Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Farm Gate

Farm Gate artwork

Why should Trump's grab for Greenland matter to farmers?

Jan 13, 202656 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this month's Wheat from the Chaff, ffinlo Costain (8point9.com) and Joe Stanley (GWCT Allerton Project) discuss: Venezuela, Greenland and world security Minette Batters' Farm Profitability Review Sustainable Farming Incentive back in June Inheritance tax climb down RFK's call to 'Eat real food' Farmers back nature-friendly farming Farm Gate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast, and we're part of 8point9.com, the land use news channel. 8point9 is supported by First Milk, Pelican Ag, the Nature Friendly Farming Network, Friar's Moor Livestock Health, Agrolo and individual donors. Search for ‘Farm Gate’ wherever you get your podcasts - and visit https://8point9.com/https://8point9.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello, Happy New Year and welcome to Week from the Chaff on the Farm Gate podcast channel. I'm Finn Locostein, the Chief editorof8.9.com. And I'm Joe Stanley, author and head of sustainable farming at The Allerton Project. Now, Joe, it seems a bit left field, but I kind of feel like we can't continue until we've talked about Venezuela and Greenland and, and, you know, kind of had a conversation about whether it's remotely relevant to us and and if it is, why it is.

What do you think? Look, I mean it, it would almost be remiss not to talk about the big issue of the day, right? And terrifying as it is from a, an existential point of view, it does have an impact I think on sort of, you know, farming and food and landscape management inasmuch as. But what we are once again seeing, and it's what we talk about, you know, frequently, Finlow, is the fragility of the of the international system. And here we have what for the last, you know, two to three generations has been the

guardian of that kind of liberal rules based order, our greatest ally. And yeah, we we're seeing a complete shift in in the way the world works. Essentially, we're going back to 18th and 19th century big power politics. And the, the danger of course, of this is that all of these things that we worry about and that we've talked about so often in terms of food security and food sovereignty and our ability to sort of make maintain our way of life is, is at threat with this. So, so absolutely, you know, all those concerns that we have

around, are we able to import that 40% of food that we, that we currently import? Are we able to source those sources of machinery and spare parts and fertilizer that we rely on in this country? The sorts of things that we're seeing going on at the minute. And especially with, you know, the key member of NATO threatening now to invade another NATO member and steal their territory. You know, these sorts of actions are of course, they're terribly just concerning on a human level. But from, from a food systems point of view, given the the

extensive fragile nature of our international food system, of course, it's the sort of thing that should really be making policymakers in Whitehall sit up and think, you know what, We really, really do need to address this now. Yeah, I think that's right, Joe. And I think there's a degree to which you've stolen my Thunder that you've said an awful lot of the things that that I was planning to pick up on there. But I think the two are connected and I think it's sort of worth kind of talking about how they're connected. Obviously, in Venezuela, we've had the president of the United States ostensibly setting up this this invasion into another

territory on the basis of drugs, which is relatively spurious. I think, you know, even before the invasion happened, there was this idea that, you know, it was only a very small part of America's drug problem coming from Venezuela. Ever since anybody arrived there, Trump has been very clear it's all about oil. And and so, you know, there are two things. The first is that this, this is the president of the United States just demolishing with no pretense the international rules based order, you know, which is why that's relevant in terms of talking to Greenland, but also

signalling that oil is right at the heart once again, you know, if there was ever any doubt of American foreign policy. And then as we, you know, we come to Greenland and of course Trump has been talking for a long time, hasn't he, that this is this is a big ball ball. I'm not quite sure exactly how much area this would add to the US if if he was able to acquire Greenland, but it's an awful lot. It's a huge piece of territory. And of course, up until this moment, Greenland has been very low in value.

But climate change and of course an oil based economy is going to accelerate climate change, climate change therefore becoming an opportunity from a commercial perspective, you know, at least in the short term from Trump's point of view, the ice sheet melting, unlocking that opportunity for rare earth minerals. And, and then around Greenland, you have the potential of open up, you know, the top of the world, this trade route that's strategically important. And so I think sort of, you know, annually now we're going to see this incredible exponential rise in the value of

Greenland and and other territories around the north. And of course, at the moment we've got the US their first into the mix, aren't they? In terms of that security equation? They're sort of saying, right, ours is first dibs, despite the fact, of course, that the Greenlanders had first dibs. Denmark has dibs on it already, but. Yeah, the Vikings got there first, didn't they? They had the right. Indeed, but but the US is there. We don't yet know what Russia's response is going to be. Russia is already pretty active under the ice around there. And then what China's response will be. Of course, China has its own

access to a vast resource of rare earth minerals already. Russia has quite a lot. But will they be prepared to accept the US going in and just claiming all of all of these minerals as they go and dictating the terms on which, you know, that northern passage can be used? So I think there is the potential here for this conflict to, I mean, not instantly, but over time, you know, sort of precede a global war. And of course, why are we talking this? It's the things that you raised there. Ultimately, the UK does not

exist in isolation, but we do need to become much more nationally self-sufficient in terms of the food, which shows that, you know, the kind of things that we've been talking about, the regeneration, the agroecology, the sort of farming that we've been talking about becomes incredibly important in terms to delivering that sort of level of food sovereignty that's needed in the UK. And that level of resilience, you know, water cycling, soil health, integrated pest management, all these other things become incredibly important so that we're able to produce food even when it

becomes increasingly difficult to access the things that you were talking about, the commodities, the technologies from elsewhere in the world. Yeah, absolutely. It's just so, it's just so horribly destabilising, isn't it? And, and again, you know, we with 7 billion people in the world, 8 billion people in the world, we all rely on the international movement of goods and and commodities at the moment. And you know, I, I just think this, this just highlights the fragility of that system. You know, one man basically gets

