Silicon Valley Bank (SVB): What Happened And The Opportunity With James White And Dan Catinella
28 minAudio
Headlines were flooded with the news of the Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) collapse, leaving consumers with questions and uncertainty. Banks and lenders, on the other hand, are trying to restore consumer confidence and make the next best move. Total Expert’s James White and Dan Catinella join host Joe Welu in this episode to make sense of the news, break it down in simple terms, and outline the opportunities. James and Dan offer tactical advice for banks and lenders on how they can lead with education and advice when engaging with their customers. As the saying goes, “Never waste a crisis, but rather lean into the growth opportunity.”
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello everyone, I'm Joe Well U. Thanks so much for tuning in to Expert Insights, where we talk with industry leaders across modern financial services to discuss leadership and innovation. Let's get started. All right, hey everyone. Welcome to Expert Insights. I am joined by two of my best pals here, Mr. Dan Cantonella, our chief lending officer, and Mr. James White, our GM and industry principal for banking.
SPEAKER_01How are you doing, guys? Great, great Monday. There's been a little bit going on in the world in the last, uh call it 10 days, two weeks or so. And thought we would come together and have a discussion around Silicon Valley Bank SVB, as they are known and the people that know the organization. Talk about that and what happened, and then also talk about what the opportunity is right now surrounding all this dislocation that we're seeing. So I want to start out and talk about Silicon Valley Bank, the collapse. And as of a couple of weeks ago, a lot of people didn't even know who Silicon Valley Bank was or why it was important.
SPEAKER_01And they are, for those of our audience that don't know and haven't been reading the news, they fund and are the preferred bank to much of the tech community. I think upwards of 50% of technology companies, a bank there. And so they had a very abrupt decline and ultimately were taken over by the feds. And that has caused some dislocation in the market. So I want to start out, guys, and talk me through exactly what happened. And just to simplify for those in our audience that haven't had it explained in simple terms.
SPEAKER_01But James, I'm going to let you expand on this. But so from the way I understand it, they had really ultimately a mismatch in duration of the deposits they invested in securities in treasuries and MBS in bonds, essentially. And they had a duration mismatch, meaning they were in longer-term securities, and they had a bunch of deposits that were potentially needed in the shorter term. When interest rates started going through the roof, those bond prices fall, which is not a problem if you can hold those bonds to maturity.
SPEAKER_01But if you need to access the cash, meaning you need the liquidity, you ultimately have to sell them at a discount, right? Which is what happened, which is what kind of propelled this thing. So I'm generalizing, but give me your take on it. Tell our audience what happened.
SPEAKER_02So from one thing I think if you don't understand banking, is that can be a little bit of a confusion point, is that deposits are actually liabilities and loans are assets. And oftentimes people may get that flip-flop. And so what that means is when you receive in deposits as a bank, there's a cost associated with holding those deposits. You think about just the systems that process deposits, generating statements every month, all those things. So they have to find ways to invest them. They have to earn some type of income off of those deposits, otherwise, they'll just continue to lose money.
SPEAKER_02And so what happened was to your point, Joe, they received a tremendous amount of deposits and they weren't able to offer enough loans to offset those deposits to generate income. And so they have to find other vehicles to invest those dollars in.
SPEAKER_01Let me drill into the into that just a little bit. And ultimately, I want to get to the point where we talk about everybody maybe saying, hey, yeah, this has been in the news a lot. And I think our focus today is ultimately to talk a little bit more about what happened, but then get to why is there opportunity for those that are paying attention? What you're saying is ultimately there was so much money coming in the door, like literally they they didn't hardly know what to do with it. Is that what you're saying? Yes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they couldn't generate enough loans fast enough to offset it. They have to find ways to invest to get some sort of return. Bonds are typically a very safe way to do that. If you can hold them until term, then you can not have to worry about a high risk. So if you lend out the money, you may not get it back as an example.
SPEAKER_01So in hindsight, they should have invested in much shorter term bonds, though, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, oh yeah, for sure. They wouldn't have got as much of a return, but they would have been able to invest in those shorter bonds.
