What's the business model for regenerative dairy? What sort of financial models are required to help deliver regeneration through the dairy value chain. This conversation is based on a panel at Land Alive at The Dairy Show at the Bath & West Showground. ffinlo Costain is joined by: Nick Hindle, First Milk's Communications Director Tamara Giltsoff, Senior Associate at the Soil Association Exchange and co-founder of Land Alive Niels Corfield, an independent farming advisor & trainer Harry Farnsworth, who works on financial innovations within the food and agriculture supply chain at Rabobank Thomas Slattery, a comms specialist working with the ADOPT Support Hub. Land Alive at The Dairy Show was curated by Tom Pycraft from Ark Events.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, welcome to Farmgate, the world's number one food security podcast. I'm Finn Locustain, the editorof8.9.com. Two weeks ago at Land Alive at the Dairy Show at the Bath and West Showground, I chaired a panel called Financing the Future of Regenerative Dairy de risking the transition now. I thought the conversation we had was fascinating. So we're going to have it again, and I hope you enjoy listening to it. We're going to ask what regenerative dairy looks like in terms of its business model and then we'll consider what sort of finance models are needed to help deliver regeneration
through the dairy value chain. I'm joined by Nick Hindall, communications Director at First Milk, Tamara Gildsoff, senior associate at the Soil Association Exchange and a Co founder of Land Alive, by Niels Caulfield, an independent farming adviser and trainer, by Harry Farnsworth, who works on financial innovations from within the Food and Agriculture supply chain for Rabobank, and by Thomas Slattery, A specialist working with the Adopt Support Hub. We're going to tackle the issue in two stages and I'm going to start with questions about the future business model for dairy
and then we're going to talk about how we might get there, how we can finance that transition. So Tamara, can you get us started? Why do we need regenerative dairy? What's the problem that needs fixing for? Me really the the issue is systemic risk. We are living in a time where there is growing and mounting evidence of climate impacts and we have seen it in the last year. We've had an incredibly dry year and poor 50% down harvest for many farmers not blanket across
the country and Europe is the fastest warming continent in the world. And the European Environment Agency says itself that Europe is not prepared for glowing growing climate risk. So really this is this is really on my mind. S&P have just come out with a recent study saying it's 90% likely that we're going to be 1.5° warmer by 2040 and 50% likely that that could be we could be on a 2.3° pathway. So we really need to be thinking
about how do we build landscape resilience? Yeah, really significant. And I've said it many times before, but farmers really are the keystone species of our economy and of our times. So Niels tomorrow talk to us there about temperature increases about the likelihood of 2° or more by 20402050. So essentially that's a kind of a weather forecast if you like. What we're what we're experiencing today is going to accelerate more of those extreme weathers in the future. Why does regenerative dairy
provide a solution to those challenges? Yeah. So essentially I think the key point here is that while we certainly are seeing significantly significant impacts from drought, for example, last year on grass production through sort of long wet winters in terms of extended housing periods. The evidence that I've sort of gathered and my colleagues essentially that work in this space through direct on farm monitoring myself, I've monitored well over 200 grazing operations right across the UK for soil health and pasture
health. And what we see is that pasture health is poor. So we're seeing sort of thin swords with very shallow roots essentially. And we're also seeing soils that, you know, essentially when they're unhealthy, they have a very sort of blocky structure essentially. And that blockiness in the in the structure basically means that the water can't get in to the soil in the winter. So it lies wet sits, wet poaches, for example. So producers feel like they have to house and that might mean an extra month or two basically, you know, average being sort of five to six months, particularly
as most dairy is in the sort of West of England, which is sort of the generally sort of wetter part of the world overall, for example, it's translating to the bottom line through extended housing periods and increased cost of production essentially. And effectively what we're saying here is that through regenerating the sort of land base by improving soil health, essentially we're addressing those root causes, we're alleviating that compaction basically. So that now means that land is free draining. So it means we can have animals out for longer periods and it
means there's also that now moisture in the soil for when it then done does turn sort of hot and dry in the summer basically. So we either sort of drought later or less severely or not at all. So when you're talking there about the, about the fact that you're able through managing the soil, through managing the sword differently to try and get increased water holding. So there's more grass growing through the year, improved water holding, so there's less flooding taking place. So the animals are indoors less, meaning that there are fewer costs associated with the
additional feed and and electricity, et cetera. What you so essentially saying I think and maybe you can comment on this is that we are experiencing impacts, quite severe impacts at times already at the moment, but we don't need to. Yeah. I mean, I think essentially that these extreme weather events, the changing weather patterns are essentially revealing an underlying weakness in the system or systemic weakness. You know, back in the day we used to have a get out of jail free card, which was known as April showers.
Small amounts of rain continually falling with perhaps in between over many weeks will essentially re wet any source. That means we can establish spring crops and it means we've got, you know, a reasonable sort of Bank of moisture in the soil when it does turn hot and dry, which it obviously didn't to the same extent then basically. But again, the main point here is that we're looking at, we shouldn't confuse the symptoms with the causes. Fundamentally, the weaknesses in poor saw health, a lack of natural capital essentially, and regenerative agriculture essentially addresses that at source. Now, Nick, lots of successful
regenerative dairy farmers are supplying retail customers with liquid milk independently, or else they're producing added value products. Now First Milk is a large dairy cooperative working with over 700 farming families. What does regenerative dairy look like for First Milk? Well, I think we paint a very optimistic picture and I also think we paint a very detailed picture optimistic because you know, when you look at our total milk pool from those farms and also people who supply us directly, but 96% of that milk pool is, is covered by regen plans and that's happened since
2021. So it's that replication that scaling has has happened really, really quickly. But it's one thing to say it covers 96%. But the really good news is actually the amount of increase in activity that's happening hectare by hectare each year and also the increase in the amount of land that has been covered by regenerative plans. So, so we measure actions or interventions that goes into a regen bonus payment and they've nearly doubled since, since, since 2022.
