English nature faces an unprecedented human-made environmental crisis as thousands of Countryside Stewardship agreements expire at the end of this year. Over 4,500 farms are affected, threatening to undo years of conservation work. We'll discuss why we're in this mess - what it could mean for England's nature - and what can be done about it. ffinlo Costain (8point9.com) is joined by Anna Biesty (Deepdale Farm) Martin Hole (Montague Farm) Chris Millward (Bibbey's Wild Farms) and Martin Lines (Nature Friendly Farming Network). * Watch instead? Search 'Farm Gate podcast' on YouTube * More land use news at 8point9.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, welcome to this emergency farm gate. I'm Phil Locustine, editorof8.9.com. English nature faces an unprecedented human made environmental crisis as thousands of countryside stewardship agreements expire at the end of this year. Over 4500 farmers are affected, threatening to undo years of conservation work on an area more than twice the size of Greater London, Birmingham and Manchester combined. In this program, we'll discuss why we're in this mess, what it could mean for England's nature and what can be done about it.
I'm joined by Anna Beastie from Deepdale Farm on the North Norfolk coast, and by Chris Millwood, the conservation manager for Bibby's Wild Farms near Helzow in Birmingham. And then a bit later in the program, we'll hopefully meet Martin Hall from Montague Farm in Sussex. And for policy context, I'm joined by Martin Lyons, chief executive of the Nature Friendly Farming Network. Martin, what's happening and why? Yeah. Thank you. If you know the So what's happening is many farmers five years or 4 1/2 years ago now signed up for agreements on A5 year term called countryside stewardship, which the four and
a half thousand of those agreements come to the end of the end of this year when the government closed the new round of schemes called SFI Sustainable Farming Incentive back in the spring. That left no pathway for these farmers coming out of agreements to continue being rewarded to deliver on their habitats. So farmers have found themselves in a real difficult position that there's no schemes to carry on getting funding to do with public goods from their farms and them having to make some tough decisions around what they can do with their land to generate some income going
forward from next year. We identified the problem back in the spring when they've closed the SFI and they said they're not going to open anything for a while. And we were increasingly raising our voices and and sort of really asking government to give those farmers a decision, a pathway, but also give them a one year rollover to move those agreements over for one more year until the new schemes are up and running. And then they can continue delivering their public goods and environmental outcomes on their farm to be rewarded for them. So really this is this is a product of a double whammy of
the end sort of precipitous ending of the SFI at the same time as now having the end of countryside stewardship. And therefore there's no money coming in at all to support nature friendly farming. Yeah, that's right. I mean this timeline was predictable. We knew what schemes are coming and going and there's other schemes that have shut or people come out of this year, the higher tier stewardships. So but the government because of the chopping and changing and funding running out have no pathway. Farmers have no pathway to continue delivering and only far the farms are actually in
schemes now. And so half the farms are not delivering or being rewarded for those public goods. And what it means is we we'll see significant areas of habitat being lost or managed not as as well as it could be because of financial support for the cost of that management won't be coming from the public purse. And whose fault is this? Can is it reasonable for Labour to blame the previous government, or do they need to take responsibility themselves? Is it Treasury's problem or is it Defra's? I think it's all actually, you know, previous government should
have had the a road map and a plan, which they did, but they, you know, stopping the starting schemes, not delivering A scheme with a clear pathway of continue building. And then Labour have come in and it's taken a while to get to the grips of the issues and, and get the understanding. I think that's been a real challenge of a new government with new people having given them the information and getting civil servants to brief them has taken time. And then we've just had a reshuffle. So while decisions could have been made now, we're now going to reshuffle again and those new ministers and Secretary of
State's got to get themselves up to speed before they make. There are hopefully some sensible decisions that allow farmers to actually carry on really supporting nature recovery on their farms. Now, Martin, I'm not going to ask you about the impact this is going to have on your farm because people who are regular listeners to Farmgate will have already heard Martin's Farm, which is of course the new series that started just this last week. And we talked a bit about it there. Of course, today I'm joined by hopefully three, certainly 2 at the moment, members of the Nature Friendly Farming Network
to talk about the impact on their farm. But we sort of get into the impacts. Let's find out a bit about their farms. And Anna, I just wonder if you could tell us about your farm, you know, the size, land type, what you produce and where you sell into. Yes, we're an organic arable farm on the north Norfolk coast. We're 300 hectares. It's mainly sandy loam, but we do have some heavier reclaimed marshland as well. We're currently growing spring wheat, selling to an independent mill and spring oats, which we
sell to whites in Northern Ireland via the organic arable contract. We've also just drilled rye for the first time. So hopefully that will be a good addition to the harvest for 2026. And it will definitely be good to have another crop in the rotation and an autumn zone one, given that this year we had almost no rain during six months, months of the growing season. Thanks very much. That's really interesting. And Chris Bibby's Wild Farms is over 2 sites right next to Britain's second largest urban conurbation, Birmingham. Tell us about the farm.
