What's happening on Papley Grove Farm this November? ffinlo Costain talks to Martin Lines from the Nature Friendly Farming Network - and meets Ifan Davies, who farms with his daughter at Carreg-y-Bîg in Wales, to talk about the pressures of social media and the Welsh Sustainable Farming Incentive. More land use news at 8point9.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello and welcome to Martin's Farm on the Farm Gate podcast channel. I'm Finn Locustein, the editorof8.9.com. And I'm Martin Lyons, the chief executive of the Nature Friendly Farming Network. And in this series we're finding out about what's happening month by month on Martin's farm, which is Papley Grove Farm in St. Neots in Cambridgeshire, as well as meeting key staff and farmers from within the Nature Friendly Farming Network. Today we're going to find out what November looks like on the farm and now that the UK party conference season has finished, we're going to get Martin's thoughts on the party positions.
We're also joined by Ivan Davis, who farms with his daughter at Carrigerbigg and is the sustainable farming officer for the Nature Friendly Farming Network. Hi Ivan, Have I said the name of your farm correctly there? You have. I was just thinking how impressed I was with it. Thank you very much. Now, I mentioned that you farm with your daughter and that's something, you know, that's talked about on various different websites. Your daughter to Rhiannon. Tell me a bit about that relationship, because speaking as a father, I confess it's not always easy to get kids out working when it's wet and cold. No, but she has always been very
willing. I must say the whole family are always willing to help out when necessary. But Rhiannon would be by my side since she was very young and by my father's side before we actually moved here, she used to spend a lot of time with her grandfather out on the farm. She has stepped back slightly this year to concentrate more on her GCSE, but luckily her eldest sister is back from New Zealand so the the labour is still there, going on well at home. Fantastic. And, and I'm aware that she does quite a bit on social media or has done which of the channels
that you've found or that she's found work best? Well, she had a very successful but brief stint with TikTok. It was the the right gap for her age group to post on, but she got quite a lot of unwanted attention when she got popular videos and she had to remove herself from that Channel. But I think her first video up on TikTok came to 15,000 views. Right, Really, that's quite remarkable, isn't it? And as you say, it's such a shame, isn't it, when all you're
trying to do is sort of explain the things that you're doing and then you, as you say, you get that unwarranted attention. And and these days being able to communicate through social media has become so important, particularly for farmers that are sort of selling outside of those more traditional kind of contract based supply chains, trying to do more stuff at an independent level. Yes, definitely, definitely. And she was having such good feedback from people as well. It was really fantastic. It was very gentle and just explaining a bit about day-to-day life.
There was nothing too pushy. You know, she wasn't didn't have an agenda to sell. She was just merely trying to explain what was going on. It was just the unwanted attention became too much hard work really to keep on top of. Yeah, it's really difficult. And it's very difficult as well to sort of separate yourself, I suppose from, you know, being that individual person who is getting the abuse or that sort of unwanted attention targeted at you. And then to kind of understand yourself as a almost as a product really within social media and and to use social media in order to get messages across.
But then be I guess strong enough to be able to differentiate that stuff that you really don't want that is unwarranted and just put it to one side. And that that must be an incredibly difficult balancing act for everybody, but particularly for young women involved in social media and farming. Yeah, I mean, she was only 13 when she tried to post on TikTok and then had to remove herself. So it was quite difficult. It's quite difficult for most teenage girls anyway without and the the extra hassles of life. So yeah, it was it was difficult, but it just got to a stage where we were spending an
hour every night going through removing people and it it became the enjoyment was taken away from it. So we just stopped doing. It I'm really sorry to hear that and it and it wasn't something that I knew before we were having this conversation as well. So I might have hesitated to bring it up. But I think actually it's really important to talk about these things and to, you know, just flag up the the difficulties around social media for farmers. And just, I mean, obviously that that's, you know, sort of a fascinating sort of area, you know, thinking in terms of the way that you found not just with your family, but it was quite particularly with your daughter
there. But we'll be coming back to you a bit later in the program to find out more about your life there on Carrigebig and to dip into Welsh farming policy more broadly. But now, as usual, let's start instantly. It's with Martin and Martin, it's about to be November. What does that mean? What are you doing in November? What's happening on the farm and what are other people doing around you? Yeah. So, yeah, heading into November for us, we've had a really dry autumn. We haven't done finished all our drilling this week is is what we're currently recording. This is showing some light.
We hoped next week, the week after beginning of November getting to finish planting the rest of our crops that we've waited for the moisture to come to germinate the weeds. We've been really trying to key into sort of where possible delay that planting to encourage the weeds to to germinate them to grow so we can kill them before we plant our crops. The crops that we have planted, we'll be looking out for what weeds may be coming up. And as a non organic farmer, we, we look to use some herbicides to manage some of those weed problems, particularly the ones that can take most of the yield
from us later on in the year as those crops go forward. And then once all the plantings or soap planting of our crops have done, it's a case of get the pressure washer out, get your waterproofs on and get everything cleaned down ready, greased, put in the sheds and then start the maintenance programme of fixing anything that's gone wrong over this summer period. But also getting wrapped up for winter lagging water pipes, checking antifreeze and tractors and machinery sort of do it before the Foss comes so we can be pre ready. But there's nothing worse than
on a Saturday night suddenly a -, 4 gets forecast and you're running around trying to wrap up that water pipe or checking their tractors got an antifreeze top up, been placed in it. And then we sort of kind of wind down as the days get shorter as an arable farmer, our days can get shorter and we sort of get into that maintenance and and prep for prep for winter really and, and, but get ready for the new year. And then when we look at my neighbors. Just just before you, just just before you go into your neighbors margin. I'm just sort of wondering about
that, that kind of winter period. As you say, you know, the clocks are about to change. The days are going to be, you know, a lot shorter. I sort of feel a lot shorter. Is there a kind of a sense of hibernation where you know, the the work that you're doing where you're spending a bit less time working than you would be in those long days in the summertime? Or are you simply taking advantage of the daylight when it's there? But then moving into sheds and and doing a lot of maintenance and and other things during the the darker times. There is very much of feels like hibernation because the days get shorter.
