Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Farm Gate

Farm Gate artwork

Wheat from the Chaff: Kids working on farms, CPRE and brownfield homes

Oct 7, 202555 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

FFINLO COSTAIN (8point9.com) and JOE STANLEY (GWCT Allerton Project), are joined by MARY-ANN OCHOTA, the president of CPRE, The Countryside Charity. They discuss: 🚜 🚸 Kids working on farms 😊 Nature as a positive, unifying force 🥬 Vertical farms 🦋 The role of CPRE 🏠 Brownfield first home building 🧱 And new towns Watch the rough cut video edit on YouTube

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, welcome to Wheat from the Chaff on the Farm Gate podcast channel. I'm Finlay Costain, the Chief editorof8.9.com. And I'm Joe Stanley, farmer, writer and head of Stainwell farming at the Allerton Project. And we've got a packed schedule today. We're going to be talking about the exploration of countryside stewardship agreements, and in particular, what that means for Joe at the Allerton Project. We're going to talk about the need for positive and unifying stories in a national landscape where there's so much grimness. And we're joined for the program

by the fabulous Marianna Hotter, the president of CPRE. Hello. It's a real privilege to be joining you, Finn, though. And Joe, thanks so much. There's so much to talk about, isn't there? Yeah, absolutely. And later in the program, we're going to be talking, of course, about all things CPRE planning, rural development, home building, solar farming. And we'll look at Cpre's unique role as an NGO and whether the organization which has, well, frankly, so many useful things to say about farming, can shake its reputation for Nimbyism. But for now, let's start with kids on farms.

Now, Joe, a couple of months ago you wrote an article for Farmers Weekly which was talking not unreasonably, about whether it was safe for kids to be working on farms, the sort of things they should be doing there. I'm just sort of raising the issue. And then again, this week you've written a follow up to that article and I'm just going to read out a couple of the things that you said. I mean, the article was sort of headed. Do we really want defensive noise to drown out self analysis? You said in August I wrote a piece intended to initiate a conversation about the role of

young children on farms and their safety. The response was in some quarters deeply dispiriting. Rather than engage with the question of chorus of outrage and personal attacks was unleashed on social media media, we must cultivate instead a culture of curiosity, humility and responsibility. Give us some of the background on this, Joe. I've touched on this subject before in some of my articles and it's never gone down. Well, I appreciate that. You know, it's, it's a really nuanced, difficult subject to talk about having children on

farms because farms aren't workplaces. They're also, well, they're not just workplaces, they're also homes. So this is a really complex subject, but really I was just making two points in the original article, which is 1 safety. We have young children killed every single year on farms and clearly there is an issue there around safety, whether they're just playing and interacting on the farmyard or whether they're working as young children on those farms. There's an issue there, right? And secondly, I guess that the

point I was also making was having children working on farms often working, you know, during school holidays, working full weeks, working adult hours, working fifty, 60-70 hours a week in adult jobs. Is that something that we should be allowing to continue as an industry? Is that something that we should just be sort of just accepting as the status quo without ever, without ever really giving it any thought? So, so that original piece film, though, was really, you know, again, accepting that this is a really difficult issue, but also saying, look, we should have the

ability to to talk about this. Let's have a conversation. And just, you know, for the sake of the conversation, Joe, define what you mean by a child. I mean, it's legal for, for a 13 year old to drive a tractor and, and do, you know, again, an adult's job on, on a farm, you know, from 16, you can drive one on the road, But of course, many children are working on farms much younger than that. And, and of course, you know, mostly those kids really want to work on those farms. But again, it's not really up to the kids to, to decide what is

a, a good situation in, in any given farm. And again, I can imagine people are kind of screaming at their radio at this point. Again, I'm not saying that I've got all the answers to this or that I am necessarily even correct in my analysis of the situation, but we've got to be able to have a conversation with this. And I think that the piece that the second piece you referred to there, Finlay, was it was really me saying that on difficult issues such as this, and it's not just all about this issue, it's about other things such as the whole transition that we have as an industry towards, you know, a future footing.

We need to be able to have difficult conversations without them just descending into into vitriolic and and auto reflexive. Just defensiveness. I mean, I think, you know, you mentioned there the legal situation, and I think that's something that we should just dwell on for a moment because there's opinion about whether kids should be able to work on farms or not. And then there's the legal situation, isn't there? So what is allowed is family help. And children are often able to help with light tasks, which means, you know, maybe collecting the eggs, helping sort of, you know, milk the goat or something like that.

But the minimum age for actually doing any kind of real work as such is, as you say, 13. What isn't allowed is kids using machinery. So tractors, harvesters, chainsaws. Can you imagine a three-year old with a chainsaw or work with dangerous chemicals? And, and again, as you suggest, it limits the amount of time that kids can spend, you know, helping out during school days or weekends. And, you know, I'm sort of aware of this. There was a a a time when my wife was doing a few hours in the local shop and, you know,

the kids just weren't allowed to go in and help. They couldn't go and volunteer because there was the danger that they were going to be seen as being employed. So I think obviously when we're talking about 8 year olds or 9 year olds, if there's probably more consensus that there are obvious and sensible limits to what a child should or shouldn't be doing on farm. But I think the real grey areas and the bits where Joe has experienced a really vitriolic kind of pushback that we don't even want to have this conversation. And I agree, Joe, that's completely a problem and you'll probably get pushback for that

too. But it's, it's really courageous to call it out. The real issue, the grey area is at that period point where you're 13. So it is legal. It's not a question about legality. It's a question of ethics, values, genuine dynamic risk assessment. And the bottom line is that farms are not places that are as safe as they should be. And that there is a, a kind of a broader sense that, well, these things happen, but we've had 18 people die on farms since April. That's not normal, That's not

appropriate. And there's eighteen families and communities who are devastated by those tragedies. I think it's, it's the broader mindset. And actually, if you kind of did the thought experiment, I said, well, hang on a minute. If farming were as safe as other industries that use heavy machinery, that actually, you know, implement really solid PPE plans, would you put a child, would you put your 13 year old in full 5 point PPE to then go and work with a Tele handler? And actually, if you say, well,

