Pathways scenarios are plausible futures for the food system
1 hr 2 minAudio
This is the third of our programmes investigating Pathways - a 5-year EU Horizon 2020-funded research project that's been running since 2021. We discuss the scenarios work that provided the foundations for Pathways. These were designed as plausible future storylines for how European livestock systems might evolve under different economic, environmental, technological, and social conditions. In particular, they helped researchers to test trade-offs between different sustainability goals and outcomes. ffinlo Costain is joined by Pierre-Marie Aubert, director of agriculture and food policies at the French think tank, IDDRI - by Dr Tom Staton, a senior research fellow at the University of Reading - and by Dr Jessica Bosseaux, a postdoctoral research associate, also at the University of Reading.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, welcome to Farmgate. I'm fit Locustane, the editorof8.9.com, the land use news channel. This is the third of our programmes investigating Pathways A5 year EU Horizon 2020 funded research project that's been running since 2021. In this programme we're going to discuss the scenarios work that provided the foundations for pathways. The scenarios were designed as plausible future storylines for how European livestock systems might evolve under different economic, environmental, technological and social conditions. In particular, they helped researchers to test trade-offs
between different sustainability goals and outcomes. 5 scenarios were developed, feed no food, high animal welfare, rural Renaissance, efficiency first and stock free Europe. To discuss them, I'm joined by Doctor Pierre Marie Ober, Director of Agriculture for food Policies that the French Think thank IDRI, by Doctor Tom Staton, a senior research fellow at the University of Reading, and by Doctor Jessica Boseau, A postdoctoral research associate also at the University of Reading. Now, Tom, you're just back from the final Pathways event in Brussels.
What were your key takeaways? I think for me it's just a reminder of how broad ranging the Pathways project is, because in these large continental projects we tend to get focused on our own work and our own models. And then when we come together in these once a year big project meetings, we just realized how much work is going on in the project looking at different aspects of livestock sustainability. Because when we're thinking about the future of livestock sustainability in Europe, there is a lot to consider. So there's the environmental impacts, like the impacts on climate change, biodiversity,
pollution, land use, and there's a whole range of social impacts. There's economic impacts. And then of course, there's food security, which is very high on the policy agenda across Europe because of recent conflicts and geopolitical events. And then there's the whole consumer side in, in terms of the consumer demand for food, which is affordable and nutritious and with high standards of animal welfare. So when we're thinking about the future of livestock in Europe, which is what we're doing in Pathways and what we're talking about today, there's no easy answers, there's no silver
bullets which can address all of these issues simultaneously. And so each future scenario that we've developed in Pathways, which we'll talk about, is good at addressing certain issues, but they all kind of fall short in other areas. So really a key take away for me is thinking about how we can blend the strengths of each of these scenarios going forward and really finding that balance and that middle ground between the scenarios. Yeah. And so moving on to that scenarios work, can you sort of broaden out that overview about the purpose of the scenarios or
the storylines as they're sometimes called within pathways? Yeah. So I think if we if we go back to the aim of the Pathways project, which is essentially to support a transition towards more sustainable livestock production and consumption. But the question is, what does that really look like? And that's very subjective. So, you know, if I were to ask the four of us, what does that look like, I'd get 4 different answers at least. Yeah, at least. Yeah. And so the idea of the scenarios work is to to try to capture some of that range of different viewpoints and visions for the future of livestock
sustainability in Europe. So let's try and get to grips with the detail of the scenarios themselves. And so forgive me, Tom and Jessica, but I'm going to spend the first half of the program with Pierre Marie because he's the sort of the key architect, if you like, of the scenarios work. So Pierre Marie, how did you go about selecting themes for the scenarios? Because I can imagine that there are other topics, for example, nature first or woodland integration that might have thrown up similarly interesting challenges and trade-offs. So how and why did you choose those themes that you landed on? I guess the, the point is that the, the project, the past five
project intending from the very beginning to not be only, you know, researchers thinking and discussing between themselves, but rather a project that really engage with stakeholders on the ground, farmers processes, etcetera. So I mean, the project started in 2022 with practice helps, workshops and multi active platform conversations where we basically asked people that we are joining, OK, what, what's your vision for the life successor in Europe? What would be desirable, what would be feasible, what would be plausible? And so we ended up by the autumn
2022 with like 4 broad IDs where people were saying, hey, I can see one future where efficiency would be leading. I can see one future where evaluated would be leading. I can see a future combining the two. And I can see a future where agroecology would be leading. And I can see a last future where the animal would be the backbone of, you know, the future of the life successor. So we had those kind of five very broad, even not storyline, but, you know, broad IDs of what could be or what should be a driver for the future of the life successor.
And we started from there. And then we had a number of interactions online and then in person within the project with stakeholders from all across the EU to sort of sort of like gradually refine that by trying to kind of, you know, fleshly with the bond and put a little bit more around those ideas. And of course, while doing that, you know, we changed them a little bit gradually. So to get a Long story short, it took us a year and a half from that point where we had the 5 broad visions to get to more details, what we call
storylines. So basically broad stories, pretty much production focused, not talking too much about the demon side and, and really get to the five stories where as I said, the focus is really on like how we would be producing and rearing and transforming animals without paying too much attention on the demon side because we wanted to basically use the demon side as let's say a sensitivity analysis, OK, What kind of demand would be compatible with those kind of evolution in let's say the supply side, the animal side, so
to speak. We'll go on to talking about those scenarios specifically in just a moment, but I'm, I'm really interested because you sort of explain the process, therefore, you know, how the scenarios were landed on, you know, why it was that those things were decided. But of course this was, you know, 3-4, almost five years ago now, certainly five years ago that you started working on these. And, and I wonder how much things have changed, how much the world has changed around you over the course of that five years. Because there's a danger, you know, for you in France of sort of thinking of a sort of France first perspective for me in the
UK, you know, I can think about UK policy, but over the last five years in the UK, things like nature integration, things like agroforestry, they've sort of grown up and become really important parts of the conversation where actually four or five years ago I don't think they would have been. I think we'd probably have come to similar conclusions to the ones that you came to at the time. Then. Do you think that across Europe things have moved or changed at all, and that you might have chosen slightly different scenarios if you were picking them today, or do you think they'd largely be the same?
