Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Farm Gate

Farm Gate artwork

In-the-field at Groundswell: Wildlife Trusts' vision for farming

Jul 12, 202519 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This programme is part of our series of impromptu in-the-field podcasts, recorded at Groundswell 2025. In this episode we The Wildlife Trusts' new vision for the future of farming in England. ffinlo Costain is joined by Vicki Hird (Strategic lead on agriculture, The Wildlife Trusts).

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello there. I'm Phil Acostein, Chief editorof8.9.com, and I'm joined by Vicky Hurd, who is the strategic lead on agriculture at the Wildlife Trusts that have just brought out their vision for the future of farming in England. Lots of people have visions. How is yours different? Well, I think we've gone quite early actually because the government's developing it's 25 year road map. So that's one thing. It's earlier than that and we want to influence that and we want to use it as a talking point.

So talk about. But I think it's different because it covers the whole food chain as well as farming. You might think the Wildlife Trust would just do farm policy, Agri environment schemes, that kind of thing. We've covered diets, we've covered the food system, fairness, training, all sorts of areas which are actually influencing what farmers do but often get neglected, you know, if we just focus on farms, payments and things like that. Talk me through one or two of the goals that you have for the the vision and then you there's a sort of second section that you call transformations. Tell me what you mean by that.

Well, the, the, I think the most important goal is that all farming is either a, in a transition or is actually a regenerative or organic or agroecological. They're actually doing things on a whole farm basis, which is good for their bottom line, but also for nature and climate resilience and storing carbon, storing water, doing all the things that each farm is going to be different. But if they've got a plan which is truly regenerative and sustainable, that's what we need everywhere.

So that's a big goal because a awful lot of farms aren't doing that. A lot of farmers want to do that and some farmers are doing that. So it's it's a big goal. And I think the other goal should be to tackle things like trade and supply chains. I would say that because I've worked on that for a long time. And I think that influences in the wrong direction a lot of what farmers do. And so it really needs acknowledging that that's a problem and doing something about it through regulation and some, you know, pioneer parts of the food chain, you know, some companies doing things right. But it really needs the

government to get get things going. And in terms of those transformations, what is it that you mean by transformation? Are these means by which these goals are achieved? Yeah, that's what we mean. We've got goals and transformations means, you know, what changes will need to happen to policy and to what the industry does, what farmers do and, and making sure that they're comprehensive enough and coherent and strategic. They're actually going to make the bigger differences because we've had a lot of tweaking, let's face it, over many, many years. And I've been working on foreign

policy for 35 years and I've seen a lot of good stuff and a lot of good voluntary stuff. And then as soon as the market changes or a director changes, the voluntary stuff disappears. So we need it underpinned by really strong transformational regulation of of the farming and the food system and. One of my criticisms of policy in the way that it links to agriculture and the way that finance comes into agriculture, I suppose from the government, from the public funds, is that government has been driving farm policy for 7080 years and now

it's being driven in a very different direction, but there's a lot less money available. One of your key transformations is about aligning public and private finance. How do we best do that? That's a really good question and we have done a really good study saying what the scale of need is and it is more than we've got as you say the the last budget it didn't get cut massively, but we knew it already wasn't enough, particularly because of inflation over the last couple of years, you know it's been maintained, but that means it's cut. So we need more money. But they key thing is to match that with the right kind of direction for industry.

And, and I mean those that want to invest in carbon capture on farms and that kind of all soil, it can be agile forestry and forestry where possible, but it's underpinned by strong codes of practice which are legally binding. So that it's clear for the farmer who owns the carbon, you know who you know, who owns the biodiversity that they have created and where the funding is coming from. But you know, we won't, we won't be able to do it all without private finance. And there are some great companies out there who want to support the transition, not

least because they know their future depends on having a climate resilient farming. You know, we won't get the food from the system or, or indeed the fibre or the fuel unless it's climate resilient and then making it nature friendly is a key way of doing that. Trying to find, trying to get the architecture right in terms of getting that private finance in place is really quite difficult. And, and I think that the, that the UK really, or you know, England is, is quite a long way ahead of many other places in the world in terms of sort of, you know, there are lots of new