It's family farm, so there's two farms and, as you say, right on the urban fringe. Sunflowers and gold of pleasure in the bird crop mixes can be seen from the top of the local shopping centre car park and also from Woodgate Valley on the edge of Birmingham City. It's 300 acres between the two farms, 60% grassland, 40% available options, local and further markets and in 2021 we gave over 10%, around 10% of the
land to nature friendly farming measures under 2 mid tier countryside stewardship agreements. A big transition for the farmers with some support from Andy Roberts, local Nature Friendly farmer and also Nature Friendly Farming Network. I suggested that, you know, you were, you were next to Birmingham, you talked there about being able to see the farm from Birmingham City centre. I mean, I, I wonder if you could just sort of talk us through the challenges of living next to that many people. Do you do you think that the farm you know is is affected in
a different way because you live so close to so many people? Yes, right. Especially when we look at the whole aims of these Agri environment agreements in terms of delivering public goods. There's so many pressures for wildlife on the urban fringe and then also you have conflicting interests there. But I have to say it's been nothing but an absolute positive journey and experience on the way to nature friendly farming which probably cover in more detail later. Now what? What has the Countryside Stewardship Scheme specifically
meant to you? You said that you know 10% of the farmers sort of been managed for nature. Just talk us a bit about that. How's the scheme allowed you to farm differently? It's, it's really allowed us to express ourselves by giving 10% of the land over. We have a wide range of grassland and arable options. We're able to deliver at scale. The 300 acres are across a wider area because there's there's an area in between the two farms.
So we've really been able to make a bigger impact on the landscape. So I mean, all of this is about delivering public goods, but now experience, it's much wider than that, that quite cold term. It's really about restoring the critical life systems upon which we all depend, and the story that's unfolded has been quite remarkable. If we start with farmland birds, then we actually have 15 of the 19 farmland bird species, which are the indicator species.
The four that absolute, they're actually absent regionally, so we couldn't do too much with those. But those 15 species are all on the increase. Yellow hammers linit, I mean linit, the baseline for linit on the farms was actually 50. It was three families during the baselining years that came and had a quick look at the farms and moved on after one year of four hectares of bird food crop and supplementary feeding, we were serving 1050 lini and not
only that, they went on to breed on the farms for the first time in a century. Similar stories with yellowhammer Reed bunting. Reed bunting we had one local sighting in the 1990s and during this journey since 2021 they've become passage birds and then they became wintering birds. They've wintered in numbers of up to 30 and now we've got singing birds on the farms. Butterfly numbers If we take the crash of last year aside, in the first three years butterfly numbers doubled. The interesting thing this year,
the butterfly results that the big butterfly count results with the early broods suffering the impact of Last year the results were quite poor but because we've had better conditions this year, we've actually broken the record for the late broods of small copper and common blue. Another classic example, white leg damsel fly. We've had our first recordings on the River Stour and that's as a result of buffering water courses and producing habitat that favours species like this.
