ffinlo Costain talks to author Chris Smaje, whose new book, Findings Lights in a Dark Age, is the perfect Christmas gift for anyone with a vested interest in the future of humanity. Now is the time, says Smaje, for local communities - not multinational corporations or centralised government - to reorganise economy, land, energy and food production, so that the light at the end of the tunnel is lit, and when we fall into a global multiverse of crises, we can find our way more easily to a better world. Findings Lights in a Dark Age, by Chris Smaje, is published by Chelsea Green, and is available wherever good books are sold.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, welcome to Farmgate. I'm Finn Locustein, the editorof8.9.com. There is a certain joy in finding writers with whom one broadly agrees, but who are able to articulate their thoughts so much more coherently than one can oneself. Chris Mage is such a writer, and his new book, Finding Lights in a Dark Age, is the perfect Christmas gift for anyone with a vested interest in the future of humanity. Now is the time, says Chris, for local communities, not multinational corporations or centralized government, to reorganize economy, land, energy
and food production so that the light at the end of the tunnel is lit. And when we fall into a global multiverse of crises, we can find our way more easily to a better world. Chris Mage, writer, thinker and farmer, joins me now. Hello, Chris. I feel like to be here again. Now, Chris, I loved your book and I've only just been able to skim it and I'm looking forward to going through it again in much more depth. But you start by saying that humans today are facing a modern version of Ragnarok. Why Ragnarok? What do you think is the link between 9th and 10th century
Viking culture and our own time? I suppose a number of different parallels. I, I, I mean, one thing, I'm, I'm certainly no expert on Norse history and literature, but, you know, I think there's sort of, there's a complexity of thinking in, in those legends of Ragnarok, a kind of sense, you know, I think a lot of contemporary culture, we kind of have this sense that there is no alternative or we've never had it so good. And that the, the kind of openness to, you know, really dramatic catastrophic change.
And, you know, the death of the gods in Ragnarok, you know, the death of our modern gods, you know, was something that that I found interesting. But the other two aspects of it were partly the onset of the Viking period, you know, the, the kind of explosion of the Vikings out of Scandinavia, according to some current historical thinking, was prompted by climate change, you know, essentially by volcanic eruptions that led to to volcanic winters. You know, crops didn't grow for two or three years.
And that prompted all sorts of changes, some of which were already underway. You know, it's not judging. It's never just the environmental 'cause it's always more complex, but, you know, and that's a clear parallel with modern times, you know, that we are facing climate change and other biophysical challenges that are potentially going to push societies in very different directions. So that was interesting to me. And the other, the. The 3rd and final aspect was, yeah, in some ways the Vikings pioneered the modern world that we've inherited, you know, sort
of trading, raiding, enslaving. And, you know, it was in many ways a sort of complex, interactive world of the kind that we celebrate, you know, globalization and all that. But it was undergirded by violence and ultimately by predatory military violence, slavery and so on. And, and that has very much been the legacy of the modern world. You know, we don't sort of see it quite as explicitly now in terms of, you know, there isn't a kind of global legal slave
system, but that was very much undergirded the modern world. And still in many ways, the sort of violence against people and against nature. You know, we almost don't see it because it's, you know, it's, it's, it's sort of so in the warp and weft of modern life. So drawing back on that kind of Viking example, I found interesting to say that, you know, we are the inheritors of this, you know, of this legacy, you know, in, in England particularly, obviously the Norman conquest was, you know, from a, a, a kind of splinter, A Norse splinter group in Normandy, you know, and that was
quite consequential in terms of British history and, and the, the sort of later development of the modern world. So, you know, there's all of these sort of interesting parallels that I thought just to have a brief introduction that kind of connected all that together, you know, with the Norse example. And you preempted my sort of follow up question, which was around the Normans and the way in which, you know, they created essentially structures that that in many ways are with us today. But of course, the Vikings when they first arrived, that was the point at which there was lots of violence sort of running over. But once Vikings had arrived,
they sort of assimilated, didn't they, And built themselves in within a sort of Saxon culture as well, where the Normans kind of just took over. And you mentioned enslavement and the way that we don't see enslavement in the same way today. But you know, we have discussed on the podcast in the past the way, for example, that the Gates Foundation is using its power to to impose a view of agriculture on parts of Africa apart in other parts of the world as well, which is very much kind of fertile, the petrochemical databased, which in many ways is a sort of modern form of
enslavement. Yeah, I mean, you know, there's all sorts of ways in which the existing global political economy and, you know, there's a lot of bad stuff that happens kind of outside the, the, the well, you know, even even within countries like Britain, you know, all sorts of labour practices and and so on. But, you know, more so elsewhere in the world, we're not so much talking about the sort of mass brutal exportation of people to, you know, sort of, you know, that kind of plant old slave plantation model.
But yeah, there's. Still economic enslavement in place, Almost. Yeah, you know, there's still neo colonial models, which and and, you know, they're often as they were back in the days of slavery, they're often presented as this very positive. You know, we're we're sort of bringing civilization and Christianity or, you know, whatever, or, you know, more benefit to the world. But, you know, I, I guess I am skeptical of of, of that kind of argument. And that's where the bottom up localism kind of argument comes from really, that ultimately,
yeah, you know, we have all, some of us more beneficially than others been subjected to this process of global colonialism and and we actually need to regenerate almost literally from the grassroots locally. Yeah, Let's go back to the Vikings a moment because I think there's a really powerful section towards the start of the book where you follow an ancient Viking trading route, which of course is going from going from Norse lands across the top of the world and then down across across America.
And you paint a picture of a possible future world sort of taking almost a a bird's eye view across that trade route again. Could you just talk to us about, you know, what you see as that future world and also what forces you perceive as changing the world and, and you know how it will change? Well, it's very, you know, I, I guess a lot of my writing has been focused on the future, which is always a difficult thing to write about. And I'm almost bound to be wrong in fundamental ways. And yet, you know, partly it's that death of the gods kind of
thing. I think we have to be talking about the future because we are reaching the, the, the end of the present Rd. So, so, yeah, I try and sort of put some colour on that in, in, in various different parts of the book. I mean, the, the forces driving it, I think fundamentally are climate change and connected to that energy futures. You know, I guess we we can easily get into a whole debate about energy futures, but you know, my view of it is that the world as we know it now is
fundamentally dependent on fossil fuels. And you know, we talk about a transition, but the reality is, you know, we use more fossil fuels last year than ever before. Again, it's almost like this kind of stages thinking where, you know, we talk about the age of wood, the age of coal and so on, which I think deludes us. You know, we're using more wood now than ever before, more coal, more of pretty much everything. And that I don't think is sustainable in the long run. So climate and energy futures are really significant. And I think ultimately, in one
way or another, we are looking at most people having less energy, you know, less cheap abundant energy available to serve everyday life and that the consequences of that are huge. Water is another issue that's, you know, very significant agriculturally and, and in terms of settlement patterns, you know, like you say, I I do this kind of flights over over the United States and, and also Europe. But yeah, you know, the, the western US water issues are
increasingly huge there and, and are going to change patterns of life. And then finally, what I call political economy, which, you know, I guess is a bit of a sort of jargony mouthful, but we tend to talk about politics and economics as if they're different things. But historically they have very much been connected, as the Vikings sort of history shows. But we are very wedded to this model of constant economic growth. I mean, you know, you see that in the present government, gross growth, growth, you know, it's kind of the only model we have.