I think the, the idea of a, let's say nature driven scenario is pretty much part of the agricultural scenario, the feed no food scenario, which is pretty much about building nature within landscapes with animals and and other things. So you're right, we could have put more the focus on trees and agroforestry and all that. That was an option that was discussed actually. But we thought, OK, it still needs to be animal centered so to speak. So the agrophorestry part was like a little bit on the side of that. I think if we were to redo the
scenario exercise now, I guess one of the theme that would emerge much more strongly that it did in the past is this competitiveness question. And that would we would really see the tension between OK, sustainability objectives, you know, broader societal objectives and this competitiveness objective. You said UK first, France first, whatever. I mean at the moment that the Commission is EU 1st and how do we make sure that what is produced in the EU, you know, can compete on global markets and can resist imports from the rest of the world.
So that would probably be one of the, you know, strong ID that would emerge from, you know, another kind of focus group or whatever. Yeah, no, it's really interesting, but it's it's just interesting to sort of hear how society changes because of course, you know, it does and and different things become priorities. So yeah, thank you for that. So let's talk through each of the scenarios individually and let's begin perhaps with the most radical, the most provocative and that's the the stock Free Europe scenario. Talk me through that. What is it and why was this particular scenario needed and what were the key trade-offs that the process unearthed?
I mean, the stock free scenario, the European stock free scenario is rather storyline at this stage. Yeah. I mean, the distinction between the storyline and scenario is that the storyline is basically a set of IDs that are, you know, more or less nicely articulated. The scenario is when you start computing those IDs, so putting some quantitative parameters behind the IDs to put them in the model and then say, OK, what would the life success in Europe look like really if we were to. But the storyline can give birth to two or three scenarios because there are many ways you can translate, you know, narratives into quantitative
parameters. The model, right. So the stock free storyline emerged as OK, we are missing something. We are missing sort of a counterfactual that would tell us basically what are we missing if at some point we lose all the animals we have. So I guess the idea was not to say this is miserable, but rather this is something we need to have in the scope to really see what animals are bringing to landscapes, nature, society, economy, etcetera, etcetera. But I should add that that was
highly debated. I mean, like many colleagues, many stakeholders were like, what the hell, I don't even want this. I don't want want to see this because it will give IDs to other people. But we were like, wow, that's very interesting because we are all, we were quite kind of all very sure that this scenario would yield results that make it not very desirable. So we are quite confident that it was a nice thing to do, rather, not to say we don't need livestock, but rather hey look, we really need animals. And you say, you know, that
there was sort of pushback within the team, and I can imagine that there was. But at the same time, you know, this is something that NGOs are pushing for, certainly, you know, not all NGO, but certainly some campaigning organisations are pushing for and some commentators within that. So it's important, as you say, to think, think through the benefits of livestock and what would be absent if if they weren't there. And I know that this was an extreme scenario. It was a counterfactual as you say, and you've talked about not focusing too much on the demand side. But I wonder whether you consider the acceptability of this from a a European business
and citizen perspective, how society might reject or arrive at a stock free food system. Well, I think that I wouldn't even dare to raise that question in a political conversation. I mean, like we've been working at Ely with many of the colleagues at feeble part of the pathway project, you know, to discuss in a sort of like peaceful manner about, you know, how to get people eating a little bit less animal source foods, you know, for global justice reasons, for another
reasons, whatever reasons. And I mean, I've been, you know, in many hearings in the open parliaments, in the Irish parliament, in the French Parliament, as soon as you start saying, hey, look, guys, there would be some value in in trying to get people, you know, gently, not forcing them, but to go towards less and better at my source food. You know, the level of pushback you get is like that high. So discussing in in in terms of setting about a stock free Europe is for me probably something unthinkable. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And, and I guess you know,
within that I was sort of thinking, I mean, precisely as you were saying that there is, there's so much pushback that actually the only way of getting there would be through incredible political polarisation and, and, you know, quite significant state control over the food system, which would not be popular with with very many people. So the efficiency first scenario is probably the scenario that's most diametrically opposed to the stock for a Europe storyline. So this is focused on maximizing feed efficiency to produce as much animal protein as possible. Can you tell me a bit more about that scenario?
Yeah. Well, I guess as I said, there are many ways in which you can model efficiency. First, depending on what assumptions you put on the demand side and whether you consider that scenario through, let's say your market equilibrium model. So basically where supply and demand are dynamically linked through markets or whether you model that storyline with a biomass balance scenario where you basically you are the special planner and you decide, you know how much you produce and how when you do model an efficiency for scenario via a
market based model, you know what you get at the end of the day is exactly what you said. Basically you maximize put in prediction because basically efficiency gains most of the time comes with productivity gains. So basically you are able to produce, you know quite significant and increase the prediction. And in a market based model you basically increase the prediction, you decrease the prices, you increase the consumption and you increase exports, right. So that's what happens in an efficiency first scenario model through a market based model, which means that basically you
have a very well known rebound effect where basically your efficiency gains are lost because you have an increase in total production. If then you model the efficiency for scenario with the biomass balance model where you decide how much you produce, you can easily go to a sort of like land sparing scenario where basically you have massive efficiency gains that if not accompanied by an increase in the demand, translates into, you know, gains in the land use, gains in emissions of whatever greenhouse gases, gains in manual
management problems, etcetera, etcetera. And that is what, you know, many colleagues like Greens and others advocating for land spring, you know, philosophy have been adverticating for. But the reality is that it's not the world in which we are. So that's, you know, that's where we get to. Yeah. And I guess it's sort of particularly important when we come to some of those futures scenarios to kind of compare these different scenarios to get the trade-offs, isn't it? Because that's where again, we sort of get to grips with the whole land sparing, land sharing discussion and whether in and how to deliver the greatest level of, of efficiency within
those systems. And, and for me, it's always seemed that you've got to have a combination of things that land sparing as such is just inherently inefficient because you're only using land for one thing. Whereas if you can layer up a whole load of different things onto that land, it's delivering XY and Z, then that you know, surely is, is it's a better approach. But it seems to me that by and large the the efficiency approach in addition to sort of supporting that land sparing approach, that it's essentially a description of business as usual and sustainable intensification, you know, as we've understood it over the last decade or so.
