Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Expert Insights

Expert Insights artwork

How Product Innovation Changes Customer Experience

Feb 24, 202237 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Service is in banking’s soul. It’s a core part of driving growth. However, recent history in banking, especially fintech innovation, raises an important question: With fintechs winning so many new customers, does product innovation mean banking organizations can no longer depend on service to compensate for a commoditized product offering? Joe Welu is joined by Ron Shevlin to answer, is customer experience dead?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Expert Insights Podcast. Each week, we sit down with executives and leaders in financial services to discuss industry trends, challenges, and strategies, creating a playbook that upcoming leaders can follow to drive revenue and find their own success in the market.

SPEAKER_01Joel U here with another episode of Expert Insights, where we tackle the growth and loyalty playbook for modern banks and lenders. Today I am joined by Mr. Ron Chevland, Chief Research Officer at Cornerstone Advisors. It's always awesome to catch up with Ron. Ron is considered one of the industry's preeminent, most notable banking experts. Ron has been a management consultant for more than 25 years, has worked with leading financial service organizations, consumer products, retail manufacturing firms all over the world.

SPEAKER_01As the chief research officer at Cornerstone, uh, Ron calls on his analytical acumen to author a variety of corporate and commission research reports. So, Ron, it's uh it's always a pleasure to be with you, sir. How you doing, bud? Oh, I'm doing great. Trying to stay warm here in Boston. And uh thanks for having me on, Joe. Absolutely, man. Likewise, it's uh it's uh nice and chilly here in Minnesota. So, Ron, I'm gonna get right into it. You published a recent Forbes article around the rise and fall of consumer experience in banking, which initially the the headline um, you know, caught me a little bit, to be frank.

SPEAKER_01Um, and I'd love to dig into that a little bit. In your opinion, what is driving uh the need to shift focus uh on consumer experience?

SPEAKER_02So, Joe, well, I gotta be honest, I've had a uh a beef about the customer experience concept for a long time. Uh, I've always wondered why do we use that term in the singular versus the plural? We don't consumers and customers have many different experiences.

SPEAKER_01That's so true.

SPEAKER_02So the idea of trying to boil this down to the customer experience has always kind of bugged me. But I'll let it go. I'll let it go for now and say this. Uh, I think the industry has obsessed over the customer experience for about 20 years now. I think it's about 20 years that that terminology is you know really caught on in organizations and has become accepted as a you know key differentiator or enabler uh of companies' strategies.

SPEAKER_02But as I look at how consumer behavior and attitudes are changing, you know, many consumers are adopting a lot of fintech uh companies' offerings. And I would argue that for, and especially a lot of neo banks or who really aren't banks, I like to call them community fintechs because they really tend to focus on narrow niches of the market. And when you look at how they're differentiating, I don't think they're necessarily doing a better job of uh online banking or mobile banking.

SPEAKER_02They probably are doing a better job of digital account opening and loan origination, but okay, why are they even in the ballpark uh of consideration for that, for those things? And it's because they differentiate on the product offering. They have personalized targeted products for their uh customer segment that they're going after. And when you look at especially large banks, they're not focused on specific niches of the market. And if you look at the community financial institution market, the community banks and credit unions, many of whom, by the way, of the past 20, 25 years have transitioned from you know special employer group focuses to community-based charters.

SPEAKER_02You know, who are they designing products and services for? They're deserted designing products and services for geographic segments. There are no unique needs. And the so it's the fintechs who have really kind of disrupted the market, not displaced the banks and credit unions, but disrupted consumers' behaviors and attitudes with products and services that are are tailored to particular segments. Uh, and yes, they're they're they're maybe doing a little bit of things from better from an experience perspective, but it's really those products.

SPEAKER_01It's product innovation. Product innovation, really, what you're talking about.

SPEAKER_02It's product innovation, uh, more so than it is experience innovation. And so my kind of stake in the ground here is not to say that customer experience isn't important, but I think you've got to look at this from a very strategic perspective. Let's say you're a financial institution that already excels in customer experience. Joe, what's the real lift you're gonna get? Let's let's grade it. Let's say we could grade customer experience on a scale of zero to 100, and you've got a financial institution who's at 95 today.

SPEAKER_02What's the lift in terms of bottom line business results that they're gonna get from going from 95 to 97 or 98? I don't think it's a lot. I don't think they're going to get that much more lift.

