This is the second of our programmes investigating the Pathways project - a 5-year EU Horizon 2020-funded research project that's been running since 2021. Today we’re looking at Pathways modelling, which addressed a range of important areas including the greenhouse gas emissions and nutritional value associated with livestock and individual food products, as well as farm animal welfare and biodiversity impacts in livestock systems. ffinlo Costain (8point9.com) is joined by Dr David Yáñez (Spanish National Research Council), Pierrick Girad (French Institute of Pork), Dr Jenny Ygnvesson (Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences) and Dr Tom Staton (University of Reading). More land use news at 8point9.com.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, welcome to Farmgate. I'm Finn Locustein, the editorof8.9.com, the land use news channel. This is the second of our programmes investigating the Pathways project A5 year EU Horizon 2020 funded research project that's been running since 2021. Pathways is coordinated by the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences and comprises 30 partners from 12 European countries. The project aims to reduce environmental impacts while addressing societal demands for safe, nutritious and affordable meat and dairy products.
Today we're looking at pathways modelling, which addressed a range of important areas, including the greenhouse gas emissions and nutritional value associated with livestock and with individual food products, as well as the farm, animal welfare and biodiversity impacts of livestock systems. I'm joined by Doctor Davidianieth, a research professor at the Spanish National Research Council, by Pierre Girar, a study engineer at the French Institute of Pork, by Doctor Jenny Inversone, an associate professor at the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, and by Doctor Tom Staton, a senior research fellow at the
University of Reading. Tom, before we discuss individual modelling projects, can I ask you how the modelling jigsaw pieces fit together under the Pathways banner and how this work underpins other research elements? Sure. So essentially under the Pathways project, we're looking to progress towards more sustainable livestock systems. But to do that, we need to measure progress. So what does sustainability look like? How can we measure it? How can we measure our progress towards it? And that's where where these tools and models come in that we'll be talking about today. And in pathways, we're using
various different models and tools really to answer different questions related to sustainability. So in this way, we can look at livestock systems from some different perspectives related to sustainability and welfare. And some of these perspectives that we'll be talking about today include greenhouse gas emissions, diets, biodiversity and animal welfare. So when the greenhouse gases, David has been working on demystifying some of the complexities around estimating greenhouse gas emissions in livestock management and how that's affected by management choices. But also when we're thinking
about livestock systems, we also need to look at the demand side, so things like consumer choices and diets. So Pierrich has been developing a tool to look at assessing the nutrition and sustainability of diet choices. But in Pathways, we're also interested in measuring some some of the slightly trickier concepts like animal welfare and biodiversity. And these are very broad terms. So we've been looking at whether we can develop easily measurable indicators to assess farm management practices in a simple way. So essentially these these tools
and models are really essential to support as transition towards sustainability and livestock systems. Because ultimately, if we can't measure and monitor these things, then we can't assess our progress and and we don't know where we are. And Tom, I think one of the policy frustrations that farmers often have is that there there tends to be a sort of hierarchy within the policy world of which metric, which element of these things is most important. And, you know, we'll come on to greenhouse gases in the moment because there is a bit of a frustration that there is a sense that that mitigation and greenhouse gases are more
important than all of these other things. From an academic perspective, however, it's really important to be able to break these things apart, isn't it? To be able to understand greenhouse gas emissions in detail, to be able to understand the biodiversity elements in detail so that those things can then be brought together. And it's then the role of policymakers and NGOs and and other people working in that space to make sure that they fit the the jigsaw pieces together adequately. Is that fair? Yeah, exactly. Yes, sustainability is a, is a very broad concept. And in Pathways we're trying to take a, a holistic view.
