Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Family Tree Talk

Family Tree Talk artwork

Discovering a brick wall’s silver lining

Sep 14, 202651 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Family Tree Talk podcast co-host Nathan Ward has been digging for weeks now, trying to find his Elizabeth Thing on the 1851 Census. While she’s remaining elusive, his family history is in no way standing still… In fact, being ‘forced’ to stick in one place, and one time period, has provided Nathan with time to look around him - to discover more about some of the other people in her life… her brother, her son… And what he’s finding is fascinating. Join him, with Helen Tovey, to tune in to the chat.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello everyone, welcome to Family Tree Talk, your favourite family history podcast. I'm your co -host Nathan and with me as always is... Helen Dovey. Hi Helen, you alright? I'm very good, yeah, thank you. How's all things in family tree land? Well, a lot has been going on. It's good. Just trying to remember what's been going on. So the most exciting thing for me is through September, we're running this course, The Story of You, which is just so far different from going,

I was born here and I went to school. That is not that at all. It's literally about starting with where you are now in your life, thinking about what you value in your life, the things which have guided you in your life, the things which give you that kind of... sense of reason for being so it sounds really deep and it is really deep but it feels so powerful and so um yana who's the tutor on the course she asked you to think what your values are i don't want to give too much away and then everything kind of unpatched from there and literally the amount of memories that any spare moment i've had over

the last few days i'm grabbing another little bit of paper literally sometimes they are just scraps of paper like out of a notebook scrawling down other things that you want people in 100 years time to know and they're not They're not the facts. They're not the things you can get in a document. They're some of the things I've been recording, like little quirky family traditions we have. The main thing is, why do we value them? Why do we find them fun? And why do we want them to be cherished? And when I'm writing them, I wonder, I'm imagining somebody 100 years from now reading about our little family traditions thinking, will they still be going? So it's cool.

It's really cool. That is really cool. I like that a lot. Yeah. So that's the kind of main thing which has been occupying my heart and soul. I have been carrying on with the admin. Yeah, doing my family history filing. And then, as always, work is busy. It gets to the really busy time of year this time of year. And there's lots of fun things, but it does mean it's busier. So we have to pull together a little handbook, which is 100 pages long. And so we've been starting to work on that. And that's kind of a little guide by your side thing that people can just...

They get with a January issue or they can buy it separately. And then it's super handy. In fact, it's so handy that through the year, I do actually refer to it the whole time myself for useful websites. It's really good. That's a good endorsement then, isn't it? It is. But it always amuses me. I'm like, it actually is useful. It really, really is useful. Because you kind of hope, we always aim to be putting out useful stuff with Family Tree, whether it's courses or magazine articles or whatever. It's

always fun when it really feels it as well. Yeah, that's cool. How about you? Yeah, it's going well. I don't really know if I want to get into it. Well, I'm going to have to because that's what we're talking about. Yes, so I've done a bit of family history research this last week. I'm still with my things. And for anyone that doesn't know, it's a surname thing. I'm stuck in the family of thing, which is actually a sub... set of the Hearns who are on my grandmother's

line and basically I've gone off on a tangent again I don't quite know how I've got there but I was looking I'm trying to I'm sorry about this guys I'm bored of saying it I'm trying to find Elizabeth thing on the 1851 census So she's not there. She's not where she should be. So I did start looking at her. I started looking at her brother, William. She's got two brothers, but I actually only have officially found one at

the moment. Oh man, I need to come back to this. I'm having issues with the 1841. Anyway, so I found William and I got lost on a little bit of a tangent with him because he had an arrest record, which I'd not seen before. And this is like an early one. So it's... I don't know if it was like he'd been arrested or whether it was a warrant for his arrest because it said that it expired at a certain date if it wasn't issued. But if it was to be issued, he would be in prison for 14 days. So it was a really cool document to look at. And yeah, I didn't

actually get to the point where I was... I found him on the 1851. It was just him and his wife. Elizabeth isn't there with him. And I can't remember how I got to the next bit. But I don't know if you remember me saying that Elizabeth and John had a child called Elijah. And I was instantly drawn to him. He was in the Royal Navy, born on Christmas Day. I was like, oh, this guy's going to be fun to research when I get to him.

And I hadn't intended to get to him because he's obviously not direct line. He would be a bit tangential. And I think I must have got to him when I was looking. I don't know how I got to him. I found like a birth record for him. That's exactly how I got to him. Got to him on the birth record. So I was like, right, I'll add this. And then it obviously on Ancestry brought me to his profile. And I started going down his path, which I didn't intend to go down. And he's

become quite, quite fascinating. Wow. What's so fascinating? He's a new favourite. I mean, he already was, like I said, born on Christmas Day. So I'm instantly like, oh, that's cool. And then the Royal Navy hint, which was just like quite intriguing because I've wanted like military stuff. So this guy was born in 1865. I'm lying. Am I lying to you? No, I'm lying to you. He's not. This is another problem. Elijah has had children. And the child, obviously, yeah,

yeah, why not? Let's call our first born Elijah as well. And then Elijah, the second born, has had a child also called Elijah. Brilliant. Oh, it's not brilliant. It's doing my melanin. Anyway, I will start again. My Elijah that I'm researching, the one born on Christmas Day, was born in 1843. Which I actually know because I've written on my notes and I don't know why I got confused there. Anyway, three Elijahs. Common as muck name now. So he's born in 1843 and he's in the

