Rich and Tim continue their discussion about the 2026 starting pitchers
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Salitations everyone in Trich Wilson Walking Too, Fantasy Baseball Live. It's our part two of starting Pictures. I'm back as always with the great Tim McCloud and Tim has done a marvelous job of putting the rankings together. And as we left back on Sunday, Tim I asked you the question, how do you figure out this health equation? Do you look at past of the health of these pictures or do you try to predict something in the future. Do you take a look at maybe some concerns they had in the second half of the previous year. What do
Speaker 1you do? What do you personally do to try to figure out the health of these guys going into then going into drafts of whether you should grab a or not.
Speaker 2Well, it's a combination of things, Rich, I use a Ouiji board and a dartboard.
Speaker 1Which just prefer the Oigi or the dart.
Speaker 2I can manipulate the Luigi board a lot easier than I can a dark board. I have the holes of the wall to prove it. So I gotta go with Ouigi. No. I try and look at the past history, age trends, and at some point in time you just have to, like you know, we've never seen suspect sustaining health from Hunter Green for the most part. Okay, Chris Sale, we
Speaker 2struggle with Jake Crum. They both strugg and they're closing, closing in on thirty eight. Age definitely comes into play as just past history. But at some point in time I don't like predicting injuries because that's such a negative. You know, who is going to get hurt? Who isn't I have no idea. Okay, for all we know, we could. We could lose the top three pictures in the game inside of a week. We lost two first round bats inside of twenty four to forty eight hours. You really
Speaker 2don't know. But I think you can look at trends and look at the past and use that information. Hey, yeah, I can remember looking back years ago at oh what was his name, the second baseman in texas Ian Kinslor Kensler. Yeah, yeah, he was. He was. You know, he struggled in it, you know, the early part of his career staying healthy and it was a problem. Then all of a sudden it was gone and it was no more, and he
Speaker 2stayed healthy for a number of years. Predicting health into the future, I think the only thing you can look at for the most part of the keys got to be a combination of past, history and age.
Speaker 1I'm also curious your thoughts on You're really high on Youri Prez also high on Sandy al Contra and his brother, Sandy al Contera. Yes, what about guys who have had Tommy John surgery then pitched part of the year and looked healthy, Maybe not effective, but looked healthy. Do you give those guys a bit of a boost? Somebody like Sandy al Contrera, who was great before he had Tommy John surgery, struggled last season, but is now a two
Speaker 1years removed from Tommy Johnson.
Speaker 2Yeah. I think when we look at Tommy John, Okay, the assumption is, okay, he's having Tommy John. It'll be twelve months, we'll see him back on the field, and there'll be one hundred percent in fifteen months. Okay, Well that's not the case. It's not linear, Okay. Each and every person is an individual. Some bounce back quicker, some bounce back slower, some don't bounce back at all. And I think that sometimes we get too tied up in
Speaker 2the oh, he's gone for a year. Well, not everybody heals at the same face. And when I look at a player like al Kantara, we saw some real positive signs at the end of the year was his first full season back, and he wasn't the same picture he was before undergoing Tommy John. But when I see like those last eight starts last year, that to me is
Speaker 2a reminder that not everybody heals at the same pace. And he's heading in the right direction. So I am going to bump him up heading into the year following. Whether or not that that proves to be true, the only time will tell. But what do you do with a picture that doesn't come back on pace per se? You know, hey, you either down shift or you up shift and Spencer stride, I've down shifted a little bit because I say that I just didn't see the same
Speaker 2positive indicators that I saw with Al Kantara.
Speaker 1Yeah, second one for Spencer Streyder actually the second one for Jacob to Gron, but at least the first one for Jacob to Gron was like fifteen years ago. Spencer Streider has been a lot a lot less time between two before we get into twenty one to thirty. Great answer, by the way, I really appreciate that hopefully our listeners will pick up on some of that. Joe Ryan, you between shows, you made a comment to me about he's a good first half pitcher, not so good in the
Speaker 1second half.
Speaker 2Yeah. You know, you look at the numbers and the numbers look solid, but then you start looking a little deeper. And the second Alvira last year was four sixty seven. In twenty twenty four, it was three ninety eight, and you only made four starts in twenty twenty three, a second happy array of six nine and eleven starts. That to me is a trend. And if I had Joe Ryan Rostard, I would probably be looking at trading him sometime towards the middle end of July to take advantage
Speaker 2of the great first halfs versus what we've seen over the past three years, the slow second half. That's just something I picked up when I was going through and scanning scanning some of the numbers for Ryan.
Speaker 1Great stuff, all right. Twenty one, we got Pablo Lopez, twenty two, Kevin Gausman, twenty three, show of Tani. We're not going to really talk about Otani because most people will will have him as a hitter. Santy al Contra twenty four, Michael King twenty five, Nick Pavetta, Nolan McClain the first of the big young pitchers coming up. Tim likes him the best. Fram Ra Valdez Jacob Mazarowski the second of the young pictures coming up and then coming in number thirty. Hayes's lazarda all right, Timmy, you got Pablo Lopez seventeen slots higher than the NFC. Pablo Lopez
Speaker 1A lot of people for well, probably don't forget, but just two years ago he was a top fifteen pitcher.
