Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Fantasy Baseball from Prospect361.com | MLB Fantasy & Prospect Advice

Fantasy Baseball from Prospect361.com | MLB Fantasy & Prospect Advice artwork

2285 - Fantasy Questions of the NL West - D-Backs and Rockies

Dec 28, 202556 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Segment 1 - Fantasy Questions of the NL West - Diamondbacks and Rockies Arizona Diamondbacks 1.Geraldo Perdomo broke out in a big way in 2025 with 20 home runs, 27 stolen bases, and a .290 batting average. The data suggests being wary of repeats in power and speed. What do you say? 2.Jordan Lawlar - AB, HR, SB, and BA 3.Are the Diamondbacks going to go to war with Alek Thomas in center field and Blaze Alexander in left field? If so, do you have any interest in either? 4.I’ve got Brandon Pfaadt wrong, as I thought he would be more than a 5.25 ERA pitcher. Any hope, or should I just move on? 5.How many waiver wire articles will Kevin Ginkle make this year? - Over/Under - 2 6.Give me a sleeper in the organization (minor or majors) Colorado Rockies 1.Brenton Doyle - HR, SB, and BA for 2026 a.He’s going as the 37th outfielder off the board. We will look around to see if it’s too high or too low. 2.Kyle Karros (574), Zac Veen (494) and Adael Amador (590). a.According to RosterResource, they all will start the year with a job. Order them in how you would draft them. Do you have any real interest in any of them? 3.Victor Vodnik has the Closer gig, I think. Uhh…you interested? 4.How many wins do the Rockies get in 2026 - they were 43-119 in 2025 5.Give me a sleeper in the organization (minor or majors) Segment 2 - News and Notes 1.The Athletics trade for Jeff McNeil, with the Mets receiving Yordan Rodriguez. a.a. The Mets pay 5.75 million of McNeil’s contract, and it appears he will slot in at second base. Any interest? Would you have rather seen Darrel Hernaiz get some at-bats? b.b. Yordan Rodriguez is a young 17-year-old RHP with a fastball that can touch the mid-90s. 2.The Marlins sign Pete Fairbanks a.The Marlins needed a closer and signed Fairbanks. I guess they think they can compete. What say you? 3.The Pirates sign Ryan O’Hearn a.The Pirates are continuing to get better, maybe marginally, but this feels like what the Royals did two years ago when they signed several mid-level Major Leaguers and did ok. Your thoughts?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Green and Society takes everyone at Richwelves'm looking too. Fantasy Baseball Live Today is December twenty eighth, about three twenty in the afternoon. As always, I'm here with my good buddy, mister Tim McCleod. Tim. Happy Happy Christmas, Happy New Year's, Happy Christmas week, Bloody bloody.

Speaker 2Bloody is happy, happy happy. I always get so confused when we do the prospects first because I don't know what day were on. That was Tuesday. Now we're back to Sunday, right, We're.

Speaker 1Back to Sunday, so we can talk like what's happening in our lives. Tim sent me his Christmas pair care package that he always sends me. Thank you very much. That dorito's, the uh the sweet and Sweet Chili's I think they're called, and the jujub.

Speaker 2Does LORI share any of those with you, rich or? Is that just for no?

Speaker 1She she shares them with me, But she had the first bag herself. That's her. That's her, Okay, that's that's I mean, she is a big dirty She's actually like her death row meal would definitely be not your cheese, not your cheese. But she likes the fact that that you send sweet chilies because we can't get them here at least we've never seen them, uh so, so I think she likes that. So the last you know, for maybe one a week or one every other week or

Speaker 1something like that. So the last were a bit.

Speaker 2Okay, good stuff good and your chocolate covered jube jubs. They worked to perfection.

Speaker 1And Tim also sent us some caramel popcorn, which was went away first. So that was easy because that's very easy to consume in the car. So so we we did that.

Speaker 2So I'm I'm glad it got there and you enjoyed it. Bridge. It's it's tradition.

Speaker 1I feel like we get we get the uh the sweet treats from and I save retreats from from the north. So it's always cool to see that.

Speaker 2And believe you me, I I haven't eaten them in a long time, those chocolate covered jubejubes. But I opened up a bag. I bought a bag for myself. I said, I hate I got, I gotta have have some of these. It's been a while. I opened up a bag yesterday. An hour and a half later, they're all gone and I'm bouncing off the walls. Yeah, it was great.

Speaker 1One year one year you sent us, Uh was maple syrup from from Canada? Yeah, I have to tell you Vermont has nothing on the Canadians in terms of making good maple syrup.

Speaker 2That was?

Speaker 1That was really good.

Speaker 2Well, I'll have to I'll have to make a mental note to send you another next year.

Speaker 1Because it was. It was like one of those that we have friends over and they still comment, Hey, has that guy sent you any more maple circle Canada?

Speaker 2Well tell them, tell them to tell them to book a breakfast in January of twenty seven. How was that?

Speaker 1There?

Speaker 2You go?

Speaker 1Yeah, so we'll we'll be there for Christmas next we're back at the beach for Christmas and we usually have that so they'll be ready to roll.

Speaker 2Okay, good stuff, good stuff.

Speaker 1So Timmy, how's life been doing it? You finish your draft? Do you do any more baseball work? Anymore drafts coming up?

Speaker 2Don't have anything coming up in the next short while, at least not nothing that I'm aware of. I'm going to start focusing and analyzing this first draft a little bit and pulling things apart and just taking a look at things. You know. One of the reasons I do it is to get that first one in, but also to take a look at the results. A group I'm playing with is a very good group, and it'll give

Speaker 2me some ideas as I start my future planning. But I'm going to be tied up with second base, shortstop, third base. We we got we gotta, we got some work to do ahead of us, rich and I'm gonna get ready to add it. Uh, who was m Sabi? I was wondering about I that was gonna go over?

Speaker 1What do you? What exactly are you saying? Because I I've done my I've thought all of my draft targets except for pitching. I haven't published that yet to our patron members. But the work is done. But uh, if you want me to do it, let me know, dude. But uh, that's not on my.