I wouldn't send them onto a construction site at 13, maybe you should be asking the same question about sending them out onto the yard in the dark, wearing green and brown clothes, hoping for the best because that is genuinely what you're doing. And it's true of of that youngster who's 13, but it's probably also true of your contractors and of your, you know, family members or other people that you're working with who are 20, 2 or 52. When those wellies are empty because someone's died, it's a tragedy, regardless of the age, right? And they are preventable. Joe, just sort of talk us through some of the the vitriol

that you experienced. I logged off all my social media accounts for the couple of weeks after this because you just don't want to scroll through that stuff. I had enough people sort of contacting me saying screenshots of things. Have you seen this? But you could talk about sort of the essentially what is what is trolling. And again, in in in the piece that's come out in the farm weekly today, I wrote for those people who disagreed with me, but did so in a constructive manner. Thank you. This is part of the conversation we need to have. But it's that just absolutely unstructured rage.

It was what isn't helpful. Some of the sort of well known figures that are now kind of across farming social media who frankly, you know, they whip up, you know, Twitter storms because that is part of their model of being social media figures. You know, that that is not it's not helpful to anyone. It might generate likes and clicks, but it's not doing anything positive for the industry. But, you know, I had enough people come up to me in real life and and, you know, say that they'd read such a piece. And again, even if I didn't necessarily completely agree

with me, they thanked me for starting that conversation, for putting it out there. And, you know, somebody needs to do that. You know, I'm proud that that I sort of, you know, that I made that intervention again. I've done it before. I think I'll continue to do it because this is an important issue. And as I said in that original article, you know, we used to think that sending children up chimneys, down mines and under the spinning Jenny was completely normal until all of a sudden it wasn't. And, and we just need to have the ability as an industry to have these moments of introspection without essentially making any breaking from the status quo something which scares people so that we

don't have those conversations. And then as an industry, to date, the messages I've received, you know, personal messages and personal interactions, real life interactions have all been very positive. And I think, again, that tells you a lot about social media. So a lot of the responsibility obviously needs to sit with the people who are being the keyboard warrior in that moment with that kind of real immediate response that you wouldn't necessarily throw at someone if you were face to face. But the publications need to take responsibility as well, because the way they frame these conversations is to provoke

outrage. There is a whole revenue dream in provoking outrage because like you say, Joe, it's clicks, it's interactions, it's engagements. And you've got someone sitting in their communications and social media team going, oh, wait, this one's playing really well to the crowd. And actually, if their sensibilities, if their kind of targets are about engagements and clicks rather than how what is the quality of this conversation that we are convening, then publications like the farming press are doing a disservice to the industry that and the communities that they're supposed to be serving.

So they need to moderate the comments. They need to put the headlines in in such a way that is possibly a bit less breathless. I agree, Mary, and, and, and in this particular case, exactly that did happen. You know, I, I was, you know, and, and I've had this conversation with, with Farmers Weekly and, you know, I, I really, you know, value writing for farmers really. But I did have that exact conversation, which was, yes, their kind of approach to this particular piece did seem designed to to to whip up additional I'll sentiment, which again drives traffic and I understand that, but also it's

not ultimately helpful to to anyone do. You write your own headlines for Farmers Weekly, Joe. Or do you write the articles and somebody else sticks the headline on? No, I do not write the headlines, and I wouldn't have written the headline that appeared over my original article. It was, you know, intentionally inflammatory. Yeah, it's interesting. Just for the sake of, you know, because we're talking about this, just clarify your view. What is your view on you know what a 6-7 year old should be able to do on a farm? What a 13 year old should be able to do. And this is the, the difficulty, right? Farms are homes and they are

workplaces. And there is never going to be a single answer for any given, you know, there's not, there's not going to be a blanket answer, right? There's not. I grew up on a farm. It was a very, a hugely valuable experience, right? But I, I just do feel that there is not enough thought given to what is, what is sensible. And we see that reflected in annual death tolls of children on farms. We don't see children and killed in any other workplace. And literally days after my piece came out and as the Twitter storm was reaching its peak, another child was killed

on a farm. Every single incident is, is a huge tragedy for the people involved, for the families involved. The reason I care about this subject. I didn't used to care about this subject, but I lost the child myself for some reason. I've I've then decided that this is something I'm, you know, passionate about. I want to I don't want anyone to go through that. So that's where I'm coming at this from and we just need to have better conversations about this. And, and if a single person, if a single farm business took the time to think about how they do

things and maybe to slightly change how they do things in the future, then that that's a success as far as I'm concerned. And just to sort of round this off, you know, we're not talking, are we for one moment about kids not going onto farms in another part of, of Britain. We're talking about trying to get more kids from more schools, you know, primary age and upwards or even younger out onto farm so they have a proper understanding of what goes on there. I guess, you know, if we're talking about younger children, whether it's the children of the farmer or whether it's children coming in from the school with a, you know, full risk