put in a position of power and 70 years of the international rules based order can collapse almost overnight. So that's, that's how fragile the system is. So again, I hope there are contingency plans being drawn up at speed and I hope that that dovetails into things like the 25 year plan for farming, into things like the farm profitability review response because yes, we are not doing these things in a global vacuum. And I think the important thing, I mean, you're right that this one man is an incredible sort of

force of nature, and he is the instigator of an awful lot of this. But there is a machine behind him, particularly in this second term. You know, there are an awful lot of people, an awful lot of policy people who are behind that Trump machine, part of that Trump machine. And so part of the question is, you know, to what extent this sort of change in the world order ends in three years time when Trump stops being president and the degree to which he will create a new world order, which then is sustained and maintained when he leaves office, if indeed

he does leave office, they stop talking about a possible third term quite so much, haven't they? And, you know, and I, there will be people I know listening to this, you know, who are Trump supporters, people who think that President Trump, what he does, you know, in a whole range of different ways, the chaos that he unleashes and, and the destabilization that he creates is actually important and useful and a good thing in the world. And we will come to, you know, something in just a moment where Robert F Kennedy has has launched his own sort of sense of what American nutrition should be. We'll come to that in a second

because that potentially is a good thing that's coming out of the Trump administration. So it's not to say that that everything is bad, but I do think that there are some real challenges, you know, around Venezuela and decisions around Greenland and governments here. Individuals here really need to wake up to the change in that world order. Let's move on Joe, to the farm profitability review that you mentioned. This is of course led by Baroness Minette Batters. It was published just before Christmas, a six month review which examined farm

profitability in England, setting out 57 recommendations for government and industry to strengthen the resilience and viability of farm businesses. What did you think? To me, obviously setting minute on to write this was, was good news, you know, for, for the farming industry. And you couldn't help but feel that the then Secretary of State Steve Reed. I, I said a lot of the time this is what I would do if I was just looking to essentially kick a can down the road and hope I wasn't in office when the results came out. And lo and behold, of course,

everything could be put on hold until the batters review came out. And lo and behold, Steve Reed wasn't in office when it came out. So that's one way of sort of slightly cynically looking at it. But of course, you know, Minette was a great person to put this together and she has come back with a document which is, you know, essentially of no surprise to anybody with any familiarity with the food and farming system. And and of course, you know, focusing on how challenging it is for farmers to do farming today in the UK in the 21st century.

Now that's not to say it's not hugely valuable because of course the people who need to read this are the policy makers, the civil servants, the MPs, the ministers, they are the people that the journalists, the people who lead our national conversations. They need to read all of this put together into a single document, bringing all of these huge, hugely diverse strands of challenges that are facing farmers today. And it's of course invaluable to have all of these things in one place because it's not just the case that the challenges facing farmers today are the fact that

SFI is currently unavailable, the weather's bad because of climate change, and that global commodity prices are generally poor. They are three strategic issues that we face, but there are dozens and dozens of large, medium and small problems, which Manette has highlighted in this in this project and bringing them all together, showing how they all fit together. Everything from planning to labor availability, to access to finance, to just having an agreed metric for soil health. All of these things absolutely

vital. And, and of course you know that the report has been widely welcomed. Of course, the challenge now is the extent to which government will, as with almost all reports, just put them on a shelf, ignore them, or whether you know the the findings of this report will be implemented in policy in a positive way. Yeah. I mean, I think there are elements of the report that have already been sort of picked up in terms of new, new boards that are coming into Defra and also things like BNG. I mean, we talked before Christmas on another podcast about the way in which, you

know, biodiversity net gain rules were changed immediately before Christmas so that building developments up to 1.2 hectares are now exempt from BNG. And of course, you know, this is partly sort of Steve Reed being lobbied by the NFU to an extent around the idea that, you know, in order for farms to be profitable, they need to be able to build more stuff, more infrastructure on there and they need to to be exempt. And so the NFU was not. Sure, the NFU. He was championing that as a win. I mean this they were.

Quite not sure that, Tom Brady said. That quite explicitly I. Mean I've, I've been seeing, I mean the, the comment I always see from the NFU is that they just wish there was policy certainty and that, that, you know, 90% of BNG is delivered in that minus naughty .2 hectare block. So, you know, I, I, I think although, yeah, absolutely farming aggregate, you know, I don't, I don't disagree that certainly the NFU has been calling for small agricultural developments to be exempt because, you know, it's, it is sort of constricting for, for

farms to have to do the same sort of restrictions on an extension to a grain store as as a housing developer would. But I think we're all disappointed at the very small scale of the BNG market. And this will obviously do nothing to to improve that. Yeah. I mean, just while we're sticking on that for a moment, I mean, I don't have the quote in front of me, but you know, there was very a very clear quote from the NFU basically saying, you know, this change is fantastic. It means that we can get on with, you know, farm development. It is something that we have been lobbying for over the

course. So, you know, regardless, the point is really that this is, you know, this is something that a lot of charities, the Wildlife Trust, for example, have been talking about as the thin end of the wedge that, you know, this is an exemption for basically an awful lot of the infill that's going on. So aside from farms and the type of development that might happen on farms, I was talking on the podcast about the way in which the street that I grew up on in Worcestershire was a street with orchards, with big gardens. And now it feels like an urban Rd. because every tiny piece of ground, every allotment, every orchard, every, you know, the

farms sort of going out at the end of the lane, these have been built on an infield. So that is a shame. But at the same time, there was a degree, I think where the Wildlife Trust were being quite disingenuous in suggesting that this was 60% of all building, all development that was going to be caught within this change. I mean, yes, it is now, but if we are going to see 1.5 million houses built, then it's certainly not going to be 60% of, of that overall, you know, going forward. But I think we've got slightly, slightly diverted. So I allowed myself to be