Speaker 2Well, yeah it was. It wasn't a good year. He had a terrace major strain okay, and a mild forearm strain in September, and he was limited to only fourteen starts. Now, they were very good starts when he pitched, there was there was nothing wrong when he was on the mound. The run of three consecutive thirty two start seasons came to an end. But I think people are forgetting how good Pablo Lopez was for an extended period of time,
Speaker 2and I think he can return return to what he was after an injury riddled twenty twenty five, which I'm I don't see anything at this point in time. That leads me to book believe he can't be who he was. It was a pretty good picture.
Speaker 1Do you know where the terrace major muscle is?
Speaker 2I have no idea. The minor one. I think I know where it is.
Speaker 1Terrest majors is terrast majors under the armpit the ar Yeah, that's that's where. So obviously pretty important. You're trying to pitch, maybe not for sidearm pictures, but for for guys that over the top. You kind of need that so in case anybody.
Speaker 2Yeah, and that's a tough it's tough on deodrant as well.
Speaker 1That's true. It's funny when we uh when we moved to me Up. It's so you're you're consolidating two houses and we're gonna throw away stuff that's still usable. But I have I think I bought I bought two h six packs of deodorant, and I only use one out of each place. I've got ten sticks of deodorant. Tim, I think I'm good for two years.
Speaker 2Of I was gonna say, yeah, you're you're good to go for a while for a while.
Speaker 1Kevin Goussman, you like him ten slots higher than the NFC thirty two in the NFC. You got him going twenty second.
Speaker 2Yeah, you know. You look at the number of starts he's made over the past five years thirty three, thirty one, thirty thirty one, thirty one, thirty two. His highest year over this span was a three eighty three. The sinker is a devastating bits. The whiff rates what thirty eight six as a number two starter. I like Kevin Gossman, I really do. I know there's no such thing as a safe pitching pick, but he's just been reeling off consecutively solid, heavy workload type seasons for a while now
Speaker 2and I don't see that changing this year, so've I bumped him up, considering him to be a little bit safer than some of the other picks in this group.
Speaker 1I think people got ex when he had that low era in twenty twenty three. I mean it is the ra's kind of gotten back to where's expected eras, which is an upper threes pitcher. But that's just yeah, I think that's who the guy is. I mean, he does get hit harder than his stuff would suggest. His fastball is a little flat because of that, and if you take a look at the expected slug on his fastball is let me get that three four sixty five. So
Speaker 1it does get hit hard, so and it's this smot finger that that nobody hits obviously, So that's the why he throws a lot too. Yep, definitely, Michael King is the reason he is going lower in drafts because there's some injury concerns about him.
Speaker 2Well, last year wasn't a good year. He was rolling right right along up until May eighteen. Then you woke up with what was you know, a kink in his next sore and shoulder and it ended up being a nerve issue in the sideline and through to August nine, and then he had some knee inflammation he missed another month. Yeah, it wasn't a good year from a health perspective. But everything I've been reading is that he's heading into spring
Speaker 2in good condition and he had a really really good run as the badres Ace, and I'm betting he picks up where he left off.
Speaker 1I'm going to get a little out of joy years ago, you know, one through X, but I'm gonna group these next guys stolen, starting with Nolan McLain. Are these young hot shot pictures which we all saw last year to a certain extent, and it's Nolan McClain at twenty seven, Hayes, Jacob Masarowski at twenty nine, Emma she In at thirty three, camp st at thirty seven, and Chase Burns forty. Kind
Speaker 1of use those five guys together. You clearly like Nolan McLain the best and a little bit down on Chase Burns minus nine. So kind of talk about those guys together on why you like, you know, why you have them in that order.
Speaker 2Oh well, hey, McLain moved, made the move from double A thirteen starts at triple A, and he sure didn't look lost when the Mets called him up. I think the kid's got a ton of talent, and I saw enough last year that I think of those of those five, he's a boat. As safe from that group of five as you can get. I expect big things from Nolan McLain.
Speaker 1Does he have the highest upside?
Speaker 2The highest upside? No, The highest upside, in my opinion, is Miserabi in Milwaukee.
Speaker 1That just because the fastball and the crazy height and so forth.
Speaker 2Yeah, yeah, the whole package. The problem with Miseroski, and you mentioned it numerous numerous times. Is control. Uh huh, yeah, yeah, you know, Hey, you gotta throw strikes. Okay. The skills are as good as any young starters in the game. Is where I put my nerves. He's just gotta throw strikes and if he heaved. Is the wide range of potential outcomes for Jacobski. He could be a top five starter.
Speaker 2He could be off out of the top one hundred inside of three years.