It's not just about greenhouse gas emissions and carbon. That's often where the focus is these days. But we're taking a very broadview and including animal welfare in that as well, which we'll be talking about today, which is, yeah, taking this, this wider One Health view of of the system. And David, let's start with greenhouse gas modelling in that case, because I think as I say, from a farmer perspective, particularly a regenerative farmer perspective, this is probably one of the more controversial elements, as I say, because we've been looking at this through a policy lens and, and how policy gets
applied. But your work here is of course based on emissions averages. But you're working to update this information, aren't you? Based on the 58 project defined farm system types Is is that essentially correct? Yeah, that's right. Good morning. First, before we define the different emissions for different system, we need to characterise those systems. Livestock production in Europe and in general is very diverse, adapted to different ecosystems, habitats, cultural contexts, and we needed to define those systems before we could actually
see the progress of those systems, in our case in terms of greenhouse gases emissions. So can you talk me through perhaps one or two of those systems and and give me some examples of of how and why greenhouse gas emissions differ within those systems? There are different greenhouse gases produced in in in the livestock production systems and and all of them come from biological processes. So for instance, methane coming from the fermentation in the stomach of of ruminants differ across different systems
depending on the quality of the diet. So we need to define the type of diet that those animals receive and then how we can improve the quality of that diet to really reduce the emissions of methane for instance. But there are other emissions coming from feed production from more intensive systems. So we need to also define to what extent those system acquire inputs from outside the farm to really quantify the emissions that are coming from the system. So there there is a range of different situations that need to really pre be defined and characterized before we can go
deeper into those systems to really see how much emissions they they emit. So for example, are you integrating the emissions associated for example with growing the soya or or crops that are used to produce the feed that are then fed to animals that are housed indoors or is it simply you're looking at the emissions from the the livestock themselves? Well, in our case in in the work we did in updating the the emission values, we focus on the emissions coming from the farms. So the ones coming in from the
digestion and for storing the manure or carbon sequestration. So we would touching all the elements happening, we did the farm, but specifically adapted to the kind of systems. So whether animals were grazing or whether the grass was fertilized in two different using different systems or whether the manure was stored in in a solid or in a liquid form etcetera. So all those possibilities were considered and but yeah, focusing specifically on on on
what was happening in the farm. Lots of different elements there. How did you actually, you know, take those measurements, What sort of equipment, what sort of how are you assessing those emissions? Yeah, that's a very important question. First, as I said, we we need to define the different systems and see how they operate in terms of land use, in terms of feeding system, in terms of intensity, density of animals etcetera. And then we we needed to see what indicators or what emission values were already allocated by the IPCC, the reference
internationally, and then how we could get more details into how those system could operate and what the bibliography and the literature could could offer. And in other cases, we have to actually measure directly how much methane or CO2 nitrous oxide was produced. So we combined a mix of literature review and also direct measurements to really update those values. And what we did in the end is to develop a kind of tool where any user that was interested in
getting to know more detailed emissions from a specific system, you could see what options they have in terms of either modelling or direct experimental measuring to get to know in more detail the type of emissions that come from from the system. Thank you. Thanks very much for that. It's really fascinating to hear you know that level of detail. And as I mentioned, farmers listening will be concerned that a focus on greenhouse gas emissions alone risks distorting views of sustainability. So pasture based livestock are often the most efficient when it
comes to a combination of climate adaptation, biodiversity restoration, carbon sequestration and water management. But they are seen as much less efficient in terms of pure emissions and that's often where the policy focus sits. So how does the modelling and the Pathways project overall deal with this apparent contradiction in terms of efficiency? Yeah, this is a a complex issue and obviously a simple answer. It's not, it's not, it's not easy either. I think here our role as scientists is very important and, and to show that large the production has many different
elements in terms of sustainability and some can be positive and some of this can be no so positive. And, and the idea is to 1st define those systems in in detail. And then it's about optimizing them as much as you can in the different context where they operate. So we we don't want to compare intensive, extensive and say this is better than the other because they both are needed in the different places. So, so first is to have this multi element concept where we have a holistic view. And again, greenhouse gas