diverted there in terms of the, the, the farm profitability review, my big take home from it. And, you know, there's nothing, you know, as I read through it that I, I particularly wildly disagree with, but it does feel like a missed opportunity. Minette has sort of talked, you know, right at the beginning of the executive summary, the core focus, she says, of my recommendations is to restore balance between food production and the environment. They should be treated as two sides of the same coin. And I really didn't get the sense of that going through it. I, I felt that she got kind of lost in the detail before she'd

finished with the vision. And that's where the last opportunity is. I, I felt like it really needed a chapter which really framed the problem, framed the challenge and, and talked about the way in which, you know, farm resilience, all the things that we talk about and not just down to, you know, whether the government tweaks this or tweaks that in order to create profitability. But it's, you know, it's the fundamental underpinning of the farm and food system. And that actually, if we're just looking at food, then there's a degree to which that creates

distortions. We need to look at, at land ownership, Land Management, in more general terms. How can farmers make a profit, yet they should be making a profit for the food that they're producing. But there are so many other the things that farmers do that get layered on there and that natural capital market, which is really why I was getting diverted onto BNG. That natural capital market, which needs certainty and needs, needs real support from government to get underneath and create those frameworks to accelerate that delivery so that

natural capital can become something that really brings money in from the market for farmers. Yeah, I, I agree. So look, there's, there's 57 recommendations in, in this report for me that that's too many recommendations. You know, I would, I would, I think I agree with Ethan. I would have had fewer, more kind of strategic recommendations. It's the, my concern would be a government will look at this and you can, you can quite easily kind of, if you like, get people

lost in the, in the maze of recommendations, some of them really very specific, some of them really broad. My concern would be that it would be relatively easy for a government to take this pick a few that they that they, they can quite easily address and say that they've, you know, carried out a number of the recommendations from the batter's review. So I agree, yeah, personally, I would have tried to make it a bit tighter. I would have tried to have sort of focused it perhaps more on those big strategic issues and, and and sort of kept the, the detail in, in the appendices almost. But I think you look, we, we, we can, it's easy to criticize.

And, and, you know, Manette was faced with a, a huge challenge. Again, how far, how wide-ranging do you want to go? And of course, the terms of reference would have been, would have been laid out as well. And it probably wasn't allowed to, to stretch too far into kind of wider food policy and social health and all that sort of thing. We know she wasn't allowed to talk about inheritance tax, for example. So there's, you know, that there were terms of reference. But I think one thing which was, you know, I think recommendation #1 which does come back in a very positive way to all the things that we often discuss on

here is. And again, I think this was the headline recommendation, which is that agriculture can't just be viewed in in the in percentage of GDP that it directly contributes to the economy, which is yet nought .6% one percent of employment. And that is, I think that is at the absolute crux of how we are going to make this industry sustainable financially and environmentally, which is we have to appreciate a all the other things that agriculture contributes indirectly to the food sector.

But also, yes, the true value of natural capital. And I think that was strongly in the report that there needs to be that, you know, going back to the, the, the, the Goopster review and etcetera. We need to actually now we know what we need to do. We've been talking about it for decades, literally. And in order to make those natural capital markets really fire up, we have to put a genuine value on the natural capital and ecosystem services that farmers are almost uniquely placed to provide. And I think that does come through very strongly from the

report. Yeah, and I think you're right, sort of link it to the desk up to review as well. Because of course, you know, one of the challenges I think, you know, whenever we sort of try and look at the way that land is used through 1 prism or another prism, there is the danger that that we just kind of present it as a fairly small thing. And and the way that the government views farming is that it's a very small percentage of GDP, as you just said. But but the reality is that nature and the way that we manage land underpins our entire economy. And, and so you kind of, you either go from this sort of

small, you know, less than 1% of GDP up to 100% and you just got to kind of almost pick your number in between. And I think the governments have struggled to understand that for a very, very long time. And, and, you know, every review that comes along tries to reframe this and get government to understand in a slightly different way one of the things that has come from it. And, and I guess just to sort of go back again, it is easy to criticise, but what it felt to me was that it was a draft of a report that Minette had written her that then really needed to go to other people within Defra

to help her Polish it and turn it into something that was, you know, that was really good. And, and, and it may well be that she had lots of support in Defra. But, you know, if it really was just a question of, of Minette having to do some research by herself and then write effectively, you know, a PhD dissertation all in the space of six months, then, you know, that was that was always going to be an enormously tall order. And she clearly needed a bit more support. But the Farming and Food Partnership board seems to have come out of it. There was a board that Minette seemed to get really quite

excited about. I can't remember what her acronym it was an there. Was there were there were quite a lot of acronyms? Yeah, and and she seemed to sort of keep pushing these things. But anyway, the the government sort of rejected her acronym and come up with one of its own. Came up with her own quango. Yeah, yeah. So it's the final. Thing I think with that, yeah, that that that board that the government has announced, it's going to be a strategic body where all of the big players in the food and farming set to come together under the auspices of government chairmanship to discuss the direction we need to travel. So it's the Food and Drink Sector Council, which was disbanded recently because it

was widely believed to be a complete waste of everybody's time. Now I've written a piece for Farmers Weekly before this came out. Which comes out next week, basically calling for for that body to be formed, but excluding government. Because I believe that essentially we've, we, you know, government has let us down time and time and time again. I don't believe another talking shot being created, chaired by government and at the whim of political winds blowing left and right every 10 minutes is the way that we're going to achieve

