Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Farm Gate

Farm Gate artwork

Derek vs Derek

Dec 16, 202552 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What's it like living next door to Britain's most notorious rewilder? The new movie, Derek vs Derek investigates. In this programme ffinlo Costain meets the two Dereks - rewilder, Derek Gow, and dairy farmer, Derek Banbury - alongside the film's director James Dawson. #derekvsderek

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, welcome to Farm Gate. I'm Phil Locustane, the editorof8.9.com. During the summer, I was sent a draft trailer for a new film. Now, the film was about the conflict between two farming neighbors, and I responded saying the last thing farming needed right now was yet another story about division. Then last month I was sent the whole thing and I have to say my whole attitude changed. Yes, there is conflict. It's in the title, Derek versus Derek, but the film's been made so respectfully and compassionately that the warmth of the two main characters,

rewilder Derek Gow and dairy farmer Derek Banbury, really shines through. The film made me wince and grind my teeth, but it also made me laugh out loud and feel genuine affection towards each of the protagonists. Now, in advance of the film's release, I'm pleased to say that I'm joined for this program by the 2 Derek's and by the film's director, James Dawson. Welcome all. Now, James, let's just get started and come to you first. How did you come across these two gentlemen and why did you want to make this film about them? I spent a lot of time as a young youth, actually as a teenager

working on farms and when I even in the 1970s, it was quite a long time ago, I used to go out in the fields and there was quite a lot of nature. There was insects and bird life and it was wonderful. I had a great time. And nowadays when I go out into fields, it's pretty quiet. And it got me worrying and it got me thinking. And I read an amazing book by a man called David Golson, which outlined just how serious the loss of biodiversity is across the industrialized world, not just in Britain. Because I'm a filmmaker, I thought, well, how can I make a film about this? It worries me a lot.

And I wondered, you know, what would be a way of doing that? So I started researching and I came across Derek, Derek Gal, because he's an interesting character. He's a farmer, an ex farmer, but he's not one of these rich land owners. He's a working class background from Scotland. And I thought he'd be really interesting. And he's also very passionate about what he's doing and he's attempting to or nature in his own way and to transform his farm and to breed all these nearly extinct species. So I thought there's a lot to film and it'd be really interesting to follow his

journey over a period of years to see whether or not what he was hoping to do could could actually come to fruition and how. Did you come across Derek Banbury? Because obviously I presume you got in touch with Derek Gow? Did he say, look, I've got this cussed neighbor next to me, why don't you talk to him as well? Or did it sort of come more organically? No, it came very organically because I thought, well, it would be really interesting to talk to Derek's neighbors about what he's doing. Maybe they don't like the wild boar. Maybe they're not interested in Beavers. And also Derek Bambury's family run AB and B and I went to stay there.

And as soon as I met Derek Bambury, I've spent a lot of time making films. And as soon as I met him, I knew he was a terrific, what we call a terrific film character. He was open, funny, warm, and he believed passionately in in the farming that he was doing. He was a dairy farmer. He believes in feeding the world. That's what drives him. And he just looked over the edge all the time at what the other Derrick was doing in horror. So I thought this is a different time in a film to be a different kind of film to be made. But by looking at their relationship and seeing what the tussles were about, it would

allow me to explore what I thought was the the deeper concern I have, which is about biodiversity and why and, and explain how it is also that with modern farming techniques and the use of aggregate, you know, pesticides and herbicides and fertilizer, that we've actually created a situation where there's so much nature being lost. And to see how this relationship developed over time. It's really interesting, of course, the way that you talk about that, you know, it almost could be any, any farming, any rural, in fact any community around the UK and probably around the world. You've always got these

characters. And if you can manage to find somebody, you know, who is, you know, or two people who are so honest and genuine in the way that they talk, then that's, you know, it's just gold, isn't it? And of course, Derek Banbury is sort of coming over to you. You know, that's the story of how James came across you. But what made you want to take part in the film? What was the pitch to you? Well, James was a was he stayed at our house and our cottage and he and he, he was talking about Derek Gow and, and explaining and I thought, well, I want to put across my point of view as

well as anybody else's. And he started recording me and, and it looked good and it sounded all right. And, and he offered me a little bit of cash as well, which helped. And so way, way we go. They always say if you want to change farmer behaviour, then you you make sure the financial incentives are right. That's right. Excellent. What did your wife think? Did she kind of roll her eyes and say, oh, yeah, I knew something like this was going to happen? Well, she. She deep down she likes it, she loves it really, but she thought it was all a bit of a farce to start with, but she's enjoying

it now as it as it's progressing. Now obviously you've not quite become the movie star that you will be as yet because the film has yet to be released. Have you had to sign any autographs this point? Are you just looking forward to going down the Mart? Once people are is that is the Mart gonna do a showing? Not yet. I haven't signed the autographs yet and I don't wanna be a star. I just wanna as I am. Do you think the Mart is likely to stick a show on? Cause of course, the Mart appears in the film almost as a character in its own right. The market, yeah.

The market, yeah, I've invited the the, the auctioneer and and the fieldsman, they come to the but on that day, the auctioneer is busy, but the fieldsman, I guarantee he's coming. So it'll be good to see the people there. But what would you think we might be able to have a screening at the market, Derek if? Of course, of course you will. Yeah, you could do if you if you'd like that, yes. Well, I think after the end of the market, I don't know how many farmers would stay though. That's the problem. But I think it would be great to because that's where farmers are, you know, that.