But ultimately it's, you know, again, it's not sustainable. You know, we can't keep growing the economy globally or nationally in the way that we, we have kind of assumed that we can. You know, we've sort of put our eggs in that basket. You know, when that hits the, the wall, it's hard to predict the fallout. But, you know, we're seeing it already in the, in the kind of bizarre nature of, of contemporary politics where, you know, politics at the centre is getting kind of weirder and more theatrical. And, and, and then people are having to kind of, you know, figure out locally from the
ground up, you know, how to, you know, increasingly the kind of services that we have come to expect from the welfare capitalist physical centers are becoming more problematic, more threadbare. People are having to innovate. And, and, you know, the, the, the sort of political narratives at the centre are getting kind of weirder and weirder. You know, so that I think even aside from climate and energy and water and all those biophysical things, you know, we are facing the end of a certain type of, of political economy.
So all of those things together, I think are pushing us into really uncharted territory. Yeah. I mean, as you say, it's very difficult to kind of predict the future, but I think, you know, gradually converging are a number of different sort of outlines of what the future might look like, which are broadly similar to each other in in one way or another. And obviously people have attempted in the past to describe what the future world will look like. George Orwell's 1984 is a really obvious one. But at the same time, there are elements on there from those books, from those visions of the
past that do come true that, you know, state overreach perhaps is, is one of those in particularly if you think of it in, in relation to Trump's America. And I wonder there was something about the, the, the sort of the fly past on that Viking route that reminded me a little bit. And, and don't hate me for saying this, but of, of Planet of the Apes of the new Planet of the apes instead of the old one. And, and the reason was that there was a lot of green amongst the concrete. There was green breaking through the concrete. And when you were talking about big American cities, for example, and the way that
they've changed, it was an increase in the amount of green, an increase in the amount of people who were, you know, working as communities, building their community orchards, their community farms and that sort of thing, as well as this sort of flight that we'll we'll talk about later, sort of flight towards the countryside. But you know, there were people still within cities reclaiming the land back from the concrete. Yeah. I mean, you know, as, as I think we both agree, you know, who knows what the future will hold. I think it's going to be very varied and there will be, you
know, certainly retrenchment of state power. You know, I think we're going to see more authoritarianism and more, you know, more conflict, more ways of, of trying to hang on to existing structures and patterns. But I think also we will see state retreat and which is not entirely a, a comforting thought because, you know, modern life, we're so dependent on these sort of big structural services sort of emanating from state centres. But nevertheless, you know, I, I
do have some confidence and faith in people's ability to to to kind of innovate bottom up and generate, you know, generate forms of community, generate forms of well-being. So, yeah, you know, I think we will, I think the sort of patchwork of future cities that I depict in that fly over is partly more green and partly more black. You know, there's going to be sort of burnt out bits and conflict zones for sure, but also people innovating and, and, and, and generating more local livelihoods.
And I think, you know, you alluded to urbanization versus ruralization. You know, I think historically people basically seek out places where they are most likely to find peace and prosperity. And in the last century or two, that has tended to be urban and, you know, metropolitan. And I think in the future, it will probably be less, less of that, you know, more rural and sort of areas that are now relatively depopulated will become more propitious for, you know, what I call open country in the book, you know, people
looking for good places to live. So yeah, it's going to be a real patchwork, I think all sorts of different things going on in different places. And and, you know, part of the idea of the book is just I think we're not really thinking about that enough. And, and just to try and draw attention to these, you know, really big changes afoot and, and try and sort guide us towards, you know, making them as positive as we can. Now Dieter Helm, Professor Sir Dieter Helm, I should say, recently painted his own vision
of the future of British farming in a paper which we discussed on the Wheat from the Chaff podcast, a sort of part of the Farm Gate channel with Joe Stanley and myself a little while ago. We were quite skeptical of his sort of descriptions of of how the farming future should look. And then just recently we had Dieter on the podcast talking to Patrick Holden and sort of talking about Dieter's vision. And Dieter was very quick to say that, you know, his vision, he's describing the way it is rather than necessarily the way that it should be. But I think it does come across very often as, as you know, an excited sort of vision of the
future. It's quite high tech, there's lots of AI data, all this sort of stuff. Is his an alternative vision to your own, or do you think it's just a step down the road, sort of driving us ever more closely towards your own? Well, I had a I've had a little look at his vision or description. I, I mean, I guess, yeah, it it that it does seem to be the sort of continuation of present trends that I think are not going to be sustainable. I mean, it's a very, it's a very high energy. You know, ultimately there's a
huge amount of energy, both, you know, fertilizer, traction and transport, but also all the kind of AI and, and and so on and all of the, you know, the financialized instruments as well that he talks about that are all very dependent on stable political power. So what he is describing probably is the way that farming will go in the short term. And I think it will be what governments will, you know, in, in particularly in rich countries in the global N will
try to hang on to. But I think it will crumble in all sorts of ways in response to those driving factors that we were talking about a few minutes ago. So I, yeah, I, I don't see it as the way things will go in the long term. You know, it's it's you know, I mean, he talks about sort of maths graduates in the farmhouse and and sort of nobody working the land, which, you know, I think we'll see kind of the opposite really will more people working the land which and you know, this is always a tricky thing. I have where partly I think we
don't have a choice about this. You know, my sort of small farm future vision is not necessarily a sort of, you know, it's, it's not a lovely nostalgic vision of how we're all going to be sort of making our own yoga or whatever, you know, this, it's a vision of crisis and collapse. But within that, you know, there are possibilities for people to generate good ways of life and good community. And I and I don't want to. Yeah. There is this tendency to be quite scornful in our sort of modern progress obsessed culture
that anything that smacks of the kind of rural and the nostalgic we we sort of distance ourselves from. So, so, you know, I want to speak up for an alternative kind of ruralism that is community rich and and and labour rich. But ultimately, I think it's going to come out of crisis and it's going to come out of the collapse of that sort of vision that he has, which is so fossil energy dependence, so central politics and and sort of economics as usual dependent.
