This programme is part of our series of impromptu in-the-field podcasts, recorded at Groundswell 2025. In this episode we ask what role food companies play in supporting and accelerating growth in regenerative food and farming systems? ffinlo Costain is joined by Øistein Thorsen (FAI Farms) - Emma Keller (Nestlé) - and Harriet O'Regan (Arla).
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, I'm Finn Locostein, the Chief editorof8.9.com. This is another groundswell podcast in the field, and this time we're going to be talking about what do food companies, what role do food companies play in supporting and accelerating growth in regenerative delivery, in regenerative agriculture across those supply chains. And I'm joined by Oyston Taustin, who is the chief executive of FAI Farms, by Emma Keller, the head of sustainability at Nestle, and Harriet Oregon from Arla, who is head of customer agriculture.
And you're going to have to explain that term to us in just a moment, Harriet, if that's all right. But but if oyster, could you set the conversation up for us? Why you? You first of all suggested having this conversation. Why do you think this conversation about supply chains rather than the farmer rather than the customer, rather than the policy maker is important? It's important for a few different reasons. One regenerative as a, as a principle is important and relevant way beyond the farm gate. And I think it's important to, to highlight that and make sure
the the companies that are engaging in this are, are not just thinking about what others can do, but also thinking about what they can do in their, you know, in their practices, in their, in their policies and, and purchasing right. And then secondly is also to acknowledge that we're at groundswell, which is a farmer LED movement and and festival. I want to acknowledge that. I want to celebrate that and we want to look at sort of bring some ideas forward of OK, what can, what can other actors in the supply chain do to really
back this up, support it, promote it and, and not not take it over, but but really promote it and, and put it into practice. And what does that mean in practice? Does that mean money or or something else? I think that's what we want to explore a little bit today. I think it can start with, I think 1 area we've we've looked at before is commitments, right? So there's a lot of companies who, who are making commitments around regenerative agriculture. We would very much like that to, to go beyond commitments. Money is obviously part of that.
But the promise of regenerative agriculture is not that it necessarily has to be more expensive. We're talking about planetary impact. So we want large scale impact with us in terms of climate, water, nature, we want, we want partnerships. So it's it's, you know, meaningful engagement, listening to each other and kind of celebrating the fact that there is a plurality of definitions. That is not just a, a weakness,
it's a real strength of this movement. So and then there's a a multitude of other things that companies can do which hopefully we'll we'll touch upon a little bit today. Emma, if I can come to you next just to sort of talk about obviously Nestle, you're a massive global corporation, so we're not talking about just a AUK supply chain here, but you have very stretching targets in terms of whole supply chain delivery. Could you talk to us a little bit about that? I and I'm interested in why Nestle has moved in that direction and then you know kind of what it means in practice in
terms of delivery. Absolutely, yes. And as just as just mentioned, commitments are super important and that is our starting point. But we're also in commitment fatigue. We've we've got these big commitments and as Nestle, we've committed to Net 0, which is of course something most companies have done by now. It's representing most of the the world's economies. And but for us as a food business to achieve that, it's about agriculture. Between 70 and 90% of our footprint comes from farming and the sourcing ingredients. And we know, and we're seeing it already, when farming fails or nature collapses, we struggle as a business and it's really
challenging. So these commitments are not just about doing the right thing and doing being good. It's actually about business resilience and business survival into the future. So the commitments are there. What it's really now about is action and evidence. So we've been acting now on this commitment for the last, well, for for many, many years, but really seriously for the last five years. And that means working deeply with our suppliers because we can't do this alone. We have to work with farmers. So I think to the question of really what is it the business can do? It's about signalling, it's showing the the value chain,
this is the direction of travel. It's then about helping them get on that bus. That's the way we're moving. How do we support them? And that's incentives. That might be finance, it might be guidance, it might be advice, it might be bringing in new partners, new collaborations. But it's also about sharing that risk because this journey is risky. We don't know how to get there. We don't know where the quite the destination is, but we know we need to move on with. And so for us as well, gathering that evidence as we go, being able to course correct, learn, share those learning so that as a sector we're all moving in the right way, but not repeated heating mistakes or duplicating
effort. Risk is a huge factor in it for everybody, isn't it? From from a kind of a societal perspective, there's a risk that if it all goes wrong, then food security could be interrupted. At the same time, if we don't change, there's a risk that food security is going to be interrupted anyway just because of the way that the ecology is going. There's a business risk and there's a risk for the farmers themselves and their businesses when they make this transition. When did Nestle first identify that there was a risk to its own business model And and how did I did it identify that? This risk has long been known.