Speaker 1A few pitchers in baseball have Tyler Glaso's stuff. Tyler Glass's problem has been health, and I think that's well documented. Jacob Zerowski's got Tyler glass stuff, Tyler Glasnow's height, size, all of that. So if you believe Tyler Glasso as a top ten talent in pitching in baseball, then I think that's where Jacob Mezerowski is now. Hopefully he'll have better health and we'll wind up higher than thirty ninth on Tim's list for Jick for Tyler Glassnow. But I
Speaker 1think that's the kind of talent we're talking about. So I agree with you.
Speaker 2Yeah, it's it's all about the strikes and you start looking at the other yeah, Emma shean, yeah, yeah, so do I. We've seen some some brilliant work from Shean and the only the big concern with she is again, you're not going You're not going to see a hundred and seventy five innings from machine. You're going to see one hundred and forty hundred and fifty and they could be very, very good innings.
Speaker 1That's my if I can emote from one, that's my big concern about all Dodgers pitchers is Yeah, I mean they I think we're looking at a different model here. We're looking at a huge U pitching staff that they're gonna They're gonna abuse the minor league options that are there and call up and bring these guys up, and they're gonna save Glassnow, they're gonna save Blake Snow, Yamamodo, All these guys are going to get time off because they're gonna bring in the river Ryans of the world,
Speaker 1et cetera, and she and once it gets late in the season, if he's still healthy, they're gonna start doing the same thing with him too.
Speaker 2Yeah. I think the only picture that I feel reasonably safe to exceed one hundred and fifty innings is Yama Modal.
Speaker 1Yeah, but he's not going to go Do you think he's gonna go past one to eighty.
Speaker 2No, no, I think seventy five top, but yeah, no, yeah. When I started doing the Dodgers and looking at their system, I think I got ten Dodgers listed, okay, on this two hundred plus list, because all of the Dodgers were Bolski, Ryan Stone. Go through the they're all going to find They're all going to find innings. There is no way that they are going to overwork o Tawni and she had a whole group of them last Snow that you
Speaker 2can overwork Blake Snell.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah, can I give you rim settle.
Speaker 2But you know where I'm where I'm coming from. Their goal is to win the third one. Okay, to win the third one. They need a healthy rotation heading into the playoffs, and they will do whatever it takes to see that, you know, come to fruition, which means on my waiver wire, we're going to see a lot of dark Dodgers starting pictures off and on this year, right.
Speaker 1Yeah, And I think they'll be taking rest as opposed they'll be something. All pictures are hurt all the time, so they'll give They'll give Yamamoto off three weeks to nurse a hamstring or assor this or whatever, and uh and that's what they'll do. So finish it up with Chase burns Mine. You got him at the fortieth. He's going as the thirty first picture off the board. There was some entry concern last season. No one's doubting the stuff, which is premium. Your thoughts on Shakespearen, why have you
Speaker 1knocked him down a bit?
Speaker 2Hell, he hasn't had his first Tommy John has he? No? Okay, may I for a moment, did you hear what you just said?
Speaker 1He hasn't had his first Tommy Jones up. The implications are there's going to be multiple ones. I just want to just if I could point that out. That was really spooky that ye.
Speaker 2Yeah, you know he missed. I'm not even gonna think about that right now. We'll move on. Wow, he missed a month with a grade one right lecxure straight and first season in the BIGS as a twenty three year old. Okay, you look at his He's throwing one hundred and twenty nine inings last year starting at High A, going right through to forty three, and the third was Cincinnati. There's
Speaker 2he's got incredible stuff. There's no doubting that. But when you can't make it through your first full pro season without spending time on the il with a right flexer strain that has danger Will Robinson written all over it. And that's why I'm a little bit lower. Okay, Yeah, this road for simple.
Speaker 1Hazus has already have ten slots lower than the NFBC. And I find this perplexing because you talk so much about strikeouts and Lazard to tie for fourth and strikeouts are two sixteen. Why, I mean, the strikeouts are so becoming so difficult to accumulate given there's not enough Indians pitch, there's not enough strikeout pictures. Why did Hazer's Lozardo so much?
Speaker 2Because he walks too many consistently? He walks too many. This isn't a this isn't a one off. He walked fifty seven last year and one hundred and eighty three twenty two the year before. In sixty six, he walked fifty five and twenty twenty three. Yeah, my thoughts on Lozardo three seventy three, seventy two four eer a type picture, a one twenty whip and a pile of strikeouts. So
Speaker 2when I look at Lizardo I start to think we know what we have. The walks have been a concern and I don't think that's going to change. Okay, my thoughts with lazarro Hey take the wins, the drakeouts, and hope the aer holds fast under four. So let's measically where I'm at. As far as Bizard it was concerned. I think he is what he is, and he's a good pitcher, but I don't think he's a top twenty type pitcher. Eer A I think is going to fluctuate on a little bit too high. And same with the
Speaker 2whip when you get a one twenty whip that doesn't screen top twenty. To me.