That's the part of the story, that's the well documented story. But the thing I want to highlight the impact on the community, the power of this success story. My photos been dry through delivering presentations and talks to local community who have gained so much value from the happiness that comes from the sunflowers to actually hearing the restoration story and believing that it's possible. So it really is a powerful story. Yeah, fantastic. And just even as you mentioned the river stower there, it evokes plenty of memories for
me. I grew up in the 70s in near Kidderminster, which isn't that far away from you, in in a village called Cookley. And we had the Stour running through US that I used to canoe on and play around, you know, but play around when I was much, much younger. And then, you know, there's the, we had all, all the, all the habitat and woodland just between the canal there and, and the Stour. So wonderful, wonderful to hear about the work that you're doing there. But you talked about the way in which, you know, you made such a difference in the space of a single year, such a positive difference. Of course, if you lose that
funding now, then potentially within a similar space of time, you can start to see a reversal in in what you've achieved. So what stage are you at now with your Countryside Stewardship Agreement? Right. So sadly it's as Martin's outlined, the the two agreements are due to end on the 31st of December and we've got nowhere to go. So, so you know, we're such a passionate and powerful story. It's really sad that we're sort have left in this position. And and if you look as well,
there's this talk about farming jobs. What, what is the job of farming? Well, if you look then obviously we deliver goods into market and we get a return on that. When we're delivering public goods life systems, then obviously we need public support to deliver on that. But look, locally, we've got the evidence to show the returns on that investment and how that can actually help communities. And what difference has countryside stewardship meant for you and for nature on your
farm? Like Chris, we've we've been in a countryside stewardship agreement for the last five years. And for us, we went into it following a terrible flooding incident, following decades of root crops and rotating around the farm, which really wasn't great for our light soils. And we needed a whole scale change to the way that we farmed and our countryside stewardship agreement allowed us to do that. And by redesigning the farms layout, we were then able to reduce the potential of of flooding and by dividing up the fields, introducing grass
strips, cover crops, beetle banks and things like that. So we had some five year environmental options such as AB 8, which is flower rich margins and plots. And so there hasn't been any bare ground in those areas, which has really reduced the flood risk. And then we're adjacent to the Norfolk coast Triple SI. So we also had areas of wild bird seed mixed to, to support that and the bird counts on the farm. Yeah, we've shown that we attract a lot of migratory species. You know, walking through those
environmental areas, you know, on a summer's day, you can find yourself literally in a cloud of dragon or damsel flies or, or blue butterflies. And it really is beautiful. And the whole farm just feels alive, you know, with constant sound of, of grasshoppers and birdsong. And we gained some Fipple funding to Farming and protected landscapes funding for an invertebrate survey in 2022. And that was only two years into into our scheme and that recorded 36 species holding conservation status.
And we would love to repeat the survey and, and compare the results and see where we are now. And then walking around with the Operation Turtle Dove team over this, this summer, we found a wall butterfly. And you know, although that's listed as endangered for us and our farm, we actually found it in six out of the 8 survey sites. So it really has had a significant impact on a multiple species. We've got a thriving owl and bat population due to the amount of habitat that we provide for them.