It's good. I get their response. Yeah. Stick on some bodies or some burgers and the farmers will stay. That that's, that's my experience. Now. Derek GAO The film is about two big characters. And of course, conflict is the central theme, at least to start with. Now you're known, you know pretty well throughout the country you, that you already have a character and people, people know by and large, who you are. But were you concerned at all about how you might be portrayed? Because of course, you're relinquishing that control, aren't you? To James? To somebody else? No, I wasn't talking sad. How to be portrayed.

I mean, I think as you get older in life, you get to the stage where you become much more liberated and with respect to how people view you or not. And really, it's not the stage where it can be. Take it or leave it. So no, I wasn't greatly bothered by how it was going to be portrayed. I am what I am and that's it. And what were you hoping was going to come out of the film? Why was it worth the effort that you were going to make? I don't think I had I was going to say James, I didn't, I don't think I had any hope in the beginning. And I think it's fair to say that that that's true. I hope. I mean, it's it's sounded like an interesting exercise. And of course, now having seen

the film fully cut with soundtracks, and I mean, I totally Terry would agree about this. It comes we need each other for about 20 years now and it comes across as a very, very warm. So a thing in the end. I mean, I don't feel very warm at the guard time at the moment because I've just noticed that he's cut bits from a top verge that I told him not to cut and he thinks I didn't notice. But I checked yesterday. I was out with a, a rule of measure in the grass and you can clearly see where he's gone across with his hedge flails. So at the moment I don't feel very warm towards them. But normally we, we, we have had

so, you know, fairly a lot of big downs. We would have wondered 2. But at the end of the day, it comes across as a very warm and actually, I think actually a very understanding film. And and you know, one of the things I have found very interesting is of course, that, you know, when you're talking to somebody like Derek, when you're actually filming, then I mean, you see one side of them. The other thing you don't you don't see because of course, you never would, you know, are things like him playing with his cattle and and you know, it is a very, very good farmer by any

standard. You say, you know, as you're not going to drive into that farmyard and see an abomination or something horrible happening. What you're dealing with. There are people who are very, very kind and, and one of the things that and, and who are very, you know, very influenced. We're all influenced by the, the economic and the, the social landscapes around us. But I was speaking to his son James about the impact of, of that, of the cow footage that was taken by the the person who was supplying, I think, milk

locally. What was it to Derek? Who was that guy that. It was. It was animal rights man, and he put all these cameras up in. It's a poodle who supplies milk to to dairy crests. That's a poodle. We're called now. Yeah. And you look at that and James is actually incredibly concerned because that has then impacted their price of milk. And you look at things like that, you think, but it's no reflection of the way that you would ever manage your animals. I mean that's, you know, it kind of, it really does make you think in that respect. It makes you think frankly about some of the things I've said and

some of the harder perspectives I've had because the vast majority of farmers are not cruel people. They're people who are trying very hard to make a living. And the vast majority of farmers are not people that, you know, are pretending that are of course, people who do terrible things to wildlife. And you know, and that's just shit. But you know, it does make you reflect on, on the community as a whole. I mean, the term salt of the earth really does apply to most of them. And but then you also have to look at where we are as far as natural life's concerned.

And I mean, you know, you wonder sometimes what rock bottom is going to look like. And I am quite, quite sure I was down at a site in, in Dorset yesterday where there is still life, where there are still breeding lap wings, where there are still breeding red Shank. But the landscape around here, you know, we are really starting to bump along rock bottom. I'm sure of that. And and that's the conundrum. How do you change that? It's a huge difficulty and it's a conversation that we're regularly having in this podcast. Rock bottom is where we feel at the moment. But next year, the year after, we'll be below that again. And how can we arrest that?

How can we get back up there? And of course, this conversation therefore becomes incredibly important because it's about, you know, how do we get normal mainstream farmers to value the kind of work that you're doing, Derek? And at the same time, how do we, how do we ensure that people, you know, from your side of the fence, you know, sort of the rewilding side, the natural capital side, make sure that they're paying farmers the respect that they need as well so that conversation can move forwards? And James, how did you go about managing the story and the conflict in particular, respectfully? Well, the way I would always manage these things really is

to, to listen to what I'm, I'm interested in hearing both sides of the coin because Derek Banbury's really is all about producing food and in, and, and certainly when I met him to start with, he was saying, well, it's just nature gets in the way a bit. James, you just got to get on with it. You've got a crack on and it's about making food and it's what we do. And I wanted to hear that story. You know, I told him that I said, I'm always tell people what you're doing. You know, I want to hear your side of it. It's about food production, if you're OK. And how do you feel about Derek next door? What are the problems you have with him? So I'm just trying to be straightforward about what

you're doing. As long as people under, by and large, as long as people know you're doing what you say you're doing, they they listen to you and you get along fine. And you sort of found that on both sides, it was a sort of similar approach for both because of course, of course, you know, the, the challenge is, or the enjoyment is when you're, when you're watching a film, whether you're watching something like this or, you know, a game show like traitors, you get to see what the what the other person thinks as well. And so I imagine for both of the derricks, they're getting to sort of see the other side, see, you know, behind the kitchen door when the conversation about them is taking place.

