We focus on natural capital opportunities for farmers in Scotland. How can farmers and other land owners get support and earn an income by improving nature and selling natural capital outcomes. ffinlo Costain is joined by Bruce Wilson, Head of Policy and Advocacy at Scottish Wildlife Trust - by David Robertson, Director of Investment and Business Development at Scottish Woodlands Limited - and by Johnnie Balfour, Managing Partner at Balbirnie Home Farms. #soilcarbon #carbonfarming #regenerativefarming #resilience #biodiversity #rivers #watermanagement #forests #timber #forestcarbon #trees #nature #naturefriendly
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello, welcome to Farmgate. I'm Finn Locustein, the editorof8.9.com. The UK's made-up of Four Nations, each operating independently in terms of farming and land use policy. Today we're focusing on natural capital delivery in Scotland and how farmers and other land owners can get support and earn an income by improving nature and selling natural capital outcomes. This program has been supported by the Nature Friendly Farming Network work. I'm joined by Bruce Wilson, head of policy and advocacy at the Scottish Wildlife Trust, by David Robertson, director of investment and business
development at Scottish Woodlands Limited, and by Johnny Balfour, a managing partner at Balburnie Home Farms in Fife, north of Edinburgh. Across the first of fourth. Welcome all. Let's get straight into it. Bruce. Can you set out the broad landscape for natural capital in Scotland? What's generally available to farmers and land owners? OK. I'll try and be brief and start at the top. So I mean, broadly the concept of natural capital comes from the capitals approach. It's the stocks and natural assets that underpin everything that we do in society and the economy. But as you said, you want to deal more with the sharp end of
how that can benefit farmers on the ground. So you know, you've got the things that are kind of currently in play, woodland creation, peel and restoration, habitat enhancement are the are the main ones. You've got public routes to funding those natural capital enhancements, which I think everyone's pretty well aware of. Things like the Agri Environment Climate Scheme, EATS Forestry Grant Scheme and Nature Recovery Fund, peatland action, those sorts of things. We then sort of move on to the natural capital aspects. There's relatively established carbon approaches, so the peatland code and the Woodland
code are the gold standard for those ones and those are the ones that people are probably most accustomed to. There's also discussion about lots of other codes at the moment, so soil carbon codes and, and various other things on the biodiversity market front. On natural capital, it's a bit more blended and not as established at the moment. The Scottish Government is trying to build a whole framework around this. So we've got principles for responsible investment in natural capital. We've got the natural capital market framework and there's a developing prospectus of natural capital investments, but those
tend to be a blend of carbon and, and various other things. There's also an emerging compliance market. Your listeners have probably heard of biodiversity net gain in Scotland. We refer refer to that as positive effects for biodiversity that's starting to trickle through our planning system now. So we've got developments require EI as are are sort of how to find these positive effects for biodiversity and those developers are starting to approach people. So the Scottish Wildlife Trust and you know, other big organizations like RSPB and others will already be getting
approached by developers looking for things they can create that benefit projects that can create that benefit through. But that in the Scottish Wildlife Trust opinion needs to start filtering down to farmers and there needs to be a bit of government intervention in there to help build pipelines so that farmers can be well positioned to deliver on these things. Couple of big things I see emerging that are their problem is the lack of landscape scale planning in Scotland at the moment. So aggregation of projects into an investment level thing is very difficult to do. You know, if you've got 4 hectares of woodland creation,
that's not really going to be of interest to to an investor. It might be on a, on a sort of compliance project in the planning side, but the scales not quite there and the fact that our new Agri bill and and the ACT doesn't really have any consideration to how private finance might come into the funding space there. So we do need to address those if we want to make things as easy as possible for farmers to to realize these opportunities. Without that, it's going to be pretty difficult. Fantastic. That was that was a really excellent overview there. Bruce, thanks so much for that. And it's really interesting to
sort of, you know, think about the amount of work that's taking place at sort of government level, the amount of thought that's happening. But as you were saying, it's about addressing those pipelines, making sure that the pipelines work so that actually farmers and land owners were able to benefit from these markets on the ground. And you know, we'll dip into those as we progress. But Johnny, from a farmer's perspective, why are natural capital markets important to you? For me, natural capital markets, it's another enterprise that we can stack into our Land Management decision making.
And if a natural capital market specifically excludes enterprise stacking, IE potentially being paid for doing the same work in two different ways, then I'm not that interested in it. But if I can get money for doing something, for instance get money for putting carbon into the ground while also farming and producing food. I'm doing one job farming but I'm getting paid for two outcomes.
Johnny, everyone likes being paid twice for the same work effectively. I'm just wondering why you think that's appropriate. Is it partly because neither of those markets is really paying enough for you to sort of subsist of one or the other? No, I I don't think that. I think it's a. It's a value thing. If we are doing work that is valued by a customer, that customer should pay fair value for the the outcome that we as
land managers are producing. I don't think that natural capital payments should be done on a cost basis because lots of people have already committed to doing the work for it. And the cost may have been paid for a long ago, but the outcomes are being created today. I think that everything that we should do, whether it's Land Management or anything else in our life, we should be paid appropriately for the value that
we are creating for a customer. Thanks so much. And that's that sort of concept of value is really important. And perhaps again, we'll we'll talk a bit more about that as we go forward. And that critical issue of stacking, be able to sort of blend these various different approaches and get paid for them for the being delivered together rather than simply approaching a single market. Bruce, from an NGO perspective, why are these markets important? What are the key opportunities that you see for nature and the public? There's a massive funding gap and there's actually a bit of a debate happening in Scotland about how big that funding gap is at the moment.
But anyone with practical experience of trying to deliver holistic landscape scale restoration or delivery of ecosystem services very quickly realizes it's way more complicated than putting a few trees in the ground and maybe doing a bit of peatland restoration. Particularly within the the new context of land reform and just transition. You've got to be engaged in communities on this work. I mean there's specifically a legislation coming through Parliament at the moment now that might not quite touch farm scale, but if we're talking
about aggregating up to be an investment that that is actually workable, there is going to have to be engagement on this stuff, plus all the the work around doing the actual restoration work. So there is a huge funding gap there. I mean, much, much more than is currently going in to investment in natural capital or just the environment and biodiversity, bearing in mind that this does underpin absolutely everything that we do in Scotland. So there's a huge funding problem and markets could play an important part in helping fill that that funding gap.