Speaker 1Before before we take our formal break down, why don't you opine when mister Tetsui Amaya at thirty one, he's going to the NFBC at fifty three full disclosure, he is on my NFC team. I've got my fingers crossed. I'm rooty for Amaya. I'm not convinced yet. Convince me and our listeners what you see in Amaya.
Speaker 2Well, four consecutive sub three ARA season in Japan before coming over with better than the strikeout recurringing. Okay, the fastball might be a little bit straight. But my big concern with him is is the walks. Okay, walks were a problem up until last year, and he had a huge decrease in his walk rates in twenty twenty five. Now, if that holds, and as I put it, if the
Speaker 2walk rates stand the test of time, he's going to be using all of those opt out clauses he negotiated into his contract. I think the stuff is that good that it's all about the walks. And when I look at the pictures in the you know, in the range of pictures from say twenty five through to forty, there's a ton of question marks in there, and I think
Speaker 2his stuff warrants going a little higher than what most are right now. How how old is the MI twenty seven I believe.
Speaker 1So he could argue his twenty six was last year. That's about the time frame that guys begin to find their control. So hopefully that is the case here, at least from your from your argument.
Speaker 2Yeah, I I just think there's more there than what people currently are believing and expecting, and only time is going to tell and that little zero point zero but oh, every time I mentioned his name, Timmy if.
Speaker 1He comes in walking six for nine, you're never gonna live it down. So just FYI. So let's let's take a quick break and continue. We've got about another twenty minutes that we're going to be talking, and then we'll wrap it up. Part two of our Starting Fit preview, timis put together just a marvelous list. Part three will be next week where we'll be talking the sleepers and
Speaker 1guys a little bit further down in the list. So lots more to talk about with starting pitchers. Let's talk thirty one through forty. We've already talked about Tetsui Ami at thirty one, Nick Lodole at thirty two, imit she and we've already talked about at thirty three, my buddy Kyle Bradish, which Tim does not like, Lewis Castile at thirty five, Spencer Streider at thirty six, Cam Schlitzler at thirty seven, Robbie Ray thirty eight, Tyler Glass that we know why he's lower at thirty nine, and Chase Burns
Speaker 1at forty. What's wrong with Kyle Bright Kyle Bradish.
Speaker 2Tim absolutely nothing. I thought I was being bullish at thirty four. Obviously I thought wrong.
Speaker 1A really interesting.
Speaker 2Yeah, I like him. I like him. I I just don't like him as much as the nfbcfol Atty two.
Speaker 1Twenty two is pretty bullish. I liked him. He went too early in the NFBC for me. I wasn't able to grab him. I thought twenty two was a little bullish.
Speaker 2Yeah, I you know, when I look at him at at thirty four, just ahead of him, I've got dam at Chian. Okay, that's sort of the same situation, isn't it. They're both relatively young, high upside Lodolo. I like the increase in inningsh and Maya Lozardo. I guess you can move wherever you want. But I thought I was being bullish. I thought it was a good spot for him, somewhere between thirty and forty Only Time, Only Time Hotel. But
Speaker 2I like the picture.
Speaker 1I have Lewis Castile on one Dynasty League, which is mostly what I play. And maybe it's me, but every time I see the stat line when I wake up in the morning, because I don't get a chance to watch many of his games because they're on the West Coast, so many times it's a lousy outing. But yet he's still you know he's gone forty nine, you kind of five he's still going as a top pitcher. Are we starting to see the downward slope of Lewis Castile or is there still a lot here?
Speaker 2I think there's a lot of bang for the buck. Okay, Yeah, you look at his error okay, and yeah it's not spectacular. You look over the past five years three ninety eight, two ninety nine, three thirty four, three sixty four, three fifty four, the whip is in the one seventeen one, eighteen one ten in the past three years. But what what what caught my attention is the fact that he's pitched one hundred and eighty seven and two thirds one
Speaker 2hundred and fifty and a third one hundred and ninety seven, one hundred and seventy five, one hundred and eighty strikeouts are consistently in the one sixty one seventy five range. I like Lewis Castillo because he's only failed, okay, to attain thirty or more starts in three of his nineties seasons. He's not going to have the highest strikeout totals or the lowest year a but I think as a number
Speaker 2three starter, he posts consistently solid numbers, maybe even boring numbers, okay, And that's okay. There's nothing wrong with having a number three like Lewis Casillo. It's going to give you a mid mid threes the ra and one hundred and seventy strikeout. It's a chance of wins with Seattle's strong offense or decent offense at the very least. I just think he gets undervalued. It's like or sort of lost in the shuffle,
Speaker 2you know what I mean. Maybe people's expectations are higher, but I like what I'm seeing from Lewis Luis Castillo year after years like that. Already, Bunny, you put a battery and he just keeps on, keeps on keeping on.