We don't, we're not doing overtime, not doing having to do long days. We've got no livestock that we own on the farm. We've got other people's. They can look after those. But yeah, that kind of gets in some jobs in that we can do in a shed that early morning and late afternoon where it's getting, where it's the nights, you know, the days and the nights are drawing in. And also we get the heater on if it's gold. But it also tends to mean we end up doing a lot more the paperwork, the planning, the budgets, the filling in forms and sort of those grotty wet days. We haven't got to be outside. So it's retreat to the office
and try and get caught up with the paperwork. It's a remarkable job really, isn't it? Farming. I think a lot of people just don't quite get that sense of, of how multifaceted the job is and that, you know, I mean, for a lot of people, they say they were Jack of all trades and a master of number. But frankly, you've got to be quite a master of a lot of different trades, haven't you, in the farming industry? The role of the farmer has expanded so much managing the soil. We're thinking about the crops, planting the husbandry of those crops, how healthy they are, what varieties to to grow, what market they need to go.
And then how do we sell our grain? Do we sell it today? Do we set market for the future? Do we sell next year's grain before we even plant it? So we're having to do budgets on cash flow, but also in market demands. So I'm looking at what the the weather impacts in the markets are globally happening to forecast cash flow and what we can sell. Then also what we buy. We're buying some fertilizers and some other inputs. Do I buy today, Do I buy next week, next year? The fertilizer we brought back in September has already gone up 40 lbs a tonne.
So I've done a good sale there because the market's gone up. But there's always the risk. And this is the thing, we're farming prices that go up and down. And if they've gone down 40 lbs, I'd have spent a lot of money on something I could have saved on. And this is that risk balance we are having to juggle now of of weather impacts, market impacts, government support payments or outcome payments. It is becoming a real juggle of need to be a multi skilled technical business operator to think about to juggle all these things together where the demand of the day job of literally
getting on with the job needs to come first many days. And, and as you sort of run through some of those things that you're doing, I've kind of written down that you're a futures trader, a farmer, sort of, you know, in soil experts that you've a mechanic and accountant and of course you're doing the marketing as well. So the, you know, loads of different areas there and, and you know, not to mention biodiversity and understanding water movement and you know, all those other kinds of things. But I was talking earlier on there with if Anne about Rihanna and, and, and obviously she was 13 when she was on social media trying to promote what she was
doing. But Martin, as you know, the chief executive of Nature Friendly Farming Network, you are obviously out there quite a lot on social media as well. You're out there being quoted in the media, in the press. And I just wonder, I mean, you're not 13 and you're definitely over 30. I wouldn't like to sort of, it'd be more specific than that. Although I think you have just had a birthday, so happy birthday. And so I'm just wondering how you juggled that and whether you've had a similar experience, obviously as an older person where you're getting lots of Flack from people that you feel
duty bound to respond to as well. Yeah, I mean, do I use social media in different levels? And I'm also conscious that I'm dyslexic, so my typing and response comes across differently and misspelt sometimes or comes across not in the way I meant it to say it, but so I used to use Twitter X quite a bit. That platform for me is not a nice space to be. So we've come off that one. I use other platforms, but quite often I get direct messages from farmers, from other people. I'm I'm out and about a lot. Some of it's quite quite
bluntly, quite nasty, quite aggressive, and I'm someone who wants to have a conversation to people. If someone thinks of my position on my thinking is wrong, I'll let I'll demonstrate through social media. This is why I reference this paper, this action, but also let's me let's talk. My farm's always open. I'm welcome people here I go go out and about a lot because it's the best way we can talk about these different positions is through dialogue. I find social media, it's given me a lot of heartache and headache. And certainly for my wider family members, they get upset
with some of the messages they see coming to me through social media or letters, emails and other things. I kind of have to go out with a thick, thick skin to it sometimes and but it does sit in you sometimes, particularly if if I've come across and I haven't represented myself in the way I want to get across. Yeah, it's always difficult, isn't it? Because it's easy to say something, particularly in a text or something like that, where where there isn't nuanced, where you people don't have your tone of voice and they don't have, you know, your facial expression along with it. And something that seems
entirely ananine can be, you know, cause offence and then create the most incredible reaction. Do you control all of your own? Because obviously you know, you're you're the head of a pretty substantial non governmental organization. Do you control your own media channels or or do you have other people sort of chipping in and helping with that as well? I do most, most of it myself. I have someone who helps with Ellie with my emails and and diary and bits that if I'm trying to get something across that's nuanced, I will get, you know, I'll get help to make sure
the spelling and the put out it's right because I don't want it to come across wrong because I'm a head of an organization. And is that corporate responsibility? But the majority of it is me posting. It's, it's me and I could do a lot more, but it's time I would like to do more because there's so much what I get up to. I think it's really interesting for other people to see and hear and my reflections. And I've started to, I use LinkedIn a little more now, and I've started doing short videos on there of reflections from past conferences or major events so people can hear my voice and my tone rather than just what I
write. And actually, I was just thinking about the way in which, you know, you were talking about typing and, and being dyslexic. I'm not dyslexic, but I, you know, I, I am short sighted. And then if I got my contact lenses in, I really can't see a thing unless I'm holding the phone a very long way away from me. So if I haven't got my reading glasses, then it it who knows what I'm typing. And often I'll try and use that sort of audio function where you're sort of dictating, but that often is even worse and it and it gets some really stupid things in there. I. I use that voice dictation quite a lot in lots of what I do.