I mean when you're a company that depends on agriculture and ingredients to make the food products that we all know and love everyday, absolutely if you can't get hold of them, that is a challenge. I think in the last few years those risks have become really acute, whether it's not being able to get hold of certain ingredients because of geopolitical issues, whether it's where you see now commodity prices at an all time high. I mean, look at cocoa, we're coming up towards a six times all times high in terms of price. And that is when you look at the reasons for that, there's a whole load of factors, but the main driver really is climate change.
So these risks are not in the future. They're happening today, they're happening now. And we talk a lot about and farmers obviously at ground swell we hear a lot about farmers taking on all the risk and that the beautiful iron of that can't be lost in us when we're sat in a beautiful sunny field for the driest spring we've had in over 70 years. Farmers are desperate for rain. When a little bit came yesterday, it was like the rain dances was happening. So these are the risks that they genuinely take on. And so for plus as a business that's serious, we'll even look now at key commodities and
resources. Getting water out of the ground is really, really difficult. So the business knows is a risk. What's really challenging is the practices and interventions we need to put in place don't pay off overnight necessarily. They can take years, many, many, sometimes even decades to start to realize. So it's about putting in place those things now so that we can start to see them in the future. Really good example, even if you look at our progress on net zero, first few years of action, we were making 123 percent reductions over each year. We now met our twenty 2520%
commitment a year early. And that wasn't because suddenly we did loads of stuff, but it was interventions we did five years ago are starting to pay back. And that's a really important thing is we need to be doing this now so that the 2030 target is actually insight. We're going to start to drill down into a particular supply chain. We're going to talk about dairy, you know, as we go forward. But just, you know, before we do that, Waitrose recently released, you know, a news story about there's half £1,000,000 that they're putting into a range of different things that help to accelerate net zero. Now their definition of net zero seems to have morphed a little
bit. They seem to have sort of, you know, built into their supply chain now or into their thinking that net 0 isn't just about emissions, that actually it's about broader biodiversity and it's about water and this this sort of thing as well. Just very quickly is, is Nestle's approach to net zero sort of becoming more holistic and all-encompassing or is it still very emissions focused? I mean, net zero has a very formal definition and it has a clear road map and we know it's about emissions, but you you can't just focus on emissions. You've got to look holistically. And we've seen that in the past with lots of, lots of examples
of unintended consequences. So absolutely our definition is very holistic. We look at circularity is a really important area looking at restoration and nature, nature's creeping up the agenda. We've heard a lot about it at this at this conference as well. So absolutely net zero is also, it's a really technical term. Who really knows what it actually means. It's not consumer friendly. So we've got to start talking about future proofing our value chains, ensuring food security in the future and building resilience. And of course, in terms of the UK and in terms of farming, actually net zero basically
means a 40% cut in in in emissions rather than 100%. And there's a lot of misunderstanding about that. So as you say, definitions are difficult. And talking of definitions, Oyston, you talked about the way in which regenerative agriculture isn't necessarily well defined, that it's a bit fluid, that different people might think that it means different things. And you suggested that that was a strength rather than a weakness. Correct. I think one of the principles of, of regenerative agriculture is also is context, right? And if you take context
seriously, then it, you know, the, the, the right thing to do won't be the same thing on on every farm. So I think it's in that regard, I think it's AI think it's a strength. And I think it's a, it's a challenge to kind of how we work to, to kind of understand how we work with plurality and how we work with, with acknowledging the different contexts require different actions and, and, but we can agree around outcomes. So I think if, if we focus on, on aligning on, on outcomes, and that's another role I think the
food companies can, can play is to come together and agree on, on core outcomes, then then the, the sort of, you know, the, the quarrel about definition is a bit more to the side. Harry, I want to ask what Arla is doing. And I know that you have been doing a lot of work around regen over the course of the last four or five years. And and often that that's been at the premium end, you know, sort of around the organic sort of side of your milk. And how can you sort of, you know, develop those, those more
regenerative principles within that side? Can you deliver the outcomes that Oyston was talking about across the entire supply chain or is it just restricted to that sort of organic regenerative area? You know, absolutely not. We absolutely can. And I think for those who don't know Arlo as a cooperative, that is a benefit in the sense that we have and a restriction in the same sense, because we have to work at a collective speed. We have to, we can't tell our farmers how to farm and we need to work to for all of them, no matter where they start from where, what their context is. So absolutely I think we can.
