Professor Sir Dieter Helm's recent paper - The future of British farming - has received applause and consternation on social media. For Helm, British farming stands on the brink of its most profound transformation "since the coming of tractors and fertilisers" - but the vision he sets out is disturbing. The paper describes the technical and financial forces shaping modern agriculture, while treating regenerative farming with a sceptic's eye. Is Helm right? Is data-enabled precision ag, AI and vertical farming the future? Should the polluter pay? Is regen poorly defined and glyphosate dependent? And - what does all this mean for the family farm? ffinlo Costain meets Professor Sir Dieter Helm alongside regenerative and organic farmer, Patrick Holden, the Chief Executive of the Sustainable Food Trust. * Farm Gate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast * More land use news at 8point9.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, Welcome to Farmgate. I'm Finn Locustain, the editorof8.9.com. Professor Sedita Helm is known as one of the architects of the economics of natural capital. But his interest in agricultural land use runs deeper, and last month he produced a new essay called The Future of British Farming. For Helm, British farming stands on the brink of its most profound transformation since the coming of tractors and fertilizers. But the vision he sets out is somewhat disturbing. The paper describes the technical and financial forces shaping modern agriculture while treating regenerative farming
with a skeptic's eye. Helm calls for pollution pricing to drive sustainable change. For example, he says that farmers should pay for nutrient leaching, not be paid to prevent it. But what would that mean for the emerging natural capital markets that he once championed? And in moving to a purely public payments for public goods system of farm support, as Helm advocates, would the state not be abrogating its duty to repair the very nature that its policies and subsidies over decades did so much to deplete? Professor Sedita Helm is with me now to discuss his paper, and
we're also joined by regenerative and organic farmer Patrick Holden, the chief executive of the Sustainable Food Trust. Hello both. Dita, I read your essay as a rather dystopian view of the future of British agriculture. Was that your intention when you wrote it? Certainly not. And if you read that into the essay, I clearly didn't write it as I intended. What I was trying to do is something quite different, which is to set out what the big changes in the fundamentals of agriculture currently underway
are, how big they are, and then to draw out some of the consequences. Now, it's a bit like, you know, if you asked me to write a paper about what causes climate change, I wouldn't start by saying, you know, I'd like it to be like this. I would say these are the fundamentals. This is what's going on. Things like AI, data centers, quantum computing, et cetera. The need for a 24/7 firm. Paris, I set that out right. And that's what I'm doing in agriculture.
I'm simply saying, you know, if you really don't think digitalization is taking place, well, good luck to you. If you really don't think that genetic science has been utterly transformed, good luck to you, OK. And if you think that we can carry on with a world in which farming essentially is a huge financial asset attached to the day-to-day business of finance, of of doing the actual farming and that this is a, a credible long term way of running farming. Well, I disagree. But you know, then you have to think through these big changes
are taking place. What are the consequences? What's our farming world going to look like mid century? And I speculate about that. And, and I guess I, it's about different sort of senses of different futures and, and I guess part of it is about the degree to which we see the future as inevitable and which elements of the future we see as being most inevitable, whether ecological breakdown, for example, might be more inevitable than the, the increase in the amount of technology that's being used. So Patrick at the top of Dieter's essay, he says that
missing from both the government and industry lobbying sides is any serious long term plan for agriculture and agricultural policy. Now, I think it would be pretty hard to disagree with that generally, but you have one, you have a a vision of the future. What is it? Well, before I try to answer that question, let me first say I I do agree with Dita and actually I agree with quite a lot more that he brings up in his essay, which I just recently read last night actually. I'm sure there's going to be some sort of areas where we are, we have different perspectives. But a lot of what you say, Dita, I think is fascinating.