Royal Navy, if I hadn't already said this. So I've got a marriage for him to a woman called Mary Ann Bardwell. And yeah, in 1873. And on that register, it says he was a widow. So I was like, OK, obviously there's been an earlier. And this is where it gets exciting on so many levels. I found the earlier marriage, which was

in 1863. This ticks so many blocks for me. I have a hobbit surname. No way. Yeah, so he marries this woman called Charlotte Crowfoot. I'm taking that as a hobbit name. They have a child later on. Again, it's Elijah II. And she must die at some point before... I'm not saying... Well, she might not die, but I'm pretty sure she dies. I haven't researched that bit yet. Because he

gets married, like, ten years later. Shortly after... What did I just say? He gets married in 1873. So, yeah, exactly ten years later. But the big exciting thing for me was Elijah's residence on the... marriage certificate to Charlotte is down as the HMS Cornwallis. That's where he lives. Yeah. So I was really excited to see that because

it's quite different. It's a little bit unique. Yeah. And then I went to do a bit of research on the HMS Cornwallis and it's an absolutely beautiful ship. It was launched in 1813, this ship. And it's a 74 -gun, third -rate Wenger -class ship. It's absolutely massive. It's like proper Pirates of the Caribbean ship. It's amazing. And the history of this ship's just really cool. It was in the First Opium War in China. They signed the Treaty of Nanking aboard it, apparently.

It's just really, really cool. So proper Pirates of the Caribbean vibes going on here. Amazing. Yeah. So he was down as being on that ship in 1863. But then in 1865, the boat was converted to a jetty. It became like a base of operations. And that's it. But I just love it. Very exciting. Very interesting. So yes, sometimes even if it

was like a shore -based establishment, they'd still prefix it HMS. So sometimes... You mean you said it got converted. Sometimes it could be that just the shore base is called HMS whatever. You don't know to what extent a boat is there. I don't know that bit. Somebody will know. They'll be able to tell us. From the sounds of it, it happened like a couple of years later. Yeah. From what I just read. So he would definitely see. It would have been a pretty old vessel by the time he's on it. 50 years old, isn't it? Yes. Apparently it was broken apart in 1957.

144 years after it was launched. So it did well. Did really well, yeah. But yeah, it's really exciting. So it's really cool to see. So I'm going to have to get a picture of that and put that on his entry. Oh, yes. A stunning looking boat. Yeah. 74 guns. You know, that's a lot. Think about how big a cannon is. 74 on one ship. That's big. Very excited by the whole thing. And then I've chronicled, well, not the rest of his life, but I've... Got him on a few more

censuses. And on the 1881 census, his address is down as number one coast guard station. So he changed to, his profession changed to like being a coast guard slash lifeguard. Yeah. And it's the same on the 1891. Yeah. And then on that 1911 one, it says he's a retired seaman. But the address is actually down as a church where he lives. What's he addressing? Oh, St

Mary's Church. But he's living with his wife, or his second wife, Mary Ann, and she's listed as deaf as well. There's just loads of fascinating little things about this guy. Loving it all. Yeah, I love hearing what he's been doing. So just the fact that, not just finding the vessel, but finding out what it was like and what it was involved in, piecing together his... The story across the census, that's always amazing. Getting one census is okay, but it's when you

get lots of them, you get a sense of somebody. So he's kept with his profession, hasn't he? So I would say that somebody who's doing really well at it, to be able to keep in your line of work isn't necessarily an easy thing. Sometimes you'll change professions because we have to or we choose to. But if you are able to keep in your line of work, that normally means you're pretty good at it, isn't it? Yeah, definitely. It looks like he's got a full career of it. And he's retired down on the coast in Torquay. And

that's where he's doing the lifeguarding. So it just all sounds really cool. And obviously the sort of the level of grandeur of the boat he was on, like he's been involved in some fairly major things. It's not just a little boat. I can find a little bit of information and it's got loads of stuff going on. It's really cool. It's exactly what I wanted. Yeah, that's definitely its own project. I wouldn't even say mini project. There's a lot you could do there. It's just really

funny because I knew I wanted to research him but hadn't intended to even start. It was going to be like, oh, at a later date, that'll be a rabbit hole to dip into. It was because of his marriage certificate, actually, I think, because obviously his father's name was on there. And it pulled me in that way and everything just started to come together quite readily. And obviously coming forward in time, I then have censuses. So I was quite enjoying getting back to being on a census because going the other way, it's getting trickier and trickier. And this guy's