emissions is just part of the human activity. Any human activity generates greenhouse emissions, including livestock. So it's not just to put the focus on livestock, it's to try to improve as much as possible livestock production from that end. But then, of course, there are any other ends, any other elements that need to be considered, as Tom said, in, in terms of animal welfare, food production, food supply, etcetera. So it's assessing and comparing different systems, but then looking at those systems and saying that whatever the system is, there are potential
improvements that can be made there. And so looking on a sort of system by system basis, I suppose. And obviously the focus of this particular program is tools for decision making. So in terms of that, how do you expect your research to be used? Yeah. The the tool we we have developed in particular in in the greenhouse gases space is basically to provide different stakeholders A relatively simple view of what tools they have available to estimate or to measure directly how much greenhouse gases emissions the
systems produce. And you can go into very detailed and technical aspects, but in our case that was not intention. The intention is just to provide a good overview of what options there are whether you work in ruminants or monogastrix or indoors, outdoors. So the project is going to have an online tool where any people or company enterprise interested in first accounting for their emissions and improving their emissions to get to know what
options there are available depending on your budget and and your needs and your time frame etcetera. So this is one of our contributions as a project to provide that tool to any any user. Lovely. Thanks so much, David Pierik. I'd like to move on to talking about food baskets, which is a consumer facing outcome from the project. I think it's sort of the key consumer facing outcome. This provides users with the opportunity to assess the sustainability impact and nutritional value of their weekly shopping basket. Would you be able to talk me through Food Basket 7, what it looks like, how it can be used,
and what it actually tells us? Thank you. Finlow Food Basket 7 Sorry is essentially free and practical web-based tool designed it to evaluate, as you said, weekly food basket from both nutritional and environmental perspective. So you can find the link of the of the tool in the password project. But the idea is very simple. So first user need to define their profile to estimate their nutritional needs or second user
enter the food they want the plan to buy or they want to consume over a week. It also work for one day but it's always better over a week. This can include single ingredients but also already complete meal and you can also choose your portion size or even customize your own food items if you want. And once the basket is built, the tool automatically analyze the basket and using several indicator. So first it looks the nutrition
quality with key nutrients for instance like proteins, energy, some vitamins like B12, AC, etcetera and also iron, some trace element and and minerals such iron etcetera. And secondly, it's also evaluates environmental impact of the food baskets such as greenhouse emission, but also land use, water scarcity, particle matter traffication, etcetera. And so, so this data come from
life cycle assessment database called Equivalis. And basically what makes the tool interesting is, is that it does not assess one product. It assess basket as a wall which is much closer to how people actually eat. And so food basket seven help user to better understand trade off about nutrition and environment, environment and and so in short, it transform complex scientific data into something more practical and understandable for for real food
choices with colour bar with visual figure and also information boxes for instance. And I'm just wondering how the food basket tool links to the rest of the Pathways project, whether you're drawing on data that that already existed prior to the project or whether you're integrating this new work that's taken place, for example, the greenhouse gas modelling that David's been working on. Is it of course linked to other task of the password project? But it's actually it's not directly linked to the work for instance of David of other
colleague of the pathway. So, you know, large part of the of the work of the password project is generated scientific knowledge or data on life talk system. So I would say it password project is more a project of production and especially animal production in in Europe and food basket is more a tool for consumption. So it's not always easy to link the two approaches. But we are evaluating with the tool, with the food basket 7
tool, some future food basket, which are link to some scenarios in the life tax system in order to determine their potential nutritional impact on the population and especially for target population surcharge for for some elderly or pregnant women etcetera. So it's sort of used, you know, different sort of stages of people's lives as well exactly to provide that, that kind of holistic information. And I'm just wondering how the nutritional values are assessed for the tool. You know where that information
comes from? So the nutritional assessment is based on 2 different data. This first one is a standard food composition database such as the French SQL database and on the second hand on dietary reference reference value recognized by the European Food safety authorities. So EFSA. So we need to compare these two to know if we cover our needs or not in some nutrients. So we had to work with several doctor in nutrition in inside of
the password project to to build to build the tool and we define at the and 28 essential nutrients. So yeah, I told you protein, but also a lot of vitamins and and minerals. Also, I want to to add something we are able to calculate with scientific equations the bioavailability of some nutrients such as iron and zinc. And this is only possible because we have a wider vision of what is eaten in the food basket.
