you know, cost and then then being paid off and below the cost of production for that food. At the minute wheat is being sold for less than 160 lbs a tonne. That is an historic low level. Now, if you're going to tax the polluter, who is the polluter in this situation? Is it the farmer who's essentially stuck within a system which is forcing him to produce food in a certain way or is it society more general, you know, in in in more general terms who are demanding food at that incredibly, you know, high volumes are incredibly low cost.

So for me that the fundamental problem with the argument of the polluter pays principle, you know, and what Sarita is saying is essentially tax the farmer until they're forced to produce food in a more sustainable way, which as he points out, is a fundamentally different approach from public money for public goods, where at the minute farmers are essentially being paid incentivized to do that. And, and I think that is the correct approach because farmers are being forced and, and have the generations been forced to essentially inflict damage on the environment in producing food?

Because that is what society has been and that's what market economics has been demanding of them. You know why? Why is organic still only 2% of the market? Because fundamentally, you know, that's the the maximum percentage of the market that that's market saturation, that's the maximum number of people who are willing to buy organic produce because it costs more. So there's no point sort of taxing farmers into producing more expensive food that then people won't be able to afford to buy. There has to be other mechanisms to support farmers to move away from polluting practices, but

those are the polluting practices that they are being forced to to to essentially do in order to produce the food at an affordable price point. So taxing farmers is is you know, that's not the solution. I guess, you know, because there is a degree to which I'm attracted by the idea of the polluter pay is sort of principle here. And the idea not just of a, a tax on farmers using the diesel and oil that's coming in, but on attacks on sort of fossil fuels more broadly. That, you know, if we're seeing carbon being imported into the country, you know, there are

mechanisms that are already, you know, in existence for, for increasing the cost of those so that you kind of force the transition. However, I, what I would say is that this can only ever be one part of the puzzle. And the trouble is that very often governments or policy makers or economists will focus on one element of, of a solution or one element of a problem and they'll come up with an answer which which by itself would potentially drive all kinds of unintended consequences. And So what we really need to

see again, is that, you know, going back to that previous conversation is an understanding of what land resilience, of what food resilience, of what food system resilience and health resilience, which we didn't touch on. But we might come to, you know, in the second-half that that that those things are really important. And in order to deliver that, we need really strong public funding of the transition. There needs to be real investment in that transition. And if at the same time you're then bringing in a tax which which disincentivises business

as usual, then I think that's less of an issue. At the same time, I really want to see, and I'm not seeing this at the moment. I've seen a little bit of language around it, but some genuine scaling and acceleration around natural capital markets. And then the thing that you've mentioned, you know, many times in the past is the idea of actually upholding standards, British standards in trading arrangements globally. So you have all these things together, then I think you have the potential to accelerate change. You do one thing alone, then you

create distortions and what we've. What we're going to see I think in 2027 is a carbon border adjustment mechanism applied to fertilizer and other high energy, high carbon imports, which I'm sure again Sedita would would welcome. But again, all that's going to do is potentially put 25% on the cost of domestic fertilizer per, you know, it's going to add 25% of farmers fertilizer bills which they're they're not going to be able to pass on. So yeah, yeah, absolutely. If the profitability is there to somehow subsidized that, then that's fine.

But as you say, Finlow, if you just, if you whack a single, a single sort of solution onto things in the complete absence of a more generalized ecosystem to allow that to be bearable, then you're going to achieve nothing except offshoring our, our food production. So this goes back to our previous conversation about the AFM plus report. You know, there's, there's what are the blockers to actually starting to go down this more holistic approach to our food system. And again, for me, so Dita's report is, it's this, it's basically chosen a winner.

And, and, and for me, it is an unrealistic, it's a fantastical future which just doesn't have, it doesn't ring true to me. And, and again, it's looking to essentially penalize farmers for society's sins. And and for me, again, with farmers already on their knees, I don't see any legs in that whatsoever. Yeah, exactly. So again, sort of coupling these conversations together, it's about having a really clear assessment, you know, with without that sort of starry eyed approach.