We've now got 92,000 hectares that are under regenerative plans. So you know, I think that's optimistic, but there are other things that point to that optimism as well. Not just the commitment across the membership, it's also the commitment from customers. We're seeing an increasing, we're seeing significant commitment for some customers and increasing interest from others and also our colleagues. It really matters to our colleagues. It's now a point of difference for people that come and join us in future. So, you know, incredibly optimistic. And then the detailed side of it is the sheer amount of data that
we are collecting and how that data can be used to benefit not just our farmers but also our customers. So in terms of the sorts of impacts that Niels was talking about there in terms of dealing with the sort of situations that Tamara referred to, do you think that your farmers are experiencing that greater resilience having put in place some of those interventions and outcomes that you were? I say yes, I mean there's a lot of data that points to improvements that are being made in soil health improvements
through the inane soil carbon in the amount of amount of carbon we're removing and and capturing underground. We're doing some work now with with Nestle Waters, which is looking at increasing water capture, groundwater capture. So it's not actually about purchasing milk from us. It's it's about a nature based solution. So we've got data, but we also get great anecdotal evidence. You know, I was out on farm last month and the, the farmer and his son that I was talking to and his, his words, not mine. We produce more milk now because we're growing more grass.
We're growing more grass in these drier periods. And they hadn't had a lot of rainfall in Shropshire over the previous couple of months. So yes, we are seeing it. And yeah, it's anecdotally it, it, it's just as important at the moment listening to what our members are saying to us. Now you mentioned there your customer Nestle and when we're talking about customers for First Milk, it's it's, it's not by and large you know the retail customer, the customer on the doorstep is it, it is more of a wholesale relationship. Have you found that there has been support from those larger
scale customers? Yeah. I mean on the business side, commercially we're business to business. So we're selling to businesses that are using milk as an ingredient or a Co packing cheese and then then selling it into into the resale sector or or wave products. So we're one or two steps removed from the retailer from from the brand or consumer. We are seeing a signal significant interest. I mean Nestle is a real, a real leader. Let's be honest there. You know, we've, we've got a 21 year relationship with, with Nestle. We've had a, a fire where we're at the end of a five year
program of regenerative plan that we've been working with them on and we're just dotting the IS and crossing the T's on, on the plan for the next 5 years. And their support is significant for a number of different reasons. It makes a great financial impact, but they're also carrying the regen message out into the consumer humour in the customer marketplace and that's to be lauded as well. And then we're seeing other businesses. We have a, we have a super partnership with, with Yo Valley with the naturally better Dairy Group. And yeah, we're seeing interest
from other UK and, and export businesses as well. But Nestle and and Yo Valley are definitely leading the way and. Nick, what do you think's been the the secret of your success? If you like, how have you been able to scale Regenerative across your farmer memberships so quickly? Yeah. I mean, forgive me, it's a little bit of a tick box answer this. But you know, you know, the reality is we're a Co-op. So we had a head start and we're a Co-op where our, our farmer members, their farm suited A regen approach, you know, doing a lot of lot of grazing platforms across that. So, so we had a very good start point.
And in a Co-op, you, you, you make that decision with your members. So that strategic decision was made hand in hand with the board, with the council, you know, and then, you know, so that was #1 #2 we went all in. You know, we, we call ourselves the regenerative Co-op. There's no hiding place there. So we weren't dabbling that that level of commitment. I think when I look at the the speed that we've been able to implement, I think that's really, really important because it comes with the top down commitment. But it wouldn't have happened unless we didn't taken the time to engage our members, talk to
our members and listen to our members in the first instance. So the cooperative business model suits building that level of coalition and commitment, customer commitment and financial commitment from ourselves. So there are payment mechanisms in there that that reward it and a lot of training and peer-to-peer learning that goes on. But it wouldn't have worked unless it worked for our members on a field by field, on a farm by farm basis. If it doesn't suit their business model, they are not going to get up in the morning
and they're not going to make those changes to their farm and their business that's required. They're not going to go to the bank and borrow more money based upon a plan that they don't believe in and they don't have a certain amount of evidence to back up. Now you mentioned within that the top down sort of board level buy in when and and the importance of that. We're going to come back to that later in the program and talk about that a bit more. But Nick, I've been doing this podcast for many years now and over the course of, you know, sort of early period talking about regenerative agriculture, we'd spend quite a lot of time
arguing about whether regen was about practices about implementing, doing particular things on farm or whether it should be focused on the outcome instead. And regenerative tends to sort of think of itself as being, you know, much more outcome focused. First, Milk's approach to regen farming tends to be practice oriented rather than outcome focused. Why is that? Well. We'll continue to argue about it, but we're very much of the view at first Milton that it, it is about outcomes. That's what we're striving to deliver. There's, there's no, there's no
doubt about that. But the reality is at the moment it's quite difficult to find metrics that you can link payments to. So we took the decision that to actually not worry about that, but to get on with it. So we identified actions together with a lot of advice coming from outside, you know, people like Farm Carbon Toolkit and other partners that have been on this journey with us that we needed to identify actions that were understandable and deliverable by our farmers that link to those outcomes. They link to a carbon removal outcome, they link to a water
outcome, they link to a nature outcome. That is the methodology and the algorithm that sits behind the payment mechanisms. I think, you know, in all these years working in the food industry, particularly in in in big businesses, it's very easy when you're making such a commitment to talk yourself out of because you don't have the evidence base there that's going to deliver the ultimate confidence. But the reality is if you let great become the enemy of good, you will not get going. You will not get started. And what I think is really impressive at first Milk and amongst the membership is that
actually that determination to get going, that determination to act. Fantastic and really interesting and, and the way that you frame that there that it's all about the outcomes, but sometimes it's very difficult to measure or sometimes incredibly expensive. Sometimes the the technology doesn't exist to be able to measure those outcomes and therefore practice becomes proxy. And also it takes time, it takes time to get credible data. You know, we, we're working with abricarbon on taking soil samples. We're doing that on 120 farms. We're doing that free measurements per hectare.