You know, that's not how I see it going long term. One of the things that Dita said, you know, quite clearly in the podcast with Patrick Holden was that, you know, when we're looking at vertical farms, which you know, clearly a lot of them are struggling economically even at this stage because they use, you know, sometimes up to 30 times the amount of energy to produce what they're producing that a land based system can. But Dita's his view was well, who cares? So long as it's renewable, it doesn't matter. Yeah, but I don't think it is renewable. I mean, you know, ultimately it's it's dependent on very high
energy inputs and you know, it might work, you know, you can grow sort of fancy micro greens or strawberries or whatever to serve, you know, very highly monetized urban markets. And most societies historically have been energy constrained and have and water constrained and, and you know, and other sort of biophysical aspects and have very carefully figured out a kind of local agriculture that's attuned to that. I mean, the sort of urban vertical farm idea, you know,
that that that kind of who cares man mentality, I think comes from our present world where energy we assume is sort of just cheap and abundant and available for anything. And, and likewise finance and the two things that, you know, are very much connected. You know, that's not the world that I see in the future. I mean, I do see a world in the future where cities, small cities and towns, you know, there will be potential for people to produce food locally. I mean, you know, it makes no sense now to sort of have an
allotment in a city when you can build a, you know, a block of flats, you know, just because of the economics of that. But when that changes, you know, there will be the, the possibility for people people to furnish food for themselves locally, you know, potentially using high tech methods, but I think not really high energy methods. You know, it's, I mean, I think last time it was on on your podcast, you know, we were talking about the manufactured food idea. And and you know, we have all these ways in contemporary thinking to try and get around
the fact that ultimately the cheapest and most carbon friendly source of energy is the sun. But it's diffuse, you know, it's diffuse energy. And we're, you know, we're forever thinking of ways of trying to concentrate it and maintain high degrees of urbanism. But, you know, ultimately we're arguing against the physics of the sun, and that, I think, is problematic. Yeah, when we're talking about dieters vision there and the way that he sort of, you know, it is a very high tech future as as you know, as we were talking about and what you've said there is that you see it as you know,
it's, it's likely in the short term that that's, you know, everything suggests that's where we're going. That's that's what big business, that's what governments are are trying to achieve. But at the same time, it's likely to be short term and who knows how quickly that will dissemble and start to fall apart. And the way that dieter's describe that future to me seems very much it's sort of ever more loading onto a system which is already breaking, you know, within that same system. And so I, I, I guess the question around that is.
Do you think it's possible to escape the future that we fear at this late stage, or is a new dark age really just pretty much inevitable at this stage? I mean, I'm not really seeing a way of escaping it. And, you know, as we've touched on already, one of the things I do in the book is, is without trying to evade the huge difficulties and challenges of a future dark age. You know, I make the point that historically dark ages have often been quite good for ordinary people living through them. You know, we very much get this kind of elite perspective of,
oh, you know, the Sky's falling, you know, the Rome has has been sacked. You know, but for for ordinary people, often, you know, those situations were actually beneficial. You know, when the when the Romans quit Britain, you know, the the archaeological evidence suggests that everybody was, you know, healthier and better off and better fed. You know, I mean, I think it's going to be much more challenging where we're going in the future. But no, I don't really see, you know, it comes back to energy futures, climate futures. I mean, we've got the COP going on at the moment, you know,
which as as we've had many before, you know, and and they're almost now, it seems to me, you know, that there has been this narrative of policymakers globally, like, yeah, you know, we're gonna we've got to tackle climate change. You know, this is. And it's almost like this retreat from, you know, Bill Gates's latest comments and, you know, this kind of, well, well, you know, maybe it's not so bad if we break 1.5 and, you know, we've got no real sort of mass politics and no mass economic alternatives to the sort of growth mania that we've had.
Yeah. So no, I don't really see that we're on a, on a trajectory to to avoid it. No, which is why I've almost stopped. You know, I've written in the past about, you know, climate change and this and that. And I kind of almost didn't do that in this book. I'm, I'm just sort of like, you know, take it, this is the new reality that we're facing. Yeah, absolutely. And you mentioned the Romans there and of course it fascinating. There was a an archaeology talk that that my wife went to recently and it was it was about the way in which, you know, we've talked about the way in which the Vikings and the
Normans to an to an extent, you know, they did assimilate and that's sort of part of the the strength of of Britain growing. But the Romans just didn't at all. They came over and very much had their own closed communities and and there just isn't the genetic footprint in Britain that you would expect if there had been any kind of assimilation. And then of course they were taking resources from the land. So having gone, it makes sense that that people were substantially better off. Now your book is, is about light in a dark age or lights in a dark age.
And as you say, you, you've taken it as read to a large extent that there is going to be this chaos, this sort of dissemblance that's taking place. But let's think about it positively. And I mentioned before we started recording my, you know, my kids, they're 11 and 13, you know, they, they have, you know, they're, they're going to grow up and need serious therapy. The amount of talk that you know, that I'm having, conversations that I'm having with them about the way the world is turning. But I want them to read your book, particularly the end of the book. And we'll, we'll come to that later, of course, about those
positives for everyday people and the opportunities, the type of lives that people might live. So, so let's turn to the light. We agree that we're probably coming towards an end, but in mythology, death is rarely literal. The death card in tarot, for example, represents the end of an era, the grim Reaper in a winter landscape. But as with winter, it's the continuation of a cycle, the birth of something new. And of course, this is what you call finding light, the light in a dark age. Just tell us a bit about that. Yeah.
I mean, I think, you know, just to react to your preamble, you know, we get into this very sort of bad dualism of sort of doomism versus optimism, you know, and, you know, I don't want to be this kind of gnarly old old man, you know, you know, we're doomed. We're doomed. But, you know, I think we have to sort of come up with a realistic appraisal of where we're at. But then within that, I mean, I call it least worst thinking, you know, within that, I think the onus is then to sort of to look for the light and, and look for, you know, how we can
regenerate congenial forms of society. And, and, you know, interestingly, I mean, I agree with what you said about cycles, you know, that out of death comes rebirth. And, you know, likewise the Ragnarok myth, you know, talks about after the death of the gods, you know, the birth of, you know, eagles sporting for fish, you know, another green earth rising from the sea. So that's what we need to be to be doing like looking for another green earth. And I think it's challenging because we're building from such a low base. You know, we've had so much sort of high energy political
centralization, sort of take away our ability to generate local forms of society. And you know, I suppose reflecting back on what you were saying about D to Helm, I mean, I think the renewal always comes from the from the margins. You know, I think the centre is going to hold strongly to existing models and you know, we're going to have a lot of high energy, high tech attempts to retain existing populations and patterns around the centres. So, you know, that's, I talk
about that a bit in the book in terms of how London might sort of behave and try and generate food and other welfare for itself. But around the margins, I think, you know, there's going to be a lot of people who are by necessity sort of basically dropped in it and forced to innovate their own solutions. And you know, as I was saying earlier, people are pretty good at doing that if left to their own devices. You know, the whole history of farming really is about local adaptation in the context of wider challenges, you know, both ecological and biophysical, but
also social and political. So, you know, the light I think is in figuring out how we, how we generate food and fibre and other services, the built environment, how we organise property relations, how we organise together spiritually and culturally. And, you know, I think there is potential for people, you know, people can do that well, but it is hugely challenging sort of given the speed, I think of the, of the, the oncoming Ragnarok, you know, and the fact that
we're not really sort of, we're not talking about it, you know, which is why I feel the need to, to keep talking about it, to keep writing about it. You know, we need to be, you know, the more that we can be thinking through these models and generating bottom up ways of generating the welfare, the food and the other things that we need locally, the, the, the, the better position we'll be in. And there are many attractive things in what you write. I have to say, you know, when I'm looking at the society, if I was living in that society now without that transition to get there, you know, there are many
positive things, I think, particularly for those of us in the way that you describe it out in the West of the country. And you know, we'll come, come a bit later, I guess too, because I think some people reading what you've written would have political questions themselves around it, whether it's it's a left wing vision or a right wing vision. And, and, and you think that's too binary and we're going to come to that in, in a moment. But before we do, let's talk about ruralisation because central to your thesis is a flight from the city, not necessarily the whole population, but a significant majority perhaps.