And I do agree with you that the forces that you've described, which acts act on all farmers, including myself, I think are absolutely there and they're not going to go away. I guess I'm a bit of an idealist, although I'm a practitioner as well and I'm stupid perhaps enough to think that the farming system that we're running here could go to scale. What would be the key features of that system? Trying to minimize the use of non renewable polluting damaging inputs at the same time
producing as much food as we can from the natural capital and I'd argue the social and human capital that occupies this hill. And to try to navigate in an economic environment where the polluter doesn't pay and we are not currently being rewarded for all the public goods that we are delivering and operating in a state of perhaps naive hope that those deficiencies will be corrected in time. So I think we set out our vision in a way our in our Feeding Britain from the Ground Up
report, which I'm not sure if you've seen Dita, but basically it models taking regenerative agriculture to scale across the UK and it looks at the impacts on outcomes and diets. And we could go into that. But I think what you might say to criticize that report is that the economic and policy conditions for achieving that do not yet exist. And the question is, could they? So I mean as you recognize Patrick, regenerative agriculture of every broad
church and there are lots of different bits in it. But for example, the idea that we should we should use fewer inputs to produce well same output or or maybe less output, whatever, OK is very, very supported by the digitalization and the AI etcetera that's coming forward. Indeed, you know, in AAI enabled digital world, the drill bit can tell you an incredible amount about what's happening in each
particular point. Now you may not want to use pesticides at all. I'm very sympathetic with that idea. But if you are doing so, as we have done, one of the reasons why the use of pesticides has been declining is precisely the kind of precision out agriculture which is only possible if you have these digital technologies. You know, in the in the good old days, and I think back my grandfather's farm, he had a feel for what was going on in each bit of the field. He could tell you which bit was damper. He could tell you where particular kinds of weeds were
like prevalent. He could tell you where germination would be good or bad because he'd got a lifetime of experience of doing that. Now nearly all of that is now data. And that's a fantastic change. It's like the bank manager used to know all his customers or her customers, and now data tells you a vast amount more in any banking transaction. So yeah, to argue that these changes aren't necessary against the grain of what you want to do, I don't necessarily subscribe to what you want to do
is to miss the point. I. Wasn't arguing that I'm agreeing with. You these are available. I I totally agree with you. I think we're entering a data age and we meaning the Sustainable Food Trust, have become very involved with this because what we are trying to do is to develop a common framework for measuring the impact of farming systems on climate, nature and people. And to achieve that you need data. So we're, we're, we're thick into the weeds of data and talking of weeds and individual field conditions, I do not think that the data collection
exercise with which we are involved, particularly my wife if I'm honest is inconsistent or what incompatible with having knowledge of an individual field. So for instance, we're growing carrots this year on 2 acres and the, as you can imagine, the top of the field, because we're a bit slopey, differs substantially from the bottom of the field. And yes, the, the, the soil mapping that we're part of will gather that data. And indeed, next year I might even if I'm lucky, have a, a machine which will have cameras on it to identify the weeds and
ZAP them and leave the carrots growing. So, you know, we're involved in all that sort of stuff as as well. But I do not. I think you're wrong if you think that the arrival of the data era is going to render the knowledge that every farmer has more or less of the unique circumstances of the sort of microbiome or ecosystem which they're managing will become redundant. I think that's wrong. And I didn't say, I didn't say that, just to be clear. I just said that it augments that very substantially and the
balance of a world in which you really did need that hands on knowledge, a specific knowledge and years of experience to the world we're now in for much agricultural production. That balance has shifted. Yes. What comes out at the end of the drill bit that goes to, I don't know, John Deere or whoever the equipment lease supplier is, is fantastically different from what went before. And it's true across a whole series of technologies. For example, you know, if you were horizontally drilling for let's say shale gas or whatever, you don't have to have the
expertise that are a wildcatter used to have. You've got at the end of the drill bit a fabulous piece of technology which tells you absolutely almost anything you need to know about that frame. Now that's the direction of change and the two changes together, that and the AI and the massive datasets that are constructible around that and those tools in the hands of farmers, together with what synthetic biology and modern genetics are doing, is to me
bigger than the shift from horses to tractors. We might want to disinvest tractors in disinvent tractors like we might want to disinvest a Harper Bosch process, but the reality is they were utterly transformational. And that's all I'm saying in my paper. I'm not making a judgement was good or bad. I'm simply saying that's what's happening. I guess the. Question partly, Patrick, Patrick, just to sort of come come back in on that and maybe you can comment on this is the question of how transformational it might be because of course, you know, tractors coming in and
fertiliser, you know, we saw an incredible boom in the amount of food that was being produced from parcels of land. Whereas my understanding is that much as AI and technology and data collection are fundamentally important. And yes, I mean, agree with both of you that they are delivering change. And many conversations I have with regenerative farmers, you know, not just here but elsewhere in the world, it's about the way that they can tweak the level of inputs they can help to boost production. But that level of boosting of production is likely to be relatively small in comparison with with transformations we've
seen in the past. Well, yeah, I mean, I violently agree with Dita about the, you know, the sort of epoch level change that these new factors are bringing into our farming. But I think, you know, I'm not doing this just to disagree with you, Teresa, But I think that what you're describing can be harnessed to beneficial effect without negating the deep knowledge of stewardship that I have and love indeed that I have for my landscape. And so I think the two are not
mutually incompatible is my point. And I think that's a really important point to raise because some of the stuff, some of the technology which is coming on, like all the sort of knowledge of the genome and everything else, I think we need to put all these technologies through a very careful, rigorous screen and reject the ones that are incompatible with proper regenerative farming. And I also agree with your point that there's a sloppy, inadequate definition of what regenerative means. Not that I think we should have a totally legal definition of it, but there is an issue there which we could also discuss.
But certainly on my form, I'm not against all these new technologies. I agree with you that economic framework is changing, but I want to apply that through the lens of a human being and a family managing an ecosystem, and I want family farming of that kind to survive the that the heralding of these new background conditions. Well, I I'm sure you do, and I'm sure there's an argument to be made for conventional, traditional family farming, but we do need a little bit of perspective here. So we got from 2 billion people to 8 billion people in the 20th
century and broke out of where they started. The 19th century. We were broke out of the constraints, essentially, that someone like Malthus would have understood, you know, that there was a very big constraint on the amount of food that could be produced, and the population of the world was limited by that in the 20th century, whether we'd like it or not, but it's good or bad. It was the utter transformation, dare I say through fossil fuels of agriculture, which meant that 8 billion people are mostly pretty well fed today, right? It is extraordinary.