Yeah, it really has made made a difference. Sounds like an incredible sort of cornucopia of, of insect and bird life that you've got there as well. You talked about flooding to begin with and I wonder, you know, the the work that you've done on the farm, which has presumably helped with water management, but also water infiltration within the soils. Have you been able to to measure a difference on the surrounding community on on sort of flooding outcomes around you? Oh definitely. So I think really good example is the winter of 20/23/24 that
January 2024 and when we'd had literally solid rainfall for about 3 months and I was walking the whole farm measuring our hedges to put them into the SFI scheme. And I mean, there was 1 patch of 1 field where I got a bit of mud in my boot. And other than that, the farm was dry. Meanwhile, surrounding villages were, you know, there were fire engines pumping out houses. There were Rd. blockages in multiple different places. And somebody mentioned to my, my mom, you know, have you noticed
how how dry Burnham detail is this year compared with the other villages? You know, what's why is that? And it is down to our farming practices because, you know, we had the ABA, which meant and there was no bare soil that was, yeah, really helping with water infiltration. There was just so many different aspects of that countryside stewardship scheme that allowed us to farm differently and to really ensure that that flooding incident didn't happen again. And flooding is terrible. It's, it's terrible for the farmer involved, for the community and the toll that that
puts on mental health as well as anything else, it's is awful. So to be able to sleep better at night knowing that our fields and our soil and our you know, that capital, which is our soil is staying in the fields is a huge relief. Yeah, and, and what stage are you at with your countryside stewardship? So yeah, it comes to an end in December. So we are redesigning the farm yet again. Ours really was quite a significant stewardship scheme. It had 60% of our arable land in
environmental options. But with no funding, we've found we've just got no choice. I've been spending time, you know, remapping that and working out where we're cropping next year and it's going to mean a drop to 10%. So that in real terms it's going from 140 hectares in environmental options to 25 hectares. So it really is a huge drop. Let's go into more of the detail on that in just a moment, Anna, if that's OK. And I, I'm pleased to say we've been joined by Martin Hall. And I wonder if you could just sort of start us off by telling
us a bit about your farm, you know, sort of how big it is, what sort of land you've got, what you produce, that kind of thing. OK, I farm with my wife and my my youngest daughter. We're a 700 acre all grass farm and we farm on the edge of the pendency levels in East Sussex. We're part of a a group of farmers within one of the largest triple Sis in the country dependency levels possibly one of the most biodiverse wetlands in the UKA claim I contend vigorously, but is obviously hard to knock down.
So we are organic cattle and organic sheep grass only system and. And that's presumably being reared for meat rather than for dairy. Yes, yes. So beef, beef and land production is what is what we do. And why did you want to enter a Countryside Stewardship Agreement in the 1st place, Martin? I think my background pretty passionate about wildlife and from a family that feel the same. We farm in this very, very special landscape that was probably had 50 or 80 years of deterioration, wetland that was
drying out. And we really had a vision of how to put that together, both both on our own farm as a business and also in conjunction with 60 or 70 other farmers through a through cluster group called the Pevensie Farmers. And have you noticed a measurable sort of difference or just an emotional difference, let alone measurable as a result of the work that you've been doing not only on your own farm, but across that cluster? There's two very big questions there, Fiddler. I mean, I think the emotional 1 is, is a fascinating 1 to explore.
I think certainly my family and certainly a number of friends within within this landscape are very emotional about about what they do. It's very hard to be a farmer if you're not passionate. I think the second part is, are we making material difference? I absolutely we are, you know, we are seeing through through the dynamic management that we're instigating with water level management, with increased flooding areas, with increased attention to Herbridge meadows,
with increased attention to how we look after the animals themselves, you know, reduction in, in pesticide use, using the right breeds. The place is changing and I think it's taken 30 years to put 60 farmers into a A-frame of mind. I am. I'm a brim full of positivity about what we can achieve here. Fantastic. And what stage are you at with your countryside Jewish agreements? Well, we're 30 years into management agreements here, so
our farmers change radically, but we are subject currently to a five year period which comes to an end in December this year. And I know just sort of coming back to you, you started sort of talking about what would happen on your farm if there wasn't a rollover in Countryside stewardship. But just talk us through that again and and go into a bit more detail will you about the way that you'll balance nature and food production next year on your farm and how that'll be different from the last year? Yeah. So as I said, we had 60% of our arable land in environmental
options. Previously, the government had already brought in a 25% cap on the last iteration of the SFI. So we had sort of had it in our heads that, okay, we're going to reduce, you know, that area to 25%, which for us was good. We felt we wanted to produce more food at the same time, as, you know, giving wildlife, you know, real support as well. But that balance has had to really shift. So having rejigged the farm over the last couple of months to
work out how we can crop a larger area in order to balance the finances. That looks like it's going to drop to about 10%, which is much lower than we would have liked to have done in real terms. That's a drop from 140 hectares down to 25 hectares. So we'll keep some wild bird seed mix because it doesn't need re sowing for next year and we want to keep it for bird life this this winter season. And then it will be sort of too late to crop for 2026.