We, we need to wait four, 5-6 years before we go back and, and resample to actually have confidence in, in, in the data that we're gathering. So yes, we've got a significant database, but it's a waiting game now before we go back on farm and, and, and, and get that next set. But we believe it's really important to carry on with the engagement with the community that is serious about the future development of Regen to identify what those right metrics. You know, we hear from wild farms when they're looking at nature, they're looking at insect counts.
We're we're talking to Soil Association exchange to see what we can learn from from, from from them. We're talking to the Allerton Project to see what, what, what we can learn from them. So don't get me wrong, we have to have metrics that work and to valorize what our farmers are doing, not just in the food that they're producing, but the natural capital solutions they're delivering. That is going to be vital. Thanks so much, Nick. Now I know that you've got to go, but thanks so much for joining it. I really appreciate it. Thanks for being here. Now, Neil, obviously there's
going to be a diversity across the value chain, but if you had to describe a vision for regenerative dairy, the business model if you like, then what do you think it looks like and what are the low hanging fruit for farmers who are starting down that journey? Yes, I think that you know like you say it's, it's a mixed picture in terms of that sort of production base. I think that in in our case we'll probably be focusing more on that sort of block carving and grass based operation, although there are still gains to be had with the fully housed. I think really and ultimately
comes back to you know sort of essentially establishing healthy pastures and it being a pasture based approach in general. And we would say that actually that is the most efficient method because we're not essentially relying on external inputs basically. But in terms of the low hanging fruit, I think that actually there's good data that points to really quite low cost interventions, looking at mechanical interventions, mineral interventions to relieve compaction, you know, in the short term essentially to treat
those symptoms that have built up over the over the years. And, you know, essentially for every month of additional grazing that we achieve in the field, that equates to 6000 lbs per 100 head per year every year from this year going forward basically. And there are many examples of people delivering on at least a month in the short term. I think two months is, you know, very achievable even. It's sort of a kind of a low ambition kind of transition.
And in terms of, you know, what that looks like as a budget that effectively translates to about £150 per hectare again per grazing around this year and every year essentially. So you know, there is, you know, some real opportunities to cash flow this. And I think the important thing is that we're not talking about a new shared for example, or other, you know, very capital intensive, you know, development projects or construction projects. So and again, key point for us is that we have a short return on investment. I think that's the key point. So in terms of that business model, if farmers are wanting to
save money in a time when you know, costs are rising, things are very difficult. Then by addressing that that compaction in the soil, by getting the grass functioning better, they're keeping the cows out for longer. That's a real way of cutting costs, you know, really quite quickly. But just in terms of that business model, I just wonder if you could flesh it out a little bit more. You talked about the importance of a pasture based system, but I wonder about the degree of circularity that you would expect to see in a in a regenerative business. Yeah. I mean, I think that we're not going to be sort of abandoning
cake, you know, tomorrow. So I think that initially, you know, that that sort of reduction, you know, should be sort of measured and marked. But, you know, but there are many levers that, you know, can be pulled, but we can expect to see, you know, reductions in fertilizer usage. That's good examples of people moving down to 40 units from 250 units for example, just by changing the type of nitrogen that's applied and and how it's applied for example, so to moving to liquid and Folia applications.