anything. I genuinely believe, and I think I've talked to to you about this before, Finlow offline. We need to everyone with a significant stake in the food system needs to come together, agree on a direction of travel and then basically present that direction of travel to government. I, we can't just continue to get let down by government time and time again. So look, this, this thing has been created again. I, I don't really see how it's much different from what was recently disbanded. The danger is it just becomes another. It's a, it's a tick in a box and it's a talking shop. And, you know, I, I just, I just

believe that we haven't got any more time to waste. And everybody in the food supply chain appreciates the urgency with which we need to act. The danger is that just no one is willing to take that first step. But I think government has has really discredited itself as the convening body in all this. Yeah. At the same time, the public is a key stakeholder in everything that takes place on farms, certainly in terms of the money that's going out. And, and although it doesn't feel like much money, it is a generous amount, you know, when we look at it globally, the amount of money that's going

from the public, from the taxpayer to farms, it is pretty generous in global terms, much as you know, I, I'd be the first to say that it needs to be two or three times more than it, it currently is. And one of the things that, that Minette brought out, which was a new framing that I hadn't, I, if I thought about it at all, I hadn't done for quite a long time, was the way in which the common agricultural policy was of course the delegation of, of land policy to the EU for an awful lot of time. And so there was a degree to which Defra didn't really need to think about an awful lot of

it. It thought about it in strategic terms at European level. Often it was just sort of fighting to maintain, you know, this, that or the other element of it. And so over the last 10 years, there has been this sort of this huge running trying to sort of catch up with the idea that we're almost starting from scratch on foreign policy. And, and as you say, we really need to get it together now, which I guess brings us on to an extent to the announcement today as we record from Emma Reynolds, the Secretary of State, about the sustainable farming

incentive and what's happening there. And I guess I, I'll give you the headlines and then I, I, I know that you'll, you'll want to come in, but the headlines are that she's, she's going to announce that there are reforms. Well, we know that, don't we, that there are going to be two application windows in 2026. The first will be from June, prioritising smaller farms, those without an existing agreement, then the second round from September. She says that farmers are the heart of our national life, but too often they've been held back by bureaucracy. We're changing that to a system that backs our farmers.

And, and again, just as an aside there, I think again, that's part of what's come out of Minette's report, is this idea that there's too much bureaucracy. I believe it, it's, you're never quite sure, but I believe that that's something that's very much at the heart of what Angela Eagle, the farming minister, thinks. And obviously we do need a simplification. There isn't the need for the complexity that exists. At the same time, got to be careful that we don't throw babies out with bathwater. So it's always, you know, when ministers say I'm going to simplify, there's going to be a bonfire of the rules. I always sort of cringe a little. I feel my sphincters kind of

tightening. But at the same time, I agree that it it needs to happen. But within there, in terms of specifics, we've talked about that Farm and Food Partnership board. There's going to be an extension of the Farming and Protected Landscapes program for three years with an extra 30 million. There's also plans to explore transformation of England uplands, recognizing the unique challenges facing the rural communities that depend on them, from poor access to services to harsh farming conditions. First in Dartmoor, then Cumbria to create farming clusters, explore new mutual funding models and lay the foundations

for new income streams from nature based enterprises to regen tourism and circular economy initiative. So you know, there is stuff in there. She had to say something to the Oxford Farming Conference. Tell me what you think is new. I mean, it's all new. I mean, this is the thing, isn't it? I mean, all those things you were just talking about, Finlay. We're basically starting from first principles again. We've been developing this policy for a decade and we're going back to square one. We've got no idea what SFI will look like when it does return in those two windows that you talked about. You know, it's really just an

announcement of future announcements. As you said, she's got to say something at the Oxford Farming Conference. But, you know, barring an act of God, come June, there will be a very partial, very slow roll out of SFI 5. This is the 5th iteration of SFI since it was released five years ago. Initially, it's almost one week, Yeah. And you know, there will be problems with it. There will be huge problems with it because there are always problems with these schemes. And, you know, so we are talking

about God knows how long until we start to see a proper roller. If you'd have gone back to this time last year, to last January, to January 2025, and I'd have told you that we would be sitting here in January 2026 looking at a 15 month gap between SFI, which was supposed to be the final version of SFI being closed down. And then we wouldn't be looking for 15 months until anything coming back. You would have been appalled. Now, obviously it is great to see that things like Fipple funding are being extended

because that has been, yeah, everyone agrees Fipple has been a fantastic program for those lucky enough to fall within those protected landscapes. But those other things you're talking about, look, yeah, farmers coming together, working cooperatively, really fantastic. I mean, the GWCT essentially came up with the cluster concept. But we are 10 years from the vote to leave the European Union and we are, we're looking at starting all over again. The single farm payments have stopped for all English farmers. There is no availability to get into these successor schemes.

Natural capital markets are not working. Cereal prices have never been as low as they are today in real terms. You know, the industry is already falling over a Cliff. We've lost 8, 80% of our dairy farms. We're looking to lose another 5000 potentially this year. And we're talking about doing pilot schemes in different parts of the. I mean, I know it's welcome to have heard any detail whatsoever, but it's also worth bearing in mind that we were promised that we would have heard this detail back in the summer of 2025. And here we are looking at a

potential soft roll out 12 months later. And you talk about reducing bureaucracy. Every single Secretary of State and minister we've ever had has talked about that SFI was supposed to be the simplest, most straightforward scheme we'd ever seen, and it became an absolute monster. We just make the same mistakes time and time and time again. And I mean, This is why I just feel that almost, we need to almost be looking at making our own way without this public money.

