ffinlo Costain is joined by Martin Lines (Chief Exec NFFN), Nic Renison from Renison's Farm, and by Jenna Hegarty, Head of Policy at Nature Friendly Farming Network.We find out what's happening at Papley Grove in June - we discuss farm business resilience in the face of climate change - Nic talks about her farm and what it's like living under the Helm Wind - and Jenna presents NFFN's new report, The Nature of Business: Delivering resilience, food security and economic value through nature-friendly farming.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello and welcome to Martin's Farm on the Farm Gate podcast channel. I'm Finn Locostein, the editorof8.9.com. And I'm Martin Lyons, the chief exec for the Nature Friendly Farming Network. Later in the program we'll be joined by Nick Renison from Renaissance Farming Cumbria and by Jenna Hegarty, Head of Policy at the Nature Friendly Farming Network. But for now we're coming. Astonishingly, as it seems, or at least as it seems to me, towards the middle of the year, we're recording mid-May, but looking forward into June. What's going on for you, Martin? What does June bring? Well, June, but normally would bring thinking about preparing
for some cutting some early hay in, in certain fields. We do a lot of the hay cutting for a grass cutting in July, but we do start in some fields in June. But also we're, you know, about to as we're recording, we're actually having some rain falling and we haven't had rain for weeks or any amount and we've had by the end of today probably 20 mils. So that's actually put some moisture back into the land and then we're going to be looking at establishing our wild bird seed mixes. So we've taken out small areas of land across our farm and five other farms we work with where we'll be planting a mixture of
seeds and plants that will help give a winter food source next or this coming winter. So now we've had some moisture, we can get that preparation done, look to get that planted and hopefully if the weather's kind, get it up and established. And the trick is with this, we've got we're kind of having to delay a bit because we want the moisture to germinate the weeds before we plant the crop, but we're getting later in the season. And there's always this as a farming is it's always a compromise of getting best outcomes through a changing weather. You're talking about the water there, Martin, and presumably because you've been doing lots of work on your soil health,
that's going to be largely absorbed by the by the land. Is that the case for everybody around you or is some of that going to be absorbed, some of it going to run off? I mean, I, you know, drove off this morning and ridiculously there was flooding around us again just from one night of rain. I, I would think a lot of soil that's not in good hearts will, if you have a, an, you know, a good rain event, it will leave the land because the ground has gone so hard. It's not permanent anymore and it will flush off the top. So all the sediment and nutrients that lay on the surface end up in our
watercourses and and beyond. So what we've been doing for a number of years is trying to make sure our soil is in a good enough state. So when you do get a bit of moisture, it soaks in and and brings those nutrients into the roots and get the crops growing. So you just had, I mean you say you're waiting for the weeds, but you have you not been able to plant yet? No, it's been so dry. I mean we've had about with the rain, we've had this last week probably about 100 and 25130 mil of rain since the beginning of the year. When I go look in other to the country where you know that's in a month in some places. We are increasing as climate is changing, increasingly becoming
a really dry region in the spring. But what it's also done is accelerated a lot of our crops, our wheat, our barley, our spring barley, they're three weeks early. The years are already coming out and we shouldn't see the year on on a wheat crop until the first week in June, yet they're already out. So our crops have been really stressed and and are suffering from yield loss, but we've had a little bit of moisture. So hopefully we'll take them forward and and they'll develop a bit more. So those fields that you haven't yet been able to plant, when would you normally be planting them sort of March time? Yeah. Well, we, we plant us, our crops we harvest in March and early
April. But the crops we're planting for the birds to harvest, we normally do them around this time of year. It kind of depends on the way that we don't want to be too early because we want to get the rubbish to flush. But if we're too late, they won't set seed, so they won't be the resource for the for the birds and the wildlife later in the season. But we also mix in as we plant crops that do flowering elements for Celia, sunflowers and others. So we're helping the pollinators in that first blank period of our crops of finishing flowering. We then we have areas in the landscape that deliver another
flower resource. And those, those flower mixes that you're using, those are just for the birds, are they? So are they creating any income for you at all? The areas we're about to plant up are areas for bird food and they'll have some flowers in them. We have other areas across the farm for flowers. We do get paid in most for most of the options for government funded to schemes and a little bit of from private sector. They don't really generate a lot of income for us, but they do deliver a return on that area. And what I increasingly see is the benefit to our farm business by having more pollinators and
predatory insects on our farm. We're not needing to use insecticides. We hopefully will be more predictable if we have an aphid infestigation coming into a crop. Ladybirds, lace wings to hoverflies, they're sitting there in those crops. So it's this balance of productivity for myself. But there is a cost to managing this habitat, particularly if you do it well. We can all just have a bit. But if you really want to give it really good outcomes for nature and for wildlife, it needs looking after the same as my crops, and it's getting an income stream that helps me deliver those returns. So you've got some crops in the
ground, some you're still waiting to get in there, the crops that are growing. You're saying that you suspect there's going to be a bit of a yield penalty because of the weather there. When are you looking sort of expecting to harvest? I think you were saying sort of July, you'd normally start the harvesting and and when do you finish? Well we normally start with winter barley in mid-july ish and then traditionally in the past winter wheat would start towards the end of the first week in August. Looking at where our wheats are now, I think we'll be done and dusted. If the weather's, if we have a dry summer, some weather, nice
weather, we'll be done and dusted in July and I think people will be harvesting some crops in early June, in late June. Winter wheat, winter barley, anybody who's listening who's, you know, not au fait with these terms and not a farmer is going to be wondering why you're harvesting winter wheat and winter barley in July The. Term winter wheat is when we plant it. We are planting winter wheat and barley in the autumn into the winter. So that was planted in October and November. And this when we talk about spring barley, that's the crops and the spring wheat, that's the
crops we plant in the spring, typically in sort of late February, March window. But it's amazing nature brings all these crops already together around that summer period of sort of normally July and August. But this is the second or third or second year we've seen extreme early harvest. Last year was the same because of really dry weather. The crop gets stressed and crop that is stressed races to seed. It wants to put its ear out. The whole purpose of a plant is to drop seeds off to re establish and we want to harvest those seeds.