SPEAKER_01Now to your point almost, right? If you know the experience is is one thing, but if they don't have product innovation, and product innovation meaning do they have a product that can get the outcome that the consumer desires, right? In whatever kind of phase of life they're in or whatever industry they're they're serving, the product delivers the desired outcome the consumers are seeking. Would you agree? Yes. I think I think it's a great way of describing it. So it's really about, uh, from my perspective, I think about um experience is one thing, but it doesn't always mean you're getting the desired outcome that the consumer needs as part of that financial journey, right?

SPEAKER_01And the product innovation is really geared towards I'm gonna focus uh on specific product innovation that gets said outcome for this particular set of consumers or target customers. Is that how you frame it, how you think about it?

SPEAKER_02It is. Although let me take the uh just to for argument's sake, kind of take the other side of the coin. This is the argument I typically get when I try to make this argument is that changing the actual product features and functions, which I would think of as product innovation, changes the customer experience. So part of the problem is where is the line between product design and product delivery, which we would typically interpret as being the experience.

SPEAKER_02Um, so you know it's a it's a murky kind of a of a situation. But I think, you know, bottom line, Joe, what reason I wrote this and the reason I'm, you know, uh what I'm trying to do is to get bank and credit union executives thinking differently. Uh, and thinking that, listen, their path to differentiating and improving in the market will come more from their product design for new products, new services, new product enhancement than it will be in terms of enhancing the experience of the existing product set.

SPEAKER_02You know, providing a better design for your mobile banking application may be great, but it's it's only marginal, though, right?

SPEAKER_01To your point, it only gets you marginal. Yes. Do you have any examples in where you think product innovation has really nailed it uh and and been a catalyst for growth?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'll give you an example. I'll give you a real example with with real names. Um, Los Angeles Police Federal Credit Union. You know, this is a credit union that is, yes, it is geographic based in that it serves, you know, certain uh communities in the in the Los Angeles greater uh metropolitan area, but they also have a very targeted market, which is law enforcement professionals. And I would argue that there's probably not a whole lot of credit unions in the country who know law enforcement professionals as well. Uh, and those credit unions would be other law enforcement-focused credit unions.

SPEAKER_02And so they have designed lending products in particular that serve the unique needs of those of uh of those segments. Um, you know, it's not a um particularly pleasant thing, but uh, as you we well all well known, law enforcement uh personnel have pretty uh dangerous jobs. And they have a lending product that basically absolves the uh borrower from any lending um requirements in case of you know death on the job.

SPEAKER_02It's you know, these are the types of things that the typical financial institution wouldn't think of if they were offering a loan to a law enforcement professional, probably they don't even know that it's a law enforcement professional. And so they also understand the life stage needs of these professionals. And so, you know, there's help in terms of uh purchasing equipment for the for the job. Uh, you know, you you see a lot of banks that you know will have portals on their mobile banking apps to have discounts on things.

SPEAKER_02Well, they focus their their design on on products that are specific to law enforcement professionals. So it's about really understanding that market.

SPEAKER_01You know, I'll give you a lot of people. It's really about it's also depth, right? The depth they're going to serve the needs of that customer base, right? If you think about uh you think about the fact that they actually thought through that it's if you're in that field, uh it's on your mind that I could get killed on the job. And if I do, having to know that that loan is um gonna be taken care of or I'm off the hook or whatever the product is, but that is really going deep in terms of needs of the customer. And that that's that's a great example.

SPEAKER_02Well, well, and look at it from the eyes of the of the member. Joe, let's say you you've got two loans you need to decide between. You know, a loan that's gonna give you, you know, it's gonna charge you 4.6% on interest or 4.7 percent of it on interest. Um, but in case of uh accident, death, your family is absolved. I think I'll take that 4.7 loan versus the 4.6. And by the way, if I have to go through, you know, a little bit extra hoop um to get that because it's not a slick online application.

SPEAKER_02Okay, I know I'm getting I know I'm getting the better loan, and I'm getting it from somebody who cares more about me than that other guy does.

SPEAKER_01Totally. Yeah, it really, it really thin makes you think about the fact that those are the organizations that do those types of things, they genuinely go deep in care at a level other people are not going to care about that specific need. So that that's a great example.

SPEAKER_02But Joe, let me last one more point to throw in there. But that's not to say that providing a great member or customer experience isn't important. You still have to it has to still clear a minimum hurdle of being good enough.