And that is artificial fertilizers at scale, tractor power and the internal combustion engine, etc, etc. And if we look forward into the future and ask ourselves, so where is all this food going to be produced? Because if people who are going to get richer and developing countries want to move up the food hierarchy, look at what's happening in China in terms of pork and chicken and so on. If they do, it might not be a good thing. But if they do, where is food at scale going to be produced and
how is it going to be produced? And if I ask myself, is it going to be the conventional family farm as in the UK model that's developed, my answer is a bit. But if you look at the frontier of all this stuff and you look at what indoor farming is doing, you look what intensive farming is doing in the East of England. It may be environmentally awful and there may be serious environmental costs, but the capacity to marry together the genetics and the synthetic biology with the informational
technology we have today is likely in my view to induce our food production world, which you won't like, I probably won't like, but one which is very, very different from the model of your farm. And I would say one thing further, which is the split between organic and regenerative. I mean a lot of regenerative farming is basically glyphosate farming, right? Whereas organic is very different and as a consequence,
perfectly understandably, organic farming tends to be higher cost and tends to have somewhat lower outputs, at least when we think about it at scale. Regenerative farming is basically a step towards using glyphosate. And I mean, you know, conventional farmers use this stuff all the time, including to dry a crop just before they harvested it to go into the food chain. And this is a world of difference between what's really
going on in a lot of regenerative farming and what you do in your regenerative organic farming practices, too. And they are not in the same planet much. Regenerative farming doesn't look a lot different from the farmer. I can as feel as I can see out my window here who basically uses glyphosate and doesn't plow and doesn't drill, but is about the most intense farming practice I know for miles around. Patrick, could you, could you come back and comment on the
regenerative element of that? Because you know, what dieter's describing there is, is not my understanding of regenerative farming at all, although a little bit of glyphosate is used in some sort of forms of regenerative agriculture. Certainly if we're talking about livestock, then there's, you know, none of that at all. And what you're getting instead is a is a really vastly different level, a very high level of ecological output as well. So let's just start with that, that sort of idea that all that regenerative farming is, is just glyphosate farming.
And, and also just before I sort of go on to that, I want to sort of mention the way in which for regenerative farming to be successful, it obviously needs to produce a lot of food. And so from, from a kind of punter perspective, fields might look quite similar in terms of what's coming out of it. I'm reminded of Leontino Balbo Junior, who produces so much of the world's organic sugar. You look at his fields from above and it's just a monoculture of sugar cane. But at the same time, what's happening on the ground, the amount of biodiversity that's there, the, the hundreds of
arthropods that he's getting, many more than any nature reserves sort of in the, in the similar area, you know, are phenomenal because he's changed the way that he's farming, but is getting a much more resilient crop as a result. Well, before I try to address some of the points you rate, you ask about regenerative and organic farming. Just to say again, Dita, I love the sharpness of your intellect. I think you're raising uncomfortable issues and I welcome that and and thank you for doing so to your last contribution. The only thing I disagree with
about what you said is you said, well, we're pretty well fed nowadays because of the Harbour Bosch process and all that went with the that the chemistry which followed it and the intensification of agriculture which defied Malthus, if you like. The only thing I challenge is that we're pretty well fed. I think if you've read or know about Chris van Tulliken's work on ultra processed food and you go back before the farm gate, I would say that the commodity crops which are more or less responsible for probably, God knows, probably 80% of all the food that we eat today, maybe
even more than that, are nutrient deficient, contaminated with chemical residues and poor for our microbiome. And I think that there is a growing awareness, particularly amongst young people, which is very interesting that the link between farming practice, food quality, nutrient density, food safety and health is going to be a big emergent driver for change. So I just like to sort of bookmark that. But to your to come on to your points about the difference between regenerative and organic farming. I think you probably pigeonholed
me as a sort of ideologically committed organic person. But in fact, I'm quite keen on the whole idea of regenerative farming being a step towards farming more in harmony with nature. But I completely agree with your analysis. If this is what it is, that was what it was, that a lot of regenerative farming is extremely dependent on glyphosate. And in my opinion that farming with that degree of dependency is actually not very regenerative.