The beetle banks will stay because they structurally divide our fields as well as being for wildlife and and providing integrated pest management. But margins. So where we've had the AB 8 wildflower mix or the AB11 which is for rare arable plants, those will significantly reduce in both an area and also on the whole become grass margins rather than wildflower margins with you know less benefit for biodiversity. So, so the margins will stay, will they, it's just that they won't be planted in the same way
or are they going, are some of them going to disappear altogether? We will keep margins around all of our fields. We are part of the nature friendly farming network and we do want to support wildlife, particularly where we are, you know in a national landscape and you know, adjacent to the triple SI. So we we've got a huge amount of hedgerows around the farm which are carefully managed on a three-year cutting rotation. We'll then have a sort of 6 metre grass margin around the edges and then we'll be into the cropped area.
So it is a significant reduction. There are another, you know, few little pockets around the farm where it just doesn't make sense to, you know, financially crop them, they're too difficult or because of coming to the end of the scheme. It's taken quite a lot of work to work out. OK. When can we start doing something else with that plot in terms of the rules at the end of the scheme? So there are a few pockets that have kind of become islands, which it doesn't make sense for anything to happen to for this year either. But if there continues to not be
any support, then that 10% may drop further as we're able to expand those cropped areas. Yeah. And Chris, if countryside stewardship agreement ends for your farm, what happens to baby's wild farms at that point? Well I mean if we look at the background here, the basic payment scheme, the withdrawal of that, so farmers have been heavily impacted by that and now to fall off a Cliff edge with Agri environment money, it really is, forgive the point, but it's a straw that breaks camels back. Farmers are going to have to make really difficult decisions
from our point of view for 2/3 reasons. I suppose ever the optimist. Second, seen how good this scheme delivers. So hope that the policy makers will see that and realise it's important, especially when we look at the local nature recovery strategies which are on that across the country. If you look at the removal of nature farming and how that breaks up the landscape at a time where we're supposed to be restoring nature for 2030.
So at this point I've actually paused because I have great hope that the importance and age friendly farming is felt. Unfortunately the policy makers of sort of left us in the position so we couldn't make decisions around farm rotation. But come 1st of January with these passionate farmers having lost their BPS and then angry enviro, then really tough decisions will come in January. So at the moment we've kept everything as it is so that we will then look at it on the
spring rotation. And the reason for that is, is that the public money's been invested A5 year period. We've built the habitat. So we've actually as a group, we've decided to see what unfolds before tearing this up that the game plan was because, and Martin and I spoke about this because of the post Brexit grand vision for engagement, community delivery of public goods. Then our aim on the farm was to learn from countryside
stewardship and then use SFI options to then further enhance our nature recovery and also sort of build that in that the farmers came into it for the first time. It was a steep learning curve. So we now we, our plan was to move with the second phase going to SFI onto more regenerative and changes in practices within the productive area. And as well as that, these were demonstrated farms for what was planned as quite a big farm cluster. But we can't engage farmers at the moment because they simply
don't know what's going on. And Martin, the whole what difference is it going to make on your farm if there isn't a rollover and the Countryside Stewardship funding ends, What difference will it make? What specific difference will it make for you? I think going back to your first question, there's the, there's the physical impact, which I think we would be very slow to change. You know, we've got 30 years of work on the farm. We've got long term vegetation change, we've got long term commitment to the bird life and to the landscape and, and all the people we've encouraged to join the cluster group.
So I, I think that that's, I think I would be slow to change. What has already happened is that emotional bond, that drive, that everyday thing where you wake up excited and want to do things and you want to embrace this future and and you know, you're on a journey and the excitement that goes along that. And I, and I know that that's a great thing to have in a career and, and you don't have it all the time, but I think we, we take with that the teams at Natural England, we take with that the, the, the local bird watching community or the
botanical societies. There is a community behind what we're doing. And I think if I lose steam and instead of looking excited, I asked the question now is, am I stupid? You know, this farm is worth millions of pounds. We're driving it into the future. I have children that that depend on it for in terms of their career and their wages and, and their children. And I'm just asking the question now in being committed to this, am I stupid? Because really the the ending of our scheme and the slowness with
which we can reapply for the other any, any sort of future version of it and the unknown sums in that it seems that the commitment is all coming from us at ground level. And I include the Natural England teams in that. And that at top level there is an utter disregard for the uncertainty and the rug pulling feeling that that this that this even this hesitancy creates. And the hesitancy is completely unacceptable in what is a really serious challenge to turn back
the ecological clocks. Thank you everyone. This really interesting sort of hearing the range of different reasons. And you know, we talked through there. I mean, one of the key themes I think is, is this kind of, you know, there's a pause that immediately the money money goes there is the hope that money will return in the future. And so, you know, rather than kind of digging up necessarily all of the nature and conservation features that exist on your farms, it's about sort of just pausing. But they're not doing anything additional to sort of enhance them, I suppose.