And what we've learned from the Regenta pilots that we've done and a lot of the work that we've been doing in the last few years on sustainability has shown us that, you know, we, we, the, the formula is, you know, help them measure, you know, get the data, whether that's on consumers or it's on or it's on carbon, you know, help them innovate, help them do new things, find inspiration and do things differently and then share that out. And then I think what's being talked about here more than ever, which is 1. One thing we really can do, and it happens a lot in dairy is bringing together a farmers on small groups, benchmarking,
learning from each other. You know, I'm not going to tell a farmer how to farm. I've not got that background, but I can help them bring, to come together. I can facilitate that pair peer learning, which is essentially how you get that movement. And I think those three factors, the data and when you've got data, you can also incentivize. So data and incentives, the innovation and the inspiration and then bringing farmers together, that's ultimately how you make change. And we've done that with our identity pilot. We've had 24 farms across Europe working together, getting data, learning together, doing some
new things, some flops and some fails along the way. But then we've together with FAI and the guys, but we've also brought a little group of farmers together who want to stay together now. They want to learn from each other going forward. So we need to replicate that model, I think right out to the rest of our cooperative. Thanks, Harriet. I, I said at the beginning that I wanted you to explain what your job title meant. So it's head of agriculture, head of customer agriculture. So you can just put that in context and what your role is in, in this sort of delivery, your sort of position in the supply chain. Well, it goes back to a lot of
what we're saying about what people's roles are, because we're fortunate in dairy. Certainly, I wouldn't want to speak for the sectors that our customers, our retailers in the UK and also our food service customers actually recognize the risk and the importance of getting involved with farmers and helping them along the journey. So what I do is I work with our customers, our supermarket colleagues and our food service retailers that they want to be on the journey. We have programs that they are part of. Those programs support innovation, they support farmers engagement and they also put
data and getting the data and reporting. So they then get with the reporting back, but they also get to be involved in the journey. And it's a, it's a delight to be part of doing that because it, it really feels like it's the most important part actually of the journey is using all of our resources, including financial support from our, from our customers to help the farmers move along on that journey that, that we want them to take. Help me out with the idea because obviously if you've got organic, which is becoming more regenerative, that's quite straightforward, you sort of have an understanding of how they can deliver that. When you've got sort of more
intensive dairy herds, you know, sort of fully housed dairy herds, how do you start to move them on that regenerative journey? How do you start to sort of deliver some of those outcomes that we would, you know, normally associate with the kind of things that we talk about all the time here at Groundswell? Yeah, yeah. I mean, I've been a huge advocate of supporting groups like Organic for a long time. But also I think what we've learned is that we need to not necessarily have farmers in silos and actually help everybody move whatever with their starting point is. And then beauty about the
regenerative pilots that we did is we had farmers from all different types of systems, all like for absolute extremes. Actually some of the biggest farms we had to some of the smallest, you know, micro level work on a really high intensive kind of well, a really in depth regenerative kind of process. And they enjoyed learning from each other actually. And some of the ways of running businesses could be could help the organic lot a bit more. And then the vice versa, actually thinking about your soil, thinking about what the land that you you thought was that was not useful land and
using that better. So I think wherever people are starting from, and I'm always surprised, I think the regenerative term is sometimes, you know, upset some farmers some, but but actually many of them are on the journey even though they didn't realize it. And I think more and more people are open to that than than we think. And I think at this point it's worth just mentioning the Regen dairy.org website, which is something that in a previous incarnation when I was chief exec of Farmwell and Oyston from FAI farms that we work together on, on this particular project,
which was part Co funded by by Arla as well. And that website has so much information on there from, you know, podcasts and webinars, but also personas. So they're sort of these, they sort of caricature's, not quite the right sort of phrase, but these sort of fictional farmer types. And it's describing the journeys that they can make, whether they are the most industrialised system or the least industrialised system or anybody in between. And so there's an awful lot of information there for for people to sort of have a look at and get behind, no matter what stage of the journey they're on.