lived a long, full life as well. So it was just really cool to research. Cheers. Sounds really good. kind of run of findings, isn't it? Yeah, exactly. It was just all flowing. So I've got him all the way up to the 1911 census. I can't remember if I've got his death. Oh, he died in 1921. So you might get him on the 1921, depending on when he died in 1921. Yes. And it says like on the 1911, it says he had four children and

they all survived. And it's just like, oh, this guy's just had a nice life. I mean, might not have been a nice life, but. He's had a full life. Obviously, his first wife died. That's really sad. But he's been with his other wife and she's deaf and they're still together and all the children have survived. It's good. It's really good. So are you going to find out any other names of other vessels that he's served on? I'm not sure. I mean, I don't feel I've honestly scratched the surface with this guy despite getting all

this information. It's all just sort of, apart from researching the common wallace, everything else has just fallen in place. So I'll do a bit more digging to see what else I can find. Because I've still got to locate him in a couple of censuses early on. And yeah, I want to research this. I'm pretty sure if you go to Find My Past, and then I think they have the log. So if you can find his log, please, this is an apology in advance because I'm saying it wrong. then it will literally

have, it will be his personalised log. So it will say the dates that he started and finished serving on each vessel. And so why that's really cool, because we see HMS Cornwallis is an amazing vessel which did loads of military activity. And that's still exciting, even if he's not on it at the time when it's doing that activity. But it's even more exciting if you can say my guy was there when this happened, isn't it? So getting a feel for... We had where else he served.

Yeah, we showed the ship names. You can get a whole collection of them. Yeah, sounds really cool. Yeah. It's just nice to have... I know he's not necessarily a major character, but tied to that book, he's in a bigger place in history. I was reading about it. It was involved in the Crimean War as well. I believe it was commanded by George Wesley. I may be pronouncing that wrong. And he was the nephew of the Duke of Wellington. So it's... Yeah, Wellesley. Wellesley, is that what it is? Yeah, I think that's right, yeah.

Yeah, so it's really cool, isn't it? Like, leaky. Yeah, and also he would have been so young then in the time of the Quaternion War, wouldn't he? Yeah, well, he wasn't actually... He wasn't actually... Well, he could have been. I don't think he would have been a bard at that point. No, he'd have been 12, wouldn't he? Well, he would have, like, boys. Right, OK. I'll do some research and find out, but it's cool. Yeah, very, very exciting.

Not even a rabbit hole research project. Yeah. Well, it was, like I've said it already, but it just amused me that I was going to have it as a little mini side shoot rabbit hole at some point. Yes. And I've accidentally got sucked in through not full progression and it's just proved to be as exciting as I wanted it to be. Yes, it's been calling to you for a few weeks now, hasn't it? It really has. And then to get myself a Hobbit name as well on the old scoreboard, that's good. Yes. So just to make up in case

anyone doesn't know, then podcast listener Kevin got in touch a few weeks ago. And was it Barnabas Bramble? That was it, yeah. Yes. And he has an ancestor with that wonderful name. And so then we were inviting other people. If you have a Hobbit name, do get in touch. It's just fun to hear. And actually, Kevin has written in subsequently with the adventures of Barnabas Bramble. So, yeah. It's all good. All these exciting, slightly

eccentric sounding ancestors. Real people that dig real stuff. It's very, very exciting. So what about this arrest warrant for that other one? I'm not sure if I actually officially... I haven't put it on my tree because I was still... It's in that grey area, isn't it, where I can't be sure our records are tying properly. But it looks like it's him. Unless, yeah. So I don't

know too much about it. I was interested to read the document, but I haven't put it on my tree for him. Let me just see if I can bring it up quickly. Just be wondering if it had any other clues, like why... why there was a warrant out for his arrest and what date it was. Because I think it's the 1840s, isn't it? Here she goes again with Robert Peel, isn't it? With him starting up a bit more of an official police force. So it'd just be interesting to know under what kind

of law enforcement landscape he is being pursued by having a date for when he's done his misdemeanor. If it's only 14 days, he hasn't gone too far, has he? He's really wobbled off the path a little bit. Rum can be saddled in here, but who knows? So I'll just share my screen with you. Oh, he's a shepherd. That's a cool occupation. Yeah. So this is the brother of Elizabeth Thing, who married

my John Hearn. And, yeah. What a brilliant record. So it's, I can see from Nathan sharing his screen, it's from the Suffolk Jail Records, 1791 to 1878 on Ancestry, the Ipswich Jail Receiving Book, and the information it gives about... Nathan's ancestor is fantastic. So he's not a direct ancestor, but it's still pretty cool. It's his direct ancestor's brother. So it's William Thing. He was a shepherd.