Do you think that's fair? Yeah, I think it's totally fair. And I mean, the interactions we had with stakeholders in France, in Europe, in other countries are, you know, pretty much aligned with that in the sense that in most of the sectors, because I mean, livestock sectors is obviously the meal sector is different from the beef sector, etcetera, etcetera. But by large and far, as you said, conventional actors were really happy to see themselves to project themselves into a efficiency for scenario because that's what they've been doing basically for the last decades or so. And and they see quite easily how they could convert those
efficiency gains into competitiveness gains. So for them, you know, fair enough, let's go for that. And last thing, I guess one of the big challenge behind the efficiency for scenario which also makes it very close to business as usual scenario is that it would not go against what we can call the commodification process of meat and dairy products. It would continue to see and you know, consider all type of animal source foods as commodities that you need to produce by reducing as much as
you can your production cost. Which means amongst other things, making sure that you have concentrated supply shed production systems. Well. So basically concentrating animals in the same place to reduce transport, transport costs, moving milk to the dairies or meat to the houses. And that in turn comes with massive problems of like nitrogen surpluses and animal welfare, etcetera, etcetera, right? And I would imagine that the other sort of element around that is that if you've got an efficiency first system, which is relying quite a lot on technology to be able to
deliver, you know, any of the environmental games or the social games that are associated with those systems. Then there's the potential for patented technology and that sort of thing, which then governments quite like because they, they, they can envision them being sold on a global level and therefore bringing money, money into the exchequer in different ways as well. So there is this sort of interesting into linkage, isn't there, between that efficiency first scenario and the way that the government funds. Very often it's, it's research funding. One of the things that I really like about the scenarios is that they're really quite clear and they're really, they're simple
and straightforward to understand. And very helpfully on the Pathways website, you've got sort of 1 pages describing these various different scenarios as well. And on the efficiency first one pager on the key policy recommendations, there's a term that's in astral ecology approach. You couldn't just explain that for me, could you? I guess the idea behind that is that, as I was saying, the efficiency first would in any case rely on concentrated livestock from a special point of view. And so this could only work, so to speak, from another point of
view. If you manage to recycle all, you know, the byproducts, so to speak, of the lifestyle systems, so manure and how you manage to feed, etcetera. And so we have good examples of the practice hub level. So what we call the practice hubs are basically those hubs where we gathered stakeholders from the lifestyle value chains. And we had a few examples across the EU, in Denmark, in Britain, in France, where, you know, at the slaughterhouse level, you not only have, you know, animals being slotted, but you also have a whole system of recycling the manure.
So basically producers are are asked not only to bring the animals, but also the manure. And this means that they are very close from the store, the house, and then the manure is like dried and transforms into whatever kind of organic fertilizers. And then, you know, sense away from the territory to avoid those massive natural surpluses that we're talking about. So you have this whole kind of like ecological engineering of all the byproducts and all the different aspects of the physical processes that we try that stakeholders try to manage to limit all the side effects of
this very high concentration livestock systems. Yeah, interesting. And we've been having that discussion actually just recently in the UK because of course there there's, you know, the sort of limits on the amount of fertilizer that can be imported at the moment, in particular because of the situation around the Strait of Hormuz. And so they've been conversations about whether fertilizer itself should be subsidised, for example, or whether we shouldn't find ways around the, you know, the big intensive chicken units around the River Wye for example, of of harnessing that manure, making sure that it can be sold off. And then again, we talk about
those sort of synergies and trade-offs between systems because then you've you're sort of creating a dependency on these, these large chicken units in order to then fuel a more agroecological transition in the East where livestock don't exist and where, you know, that fertilizer can be replaced by more organic fertilizer. It's, it's all fascinating stuff. There are three more pathway scenarios and I just want you, let's talk through those before we start sort of comparing them. And I wonder if you could talk me through the key features and learnings from the high animal welfare storyline. So the high animal welfare storyline, as Tom said earlier, is really decided that we, we
put the animal at the forefront of the, of the whole sector. Meaning that the idea is that we, we give, we, we create systems at the farm level, at the house level, at the Daily Devil, where really animals can express its behaviors, can have more choices, so to speak. And that comes with, so to speak, radical changes and the way animal are rare, you know, transported and then slaughtered. I should say to to to be very honest that it has been quite difficult to model Percy. The high animal welfare scenario
because we basically don't have any references to put figures behind what those systems would look like neither at the farm level nor at the slaughterhouses level nor at the, you know, transportation level. So it's been something if you look at the results for example of the market based modelling exercise that we did for pathways, there is differences between animal welfare and the business as usual scenario are not that you know clear precisely because the team you know struggles to really see okay, where do I implement
changes in the model, what does it mean really et cetera. So we did try to do that with French stakeholders at a sort of lower level, so to speak. And the reasons we are quite challenging because we basically just to give an example, we did decide with the poultry sector in France to say, OK, let's assume that all half, I think it was half, half of all the chicken raised in France would become European chicken commitments, you know, compliant.
Yeah, at that level. And and then we calculated what it would mean because we had the references in terms of pushing cost at the farm level. And then we, you know, made some very rough assumptions at the sort of house level. And the stakeholders with whom we were discussing about that scenario said, hey, but we won't bring any changes into the market dynamic because we don't believe anything can change. And the result was that prediction in France would drop
by largely 3050%, import would go up because basically the rest of the world would continue in the way in which they produce. And so we would become not competitive enough. So I think that was quite interesting to see that whatever the scenario and for that scenario in particular, because it's the most radical probably if you don't reflect your ambition into whatever trade measures or market measures, it's really complicated in the world in which we live. So, so what's the sort of key finding, I guess there that this
was something that was intensely difficult to do at a national level because other nations, whether those were the European nations or, or other nations around the world would, would sort of step in to fill that void because of the demand still exist, yeah. Interesting. Exactly. Yeah, because I mean, just to, to put it very simply, with the same, let's say the same size, the same farm size in poultry, if you go for very high animal welfare standards, your level of prediction just is just cut by two or even 3 depending on the standards you get.