And I think when we start properly measuring the impact on biodiversity and soil carbon of those regenerative farmers who are scapegoating the plow to hide, in my view, view their dependence, their umbilical dependence on Roundup, I think we'll find that many of those farming systems actually are not very good for biodiversity or soil carbon. But we need to collect the data to find out. So I think it's really important that we look at whether those farming systems are truly regenerative. And certainly if you're looking out of your window and seeing an orange field, which I suspect is what it looks like at this time
of year, there is no biodiversity in it because it's all been sprayed off. So I think, you know, there's a, there's a lot to talk about there. The question is whether seriously regenerative farming can go to scale, meaning farming that is regenerative both of nature and addresses climate and produces really good food. And I think there are opportunities for that which won't necessarily be organic. OK, Just a couple of quick points, because we agree on most things here as we often do. So I agree with you entirely that we have replaced in developed countries, and indeed increasingly in developing
countries, a world in which quite a lot of people were short of food, full stop. And we had a lot of people globally, including actually in China, who were not starving, but, you know, in a pretty bad way because they didn't have enough food. We've replaced that with a world in which we've got too much of the wrong sort of food. We've got obesity, we've got all sorts of diseases and problems and frighteningly, especially amongst the. They might be enlightened young people who see the light
etcetera, but that's the people who write in the newspapers and appear on the television etcetera and go on social media. For the vast bulk of people, this isn't their world. OK, so what's the answer to that? Well, someone like me would say the externalities involved in this are not being paid for properly, right? So it's not etcetera, etcetera. So remember in my world, it's a world in which these technologies just happen, right? They are happening. It's not even the future, it's now, OK, but they're not necessarily good in their
outcomes. So for me polluters should pay public could should be provided. Now if we applied the polluter pays principle to the damage that quite a lot of this hyper process. Now the food does the extent it does we had proper sugar taxes and all those kinds of things. Then the outcomes would be very different, but what they would? Agree. They wouldn't make go away is the fact that this is in a context in which our knowledge of genetics, genomes and synthetic biology is just phenomenally different from five years ago in that alone. 10 And
our information technologies are exploding all around us. And I think you need to put those things together to get a picture going forward. On the glyphosate. Yeah. I mean, you know, I'm amazed. I I did a presentation at farm it down the road from me on this paper last week and I mentioned some things about glyphosate. The pushback's enormous, but I remember when a crop after a crop of wheat or barley or whatever, there was a lot of undergrowth, the sheep were put on it and then it was plowed in because the organic material went into the soil.
And we're told that that's much worse than just killing everything on the surface. But much? Is nonsense, by the way. My my picture of a glyphosate field. It is dead. It is utterly dead. In the soil that's better than it might otherwise have been if you're doing badly plowed with heavy tractors, etcetera, correct, right. But this cannot be, you know, environmentally a great idea to doubt it's a. Terrible. It's a terrible idea. With glyphosate, it's a terrible idea, and the sooner it's banned the better. You can't blame farmers for using it while they can make
more money if they grow crops every year, put a catch crop, a cover crop in and then spray it off. But in terms of what it's doing to nature and probably to the human Biome microbiome, I think it's really bad news. And so I think we're completely aligned on that. But I just raised one other issue about the the gene editing and all that goes with that, the knowledge of the the genome. It's interesting. We used to grow oats here that were the best varieties of the time, you know, because they keep evolving, The varieties keep changing.
For years ago I got a couple of sweet jars of heritage black oats which used to be grown in Wales on these poorer, more challenging microclimates and soil conditions until about the 60s. And then the Welsh plant breeding station came along. We had lots of new varieties of oats and now the generation of new varieties is increasing faster, as you say. But anyway, four years after we got these two sweet jars of black oats, which are the traditional oats, we had enough this year to drill our entire 30
acre block of oats, which we feed to the cows with these black oats. What was really interesting was that the combine driver who happens to be because there are not that many cereals grown in West Wales nowadays, he happens to have those sort of not a monopoly, but he's, he's combining the majority of the grains grown in West Wales, including the Aberystwyth plant breeding station where they are responsible for the emergence of new varieties of oats. His comment was that he didn't see anything he was combining an aberyst with which is any better than these black oats that are
very long strawed that smother out the weeds. And yet they, as you said, the the aftermath is full of unsound plants and it's really good grazing. We won't plow it until the spring for a next crop anyway. And the nutrient density these oats appears to be different because the cows really milk well on them. So I'm, I'm just thinking that in a world where we're thinking that we can improve on nature, sometimes epigenetic adaptation, both of animals and plants, I think can actually rival this
incredible new knowledge we have. I'm not saying we shouldn't look at it or pay attention to it, but certainly if the combine drivers analysis is right, we shouldn't turn our back on some of these traditional varieties. But who? Who would want to? It's not an awe, it's an and what we now can do is tell you a huge amount about what that traditional black oats. I'm not familiar with the the territory as you'll obviously be aware, but can tell you vastly more about it than we knew before. And what's more, the data from
what's going on in the field right down to the, you know, really quite close density can be fed together and so we can feed the two together. So I don't see any contradiction at all in that. And what's more, I think it's incredibly important that we use the technologies to record all the varieties we have before we lose them. Because one of the problems about modern agriculture, again, you're much more familiar with this stuff than me, but is that how very, very small number the varieties we use?