We're really clear though, this can't just be the government sort of leaving responsibility for funding the environment at natural capital markets, this has to be everything pulling towards meeting this colossal challenge. So this is sort of a stacking of responsibility that you're talking about. You're saying there is a huge need for nature to be recovered, there is a need for funding to do that, that the the public exchequer is is unlikely to sort of step up to the level that's necessary and therefore markets can operate within that environment alongside and stack
with that public funding. Absolutely. And it could potentially go some way to addressing some of the, the kind of market externalities that we see. I mean, should the public purse really be picking up some of the the burden of this because some of this is private benefit that's being realized. So there there could be a system where some of that money is, is invested and it is a little bit fairer. It comes right back to the pipeline though this, this can just be private sector interacting with few different land owners. It's way more complicated than that. The government is going to have to provide some of the infrastructure and make this stuff work.
Now, David Bruce mentioned the funding gap and of course you've been here before for our Filling the Funding Gap series earlier in the year, which of course was looking at the UK as a whole rather than specifically looking at individual nations, which is it's great to have you back here looking at at Scotland specifically. We're obviously going to cover some of the same ground, but you don't worry about that. And can you just talk us through the basic opportunities for integrating woodland on farms in Scotland? Yes, and, and thanks for having me back, Finn. Well, it's a pleasure to be here again. And yeah, good to be talking with the group.
You know, multiple benefits in including woodland in farms in Scotland, you shelter really, really important sheltering stop from wind and from inclement weather. You know, that's, you know, really looking at the benefits of that up to 30% better survival rates for lambs. You know where you got shelter on the site. Beasts make better use of feed, convert that feed better. And when they're not exposed to pure weather, shade is really important. We've all seen beasts coalescing around a tree and trying to hide away from, from the heat in the summer and your heat stress, you know, in cattle, especially as
a, as a major detractor from, from productivity in very hot weather. Stock management on farms really important and you know, streamlining the stock process, the stock management process, taking out those difficult parts of farms where kind of might go to, to carve in difficult places. And then you've got difficult problems with access there. Stock management is really, really important and for integrating woodland and you know, just taking out those more difficult areas to access within, within fields. Timber production, you know,
we're a forestry business. Timber production in the UK is very, very important. We import 80% of all the timber that we use. We need to generate more timber production farms doesn't need to be large scale softwood plantations. You know, I think that's really important to say that it can be smaller scale niche market and indeed firewood markets for for local consumption. So, but one of the things is access is, is absolutely key for that. You know, we need to have good access into these, into these areas. And again, nature based solutions and, and, and nature based opportunities and carbon credits, biodiversity credits,
habitat creation, habitat banks. Now, as we were talking earlier on, Bruce was talking about that biodiversity net gain that's coming in England. And we've got NPF four and Scotland National Planning Framework 4, which is pushing a lot more of developers into looking for biodiversity banks within Scotland. And, and we are doing a lot of work in that space at the moment looking for large scale developers, local developers as well who are looking for biodiversity enhancement areas. So, you know, lots of
opportunities, lots of potential. Carbon is one of the main established routes at the current time, as we know through the Woodland Carbon code. And that's one of the main focuses for people. And we always say to clients and farmers when they're planting, you know, be careful to make sure that you take care of your own requirements for carbon first before you start to sell. Don't look at the market and say I can capitalize on this and sell all the carbon credits from my farm and then find that you have to buy them back at a multiple of 10, 20 years down the line. So First off, look at your
carbon requirements on the farm yourself. Then look at those and only sell the surplus that you're generating on your farm. I think that's really, really important. Like slightly off from a tangent. Well, no, but it's, it all connects us with my next question for Johnny, because of course there is that challenge, isn't there that it's not just about assessing it once you're not sort of saying this is my carbon impact and that's kind of the end of it, full stop. It's there's an accrual of that carbon impact. You're on you on you as well. So it's really quite, quite a complex thing to to get one's head around. And we'll go through those different sort of markets that
you referred to there, David, a bit later. But let's stick with carbon for the moment. And Johnny, you've recently gone through the process of selecting a partner for trading carbon credits from Balburnie Home Farms. Who have you decided to go with and why have you decided to go with them? So it's very interesting listening to David talking about this. And those are some of the same issues that I was having in the marketplace. I've chosen regenerate outcomes and one of the main reasons I've
chosen them is that I don't sell modeled carbon. I sell actual carbon that has been measured as being put into my soil. So tell me the difference. Normally in many, many carbon calculators, when you sell carbon, it is based on a model of how much carbon is going to be put into whatever scheme. It is based on particular behaviors, in particular the forest carbon code.