So that nature's kind of left a bit to fend for itself or be it in spaces that have been good for nature in the past. But then you've got that emotional bond that's being replaced with stress and and instability. And of course, you know, on on your farm and you know, on other farms, I'm sure we're going to see a reduction in that space for nature because you're changing the way that you're farming the amount of land that's being used for production. And then, of course, Martin Holy were talking about the inheritance and succession
issues and, and perhaps the way in which, you know, the end of this particular branch of funding and the instability that exists there means that you might, you know, sort of bring some of your succession plans forward and and think about other ways to maximize the value of your farm. Really fascinating Martin lines just because some people listening might feel that the government, you know, should focus on other spending priorities. And to be fair, you know that it's not just farming, but the country overall that's in a bit of a hole at the moment. Lots of demands on the treasury funding and and public funding.
Why should the public be paying farmers to to great nature outcomes in this way? I think, I think also the government kind of understand nature underpins our economy, our health, our food, everything. So if we don't get that investment in to do that, we will not have food security, we will not have personal health and economic health in the future. And the couple of billion, £2 billion is, is you know, out of or £3 billion depending on which figures you want to use. It's a drop in the ocean investing into our landscapes. I was really supportive of moving away from a farmed
payment system that just paid me for being, I'm a farmer. I want the public to really connect. And that's what we've been hearing with these people with with the other farmers here, that that connection to the public and the outcomes and the engagement and it connects yourself to receiving public money as a term is for public goods. Paying for the environmental improvements is a real benefit to society. But what we are seeing many farmers want to do this because it's the right thing to do and have habitat on the farm. But to do the recovery the nation needs to have a healthy planet in the future is an investment cost and farmers
can't bear that. We haven't got the profitability to do that. So to invest a relatively small amounts of money into farmers to help them deliver nature restoration that underpins food security and access to nature and they all the multiple benefits that is that has got to be a win win. And, and I know many people say, well, the hospital wants paying or the bus wants paying, but if we don't have nature in our landscape at an abundance, we, you know, we're going to struggle in the futures. And we often hear politicians saying, oh, you know, that
climate impact, that that nature impact, That's, that's that's tomorrow's problem. We'll invest. You look at growth. We're hearing from Anna, the impact of climate change is having to her own farm, how changing her practices by using public funded support helps protect local communities. And for me, the countryside stewardship is a whole farm approach. We look at across the landscaping farms and the, the newer schemes are more individual actions. But if we wrote back on this and if, if the government doesn't want to support this, what we're going to see is, you know, a
real further decline, but a real disconnection from farmers because many farmers have been investing in this for years. And it's not just this five year scheme, They've been in it for 5/10/20 years and recovery is happening on on those farms that have been doing nature friendly farming and working with government funded schemes to get the outcomes. And we talked about the way that the end of this country, so stewardship's going to affect you and your farm business. I wonder if you could reflect on the way that farming is going to be affected around you, Perhaps not just with those farms that might be in CS agreements, but you know, where farmers, you
know, were hoping for the for the SFI, but they didn't manage to get it and where that funding is just proving really challenging that public funding. How is farming changing in the landscape around you? I mean, we have a, a really brilliant cluster group, the North Norfolk Coastal Group, and they have been so supportive of getting loads of farmers involved that, you know, weren't before. They've helped us explain, you know, higher tier SFI, you know, countryside stewardship, all of these. And feels like a huge amount of wasted time to some extent
because I looked back at a Zoom presentation the other day and I immediately deleted it because I thought this is higher tier. Oh, sorry, this is SFI explained. It's no longer relevant. We'll see what the next iteration is that that have gone in to trying to plan what will work for your farm. And you know, I mentioned the flooding impact there are changing farming has had and there's plenty of farms around us who could do something similar, but they do not have the financial means to do it at the moment with, you know, low commodity prices.