Emma Nestle is a customer as well as obviously a processor. But in terms of dairy, you're buying, buying milk from from a cooperative. So just talk to us about that relationship and how Nestle has helped to develop the way that that customer your your sort of big UK customer works. Dairy is an incredibly important ingredient for us. We saw something like 7% of Scottish dairy. So we are a big, big buyer of it. And actually if you look back to us building our infrastructure,
so if you look at where our factories are based, they are based in supply sheds where dairy farmers are operating. So we've made decisions based on where these farms are positioned. So we're really, really proud of Nestle. We've been working with our regenerative cooperative First Milk for 21 years. That's quite an incredible achievement. And that hasn't that was started a very much as a commercial relationship, purely a buying and selling and it has evolved into so much more than that. It is now truly a partnership. We do see ourselves as one team that's not been out without its highs and lows and challenges. Of course, we've seen points in
the time where dairy farmers wanted to move out of dairy farming because it was not profitable, and that was actually where it was a really important role for us as Nestle, who depend on that ingredient that goes into much love products like Kit Kat and Nest Cafe frothy coffees to make sure that these dairy farmers are farming. So I think much to Harriette Point, this is about bringing those farmers together, meeting them where they're out. We want all of the farmers to win. We don't want there to be losers. So we need to support them at all the stages of the journey. So with our farmers in first milk, Yep, 21 years together. But it's really been over the last five or six years where we've gone deep with a milk plan and that's been all about moving
them on this regenerative journey. So that's what I was gonna ask you about cause of course, you know, first milk hasn't been regenerative to for 21 years, but it has been a cooperative dairy for that length of time. And Sheila Hancock, the current chief executive, you know, really was instrumental in sort of making that shift towards regenerative. And I just, I wonder if you could talk me through that relationship that, that you had with Sheila and the way that you were able to support her in that transition. Because you know, across their whole supply chain, I think 700 odd dairy farmers, you know, they are now sourcing over 95% of their milk is coming from
genuinely regenerative pharmacists. The fundamental here has been trust. It's been about saying that, look, we are in this with you. This is the direction of travel we want to go on and we're here for the long haul and we're not going to move away. And yeah, with those fails and flops, we're going to be there and we're going to share that risk. And what we've really done to build that trust is provide the right incentives and make sure it is seen as a a journey. The farms can opt into different parts of it. They don't. You're not have to go all in in one go. You can test and learn and and do what's comfortable for you. And what we've seen through that
is that farmers have been much more willing to now as we're five years in and we've just really proud that we've reduced our emissions by about 30% in 2024 with these regenerative farmers. And we're now working towards the next phase towards looking at 60% emission reduction. It's a huge achievement. And when we asked farmers now to do new weird and wonderful things, things like silver pasture, planting trees in the middle of dairy fields, these are not common interventions that dairy farmers do. They're up for it because they understand why they, they've seen the benefits from these other interventions and they,
they've got the trust in us that we're doing it for the right reason and we're working with them on it. So it's a really exciting face, the partnership. I cannot wait to see what comes next. And the beauty of it is we know our farmers names and I think that's so rare. You'd never think a huge business like Nestle can turn up, know the farmers names. My colleague has sat round, he's been working at Nestle for 30 years. He sat round the table with the farmers and their kids and those kids are now running the farms. And that's a really beautiful story. It's just one thing that want to ask you again before going back across to just for sort of final thoughts really from, from