And I'm sorry, Bruce, I'm going to disagree with you when you say that the forest carbon code is the gold standard. I would say that the forest carbon code is probably the lowest common denominator of carbon codes because it is all modelled. It is not actual carbon that is being sequestered. So that's primarily why I've chosen regenerate outcomes. The fact that they also as part of their their fee, which is not insignificant, they take a large
proportion of the carbon credits that we generate. They take those as a fee for them. But if I don't generate any carbon, they don't take any fee. So it's in their interests that I'm able to actually put carbon into my soil. They supply a mentor or a consultant who will assist land owners, land managers with making so that we can maximize our carbon. Also the fact that I'm able to make the decisions to put carbon
into the into the soil and be able to sell that, but I'm also farming on the top. So it is this is proper enterprise stacking. This is not then just paying me for something and saying I can't do anything else on that land, which I would do if I was doing the forest carbon code. They would say you plant trees on that bit of land and you can't do anything else because our models say that you will create X amount of carbon in Y number of years. So there's the difference there that you were talking about between model carbon, which is essentially A futures prediction
projection, an actual carbon and we generate outcomes. What they're doing is, is recording, assessing the amount of carbon accrual that has actually existed that's been sequestered in that land. Then they are aggregating your carbon with other farmers carbon to sell that as sort of carbon units onto the market. And they're taking an agency fee effectively, aren't they? So, and they're taking the credits are, you know, as that I'm just gonna pop across to Bruce for a moment to ask because you've put that
challenge across to him about, you know, the difference between model carbon and actual carbon and the forest carbon code. And I just wonder, Bruce, if you've got any comments on that? Yeah. No, I think those are totally fair comments. I think just in the initial question, you just asked me to outline the kind of broad framework of what exists out there. So I'm putting forward what I suppose is the kind of quality assurance standard that's what seeking. So those are the ones that are out there are most common. So that's, that's all I'm I'm saying with the codes there. And I think, you know, I, I don't work for any of the
organizations behind those codes, but I think they would say that they're very robust in, in the way they take them forward. But I do, I do think it's a very valid point, Johnny, to me about the actual versus potential. Yeah. OK. And just David, do you wanted to come in, I think. Yeah. So I, you know, I think you might find it unusual, Johnny, but actually, I, I agree with you to a certain extent on, on some of the comments make the woodland carbon codes. It's no, not the forest carbon code, you know, is there. It is a government backed system that has a very clear process of validation and verification,
which is, you know, which is gold standard and absolutely. But I share concerns about the quality of some of the schemes that are going into the Woodland Carbon Code and the potential outcomes that come from those schemes are being planted in sites that simply will not produce the outcomes that are expected overstatement of yield classes. And that will all, all boil out, of course, when the verification start to happen at Year 5 and at year 15. But I think there is a, there is a real case for a real case for increasing the scrutiny of those schemes at the start of the
process instead of kicking the problem down the lane for people to find out that there's an issue later on. And so I, I agree that, you know, there are, there are some, there are some aspects, the wooden carbon code, which are, which are, which need further scrutiny and, and that it is not necessarily as, as, as high as standard as one might expect, but it is it, don't get me wrong, it's a very good standard. As long as the quality of the scheme that goes into it, then the first instance is correct. David, I wonder about how, how to sort of move forward on that
scheme and how to ensure that the, that the projections around the timber production, the carbon production in those trees is actually delivered. I'm going to, I'm going to ask the question to Johnny and then come back to you, David, if I may, because Johnny, I wanted to ask you about regenerate outcomes because they talk in terms of stacking nature delivery with carbon drawdown in order to add value to those carbon credits. So those carbon credits are worth more. And I wonder in the first instance whether you have a sense yet of how your going to be delivering those credits. I mean obviously you say you
know you've already got that accrual, but where is it coming from? Is it, you know, how are you building those and and is there additional benefit to you from that nature enhancement as well? I think what you mean is how am I going to be managing the land in order to put carbon into the soil? You see you. Should write my questions that was a much more straightforward by putting it. The, the answer that that's the question I would like to well, I'm going to answer which is that we are going to be putting in grass and managing that grass
with cows and letting that grass rest for long periods. Grass that some of our cows are grazing today was last grazed during the Highland show. So that was what last week of June and we expect that that management style is going to deliver that carbon into the soil, particularly because we expect to be growing more grass for longer in the year and not
eating at all. So it's got to go somewhere and where it's going to go is back down into the soil. So you what you've got there is, you know, really rich meadows, that's what you're aiming for with with diverse swords, deep roots, lots of biomass, soil organic matter that sort of been created in their necromast, all these things that are sort of building up though, you know, the carbon within the soil there. Are you also thinking in terms of hedges or tree integration or anything like that? Or is it simply that it's it's Meadows with diverse wards?
I'm, I'm quite happy to have hedges and trees and that kind of thing, but actually they all cost money to put in and it doesn't cost me more money to actually graze it. Graze it. You know, I'm, I'm being remunerated for the grazing in the fact that the cows grow and I get kilograms of beef. That's great. So that's a work done payment outcome. Perfect. The fact that that also grows more grass puts carbon back into the soil we expect.
Means that I can also get paid for actual carbon that is being stored in the in the soil. And so just sort of quickly coming back to you, David, just for a, a brief thought, really whether there are ways of, of enhancing nature, you know, in order that you achieve better water holding capacity, for example. So there is more likelihood of the the forests that are being planted, the woodland being planted, actually surviving and and growing to sort of full value carbon credits. Is that something that you're looking at? Yes, I mean it. You know, there's a, a widely used being right to your right
place for the right reason. I, I don't necessarily like that. I must say it's about using experienced people to give you advice about what will actually grow on, on any given site. And, you know, we come back to the, the question I had about the woodland carbon code or the statement I made about woodland carbon code earlier. My concern is that people can submit a scheme to the woodland carbon Code and, and within the, the, the assessment process of the woodland carbon code, the growth of those trees is not necessarily one of the key aspects which is is assessed. Yes, it's the error you're making a statement about the
ecological site classification, which is the model that we use for determining how to quickly trees will grow. But, but actually, if you're inclined to or don't feed the right information into the system, you can make that system say what you want it to say. And we know, we know as practical foresters that, that, you know, planting trees 300 metres up a hillside in the West Coast of Scotland is not going to result in yield Class 6 Downey Birch. But we will see schemes coming through with that in the system. And you know what I've advocated for for a long time as a, as a
check and balance and almost a traffic light system for schemes where if, if it's green, it's good quality land, the scheme gets a gets a light touch. If there's any doubt whatsoever, then it potentially goes out to a panel of industry experts, perhaps through the institute charter foresters, who then say whether this scheme is actually appropriate for the site and not appropriate for the site. That's a different discussion, but whether it's going to grow the carbon that is intended to grow. And you know, it's about having those checks and balances because I do think that we're
storing up promises through sale of Pius and through generation of carbon units, which will not be realized in the future. And that gives us as an industry, as forestry and, say, woodland industry and land managers, a reputational issue. Bruce, I'm gonna come back to you. Maybe I know that you wanted to to comment and maybe you can sort of wrap it up within the next question, 'cause I'm aware that we've spent quite a bit of time on carbon credits and we've got lots else to get through as well. Bruce, Scottish Wildlife Trust is particularly interested in nature based solutions or MBS. And I wonder if you could just
talk me through, you know, in relation to what we've been talking about so far, your working definition of what nature based solutions means and tell me why they're so important. Yeah, sure. I mean, I think I would just say the last part of that conversation was getting us towards why carbon is pretty easy and it's so difficult. I completely agree with everything that everyone's saying there. Nature and biodiversity credits are fifty 100 times more complicated than that because garden is 1 unit. Nature is, you know, is just infinitely more complex. So maybe a bit of a clue as to why we're not so advanced with
those discussions. Yeah. So nature based solutions, they're not what the Scottish Wildlife Trust is doing on its reserve for nature. We do nature for nature's sake, for the the sort of moral obligation. That's the reason that our charity was set up a solution. You're looking at this problem, you've got to find a solution for it. So you can incidentally provide all sorts of brilliant solutions on a nature reserve, so water quality, carbon sequestration, sequestration, but it's more about the reason that you set
out to do that. So if I'm putting in a piece of grey infrastructure, I'm setting out to solve a flooding problems with a culvert or something like that. If I restore a wetland meaningfully with the main outcome being the flood protection value of that, that's that's kind of the nature based solutions element coming in. Carbon sequestration is the biggest one that we're talking about. But we really want this to be a wider discussion about solutions to all of the big challenges. So John Swinney is the current first minister.