For instance, if I eat a food rich in Iran with another food reaching in fitat, for instance, we know that fitat will reduce the absorptions of iron by the body. And so this is only possible to calculate this food integration because we have a wider view, because we look at the World Food basket and not one food item. Yeah, that's really interesting. I think it's, it's really helpful to have that bioavailability element within that that often sort of seems to be missing from, from other, you
know, not necessarily similar nutrition tools, but, but often it seems like sort of quite raw information that you're getting. But when you're able to make that comparison within the tool itself to see, you know, what, how and whether people are actually getting the nutrition that's theoretically there, that's that's really useful. Now, I've used Food Basket 7 myself and it is quite time consuming to work through every meal and each ingredients as an individual consumer. But I can imagine the tool being really very helpful for caterers in particular, for example, for assessing the value of school
meals or well, you know, any institutional catering context really. Who would you say are the main target users for the tool? Yeah, you're right. It can take quite a while to to fill in the seven days to create a weekly food basket. But first we would like to work on the next version of AV2, let's say to integrate planning assistance to that could potentially incorporate maybe artificial intelligence to help and to help the user to build
the food basket. But concerning the target user, this is a good question because the potential user are broader that only individual consumer at the beginning consumer of of course the main audience, especially people we are motivated to better understand the impact of their food choices on environmental and and nutritional point of view. But as you mentioned, entering every ingredient can take time, so the stronger use case may also be professional.
For instance, as you say, school caterer, hospital, universities, counting, etcetera. They could use a tool to compare individual menu or weekly menu plan and they often need to balance the nutritional budget, accessibility and sustainability at the same time. So it could of course help, but it was also built for researcher. We want to to illustrate our dietary shift affect multiple outcome. And it's also some some people
that can also use a tool. Brilliant. I certainly think it would be extremely useful for the people who theoretically at least plan the school meals across in the UK. They there's definitely some room for improvement there now Jenny, just sort of coming across to you and thank you for your patience. Agroecology, obviously, you know, has many different facets to it and farm animal welfare is an important one, and that's the focus of your research. I wonder if you could tell me about this part of the project and what you were setting out to achieve with it. One of the goals was to see if
we could find animal welfare iceberg indicators. So animal welfare cannot be measured in itself, but we can measure indicators that sort of give us an estimate of animal welfare. And animal welfare is how the animal is perceiving its environment and its situation. So it's really what the animals, their opinion. About their lives. So that's sort of what we're trying to to get AT. And if we could find these iceberg indicators, which are feasible easily assessed
indicators that give us information about welfare, preferably about a large part of the whole animal population. And we have a lot of animals in Europe and a lot of different species. So finding these indicators is not so easy and it's even debated whether they actually exist. But we have a few that we have sort of based on previous research and also their feasibility that we can look at and and at least think that there might be iceberg indicators. So that's one one part of what we're trying to do.
And then we also try to incorporate animal welfare in life cycle analysis. So we could really include animal welfare in the social part of sustainability, if sustainability is economy, environmental impact and the social aspects of production. When we spoke previously, you talked about the way in which, you know, when you start looking at farm animal welfare indicators, there are potentially thousands of them that you've been trying to narrow down to these sets of iceberg indicators. As you say, smaller sets of metrics where the information
they're providing is greater than the sum of their part. How did you go about sort of, you know, looking at those thousands and then bringing them down to a, a group of a dozen or or 20? We started out with a, a sort of scientific approach. So we did a literature review and we also used that's a great set of experts within pathways. So we, we defined these indicators and we looked for them in scientific literature and we categorised them. David mentioned these different systems. So we tried to and, and relate them to the systems that the
animals are in and of course the species, because it will vary a lot what indicators you can actually look at. And then we looked at their relevance. And that's the relevance for of course, the animal and the farmers, the consumers and other parts of the food chain. And then we also looked at feasibility, can we actually measure them? And it boiled down to a lot fewer than those thousands of indicators that we could actually practically use and that actually mattered. So that's the first part of the approach. And then after we had sort of boiled down to these fewer
