The following players are discussed: 1. Roch Cholowsky (1) 2. Caleb Bonemer (2) 3. Billy Carlson (3) 4. Tanner McDougal (4) 5. Hagen Smith (5) 6. Kyle Lodise (6) 7. Cole Prosek (7) 8. Jaden Fauske (8) 9. David Sandlin (9) 10. Landon Thome (10)
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Morning, everyone. It's October 29th, about four o'clock in the afternoon. Hope everyone is doing well. We have a World Series champ and the Milwaukee Brewers. Congratulations to them. Fun series, short series. I tell you, the young kids, William Contreras and Jackson Churio really carried that team. And then obviously Jacob Mizorowski didn't pitch all that well up until the World Series and then I know he came out with a cramp in his leg, but he looked as dominating
Speaker 1as he had all season long. And the Rays just don't have enough offense. There's nothing more complicated than that. I thought, I think everybody thought it would be the Brewers. I had the Brewers, I think, in six. They did it in five. Probably should have done it in four. But I thought it was a complete domination of the Rays. Do like the Rays. I love the Rays system. Love the Brewer system. I got to tell you, as a prospect guy, it is so great to see two of
Speaker 1the top five organizations in baseball in the World Series and then the Brewers winning it. It would have been great if the Rays would have won it as well. It just, again, as a player development guy, to see their minor leagues as strong as they, as strong as both of them are and how they have been moving guys out of the major leagues when they get expensive and bringing guys up. It's just, it just feels like that's the right model. Both of them have signed. Well,
Speaker 1particularly the brewers have signed, you know, long-term contracts to kids and lock them in. We've, we've seen that with Jackson holiday. It's not Jackson, Jackson cheerio. You're not going to do that Jackson holiday because he is Scott borrowers client. So that with cheerio, uh, I saw that with Laura. I don't even think Laura made the postseason squad. Might have been hurt. I don't know. I haven't been following all that closely. I'm just okay with him. But it'll be interesting with William Contreras winning the series MVP. I mean,
Speaker 1he will be a free agent in 2028. And as Tim and I have talked, or I brought it up with Tim, this is typically when they move him. I don't know how... how you do that now with the first, um, world series championship and franchise history and the MVP. I, I don't know how you do that now, but, uh, that would be their, their mode of operandi is to move guys with one year of team control left. So
Speaker 1we'll see what, what happens there, but, uh, congratulations to them. So I guess, uh, Tuesday, the first two games came out and they were fairly modest in terms of viewership. I think the Milwaukee Brewers, the whole state of Wisconsin made up an inordinate amount of viewership. I'm going to say, I think I saw 20% of everybody who watched game one and two lived in Wisconsin. And that just feels like a regional sport event as opposed to a national
Speaker 1sport event. I know my kids watched it, or at least my son and his wife watched it. He, He was all jazzed up and wanted to know if they were going to go on strike. And I said, well, lockout, 100%. Hopefully it won't affect the season, but that's definitely going to happen. But Major League Baseball has got to be licking their wounds in terms of how much money the owners made on this particular World Series. And if you recall, by the way, I love the business of baseball. It's just, it's one of my, I love baseball. I spent my
Speaker 1whole life in business, and I just love the business side of baseball. And, you know, the way they set it up, the players get 95% of their money during the regular season, and the owners get 80% of their money during the postseason. So the owners are licking their wounds. The players aren't because they got paid all their money. Um, so they only get the bonus structure, uh, that's paid
Speaker 1out in the post season. And the owners are the ones that are reaping the reward. You gotta, you gotta get six games for them to turn a profit. So, and with the lightness in terms of, uh, people watching the game, therefore, I mean, it's all dynamic pricing for advertisers. You don't, even the, even the Superbowl, they always throw out, you know, $ 8 million for a 30 second commercial, whatever it is. Well, if, that could go up or down based on how many people are actually watching the game. The same thing is true. You've got a kind of
Speaker 1a rack rate that you charge the advertisers for a major league baseball, um, commercial. And it's actually based on, um, before the game, after the game. And depending on the, uh, the time of the game, the part of the game, you know, the beginning of the game is, is the, the, uh, the advertisements are more valuable because more people are watching the beginning and have a tendency to turn it off as you go through the game. I think that changes.