We've got an election coming up, but the SNPs 4 big pledges, one of the main ones is public services. Now one of the best ways that we could achieve great value for money returning investment on public services is investing in nature based solutions. You know, water quality, flood prevention, these things are all public services. So it's more about the the kind of seeking a solution aspect of it that makes this a bit different. And there's huge biodiversity. Win, win, wins in in all of that. I just, I'm, I'm kind of
reminded as you talk about that and as you talk about the grey infrastructure of various sort of 70s and 80s sitcoms and probably pretty much every local paper that exists where you have a politician standing next to a ribbon with a great big pair of scissors opening a flood protection project, opening something grey and built. Because if it's grey and built, then you know that you've spent the money, The public can see that you've spent the money and, and you can go and open it and, and everybody can cheer and clap their hands.
In terms of the politicians in Scotland and the political climate, do you feel that there is an increased understanding of the importance of nature based solutions of that green infrastructure and more politicians wanting to come out Watson be photographed in front of, you know, a bog of a highly functioning bog that's managing water well. Incredibly complicated picture of this, roughly 130 MSPs roughly. Each one is entirely different. Levels understanding differ. We are moving into an election
period. The cabinet in the Scottish Government is 100% going to change because Marie Gujon, for example, the cabinet secretary, has announced she's stepping down. So there's going to be a new person in place. They are very much depends on their their understanding. I think what is changing though is a slight change of focus from that announcement of we have spent 100 million on flood defences to here are the outcomes, you know, throwing £100 million flood defence, whatever, great. But what are the outcomes that
you've actually achieved? I'd far rather that we spent £10,000,000 on, you know, a scheme that Johnny could help provide that, that actually provided evidence outcomes, which is sort of where Johnny's getting to with the, the evidence around his carbon. So that's that's where I hope we're starting to affect the change within politicians. And the problem with with all the nature based solutions stuff though is it's long term and it goes beyond parliamentary cycles. Yeah, yeah, OK. Now one of the schemes that I, I'm really impressed by with the Scottish Wildlife Trust is involved in is the River Woods project. Really fantastic and a great
example of nature based solutions in action. I just wonder if you could, you know, talk us a little bit through River Woods. I mean, actually it's something that we probably will come back to in a separate podcast at some point because there's so much to talk about. But just where did the idea come from? What's the ambition? Where's the funding and who's actually delivering on the ground? It's a shift, a long term shift in Scottish Wildlife Trust thinking away from individual islands of our reserves and to realize that we can have those reserves performing brilliantly for nature, but it's not going to make the difference across
the piece. So we need to be impacting the wider ecosystem and and and helping there as well. And it needs to be beyond us. We we can't deliver across all of Scotland. It needs to be an entirely team effort. Rivers. I mean, are you ever further from this isn't an official stat? I don't think you're probably or further and about four kilometers from a river in Scotland. Certainly we're we're all sitting or standing now. I think that probably the case. Probably most closest to tributaries. Exactly. So there's arteries going everywhere and also they tend to be the less production focused
areas tend to be of the land that we manage. So there's lots of things coalescing around them being fantastic opportunities. So we've developed this partnership and we're trying to do a lot of thinking about how we can enable rather than sort of put blockages in place. And there's been lots of discussions about how governance structures can, can actually make things happen. So we even use the word Poly centric governance internally for a while, which I think we're trying to do away with now because it's just getting too complicated. But, but trying to get individuals to move together collectively rather than the more traditional sort of board
structure for things filtered down. So we're, we're currently in a phase of designing Blueprint project, which is Heritage Lottery Fund supported, which is about really getting a blueprint in place for, for how this can can work and, and facilitating this, this collaboration across all different parts of Scotland. And it, you know, goes way beyond Scottish Wildlife Trust. There's all sorts of different partners in involved. You know, we're very thankful to them. But this, this is about us trying to really take our high level policy, which is about
joining off of nature and networks, trying to get strategic landscape scale planning in place, trying to build pipelines, bring all sorts of funding and finance together to deliver on the ground. It gets a bit awkward if we constantly talk about this but don't actually do it. So we are trying to do it and help do it through River Woods. And, and just to sort of illustrate it for people, because I, I don't think you, you talked about the project, but I don't think you quite describe what's happening there. It's, and my understanding is if you kind of had a map in front of you and you ran a highlighter pen down either side of of the main sort of tributaries and rivers.
