CLAIRE WHITTLE and BEN RASKIN join FFINLO COSTAIN in-the-field at the Agroforestry Show. We don't know what the world will look like in 2050, but we do know that our temperatures and weather will be more extreme. How will farms, landscapes and livestock need to change to become more resilient? How will agroforestry help farmers maintain food and fibre production - and profitability? This is the second of six impromptu in-the-field podcasts recorded at the Agroforestry Show 2025.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, I'm Finlay Costain, editorof8.9.com, and of course running the Farm Gate podcast. We're doing impromptu sessions in the field again. This time we're at the Agroforestry Show and I'm joined by Claire Whittle and by Ben Raskin, and I'm going to ask them to both introduce themselves and tell me about the sessions that they've just run. Just really guys, just introduce yourselves and tell me the names of your sessions. Hi Finlay, I'm Claire Whittle and I am a regenerative vet, so I basically advocate for healthy
livestock that form part of healthy ecosystems, but a farm vet by trade and a farmer. And what was your session? My session was what does a climate resilient farm look like in 2050 and that was in conjunction with the Woodland Trust. And that's essentially what we're going to be talking about in this. But there was a lot of crossover with your session. Ben, what was your session? So my session was adapting our growing systems for climate change, and it was really Martin Crawford was talking about how we build diversity into our systems and balancing that against how we run an
economically viable farm. And then just in case there's anybody who hasn't listened to you recently on the Farm Gate podcast, who are you? Where are you from? So I'm Ben Raskin, I'm an agroforester now. I'm background in horticulture. I work partly for the Soil Association, partly for Helen Browning at her farm and then I do independent writing and consultancy as well. Fantastic. Now, I think that lots of people listening to the podcast will have a pretty good idea of what they think 2050 is going to look like and therefore why we might
need to have more resilient systems. But I think we should take it kind of back to brass tacks, really. Why do we need to be more resilient? What are the issues that you think we're going to be facing in 2050? What's the world going to look like then? So I obviously think from a livestock perspective and one of the things I think we'll get increasingly concerned about is what the future weather is going to be like. So one of the things for 2050, sort of July 2050 under the high emission scenario that we're currently in is we're expecting temperatures where we get sort of above 35 degrees, 40° C even in the summer periods and the massive effects that that then
has on our livestock. So if you're a dairy cow, for example, obviously you've got a very high metabolic rate, your production can drop anywhere from sort of 20 to 50%, which is drastic, obviously has a massive impact on profit on that farm. And then when you get that production loss, you then get you get fertility effects, you get a knock on effect on fertility, you get reduced ability to sort of fight disease because your immune system actually becomes suppressed. And there's a study in the Journal of Dairy Science that has shown that heifers that are born to heat stress dams actually have reduced milk yield potential for up to three
generations. There's a long term generational impact of heat stress on our farms. And obviously when we're talking about climate resilience, we're talking about heat, but we're also talking about wet and again, wet cold animals that those kind of effects. So generally think about what what impacts it has on our livestock. And we're very good, I think in the UK at designing sheds for livestock, but we don't often think about landscape design. So no one's really thinking about what does our hedgerow planning look like or what trees have we got. And the resilience of those sheds will get tested in the future when we have a you know,
potentially energy costs are increasing and price hikes on those of people get more air conditioning in their houses etcetera. We don't necessarily think about the resilience of those those outdoor systems from, for me as a vet from a livestock help perspective. And thanks for that. I mean that that's a lot about what what farm and farm livestock might look like and how they may need to change and the sort of issues they're going to be facing in 2050. But if you can take a sort of slightly broader view in terms of what the world is going to look like, what society is going to look like, the the sort of
broader impacts that farms then exist in whether they're producing food or fibre or, or whatever else. Yeah. So I'm, I'm a new entrant farmer myself in life. So I guess some of those things I'm going to be feeling, as I say from from a societal perspective, I think it's a tricky 1. And I think farmers are potentially more isolated than ever given some of the way that our businesses function. One of the plans for our farm is, is for it to be, well, I'll give you the whole plan is for it to be a circular community nature friendly farm. And by that I mean, we have lots of people on the farm, which I think will be really beneficial
in terms of thinking about how we grow our food from a climate, a climate friendly perspective. It's not only thinking about the livestock, it's actually thinking about what that farm is going to produce, not only in terms of forage, but how it's going to provide potentially more within that community too. So whether it is horticulture, like Ben's going to be talking about or whether it's thinking about, yeah, how we just just invite people into those systems, I think economically it's going to be interesting. And as I say, if we have that knock those knock on effects on on the on the livestock, it's thinking about then what does that, what does that resilient farm look like and how it's going to be beneficial to them.