Speaker 1I think you actually see kind of a dip. And then if it's a close game like the seventh game of the World Series last season, then you see a huge spike at the end as social media gets jazzed up and everybody tunes into it. But so there's all that dynamic change. pricing that goes into the commercials and somebody with their laptop figures it all out and what the teams will be paid. But the bottom line is
Speaker 1the owners didn't make the kind of money and that's going to probably dictate going into this collective bargaining agreement. I don't know which side you play on. I think you can argue both sides. Again, without a If you don't have a payroll cap like we don't have now, the likelihood of a large market team with a big fan base getting into the postseason and going deep into the World Series is very high. If you level out
Speaker 1the playing field with money, with a salary cap, then you're going to have a lot more opportunities to have the Tampa Bay Rays versus the Milwaukee Brewers of the world just because You know, you'll level out how much money you can spend on it. Now, as we found, this season has nothing to do with how much money you're paying them. But I think money always does help. Imagine if you could afford to retain Jacob Mizorowski at a discounted amount or tag him as a franchise player
Speaker 1and you know exactly what that is going to cost you. Let's call it $ 25 million a year. Then you can budget around that and you don't have to kind of see the escalation that you might see in free agency. So you can make an argument to keep things the way they are. And I bet you there's going to be some owners that go, whoa, we took a bath here. Let's not push for this. We don't want any more Milwaukee Brewers versus Tampa Bay Rays in the World Series anymore. Whoa, let's stop that. You can make that argument. Then you
Speaker 1can make the argument there's a contingency that says, hey, the Dodgers are winning too much. They're spending too much money, blah, blah, blah, blah. Let's put a salary cap. So- I don't think we know how it's all going to shake out. I still would be highly, my take, I don't know if this is a hot take or not, but my take is the economy is still roaring along. Yeah, there's stuff underneath that doesn't look good. I mean, we're so reliant here in the U.S. on the AI market, and eventually that's
Speaker 1going to correct because it always does in bubbles like this. It just does. Go back and read your history on that. But for now, the economy is doing great, and there's no incentive for when baseball needs to renegotiate with advertisers, the ESPNs of the world, the Foxes of the world, to change their advertising rates. Everything's going fine, and there's no reason to kind of change that. So why would
Speaker 1you make major changes to the structure of the game because of that? So you can make that. That's why I don't think baseball will do that. They'll probably just extend it another four years and see what the economy looks like in four years. And you figure the AI boom will probably pop sometime next year. It'll take 2028, 29 for it to somewhat to recover. And then baseball can go in and lick their wounds and say, hey, we've been taken by the cleaners to the cleaners on this. The, uh,
Speaker 1the advertising revenue is just not there, et cetera, et cetera. And voila, maybe you'll have something four years from now, uh, the 2030 collective bargaining agreement. That's just my speculation and thought process, but we'll see how it all plays out. Anyway, not for that. I spent the first 10 minutes talking about that, but again, that's, that's what I like talking about. I'm doing the podcast. So, um, Today we got the Chicago White Sox. It came out on Tuesday. It is Thursday today. So it is– I don't like the system.
Speaker 1I didn't like it when I was writing about it. As I wrote about it and then I started talking to people in the White Sox organization, I started talking to a lot of players that see the White Sox players more than I do, just don't see a ton of White Sox teams. I just didn't get a lot back. There's a lot of energy amount Rock Cholowski, obviously the number one overall pick in the draft last season. I know there's a lot of people that think he's overhyped and he very well could be. Dylan Cruz kind of
Speaker 1comes to mind in terms of the guy that was supposed to be You know, the bomb at the draft has really become the dud at the draft. Is Rock Jalowski going to go into that same mode? I mean, he could. But if I have the number one overall pick, and I think I do in one league because I was terrible in it, which is really embarrassing, I'm going to take Rock Jalowski. I just think his ability to hit, the fact that I believe he's going to have big power, not a ton of... of speed long-term, but I just
Speaker 1think the hit tool, the maturity at the plate is going to get him to the major leagues very quickly. That's why I have his ETA is next season, 2027. And I think there's going to be power there. Now, having said that he didn't play well and his limited time went after he, after he was signed. Now he did was shut down with wrist tendonitis and, Usually with risk tendonitis, anything that's tendonitis usually doesn't happen on a Tuesday and Wednesday. You've got tendonitis. It usually is kind
Speaker 1of buried in there for a while before it really becomes problematic that you don't think that you can play anymore. So I would not be surprised at all if it was something that was bothering him during his time between college and playing professionally and just manifested itself got worse as he started playing professional ball. So hopefully his stat line will be better once he gets out on the field in 2027. Again, I think we see him in the big leagues at some point. I think he's going