assessment, I guess they should be doing roughly similar things. Not necessarily, because as Joe rightly points out, the farms where those children are are also their homes. The people that they're with are their family and it's kind of one of the remarkable things that about farms is that they are often family businesses and family businesses where the kids are involved hands on from a young age. And that's right. It shouldn't be a case of legislating to ban that beyond what what controls and and legal

restrictions and limits that we have at the moment. But I think the point that Joe is rightly making is that a, the farming industry and farming families need to be confident enough to have this conversation because otherwise you've got loads of people who feel incredibly uncomfortable and they're not brave enough to raise the the conversation in their local branch of the NFU, in the pub, in wherever their meeting saying, hang on a minute, aren't they a bit young? Or Are you sure they're all right to drive that 250 horsepower tractor on that massive arable field that's

really far away with a slightly sketchy mobile phone signal? I mean, we wouldn't, if you wouldn't do it on a construction industry and hand your kid, your teenager, over to people you do not know to do heavy and difficult and dangerous manual labour, then think twice about doing it on your own doorstep. Because they're not more protected because they're going to get killed in the field next to the house. As Joe said, there's no one right answer, there's no blanket rule. And I think anyone who's suggesting that that's what he's saying hasn't actually read what

he's written. What you need to do is just have a really honest conversation with yourself. You don't even need to have it out loud, but be brave enough to go there and go, well, actually, what do I think? And if you've got teenagers at home who work on farm, talk to them because if they're smart and adult enough to drive the, the big machinery, they should be smart and adult enough to have this conversation. And and then also think about what are your safety measures on farm for all the people who are on farm, not just the youngsters, because that's the

way that we actually tackle farm safety. It's reminded me of a there's, there's the whole thing of, you know, what do you do when you've got the kids and you and you need to look after them and whether you have them with you working on the farm or, or whether you sort of find some other more extreme version of babysitting. And there's a family story across on the Isle of Man where there was, you know, one of my one of my ancestors, a farmer who was left looking after the baby, but he had to plow a field and so stuck the baby in it's sort of basket up on top of a standing stone and then proceeded to plow the field and

then completely forgot about the baby, went home and eventually went back and found it. It was perfectly OK. But obviously. Sounds very Spartan. Yeah, wow. Yeah, doesn't it just? That's my, I mean, my first job was on a farm. After I finished my GCSE's, I got a farm, a job picking potatoes. I grew up in Cheshire. And did we get a safety briefing? No, I just turned up and hoped for the best and was told don't put your fingers in that bit because you won't have any fingers at the end of the day, which was fine, you know, and

don't fall off the trailer. But I mean, there is a kind of a sensible version of of making. And then we dipped sheep and I was just wearing shorts and trainers and and the kind of thing is, yeah, we got away with it. You know, the baby on the top of the standing stone, the kid tucked into the combine. But that's not, you know, that data point is not evidence that it's safe or sensible. Certainly I feel like the four Yorkshiremen sketches coming on because at least you had machinery when you were doing potato sorting in my day, you know it was you were just sitting in a freezing cold barn doing it by hand. But, but anyway, there we go. Should we move on to countryside

stewardship and the Cliff edge that's coming 4500 farms that are facing the exploration of countryside stewardship schemes. We're not going to talk about the generality of it. We're going to talk about the Allerton project. And Joe, when we've talked about this with Martin Lyons, he isn't necessarily going to be changing that much of what he does. He won't be enhancing the land that's been in countryside stewardship, but he won't necessarily be going on and sort of plowing into those edges. I think that you're you're feeling differently at the Allerton Project, Joe I.

Think the Allerton project has always reflected essentially what is what is possible, right? We, we are a working farm that does an awful lot of scientific research. So as such, we, we always try to be as relevant as possible and, and ultimately the working farm has to make working farming decisions. So we are in the situation at the minute whereby our five year countryside stewardship scheme runs out in December, as thousands of others do across the country. You know, we're looking at

essentially what we can continue to support from the farm going forwards. And there are things absolutely that we will that we will leave in place. So awkward field corners, you know, watercourse, buffer strips, beetle banks, these are things which fulfill A regulatory role or take up so little space and are of such utility that we would we would leave them there. They don't interfere with the farming operations. But there are things that are going to, you know, frankly at this point they are going to go so our pollen and nectar areas, our low input unharvested cereal options, lenient grazing in

pasture. And there are things that are going to be reduced, things like winter bird seed plots and supplementary feeding of winter birds. Now those areas are going to be reduced rather than got rid of because actually we have a shoot, a game shoot on the estate and that game shoot, as game shoots have always done, will continue to pay from its own pocket for the upkeep of options which benefit the shoot. But of course, as an awful lot of research at the Allerton projects demonstrated, you know, essentially by maintaining winter bird seed mixtures to feed game birds through the winter, they will continue to

feed farmland birds through the winter as well. So some things are gonna go on current plans, some things will stay and some things will be reduced and reduced, especially if we're talking about those winter bird seed pots, for example, going through the middle of a good arable field, you know, where, where they're being paid for at the minute to compensate us for not having crops on those best bits of the field. Those those pots will get moved to the edges of the fields. You know the the worst bits of of of land. I'm interested in the way that you, you frame that you're talking about the way in which the Allerton project tries to work as a commercial farm, a

research farm, which is, you know, absolutely understandable. But then it's how those decisions are taken in terms of what you do and how you, how you manifest a, a normal farm in inverted commerce on what's an experimental farm and how you make those decisions. So you know what you're choosing to do. Is it purely coming down to the way that you perceive the commercial advantage or otherwise of particular bits of land, Joe? It's always a trade off because again, the unique thing about the Allerton project is it is a working farm with a research establishment attached to it. And we also have a shoot, you've