And I think an increasing number of farmers are thinking that because it is just so uncertain. The government has just proven itself to be so unreliable a partner. It is so frustrating. And if you look at things like Defra's confidence tracker, 80% nearly of farmers in England at the minute have no confidence whatsoever in Defra's ability. And this is going back to April 25, have no confidence in in Defra's ability to deliver this scheme. So we are and and that's an all time high. And of course, that's of no surprise given where we were in

April last year. So, you know, there is just such a huge mountain to climb here. And, you know, look great, we've got a date. June is when we might start to to get some detail about this scheme. But farms are in pain right now. And it has just been such an abdication of responsibility by this government and previous governments to leave us where we are today. Yeah, I mean, I think this is actually a strategic objective develop the government, isn't it that, you know, farmers feel that there is no reliability from a government perspective

and therefore the market itself will reform. And I think, you know, there's there are places where they're almost quite explicit about that, that, you know, the market is the thing that needs to be rewarding farming. The trouble is that as markets form, as we've seen with natural capital, with biodiversity net gain, the government then gets involved and re tweaks and undermines that market. And you know, that's a huge problem. And what it seems to me is that in England we are seeing a prioritisation of one sort of farm or farmer over another sort of farmer, which we're not really seeing in the same way

across Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, You know, there, there is funding that is available across the piece for farmers in those other nations. It's just in England where we're sort of seeing this, you know, farmer against farmer. And it was something that you were concerned about, you know, sort of 6-8 months ago when we were talking, you know, this idea that that actually the larger arable farmers would perhaps be ineligible for an awful lot of money from an SFI because there would be a prioritization of those uplands farms where where, you know, to be fair, at the moment, the need

is greater, but we need support for all farmers. And you talk about the way in which farmers are increasingly feeling that they need to just step away or give up on government. And you know, that we need to sort of create new markets. I completely agree that those markets need to be created, that those markets for food, for natural capital, for forestry, for agroforestry, for a whole range of different things need to be created. But I also believe that there are things that the public gets out of farming from landscape to the maintenance of public rights

of way. And the public should be paying for that and that money should be coming from the government. And there's always been this question of whether food is a public good or not. Well, I would argue, you know, as I am increasingly that sustainable food, regeneratively produced food, nutrient rich food that is a public good versus the kind of commodity crop where, you know, nutrition is relatively low, where an awful lot of Petro chemicals are used, where there's environmental damage. So let's see that reframing and get decent government money in

paid simply to farmers who are doing a good job environmentally and nutritionally with the food that they're producing at the same time as getting those markets functioning so that farmers, you know, perhaps in the future might actually all be able to earn a decent living. Well, the, we can but hope Finlow and again, this is the year where supposedly there will be many things coming to final fruition. Things like the land use framework, which is much delayed will come out. Things like the, the 25 year plan for farming. You know, these are all supposed

to come out this year. And we've got another three, 3 1/2 years of this government left. So we will see where we end up. Of course, as always, you know, we will, we will engage constructively with government and of course government should absolutely be the key stakeholder here and that public money paying for those public goods and for national security should absolutely be a part of this. But the the problem is, you know, you try telling that to a farmer who's not been able to access an environmental scheme in the last 12 months and is

probably looking at another 12 months until they're able to, they are going to have to start going their own way. I said that there are good things coming out of the Trump administration, so let's talk briefly about putting real food at the centre of healthcare, which is what RFK Robert F Kennedy Junior says that he's doing. New guidelines came out just today or yesterday, depending on your time zone, I suppose. New guidelines deliver a clear and simple message to the American people. Eat real food. These guidelines return us to

the basics. Secretary Kennedy said American households must prioritise whole, nutrient dense foods, protein, dairy, vegetables, fruit, healthy fats and whole grains, and dramatically reduce highly processed foods. This is how we will make America healthy again. Now, if this happened, it would be a complete revolution, wouldn't it? And, and, and as I think, you know, the last time we discussed the plans of RFK, you know, there is this concern that, you know, he comes out with a good idea. He comes out with the idea that people should basically be eating real food while the

government continues, you know, subsidizing processed food and and petrochemicals to the extent that they are. So, so it's always a question of whether, you know, there is the ability of one arm of government to deliver, you know, despite the actions of the other arm of government. But just sort of putting a couple of those bullet points from from our article across there. He's talking about prioritizing protein at every meal, consuming full fat dairy with no added sugars. I mean that's completely different isn't it to the UK where you see every yoghurt is low fat, sugar stuffed, etcetera

etcetera. Eat vegetables and fruits throughout the day, focusing on whole forms of food. Incorporate healthy fats from Whole Foods such as meat, seafood, eggs, nuts, seeds, olives and avocados. Focus on whole grains. Sharply reduce refined carbohydrates. Limit processed foods. Eat the right amount for you based on your age, sex, size and activity level. Choose water and unsweetened beverages to support hydration. I mean, it's really not rocket science, but it does feel like it flies in the face of of an

awful lot of government nutrition guidelines around the world. As you say, it sounds like the sorts of things we should be encouraging people to do. My problem with this is the source from which it's coming. And, you know, the Trump administration, you know, it's, it's like when President Trump came here and had opinions on things like inheritance tax and farmers and even the NFU were all over those comments saying, look, look, oh, great. Isn't President Trump's on our side? I don't want President Trump on our side. You know, this administration, it's kind of like a stopped

clock. I suppose it's inevitable, though, they might get something right at least twice a day. But I, I have a fundamental problem that, you know, for example, this, this story we're talking about now, Finn Low, you can't help but feel that it's, it's coming out for ideological rather than health reasons that this is, it fits a, a certain culture wars template coming out of the UK. I've become so innately cynical and hostile to almost any of this sort of stuff coming out of sources, which I disagree