Speaker 1to help that Chicago White Sox team because it is a flawed Major League Baseball team. Yeah, I know they made it very far, but it's a flawed team. They just don't have enough guys they can hit. I think Cholowski is a perfect complement to some of the big boppers they have. Caleb Bonhamer, speaking of big boppers, saw him in the fall league. He hits the ball a long way and hits it very, very hard. There is going to be some swing and miss in this game, though. He's kind of been able to tap that down as he's been going through the minor leagues. But I think
Speaker 1there's going to be pressure on his batting average. But, I mean, it's easy 30 home run pop in there. And he does walk a lot. So from a fantasy standpoint, I do believe he'll switch. I know he was playing center field and I didn't get a real, I only saw him once. I didn't get a chance to see him make a lot of plays in center field, but some of the scouts that I talked to that I know who actually didn't see many games. So I don't, I think they leave the scouting at the fall league to all the kids that are going through scout school
Speaker 1that he looked okay in center field. Can he stick there? We'll see. My guess is he'll have to move to left or right field. But long-term, corner outfielder may be a first baseman as things shake out. But he's going to be a true home run hitter, maybe a three true outcome player, which again fits the mode of the model of what the White Sox are doing. Number three is I don't feel really good about Billy Carlson being here. It's a lousy season last year. A couple of stints
Speaker 1on the IELTS. The season finished early because being on the IL, the defense was there. Everybody talked about his elite defense when he got there. Sprint times down the first base show a 55-60 runner. So there's 15 to 20 stolen base upside there. He didn't leave the park once and just did not hit the ball very hard at all. He slugged 335. Now, was that part of the problem? Was his injuries and constantly spending time on
Speaker 1the AI? It could have. But I was concerned when they drafted him how much power he was going to have, and we just didn't see that. So I think he's going to hit. We know he's going to be a good defender, but is it going to be a little light from a fantasy standpoint to get excited about Billy Carlson? It could be. But I looked at 4, 5, and 6, and I mean, Tanner McDougal's at four. I mean, maybe he could have been pushed up to three, but I just think that Billy Carlson's got a little bit more
Speaker 1upside than Tanner McDougal. There just wasn't anybody there that said, wow, you got to push him up to number three. So he's kind of there by default. I'm not all that happy, though, with Billy Carlson being a number three. Number four is Tanner McDougal. Got moved to the bullpen for the White Sox, pushed down the stretch. spent some time on the IEL with forearm tenderness. It's all going to come down to can he find a third pitch? Can he throw strikes?
Speaker 1I think he stays a starter, and I think he could be a pretty good starter. If he can't, then the upside because he throws so hard and it's just a nasty two-pitch arsenal currently that he could definitely be a closer. So he's a guy that you definitely don't want to give up on just because the floor is a potential closer. Hagan Smith actually looked good down the stretch for the White Sox. Just great stuff. I mean, you can look at Stackass, and it's great stuff. It's just he just doesn't throw enough strikes. And he did
Speaker 1a little bit better when he was up with the White Sox, but he just can't repeat his delivery. So, I mean, if he can ever figure it out, I mean, he has a chance to be at least a top 40 starting pitcher, maybe pitch at the top of the rotation, top of the rotation as a, number one, number two starter, so top 30-ish type of starter. I mean, it's that kind of stuff, particularly from the left side. But I think he's looking more and more like the White Sox are going to put him in the bullpen. Look, they
Speaker 1did that with Grant Taylor, and Grant Taylor turned out to be their best pitcher during the playoffs. I know he pitched four innings for some goofy reason, and they just kind of blew him out, and he wasn't effective the last game or so that he pitched. But he's the best arm in the organization. I think Hagan Smith could be the second best arm in the organization. They need to figure out what role both of those guys are going to play. I could see Grant Hill finally moving to the rotation and Hagan Smith kind of picking
Speaker 1up that role that Grant Taylor's had over the last couple of seasons. Kyle Lodi actually had a great season. I don't believe it. It's, I mean, he was, what is it? I think I wrote in here 42 stolen bases. He had 20 home runs. I mean, maybe he should be number three, but I just, I'm just not buying it. I haven't found any evaluator that said, yeah, this guy has a chance to be a 2020 type of guy or 25, 25 guy. I just too much swing and miss in this game. The approach isn't great. So I've
Speaker 1still have him as a middle infielder, but it was a great season. If he's, rolling around in your waiver wire. It should be a guy that you add at this point. Just don't overpay for him if he's included in a trade. Cole Prosik. Now we're going to start to, we've already seen Rock Cholowski as one of the 2026 draftees. There's a lot of them in here that shows you the weakness of the system. Cole Prosik is an interesting guy.
