This is a new series on the Farm Gate podcast channel that we’re calling Nature Friendly Farm Gate. In this series, FFINLO COSTAIN will be joined by MARTIN LINES (Chief Executive of the Nature Friendly Farm Network). The pair will reflect on food and farming policy landscape in each of the four UK nations, and we'll find out about the ups and downs of Martin's farm business in Cambridgeshire. This time, ffinlo and Martin discuss the impact of English farm policy, the need for a strong (but not too strong) Secretary of State at Defra - and we hear about the harrowing possible future for Martin's farm. * To watch this podcast instead, search for 'Farm Gate podcast' on YouTube. * Farm Gate is Britain's top-ranked regenerative agriculture podcast - globally ranked 2nd for food security; 3rd for regen. * Farm Gate is part of 8point9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican Ag, Rural Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Agrolo and individual donors.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello and welcome to a new series on the Farm Gate podcast channel that we're calling Nature Friendly Farm Gate. I'm Phil Locustein, the editorof8.9.com. And I'm Martin Lyons, the chief exec for the Nature Friendly Farming Network. And in this series, Martin and I are going to try and reflect on the food and farming policy landscape in each of the four UK nations. And we're also going to take advantage of Martin being here to find out a bit more about how and where he farms and the ups and indeed downs of trying to make a nature friendly living from the land in the midst of ongoing Financial Policy and
geopolitical instability. And we're going to try and do all this through a reasonably positive lens. And Martin, perhaps that kind of brings me to a question. So let me start by asking you this. While the NFU could rightly be criticized for its cut half full approach to government and communications, often defending the status quo and reacting against policies that it doesn't like, the nature friendly farming Network often takes, it's a very different perspective and you're often quoted giving the government credit for what they're trying to achieve. So I guess the question is, do you think the NFA could be criticised for sometimes being a
bit too soft on the government? I think some people could feel like they could criticise us, but I try and work with governments across, you know, across the country, across the nations in finding solutions to problems and actually moving our industry into a better future of better profitability, but also delivering in better environmental outcomes, climate solutions and the multifunctionality of our businesses and farming to do that. And that does mean sometimes actually having to praise the government for doing things when they haven't done everything we've asked, but they've at least moved in the direction.
And if we can continue to complain at them and moan at them, why would they want to engage with us? And we've found that opportunity of having better engagement by trying to have a better constructive relationship. Do you? See, when you're in a room and you're, you're there perhaps around a table with representatives from the NFU and yourselves and other NGOs, do you kind of see a, A roll of the eyes from the government? You know, either in reality or you sort of sense that roll of the eyes when they hear from the NFU criticizing them? And do they have a different approach to you?
How does it feel when you're in the room? I, I think government are, are well, you know, engaged with various different organisations. Yes, we come from different arts and perspectives. I'm trying to help work with farmers to go move things forward. Other organizations are trying to say actually it's a bit difficult. We've got to stay where we are. You know, it's not our fault. I recognise many, some problems are farming's fault, but it's not the farmer, it's the system. And yes, I think it's, it has given us increased opportunity to have deep good engagement and talk through policies and
decisions. And that doesn't mean we get everything we want to ask and we want, but at least we have good relationships and we're finding an increase in the opportunities to be in the rooms and at very high levels for helping to sort of shape things that hopefully leads to better outcomes for farmers. It's interesting, isn't it? I mean, this is 20 years ago, this anecdote, but I'm remembering being at a conference and there was a panel, I was in the audience with a guy called Michael Jacobs, who was a government adviser, did a lot of sort of advocacy work with government for government at international
level on the climate crisis at the time. And Andy Atkins, who was the, the then CEO of, of Friends of the Earth. And I can remember Andy, you know, sort of being in his sort of normal approach of sort of criticising what the government was doing and Michael Jacobs just sort of making the point that do you know what, there was so much that the government of the day had been doing that they felt that they've been doing that was positive. And all he heard from the NGOs was just take, take, take. It was just you haven't done this, you haven't done that, you
haven't done the other. When actually he just he just kind of wanted the NGOs just to occasionally say thank you. It's like recognition that they had done something that was positive, albeit it wasn't enough and they needed to do more, but at least start from that position of saying good, well done. You've done this in the same way that if you're talking to a child, if you, if you just berate that child or, or berate a dog every time it does something wrong, you've got to give that sort of positive recognition as well. Yeah, very much. And I see so many organisations and campaigns where they're
complaining to the government that you've got to fix this. You, the government wants to know the solutions come with problems, but with a solution, because government people, it's not up to them to find all the solutions. It's us to help them as well to come with some positivity, come with some, some gratitude where things have moved. Or at least you've had the opportunity to discuss something and, and understand why it can't move because some things it's not in their power to move at that time. But at least you've been able to have that conversation and then offer farmers, you know, so they can see farmers who are living the solutions they're thinking about creating a policy for.
And, you know, if you do it this way, look what can happen. And we've found that it's given us really good opportunity interactions, not just with the Westminster government, but with many of the devolved governments as well, and some international work we're starting to do. I wonder if it's sort of partly a reaction to the type of government that we have and the way the Parliament works where you, you know, you're at 2 swords lengths, aren't you across, across the aisle away from each other and and often it's just a kind of roaring and berating of the other, which lacks any sort of nuance, certainly in England. But then when you go up to, you
know, some of the devolved assemblies go up to the Scottish Parliament, it is more collegiate. There is a bit more working together, albeit that there, you know, there's clearly debates and argy bargy. But it strikes me that a more adult sort of way of approaching these things, a more grown up way of approaching these things, is to recognise that there is nuance, that government has challenges and constraints that it's working within in the same way that farming does. Yeah, and then politics is about debate and almost civil arguments. If you're the opposition, you can criticise everything the current government does, and if you're in the government you're
trying to defend it. That's kind of how politics works in the news and media and social media. But actually constructive engagement, that's where things get done and it's about that engagement with all parties across all places. So how do we hold a government to account with opposition parties and organisations, but also work with government to try and get those better outcomes? Yeah, absolutely. And you know, we'll perhaps come back to that a little bit later in this conversation. But you know, we've we've launched straight in and and I just want to explain to people what we're doing. As I said, this is a new monthly podcast.