kind of got three sometimes completely competing priorities going on there. Now the important thing to mention on this particular issue is, you know, the Allerton project, actually I'm told some 2/3 of the options that farmers can carry out on their their farms today in the Agrium Environment Handbook come from research that we have carried out at the Gallatin project or the wider Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust. You know, we have had a, a huge impact leading the way on on this in the last 35 years. How we do we make those decisions? Obviously we are a demonstration farm, but we are primarily a commercial farm. So for the last 35 years we've

been able to demonstrate that doing all this stuff is of commercial benefit to a farm by having these winter bird seed mixes is by having these pollen and nectar areas, yes, they benefit the wider farming operation. But they also bring in their own income stream, which is which is great. So we can demonstrate the benefit of that. The problem comes Finlay when you're not being paid to deliver these nature things. Now, if we're talking about a water buffer strip on the edge of a field, which is fulfilling A regulatory compliance objective, that's a no brainer. If you're talking about having lots of pollen and nectar areas across your farm or winter bird

seat, you know, frankly, having a thriving population of farmland birds on our farm does not directly benefit the bottom line of our farm. It's a nice to have and that's the sad react. That's why we are where we are, because there is no value attached to nature. So that is why the payments to date from both the European Union and then the the English government have been so vital in ensuring that more and more farmers are taking up these options. Because fundamentally, if they're not going to provide a financial return to the farmer, most farmers are not in a financial position to be able to

to subsidise this from their own pocket. And that's the sad reality of where we are, right? Now I just want to sort of drill into that you sort of use that, you know, those areas that don't interfere with the farming business. And you talked about the way that the birds don't have a particular capital advantage for the farm. And I'm just sort of reflecting on some films that I've been making for the Nature friendly Farming Network in Scotland. And, and John Seed was one of the interviewees and he talked about, you know, his beetle banks and the the presence of beneficial insects and, and that sort of thing, meaning that he's having what he thinks is a sort

of 15 to 25 percent yield bump as a result, that he because of these nature interventions, there is a financial benefit to him and his farm. Are you not experiencing a similar thing? Ultimately, of course, having a thriving ecosystem on your farm is going to be beneficial to your to your farm right in the medium to long term. That is going to build resilience into your farm. And of course, it's especially easy to talk about beneficial insects because that reduces our use of pesticides, it increases the number of pollinators on the farm. Reality is, of course, if we're talking about pollinators, most,

you know, grass crops and most arable crops don't actually require pollinators. This is more of an, it's an ecosystem service for, for society and for our wider landscape. Again, it's, it's great to have as a farmer there. But if it's costing you 1000 lbs a hectare to establish and manage these pollen and nectar areas, but you're not getting any payment for that and the the benefit it, it will be returning to you. But it is incredibly intangible. It's very much based on what you've specifically got going on on your farm in terms of a rotation. That's a hard sell to a farmer

who let's bear in mind, you know, if you look at recent death for statistics, most farms across the UK are losing money on agricultural production. Now that's not a great, you know, so you might then also say Finland, Well, why would you grow more food, right, if you're already losing money on it? Well, that's because farmers have got 70 years of muscle memory where it, you know, they will try and grow as much food as they possibly can across the landscape. And of course, by putting lots of lovely nature stuff across their farm that reduces the, the efficiency in some cases of their farming operations. So again, taking things like

winter bird seed mixes out of the middle of their best arable farm will be an obvious solution to them to try and improve essentially their, their food production. And yes, it's always incredibly uncertain what a farm is going to get paid for their produce at the end of the year, but they will, they will likely roll that dice and go, you know what, let's hope in 12 months this extra 10% of wheat I'm going to go across this farm will be worth something as opposed to doing stuff for nature, which I want to do. But if no one is going to pay for me to do that, and I can guarantee they're not gonna pay for me to do that in the next 12 months, I'm gonna take my chance with the farming.

I'm gonna move on and we'll go to a break in just a moment. But the last story that I wanted us to pick up on before we do is 80% of British people say that nature makes them feel not just happy, but very happy. And we're recording this, you know, a couple of weeks after that big demonstration that was in London, you know, which talked about Britain United, but really was a very polarizing demonstration built around a particular view of nationalism. So I think, you know, when there is a lots of doom and gloom, when there is lots of division

that's taking place, whether you agree with, you know, whichever side of of that conversation you happen to be on, it's really good to see something positive that genuinely unites, you know, absolutely the majority of people in Britain. And I'm just going to pick up a few things from this report. So this was a study more than 7000 people across England, Scotland and Wales. The report found nature matters deeply to people. That four in 581% agree that being in nature makes them very happy. Almost all Britains expressing pride in environmental efforts such as tree planting, National Park protection and recycling.

The climate concern is also a unifier in a time of polarisation that 74% of Brits believe climate change is important and only 4% say that they're not worried about it. Desire for strong leadership on this as well. Over half of Brits wanting strong and ambitious leadership on climate and nature, with 86% of Brits thinking that it's important that climate action should also protect nature and wildlife. Half of those, I mean, this is sort of the slight downside. Half of those surveyed worried that their children's prospects are going to be worse than their

own. And and also sort of coming back to that whole cost of living thing that people support climate action, but they really want climate action that is going to help them, you know, now as well as helping nature in the future. So the cost of living being a real concern, people wanting to see climate policies that lower their energy bills with 74% of Brits believe in climate policies are actually going to cost them money rather than help them save it. So there's, you know, there's some friction there between those two positions, but ultimately there's an awful lot of people want to see concerted

action on climate, 3/4 of people wanting to see that connected with nature as well, understanding that climate and nature work hand in hand. But again, it's that 4/5 of Britain's being made really very happy by nature. It's a natural part of being Homo sapiens that that is our natural habit, not to be in a high rise flat like a battery chicken, you know, under artificial lights, eating food from packets. It's our natural condition to be outside and surrounded by rich, abundant ecosystems.