SPEAKER_01It's almost table stakes, right? Like you get to a point on customer experience, and from our purview, like baseline customer experience, the the stakes have been raised, certainly. And there's a minimum operating level that you have to be at to be table stakes, right? Or or you're just gonna get evaporated uh over the next few years if you don't meet some of the some of those minimum thresholds. You agree?

SPEAKER_02Yes, it's the it's it's an that's why this is not an either or type of situation. You could have if you have a great product but a really lousy experience, you're not gonna win. But if you have a great experience and at least an acceptable experience, then you're you're you're going to be competitive. So it's it's it's really understanding how good you are on a lot of these dimensions.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So my takeaway from this is customer experience in and of itself, as organizations many times think of it, improving my more mobile uh application, improving my you know, my onboarding process, those things in themselves are not going to be enough from a differentiation standpoint to drive the the growth in the future. That's my takeaway. Yeah, yeah, awesome. Well said, sir. Okay, next question. Um uh we talk a lot about fintechs. You guys have so much knowledge about the fintech space in general.

SPEAKER_01Uh, how are rising fintechs challenging financial institutions specifically? And what do the banks need to do differently, like right now, this year, to take action on it?

SPEAKER_02First of all, many fintechs, and let's talk about the ones that are kind of direct to consumer. Uh, because you know, many fintechs now are you know, in effect, B2B players as much as they are B2C players. They're looking to help the banks uh and provide capabilities around uh you know lending or deposit or you know, whatever it might be, new product design and development.

SPEAKER_01And I would break it down into like you have fintech that is competition and you have fintech that's partnership driven, right? Is that how those are the buckets that I think about it?

SPEAKER_02Um yeah, I wouldn't have used I think you're right about competition, um, but I would have put the other bucket as sort of you know capability. It's it's helping the the financial institution create capabilities which might be you know digital lending, digital account opening, yeah, yeah, yeah. So they're a partner, they're a tech management, things like that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, they're a technology partner, yeah. That makes sense.

SPEAKER_02Yes, more in effect, they're on the path to becoming vendors. But the reason that I I would push back on the partnership, because I think even if you're potentially competitive with uh uh from with a fintech, there still might be products that they offer that you can partner with because you will never get, or it's gonna take you a long time to get to that level of product capability. Now, if it's a head-to-head comparison or head-to-head competition of a particular product or service, then yes, it's it's probably not a great partnership opportunity.

SPEAKER_02But you know, for many instances, like you know, think about companies like maybe a True Bill, um, you know, providing bill payment analysis and negotiating negotiation services. Uh, how long is it going to take you to, as a bank or credit union, to build those capabilities? A long time, and you probably could never make the case for it. But you know, finding situation, you know, companies, fintechs, that offer that and partnering with them, those that provide, let's say, uh subscription management capabilities.

SPEAKER_02I guess a bank could probably go off and build its own crypto investing and trading capabilities, but why do so when you know NIDIG is now partnered with every one of the big core vendors? So you know, there's there's a lot of you know partnership that's going on, and partnership opportunities. You know, the fintechs um you know are creating either you know very narrow niche products uh that they need help in terms of getting scale to market, and that's why there's a great partnership opportunity.

SPEAKER_02Or you know, you get the true competitors like a chime, uhvaro, aspiration, uh, you know, who are attracting consumers on a national level and to some extent, you know, competing directly with the established um, you know, banks and credit unions. So from a strategic perspective, it leaves the bank or credit union with a couple of questions to have to address at a very strategic level. Number one, uh, where are we vulnerable from our market perspective in terms of reaching the target market we want to reach?

SPEAKER_02How good or bad are the products that we are offering to our target market? And how how do we best proceed? Do we partner? Do we build? Do we buy? You know, the old build versus buy um dichotomy is is now a trichotomy. It's build buy or partner. Which way do we go on that? And so for many banks, and in fact, I just published a report on the state of the union and bank uh fintech partnerships, and you know, a couple of snippets from that.

SPEAKER_02Number one, nine out of ten banks and credit unions say that partnerships are important to their strategy and to their overall growth. Uh, but Joe, interestingly, you know, in the one to ten billion dollar asset range, you want to take a guess at what the average number of FTEs in those institutions that are dedicated to fintech partnerships are?