Then what you're looking to do is to plant trees, get nature functioning alongside each of the rivers in order to catch nutrients as they come off farms. In order to, you know, help with that sort of water cycling to avoid, to keep water held back into the landscape so that there's less flooding further downstream, all those different outcomes. It really is that immediate river zone. I've been told I cannot say riparian because it's a real turn off for people. So. So I think we all know what I mean when I say, say riparian. Beside war courses. Yeah, just immediately in that that space there, a lot of it is about planting, but there is also elements of how do we get
natural regen on the go. Deer management is a huge part of this. We start to see hugely overlapping policy issues coming into play. Invasive non negative species are a huge part of this as well. So there's all these things that are like the big issues in Scottish conservation at the moment all coalescing around around rivers. So it's a useful way for us to try and explore this and and make progress. Fantastic. And as I say, perhaps we can come back and have a conversation about this that would be brilliant. More broadly in the future, David, I want to move on to, you know, Woodlands, specifically
woodland markets. And we talked earlier on about stacking in the importance of being able to sort of try and earn a number of incomes together to, to recognise that there are different values that are accrued often on the same piece of land. Clearly there are different sorts of woodland markets. There's timber, there's carbon, there's nature, there are probably others that you can tell me. Can farmers benefit from all these three markets at once? Yes, certainly they can. You know, back to Johnny's point about stacking credits, biodiversity credits, carbon credits, you know, that is that is currently difficult under the woodland carbon code and that's
something that woodland carbon code are looking at. But you know, if we look at the the sort of macro view of it, yes, absolutely there is, you know, really good opportunity for establishing forestry and or woodland and forestry we always term as being, we think about being large scale commercial conifer Woodlands. Woodlands to me are are smaller scale, perhaps multi species, absolutely great opportunity for implementing and integrating these in forms. Timber income again as I said earlier on really depends on
scale. If you're looking at a conifer woodland for for real income generation then that needs to have a certain element of scale to it. And you know, for us that that scale is probably 25 hectares plus, which is perhaps not achievable in most, most farm holdings, but smaller scale Woodlands can really contribute pretty widely to that as well. And nature benefits, making the most of the areas that you have in the farm, which perhaps might be difficult to manage, may have water courses to tie into the
river woods element, Bruce, you know, tying into the benefits that that nature can provide and the, the protection that woodland and that exclusion of, of livestock can have in those areas is really, really important. Species selection is key, really depending on what you're aiming to do. Species are limited. You know, if you're planting .25 point, 51 hectare, there's no point filling it full of sickness spruce. That's going to cause a problem in the future. It's going to shade everything out over that small area and is
going to be a, a problem for you to manage in the future. So you need to be thinking very closely about the types of species that you plant and, and, and where indeed those are planted and, and again, for what purpose where carbon is an objective, then you know, again, that species choice is, is vitally important and engaging a specialist to guide you in that. And actually also looking over the fence to see what's happening and, and, and, and what's growing well within a local area is really important. So yes, we can benefit from all three. It needs careful management and
you know, the monetization of the nature element as Bruce suggested earlier on is, is still very much at, at an early stage because it's incredibly more, you know, it's much more complex than than carbon, which we can measure through the accrual volume in a tree. And nature is is more complex. But you my feeling is that will come in the future. Yeah, and certainly there's an awful lot of work being done, you know, various places around the world, but certainly in the UK looking at how best to monetize this and and how to how
to value it. Now, I appreciate that these are going to be fairly swift overviews, but let's let's dip into them anyway if we can, David. And of course Johnny was talking about soil carbon earlier on. But if farmers want to grow trees for, for the carbon market, what sort of advice and support and incentives are there for this? Because I mean, I imagine, you know, for a farmer who hasn't been thinking about this until now, it'll it, you know, it's a set of minefields that they've got to sort of go through and what sort of trees will be ideal. Yeah, I mean advice and support, you know, organisations like Scottish students will, you
know, will come out to, to farms and, and carry out farm visits for free to, to help people assess the type of opportunities that they may have. You know, part of that process really getting to understand what the, what the overall objectives are for, for the farmers and, and land owners in the first instance. Is it biodiversity? Is it shelter, is it carbon, is it future timber income? There are other really good initiatives like the Farm Advisory Service, FAS, funded by the Scottish Government and again that will provide funding and assessment for farmers to
consider what some of those steps might look like for them. We have a, a fantastic initiative called the Integrating Trees Network, which is a, a sort of farmer LED initiative happening in Scotland, again, funded by the Scottish Government. And that is using case studies of real life farms who have open days, you know, several open days a year to, to allow farmers to come and see for real what's happening on, on, on people's properties. And there's some really fantastic examples of that. And that is stimulating land owners and farmers to look at
how they might manage their land in a, in a slightly different way and to look at the positive benefits that Woodloo can bring for their farm. And then you go down to, you know, even really small initiatives like the small woods initiative in Aberdeenshire, which is something that we actually support through provision of trees as a, as a sort of donation into it. And that's encouraging farmers to plant small areas, corners of fields, you know, maximum size .25 hectares. But it's just these small interventions that can, you know, can create some really nice biodiversity areas within farms as well.
Incentives. The Scottish Forestry Grant scheme is the main incentive that's run by Scottish Forest, Scottish forestry or government organization again, and that's the main route. And you know, the Scottish forestry grant schemes, it's encouraged almost 100,000 hectares of planting since 2017. Interestingly, the average size of those schemes would be about 2028 hectares. So the vast majority of the, the The Woodlands that the forestry grant scheme supports are actually quite small in scale. You know, the ones that hit the headlines and are are are seen
by most people are the larger schemes. You're the larger commercial forestation schemes, but there's a huge amount of really good work being done by farmers and land owners through the forestry grant scheme to, you know, to put that in place. And then finally the future farming investment scheme, which was which was launched last year, will also pay for trees, fencing protection as well, up to a limit depending on the scale of your farm, you know, mid size farm, it's up to a limit of about £10,000 in total. But you know, I think the application process for that's
been quite challenging, let's say in the in the first round. We just need to see how that develops. So lots of initiatives out there, lots of, lots of opportunity. Lots of stuff there, you know, in relation to carbon definitely as you say, and just sort of moving on to timber and timber specifically, is this a good use of land? Yes, it is, but it needs to be planted in the right place. You know, there's been a lot of controversy about planting, of planting farms, planting whole farms. You know, there are areas of, of grade 3 land in Scotland that probably are suitable for
planting trees. There are areas that definitely aren't. There are areas of grade 4 which should not be planted because they're, you know, they're in production and they're, you know, they're, they're highly productive areas of areas of land. So it's about choosing the right areas for the right reasons. Again, is it good use of land? Yes, as a, as a diversification for farmers taking poor areas of land where they have high inputs either in drainage or fertiliser or lime or, or whatever to bring it into agricultural production on an annual basis.