And yet you post something and you and then I'll get a message from a friend of my wife or someone and sort of you need to go and edit that. That doesn't mean that word isn't what you words that mean the same but spelled differently. So I've used the wrong one in the wrong context. Some platforms you can edit, others you can't. But that's me. I'm not perfect. I I, I have these challenges and as many other people do. So I try and be more honest about who and what I am now rather than not to post and hide from it. And and you were talking there
about doing those sort of pieces to camera, which I think are really helpful as you say, because they allow that nuance to come through. But also, I know that an awful lot of farmers use, use the on WhatsApp where you can send a voice message instead. And, and that's something that's quite interesting that's used across the developing world where there, you know, is a lot of illiteracy, people can't rise. And so, you know, Whatsapp's become really important for sharing messages between farmers in some of those countries where illiteracy is quite high because people are able to share those voice messages, which is just an aside, but I, I find it really interesting.
I just wanted to go back to you were telling us about your, about your farm. You mentioned keying in the weeds and I wonder if you could just explain what that means. And also I get the impression with your cover crops that those cover crops are then going to be sort of, for want of a better word, mixed into the soil. So if you could just sort of talk us through that phase and why that happens? Yeah. So after harvest, we always plant majority of our soils with what we call a cover crop or catch crop because we don't like to leave bare soil. Sometimes we do a bit of cultivation.
So there's not the opportunity. So when we come in into planting our crops that they're sort of the last month and this time of year sometimes there's that cover crop. So that needs to be terminated. We try not to move the soil, so we plant our seeds direct into that soil. So that means we have to use a herbicide and quite often currently that's round up to kill those weeds. But also we can use herbicides that I can place on the soil surface and it becomes like a weed barrier as weeds that come up in the next month will get terminated.
But we're constantly trying to move away from pesticides or from herbicides. But there's this balance of do I move lots of soil and burn diesel and oxidise the soil to cultivate the weeds or do I put a herbicide on? And for me, that's trying to get this balance of use as little as possible, but leave the best conditions as possible. But also where we're not planting this autumn, that cover crop can carry on growing right through the winter. And what we found last, the winter before last when it was
really wet, because we haven't got bare soil, we've got a cover crop on or catch crop, a green manure on the ground. It was so wet we couldn't plant, but that protects the soil until it was in good enough condition. I could plant if I'd have done a lot of cultivation. It'd been a bare soil and it may have lost the nutrients and the sediment away from the field. So if there's a farmer, there's always this balance of what's best. And just very quickly, if you could just talk us through what other farmers around you were doing before we quickly whip on to the party conferences.
Martin. Yeah. So many of them have done all their planting, packing the, you know, putting machines in the shed, many of them out there doing the hedge cutting and ditch maintenance. We do our hedge cutting up preferably after Christmas once all the berries have have come off. So, yeah, so other other farmers are sort of further ahead, but I've also watched in a lot of them that have dry drilled in dry soils, their crops are struggling getting going because that moisture wasn't there. So they've got a very uneven crop coming through and that'll just mean more management going forward. Really good to hear all of that. And I know that we've spent a bit of time talking about social
media, but I think that's that's important. That's been interesting. Just moving on to the party conferences, Martin, I know you've been to at least three of them. I wonder if you could sort of summarise the party positions for us. And you went to Labour, Conservatives and Lib Dems. Did you go to any of the others as well? No, not this year. We went for the three main party, the UK party conferences of political parties. Very interesting. I find going to them one after the other, the different politics perspectives and memberships that are in each one. So you get to engage at different levels.
For the Labour and the Lib Dems, a lot of focus on climate, nature, resilience. With Labour, it's, I always find a bit of a judge with the the talking about planning bills and nature being an inconvenience to growth. Well, nature underpins our economy. So how does that work? But the rhetoric, the language is right. It's just the delivery. And then we went to the Conservatives one where there was talking around stepping back from the Climate Act and other things and and sort of complaining about arm length bodies from government to, to holding back growth.
And it's this conjecture of different politics working together. So there's quite a mixed bag. But I'm always down to what what are you actually doing rather than the rhetoric? What's your action? And we see that very differently across all all those three main parties. And just give people a sense of what a party conference is like, because I get the impression that the Conservative Party conference really will feel very different When you walk through the double doors of the the Exhibition Centre to the Labour conference or the Lib Dem conference, what's the feeling that these things, are they
exciting places to be or just actually deadly dull? Very busy places and they've changed a lot as politics and elected parties have changed over the last few years. It's shifted so you go to the Liberal Democrats, A diverse section of community and people. As a non party affiliated person, I can go and sit in to listen to their members debating their policy. I find that fascinating. So there's stalls, stands going on, a lot of sponsored events and sessions and panel sessions. You get to meet a whole range of
different people. Labour a lot bigger. That's particularly now it's in Liverpool, lots of corporate sponsorships and, and events where panel sessions, roundtable discussions, bringing in different MPs, different ministers, opportunity to mingle events and you know, drinks receptions in the evenings to bring people together. So there's a great networking opportunity and very busy four days talking to people, breakfast at 8 events sometimes don't finish till ten, 11:00 at night. They're long days talking to people.