And were you kind of cognizant, sort of aware of that as you were doing it or just just got on with it, James. Well, I, for example, the Beavers, I knew once Derek Banbury had a took a close up of the Beaver activity on well, I didn't know, but I hoped that once he looked at the Beaver activity on Derek Gow's farm, he couldn't help but be impressed by the dam building engineering because they're amazing engineers. And he was. And I was really pleased because I wanted, I was hoping that he might sort of have another thought about all that, that

there would be some something he would find appealing about it and interesting or at least be engaged with it. So they had this interesting conversation and Derek felt Derek Gow fell over and he found this little frog quite by accident. It was brilliant. And then that led to another chat about, you know, what the benefit of Beavers are in terms of nature restoration. And Derek Banbury, that's one of the things that we often sort of talk about in terms of, of natural capital in nature, the way nature functions on farm that that actually nature itself is, is a remarkable engineer. If you, you know, if you farm in

a particular way, then the way that water moves across your land or is held in the land will change phenomenally. And of course, Beavers there as engineers. So did you feel that, did you sort of feel that you could, even if you didn't want them on your on your farm necessarily, could you respect what they were able to achieve as, as nature's engineers? Of course. So, you know, we haven't, we haven't seen them yet, but Derek's really encouraged. And you know, he reckoned they'll come up the valley and if they come, they come. And there's nothing I can do about it.

And we'll wait and see. And I, I'm very open about it, you know, and what they do. Nature, you can't fight nature. We are all involved in nature. Even the grass, you know, don't grow without nature and sun and rain. And we're all down down that road. Now, hedges are a big part of your story, and certainly the way that you trim your hedges is diametrically opposed to Derek GAO's wild and more regenerative approach. There's a, you know, wonderful shots sort of looking down the lane where you've got big and bushy on one side and very neat

and trim on the other. Why do you want your hedges so neatly trimmed? I think it goes back a long way. I can remember when I came home from school years ago, I came over and joined the father and he was, he had, there wasn't so much hedge trimming then and everything was long and tall trees and father was struggling because he used to do a lot of, they call it steepen. They just bend them over and cut them back and they bend them down and, and then they lay a hedge and and wait, wait for the next spring for it to grow with

so much work. And I and I thought to myself, surely I'll never let my hedges go to this, this, you know, description and, and that's why I'm a bit obsessed, I suppose. I keep them down short, low and, and, and So what they make it. They do make a good fence and that animals don't go through them but. You're not laying them, are you? You're No, you're trimming them. Trimming them, Yeah. I've never laid the edge. I've never had time. But you know you've got other things going on in in your farm now. You keep them, double all the

cows and double the stock that my father used to used to keep. And you haven't got time to lay hedges. And you never felt that, you know, there was an opportunity to be a rebellious teenager as you sort of grow up, You know, instead of going down into the town and staying up late at night, you could just kind of let your hedges grow wild. And that could be your sort of sense of rebellion against your parents. If the trouble is if you do let them go wild, you know, what do you do in the future? I don't know. You know, they get out of out of hand and, and I wouldn't want that because animals get

underneath and I I wouldn't like it. Yeah, it's interesting. I was noticing that in Wales in order to be eligible for the basic sort of farm payment, the the Sustainable Farming scheme incentives there, all farmers are now or going to be expected to not cut their hedges every year, but actually to leave them in a three-year rotation. But they'll need to do that to get the farm support. If that happened here, would that be something that you'd be comfortable with? No, no, because you let them go three years in in this in the store, the sticks get so big and

you knock on the hell out of them with these flower hedge trimmers and it would look horrible. It would look horrible. I trim mine every year and just trim them back where they should be and it makes a really good fence. One of the things there that Derek Banbury is saying, Derek Gow, is, is that, you know, if you let the hedge go, then you start to get gaps and that sort of thing at the bottom. Is that what happens with your hedges? Is it possible for the animals to get through at the bottom and how do you deal with that? It's an interesting one. So the moment I've done nothing with the bulk of the edges for the last 10 years, but before

that and I, Derek may have a better idea than I. Before that there were a couple of old guys who you used to live locally and they could lay hedges properly. So that we had a grant at one point in time which enabled us to do more fencing and, and these two old guys came in and worked their way along the edges and they did steep them properly. But I'm pretty sure they're dead now. I I So when it comes to actually all the hedges, you're right, in time what will happen with those hedges is that they'll go up, up, up and they will become

gappy in the bottom and they'll be trees with little in the way of an understory. And when they get to that stage, they go from being this a billion halfway house with lots of berries and lots of wildflowers and lots of food for a whole host of different things to being something very different. And he's right. By the time you get to that stage, you're then back to cutting them right back to base, sleeping what you can, if you can find somebody to do it and, and then you have to start again. And even though Derek is a hedge

Nazi and I'm not going to describe him in any other way, it also has to be said that if you go from Derek's farm and then go right the way up to the top of our Rd. which is AT Junction, you go along and you look at it's without a word of a lie, it's much, much worse. You've got people who are clipping them right into the old hedge banks to the point where there are no trees and shrubs. There's bracken that comes up through in the summer and there's a tiny bit of Bramble and you'll be struggling to find anything of the hedge bank at

all. But the hedges are the corridors. I mean, we've just just acquired of yesterday a small breeding group of redback shrikes, which are the bird that used to be called butcher bird. It impaled its prey, the big beetles, the dragonflies, the lizards on the thorns of all scrub. And the scrub, you know, was, was in part something we found in the hedges and that bird no longer breeds in Britain. Now. The last one died. The last pair died in Dartmoor about 3 years ago. In the 40s and 50s. They were everywhere. And the thing with the hedges that we just don't realise.

And actually James film was quite interesting because they don't show all of the footage. There's a tiny bit where they were baiting animals in the middle of the hedge. And what you find is that, you know, you view a hedge as a solid structure. A hedge is not a solid structure at all. It's something that's got, you know, the areas within it that are more open, more sunny. It's got good areas that are dry and a lot of the short. But it was, you know, obviously this little Bower where you're putting the food out for the small mammals. As soon as you put the food out for the small mammals like the wood mice and the bank voles, then of course there in the dark as a fox, that's just Krypton to watch them.