We've had, you know, a not great harvest around us because because of such low rainfall and without environmental options and Agri schemes to go into, they aren't going to be able to to afford to make those changes. And Chris, what, what have you seen? Have you seen evidence that other farmers are already starting to pull up conservation features on their farms around you? Yeah, it's been horrendous really because on social media there's really prominent nature friendly farmers delivering the very best in this and they've been forced to the pollen and
neck to the rotational arable options. Obviously 1st to go. They've had to look at the autumn rotation as a said difficult decisions having to be made. It's apparent that those rotational options are going, but behind that there's already firm plans to take up meadows, water protection, all of the things that have delivered so well. And also as Martin saying that that doesn't just represent grass, that's an investment. It was a UK investment in nature
for thriving future. I was seeing on your social media just the other day that a farmer had posted showing that they were, they were plowing up their margins. And I guess that's the sort of thing that you're coming across quite frequently. More so because as I say, if you take, if you take the transition from Europe to post Brexit, farmers really have taken a lot. And so even with the most passionate of farmers, at the end of the day, they're having to try and stay in business. These are really difficult decisions. As I say, we've deferred as till
January because we, we, we couldn't plan on the rotation given the, the current information. And that's going to be the picture across the landscape, I dare say. Martin, you talked about, you know, being part of a larger cluster as well, but you know, from your perspective, do you think though there is a genuine in danger of a widespread reversal in nature outcomes around you too? I think it's very hard to say, you know, a month, a month is a long time in politics, but a very short time on a farm. I think what you very early
represented this, this physical activity on the farm and what the farmer thinks, I'm going to think in every, everywhere, in every bit of every field. For us, what the farmer thinks, what we think is mirrored in what we do. And at the moment the, the policy, the hiatus is maybe affecting what we think and how we feel and we are holding off the physical change. I would implore farmers everywhere to hold off the physical changes. They can feel aggrieved, they can feel angry, they can feel
confused. Let's just run with that for a little while while the government makes its mind up. But I think the age of nature recovery that we are in, this government will have to it just must support these changes on farms everywhere. What do you feel the conversation is on the ground? Martin Hall Do you think that you have the support of the the whole of the public around you, whether you know people are rich or poor wherever they come from in your region? Because obviously the
government, it's elected by a proportion of the country, but it's there to represent the interests of the country as a whole. What do you think the public would would say to government if it had the chance to comment on this particular situation? Well, I've been amazed at the support of, if you like, the man on the Clapham Omnibus, people who know nothing about the farming industry and the policy and the minutiae of my landscape and the landscape that we farm in. They are so supportive. It is absolutely common sense that the quality of the natural
environment underpins, as the other Martin said, every aspect of health and community and belonging. And I think that that is so intimately and so instinctively understood by the man on the street and the woman on the street and the children in the streets. And I think it's a no brainer. And I think losing the population politically to to what is crass administrative dilly dallying is, is such a political sort of shot in the
foot. Yeah, a major own goal. And I mean, thanks so much to the three of you who've been sort of explaining what stewardship has meant to you and, and what the impact of the loss of it may mean for nature on your farms. It's I mean, it's been depressing, but it's been, you know, really interesting to hear that. And Martin Lyons, just before I come back to you, you mentioned the amount of money that this costs, you know, the the the government spends on farming somewhere between 2:00 and 3:00 billion if we're talking about England. And while that sounds like a lot of money, it really isn't in the big scheme of things.