So you're envisaging food insecurity, people leaving urban centres very often hoping to find land to produce food for themselves, greater security. And if that's the case, how do we avoid civil war between villages and land owners and those city immigrants? The book on trying to sort of paint a fairly global vision and and it does depend a lot on which part of the world we're talking about. You know, there's already, you know, there's a lot of seasonal labour migration to cities in global S countries, for example, which I think will sort of quite possibly slowly grind to a halt.
And you know, people are already quite well connected to to a rural base, whereas in a country like Britain, you know that that's not the case. And you know, I don't think we will avoid conflict. I mean, there already is conflict over land in, in many ways, but it's, it's relatively peaceful, I suppose in a, in a country like Britain. Well, I think we kind of export a lot of the violence and the conflict to other parts of the world. You know, that's sort of implicit in, in the way that we manage land and food and so on. But I think the way it will manifest is, you know, I mean, I talk quite a bit in the book
about land ownership and, and property forms of property. I mean, ultimately that is the social agreement about who has rights of appropriation to, to, to which bits of land. So, you know, ownership doesn't really mean anything in situations where all of those social agreements are sort of up for grabs and being renegotiated. So I, I, you know, I think there's a spectrum of possibilities. You know, there is the possibility of landowner power. So, you know, essentially a sort
of neo feudal scenario where the landlords, the the the powerful people really sort of call the shots about who gets access to land. I mean, I think a lot of people think that that's almost inevitable in the future. I mean, I don't think that, you know, that kind of landed warrior aristocracy model that we've inherited from the past requires a lot of politics to generate it. You know, the fact that, you know, we have farmers and rich land owners now who, you know, might have a shotgun in the cabinet or whatever, you know, doesn't really cut it in terms
of being a, you know, a kind of neo feudal aristocracy. The other extreme is land occupation, you know, that we see in countries like Brazil, you know, with people, landless people essentially taking land from, from the large landed estates. But I think the, the thing that sort of particularly interests me is the, the, the zone in between that where I think there's potential for a lot of negotiation and new forms of access to land, new Commons emerging. You know, a lot of farmers, you
know, if, if you're a sort of average Modern Family farmer with a few 100 acres that you're, you know, that you're farming with tractors and other sort of high energy, high tech means. All of a sudden your inputs and your markets start going haywire. And there's a whole bunch of people, you know, suddenly around saying, hey, you know, I'd like to have some access to land. I think there's a lot of potential there. You know, a lot depends actually on how existing farmers and land owners Orient to that. Do they Orient to the centre? Do they Orient to the status quo
and, and sort of managed to set themselves up as as kind of neo feudal land owners? Or do they ally with incoming people, new new forms of local production and, you know, the need to have more people on the land to have lower energy input, more localised markets and so on. And if they do the latter, I think all sorts of interesting things could happen. And that's kind of what I want to amplify. Quite often in the book, you talk about innovation and economic opportunity and the way
that farmers, you know, traditionally have been very good at spotting economic opportunities in sort of following, following and innovating within those economic opportunities. And certainly if I think of, you know, some of the farmers within the regenerative movement, obviously that again, there's a spectrum, but there are farmers who are brilliant at spotting when there is some money to be made that might be in a different way to the way they've done it before. And then of course, you've also got those farmers who just want to stick with the status quo. So, so as you say, you know, there will be sort of either end of that spectrum that you're talking about.
You've got farmers who will desperately try to hang onto their land and will be trying to defend that. But at the same time you'll have others who are perhaps seeing an opportunity for making, making a bit of money through engaging with the community in, you know, sort of letting out smaller, you know, half acre sections of land, perhaps to to families or, or sort of small holders in order that they're able to maintain some control of of what they were still perceive, I guess, as being their land. But at the same time, they're taking some of the heat out of the situation by engaging
creatively with it. And, and I'm interested that there are one or two farmers already doing that. And I'm thinking about, you know, the leaves up in Cumbria, A Trepena farm where, you know, they are actively thinking about the future and, and have set aside or thinking about, you know, 10% of their farm specifically being used to produce food for the community. So that you know, if this sort of thing starts to happen, if we start to see this disassembly, there is already this relationship with the community that can then be built up and built on. Yeah. I mean, I think, you know, it's the story that hasn't yet been written but is sort of starting
to get written. And I think a lot of our existing sort of political, you know, mind maps about the way politics were aren't really relevant to it. You know, this is the time when people can write these stories anew. But, you know, I do think, you know, the farm sector, you know, going back to Dieter Helm's vision, I guess, you know, it has got accustomed to a lot of cheap, abundant energy and and a lot of money sort of floating around in one way or another. And I think neither of those things are going to be the case in the future. So the real, you know, the real richness is the land itself and
its capacity to produce and people you know, who are there and, and, and able to work to produce things. And that can go in all sorts of ways. And, and as you say, you know, farmers are beginning to think about that and sort of stacking micro enterprises on on bigger farms to serve local market. So, you know, all of that stuff, you know, this is the time to be thinking about it and experimenting and it, you know, there is, I mean, you know, we do it a little bit on our whole building, you know, on a in a very small scale way. And it does generate social
tensions and questions about who ultimately calls the shots. You know, what does ownership mean? But this is what we need to be working on and, and, and sort of figuring out how we do this, you know, how we how we collaborate, how we cooperate with people, how we give people the ability to generate welfare, generate food and services. And, you know, I think what we can learn from past societies is that it is that it's very complicated, you know, that, that that, you know, there's all sorts of levels of family,
households, community, larger structures, Commons, you know, and I think we tend to sometimes we're a little bit non musical, you know, not very imaginative about how we think about these, these relationships. And, and, you know, we can learn a lot from past farm societies that had to generate welfare with with little money and little energy and, and did it through, you know, really thoughtful, complicated social arrangements, you know, and, and you know, that's what we need to do now. You mentioned mind maps and it
just put me in mind again of, you know, the way in which we can have one strategy after another. There are loads of plans, loads of reports that come into government, come out of government and nothing seems to change. And, and I think there's a degree to which within this book, and you know, as I've sort of said to you before we were recording, I've, I've really genuinely enjoyed this book. I, I thought it was the most engaging for me. It was, it was the best book that you've written and, and it's, you know, really accessible. And I think one of the reasons for that is because of the storytelling that you have
within it, both at the beginning and the end. This fly over over the Viking trade route that we talked about earlier, but also this, you know, this description at the end of your new local world. And I think there is something about storytelling and about theatre and, and the arts that can perhaps create a change or describe a change that people can see themselves in much better than any report or mind map can ever do. And, and as I say again, I, you know, I just really encourage people to get hold of the book because it is a really, really good read.
Now, one of the things that I wanted to move on to was talking about governance, which you mentioned there. But governance and law, of course, will still exist in one form or another. But you're imagining A scrappier world of mixed dependencies and enterprise. And I wonder, you know, thinking about still, if you can tell me the story about the world described by Daniel Defoe in 1724 when he encountered the cheddar cheese industry. Right. Well, that was yeah. I mean, I talk about Commons in the book. And again, I think the way that we tend to talk about Commons
now is, you know, it's a bit too coloured by existing political, you know, left, right, dualities or whatever. And yeah, so defoe's tore through the whole island of of Great Britain when he visited just up the road from us here. It's just an interesting example of of that kind of subtlety of thinking about how you generate well-being. So basically families, households would own cows individually and milk them individually.