We've got six months of dates sort of they're stuck in the diary now in in good red pen and the two of us are going to have those conversations across that period. And so I guess the first question really is around, you know, why we're doing this. So obviously we have wheat from the chaff already that I, I, I run with Joe Stanley where we sort of chew through some of the, the news items of the time. And we, we have a guest on often we're trying to sort of get to the nitty gritty of these different news items that we're talking through. And I guess Joe is coming from
a, a slightly more skeptical approach sometimes of the way the government operates, trying to hold them to account in that way that you've just talked about. What we're trying to do slightly different isn't it, is to try and find that positive emphasis. And I just wonder if you could talk us through, you know, why you thought the podcast was necessary and the sort of issues that you might hope that we cover. I, I think it's that kind of finding solution, that positivity, some of the stuff governments do is really difficult. Farming can be really challenging, but we've got to look for solutions. We've got to move forward in those challenges. And I think the, the opportunity
of this podcast is to what's different things are happening in different devolved governments. What's the best that may be happening in Wales and we might be able to bring across and offer to other other farmers and other policy makers and have that bit of joined up work that goes across the nations because we're one Big Island with many different governments in and actually nature, water, climate, farm produce, farm production knows no boundaries in many times, but we're farming together trying to get the best outcomes. Absolutely. And, and you know, as I said, we're going to talk about the,
the four UK nations and look at those policies in some detail as you just mentioned there. And of course, your own expertise, your own advocacy work is largely focused in England, isn't it much as you sort of have a helicopter view, I suppose of, of all the devolved nations work as well. But we're going to be bringing on representatives from NFFN Scotland and Wales and Northern Ireland, aren't we? So that we we get a bit more of the nitty gritty on those policies and we're able to pull out the best and indeed, you know, some of the challenges as we go ahead. Yeah, that's right. And I farming in England.
So my business, this is built around England policy and, and that, but I in my role, I, I'm supporting and developing the, the organization that works across the nations with steering groups in England, Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland. So I'm trying to have a, a grasp across, across the whole business. And As for farmers to also help shape and steer all of that work. So for my role is to have knowledge of everything, but not always in depth. And that's the benefit of bringing people in that are are focused in the different nations
that can come in and and give the real nitty gritty detail or the real sort of voice from from Scotland or Wales into this podcast. Fantastic. Now I think we should give people a bit of a sense of who you are because I imagine that people you know will know of you. They'll have seen you quoted in various different places, maybe seen you on panels. But let's try and get a sense of you as a farmer and you know some of the challenges that you face in your business, some of the things that you that you you really wish you'd never tried, some of the things that have gone well for you over the course of the last year. And let's just start by by
talking about where you are. You said you're in Cambridgeshire. You're not quite in the fence, are you? No, I, we're, we're on the hill in Cambridgeshire, almost on heavy clay soil and we look down across the fence and out the other side. It's the chalks of Cambridge City and South Cambridge on there. So we're, you know, pretty much in the centre, very good connections with infrastructure and roads. That is also becoming challenging because of the growth that's coming creeping around us. We're basically round an outable system, but we're bringing, we used to be very mixed. We're bringing us trying to bring livestock back in and
trying to get that balance of environmental improvements, production improvements, soil health. And my own journey was I did a bit of we did some stewardship and then we started to value the habitat that was in that stewardship. Pollinator or the predatory insects. And then we started focusing on soil health because I recognised our soils as depleting. That's whole, they're standing in water more often, they're becoming harder. And actually it was our cultivation systems, our then farming systems that were actually adding cost to my business by destroying our
soils. So we've gone on our own journey over a number of, you know, over 20 odd years now. And what I've found is that it does improve our business. It, it doesn't make us, you know, massively more profitable than anyone else, but it de risks us sometimes. And I'll face the same challenges of we we wanted to get into the latest schemes, but because of RPA delays in managing their paperwork, we missed out in the same as again with the capital grants. So I'm facing the same challenges as many farmers. I'm not gifted by having early
access to information and getting a, a preferential treatment. And we're trying to run our business as as profitable as we can, but focusing on environmental improvements in soil health, more diverse cropping. And we've gone like many sort of down at regenerative rejuvenating route. We go a drill with a crimp roller because if you look on social media, especially in other countries, a crimp rollers. The thing for the future is we don't use glyphosate. It doesn't work as well as you think in Cambridgeshire. It works on some crops, but not
everything. So we have been learning for the last several years as much as we can and share with neighbors, but also recognising we were moving away from an area based payment that gave us guaranteed payments for more action payments, you know, public money for public goods, which makes our business more difficult because that guaranteed payment isn't coming. So I needed to learn early and now I want to share some of the learnings with others. And that's the beauty of the network of working with a range of farmers sharing information. Fantastic. I'm going to go into some of the detail on that in just a moment,
but I'm just sort of trying to locate you still within the UK. I think you're about sort of 10 miles east of St. Neots, Is that about right? Yeah, that'd be about right, yeah. And I remember because I used to live probably about 20 miles north of you in a place called Chatteris in the fence. So I was sort of on the edge of the fence. And you've reminded me of, of a time really, you know, soon after I'd moved in and it was in the winter time and, and at the time I was still commuting into Westminster on at least three days a week basis. So I'd got the train back from from London up to Huntingdon and
was driving back in. Most of the roads in the Fens are really straight for about sort of three or five miles and then they suddenly have a right angle bend, you know, when you need to know it's there. Otherwise you're straight in the dike. But this particular Rd. was really snaking the road between St. Neots and Chatteris and, and it, and it really curved, you know, quite gently, as if it was following an old riverbed. I don't know if it was or not, but I can remember going up there and it was, of course, pitch black because I was getting, you know, driving up there at about 7:00 at night and
I saw what I thought was a UFO. And there was this incredible light, a horizontal light that took up, you know, kind of 1/3 of the windscreen at this point. Maybe it was more like the wing mirror size, but it was, it was this incredible sort of flaming brightness that was that was it was in the road and it moved. It seemed to be hovering above the ground and it was moving from the left to the right across the Fenland. And it was really strange and really disconcerting as I was sort of going around these bends getting closer and closer to
Chatteris. And as I got closer, of course perspective works this way. The thing was getting bigger and bigger and bigger until it really was taking up a third of the the windscreen. And it was just this brightness that kept on hovering and moving left and right across. And I really had no idea what on earth this was until suddenly I realised that it was a massive farm fire. It turned out that a farmer had built a new farm just next to the old farmhouse and instead of demolishing it in the way that that other people might have, he just set fire to it.