Speaker 2I'm hoping when I'm hoping when we get to the outfield, you might do of those capsules off my hands, because I probably two hundred deep.

Speaker 1I could definitely write up capsules, but ranking them, I'd rather leave that to you. But yeah, because because it'd be good to have two different views of the Yeah, anytime you need me to write just I'll give it to my AI engine getting split.

Speaker 2Yeah, loan me your AI dude for a couple of weeks.

Speaker 1Rich, all I have to do is send him catching him first base, and I say, here's the style of Tim McCleod. Now write similar capsules for everything else, and boom done. It's a it's ridiculous, Tim, it's ridiculous.

Speaker 2I am green with envy. And then my friend, Yeah, it's.

Speaker 1It's uh, it is so ridiculous to have. As I say, and I'll keep saying it. This artificial intelligence is going to change the world. I see it in just my little world here that I mean, I can eliminate me. I really can. And it's it is remarkable. It's remarkable.

Speaker 2Yes, but AI doesn't have a man.

Speaker 1That's true. That is true. He doesn't have a man crush. So timmy, I have been busy. I finished up all my draft targets as I mentioned, and yesterday I started working on my draft spreadsheet that all over Patreon members get a chance to have it. Brings in steamer and zips and everything else, and then you type in the name as you're drafting, and it tells you what those projections are, and then looks at old NFBC drafts and Dynasty League standings and figures out where you will finish up.

Speaker 1So it's a nice little, clever little spreadsheet. And I finished that up last yesterday afternoon, first version of it, and I'm looking, I've gone, I've got everything ready to do a draft. So I'm like, well, I'm I have four days ahead. So I decided we go over and plunk down my one hundred and fifty five dollars from my Draft Champions League. Yes, Tim, I do the cheap one. I don't do the four hundred dollars one because I'm cheap and I'm in the seventh slot and I've already made my first pick.

Speaker 2Oh yeah. We talked about that briefly, I think at the beginning of two day's show. But are you going to expand on that first pick for our listeners?

Speaker 1So with the nice thing about the NFAC, they have something called KDS, which I think is Kentucky Derby whatever the S stands for. But you go through and you say what your preference slot for picking. And I decided this year I wanted to pick in the middle because I didn't want to get aced out of like I got burned last year with closers. As you know, alexis ds Jason Foley at all, and I think Victor Vodnik. If it weren't for Victor Vondnik, I would have finished

Speaker 1last and saves, but it got a few out of him at the end of the year.

Speaker 2But it was no trouble with Victor Vodick. Is you.

Speaker 1S But I'll take whatever I got. But anyway, so I put in number seven would be my preference and actually got number seven, which and it showed me that mine was actually picked first. So as it turned out, if I would had won the one slot, I could have had it, I could have picked up probably show a Tani or something like that. But I got the seventh slot because what I really wanted was Corbyn Carroll uh and just looked at what he did last year, and my data model really put that out. And as a backup, I would take Eli de la Cruz because

Speaker 1I just that was that was what the model was telling me. But I really wanted Corbyn Carrol because Tim and I have talked about and what I wrote up to our Patreon members over the weekend is Tim is right. Don't dilly dally around with outfielders. You don't need to take him to the first four pick. You don't need to have four outfielders with your first first four picks. But my belief is you can't wait till the end of the draft and expect to do well. You gotta you gotta get on it.

Speaker 2Yep.

Speaker 1Unfortunately, Corbyn Carroll went sixth, so my master my master plan did not work. So I got Ellie de la Cruz very happy with the pick. But if I'm totally honest, I wanted Corbyn Carroll. My third pick would have been Trek Schouble. I thought picking in the middle there, going Schooble and even coming back with another pitcher or maybe even a closer in the second round I thought would have been really really interesting and something I've never done before.

Speaker 1I do think there's some quality pictures that you can get late, but I thought that would have been a lot of fun. But I went with my plan and decided to go led at Cruz.

Speaker 2Just so it's a great pick. And you know what, if Cruise would have went, you would have got one of those, You would have got Carol, or you would have got somebody. So your your plan B would have been if you know, if you're planning to see if if Cruise and Carroll both would have gone. You would have got somebody you really wanted. Anyways, Yeah, as you're before you went into even into pitching, simply because it would have bumped somebody down. Right.

Speaker 1If I had the first pick, I probably would have gone Otani, but I would probably gone Sodo. It would have been my altar. I mean, Juan Soto, what he did last season was ridiculous and the data totally supports this is this is one of the best players in baseball. I mean, he can't say he's better than show Heyo Tani, but he's really good and so, but the way the draft went was show Hey Otani, Aaron Judge two, Juan Soto three, Bobby Wit four, Jose Ramirez five, Corbyn Carrol six,

Speaker 1Ledlok Crew seven, then Scooball, Ronald Lcunya, and Scheme. So it's gone somewhat chalk. I will say, after doing the data on the researching on Jose Jose Ramirez, Look, he's been Hall of Fame worthy, but the data does not support what he's doing. So I just think at some point there's going to be, uh, there's going to be a fall off, and it could be severe. And I just don't want to be spending my first round on somebody that could fall off a cliff, And so that's

Speaker 1why I would not have taken him if he would have been on the clock. And Ronald d'ccune was a bit of an emotional pick. I mean, I look at the data. It all looked good last season. He didn't run like he has in the past, but it's the speed is still there. I don't know, Tim, I just I'm just scared of him. So I was not going to take him.

Speaker 2Well, all you have to do is look at recent history and you've got caused to be Yeah, yeah, you know it's safe. It's a it's a perfectly logical way of looking at you know, Ronald leccun you could post in theory the best numbers in baseball this year correct at the same point in time. He could cost you your league. Yep, it's is it worth taking that sort of a gamble?