So it's kind of awesome that people recognise that and are able to say it. I think the thing we have to remember though is that the more opportunities people have to care and genuinely engage so actually have access to green and blue spaces, the more important it goes from this kind of abstract notion where maybe you'll watch like a a nice documentary or, you know, buy a calendar with like landscapes compared to the reality of living or visiting rural countryside. And I think that's the

difference 'cause sometimes people have a kind of chocolate box, It's there, it's sort of a museum, a naturally museum place that has to be bucolic and pastoral and not make too much noise 'cause it's nice. Versus the reality, which is the we actually want a countryside that is a place for thriving businesses and rich multicultural communities that are inclusive and supportive. And it's a place that people want to move to as well as stay and live in and actually have kind of Fair access to services, to affordable housing, to good

jobs and prospects. So I think it's, it's a kind of combination of like, yes, it makes people happy, but how often do they a have access to nature and how disproportionate and unfair is that access? And then when they're thinking about nature or thinking about the countryside particularly, what actually is it that they're thinking of? Is it museum or is it reality? And Joe, I've always made the point, absolutely agree with everything that Marianne said there. But I've always made the point that, you know, the NFU and other farming organisations really ought to be talking up the way in which, you know,

farmers have such an important role in terms of nature guardianship, in terms of making the case that there ought to be money going to farmers to help them do the best for nature. Which of course goes back to that previous conversation around countryside stewardship. 4/5 of voters there believe that nature is making them very happy. Well, there's a cost associated with that. Absolutely. And I think, you know, pretty much all organisations and they're making the case that it's, it's not just being out in nature, it's what, what healthy food can we produce and provide to people to reduce the strain

on the NHS, on mental health and, and all the rest of it. Absolutely. So, so now this is totally a huge and evolving area. But again, at the minute we're not even getting the basics right. We're not even able to put together a really small amount of money just to safeguard what we still have, let alone start talking about how we can get more people out there, how we can, to change the food system to, to realise all the potential benefits. So yeah, we, it, we, we've got a lot of work to do and conversations like this are are, you know, a small part of that. We're going to go to a break and

when we come back we're going to be talking about CPRE, rural development and building on brownfield. So queue music. And we're back and we're joined by Marianne Hotter, the president of CPRE. And just in the break, I was talking about the things that we're gonna cut because we're just not gonna have time to talk about them here. And, and I mentioned that vertical farms was one of them. And Marianne came in and said, oh, no, I wanted to learn about vertical farms. So we're gonna talk about vertical farms briefly before we

move on to CPRE. Joe, were we talking about great big pigs in high rise blocks? No, we're, we're talking in the UK context very much about, you know, using, using controlled atmosphere indoor environments to produce, you know, for the most part, sort of small greens and salad garnishes, that sort of thing, herbs. And, and yeah, I think the reason you want to talk about this Finlay was because a, a recent report suggested that actually in a vertical farming situation, even using solar energy, the carbon footprint of of these sorts of, you know, small greens produced in such

systems are actually potentially demonstrably higher than if we're growing them in an outdoor environment. And you know that that's not the be all and end all of it, of course, is it? You know, the the in terms of the efficiency of water use, efficiency of nutrient use, the ability to have that controlled environment. So you've got guaranteed production, you've got guaranteed low levels of disease and pests. So you can have, you know, virtually no, if not no synthetic, you know, pesticides and chemicals in there, etcetera. So there's obviously huge benefits, but the problem of course is at the minute they

can't even make the economic model work for those really fast growing, really low value commodities like, you know, herbs, etcetera. You know, sadly, you know, we're just seeing these these things going bust left, right and centre all around the world, including here in the UK, one of the world's largest vertical farms that's just going out of business earlier in 2025 because they just couldn't make the sun stack up. So the huge potential there not to feed the world, but to potentially, you know, do some nice stuff. The garnish.

The garnish the world indeed. That's that's the thing 'cause and just sort of going back to the report, Joe, just to cut you off, you come back in a second, but the results were showing that in terms of the land footprint, if you're thinking of lettuce being produced in a tube station, an old tube station, they can get 20 times the yield and of course they can manage the water and the nutrients more effectively. But if they weren't using this, it says when renewables are not used and instead the UK's grid electricity mix is applied, the carbon impact of vertically farm lit lettuce rises to about 800%

more than field grown lettuce, and even with renewables it was double. Yeah. So, but, you know, ultimately you can't have everything, right? There's always going to be trade-offs. But again, I mean, fundamentally the problem we've got here is people see governments especially, you know, they'll see vertical farms as, yes, a way to feed the world and to move away from conventional agriculture. The reality is that's not the conversation we're actually having. And also the business model sadly still doesn't seem to add up even for what they can grow in these vertical farms. So, you know, one for the future, But yeah, it's, it's,

it's not really happening right now. Thanks, Joe. Marianne CPRE is the campaign to protect Rural England rebranded as the Countryside charity. Tell us about it, and tell us about your role. Yeah, so CPRE is all about having a passion for England's countryside, making it a place, a better place for people to work, to live and to visit. And So what we do is we advocate for policies and culture shifts, I guess, that are going to