And then you've got the Conservatives, very much more corporate, very much sponsored this year, a lot smaller than the previous few years because an opposition party now, but as a, you know, Labour, their members can go in and debate their policy. The Conservatives, I've never seen that really happen. They're sort of told what The thing is as as a if you're a Conservative member, how do you affect? And engage with the policy during that conference season. And obviously, you're apolitical in the position that you're in, but I wonder if you're able to
give us a sense, you know, in this sort of slightly dispassionate way about which party platform you think is probably most attractive from a farming perspective. So non political ways. I like some of the Liberal Democrats. Agriculture, food, paper, climate, nature stuff. Kind of building resilience in landscapes, opposition politics is easier because you, you're not delivering Labour. The, the focus on climate in nature I think is, is positive, but it's about delivery and particularly in England, farming schemes that I haven't actually
got traction at the moment and everything's opened and closed. And then Conservatives, you know, they've done some really good stuff around the Climate Acts, the Environment Acts, the Agricultural Act in their previous, but they're now kind of turning that round again and saying, well, maybe that wasn't such a good stuff we're doing, we need to improve it where they were, the ones that put it in place. They're so diverse, those political parties, there's a bit of good in each of them and what I would like to see is a bit of each pulled out and made something that delivers long term outcome. So as with many things, it's
about trying to sort of say, let's not make this a political football. Let's actually just sit down together and try and have a creative, sensible conversation. We're going to come on to Wales later. But it it'd be really interesting to sort of look at that in context of what's going on in England as well. Because it strikes me, you know, and this is a hostage of fortune because the scheme hasn't yet been delivered, but it seems to be a much more coherent scheme and one that it, it would be easier for more farmers to support as they go forwards. And, and we'll, we'll see whether that's the case or not.
And we'll, we'll have a chat with Ivan on that. I'm just wondering before we move to Wales about where disaffected farmers go. Because I think, you know, there was a lot of disaffection with the Conservatives before the last election, probably one of the highest votes for Labour from within the farming community at the last election. An awful lot of that support has died off. Is everyone going to the Lib Dems or do you think that people are interested in reforming the Greens as well? I think it's quite open and mixed now. I think quite a few are moving towards Lib Dems because they're
trying to be a real more rural vote. Conservatives are trying to recapture that. Many people have are disillusioned or very unhappy with Labour, particularly some of the budgetary decisions. They've done this scheme implementations. So there's a lot of unhappy farmers around. Like with Labour Party, some are being tempted by the rhetoric of reform around, you know, going to get rid of this and we're going to do this and make life so simple. And, and some attempted by the Greens a little bit because they're actually those more environmentally minded and climate minded farmers as thinking, well, actually, that's
the pathway. And that's something we haven't seen for well, as much as I can remember, such diverse views from different parties where farmers, countryside people are spreading across them in in very diverse ways. But what would that mean to come to election? And we know Wales and Scotland have got their election next May, that the national UK election won't be till probably 2029. There's a long time till then. So what will politics look like and where do we move to in the language? And it kind of goes back to the
social media and the rhetoric we hear, to the delivery we see. And I'm very much focused around the delivery and actions and outcomes rather than rhetoric and noise because all that does is get people upset and angry and not be realistic. If our climate is changing, that is already impacting our our our businesses, our weather. We need to focus around building resilience in our countryside and our landscape and our farms and actions and language that drives money away from that is not the best. That for me is not the best
outcome. We need to see. We need to bring public and private finance into our landscapes for flooding, for nature, for food, for other things rather than rhetoric that takes investment away. I'm really interested in, in this sort of sense that an awful lot of farmers across the British Idols. And I imagine it's the same everywhere because you, you've got this sort of connection with the land that there is more of a, an association with, with more of a nationalist perspective. But that's sort of very much been within Scotland and Wales, more farmers within perhaps
Plaid Cymru, more farmers, you know, sort of supporting what the Scottish Scottish National Party have been doing traditionally. And I'm interested in whether there is a sort of a building of sort of interest in nationalism within England as well. And, and, and you sort of talked about the way in which some people are being attracted towards reform. Obviously that's one type of nationalism, but the Greens sort of have this sort of sense of, of kind of almost leftist or green nationalism as well. And, and certainly I was listening to an interview with
Zach Polanski, the new leader just last week. And they've, what was, when was he elected as leader? I think it was two or three weeks ago and they gained 110,000 members or something in that time. That's a member a minute since he was elected, which is, which is quite phenomenal. And and I I do get the impression that some of those at least are going to be nature friendly farmers. Yeah, and and that's the diversity of a political destination now, left, right, centre, centre, left, centre, right. I find that quite extraordinary really in such a short period of time that Brexit has opened up. But it kind of goes back to
this, this traditional parties not giving a clear enough offer to many people that they've gone off one side or the other. But it what it really gets down to. But what are the policies or actions rather than just the words? Because what do they actually really stand for and what can they deliver rather than being an opposition party that can make noise knowing they're not going to have to do anything? If I'm let's go to Wales and I'm interested in just sort of continuing briefly that conversation, you know, and I, I kind of made that, that rash
suggestion that lots of farmers might be quite supportive of Plaid. Is that the case? And and are more people becoming more supportive of Plaid Cymru as more people turn away from traditional parties, which I think is happening in Wales just as it's happening elsewhere? Well, I do think that in general Vote have been disappointed by the current leadership and they will likely be looking for other options. So I think that it is quite possible that guy that plight gumery will gain more seats in the next election. But I don't want to attempt to
predict political outcomes. Voters tendencies will also probably rely heavily on the ability of the local candidates to represent each community's best interests. It's interesting, isn't it? Cause come the election, I, I'm always aware that, you know, my, my attraction to national political parties is often very much dampened by the local candidates and, and their own particular skills as well. And of course you're electing an MP in the same way that you're electing a government. And it, it, it is a, it's an interesting, interesting thing. But let's stay with Wales.