So basically your total production would go down while production costs would go up. And so just sort of working on the basis for a moment, I suppose that that, you know, there was a way of having a border around around this policy and that, you know, high animal welfare was delivered across Europe and there were there weren't going to be imports sort of coming in to fill that void. Was there going to be an impact on the availability of of protein, for example, for poorer European citizens? Was there a sort of an expectation that that meat, for example, or, you know, certain
cheeses would become become the preserve of of the middle classes and and the richer sort of elements of the population? I. Mean that's for sure, assuming that, you know, the the markets protected and that, you know, adopting the students would not lead to massive imports. Prices would go up, that's clear, and availability would go down and the 2GO together of of obviously. And I guess we should not, you know, underestimate how much less animal source food you can produce if you really want to respect, let's say, animal choices.
So indeed, that raises the question of like, well, for whom meat and dairy products remain affordable. And there's such a scenario, right? And is that something that we should care about? Definitely, yes. But I guess it directly points to the question of the difficult question of the needs, right? In the sense that basically consuming 76 between 65 and 75 grams of animal proteins a day has nothing to do with our needs. We need probably like 25 to 40
grams depending on who we are, what age we have, etcetera, etcetera, which basically means that even though it would become, you know, more expensive and we will, we would be less able to buy it for most of the population, that would not lead to any nutritional problems. While at the same time, if this is accompanied by a drop or at least you know, incentives to buy more fruits and veg, you know, which we really miss in our daily diets, that would only be good for all of us from a
health perspective. So that's a little bit the challenge. And we did some calculation on that at the French level again. And what we showed was that to you, you could think about a world where all the households from the poorest to the richest would eat 20 to 30% less animal source foods, eating 50% more fruits and veg, while assuming, you know, 20% increase in unit prices of the product. And you would still be able to afford your, you know, food basket with the smallest same price with no increase in
prices. So that that shows that it's not only about prices, but it's all about also about, you know, choice households habits and purchasing willingness. Whatever. Yeah, That's really fascinating. And it's a conversation that we've had on the podcast at various different points over the last few years. And it's really interesting to hear the way that you framed it there, that even if food prices go up, the cost of a food basket can remain the same depending on the different dietary choices that people are making within that now. And Tom and Jessica, thanks for so much for being patient. And I know that, you know, we're spending a lot of time with PM
Marie here, but I think, you know, going through these scenarios before we sort of discuss them together is really, really interesting in the first instance and important as well. So there's two to go. And the scenario that focuses perhaps most strongly on biodiversity and agroecology is the feed no food scenario where livestock are primarily grazed on grass and fed on waste products if they're monogastrix. The aim is to optimize food production for human consumption rather than growing food specifically to feed livestock. Could you just talk me through the storyline, the primary
features, why it's important, what the key trade-offs are? So indeed, as you said, to feed no food scenario is probably the most agrological scenario that we developed. And I I think we didn't call it like that because we wouldn't we really wanted it to be. As I said again, animals focused animal sentence. Also from the from the title point of view, As for animal welfare, we should not underestimate the effects of feeding animals with no food competitive food stuff. It has dramatic consequence on
how much that you can produce and it has a 2 fold effect. Basically the first effect is that you know how much byproducts and non food competitive feed stuff is available means that you cannot feed as many animals as we do today. So you have less animals. But the other thing is that let's be very clear as well. The quality of the feed from a productivity point of view is lower. So the the animal productivity so to speak. So the amount of meat, milk or eggs that is produced pair anymore is lower. So you have this twofold effect and I mean depending on how you
model it, what assumptions you make, etcetera. But you get to a world where or to a European life successor where pension is decreased has decreased by between 30 and 50%, right. That's the, that's the hard truth, so to speak, or the hard calculations we we got to in such a scenario, which is, you know, similar to a high demand welfare scenario. When you say that, I'm just sort of wondering around, even though there's a reduction and the perhaps the amount of meat and dairy that's coming from those animals. I'm wondering whether you looked
at nutritional levels? Because I think one of the things that I hear a lot from regenerative farmers is that they think that the nutritional contents, the value of the food that's being produced is much greater than it would be. And therefore you potentially need less of it to get the nutritional value. Yeah, well, I guess overall you definitely don't need to eat as much animal protein as we eat today. So, you know, whatever the quality of that animals false food, you know, eating less of those is, is not modeling itself for anyone. Again, 70g compared to the 30 to 50 grams we need a day.
So you can cut by half. So without any problems there. And I guess yeah, that that's true that from the dairy and beef point of view, it's been shown that grass fed animals produce meat and dairy products that are of higher neutral quality on fatty acids, composition, etcetera. That's true. And that's that's great. But, but, but I think it, it could be an argument, but we, we should put that in a broader context of like, well, the fact that we don't need as much animal product as we eat today. Yeah. And I remember the work that you
did a few years ago, which, you know, was around the whole sort of agroecology question as well. I think it was can agroecology Feed Europe was the essential question that you were addressing. And you later transposed that to the UK as well with the Food Farming and Countryside Commission. And my memory is that the answer was basically, yes, agroecology can feed Europe, no problem there. But as we've just been discussing, diets would have to change. And I'm just wondering, you know, not just about diets, but how value chains would shift within the feed no food scenario. So we, we also did some further
calculations about that and I, I guess it speaks again to this question of animal concentration, special concentration that I mentioned earlier. If you go for a feed no food scenario, you basically would have animals, you know, scattered all over the Europe instead of being concentrated here and there in Brittany, the Mark, Netherlands, etc. And islands. Which basically means that the very structure of logistic chains, value chains would have to change and the facilities as well. There is other houses, I mean as they are today has basically nothing to do so to speak with
the reality of a feed no food scenario. There are way too large way to automatize for the kind of production system we would have in the future. So in that sense we did with my colleague Michael Esquerbo, we, we did try to figure out what it would mean if France would go towards a fully feed no food scenario. And the result is that it would basically lead most of the largest slaughterhouses and dairies to, you know, quit the market because transport costs are basically too important and
are more important than the economies of scale you can make by staying big while being remotely located with the DDD demos. And that would also lead to smaller units to be recreated closer to the animals in the massive central island, wherever, wherever you look at that. So we, we had a specially explicit model that that was, you know, that enabled us to, to really characterize that. But overall that that's again, some sort of a, you know, difficult thing to handle.