Exactly. Dairy cattle, we've seen it in beef, we see it in wheat, we see it. Barley, we see rapes sidor and we lose a lot of that. Fortunately, people are building seed banks and taking the stuff seriously, but it's not an awe, it's an and. And the new technologies help with that process, not hinder it. What hinders it is where large oligopolies in the industrial side of equipment, plant breeding, et cetera, control those outcomes and I don't think
it would be the case. Back to our earlier bit of conversation that we'd be using glyphosate in quite the scar we did if it hadn't been for Monsanto and now it's successor promoting it so hard. And that's what we have to be careful about, about letting particular interests narrow the opportunities that are available. Technologies are neutral to that. And of course. Fiddler, we're in danger of agreeing with each other too much. No, no, no, no, it's absolutely fine. You know, what I'm interested in is having, you know, is the 2 of
you having a conversation and, and finding where those points of agreement are. And if they're broad, that's great, but then finding where those points of disagreement and challenge are as well. And one of the things I'm sort of struck by data is that you have, you know, very beautifully described. And I think this is sort of part of the challenge on social media, the way that some farmers have, have read your essay is that it's quite a description of what many people would see as being quite a dystopia around the technologies and so on. But then beyond that description of the world as it is, I'm interested in the world that you
would like to see because of course in terms of natural capital, you were very, you know, sort of instrumental in driving policy changes. I don't think there's any disagreement between the three of us that data is. Can I just jump? Can I jump in there and say Schumacher, did you read Smallest Beautiful data? Many, many times. OK, because I mean, he was an economist and his the subtitle of his book, The Study of Economics as if people mattered. And I guess that's where I think we might be able to tease out some points of difference because you're describing what I think is a very bleak outcome to
these new forces coming into the equation. And I'm thinking, no, there are counter forces which may stop that bleak outcome. And I guess I'd love to explore that more with you. Yeah, exactly. And maybe you could sort of set out some of that to start with, Patrick, because I think there are two visions of agriculture. 1 is the one that that has been described very clearly indeed as essay. The other is a world which is, which is much more regenerative, organic, where there is much greater diversity, where the supply chain has been interrupted for whatever reason. And we have shorter supply
chains as a result of that. And there is a change. And of course, as part of this, we need this massive transformation in the way land is used away from fossil fuels that, you know, would be fuelling the the sort of vertical farms that Dieter's talking about, a lot of the, you know, the more industrial processes. And therefore, in the future, if we're talking about food security at a global level, we may not be able to get our hands on those things anyway. So, so it's sort of trying to sort of identify what the world might look like in 20 years time
with geopolitical instability, ecological breakdown, and therefore say, OK, we know what the world is now in terms of the way that farming works in the financialization of farming, what should it be? And of course, how do we get there? So first of all, you mustn't assume that. I mean, I'm not in favour or against, but I observe how much more production takes place indoors rather than outdoors, whether it be mass production tomatoes or mushrooms as my family used to, or et cetera, et cetera. OK, but you mustn't confuse vertical farming with fossil fuel farming, right?
Go and have a look in the Hutton Institute. I did years ago at the vertical farm. It's well on renewable energy. You don't have to, but. It's 30 times amount, the amount of energy that non vertical systems are using and also they're economically they're they're falling apart. It's renewable. The sun comes up every day, right? We're not short of any energy. We're short of them. So I'm just remembered by the way, in your transition from fossil fuels in this world, remember that 84% of the world's energy is fossil fuels. So over 70 something percent in
this country and actually globally, the demand for all of these things continues to go up. And just because you think you might not use fossil fuels, almost everything you use and buy into your farm has had fossil fuels behind it. Your tractor is an amazing piece of fossil fuel production from the steel, the mining, the iron ore, etc. And if you stick a battery in it, just think about the fossil fuels involved in the lithium, the copper, the cobalt and the nickel, etc. But that's an aside. OK, So what should food farming look like?
So in the paper, I don't say what it should look like. I say the fundamental changes that taking place in the background. So in a farming policy, which is where government intervenes because the outcomes of a market process are not socially economically optimal, etc, you have to ask, well, what are the failures here? So the first one is we don't pay for the pollution because we're living environmentally beyond our means. So any rational economist would say you should pay for the
carbon that you're emitting. You should pay for the damage to the water systems of all the stuff leaching off your land, etcetera, etcetera. So should everyone else. So polluter pays principle is you're never going to have a sustainable agriculture or sustainable economy if pollution is not properly paid. Can I intervene and say I completely agree, But I think we also agree that in the near future the government are unlikely to introduce the polluter pays principle to agriculture because it's going
to have the effect of putting the price of food up, and that's politically unattractive. Look, let's be clear. I'm not suggesting we're going to have a sustainable economy. I'm not suggesting that agriculture is about to become environmentally benign, right? I don't think it is. It should be. I agree with you because I would like to live in a sustainable economy, but the electorate aren't voting to pay more for their food, correct? And and they're not paying and not voting to do anything that seriously addresses carbon emissions either.
Not quite. The net 0 consensus has completely broken down, right? Right. It hasn't completely broken down Well, I know because I'm talking to a lot of companies because I've joined. No, I said consensus. I didn't say everybody's given up on net zero. I said that we had a consensus when it wasn't costing us anything. Now we have the most expensive electricity in the industrial world, right? And the voters are going in the direction which is not helpful for climate change.