And I mean, I'm possibly extrapolating a bit from Defoe, but I think this is how it works. This is certainly how it works in a lot of sort of pastoral varying economies worldwide and sort of people at an individual household level figure out supplementary feeding and haymaking and that kind of thing. But then the cows are grazed in common. So, you know, having been milked in the morning that the cow herd takes them off to the common pasture. And so that's a pasturage, you know, that there are these kind of whole landscape things that really lend themselves to
Commons in in low energy, low monetized situations. So grazing is is 1. Irrigation is another sort of woodland use of Woodlands would be a another classic 1. So, yeah, so the cows are off grazed in common, then they come back in the evening to to be looked after individually. The milk is made into cheese, you know, sort of collectively, you know, there's a there's a sort of cheese making facility that's shared in common and then the cheeses sort of go back to
individual households to use or to sell. So there's this kind of complex dance between individual household and more collective Commons based arrangements, which, you know, one of the problems I think is that that whole dynamic dynamic gets Co opted by modern political thinking about, you know, either the need for us to do everything collectively in common, the kind of left wing view versus, you know, everything has to be sort of organised through private
property rights or more right wing view. But the reality is farm societies, they figure out the ways that this actually works sort of ecologically in terms of best use of resources, but but also socially in terms of, you know, where do we have to come together and collaborate and where is it best for us to just to get on with it and, and sort of, you know, have our own autonomy to sort of manage our resources. So yeah, that example from Defoe in Cheddar was a good one of of the complexity of that and the way that people, you know, figure out good solutions
locally. Yeah, no, I thought it was fascinating, say that that sort of combination of individualism and collective action, you know, within a business setting as well as a common setting. It was a real combination of of different elements. But of course in 1700 or it was 1724 that Dafoe was doing, his tour of Britain's population was just about 6,000,000. Today it's about to tip 70 million. Can that many people in Britain live an agrarian life or live reliant on an agrarian food and fibre economy, do you think? I mean it's challenging and
obviously you know, the long term, if we kind of spool it out over long term history, I think there will be less people in Britain than there are now and probably more people in parts of Eastern Europe say which are now, you know, relatively. Deeply populated, but in the short term, I mean, I don't know, I've done some sort of back of the envelope number crunching and people like Simon fairly have as as well. And of course, there's more mainstream, you know, his name has escaped me now the, you know. The Food Farming Countryside Commission. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So I think it's challenging, but
ultimately people can produce an awful lot of food and fibre on, on small acreages. You know, that the key thing there is human labour, you know, so I encounter a lot this sort of notion that, you know, small farming can't feed the world, you know, it's not productive enough. And really, I think, you know, there's, there are all these sort of quite technical debates. You know, in, in some contexts, there's evidence that shows that small farming can actually be more productive per acre than large scale farming.
You know, others might dispute that, but my, my view is sort of generally that it's kind of scale neutral. And, and, you know, part of the problem we have globally is this massive overproduction in farming where, you know, we're sort of cutting down the Amazon rainforest to sort of pointlessly grow soy or whatever, you know, So generally I think the problem is, you know, it's, it's not productivity of, of, of small scale farming. And, and, you know, I think we could just about produce enough food for ourselves. It probably it, you know, they,
there would be less luxury food, there would probably be less meat than than people are accustomed to in in the existing diet. And we'd have to start thinking of livestock, you know, more in the old way as, as a kind of ecological servants to the farm where the, you know, the meat and the milk and other, other products from animals are a kind of bonus rather than, you know, going to McDonald's every night or whatever. We do, you know. But, yeah, I, I, I think conceivably we could do it again. The challenge is the even
thinking that that's something that we should be doing, you know, within sort of existing politics and, you know, the speed of transition to it, that, you know, the lack of skills, you know, having to rethink access to land, you know, all of the politics and all of the sort of cultural vision around it. We're so not up to speed with that. That, you know, that I see as the main challenge. Not necessarily, you know, the actual productivity of the land, although, you know, saying that I think the density of population in a country like Britain, you know, wouldn't
really have Verizon, you know, out of a low energy agriculture. So it is challenging. But, you know, I think we, we sometimes mislead ourselves. You know, you get this sort of stuff like, you know, 50% of the, of the nitrogen in people's bodies come from Harbour Bosch. And and then people say, therefore if we didn't have synthetic nitrogen, you know, half the world's population would be dead. And you know that isn't true, you know, I mean, you know. They existed for quite a long time before Haber Bosch. Yeah, You know, and Haber Bosch sort of enables us to sort of
buy ourselves out of certain kinds of engagement with the land. But, you know, if we had that engagement, could we sustain the existing world's population? You know, I don't know. Arguably perhaps, yes. But there's a whole bunch of other challenges, you know, I mean, Eve going down the existing, you know, the sort of D to helm route, you know, we are going to still ultimately face the same reckoning, I think. So, you know, this isn't some kind of ducking of the challenge of feeding the world. It's it's actually stepping into that challenge rather than assuming that there's a kind of
techno fix high energy solution to it. Yeah, and and certainly within the book and you alluded to it there in in your answer, you know, you're talking about, you know, the animals that are there land isn't being used to grow feed for those animals. You know, the animals are working within the land or the waste and the scraps, you know, that are produced through other, other processes. And, and I was thinking as well as you were talking about the way in which an allotment or, you know, market garden can produce so much food year round when it's well tended, you know,
in comparison with, you know, half an acre and acre of a conventional potato field, for example, which is simply growing potatoes. And that's, that's all it does. And so if you're sort of thinking about that small hold of vision, then there is the, the real potential to grow significantly more. But, but at the same time, you know, we've talked about 70 million people here. If we're likely to see the kind of ecological crisis and the human responses, the conflicts, the, the interruption in food systems worldwide that are likely to arise from those
ecological crises. We're going to see a mass migration from the global South and then we're all going to get here. But probably quite a few are going to get here. And, and I guess it comes back to, you know, how do we, how do we sort of furnish that future? How do we feed that future? And, and again, it comes back to that Dieter Helm perspective And, and also, you know, the perspective we were discussing in the last podcast that we did together about lab produced food. Can we produce enough if the population double S, for
example, in Britain? Because that's going to be challenging on whether it's high tech or, or, you know, sort of agrarian. Yeah. I mean, you know, tricky questions. I think you didn't. Come here for an easy life. You know, well, it's partly, you know, my, my, my skills as a crystal ball gazer. You know, despite the fact I write about the future a lot, I, you know, I'm just as clueless as everybody else, really. But I mean, I think the migration thing is, you know, it's it's obviously a huge
controversial political topic. And I think in some ways it's overstated. You know, most global migration is within countries or within regions. You know, I'm not sure that we're going to see sort of mass migration from the global S to countries like Britain. And, you know, it depends obviously on the sort of future scenarios we're talking about. You know, people talk about the Amop shutdown and the the fact that, you know, the temperatures in Britain could suddenly plummet as as a result of, you know, these sort of complex dynamics of climate change.