fundamentally with 95% of what they say. If they say one thing which seems reasonable, I'm then immediately cynical and suspicious of the reasons why they're saying it. So I, I, I don't know it, it sounds good, Philo, But you know, this is again, from the same person who says that we shouldn't vaccinate our children, that COVID was all a, you know, a scam and all the rest of it. I struggle to get excited about this. Yeah, I mean, I, I, I hear the cynicism and there's a degree to which I entirely agree with you, Joe. But you know, I like to be fair. And and if somebody does say something that that I agree

with, at least with regardless of whether it's sensible or not, that it's nice to give them a bit of applause. And the idea of eating real food, getting rid of processed food, I don't care who says it, it's a good idea and it and it is think. We should care. I think we should care, Finlow. I think we should I think we should interrogate the reasons why people are saying things. I think it's dangerous to to get into bed with people who might say something we agree with when we know that fundamentally we disagree with them on almost everything else. I think it's a we should, we should be implementing policies

for the right reasons, with science and with the best of, of intentions. I, I think we should be wary of journeyman grifters and attaching our wagon to them. I think that's important. I don't wanna get into bed with RFK because I think that's an image that nobody needs at any time that they're listening to, to this podcast. At the same time, you know, I think a lot of people have been saying for a long time that our, our, the NHS, that our health system is all based on just kind of repairing people when they're

broken, rather than actually having something in place, which is about sort of building better and nutrition, better health outcomes, you know, from the community at large. And while I completely hear what you say, I'm, you know, I'm, I'm pleased to see that there is a conversation taking place about the value of real food, no matter where that comes from, because every time somebody says that there is an opportunity to, to progress that conversation further. And that's fair enough. That's fair enough. No, but look, yeah, we, we are, yes, yeah, look, yeah.

Our, our diets are hugely problematic across the West. Of course we need to address them. But yeah, I, I would just like us to, I would like this to be part of a more coherent evidence based policy, you know, rather than it being just another potentially another culture wars press release. And as you say, it would be flying in the face of basically all of American culture and most of the rest of the arms of the US government. So we'll see how far it gets. Let's talk about inheritance tax. The government has essentially

rolled over. It's taken a long time. The press release came out. The decision was announced on December the 23rd when most people were looking away and doing last minute Christmas shopping. But they have announced that the level of agricultural and business property relief threshold will be increased from 1,000,000 to 2.5 million when it's introduced in April 2026. So essentially if you're a married couple, a farm owned by a couple will mean that that farm can be passed on tax free

up to when everything else has been taken into account up to 5.65 million, so nearly £6,000,000. So inheritance tax essentially won't affect a married couple farming until that farm has a value of of 6,000,000. And just to sort of go into a couple of other examples that the government put out a farm owned by Oh, and this is important that if the first death. So if you've got a farm that's owned by a couple and and somebody has died, then if that first death was before the 6th of April 2026. So in other words, if you die

now or you, you die before now, then it will be assumed that the entirety of that 2.5 million allowance will be available for transfer. So a married couple, whether that second sort of element of the couple the husband or wife is, is dead or alive, they'll, they won't be paying tax until the farm is is worth more than 5.65 million. And then a farm owned by two people, two people such as siblings, again, that's going to be 5.65 million tax free. If you have a farm that's only owned by one person, then it's

half of that, of course, at 2.825 million. The only thing I'm just gonna say, Joe, before I pass over to you is that when this policy first came in, there was an awful lot of smoke and rage from people about the idea of inheritance tax. Now, personally, I've got no problem with the principle of inheritance tax. It's all about the threshold and, and the value of those farms. And so I agree entirely that the family farm rather than the corporate farm needs to be protected. But when I was talking to people then they said, well, you know, it's, it's ridiculous.

It's, it's said it's about 3 million. Most farms are worth 3,000,000. If it was at something like 5 or 6,000,000, that would be OK. And now that it is at 5 or 6,000,000, I've spoken to one or two farmers and they said, well, if it was at 10 million, that would be OK. So, So what? Where are you? What are you thinking on this? They're obviously incredibly welcome to see this, this movement. It's more I think than we'd come to expect from, from this government. I think, you know, the NFU had really almost given up hope on, on getting any movement. So clearly 150% increase in the threshold compared to where we

were, you know, 12 months ago is, is really, really welcome. However, yeah, I mean if you fall below the threshold I suppose you'll be relatively relaxed. But it's worth bearing in mind that even if you are in that lucky position of being able to make use of two people's tax free allowances and, and all the rest of it, you know, £5,000,000, that's a 500 acres of bare agricultural land. So that's not including the buildings, the house, machinery,

livestock and all the rest of it. So given that the the average farm size in the in England is something like 365 acres, by the time you do throw all of those things in, you're you're talking about the average farm size butting up against the bottom of this threshold. Again, assuming you're lucky enough to be able to make use of two people's threshold, this is an improvement. It is still leaving a huge number of people in a horrible position which they were not expecting to be in.

If you are not married then all of a sudden you you have to pay tax on an extra 2 and a half 1,000,000 lbs of assets just because you, you aren't married. If you know the the anti forestalling clause is still there. So anyone who has acted to to try to transfer their assets in the previous 12 months, you know the elderly, the infirm, the the terminally ill will still be caught by this policy. It is still a hideous policy. I don't believe that it is fair to to tax business assets as opposed to personal wealth on

the death of the previous generation. I, I don't see how that makes any sense whatsoever. I think, you know, again, this was more movement than the, the, we could have hoped for. But if you go back 18 months and saying that we were in this position, there still would have been, of course, total outrage that, that we were in this position at all. So, look, it is good news. It was a very welcome Christmas present for, for very many farms. I know you know, it's well, we've covered before that the distress and the, the upset and even the deaths this has already caused.