So whether it's more trees, whether it's more hedges, whether it's thinking about the soil health and what that pasture is going to look like in order to provide the benefits and the nutrients that our cattle then need. I think the system that we're in now, particularly where it's very sort of input reliant is going to be at risk of, of of falling down there. Then what do we need resilience from? So it's Sinclair talked a lot about the heat and obviously that's something that affects crops as well. But the other thing I think around, particularly around crops is the uncertainty and the extremes. So yes, the heat, but the wind
flooding. And when you're trying to cultivate soil, trying to establish crops, actually the wrong weather for a couple of days suddenly could be the difference between you establishing something or not. And most of our horticultural crops, for instance, don't actually want to be in full sun. They're they're happy in partial shade. And particularly if you start getting up to 3035°, most of them will suffer. So providing shade for crops is as important as Claire outlined for for livestock as well. And again, that question about society, you know how, because there's a degree to which we can
think about the weather now and the way the weather might change in relation to climate. But how does society feel in 2050? Because for me, that's, that's a point sort of after the time when I expect society to have started to collapse. And, and if that's the case, what is the role of farms at that point? What are the issues that farms are trying to to deal with at the same time as sort of coping with the weather? So obviously we have at the moment a very globalised food system and it's very, it's very volatile, it's very fragile in a
way. And it feels like it's great and it all works because we go into a supermarket and there's food on the shelf, but but you only need a war or COVID or something, you suddenly start to say, well, that doesn't work. And, and if things go wrong, what do you want? You don't want to have to rely on food coming from even across the country. 60% of our vegetables are grown in low lowland peat. You know, that's not really feasible life. We should be rewetting a lot though. So there's massive structural changes within our food system that we need to change. But a lot of it I think is about relocalisation and it's about
community and it's about bringing those two together so that the food production becomes again the heart of that community and people are invested in it and they want to support it. I mean, community supported agriculture is a particular model that can make that work. But but there's lots of ways that you can bring that resilience into a food system by having lots more lots and lots more local food production. We started drifting into how we how we achieve resilience. What I'm wondering before we
kind of get to that stage is, is if we can sort of pick out some of the ways in which the food system is currently lacking resilience. And so I wonder again, if I can come to both of you for your thoughts on that. Why are farms today not resilient? Yeah. So there's there's a a farming bit of it. The soils have become some of them degraded. So there's a, there's a farming non resilience bit, but I think there's also to, we've become reliant on too much of one thing from one place. So all of our, you know, vegetables come from one place,
all of our fruit comes from another place. And so if something goes wrong in that place, then you're stuffed. And if someone else, you know, if there's a war in that place or the, or the, the transport's messed up, then suddenly you can't get hold of stuff. And so, so it's, it's where, where you're relying on sort of what feels like a very streamlined process, but actually there's only if something goes wrong and that affects masses. Whereas if there's a local bit, something goes wrong with your local producer, that's fine. It probably isn't a massive thing. So it's, it's to do, I think with some of that, you know,
monocultures are not resilient and, and you get monocultures within the supply chain. So you get 4 companies supplying, you know, controlling most of the food in, in the world. And that's not resilient. You know, it works for them economically in the current climate, but it's not a resilient system. And where for you, Claire, where are the key vulnerabilities, the key sort of break points in the system at the moment? Yeah. So as a vet, I suppose I'd go back to thinking about the livestock systems that we actually have. And I think dairy is one that where I'd say where there is definitely less resilience, particularly on a high yielding dairy farm.