It's also that the number of jobs and the overall value generated by the the sexual would go down quite significantly by 30 to 50%. And again, so that's, that's not an easy story to tell to the world and to policy makers and stakeholders. So that's something that we usually don't want to consider that much because we say, hey, it's less and better. Wow, it's less and better, yes, from an algorithm point of view, but from a mechanic point of view it might be less and less. That's interesting because I think the way that I've always sort of thought about it and,
and you know, perhaps your numbers there are, are telling a different story is that if you know, for example, thinking about the UK, if the murder did feel abattoir, which is, you know, pretty enormous, we're to close and we were to see a, a resurgence of small infrastructure, a small abattoirs, then you're actually creating more jobs as a result of that. They're being displaced and they're being moved around. And so I, I guess it's arguable, isn't it, depending on, depending on exactly what that solution is and what the, the infrastructure response is. And I guess that brings us, doesn't it to the rural renaissance scenario, which is, which is looking at the the way
in which livestock can contribute to a a renewed rural economy, to a strong rural economy, which which frankly, you know, doesn't exist in that many places I don't think around Europe at the moment. So what's the purpose of this storyline? Again, the key elements. What were the main challenges that you identified here? Let let me come back to the point you made just before very quickly. I, I think the question you're, you're raising with like whether relocating about war would be good or not, whatever it has to do with what we can call the labour intensity of the processing. And what is true is that in the dairy sector, depending on in
what which pipes you send the day the the the milk, you basically have very contrasted labor intensity. So you can have a decoupling between volumes and value in jobs. In the dairy sector that is true. You can have like 20% less milk and the same amount of value and jobs created right in the mid sector when you have an animal, you stutter it and you get into pieces full stop. So it doesn't matter that much if you have a bigger trois or small 1, you have like nearly like 5 to 10% difference in labor intensity, not more. Which means that if you decrease the volumes, you decrease the
values and the number of jobs even, you know, not that much because you know, you, you have this slight difference in labor intensity. That being said, it relates very much to the reward renaissance scenario. That is why, you know, I, I, I was keen to, to make the point because the reward Renaissance scenario again was not that easy to model because there are many ways in which you can translate the story into quantitative parameters and into a scenario depending on like again, what model you use and, and what all the stakeholders are on the table, right. So the way in which we did that in in the French exercise, which
was a bit different from what was done at the at the EU level with the market based model, was that we we assume that if we want the livestock sector to play this central role in rural economies, it probably needs to be very different from one place to another place. There are places where you would still have, let's say, commodity focused production systems from the farm to the other tour to the Davis. And there are some places where basically the only way in which the life successor can thrive is to have high value added is to
produce high value added products, you know, towards niche markets and stuff. So basically in the way in which we have modelled it, the rural Renaissance scenario is a bit of a mix between feed, no food and efficiency. First, in the sense that where you have capacities, skills and potential to do, let's say commodities, you do them and you improve them the way in which you produce them, etc. And where you have, you know, capacities to do this kind of like high value product, you do them, but you increase how much
you do and, and, and you improve the the overall quality of that. This in a context where, I mean, we should be very clear about that. Even though the European Union puts the emphasis strongly on the fact that we have an excellent livestock sector, blah, blah, blah. Our ability in many countries and in French in particular, to really sell our products to the rest of the world under the banner of excellence has weakened over the last few years because, you know, the rest of the world does not necessarily continue to want that. They have their own way of producing this and that and that. So the only ones that are really able to do that at the moment in
Europe are the Italians, you know. So, so just to say that real Renaissance assumes that there is also demand for both types of products, the communities and let's say the high quality projects from whatever point of view. And that's not necessarily the case today. So the real Renaissance scenario is also one scenario that relies on a certain, in a certain sense, on an evolution of the demand, both the domestic demand at the EU plus UK level, but also of the world demand, because there would be a need for the rest of the world to be
interested in those kind of projects. The way that you're describing that, it's slightly different, I think to the way that I'd imagined it because I'd, I'd sort of imagined it being much more closely linked to I, I suppose to that sort of agroecological feed, no food. But the, but you're talking about it being a combination of, of both that and the efficiency first. And, and in that way, it feels like it's a, it's, it's kind of a bridge towards the feed, no food, a bridge towards the agroecological model where, you know, we've got to get there. We already have the infrastructure set up in the way that it is. So how do we move from, from one
to the other? And, and that would be one way of doing it. And of course, towards the end of your answer there, you were sort of coming towards those, those, those sort of financial model elements. And I'm guessing that for this storyline to work to manifest itself, we'd need to see a significant shift in where the profit goes, wouldn't we? The the idea of profit moving away at least a little from retail shareholders, for example, and back towards the farm gate, there's sort of, you know, profit moving back down the value chain. Are there any downsides to that? Well, I guess the question is,
is how much do we understand about the value distribution across value chains. I mean, there is there is this idea that farmers are the ones that are the least, so to speak, you know, remunerated for, for what they produce while downstream the chains you have big shareholders, you know, making a lot of profits, et cetera, et cetera. We've made some stupid calculations just to kind of like try to objectify that a little bit and looking at a big dairy company that I would not name here that is making a lot of profits, right. And we did divided the overall
profit made by the company by the number of farmers that are supplying the company. And at the end of the day, even though all the profits were redistributed to farmers, it would mean roughly €1000 more per year. You're not going to do the transition with thousand €1000 more on your farm a year, right? You need more than that. So I think we should be very clear about the fact that there are two different problems. There is one problem, which is that of, let's put it like that, social justice, how equitable is our food system? And we need to address that problem. But we should not believe that
once that problem will be addressed, all the rest will be solved. I think those are two different problems. My understanding is that at the moment, what is putting pressure on farmers and volition actors alike has probably a bit to do with an equal Power Distribution across the chain. Fair enough. But also with the fact that as we've been discussing, all those products, meat and dairy products are basically commodities for 90% of the market, meaning that at at some point you need to align with world market prices. When you know that the Thai producers, the Brazilian
producers, they are able to produce 1 kilogram of poultry with like 30 to 40% lower approaching cost, you can easily understand how difficult it is for all the Virginian actors from the farmer to Salter houses to the potatoes to realign with that. And the reality is that we still have like 30% trade tariffs on poultry in Europe because basically if we were to have like 0 tariffs, we were a bit, we would basically be eating Brazilian and Thai poultry.