Forestry is a really good option. And you know, and, and I say forestry as in as, as in commercial production is a really good option. It brings potential for future income. It brings some taxation benefits. You know, it, it, it just allows diversification of assets and it, we've seen really good examples of, of farms where they've turned round some of the financial aspects of the, of the farm and the financial performance on the farm by excluding some of these areas which are constantly sinking money into the year, year after year. It's about the right piece of ground and choosing the right
area and. About 30 years before you can harvest something like that. 30 to 35 years generally on a on a conifer crop, broadleaf crops much, much longer. But again, if you've got good access, you can be in and you can be thinning these sites, you know, from the age 60 onwards, so you can start to generate smaller small amounts of income on a gradual basis. Fantastic. Then finally we come to woodland for nature. Obviously we've talked about this and the difficulty of valuing, valuing nature within that, but perhaps we're talking about, you know, broadleaf woodland, a bit of timber from
Copper Sing, but also Deadwood that's left for habitat creation. Is this sort of woodland supported by Scottish Government and Scottish Woodlands and nature markets in Scotland? Yes, absolutely. The, you know, the Forestry Grant Scheme has eleven options for 11 options for woodland creation across the nation, and only two of these cover corn for planting. So there's a, there's a vast array of opportunities available for smaller scale and, and, and sort of natural native Woodlands. But I should stress that Woodlands don't need to be native to be good for biodiversity. And I think that's a really
strong point I'd like to put across. You know, what they do need to be is diverse in species and in structure. We need to be looking to enhance where possible and, and, and, and take advantage of good biodiversity areas that already exist. You know, wetlands, rivers, riparian Woodlands, sensitive heaths, you know, open areas, which are, are, are important for habitats and for existing species as they are. So I would, I would say that, you know, a woodland that is planted doesn't necessarily have to be native to be good for
biodiversity. We can see mixed diverse forest complex has also been good for biodiversity. In fact, a lot of our a lot of our iconic species in Scotland thrive and and commercial plantations, red squirrel, Tapper Kelly and for instance, are good examples of that Woodlands for carbon, you know, need to be considered very closely, as I said earlier on. And you know if carbon is a is an objective of a landowner then? You do a really careful consideration about the potential growth of these sites and the the correct species choice. We will not grow significant
volumes of carbon planting broadleaf Woodlands on exposed sites between now and 2050. We will grow significantly more carbon and sequester significantly more carbon by growing conifer trees in the right place. And so it's that early boost of carbon from conifers with that late tail of carbon from broadleaves is a really important way to look at it. So it's not one-size-fits-all. I think we need to look at all the solutions here. Thanks so much for that. And just you mentioned native Woodlands there and of course one of the important types of
native Woodlands. I mean you were saying that trees don't need to be native in order to have biodiversity value. But of course in terms of native Woodlands, you've got the temperate rainforest, which is so important across Scotland just in a few sentences. They're sort of schemes available to support farmers if they have temperate rainforest on that land in in preserving that yes, I'm. I'm I'm personally not a great fan of this rainforest trope that we have for the for the the scattered sort of native Woodlands that exist in the West Coast of Scotland. But yes, there, there, there definitely, there definitely is funding there and funding
available through it, specialist, specialist funding available in the and certainly in the Highland area. You know, the expansion of those is, is really about stock control and it's about removing stock. It's about taking that browsing pressure away and stock and of course dear, which are a which are a major threat to. Fantastic. Bruce, from your perspective, what are the benefits in terms of both resilience and also you know, the financial benefits for farmers delivering nature based solutions well? Yeah. If we want to talk about overall resilience, I mean overwhelmingly native Woodlands and provides by far and away the
biggest biodiversity benefit. So, so there there there absolutely is some biodiversity benefit from non natives woodland creation. But if you want overall resilience of the system, the native trees are are far better for that. And that's, that's strongly supported by the evidence. So I think, I mean, there's, there's a part of nature based solutions that is definitely like teaching your granny how to suck eggs. And I would not ever want to do that to a farmer. So there's a stuff that you do on a farm that is natural Land Management. You would never think of calling
it nature based solutions. They would already mentioned the amazing benefits of shelter belts, for example. You know what I'm trying to remember back to my days at agricultural college about the sort of equations we used to do about soil protection from a land, from a, from a tree, that sort of thing. So there, there are all those benefits on farm and I've heard Johnny and, and lots of people within nature friendly farming network talk a lot about reducing input costs. So nature based solutions on the main things they can help do on farm is reduce input costs. So there's that direct benefit to farmers that is just part of,
of running a, a successful financial operation these days. And Scottish Wildlife Trust is absolutely clear on the need for them to be financially viable these farming operations. But then there's the the wider societal stuff. And this is where the farm support package from government really needs to be, providing it for an incentivizing nature based solutions. Yesterday the Scottish Government produced the climate change plan, which we've all been waiting for for for a while now. Really explicitly we will fund nature based solutions to deliver. So that is a big direction of
travel shift from the last one where there was good nice words about nature based solutions. But that that is in there firmly. What we actually need to see now is what funding that's going to be, how that's going to be delivered because I think we would all say the current agricultural support packages are not really geared to delivering that. They've made some great points about the importance of advisory service. There needs to be money moving into things like advisory service to help farmers deliver the change that's needed there. So yeah, I would, I would split benefits to on farm benefits
from nature based solutions. Then the wider societal benefits, some of which aren't recompensed for and probably might be very difficult to recompense for. Some of which we can develop schemes to help pay for, for those benefits. And that's where you can have the conversation that Johnny was talking about stocking and those kind of things, which is really important that we have those conversations and that we have that. I think that really needs to help, facilitated by government, those discussions. Johnny, we're coming towards the end of the program. I'm just sort of wanting to round out a few of the conversations that we've been having and thinking again for a moment about the soil carbon
market. It's, I think it's pretty easy to be glib about, about this because companies tend to make it sound so straightforward and attractive. You go to an agricultural show, you talk, you know, it sounds like it's really easy. But from your perspective, in trying to move from that kind of general attractive activeness of the idea to the practical reality of delivering it, how difficult was it for you to understand the market? Pretty difficult. It's taken me many years of I haven't dipped my toe into the market, but I've tried to
understand a lot of different organizations that are doing this. I would describe myself as relatively clued up in terms of what's going on and it's taken me a long time to get my head around it such that I've got a form to fill in for generate outcomes. Now you know I've signed up, but that's only happened last month. It's not easy. Are there things that you can think of that would make the market or you know, just the whole sort of scene there easier to navigate?