Speaker 1I'm going to get that. I mean, he is definitely consistent, but his expected hera is pretty much four for the last three years. And I think that's what That's what I've experienced, is a guy that gets knocked around a little bit too much for a guy that you can count on as a number two starter. I think he's more of a number three starter, but going in the wrong direction. And I think if he ever gets traded out of Seattle, then I got real problems. With that.
Speaker 2There. Yeah, I don't have any problems with it. I just think right now if I if I had Luis Castudio as my number three, I'd be happy any in the next year.
Speaker 1Let's see what his home away splits are here, shall we? Yeah, that would be splits splits twenty twenty five at Baseball Reference, which has the best best split data in my humble opinion, and see your platoon splits home he is a three sixty three at home and oh, I'm sorry that's not right. Uh home a way splits Whe's is the Era two sixty earra at home for seventy one away?
Speaker 2Okay, So yeah that tells the tale is yep.
Speaker 1So that's what I would have. And you can even argue if he's got a tough away matchup, you might want to sit him.
Speaker 2Yeah, if he's going into Dodger Town and going up against any one of their fourteen aieces, Yeah, that it might be time to let him.
Speaker 1Write are going into Sacramento with the Athletics and that Hu Hummer Park, Yeah, stuff like that. But you know you're probably playing at Pittsburgh and you know you're playing with the White Sox and the way and you know all those types of teams, but the other ones tough top maybe seven or eight clubs, you might and environment you might want to sit them.
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 1I agree, Spencer Stryder. You talked a little bit about him at the top of the show. Up of the last show. You got him down at thirty six. He's going as a number two starter with the NFC at twenty eight.
Speaker 2Yeah, at this point in time, I like, hey, you went seven and fourteen last year with a four to forty five year a one forty whip and he struck out basically a batter in an inning. I you know, I I I look at the results from August on okay, starting at August six five and runs eight e and runs seven ere and runs one three, two, one zero three.
Speaker 2Definitely it improved in September. But again I look at the strikeout rates per SAE at the beginning of August six two two three one Spence Australier only striking one bagger against the Cubs in Chicago. I just have some concerns. I think Spencer Strider should improve this year, but I'm not willing. I'm not willing to pay for it. Quit yet.
Speaker 1Cam Schlittler's at number thirty seven, also going thirty seven in the infancy. I'm gonna I'm gonna start on this one. I saw Cam Schlitzler play a lot in the minor league, and I remember the first time I saw him, I'm like, why don't I know about this guy? Loved the arm and his big fastball was a great slider. But as I got more data on the guy, I never saw the kind of breakout that we saw last year. Was a sub three era and a guy that just looked like a potential young stud coming up. The data just
Speaker 1does not support that. Everyone that the expected era is four thirteen. He's got good stuff. He does not have a pitch. He doesn't have a splitter or a change up to go against glove side batters. He just doesn't. There was a little bit of a sinker, only throws at six percent of the time. It is a four seemer cutter. It's not even a sweeper curveball as a four seam cutter. And both get a twenty eight percent with rate, which is good especially on the fastball, but not on a secondary pitch like a cutter. Should be
Speaker 1a lot higher than that. I think there's some warning signs here. I think he's a good picture. It feels more like a number four pitcher as opposed to a number two pitcher. And he's going as a number two starter, and I'm a number two, number three starter, and I just worry about that.
Speaker 2I worry about it as well. I thought I was. I thought I was being a little bit over exuberant in having him at thirty seven. We match up the NFBC and yours, truly, we match up on that one. I am really concerned about the fact that he walked thirty one batters last year in seventy three innings.
Speaker 1Yeah, there's that.
Speaker 2Uh yeah, that concerns me. And I thought I was being bullish at thirty seven, taking into consideration in the walks. But the walks concerned me. Yeah, it's I can tell you how many teams I'll have him on this year, and that's the answer, there is none.
Speaker 1I just remember seeing him. I think I saw him in the postseason for the first time pitch and I remember distinctly writing out the notes to our Patreon members, gone, I don't know this guy is, but stuff looks really good. And then you know, that's kind of my head was like a number four starter, and all of a sudden he does what he does last year. I'm like, I don't get this, and it's you know, so it's funny. You go from exuberance like wow, I think I found something with Cam Schlittler going and then also going what is that good? And I just I can't go there yet?
Speaker 2No, I can't either. Nope, all right.
Speaker 1Number forty one is the bane of Tim's existence and Tanner Biby still got of fourteen slots higher than the NFCC.
Speaker 2I can't.
Speaker 1He thinks he can let go, but he just can't quite let go, right.
Speaker 2No, I'm it's it's like gorilla glue. Okay, yeah, I'm still stuck on Tanner.
Speaker 1He was one of He's one of my targets too, Timmy, So I the data looks great on this guy. I don't know. It maybe never comes together.
Speaker 2Yeah that's yeah. If it does come together, yeah, it's his, won't It might not be on one of my fantasy teams. I still think there's more there than what we saw last year. Wild Lady in consistent. I can't believe that's the best that we're gonna see. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's it's.