As I sort of mentioned before, I think so many people have different views about what society is going to do and how it's going to respond in different things. But until we have clear eyed assessments of what the external threats are, of what the, you know, what the internal challenges are in in response to that. And then we've taken away this sort of approach to these issues, this sort of single issue approach so that we can start to look at things holistically. We're not going to be able to make progress. And so in terms of those blockers that you were talking about, it's getting rid of single issue lenses yet.

They're useful enough in order to be able to have, you know, conversation to start with, But you very rapidly need to move on to where they sit within that sort of broader, more holistic understanding and then some genuine clear assessments of these things that are currently missing. Joe, let's take a break. We're back and we're going to talk about that Lloyd's report that I mentioned earlier on addressing climate and nature risk in UK farming, and we're

going to ask whether UK style class actions can help to arrest ecological decline. So we're not going to spend that long on on these individual stories. I think we've got 3 or 4 just to kind of whip through before the end, Joe. But the first one was Lloyd's farm report aims to help farmers reduce climate and nature risk. Lloyd's have launched Farming with Nature mapping the growth opportunity for UK agriculture, A comprehensive analysis mapping 5.1 million hectares, almost a third of the UK's farmed land, using geospatial data on farm assessments and new economic

insight. The report also marks the introduction of Lloyd's Agricultural Transition Finance and new product which will be launching later this year. The report identifies 1.2 million hectares of UK farmland with the highest potential for habitat creation. 600,000 hectares prime land for of the of land that's prime for trees and hedges and then 700,000 hectares in drought prone regions that could benefit from improved water management. And they've used Earth Blocks, which is a platform using

satellite data, to come to those conclusions. It's a nice, it's a nice report. I'm not sure there's a, there's a huge amount in there, which is kind of groundbreaking. I think it's, again, it's part of that corpus of, of evidence, which is very welcome, that's building, which is demonstrating that there is probably, you know, that there is a better way to manage our land, a more regenerative way, a more sustainable way. I think, you know, some of those figures you've just read out there, Finlay and then some of the maps that come with it, you know, it's great. It's basically saying, look in, in the east where there's lots of arable crops, maybe we should be growing more cover crops in

the West where we've got more livestock, maybe we should be using more lagoon fallows, right? And, and more herbal lays to sort of increase the resilience of our livestock production. It's, you know, which is absolutely right. And again, hopefully sort of people within the food supply chain, people within government, people within the finance sector will pick this up and it'll, it'll just be another kind of spur to kind of better educate people kind of outside the farming sector. So it's, it's very welcome. I think the, the, it's kind of it's linked, isn't it, with Lloyds planning to launch a sort

of a regenerative transition finance product later in the year. I don't think there's any details of that as of yet, but presumably it'll be much in line with similar products already available from banks such as Oxbury from HSBC. And they are, yeah, they're welcome. They, they offer beneficial terms for, for, for finance, for credit to farms looking to fund more regenerative practices. They're never going to be game changing. You know, it's going to be one element, one small element of, of how we help finance this

regenerative transition. But, you know, it's, it's welcome and it's great to see a big agricultural lender, Light Lloyds, recognizing the benefits, the wider benefits. Again, it's not just about food production. It's also about natural capital that more regenerative farming can bring. And it's great to see that again, a big corporate giant Light Lloyds is getting on that bandwagon and throwing its weight behind, you know, behind that kind of that rolling ball. You know, we we want to see that

that snowball picking up more, more and more mass. So yeah, it's it's welcome to see them talking about this. Yeah. And I think I would agree with that, that it's, it's welcome to see them talking about it. But I, I can't remember quite the phrase that you used earlier on that it was essentially it's another report which is telling us to a certain extent what we already know. And, and I think that's the thing that I'm kind of pulling out of Lloyds because Lloyds often present these reports in a big fanfare as if they are, you know, they're sort of keen insights that nobody's had before.