But because it's been just dry, when we plant a seed, it has lots of shoots that come up, which are called tillers and they all have an ear. And because it's been so dry, a lot of those side shoots, the tillers have been dying off. And so we're not going to get the yield and the and the output that we'd hoped for. But I do think we are slightly more resilient than others. When I look around sort of our local landscape, because our soil is in better condition. It is the crops aren't doing in the dry and particularly when that that dry wind was blowing, our crops really go backwards. I want to go across to Nick in just a second, but before I do,
I want to talk to you about machinery. Because one of the issues, I guess, with setting up a farm quite apart from, you know, finding the landing and and getting onto it is the cost of all the machinery that's associated with agriculture. Do you have to own everything yourself or are you sort of involved in some kind of cooperative where you're able to share the machinery? I imagine that's that could be quite a challenge, but harvest time when everybody's needing to harvest at the same time. Yeah. So we've set our business up that we farm for other people. We share farm, contract farm.
So we go and work for other farmers in the local area and offer our machinery as a service. We also work with some other neighbors where they come and do some jobs for us. They've got machinery item we need, don't need to get harvest time and any other operation is time sensitive and everybody wants it all at the same time. So what we tend to do is end up buying a bit bigger machine and going to work over more ground and if you get payments to cover the cost of it. But the machinery cost has gone up sort of 3035% in the last few years, yet our crops we sell
haven't gone up at all. And this is becoming increasingly difficult as machinery and technology further develops. The cost of the machinery is getting out of reach now and it's becoming increasingly difficult to justify investment in new machinery. And presumably the computer systems that come along with them, and the servicing that that requires. Absolutely. All of our all of our main tractors operate in a field to 2.5 centimeters. They're all GPS linked, they're satellite mapping, they're collecting data, they they know where the poles and the obstacles are in the field. But all of that has a cost and
the latest technology in engines and cab efficiencies and everything else, oh, it's always adding better comfort for the operator, but additional cost. But it's the data that's going to be important that I can prove what I've done in the right place at the right amount, but also hopefully cuts and costs of inputs. But at the moment, cost savings and the cost and investment aren't marrying up at the moment. Yeah, it's interesting, isn't it? In the old days, of course, you'd have been able to tell who was a farmer in the summertime because they, you know, they'd, they'd be deeply tanned. Whereas these days farmers are inside their tractor cabs.
And so perhaps the farmers are the ones that are even, you know, paler than the rest of us that are going around. I wonder as well, you know, just around that whole machinery thing that it sounds like what you're doing is that you're, you are sort of sharing out the machinery, but that you're sharing the labour as well. So that it's sort of yourself and the tractor or yourself and the the harvester that are going to other places. And in terms of other things that are coming across to you, it's the machine and the person that's that's driving it. Yeah, I mean, before machines were fairly simple to operate and so anyone could almost jump
on and go. So they're really technical pieces of machinery now. And to get the best out of them you need an operator, know how to work them well. And also if they don't work well, the cost of repairs when things go wrong are astronomical. I mean, some of the repair bills and service bills we get nowadays are eye watering because so you want a good trained operator on there. So that's where we send a machine with an operator, and we'll bring someone in with an operator to get the machine to do the best output it possibly can. Fantastic. Look, Nick, I'd like to come across to you and you know,
I've, I've seen you around the regenerative scene for, uh, for many years and never quite managed to get you on the podcast. I'm really pleased that you're here today. And I just wonder if you could tell us a bit about your farm, sort of where you are, how high, how many acres, what you produce, all that sort of thing? Well, thanks Finland, it's a pleasure to be here and from your last conversation, I'm very pale in the north. There's not much sun, pale and cold. Umm, so I farm with my husband Renault, uh, half an hour east of Penrith in the, on the kind of Eden Valley on the, the edge
of the Pennines. We farm 360 acres. We go, the farmhouse is kind of in the middle of the farm and that's the 800 foot and we go up to 1100. We probably got out of that 360 acres, 200 of kind of good pasture, grazing land, silage and the rest is either woodland. We've got a big wood pasture scheme on, on a quite a rough area and, and kind of quite new woodland that we planted. We farm 7080 Aberdeen Angus suckler cow and then we have, we
used to have a lot of sheep and we haven't got any sheep anymore. That's been kind of a major change in the last 1213 years. But we also have 600 laying hens who follow the cows around in rotation, kind of inspired by Joel Salatin, Richard Perkins, their work. And we've been doing that for six years and that's quietly grown and, yeah, involved in countryside stewardship, SFI and we have a few pigs. Yeah, fantastic. And you say you got rid of the sheep. Why did you do that? Because Renault said one day
that he, a very big swear word, couldn't stand sheep. No, there was a, there was a mixture, I think sheep when we first got here, sheep are really a good kind of starter enterprise because they're cheap to get into, quite a quick turnover of cash, don't require much kind of infrastructure. And I think, but the more we got into the rotational grazing, we just realized that sheep, the way they're grazed just didn't really suit our system. And now bizarrely now if we had maybe 200 sheep, they would fit really well into our system because we'd have clean pastures and they'd, they'd do a job.