markets. There are lots of sort of mechanisms to try and get money in for natural capital. And obviously, you know, we've done a long series, you know, looking at natural capital income sources, but they're still new and they still need scaling and they need that to be scaled rapidly. Do you see any sense from government that that might actually be going to happen? Well, they've been talking about it as, as you know for a long time and the blended finance initiative, but that was an awful lot of talk, not much out there yet. But they have got a new consultation on private markets for, for Nature, which is obviously we'll be responding to

the, the World Love Trust and making the points that it needs to be really underpinned by strong regulation transparency. And I think the, the key will be to make sure business, you know, the, the transparency is a really key part of it. And so that needs to be a, a element of the policy that businesses know they'll have to adhere to where the money's going as well as what's happening as a result of that money, what changes are being witnessed. And if they're not there, you know, if you're not protecting

the water resource or the biodiversity or the hedgerows, whatever, then why not? And, you know, if penalties need, penalties need to be brought into the equation, they should be, if, if the money isn't delivering what it should be delivering, then, you know, we've got to ask why. And gosh, this is very big, big problem I, I think with relying on private money. So we've got to get it right. Well underpinned by regulation. One of the other things that the vision sort of emphasises is the need for knowledge exchange for

for a decent sort of advice service. How important do you think that is in terms of delivering this transition that we know is needed? Yeah. Well, I've been working, I've been saying this for many years in whatever organization I I've been at. And I think one of the key things we said when Brexit happened and we were going to, you know, be directing our own farm policy, that we need farmer LED research and farmer LED demonstration because farmers listen to other farmers much better than anybody else. And so ideally you'd be having a lot more of that. And it will be funded by by go on.

I think, you know, the fact that government effectively started the whole farm cluster initiative is really positive and that's farmers talking to each other about how to deliver outcomes. And it's gone way beyond the original, you know, aims of a particular bird or things like that. Now I've, I hear about clusters everywhere and they're delivering on, you know, joint work on markets, joint work on biodiversity, joint work on water retention and so all that all that's a really good outcome. But we do definitely in England need a free advisory service, which we don't have.

They do in wells in Scotland and it, you know, it's clearly a huge transition for a lot of farmers. So they need this, the kind of support that they can understand and respond to as opposed to possibly agency staff coming and dictating to them on the farm. Now, you also mentioned supply chains and of course, so far we've been talking about government and what government should do. We've been talking about farmers and what farmers should do. What's the role of the supply chain in terms of directing this change, supporting the change, creating that knowledge

exchange, I suppose, to an extent, and also in, of course, the funding? I think the supply chain has a huge role to play, but I do think some of these things happen are going to hurt the supply chain that they need to because it's so extractive. You farmers get so little of the food pound. You know, it's less than 10% of the gross value added of the food Agri food system. And that that can't continue because farmers need to be able to have the money to do what they need to do to become resilient and protect the natural ecosystems that they rely on. So it's going to some of it's going to have to take a hit. But then there are, as I said,

and and you know, there are businesses out there that do get this and there's some really interesting ones that I've been listening to the landscape lens initiative of, of some of the industry players and manufacturers recognizing that there is a a real problem. But at the end of the day, we've really also got to change what they sell to eaters. And that means really turning away from the a huge amount of ultra processed foods that's really reliant on very cheap raw materials because those cheap raw materials are bad for nature, they're bad for farmers, bad for climate.