You know, there's a lot of debt involved in those dairy systems. And what that means is the animals and the soils within those systems often are pushed their limits. So whether that's so a cow being pushed physically, but also physiologically in terms of how she performs in that system, a dairy cow producing 70 litres of milk a day for me is walking a metabolic knife edge. And that means that they're going to have to, they require inputs that are, you know, not within that system itself. So whether it's veterinary interventions, whether it's medicines, whether it's in terms of things like feed and concentrates, in order to be able to maintain that, we're not dealing with systems that are focusing on profit. We're often dealing with with
businesses that are focused on yield and are often working from the point where they're already in a severe amount of debt as a result of that. So yeah, for me that's, that's the hard one. And where we can support farmers in that change is is really tricky. And I guess, you know, zoonotic explorer and and pandemics and the way the disease spreads and and moves and morphs from one country to another, that those are going to be issues that we need to think about too. Yeah, definitely. I mean, there's a, there's increase a lot of work done on biodiversity loss on human disease. So not so much with livestock, but what we tend to say is where
we have impacts of, of human disease. And I think something ridiculous like there's been over 300 emerging diseases in humans since the 1940s and over half of them are due to changes in agricultural land use in humans basically. So if you think about like nipa virus in Malaysia, that was because of spillover into pigs, because we decided that it was a good idea to sort of go into intact ecosystems and put pig farms there and then suddenly have these high numbers of pigs, spillovers, pigs spillover into humans and suddenly you've got human deaths as a result. So how we use our land and how we use our land in not only in our country, but also in other countries can often dictate how
these diseases work and move. And we need to be very careful, I think in in a changing landscape about how we how we manage that. I wonder if you can reflect on that sort of same point around pandemic and how agroecological systems and how agroforestry systems can help to sort of start building some of that resilience in the face of some disease movement? Yeah, and we know that diverse systems are more resilient. So diversity for me is the key to everything. So diverse cropping, but diverse genetics within that crop as well.
You know, it makes me nervous that I don't know, all of the nut trees, for instance, that we're growing in the UK are probably 5 variety or 10 variety. You know, if something goes wrong with one of those, we're in trouble. Even apples, you know, the, the main commercial varieties now, although we've got 2000 in the national collection, the main commercial ones, there's five of them or something. So if something goes wrong, we're really, we're, we're really vulnerable. Even things like the spread of something like scab across an orchard, different scab strains are adapted for different
varieties. So, so if one's really, you know, adapted to Cox and then it suddenly hits a Spartan, it's going to slow down a bit. So even at that level, having diversity within the system helps. But if you're then mixing up your apple trees with cherry trees or with, you know, nut trees, and again, you're, you're stopping and you're, you're creating breaks effectively for those diseases. And, and that diversity brings in press pests and predators and pollinators and all those other things. So you've got that wide variety of things that stops anything getting out of control. So there will always be problems, there will always be
new diseases. But if you've got diversity and things are able to adapt and we can breed new varieties and slow stuff down, then that helps. So it's building as much as that as you can into your system, I would say. So I guess I want to ask you both 2, two additional things. And the first is what resilience looks like in 2050, what a resilient farm is, how farms need to adapt. You know, whether there's space for, for the variety of farms that we have now from the more intensive to, to the less intensive, whether every farm needs to change and what, what
those farms might be. But then secondly, to ask you about how we get there, how we support that transition and how we get more farmers to be working in a way that is more resilient, What what those sort of key factors are that will promote change and and provoke people to change, I suppose. So why don't we start with that, You know, looking forward to 2050. What does a resilient farm look like? So I think it's diverse. So by that I mean it probably has some livestock on mixed in
as part of a rotation. If it's, if it's also growing crops, it has mostly more trees than it does at the moment, I would say. And it has more people on it. So where I work at Eastbrook with Helen Browning, you know, we, we have, I can't remember now 1015 people working on a farm that if it was just arable, we'd have two people probably. So it makes it more complex and and sometimes more tricky because it's complex, but it also that I think makes it more resilient. So I think there'll be, you
know, more people, more enterprises, more skills, you know, so all of that we're going to go on to how we get there. But that that does create a challenge. But I think that's my vision of that is something that is is hearted in the community with a range of people in a range of enterprises. Claire, same question to you. I pretty much say exactly the same thing, but from a from a lifestyle perspective, maybe I need to start growing some vegetables a bit better than I currently do. But that diversity is really important. And I think that's diversity from what is in our soils, what's in our pastures in terms of again, coming back, exactly