But we've kind of got used to life without them. Also, it's the fact that they, I can remember going for a walk and I found this little, I think it was AI can't say it's a ragged Robin plant a flower. And I got really excited about it. So I went back to show tell Renault to come and have a look at it. By the time I've got back to, it'd been eaten. It's that kind of thing. Cheaper, just they, they love tasty stuff. But I, we don't miss them, I think. I think as you get older your back starts to play up. Sheep are just quite hardware. Yeah, fair enough, fair enough. And you talked about woodland pasture there. When you say that, is that sort
of woodland that the cattle and the pigs are in? The, yeah, the cows, the pigs don't really go in there. It's, it's a woodland pasture scheme, which we're in year 4 of. So a lot of cactus guards on the side of a hill. I don't think our generation will see the benefit, but I think in time, whoever's here in 50 years time will 60 years time will be having a will have a lovely 100 acres of proper wood pasture. Yeah. I wonder, I wonder if you could describe it for me because I'm, I sort of have in mind, I went to visit Mark and Jenny Lee at Trepena up in Cumbria a little
while ago. And they're doing lots of woodland pasture where they're sort of they've got different trees that they're expecting to grow to different heights. And they've sort of got medicine boxes as they sort of call them. I think with fenced off areas with trees growing in them that they expect the cattle to be able to sort of self medicate it, you know, over time. Do you have that kind of thing? Are you building that sort of, you know, range of habitat? Yeah, kind of. So this is a 130 acre block. We've just imagine a bleak Pennine hillside, quite scrubby, lots of bracken, poor grazing really, and had been over grazed
with chic for generations. So that's just, we've just covered that in cactus scars, but done it quite strategically that we can still graze the cattle and we they go up there in the in the kind of late summer and graze in blocks. But yeah, it's just, it's, it just works really well. And financially wood patches, it's a very good scheme to be in, but it does require quite a lot of beating up. So within each of those cactus guards, there's three trees. So the, the hope is that one of them, one of them's got to live
and hopefully they'll be like a hawthorn or a dog rose which will accompany the main tree. But at the minute it just, it's like with all tree planting projects, initially they don't look great and it just takes time. And of course it takes water at the right time as well. And Martin's been talking about his water problems particularly. Not enough of it and and hopefully he's got a bit that's come over the last 24 hours. How are things for you up in Cumbria? We're not too bad I think, and that's partly because we're because we haven't got sheep. The cattle go in kind of late January till the end of March.
We went into winter with reasonable covers and so when it does rain we hold it. But we've had, we had quite a dry April and it's a bit the our main problem this year is it's cold. It's really quite chilly. We still got daffodils out. It's that, you know, we're so Tilaid and the Hawthorn, our whole Northorn isn't out yet. In comparison to last year, it's just quite miserable. Yeah, yeah, you're not alone there. Down in Dorset, it's been pretty miserable as well. But we are long past the daffodil place. It was strange. We kind of, you know, we, we waited and waited and waited for spring to happen and then it
came and suddenly everything came out at once, including things like the Campion, which normally I would associate with June. And so we've, we've, you know, even now mid-May, we're at the point where most of the summer flowers have kind of gone over and everything's looking very green. But of the flowers have passed, which is, which is very strange at this, at this time of year. I wonder, you know, whether you're noticing. I mean, you talked there about the way in which you're holding the water, which, you know, for a, a hillside farm is great. You know, it's, it's pretty unusual in itself.
But I I wonder if you're noticing impacts of climate change on the farm? Well, I think it's just like example this year is the house Martins just haven't really come back. I never thought I'd kind of overly worry about bird life in my younger years. I wasn't really bothered to about birds, but if these house Martins just kind of slowly decline to nothing that's going to it really makes me quite sad. But I think it's funny whenever I do talks and stuff and they ask you, you know, what's your biggest worry for the farm or the weather is always the thing that I say. It's the, we got really battered
by the beast from the east and that just made us realise that we need to have a resilient, you know, we need to have a plan in place for, for things like that. And if we have a particularly dry spring, because we're quite, even though we're quite high, we're quite sandy and we can very quickly dry up. So I think the weather is a part of the bank managers cause a stress as well, but the weather is kind of our main potential for for stress really. You mentioned the beast from the yeast there, and I have a beast from the yeast in mind, but I suspect it's possibly different from yours.
Which it was yours? 2018, yeah, no. It was the same then. So that's a long time ago. And that was really heavy driving snow, wasn't it? Yeah, it was just a combined. So we we live under the helm wind. It's the only name wind in the in the country. And it's just, it's utterly grim. I think if we looked into it that much, we wouldn't have moved here. So it's it's just a serious helm wind, a serious easterly. Yeah, we were just, we wore ski wear for three days, lost a load of sheep. It was just, it, it was, it was
quite, it was every time you went outside you were kind of risking it was life or death. It was, it was proper bad. And you realise how powerful the weather can be and Mother Nature's in charge and we're just kind of little stick men on a massive football. Yeah, it sounds tough and, and and being under a named wind. Yeah, absolutely. It's it's one of those things they ought to stick on the estate agent information, isn't it? I remember, yeah, where I grew up in the West Midlands, not far away from us, there were two tower blocks, I think, sort of council tower blocks. And it was said that the wind
didn't stop anywhere on on its way from Siberia. It was the highest point on the way from Siberia. And so it just got everything. And it must have been really pretty grim. Well, it was 105 miles an hour wind just on the top of our hill and it was just, it was breathtaking. It literally took your breath away. Yeah, but at least you, you just, you didn't get blown away yourself. Now, Martin, what's been happening in the policy world? Apart from anything else, you've got a new report out. Yeah. So to sort of kick off on, you know, this week as we're recording it is our nature friendly farming week. And to sort of kick the week off
where we've pulled a new report together, the nature of business. And it really sort of that focus of nature is part of business and business should be part of nature. We had a launch event yesterday down in Parliament, had a whole range of organisations, NGOs and all the parliament parliamentarians there to come and kick that off. Brilliant. And Jenna just sort of bringing you in. I mean, let's just pretend that Martin isn't here. Does he actually do any writing on these reports or is it all you? He's the all seeing eye that makes sure that it contains what it needs to, umm, Now I, uh, I'm
sure Martin won't mind me saying. And writing's probably not his idea of having a good time. Whereas I enjoy writing and I enjoy trying to communicate. Some really chunky, contentious, sometimes often quite challenging topics in a way that is accessible and not alienating or, or a turn off. And I think, you know, for a member LED, uh, you know, a member LED organization, a farming organization, if we can't talk in ways that are accessible to both people on the ground and you know, the people
in offices making and shaping policy, then when we're not doing our job right. So I kind of see that that's a space where I occupy. But if it's all right, I might say a little bit more about what the report does and says. I mean, the preceding conversation teases up. I mean, it's almost like, you know what you're doing. Finlay teed it up beautifully. Don't tell people that, that would just be embarrassing. But that whole, you know, volatility is, is the new norm. I mean that I think that that can't really, it doesn't really come across any more strongly than when you're. Talking to two farmers and we've got, you know, an arable and a livestock farmer, different
parts of the country and that are experiencing essentially the same thing but in in different ways. And it is sadly because of our change in climate, you know, it is the new normal. Farming is being consistently clobbered. You know, what were kind of one in four, one in five kind of, you know, year risks, you know, are now much, much more frequent and are set to be become even more frequent. And it's, you know, again, timing is, is is beautiful. By the time this is out, the the latest Climate Change Commission report on adaptation will be will be out in the public domain.