Speaker 1I wouldn't so I I to me, I felt like I could win a league with Corbyn Carroll, Eli de la Cruise and Ronald Accunya. I don't think I'm going to lose a league with Elie de la Cruz Carroll. Something tells me I could lose my league with Ronald Acunya if he decides not to run, if he gets hurt, and the other guys Corpy and Carrol had that weird injury in twenty four. But for the most part, those guys, Yeah, those guys have been okay. It's been a counya. That's just been it's been tough, and I just decided it

Speaker 1was too much risk for me and I would not have taken him if if I would have been a little bit lower. So that was a decision I had made. So that's so my next election. Look, I hate the second round. I'll be honest with you. I don't like the outfielders going in the second round. The pictures I like some pictures. A little bit later, maybe I go a picture. I might go a closer, just because of being burned last season. I might go with Edwin Diaz and just say I'm done.

Speaker 2Just go, just get it done, get it done, and then just pick up after round fifteen. You just fill in the holes and as you get into the thirties and forties, start hoarding set up guys and you'll find saves.

Speaker 1Yeah. The problem with these NFBC drafts. There is no draft in holds that there's no pickups. And if you blow it on saves, you can't win the league. You just can't win the league. And that's why everybody goes early on closers. And yep, you know, so I know if I wait, if I don't take them in the second or third round, and I wait till the fourth round, forget about it, they're gone.

Speaker 2So yeah, And the thing is that you're right, Okay, you've got nine kad if you're playing to finish last in saves, Okay, you're playing on a max of basically one thirty six. Okay, Now, if you're playing on a max of one thirty six, what does your winning number you Where does it usually sit between one twenty and one thirty, Right, you got to be pretty darn good. And then the other nine categories to a mass. At

Speaker 2level of points, you're really you're get dominant, and the odds are slim that you're going to nail every category in the top two through greet it's you're you're asking for a miracle.

Speaker 1Basically to finish in the top four or five. You gotta have ninety points to finish in the money generally you got to have one hundred points, sometimes not, but to when it's one ten to one fifteen, and to then to have a chance to play in the big money with the NFC, you got to have one twenty one thirty. So you just you, you know, you just you have to have a closer. And the problem is everybody knows that and they go early. So if everybody's doing it, you might as well do it yourself because nothing's really gonna change because the.

Speaker 2Same whatever you do, yeah, yeah, it's not gonna influence the outcome unless you can find a way to finish mid pack and saves. And to do that you got to get lucky later on, right, and nail nail guys outperformed there and just a paged value.

Speaker 1Right, So the weird thing about NF youc draft and whole everything just slides down around. Right, So the guy that you have gotten, the outfitter you've gotten the third third round goes to the fourth round because everybody took closers in the third round. It's just the way it is.

Speaker 2So yeah, ten ten closers are off the board by the time you're done the third round.

Speaker 1Probably right now, if you're really lucky and smart. You could get all the guys that closed all the games in Cincinnati last year. Yeah, there's always those things, those weird things that happened when you grabbed him in the thirty fifth round and it all worked out, But you just that's just dumb luck, right, So.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, you could easily end up with an ERA of seven and three.

Speaker 1Saves, that's right. Yeah, So I've never been able to figure out where to uh, where to pick a closer. I think I'm just gonna take a guy off the off the board early here, either the second or third round, and call it a day.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's not a bad approach, taking care of business. And like you said, everything gets bumped down, so you're in the same situation because everybody's doing the same thing. Okay, then it's it becomes a little bit more of a skill game, doesn't it.

Speaker 1I think so. And again I got my targets on. If you're interested in seeing my targets, you're interested in seeing Tim's expanded coverage of his rankings, join us at the Patreon site patreo win dot com. Forward slash Prospect three sixty one. You get Tim out of the Discord site was out there the other day looking at some of Tim's little cute comments, and it seems like you're having fun out there.

Speaker 2Yeah, I'm having a riot. It's a good group. We have a lot of fun, and we cover a lot of grounds. So I'm really enjoying myself on the discord site. And Hey, I'm not afraid to give my opinion and answer questions and have some fun. So come join me. Looking forward to it.

Speaker 1To me, it's a quick break it back. Let's talk about the fantasy question of the Diamondbacks and Rockies ses. That sound like a reasonable approach.

Speaker 2That sounds reasonable to this old guy.

Speaker 3Okay, we game ten to.

Speaker 1Week off of doing second base and third base, so I thought we'd sneak in some fantasy questions of the divisions that we're going through. And we've done four of them, Tim, So let's get it at it with the NL West. I'm starting off with the Diamondbacks. Geraldo Perdomo broke out in the big Way in twenty twenty five twenty home runs, twenty seven stolen bases, on the two ninety batting average. One of the best players in the league. I got some MVP voting. We all know that the data that I'm looking at us suggests be wary of repeats and

Speaker 1power and speed batting average a guy can flat out hit. What do you.

Speaker 2Say, well, I love the hit tool. How can you not love the hit tool? Ninety four walks, eighty three k's okay, and he's batting at the top of the order. But I'm thinking fifteen home runs in twenty stolen bases seems a little bit more reasonable as a floor. You toss in the ninety five runs scored, that makes for a really good player. I'm downshifting a bit, but I'd

Speaker 2be very happy with him in this. I think the numbers warrant that. But I'm not setting my floor based on what he did last year. I'm dropping it down a little bit, and I think it's more reasonable that way.

Speaker 1Roto Predoma at number nine, Jeremy Painia at number ten.

Speaker 2Definitely, I'll take Perdoma.

Speaker 1Really, I'll take Painia, Corey Seeger at eleven, Perdomo at nine, Prudomo Trevor's Story at twelve, Perdomo at nine, Verdomoy the one more Bobaschett Verdomo. Yeah, you don't like bobaschet all right, Perdomo at nine, cj Abrams at eight.

Speaker 2I'll take Perdomo. So you like.

Speaker 1Predomo a little bit more? So, what about Mookie Betts?

Speaker 2Uh, Oh, that's a wash for me. I would probably. Yeah. I think what we have is a really good, good player, even at fifteen home runs twenty stolen bases. When you add in the ninety five runs scored and that hit tool in the sixth round, I I guess maybe I like Predomo more than most, but I'm downshifting on the anticipation.

Speaker 2I'm not anticipating twenty home runs in twenty stolen bases what he did last year. Maybe the two ninety batting average, yeah, that, but across the board there's a lot of goodness there.