So, and that's going to be a bit of hurt. And so it's going to have to take government, government action. And you know, they're starting to tentatively dip the tone the water, aren't they? But it's going to have to go faster, as we know the crisis isn't far away. Just before we finish, I want to talk a little bit about government policy and where we're at with that at the moment. And and of course you started this, the first sort of part of this vision is that all farming land in England should be operating under agroecological and regenerative principles, as you said at the beginning. Now that's quite a big change

because it feels to me that a lot of the direction of travel at the moment, and this is, you know, this feels like it's a conversation that had almost been put to bed a decade ago, but it seems to have reared its ugly head again, the idea of lamb sparing versus lamb sharing. This is clearly a Lamb sharing approach. It is, but there might be some quite, you know, not intensive because I don't know it's the right word, but highly productive systems within that model that are still agroecological. Some of the most productive land

is permaculture in terms of, you know, volume and, and calories and nutrients from a hectare you can get in a permaculture is huge, but it's not what the food industry relies on, you know, because it's not uniform form. It's very diverse. It, it's, it's not predictable always. So we've got to start to change what we want from the food system to make that land sparing, land sharing approach versus land sparing approach work. But then as you know, all farmers different. And there will be, I think, you know, ultimately in 25 years, all farmers should have that plan that I spoke about, that's

about working with nature, protecting the natural systems. And, and that won't happen. They won't be able to do that if they continue with a really intensive monoculture system, 3 crop rotation. And I don't think they'll be able to because climate change won't, it just won't work because we've got to be saving more, more water in the soil, more carbon in the soil. They know that it works for them as well, you know, So ultimately I think the sharing will come out of all the changes and then the challenges we've got. And you talked there about the way in which agroecological

systems can be highly productive. And so it shouldn't be a choice between having lots of fossil fuel reliant agriculture in this place and nature in another place. Actually we need to accept that the most important habitat is the centre of a field is the soil. It's not just the margins at the side. And and it's all about sort of seeing well, how efficient and how productive can we be within those agroecological systems. And then it's, I presume about sort of the gradations between areas that are more prioritised

for food, areas that are more prioritised for nature, but they're both delivering both. I think that that spectrum, what you've described is exactly what we need. But unfortunately, when you talk about government policies and land use framework, it's it's, it becomes percentages, isn't it? And everybody gets terrified. But I think it is a spectrum. And I think farmers will discover and are discovering just how much they can achieve doing this differently. Like we did a piece of work farming up the sweet spot, showing how you can make just as much money up to 45% more by reducing your input costs and

doing things differently and possibly having fewer animals, but having lower veterinary costs, all these things. And it showed that you can make just a good business like that. But I think it's going to be a, a, a tough one, but we also need to change diets to make this work and have more diversity in our diets to make it work so farmers can produce legumes that we eat, you know, and as well as other things. And there's a whole thing load of things that need to change. Of course, when we're talking about livestock, it's quite

straightforward in many ways to go regenerative. It's possible to go regenerative within cereals, much more of a challenge when it comes to vegetables and root vegetables in particular. Yes. And I today at Groundswell was talking about lowland peat where 35% of our vegetables come from. And yet that's a real problem because that's a massive carbon store, which is actually responsible for 29% of agricultural agriculture greenhouse gas emissions just on 2% of the land. So that's got to change. But as we found in our workshop today, farmers are beginning to trial ways of rewetting the

peatland soil and still producing from it. They're getting berries, they're getting some lettuces and all sorts of things. But it's, it's a period of trial and, and error at the moment, which needs supporting by government and I'm possibly industry as well, because they're going to rely on those. We need to be eating more fruit and veg as well. But it is, as you say, it's a really tricky one. But the best kind of fruit and veg production is is a more diverse one where you're using more of the solar energy to to produce berries and roots, crops and all sorts in the same area. And you can do that.

That's what permaculture does. But scaling out means changing what we eat and getting the supermarkets to do that. Vicky, I mean, it would possibly be unfair to say that you're close to government, but you certainly work closely with government and, and you know the, you know, the, the environment secretary well, you know the team well, how would you score them at the moment? How are they doing? I think they're constrained that we want to score, very constrained. I was very pleased that they managed not to get big cuts from the Treasury.