indicators, we ran them through the consortium. So we validated them in both the people who are working within pathways and also our multi actor platform, which is stakeholders in the food food chain that are not farmers. So we also ran the indicators through those in in the workshop process. And then we finally asked our farmers, which are involved in pathways, what they thought about the indicators and what indicators mattered to them. And they got a large set of indicators that were
specifically picked from their type of systems and their animal species, of course. So the beef farmers, for example, did not have to validate the pig animal welfare indicators and. We'll come on to specifically what the farmers were doing and what we'll have a look at that in just a moment. I'm interested in the LCA's, their life cycle assessments because, you know, the idea of of narrow bring down trying to develop iceberg indicators, I think that's something that that's relatively familiar to me. Hopefully it'll be reasonably familiar to many of the people listening. The idea that you have an indicator which essentially can
measure something in itself, but also offer a proxy for other, other elements around environmental or, or welfare. But I'm not so familiar with how this fits within life cycle assessments and I wonder if you could just talk me through that element. Actually, life cycle assessment is not my expertise, but I'll give it a go. So you can, you can put in in some really blunt indicators, but they are still highly relevant for both the animals, for the farmers, for consumers and for the rest of the food
chain. And, and that's one example is mortality. And if you die as an animal during the production cycle, we can assume that it's often connected to some sort of suffering, which sort of makes it relevant for from an animal welfare perspective. And this indicator is also really relevant for profitability. So it has a lot of relevance for other parts of of sustainability. And of course animals that do not enter the food chain, they are sort of wasted. So they will their environmental
impact is is pointless or didn't bring any good. So therefore mortality is an important indicator that should be included or can fairly easily be included in a life cycle assessment. But then when we look at more sophisticated assessments, for example animal behaviour, and we can even go as far as look at positive animal welfare and, and, for example, play behaviour, positive social interactions between animals, positive interactions between animals and caretakers or farmers, then it becomes of
course much more difficult. How do we assess that? How can we quantify a social positive interaction between a calf and a farmer compared to a cow and a farmer, for example? And here there's a lot of research to do before we can actually both assess this this indicator and include it in some sort of model. Really interesting and of course, as you say that being able to assess and model those natural behaviours is is a tenet of positive welfare assessments.
Really interesting and I think it would be helpful to bring some of this work to life. And probably the easiest way to do that is to talk through some of the key metrics, for example, for Beef Catalina. And I wonder if you could just talk me through some of the key indicators and also how they were actually measured in the practice hubs, because we haven't really talked about the practice hubs much, but they've been, you know, a fundamental part again of the pathways project where you have farmers working on the ground in different European countries, you know, actually testing some of the works that you've been doing. So, so just some of the the beef cattle indicators and how they
were measured. Absolutely. So the example here is beef farmers and they happen to be in Sweden. So it's Northern Europe where we have a period when the animals are indoors in the winter. But this indicator validation was done in the spring when the cattle were outdoors. And that might be the the reason that the farmers were really interested in in more or less only animal based indicators. So we can sort of categorize in indicators in resource based, like how large space do the
animals have in a pen and how much space do they have at the, the feed through or whatever. And then we can also look at management based indicators. But in this case the farmers were were really interested in animal based indicators. So they first had a training where they could sort of get to know the indicators and how to assess them. So for example, they were trained in lameness scoring, they were trained in, in body condition scoring and, and they know all the these things beforehand, but they, they might not have the, the scales or the assessment tools and, and have
words or a map of how, what is a good body condition, for example. Then they were also trained in pain phase. They did a small test of this human animal interaction. Could they approach their cows? Were they afraid? Did they see play behaviors in the calves? So those were indicators that really all of were very. We had had very good feedback from the farmers. They found it really interesting and, and especially this with a pain face was like an hard experience for the farmers because they were feeling sort of in their gut, there's something wrong with this