So the hedges actually, even though they've been in large part destroyed and removed and overshorn and, and, and the hedges in the landscape like ours, you kind of don't really appreciate them until you somebody sitting next year from the Netherlands in a car. And they say this is amazing because these things are the last of the corridors. The whole challenge we've got with regard to farming and how we use land is quite clearly we can't keep on going the way we're going. I mean, it's no joke that, you know, you're seeing noses, the farmer's guardian to tell you,

you've got, I don't know, whatever 30 harvests left or 10 harvests left because the soils are so degraded that you're basically trying to farm silica now. And you can't do that. And even when people take the dung out, put the dung on the the land now that's so full of ivermectins that the goodness that should be in that is, is just not translating related to the bacteria and the things that exist in the soil because it kills them. So you're in this horrible vicious cycle of degrading the land all the time to try and produce what you produce to the

point where it doesn't produce anything at all. So the hedgerows could be one of these things that are the kind of last arcs. And if we can figure out how we expand through landscape recovery or whatever other funding system there is. These things back to allow them more space at either side, then perhaps we could start to look at a situation where wildlife recovers. But it's it's challenging. Now it's interesting 'cause certainly around Dorset, where I live, there's an awful lot of hedge laying that's taken place this last year. And I think a lot of it's been funded through the farming and

protected landscape scheme, but I think there are other schemes as well. And I'm, I'm just sort of going back Derek Banbury to you and, and, and your hedge. You know, I'm sort of looking at you and you know, you, you're nicely trimmed haircut, you're clean shaven. You look at Derek, you know, and he's, he's got a great big bushy beard. You know, Derek's hedge you would expect to be big and bushy. And it seems like yours are sort of an extension of your own personality. And how do you want to be seen by your community? How? How do you think other people in your community see you? I always get told you look at your hedges and you, you can sell how good a farm you are as a farmer down the road.

And he always trims his hedges every year and he haven't, he haven't done one this year. And we drive past her very often and say, oh, he haven't trimmed his hedges yet. He must be, you know. He You must be a bad farmer, you know? So is that it, that there's, there's a degree to which you want to be seen as being a good farmer And, and, and almost, you know, it's like sticking the right tie on when you're going to work or something in the city that it's, it's your expression. It's the thing that people see as they're driving past your farm is your hedge. And it's that's important. It is important, yes to me and I

like to see it as well. I wouldn't like to see my hedges overgrown and and untrimmed. And I was speaking to my local machinery ban the other day and they've sold more hedge trimmers this year. I can't believe it. They've sold more hedge trimmers this year, and they've ever sold in their. Life and they're all being used on your farm. I only got 1 so yeah, somebody must be trimming hedges. Interesting. Now, Derek, Derek GAO, you're working to rebuild the relationship between your land because you took it over from another farmer and you you felt that it had been damaged and

sort of, you know, worked within an inch of its life, I think. And and so rebuilding that relationship between land and nature. Think of yourself as a farmer or as a rewilder. I didn't feel there had been damage beyond life. It had been. I mean, when I started 20 years ago, I remember seeing one hen Harrier, you know, two years, one curly per year, one year, two wind rolls. But I started here. I mean, Derek might remember them. You used to go past Stocky and there were flocks of thousands of golden plover, and then there were flocks of hundreds of

golden plover, and then there were 15 golden plover. And the last time I saw one, which was two or three years ago, there was 1. And I don't ever expect to see them again. So. And again, if you look at, you know, Derek's got an interesting series of photographs when you go into his entrance, lobbying up to his main sitting room, you know, which shows you what the farm was like when his dad had it. There's there's the wet meadows, there's the ponds, there's the fallen down barns, there's the orchard, These, there's all these things that gave all manner of other things the, the

ability to to live. Do I consider myself to be, you know, actually I, I liked farming and I farmed for way too long and I lost too much money. And you know, Derek says in the film that I was a very good farmer And you know, he's right because at the end of the day, I like breeding animals, but I was shit at selling them. So to be quite frank, it doesn't make for a good farming combination. You know, if you see all your money's going out to buy nice cement towel bulls that then get TB and, and, and whatever, you know, it just, it just, and, and in the end, I didn't get fed up

with that as much as, you know, really the thing that always got me. And I mean, James has included a lovely little bit of footage in the film about, you know, there's all bits of footage of the curlews and the wet meadows. And I never, ever forgot. I mean, one of my friends told me when I mentioned to him there was, there were curlews here. He, he was Kevin Cox's was the president at the time of the RSPB. That, that was the last of the old column birds that I mean, because these things will live for 35 years and just think about it, there's 35 years, your

habitat's probably destroyed by the time you're two or three. And for the remainder of your long, long life, you come back to find your fields drained, silage, no mates left, no feeding opportunities. In the end, you spend most of your time around the coast because it's the only place where you can feed. But every so often in this spring, for a time, you decide you're going to come back and land to the place where where you are hash. Think about it. Just think about it. You know, it's a long OK. Do these birds lament?