Speaker 1Not okay forty so forty one, tender Biby, Ryan Peppio at forty two, Sundie Gray at forty three, Baba Channeler the first rookie elig well Amaya's rook yell, but the first legitimate rookie eligible guy is Bubba Chandler. Drew Rasmus forty six, Andrew Abbott. Blake's now Tim hats Blake's now minus twenty eight. We know why because he gets hurt all the time.
Speaker 2Kate Horton again, Has he hurt again? Yeah, oh yeah, oh yeah, he's not going to start the season. He's starting the season, I believe on the ale. I'll just confirm that.
Speaker 1Wow, Kate Horton at forty eight. My buddy at Ranger Swarre is at forty nine. There's still no love for Rangers Swars. Yet he just goes out and performs and shutting up Amanaga at fifty which last year he was at twenty four. So pretty interesting drop by Emenaga a little hurt last season. So we're to start here, Sonny Gray minus ten from where you have where the NFC is going. Any thoughts there.
Speaker 2Well, other than the fact that Sonny Gray is hold is Sonny Gray here, thirty six going on six. Okay, yeah, he's thirty six years old now turning turning thirty seven later on this year. Last year, he won fourteen games. He posted a four to twenty eight ERA one twenty three whip. Yeah, he struck out two hundred and one
Speaker 2saw a high workload of one hundred and eighty and two thirds innings. I think, I think what you've got is one hundred and eighty to two hundred strikeouts and a four plus and one twenty plus whip to go along with whatever whatever wins he can he can muster in Boston. And I'm just I just don't feel confident that we'll see we'll see another two hundred strikeouts. We might see the two hundred strikeouts, but the ERA has
Speaker 2been trending seriously along with the whip in the wrong direction, and he's not getting any younger. So that's that's my that's my sunny great story.
Speaker 1Coming into the twenty twenty five season, Bubba Chandler was my top ranked pitching prospect, and rightly so. After the first four games, he looked like, boy, this guy is going to get caught up any moment I was doing the countdown for when Bubba Chandler was going to be caught up, thinking that he'd follow the Paul Schemes roadmap, and then it all went south.
Speaker 2For him, and yeah, big time, didn't it.
Speaker 1They finally brought him up at the end of the season actually looked pretty good. So is Bubba Chandler going to be the guy that I thought he was coming into the season in the first four games last season? Or is he the guy that struggled after May first in the minor leagues?
Speaker 2He's going to be that first guy? Yeah, yeah, yeah, there's I have no notes at Bubba Chandler's going to be a very good Sure, it might take a little longer than we originally anticipated, because hey, you know, you look at what you've done in the minors, et cetera, et cetera. You know, Para skings up early. Bubba Chandler is almost as good as Skiing, isn't he. Not everybody progresses at the same case. And I think part of the Bubba Chandler thing is the Paul Skiing thing, right.
Speaker 1That's true. I mean, Paul Skans, Paul Skins is an exception. Paul Skins is you know, a oh what do they call it where yeah, you know, yes, a unicorn. I was thinking a guy like Mike Trout, like comes a generational talent. There you go, that's the what I'm looking for, a generational talent is that? And then some yeah, yeah, he's just that guy. Uh And Bubba Chandler struggles a little bit and people go like, that's impossible. He's as good as Paul Skins. He's not.
Speaker 2No, I'm out. But I think I think that's sort of magnified the issue because all the hype on Chandler was as as he's going to be one of the best in the game, and not everybody progresses at the same pace. And I still think Bubba Chandler is going to be a very good picture.
Speaker 1And they change up is Wick at ninety nine mile hour Fastball with a ninety two mile hour change up that got a forty rate. It's good stuff, Timmy, it's good stuff.
Speaker 2Yeah. I wouldn't be at all shocked if we're talking about Bubba Chandler two three years down the road. It is a top ten starter. It won't be here, but I see that future potential in the cards.
Speaker 1So it's it's all. He's really athletics. He's got to repeat his delivery. He might want to many in the next year or so, but eventually it's all going to be there.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, it is. And like I said, I like Bubba Chandler.
Speaker 1A lot Andrew Abbitt. You've always had love for Andrew Abbott. He's sixteen points sixteen slots higher than he's going in the NFBC forty six NFBC sixteen. Why the love for Andrew.
Speaker 2Abbit Because he's good, He consists, he consistently, let's write, because yeah, he's good. Well, you know what, Andrew Andrew Abbott is the contradiction of all contradictions. Okay, in the game of baseball. Okay, he consistently out performs every metric you toss out at him. Okay, and he does it well like last year. You know, we saw him in
Speaker 2twenty twenty three, Okay, is expected. He was six and he pitched to a three eighty seven. So that means in twenty twenty.
Speaker 1Four, we don't pick this expect was a three ninety three. Mister Mclouds. So you're you're being a little bit over over dramatic.