But it doesn't fix the problem. It just ameliorates the problem. So we, we are where we are. And, and you know, great, as you'll see, the government was widely crediting the NFU with, with essentially working behind the scenes, working with Labour backbenchers to, to achieve this. And, and very Many thanks to all those Labour backbenchers who did stick their necks on the line to, to sort of to stand up to their own government on this. But, but yeah, look, this isn't, this isn't, this isn't fixed the problem. We you know, we will be back talking about this in in future.

Yeah. And of course the purpose of the policy was to try and sort of balance out a bit of unfairness in the system. The aim is to release land the I think the aim was. That the purpose, I thought it was to fund the NHS. No, the, well, this is what we were told at the time. That was the rhetoric that came out. But as a policy, it's a policy that's existed within Labour circles for, you know, decades really. It's been about trying to release more land for more farmers to be able to buy. Is that it to to reduce the prices however? Well, that was always a nonsense view of the country.

I mean, that was just ridiculous. This is the worry, isn't it, that, you know, if that land is released, it's still going to be so expensive because land is so expensive. And so the idea that new farmers or farmers are just going to be able to buy a few acres or a few 100 acres from themselves is nonsense. And what we really want to avoid is the corporate takeover of agriculture. And that is that is the fear that as land is broken up, it's corporates that are buying in big corporate farms rather than family farms rather than

individuals. And and that really would be a massive backfiring in terms of policy objectives. Look, it's just, the whole thing's just been so confused. They, they don't know why they did it and and they don't know why they're sticking to their guns other than they're just being bloody minded. But look, yeah, it's, it's positive. But yeah. It's it's a welcome. Change the end of the story. It's a welcome change and there may well be tweaks again in the future. Is, you know, is, is what I would expect. I think that the government now is going to want to see two or three years of sort of watching how this policy actually beds down and what it actually does

in terms of family farms before it then tweaks it again. And, and I guess the other thing to say is there are still plenty of ways of avoiding this tax if people take, you know, tax advice. There are many of them, very expensive. Yeah, yeah. Fair enough. So welcome news could be better. That's the message I'm basically hearing, Joe. Which is a win these days. That's a big win for us. That's great. Yeah, we'll take that. Last story that I wanted to talk about, and it may sort of lead on to a couple of other articles that you've noticed as well, is one that came out from the Nature Friendly Farming Network,

UK Farmers back Nature Friendly Livestock Systems. Now this was in response to a Savanta piece of research, but what it essentially found was that many more farmers would move to diversified nature friendly systems which are more resilient, more sustainable and better for people and planets if the right support was in place. So again, this goes back to those conversations that we've been having previously. In this survey, 94% of UK farmers surveyed would switch to less intensive systems if the right incentives were there. Almost three quarters, 74%, believe public investment in

farming should focus on mitigating and adapting to climate change. 83% said funding should be used to encourage less industrial meat production. And of course, you know, over the course of the last few decades, there has been an awful lot of subsidy that has basically been used to produce as much food, as many calories as possible. And we keep saying, don't we, that we need a change. And I keep hearing messages from farmers saying we'd love to be able to change. By and large, we'd love to be able to do the right thing. We just need to be able to make a living. They, you know, at the end of the day, what we need from farming is to be able to buy our

kids Christmas presents, send our kids to school, go on holiday, you know, perhaps once a year. And that doesn't seem to be an awful lot to ask. So if there is a way of using SFI and public procurement, of making sure that markets function properly, all these things that we've been talking about before, then hopefully we can inspire farmers to move in the right direction. Absolutely and and I look I I my emotional attachment is is so much greater to those, you know, those kind of extensively grazed livestock to more intensively. I would much rather see that now

am I aware that there is a huge amount of Gray area and nuance around what sustainable actually looks like, whether it's cruel and inverted commas to keep an animal and a shed. That's a whole nother topic, which I'm sure we'll return to another day. I think we do need to be slightly wary of when we start to talk about, you know, industrial and intensive and exactly what we mean by that. What I. Mean by that is fossil fuel intensive. Yep. And we, we absolutely need to reduce our reliance on fossil fuels, if only to improve the resilience of our own

businesses. And, and sort of, you know, and we look, we, we know we agree on this, but no, absolutely, look, let's say as a, as a sort of a, as a key starting point, I absolutely would like to see more of this kind of extensively produced livestock. And however, however, it is just absolutely critical that we address essentially the market economics of that. And that's, that's what it all comes down to. Farmers will produce food in whatever way society wants them to produce it. But as you've said, Finlay, then we have to, we have to address

the economics, we have to address then trade competition as well within that. So it is just, it's a hugely, hugely complex issue. It sounds great. We all want to do it, public wants it, or at least they think they do, but we need to then create the conditions to enable farmers to move in this direction and as we've seen with the organic sector for generations, that is where we have the challenge. Yeah, absolutely. But it's about making sure that that food remains affordable. And that again is the role of government, isn't it?