SPEAKER_01Essentially, this is my understanding again, and I'm making no judgment as to leadership decisions at Silicon Valley Bank, just trying to understand the facts here. But basically, the mistake, if there was a mistake, and clearly a lot of people are saying there was underestimating the potential increase in rates and the velocity, okay, of those interest rate increases. Is that where the mistake was? Yeah, that's one of them.
SPEAKER_02The other was not having a diverse portfolio, both of customers and investments. They were really very narrow from a portfolio perspective. And really what you see when the rates rise this quickly is people typically, even for other financial institutions, are going to chase those rates. They if they have no loyalty, they're going to take those dollars and move them over to another institution where they can get to a 3%, especially on millions of dollars.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So I was having dinner last week with one of our bank customers. They're about a two and a half billion dollar institution. And I wanted to know, I'm like, hey, have you guys had pressure? And he was like, basically, no, they didn't feel any, they actually were the beneficiary of this. And in your mind, I know the regional banks have had pressure on them. We saw First Republic, and I guess they're super mid, super regionals, depending on how you categorize them. But where's the pressure at? Let's separate Silicon Valley Bank from the rest of the banking world because arguably you can look at VB and say they were really unique.
SPEAKER_01A, their customer base was not very diversified, as you mentioned, or at least that's what we understand. And how does it compare to the rest of the banking ecosystem? And where's the pressure coming from? And what are you seeing, James? And I know you monitor this closely.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, first off, I want to be clear. I'm not even remotely saying that other financial institutions are about to be in the same situation Silicon Valley Bank is. I think Silicon Valley Bank is the situation that other banks and credit unions are seeing on steroids, which is people are starting to chase higher deposit rates. And the first ones to do that are commercial deposits because there are larger balances. And so when we talk to financial institutions and I'm able to look at and analyze their balance sheet, a lot of them are having deposit runoff.
SPEAKER_02And that's because of those rate chasers. So that is very much a prop for just about all banks and credit unions. But that doesn't mean that they're going to be in the same situation as Silicon Valley Bank is because they have more of a diverse portfolio, less risky investments. They also have less large dollar depositors. It would take a lot of depositors to leave a financial and your average bank.
SPEAKER_01And I don't have the numbers in front of me, but a lot of the community banks, regional banks, a lot of their depositor base falls under the$250,000 FDI and FDIC insurance limit. So their pod deposits are protected.
SPEAKER_02Oh yeah. The average bank, their average deposit, and this includes commercial deposits, is about$35,000. So it's nowhere near. It was$1.2 million for Silicon Valley Bank was their average depositor.
SPEAKER_01And I just think it's important to put some context around this because there's just a lot of all of us talk, we talk about the media and the hype and the sort of panic that starts to set in and how people don't necessarily look at the data and the facts. They start acting with emotion, essentially panicking, right? And so this is important to really understand what is really happening and what's at risk. Now, the government stepped in and backstoped the depositors for SVB. And there's some rules of thought that maybe they shouldn't have done that, maybe they shouldn't have done that.
SPEAKER_01Happened to be in the camp that said, that says they A, it was the right thing to do with the information that we have. If you didn't do that, you would have had ultimately a pretty chaotic, call it, extinction level event for a lot of organizations because it would have just had this contagion, it would have spread. You agree with that, and what's your opinion on that?
SPEAKER_02So I agree 100%. So it's really all about consumer confidence. That's really the narrative that you see out there. There are a lot of media outlets, a lot of other institutions are going to continue to throw SVB under the bus. And the reason why they do that is because it's important to make sure that the consumers feel confident that the banking system is strong because it's really all built on trust. And the banking system is strong. Covering those deposits was crucial, I believe, because you want to make sure consumer confidence stays strong because it takes a lot of$36,000 deposits to leave a bank for a bank to have liquidity problems, but it can happen with the media if you let it continue to spiral out of control.
SPEAKER_01All right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, housing and lending typically always enjoy the benefits of a good crisis, we'll just say.