And and then we will be the ones that will be migrating, you know, kind of white folks in both setting across the Mediterranean to places like Libya. You know, how do we feel about that? But I think the key is to keep emphasizing sort of local production, you know, meeting meeting needs through job rich local agriculture. And, and, you know, I mean, for example, my son is currently doing really interesting research in Bangladesh where the narrative there is, you know,
threat of climate change, sea level rises. Let's get into shrimp farming, which is a very sort of capital intensive, environmentally destructive type of farming that that is kind of seeded by global capital as compared to people wanting to be rice farmers and, and, you know, being able to produce, you know, a lot of food and, and, and, you know, a diverse diet, not just rice. And so we have this kind of narrative that old climate change means that, you know, we,
you know, we need these sort of high tech solutions as people are going to be on the move. And that in a way, I think undermines what we, what we need to be doing, which is supporting people in place to, you know, to avoid that kind of overproduction that you alluded to of, you know, shrimp or soy, you know, that's being used as livestock fodder or biofuels or bio industrial inputs. You know, we need to, you know, we, we need to not be doing that and, and to be thinking much more locally about land as actually being promoting of, of,
of people's lives. And, you know, I think we do need to be that needs to be not in a kind of closed, you know, where the locals, nobody else, I mean, allowed here. We've sort of touched on that already, but I think that the sort of the idea of of of sort of huge global population flows, I mean, I think that will happen over the very long term. You know, as I said, people move to where they will find peace and prosperity. Ultimately, I think that means life will be less urban, more rural. You know, there'll be more people in Eastern Europe or the
Northeastern USA than in the, you know, the Western US and Western Europe. So, you know, these patterns will happen and they can happen in better or worse ways. And, you know, I don't think it really benefits anybody to, you know, have these kind of militarized borders and, and, and, and, you know, a lot of articulation of of sort of local land for local people kind of mindset. But I think it's, it's doable if, you know, if we focus on producing well-being, not on producing global commodities,
you know, using high energy methods and, and, and, and sort of footloose global capital, you know, there will be population movements, there will be places that are increasingly not propitious for life. But I think we need to avoid overly dystopian thinking about, you know, nobody will be able to live in this huge swathe and everyone will be coming to Britain. So, you know, we need this kind of high energy, high tech solution, you know, that that ultimately I think is going to cause, I mean, you know, we've had arguments obviously in my previous book, sort of arguing
with George one bio along this line, you know, I guess, you know, he thinks my vision is going to lead to mass death. I think his vision is going to lead to mass death. I mean, it'd be nice if we could have a more even tempered discussion about it, but I don't think it helps to get into these sort of mega dystopian, mega migration scenarios that then prevent us from developing good bottom up local solutions that can potentially benefit everybody who's in place and, you know, people elsewhere. I guess if we're sort of taking
things to the NTH degree, to the sort of more extreme end, then it helps to sort of identify a potential challenge. But you've got to walk back from that quite quickly, haven't you, in order to sort of find sensible, practicable approaches to it. And you, you sort of talked within their, you know, sort of militarised borders and this sort of thing. And, and the way that, you know, nationalism can sort of drive you to hoard your own resources at the same time as defending your borders. So other people don't come and use those resources. And we can think of that at farm level or, or a country level.
But one of the things you talk about in your book is the way that you think that people will need to become more indigenous. And I think indigenous is a word that's often misused by nationalists. And so I wonder if you could just talk about what you mean by Indigenous and just very briefly how how it will happen, how people will become more Indigenous. Yeah, there's a whole little section in the book about becoming more Indigenous and it is a, it is a very tricky word. I mean, in the sort of English speaking world, most countries, you know, if we're talking about
Australia or the USA, when we talk about indigenous people, we mean the aboriginal, the native people who were essentially displaced and subjected to genocide ultimately. And, and, and you know, the narrative then that that old progress narrative was that they were kind of yesterday's people who are being swept away. And now we've almost flipped that. And it's like, well, the indigenous people, you know, the land defenders, the water defenders, they, they know, you know, how to look after the land. And there's a lot of truth in that. I think sometimes we, you know,
we almost sort of flip the romanticism. You know, it's it's kind of a an argument that that that we're having with ourselves in the global N for sort of the rich Western countries using indigenous people as a sort of, you know, as as as a counters in that argument. But what it means, I think, which is what it's always meant, which is learning to live locally, learning to be indigenous, to place. It's not being an indigenous person. And that's where the nationalism comes in. You know, the way that people
talk about indigenous in Britain is it's a kind of code word for white. You know, it's like, you know, that's where the, you know, a very problematic nationalism kind of basically wants to exclude people from other parts of the world. And and you know, it's racially coded. You know, when, when we you sort of see that in the US with with Trump sort of granting asylum to white S Africans, you know, I mean, there's a kind of real lack of reckoning with the history of racism and the history of colonialism. So indigenous partly outside of
Britain in in the anglophone world, it's partly about ways of life, but it's also about politics. It's also about an indigenous nation defining its own borders. You know, all of that complex history of of sort of land theft and and sort of negotiating, you know, land back and so on. So that is partly in my mind in all that this, but you know, it's more about the ecology of the land actually learning to live locally on less exotic resource, you know, less water
inputs, less energy inputs, you know, that indigenous people have done. And we all, you know, we have this kind of weird duality where it's almost, if you argue for sort of Indigenous self determination, people are like, yeah, it's great if, you know, Indigenous people can live, you know, a sort of traditional local land based lifestyle. But then if you say, yeah, well, we should be doing that too. You know, we, we, we sort of rich white westerners. And it's like, oh, no, no, no, no. You know, you're, you're you're being sort of nostalgic. And but that is what we have to do. You know, that is the world that we're facing.
So being Indigenous means taking those steps to, you know, really looking at what local landscapes, waterscapes can, what they can provide, you know, for us, for the necessities of everyday life and not assuming that we can just use abundant cheap energy, abundant finance or our political power. You know, it's huge issue in Britain. In terms of I suppose relates to your earlier question, you know, we haven't been self reliant in food historically for many
years. Large not not because we can't be necessarily, but because it's easier for us just to sort of use colonial connections or buy in food from other parts of the world. And, and you know, particularly you mentioned horticulture earlier, you know, buying in labour, which is where we get back to the migration issue. You know, we either because energy is cheap and human labour is dear, we tend to either import labour, import cheap labour or, or import goods produced through cheap labour or elsewhere. You know, we need to take more
responsibility for that ourselves. And that ultimately is what being indigenous means. It's not about the, you know, the, the particular people or the colour of their skin who are doing this locally. It's about, you know, learning how to generate welfare and well-being from local resources. Most parts of the world have got very ecologically rich and thoughtful traditions of livelihood production and, you know, as we do throughout Britain. And that's, you know, that's what we need to learn. That's what we need to focus on. That's what being Indigenous means to me.