And that's, you know, that's the situation. So I think we should, you know, there is the market, there is the very change question, but there is also the, the, let's say the market economy question, which is probably as important as the former. And, and I think within that, I was sort of getting the impression as well that, you know, it, it's not just about farmers and the shareholders that there's an awful lot of of people in between. So if, for example, we were, you know, shifting to a situation where an awful lot of that profit was being held on farm because the farmers were doing their own processing and their own marketing and all this sort of stuff, then then actually
there's a whole impact on the jobs that are higher up the value chain, but below the shareholders themselves. And so, you know, understanding that impact on the economy alongside everything else, you know, is it would be, you know, and is really interesting. So we've heard outlines there, haven't we? For for the five different scenarios, each individually interesting in their own right of of course, but what do we do with them? What do we do with them now? How do we put them together within the Pathways project? Yeah, I mean, what we've been trying to do. And yesterday Tom spoke about the, the, the, the government we had in Brussels.
I mean, the European Union is preparing. So-called livestock strategy whereby the idea is to give visions and guidelines for how policy makers at the national and EU level should treat the livestock sector in terms of subsidies, in terms of regulations etcetera, etcetera. What what we've been trying to do with the Pathway project and all our organizations involving the project has been to really help and support policymakers in designing this livestock strategy so as to reflect some of our findings at least in how
subsidies will be, you know Petro farmers, what regulations should be given the priority etcetera, etcetera. So that's the one of the thing that we have been trying to do with Pathways. The other thing being that I guess I hope at least that with pathways we've tried to take, you know, I don't like that much at all, but to take a sort of a holistic or systemic view on the life successor. And, and we're trying to really get that into further future research and trying to get our colleagues from other universities, from other research centers to really take
step back and stop, you know, looking only at OK efficiency gains at the animal level, but rather, OK, how does this efficiency gain fit into a broader evolution of the whole sector? Thanks so much for that. I think that's it. It's been really interesting hearing about the work that you've been doing and and that conversation that we've been having, PM Marie through those different scenarios. But Tom, just bringing you in, as we discussed in a previous episode, your interest is in biodiversity and monitoring biodiversity. How do the scenarios help you to think about the trade-offs
between food production and nature? Yes, I think this comes back a bit to the land sparing versus land sharing debate that you we touched on earlier. And we can definitely see efficiency first as being a good example of land sparing in that agricultural land is focused on maximizing efficiency and productivity. And the other non agricultural land, if we maintain the same output, we can then spare other land for for nature conservation. Whereas the Feed no food and Royal Renaissance really are more of an integration of
biodiversity into farming systems and so hence more of a land sharing approach. So I think you can see these different, different ways of integrating biodiversity and agriculture. But of course this is. This is taking quite a simplified and polarised view to some degree and it's I don't think that it's 11 approach is better than the other and then sparing and sharing have advantages in certain contexts. So there's some important biodiversity habitats that are not really suitable for
agricultural production like wetlands. There's others like semi natural species rich Grafton's which very much are reliant on livestock, albeit at quite a low production output. Both approaches have advantages in certain contexts and so it's about finding that right, that right balance and the right context between man sparing and sharing. And similarly in the pathway scenarios about finding that right balance and what works, what works well in different contexts. So again, just reiterating that point that there isn't 1A1 size
fits all solution here, but it's about finding that right, that right blend and the right context. Yeah, it's interesting. And I wonder how one goes about using the different scenarios and and blending them fairly because I'm sort of thinking about this from a policy perspective. And you know, before I was working as the editorof8.9.com and was primarily, you know, sort of working within the policy world. I can imagine looking at these different scenarios and cherry picking the bits that seem to work best for me and using them to to make my arguments. So I can sort of see from the
efficiency first that there are certain elements that I ought to be drawing out and from the the feed no food. There might be other elements to draw out in order to help build a picture of rule renaissance, for example. Is that how you expect people to use this and this and, and how, and I guess, I guess the question is, really is that an appropriate use of the scenarios? Do you think Tom, or should we be looking and and combining them, blending them in a different way? No, I think that that does make sense. I think there is a need for for some regional differences. I mean, Europe is a big place and there's different cultures
and contexts and climates within that. So in certain member states in the EU and other non EU countries, different approaches might be better suited to those contexts. So yeah, I think picking out the strengths of each scenarios works, but also taking account of those regional differences in the local contexts and local cultures and and societies. Now, Jessica, you're quite new to the Pathways projects. I wonder, you know, you come to the scenarios fairly late in the day, I guess in the same way that I have. And I wonder what you find most
compelling about the scenarios. So yeah, as you said, I I just joined the project, so I'm still discovering a lot of things in the in the scenarios. So far, what I find the most interesting about the scenarios is that they are built on the three core concepts of pathways and they are both complementary and transdisciplinary, which is both things that I have done in the past. So you have the sustainability trade-offs, which will be one of my focus, the leverage points with the reconnect, rethink and restructure and then the one welfare. And I think what's powerful here
is that it goes beyond all of the classic triple bottom line sustainability, you know, approach. So we capture the complexity of the livestock systems and we include positive and negative consequences that can be direct or indirect. So as we just said, none of the scenario is ideal or realistic, let's say. But they give some trends and they give some tools to what we may face in the future because as just Tom said as well, we
have various places, various policies, and I guess we will use those as tools to respond to some challenges that may be faced in the future. And from the personal note, let's say I'm very glad to work on the animal welfare parts because I think here it's treated as a unique dimension, distinct dimension of sustainability and not gathered in across environmental and social. Sometimes it's kind of in the background. And this time it's like really one of the focus. So as Pierre Mahi said, we do not know what we're going to
face. We don't have realistic data of managing differently the animal welfare across livestock. But this is a really good stone like on this future architecture of what will be the food systems, because we we questions how we can do without the animals or differently with the animals. And I think it's a very important question that we start really questioning and answering with that project. So yeah, I just joined the project, but already struck by the depth of the analytical work that has been done. And yeah, it's quite remarkable.