animal, but they didn't have the words to describe it. And when they sort of looked at the facial expression of the cows, not in pain and in pain, then then pieces sort of fell into place. Yeah, I think that's really interesting because of course, you know, anybody with kids knows that, you know, there are different expressions and you can you can tell fairly quickly if if a child what is certainly, you know, especially if you're working as a teacher, you can tell by looking at different children. Which again, I suppose is sort of like having animals in a in a
farm or in a field situation where you've got 30 different kids or 30 different cattle and you can see the different expressions and, and whether there's there's pain coming in. And because of course we're humans, we're used to looking at that sort of thing. So really fascinating that you can do that with livestock as well and that you can train the farmers to do it. But there were other indicators weren't there as as well that you were looking at with you talked about body condition, but also hoof health and the way that the gut was working and and that sort of thing as well. Exactly. So there was a whole range of
around 20 indicators that ended up in our self-assessment tool. Brilliant. And I'm just looking down the list that I made before and a nose discharge was there as well. So you're sort of looking at every end of the animal and also the expressions and the and the general condition. Really interesting Jenny, in terms of tools for decision making, how do you expect or hope that this work is going to be used in the future? For the self-assessment tool, there are some tools already available and they, they empower farmers because having somebody
else come in and audit your farm or your animals and the work you do might be really valuable. But but having the, the power yourself to see both the current state and, and then do an intervention and do a reassessment to see did it work like I hoped it would. That is really empowering farmers. And we see that these self-assessment tool, they are, they are used quite frequently and they, they are very meaningful to, to the farmers. It sort of gives them the, a tool to, to do this
self-assessment and, and check whether my investment or a training of some sort did it work, did it have an effect? So I think that is the what we hope for. Fantastic. And Tom, just finally, let's move on to talking about biodiversity. And I wonder if you could talk to me about how your work fits within Pathways. Yeah, it's important firstly to recognise the importance of biodiversity for sustainability in livestock systems. And so for example, in the UK, some estimates suggest that we've lost about 97% of our
species which grassland over the last century, which I think is an astonishing figure really. And there's a similar picture in in many parts of Europe. And so restoring this biodiversity in livestock production systems as well as conserving the little species which grassland that we have left is a really essential part of the sustainability picture. And within Pathways, our biodiversity work sits alongside some the greenhouse gas and welfare indicators we've been talking about. So aiming to make biodiversity visible and the same conversations that we're already
having around emissions, welfare and system change. And specifically we've been aiming to develop grassland biodiversity indicators that could actually be used in practice. This is similar to what Jenny was talking about with animal welfare, but with the focus on on biodiversity. So the focus is very much on involving farmers in recording and monitoring biodiversity on their own farmers, so not just relying on ecologists to do that. And there's a few reasons for that. I guess one of the main reasons is that there's a lot more farmers out there than there are
ecologists. So the more we can engage farmers in monitoring biodiversity, the better we can understand how grassland management impacts biodiversity and also the more we can reconnect farmers with grassland biodiversity. I think many farmers are are interested in biodiversity anyway. So it's about trying to re establish that connection and that appreciation of university in grasslands. Yeah. And it's really interesting when you talk about that sort of re engagement because of course a lot of farmers are interested in in what's going on and they have
a general sense of how well nature is doing. But having gone through, you know, different processes, whether it's for example, having specifically going through a bird count to to identify particular birds, they'll learn those particular skills. And then that will be inherent in in that kind of, you know, self-assessment as as they're going forward. And again, as you mentioned you you're trying to find ways of simpler infield biodiversity assessment. So I wonder how you went about, you know, testing could be because there were so many different metrics that you could choose. So how did you go about testing the existing metrics in terms of
their effectiveness, ease of use and repeatability? Yeah. So we, we started from a a pretty basic question really, which is what, what information can farmers realistically collect themselves without relying on specialist training And a lot of time we know farmers are all busy. So to answer that we combined three things and I like in Pathways, firstly we did a review of existing biodiversity monitoring scheme. So as you say there there is a lot already out there. So we looked at what is already out there and has been out there which have involved farmers in monitoring biodiversity.