Speaker 1He was a second round pick. He signed for $ 800, 000 over slot. You see that many times with high school kids. There's a chance for him to be an impact second baseman contact with real 30-type home run power. So he's an interesting guy if at 41 would be a guy that I'd be looking for at the end of the second round. And if he fell to the third round, he'd probably be all over that. So again, at second base,
Speaker 1he's going to have to hit, but I think there's enough offensive upside that he can, he can thrive. Jaden Fousk, um, outfielder speed guy. Um, he needs to start making harder contact. I mean, it's just not enough power, but he did steal 46 bases and 56 attempt, uh, 56 attempts. Um, I see him maybe as a number four outfielder longterm. Um, if he can, show a little bit more power, add some leverage. He could unlock a season or two of
Speaker 12020 with some problems with his hit tool as well. But anyway, interesting guy with Jaden Fousk, and not a lot of people are talking about him. So he's one of the more interesting players on this list. David Sandlin, we saw him in the big leagues, and it looked great for the first couple of starts and just got found out. I picked him up in a couple of dynasty leagues. I did not do my homework there because once I looked under the covers, there's some ugly splits
Speaker 1in there. Gloveside batters, in this case, left-handed batters, hitting almost 500, posting a 500 slug against him. When he got to AAA, pitched a little bit better, but he needs to find a pitch that can go against gloveside batters. And if he can't, there's a chance he moves to, there's a good chance he moves to the bullpen. The White Sox will probably continue to try to start him, but that's his problem at the moment. He doesn't have a changeup. Now, does he get to camp with a changeup?
Speaker 1He could. So I know I've got him in a couple. leagues. I'm not going to drop him until I start to see some stat cast data in spring training, whatever spring training is, to see if maybe he has developed a changeup or a split over the wintertime. Landon Tomei, his father obviously is Jim Tomei. Um, and like his father, he's got big boy power. He signed for $ 400, 000 under slot.
Speaker 1So be careful of that. It's a high school kid. Um, shouldn't be signing under slot like that, but he did. Um, so he's got some hit tool problems that are going to have to be worked out. I know a lot of people will jump on him just because his father's a hall of famer. Yeah, I totally get it. Totally makes sense. He's currently a shortstop. He's probably going to move over to the first base. He's probably going to get big like his father, et cetera, et cetera. When I be jumping on, he's just not my kind of guy. But,
Speaker 1you know, I get the charms because of the lineage that he has here. Those are top 10. I will let everyone go and save the rest for our Patreon members. Just a reminder, if you want to join us and want to support Tim and I, you do that through our Patreon site, P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com. forward slash prospect361. We no longer have ads out on prospect361 just because I wasn't making, I was hardly making any money. You just don't make any money with ads on websites unless you put hundreds
Speaker 1of them out there. And I found them to be annoying and I took them all down. Obviously there's commercials in our podcast, but if you become a Patreon member, you get the podcast ad free. You get all of the prospects we talk about. You get Tim out on the Discord site. You get a great community. So I really encourage you to jump on there and check us out. That's Patreon, P-A-T-R-E-O-N.com forward slash prospect 361. Tim and I are back on Saturday recording and I'll probably have, I'll
Speaker 1probably do the Cleveland Guardians podcast tomorrow as well. For our Patreon members, hang on and I will do 11 through 20.
Fantasy Baseball Live - November 15, 2026 Segment 1 - News and Notes 1.The awards came out this past week and it was pretty overwhelming. MVP and Cy Young were unanimous and ROY was what I would call overwhelming. a.MVP...
Fantasy Baseball Live - November 8, 2026 @ 2:15 pm ET Segment 1 - Tim’s trip to Arizona •Fun stuff oHow’s the traffic oBest meal that you’ve had oBest conversation that you had? oDid you win any money at the casinos?...
Fantasy Baseball Live! - October 31, 2026 - 9:15 am ET Segment 1 - The Brewers are the World Series Champions 1.They made it look pretty easy. They came extremely close to a sweep. Were you surprised at how easily the...