Yeah. And and also it probably enhanced greatly by you know working with the pharma groups around Europe as well. So there is the agricultural underpinning and then the architecture over, over and above that from an intellectual standpoint. Now one of your study interests is around land use impacts a long the life cycle of food products. Do you think the scenarios can help you to better understand impacts there? Yeah. So land use has been one of my focus in my previous research. It's a very valuable tool to capture a lot of different indicators along the life cycle and for food products.
But here we can have a complete complementary approach as well with other types of like geosol for example that have been used. So I think thanks to the scenarios, we'll have a better understanding what could be the land use impact and try to assess land use consequences in the future according to what sort of policy or maybe just decisions if it's at farm levels or business level. I think it will be really interesting to compile it with the Geosol analysis and try to
to see both type of consequences that can have not only from the sustainable environmental impact, but also having the nitrogen flows and something a bit more biological, let's say the nutrient cycle. Combining those two methodologies, I think will be very valuable to understand the land use and the consequences of the farming systems we will develop. So yeah, definitely. Now, Tom, I wonder whether you could tell me a bit about how the pathways data modelling work, not just your own, but broadly interacts with the scenarios.
Because we've talked about the way in which, you know, I've just mentioned there the pharma practice hubs, you know, key part of the pathways work. We've got the scenarios work, the data modelling that we talked about in a previous episode. So how does the data modelling fit within all of this other stuff? So yeah, I guess there's there's two kind of ways to think about the scenarios. We can think about them in a more qualitative way by talking about them with stakeholders. And there's a lot of value in that because there's a lot of things that are quite difficult to model, like cultures and societies and power dynamics. But there's some things that we
can model that are based on hard numbers, things like greenhouse gas emissions, GDP, protein production. So these are things that we can we can model, and those models are perfect, but we can come up with good estimates. And so we've used various modelling approaches to compare the five scenarios we've been talking about, and we've used a variety of different models to provide different perspectives. So different models will do different things, look at the system in different ways and at different scales from the farm scale to more continental scales.
And then in pathways we've we've then brought these together at a high level to try to deliver some key messages about what the strengths and trade-offs of each scenario are. So in terms of the models, we've done a life cycle assessment that you've just been talking about. So that includes both environmental and social impacts. We've used an economic model which works at a global scale. So it looks at things like trade and how how the system level economics changes and also a more spatial and nitrogen balance and food production
models. That's the GSO model that Jessica just mentioned. So these all look at the scenarios in different ways, different outcomes, and to give you a high level overview of what the models found. And this is very high level because of course, once you get into the nitty gritty, there's also lots of nuances. There's differences between livestock species and differences between regions and things. But being very general at a very high level, we found that the food, no food was very strong for environmental impacts in terms of lowering environmental impacts of production,
particularly in terms of when we measure it by the unit of land area, as you might expect, it wasn't so great generally for the economic impacts and for and for production. The high animal welfare scenario was quite strong for social impacts and economically it was reasonably strong, but it does come with relatively high environmental impacts per production unit just because it's, it's the animal was front and centre of the production system. So it's not not the most efficient. Then the rural renaissance was quite strong for economics,
particularly as you might expect, the rural economy like wages in the agricultural sector, it was relatively productive, not the best for environmental impacts. It was relatively middle when we compared the scenarios to each other. And then efficiency first, as you might expect was best for production as strong economically with low environmental impacts per production unit. But when we look at environmental impacts per land area, so if we keep the same area of land for livestock production and convert it all to efficiency first, we're producing a lot more that we're
having a lot more environmental impact as you might expect. And then the stockless was this quite extreme scenario where it had strong environmental improvements in terms of reducing greenhouse gas emissions when we remove livestock, of course, but it was fairly disastrous in terms of economic impacts. So I think that gives you a bit of a flavour that all of the scenarios have certain strengths, but they all come with with certain trade-offs as well. Yeah, I'm interested in the way in which the different elements of the projects mesh together.
Because there's a sort of a chicken and egg situation here where there's a degree to which the use of the modelling depends on the scenarios being developed. And and perhaps there's, you know, a degree to which the the reverse is true as well. But if we take, for example, the modelling work or the metrics work that Jenny Inverson was talking about on a previous podcast around farm animal welfare, there is it the case that that the kind of metrics that she was arriving at. And if you remember, she'd taken, you know, thousands of animal welfare metrics and boiled them down to, you know, around 20 iceberg metrics for
different, different farm animal species that were telling us a range of different aspects, whether those were social or environmental, including the welfare aspects. Were you taking those and then applying them to the different scenarios in a sort of specific and studied way or or was it, you know, sort of less precise than that? That was a challenge in that each scenario had to be had to be quantified in terms of numbers. And you know, all models have assumptions or models require inputs. So you know, we have this a text qualitative description of a scenario and then we have to
convert that into some kind of numeric form which we can use as as model inputs. So yeah, that was a bit of an iterative process and it was we had modelling workshops to decide on on how to do that. But yeah, there are of course some options that come with that in all the models, so there is detail there. Yeah, Now I'm a big fan. I, I was a very big fan of the rural Renaissance scenario before the conversation now and I sort of understood that it's slightly more of the efficiency first element. I particularly liked it when I thought it was primarily Agri ecological. But but Even so, it feels as
though those last three storylines that we talked through, the rural Renaissance, the feed, no food and the high animal welfare, they're actually quite complementary to each other. Yeah, I think, I think they are to a degree. And I think a lot of people, people do see the Royal Renaissance as quite an idyllic scenario. So you're not alone there. And I think, yeah, there are complementarities and taking animal welfare, for example, I think that's very compatible with the female food and Royal Renaissance scenarios. And to some extent, I think our modelling results back that up.