And I always want to remind people that just the cost of administering central government is 11 billion. So we really are talking about a very small amount of money in governmental terms. But Martin Lyons, what needs to happen? How does the government need to address this? Well, what needs to happen for for these people that have finished the schemes at the end of this year, they need a A1 year rollover. They need to have certainty and that announcement needs to come out really soon, really quickly if it shouldn't already come out. But we need that announcement to give certainty farmers so they can feel that they can plan
their year ahead and then the new iteration of schemes need to be rolled out as soon as possible. Farmers are planning for not just the months ahead but the years ahead. And we want to be able to have certainty in a road map of actually next year, the year after. As a business, I know what I can do. I know where the public support and the outcomes public want from investing in into our landscape and also what the market can do. So that's what we we continue to call for is the government come out with an announcement to give these people the rollover that
they really need and deserve and nature needs it as well. We don't want to see a road back in that ambition and and we want that from Defra as soon as possible. So that's an emergency rollover of one year and then, you know, shortly thereafter, a proper sense, a proper sort of funded road map for how things are going to work in the future so that people can plan. Because as, as I think everybody said in one way or another, it, you know, farming isn't something that you can can change on a month to month basis. You're making decisions that often affect things, you know, years ahead. So you've just left the Labour Party conference.
Martin, did you get a sense of the mood music on Countryside Stewardship? I think for many MPs and and the new ministers have have little understanding really, they haven't had a chance to have their briefings and civil servants to explain the challenges and problems. But we're certainly raising it in every meeting as as we could in every panel session, making sure questions were asked around do they understand? Do they understand the impact? What we did here is lots of converse talk and presentations around climate resilience, climate investments, nature
being at the heart of stuff. And nature's so important. Let's make those words into deeds. Let's put them, you know, what we need them is to have the action. And being at a conference, you hear so many other stuffs about sustainable aviation and aviation fuels and, and actually being there gives you an understanding to really help MPs within the Labour Party and their ministerial teams and staff to understand what it is. Does it mean to be a farmer and understand to deliver on a longer term framework, there's lots more engagement needed and
that's what I come away with. Just how much more as farmers we've got to open up and engage with politicians and public and explain what we do in a in a friendly nature friendly way that helps deliver the outcomes we want. So that not with understanding that that job of work that needs to be done to bring more and more MPs and and Defra team up to speed on why this is important. Just give me a sense of a percentage. What, what, how, how likely do you think it is that there will be an emergency rollover that's. Entirely down to the Secretary
of State and the new Secretary of State and minister to make the decision. I, I am hopeful, certainly talking to senior civil servants and previous ministers that you know, that the intent is good, but they've got to make the right decision. But it does come at a cost and they've got to work out where that budget comes from and what the difference that makes in future options. So I am hopeful, but until that decision is made, I, you know, I'm like many holding breath and that's what I'm asking farmers, just wait for the moment and give this government a chance to
do the right thing and make a decision and then we plan going forwards with that investment. And of course, we're not just talking about money here, are we? There is a a real job of work to do, you know, but we've discussed before to win back trust from farmers and other people in the countryside, isn't there? And this is, you know, one thing that we've heard time and time again this morning, that even if the money comes back, it's having faith that there is actually going to be decent policy underpinning, you know, structural progress in the future. Definitely and kind of getting weary of hearing what you know, big commitments from politicians
from right across the different parties to not deem coming into action. We know our climate is changing, it's impact us. We know we have nature loss and we need to recover it. And what we need is certainty and joined up a sensible grown up conversation about that investment that's needed, that underpins our whole country, our health and our economy. Yeah, Thank you. Thanks, Martin. Thank you all, it's been really interesting and let's hope the government is listening and that it gets the message that funding for nature on farms is a need to have and not simply a nice to have.
I'd like to thank my guests Chris Millwood, Martin Hall, Anna Beastie and indeed Martin Lyons. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. You can hear more from Martin Lines in our new series, Martin's Farm, which focuses this month on October's activity at Papley Grove Farm in Cambridgeshire. On Gate is Europe's highest ranking food security podcast. And we're partof8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican Agri or Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Agrolo
and individual donors. I've been Finlay Costain, bye for now.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...