SPEAKER_01So never waste a crisis, man.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, volatility has been pretty dramatic over the last week. Looking at the markets from some of the swings, the rates swinging up to the 7% range, then falling pretty dramatically towards the end of the week, down where they landed about the six and a half range on 30-year fixed mortgage. We've also seen those are immediate responses to home buyers that came back into the rates dropped, and applications rose six and a half percent just last week alone.
SPEAKER_01So applications were up. I haven't looked at the data yet, but uh applications for mortgage were up six and a half percent week over week.
SPEAKER_00That's right. Yep, and meaningful had some of our top clients report that they had some of their best lock days in almost nine months just last week alone. We we all expected mortgage rates to drop to the lower in a into a six percent range sometime in the second half of 2023. I think with what's going on in the banking market, some of the fears of a recession looming, I think we're gonna see that really come at a much faster pace this year. But I think the next 60 days are still gonna be pretty volatile.
SPEAKER_01They're gonna be volatile. I would agree with you. Yeah, I think we have a high-level overview of what happened, and there's certainly massive amounts of research out there that people can go and dig into that if they're trying to understand it more deeply. That wasn't necessarily the point of this discussion, but wanted to level set there. And now I really want to focus on we spend most of our time as an organization. Of course, we look at all the data, what's going on, but then how do we find the opportunity? How do we find the opportunity for our customers? And when we partner strategically, where are the opportunities for growth? So I want to talk about that. James, when it comes to banks, credit unions, all right, how should they be using this as an opportunity?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so this is a great opportunity to build further loyalty, especially with your younger customer and member base. Cause right now, we've dealt with loyalty issues with the younger demographics for a long time. We just the way a relationship is built with them is different than what we have seen historically with banks and credit unions. And so now is a great time to lean in with financial wellness and financial education, differentiated deposit strategies, relationship pricing would be a great example.
SPEAKER_01Let's talk about that one because people talk about loyalty all the time. We can have a whole conversation on that. And I agree a hundred percent that it is important. And when I think of loyalty, it's really you got to build authentic relationships with customers. And you can't fake it. It has to be, it has to be intentional, it has to be organization-wide, it has to be a directive. We all we agree on that. But you said something on relationship pricing, okay, as it relates to a deposit strategy. Walk me through that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so there's a couple of different ways that you can leverage relationship pricing. So one is just at the individual level. How engaged am I with the institution? The more products and services that I obtain, leverage, and use at the financial institution either benefits me in reward points if I have a rewards program, or benefits me in reduced fees or reduced loan rates or increased deposit rates. And so what that does is one, it encourages me to leverage more products and services from the institution, but two, it makes it more sticky because I'm not going to move my savings account from a bank if it's going to cost me an extra interest point on my auto loan, as an example.
SPEAKER_02And so now you start to get very sticky. That's one way you also can branch that out into the whole household and even the family. So now you're starting to engage the whole household.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so let me just give you my ideation on this and just tell me if I'm correct in thinking about this. So I'm a bank credit union and I have a lend, of course, I'm lending money. Most of them are lending money in some capacity. I'm seeing volatility and interest rates right now. Potentially, we would, I don't think we talked about this, but ultimately, what all this dislocation in the banking system and the chaos that it's creating, a lot of people are feeling it's gonna be a catalyst is pushing us into a recession. And if that happens, arguably, and I don't think it's a question of if I just don't see how we avoid it, rates are gonna come down, right?
SPEAKER_01Lending rates are gonna come down, mortgage rates for sure are gonna come down. And so what you're saying is if I'm in the lending business and I can have a dual-pronged strategy of A, I can drive income from my lending business, but I can also help fix my deposit problem, okay, by having a preferred rate on those mortgage rates, on those lending rates, okay, interest rates, and I can use that as a catalyst or a driver to increase deposit growth. Is that what you're saying?