what Ben said, just the, the people that are on the farm, the trees and the hedges that are there. And then also, you know, things like, you know, how that promotes clean water. And then for, you know, the local community as well. We're not just thinking about what's actually going on on the farm. For me, a really resilient farm actually protects that community and how it performs as well. These days, you know, a lot of farmers will talk about themselves as being dairy farmers or arable farmers or, you know, whatever else. Do you think that that sort of conversation is going to be the same in 2050? Do you think people will be
dairy farmers or arable or horticulturalists? I think it might be a bit of both. So I would one of the things the plans for the farm home is that we have people that come on with different businesses. So if somebody wanted to do chickens or somebody wants to do sheep, they might still be a sheep farmer, but they'll be on a very diverse farm. So maybe the farming system might be different. Maybe the farmers will still do their have their particular interest. But for me, I would like to see farmers just being farmers. And, and also, I think just reiterating the point that I think in the UK we have this thing where farmers feel like they can only be farmers. I feel like I can have another
role outside of farming, whether it's farm vetting or whether it's something else as well. I think in other countries, they're much better where everyone is almost a farmer and you know, they have a, a main job that is outside of that as well. So I think there could be a little bit of both. Hopefully it'll just be much more. Hopefully it'll just be very diverse. We tend to think about farmers when we, when we talk about them just in sort of general society as being food producers. They're not just food producers, of course. Do you think that the other things that farmers produce will become more by 2050? Do you think that we'll start thinking about farmers as not
just being about food, but about other things as well? I do hope so. I mean, my next book is about part time farming, so I'm glad you pulled that up. But I, I agree. And I think one of the interesting things here at Wood Oaks, which is where the agroforestry show is we are on the edge of London and how we bring urban population into farming. You know, there's so many opportunities within farming and, and we need the, we talked about diversity, but actually there's lots of opportunities for people from a much more diverse background to come into farming and how do we create
those opportunities for them? So, so I think, you know, even to the point of supply, you know, there's lots of people from different ethnicity with different food needs and we're not catering for that mostly at the moment. We're importing a lot of that, but a lot of it we could grow in this country. So how do we support people to make good businesses from growing pumpkin leaves, for instance? You know, so there's lots of stuff where we could be growing much, much wider range of stuff, but again, would make those farms more resilient. So let's talk about how we get there.
And Claire, let's think about vets in the first instance, because vets sell meds. That's that's how they make money. How are they going to be making money in 2050? Hopefully not doing that, I feel over. Yeah, I suppose the answer remains unknown for me. So with the regenerative vet, the aim was to try and build a practice that sells time, but that's not necessarily associated with selling times associated with the problem. So it's changing that mindset from a vet is a problem on farms. How can we make them something that actually can help us drive
our business forward? And how's that going? It's going well actually. So it's, I mean, it's obviously lovely to come today to the Agra Forestry show and talk to lots of groups of people, but it's also really nice working with individual farms and then on a bigger scale, as well as working with people so like Yo Valley and the Woodland Trust to try and just disseminate that information further. It's work that I feel is important and it and it and it makes me happy to be honest. Finlay So that's the main thing. Ben, how do we get to 2050, to the sort of, you know, Vista
that you've described, which sounds quite idyllic, but how do we get there? And idyllic. I don't see it as idyllic. I see it as essential in a way. And I think we need to support new entrants. I think it's the big thing. I mean, we also obviously need to exist, you know, support existing farmers to transition their farming systems. And, you know, we've got more than 1000 people here today who are looking to do exactly that. So I think some of that is happening. There is obviously a role for government and whether they're playing that at the moment or not is is up for debate.
But I think actually we need to be just getting on with it ourselves. And Martin Crawford in his session this morning, he said, you know, we can't wait for government. Actually, this is essential work. You know, diversifying your farms, building resilience in is essential for the future of your farm and for the food system. So we do need to just be getting on with it and, and, and effectively that's what we try and do at the Soil Association is, is try and support farmers and bring new farmers in to do that. But it, it's not easy and, and farming is hard at the moment.
