Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Fantastical Truth

Fantastical Truth artwork

333. How Do Scoffers Subvert C. S. Lewis and Slander His Fans?

Sep 29, 20261 hr 19 minAudio

Narnia fans had a rough week. After the confirmation that Netflix’s version of “Narnia” will have a female-voiced “Aslan” for a 1950s-set movie with a “rock and roll” vibe, the internet lit up. Fans were upset. Pundits piled on. Non-Christian critics on YouTube cussed at Greta Gerwig. And in response, apparent defenders of the corporate creator began repeating old myths about The Chronicles of Narnia and C. S. Lewis while scoffing at his fans for being so overexcited about a movie. How can we best address these subversions and slanders? Episode sponsors Enclave Publishing: Return of the Guardian King by Karen Hancock The Guardian of Ailos by Michael B. Foss Etania’s Worth by M. H. Elrich Mission update New at Lorehaven: book quest for The Monster in the Hollows Also, don’t miss our new review of A. M. Daylin’s fantasy Eventide Last week’s breaking news and popular audio-livestream on X Subscribe free to get updates and join the Lorehaven Guild Concession stand You may be curious about the movie or skeptical of upset fans. If so, don’t be distracted by extreme examples in the discourse. But we oppose pushback about “outrage culture” or “culture war.” We believe this is a verbal battle worth engaging for Christ’s glory. After all, real Christian cultural engagement isn’t meant to be easy! At the same time, not everyone will choose to engage identically. God has given His body many different gifts and resulting roles. Pro tip: don’t fault someone for engaging/not engaging as you do. For each of our examples, we’ve seen real parallels from people. However, we find it easier to talk in Narnian terms as comparisons. Quotes and notes “Our Interview with Greta Gerwig,” Crash.fr, Jan. 2028 Today It’s Official: Meryl Streep Voices Aslan in Netflix’s ‘Rock Inspired’ Perversion of Narnia, E. Stephen Burnett at Lorehaven Alleged ‘Rock and Roll’ Soundtrack Incites Suspicion of Netflix’s Narnia Movie, Sierra Simopolous at Lorehaven Podcast episodes What Are the Best Books by C. S. Lewis? Why Does ‘Church Back Home Syndrome’ Distort Christian Imagination? How Did C. S. Lewis Fight for Living and Learning in Wartime? Did Christians Expect Cultural Engagement to Be Easy? Seventy-Five Years Ago, How Did C. S. Lewis’s Fairy-Stories Change Fantasy Forever? Why Do We Fight Like Narnians for the Stories We Love? 1. Answering good-faith challenges Edmund Pevensie - tempted by evil, yet saved by Aslan’s sacrifice Trumpkin - skeptical of talking lions, but overcome by Aslan’s love Eustace Scrubb - practical and skeptical, yet changed by Aslan Jill Pole - hurt by bullies, yet called to new challenges by Aslan Aravis Tarkheena - raised as a harsh survivor, chastised by Aslan Digory Kirke - grieving, impulsive, sinful, yet captivated by Aslan Puzzle the Donkey - used for great deception, yet loved by Aslan 2. Fending off random scoffers and slanders Ghouls, Boggles, Ogres, People of the Toadstools - generic mobs Nikabrik - will do anything, even evil, to get rid of villains he hates Governor Gumpas - hyperfixated bureaucrat, ignores basic virtue Harfang Giants - act hospitable while planning to make man-pies Lasaraleen - frivolous and flippant, eager to affirm cultural elites Uncle Andrew - materialist magician wanting to exploit other lands Dwarfs - disaffected and deceived, literally shoot at both sides 3. Challenging defenders of deathworks Jadis, the White Witch - simply hates Aslan and all his good magic King Miraz - foreign conqueror who despises the good old stories Deathwater Island - offers the illusion of riches that actually kills The Lady of the Green Kirtle - uses enchantment to subvert reality Rabadash - unstable, entitled elite who rashly slanders good kings Jadis yet again - otherworld sorceress who sacrifices all for power Shift - wickedly subverts earnest faith with the ultimate deathwork Com station Top question for listeners Who do you feel is the worst villain in The Chronicles of Narnia? Next on Fantastical Truth Now we move into spooky season, with appropriate topics planned. Lord willing, this month you can expect more from us about scary stories and how parents can find the best Christian-made middle grade fiction. Meanwhile, what about UFOs? That news has gone suddenly quiet of late! Plus: Satan and/or demons, and maybe even a little Godzilla as the big king of all monsters stomps back into cinemas.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 340. What if Magic Beetles Could Help You Win a Tournament? | Karabos with Lyndsey Lewellen

    Nov 17, 202656 minAudio

    Homeschooled students can face some challenges in the non-homeschool world. Some of us struggle with common public-school practices. Like instantly knowing what grade you’re in. Or how to untwist a rotating combination...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 339. After Sir Patrick Stewart’s Passing, How Can Christian Fans Best Honor Humanistic Heroes?

    Nov 10, 20261 hrAudio

    Some people like Donald Trump. Some people like anyone else but. Some like Coca Cola; for others, Pepsi is okay. Others debate DC vs. Marvel, originals vs. remakes, Star Trek versus Star Wars, or even for Trekkers, Kirk...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 338. Why Do Big Audiences Want to Feel Small Next to Godzilla?

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    Less than ten years after the United States dropped atomic bombs on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, another radioactive monster stomped across the shores of that struggling nation. Yet a strange thing...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 337. Are Passionate Fans Really Waging a Scary Culture War?

    Oct 27, 202658 minAudio

    In the last month, we have seen fans who share their strong feelings about, say, horror fiction, movie trailers, or big studio companies. In response these fans often hear scoffing from high-school bullies who hate...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 336. Who Is the Worst Real Monster of All Time and Why is He Satan?

    Oct 20, 202650 minAudio

    “The Prince of Darkness grim / We tremble not for him.” Martin Luther wrote those words, and yet many people don’t follow them. When they aren’t denying the Devil exists, they’re scared of him. And outside of a biblical...

    Credit the people on this episode