SPEAKER_02That's exactly what I'm saying. Think about if you, as an example, reduced origination fees in exchange for a direct deposit. So now they're that consumer is going to move their income deposit into your financial in exchange for a lower origination fee.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and if you that's yeah, that's really great. This is a concept that's not new, obviously, but what I do think it has not I don't think banks and organization banks, credit unions, organizations, deposit institutions have done a great job of packaging it. Would you agree?
SPEAKER_02Oh, I would agree completely. And they haven't had to. So that's the big thing is that they were flooded with deposits and flooded with loans. They were throwing people at the lending problem because they just couldn't get them processed fast enough, and they didn't know what to do with all of the deposits. And so now loans are slowing down and deposits, there are no more stimulus ticks. There's no more PPP loans, and people are starting to spend some of that savings as well as move it around chasing rates. And so now they're having to leverage these muscles they haven't had to leverage in quite some time.
SPEAKER_01So if I'm a banker lender or I'm a banker credit unit and I'm doing, I'm looking at my lending and my deposit growth strategy, I would say at the top of the list strategically, I should be thinking about what my playbook looks like to wrap a VIP type of offering for that relationship pricing. I'm gonna get customer acquisition based on that lower rate, okay, that I can offer if I get the deposits. And I'm gonna bolster my balance sheet with, I'm gonna bolster my deposit base.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely. And it's now a lot stickier product too. They're gonna be less likely to chase rates.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So uh obviously we agree this is an opportunity, and I think it really underscores conversations that we've had over this past year about being incredibly nimble right now and the ability to pivot strategy based on what's happening in the markets, meaning, hey, do you have are you nimble as an organization to be able to get a go from ideation from concept to campaign to execution of that campaign? How do you think that's a struggle for most companies?
SPEAKER_01And my opinion is yes, but I want to hear your perspective.
SPEAKER_02Oh, for sure. And a lot of it is cultural, just being able to get out of our own way sometimes and being more focused on the consumer or the customer or the member versus the back office processes. Deliver something that's meaningful to the market and then build the back office behind it versus allowing the back office to dictate what's going to be delivered to the consumer.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So we talk about this a lot internally, just the velocity at which you have to iterate and be able to adapt is increasing so much. And I think this is a perfect, a perfect example of where the banking system, the banking world, credit unions and banks need to embrace that mindset and really lean into it to take advantage of things like this. Dan, talk to us about the opportunity that is just on the horizon potentially for the independent mortgage lenders that are out there. They're not taking deposits, but they're highly sensitive to interest rates.
SPEAKER_01So unpack that opportunity.
SPEAKER_00But in discussion with many lenders, they're either breaking even or they're in striking distance for profitability. So ultimately, as rates drop, we've seen hopefully that continues, even though there will be some probably up and down over the next 60 days. Hopefully, this is the boost that the lenders needed to really enter their spring market and start seeing some profitability. But ultimately, every lender needs to lead with education and advice. And especially as you got a large portion of the purchase market made up of first-time homebuyers that need a whole different level of education right now.
SPEAKER_00Making sure that you're packaging kind of some of these macro factors and translating them into ultimately all the individuals want to know is how can it how can economic tribulations ultimately lead to my success, my meeting my financial goals in the future. Explain what this means for them, and ultimately show them how the real estate and housing market ultimately could build the most financial success for their future.
SPEAKER_01Long-term financial health and fitness, right? We agree homeownership is a great strategy there. But ultimately, the pattern that I'm seeing here, the opportunity really on both sides of the table, banks, credit unions, independent mortgage banks, the opportunity to put the stake in the ground and be that trusted financial partner, be that source of information, be that source of advice, that trusted ally ultimately. That's really a big opportunity right now to if you can go to your referral partners, your relationship partners, accountants, wealth managers, whatever it is in your local ecosystems and be the source of actual factual information, ultimately, and then taking that, of course, down to the consumers and educating them on saying, hey, yes, there is a lot of panic in the world right now when it comes to the financial markets, but let's ground on the facts, okay?