OK. The more we realize, the more we begin to understand animals because the more you have to do with nature and ecology, the more in my long life you begin to realize that actually we understand very little. But what we do understand is that these things have cultures. This is their home. I mean, there's a the BBC did a wee article on a pair of oyster catchers on the wash that we're 40 years old this spring. And for for 40 years these two birds have nested and one spit of gravel in the wash. And every year these old birds come together to nest again

'cause it's their home. Now you think of the scale of landscape and agricultural change over the course of the last 40 years. You think of the level of destruction, how many things have got a home left. And when you start to think that way, you then get to a point where you think, well, I could just do what I'm doing for for the rest of my life. I'm not bothered about it. I mean, I quite enjoy bits of it. Or you could do something that actually is fundamentally a lot harder and say, you know, actually, no, no, this time round we try to make a difference and, and making it

easy. I mean, it's like the footage of the wild boar and me planting pendulous great Tussex edge. I plant it, it digs up plant never comes. We've learned a lot about Tussex edge and one of the things that's a very important plant, but it has to have virtually no grazing. What's whatsoever? None at all. As soon as you graze that plant, that's the end of it. And you look at that thing, well, that didn't work, did it? But then this summer, you know, we had about a week when when we literally had tornadoes or swallows, No Swifts, House Martens and and bizarrely, sand

Martens, which don't breed here. So there's somewhere on the river around us and they're working their way from one end of our farm to the other end of the farm. Literally just Swiss of swishing these upcoming end insects, you know, just just just just stuffing themselves before they go to Africa. And that frankly shows you quite palpably that what we're doing here is making a difference. Because if you go, and this has not been being rude to Derek, but you go to Derek's land, you go to the land down the road, but there are no insects and there are none of these birds.

And actually yesterday Derek was out. And sometimes you think it's all just self defeating. You're never going to make a change. But I was over in Dorset, went to a really good bird reserve on the outskirts of Poole Harbour. And would you believe they're telling me there are, they have no breeding Linux. They have no yellow hammers at all now. They have no breeding skylarks. And you look at that and say, well, you know, actually we have got skylarks. There are skylarks that are returned here and they are breeding. And every year there's another pair of thumb. There are still yellow hammers, not many. And I'm not sure what we can do

about those. But the 2 little flocks of finches that really have words are the gold finches, which are here in hundreds and hundreds now. And the Linux, there are many Linux here now. So what you do in life matter, and if you make a conscious decision to do something like this and you just keep at it because it's a lifetime and well beyond any lifetime of mine commitment, then it doesn't have to end in in a way that is truly Armageddic. I'm interested in that sort of Paul Harbour story because of course. Yeah, I, I know the reserving question and it's interesting.

And of course it shows the importance of having connected landscapes because of course you can have a reservoir where that landscape is managed for, for wildlife. But at the same time, if you don't have places for birds, particularly migratory birds to, to stop off on route for those those wildlife corridors that you were talking about, that interconnectivity that should exist in the countryside for nature, then then of course those reservoirs themselves will be depleted as well. You've talked very nicely there, Derek, about about different kind of bird species.

But one of the things you're best known for is your Beavers. And I just wonder if you could tell us, you know, briefly why Beavers are so important to you. Because you can't save nature unless you have the Beavers here to to help you. I mean, next to us elephants, the Beavers, Beaver as a species is the third most impactful creature on the planet. So you were saying about, you know, Derek, having a look at their engineering abilities long before, you know, we as a species who could, you know, who live the lives we live or, or in

the in the time we live with language, the infrastructure we have roads, cars and everything else. You know, we know that prehistoric people were sitting looking at these animals in the wetlands beneath them. I mean, if you want to actually elucidate into words, because we have no words from from from the Neolithic people, then then the First Nations, you know, like the Black Feet tribe in North America will tell you these are the little people. They are the earth's kidneys. And round the Earth's kidneys all other life revolves. And so when the worst of the

trapping times came and we're out there to open, you know, North America and Canada and and benefit great love. You know, that's what made in large part our mercantile empire. You know, they strip the landscape of the trees, the the fish, the the and the Beavers, the farce. Then then it's these things that basically, you know, they they this this one tribe said, well, I'll tell you war. You're not killing them here. These animals are too important to us. You kill them, we'll kill you. And then you have another Indian

war over far in a different way. So they are, they're just, they're just critical. They're critical for big mammals. They're critical for water regulation. It never ceases to amaze me every time that you look at another massive flood incident as we had in Wales a week and a half ago, you look at, you think, well, what's that down to? It's down to the fact that you've drained the wetlands. They've all gone. There are no natural sponges. You've, you've made the streams, the ditches, everything else is a straight line. You know, the hills are completely denuded of trees. So at the end of it all, and

they're hard compacted by the, by the hooves of the, the millions of sheep that live there. So when the rain comes, and of course it's coming, the climate's changing, it's getting warmer, These exceptional rainfall events are going to become much more common. Everything comes down, then it hits the structure and then you look at the cost of rebuilding that infrastructure and it would cost you infinitely less to turn around and say, right, that's it, reforest the uplands. Because in the end there will be different jobs, there be different ways of making an

income, but the cost to infrastructure and the misery that's caused to, you know, huge numbers of people infinitely outweighs any food argument that is for keeping sheep up there. We don't eat them, we don't use them. We need to. So much of what needs to be done is about how do we re engineer the landscape? How do we change the shape of the countryside? Because everything we see, the hedge, Everything Everywhere has been, is something that's been made by us to make it good for

nature and for farming and for recreation and the many other myriad uses of the landscape. We need to choose the sheep of it. Derek Banbury, I I want to come back to you because of course, you know, we've heard lots from Derek GAO there about, you know, the work that he's doing and the way that he sees the world. And, and what's nice in the film is that it's it's very balanced. You get a lot of of what you think of Derek's farm as well. In the same way, you know, Derek, there it is perhaps being slightly rude about, about, you know, the lack of nature on your farm. How do you feel as a neighbor of Derek's, you know about what

Derek is doing there, about what you you see, you know, is the the landscape that that derricks managing? Well, I, I do like some of the aspects of what Derek is doing, but as long as he does it on his farm, we're not mine. I don't mind. I'm here to farm and produce milk and beef and just to serve, to serve it to the world and or to this country in a way, if so long as they want it, because directly when all the supermarkets the shelves get, get empty, then they'll want us in that time.