And, you know, we all have a pretty good idea of what that's going to be saying. It's not going to be saying everything's fine, don't worry, we don't need to worry now. Quite the opposite. So business as usual is not a viable option. But hope is not lost. And that's, you know, what the report essentially is trying to get at is, I suppose three things that provides a really useful snapshot of kind of up-to-the-minute evidence on, you know, impacts of climate change and nature loss to particularly to farming, but also crucially, the, the solutions. And it sets out really at its heart, it's the investment case for nature friendly farming.
And we come at it from three different spatial spatial scales. So the farm business level. So why working with with nature as a farming partner essentially is good for your business. And both Martin and Nick have brought in different examples of how that helps their systems. It's also imperative at the national level. So whether you're looking at the kind of UK across the, the piece or individual developed countries, nature friendly farming is absolutely critical for a number of things. You know, if we don't sort that out, you know, our long term food security and indeed national security is going to be
severely undermined. We've got a range of binding nature and climate targets across the UK. If nature friendly farming isn't at the heart of our, our food production system, then we can kiss those goodbye. And, and also we have to remember why those, why those targets are so important in the 1st place. Because if we don't fix climate and nature, then we really, we will not be able to produce, you know, into the future. So it's, it's not a kind of like it's nice to have it an absolute kind of critical underpinning. And then the third scale it looks at is the benefits to the private sector. You know, particularly, I mean, there's very few elements of, of
our supply chain that doesn't depend on agricultural outputs of some kind. But you know, food supply chains are the obvious 1. You know, again, nature friendly farming as a kind of de risking mechanism for supply chain actors is getting more and more embedded, not to the extent that it needs to be yet, but it's getting there. So the benefits at those 3 levels are really, really clear. We're not quite where we need to be. So like with any influencing report, it concludes with a series of strategic recommendations to essentially to government, but it speaks to the role of the private sector
as well. And basically just, you know, says get a move on because we can't hang around. No, it's a really interesting report and I've enjoyed reading through it and I'll talk to you about some of the some of the conclusions that you come to in just a moment. But you mentioned the climate change committee and the adaptation report that's, that's coming out and we can we can talk about it now because this this, you know will come out after that report has been released. One of the things that I found when I was just sort of looking at the basic bullet points associated with the report was that, again, although it was talking about nature, although
it was talking about farming, it didn't seem to be connecting the two very well. When it's talking about water, for example, it's talking about creating on farm water storage to reduce drought risk. But I get the impression that they're talking about built infrastructure, They're not talking about soil, they're not talking about nature's infrastructure. Was that the impression that you got as well? I was lucky enough to be at a pre briefing session last week and you know, the, the CCC, they, you know, they play things close to their chests because
understandably they don't want things leaking out in in advance. But I kind of came away with a sense, you know, the devil with the detail. And it's, it's going to be a big report with lots of, you know, technical annexes, which will be equally kind of, you know, complex to, to chew through. But I got the feeling that they, they were very much speaking about the need for more built infrastructure to store more water on farm as being part of it, that the imperative for making our landscapes more, you know, permeable and able to hold water much better is equally, if
not more important. So, and I, I do think we need to do both. I mean, I think that the, the, the need for, on, on farm water sources that are there for, you know, primarily, let's say agronomic purposes is just something, you know, with changing climate, particularly in the east of the country, I think we've just got to face up to our, our rainfall, you know, just occurs at really random Times Now, particularly when it comes after a drought, our soils not really able to, to absorb it quickly. So you've got to, you know, find a way of harnessing as much of that as possible so we can use it when, when the land is able
to take it and unable to absorb it. But I think the role of soils is going to come through really, really strongly. I know that the CCC are increasingly interested in, in the role of, of agricultural soils, you know, how we can improve the health of soil so it can, it can do its ecosystem services jobs even better. And yet we need, we need, we need to be able to hold more water on, on farms. And I think that is a it's a mix of both built infrastructure in the right places at the right scale, but also a hell of a lot more nature based solutions.