And I just wonder if you could start us off by talking about your farm, Ivan. How big is it? What sort of land are you on? What are you producing? We farm 220 acres of upland in Montgomeryshire. The Land's all between 12 and 1400 feet above sea level and we range massively in land types from areas of peat bogs to areas of rock and scree to actually quite good deep brain soils.
We really sheep for the store market and pedigree hair for cattle and all the livestock are completely forest fed. Just talk me through nature because obviously you're part of the nature Friendly farming network. How's nature doing on your land? It's actually thriving. We consistently see over 60 species of birds a year. We regularly see brown hair, barn owls, otters, trout. There's three species of bats that were recorded here this summer. And the hedges and pastures are
also species rich. And I'm hoping that the soil is moving in the same direction. We've planted a lot of hedges over the last 25 years, just enough that we can manage to plant them ourselves each year. So they're not all coming to maturity at the same time. And also it takes a very long time for a hedge to grow here. So we we've only just started laying them now at round about 20 years old. So you've you've started laying them, but what sort of scope and size are they pre lay? They are probably a couple of
meters wide, 3 meters wide and about four meters high, but I'm a trainee hedge layer so I'm not sure if that's the best practice to use. Yeah, but that's fantastic, isn't it? And it, and it strikes me, you know, I drive around Wales a fair bit and a lot of the hedges that I, you know, a relatively neatly trimmed. So those those are quite different and they must be doing something really quite special. Yes. Well, as Martin alluded to earlier, we attempt to leave certainly a large proportion of the hedges unbrushed.
So we only tend to do this side of the tracks so that we're not damaging vehicles when we drive up and down the field sides. They're all fenced away from the livestock. So the field sides are fairly well maintained by the sheep, but also mostly the cattle. So anything that grows through a fence, they'll trim them back themselves and it also adds to the interesting brows that the livestock can eat. And when we spoke previously, you talked about the way in which, you know, just sort of thinking about the sheep that you have and the, and the pedigree cattle that that when
you first moved on to the farm, when you first started farming at Carriger Beak, that's that you had a different stocking level and that actually your productivity improved by the time you'd halved your livestock. Can you just talk me through that? Because we've talked about this on the podcast before, but this is so counterintuitive that I think it is worth talking through every time we come across it. Yeah, I think it's important to point out there, Finlow, it was a profit which doubled rather than our productivity. So although. I guess that's the definition of productivity, isn't it? And.
Exactly. Exactly as we almost halved the livestock numbers, the profits almost doubled. A large part of that was due to the expense of bought in feed. Also by reducing our inputs, we retained a larger proportion of the value of what we were selling at market. We also reduced the pressure on the remaining livestock, allowing for less intervention measures such as wormers and very rarely have issues with lameness and things like that anymore. And.
When you sort of got that discussion, I guess around profitability and productivity and what you've just described there, that's kind of why I'd written down in my notes. I think when we you spoke before you talked about profitability and I wrote down productivity because it was about the way in which having reduced the costs that you had on the farm, it wasn't that you were suddenly producing, you know, more stuff, but your profitability went up And, and that's Martin, what would you, how would you define productivity? Productivity of what? As well of nature of food, of
water quality, we want to be, I want our landscape to be producing the best we can and I harvest some of that to to market and sell. We're running businesses. So we've got to be focusing on that profitability and what we've seen across the network and across the country. Many farmers who have stepped back on inputs have found margins and profitability and resilience go up, which is counter intuitive because the the language from the industry is focus on productivity on production and squeeze more out.
And actually realistically and particularly while our changing climate going back slightly and getting the right balance of of productivity to production from our landscape with minimal inputs is the most profitable way we can go forward. And that's what we see many farmers being in the position of. Yeah. It's that idea that you reduce production, but you increase productivity and it's it's that link between the amount of profit that's coming in versus the costs that are there. So that's really interesting, really interesting to hear that and. Also, how much harm we be
causing it, because if you're pushing your landscape harder, water quality may be deteriorate, soil health may deteriorate, which are unintended consequences that have a cost to our business and a cost to society. If if you know our soils, leaving our fields and running down the river or the water quality is not as good. So we've got to think about that balance of what we do with our landscape as farms and businesses and who pays for. What and Yvonne, I, I guess what we're talking about there is sort of moving from an unsustainable level of production to something which is more akin to what we might call
sustainable maximum output. Yeah, exactly. I think sustainability and resilience go hand in hand. You become far more resilient when you're not exposed to external market forces. OK. And if people want to know more about that sustainable maximum output, which helps to sort of explain that idea that, you know, as you reduce your costs or as you reduce your, your livestock, you're also reducing costs, but you're able to increase the amount of profitability that's there on the farm, as well as delivering those those nature outcomes that
Martin was referring to. Then if you scroll back in your podcast feed, then you'll find a recent program, I think it's only four or five back called the Profitable Farm, which goes into quite a lot of detail on this. And certainly it's been a very popular podcast up to now. Moving on a bit, can we talk about the new sustainable farming scheme in Wales? How are things likely to workout for you with that? Well, I have actually completed the Welsh Government's Ready Reckoner and predictions do look positive for my business. The SFS should be a significantly larger payment than the BPS.