Speaker 1So Predomo's at ADP of eighty, Mookie Bets at forty nine. Is Perdomo at eighty too low? Or is Mookie Bets at forty nine too high?

Speaker 2Perdomo is a bit low, I think, and BET's a bit high. At a combination of both.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think Bets feels a little. I mean, it is Mookie Bets, right, I mean, he's Hall of Fame player, but I mean it's not the same guy last year.

Speaker 2Mhm, Yeah, No, I I think Perdomo's safer on the floor.

Speaker 1Yeah, it might be. Okay, let's go, let's move on good stuff, Tim Jordan Lawler. Here's an easy one, Tim. Twenty twenty six stat lines at bats was pauls after we could do at bats, home run, stolen bases, and batting average. How many bats does he get?

Speaker 2Oh, I'm gonna go with four fifty?

Speaker 1Oh okay, so he's gonna play.

Speaker 2Yes, And I'm assuming that some of those are are gonna be in the outfield because the Diamondbacks have a third basement in Gino. Groover is getting pretty close, right, Does he have the skill set to push Lawler into the outfield. There's so many questions with him. With Lawler, I think eventually he's gonna have to be an outfielder in Arizona. And I'm sort of trying to build that

Speaker 2into this estimate of you know, the four hundred and fifty at bats. Okay, what do you think is that reasonable?

Speaker 1Or guess I've been burned by Jordan Lawler so much, Timmy. I thought he I thought he'd have two years of his service time by now. He just he's been heard. He hasn't played. Other players have played better. Heroldo Perdoma we thought was going to be a, you know, the utility guy. He turned out to be a star. And Jordan Lawler is still trying to establish himself. So it just hasn't worked out.

Speaker 2So yeah, that's a tough one. It really is.

Speaker 1I mean, Lawler has the skills to play center field. And it kind of bends into the next question. The Diamondbacks, on according to roster resources, are going to war with Alec Thomas and Blaze. Alec Thomas and center field is a great center fielder and Blaze Alexander and left field. Are they really going to go to war with those two in the outfield?

Speaker 2Uh, you know, not unless they want to see a lot of casualties. I would say no, No. I think when you look at Alec Thomas, you know, rumor has it the Diamondbacks are looking at trading one of Jake McCarthy or Alex Thomas. Okay, one of them is not going to be there. I'm going to say Lawler's in centerfield at some point in time and Blaze Alexander that those k rates are just they're flat out scary. What

Speaker 2what I would be looking at as far as the Diamondbacks this year by July, maybe maybe even earlier. Jordan Lawler's in centerfield and Ryan Walshmid is called up and playing every day. So I don't think either McCarthy or Thomas or Blaze Alexander is going to fit into the big scheme of things by June July somewhere in that range.

Speaker 1Yeah, I love I love Ryan Walschmidt as well. I mean it's yeah, I'm looking at Blaze Blaze Alexander. I mean, he's fast, can't hit, and it hits the ball a little bit harder than you think ninety mile an hour eggs of velocity. But I don't know, it just doesn't feel like there's much there.

Speaker 2No, I Like I said, I I think we're gonna see Lawler and Walshman in that oakfield, and I don't think it's gonna be I don't think it's going to be that long into the season, maybe a couple of months. So I'm staying away from that whole mess. And if I were to stash somebody else, dash Ryan Walshman and my miners in Red Graft League, have him on my bench.

Speaker 1Yeah, right, like Walt.

Speaker 2Yeah, ready to think. I think I think he's going to be ready to go, and I think he's a better option than all of the other ones did the Diamondbacks have.

Speaker 1I like to pride myself and I think I know what I'm talking about. But with Brandon, thought to me, I've just been flat wrong, dead wrong. I never thought he'd be a front of the rotation guy. But it was a five twenty five ear egg pitcher again last season after ALLOWSI twenty twenty four. He showed some promise in twenty three when the back said that run my question to you, is there any hope or that I just move on?

Speaker 2Well, I think he'll make at least one of my waiver war articles.

Speaker 1Okay, well, great, but.

Speaker 2But the on again, off again success that the risk is incredibly high. Okay. At April twenty seventh last year, okay, his RA was two seventy eight after his first six starts, and Rich was sleeping very well and smiling. After his next six starts, at the end of May, his ERA was five h five. Rich was having nightmares. It was not good. After April, okay, he had at least one

Speaker 2start each month with six or more earned runs. He's just I think the stuff is there, but it's not. He's not consistent at all. And how do you go about rostering a picture that once a month is getting shellacked it? It just kills you. So I'm gonna stay away. I'm just not going to play play the game. And for those that do draft brand, if he gets through April May with a decent era.

Speaker 1Move on so high, yeah, so high?

Speaker 2Yeah, move on, Yeah, that would be my advice.

Speaker 1The launch angle of twenty degrees off is forcing. I mean, guys are just he doesn't throw it all that hard. It's ninety three point six one hour fast, but it's got a huge spin on it, but they're just launching it him. He's got a three twenty three expected batting average with an expected slug of six point fifty four, and that's the one he throws the most. It's not pretty good. I don't know what to say.

Speaker 2Well, yeah, he has two or three starts, okay, and he looks great. He's a solid number number five, four or five starter, okay, and then in that fourth starter, the fifth start, it's absolutely destroyed and ruins everything he did in the first three or four. Right, So where are you going with this guy nowhere in a hurry would be my answer.

Speaker 1Yeah. This foreseingmer against right hand and pitching which right handed hitters, which he doesn't even he only throws twenty percent of the time, is an expected slug of eight twenty four. I don't think I've ever seen.

Speaker 2That HiT's number over that number. Yeah, yeah, man, that's brilli. Oh yeah yeah. There are badgers lining up saying they put me, put me in coach, I'm ready to play.

Speaker 1I will say that the Diamondbacks have recognized that he threw it. He threw his foresinger forty three percent of the time in twenty twenty three, and it's down to eighteen percent of the time now, So they recognized that, don't throw that pitch anymore.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's still too high, but yeah, they're working on.

Speaker 1It all right. How many waiver wire articles do we see Kevin Kinkle in this year. I've got the over under set it two.