I think it's really important that groups like the Committee on Climate Change really do start to talk much more about land and nature and farming to sort of integrate these, you know, the things that they're trying to achieve in terms of adaptation and mitigation with the things that we are frequently talking about on the Farming Gate podcast, you know, whether that's with yourselves or, or, or with other people. Because it's only by having those connections to other big sort of strings within government that that the case starts to be made for additional funding coming in there. And one of the other sort of elements within the report,
again, was, was this sort of aspect of, of adapting infrastructure to avoid cascading disruption. Now at the moment, you know, we've got what, 8 shops, something along those lines delivering 9095% of the food, you know, retail to people in this country, huge, you know, sort of centres of, of food, food retail and, and actually a regionalisation of that infrastructure, a localisation of that infrastructure would make it much more difficult for
anybody, whether that's through technological sort of, you know, sort of data type attacks or, or whether it's, it's physical attacks from from elsewhere if we're looking at food security. But at the moment the, the CCCCCC, the Committee on Climate Change is primarily talking in terms of that infrastructure adaptation around transport and energy and, and telecommunications. I, I feel like there's a real opportunity here for, for food system regionality as we go forward too. Yeah. And the the food strategy that was announced, the new the new
one to to some fanfare when I think Steve Reed was still Secretary of State hasn't done a lot. Before we went to housing and forgot forgot farming even existed. Yes, absolutely. You know, build, baby build. Yeah, it's, I mean, we've, we've had since, since labour has been in, in power actually, you know, a lot of really important strategic processes have kind of crept forward frustratingly slowly. And, and, you know, the lunges framework and it's really, really positive initiative. It's really great that it's out. I think it contains some, some really very good useful stuff.
But it did take a while and that was, you know, in part because it reshuffles and and the like. But the food strategy, I mean, I'm, I, I don't know, I'm quite worried about it, but that, that obviously is the most obvious place to do exactly what you've just set out as in, you know, well, how do we kind of de risk off our food systems? And well, and you know, one another element of it is, and it's included in, in de risking, I suppose, is making it healthier and more sustainable for people and planet. But that strategic process just seems to have lost its momentum. And I'm hoping that the, you know, the CCC report, which is going to be pointed and have a
lot in it. And we'll talk about the, you know, we'll talk about the changes needed in the food system as much as anywhere else will provide some useful kind of, you know, impetus to get that, get that moving. Because I think, I mean, you're absolutely right. I think more regionalised food systems are the way ahead to to do you risk a lot of our current system. I wonder whether, you know, I mean, there's a term that I've been using recently which is shadow economy. And it's, it's sort of trying to work out ways of building and having a strategy to build this regionalisation that's necessary, this sort of, you know, shorter supply chain
network that we're talking about. Because of course, you know, there is going to be pressure towards government from the big retailers not to do this. But at the same time, there is a real need for it. And, and, and now that in England, for example, the rural economy is being delegated or strategic responsibility for the, for the rural economy as being delegated to local authorities. So it'd be quite interesting to see whether it's possible to build up that sort of shadow economy strategy so that it can sit alongside and in parallel with the, the bigger retailer model.
Because, you know, we're obviously not going to move from one system to another overnight, but it would be good, good to have some real impetus to, to build that, that sort of second economy underneath the, the, the primary 1. Martin, I'm just wondering whether I could come back to you on on this next question, which is around whether nature friendly farming can create resilience for all kinds of farming. And you know, obviously if we're talking about farms that are already, you know, relatively extensive, you know, whether that's land production or cattle or, you know, woodland pasture as we were talking about with Nick or arable and horticulture as we're talking about more with
you, you know, we can see that resilience can be built in by working more closely with nature. But I wonder if those more industrialized models, of which there are so many across the UK, are there ways that they can better integrate nature and build resilience for themselves as well? Yeah, I think they can. I think they also need to consider where their future is and, and will they fit into a, a, a changing climate and and that, you know, housed animal system is appropriate. But certainly planting more trees around chicken sheds and
having and and livestock buildings can, you know, suck up a lot of the ammonia emissions taking off a shade and shelter. There's are multiple benefits that you could really look at nature as a partner in your system to help deliver shade shelter, slowing the flow of air down. You know, if you're in the middle of the winter, you got 120 mile an hour winds, having a few more trees and hedges out out and about can help deliver that. So I think everybody needs to look at their business, their landscape and think how do we put more natural systems and
nature into that thing? So if you're planting a tree, can it have a fruit on it? Can it have a flowering element on it rather than just the a green tree And it and it's putting that mixture into the landscape and always thinking about diversity of stuff in there rather than monocultures, because nature doesn't do monocultures. And that's the real key thing is how do you join things up and deliver a mosaic of things that can offer you goods and services, offer you some fruit, but also shade and shelter? So for me, everyone can, and I think everyone must, because if
not, we're not going to get to a pleasant future. And then the question there always of course comes back to who pay is what's the incentive and and making the economic case for those farms to, to put that woodland in. And if we're talking about it, as you say, with around chicken sheds where you're sort of trying to soak up some of the ammonia and so on, you know, who is it that's benefiting from that and therefore who pays for it? And we'll maybe come back to that in just a moment. But Nick, looking at your farm individually, because it's all very well sort of talking on a national level, resilience
happens on, you know, really a farm by farm basis. What have you done to create resilience in your business? Well, just going back, we initially put in a lot of hedges and I think my thought at the time was that it was going to create shelter. But when we were lambing, but actually now as we're doing, we've obviously got the cattle, it's its shade. And we're looking at putting wood pasture further down the farm on our main grazing blocks for that reason, because you've got a field of 100 head of stock and it's a hot day and they're black.
It's not, it's not great. But the resilience as far as selling produce goes, we've, we've just, I'm just thinking we've really shortened our supply chains. So all our store cattle go to Westmoreland services to their farm to be finished. So that's a relationship we've kind of built up over a number of years and that works really well. And our eggs are all sold locally and just to small businesses, cafes, some direct to the consumer. So we're very much in charge of where stuff goes and it's building those relationships.