It's the rural police who are after him. It's the November of 1854. You've learned that he's 55 years old. He's old enough to know better, isn't he? And he's quite a little chap by today's standards. He's five foot three and a half. That wouldn't be unusual back then by any means. He's got a fresh complexion. He's still got brown hair, says Helen extremely enviously. He's 55, still with brown hair. He's doing very well. He's got grey eyes and a long visage, so a long

face. What's it next say about him? It tells you all the things that he had when he was arrested. He's got a bag. He's got... A felt hat. Yes. He's wearing a smock frock, so he's a shepherd actually wearing a smock. That is fantastic. Yeah. Two waistcoats. Two waistcoats, a flannel one. Trousers. That's nice. Stockings, boots, shirts and a handkerchief and a purse, which

contained... I don't know. I don't know what the denominator is. Six shillings and six pence. Right. Six and three quarter pence. Nice. Yeah. Oh, his father's deceased and he's married. Yeah? Yep. And offences, let's go down a bit, says his offence, misdemeanour in service. So he's done something bad at work. Oh, man. Yeah. The magistrate is the Reverend Hill and a C .R. Brecroft.

Yeah. And if he gets convicted, he's down for 14 days. Well, that's quite sad. Can he read and write? Oh, I can't read the answer to whether he... Oh, can he read and write? What do you think that says, Nathan? Can't even see that as a... Right down near the bottom of the document, it says something not very legible, ironically, for the... What can it say? I don't know. It could be anything, that, couldn't it? Wow. No

clue. Interesting. Very interesting. Well, that's kind of worth following up just to see what else you can learn. Yeah. And the fact he's a shepherd, that's very cool. Yeah. The location matches, his birthplace matches, his date of birth matches and his father matches. So it's looking fairly solid that it is my fella. I wonder what he did

at work. Exactly. I mean, his work, he's a shepherd. Who's going to, like, arrest him? Maybe he fell asleep when he should have been looking after the sheep and some of them strayed. I'm just going to make out the story mode. I'm going to shut up and we're not going to do that. You could look in the newspapers and see if... The nature of his misdemeanor got captured there. Right. So would I do that on Find My Past? Yeah. So

I'm looking... And it's good because I've got a date, don't I, roughly? You've got a really precise date. All right. I'll make a note of this and try it. And I don't even know how the procedure works because, I mean, he's got... There's a warrant out for his arrest, so he hasn't been found. But the... The warrant is going to expire. So they haven't got long. He must have been found because they've got all of his, like, particulars and then the contents of his pockets and stuff. Hmm. Oh, yeah, it's a jail receiving

book. So then he has been. This isn't a warrant then. This is him. He has been found. He's been arrested. You're right. This is him getting into jail. So I think maybe the date of the ex. Oh, it's a discharge date. Yeah, so the admission date was the 4th of December. Yeah. The sentencing date was also on the 4th of December. And the discharge was on the 17th of December. So he's done his 14... So in the lead up to Christmas

1854, he was doing a little time. Hmm. Yes. I think he got a bit drunk and fell asleep. Oh, it's just a cool document. I love hearing what he was wearing. Yeah. Yeah. Almost draw a picture of him now. You could. You really could. Yeah. So not helpful in my actual mission, but I like it when I get a new document that I've never seen before. It's fun. And obviously, in this time period, I'm expecting things to get harder

and I'm actually getting a lot more solid information, I feel, about people, which is fun. Yeah, you're getting... Actually, you've always said you want the colour and things like that. You don't just want it to be names and dates. And you're definitely, definitely getting that. Yeah. His mother, his sister would have been alive, presumably around that time. She was alive, wasn't she? It's 1854. So she's still a, you have her on the 1860s. So his sister's alive. Your ancestor, Elizabeth.

She probably knows her brother's Ibiswich jail, which might be a source of local. Chin wagging. Do you know what? He might have just been really depressed and got drunk because he knew his sister was missing from the 1951 census. It's all possible. Three years later, he's like, I'm having a drink. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, so that's largely it for me, but it's good. There's so much to explore. I

feel like I'm getting boring constantly talking about Elizabeth Thing. But she's like, seems to be the focal hub for me to zone in on. And it's just getting me lots of little side shoots and information. That's all been quite fun. You know, she's actually serving you a really good purpose, isn't she? Because let's say you'd found her on the 1851 census. You wouldn't have given it a second thought. You'd have recorded down the 1851 census. You'd have continued to work back in time. OK, doing a really good job. building a tree gathering more and more names but you'll

be using the same records till they trip you up you keep using the same records don't you just like the birth, marriage and death census and then the parish registers and then when we get tripped up or something stops us or it can be just a point of interest or it could be we get stuck then we have to look at other things and that's exactly what's happening with you it's forcing you to look at sideways and you're having an amazing time so she's actually being a great research Yeah. He's like ground zero for all this. Yes. Exploration that I'm having.