It's approaching very fast. Interesting that that phrase that you use that it's, it's my job to feed the world. And you know, I've heard that from farmers over the course of the last few decades at various different times. Do you really think that? Do you think it's your job to feed the world or or is it more that it's it's your job just to make sure that your community can eat? Yeah, that community as well. But you know, food is getting short and and there's people starving over the world, over the in the world. And there shouldn't be, shouldn't be these days, you know, because we can produce

food as as as cheaply as anybody in the house in the world. One of the things that's interesting in the film is the way in which, you know, it's not just yourself, but it's other farms around, you know, Derek's land, Derek Gow's land, of course, that are impacted by some of the things that happen. So the idea of, you know, a boar escaping and getting onto their their fields or the Beaver sort of coming up. Do you do you feel that the way that you you sort of think about Derek and what he's doing? Is that a feeling that's generally shared by other farmers around and about?

Or do different people have different attitudes, different views? Of I'm sure it is other people feel more more than I do I expect. But we did have an episode food to go or a bit more. I've had some wild boars come over on door land because you can't stop them. They just get their head under the wire and they've gone. And we've seen some digging in the fields and we didn't know what it was. And then I rung Derek and said, you know, have you lost any wild boar? And he said yes. And it was wild boar. And we just, we just disposed of

them, which Derek told us to do. And well, there's only two of them, so it wasn't too bad. Yeah, and you made sausages, I think. Yeah, we did. They didn't make very good sausages. We never did have a joint like beef. It was nice, but the sausages weren't very good. They was, really. But but if something happens, if there is an accidental release, you know, in that way or, or the the wild animals come across to other people's land, then it sounds, sounds like Derek's pretty reasonable about that and, and we'll sort of find a solution fairly quickly.

Yes, he is, You know, yeah, he's pretty good like that. You only gotta talk to him, which is is natural. And he said he tells you what to do and. Derek, your reputation, I have to say, you know, amongst even amongst some in the rewilding community or the the the regen farming community, is that you can be a bit antagonistic and and frankly, you haven't really come across that way, I don't think on the podcast at the moment. But there are sort of bits in the film where you you do just kind of say, well, stuff them If they don't like it, they don't like it. How do you sort of feel about that? Do you do you recognize that

sometimes you can be a bit antagonistic and maybe you could win more friends by being a bit gentler? 60 years old, if I wanted to win popularity contests, I would have started down that road many years ago. I'm not interested. I don't really have a view. There are a few people in life who matter to me. That's actually a fairly short queue. So when it comes to it, I find nature conservation a very, it's a very, very young way of viewing land juice. It's barely a century old before you look at the idea you're

going to maintain a landscape for its intrinsic value or its beauty or for the OR you're going to maintain creatures because of their the the fact that you know, we are, if we consider ourselves to be guardians of the landscape. There are two definitions of the word guardian. One is somebody who takes something and trust and cares deeply for it and looks to its interest before they look to their own for for the centuries and the generations to come. And the other is somebody who stands in a watchtower with a machine gun and kills everything that runs towards the wire.

Which definition would you like? And when it comes to it, you know, I for the the the last of the time I have on this earth, I am working for these creatures. That's it. Not here to make people happy, not here to pander to PhDs. I'm not here to to listen to another tedious series of presentations and a tedious meeting about how sometime we'll get around to doing something. We're doing it now immediately with urgency because it needs to be done urgently.

So that's kind of where they come from. And if you like that, find good and well. And if you don't, you don't. And that's. It since that you mentioned the PhDs and so on there and of course you have lots of people coming down to your farm and and I was struck, you know, watching the film about the way in which you seem to have passed quite a lot of business across to to the Banbury's and and Derek. It seems like there are some benefits to having Derek Gow living next door to you because you're certainly getting, you know, lots of people to stay in your farm cottages. Oh yes, yes, it's adds to the

the coppers in my wife's pocket actually. Yeah, and she managed just that side of the business, I think. And, and certainly she seems pretty pleased. And actually she comes across, you know, there's, there are loads of cutaway shots, you know, just sort of seeing her in the background when you're, you're talking about Derek or, or sounding off on something or, or, you know, when Derek GAO's doing a similar thing and she's there in the background just giving a wry smile. She comes across quite a hero in the film. I thought she she loves Derek. Excellent, Derek. Derek's wife Linda is a hero.

You have no idea how much of A hero that woman is. Like before Derek's daughters kind of grew up and got to the stage where they could look after him and his brother Raymond. And James is actually James is much, much better looking after himself than Derek or Raymond. But there used to be a time when Linda would have a very odd time away and she'd put the food and she'd put all the dinners in the microwave. And then they didn't know how to use the microwave. So they'd go down to nip down at Tesco, get a trolley, fill it full of beers and cakes and then

that's what they're going to be feeding on for as long as long as it took for Linda to get back home. And so Linda, Linda is one of these amazing people who's incredibly adaptable, who's developed the holiday cottage business. And he's, it's just, you know, she's like this huge mother hand that kind of like just takes care of everybody. And, and the people that come absolutely love it. You know, so it's, it's a huge business asset for us. And you know, and you know, we're just looking at landscape recovery. I mean, we'd like to do more because at the end of the day,