And then secondly, which was related to that, we also carried out interviews with some of the people who were involved in designing and running those schemes. And we really wanted to get a feel from them as to what worked well, what didn't work well and what lessons we can learn from them. And thirdly, we aim to develop a simple methodology for farmers to monitor their own grassland biodiversity and compared this with a more detailed ecological assessment of the same grassland to look at whether farmers can reliably record biodiversity and how that compares to a more
detailed assessment. So this allows us to to assess these indicators not just on their scientific credibility, but also their ease of use, which turned out to be just as important, really. And presumably you were working through those practice hubs again to, to to assess these different elements and, and I think you found that counting Forbes was the best proxy for assessing broader biodiversity. Tell me a bit about how you came to that conclusion and how those assessments are actually taken. Yes, that was a really interesting finding. So when we did our, our field
testing of a, of a simple protocol, we looked at how different simple plant based indicators related to a more detailed assessment. And we focused on plants just because we know that they're quite good indicators for other biodiversity groups like insects and birds, really just because they sit at the base of the food chain. But also they're quite relatively accessible. You know, they don't run away from you, they don't hide when it's raining or anything like that. You can go out at any time and measure them. And So what we did was we went out into these practice hubs and
we focused on it's Subs in in three countries, so the UK, Sweden and Romania, so looking in different contexts. And we took farmers out into one of their fields and we measured out five by 5m quadrats. And we simply asked the farmer to record the number of forb species. So a forb is just a plant that's not a grass basically. Can you give us some examples? Yeah, so things like Daisy, Clover, dandelion, knapweed. So lots, lots out there. Any plant that's that's not a grass.
So we measured out the quadrat, asked the farmer, how many Forbes species do you think are in this quadrat? They didn't even need to be able to identify to species level. They might just say, well, I reckon there's 15 different Forbes species in this quadrat. And the farmers really varied in, in terms of their attention to detail. Some really got down on their hands and knees and gave us a really detailed species list. Others were a bit busy that day and just kind of had a bit of a guess. So surprisingly, what we found was that their estimates were actually statistically significantly correlated with a
more detailed botanical assessment of the same grassland, Despite that variation in their attention to detail in doing that assessment. So this really shows that biodiversity monitoring it, you know, it doesn't have to be complicated. We can use simple measures like that so to monitor what's in the grassland. Yeah, really interesting. And I don't suppose it's an easy question to answer, but is there a sense that a particular number of Forbes within that 5 by 5 metre square is, is, is good in if you had 15, would that be at the high end of, of of Forbes
count or or would it be sort of bang in the middle or at the low end? Yeah, 15 is pretty good in a 5 by 5 metre quadrat, so that's getting pretty good. It buries a lot on country. So we did the testing in Romania and that was particularly species rich. So that was very much at the higher end. The UK is, yeah, we've been putting a lot of effort into intensifying our our grassland production. And so species diversity has declined. And so overall the the average was lower there. But yeah, that's the other thing that it can be used is to benchmark against a kind of average or typical value if you
like. Fantastic. I feel an experiment with the kids coming on this weekend. That's that's very helpful. And I just wonder how you expect this assessment approach to be used in the future? Yeah. So I think both as a monitoring tool and a learning tool. So really we've showed that the biodiversity monitoring can be simple. This is one way of doing it. Just by counting Forbes. There's lots of other ways of simply monitoring biodiversity. There's lots of technology out there nowadays like phone apps that will identify birds and and plants and things like that. So it's becoming much more accessible now.
And so monitoring biodiversity like this can be a really useful way for farmers to to track change over time to see how their management decisions influence biodiversity. And just a benchmark, as you say, comparing their grassland to an average or typical value. So ultimately, I think all all of this is about trying to lower the barrier to, to people engaging with biodiversity again. So making biodiversity something that that people and farmers can measure and that they can appreciate rather than being a, a purely specialist subject. And I think just to reiterate
that it's, this isn't just about collecting data to protect biodiversity for its own right. It's also about that reconnection and that reengagement and that appreciation and just noticing what we already have. And it's also important, I think to recognise that the the functional role of biodiversity in grasslands. So it's again not just an ethical duty to conserve and restore biodiversity, but there's lots of emerging evidence that diversity can help improve grass and resilience to drought, for example, which is becoming more and more of a
problem in many parts of Europe. I can also help with things like animal health and the quality of livestock products. So it's a lot more than just ethical obligations or hitting policy targets. It's about re establishing that connection to nature and part of that bigger picture about building more sustainable and resilient and and healthy production systems. That's been really interesting. We've had a good chat through the different sort of elements of of the work that you've all done individually and just to sort of bring us towards a conclusion, I'm just sort of, you know, a few more general questions I suppose.