Speaker 2Okay, he but again in twenty twenty four. Okay, Yeah, he's a four fifty eer A type guy. Okay, he throws a three seventy two era and strikes out one hundred and fourteen ron and thirty eight last year one hundred and sixty six, and the third you have one hundred and forty eight hits only forty three walks. Okay, struck out one hundred and forty ninety posted the two eighty seven era. Yeah, all the metrics say this guy is a four ERA pitcher, but guess what, he hasn't
Speaker 2done it yet, so he totally defies the argument the expected era. Yad Edi ed, I've had him rostered in several leagues for all three of these seasons, and I'm very happy. At some point in time, can't we just say he's an anomaly and roll with the results.
Speaker 1I mean, he looks like, based on the day, was a three fifty six expected RA last season three ninety six seven ninety three is split the difference of three sixty this type of VRA. I think that seems to be The picture is he's a fly ball pitcher, and you worry about that, and you know the great American small park.
Speaker 2But right he's like that done. Yeah, No, like I at some point in time, you know, if you got to sort of believe. And when I look at the pictures going around him, I don't have any problems looking at Andrew Abbott as you know, as potentially at number three, but drafting him as a number four, I think there's value there. Again, he defies all logic. But at what
Speaker 2point in time do you say, Okay, maybe we'll roll with the actual results year after year after year. It's yeah, it's a contradiction. He's a contradiction in terms, but one that for those that have already taken in the plunge especially, it's worked out well.
Speaker 1Two more pictures and then we'll we'll wrap this puppy up. Kate Horton ten slots higher than where he's going in the NFBC.
Speaker 2Yeah, Horton needs a who or is that a What he? All Horton needs is a few more strike oats and he'll move up this list very very quickly. Again, I think, yeah, you're looking at his minor league history, okay, and he didn't have any he didn't have any problems with the strikeo rates for the Moise for the most part, heading he was better than the rate on.
Speaker 1The sweeper of thirty seven percent with rate on the change up of forty percent. I'm the basketball, Yeah, the fastball doesn't. I mean that that's okay, but I don't. I think the strikeouts are going to come. I mean it's swinging miss second Yeah pitches, So.
Speaker 2I do as well. And last year in twenty two starts posted the two sixty seven ARRA and a one o eight whip. Okay, if you look at his minor league history other than the initial high a start in twenty twenty three, where he posted a four thirty three ARRA and eighteen innings a trip LA in twenty four with a seven fifty all of his eras the other the other four stops along his journey, his ERA has
Speaker 2been under two was better than the strikeout an inning. I I know why people are down. They're looking at the strikeout rate and they're saying, no, this ain't gonna happen. I'm looking at the strikeout rate and saying, damn it, it is going to happen. And Kate Horton could be an incredible value as a forty eighth starter off the board.
Speaker 1I love your logic, man, I like lot, I like.
Speaker 2I like him a lot. I like him a lot, and you know at fifty eight, no, that's blasphemy.
Speaker 1Yep. Last guy coming in not coming in number fifty one is Zach Wheeler. I don't think anybody will dispute the greatness of Zach Wheeler. I think he said this is his last season, whether whether I mean the thorascic outlook syndrome a sign. He said that a couple of years ago that he was going to finish out his contract and that would be it.
Speaker 2Yeah, hell or high water, he says he's done. Yeah.
Speaker 1The fact that just throwing this out, I mean, coming back from TOS surgery is difficult. I mean, it's the the data is not good. Guys struggle to come back. Positional players a little bit better, but pitchers have really really struggled to come back. But it is Zach Wheeler. He's also said that it looks like if he misses any time, it's only going to be a couple of starts at the beginning of the season. If do you start to get more excited, if you start to see him in spring training games, that this is a guy
Speaker 1that Zach Wheler can turn back into the Zach Wheeler we know and love, or you're going to keep him where he is. I mean, what are you thinking as you see more information come out about Wheeler.
Speaker 2Well, it's it's not only just the tos, it's also the shoulder, okay, And it's also the fact that he's heading into his age thirty sixties and he's getting up there, and let's face it, he's worked a lot. Okay, you go back to twenty eighteen when with the Mets one hundred and eighty two innings, one hundred and ninety five seventy one in the COVID year two thirteen, one fifty
Speaker 2three one two two, one hundred and forty nine last year. It's a combination of things. But he's just a starter at this point in time. And if I'm wrong, I'll gladly fess up. He beats the odds and he comes back and he shows us something you know that I personally wasn't expecting that the combination of the shoulder, the thoracic outlet. I'm just staying away, Rich. I think there
Speaker 2are there are too many things that could go wrong, and there are too many other options from other starters that could go right.
Speaker 1Yep, Yeah, I think that's totally fair. I think that's totally fair.
Speaker 2Like, I love Zach wh Wheeler has been one of the best pitchers in the game over the past five six seasons, and I nothing I would love more than to see him go out, you know, with a great season. But I just have a hard time in believing that to be the case.