So again, really drilling down into that use efficiency piece and that obviously brings its own savings. So a good example from the Republic of Ireland, they save themselves €40,000 in one year and that was sort of 200 cow dairy sort of, you know, moderate yielding operation. And then when you start to build into diversity in the pastures, for example, so shifting away from rye grass only then we build in a lot more kind of drought tolerance for example. And actually, there's good evidence to show that broad leaves, legumes and herbs, for example, actually bring better
yield as well as being sort of, you know, more medicinal and containing, you know, tan ends, for example. So controlling methane emissions, for example. Yeah, so it's a a more gradual revolution than some and you say to let the meat cake but just perhaps not quite so much of it. And, and Neil, one of the assumptions round transition, certainly when I talk to farmers around the Dorset area, is that that transition to regen will mean a reduction in yield. Is that true? I mean, I think essentially that change in yield or yield profile, if you like, it's a
choice. And some producers have chosen to go down that sort of reduce yield and swap out their cows, for example, to take a genetics choice. But others, you know, essentially by substitution, you know, can maintain a particular yield. But I think the main point here is to understand that most yield, that most high yield is achieved through quite high cost operations. Essentially that yield comes at a cost. And one of your guests recently kind of highlighted that one of their case studies went down
that route to take advantage of increased milk prices, increase their output and actually ended up in the red without even, you know, sort of a change in milk prices. And again, the main point here is that margins shrink. As yields typically using orthodox methods to deliver on that yield and shrink margins. However, if you're investing in natural capital, essentially in soils and pasture, these are the types of capital that sort of pays back each year. And so that yield, you know that we're achieving, you know has a
high profit margin associated with it. And I think that's the first port to call fundamentally whilst also building in resilience. So you're resilient then primarily to well volatility in the market. So you're very much less dependent on inputs to maintain a particular yield or maintain a number of animals, for example. But you're also less exposed to volatility in prices because the yield that yield are generating is very low cost. I think that's the important thing. It's interesting of course within dairy you have a huge sort of spread, don't you, of
those farmers who are, you know, really very, very pasture based and then other people who are essentially running a factory system at the other end. And, and within those that sort of farmer group at the, at the top end, those sort of high yielding, high producing farmers. When they've made, you know, sort of multi £1,000,000 investments there. It's going to be quite a challenge for them to get their heads around the idea of, of a, of a transition towards a more regenerative, perhaps a, a lower yielding system. And I suspect we probably ought to do a, a specific program looking at that and how farmers
within those systems trapped within that particular treadmill are able to, to take steps, steps towards regeneration. But it always strikes me that one of the biggest opportunities is in the dairy sort of where you've got dairy set stocking where farmers haven't necessarily thought that much about grass growth for for a long time. They've just accepted it as it comes. And, and if we think of that as being probably half the dairy farmers in the country, it seems to me there's quite a big opportunity there to start integrating more rotational
grazing, more of the things that you've been talking about to get more grass out of the ground and therefore potentially more milk out of the cow. Yes, absolutely. I think that's sort of essentially increasing milk from grass sort of heading, you know, really captures those points very well. And you know, essentially as you've outlined then you know, how that grass is managed very much determines sort of productivity and also the quality. And yeah, as you say, you know, if you're there's a, there's a history of set stocking on those
operations, then that will leave both the sort of pasture compromise and the soil compromise. But it also, you know, ends up with a sort of essential yield penalty of about 50% or more. You know, the the shift from set stocking to rotational grazing delivers, you know, a reliable 50% increase in grass without any additional inputs, for example. But I think the other thing that I would also highlight, and again this is very much from my own monitoring work done directly on dairy farms
particularly, is that when you actually look at the sword composition, you know, as you get down on your knees and sort of, you know, actually look up close, what we find is actually often that although you know, it may well have been reseeded with rye grass in the past, the actual proportion now of rye grass present in the sword is very low. And what we end up with is a lot of running grasses or otherwise sort of weed grasses or otherwise grasses that are very small. You know, you might also think of as sort of being bonsaied. And often I'll sort of tease these individual grass plants out from the sword and there'll be only sort of a couple of inches time for example.
So while it might all look sort of green and growing and you look like a sort of contiguous sward, the composition of it is actually very sort of low value essentially. So we've got a couple of sort of levers to pull there. We can change how the grass is managed and also we can modify the composition of the sward. And I think this is where that diversity piece can really come in. So, you know, we can look beyond just grasses in terms of addressing that sword density piece essentially. Fantastic. Now we spend quite a lot of time talking about the farm business model, about the way that
farmers, you know might change things and how customers can support from that sort of first milk perspective when they're selling, you know in that wholesale, wholesale manner. But tomorrow I wonder if we can start thinking more specifically about how we how we finance that regenerative transition. And I guess the first question there is who's responsible for the transition, who's responsible for financing it? Where should the financial risk lie within the value chain? Well, just, I'll start off by saying we're all implicated. We are all part of an economic system that has led us to the
point where we've depleted nature and evolved our climate to a point. So ultimately, we're all responsible, but yeah, I would really emphasize the entire value chain really. And it's not sort of one-size-fits-all, I would say. So there's definitely a responsibility from the financial system and we've seen some very interesting responses like Oxbury Bank's transition facility, which I know that we'll go on to talk about. But all the way through that value chain, including the
processes and the distributors and retailers very much should be taking responsibility because the risk, and I talked about risk at the beginning of this sits through that entire value chain. I think this is one of the things that we're not going into a lot on this talk, but it came up a lot land alive as the concept of nutrient density and regenerative dairy. And you could argue that there's very strong responsibility around the health of our nation as well. And I would like to see much
more policy development and responsibility from government around how do we evolve economies to be more regenerative? How do we support rural economies and farmers in particular to lead on that regeneration that can then that can then build resilience through an entire value chain? So yeah, there's not really one individual that we can point a a finger to in in in response to that question. So, so let's break that down
just a little bit, if we can tomorrow and, and look at what the value chain looks like for dairy, because, you know, these these things are quite complicated. And so, you know, for me, if I'm just trying to sort of think about it off the top of my head, you've got the farmers at the bottom there, you know, sort of largely taking what's what's demanded by those further up the value chain. You've got the processors, the distributors, but then you've got the retailers, but you've also got those sort of banks, Oregon financial institutions through investing there. Have I missed anything out? And I think that you're saying
within that, that everybody shares some responsibility and and should be contributing. Yeah. I mean, I'd add consumers to that. And you know, it's very difficult to kind of unpack this, right. We've been in a system that has heavily pushed quite industrialized dairy and we've been used to getting receiving large volumes of dairy products, but not much money ultimately. And now we've got to sort of rewire that entire system and and rethink it. So it is, for me a shift in business model.