Making a living out of farming is hard because we don't pay enough for food. And I know that's hard if you can't afford food to, to hear someone saying that. But effectively, you know, just because people can't afford things doesn't mean we should then not have our farmers be able to live either. So we do need to be able to not only produce food and make a living from it, but also reinvest in farming businesses. And at the moment, the margins in farming are not enabling farmers to do that. They're barely scraping by. So we, we have to address that somehow. And and if we don't address it
sustainably, it will happen anyway through failures and market. So, so it's going to be interesting, but I think, you know, we all have a role I think to play in starting that transition and the sooner we can start it, the better. Before we wrap up, I just want to ask you both about questions that farmers and, you know, other people who are here today were asking in the sessions that you were at. So I'm going to try and give you a couple of moments just to think about questions that that stuck with you. And Claire, I'm going to come to you first about flies because that was a question that I heard
as I was sort of walking past the idea that some farmers think if they have. You know, more trees and hedges on their farm, they're going to get more flies. Yeah. So a question I often get asked, and I don't know, I think the answer's probably more complex than just this, but I often get told that livestock will get issues with flies when they go under trees. I think it's because we haven't got enough trees in our landscape. And I've certainly seen that on my own farm at home where we've only got like the odd tree in a field and I think all the animals gather under that. We get a build up of fecal matter under that tree and then a result of it, you get a huge increase in flies. And then the animals keep going back to that same shaded area
because it's only one. But if you have 100 cows under one tree, for me, that's going to be a fly issue. If you've got 100 cows under 10 trees and you've got 1000 each, you're going to reduce that fly problem under that, under that individual tree. So yeah, that was being my answer to that. But I think, and the other thing, the other question I remember getting asked, which I just really liked as well, how would you deal with this issue if we were going to be 10° cooler? And I was like, well, exactly the same way. So it's still nature and it's still diversity for me. Whichever way you look at it, I think nature's the answer. It's interesting because of course, sort of certainly looking forward towards 2100, we're expecting that, you know,
big changes may happen with the Gulf Stream. And so having gone through this period of, you know, much greater heat, we may well then snap into, you know, sort of much colder land and, and, and, and weather thereafter. It, it, there's a, a farmer who lives near me who also has a campsite and I, I've, I've gone there with, with my lads And one of the things I always notice on campsites is that they're, they're mowed fairly low and that as soon as you do anything, you get sort of bombarded by flies and mozzies and you know, all that sort of stuff at this particular farm, because it's
much more nature friendly, it's much more regenerative. They have an awful lot of foliage. And so there's an awful lot of long grass, loads of fantastic wildflowers. And then the camping pitches are quite small and they're sort of cut within that. And when I got there, I thought, do you know what, we're likely to get bitten to shreds here. And, and partly because you could just see that there were so many more flies, There were so many more insects, quite a diversity of insects, but we just didn't get bothered at all. And I'm sure that that's just because there was so much else for the flies and the insects to
do. Yeah. No, I would definitely agree with that. I think we have these sort of monoculture fields, don't we? And we don't see, you know, you then get a problem with with pets as a result of that. So if you can have more diversity in there and we see it with another example would be when we use fly products on, on livestock, you know, we have a native fly parasite that literally knocks the top off a nuisance fly egg and lays, it's only an egg inside it and causes absolutely no problem in our livestock whatsoever, but does reduce those. But because it's a family, when you use a family treatment, you then kill the good stuff. So you end up killing the good stuff in favour of in favour of
the bad stuff, sadly. And I think the same would probably go for horticulture as well. So let's just talk about questions that were, you know, that came up in your session, Ben, if there were any that sort of stuck with you, I. Think there were two types of question which actually probably reflect our delegates as a whole. I think so. There was because Martin's got very practical, but also research background. There was some very specific technical question. What do I plant under a chestnut tree? There's not going to be shaded out, you know, so there's that kind of question. And then there was a question around the carbon sequestration
and the food production potential of food for our system. So you got this, both this very specific technical question, but also, you know, looking up to that broader thing and actually how do I design a system that really works? Fantastic. And we can't finish a podcast with you, Claire, without talking about dung beetles. What's the dung beetle population going to be like in 2015? I I hope, I hope it's going to be better. I think sadly the dung beetle population is going to be worse. So I think they, they're being affected by things like all of our insects being affected by climate change as it is at the
moment. So that's going to have potentially massive impacts. I don't want to end on a downer Finlay, but I think I think that is going to be a downer of a question. Hopefully they'll be better on the farm on my farm though, than they are now, which is, yeah, it would be a good thing to see how we manage it, I suppose is the is the key. Well taking your prompt, I don't want to end on a downer either, so both of you just tell me something that makes you feel positive looking to the future. But just how many people are here and therefore interested in agroforestry and therefore going to be making the more most of their trees on farm, which is going to build that diversity
and resilience we talked about? Yeah, I would agree. Just the amount of people here just talking about trees, it's just a really nice thing to come and talk about trees and there's like over 1000 people here or something. So incredible. Yeah, that makes me very, very happy. Claire Whittle, the regenerative vet, and Ben Raskin from the Soil Association thanks so much for joining me.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...