Speaker 1I think that's sound logic and fair to make a sec our, final break, get back and somehow wrap this thing up. I'm not sure how we wrap it up, or at least put a pen in it.
Speaker 2Yeah, a bowl something like that.
Speaker 1They've called through fifty players, fifty pictures. Let's call it fifty one, and we will do at least another forty or so next week in detail, then start doing sleepers and so forth. I want you to give me two guys in this top fifty that you want one of them. I know, maybe I should do three because I know one of them is a Maya, So that you want to leave the draft with having a real good shot at landing these two guys.
Speaker 2From this group. Yeah, I if I can get oh.
Speaker 1Cale bradish and yeah, there's a whole slew of pictures.
Speaker 2I like at the top like in the Max Reid Logan web in that group, Okay, I'd be happy with a Max Freed Logan Webb followed by the guy that I want badly is Uri Perez, and I think I've made that clear with my rankings. Jury Perez would be another. And Styllan Cease has my attention. Uh, Pablo Lopez if he falls far enough, has my attention, and getting into
Speaker 2the two three range Lodolo in Cincinnati, Bradish Yeah, and Tanner Biby come back. I got it. I got it for old times sakes. What what? What's more on the old Margo round from Marry go around? For me and Tanner Biby, that's that's just the definition big time. And one guy that you can bet any amount of money and give me any amount of odds will not be
Speaker 2on my team this year is Blake Snell, who had twenty eight slots. Like drafting Blake Snell as your nineteenth starting pitcher, that's insane that to me.
Speaker 1I yeah, Blake Snell's defense few pictures. If anybody has better stuff than him, it is nasty, nasty stuff. But he pitches. Few are better than him.
Speaker 2I agree, he's had one season over one hundred. He's had two seasons in his career over one hundred and thirty innings. One was twenty three the other one was twenty eighteen. And he's going into the season, uh you two lingering shoulder issues. He could begin the season on the IL.
Speaker 1Believe it or not, he has a decent case for Hall of Fame. He's got two Cide youngs in both leagues. He's got World championships under his belt. I mean, he doesn't have the innings and that might basically rule him out, but he's got quite a resume.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, he does. I I just don't want to have anything to do with you.
Speaker 1I'm not trying to change your opinion.
Speaker 2I'll do I'll do steak and liquor. The tyler Glass pitches more innings this year. Okay, how's that?
Speaker 1That's that's yeah, I'm not that's I don't think that's not a very effective bet for either one of us. Right, So well, because there's a good chance they're both going to be on the ie L at the same time.
Speaker 2So well, Yeah, and pitches the same amount of innings as the other two combined.
Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, those guys, says they can't stay healthy.
Speaker 2I mean that's I mean the question at.
Speaker 1The top of the show, how do you figure figure out injuries? I want as you never draft Blake Snell and Tyler Glass, no matter how good they are, it's just that they just don't pitch enough.
Speaker 2Well. No, that that is Hey, if you can get them at the right place and utilized that quality. Yeah, but there's you can't.
Speaker 1You can't get him at the right price. There's always somebody.
Speaker 2Yeah, exactly. I am just looking at Blake spell with going off the board with an ADP of nineteen. Okay, Yeah, that's sort of that sort of takes him out of my range. I don't even know how far down Tyler Glasno. Twenty nine. I'm not taking him as a top thirty. I can't. You're you're drafting him as a strong number three type starter and you're gonna get one hundred and twenty innings. No, that's that's a no. That's all I have to say.
Speaker 1No, strong, No, that is a wrap. We got to get you out. I told you we'd done it two between two and two fifteen. It's two twelve. So I'm gonna let you get over to Okay, to the big birthday party, and I've got that wedding reception I was supposed to go to a month ago, but it's snow so I'm going to that to night, so we'll both be partying with older people.
Speaker 2Leaves an eighty year old me feeling comfortable.
Speaker 1That's cool, all right, demmy be well, my friend. We will finish off pitching next week, and again I speak on the half behalf of all of our listeners. Great job with this is really really good quality work.
Speaker 2Thanks so much, Rish, I really appreciate it and hope our listeners get it. I get as much other as they possibly can. Have a good weekend. We'll catch you a little bit on the leader side.
Fantasy Baseball Live - November 15, 2026 Segment 1 - News and Notes 1.The awards came out this past week and it was pretty overwhelming. MVP and Cy Young were unanimous and ROY was what I would call overwhelming. a.MVP...
Fantasy Baseball Live - November 8, 2026 @ 2:15 pm ET Segment 1 - Tim’s trip to Arizona •Fun stuff oHow’s the traffic oBest meal that you’ve had oBest conversation that you had? oDid you win any money at the casinos?...
Fantasy Baseball Live! - October 31, 2026 - 9:15 am ET Segment 1 - The Brewers are the World Series Champions 1.They made it look pretty easy. They came extremely close to a sweep. Were you surprised at how easily the...