So yeah, ultimately there's responsibility through that entire value chain. There are some major actors in that value chain like the financial system, like banks, like the large food producers and retailers that are taking responsibility. I mean Soil Association exchanges business model is designed around a part of the value chain taking financial responsibility and working with its farm businesses. But we need to see much, much more of this. And I really strongly believe we need to see industrial strategy supporting this because
ultimately we will we will arrive at more resilient landscapes, more resilient economies and economic development, new ways of producing food, distributing food and reviving economies that have that have disappeared in this very industrial food system. So, yeah, I think it's also a really exciting opportunity for all of those actors in the in the supply chain. As part of that, you mentioned banks and the importance of banks in this. So let's talk to the bank.
And Harry, we focus quite a lot on farmers, but they're just part of the story as we've just been hearing. And there's an obvious need to deliver change from the boardroom and down through retailer and processor strategies and staff teams, not least because farmer contracts can be quite restrictive. Why should processors and retailers specifically change, and how can banks support them through the transition? Thanks very much. Yeah, it's a, it's a, it's a great question, sort of why and I think it's it's embedded in a couple of different answers that
I think 1 is sort of echoing some of the stuff we've talked about on farm, which is, you know, you're doing this on farm for resilience for the long longevity of it. You might call that in the business sense more of a risk reduction, shoring up your supply chain going into the future, making sure you actually have something to turn into a product and sell to a consumer. I think it's sometimes slightly more abstract in the Northern Hemisphere, though. It's very interesting to hear tomorrow say at the beginning that Europe is the fastest warming constant. But I think sometimes the idea of climate gets a bit abstracted
and climate disruption, perhaps not if you lived in South Spain, but what we saw in in commodities like especially like cocoa and what we might see a bit more in coffee this year is very bad supply chain disruption and price volatility due to farm issue on farm issues due to climate. And that's probably only likely going to be exacerbated into the Northern Hemisphere as we continue to warm. So I think that risk or on farm we call resilience is it is a big reason or a reason that we talked to some of the supply chain about doing this. But there's also a sort of
compliance piece in that as well. And this is where you start getting into slight acronym soup. So I'm not going to start using all of the acronyms for all these different reporting standards. But let's just say there is quite a substantial amount of reporting which larger producers now have to do. We've mentioned one on this call you mentioned Nestle. So Nestle would have a lot more a lot more standards coming at them from European Union and alike, which may be smaller producers might not have to do right now processes. But I think the thing to
recognize is that Nestle, because the way these reporting standards work, need to get information from their supply chain and they need to put pressure on their on their downstream or upstream. So they will then start requiring you to be doing stuff further in in your supply chain, which you may have thought initially wasn't going to land on your plate. So there's comes this weird bit of collaboration through compliance as well. And I think there's a lot, you know, the banks can be doing. I know we're now talking more about the supply chain, but I think it's good to look at the sort of farm because that's
where the initial excitement, I think for the bank was like, oh, there's going to be this transition. But as Neil says has eloquently put before and Nick, some of the changes that actually need to happen on the farm are not that capital intensive. So suddenly the position of the bank is like, oh, OK, well, perhaps the farmers don't need us to do this transition as much as we thought or something more attractive is to work on their existing debt. But you know, we can go into that in a bit where the compensation codes, but once we start looking at that into the supply chain, OK, then there's a bit a bigger capital need for
some processing or something that needs to happen. I think that's where a bank can really support and start to look at interesting ways of financing and look at interest rate discounts for sort of quote UN quote one for a better word, ESG aligned investments in supply chain. So I think there's there's a lot we can be doing and a lot more we can be doing. Yeah, interesting. And when you're sort of talking there about reducing the risk level that that in the same way that farmers can increase their own resilience by changing their practice on farm, that it's also
about reducing risks through the supply chain so that they still have products to sell. And certainly when I've spoken to Nestle in the past on this podcast, they've talked about that, about recognizing the volatility that's within their supply chain. If their farmers don't change that, they simply won't have products to keep selling to people. And that's a real problem for them as a business. Yeah, yeah, yeah, definitely. And, you know, I think that can't be underestimated is actually just the shoring of supply. And again, with the disruption we've already seen in terms of
cocoa and coffee, as I mentioned, that can happen quickly. But I think if you even look at it through a geopolitical lens and, you know, let's face it, we still do have a massively system propped up on global trade. You start bringing in tariffs, you know, leaving all political opinions at the door, but the tariffs exist. You suddenly got a very, very different market dynamic and you suddenly have very quickly changing favourable export markets. And to look at America right now and see what the farmers are doing in terms of soy export to China, which is 0 and Brazil is picking that up.
You got a, you got a really good flavour of how quickly these things can change. But I know we're talking about dairy, but obviously that that all inter wines because some of the feed obviously comes from soy. And so I'll try not to be too globalist about it. Fantastic. Thank you. Now, Thomas, you've been very patient and I appreciate the fact that you've been sitting waiting for quite a long time. But let's start off with the adopt fund because I suspect you know some listeners will will be aware of what the adopt fund is, many won't be. You work with the adopt fund. What is it and what's it doing to support an acceleration in
regen dairy? Yeah. So very quickly the Adopt fund is a 20 million fund from Defra. It's managed by Innovate UK and it's looking to support farmer LED innovation. So projects need to be led by farmers. They're small scale, 50 to 100K grants to help farmers test and trial innovations on farm. So with that context, I think, yeah, I think it'd be really interesting to go back to some of the stuff that Nick and Neil's had talked about at the beginning of this. And I think, you know, from research that I've done
previously and from everything that they were saying around, you know, the cooperatives and looking at wild farmed and the kind of people that Neil's works with, there are lots and lots of farmers out there who are really excited to innovate. Farmers and natural problem solvers. They want to try new things, they want to do new things. But I think the point is, a lot of this stuff we're talking about, whether it's within dairy or as Harry's talking about more broadly across the farming sector, a lot of this stuff is still very innovative. It's still cutting edge.