everyone. But it's about water because I know that, you know, water, it seems to like it seems as though water and the way that it works in the landscape has become much more sort of part of the zeitgeist over the last 12 months or so. And so you've got Wild Farms and Andy Cato who've been sort of working with water companies, they're now paying the Wild Farm farmers to reduce the nutrient levels on their farms. And you have a similar thing going on in Pembrokeshire, I think with one of your water sourcing facilities. We do, absolutely. Yeah. So we, we bottle water in
Pembrokeshire as part of our Nestle Pure Life brand. And what is a precious resource, right? We, we either hear about it when there's too much and there's flooding, or we hear about it like now when there's too little and we haven't seen rain for so long. So it's something incredibly important. And what is beautiful about the Regent of Journey is that we know that these interventions that we're looking at for carbon reduction and for nature restoration also play a huge role in water infiltration, in preservation of water at landscape level. And that's really important. So really excited as well that we're working with First Milk in our Pembrokeshire area. We don't source dairy there, we
source water. But it's a really nice link up of what they can do with other supply chains that actually preserve water that help us. So it's a lovely example of you need to collaborate at land landscape scale. Going farm by farm is a bit old school now. It's really about bringing them together because water doesn't operate at a farm by farm level. It moves a landscape. So too does nature carbon even more. It's not just landscape, it's global. So really exciting work and. Yeah, really proud to be part of it. And the wonderful thing about that is that, you know, these are dairy farmers that are being
paid to produce water as well as dairy, isn't it? Which is really interesting. Oyston, just sort of coming back to that sort of whole supply chain elements and obviously the work that FAI does supporting supply chain change. Where is it that you think we are at the moment on the journey and where do you want us to be? I think where we where I'd like food companies to be is to do the actions the basically as if their business depends on it, right? Like I think when that penny drops and I think that some of
the examples Emma Emma raised kind of shows that companies are starting to get on that, you know, get get on that mindset shift that their business depends on this. This isn't something that we're doing because it's nice or we're just looking for something to tell our farmers to do. We are investing. We you know, we're investing in our own supply chain because if we want to be sourcing the ingredients we rely on in 1020 years, there is no, you know, there is no other choice. So I think for me, that's the, that's the switch that we're trying to turn more companies
onto to sort of see the self, the self-interest in investing in, in regenerative agriculture and then do that in deep long term partnerships with their with their farmers and suppliers. Fantastic. And just finally, Harriet, what is Arla's sort of vision here? Where do you want, where do you expect the company to be in five years time? Yeah. I mean, what we haven't really talked about today in terms of the role of our kind of companies is also the consumer. And I think that that we've debated it a bit here in terms of what how we can motivate and also arm the consumer with the
ability to help change the food system. And I think Arla certainly also knows a lot about it's consumer. And we were we were talking just yesterday about some data that I've seen that showed that actually the movement of regenerative farmers is actually really powerful for consumers. The fact that there is like the owner make a story if if it's, you know, the cooperative of farmers that got together and and are changing the way things are happening, that's really motivating. So I think that, you know, working with our consumer and then working with our farmers together and helping them all move forward is essentially what
Arlo is keen to do. Yeah, that in a nutshell. Fantastic. That's been really interesting and thanks so much. It's been really exciting to hear about what's going on and to hear about how how you're hoping things are going to move in the future. So thanks so much for joining me. Harriet Oregon and Emma Keller from Nestle and Oyston Tawson from FAI Farms, and of course, that was Harriet from Arla. So thanks very much. I've been feeling like a stain. Bye for now.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...