Discoveries. Yeah. All from one document, like you said. Yeah. Yeah, it's been good. I have had a few issues. Like, remember a while ago I said I was really scared of the 1841 and I was terrified, wasn't I, to go into it. Yeah. And I sort of just haphazardly went into it and I felt fine with it and all was good. This last week has brought back the fear. And I think it's, again, it's the problem of it only putting on the person that you're looking at and not the

other people related to it. Partially, maybe it's laziness on my part that's just making it harder work. But I tried to add John thing on from the 1841. And when I went to add him on, I went on Ancestry and it said, I was looking at this through Elizabeth thing because that's what brought the document up. So I was on Elizabeth thing, brought the document up for the 1841 and

then John thing's on there. So I'm like, right, I want John thing to have this document as well. So I clicked on the add to a person on your tree, selected John thing. When it went to add person to the tree. It had John's thing, but it was pulling in Elizabeth's details. So it still was associating it with her, despite me saying I want to associate it with John. So I had to stop there because I thought I'm going to ruin his records by putting his daughter's information

on. So that was frustrating. So again, it's potential laziness on my part. I can just do a proper 1841 search and put all his information in and it will come up and bring me the right document and I can link it. But I wanted to link it from the fact I was already in the document. True, definitely. That sounds much better. Your ideal way of doing it sounds much better. I don't know whether you could... I mean, you've got the URL, so you've got that 1841 census document over at the top. And then the URL, if it doesn't include

search terms, it's basically... It's a static URL, isn't it? And so you can change it in the future. But for the minute, you could copy and paste that URL and then... Could you do it... If it's not got search information with it, then you could either download it or... Yeah. I guess if I do that, it might then let me associate, you know, use a document of somebody on your tree. Yes. Yeah. I mean, equally, I could just do the proper search. No, I feel like we're missing

something. I actually can't have made it that hard. You said when it gets to this point, they've done that, so you don't... randomly put on people because i completely agree with him about that so you've got the 1841 and it's not telling you the relationships between the people so you don't want it you don't want to have that kind of very easy way to just keep ticking the boxes and add the people from that census household onto your add those details to the people on your tree you don't want to be able to do that with 1841

because unless you've got other evidence you don't know for sure that They are husband and wife. It could be brother and sister. We've talked about that before. So I agree with Ancestry to do that. But equally, if you are saying you want to attach this document to someone else on your tree, you don't want it auto -populating with the person you searched on. You want to be able to attach the document. So there is something they're missing. They can't believe they've made it that hard. Sure, I'm just being a dummy and can't remember it. Yeah, I felt like I was potentially

just doing something wrong or I hadn't checked a box. I guess I could manually delete all the information it was putting in for Elizabeth and then put John's stuff in. But that, again, seems a bit laborious. There were other bits and bits. It's all relating to this idea of not knowing and not being able to add. It just made me feel a bit sweaty. Yeah. I was worried I was creating duplicates as well. Yes. This was then compounded further by the fact that I've now got three Elijahs

as well. Yes. It just got a little bit confusing and I think at this point I'd done too much and just needed to step away. Yeah, yeah. Kevin, who we spoke of just a moment ago, a little while ago, with his Hobbit ancestor, he wrote in and he's actually saying he was listening to the podcast very recently. the last episode and he heard you Nathan talking about your worries about

entering names on your tree without triangulating multiple pieces of evidence. This is Kevin speaking and as you'll already know this task becomes more difficult as you go further back in time i .e. it can be harder to get enough pieces of evidence. One solution that Kevin has heard of is to enter the name in the tree without triangulating after you find the first piece of evidence. So I do think that is potentially a good thing to do, but with some caveats, because otherwise, if you don't add them to your tree, it can be really hard to hold the information in your head

unless you've got a tree such a helpful visualizer, isn't it? Kevin says add the information even though you've only got one piece of evidence but then add three question marks to the name and when you get more evidence then you can remove the question marks until there are none. Hence once you're satisfied this person is correct. Obviously add the citations for each piece of evidence as you enter them. He does go on to say that he hasn't personally used this method but he heard from someone else and thought it was a great tip. For ancestors going into the 1700s and before, or even the early 1800s or

whatever stage you're at. So I do actually, that's actually quite sophisticated. So by adding three question marks to their name, you can just delete off the question marks and you've got your three bits of evidence, isn't it? Yeah. Yeah, that's a good idea. Yeah. Yeah. And also you can search on those question marks. And I think we mentioned it recently. So Krista Cowan, who's the... corporate genealogist ancestry, when she's going back and she doesn't have the mother's maiden name, she puts in five underscores in place of her surname because then she knows, it's a kind of mental

note to her that she knows she has not got this name. It's not that she's forgotten to add it, she just doesn't have it yet. And she can also search in all the instances with the five underscores and also make like a kind of hit list of people who you want to look into further. So these are kind of very homemade hacks, but they're really useful, aren't they? Yeah, well, I've adopted the underscore one. I've started doing it. Have you? Yeah. So that's working for me, particularly on the five times great grandparents because it is getting harder and harder to find. I do like the question mark idea. I think the question