We haven't had the time, as Nick was talking about, to see how these new systems work within different contexts and different systems. And the fact is inherently there's a lot of risk in that. And as always, a lot of the time, a lot of the risk of innovating needs to be done at a farm level. Frankly, that's just just what has to happen and it's quite risky. And so a big part, I mean, adopt essentially has got two big roles here. 1 is to try and help de risk that innovation.
So farmers who want to try some of the things that Niels has talked about, farmers who might be within a cooperative network, whether it's a wild farmed one or whether it's within the first milk one who are like we can see that there are things that are happening and there are better ways to farm that are going to be better for us and better for nature. But you know, it's a risk to do it. So the opportunity with Adopt is that there are grants there which will pay for farmers time and expenses to try these things and collaborate together to do that. So that's a big part of Adopt and then the second part of it
is working along with lots of other partners in the sector to try and help get that information out there because it's all very fragmented at the moment. As we're saying, it's quite anecdotal. So we're aiming to try and you know, pull some of that together to help encourage people to do these innovative trials. So it's not just anecdotal, it's somewhat scientifically backed and then get out there and hopefully because it's led by farmers and not by industry so much that's that will help with kind of spreading these ideas and getting people more comfortable to do them. Let's move on to the knowledge
sharing element in just a moment and how that's how you know how that can actually take place. But we're talking about the adopt fund. Obviously in terms of regenerative dairy, there are benefits to dairy farmers globally wherever they are on the planet. But the adopt fund is specifically it's an England only scheme, I'm assuming. And and in terms of that, I just wonder if you're talking about the innovation projects that you're funding there. Can you give us one or two examples of the sort of innovations that you're talking about specifically? Yeah.
So at the minute we were on round 3. So there were five rounds announced for this year. We've had rounds one and two have already closed and round 3 is currently open until the 22nd of October. We're yet to put out an announcement of what's been funded in the first two rounds. But to give you some sense of what is look to be funded, ADOPT stands for accelerating the adoption of practices and technology. But but as I said before, this is about farmer LED trials and it is a very, very broad scope of grant funding.
So within dairy, you know, we might be looking at someone coming in and looking at doing an interesting different type of rotation or trialling new and innovative feeds or as was talked about earlier and Neil's talked about it, looking at some kind of measurement technology that can be used to try and understand better how those two work. So it can be a mixture of all those. It can be very much practice based, so trying to implement and test and trial some of the things that Neil's has talked about or it could be working with the technology company to
try and better understand and maybe answer some of those questions that we talked about around regen about, you know, is it practice based or outcome space and can we use technology to try and bring those two together. It's a very broad scope as long as it's on farm and it's practical and it's going to drive profitability, sustainability or resilience for those farmers and for the for the wider agricultural sector in the UK. Fantastic. So I guess we need to move on to knowledge exchange because you can have, you know the most innovatively run, you know, exemplar of, of regenerative
dairy that exists in the country. But if nobody knows about it, then all it's doing is is is very local. So knowledge exchange becomes incredibly important. And knowledge is of course a key factor when we're talking about accelerating or constraining transition. So how can knowledge exchange help to de risk regenerative dairy? I think it's a phenomenal question. It's something that I think about a lot. And I think obviously it, it changes depending on the sectors we're in. I think something that's really fascinating about agriculture and farming is that, well, there
are a number of things, right? So 1 is that it's, it's a, it's a very unique sector, right? You have what 117,000 essentially predominantly small family businesses across the UK. It's very, very fragmented. But those fragmented businesses are all deeply passionate and lifestyle made. So we see a lot of knowledge exchange happening within farming, happening between social circles and regionally. So it's something there's there's a big part about trying to tap into that. I think, you know, there's a
huge number of existing organisations, farming organisations, small, medium and large all across the UK and that is also fragmented. So I think there's work to be done to try and work out how we don't sort of double up our efforts and we bring some of that together. And then I think, you know, the work that you're doing across this, I think is a good exemplar of how we use digital tools and those digital tools that are available to us to try and access those networks and and to get knowledge out there. So I think those are three observations and it's something
which, you know, doesn't keep me awake at night, but I think a lot about. And how we can do that better. And I think a lot of it is about trying to understand how to get efficiencies in a very fragmented sector. It's really interesting is I think I always think about peer-to-peer networking. You know, the best way of exchanging information in a really practical sort of sense is for people to talk to each other, for farmers to talk to other farmers. They trust other farmers more than anybody else. But the opportunity of technology, the opportunities we have today are to build that
peer-to-peer network exchange, knowledge exchange to to a phenomenal extent. And so you know, this, this regenerative transition, I guess, is coming at precisely the right moment. And, and therefore we can kind of have this have this transition, this knowledge exchange on steroids. And it's so different from the way it would have been a decade or two ago. Harry, how is Rabobank supporting the regenerative transition? Yeah, it's a good question. I think as with all these big organisations, there's, there's quite a lot of people trying to solve these problems.