And I think they acknowledged that, you know, our big lobby with the farming lobby, you know, helped with that. And it's good that they listened, good that the Treasury listened, but they, they need to take, I think a, a, a next step with saying what they are going to be doing. So the 25 year road map, the new iteration of the sustainable farming incentive will need to really demonstrate a recognition that climate resilience in farming comes from nature friendly farming. And they're going to support that and support the transition. Ideally give us give money for

an advisory service as we're discussing, because this is a huge shift for most farmers. So Groundswell is a wonderful demonstration, but it's only 8000, you know, we need all 120,000 farmers to have access the kind of support they need. So you know, the foreign ministers and the Secretary of State, I think they get it, having spoken to them, they get it. They and they understand the importance of biodiversity and ecosystems. But ideally they'd ideally they'd be the heart of government and had all the power they need, you know, and we also

know that they need to have other departments working with them like Department of Health, DCLG, desness, you know, the energy stuff that's going on, you know, it's potential for real loss of land to energy projects when we should be doing both the multifunctionality. There has been a sense, I think it's fair to say that there isn't much of A vision from government at the moment. And of course your vision has come out and, and perhaps that will be, you know, relatively successful in terms of framing the way that the the government starts to think about these things. A lot of what we've heard from the Defra team has been quite

negative. You know, farmers have either felt that it's very negative, they've reacted to, you know, things like inheritance tax and so on. And it's created quite a, quite a challenge for the government to get over. Do you think that the Defra team just needs to get rather better at sugaring the pill? Well, that's tricky when they're so constrained by not having enough a budget. And that's, you know, some of the, the inheritance tax I, you know, that was a big problem and possibly a mistake, you know, the way they did it, but.

Just just to give you an example, I mean, when Dan Zeishner was, was talking to a, you know, Select Committee about the way that Elms ended and, you know, that sort of sudden abrupt closing of the, the scheme, you know, he was very much, you know, the way that he put it across was very much well, you know, that's just the way it is. We ran out of money and and there was a degree to which there needs to be a slightly more friendly narrative at this stage in order to be able to bring farmers back on side because they have to an extent created rods for their own packs and and they need to get better at at sort of bringing farmers back on side.

Yeah, there's a there's a balance to be struck though, because if they were sugar coating it saying we want you with us and you know, we, we really are going to make things better when they don't have the money, it's really impossible because there's lots of money that's already allocated. There's lots of contracts that are several years they make. So they are really constrained and and they can blame the last government for not putting chicks and and limits and prioritisations in the SFI. It really was a mistake which we pointed out many, many times. So I don't know, I think Daniel

and Steve Reed, the the Secretary of State are aware of what the farming community needs, but they can't promise too much without having the resources to do it. But I hope they'll come out very soon with the new design of the SFI. It won't come out until next year, but the new design I hope will be acceptable. But they can't go for the universal scheme idea, you know, trying to get as many farmers on board because there just isn't the money there. And to deliver on the targets we've got for climate, nature, it's not going to work. So that I think they've got to be realistic and honest.

Farmers should accept that. Just finally, because I can see that this, this tent is, is going to be used for something else. In a couple of minutes, your vision has come out. The Wildlife Trusts is a big organization. You know, it's very well respected and, and very popular, you know, with its, with its members across the UK. Do you think the government's going to take up your vision and and listen to it? I think they'd be grateful as not to. I think it's a good vision. It draws on work for many years and from 47 organisations across the country working on the

ground. That's the wonderful thing about the World, Love, Trust, it's a federation and they're really locally grounded with local communities, local cultures. And you know, we've built up these ideas from from there and from the research base that government really would make sense to listen to. Fantastic. Vicky Hurd, thanks so much. I've been Finn like a stain. Bye for now.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 'Soil health is the north star of agriculture' - David R Montgomery on ReGen

    Nov 17, 202658 minAudio

    This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Place-based preparedness in practice

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Food industry insiders speak out

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Living adventurously" in the UK House of Lords

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is food sovereignty needed to face climate extremes?

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...

    Credit the people on this episode