SPEAKER_01It's small. Two and a half. I don't know, but two and a half and two and a half FTEs.

SPEAKER_02Now, let me ask you how many partnerships can two and a half people identify, negotiate, vet, deploy, and scale? And the answer is not a whole lot of them.

SPEAKER_01So maybe not even not even anything meaningful, right? Not even a meaningful one.

SPEAKER_02You know, one on average, you know, banks and credit unions uh are now at about two or three partnerships, up from about one to one and a quarter from two years ago. Uh, but you know, what they haven't done, and I think was important, is you they need to recognize you need a capability, a competency in partnering. You've got your procurement department, they know how to buy. Where's your department that knows how to partner? And it's a different set of skills. It's not an IT skill, it's not a line of business functional skill, it's it's a new skill.

SPEAKER_01It is a new skill.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, and so for many banks and credit unions, uh, the way to go about it is is you know to partner with each other first. Um, I've been a big fan of what Alloy Labs has been doing over the past couple of years. Um, you know, they just launched the Chuck Network. Uh, another bank, another consortium of uh community banks just launched a week or two ago called the USDF Consortium, uh, to establish and build a stable coin and provide you know trading capabilities around that to get into the crypto world.

SPEAKER_02So I think banks are actually learning that the better path to fintech partnerships is actually first partnering with other banks to create so interesting.

SPEAKER_01You got to create uh yeah, say a little more about that, how you see these banks partnering with each other. I think it's uh this is really an important conversation for a lot of the people that we talk to and probably a lot of our listeners. But say more about that.

SPEAKER_02Well, number one, it's a cultural shift. Uh, I don't think many community banks have been uh oriented towards collaborating with other banks, even if they're not in the same geographic area. But I think what's happened over the past couple of years is that there have been some banks like uh I live in the Boston area, I'm just down the road from Reading Cooperative Bank. Julianne Thurlow there is, you know, and maybe it's because it's a cooperative bank, and it's probably almost as much as a like a credit union than it is a you know a true bank, but of course it is a bank.

SPEAKER_02But you know, uh executives like her, like Jill Castilla from from uh Citizens Bank, Edmund, Chesapeake Bank, there's a number of them that you know have this mentality that look, we don't compete with banks a thousand miles away. Why wouldn't we why wouldn't we cooperate, collaborate with them to scale the resources we need? Because we can't hire 15 people to do it. But if I put up one or two and you put up one or two, and we get six or seven more who put up one or two, now we've got the the the scale of resources we need to to build that.

SPEAKER_02And if the consortium approach is important because you really do need somebody who kind of takes control of it and manages it across it. You know, it can't be a free form, hey, let's just all get together whenever we can. Somebody's gotta make this a real thing. So uh, you know, I think that's, and I do think to a certain extent, despite the fact how much banks despise credit unions for their tax exemption, uh, I think they look at the credit unions and and recognize, although they might not be too willing to admit it, yeah, those guys do a better job of collaborating with each other through you know, CUSOs and things like that than we do.

SPEAKER_02And I think that mentality is changing in banking, Joe. I I think the community banks are realizing one last point on that. They're also realizing that the merger approach to gaining scale isn't gonna stop. Let's put it, let's get real. That's not gonna stop. But the if you're a$1 billion bank who's got designs of being you know getting to the$10 billion level, uh it's gonna take a lot of acquisitions to get there. I was meeting with the CEO of a local bank around here who's at about billion and a half to two billion, and he looks around and says, Yeah, I can identify three or four more, you know, two billion dollar banks in the area, but if I got to buy them all out and merge them all in, that's gonna take me 10 years.

SPEAKER_02I don't have 10 years to do that. So the way to get scale these days is by having 10$1 billion banks in a consortium. And even though you're not a single legal entity, you've now you know are approaching the scale you need to do some innovation things uh from a new product and service development perspective.

SPEAKER_01So walk me through on the consortium, and they're as these guys are building these consortiums, creating these consortiums, and I'm familiar with some of them. Um, in terms of actually driving the initiatives, the process for evaluating where they're going to spend time and resources. So I'm guessing there's there's some alignment that has to happen up front on what the priorities need to be. Is that is that how typically you're seeing it executed?

SPEAKER_02Let's say you got a consortium with 15 banks. Typically, what's going to happen is for any particular single initiative, you're going to get three or four who's really leading it, and maybe five or six who are actually in on it. Though the consortium itself is bigger, they may have three or four initiatives going on at any one time. Not all 15 are actually going to participate in all of the initiatives their priorities.