Speaker 2Okay, I'm going with the under on that. Really what my early because my early season waiver wire might mention him as an option assuming the shoulders heeled with a string of caveats includer including never having sustained long term success you want him assume the risk. Before I bring up his name a second time, I will. I'm making it a point to mention and yourself, Frank, Ryan Thompson and Dre Jamison, anyone, anyone with a pulse, but Kevin Ginkle.

Speaker 2I'll go with Sell Frank in that eighty nine point two mile per hour heater and the Curfsiker combo at three point thirty eight off the border of the seven sixty ADP. Before I mentioned Kevin Ginkle twice.

Speaker 1I think that's wise because it's a every year Tim mentions Kevin Gekle and it's it's it's gotten to be ridiculous, it's it's funny. Actually, it's like.

Speaker 2I'm done.

Speaker 1I'm done, all right, give me a sleep in the organization, Minor and majors.

Speaker 2Okay, uh, I'll go with Salf Frank and that eighty nine point two mile an hour here. Somebody's going to close there and everybody's either heard or has proven to be ineffective. So I'll go with Salf Frank as a closer for some cheap saves. And we already mentioned. I already mentioned him earlier. Ryan Waldschmidt a combination of the skill set the mess that is the d Backs outfield. I think we're going to see him, possibly early in twenty twenty six. I like Ryan Walschmidt as much as

Speaker 2you do Rich a lot.

Speaker 1Andrew Southrank, according to roster resource, is lined up to be the closer. I actually don't know a ton about him.

Speaker 2Well, he's got eighty nine point two mile an hour fastball and he works with a curve sinker combo.

Speaker 1Okay, well ninety eight you said ninety eight mile hour fastball, right.

Speaker 2Eighty nine point two? What oh.

Speaker 1Eighty nine point two I'm looking at that. So he dows his curveball.

Speaker 2A ton, Yes, he does.

Speaker 1So. Nobody can hit his curveball. And he's got a four seamers coming up at ninety miles an hour. Great.

Speaker 2Yeah, I don't think he's going to be on many of yours jeams. Rich, I could be wrong.

Speaker 1No, wonder I know much about this guy. He's a short striker too good.

Speaker 2Yeah, oh yeah, he's he's got it all.

Speaker 1Rich had an ERA in one twenty four last season, with an expected ERA at three ninety one. Wow, that's a wow.

Speaker 2Anyone but Kevin Ginkle.

Speaker 1Okay, wow, I might even take Kevin Ginkle over that guy. Is there any is there any closer left on the on the board to be able to be signed.

Speaker 2I don't believe. I think I have to check, but I think they're all gone with the Fairbank signing.

Speaker 1Yeah, I think so too, but I could be wrong. Jason Foley's available now, he's still recovering from Tommy John surgery. I'll just go down my NFBC list last year, tell you all the guys that are available.

Speaker 2Yeah, there you go.

Speaker 1Tell you to take a break and get back, and let's doe the Colorado Rockies, all right, Timmy, let's hit it hard here with the Rockies. We both don't like the Colorado Rockies system at all, don't like how they approach things, but it is what it is. Brenton Doyle, Timmy, give me his twenty twenty six stat line for home run stolen bases in batting average.

Speaker 2Let's go with seventeen home runs, twenty six stolen bases in a two forty five BA.

Speaker 1All right, So that's not great batting average, but that's pretty good numbers. He is going as the thirty eighth I got all let me let me go change the filter to Uh, Draft Champions, I might have to sneeze here in a minute, I feel a sneeze coming on. We'll see if my my mute button works. We're going going as a thirty seventh outfielder off the board? Would you rather have Brenton Doyle or thirty six Brandon Nemo?

Speaker 2Uh?

Speaker 1Did you hear that? You and I need to hold a mute button? All right, I'm sorry, Tim, I'm sorry all of our listeners as well. I apologize. Wow.

Speaker 2Okay, that's that's that's okay, okay, all right.

Speaker 1Brent Doyler, Brandon Nemo at thirty six.

Speaker 2Uh, I'll take Nemo.

Speaker 1Wow. Chandler's sense that we're gonna skip Jacob Marcia. You're gonna take Marcia, You're gonna take Lawrence Butler. I'm assuming.

Speaker 2Yeah, I won't take. I won't take. I won't take the next two though.

Speaker 1Say Don Rafael and Noville Marte. You don't like those guys.

Speaker 2Yeah, I'll pause on those two playing time issues concerns between the two of them. Yeah, I'll take Doyle before then, but I personally thirty one and thirty two Marte, and I'm bumping them down the list of airy bit.

Speaker 1Uh, Dylan Cruz at thirty eight or Brenton Doyle at thirty seven.

Speaker 2Dylan Cruz, you're still a believer, Yes, I am.

Speaker 1I think we talked about him briefly last week. I got mixed up in my players. The data doesn't look good on that guy. But that's just he's fast. It's about it. Yeah, So Taylor Ward at thirty nine.

Speaker 2I'll take Doyle.

Speaker 1I'll take Ward, Stephen Kwan at forty I'll take Doyle, Ian Hap at forty one.

Speaker 2M I'll take Joe, I'll take Cap.

Speaker 1All right. So do you think that Doyle is about in the right spot then?

Speaker 2Yeah, I do. I think he's in, you know, give her, give her to take a spot to either. I think he's in about the right spot. Which identifies the fact that the you got some interesting choices and some incredibly interesting risk. As early as after pick thirty, I would say in the outfield, actually you go a little bit further. You could, you could go you go down the list, up the list, I guess is the appropriate wa say a little bit further when you're looking at risk. So it it identifies the fact that outfield presents some challenges.

Speaker 1Yeah, I we talked about that. We talked about that this Yeah, we talked about this at this podcast. Yeah, that's correct. I agree again my take according to when I share with my Patreon members, you don't need all outfitters in the first four or five rounds, which you can't wait till the end, otherwise it gets ugly. And let's talk about some of that in the next question. Kyle Carro's at five seventy four ADP, Zach Vien at four ninety four ADP, and Adele Amador at five ninety

Speaker 1According to roster Resource, they all will start the gear with a job in Colorado. Order them and how you would draft them?