the more people we have coming here to be taught, the more bursaries, the more, the more we can basically use this land in a different way to make money. Then the more we can reinvest, the more people we can employ. This is, you know, I think one of the things that came through very clearly from the farm is that when you look at Derek's business, it's hard work. When you look at this, it's hard work. It's not as physically hard as it used to be, but but mentally, you really absolutely have to be on your toes because you can't afford to, to pass opportunities by, you can't afford to miss the

tenders for jobs. You know, you have to be, to run this. It costs 80 grand a month to to run this. And it's no light undertaking and it's not easy thing to do. So changing landscapes, changing the prospects for nature. In the end, this should be a government responsibility. But we all know that, you know, the government now, despite the massive commitments they made to spending, however, you know, to following the budgets that used to be there before the EU, to paying, you know, we left the EU to paying for a whole range of different services to make, you

know, landscapes that are good for holding water, good for capturing carbon and good for ecology need. This was all supposed to happen. There's no clarity with regard to any of this. Yeah, so when it comes to Derek and his, his nature focus areas and and turning around saying, well, we can move the boundaries back, who the Hell's gonna pay for that? Now, James, just sort of coming back to you for a bit, in the time that we have left together over the course of the film, despite the conflict that there's there, you know, and there is, you know, a good amount of conflict. It's and it's and it's entertaining conflict. I have to say as well.

There is a coming together of sorts towards the end of the film. Were you always expecting that that was gonna happen? No, not at all. I don't. I wanted to try and get both sides of the head, so to speak, to engage with each other and think about the issue from each other's point of view. But one day, Derek in the maze field and I was filming with him. He was, we were admiring his maze crop and he was most impressed with it. But the truth is, you know, there weren't a lot of insects and there, you know, there were hardly any butterflies. And he did turn around. He's an honest man. He said, you know, there aren't really insects, are there?

You get a lot of insects on Derek Gow's land. And I thought, OK, that's an opportunity to. So I said, why don't we go look at Derek Gauss landing if you you know, I think he does. And it'd be interesting to see what you make of it. So there's a scene in the film where he does go and have a look and then the two men stand and look at the field. And I find it very moving because Derek Banbury sort of it felt like there was, I could see the, you know, the the the wires moving in his brain or whatever, the gears turning and thinking. Well, it because it was a very, very different. It was full of nature.

It was full of insects of all variety. And we went back the day after to film all of them very carefully because I thought, we've got to capture what he's witnessed. And there's a huge variety of insects. And to his credit, Derek responded to that. And, you know, I won't tell you exactly how he did, but there was a, there's a certain shift which I was really interested in. And, you know, I think Derek sort of maybe softened his view about his neighbor. Yeah. And maybe softened his view about the benefits of the project, even though he thought it was a mess. It's a good story. It's an entertaining story.

What impact do you think that it will have or do you hope that it's going to have? We really are keen to try and use the film as a sort of catalyst. I know these debates are already happening in the farmer community, but what I like about the film and what I like about these two men's relationship is that you don't have to have finger pointing and vicious arguments about these issues. You can find a way of talking to each other. We need food, we need nature. There must be a way in which in our country where we can have these two together. So we, we've started a crowdfunding campaign where

we're looking to try and raise funds to take the film into the agricultural community around Britain, into agricultural colleges, to agricultural shows, to village halls. We will want to do screenings where we, we can get the film out and have these have discussions, have panel discussions with people so that these issues can be raised. And I'm hoping the two Derek's will help help us with that. But we're looking for people to help us in the crowdfunding campaign to, and to give some money to help us do that. So there's a, there's a website, you know, the crowdfunding website where you can find Derek versus Derek, which is our name

of our film and people can give money there so we can start this campaign and. When we talk about the impact, really the, the question I was asking was whether there are particular things that you wanted people coming away to sort of thinking. And I, and I think I'm taking from your answer that what you're wanting rather than people going away thinking this is the right thing to do, this is the wrong thing to do is to go away and, and think that actually they've seen both sides of the story. Now let's have a conversation about it, that it's a way of enabling communities, you know, farmers at all different stages

and perhaps environmentalists who have a range of different attitudes towards farming to be able to. Have that conversation together. Yes. Yeah, I think so. But for me, the starting point is if once you recognize that there is a really, really deep problem about biodiversity loss, and once you grasp that, then how do you then the question is how you solve it. And there might be, I haven't got the answer to that, but is it's got to be solved. You know, it really does. It's not, it's not funny and it's not, it's very serious. And so that needs, that needs proper conversation amongst everyone who's involved in farming and and nature

conservation. Now, as you said, you know, your impact campaign, you're hoping that the the film in the same way that 6 inches of soil, you know, shown in so many communities around Britain, that this will be similarly embraced by lots of community groups, different farming groups, different environmental groups around the country. And one of the things that you're hoping is that, you know, you've got Derek versus Derek in the film's name. We've got the the 2 Derek's here. You're hoping that you can find other pairs of farmers or, or people who were, you know, working or using the land in one

way or another. So a sort of Peter versus Peter in Peterborough and a Jane versus Jane in Liverpool or, or, you know, something like that to help bring those challenges to life for their local communities. How are you gonna find these local couples? Are you hoping that they're just gonna spring up and come to you? We'll research, we'll research. We're good at researching. I'll find them and it's but it's a, it's a lovely and interesting way of engaging people in that discussion. Yeah. And you, you mentioned that there is a website and a crowdfunder and the website is Derek versus derek.com. So that's Derek VS derek.com,

isn't it? And how do people find you on Crowdfunder? Well, they go to the Crowdfunder website and then they look for Derek versus Derek on there. And that's what that's how they can find us. Now, Derek Banbury, when you got to see the film, what did you think of it? Were there things that surprised you in the way that you came across as a personality? Yeah, I was shocked. I was shocked immensely. And what shocked you? Well, how good it was. And then and because we've had all this filming and you don't realise it's, it's the filming's going on, you don't realise what's, oh, it's gonna feature in a film.