And Jenny, you were one of the originators of the Pathways project and clearly this modelling workers both updated existing data sets and provided important architecture for other research in the future. So I wonder how you expect the research and the tools that have been created for Pathways to be used in the future by both the academic establishment and other external stakeholders. I think one of the main take on messages from Pathways is that to achieve change, which is really what we want, we want to work on this path towards
sustainability in livestock production. We need to work with all stakeholders and that was part of path pathways idea or or solo whatever from the very beginning. So one tool that has been developed in many other projects but also refining pathways is for example a facilitator toolkit. So with this practice hubs and also other groups of stakeholders within Pathways, they always need a trained facilitator and this training and the skills by the
facilitators who lead these groups towards innovation, they need to become created so that they're owned by the facilitators in a mental sense. So that's one really important thing. And then we also picked up on a tool called the public goods tool, which I think will be, it's been changed in Pathways, a bit modernized and more welfare is added. And it gives a really good basis of discussion between, for example, an assessor or a facilitator and the farmer or a group of farmers, a really good
visual view of what sustainability strengths and weaknesses this system or this farm has. So those are some other tools that I think are going to be used in further sustainability work. Yeah, brilliant. And David, we started discussing this earlier in the programme, but if policymakers were to take any single aspect of academic research more broadly, I suppose. But but if the pathways work, they might end up with a distorted perspective, you know, in favour of greenhouse gases or in favour of welfare, biodiversity, et cetera, et cetera.
But the impact of livestock systems, of course, is multifaceted. How do you ensure that the project contributes to a more holistic understanding of livestock systems, which was, you know, the basis that Pathways started from in the first place? Yeah, I think basically Pathways is going to provide like and holistic message to policy makers trying to make them understand that many different elements and none is more important than the other and they all need to be considered
as much as possible. So greenhouse gases emissions is just one element and and again it's a biological process happening in in food production chain and that can be improved but cannot be avoided. So, and, and so that kind of message, I think is, is, is important and, and, and there are tools now available to understand in more detail how those gases are emitted and how we can measure and estimate them, especially knowledge in the diversity of systems that we
have in Europe. And, and therefore we can try to improve the sustainability of those systems in in a specific aspects of those systems and you know, as an overall exercise which is very complex. Fantastic. And Tom, just finally, do you have a sense of what's next? This phase of pathways is coming to an end. What's next in terms of modelling and tools and life cycle assessments? So what are the continuing knowledge gaps that you think that you've identified as a result of the project and that need addressing? Yeah. I think what comes next is
probably not so much about building and developing ever more complex tools and models, but more about consolidating and extending what we already have and working on that usability. And that's really the big opportunity here is that is that usability and many of the indicators and tools that we've be talking about today, I think we now need to work on really embedding them in decision making, decision support systems, also advisory and ultimately making these tools and indicators things that people can use on on a
day-to-day basis. And that's really where a lot of the impacts will come from. So yeah, Pathways isn't really an end point. It's more about building that foundation and sharing how these integrated and practice grounded tools can work, and pointing to where future research and innovation efforts should focus on that usability. Thanks so much for that. And I think it's been really, really fascinating listening to the work that you've all been doing and what you've been trying to do within Pathways. Because you know, there has been this challenge in the past with academia where, you know, just the nature of research is that
you're studying one element in, in quite a lot of detail. But Pathways has been all about bringing back this information together into one place and trying to understand the jigsaw puzzle effectively as a as a whole picture. And the challenge now, I suppose, is for people within the policy world, within NGOs or farming establishments, policymakers themselves, to try and get a better understanding of this, this sort of integrated work that's taken place so that they themselves aren't prioritizing one measure 1
aspect of sustainability over and above the other, which of course has been a policy challenge over the course of the last decade or two. So I think, you know, clearly this work is, is, is hugely important going forward. Well, look, that's it. That's that's all we have time for. I'd like to thank my guests, Tom Staton, Jenny Inverson, Pierreck Shiva and Zavid Yanieff. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more. Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. You can sign up for our free weekly newsletter@8.9.com. That's the number 8, the word
point and the #9.com. Farmgate is Europe's highest ranking food security podcast and we're partof8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is supported by First Milk, Pelican AG, the Nature Friendly Farming Network, Friars Moore Livestock Health, the Royal Agricultural University Agrolo and individual donors. I've been thin loca stain bye for now.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...