Chris, we've been talking for an hour and I've still got two or three questions, but it was enjoy talking to you so much. I hope you don't mind if we carry on in just just a little bit. And while you were talking, it reminded me of a podcast I think from about 3 years ago on Farmgate that I just want to signpost people to and I think it's called Indigenous with the Earth. So if people search Farmgate podcast Indigenous with the Earth, it should come up. And that's an interview with Reckonaldo Hazlit Marocheen, who, you know, talks very beautifully and passionately about what what being Indigenous
means. So I just wanted to signpost people, right that particular direction. Now you describe a transition from a world where homogeneity is queen to a future where context is king. And I wonder who will decide that future. You know within that what the role of government is, what the role of governance is. Well, yeah, I mean, I the way I, I, I suppose the way I address that in the book, I have this, these three celestial metaphors. I don't know how well they work,
but I was trying to sort of find an engaging way of describing it. So I talk about Suns, supernovas and solar systems. So the sun model is like the existing nation state model where, you know, the laws of the land are sort of set within the political capital and sort of apply everywhere. And I think, you know, we're going to, as we were talking about earlier, really I think government is is going to come from the centre. You know, we're still going to get that attempt to impose that sort of nation status model on which I think, you know, things
like Dieter Helms vision sort of rely on that. But increasingly, you know, as I've been saying, I think that's going to sort of fray around the edges and, you know, there will be a need to create governance bottom up. You know, here in the People's Republic of of whom, you know, we've got our sort of little independent town council that's done great work on that. But obviously very much within, and I talk a little bit about that in the book, but you know, very much within the limits of the existing system. So, you know, I think we're going to have this tension
between, you know, the existing model of very centralized government, that sort of fraying and, and, and people, you know, having to innovate bottom up. We will get, you know, what I call the supernova model, which is, you know, big explosive superpower politics. You know, who knows how that's all going to pan out, You know, the US, China, Ukraine, Russia, you know, so there is a chance that this could go very nasty in a very big way. And, but I also talk about the solar system model, which, you know, emerges from a lot of
studies of historic peasant societies where you sort of get this pulse of political power and, and a sort of complexity to political power that we've we've kind of forgotten about in, in modern times, You know, that we just have this very singular model of the government, you know, Westminster or Washington, DC or whatever. But the reality for a lot of people's lives historically is that, yeah, you know, there's some king in a distant capital and there's probably some local potentates as well. And there's also religious power. And then there's, there's kind
of more local forms of power. And it's a much more complex field that can sort of pulse between different centres. So that's what I mean by a kind of solar system model. You know, that there might be the sun, you know, Westminster is the sun as it were, but then there's the Earth and the moon and, and, and people are sort of placed in sort of complex ways with respect to those different sources of power and are also creatively navigating those forms of power, you know, trying to keep the king at Bay and, and, and sort of, you know,
yeah, tugging the forelock when necessary. But, you know, but actually getting on and doing their own politics, generating their own life locally. So, you know, I think we need to be aware of those kind of models and, and not to keep assuming that, you know, we need to write a policy document about the future of farming and, and sort of get the Keir Starmer's government to sort of take it seriously and sort of generate it all top down. You know, I think this will emerge historically anyway, out of the out of the drivers that we talked about earlier. But it's as well to be aware of it culturally and, and, and, you
know, to be a little bit more sort of determinedly local and autonomous in our political thinking, not to keep orienting to the centre the whole time. I always think of the, you know, in, in this conversation, the constitutional peasant sketch in Monty Python and the Holy Grail. Where, where, where? I can't remember. It's Michael Palin, isn't it? I think who, who, who's just astonished to discover that they actually have a king because they live in an Arco cynicalist commune. And and you, you mentioned the supernova as well. Yeah.
So that's basically just, you know, I think we're sort of seeing that now with the US has been the global superpower really, and it is beginning to lose that power and that there's a fear that what will happen is that it will kind of lash out in all sorts of unpredictable ways, which I think we're kind of seeing. And, and, you know, likewise, you know, so China, Russia, you know, sort of regional powers flash points over, you know, Ukraine and, you know, there's, there's, there's endless other iterations of that.
So the supernova is when the, the sun kind of explodes. I mean, I'm, I'm not an astronomer. I'm probably getting this all totally wrong, you know, in terms of the physics of it. But, you know, the fear is that the supernova is when the, you know, the state explodes in its attempt to, you know, to try and maintain its power. And, you know, there may not be much that we sort of here in Southwest England can do about, you know, what Trump and Putin and Zia are talking about. But you know, that's where I think we have to have a certain kind of cultivate a certain kind
of autonomy and indifference to that and to sort of try and generate, you know, what we need locally as best we can. And it, it may all come to nothing and you know, we might get nuked or whatever. But if you know. If people are doing that on the bright side, yeah. Yeah, You think my book's looking looking miserable, you know, you ain't seen nothing. But. Yeah, you know, I think that's all that people have ever done historically. They have cultivated well-being as best they can locally and, and tried to develop autonomies.
And sometimes it's like, well, actually, you know, I'm going to step into power. And, you know, there's sort of, you know, a lot of interesting historical debates about this sort of stuff, you know, the extent to which the industrial revolution, for example, was sort of top down or bottom up, you know, But you know, people, sometimes you get you have no, you know, most of us in contemporary society, contemporary Britain, we don't really have much choice. You know, we've, we've all got our sort of National Insurance numbers and, you know, endless bureaucracy and, you know, have to navigate centralized power. I suppose what I'm arguing is
let's also, you know, I'm not suggesting that we sort of have a revolution and try and knock all that out or that we, you know, I, I no longer really have any faith in any politics that sort of says if we get the right people in Westminster, then everything will be fine. You know, I don't think creative politics is going to cut be coming from political centers in the future from Westminster or Washington, DC. So I think we need to cultivate, you know, whatever type of accommodation or indifference to centralized power and and, you know, embracing what it can achieve.
I'm not, you know, I'm not saying that politicians are evil and corrupt and nothing good has ever come, you know, but I think ultimately that is a an old and failing model. So what we need to do as best we can is, is generate new, you know, this, this solar system model, you know, sort of new well-being locally, because ultimately, I don't think, you know, the centralized state, it's is going to sort of save us. It's too wrapped up in its own battles. And you know, of greater as in, you know, that that global power politics or, or more local
nature. But it's, you know, ultimately, you know, there's sort of interesting writing about this, you know, that ultimately the there's almost a deal between the public and and the state that, you know, we will pay our taxes and, you know, follow the laws and you will provide us with health services and other needed services. Increasingly, we're getting less and less back from the state, you know, because of the nature of the growth model and, you know, other aspects of the way that the global political economy works. So there comes a point when, you
know, when it's like, well, you know, why am I actually toeing the line with this state power in terms of what it's giving me? And, you know, this is where we see historically, you know, the fall of Rome and sort of other such examples, you know, in some ways follows that model. So it's like, yeah, you know, we need to generate this politics bottom up. And and that's what I'm trying to amplify in the book. I'm struck by the way that you describe it in the book. You sort of talk, you know, on your sort of journey towards the end of the book. You talk about the way in which someone's trying to get out of London and they're trying to
move to the West. And it's the way in which you have this, you know, still quite powerful centre in London, which still maintains power, I guess up to sort of around the Home Counties. But then it starts to disseminate. And I'm sort of thinking really in in visual terms of a pond where you've got a perpetual fountain that's still bubbling over at one point in the pond. But actually there are lots of stones that throw in. And you've got the ripple effect from these sort of slightly larger stones, maybe the governance coming out of Bristol, for example, or out of Liverpool at the same time as
you've got this sort of big rippling coming from London. But then smaller stones where you have individual villages or towns, like you say, as you call it, the People's Republic of Frome, you know, that are, that are delivering, you know, within their own context and, and in the context of governance. You, you know, I, I talked about this question with you before we recorded and you pushed back and you said, look, I, no, I do talk about religion. I do talk about the church, But I think there's a degree to which the church that you're seeing, you're sort of drawing on the past different kind of schools of religious thought. What I'm more concerned about is
the way that the church, you know, when you have this competition between historically church and state, which still exists in many countries around the world here to to an extent, but obviously much, much less so. But you do have this competition in terms of governance and power that comes from religiosity in the church. And historically, when times are troubled and disorderly, many people do look for comfort and order in the divine and from those structures on earth that seek to channel the divine. Do you expect to see a resurgence of religion and
cultism in this new world? Yeah, I do. I do for those reasons, I think. And I think also, you know, we will, I mean, I sort of feel it myself personally. And having had a very sort of non religious, secular upbringing and education and, and starting, you know, I think there is a, a religious turn amongst formerly secular sort of environmentalist thinkers because of the increasingly obvious defects of modernism and, you know, secular modernism
And, you know, the whole enlightenment legacy that I think has, has sort of run aground, which is not to say that, you know, it's simply like, great, you know, let's just sort of all go to church and it'll all be fine. You know, I mean, the, the church historically has not always been a, a great player in this, but I think I draw quite a lot in the book on Catholic social teaching and the distributist tradition where I, I, you know, which I, I do think and, and sort of natural law thinking emerging out of thinkers like Aristotle and Aquinas. I mean, I only touch on it in passing.