Speaker 2Uh, veen, Amador and Caros. And the reason for that is I don't have any real interest in any of them. Okay, but when in doubt, I'll buy Speed, so Ving and Amador get the nod for me. Caros is no Speed, I'll go if I'm if I'm forced into it, it would be Ving, Amador and then Carols.

Speaker 1Do you have any interest in any of them?

Speaker 2No? None, Maybe maybe Zak being in a draft and Old depending on where where I'm sitting.

Speaker 1You know, Charis is a pretty good player though.

Speaker 2Yeah, he is. But but yeah, I when I'm looking at all three of them, the only thing that interests me is cheap speed.

Speaker 1Okay, but do you believe that they're going to start with jobs? If so, that gives them, according to the Tim McCleod manifesto, that gives them value.

Speaker 2Not in Colorado, it doesn't. There's a caveat to that manifest.

Speaker 1It because there was a manifesto out there. It's not uh, who is it that the manifesto? Who was the mm hmm okay, yeah, not to suggest that Tim is my lining with Ted, but there is a manifest There is a McLoud a festal So well.

Speaker 2I got a you know brow does that count?

Speaker 1Wow?

Speaker 4That's funny, all right, I just I've met, But it's very funny.

Speaker 2Who was there?

Speaker 1All right? So zach Bean would be the only one that you'd be remotely interested in, and that's only in the draft and hold as a late speculate bid on a stolen basis.

Speaker 2Yeah. Now again, if they get off, if any of the three get off to a hot start, you will see me taking notice fairly quickly because of the playing time situation, and I could see the potential for the ten man possibly all three of them making a waiver war article. Depending on what happens between now and Game one of the twenty twenty six season, guaranteed one or two of those guys will make a waiver war article online.

Speaker 1Well, or it's got the highest pedigree, if you will, just because he can hit. The pedigree is not the right word. He's got the highest floor because he can flat out hit. I'm not sure what happened in twenty twenty four, the year he got called up, when he hit one seventy one. That guy can hit, So I'm gonna call that a mulligan. Last year in TRIPAA hit three h three with a four or five to one base percentage, more walks and strake. That's more the player he is, so so I do give him up. Now,

Speaker 1how much fantasy relevance is he gonna have because there's not a ton of power. There's a little bit of speed. I mean it's maybe eight to ten home runs, twelve to fifteen stolen bases, but I think he can hit.

Speaker 2Right, Yeah, And again a lot of it's relevant on where you are in the draft, right yeah, if you draft that, Yeah, it's if he's sitting there in around thirty eight, why not? Yep, yeah, hey, but overall most of my leagues are redrafted, so for redraft purposes, no, no, none of the three will cut the mustard.

Speaker 1Victor Vodnik has the closer gig yet you interested, Tim.

Speaker 2I'll pass. But if you're totally desperate as it can get for saves, he saved your bacon last year, he should have first crack at the job. So yeah, if it gets down to the point where where he's the last closer on the board and you're lacking a little bit, yeah, okay, yeah, do what you have to do.

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 1I like Victor vonic having a bunch of dynasty leagues and you brought him up in twenty twenty four. I like the date. I took a gamble and he's gone as four to oh one off the board. So that is the twenty seventh round. I don't know, timmy I would I would, I would grab him.

Speaker 2Yeah yeah again, Yeah it's twenty seventh round. Sure, I'm not grabbing him in the teen round. Any you know it's I I've got, which sort of rules into our next question, how many wins do the Rockies get? I don't have enough that if Victor Vodneck saves them all. He might not be. That's true.

Speaker 1Forty three wins last year, so let's say he saves half of them. That's only twenty.

Speaker 2Yeah with an ERA of four plus.

Speaker 1Yeah, fair, that's fair. So do they win more games than forty three? They have to write?

Speaker 2Yes, I'm being an optimist. I'm saying they're gonna go fifty four and want to wait? Yeah, there a few.

Speaker 1Yeah, still a chance to be the worst team in baseball again.

Speaker 2Yes, the White Sox are all over them.

Speaker 1Not even well, they got mca murrow murkham. How do you pronounce the name again?

Speaker 2Murkmy murkhmmy.

Speaker 1There you go. Yeah, I just manually added him to my uh my data birth database so I could spell his name. When I was putting all my stuff together, he was falling down. I'm like, why, whatever the feed I have because I wasn't playing a major league game yet, it's not in my data feed coming from the provider, So I had to manually put him in there. Anyway, who cares? So I did have Spell's name?

Speaker 2Well, yeah, and you know that's a shame as a top five pick.

Speaker 1Rich that's for sure. Okay, Timmy. Can you a sleep in the organization? Minor and majors? I don't care.

Speaker 2Okay, well we gotta go with Charlie Condon. How long do Blaine Krim and Troy Johnson hold him off? I'm gonna say not very long. I agree with you, Okay. And if Amador can't get the job done, how can you argue with a prospect that is as rock solid as Regio?

Speaker 1Oh? I love Rock Ragio. Oh that would be great, and look that I will get.

Speaker 2Solid.

Speaker 1Yeah, I got everybody got that. I'm not giving you don't even think about getting a uh you work. You had to work too hard.

Speaker 2At it, man.

Speaker 1I'm that was prepared material, and everybody can tell that was prepared material. But I do like Rock Riggio. I saw my tons as a Yankee. That's a he's a grinder, he doesn't he's not a great player, but he's got a little bit of speed, he's got more pop than you think he can hit, and he just just goes out there and plays. So I do like Rock Riggio, and I will give Colorado one thing. They're not afraid to bring guys up. They don't stay up very long, but they're not afraid to bring them up.

Speaker 2No, well, hey, you're bringing them up to a Triple A team, right, so.

Speaker 1Yeah, well that's true. Don't forget about don't forget about col carrig either. It's a guy that struggled in Double A last season, but he's going to perform well because and uh, he'll be in triple playing Colorado Springs. Things will look really good. And that's what Colorado cares about. They look at you know, batting average and home runs and say, oh, bring them up.