If government and the public value cheaper food and, you know, food that people can afford, quite rightly, then there is a role for government in making sure that farmers are able to make that transition, you know, affordably and that the food remains at prices that people can, can buy so that everybody is able to eat sustainably and regeneratively. And I guess this, you know, this is about the food and the prices that consumers are paying, that customers are paying in the supermarkets or, or wherever else they get their food. But it's also about farmers making sure that their farm will still be there in a year's time, in a decade's time, and making

sure that there is resilience in that system. And as we know, you know, the less sustainable that farm is, the the lower level of resilience that farm has. And you were pointing out a couple of articles, both of which happened to be on the Guardian, where UK farmers lose 800 million after heat and drought cause one of the worst harvests on record. Obviously soil health and water holding, water cycling really critical in terms of dealing with that. And then there was another one which was borrowed time, crop pests and food losses supercharged by climate crisis. I'm going to hand over to you

just to say that, you know, in a few weeks time we'll be doing a panel on integrated pest management, which I hope that people will be able to tune in for learning about how to reduce those crop pests using other insects and so on within those systems. Oh, super TuneIn on that one. Yes, look, this is just more, more evidence of the impact of essentially of climate change on our, on our food system, on farm economics, on our on, on availability of food. So yeah, the Guardian, well, it was actually the economy, the ECIU, the economics and what's what what do they stand for,

Finlay? In the Energy and Intelligence unit. That's right. So yeah, they're always putting out some some really good stuff just sort of highlighting issues such as this. And yeah, 800 million in, in lost productivity from just the you just the English arable sector last year as a result of, of, of one of the most, you know, historically pour harvest. We've had 2 billion lost just in the English arable sector since 2020 due to extreme weather. We've had the three lowest harvest totals in the last five years than we have in data going

back to 1984. So, you know, climate change really is starting to impact. I've run some numbers actually last night and we all know that yields have kind of plateaued in, in, in, in the UK in recent decades. They are now declining. You know, we are now starting to see a decline in yields of some of our key crops. You know, the good years are potentially better than they've ever been, but there are now the volatility has now become so great that the bad years are much worse than they've ever been. So we are now starting to see these declines in overall yield. And you know, globally, the

other piece from the garden was talking about as much as 40% decreases in some of our key crops like rice, wheat, maize in the coming decades as a result just of increased pest pressure in a in a warming climate. That's excluding all of the other issues that might come with with climate change. This is just talking about insect pests. So I think what what this demonstrates is again, look, the danger of very brittle monocultures supported by large amounts of inputs. You know, where you've got essentially the perfect breeding ground for pests, where you've got the perfect storm, if you like, in terms of impact by

extreme weather and the benefits of moving to a more regenerative system for all the reasons that you always highlight Finlow to more diverse systems. But, but, but, but of course, again, we need to find the market economic mechanism that can help more farmers transition, transition towards that. And that is the the absolute key point here. The other thing I just wanted to bring up before I bring you back in Finlay was also, you know, I, I posted about these, these two pieces from the Guardian just highlighting the real world and measurable impacts of climate change on food production and the amount of of incredibly

angry kickback you always get online about this. Now, I don't know how much of that is literally just computer generated bots. How much of? Twitter specifically. Absolutely. But it's absolutely crazy the amount of of really, really angry kickback that I always get when I post things about climate change. It's something that we really do need to be aware of, I think. And, and, and again, I'd love to get to the source of is this a relatively small number of people who somehow managed to to magnify their their opinions on social media? Is this very widespread genuine

opinion in society that we really should, you know, we should be angry about people who are, who are highlighting the very real consequences of of climate change? Because again, the danger is, of course, politicians who blow, blow in the wind will, you know, will be influenced by, you know, very vocal, small potentially pockets of, of public opinion. And that will have, you know, potentially really dire ramifications for our ability to actually build resilience to these, to these climate impacts. So yeah, that's kind of my 2 pennies worth on this. Yeah.

I mean, there are trending conversations on that, you know, where, you know, things like net zero people will be talking and have an opinion on net 0 without really necessarily having much understanding of the, you know, the policy underpinning of of that. But I think ultimately the kind of pushback that you're getting is from often funded a very, you know, a very small minority of people, often quite well funded, deliberately putting out disinformation. And the challenge is, you know, I've been working on this in this area for well over 20 years now.

And, you know, I can remember in a, in a sort of previous incarnation where in the local newspaper, every week there would be somebody writing in with, you know, basically the same people writing in with some piece of, of, of global disinformation around climate change. And, and they'd say something stupid. But you can't just sort of kind of come back to them and say that's ridiculous because they say, well, prove it. And the amount of time that it takes to sort of take down some of this stuff, which is why it's sceptical science that's

sceptical with AK, it's sceptical science.com. I think it's such a good website still. I think it's a, a group of Australian scientists that put it together in the first instance where they basically try and hear every bit of nonsense from a climate change denier. And they, they give you the kind of the immediate response, then the kind of, I mean, that's the kind of 50 word response, then the 200 word response and then the full peer reviewed science, you know, sort of beneath that. But it's, I think it's so important to have people like

you constantly prepared to get the Flack that you do on sites like X, like Twitter, because as you say, you know, when you put this out there, I was just looking down. I mean, there's so much bile and there's so much disinformation, so much stuff, which is just quite simply wrong. But it it would take days to to rebut it's effectively and efficiently. But within that, you also had a lot of people supporting what you were saying and the basic premise behind the story. So look, we, we need to, we need

to finish. We were trying to end within the hour. We thought we might even get within 45 minutes, but I'm determined to finish within the hour. So let's do that. It's been great to talk to you again, Joe, Thanks as ever for your insights. As I say, happy New Year. I'm glad you had a good Christmas and and to everybody, Happy New Year. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast, and Farmgate Leaders and Martin's Farm and a whole host of other programs are available if you just scroll back in your

podcast feed. Farmgate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican AG, the Nature Friendly Farming Network, Friars Moore Livestock Health Agrolo and individual donors. I've been Finlay Sustain, bye for now. And I've been Joe Stanley, thanks for joining us.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 'Soil health is the north star of agriculture' - David R Montgomery on ReGen

    Nov 17, 202658 minAudio

    This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Place-based preparedness in practice

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Food industry insiders speak out

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Living adventurously" in the UK House of Lords

    Oct 30, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Is food sovereignty needed to face climate extremes?

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...

    Credit the people on this episode