SPEAKER_02Although all are can can benefit from it if they opt in. But I do think that it's generally led by a you know smaller coalition, some subgroup within the broader consortium itself.

SPEAKER_01I want to just spend a little bit more time on sort of the landscape and how it's changing, all of the options that consumers have out there. Um how do you think organizations need to think about loyalty of their customer base? Let's say you're a$5 billion bank,$10 billion bank, right? Yes, I need to innovate on product, I need to improve customer experience. Even if I'm doing those things, right? There are, at least from our perspective, customer loyalty still becomes challenging because consumers are getting pulled in so many different ways.

SPEAKER_01As you think about customer loyalty, what do you think the secret sauce is today and on a go forward basis?

SPEAKER_02So let me preface my comment in answer to that, Joe, by telling you and everybody else who's listening that I've got an MBA in finance and statistics. I'm a numbers guy. Uh, I don't like touchy-feely stuff. You know, I'm I'm I'm not super emotional, any of that stuff. But it has taken me a long time to come around to the belief that loyalty is is more of a qualitative measure than a quantitative measure. Uh, first of all, if you're measuring loyalty today by um retention rate, you're really crazy.

SPEAKER_02You're you're really off the reservation on on that one. Because look, the reality today is that consumers don't close their accounts, um, especially from the deposit size, they just kind of move on and move the money. So, at a the minimum, wallet share is a better uh measure of loyalty than retention rate or attrition rate.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, because you can have so just to be clear on retention, right? Why why you're saying that is because theoretically it still may show that I have an open account. They never close the account, but they're really not my, I'm not their primary institution anymore.

SPEAKER_02That's why you're saying no, and you may not even be their second or third account anymore.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Um, and you to some extent that money's just sitting there. But I have over the past couple of years heard so many banks and credit unions brag that their attrition rate is in single digits. And I am always thinking, big deal, big whoop. It's it's everybody's in that case, but you don't seem to be generating any more profits out of those accounts. So at a minimum, wallet share is better, but here's the other challenge to that one now. You know, I did an article a couple of weeks ago, um, which I called something like uh, you know, consumers, you know, hidden financial lives.

SPEAKER_02And you know, it's kind of the belief in the in in the industry is that, well, the typical consumer has, you know, six or seven different financial relationships. And my point was, no, I think they have 30 to 40. If you really look, I mean, yes, they might have, you know, one or two checking accounts, but Joe, they got a health savings account that they're spending money on. They put money into their Starbucks app and their CVS app and their other app, and those become payment mechanisms.

SPEAKER_02And then they're using Apple Pay and Venmo, and there's money sitting in those accounts. And yes, they have their traditional investment account at Schwab, but now they've got one at Robinhood and they've got a Coinbase account, and they're using Investor to play Fantasy Finance. Um, and so you start counting all of this up, and it's not six or seven relationships, it's 30 to 40 relationships. So, number one, you can't calculate wallet share anymore.

SPEAKER_02It's nearly impossible to figure that out uh because there's so many providers. And so, where I'm going with this, and why I started with the I got an MBA in finance and statistics was well, first of all, just to brag about the fact that I got an MBA in finance and statistics.

SPEAKER_01I don't have one, so brag away.

SPEAKER_02How engaged are your customers? And it's a proxy for their emotional connection. Look, I've got a favorite cereal, Joe, and I'm very loyal to that cereal, and my wife's on my case all the time that I eat too much of it. But I don't just have one favorite brand, I got a couple. And so the product manager for that number one uh cereal might get mad at me and think I'm being disloyal by eating my number two or number three cereal, but I don't look at it as being any less loyal.

SPEAKER_02It's I just need a little variety.

SPEAKER_01That's an interesting and well said, Ron.

SPEAKER_02And so, look, from a banking perspective, I'm simply not going to go to one institution for every product I need. But that doesn't make me any less loyal to the ones I do use for what I use them for, especially if they're always in the consideration set the next time around. That's a really hard thing to measure. And yet, you know, Joe, remember the report we did with you guys a couple months ago last year? You know, what did we find?