And and that was that was my introduction to the Fens. There are different people up there, Martin. Yeah, it's a very different landscape and you can certainly see from a long way. And so we sit up on the hill, we look out across, we look across the top of the wind turbines, they're out in in Chatteris, Wisbeach a Chatteris and War Boys. So we're sort of that much kind of we're 65 foot up where the the Fenlands, you know, 10 to 15 foot down. So let's go into some of those details that you were talking about. You mentioned clay soil. And one of the things I I hear
from lots of farmers is that, you know, I'm on clay soil. Regen can't work for me. That. Is that true? I think Regen can work everywhere and anywhere but the principles and the practices and that thinking about where you are. We have clay based soils, but each field is slightly different. We have some really healthy soils and they're many of those who are old pastures or something in the past or had more manure on organic matter. So every field we treat differently. And that does mean soils are colder to, to get going in this, you know, to warm up in the spring.
They get when they get wet, they are wet. That might mean I need a time cultivator, a time drill instead of a dish drill and it means that flexibility. But what we have found, and it actually wasn't me that noticed it, that as we're focusing on improving soil health, our soil has changed and become more forgiving. It is when our agronomist, the the gentleman that comes and tells which chemicals to be used in the pesticides to be used in and and crops to be in his advice. He turned up one day, got out of his truck, took his wellies off that were covered in mud and put his boots on.
And I said, oh, it's not coffee, we're going for a walk. And he says, but your mud doesn't stick to me anymore. And it was that moment I realised that actually something was changing and our soils that while they're, you know, the heavy good clay content, they are adapting, they're becoming more fireable that that organic matter that we're incorporating into cover crops and other practices and straw chopping straw are making a slow benefit and a difference. And we've seen that this year in a really dry season, we've, you know, yields are down, but they're not disastrous. And yes, price design is disastrous because the price has
dropped through the floor. But when I talked to some near neighbors who have not been doing the same practices or are still farming a very conventional way, moving lots of soil, they've had some really disastrous yields. And it's actually that kind of slow building up to build resilience into our into our system. And so you're getting more water holding presumably in there so that the the crop is better able to to grow even in those dry periods. Yeah, Yeah, it's it. I think it's better. It's holding better water. The structure's better. We focus on, you know, making
sure our drainage works well. So when there's excess so that those roots can get down. And I think because we're not doing so much heavy soil movement, we move it occasionally when we're incorporating manures, those root structures and worm channels, all that stories you hear. I think that really works. We were doing some ditching work this in the last couple of weeks and where you dig down to cleaning the ditch out, just the depth of where the roots have gone and the structures there. And it really sort of opens your eyes And where we put some drains in some fields, just how much our roots have gone through
our soils to go chasing water. And that's got to be a benefit. And it also a benefit on a really wet year like it has the last two years to let the water flow through as much as possible. It stands in places it's, you know, we're not immune to problems, but it is slowly improving. And how do you manage water on your farm, Martin, Because Joe and I were talking about drainage. Joe wanted to raise the issue of drainage in the way in which, you know, in the past, a few decades ago, there was a scheme where an awful lot of drainage infrastructure was put into farms. But this hasn't been hasn't been kept up.
And there isn't the the same sort of financial incentive to do this at the moment. And so a lot of it's kind of breaking down. Do you have that sort of pipe infrastructure in your fields as well as trying to get the soil to work out? How does it work for you? Yeah, we're saying we had infrastructure put in in post war and and even somewhere near lots of it is collapsing, filling up with silt. And the biggest challenge is when we're having high rainfall events, the water gets into those drainage pipes and then where there's a blockage, it's bursting up through the profile, which collapse the drain
completely. Or where we haven't maintained the ditches enough and the, and the water can't get out the pipe fast enough. So we have a degrading infrastructure under our soil. Many of our fields have a bigger fields now than they used to be because there was ditches and hedges that have been taken out post war. So some of that infrastructure is collapsing. And that's why we're having a focus on routinely going round and cleaning ditches out, but also trying to slow the flow of water in ditches. And it's getting this compromise of getting our drainage working to get it off the field, but
hold it in the in the water courses to let it flow through the soil as much as possible. And we're having to do more mold draining on clay soils, mold drain, running a leg with a plug through it, that will work. And before we try to think, well, if I concentrate on roots and worms, I won't need to think about drainage because that would do it all for me. It can do some, but I have to keep the infrastructure going. And we will have to look to invest on that infrastructure in the near term. And that's where the government could step up and look at facilities to, to help support that real high investment to put drainage back in.