So if we have a problem, we can communicate that and, you know, we can negotiate a slightly better price. But you do have to be competitive in the market. I mean, it's not, we're not kind of talking, you know, crazy niche product prices and, and soil as well. When we first came here in 2012, we we got the farm or we didn't even, we didn't think about digging a hole. We didn't, you know, we didn't look at the soil. And now the soil is our main asset and we're lucky that we've got good soils and we haven't used fertilizer since 2015. So we, we were just here the other day.
We were with some chap putting in a water pipe and it was the first time I'd seen really good Rhizo, you know, the sheaths, the kind of Rasta. So that was great because that's been a long time coming. It takes time, like we're kind of 1213 years down the line and it's we're just seeing that. So takes time. Yeah, brilliant. And and you mentioned that sort of shorter supply chain that you have and Westmoreland services, which I think is up on the M6 or up for me, maybe it's down for you And, and, and so how does that work? Do do, do they produce?
I mean you're selling into Westmoreland, do they produce? Do they have a farm themselves produce? They, they have a farmer just as you come just below the T Bay services run by a chap called Sean. And they're well, well in getting into the regen journey. And yeah, so they just, we agree a price, a couple of lorries come and and they're just, we're just paid, paid a pence per kilo. And it's just really it's a very clean, simple system. And then we we give them feedback as we're carving on our bull selection and they give us
feedback on how the animals go through through the shop. Really. Yeah. So it's good. Brilliant. And in terms of, you know, the sort of the broader farm business, are you simply producing food and selling food or are there other aspects of the business as well? Well, so we're lucky that we're in a, it's called a different name now. It was a area of outstanding national landscape. So we're lucky that we're just in that. So we've been able to apply for Fipple funding. So that's been really good. It's paid for some of our hedges, some water stuff and
water. We've had part funding for a barn. We've done that because we do quite a lot of farm meetings and events on the farm. And so we've had a barn that's been done and we're just starting to get that as a space for schools and stuff, but also for kind of corporate to bring corporate people here. So we recently had dumbier was dumbier and and they came with a Co-op. So it's it's really good that they can see in a farm that's actually doing stuff. And then they just had a normal business meet their normal
business meeting. So that's it's getting more people on the farm. That's what I'd really like to do. So when you say sort of corporate events, you're talking, you're not talking about paintballing among the trees, you're talking about people coming and using, using it for for meetings. So my vision is they'll, they'll have their kind of corporate meeting and they'll sit on our comfy chairs and enjoy all the surroundings. And then at coffee time they might go and collect eggs or they could help run and move the cows or they could, I don't know, go and do some hedge stuff. So it's actually seeing what it's like on the ground because I think in this space the danger
is it becomes quite academic and you've actually got to, I talked to someone yesterday about egg production and they have little idea of where the actual free range eggs are produced. So it's just that quietly, quietly drip drip education piece. And apart from these other sources, you know, things like fitball or the the money coming in from corporates, would the farm be able to sort of survive to cope purely on food production? Yeah, yeah, it, it would actually because we just, there's only Renault and I, there's two of us and we run
quite a kind of our inputs are very low. We've we've managed to apart from chicken feed, we've kind of stripped all inputs out really. And I think it goes back to the report we, we've done a little bit of work with Chris Clark and it's reaching that sweet spot. It's and Rena's got this, this phrase he kind of comes out with every now and again of farming in abundance. And I think when you start to put we and in the past, we have pushed, we pushed cow numbers maybe went to 100 and it was just too, too much for the, for the farm. So it's just drawing everything back and when you get to that sweet spot, you have less vet
spills, you know, everything just runs a little bit bit sweeter. And when you say Chris Clark, we're talking talking about the whole maximum sustainable output process. Yeah, which I think is unbelievably complicated, but if you draw back from it a little bit, it does make complete sense. Yeah, I they, they have to write the whole book. And so it's sort of, it can come across as being unbelievably complicated, but, but actually it's it, it can be sort of boiled down to something relatively simple, isn't it? It's, it's just basically making sure that you're producing, you know, what the land can sustain. I I guess in a nutshell, but but
it but obviously that, you know, there's more complexity to it. And I wonder if you've been able to benefit from nature markets as well. You talked about, you know, The Woodlands that you've got on the farm and that that planting as well. Is that sort of largely farm support to plant the trees or are you also managing to sell woodland or nature? No, I was talking to Martin about this yesterday. We're a bit slow to this party. We've just, all of our planting has been heavily helped with the Woodland Trust and, and countryside stewardship and stuff and Fipple, but we've just joined Regenerate outcomes.
So we've had our everything measured, but I've just always been very anti carbon footprint calculators just because I think there's, I don't know, I just very anti that kind of thought process. But we have just done the Regenerate outcomes and I in my mind I'd like to, we've got lots of little pockets of woodland which are quite young. I'd like businesses locally to sponsor that woodland. That's how I see it in my head. I'm, I'm a little bit sceptical about the big corporatisation of, I don't know, I'm, I'm, I'm
a slut. Yeah. I'm not a huge fan, although I'm probably I don't know enough about. It, I guess there are lots of different ways of doing these things, aren't there? And and the way that we generate outcomes works is that they are sort of adding value to, to the carbon credit with that sort of nature element as well, which I think you know is quite an interesting model. But but that sort of idea of selling shares to the woodland, to the local community, I've not come across before. Presumably that would be in return for access and and and a range of things like. That yeah, I think so because we we've just put in, we put in a
200 metre, 5 metre wide hedge. We just kind of did it on a whim and that is just full of wildlife. And we we don't actually get any payment for that. And I just think it, it would be worth someone to have it on their website that every year they gave give us a certain amount of money for the upkeep of that. And you know, they could bring people out and see it. And I think it's just, rather than some random multi international company saying, oh, we plant trees every, every flight we we get a tree or something. It's it's, it's more tangible, it's local.