enhance the the the future of the countryside. We publish policy and research to guide that conversation. And then we have practical work through our network of county branches as well. So we've got a big project called Hedgerow Heroes, where next year is our 100th anniversary and the aim is to plant 100 miles of hedge across the country because it's an amazing wildlife connector, shelter belt for for a kind of farmed land or, or pasture land. But also it's a way for people to who perhaps do not work on

the land to have an opportunity to get hands on. And whenever you plant something, you're planting legacy, aren't you? So to really be part of the future of the countryside and feel invested that this is something that is ours wherever you live or work. And you're the president. I am, yeah. So it's an honorary role. And I was appointed in July 2024. And obviously it was kind of, it was the same week as the new government coming in. So there was kind of a big job of work. I think CPR is traditionally been seen as perhaps a kind of a

right leaning organization, kind of small C conservative and perhaps big C conservative. But the reality is across our membership and supporter network and the organisations that we work in partnership with, I think we're a kind of very broad church in terms of politics. Our aligning focus is what would make the countryside better for everyone and why is it important? Making the case for why that's important. Yeah, it's interesting because of course, you know, the way that different organisations are seen at a national level and a local level can often vary.

And you and I started to have this conversation at Groundswell, which is, you know, why we're having this conversation now. But there is a degree to which CPR's reputation is sort of as Nimbys United. It's a sort of a walking, living, breathing version of the Daily Telegraph. And perhaps even more disparagingly, it could be pensioner Nimbys United and and I think you're. Suggesting that's all the energy that I'm bringing. Definitely, yeah. And can you tell? Yeah. And so I, I want you to push back on that to an extent because what I found, you know, when I've sort of interacted with CPRE in the past, when I was chief you sake of Farmwell,

before I was editor at 8.9, Graham Willis was your sort of rural advisor, farming advisor. And I found him one of the most sensible people that that I was meeting anywhere. I had a huge amount of time for him. I thought his solutions were really interesting, really well informed. I thought he was, he was absolutely fantastic. And yet, at a local level, you know when most people are coming across CPRE as an organization, it will be a local group opposing something fairly vociferously and not always factually.

Yeah, I mean there's a tension there because sometimes people come to CPRE because they know that we are a charity with planning expertise and can help individuals navigate what is a local plan, how do you engage with a planning system? And often people kind of come to that awareness when they sense or or or hear about something that's happening in their local area. Now of course I am pro democracy. And so the more we have well informed citizens who can take part in those democratic

processes of which kind of planning applications and planning hearings are a part of, but also are able and kind of confident and armed with importantly, armed with the facts to kind of actually say, well, this is what what do you want the countryside to look like? How do you want it to work? What would make a big difference in terms of where we put the energy infrastructure, where we build new homes? What do those homes look like? Who were they for? Crucially, things like how important is food sovereignty? What is what is the important conversation around land use and what goes where the more

empowered and more welcome people feel to be part of the conversation. I mean, it goes back to the conversation about kids on farms, the better quality of discussion we can have and the better outcomes because you've got a more diversity of thought, you've got more curiosity and people are more invested in the solutions that are then put forwards because there's always going to be compromises and trade-offs. I mean, that's why something like the land use framework is so important as a sort of guiding principle that everybody can sign up to and say this is

going to help us streamline and get more coherence around the decisions we make. Because when you decide to put one thing there, whether it's ground mounted solar, whether it's a vertical farm, whether it's an urban extension of a town to house another, you know, 200,000 people, you're making a decision about what is going to be there and you're making a decision about what is not going to be there and how the whole system works. So yeah, some of the work that we do around farming, for example, we recently published a report on peri urban farming. So, so the farmland that is

right adjacent to urban and suburban areas. And one of the things that's really striving taking is that there is a much lower uptake of the higher tier countryside stewardship in lowland, predominantly lowland peri urban farmland. And that in itself is, is kind of telling because maybe you go, well, it's because it's productive like grade one or two land and people aren't really bothered about planting strips for arable birds. They're going to just crack on and do as much wheat as possible. But then the question is that

that's actually the countryside next door for the vast majority of the population. And that impacts access to that, the quality of that, how much it's working hard to, for example, clean water, hot store water in the landscape, protect from flooding, reduce heating and wildfire risk, all that stuff that's happening, you know, adjacent to where all the people are. So it's all well and good having some amazing schemes that impact the uplands, like the farming and protected landscapes. Often that's the national

landscapes, that's the national parks. A lot of those landscapes are places where people visit, but actually the resident population is relatively low. We need to turn our attentions and care and money and investment to the peri urban farmland as well. Very interesting. And just sort of whipping back to that NIMBY idea you, I, what I heard you saying, I think was that often people at a local level will come to you because they're angry about something 'cause they're worried about something that's going up and what your role is or what CPR

Louise's role is to support them. But then to translate that, that anger into something which is much more positive, positive action, you know, for the countryside more broadly. I see my role as making the case for CPRE being a place where we can really clearly and confidently say that's great, let's do more of that This is why and actually build consensus around that. At the moment, I think our inheritance is that we are quite good at saying no, not that. And here's why.