And, and how do we pay that off over a period of time? Because that was that will also reduce the oxidisation of our soils, causing methane and gases coming off and the organic matter and actually to help deliver food security by having soils that are healthy to produce the goods we want. You mentioned there when you get blockages in the drain that the, you know the water builds up and it bursts out and it and it collapses the infrastructure. Are you, is it possible to identify where those blockages are and to manage before that happens or are you just kind of stuck with waiting for those
bursts to happen and then sort of recognizing where that drain is and dealing with it at that point? There is some way, I mean on a dry year, it gives you a really good indication where the water still stood. So that might be a problem where there's a blockage. We try and maintain all the outflows and and remember where they are and sort of monitor them. We can clean some of them, but there's lots and lots of drains in every field and they all run. And I've only got so many maps. You know, my grandfather and the people here before us, I mean, we've got Victorian and you know, in Bush drains in places
you can steal the evidence where they cut spade open the soil, drag bushes from the hedgerow, laid them in the bottom and that organic matter just let the water seep through the soil. So we haven't got all the plans, but we've over the last five years we were increasingly focused on maintenance and trying to identify the problems before they get too bad, because then it's a big expense and a new drainage system rather than a maintenance and fixing up where you think a blockage is. But trying to find a drain in a in a field when you've got a
guide on a map that says it's there somewhere, trying to find that drain without destroying it with a digger can be a real. Challenge sometimes, Yeah, absolutely. And you mentioned Bush drains there, which is something that I've not come across before. And of course, an awful lot of drains when they go in Victorian drains are kind of pottery pipes, clay pipes and, and these days it might be plastic. Do you think that there's a future where that sort of Bush drain infrastructure could be, you know, reused and, and, and reintegrated as a matter of course? And obviously that might be the most nature friendly approach to
drainage. Yeah, or that French drain of of putting some hardcore stone down and just for much of it, it's just moving, keeping the water moving to stop it ponding. If you're moving it from the middle of a big field across, that's going to have to might probably need a drain pipe. But if you're just moving it 1020 yards, 30 yards, putting some organic matter in there and making a sandwich of, of filtration, that may just let that water move and maybe just stick the pipe on the ends on the last few metres. And that's kind of that can work. So I mean, we've put straw, lots of straw bales in it, but drop
them in there and fill them in and done all sorts in the past just as a temporary fix. And it's amazing how long that that stays there for just that organic thick content just gives enough to sort of keep the soil moving or the water moving within the soil. It's fascinating. I, I just want to go back to, you know, this year's harvest and the way in which you were saying, you know, although your harvest is down, it's not down as much as some of your neighbors that are farming in different ways. But you also mentioned that we have this low harvest, but there's also been this price crash where there were low
prices. Surely if, I mean, in other industries, if there was a scarcity of a product, then potentially the prices would increase. That doesn't seem to be the case here. No, we have, we will have a scarcity product in this country, but globally there's a massive amount because of the trade tariffs in America and the moving away from state the the aid program, there's huge quantities of grain, maize, soya available in America that has no home that was going for aid. So that's flooding the market. We've got good yields in other
places because they're weathers. We have a small island trading globally on commodities of grains and actually it's quite cheap to bring it over on a boat and get it on board. And I think the previous governments in the past doing trade deals and not enforcing standards undermines the UK farmers so much because as soon as the price point is better to import, regardless of quality, it's imported. And actually, if we had a clear standard of what health good nature friendly production could be focusing on quality food,
quality environmental outcomes and quality climate outcomes and built that, we would trade globally for driving standards up rather than sucking in the cheapest product that's grown or produced globally with no care for what it the impact it has there, all the impact on our own health. We've talked, you know, often you and I in the past about food security and some of those other issues that you raised there. But that's incredible, isn't it? That, I mean, I can't imagine for one moment that these were, were reactions that that Trump would have expected when he closed down USAID and, and
introduce those tariffs that suddenly there's a surfeit of grain that's then flooding the market globally, which then has this sort of depression effect on prices here and elsewhere around the world. I mean that that is an incredible illustration of the way in which we are connected geopolitically and the way in which our food security to an extent depends upon decisions that are taken, you know, in places entirely different from Westminster. Yeah. And the challenge is as a farmer, you know, we've had a number of years that the weather has been impacting the prices jump on down the lead the lift,
we're producing less and our price goes down. It no other business or market operates like that. But farmers are not going to have the money to invest. They're not going to have the confidence to invest. So we're going to see a lot of exit of businesses and farmers. And I worry about actually the production level we'll have of security in the future, because if we go too low, the infrastructure starts going because that can't make the, the manufacturers, the machinery dealers, the the processors, the avatars, everything else shrinks. And then we become into a real problem that if it comes back as
I haven't got the infrastructure to sell into then and it holds the market again. And that's where some of that food security, what national governments should be looking at is what is the core infrastructure do we need in this in this country to facilitate producing and delivering food on from plates from our fields. I've just come back from the Isle of Man where I've been away for a couple of weeks. And, and, and as some listeners may know, I used to run the, the NFU on the Isle of Man as the general Secretary there. And one of the challenges that we had at the time was the meat plant.