So sometimes it's hard to keep up to date with what everyone's doing. But you know, in our, in our main farmer market in, in the Netherlands, we've certainly been doing a lot. And we're building out a European alliance with Future Fit Dairy initiative, which is now looking like going into some of the UK as well, which is brilliant. I think what's been really impactful has been looking at some of this, this bit we talked about earlier about, OK, well, if the initial capital or the sort of CapEx versus OpEx model of this transition is, is a bit
lower at the beginning, what can we do to help these farmers transition? And I think one of the big stumbling, well not stumbling box, but one of the barriers that some farms have is they already have an outstanding debt with some some lender somewhere, which may feel like a prohibitive barrier to them to actually going on this journey. So we've been looking at ways of of restructuring or, or looking at existing debt and we had a very successful. Well, it's not a pilot actually because it's more of a mainstream project with McCain where we actually, yes, initially it was a list of practices that McCain wanted to
see happen on these farms. And I know we're talking about potatoes here, but the principle still underlies. But we knew there would be certain outcomes that come from that. And we were looking at actually giving a discount on the existing debt these farmers had with us instead of burdening the more over leveraging farms with with more. But I think, you know, if I think about some of the other successful stuff we looked at in dairy, I think what you know, especially something we did in Ireland, it was about changing the sort of financial cycle to reflect more the farm cycle. So actually let's look at the
milk cycle of a cow and let's try and match more of the repayments or the interest rate periods based on when milk price might drop or when it might go up or when those cows might be dry. So that the farm just feels like their financing packet more reflective of the model they have to deal with day-to-day. I think there's still a lot we can do that the the understanding of the risk or the risk models under some lending is still not fully there. We know we need several years of financial data to change some of
that. And I think there's a lot of the initial transformation or, or poster examples in in this field happened and some recorded that in some of the big books. But you know, a book is not something a bank can really base the financial model on. All the rest was all sort of word of mouth. Oh, I saved, you know, X amount of hectare by doing this or, you know, some of the figures that Nils was talking about earlier. Fantastic. But we kind of need it more in in hard copy rather than people talking about it at the farm gate. But that is coming. So I think once to really
understand what these new types of models yield in terms of financial performance, I think we can really start cranking it up a bit more. It's really interesting hearing about the way that those data sets sort of help you with the design of of any sort of financial mechanisms that can be used by the banks. But I wonder if you're able to reflect on some of the key differences between the kind of lending that Rabobank is used to and the kind of lending into the new system that we're talking about. So the difference between lending in the mainstream and
into the regenerative agriculture spaces? It's a good question because I think to just in, I don't want to use the wrong and the wrong way. I don't want to say traditional, but it's the system that we had before. It was quite clear in terms of a farming system, you might be looking at 3 or 4 different outputs in terms of crops that you'd sell to the, to the market. And you know, we very much understood the inputs and the outputs of what would you need to grow a potato for McCain, as I was saying earlier. But now we're looking at sort of these mixed systems or even like
something like introducing trees into, into farmland. It needs a different financing model, especially if you're starting to bake. And I know it's still a bit sort of cutting edge and everyone wants this sort of payment for environment services to come. But if you start baking in some of that benefit as well, so you're not just looking at the financial benefit, but also the environmental benefit in in some of this financing, yeah, then that's a different model completely because that may take 5789 plus years to actually return the outcome that you're you're looking to, to offset
some of that financing with. And I think something Nick mentioned earlier about his soil samples they were doing with agricarbon, they're only going to go back after five years. So you're looking at a model that needs to bridge or you know, a lot of things we talk about now is like sort of a bridge financing or, or, or what's some people call the Death Valley. And some of these regentive transitions, which have baked in more of the environmental side of it is like, how do you actually do that? Because traditional financing might look for annual returns and you end up, funnily enough, echoing something that looks
more familiar to a mortgage. It's a longer term horizon on the farm then sort of you know, three to five year tenure on on a loan. So it's just understanding these new practices, what you're going to expect in terms of outcomes and how that changed the operation of the farm as well and and what the farmer will be doing. And just finally, Harry, you sort of you know, we would associate you, you were talking about mortgages there and and the way in which an awful lot of investment coming out of the bank through the farmers likely to go into sort of capital investments, you know, very often.
But you also mentioned trees and it just made me sort of think about the way in which, you know, a bank would recognise the function of a barn. It would, it would see that a barn was something that lots of other farmers had built and it would understand the depreciation of that barn and how a loan, you know, would work with it. But if we think of trees and farmers using trees, growing trees as a living barn, then essentially that becomes capital infrastructure in and of itself. Do you think there's ever a time when in the future, Rabobank might consider trees and living
barns in the same way and understand them in the same way that they would a barn of steel and concrete? Yeah, that's a that's a that's an interesting question. You know, I would always be the optimist. Let's glass half full. I hope so. But you know, sometimes the biggest task in some of these transitions is the internal conversation. So it's just bringing a lot of people along on that journey. And I think we could do a better job with getting more people out on the farms again and seeing them, you know, seeing as believing. I think it's very different when
you get a, someone sends you a wack e-mail saying we now, you know, we now class trees is the same as barns. People are like, well, how does that work? But if we can get people, get people out there. But yeah, you know, hopefully I think it's a dynamic space and, and financing has to catch up with where, where people want their food to be produced in the future. And, and we will do. But obviously there's, there's a risk tolerance which has to be met because there's a fiduciary. You know, we have to be sensitive to to that. And, you know, we know we'll know what's happened in the past when people haven't been at the appropriate level of risk.