And I was shocked and it was really good. And I think everybody will enjoy it. I hope they will anyway. And, and As for me, yeah, I I've enjoyed it. What was it like for you? Was it essentially like having a kind of a family on the wall documentary team? Were you just being followed around, you know, with, with cameras sort of getting in the way of your everyday business? And how long did it take? Wow, it took a long time. It took a couple of years, I suppose. We've been filming and it isn't and all they've filmed it and all in the film, but they've they've cut cut some out and it's been really good.

I've enjoyed it because you know you're in your own environment and, and you're proud of what you've accomplished in your life and just see all the drone footage of your farm and it makes you feel good. Did you feel that you sort of your relationship with the camera and with James and the team changed over the course of time? I, I, I would imagine, you know, it's sort of, I imagine this, if somebody was following me around that I'd be really self-conscious for the first, you know, probably the first month or two. But did you find afterwards that, you know, after a while you just kind of got so used to

it that it was, it was just like, you know, having having an account following you around? It was, it was, it was, you know, I'm quite natural in a way. I don't, I don't show off at all much and I found it easy really in me own way. And, and it's obviously people around you, your friends and neighbors are gonna see the film. People at the market are gonna see the film. What? What is? What do you want? What do you think they're gonna think of their particular moments that you're sort of worried about or that you're really looking forward to them seeing? Well, when we got this release we got a a venue.

I don't know if James had told you, we got a venue at a local hall on December the 6th at 7:15. We've invited lots of people there and I think I'll be doing the most all looking out. Excellent, excellent. But then they're at the end with a pen. So you can sign the autographs, you can sign people's T-shirts as they leave. Brilliant. It's been, it's been really interesting having a chat to you, Derek, Derek Banbury because obviously I've sort of seen you in the film and really good to talk to you now. And just finally sort of coming back to you, Derek GAO, just to sort of lead us out. What do you think of the most

important messages from the film from your perspective? I think the film actually unconsciously, it's not entirely because of the way it's been cut. Of course you want to cut this to create disagreement to begin with and then again coming together. But I think the film actually comes across as a very warm and a very human thing. And I think if there is a message from it, there is, I mean, it's reflective understanding, but then has still means that there are going to be the, you know, you'd are you looking at something that's

so philosophically different, an approach from both angles that there can't be a meeting? I don't think you are. I mean, for reasonable people, there can reasonably be, you know, an understanding of the issues and a a reasonable coming together, but it is difficult. I mean, if you're, you know, it's kind of alluded to is that, you know, when is, I mean, correct me if I'm wrong, Derry, but you know, his dad was alive. I remember you saying that you, Raymond and your sister had a great childhood. You'd something like, I don't know, 8 or 10 cows, few sheep, few pigs.

That's what farming was. And now it's this nail biting exercise and terminal tension whereby, you know, these massive overdrafts here and hawk to the bank. Everything is just, you know, it's just it's it's not this quiet straw Turing rural way of life anymore. It's very far from it. And and you scope to to then take your own land and say, I'll tell you what, we'll just set these bits aside for. You know, I remember you talked

about the car losing your granddad taking you down to see them when you were a weak kid and, and you obviously remember that very fondly. And how, how on earth do you create a basis for saying, well, I'll tell you what, those wet meadows at the bottom, let's go smash the drains. I know you wouldn't want to, but even if you could, I mean, the, the, the financial basis for doing it is it's just, it's just not there. So until we as a wider society look at things like this and really begun begin to understand how jolly important it is and what the restrictions are on

people like Derek, then how are we ever going to move forward with this? This, You know, we can reintroduce a variety of different creatures, but if there's nowhere for them to feed and nowhere for them to nest, then then we really, truly have with a whole host of different species that were once common and abundant, we thought nothing of. We've come to the end of the line in less than a lifetime. It's a frightening place we brought ourselves to. Well, look, that's been really fascinating. But that is we have time for we've gone a bit overtime. Again, I keep doing this.

I need to need to constrain myself. I'd like to thank my guests, James Dawson, Derek Banbury and Derek Gao. Derek versus Derek will be released nationwide in 2026. And if you'd like to find out more about the Impact Campaign, then please do visit derekversusderek.com. That's Derek VS derek.com or search for Derek versus Derek on Crowdfunder. You can also follow the film and the Impact campaign on socials. So that's Derek versus Derek, Derek VS Derek on Instagram, on Facebook, and then on X, it's different. It's Derek V Derek doc. So that's on X.

Or if you're old fashioned, on Twitter, if you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast and Farmgate leaders, Martin's Farm and Wheat from the Chaff are all available on the Farmgate channel if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. Farmgate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is supported by First Milk, Pelican AG, Rural Solutions, the Nature Friendly Farming Network, Friars Moore Livestock Health, Agrolo and individual donors. I've been Finlay Costaine, bye

for now.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 'Soil health is the north star of agriculture' - David R Montgomery on ReGen

    Nov 17, 202658 minAudio

    This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Place-based preparedness in practice

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Food industry insiders speak out

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Living adventurously" in the UK House of Lords

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is food sovereignty needed to face climate extremes?

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...

    Credit the people on this episode