The meat plant was much too big a, a piece of infrastructure to support the market that existed on the island at the time. And so there was a constant issue with throughput. But at the time there were also, and this is, you know, sort of 1520 years ago, there were also supermarkets on the Isle of Man that were committed to Manx produce of one kind or another. If meat was produced on the Isle of Man, it would get sold on the Isle of Man. There was a derogation that meant that there was a limit on the amount of red meat that could be brought in. But since then, just in the last
few years, Tesco that only had one store has taken over ShopRite, which was the, you know, the store that existed. It was, it was actually owned by an Irish company or an Irish family, I think. But it, it sort of was on the Isle of Man and more committed to farmers since then. I don't think now that Tesco's taken over those stores, Manx meat is available anywhere on the island, certainly not in supermarkets. It may be, you know, some independent retailers. And so the bottom was dropped out of that market means an awful lot of livestock are now
being exported into England for slaughter, let alone, you know, sort of onward sales. And therefore the throughput for that meat plant has has dropped through the floor again. And the whole thing has just become incredibly difficult with no immediate on island market for the produce that's that's coming from the island. I mean, it's just, it's criminal really. And it's just awful. And that's in microcosm, I guess an example of what happens and how important that infrastructure is. And if we look at the UK, then we look at the fibre industry
and, you know, it's really difficult, isn't it, to sell a fleece for a decent price. And, you know, we've lost that infrastructure. And so we really need to guard against that happening to any greater degree, make sure that we rebuild the infrastructure, that we get more small abattoirs, that we get more of this processing infrastructure in place. Yeah. And I think it is, it is that what's the unintended consequences of of a supermarket buying out of things what it breaks down particularly for livestock if they move out of the area they're produced to a abattoir or something further away, they don't come back to feed the people in that
community in that location. That means the economic benefit and the the system benefit goes. And I think that kind of goes back to the beginning of our conversation of the access to government, because I enjoy having those conversations of sort of you're thinking about doing this from a farming practical point of view. I will see this domino effect in the future. So if we want to have more wool, get better value for wool, why are we not making it into insulation? Why are we not having policies that actually focus on that joined up circular system? So as a by product has a future home that drives value right
through the supply chain and and the economic benefit right through. And that goes back to the the opportunity to make sure that governments and policy makers and supply chains, you know, we are in that room, make trying to communicate the the unintended consequences of their decisions before they actually make them where then it really comes back and effects farmers now and in the future. And of course, you know, in terms of nature friendly farming, often it is farmers that are supplying and not always by any means, but often it is farmers that are supplying
into those shorter supply chains that really rely on small abattoirs, for example, that that are actually delivering an awful lot of that regeneration in the hills with their livestock. Do you have livestock on your farm, Martin, at all? We have some sheep visiting, we used to have catalog love to get that back in, but the cost of the infrastructure and the cattle at the moment are too high to do that investment in an uncertain market. So we work with local shepherds who haven't, you know, just given a grazing licence or opportunity to a a 16 year old. I think they've got, he's got 20 sheep and he wants to build.
So we've said here's a field, if we put it into a herbal lay, you sort some water out for you, we're not gonna charge you for it. You just go in. Great. The benefit of having those livestock on our soils and grazing at grass is valuable to us. So that's our value. And we've got to sort of work with others to make opportunities and stackable benefits within our farm. And, and I think the white livestock in the right place is a real benefit, but it's got to be done at a right balance. Martin, there's there's so many things that you've raised and throughout the conversation really that I'd love to get into
more and there are so many more questions that I have. So it's a good job that we've got six months at least to talk about these things. But let's move on and talk about the policy landscape, which you mentioned again just now. And let's talk about English policy because you know, that's that's where an awful lot of your advocacy goes. And just to say that, you know, in the next program we do next month, we're going to be talking about Scottish policy with Adam Forrest from NFFN Scotland, who's going to come and talk about the NFFN Scotland Conference that's taking place a bit later in the autumn. But focusing on England for a
moment, clearly there are a lot of challenges taking place within government. Farmers have been railing against a whole range of different decisions that have been taken. Inheritance tax, obviously being the the sort of topmost of that. Is the government getting anything right in England? I think the review of what they're doing is, is right. They've not come in and kept traction happening and clear communication and the, the focus on the right value for schemes delivering the right joined up approach is good. Not everything was perfect with
the previous government and there were some things that have put in place that have made this government picking up some difficult challenges. But I, I do think they can do better, they can communicate better. And actually that's what they really want of a clear plan and focusing on, you know, Minette batters profitability review, a 25 year road map for farming rather than, you know, we've got an environmental road map or plan. So what is the vision? But we do need them to step up and get that communicating to us. So we know where we're trying to invest and where that support
will be for those areas. It's interesting because you mentioned vision there and, you know, much as one can criticise elements of what the previous government was doing, I think it's fair to say that they, they did have a vision and they communicated that vision to a, to a pretty clear extent. It seems incredible that a month into a, sorry, a year into a new government, that really still doesn't seem to be a vision beyond farmers need to make it on their own. And, you know, gradually this, this funding support, this rug is going to be pulled out from underneath farmers.