But really they're talking about cover cropping, they're talking about tree planting, they're talking about water management. Again, they're sort of, they're identifying little bits of land or what you mean 700,000 hectares of land. But it's still part of the land where we ought to be thinking about water management rather than actually that we need to be thinking about water cycling on all land. And if farmers are thinking about a regenerative approach to, to to to their farm, to their their production systems, then they need to be understanding how these things work and integrating them across. So, yeah, I mean, maybe there's some use in, in this sort of

satellite information, but I do tend to feel a bit underwhelmed by Lloyd's reports. I mean I. I think you always have to treat big, big numbers kind of with, with a great bit of scepticism. Of course, you know, one of the prime things about regenerative farming and about any farming is is the context, right? So sort of, you know, big, big shaded boxes on maps and all the rest of it. As with anything, you do have to treat with a certain dose of skepticism. But look, it's fantastic that, you know, a big corporate giant light Lloyds is is, you know, is basically it's part of this conversation.

And they are they are clear. You know, we're hopefully here, we're pushing open doors, right, Increasingly pushing it open doors. But I think, again, we're all kind of saying the same thing, which is, you know, we need that private finance to be coming in. We're all kind of waiting for that private finance to appear. We're not seeing that private finance. And again, look, this is a serious player. Hopefully the more serious players start to say the same things, we'll start to see more of that money actually coming into play. Yeah, fantastic. And you know, don't be able to

get the wrong idea. I mean, it is welcome to see this. And what's even more welcome is that Lloyds as this sort of great big lender are doing a lot of work with sort of association exchange that I think is a, you know, it's a really important organization sort of sharing data and sharing knowledge. And in that way, I just wish that, you know, they would get their reports out a bit faster and and be on the front foot rather than just kind of stepping in other people's treads, I suppose. I imagine there's a lot of different circles of corporate something that you need to go through before you can release a report. I bet there are.

Let's move on to the next, which is extreme weather is making our bread less British. And of course, these are all headlines on 8.9.com. I'm just going to set the context here. Analysis by the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit, the ECIU of UK harvest data suggests that extreme weather so far in the Twenty 20s has played a major role in creating a total deficit in wheat production of over 7 million tonnes. When considering the proportion of UK production used for milling flour, this is enough wheat to bake over 4 billion loaves of bread. With a population of 69 million people, this equates to 64

loaves of bread for every person in the UK over a year's supply. Tom Lancaster, the land, food and farming analyst at the ECIU, said this is what farming in a changing climate looks like. Extreme weather is making our bread less British as Millers have to turn to imports due to shortfalls in UK production, costing farmers billions in lost income and reducing our self-sufficiency in our main staple crop. Although we can do more to support our farmers to adapt to these extremes, only reducing planet warming emissions to net

zero can prevent these losses to extreme weather escalating in the years to come. Now, when I received this press release, I have to say that it had a, a different, a different headline and I pulled that out because I thought it was, it was rather a sort of tongue in cheek, slightly cheeky sort of hat tip to nationalism that reform. And many of the nationalists, you know, of that ilk tend to be climate change deniers or against net zero in one form or another. But, but here we are.

It's extreme weather, it's climate change that's making our bread less British. We need more British bread. Therefore, we need to, we need to address climate change, Joe. Yeah, Well, maybe if they, if they come to power in a few years, they can just sort of ban the import of foreign wheat. Maybe that'll sort of be one way of of, you know, coming here on our boats and stealing our loaves. That'll be one way of doing it. But yeah, I mean, this is, this is, it's a, it's a relatively simple story, isn't it? We've now had three of the worst five harvests on record this decade. And it's 2025.

You know, we are clearly facing huge volatility in domestic food production. We've talked about this before. And yeah, we we're now looking at sort of record amounts of imports to make up that shortfall in the last couple of years. Of course, we're always gonna have a requirement for imported wheat. We can't grow that kind of hard red wheat, high protein wheat with that sort of consistent high protein levels in the UK because of our climate, because of the size of our farms. We just can't do that. So we're always gonna have a certain requirement. But yeah, absolutely.