The Welsh Government have put a made a ready Reckner available online, which is very simple tool to use. I think there's only three or four figures that you need to input into there and they will throw the figures back that says what the basic payment scheme would be and what the sustainable farming scheme payment payment rate would be and. And you think that you'll be better off as a result of the SFS coming in? Yeah, almost double. What about other farmers?
What's the general sense do you think about the sustainable farming scheme amongst other farmers? Because, of course, there has been quite a lot of disquiet at different stages over the course of the last couple of years of the development. There has certainly, I think there's a lot who still don't fully understand the scheme, but knowledge is improving. In the last couple of weeks the two a month Welsh Government have provided road shows around the country and we've got a summary of the sustainable farming scheme on our website as well.
It's a quite a heavy document to get through the the Welsh Government document. It's over 200 pages but Reece, the Wales manager, has managed to create a summary of about 15 pages, which is just the main points and it's it's quite easy to digest. Yeah, it's really helpful. I've been going through it myself. Yeah, You mentioned that meeting there, the government was sort of running explaining things to other farmers. But what was the general feeling in the, would you say? I think generally they're quite surprised and hopeful. I get the feeling from talking to others that they may sit out.
Farmers who were unengaged in the past and were intending not to take part in the sustainable farming scheme may sit out the first year to gauge any problems they might there might be. But I think I'm really pleased with the scheme. There's a number of stakeholders that have been involved and we have to remember that this is a compromise. It's not perfect and I don't think it's a good thing if it's perfect for anyone really. We all need to compromise a little bit. Perfection is always a hard thing to achieve and as you say, it's always, there's a unique
understanding about it for everybody. But I'm just trying to get a sort of sense of how how this works in, in support terms. So you've obviously got the sustainable farming scheme and there's the continuation of the basic payment scheme as well. So is there a sense of, you know, you choose which one you want to be part of, or can you be part of both? The basic payment scheme will reduce by 40% next year. So in 2026, a basic payment scheme will be 60 percent, 2027, it'll be 4028, it'll be 20% of
its current value. And then in 2029 there'll be a quick complete withdrawal. Now you don't have to apply for the sustainable farming scheme, but if you stay with the basic payment scheme, that tapering will occur. If you transfer over to the sustainable farming scheme, you cannot then not go back onto the basic payment. So that's that's quite a stipulation that people need to think about. So it's kind of an all or nothing, but you can't be part of both. So you can't get some of your money from one, some from the
other. It's either you choose the new scheme or you stay with the other until it's, it's worth so little that you really have no choice but to go with the other if you want to get some kind of support or not. When we spoke earlier as well, you mentioned that there was still a bit of a knowledge gap in terms of, you know, woodland and hedges and how they're considered within the new scheme. Yeah, I think, I think farmers would be surprised or are surprised on how much habitat they already have on farm. And I urge people to do the data confirmation exercise, which actually asks you to confirm the
data for the habitats that the Welsh Government hold. And you can alter that to your wishes to a certain extent. That exercise will give you the figures of, of the habitats that are on your farms and the areas of tree cover and things like that. So it's it's quite a useful exercise to have because there's a lot of people who don't think that they have much habitats. I was gonna say do that. You had a story that you told me about the farmer who told you quite confidently that he didn't have any habitats on his land.
I did. I had a farmer, dairy farmer, who said he didn't have any habitat because he was intensive dairy. So I asked him if he had any ditches or streams and he said yes yes he had quite a few and I asked him if he had any hedges and he said he had a couple. And by the end of the 10 minute conversation I discovered he had a lot of stream sides, Riverside to quite a main river in Wales as well and a large block of deciduous woodland and and quite a long meterage of hedges as well.
So potentially he was sort of, if not already at the 10% requirement for habitat, then he wasn't far away. He. Would have been very close and also I think what's the problem to a lot of people is that the Welsh Government will also allow temporary habitats. So things like herbal lace will be classed as temporary habitats and as long as you manage them for nature to their stipulations then they can be accept a way of creating the 20% requirement to get into the scheme. So let's just go on to the scheme and in particular around the payments.
Now they've essentially you start off in the SFS and there's the universal layer, isn't there, which is where the payments are essentially coming from. And then beyond that you've got optional layers and collaborative actions as well. Just talk us through that universal layer. Is a universal layer is a baseline payment, so there's a social value payment of £107.00 a hectare for all eligible land. And what is eligible land because that doesn't seem clear to me in terms of that when I
was sort of going through the briefing, because everybody seems to be eligible for it. Does that mean that essentially most land is is getting a social value payment? That's correct. Yeah. It's, it's very similar to the BPS eligibility. So land that was eligible in basic payment scheme is likely to be eligible under the the Sustainable Farming scheme as. Well, so that's about just recognising that farmers have, you know, there is an, an innate social value to that land being managed. Yes, exactly. Exactly. It puts a financial value on everything else that agriculture does.
Clean air, clean water, landscape maintenance, outdoor space, you know, visual experiences. So what's ineligible land? I believe yards and buildings. OK. So it's everything that's green effectively. I believe so, yes. Yeah, I'm without checking. I'm not 100% sure on that. But interesting. So I interrupted you because we've got these four different types of payment within the universal Labour. We've got the whole farm payment, the social value payment, habitat maintenance and woodland maintenance. You've mentioned their social value payment. What are the others the?