Yeah, if you listen to the various speeches by the ministers and Secretary of State, I think there is clear language in there, but it's not been communicated as well. It's sort of their direction is to support a more nature friendly, a more balanced farming system where food, nature, climate come together on landscapes. But that clear narrative and messaging coming out of Defra and of government, I think many farmers are a bit annoyed with some of the language of food securities, national security and what does it really mean when we see policies that the
scheme suddenly stop. Grants are available now but not tomorrow. Area payments have come off quicker than what we had budget as a farmer had budgeted for a timeline of funding changes and hopefully new stuff coming in. They've accelerated the transition away from the payment we're receiving, but the new money is not there in front of us. We cannot apply or many farmers cannot apply for stuff because it's not been brought forward. I think that's the real challenge of of a change of government with a change of focus of what they want to do
from the previous government is that instability. It's put into the whole system at a price where they went and done tax changes and commodity markets are on the floor. And just in terms of, you know, going back to you as an individual farmer, what's been the impact on you and your business of of those changes financially? Personally, it's been absolutely pretty significant. We're in some schemes RPA were delayed in giving us our annual declaration and we've taken some options out of one scheme to make make a better scheme of the next one and we missed it
because the RPA hadn't processed a thing. The capital grants just lately we went to apply but because the RPA hadn't cleaned our system cleared some options off that we've done previously in the last round of stuff we couldn't apply. And I got actually got an e-mail last week to say it is now fixed. You can now you know we've fixed your problems. The scheme finished 3-4 weeks ago. So it means you know it's £180,000 of income I could have gener I could have received on delivering public goods. That has now stopped us on this farm doing more, bringing in the
right infrastructure, actually joined doing a joined up approach with that significant amount of funding coming away from us from that area based payment stuff. On top of that, we've had two really wet years and a dry year and the commodity prices have been really fluctual. So it's caused us really significant pain. And now I've also got the potential of a railway line coming through the farm from the Oxford to Cambridge. They may want 4045% of the farm, not sure quite when it is, but they're doing lots of work to investigate it. So what's our future plan for our farm and our soils and our
system if that infrastructure is going to come through and significantly change our business? So for us it's quite challenging at the moment. I was going to say, I mean, aside from the financial challenges, you know, and the substantial amount of money that you were expecting to get that you haven't got and the impact fact that that's had. And I'm, I'm sure for, you know, many farmers, that might mean that they simply don't do the nature friendly sort of work, the ecological work that that you're so committed to on your farm that that that sort of puts back that whole sort of ecological change and that
regenerative change. But then when you're talking about the potential of a railway line coming through, the psychological impact of that must be really quite immense. Yeah, it literally is. Because they want to do some archaeological, for an example, some archaeological trenching where this, not just the railway line, all the additional land they want to take, they're going to put one per acre of the 20m trench down to a meter. So there goes our drainage. Every field's going to have this, but we don't know when. So do we plant? Do we wait? And that actually the time and energy it's taken to engage with
them and push them back and say why this and challenge it. It really adds a lot of pressure to us and my family and the business. And then it's that transition of I have been invested in that more nature for anything. I can see the benefits of doing stuff, but the additionality that I could really deliver with some additional funding, support to up the delivery for pollinators, predatory insects, public access, educational visits, all sorts of stuff that would really deliver better outcomes. I can't do that on my own and I need some funding and public
support to be able to deliver those elements on top of what I'm already doing. And that's where I get really disheartened sometimes and I try and stay positive because it's I see the future can be a lot better, but I see policy and supply chains and government infrastructure come round that is really given uncertainty for our own personal business here on a farm. And so what's the process, Martin, if for example, you do end up losing 1/3 of the farm to that piece of infrastructure, Is that going to be a compulsory purchase? Do you get some benefit out of
that? What, what are your options then? Do you have to completely redesign the shape of your business? Or I mean, you're not just able presumably to find that that land next door, you know, just just to replace the land that you've lost. It's so it's compulsory purchase. Looking at other infrastructure, we're not sure when you're that payment will come and. That'll be agricultural value, presumably. Yeah, at basic agricultural value, regardless of any uplift of nature, carbon in our soils or other, you know, developments that I could get benefit of BNG and other things.
So we'll get that. We don't get full compensation for a year and one day after the the railway line opens if it happens. If it does so, that could be 10 to 15 years down the line before we receive full payment of the loss of income, not to our business, to our business and our, you know, our house and our farm. But then also that money, everyone else in that locally has also been impacted. They're all looking for the same, to spend the money again. So we might get compulsory purchase, we'll get paid some money, we might get some of the legal fees paid for. But if I go and buy some land,
I'm going to pay stamp duty legal fees over there. So why actually it's going to cost me and it is costing us now for for that interruption. I have no choice over and they literally want to do what they want to our farm, take our drive, plant some trees, put some ponds. They're doing what they like with us having to stand here and just question what they want to do and why and push back. There may be some benefits of the biodiversity, net gain, some of the environmental features, but it actually puts a railway line 30 yards at the top of my garden. And I've grown up on this farm. I know every tree, wildlife,
drain, soil, field, it's not somewhere I feel I it will be my home in the long term future. Feels like it must be a really difficult place for you as the leader of the nature friendly farming network of a of an NGO that's working to government and trying to sort of put that positive face on farming, positive sort of face on policy responses. And yet you've got this challenge in your own backyard that I mean, that sounds sounds like a really tough balancing act. When I'm representing the organization, I represent all our farm members and that means
making sometimes like advocating things. I actually won't personally do my business as much as it could, but it's the right thing to do to to help the farm industry and all of our members champion those things. While I face many challenges at home and it is quite hard sometimes, particularly where I see policy makers and decision makers do daft decisions and just communicate in poor way. You just think you've got to get up in the morning and try and be happy and energetic and engage in ways that try and get better outcomes for the future when you well personally, we fight face
many challenges in our in our home business and with infrastructure coming around us. I wanted to ask you about the government rhetoric in relation to farming and and to nature, because we seem to have two different stories that are being told and you turn and and that story that you've just told about your own farm really exemplifies some of the challenge challenges here where you were talking about the way in which you think if there is any vision from government at all, then it is around the idea of having more nature friendly farming getting. Nature better integrated within
agriculture, but then at the same time we have this communication in relation to planning and the suggestion that nature is a problem, that nature is somehow an impediment to having new houses and new infrastructure. How do you feel the government is communicating? I think some of the communication is at odds with their own government and their own departments. You know, you're hearing infrastructure and Rachael Reed growth, housing, Newts and bats are in a way and we're going to push on with it. Actually, nature underpins our
our whole economy, our whole system, and we need to make it work in tandem. Yes, the developments will always cause problems, farming causes problems, but we've got to get the right balance going forward and join that up. And I don't think many within this government, and we heard it in the rhetoric in the previous government is, is that joined up approach of the role of nature and access of healthy food, access to nature, joined up development and infrastructure that gets the best of both worlds rather than making the right, you know, the typical argument, it's in the way and
it's stopping development and some of that sort of policies that have been designed. And the, and the, the investment in more and more surveys, rather than talk to people on the ground goes back to the railway line coming around here. They're doing all the biodiversity surveys. They've not once asked me for my evidence and research. I've got on the farm where I know the little owl less the, the kestrels nesting. So they're paying more money for, for surveys where they're not using local knowledge. And I just, I'd love to get Rachel Reeves out and various other people on farms and say, and they in landscapes, this is