Wheat, the staple UK crop, is becoming harder to grow. I see we're starting to grow rice in the UK now. There's a farm in Ely at the minute that's growing, growing the first UK trials of rice. Undoubtedly we're gonna see different crops being grown here, but, but I think we're a long way away from rice. Replacing wheat is our main domestic carbohydrate. But I think your your point. Finlay yes, around that kind of that confusion, that policy confusion by, yes, reform that essentially, you know, they're

going to repeal all of the kind of net zero and, and climate, climate policy. And they're, you know, they're backing farmers. But at the same time, of course, very, very happy to sign trade deals with places like the US and import lower quality food from from elsewhere. While saying that, you know, one of the big benefits of Brexit is that that we can do that and we can import food and we can reduce consumer, you know, we can get ever cheaper food. Yes, Look for me on that particular point, there's a great deal of confusion around reforms policy platform when it comes to agriculture. I would certainly encourage

farmers to take a a bit of a closer look at it before they get too far on that bandwagon. Absolutely, the the nationalist response to food system change really needs to be about additional resilience, making sure that we address climate change, that we get the water cycling and the biodiversity and the soil fertility that we need. So it'll be interesting to see of that policy emerges from reform in due course. Moving on, 4000 people join why production legal claim against chicken firms A legal claim which almost 4000 people have

joined challenging river pollution in the why and US catchment areas has now been filed with the High Court. The court action is against chicken production firms Avara Foods Limited and Freemans of New Unlimited as well as a sewage company Welsh Water do a Comrie. They're blamed for extensive and widespread pollution. The rivers Wye and Lug, and they're tributaries. And we're talking here about 3943 people who have signed up to be claimants. They're all residents, local business owners or people who use the rivers Wye, Usk and Lug for leisure and family time, including people with Riverside

properties or fishing rights, other householders or tenants who live and run businesses near to intensive poultry units. It's about the smell, I think, and things like that and dust, chicken growing farms, sewage infrastructure, businesses who rely on local tourism and river activities who have also joined the claim. Now there are two reasons for talking about this. The first is, you know, let's just kind of look at that claim and whether it's a realistic 1 the idea that chicken farms are are the keeper looters in the why Usk and LUG regions. But then also, and I think this

is almost the more interesting element is this idea of importing the idea of a class action, which is AUS thing. It doesn't exist in terms of legal procedures in the UK, but this idea of mass claimants on a particular thing in order to drive ecological change your views, Joe? Yeah, I mean, this is the story that just keeps coming back and back, isn't it? The whole Wyaska Valley and the water quality down there. I think we fundamentally sort of have a similar view on this Finlayo and I agree, you know, clearly there there is an issue, you know, down there with water

quality and agriculture's impact on that. Of course, agriculture nationally has a significant impact on water quality and we can't shy away from that. There's much that we can do to improve that. However, it's also overstated the extent to which agriculture is responsible for the problems in that part of the world. In particular, I've sat through a briefing from the Environment Agency that says, you know what? Look, actually the major problem really is climate change. Again, it's low water levels, it's high water temperatures. It's not necessarily the amount of phosphate that we're finding in the river. In fact, phosphate levels are much higher in other rivers

around the country. So it's a multi faceted, complex issue, of course, but it's really easy to just boil that down into there's too many chickens in this catchment. That's the problem and that's how we're going to go after it. So yeah, as with many, many issues when it comes to food, farming, the environment, I wish there was more nuance. Of course, nuance doesn't really lend itself to a class action lawsuit, you know? I know you've got thoughts on that as a mechanism. Finland. Well, I, I think it's quite an interesting one. I, I, I'm generally of the view that an awful lot of

environmental campaigning is money that's, that's wasted in various different ways, that there are an awful lot of NGOs who are campaigning for public awareness raising and policy change. But actually, if you really want to get a bang for your buck, if you really want to make change, then the legal system is the way to do it. That the way that the law works and treats means society at large. If you can make a change in the law or create a precedent and do it, you know, at reasonably

limited expense, then you're likely to drive that change more quickly. And I think that's why we're seeing a lot more sort of legal actions taking place and a lot more organizations, you know, whether it's Lee Day, who are, you know, doing this in this particular instance or I think you mentioned Wild Justice at the same time, Client Earth, there are lots of organisations that are starting to do this. I mean, I may not always agree with the things that they're picking up to create that legal case around. And sometimes, you know, those organisations are being a bit

simplistic about their understanding of these things, but at the same time, it does get them coverage and it does mean that if they win, there will be a change that is forced and, you know, sort of foisted upon people. Again, but when you're looking at it through that incredibly narrow lens of a single issue and, and often distorting the evidence is, is, is the right way of putting it, but you're not often going to get a good outcome from that. And when we should be having more, more nuanced, more complex conversations and we should be acknowledging that there are