But you'll you'll know that one of the reasons why the electricity is so expensive is because we are vulnerability to imported fossil fuel energy. Absolute rubbish, Patrick. OK. The price of of gas in real terms is now below the five and 10 year average. What we're doing is making sure and for climate change reasons, perfectly understandably, that we're not going to benefit from lower gas prices in the future. We assume we're going to run out with the stuff and it's going to be high and volatile if only
we've got enough fossil fuels to fry the planet several times over. And unfortunately these things are fantastically cheap for what they deliver. OK. Yeah. So I think. Also. Renewable. Reason why The reason why electricity prices are high in the UK is because of the government driven policy decisions so that even the wholesale price is only 30% of total cost. Now we have the most expensive nuclear power stations in the
world to build. We have really expensive solar and wind once you take into account the system cost. Do you know in this country we now need 120 gigawatts of capacity to meet what 60 gigawatts used to do. We need twice the size of the grid and we need all the storage and batteries and everything else. And then people tell you that renewables 9 times cheaper. If only that was true. It is not true. And it's very, very important to get this energy question right because a lot of agriculture, like everything else in our
world, is energy. Mark should have talked about the energy theory of value, not the labour theory of value. It is. Also true, isn't it, that the market has had to bear the cost of developing renewable energy in a way that it never had to do with fossil fuels or nuclear? Come on, if it's nine times cheaper, right, the market had to bear the development costs of the iPhone and the original computer. There are a huge number of things. The market develops because there's a profitable market At the end. We pay very large subsidies, and not against the subsidies
either. I'm simply saying that we've now got to point where we're told it's nine times cheaper by the Secretary of State. It isn't. The system costs are very considerably higher, and what we need is twice the energy system and all the pylons and all the batteries and everything else to produce the same. It's called the broken windows fallacy. Yeah, break windows. Let let's see new Windows in place. And you think you're better off at the result. You're not. Let's say you're right on the huge cost of getting the
infrastructure in, but what does definitely happen once you've got that in is that the price per unit, say using PV, the price for PV units has dropped dramatically in the last few. Years, that's not true. It's true of the marginal cost that's come down dramatically, very dramatically, but the system cost of all the backup and support that's required. Let me give you an example. Well, I'll give you an example on my own farm if you want me to, no. I've got, I've got my own solar panels at home. It's great. But the system is quite
different. So if you take where we put a lot of, let's say offshore wind off the coast of Scotland, right, it's a long way from the market. Scotland has excess energy, right? It costs at least 113 LB a MW hour in subsidy. It has to have all the transmission lines, the pylons, everything else created to take it down to the South of England. And then let's just be clear, it only works about 40 or 50% of the time. And when even in that time, actually in Scotland, for 40% of the time it actually works, we
pay it to produce electricity which we do not use. These costs do not go away because the marginal cost of a wind turbine, which is actually going up, not down anymore, or the very low cost to the marginal cost of solar panel go South. You're not paying the true cost the system of your. You couldn't possibly, you couldn't deny that the system costs associated with creating the infrastructure to be able to use the renewables, they are there and they are very significant. Getting the the grid sort of updated is, is going to be a
decades, several decades long project. It's really important. But of course that all had to be done in the 1st place for fossil fuels. And so the trouble is that we're looking at the cost of renewables now with those system costs built in and we're trying to compare them with something whether the system already exists, which makes it difficult. The point is we need double the system to produce the same output in fact demand. Is that doesn't matter? Does it Deta? It doesn't matter. And the second thing that's true is the outcome of this, which no doubt our Prime Minister and our Secretary of State will be
explaining in Brazil in claiming world leadership, is we have the most expensive electricity, industrial electricity in the world. As a result, Grangemouth's going, the steel industry going, the fertilizer industries closed down. The car industry outputs are momentarily back to the 1948 level. And then back in the 1950s, we've closed most of British industry as a result of this. Now, no, it's absolutely obvious. Of course, emissions fall as a
result of that. We can import the stuff like we import the beef from Brazil, we can import the steel from China. We aren't improving on climate change as a result. You have to. But wait a minute, what? Let me, let me just ask you what what? I don't know what you're for anymore because you say you are in favour of renewable energy and you've got PV cells. I haven't got enough and I'm massively dependent on fossil fuel energy on this farm, diesel and everything else that you've mentioned. But what do you want to happen? What? OK.
So so I. Think you're not being clear about that? I know I am, and that I haven't written in this paper on farming, but I have more generally. So indeed I have another recent paper out on the subject. So if we want to address climate change, and I really do, we should address climate change, we shouldn't kid ourselves with domestic net 0 carbon territorial production targets. We should mark our carbon consumption. We should take into account the imports. We shouldn't claim that Drax isn't producing carbon emissions in the UK because of UN
accounting figures. We should look at that the imports. And this is very important for agriculture as well As for industry more generally. And we should spend our money in a way which has the maximal impact on reducing global emissions and increasing global sequestration. That's one thing. Can I intervene and say I let's supposing you're right on that I'm a farmer farming 300 acres, which is like a cell of the
energy system or the food system, depending on how it's both really at a cellular level. What should I do? Well, I'll tell you what I've done so far. I've haven't used any chemical fertilizers or pesticides for 52 years. So I'm trying to farm with, as I said at the beginning, with an ecosystem which is producing A genuine surplus of food without depleting our natural capital. But I'm also trying to wean myself off fossil fuel energy because that's my biggest dependency.
What I'm planning to do is a combination of solar PV and wind and yes, possibly some batteries because I take your point that it's, you know, you need to produce more in order to wean yourself off it. Do you think that's a bad plan for you? I'm sure it's great. Do I think that British agriculture is in a position to do that? No. Why not? Why not? Why? Because you know the incentive structure around much of British agriculture. In fact, all of it is points in the opposite direction.