And in the the kind of the 100 years history of of the charity which. It's it's pretty awesome. I mean, the, the charity has done a lot of really cool stuff part that had it had a significant part in helping to establish the national parks, for example, making sure there wasn't a motorway that went through Steyhead Tarn in the Lake District. But often the kind of the celebrated wins are the things that we managed to stop happening. And we actually need to change that to being a real powerful advocate for what good looks

like. That is the hill that I will die on. And access and access seems to play quite an important part in that. You're talking about those sort of peri urban landscapes, those landscapes that are, you know, immediately adjacent to Bristol or Birmingham or London where, you know, people need to have access in order that they can get out there and value nature, value of the countryside. But of course, that countryside needs to be accessible and it needs to be beautiful. I'm less fussed about beautiful because I think it's, it's subjective and often that is kind of wielded as a reason to

say, and therefore we can't have houses here. And you go, well, people do need to live. We do have a housing crisis in England, in the whole of the UK. But the crucial thing is where do we build it and what are we building? And at the moment, we have a really imbalanced kind of, you know, unhealthy system where the vast majority of housing delivery is built by the provided by the, the volume house builders who are operating on a, a market model where profit is their focus.

And we've got a legislative system that supports that extraction of profit. And so the focus isn't to build homes for people that are affordable in places that they need them. At the moment. The focus of the market is to enable building and the details of that get lost in the conversation. The problem is that, you know, those big house builders have massive pockets. They can bank land, they can sit on capital, they can sit on losses. They have no intention of reducing house prices because

that reduces their profit. Let's just fortuitously, I mean, we've, we've had you booked on this podcast for for a little while now, Mary Anne, but there was a report that came out from CPRE in this last week. And our headline was half of government's new homes target could be delivered rapidly on brownfield sites. So just the first couple of paragraphs here. New research from CPRE reveals that more than half of the brownfield sites had some full or in principle planning permission in 2024, meaning that they could built on, be built on.

Not just built on, but built on rapidly. The charity says that the UK's huge supply of brownfield land should be the first choice for building the homes that the country desperately needs. These sites are typically located near existing infrastructure such as public transport, schools, healthcare facilities, making them ideal. Furthermore, CPR ES calculations show there's enough brownfield land to build 1.4 million homes in England, based on data from local planning authorities. Most updated brownfield land registers up to 2024. So importantly, the key message

really is that prioritizing brownfield sites would allow for quicker timelines compared to Greenfield developments. It can also minimize the environmental impact. Good timing. Tell us a bit more about that. So obviously the government have this massive target, they've pinned their colours to the mast on building 1.5 million homes before the end of this Parliament, which I mean you don't need to be housed an expert to know that that is going to be a reach. What's important is that we have a really well informed conversation about where those homes are built and what homes they are.

So they need to be affordable homes, they need to be in places where there is a genuine local need for more homes. And it feels like a no brainer, right? You look at the kind of the map, the coloured in map of of England and you say, well, where would you build the homes? Are you going to put them here on agricultural land or land that might could be managed for nature, flood mitigation, all the rest of it? Or are you going to put them here on the site that used to be an old factory, which is actually close to the train station, close to services?

There's energy connection already. And the challenge is that build them on the brownfield sites. Build them on the brownfield sites in a way that is nature rich, that is way that is really good for people and creates places that communities that people want to live in. Now, the reason that that folk go for the for the companies, go for the Greenfield is because you can sort of do it with more certainty that you're not going to come across an old gas pipe that you need to remediate before you keep building. But this is where the market needs to be controlled, because

otherwise we will live in the English equivalent of Los Angeles, where suburb sprawl just carries on into the countryside and you go, well, what else is that land supposed to be doing if it's not under a suburban housing estate of identicate little boxes? The question I wanted to ask you about was round sort of brownfield versus Greenfield. If I think of my village, then on the edge of my village there are fields which are essentially just monocultures of rye grass with very little nature value. Whereas, you know, if you're going into sort of some more inner city areas, then those

brownfield sites that have been left derelict perhaps for 20-30 years have got some really quite high nature value. I mean, you're right, there's the. It has to be to some extent on a case by case because you're right, there's industrial sites. There's there's a site in Tilbury which is full of this thing called pulverized fuel ash, which is basically like industrial waste that has been dumped. But now it's this amazing thriving community of really quite rare invertebrates, butterflies and dragonflies and beetles and all sorts of stuff.

You kind of go, oh, well, it's kind of scuzzy. That's the problem with with beauty Scrub is a perfect example of no one really wants a calendar of pictures of scrub, but it's super important in terms of how an ecosystem works and where the nightingales are going to live and where you've got these kind of corridors of nature connection through our landscape so that actually species can shift as the climate changes. All this stuff is super important. But then you kind of look at that Greenfield Finlow and you say, OK, well, it's a

monoculture. It's it's nature poor, but could it be nature rich? Could it be farmed in a different way that is still producing but also is supporting and storing nature? And if so, maybe we should be putting the in your village an additional 7 houses in that funny little bit behind where the garages are that people don't really use very much? Yeah. Now that's. Gonna be trickier because, yeah, well, because there's a kind of narrow lane and there's not the economy of scale of like raising a huge bit of Lincolnshire and

building, you know, identificate boxes. Let me give you a couple of anecdotes. You know, behind me there was, you know, a couple of acres of wasteland that was really, you know, beautifully high nature value, lots and lots and lots of stuff going on there. Huge amount, really diverse wildflowers, loads of insects and birds and, and other things. And some out of, you know, some people came in from London, they decided they were gonna buy it from the developer that hadn't managed to develop it for years and years and years they've plowed it out and just replaced it with rye grass. And it's an absolute desert.

And that's because, you know, people are sort of coming in and their view of what the countryside should be is that it's green rather than messy, which is, you know, which is a huge problem in terms of nature. But then we've been involved in, you know, as many communities will be around Britain at the moment in, in zoning conversations. So the Dorset Council has wanted every village to sort of think about where in that village or around that village might be suitable for housing. And so we had a great big public meeting with a couple of 100 people in the village hall

earlier this week. And, and there were very few voices basically saying, look, you know, where you've chosen, where you've identified to build some houses, looks like a really good place to build some houses. And I think, you know, there was me saying that and possibly two or three. And one of those was my son. You know, everybody else was, was really just against the idea of of homes really being built anywhere. And there were some quite vociferous voices saying, well, we should be a special case. We have a particularly nice village.