pros and cons to pretty much any decision that we can make. You know, I, I find that the concept of, again, sort of legislating via via lawsuit where you have to have a winner, you have to have a loser, you have to have sort of a binary kind of 0 sum game. I just don't personally, I, I think that's, that's a bad way of going about things. And, you know, again, who who is probably almost inevitably going to get caught up in the crossfire and it's usually going to be farmers. You know, we've we've got moves

afoot by other sort of campaigning organizations to have farmyard manures reclassified as waste products which need to be incinerated rather than applied to land. You know, these are the sorts of crazy sort of scenarios that you have to then start considering and the implications that that would have for our food system as we're trying to wean ourselves off, you know, carbon heavy synthetic fertilisers. If we then end up having to incinerate our manures, that would just be nuts. But this is the problem when you have single issue groups going after single issue outcomes.

I I have concerns, it's fair to say. Yeah, I mean, I, I don't necessarily disagree with those concerns. You know, I think they're, they're, they're reasonable in, in every way. But at the same time, I, I just find the whole approach of using the law quite interesting because I think it can be powerful and it can be, you know, productive, as I say, in terms of, you know, those donations. And I do wonder, I mean, I'm what I'm interested in here because there's no question in my mind from what I've seen that chickens are a very significant part of the problem, you know,

in those rivers. But at the same time, they are only part of the problem. And there are lots of other things and you listed some of them yourself there. And so the question is whether the court is that, whether the court process is able to to deal with that differentiation perhaps in a way that legislators find more difficult, Whether the court process can look at things and say, well, we can understand this in context. You know, the chicken production is a problem, it's only part of a problem. And therefore, how are we going to deal with that in a legal

sense? Are we going to award some damages but not all damages? And I kind of, you know, I sort of thinking back to the way that, you know, the tobacco companies were arguing, you know, trying to sort of say that, well, there could be all kinds of reasons for lung disease. It, it isn't us. So it's really hard to sort of point that and find that smoking gun. Then I, I guess a final thought around that is the way that if these are jury trials, there are, I mean, when we were looking at the AFN network plus that we're talking about wanting to have more citizens assemblies. And I've, I've never been

entirely convinced by the notion of citizens assemblies. I'm yet to be convinced in in that, but essentially a jury is a small citizens assembly being presented with evidence. And I I'm just fascinated to see what the outcome of these things will be. It's not that I'm sort of interested in pushing 11 outcome or another. I'm I'm just interested to take a back seat and see where these things go. Should we move on to our last story, which is using nature to help tackle mental health issues? And I don't think we're going to

spend very long on this. It's just, you know, sort of flagging it up as an idea. Healthcare professionals are using nature to tackle a range of mental health issues in one of the most densely populated areas of the UK, thanks to a new project. This is the RSPB's Nature Prescription scheme in the West Midlands, reaching an impressive milestone this October, with 150 practitioners now trained and given enough resources to help their first 1000 patients. Speaking about nature prescriptions, RSPB President and NHS GP Doctor Amir Khan said As a GP I've seen first hand

held beneficial time spent in nature can be free. Services such as nature prescriptions empower healthcare professionals to guide patients towards meaningful connections with nature, helping to improve their well-being alongside any other required care or treatments. Whether it's a simple walk in the park or a local green space, listening to birdsong or simply watching leaves flutter in the breeze, nature has a profound impact on our mental health. Time spent outdoors stimulates serotonin, which is the brain's happy chemical, and just 10 to 15 minutes in nature a day can

lift our mood, reduce anxiety and increase feelings of calm. And what I wanted to do was to sort of connect this not only with mental health but to health more broadly. And I wondered if you had any immediate thoughts, Joe? This is one of those things that, yeah, the farmed landscape can deliver for society. I mean, we know that the huge cost of mental health or poor mental health on society, on the NHS every year. And yeah, I mean, every time I visit London, for example, I'm just struck by, and I guess I'm