SPEAKER_02Was that in the mortgage space, what was really important was being in the consideration set. If you're in the consideration set, then your, you know, your your opportunity to you know grow the relationship is what is the first step in that. So it's more than just you know trying to be at the right time, at the right place with a message, it's about building the relationship to be in the consideration set first.

SPEAKER_01You have the trust and the relationship credit, the quote, the depth of the relationship. You've provided enough connection to where you've earned the opportunity to then have the seat at the table when they decide to make that next transaction or that next product that they might need. That's that's really what you're saying, right? Right.

SPEAKER_02And it's not a science, Joe. There's not like I can say, here's the formula and it works, go do this. You have to, as a management team, you have to go figure this out for yourself. What does your best client look like? Not just physically look like, but what do they look like from a behavioral perspective? What do they do? How do they interact with you? Where do they interact? How often do they interact? Do they um and and please don't tell me, Mr. or Ms. Bank Executive, oh yeah, our bubble banking customers check their balance 17 times a week.

SPEAKER_02That's not engagement. But tell me how to do it. How do you define?

SPEAKER_01I'm gonna push on you on that. Okay, how do you define it?

SPEAKER_02Uh with a range of both transactional and interactional type of things. So, for example, how many debit card transactions do they make on a monthly basis? If they're making a lot of debit transactions on a monthly basis, that's one sign of this level of engagement. Now, if you've got the data and can see their relationship, what percentage of their spending behavior is debit versus credit card? Uh, because my bank would look at me and say, Well, I never uses his debit card, which doesn't make me disloyal.

SPEAKER_02It just means that I I'm more of a credit card spender than a debit card spender. So then after that, I would be looking at things like do I make use of personal financial management tools? Um, do I have an account manager that I interact with? This is not even digital anymore. It's how often do I interact with an account manager? Um, when I go into the branch, what kind of transactions and interactions do I have there? You've got to look at the whole of the relationship, not just the digital behavior. Uh, you've got to look at the types of transactions and interactions that somebody's having with the institution and the frequency of those interactions.

SPEAKER_01What you're describing to me is something that we're we're really passionate about in our parts of the partnerships that we have with organizations. And that is having uh an intelligent view of each and every human, each and every customer that that is in your organization. It's incredibly hard to do, to have a truly intelligent profile that brings all those things together, but that's kind of what you're describing, right? The only way to really understand it is you need to be able to have all of those data elements and be able to uh visually lay that out and decide, hey, what what do my best customers do?

SPEAKER_01What are the patterns with my highest profit customers? Is that what you're describing, or am I off base there?

SPEAKER_02No, I think it's exactly what it is. Uh you've got to have you know wide range of data sources, but it's an art. You you have to you you have to come up with a proxy, maybe a formula for something, and it's gonna differ across every institution. Uh, but the management team's got to set their data people off and say, you know, go play around with this and come back. And you know, you use the the growth in the relationship as the dependent variable in this equation, but the independent variables that go into it, um, you got to figure out which are the right ones.

SPEAKER_02And those are the ones you you then measure and manage to.

SPEAKER_01So fast forward 24 months, Ron, and walk me through the things that if I'm a if I'm an organization, I'm a bank or a credit union, what are the things I'm going to regret that I didn't do in 2022?

SPEAKER_02Uh number one regret would be not figuring out kind of what ecosystem you play in. Uh, you know, I think the days of the standalone financial institution that just has its little market, has its little geographic market that it focuses in on and provides its, you know, standard traditional financial products, uh, is going to find, I'm not ever going to say they go out of business or fail or their dinosaurs. It's nothing like that. But their growth rate will be challenged. And so there's a there are, when I say ecosystem, I don't necessarily mean, you know, some sort of uh very formal thing, but the interconnectedness, who are you partnering with?

SPEAKER_02What distribution channels are you uh looking into? You know, I'm a big proponent and fan of this trend of embedded finance and banking as a service. I think um my colleague uh Alex Johnson and I are working on a report now looking into embedded finance. And uh we haven't published anything yet, but Joe, the consumer interest in getting financial products from non-traditional financial providers, from companies that they do business with every day, whether you're a Lyft or Uber driver, whether you're a gamer playing on the same platform all the time, if you're a gig worker using various gig worker platforms, these consumers want to get and are open to getting financial services from those providers.

SPEAKER_02But of course, they need to partner with banks and other financial institutions to get it. From the banking perspective, this is a big challenge mentally and culturally, Joe, because they lose the ultimate connection to the face of the them being the not being the face of the of the product to the consumer anymore. But from the bank perspective, it's simply a new distribution channel.