So there's that element to it. But yeah, you're right. You know, actual church attendance and people embracing religion. And I think, you know, that again, as with all of the other stuff, as with all of the politics that can go in in in different ways. And again, my crystal ball, I'm afraid is, is, is is too smoky. But, you know, I can see that can go in, in, in quite problematic directions where I think people, and, you know, we're seeing this a bit around sort of Islamophobia or
anti-Semitism and, you know, people sort of again, defining their their sort of religious or spiritual boundaries And, and it being, you know, developing sort of closed cults of, of, of spiritual power. Or it can be something that's much more ecumenical, much more open to cultural flow. And, you know, it's one of the interesting things about the Catholic Church is it, it's historically, it's kind of been both of those things. You know, it's been the word
Catholic in a sense, you know, it has been very open to sort of local possibilities and the ability of people to, you know, to sort of generate spirituality from the ground up. But it's also been this, you know, this deeply hierarchical and sometimes repressively violent institution orchestrated from Rome. You know, and, and, and likewise, I think there are there are ways of behaving that I see in both religious and secular people. You know, it's almost, it's like the extreme poles of of like,
you know, you're an infidel. You know, you are condemned to eternal damnation versus kind of logic of or, you know, a sense of humility, a sense of being equal before a higher power over which, you know, we cannot control. And you know, the the emphasis is on ethical behaviour and being open to other people and all of that. And, you know, you see those extremes both in secular politics and in religious beliefs.
So I think there will definitely be more religion. I think there will be religious conflict and the closing of boundaries. But my hope is that there will also be, you know, that sense of human fallibility and humility and sort of ability to kind of embrace other vulnerable human beings. Basically, you know that that that religion does inform or can inform. Yeah, it's really interesting, isn't it? Just looking across the world now, for example, and seeing the way that that Trump is is weaponizing the religious right.
And very often in those circumstances, the first thing that happens is that the rights of women get subjugated. And that's I guess one of one of my concerns about the future. And you know, this sort of focus on women's reproductive rights in the first instance. But very often, you know, the Catholic Church is, is a great example, but other churches, two of the machismo, this sort of very male dominated societies and structures. At the same time, as you say, on the other side, you have, you know, the church, whether it's Christianity or Islam or, or Judaism, it's sort of notion of
alms and looking after, you know, others in society and, and kindness and, and generosity. Look, we need to finish, but let's finish with your local world, the world as you describe it after it's changed around you. You write about this in some detail. I'm not expecting you to go through the whole 15 pages or whatever it is at this point, but can you just sort of summarize it for us now to bring us to the close? Yeah, I mean, I, you know, the the little sort of fictional end piece to the book where I talk about, you know, in about 100
years time in a very climate change challenged world, somebody essentially deciding to leave London, which is kind of falling apart and head to visit a a member of family, a kittens woman in Glastonbury, as as a matter of fact. And so I kind of play with some of the ideas we've been talking about earlier. So part of that is that, you know, government in London is still that's still the core of the nation state. But you know, as you alluded to
earlier, you know, I think what will happen there is that it will emphasize, you know, any sort of access to fossil energy to, to exotic energy will be monopolized and used in kind of high tech arable farming to sort of keep, you know, keep London fed. But we sort of move out to sort of gradations of the loss of that power. You know, I don't know if this will play out obviously exactly like this in the, in Britain, but it, it, you know, it's, it's a sort of wider model for thinking about this.
So then as, as we go out, you get other centres of power, you know, which we're already seeing in the US, for example, in the conflict between, you know, federal and, and, and city governance. And so, you know, I play with the kind of People's Republic of Frome thing, you know, so I kind of have this solar system model of Bristol and Frome being these kind of very rational Republic, kind of, you know, city republics essentially, you know, trying to sort of lay everything out sort of rationally. But then bubbling beyond that is
more, more localism, you know, people just trying to figure out how to produce food, how to manage property relations in, in villages that are sort of more or less coordinated with, you know, Bristol and, and, and Frome and so on. And an element of spirituality and, and religion, you know, kind of being generated bottom up in sort of fairly crazy ways versus the, you know, the existing church and, and, and more established religion. And that, you know, you mentioned the gender issue there, which is important as
well. And I do talk about it a bit in the book that and, and again from an agricultural focus, the agrarian history of women's women gardeners, essentially women's gardens and the the sort of key generational transfer between mothers and daughters. So, you know, I think the gender aspects in this are critical. And I sort of I talk about that in terms of matrilinee, which historically is associated more with horticultural than agricultural societies. So I have a, I have a male protagonist who's finding sort
of haven with a kinswoman. And, you know, part of what I'm trying to do in that little bit is discuss the way in which a sort of matrilineal inheritance of garden from mother to daughter might play out. So yeah, so there's all of these different levels, centralized politics, kind of city republics, religion, village generated, local farming and the the sort of tensions around that and and sort of gender politics in it as well. So, you know, it was just a way of, I suppose trying to dramatize, you know, the
discussion earlier in the book is a little bit quasi academic and and, you know, picking these examples from around the world and just trying to sort of bring it to life a little bit and and give some local colour to it. Yeah. So that's how it pans out. Fantastic. I mean, we've got to end Chris, but it's just been fascinating as ever talking to you and you know, and thanks for sort of sharing that story. And I think you're perhaps overly critical when you suggest that, you know, that it feels a bit academic because I think it's lightly written and people can dip in and out. They don't necessarily need to
read the whole thing, but I think if people do, then they will get a vast amount from this book. I think it's really, really fabulous. And and I hope that people listening will go out and get a copy. But, you know, that is, as I say, all we have time for. We've gone quite a bit over the time that we had scheduled. I'd like to thank my guest, Chris Smage and Finding Lights in a Dark Age is published by Chelsea Green and available. Whatever good books are sold, if you if you enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is now the world's
highest ranking food security podcast and Farmgate leaders Martins Farm, Wheat from the Chaff and are Filling the Funding Gap series are all available on the Farmgate channel if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. Farmgate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican AG, Rural Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Agrolo and individual donors. I've been Finlay Castaine bye for now.
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...