I guess it would it be interesting as well if you've got solar or wind developers in the area either talking to them or talking to the communities in which those, those renewable energy installations are going into. Because often there are, you know, there are funds that are set up within the community to fund things within the community. And actually, rather than paying for a new playground or paying for yet another village hall or something, if there was a way of diverting some of that money to pay for nature outcomes such as yours, that would be really quite interesting to to think about. Yeah. Well, in, in my mind, we've just
got to, we've got our bit of land and we've just got to make it as diverse and alive and, and you know, not be, just look quite broad at what's, what's possible here. And I was interested as well in the way that you talked about the, the chickens following the cows around. I, I haven't asked you about it because we've spoken about that kind of thing a few times on the podcast already recently. But, but that, you know, is a fantastic model, isn't it? Of, of making sure that the, the chickens are going in, they're eating up the fly eggs and, and the, the larvae and, and all that sort of stuff. And and just again rebuilding
some of the fertility into the soil. Yeah, it's a. It's a, it's a perfect symbiotic relationship and it's just, I, I, we've got a student here at the minute and she's the studying rewilding. Anyway, she's come for a month and I, I did it with her this morning and I just said there's a, there's a saying that if it, if it doesn't smell right, it's, it's not right. And with our chickens, because they're being moved every two days, they're always being moved away from their poo basically. And there's just absolutely no smell there. And it's just definitely in my mind the the way that we should be looking at production, but the regulations of a different
subject and they make it very tricky. Yeah, maybe we ought to talk about the regulations another time. Yeah, absolutely. Thanks so much, Nick. That's been really interesting. And coming back to you, Martin, just on that economic question, one of the report conclusions is that the government needs to increase public investment in farming. Now, government has been pretty stone deaf to this message over the course of the last few years. Why would it suddenly change its mind? What are the new arguments that you're making? Why should government essentially double the funding this year if they've refused to last year? I think it's making a case for why investment is so important.
I think previously as an industry, we've shouted about, you know, protecting food production and as a single outcome, and we we continue to to demonstrate and put through the report and throughout the documentation of the value of nature in a landscape, the value for nature, for society, for flood mitigation, for shade shelter, access to nature. That shouldn't just fall on Defra's plate. That needs to fit across the economic houses of government. So the health department, the Treasury Department, housing
department, all of it, because actually 70% of our landscape is farmed and we don't think enough of all of the things it can deliver. We put it in little categories and silos. And if we stack it together, and that's what we're trying to come across, that that landscape needs investment to deliver really sustainable outcomes and sort of regenerative outcomes, not just where we are. And that might mean water, nature, access, shade and all of it, fiber, timber. So who pays? This government needs to pay its part, but does so does the
supply chain, and so does we as society. And how do we then use our economic power, as in purchasing power or investment power, to bring that investment into our landscapes to deliver for the nation's economy? We have a huge opportunity to grow an economy by growing better things in our landscape. As you know, I'm interested in the whole national security argument around food systems and the way that they operate in terms of delivering ecological security as well. And one of the points I think it
was made by Joe Stanley on the podcast recently is that armies and you know, sort of these defensive organisations, they're quite unique in the economy in that we invest ridiculously vast sums of money into these things. You know, and in an ideal world, in the hope that actually those armies never go to war, that we're never going to need them, but there's an awful lot of money that goes into them anyway. And this whole sort of situation around resilience, that having a resilient homeland is part of NATO Article 3.
There is a duty to deliver that. And soil and ecological security, food systems at a regional level. Those are all things that are really critical in terms of delivering that resilience. And I wonder, you know, if there is an argument there in terms of that national security argument in the same way that the armed forces are getting a lot of money that hopefully they will never need to spend, that we need to deliver that resilience to achieve national resilience. National security investing in farm systems actually is important from that perspective as well. Yeah. I think it's, it's, it's
absolutely critical. I think as an industry we've and and and supply chain, we've only focused on the food elements of what what we produce, but we produce so much more. So we've not made in the economic case of investment and I think treasury and government as a whole and I think it's part of the nation, how do we put a price on nature? How do we put an economic return? So corporates that do invest in nature based solutions can see economic return for their balance sheets and it's getting across. And I think that's what we've really got to do over in a pretty emergency state, get out,
get this message across over the next short period of time to shift the Treasury's mindset. And it's modelling that investment by the nation and by industries will deliver long term benefits. And hopefully even if we don't need those benefits as in a return, the benefits it gives gives us a lot better landscape that gives us a lot more security for everything as a in a changing climate. So it's a win, win all the way round. Now, Jenna, we talked briefly about the Committee on Climate Change and the way that it's really important that
organisations like that or like for example, the NHS start talking about food and farming and tackling siloed decision making is another goal that you have within this report. And it seems to me that this is becoming more and more difficult, that democratic government in the social media age seems to be destined only to deliver tactically. And often when we're talking about tactically, you know, that's within a month or something of an issue arriving. How do you get a government to think more strategically?
Well, I think you've kind of touched on it. I, I think it is somehow finding a way to, to communicate the reality that we are in an emergency situation because that's when you see joined up thinking across, across governments where, you know, we saw it in COVID, We see it in times of, of geopolitical conflict. I very recently, I'm, you know, slightly behind the curve, but went to a community viewing of the national climate emergency film the other week. And that does a very good job. I think of kind of communicating that, you know, level of like
this is the situation. We are in a crisis. We can, you know, avert the worst and we can generate a whole load of, you know, wider societal benefits through those same actions. So what are we waiting for? And, and it is, it is ultimately a political choice. So like citizens in a in a, in a democracy, it's about trying to apply as much pressure on those in power and those who influence the people in power through a variety of of ways, which is, you know, compelling evidence. It's compelling stories from people who are, you know, proof of concept.