We don't want any houses built here. They can go somewhere else. And so the question really from that is, you know, is CPRE in favour of any development? And I think it is, you've just talked about some of that. I was surprised that I think CPRE are even proposing that new towns in some place would be a good idea. Yeah, absolutely. So we've got the government's new towns announcement and CPRE are entirely behind it because we do have a housing crisis that we need to tackle. The crucial focus, the goal, is build it well and build it in

the right place rather than be entirely beholden to profit making enterprises who are going don't worry, we'll build it for you. And what they will build is what suits them and their bottom line, not what suits us as a society. Because everywhere is important to somebody. So how do you choose that right place? It is really important that we help people understand the issues in a broader context. And again, we go back to that kind of, we're not inviting outrage, we're inviting understanding and then a kind of

a synthesis of ideas where we can all back the, the solutions. Even if you go, well, that's not exactly what I want, but I can understand the logic and the rationale. I trust that the system has worked to deliver a good outcome for us as a community or us as a society or us as a nation. So in where in terms of where new towns should go, we should be looking at places like urban extensions where you've got kind of nature corridors or, or kind of encircling nature. Whether you want to call that a Greenbelt or not, I don't mind.

We should be looking at communities that are not built to be entirely car dependent. So you've got a massive main road, you've got those suburban streets and then really dispersed kind of low density housing that sprawls because the more land you take for housing, the less land you have to do all the other things that we need land to do. There's a kind of a term in urbanism called gentle densification. So for example, a round of train station, you could say, well, actually we're going to have

some mansion blocks. We're going to have terraced houses because that's the way of densifying how many houses or how many homes are in a particular given acreage of land. But in a way that makes people feel like they're part of a community rather than intensively farmed animals next to a, you know, a kind of a bus stop. So there's ways to kind of create a place that feels like it has all the things that are in important for a good life. So access to education, access to nature, access to active travel places that are going to

actually enrich our our health, our economy, make us happier and healthier and more prosperous rather than sicker and sadder and poorer. Joe, thoughts on this? Yeah, No, absolutely. I mean the, the fundamental problem I, I think with this as I think we've talked about, you know, things like solar before, right? The, the problem is fundamentally that if we're trying to do everything as cheaply as we possibly can, you're not generally going to end up with the best outcomes. And I guess it's much the same here, as Marianne was saying from with developing brownfield sites, is that it's going to cost you more than to just build it on a Greenfield.

And whilst our economy really only values the cheapest and most efficient way of doing anything, we're not generally going to get good outcomes. That's when you whether you're talking about housing development or whether you're talking about food production. And the truth is with the with the brownfield sites, the government have announced this brownfield passport scheme. So in Prince that there's a default of planning application and that you would get a yes. So if you bring a scheme that meets the design codes of the area that kind of fits the requirements of that local area,

the default is that absolutely you're going to get planning permission. You can get shovels in the ground so that you're not in a situation which at the moment the system sort of rewards just kind of discretionary case by case planning applications that then get rejected and then there's an appeal. And then there's a kind of tinkering of the and then it goes back and people don't trust the planning system rightly because it is inefficient and it feels really opaque. And there's this kind of black box answer that comes out and people go, well, how did that get consented and this thing didn't, It doesn't make any

sense to folk. I think what we need to do is make it much clearer and much more transparent and definitely more efficient, but that isn't by reducing regulation, it's by making it much easier to build the things that we want developers to build and much harder for them to build the things that we do not want them to build. So just finally, I want to sort of, you know, try and summarise the position of CPRE around this, around the idea of development, not just in terms of homes and houses, but development more broadly. And what it seems to me that you're saying is that we should be developing communities rather

than simply building buildings that you're after. Gentle, gentle densification, I think was the phrase that you used. And if there is that sort of field on the edge of a village, then yeah, there could be some houses there, but not on every field, around every village. And we need to make sure that we find ways, going back to that initial conversation we had around countryside stewardship, that there are ways of funding proper farming, food, fibre production that's integrated with nature and makes those, you know, really good fields in a good countryside landscape.

Absolutely, because that works for for farmers, that works for the UK PLC bottom line and it works for people. Fantastic. Look, we're going to have to end there. We've gone way over time. We've missed a whole bunch of things that we're going to talk about, including things that I wanted to talk to you about, about CPRE, Mary Anne. So maybe, you know, at some point in the future you can come back and talk to us about other sort of elements, maybe when those new towns are being planned and we actually have a sense of where they are and to talk about solar and a range of other things as well. But that's it. That is the time that we have. Thanks, Joe. Thank you to our guest Mary Anne

or Hotter from CPRE. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is the highest ranking UK podcast for regen farming and food security. Farmgate leaders and nature friendly Farmgate, now called Martin's Farm, are available if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. Farmgate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican AG, Rural Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Agrolo and individual donors. I've been Finlay Castaine bye for now.

And I've been Joe Stanley.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 'Soil health is the north star of agriculture' - David R Montgomery on ReGen

    Nov 17, 202658 minAudio

    This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Place-based preparedness in practice

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Food industry insiders speak out

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Living adventurously" in the UK House of Lords

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is food sovereignty needed to face climate extremes?

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...

    Credit the people on this episode