So that has to be a careful transition for us as well. Tamara, the Soil Association Exchange has been working with Oxbury Bank and you mentioned them earlier on. Could you just tell us a little bit about the Oxbury transition facility? So we LED a piece of research almost exactly a year ago, we published it to this month and the research that we LED at Exchange was with farmers on farm exploring what the financial barriers to transition work for farm businesses. And we the work was actually
funded by the British Business Bank, one of our development finance banks that should be playing a really significant role in this. And the research lifted the lid on this inside that's been talked about quite, quite a bit, which is that there is a financial risk transitioning a business model or shifting a business model. And that would be the same, that would be the same in any sector. Shifting an entire business model over any period of time does come with risks as well as economic upsides.
In the research we called for a number of things. One of them we called it nature Transition facility that would provide flexible funding. Harry's talked about reducing the burden of existing debts. One idea of that, we also talked about flexible products almost acting as a sort of overdraft facility where a farmer over a six year period wouldn't get penalized if they weren't able to repay for a number of years as example. We also talked about the need for innovation funding. So the adopt funds really sits
within that context. And then we can convene all of the major banks at the round table in December of last year. And we have one AG challenger bank in this country called Oxbury Bank. And the good news with an AG challenger bank is that they have the flexibility to innovate their model quickly. And in February of this year, they launched the Oxbury Transition Facility, which was a bit of a surprise to us, but a fantastic outcome of the insights of this research. And really the insights are farmers voices and Oxbury really responded to that.
So they launched the Oxbury Transition facility. It's a flexible financing facility, but very, very low interest rates, 1% above base rate and .5% fees. And it's been really successful. And actually what they require Oxbury requires to qualify for this other than alongside obviously existing checks, is that you need to provide evidence that you're transitioning on farm and that can come in multiple different forms. So for instance, evidence that you'd applied for Sfis evidence
if you're already a Soil Association exchange farmer, Oxbury have just partnered with Lens and the work that's going on there. And actually I just caught up with Carolyn Sampson who was behind the product and really sort of took our insights and ran with it. And she was saying that actually a lot of they're partnering a lot more with the value chain now. So they're working a lot more with processes to offer this product to their farmers. Ultimately, and what can I say 200, they've got about approximately 200 approved loans
so far amounting to about 30 million, which is pretty significant. I think it's their fastest ever product from launch, which is super interesting. And just in terms of what it's being used for, a combination of different things, many of which we've talked at today. So cattle being bought by the facility, changes in rotations, capital grant, bridge finance, which is really significant. So a lot of grant funding requires you to match, so
farmers are using it for that and then going beyond the SFI. So again, the need for flexible finance to experiment and trial and push things beyond what there were, what farmers may already be receiving funding for. So yeah, it was a really fantastic outcome. We need to see many, many more of these. Barclays have launched their equivalent facility recently. We are still very keen to work with the development finance banks in this country to de risk that finance even further, to work with higher risk, smaller scale farms that protect
potentially holding a lot of debts already. So there's a lot more work to do. That's fascinating. Thanks so much for that. Thomas. One final area that we haven't really touched on yet is the retail customer, the person who eats the cheese, pours the milk onto their Weetabix. How should we be communicating regenerative dairy to the general public so that they want to and are able to actively support regen farming principles and practice? Yeah, another great question. I mean, it skews quite a bit of way from what we've talked about previously, but I think it's a
really important part of it. So again, something I thought a lot about and I think we get the messaging wrong with the consumer. And I don't think this is just in regenerative or in dairy. I think this is in sustainability more generally. I think we we often try and sort of become quite worthy and you know, we rely on the fact that we see statistics like 80% or 90% of people and particularly within kind of younger generations want to pay, will pay more for sustainable products. But the reality is that doesn't net out and actually what you
find is if you try and talk to people about their own health and things like that and taste that, you actually have a lot more success. So for me, I don't think there's any silver bullet to this, but I think from a kind of markoms and consumer marketing perspective, I think we should be thinking a lot more about how we talk to consumers about things that they really care about, which is good food, delicious food, good chefs, restaurants, cooking, the kind of things which are very popular. And also family health, human health, you know, even animal health and environment health,
health to some extent. These are things that resonate and people care about. And thankfully they're all things that regenerative agriculture is able to be an answer for. And, and I think an important addition to that and something which is really emerging recently and Tamara mentioned earlier is this nutritional element. So, you know, the technology hasn't necessarily been there either to understand very well, like are we actually increasing nutritional health of or the sort of nutritional content of food producing through regenerative agriculture and other agricological systems?
I think, you know, we're starting to see some studies that are demonstrating that, but can we actually test it on a day-to-day? There are a number of companies now that are sort of demonstrating that we could do that at a sort of a cost effective rate. And I think that is going to be a big part of what drives consumer change. But again, it's about reframing it, making it less worthy, and talking to people about the things that actually matters to them and their families. Fantastic Neil's just as a final wrap up from you. There are going to be lots of farmers listening for you. What's the key message in 30 seconds? The paramount reason for a farmer to actively deliver
transition in their business. Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think the key point is going to deliver on the bottom line. You're going to significantly reduce nitrogen inputs, shorten housing periods, essentially all of that translating to significant reducing cost of production, whilst at the same time we're also going to be growing more grass and producing more milk from grass. So it truly is a win win. Brilliant. Well, look, that's all we've got time for. I'd like to thank my guests, Thomas Slashery, Harry Farnsworth, Neil's Caulfield, Tamara Giltsoff and Nick Hindle, possibly the largest panel that we've had on Farm Gate.
So thank you all very much for being here. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farm Gate is now the world's highest ranking food security podcast, and Farm Gate leaders, Martin's Farm and Wheat from the Chaff are all available on the Farm Gate channel if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. Farm Gate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican AG, Rural Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Agrolo and individual donors. I've been thin locustain.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...