I think understanding the difference between models and actual carbon is a is a critical element in this. And I'm going to say it again, I I really don't like the forest carbon code because we already have quite a lot of forestry on our land, and because the forestry already exists, I am excluded from the forest carbon code 100%. I cannot take part. There is no way of measuring how
much carbon is in the woods that we have standing and getting paid for carbon that gets added to that wood from now in the future. So I I really dislike it as a as a scheme. And are those Woodlands? Are they conifer Woodlands or are they broadleaf? Mostly conifer. My grandmother was a forester and she planted a lot of coniferous Woodlands over the past 70 years. So presumably there are opportunities there for you to cut it for timber use I'm
guessing, and then to replant for nature or for carbon? No, because I can't. I can't replant something that is and get money for replanting. That's already a forest, so no. David, do you want to just come in on that? Yeah, I think, I think it's just worthwhile coming in on that. You know the, the fundamental tenets of of carbon woodland carbon as additionality. And you know, the reason, Johnny, you can't get, you can't get carbon credits for your existing Woodlands is the fact that you need to be able to prove that that planting would have happened in, in any case
and, and, and required carbon funding in order for it to happen. And, and because you've done it, you can't therefore prove that. And you know, in, in, in other jurisdictions and other carbon schemes, you potentially under improved forest management schemes which happen elsewhere in the globe, you can't actually do it. But in the UK and there wouldn't carbon code, you don't. And that's just one of the kind of fundamental tenets of, of, of that type of carbon credit. Is that being looked at, David, because it does seem like a great big hole in the system where that, you know, you've got a lot of woodland, you particularly in Scotland, you've got lots of conifer woodland
that already exists there. And this, this notion of additionality, which I recognise is important in terms of the governance is a barrier, is a, is a challenge when you're trying to get farmers and land owners involved in, you know, in this natural capital world. It is and it's often misunderstood. And you know, I think I, I, you know, again, people will read newspapers and see that, you know, there are improved forest management systems happening in, let's say the Amazon rainforest or in, in, in, in Africa, for instance. And a lot of those schemes have not gone particularly well. So, you know, large scale, large
scale operations, we're going to change the way we're going to retain some of these areas. Instead of clear cutting them, we're going to retain them. We're going to sequester more carbon and because we've taking a financial penalty in and not clear felling now and clear felling at some point in the future, then we can that is additional so we can claim the carbon that's growing between the two periods. There's a lot of uncertainty about the outcomes of these improved forest management and schemes elsewhere in the globe. And I, I think it's good that we don't necessarily have them here in the UK at the current time until the absolute certainties
about those are, are, are ironed out. Yes, there should be a solution, but I think they would only be a solution for perhaps native woodland, which is going to be non intervention. They are for a long period of time with on farms. So yeah, it, it, it's a really complex position and there've been lots of issues around these improved forest management and, and Red plus systems as they've known elsewhere on the globe. Thanks David. Johnny, just coming back to you and sort of focusing again on the soil carbon element. You, you know, much as I hear your frustration and and David was responding to the
frustration around additionality and and forest carbon there. Do you think there's a role for government in trying to sort of simplify and standardise approaches to soil carbon? Not necessarily. I think that. It is up to government to create the guard rails around the the marketplace and to to define what is allowed to be sold and what is not. But I think the if land managers want to get paid for value then I think that has to be private
between a customer and a supplier. Most land owners are too small to have a single discussion with a single supplier. Often the suppliers who want to understand the carbon are very big and the amount of carbon that they're looking for. One person cannot deal with it themselves. So that's why we we aggregate through people like regenerate outcomes. I'm sure if I was the crime estate or something I could do
it by myself. And David, just staying with policy and regulation, to the to what extent would you say that planning permission is an issue in terms of new woodland and land use change in Scotland? Planning permission and, and really the, the, the permissions that we look for are, are environmental impact regulations and approval through the forestry grant scheme. And yeah, they are, they are definitely an issue at the moment. Time scales are, are dragging, you know, resource within Scottish forestry to deal with these is, is, is quite limited. And you know, we are, we are trying to push that on as
quickly as we possibly can and and doing a lot of lobbying with government to to sort of push that forward. Why is it the planning permissions fail? Is it because of the landscape change and people being nervous about that, or is it because people don't believe in the value of of the new woodland? Do you have a sense of what it is and how that can be addressed? Yeah, I mean, I think it's, it's probably fair to say that there are very few applications fail. You know, I, I can't think of any projects necessarily that have failed. You know, in, in Scotland, you know, there are schemes that
are, are somewhat in the treacle and are, and are slowly working through the process. But you know, we're not seeing many of them fail. Some, some may be withdrawn because people don't want to fight the fight. A lot of what we're dealing with is, is misinformation about what the forestry sector brings and what the forestry sector does. And you know, a lot of discussion about biodiversity impact and reports carried out by the Royal Society of Edinburgh. And 18 months ago, 16 months ago now I think, you know, which basically said commercial forestry was bad for biodiversity and should be
defunded by the Scottish Government. There is no scientific basis for that report. You know, that report was entirely skewed towards the, the thoughts and, and considerations of the of the authors and, and there was very little if, if any scientific basis to the outcomes of that report. Forest Research, the UK's government research agency and has produced a huge amount of literature in relation to the benefits of bioversity in woodland and, and including productive woodland. As I said earlier on, it's, you know, it's about a balance, it's
about striking that balance. So a lot of misinformation is leading through to this and that is tying in Scottish forestry and the regulators in wider discussions. And, you know, I think if there is anything that needs to happen, I think the regulators need to become regulators again instead of becoming advisors, quasi advisors, because at the moment they're, they're caught up in a lot of discussions with single interest groups who are anti forestry. And that's, that's slowing the process down. Community consultation, as mentioned earlier on, Bruce mentioned, it certainly is vitally important.