Well, yeah, that's gonna be true. But I've I've done it. Gentlemen, let's armor inside my door is extremely profitable. I want to move on from the. He was going to do what you suggest you do. He would just laugh. I want to move on from the energy conversation because we've only got we've only got 10 minutes left and there are three areas that I would like to cover. The 1st is to sort of go back on the polluter pays element because you know again there would be broad agreement that the principle of the polluter pays is a good one. The question is who pays? And when it comes to food production, who is it that has
driven the problem in the 1st place? Who has benefited from the markets that have been created and the food that's been created? And therefore, who needs to be paying for that pollution during that period of transition? Because the transition from one type of farming to another, from an intensive industrialized model to a regenerative and organic model is enormous. And at the moment, all of the risk seems to be on the farmer. Very, very little seems to be on either the customer or on often the processing giants or on the government itself.
And what concerns me about your your position on the polluter pays idea, on the idea that farmers shouldn't be paid not to leach their nutrients as is happening currently with water companies, but instead to be charged for leaching those nutrients in the 1st place. Avoids the uncomfortable history that for decades government has been telling farmers to maximize and prioritize food abundance and have just completely been OK with the externalization of these ecological and social costs. So who should be?
Paying it's been worse than that. Think about red diesel. We actually relatively subsidized pollution farm, right? So, so so why does all that responsibility land on the farmer? Just just just come back. OK, So the reason you want to make polluters pay is you want to change the incentives they confront. Now, there are people out there who are are, you know, benign, good farming citizens caring about the future, like Patrick. You shouldn't design policy for ultras.
You should just assume people are going to behave in ways that maximize their profits. And then you should. You should address the incentives to do that. And if they go as far as Patrick does, brilliant. And if it turns out to be more profitable, even better. But we don't go around. Deita, we're agreeing. We're agreeing. I mean, we are actually agreeing because So I agree with you that the application of the polluter pays principle is logical. We probably also agree it's not going to happen tomorrow for the reasons we just discussed, because it's politically unattractive.
I think where there may be a difference between us is whether it's carrots and sticks, isn't it? The stick is polluter pays principle applied not being applied, which is annoying because it and that's why extractive farming pays better than rigid proper regenerative farming. The carrot would be to first of all measure the public goods coming out of a farming system, including, I would argue, the human social public goods, and then to find mechanisms for rewarding the public goods outcomes. I'm not sure if we even disagree with that. No, no, look, look, there are
two principles in the on the face of the Agricultural Act, which sits alongside the Environment Act and is part and past of the framework that came out of the Natural Capital Committee. One is plutopase, which are clearly not doing properly. No, the second one is public money for public goods, correct. Let me finish. It was always the intention and it's been deeply perverted that the major public goods being largely in the uplands but also
in some of the lowlands too in sensitive farming practices etc. That have no. Soil. Soil is all the lowlands. Yeah, OK. No, I agree. I agree. OK. But that this is where the money would flow, and that's where the public money for the public goods would go to where the public goods the most like is produced and best produced. Well, I really disagree with you on that. That has not happened. And what we've had instead, which I think is very sad, is that we've got rid of the payments for producing food,
we've got rid of the payments for owning land, what was cat One, etcetera. And we replaced it by the Treasury essentially trying to reduce the overall budget to agriculture to as close to 0 as possible, like in the 1920s and 1930s. And there are arguments the Treasury mount for that approach relative to other bits of the economy. But the reality is that you have absurd positions like the government claiming it's going
around the largest subsidy budget for for it's ever been for the next two years, etcetera, forgetting there's been 25% inflation. The squeeze is really fast. There isn't the money going into agriculture for the public goods. They're all. So you arguing for more money or heavily squeezed? Are you arguing for more money later? I'm arguing for the appropriate amount of money to address the really important public goods that farming produces. OK. And what I don't know what the
right number is. I'm simply saying, and I say in my paper, that that the strategy that we have at the moment is simply to reduce the overall cost to the Treasury of. I agree with you. I completely agree with you. Yeah. Also, the only thing I I think you've missed out is you. You say that food isn't a public good. Well, I say just food isn't. But I'd say one of the biggest negative externalities of our current farming system is damage to public health. Yeah. But we we agree about this, Patrick, that's. Why? But that's. Those costs are properly
reflected in the prices of what is a lot of food. That's a very questionable value at all, right? I don't disagree with you at all about that, but I want to address that question head on. Because remember, if you look at agriculture as a whole, the actual farming bit currently is a very small bit of the total value chain of the thing that arrives in Greg's or wherever down the track. You know, that's the massive amount of expenditure in the frame and that's where the additional costs of what's done to the food which feeds through into our diet.
No, no, I I think that you might be a little bit wrong on that. I want to address that question. I think you're wrong to say it's all after the food leaves the farm gate, I would say. Laughter. I didn't say that. I said that the bulk of it is. I think the bulk. Of it is more on the farm itself as well than it's stress and that's where the polluter pays principle well that's very important I'm. I think you might be wrong on that allocation. I would say that ultra processing is adding insult to the very considerable injury
that has been done to the commodities which our industrial farms produce. They are nutrient deficient as I said, and they are probably unsafe because they've got God knows what chemical residues in them. And I would say that if you look at the ratio of the damage done to public health of what happens on the farm or what happens to the commodities after leave the farm, I'd say it may be a 5050 split or even in favour of what happens on the farm. So I think it's an empirical. Question. I beg to differ, but it's an empirical result. But it's an important question, isn't it?