Speaker 2Yeah. I'm going to bet that de Reggio ends up on at least one, possibly two of my waiver war pieces this year.

Speaker 1Yeah, let's hope. Let's hope.

Speaker 2Yeah, anybody else, Nope, that's it.

Speaker 1That's all she wrote to me. It's take a break, come back and talk about a few of the happenings over the last week. Good stuff, Timmy, I like doing the fantasy questions. We've got eight more systems to get through and we will sprinkle them in over the next month or so as Tim needs extra time to write stuff, and we'll just sneak them in.

Speaker 2Yeah. That's that's cool. I enjoy it too, too. Trying to trying to spitball and come up withotential answers to a lot of questions that they're gonna need answering. It. It's it's always a fun segment for me.

Speaker 1Yes, Sam and I was. I wrote all the ones on the al Wes and one of the I we talked about Edwin Diaz signing with the Dodgers, but one thing we didn't talk about was rookie Sasaki. Like all of a sudden, he was, you know, he was the closer during the playoffs and actually looked pretty good. And it's like, Nope, he's not a closer and it doesn't look like he's a closer to me. The question is is he going to be a starter? Is he going to be any good? Oh?

Speaker 2How many? Tyler Glass knows? Can you can you rock on one team? Rich? Is he that the problem?

Speaker 1Do you think?

Speaker 2Well? I don't. I don't know if we can say injury prone. But he still hasn't broken I think he's broke one hundred innings once in his career, maybe twice.

Speaker 1I don't think even in Japan.

Speaker 2Yeah, he's never hit the one twenty mark passed. I don't think it's passed. The one twenty mark. Yeah, it's you know what, there's I can see the Dodgers going with a six man rotation and making it work because in a five man rotation Glasnow and Sazaki aren't going to hold up. So and you've got Otani coming back from Tommy John. I think a six man rotation is a wise move for the Dodgers. I really do.

Speaker 1Thousand percent agree. Thousand percent agree. Okay, Timmy, let's uh, the Athletics trade for Jeff McNeil. Break up the Athletics. They're starting to, Hey, let's let's get a player. The metress of your jor Dan Rodriguez is a seventeen year old kid. Everybody could throw the ball upper ninety. So it's you know, there's it's just a you know the basically, the Mets are dumping Jeff McNeil. Just give me somebody that might be able to turn into something. That's that's what they got with Rodriguez. But Mets pay five and

Speaker 1five and three quarters million of the McNeil's sep fifteen to three quarters million, so the Athletics only pick up ten million dollars. Looks like he's gonna slot into second base.

Speaker 2Any interest, absolutely none?

Speaker 1Would you have rather seen Darrel hern eyes that get the at bats over Jeff.

Speaker 2McNeil most definitely the answer is yes, and hey, I'm not slamming McNeil. McNeil is a fine player as a super utility type on a contending team. Oakland isn't a contending team. Go with the kids, see what you got, uh. Jeff McNeil is not going to win them a World Series. On if he was traded to the Dodgers, he might be able to contribute to them winning a World Series. It's it just doesn't make sense to me on a

Speaker 2young team, why you'd want that veteran, that veteran presence. I'd rather go with the kids, see what they've got and keep developing those kids. That's my thoughts.

Speaker 1Yeah, he kind of does stick out like a sore th Britt Rooker's older, but everybody else is a young kid on that team, and Jeff McNeil is now the senior citizen at thirty three years old, the backup catchers thirty five, So it tend's right. I mean, why waste ten million dollars on Jeff McNeil.

Speaker 2Well, all you can expand on that when we get to our last question. And I think I will expand on it.

Speaker 1Okay, all right, so let's let's get to the last questions. We'll we'll go to the Marlins and Pete Fabranks. Later on, the Pirates signed Ryan O'Hearn. The Pirates are continuing to get better, maybe marginally, but this feels like what the Roys. Remember what the Royals did a couple of years ago when they made the playoffs. They brought in some established guys to fit around Bobby wit Junior and mcalgarcy and Vin ep and you know they they did. Okay, is it going to work for the Pirates then.

Speaker 2No, it's not.

Speaker 1Might you sure to think more about that? No?

Speaker 2No, no, I uh here here here's my rather and maybe it's uh uh, I'm facetious the right the Pirates had to pay someone this year's so they could prove that the current system doesn't work and push hard for a salary cap in the CBA negotiations.

Speaker 1Oh so you think that's what the athletics are doing.

Speaker 2Hey, they gotta they're they're paying somebody. Okay, the Pirates are paying somebody. Is Ryan o'harn't going to make a difference to the Pittsburgh Pirates. I don't see. I like Ryan o'hearan. I think he's a fine player. If he signed with a team like Seattle Tora, a playoff type team, yeah, it would make a difference. All this will do is boost the Pirates payroll to the point where they can say, we spent money and it didn't work. We need a salary cap. Maybe I'm just being over negative a little,

Speaker 2but that that's where I'm at right now with the Pirates, and I wouldn't rule out over to the discussion at some point in time, Hey, we spent our money. Where to get us?

Speaker 1Timmy. Look, I think man Hearn's a fine, fine platoon guy. I think he's got power and looked really good last year with the Orioles, and when he got traded, not as good, but still okay. But look when you got Paul skeins As, you're number one, Bubba Chandler's potentially going to be a fine number two. Jared Jones eventually coming back to be year three throwing blacks and Ashcroft that I like a lot, And Mitch Keller's a solid back of the rotation guy. They got the pitching, Timmy, They've got the pitching. So and once they bring up Connor Griffin,

Speaker 1which I think is going to happen soon, throw him in with the Neil Cruz and Jake mancumb is okay. And now they got Brandon Lowe, who's a fine player. I don't know, Timmy. It feels pretty good to me. It feels like they have a chance in a weak central UH central division to do some things.

Speaker 2Well, yeah, I except that you know Spencer Horowitz, Nick Zelles.

Speaker 1Don't don't talk about Spencer Horrowitz. Mister McLeod, you were all over him last year. I'm not letting off the hook, Spencer Horror. It's big fan, big fan.