Nick Martin, you know, many of other farmer members being being great examples and essentially riding those kind of, you know, those twin horses of bigging up the positives because there are absolutely loads and also kind of, you know, turning the screws on on, you know, the kind of the pain of inaction. And again, that can kind of that out in slightly different ways. There's no one silver bullet. And, you know, the kind of the frustration of, you know, even 1 government department and its teams not talking to each other. You know, you scale that up
across the whole government and then you scale that up across the four UK governments because, you know, we are shared set of islands and we're, you know, with the same challenges and we, we are really, really unjoined up. So I think it is, it's somehow kind of translating that, you know, the essence of the of the emergency going right, the response is this, but the payback is immeasurable. And I think that it goes back to, and we've been talking about this for a long time and we'll continue to do this. It is an investment. It is not a cost, it's an investment. And if I'm just kind of Wheeling around and like, you know, nitpicking a bit, but I think
language really, really is important. One of the things that I'm not a fan of in reports from the likes of of the CCC is when they talk about finances in and use terminology like subsidies, because we're not talking about subsidies, we're talking about payments for services and goods rendered. That's really, really important. I think we have to completely ditch subsidies and the language of subsidies and talk about actually what we are doing, which is investing in the land and the people and the services and that they they produce, which we are utterly dependent
on. Yeah, I couldn't agree with that more. And it's fantastic that the Nature Friendly Farming Network is doing this. And, you know, I really wish that, you know, those sort of mainstream big organisations like the NFU and the and the Country Business Association, I really wish that they would do that as well, because I just don't here enough of it coming through, which is a real shame. And you talked about the national emergency briefing. You know, I watched that myself as well. And my, my sort of comment coming away from it was that it was incredibly fear based. And actually, you know, we didn't get to see the briefing.
We it was, it was kind of like, what's the program that that's where you you watch people watching TV. There was an awful lot of that. It was people responding the Google box. Yeah, yeah, sort of responding to things that were being said. And actually, you know, much as much as the fear was there, they were still understating certain things. So they had a section talking about the, the Atlantic Meridian low turning circulation and, and science has come out since that lecture was, was made, which has suggested that the whole thing is going to happen twice as quickly as as they're talking about there.
So they're, you know, the, the fear was there, but it is, it's, it's finding the opportunity because having scared people, they then gotta be able to do something otherwise it's just incredibly depressing. And I think what's really unique about food systems and about and about farming more broadly and and sort of building in nature, building in that ecological security element is that it is a win, win, win. As you say, it's not about subsidising, it's about paying farmers to deliver the security that we need in our ecology, in
our water system and for our food systems going forward. I. Completely agree and it's I get so frustrated when you hear that word subsidy or taking land out of production, out of out of production. It isn't, it's prioritising production. That's the benefit for our businesses and the nation and it's that you know the land use framework and other strategic documents to think about what needs to be where. How do we have those local and regional discussions around localised food systems, localised landscape, resilience
and investments by everybody to get the best possible outcomes with the science we have today, We cannot wait and continue waiting for other stuff to come. Let's get on with stuff and I see that with many farmers, they are really keen to get on with stuff. They just need help and some support in knowledge, information and some funding and they'll make changes happen now. And it's worth, you know, just reminding those people that are listening that aren't farmers, that it is such a small amount of money that farmers actually get in the big scheme of things. You know, it's, it's an old
statistic that I keep Wheeling out, but you know, it, I mean, it was, it was true in 2018. I imagine it's even more expensive now. But just the cost of administering central government, not local government, just central government is £11 billion a year. As I say, it's bound to be more than that now almost a decade on and yet farmers in the UK are getting less than less than three, well, less than 3 billion in England. It's it's what is it? It's not much more than 3 billion across the whole of the UK, Is it Martin? Something like. That there's just over 3 billion, about two 2 billion coming across England and it's the same 2 billion as it was 10
years ago. And, and you look at all the other costs that have gone up, the AG, the the budget that gets delivered to farmers for positive outcomes and it's not a subsidy, it's about investment in landscapes hasn't changed. And that's why there's got to be A at all of putting incremental investment into that budget to improve it. It's working landscapes, landscapes that are working for food and for nature for, for protecting us from things like flooding. It's, it's investing in that, as you say, and it's, and it's 70% of these islands and we're paying practically nothing. Let's, let's get on with sorting
that out. Look, we, we're more or less out of time. We were going to touch on the death of road map. Can you summarise for me, Martin, where we are with that and where we need to be? But I think we're all kind of waiting for this road map, a strategy from the government of what do they want from our farms, our landscapes and and others. And maybe by the time this comes out or shortly afterwards, we'll hit, we'll we'll see it. And I think what we really need to see is set a clear direction, some clear hope where the investments needs to be. Where does food systems and regionalisation fit into that? Where does nature, you know,
nature friendly farming and investments in a joined up approach to production from our landscapes for everything we need and a timetable. And what I really hope that we can see it set out a vision and all politicians get behind a road map that gives certainty and investment to all farmers. This will be a labour document but we need opposition parties not to attack it because actually they they need to say how they could do it better because farmers are investing for the long term. We don't think one or two years with probably most of us are thinking 5 and 10 years down the
line. The trees we plant today, that's the next generations benefits, not ours. And it's that kind of vision we need to hear from the government around the the role landscapes and farmers have for the nation. If there was ever a case for cross party working, then it's something that works on the the long time scales that farming does. Well, look, that's, it's, that's all we've got time for. I'd like to thank Martin Lines as ever, and thank our guests, Nick Renison and Jenna Hegarty. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us,
review us and share our links. You can sign up for our free weekly newsletter@8.9.com. That's the number 8, the word point. The #9.com. Farmgate is Europe's highest ranking food security podcast. We're partof8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is supported by First Milk, Pelican AG, the Nature Friendly Farming Network, Friars Moore Livestock Health, the Royal Agricultural University Agrolo and individual donors. And I've been to them like a stain. And I've been Martin Lyons. Goodbye for now, thanks for listening.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...