SPEAKER_01Let's ground on the data. And if you look at the last 50 years and you compare renting to home ownership, it's not even close. It's not even close, right? And that's ultimately what you're getting at. And talk to me about the Gen Z opportunity, the first-time homebuyer opportunity. There's a lot of people that are saying, hey, I've got customers that are in the they have two and a half percent mortgages on their home. They're not going anywhere. Okay. I have a thesis on that, but give me your take on the first-time homebuyer opportunity.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so from a first-time homebuyer standpoint, it's massive, right? But I think what a launder, a lot of lenders have not done so successfully is making sure that they're understanding how to reach those Gen Zers. Because they they're on different channels, they spend a lot of their time on social media outlets, really getting their education and advice. So they're just not in the places where some more traditional lenders have really existed. Looking at your strategy to engage those customers in the channels that they exist in is really important.
SPEAKER_00Leading with education and advice, they need a whole different level of education and advice to making sure that you're looking at your touch points and your customer journeys and understanding that you're leading with education to engage them and offer them the right solutions that meet their needs. Things like rent versus buy scenarios and showing them that what their financial wellness and their wealth creation looks like over a five to ten year plan. It's pretty dramatic, as you said.
SPEAKER_01We were talking with a with a partner of ours last week about closing the gap to homeownership and how for large segments of the population in the US, how actually, even if it's a little bit more expensive, okay, for them to get into a home monthly, it's actually the long-term financial health benefit there tends to be so much stronger. And some of the reasons why is the pressure these extended communities and families get on the primary earner.
SPEAKER_01And that money just tends to get whether it's cousin Eddie that is struggling and I end up giving him a loan or what have you. If you pay a little bit more for your rent or for your house payment versus rent, and this was, I hadn't thought about this, but it made sense to me, right? Why home ownership is so important. And you think about segments of the population to where it is literally the best place they can invest in in a lot of scenarios, right? Because it's not, they can't just go spend it easily, right? They can't put it in a Robin Hood account and trade crypto and withdraw it. They can't, friends and family that are in need.
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm all about helping friends and family, but you got to be financially secure first. And that home is a great spot. And I know you agree with that directionally. Uh, I know.
SPEAKER_00And remember, it's you may be paying a little more for your home today, but it's also a fixed debt in a lot of cases, too. Assuming you attach yourself to a fixed-rate mortgage where rents are going to continue to increase over time, too. You look at that over a five to ten year span, you may be actually paying significantly more in your rents than the home you can purchase today.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, all you gotta do is look at the investments some of the big fund managers, such as Blackstone, have put into rental properties. Single family rental properties as an asset class. Okay. These are some of the smartest people in the world. Ultimately, they rarely lose over the long run. And they're betting on that asset class. So for a regular consumer to think, gosh, I don't know, some people are telling me I shouldn't I should rent versus buy.
SPEAKER_01Like, really? These guys are the smartest people in the world, arguably, when it comes to finance. And they're saying you should own. And so you got to look at and consider things like that. So wrapping up kind of the opportunity here, I want to get into one last little conversation about the loyalty, the relationship building in this opportunity. James, I'm going to start with you. We talked a little bit about relationship pricing. What are some key things as an organization? If I'm thinking about right now, today, this week, I'm meeting with my leadership team and I'm saying, what should we be doing?
SPEAKER_01Where do you start? Well, how would you prioritize things?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, the first thing I would do is say list slant towards or lean in towards action and actually execute on some of these things because we've been talking about these strategies for a long time. Now I'm hoping that this situation and the market is going to be a good catalyst for a lot of financial institutions to really start acting on. The second is build a differentiated deposit strategy that is focused on the younger demographics because we've been talking about the transfer of wealth for a long time. It's here, and a lot of institutions haven't built that loyalty with those younger demographics.
SPEAKER_02Lean into financial wellness, and that needs to be more than just a blog that you have out on your website. It needs to be active, engaged communication with financial wellness that's meaningful to those uh individuals. And then this time to really focus on being as efficient and effective as possible. Now's the time to double down and invest in the right places because the pendulum always swings back. And now's the time to do that. So make sure that you have the best processes and technology uh implemented so when that pendulum swings back, you're able to handle the volume in the right way.