Speaker 2That's an old guy. Your memory is supposed to be feeding rich. It's not happening apparently. No, Yeah, okay, moving on. No, I mean but.

Speaker 1Maybe maybe there there's nothing there with the pirates. But look, I at least start doing something. I mean, I get I get the cynical nature that that, Hey, they this is a token uh small signed by rain or Herne. They spend a little money on Brandon a little bit. In the whole scheme of things, they're not spending any money. I get it.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's yeah, the Pirates will improve, it'll come to trading deadline. There are two games out of a playoff spot, and they won't buy anyone.

Speaker 1It's kind of related to what the Marlins did with Peter Peter Fairbanks. I mean they need a closer yecause of Hernando is it Hernandez Henriki? What was the guy's name but Ronnie? Yeah, Ronnie Hericuez.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, bummer.

Speaker 1You don't sign a Pete Fairbanks. I think unless you feel like you're going to compete. I mean, that's a legitimate closer. Why did they sign him? Do they really think they could compete? Uh?

Speaker 2I don't think they can compete, But if they hold on to San Dieokintara for a while, they're going to be a solid team. I was sort of surprised. I figured Fairbanks with all the talk in Toronto about Hoffman not closing next year, they haven't done anything as far is changing that. I was sort of surprised. I figure Fairbanks would would end up in Toronto. But overall, I have two reasons why this is probably my favorite off season signing. Okay, big reason, Yeah, yep them shot Yeah, yeah,

Speaker 2it's possible. Yeah, it's one less reliever. I have to worry about cutting into Riley O'Brien's chances of closing in Saint Louis.

Speaker 1You brought that up last week. That's fair, yes.

Speaker 2And number two, I don't have to mention or even think about Calvin Fotcher in twenty twenty six. So wow, he was Yeah, he's not making a waiver where I don't have to worry about parrying him up with one and fourteen other pictures. I like, yeah, I'm I'm happy with that trade. It's all about me and this will cause me the sleepy here. What more did a guy want?

Speaker 1For sure? Tell me that is a rabbit singer final break it back and uh sayah goodbye? Shall we?

Speaker 2Yes? We shall.

Speaker 1Not as long in the show A specifically too, But tell me. I'm a big consumer of podcasts, and everybody's on vacation the last two weeks of the year, and we're we've given people two podcasts for the for the last week of December. I feel pretty good about that.

Speaker 2As do I. And I'd like to give a quick show out to uh Chris Pennants at Baseball three sixty five, he had he had a question on the pause, and he asked if you know, it sounds off to me when Rich goes into a break and Tim McCloud doesn't say sounds good or make a comment. And he actually picked up and noticed that, and I gave him an explanation. I've been dealing with colds and this set and the next thing, and I've been coughing up lungs during the break. Yet I just I got to give Chris a shout

Speaker 2out for he is a true listener Rich to pick up on on the fact that I was sneaking out early to uh cough cough my week. Wow. Yeah, So good for you, Chris, appreciate it. Thanks so much for that.

Speaker 1That that is impressive. Wow. Yeah, guy with maybe a little bit too much time on his hands, I will see trying to figure out the Tim McLoud is out there. That's that's impressive. So even I hadn't pick up on that. Wow.

Speaker 2Yeah, No, I've been for the past month or so. I've been dealing with a lot of a lot of colds, and I've been hacking and this set and the next thing, losing my voice occasionally, so I've been taking the breaks. He's sneaking out early, Rich, So if you have to deduct from my I'll understand.

Speaker 1Okay, well good, I'm glad you all right, Timmy, thought i'll be after this week and I got some more stuff and pounce our patron members again. Join us out at the patroon side if you can, and tell me your I guess we'll see in the new year.

Speaker 2Yeah, I'm gonna be busy ranking second base and the list of seven will be ready, probably by Wednesday.

Speaker 1Rich The list of seven second base. Second base is tough, so yes, yes, Jackson holiday, so.

Speaker 2Yeah, it's it's getting to look that way. But it has been a good year, and I thank you. I thank our listeners and everybody hanging hanging out to discord the whole the whole group. Here's wishing everybody all the best in the new year. Happy new year, folks.

Speaker 1Talk to you too soon, Timmy

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 2277 - Fantasy Questions of the NL Central

    Nov 15, 20261 hr 57 minAudio

    Fantasy Baseball Live - November 15, 2026 Segment 1 - News and Notes 1.The awards came out this past week and it was pretty overwhelming. MVP and Cy Young were unanimous and ROY was what I would call overwhelming. a.MVP...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 2276 - Detroit Tigers Top Prospects

    Nov 14, 202624 minAudio

    The following players are discussed: 1. Zyhir Hope (OF) 2. Josue Briceno (C) 3. River Ryan (RHP) 4. Bryce Rainer (OF) 5. Cameron Flukey (RHP) 6. Kash Mayfield (LHP) 7. Jordan Yost (SS) 8. Brady Smith (RHP) 9. Thayron...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 2275 - We finish our first mock draft - five rounds

    Nov 8, 20261 hr 24 minAudio

    Fantasy Baseball Live - November 8, 2026 @ 2:15 pm ET Segment 1 - Tim’s trip to Arizona •Fun stuff oHow’s the traffic oBest meal that you’ve had oBest conversation that you had? oDid you win any money at the casinos?...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 2274 - Cleveland Guardians Top Prospects

    Nov 8, 202619 minAudio

    The following players are discussed: 1. Ralphy Velazquez (1B) 2. Angel Genoa (SS) 3. Welbyn Francisca (SS) 4. Jaison Chourio (OF) 5. Braylon Doughty (RHP) 6. Cooper Ingle (C) 7. Liam Peterson (RHP) 8. Aaron Walton (OF)...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 2273 - Where do the free agents sign?

    Oct 31, 20261 hr 32 minAudio

    Fantasy Baseball Live! - October 31, 2026 - 9:15 am ET Segment 1 - The Brewers are the World Series Champions 1.They made it look pretty easy. They came extremely close to a sweep. Were you surprised at how easily the...

    Credit the people on this episode