And if we take efficiency first as the other scenario, I think that is quite different in that when we modelled that scenario, that was the only scenario that improve self-sufficiency in food in the EU in 20-50. And that's comparing the scenarios to a business, a projected business as usual in 20-50. But I think there are also some key differences between those scenarios. And perhaps the starkest difference is in the feed new food where we see the the pork and poultry sectors declining very strongly. There's quite a big difference.
Whereas of course, pork and poultry are much more compatible with rural Renaissance and high animal welfare, albeit at lower densities, as PM was saying. And I think there's also, when we think about the transitions towards these scenarios, then efficiencies first probably stands out as slightly different to the others in terms of being, as you were saying earlier, probably the closest to the business as usual in terms of where the sector is heading with agritech developments and specialization and scale. Whereas the other 3, Royal Renaissance, speedy food and high animal welfare do present
some some more difficult barriers in terms of always going against some of the the current trends of the food system. And that's not to say that we should forget about them because they're too difficult, because I think they have their real advantages in in certain contexts and they do have a role to play, but perhaps more difficult to scale up. Now, PM Marie, we're coming towards the end of the program, but I wonder whether you can maybe reflect on the scenarios work that you've been involved in over the last five years and the Pathways project more broadly. And I wonder how you hope that the work is going to be used in the wider world by campaigners
or by the media, ultimately by policy makers themselves. I guess there are there are three points of of third different nature that I'm hoping will be used and reflected upon by by various stakeholders. One thing is that we've shown with pathways or at least we've tried to demonstrate that you need good enough approaches from a methodical point of view to really identify the trade-offs associated to different trajectories of change for sector. Because it's only on that basis that you can discuss with a variety of stakeholders about OK, where are potential
synergies, where are trade-offs? And if they are trade-offs, if they are losers, how can we compensate theirs etcetera, etcetera. Because at the moment those conversations are basically occurring on the basis of virtually nothing because you have only partial analysis of the transformation to the sector. And so it's it's just who is going to shout the louder, who's going to win the fight, you know in a way which is not the the nicest way to design policies. So that's the one thing. The second thing which is similar in nature to my first point is that even even though we did provide researchers in
policy because with like EU wide molding and results. What we essentially say is that as Tom was saying a number of times, there is no one-size-fits-all logic or answer. And it has to be brought down so to speak to the territorial level where it makes sense where our livestock system can really develop and you know express its strengths on weaknesses. So what we are saying essentially with pathways and what we are hoping people to do is that not trade-offs and synergies at the meta level, the EU level, the national level, but rather bring that down to,
you know, broad territories and, and you know, try to discuss, to have constructive conversations on where do we want to go. And the third thing, which is kind of a different nature, is that I hope that with the work that has been done with the biomass balance modelling, we can demonstrate that, you know, the circularity dimension of the livestock sector is a backbone of any kind of more, let's say, sustainable for desirable livestock sector. And if circularity is to be valued, so to speak, it has massive implications for all the
transformations of the future transformations of the sector. And that needs to be reflected somewhere, even though again, this will need to be tailored to each specific territories. But I hope that we've proven that circular, that this circularity dimension is a critical pillar for future life success. Systems fantastic. That's, that's really fascinating. And Jessica, just a couple of questions to you to bring us to the end. I know that agricultural economics are also something that are important. In terms of your own research and based on the scenarios you know and the and your understanding of them, where do
you think the most exciting economic opportunities exist in the future of food systems within Europe? So in past, I will be looking at how to like magnet and market equilibrium model can capture how farm, farm level changes ripple out to add into prices, trade flows, adjustments where the most exciting opportunities lie. I think we need to be careful about this time frame because all these scenarios can generate markets and business
opportunities in the short term. For example, the real question will be if it will last in the long term and that's fundamentally a question about the sustainability of the economic model we choose. So my view is that the most durable economic opportunities will be those on the long term, environmentally and socially sustainable, including the animal welfare. So we need to look at the trade off to know if it's going to be economically interesting in the long term. Also, the public policy has a crucial role to play here, helping societies to make the
decisions that are good for people, for the planet, for the animals, and creating the condition economically, like the economic opportunities that can generally be resilient over time. So I mean now I cannot answer that question. Fair enough. And just finally, you're going to be gathering and analysing feedback from the pathways partners over the course of the next few months. How is that going to contribute to the final elements of the project? So yeah, my role is like really bringing at the final stage of
that project and I will be synthesizing the outputs from the different model based assessments that we have already mentioned. Like the LCA, the Geo Soul. So a big part of that will be working directly with our partners. So we just mentioned it's like a lot of stakeholders are involved and we try to gather the workshop, the interviews and validate and refine the findings with people who are actually working in the sector. So the farmers, the supply chain actors, the policy makers, the NGOs. So this Co production of knowledge is now needs to be refined and polished and try to
let's say clean a bit all of the findings we have and put that together in a consistent way. So the goal is ultimately to produce something that is a clear analysis that identify the most promising transition that pathways for sustainable livestock in Europe and set out a forward-looking research agenda that identifies where the gaps and opportunities still lie. So I will look at the future of pathways. What do we do after pathways as well? So yeah, I'm one of the last species of the pathway puzzle. Fantastic.
Look, That's it. That's all we've got time for. I'd like to thank my guests, Dr. Jessica Bosso, Doctor Tom Staton, and Dr. Pierre Marie O'bear. If you've not yet heard our previous Pathways programs and you can find them by scroll calling back in your podcast feed. And if you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. You can sign up for our free weekly newsletter@8.9.com. That's the number 8, the word point. The #9.com. Farmgate is Europe's highest ranking food security podcast. And we're partof8.9.com, the
land use news channel, which is supported by First Milk, Pelican AG, the Nature Friendly Farming Network, Friars Moore Livestock Health, the Royal Agricultural University Agrolo and Indian individual donors. And I've been thin loca stain. Bye for now.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...