mark's good as long as you don't get carried away with the potential journey slash hints that ancestry give you. Because if I start, let's say John Hearn, for example, I don't know anything about him. So I put the question marks. And then Ancestry starts giving me hints. I could start building his life quite quickly if I don't focus in and say, yes, I'm going to look at this. You know, I could have relatives that don't exist. What I would be scared of. It's what I am scared

of. Can I give further advice from another podcast listener called Sharon? Yeah. So Sharon has written in before and... she has it's all it's all about these kind of questions about when to add things to our tree and when not to add like that feeling of confidence and certainty and doubt you know they are tricky things to weigh out and for any of us it's probably good that we are trying to weigh it up rather than being a bit too confident and then causing a problem Anyway, Sharon has been doing her family history since 1967 and

then on and off. And then from 1987, she has not stopped. She says she is obsessed. So she wants to answer a few of the questions again from last time's. podcast. It says, Nathan, I would definitely add the father's name from the baptism to my tree. Yes, it's only one source, but if you don't add it, then you run the risk of a few months time of not remembering that you've actually found it. You can always change it later if you find it isn't correct. Plus, you can tag it on Ancestry as unverified or as

hypothesis. And Sharon uses both of those tags lots. So she's using Ancestry's system to help her kind of check back on things and verify them in the future. As to filing, Sharon goes on. She says she's been a computer user for years, so started a filing system years ago. And apart from the odd time, she always names the file as she downloads her. She always names the file as she downloads her files. And this has saved her many hours and has helped her enormously

when searching for information. She has many folders and her genealogy folders are all labelled gen surnames, gen maps, gen DNA, etc. So that they group together and they're easy to back up. That was a hint that Sharon got from Cindy Ingle of Cindy's Lists after watching her finding system several years ago. Sharon goes on, she's got such a lot of good information and fun stuff, so I'm just going to quickly read a little bit more. She says, as a New Zealander whose history involves more recent immigration, it makes her

smile to hear that Nathan has been unsure about moving out of Yorkshire for research. And she has been digging into her DNA across England, Scotland, Ireland and Australia so far. However, each of these families come from different counties within those countries. And of course, she's doing lots of New Zealand research as well. And the last bit, you're going to be a little bit, not told off, but like, I guess, gently encouraged, Nathan. Sharon says she does feel a little sad that you're not looking, not thinking of looking

into your DNA. I think that's where I find that bit. Yes. She says she's sad that you're not thinking about your DNA, especially as you work at Family Tree magazine and have all those people who could help you learn. Because her DNA has been a wonderful jigsaw puzzle to work through and has given her immense pleasure. And it also means that she knows that all her great -grandparents and most of her two -time great -grandparents are definitely her genetic ancestors. So now she knows that her research has been good and accurate. So she's using her DNA just to back

up her findings. Yeah, and that's something Karen Evans in Family Tree, she says that's a really good reason for doing DNA. You can be first and foremost and at heart a genuine kind of traditional family historian, but DNA can give you that certainty that those people on your tree definitely are your people. Right. Yeah. Like, am I doing it wrong? My mindset is... I'm going to do my family tree. I'm going to dig out, dig about in the documents. And then when I get to a point where

I feel really stuck, that's when I'll go back and do my DNA side. No, I do think you're doing it wrong. I mean, if you think, if you scroll back 10 years, 10 years ago, all single DNA was just like getting going, hotting up. And so DNA tests have been around for like 25 years with a useful family history perspective. 2000 so a bit more than a quarter of a century um but these these are questions that Sharon wouldn't have had to consider is she going to start trying

to learn about DNA and family history at the same time when she started back in 1987 it just wasn't part of the picture so she was you just would inevitably have solely done the paper trail tree so I don't think it's bad that you're doing that I don't think it's bad I think you I think sometimes people could take a DNA test go over to their DNA results and be confused and disappointed because unless they have any family history information already their match list most of them are going to be really hard to make any headway with at all if you don't know how to do family history

how are you going to start making sense of who those people are on your DNA match list whereas you by the time you do actually get to go do your DNA you're going to have your really robust tree because you will have been gathering these siblings not just your direct ancestors and you are going to when you do find someone who sounds interesting on your tree to you for whatever reason whether a close match or um anything else which is piquing your curiosity you're going to be knowledgeable about how you can build up

their tree and see where their tree and your tree intersect so you're going to find out how you're related to each other right so i think you're not doing anything wrong but i'm not i i like dna i think it's very exciting i'm really bad at it Whereas if you spoke to Karen, she would be like, definitely Nathan. Come on, we have no time to waste. I just feel like, obviously, I'm only like, what, a year and three quarters into this journey and I haven't run out of things to look at. No way. And I'm so, well, you know, life is busy anyway. I'm making excuses now.