Whole Farm Payment is a payment to encourage small farms to be part of the sustainable farming scheme. It's a £70 per hectare payment for the 1st 70 hectares and from then on it's £2 a hectare. It would be weighted towards the small farms rather than those who are running very large, very extensive holdings and not possibly needing the financial help. So those, those farmers that are, you know, really very big are still getting a couple of pounds a within that whole farm payment because there is still
this acreage element isn't there within the Welsh scheme, but it's capped, isn't it? Yes, exactly. And they're also getting the social value payment across the whole of it as well. And then there's also a £69 a hectare habitat maintenance payment and a 62 pounder hectare woodland maintenance payment. And those are both on on land. So if so, the habitat maintenance payment is on land that is specifically managed as habitat or defined as habitat within the scheme, isn't it? Rather than all the land that's
there? So. So what is habitat land? That's correct. There's AI won't go through them all Finlow, because there are I think 12 different habitats that Welsh Government have laid out. But it is things such as pasture, traditional orchards, salt marsh, heathland. So yeah, there's a, there's a number of habitats that would all be eligible. And habitat does not mean that it's fenced off and never seen again. A lot of these are part of the farming system. Most of these, doesn't it?
Yeah, most of these would be grazed habitats. Yeah. So you were saying I think that around 60% of your farm would be classified as as an active habitat? That's correct. Yes. Yeah, just from the the makeup of the plant species in it and the type of soil it's on. And the woodland maintenance payment against presumably that's specifically the land that already has woodland on it rather than land that's that's having planting going into it. I think the planting when it reaches a certain condition of canopy cover, I think it has to have 20% canopy cover, it then
becomes eligible for payment. But actually the woodland maintenance payment is less than the habitat payment. So that removes the financial incentives for planting Woodlands just for the sake of a financial decision of buying a farm up and planting the woodland. But it seems to me generally that the SFS in terms of this universal layer in terms of these payments is really recognizing the public good element of farming. And that if you are a farmer who is, you know, farming in a nature friendly way, you're going to be getting a,
particularly as you were saying, if you've got a, you know, reasonably small to medium sized farm, you're going to be getting that whole farm payment, which is reasonably generous. You know, that sort of 1st 70 hectares, even though it drops off after that. You've got the social value payment on all Greenland that you have. If you've got, for example, you've got 60% of your land there, that's defined as one type of habitat or another, and you ran through some of those there, then you've got the habitat maintenance payment and the woodland maintenance payment. So that's potentially quite a sizeable amount of money, which is probably not inconsistent.
And you say for your, from your perspective, it's more than the basic payment scheme was giving you. So farmers in Wales are a better off than farmers in England. Personally, I think I will be better off. There are a number of people who were looking to plug the gap so they are not expecting 100% of the basic payment because actually their next year their payment will be 60% anyway. If SFS could be 80% of their basic payment, that would still be beneficial. So I don't think it's a such a
simple calculation as looking at one and the other and saying well I'm better off doing that. There's the, AS you said, the tapering of the the payments. There's also a certain amount of capping that comes into this the system as well. So there's 0 capping for payments of up to 25,000 and that increases incrementally of 5% for about every 50,000 from then on. Those over 300,000 have 100% capping. So I can't imagine there'd be
that many having 300,000 sustainable farming scheme payment. Just quickly coming across to you, Martin, you know, I said there that it feels like, you know, the smaller farmer within Wales is going to be significantly better off than farmers in England, partly because that acreage element exists, but partly because the payments have been broken down. You know, within that sort of universal payment, the universal sort of elements of that, you're being rewarded for a range of different things that are being
delivered across the acreage of your farm. That's very different to England. Yeah. That's the wild scheme is very interesting, the way they've set out the value of the social value, keeping small farms going and that support while they it's not just a payment for a small farm, they have to deliver a range of outcomes for that. So yeah, I think that whole farm approach is, is a better approach. I've always been disappointed with the England's direction of individual actions getting supported rather than the whole farm approach and and recognising small business. Small farm family farms are valuable to the rural community
and and the aspects they deliver. Labour, since they've come into power, have wanted to change some bits for England and cap payments, so it'd be interesting to see where they go to going forward. Yeah, absolutely. And of course it's a, a Labour government that's that's working in Wales, that's running Wales at the moment. So Labour government now in England, it'd be interesting to see whether they're, you know, really watching what's going on in Wales and, and the degree to which it's a success for rolling out and, and, and how then they might be able to pivot and change the, the scheme in
England, if they were ever mind to just before we sort of, you know, talk more about the generality. The the final thing I really want to do Ifan is just to talk through the, you know, what, what farmers have to do for the money, because in order to be part of the universal payment in the first instance, there were 12 actions as well as then a carbon carbon audit that have to be fulfilled. So just to be eligible, they've got to do a range of different things. Just talk us quickly through that list, would you? Yes, certainly.
I would just say that I don't think a lot of these are very challenging. So they are, you know, things that really should be done on most farms anyway. The first is soil health, which means soil testing on 20% of your improved land just so that you become informed and can plan for the future of your farm. Integrated Pest management, which means that you need to complete an annual assessment of plant protection products used and alternative or alternative
methods to reduce chemical usage. You also will need to benchmark. So that's a complete measuring and monitoring assessment that you could do under. There's a number of different areas that you could do it in. So you could do it on your lambing percentage or your growth of your livestock. So there's a, there's a range of subjects, but they just like people to. Benchmarking against yourself or against the farmers? No against other farmers, but it's all anonymized.