SPEAKER_02But it's all of it's really all about just action, just act.
SPEAKER_01Moving quickly, right, moving fast. And analysis paralysis is the death of a lot of companies, a lot of a lot of practitioners, a lot of the loan officers' advisors that we work with over the years, and you see these deep cyclical environments, and this happens to be a pretty significant one. And one of the things that we see that separates the big winners from arguably the losers is they don't take as much action. They don't adjust, they're not on offense. And so you just hit the nail on the head, and I agree with you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I would say, you know, look at your strategy for engaging first-time homebuyers. Gen Z, millennials make up certainly the majority of that population. And look at your strategy for how your originators are engaging those demographics for sure. And also look and look at your lead conversions and look at ways that you can measure lead conversions. Every deal matters right now. So, how do you make sure that you have you're nurturing those prospects over the life of that lead? You got the sales cycles that are still lasting significantly longer than ever buyers are struggling to find homes due to lack of inventory and affordability.
SPEAKER_00So making sure that you're really looking at that customer journey and engaging those customers over a lot longer cycle than you have before. And then the other one that everybody should be looking at is really how do you use data and intelligence to surface opportunities within your database? I can guarantee you, if you've closed a transaction over the last 12 months, those will be ripe for a rate-in-turn refinance and will you know have significant cost reductions in the next you know, three possibly to six months. So making sure that you're preparing for those opportunities now so that your entire Salesforce is ready to really seize them because time, time is of all importance when you try to look at how to use data to surface opportunities and engage the customers at the right time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think both of what both of the commentary that you guys have really leads me to fully support our thesis on you have to be a data-driven organization, you have to lead with data intelligence insights, and then you have to package that with the automation and enablement of your sales organization, meaning you're forcing process down to make sure that they're taking action on those insights. Hey, if I've got Bob here or Susie that is a first-time home buyer, I want to know if they're in the market, I want to know their financial profile.
SPEAKER_01And then I want to be able to drive the touch points, the engagement. I want to do it at an enterprise level. It's not enough, and we see this over and over again. We looked at a lot of data in the last few weeks. The organization that simply says, here's an Excel file of some opportunities based on our back-of-the-house data team, go ahead and call on these. Like you might as well just throw that in the trash can. You really have to automate the entire process. And it's a leadership-driven initiative, right? You can't just put some things in place and expect your customer-facing teams to have the discipline.
SPEAKER_01And I think ultimately the organizations that are putting systems in place right now that are honing kind of their current stack, their current tech stack, and saying, I'm going to be able to analyze my current base of customers, segment those customers, and then drive communication engagement advice as the markets are moving. It plays into both sides, right, guys? Like banks, credit unions, independent banks. Yeah. Absolutely. Awesome discussion, guys. Really appreciate the conversation. Man, there's a lot going on, and it's uh equal parts terrifying and equal parts exciting, depending on how you look at it.
SPEAKER_01We always say never waste a crisis, lean into the opportunity, have a growth mindset, and uh let's go. 2023 is moving along. So thank you guys. Thank you. Thanks so much for joining us today. Be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
American Pacific Mortgage is on track for $15B in production volume this year. What does it take to lead an organization of this size through the biggest technology shift in history in the most challenging market in a...
Ever wondered how one loan officer can build a billion-dollar business? In this episode of the 10x Lender Series, Total Expert Founder & CEO, Joe Welu, sits down with Shant Banosian of Rate to pull back the curtain on...
At the core of Prosperity Home Mortgage, they are hyper-focused on communication, which includes everyone in the homebuying process. That includes the real estate agent, the lender, and the borrower. For President and...
The technology conversation of GenAI has moved so fast since OpenAI and Chat GPT burst into the public eye. But are businesses just buying into the hype of AI, and does it really benefit their goals and needs? For...
The technology buzzwords for the last few years have been AI analytics, data analytics, and automation, but businesses are still unsure how to leverage those advancements in their systems. Leveraging data and connecting...