But it's hard enough finding the time to, like, do the paper trail stuff and then the idea of going back and doing DNA on people I've already researched. feels like a pause to me at the moment. It's not something I'm drawn to. It feels more like an admin task. And I know I'm saying this from a complete novice's zone. I have no clue. I haven't had a mystery to solve using DNA. So it would, for me, as far as I know, just be for

that reassurance that my granddad is my granddad and things like that. I think for any of us as well. So hopefully what you would be getting. When you go over to do your DNAs, you're going to get that reassurance, as you say, that all of the people on your tree definitely are your people. But inevitably, pretty much all of us at some point in our tree or other are going to find there's a divergence between our paper trail tree and what actually happened. And so depending on how close in time that happens,

the more life -changing that is. If it's very distant, it's... Probably not an emotional journey in any respect. And you probably just have to build another branch. So you have like your paper trail branch and your DNA branch for that segment. But the closer in time it happens, the more devastating it is on an emotional level. Potentially it might not be devastating, it might be exciting. But from a genealogical perspective, it's potentially devastating. Because if it's one of your grandparents who now isn't your genetic ancestor and you've become heavily invested in that branch, that's

25 % of your research, you go, well... They're kind of still important people because they were the people who, you know, my grandpa was brought up with these stories about his grandpa, which is your, whatever it is, two times great grandpa. But they're not, two times great grandpa might, you know, they might not be genetically related, but they're still part of your family story. Yeah. The stories we get from our ancestors, they help inform what we value and, you know, what interests us and what excites us and what we feel loyal to, all sorts of things, don't

they? Yeah, true, true. So it's still important, but it's complex, isn't it, potentially? So I'm not saying what you should do. I don't think you're wasting your time. If you're doing regular family history, that's just always a good thing. And even the worst case scenario, even if you found that... a relatively large segment of your tree turned out not to be genetically related to you. In the meantime, if you're doing all this family history research, you're learning so many family history skills that you'll be better able to unpick what actually happened

and unpick a problem over on the DNA scene. Yeah? Whereas if you're tackling the DNA scene with limited family history knowledge, you've got multiple learning paths you're trying to turn up on quickly. I guess DNA didn't... Endear itself to me very well did it when we first started. I'm still not forgiving it for the Viking scenario. Yeah. Whatever. I'm an Anglo -Saxon. Yes. I was watching an interview with Idris Elba the other

day and he took a DNA test and basically the results came back and his mum's origin wasn't what he and she thought her culture was. I can't remember the full details of it. So his solution was to take the DNA test again. Obviously, it came back with the same results. It just amused me. He was like, I don't like these results. I'll do it again. I'm quite tempted. Maybe I still am a Viking. We know it's not going to change. Forget it. Yes. So we've covered what

the readers have been advising you. Should we have a think about what we're going to do next week? Over this week, rather. Yeah, go for it. Yeah. Well, you've got cool, exciting stories to follow up. Are you going to do a bit of adding some of these things to your tree? I have added some of them to my tree. I just haven't added William's conviction, which I think I probably, having seen the details actually of it, the things that line up seem pretty accurate, don't they?

Mm. Yes. I don't know where I want to go. I feel like I shouldn't be on this rabbit hole yet, but I am. But I'd quite like to try and find out about Charlotte Crowfoot's death. It's got to be Double Barrel, doesn't it? Not Double Barrel. What is it where someone's name's like CC or BB, Barnabas Bramble? Oh, I don't know. I don't know. Yes, it is. The word for it, isn't there? Like Peter Parker. Anyway. So Charlotte Crawford, I want to find out about her death because she

is Elijah Jr.'s mother. So I want to try and find out about that. I'm not sure how easy that's going to be because obviously we're in, when did I say, she died sometime between 1863 and 1873. Is that viable for me to find out about her death? Yeah. Yeah. Why do you think it's not viable? Because of when documents start. to be catalogued and recorded and... No, you're in good... So you're in England in the 1860s

into the early 1870s. So you've got two, several prongs of attack you can do. You can go over to normal old 3BMD and you can have a search there. You can go to the GRO website because that has births and deaths searchable online but not marriages. So potentially you can get... her death registration there. You can also look in parish registers because just because someone is getting their death registered by the state, they're very likely to get their burial registered

by the church. So you can look at the parish registers of burials for Suffolk or wherever she was living at the time. And because you mentioned that by the time her husband died many decades later, then he's now down in Torquay so keep her eye that the fact if she's married to somebody in the navy she may not be in Suffolk he was in Hull yeah so again it's another part town isn't it yes it's all tying in quite nicely yes

it was a major port wasn't it it's like Kingston upon Hull it's like massive yeah so Keep an eye out where you can look for her in the parish registers. And then the other thing to look out for is, by the time you get to the mid -Victorian period, then there are a lot of people who are not worshipping in the Church of England. They're worshipping as non -conformists to, like, Methodists and Baptists and all that sort of thing. So you could look in other records as well. So it depends. If she's in Hull, then that's in a big kind of

conurbation. Then municipal cemeteries. are growing up from the mid -1800s a lot because the towns and cities are growing massively. They're nowhere to bury people. The churchyards are overrun, so they're setting up actual official cemeteries where people can get buried. So you could be looking for her in that kind of context, not just in a parish church. So it's kind of getting, it feels a bit more complex in a way because you've not just got the parish church to look