So sort of understanding your own success rate effectively versus your peer group? Exactly, exactly. They just believing that actually if if you know you're in the bottom 50%, farmers being farmers never want to be there. They want to be at the top. So you know you will it will incentivize you to to make the changes yourself. Then we've got. Habitat maintenance, which is something that we've already talked about to an extent, then you've got continuing national development. Yeah, that's right. Which I think there's a few
people have panicked about that, But when we've discussed it, it could be something as simple as a as a farm walk that's that's eligible and that's only six hours per year. So one farm walk in the summer would would qualify you to to have completed that as long as it was an eligible one. Or, you know, it could be a number of shorter courses. Little webinars and, and you know, maybe even listening to podcasts and things like that with their CPT certified. We've got temporary habitat. We've discussed a little bit what's a designated site management plan.
That's to to improve the management of designated sites. So this means that natural resources whales who control all these designated sites must actually approach each landowner and provide a plan. So that is a requirement of the sustainable farming scheme, but it is down to natural resources whales to provide that plan. We've got hedgerow management and woodland maintenance now. Specifically, there are particular ways that you have to manage your hedges to stop them being quite so neatly trimmed to make them a bit messier.
Yes, they've the Welsh government have gone for this three by two measure. So whether it's 3 meters high and two meters wide or vice versa, they're not stipulating which way it needs to be. But they are also asking for incremental cutting. So hedges are not to be cut twice in two years, so every other year at the most. And when they are brushed or flailed they must be left with a A2 inch growth or A50 mil growth.
That's to stop the the knuckling. And also, apparently the new growth is the the part that fruits and flowers better than anywhere else. Then we've got the tree and hedgerow planting opportunity plan, and that's about just asking farmers to think about where trees and hedgerows could go that where they aren't at the moment. And then finally, we've got the historic environment and animal health and welfare. Just quickly talk us through those two. Yeah, the historic environment, it's very simple of just protecting the features and heritage that we have. So it's not asking for any major works.
It's asking if if there's a couple of slates blow off an old building to put them back. Because you've got a standing stone or a henge in your field. Then you you treat them with care. Yeah, don't go and dig it up and don't plow up to it. You know, just just generally don't cause damage. I think is that the guidelines and then the the health and welfare is to work with your vet and monitor continuous improvement in your livestock health and welfare, which there's a lot of people doing already with farm assurance schemes and organic schemes and
things like that anyway. So it's really interesting because what they've done there is essentially to sort of breakdown, you know, what, what they consider good sustainable nature friendly farming to be. They've sort of allocated it into 12, as I say, plus the, the carbon audit there. Presumably once they've got those baselines in place, then there will be, you know, sort of decisions taken to tweak those to, to perhaps make things that are slightly more onerous, less onerous, but also to tighten things up so that, you know, the standards become slightly higher as, as you go forward.
So it's, it's, it's really interesting and it's actually not dissimilar from the scheme as well where there is this requirement to to essentially baseline your farm across a whole range of different categories. So that's what's needed for the universal layer. There are also then payments for optional actions, which we won't go into today, but as, as we've said, you know, they're in this fantastic briefing that Reece has done for the Nature Friendly Farming Network and then collaborative actions, which are looking at landscape scale work. Thanks so much for that, Ivan, really appreciate it. And Martin just, you know, sort of final thoughts really, do you, what do you make of the,
the Welsh scheme there? For me, I quite like it, many of our core costs as farmers is maintaining the environment and the natural capital, natural landscape. So there's payments for that. That should help the business, that professional development and and thinking about your farm as a business and how you skill yourself and improve your product, your animal welfare and your production. That's a good value. So it's clearly set out as a scheme of adding to your business, adding to the landscape and public money. Yeah, using public money to drive good outcomes for public value.
I've been really interested to see how it sort of evolves over the next year or two and how farmers in Wales really sort of get on board with it. Yeah, fantastic. You know, the thing that also really sort of interests me with Wales is not only the scheme, because obviously the scheme is there now, it's been set out. So it's a case of just it being applied, farmers applying for it and then seeing how that goes, but also how that then sits alongside nature markets, natural capital markets. Because I think that there is more scepticism within government and within some of
those statutory bodies like Natural Resources Wales. There's less of an active market in natural capital within Wales at the moment than there is in England or even in Scotland where, you know, again, there isn't as much going on as England, particularly because of biodiversity net gain in England. So it'll be interesting to see how that develops. Very much and in Northern Ireland, but what we do need is a standard set of matrix for the market to work across the UK because what will happen is the money will go where there's the easiest matrix to measure. So actually what we need all UK governments to do in all the
devolved is what is the standard measure for the market to work and then you can tweak it to your own devolved nation. But if you want to make a market work, it needs reliability, a market to work in, and longevity to invest in. That's really interesting, isn't it, because there, as you say, we've got farming and land use there, you know, devolved activities and so very different schemes in Wales and Northern Ireland, England and Scotland. But natural capital, because they're selling into nationwide markets and even global markets,
there is this real need for governments to sit down, you know, with each other and and put aside some of their differences and just just come up with some sensible ways of scaling and accelerating that market delivery. Well, look, that's all we've got time for. We're going to be back next month thinking about December and Christmas, all the things that Martin's involved in around Christmas instantly it's and continuing our tour of the nature friendly farming network in the UK. I'd really like to thank Ivan for joining us. It's been fascinating to hear about the the Welsh scheme and
to have that conversation about social media as well. Hear a bit about the way that you've been farming there in Wales as well, Ivan. And of course, thank you to Martin for joining us. As ever, if you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is now the world's highest ranking food security podcast and Farmgate Leaders and Wheat from the Chaff are also available on the Farmgate Channel if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. farmgateispartof8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican
AG Revol Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Agrolo and individual donors. So it's goodbye from Martin and from Ifan. Goodbye. Goodbye, thank you. And I've been Finn Locustain. Bye for now.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...