That's incredibly important. Right. Yes, we need to measure. That policy to deal with the externalities at every stage of this chain because we do not want to end up in a world where what I don't know what percentage of the population is obese and you know, that's just not here. It's true in developing countries too. And that is not a good outcome. It may differ about how to go about addressing that. Also not. In the few minutes that we have left, I just like to move on finally to natural capital markets because we talked about polluter pays as a principle.
We've talked about the idea of public funds for public goods and the way that, you know, potentially the government ought to be investing much more into that idea of public funds for public goods so that we can help to fuel that transition. Now, natural capital markets are a really important way of farmers earning more money beyond what's coming from government, beyond the cost of or the the price of food specifically, in order that they can extend their farm businesses and make sure that they are profitable. What role do you see natural capital playing for farmers
these days, Dita? OK. So the the key bit here, you say natural capital markets. So a market is usually the exchange of homogeneous things. Oil's a market, right? Most oils, like most oil are almost all natural. Capital is not homogeneous, right? It's site specific. OK. And what's more, natural capital comes in systems, ecosystems, not discrete little projects. Economist cost benefit analysis, all about discrete projects.
What we want to do environmentally is protect and enhance the ecosystems we have in the soils, the rivers, etcetera, etcetera. OK, So a market, bilateral market where some developer thinks, oh look, if I put some houses on this site, hopefully I have glyphosate before I start, so we don't have to worry too much about the loss of biodiversity. But if there is some, I'll pay some person up the road to plant some trees or do something else. OK, now that seems to me to be a very inefficient way.
Of address. Agree, more natural capital and and I I think the system approach is what should be done and that's what we told there for a years ago when this came up under the natural capital committee. Yeah, that's right. Yes. The second thing about this bit like the landfill levy and my local Wildlife Trust, however it what this system does, it sucks people in. It's like sucking people in to build solar farms because it's money and people you grasp for whatever money is available to do the things that they want to do going forward, or they just grasp for the money for the
solar panels and give up the farming altogether. Now, that doesn't make it the best way of doing this. And that comes back to we could design public policy in a much better way to pay farmers to do this environmentally good stuff. And biodiversity is as a prototype public good. So is carbon, etcetera, right? And we could do that or we could just say, let's find a nice little way of letting developers
develop more land in Greenfield sites, etcetera, on the Greenbelt, etcetera. But some ludicrous housing target that's not going to be achieved. That's no problem with it. OK. Now, the carbon markets are different for emissions, but every carbon sequestration is different too, because the land different, the soils are differently, what the counterfactuals different vulnerability, disease, et cetera, et cetera. These are all different. And that's where, you know, the nice idea of markets gives I think good economics a bad name and encourages silly ideas about
marginal this and marginal that. That's the way we're going to address these questions. Well, that's what's gone wrong in this territory and that's why we're not actually achieving very much. Can I hear that we've got 3030 seconds or so? 30 seconds of the. Process, you start to have more system approaches to clusters of farms doing stuff, et cetera. But this is the exception to what's actually going on, and this government is not environmentally. Friendly Well, if you let me just spill over you let me spill over the 30 seconds a little bit
just to finish Finlow because I, I, I agree with everything that Dieter has just said. And our proposed antidote to that lamentable situation is to ensure that in future we developed an internationally harmonized framework for measuring the outcomes of farming systems on climate, natural capital and social capital. And we collect data on a farm level and we then monetize the impact that we measure and develop systems of rewarding
positive public goods because let's assume that the polluter pays principle is already applied. So I agree with Ditra on that one. If it isn't, but we'd like it to be. But even if it isn't, if I am paid for my positive climate, nature and people outcomes accurately on a farming system level rather than this nonsense, which biodiversity net gain thing is going on at the moment, I think we could take that to scale. And I'm in conversation with a lot of companies who are trying to do that.
And so far it hasn't worked because we haven't got a common measurement framework in place and we're needing to find the money which will reward the farmers for their positive outcomes. So give you an example. Water companies are already paying farmers not to pollute. That is a kind of carrot. And we need to look for where the carrots are in each of the sectors, whether it's soil carbon, which can be relation to sculptory emissions. If we can accurately measure soil carbon gain of a proper biologically based farming system, that can become a
revenue stream for a farmer. And I would say there could also be social credits or whatever you want to call them for farmers who educate children, who improve the nutrient density of their food, et cetera. Now if we could take that to scale, we'd start to move the balance of financial advantage towards the kind of farming system that I'm operating here. We would. I'm going to have to cut you off, Patrick. I hate to do so. And and both of you, thanks so much. It's been fascinating. I've just sat back and listened and it's been it's been brilliant. So thanks so much for your time. I'd like to thank my guests Patrick Holden and Professor Sadita Helm.
Sadly, we do have a firm cut off, but if you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast and Farmgate leaders Martins Farm and Wheat from the Chaff are available on the Farmgate channel if you just scroll back in your podcast feed, as is our long running series on natural capital and and how that works called Filling the Funding Gap. Farmgate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Mail, Pelican AG Rule Solutions, the Usk Catchment partnership of Growlo and individual donors.
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...