at, not just got the... The MD records, not just got the graveyard records. You've got the municipal cemeteries and things like that as well, burial grounds. But on the other hand, it gives you more options, doesn't it? If something doesn't come good, you've got more places to look. Yeah, sounds good. On a side note, I've actually seen a photograph of Elijah Senior's gravestone. So him and his wife, at least his second wife, have got a bit of an inscription down in Torquay in the graveyard there. Amazing, yeah. I've just

had access to lots of cool documents this week. It's been great. Yeah, so I also might look at Elijah Sr. for his ship logs, like you suggested. That would be intriguing because I am quite fascinated by the ship part of that. And did I mention his son also was a sailor, but I don't know to what degree. Yeah. He was just on one of the... I've not even done any research on him, so I don't know much, but on one of the censuses, he was down as a sailor. So it's like following in his father's footsteps. That could be good to follow.

It might be very confusing because it's all the same people with all the same names. But equally, how exciting, because although when we think about the British Empire as a whole from a 21st century perspective, it's something... which is very politically charged and controversial, but thinking about it from your ancestor's perspective, then it's interesting because you're putting a person back in that society and people always

talk about things like gunboat diplomacy and things like that. If he's in the Royal Navy in the Victorian period, there's endless little wars and skirmishes and like how you outlined already. We're used to the 20th century idea, if you're British, there's a couple of main wars and then a couple of smaller wars. Whereas the Victorians honoured it the whole time because they're coming into conflict with everyone. They're trying to boss about and take over, aren't they? Yeah. Regressive trade deals. Yeah, definitely. It'll be interesting to see what I can find. Yeah, yeah. So, yes, he could come up pushing

up against lots of famous events from history. Yeah, it's nice. It's cool. I mean, it is nice, but you know what I mean? No, it's interesting though. Because otherwise we just learn about history and it's just a big, broad story. And then once you put your ancestors in it, partly their lives make more sense and partly their whole historical period makes more sense when you try and see it from one person's experience. Well, this is something new for me to actually have. Obviously, I've got bits and bats of stories of things, but this feels like this guy is actually brushing up against history and like... things

that have actually been chronicled in a different way. It's quite nice to feel that texture. And the fact that this line, we're originally Suffolk family, and so if you're working in agriculture in the Victorian times, there's massive depopulation from the rural areas to the towns, isn't there? Because people are seeking better wages, even though their towns turn out to be hell in many respects as well if you're working in a factory. So I think that's always interesting to think,

what choices did people have about what line of work they took and what made them choose what they chose? Because I've got ancestors in Ireland who joined the army. And again, it's like in a similar setting, sometimes the bits of history they brushed up against. It's tough to read with modern eyes. And it's not to make an excuse for them, but I think it is useful to understand the context of their lives that they came from. So if you're an island, again, in a really rural setting, and you're really economically strapped

and you just can't make a go of it, then you do, you leave to try and earn your crust, don't you? So you might have limited choices. Exactly, yeah. So it's interesting. It makes you kind of, not mealy -mouthed, but it's hard to cast a judgment because you're trying to gather lots of pieces of information together and kind of gain an understanding of it, aren't you? Yep. We're supposed to be finishing now anyway. I know. Yes. Stop talking. Yes. Don't gloat, I'll

be doing lots more research and probably going off on a tangent somewhere else. Yes. Sign me up for that. Yeah. Well, thanks for listening, everybody, and we look forward to you tuning in again next week. Thank you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Sharpening up those detective skills

    Nov 16, 202657 minAudio

    Family Tree Talk podcast cohost Nathan Ward is busy tackling his 4x great-grandparents… and it’s left him feeling a little clammy. Is his Mary a Smith or a Lumb? Do those variations in the dates and details really...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Remembering fallen ancestors with Military Lives

    Nov 9, 202639 minAudio

    Tune in to this week’s Family Tree Talk, with podcast cohosts Nathan Ward and Helen Tovey, as they start a new season of research and reflect on the new AI tool from Findmypast. Studying historic records, it builds a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What can two years of family history do for you?

    Nov 2, 202639 minAudio

    Tune in to this week’s Family Tree Talk with podcast cohosts Nathan Ward and Helen Tovey. As we’ve mentioned a few times, back in autumn 2024 Nathan took a DNA test, wishing to prove his Viking origins. Any thoughts of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Doing a little bit of time…

    Oct 26, 202645 minAudio

    This week in Family Tree Talk it’s all going on for podcast cohost Nathan Ward who stumbles upon another pair of records relating to a pair of brothers who, it seems, may have led one another astray - and been duly...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. I just can’t stop digging!

    Oct 19, 202645 minAudio

    Tune in to this week’s Family Tree Talk podcast as cohost Nathan Ward continues his quest to locate every last piece of the Hearn Family 1911 Census puzzle. With two of the sons found ensconced in an Industrial School,...

    Credit the people on this episode