what we could do. If you're doing a joined up approach, what you're doing is, is costing a huge amount of money, going to cause a lot of negative impacts not just to to to the environment, but to so many other things. And of course, in terms of of nature and nature gain and understanding nature, it's not just about those sort of larger birds that you're talking about there, the little owl and the kestrel. It's about the microfauna and the worms and everything else that's in the soil. You know, it's just the bedrock of biodiversity. And it's all very well to say, you know, we're going to stick some infrastructure in here and we're going to, you know, create
some benefit over over there. But you've got to work from the basis that you really understand the complexity and the nuance of biodiversity before you start. Yeah, and that's part of my journey as a farmer. I was taught how to produce crops and animal husbandry. That understanding that microbiology, the all of the small stuff that's in our soil and nature and how it all works together blows your mind when you start looking at it. And we can't just come in and just say, oh, we're just going to plant some more trees over there and move or plant, put a pond there. We're going to move those newts that whole infrastructure of
what a habitat is. It is it has to be all interconnected. You can't have islands of good and it comes back to the farming. We can't just have islands of nature friendly and farms that are doing that really joined up approach and then not for for farms and then some more. It needs nature needs to be interconnected. And that's where I think we're going to have to work in the future of clusters catchments together. And actually not everyone has to do loads, but everyone needs to do some and join it up and then it joins it up to our developments and our housing estates and getting people out and eating food into into
communities and a better, more intuitive way of feeding and engaging people. I'm aware that we are starting to run a bit short on time. And so I'm, I'm going to move on and you'll, you'll notice this about me, Martin, that we have a, you know, we have a good plan and then we end up having an interesting conversation and have to skip things. But obviously we're going to come back to policy and we're going to come back to funding over the course of the next few programs as we go forward. But I, I think before we kind of move on from this conversation, we should talk a little bit about, about the comms. You, you touched on it there,
the difference between the communications, you know, around planning of infrastructure from Rachel Reeves, from Angela Rayner and then from Defra. But even within Defra, the comms can be pretty tone deaf, can't it? And there are challenges, as you said, we had a change of governments, a change of policy where there is an ending of schemes that have been put in place by previous governments. But they're really not doing a very good job of sugaring the pill, are they? When they tell farmers that they're losing something or that something's changing, they're not managing to set up that policy conversation to to gently
bring these things in. They are just kind of ramming them home and then and then telling people, well, you've just got to live with it. And that's the way it is. Yeah, I think many farmers feel that, you know, what comes out is insensitive and, and not in the real world and goes back to it gives, you know, the role of the the nature of any farming network and other one to engage and communicate to, to decision makers and governments and policy makers of what that may look like and how they can language. And I hope, and I've had some commitments from people who
defer to that, then communication will improve and they want to engage more, but they also want to work out how that works. The budget last year, I think government across the board put the barriers up. They then forgot to engage because they were unsure what their farmers are going to have a, you know, complain about or they knew. And actually we've got to do that better going forward. And it's there's a role for the network and other stakeholders and organisations to communicate the message of government. It doesn't mean we have to agree with it, but if that's what they want to get out, we want to make
sure as many farmers as possible hear all of it, not just the sound bite or what they hear online. And I guess that means that the government needs to be clear about what those messages are, exactly what it is they're trying to achieve, so that you're able to communicate that. Because, and as you say, this is something I've criticised the NFU for in the past, that they haven't done a good job of explaining what the government's trying to do. They've simply complained about what the government is doing. And I think you're right that they're there is a real role there in explaining what the government trajectory is, what farmers can expect from the government.
But the government does need to be clear about it if they have any right to expect organisations like NFFN to do that job for them. Yeah, and I've really challenged them and I hope to get some good commitments that get delivered. If we're not there just to be the government's mouthpiece, we will. We actively hold government to account as much as possible, quite often in rooms, sometimes in media and other spaces. But they've got to work with us. They've got to explain their plans in their government language that I may be able to in other organizations,
communicate it in farmer language because quite often what the policymaker says the farmer doesn't understand. And there's got to be some interpretation by organizations to their members and to the wider community of really what what needs to happen. Do you think it's possible because there has been such a, a disintegration of of sort of trust between the government and farmers, sometimes fuelled, I think it would be fair to say by some of the farmers organisations that have be kind of ramping up the rhetoric. But certainly the government's done, you know, it's played its own role in, in really damaging this relationship.
Do you think it's possible to restore that relationship? Certainly, you know, with the farmers that you talk to within the network. Do you think that there is any sympathy with government at all? I think for many that trust is really breaking down or broken down and they're really just disheartened with this stop, start not knowing. No, you know, as a business, you can't plan for what's coming down the line in, in funding. But I do feel many are seeing the solutions and are seeing the benefits and they, they will come back and work, want to work with government and delivering
things. And also it's the only, sometimes the only income stream to get some money into a business to deliver some outcomes of, of, of a product. It may be a nature product, it may be a food product, maybe flooding product. So they, if the money's there and it's at the right level and other than they asked, the right farmers will engage. But if they do it wrong, many farmers are going to say, I'll leave you alone. I'm going to get on with what I want to do. I'll meet regulation baseline, but I'll farm my farm. Howard, please. Just before we kind of round the programme out, I just want to talk about Secretary of State
Steve Reed, because he came a couple of weeks or so ago, didn't he, to your farm? How did you get on with him there? How did that go? Do you think he he gets what you're trying to do? Yeah. So I've met him a number of times, but actually to have him out on farm, I've had a good walk around and a good discussion. Actually seeing it in a field and talking about the value of the habitat, not just the grass margin, but what's in the grass margin and how we're having to spend money in, in enhancing that for public good, for the benefit not just of our farm. And the cost of hedgerows and to West stone walls, some of the
infrastructure in our landscape is a core cost to my business, but doesn't deliver any benefit to my business, but it does for the wider society. That's your public goods. And then also what's that funding needed to help farmers transition and what are those options and outcomes? So I think he really gets it. He got it. His language was really welcoming and I feel really constructive of understanding the role of nature in our systems and trying to tackle some of the fundamental problems in farming and IT and it's pollution and it's profitability
in getting better outcomes. So I think he he got it, he understood it and we had some really good discussions around the solutions to that. And where are those levers, Not just what he has, but other government departments and some private markets and supply chains. Who owns the responsibility for the some of the stuff that needs to happen? Do you think that Steve Reed is strong enough to to get a good listening from Treasury to win some of the money back that's necessary going forward? And indeed to pull together to create that sort of joined up
approach across different government departments to build those private markets and accelerate delivery of those private markets around natural capital? Do you think that he's strong enough as a Secretary of State to achieve those things? I think he has proved himself to be fairly strong because actually we didn't decrease the budget. There was real risk of having and actually some budget was increased for some of the environmental outcomes because Treasury understood that they need delivering to meet targets or deliver benefits. The challenge will be, I think he can be a really good advocate for us, but if he's too good, he'll get moved on to another
department and that's the real challenge. If we have a reshuffle at any time soon, do we end up the deck shares changing again and having to start again? And that's that's my real concern. We need somebody in that role and I think Steve could be that role of really pushing at the agenda through the government departments. But he needs to, you know, we need someone to stay in the role for a long period of time to really get traction on the on the delivery, not just the asks. And delivery takes a number of years to get the whole system joined up to what they want to achieve.