SPEAKER_01I was just gonna say, so you just hit a bullseye, in my opinion, on that one, because it's not a technology limitation really anymore. You can do it, you might not have you might not be set up right now to do it, but through partnerships and the different capabilities that are out in the market, you can essentially do that. It's not a technology limitation, it really is a mindset limitation for a lot of these organizations.

SPEAKER_02Do you agree? The uh the mindset limitation is the first hurdle, but make no bones about it, Joe. The technology limitations are a huge hurdle as well.

SPEAKER_01But they are available to them if they will if they choose to make those adjustments, correct? Well, that's what's changing in the market today.

SPEAKER_02Now, there are banks that have been in this space for a couple of years. They took, they had the luxury, although they probably wouldn't describe it that way, but they've had the luxury of being the early providers and building those technology capabilities themselves. For that next wave of banks that are going to get into this, they don't have the luxury of being able to spend two to three years to build it. But the good news for them is that there are companies like SyncTara and Move and Treasury Prime and Item that are coming into the market and basically saying, we can do this all for you and be that intermediary and help you know build that set of capabilities.

SPEAKER_02So interestingly, Joe, is just as we were talking before about the consortiums helping banks accelerate their partnership, these banking as a service infrastructure providers help the banks uh accelerate their capabilities and entry into this banking as a service market or embedded finance market. So I think the banks that don't take advantage of that and look at this from a strategic perspective, two to three years down the line from now are gonna look back and go, all right, you know, we're we're not dead because we're not dead in the water because of it.

SPEAKER_01But man, do I wish I would have listened to Ron Chevlin in beginning of 2022?

SPEAKER_02Oh man, they're gonna say I wish to listen to Ron Chevlin back in 1997. You know, well, I don't know. Actually, Joe, uh honestly, the first time I I didn't I didn't have the foresight to call it uh embedded finance, but I went back, I actually published a report in in July of 2020, in which I uh said that you know, we're gonna see the emergence of non-financial providers as as you know, providing financial services firms as is you know in indication. So uh yeah, I mean I think I I called this one back 20 to almost 22 years ago, a little bit before the time.

SPEAKER_01Man, I'm I've always been a huge fan of yours. And Ron, uh, thanks so much, sir, for for joining us. Love the love the thoughts, uh, love the comments on on the future and uh what some of these companies are are gonna regret if they don't do it. There there still is a lot of opportunity. We both agree on that, and um, it's just an incredible time to be in this space because of the change and and opportunity that we continue to see. So um, for all our listeners out there, thank you for tuning in. We'll catch you next time on another episode of Expert Insights.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening. Be sure to subscribe for new episodes each week. And to learn how the Total Expert platform, purpose built for financial services, can help your company drive three times growth and double customer loyalty and retention, visit totalexpert.com.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Leading from the Front: AI and the Future of Lending with Steve Majerus

    Nov 20, 202631 minAudio

    American Pacific Mortgage is on track for $15B in production volume this year. What does it take to lead an organization of this size through the biggest technology shift in history in the most challenging market in a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Shant Banosian: Building a Business Without Limits and Reimagining What's Possible in the AI Age

    Nov 5, 202656 minAudio

    Ever wondered how one loan officer can build a billion-dollar business? In this episode of the 10x Lender Series, Total Expert Founder & CEO, Joe Welu, sits down with Shant Banosian of Rate to pull back the curtain on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Respecting Transactions by Humanizing the Homebuying Journey

    Aug 6, 202434 minAudio

    At the core of Prosperity Home Mortgage, they are hyper-focused on communication, which includes everyone in the homebuying process. That includes the real estate agent, the lender, and the borrower. For President and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Incubating AI Specifically Designed for the Mortgage Industry

    Jul 16, 202426 minAudio

    The technology conversation of GenAI has moved so fast since OpenAI and Chat GPT burst into the public eye. But are businesses just buying into the hype of AI, and does it really benefit their goals and needs? For...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Activating Data the Right Way for a Targeted Purpose

    Jun 11, 202428 minAudio

    The technology buzzwords for the last few years have been AI analytics, data analytics, and automation, but businesses are still unsure how to leverage those advancements in their systems. Leveraging data and connecting...

    Credit the people on this episode