not used to living in that environment necessarily. But you are just, you just feel constrained. You feel it feels great. It feels, it doesn't feel like where we should naturally be. And of course, that's the experience of the majority of people these days. You know, majority of people live in those urban environments. You know, I can absolutely get behind the concept that being out in nature is going to be positive for your mental health. And again, it's kind of going back to some of the earlier stories here, Finlay. You know, it's one of those things that is, is, is not reflected in that naughty .6% of GDP delivered by agriculture,

right? It's one of those things that we can provide society that's generally not appreciated. So, so absolutely, you know, what, what more can agriculture and, and, and, and, and landscape managers, what can we provide for society? And I think this is this is a great example of something that's probably completely underutilized at present. Indeed. And, you know, it's about making use of those free resources in the same way that regenerative farmers are trying to make use of the free energy resources that are coming from the sun or from the rain. And it's and I think, you know, part of this is about sort of making the case that nature is

important and making the case to taxpayers, to the public at large, to people who, you know, live in cities and towns and sometimes even in villages, who you know, who are distant from nature and don't understand the importance of it. And therefore trying to make the case for spending more money on that rather than, you know, directly into the NHS or to education, you know, it's difficult. And so understanding this in, in sort of circular motions, I suppose around the well-being and poor mental health are really important. And nature can help with that.

Understanding that nature friendly farming and reduced nutrient use or sort of nitrogen use, fertilizer use, that sort of thing, better fertility coming from the soil can give us better, more nutritious, healthier food. And, you know, you sort of connect these things together if you've got poor health outcomes and there's no doubt that, you know, we have some really appallingly poor physical health outcomes. You know, in this country, when you have poor health, which often has been, you know, achieved through eating the wrong kinds of food, that can

lead to low self esteem, poor well-being, poor mental health as well. So these things are circular and and, and again, making the case for nature, making the case for investment in nature benefits us in so many different ways. And this is just talking about one of those ways. And just just to, to finish this off and learn and again, to take about what we're talking about earlier, it's that always that often that missing point between it's not just calories, it's nutrition, right? It's the quality of the food re it's not just talking about, well, let's get rid of all the

cows and let's just have more carbohydrates and more calories. It's the quality of the food. It's, it's more than just the bulk of what we can sort of put on, put on, put down our throats, right? That's for me what's fundamental with this whole kind of agroecological view of the food food system, that we should be looking at it much more widely. And yeah. And what it can then deliver not only for mental well-being and physical health, but then the costs that that saves to to the economy more generally. It's this, it's this incredibly holistic view of things.

And that's what I think is incredibly exciting. But it just feels that, you know, we are always so far away from having sort of serious conversations about that outside of the kind of the niches that sort of, you know, of the agricultural sector perhaps. Yeah. And that's. Yeah. I, I, I, I welcome this as a new story and let's. Yeah, we, we again, going back to what we've been talking about earlier, we need to see more and more of these kind of reports saying the same thing so that hopefully we can just get some head of steam behind it so that we can demonstrate really what a

well managed countryside can deliver for society. Absolutely, small investments in nature can, can deliver, you know, incredible cost savings overall in terms of whether that's flooding or health aspects, making sure that we we have a healthy nation that's physically able to go out and work and to learn, you know, all of these different things. It's all connected and the cost of making sure that we, you know, we have a really abundant diverse nature really isn't that great. And we just need to get on with spending some money there. Well, look, that's it and thanks

Joe, really enjoyed having a conversation with you. And I hope that you know if you've been listening to this, that you've enjoyed listening. And if you have, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast, as Joe very kindly mentioned earlier on. And Farmgate Leaders and Martin's Farm are available if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. And if you'd like to find out how to sponsor Farmgate and to advertise on the program, then please do get in touch. Farmgate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican

AG, Rural Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Ship Agrolo and individual donors. I've been Finlay Costain, bye for now. I've been Jade Stanley, thanks for joining us.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 'Soil health is the north star of agriculture' - David R Montgomery on ReGen

    Nov 17, 202658 minAudio

    This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Place-based preparedness in practice

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Food industry insiders speak out

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Living adventurously" in the UK House of Lords

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is food sovereignty needed to face climate extremes?

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...

    Credit the people on this episode