It's always the challenge, isn't it, where Defra still remains today at the bottom of the ministerial food chain when really, you know, when we're talking about the issues that we're talking about, whether it's food security, ecological security, climate, biodiversity, etcetera, it really ought to be considered much higher up the agenda. But because it's budget small, it kind of sits and nestles down there at the bottom in terms of whether if you're sort of thinking in terms of the NFFN or thinking in terms of, you know, those broader NGOs and farmers representative organizations.
What are the buttons do you think that people should be trying to press in terms of their conversations with Steve? Food's important, we all got to eat and food production, but it's all of the other goods and services, the fibre, the timber, the flood mitigation, the carbon sequestration, nature access. We've got to champion all of it and help then help defer, demonstrate to the wider society and to wider government departments of the role of healthy for soil, to have healthy food, reduce the NHS, not just see Defra as this small
department over here. What we produce from our land, from our farm to landscape involves all departments across government. And you know, and that's what we should be championing, that multifunctionality of our landscapes and the assets we can deliver that all departments and all governments should be invested in. Why are we investing in like 22 billion pounds in carbon sequestion for tech we haven't invented yet Increased soil organic matter 1% and there's most of your carbon sequestered and IT deliver so many other multiple benefits.
But we have not been communicating that as an industry and championing not just the food we produce, but all of the other stuff that are core to what we can and we do deliver. And that constructive approach that you mentioned, I think is so critical. And as you say, it's, it's about helping the industry, getting the industry to have a clear voice about the incredible value that it delivers within the countryside in terms of food, fibre, natural capital, amenity, access, well-being, all of these different things and, and public health. And to help Defra, to make that case across government to help
Defra is, is I guess one of the things that the NFM, you know, does that is, is different to some of the other organizations. And to sort of work on that constructive relationship between farming as an industry and government, you know, as, as both a, a policy maker and, and a delivery mechanism for some of the funding. Look, just briefly, because we, we need to finish, could you talk us through what's happening in Scotland? I mentioned before that Adam Forrest from NFFM Scotland's going to join us next time to talk through some of the Scottish land use policy. But there's a conference coming up, isn't there, in Scotland.
Yeah, beginning of September we've got our Scotland's First Nature for Any Farming Summit, an event for farmers, policy makers, environmental leaders to explore how farming can restore nature, long term food security and support profitable farming. So we're trying to bring all of those stakeholders and organisations and policy makers into a room and then lead it with farmers already doing some of those actions and bring in policy makers to talk about what they need and we can demonstrate how our farmers are already trying to deliver that to then really set the agenda. We've got an election in
Scotland in next May, so we're starting to build on that. What could our farm landscapes do and what's the government support look like? So it should be a really good event with a range of different speakers and activities, and it's really good to sort of talk about that at the next podcast. And is that you said the beginning of September, is it beginning of September or beginning of October? Yes, sorry, beginning of October. Beginning of October and and if people want to find out more, how can they find out more? Didn't get tickets for that. Have have a look on our website, the various social media and
other posts coming out and tickets will be available through the Eventbrite soon. Brilliant Martin, I think that's probably all we have time for and I, you know, it's been really interesting having you on and having a sort of more general conversation and I hope people have enjoyed it. And certainly, you know, we're going to, you know, develop these conversations, develop that on podcast relationship over the next few months as well. We're going to finish there. If you haven't listened yet, then please do stroll back in your feeds for a leaders conversation with Andy Cato, which I really enjoyed. I thought was really interesting, particularly, you
know, the sort of earlier stages of of Andy's life and you know, how he got into music. His, his life as a trombone player and then his, his challenge is getting into farming and the final solution for him, which was, you know, farming and processing and therefore developing wild farm bread. And a discussion with the National Infrastructure Commission for Wales about why they've put the voice of nature on their board and what that means. How do you represent the voice of nature on a board in terms of flooding decisions? A discussion about how we accelerate delivery of
biodiversity net gain so that that becomes an opportunity for more farmers, not just the, the small number that are currently able to to benefit from that. And of course, the latest We from the Chaff, in which Joe Stanley and Nikki Yoxall go head to head and discuss their different takes on regenerative farming. But I hope you've enjoyed listening. Please come back and listen to more, tell your friends like us, comment and review us and share our links. It all really helps to build the Farm Gate listening family farmgateispartof8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican
AG, Rural Solutions, the Usk Catchment partnership with Growlo and individual donors. I've been Finn loca stain bye for now. And I'll be Martin Lyons. Goodbye.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...