And as you know, it's been something that certainly as a business at Scottish Woodlands, we've taken very seriously for, for many, many years. That community process combined with some of this, this misinformation that's floating around in the in, in the, in the sector at the moment is, is one of the real challenges that we have. And that's what's slowing, that's what's slowing a lot of these approvals down. It's misconception from that misinformation that about. Fantastic. Look, I would just go what you, you know, we've been talking for a long time and and spending more time in particular areas
than others. And and so I'm just sort of chasing really around to to try and bring us to the end at some point. And Bruce, I guess this is the last question for now and we're going to come back to these issues, you know, in due course. Of course we are. But from your perspective, what are the chief barriers currently to accelerating nature based solutions delivery in Scotland? Number one, the lack of landscape scale ballistic planning we want. I'm going to slightly move the conversation away from forestry good, biodiversity bad, whatever
discussions around that towards there are lots of stated aims for our, for our land at the moment. The Scottish Wildlife Trust obviously advocates for biodiversity, but we're wanting more than ever before. You know, everything from renewables to forestry places to people that live to produce foods and everything else in between. And we don't have any way of strategically planning for all of that in one place. We have a land use strategy that is early, toothless and has no political clout whatsoever. So we need something to help plan what we need from our land and a major part of that is
nature based solutions to the biggest problems that we face as society. I would say climate and nature crisis is very high up there and the UN would agree with me. So that's a big missing part. The second is then linking that strategic planning to our main funding, public funding systems and also any potential private investment. So forestry grant scheme, for example, isn't really linked to any strategic overall landscape scale thinking. AG support is not LinkedIn any way.
So if farmers wanting to do a little bit of riparian woodland creation on their farm, which is fantastic in support, there's very little way of helping them integrate that with a a wider network and the advisory service is massively underfunded. Could help there. I would really like Johnny to be getting help with his, his search for, for carbon and, and maybe even some biodiversity work through farm advisory because I think it's very valid use of that money and that farm advisory service can really be having a view of everything that's happening in a catchment and, and helping plan that
strategically. Those are huge barriers. And also you, you touched yourself on the lack of sort of political interest in actual objective and solution stuff, rather than saying we've spent £10,000,000 on X, it really needs to move towards the, the solutions. We've got climate objectives and biodiversity targets are literally just being debated in Scotland at the moment. We've got stage one of the Natural Environment Bill 2030 is when we want to halt the decline of biodiversity loss without that better length strategic planning to claim and nature and
all the other object. That's obviously my what I'm advocating for, but and all the other objectives that we want, we're not going to be achieving that. Fantastic. That's really helpful. Just to sort of round us out there. As I say, people who are listening will have noticed that we haven't spoken about renewables. We've spent the time today really talking about stuff from the land. So you know, how food production can change, how we manage biodiversity, how we, how we account for carbon, how we grow timber and, and, and nature in various different ways and how how water's managed.
Obviously renewables are a really important part of this picture, but we'll come back to that. And if people want to skip back to the Filling the Funding Gap series from earlier on in the year, then we do have a program specifically looking at renewables. But as I say, today's focus has been much more on what we can do with the land itself. So thanks so much. It's been really fascinating. That is all we have time for. I'd like to thank my guests, Johnny Balfour, David Robertson and Bruce Wilson. If you've enjoyed listening, please come back and listen to more.
Tell your friends like us, review us and share our links. Farmgate is the world's highest ranking food security podcast and Farmgate leaders Martin's Farm, Wheat from the Chaff and as I mentioned are Filling the funding Gap series are all available on the Farmgate channel. If if you just scroll back in your podcast feed. Farmgate is part of 8.9.com, the land use news channel, which is sponsored by First Milk, Pelican AG, Rural Solutions, the Usk Catchment Partnership, Agrolo and individual donors. This particular programme has been supported by the Nature Friendly Farming Network. I've been Finn Locustain.
This episode is a Regen Ag 101, taught by one of the best explainers in the field. ffinlo Costain talks to geomorphologist David R Montgomery, author of Dirt and co-author with Anne Biklé of What Your Food Ate, about...
Place-based food economies are an opportunity to redesign food systems, from the bottom up, in ways that distribute profit and power more fairly throughout the value chain. They are also essential if we are to create a...
ffinlo Costain and Martin Lines (Chief Executive, Nature Friendly Farming Network) are joined by Nisreen Shahin from Inside Track, an organisation that represents an anonymous group of senior executives from major UK...
ffinlo Costain is joined by Baroness Julia Aglionby, the long-serving executive director of the Foundation for Common Land, as she takes her seat as a Liberal Democrat life peer. ffinlo asks Julia three questions: why...
As the impacts of climate change deepen, what will happen to food and farming systems in the UK and around the world? And do we need greater food independence and food sovereignty in the UK? Today, ffinlo Costain is...