Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Expert Insights

Expert Insights artwork

2024 Housing Market Outlook, Analysis, and Insights

Mar 12, 202428 minAudio

The housing market narrative for 2024 is shaping up to be part mystery, part thriller, part blockbuster. We know rates will come down, but when and how much? When rates do come down, what will be the biggest priorities and opportunities for lenders? And, what can lenders and loan officers do right now to help prepare for the next market shift? Total Expert Founder and CEO Joe Welu sat down with HousingWire CEO Clayton Collins to look at the data, analyze the trends, and discuss what the future holds for the industry.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello everyone, I'm Joel U. Thanks so much for tuning in to Expert Insights, where we talk with industry leaders across modern financial services to discuss leadership and innovation. Let's get started. Hey everyone. Uh welcome to the podcast. Excited today to have my good friend, the CEO of HousingWire, Mr. Clayton Collins, joining us. Clayton, how you doing, bud?

SPEAKER_00Joe, thrilled to be here, and thanks for having me back. We've gotten to do a few episodes together in the last couple years, and it's always fun.

SPEAKER_01It's always fun, man. You obviously have an incredible vantage point as the CEO of HousingWire for all things housing, such a major, important component of the U.S. economy, and certainly on a lot of people's minds as it relates to lending in the real estate community. Would love maybe an update on your outlook, what you're seeing in the data from your vantage point and what things are looking like as it relates to the housing market this year.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, appreciate the frame there. So the fun part about my job as CEO of Housing Wire is I'm not the journalist, I'm not the data analyst, but I get the chance to talk to some of the smartest analysts and economists and journalists and help build a business around these different information and knowledge points. So our mission and strategy at HousingWire is to deliver housing professionals with the full picture. And that's business journalism, it's data, it's research, it's different multimedia formats from podcasts to video and live events.

SPEAKER_00And our goal in this effort of providing the full picture is to make sure housing professionals and mortgage and real estate have the information that they need to make decisions and grow their businesses. One of the common threads that we've seen in the last few years, and this might sound very obvious, is that a lot of mortgage news focuses exclusively on the practice of lending or the practice of servicing and real estate as the same thing going on. But the thread that ties this together and the full picture really hinges around housing market data and housing market intelligence.

SPEAKER_00And it's really some of the trends that's happening in housing that drives origination volume and um and sales volume on the real estate side. So two years ago, or not even two years ago, barely a year and a half ago, we acquired Altos Research to start bringing in housing market data into our journalism and research. And that's helped us build out an entirely new skill set and understanding active market, real-time information that can drive action and intelligence for housing professionals. So we've been maniacal about tracking active market information.

SPEAKER_00And every single week and every single day, we're analyzing new listings, pending listings, how fast things are moving, where there's price increases, where there's price de price decreases. And these are the trends that actually give us a little bit of foresight into what's going to come ahead, Joe. So one of the trends that we've been watching, you know, kind of on the tip of our chairs, like just waiting to start to see data cooperate, is the total number of active listings in the US. And I'm really excited that after weeks and and months of that data line not really cooperating with us, we're starting to see a trend that is positive.

SPEAKER_00So for 18 weeks in a row, we've seen the number of active listings in the US start to inch up. And each of those little inches forward, each that little incremental add of active inventory, it adds up. So here we are entering March 2024, and we have active inventory in the US. It's 19% higher than 12 months ago.

SPEAKER_01Now, so why that's a meaningful amount of inventory. And if you're talking to any of the practitioners, the professionals out in the trenches, you realize that we have an inventory problem or have had an inventory problem. And I would say that's been for a lot of people, it's been a bigger issue than even rates. Even at current rates, there's more demand than there is supply, at least from a lot of the organizations we talk with.

SPEAKER_01And I is that your point of view as well?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Now, there's a few different we'll we'll talk about demand in a minute, but as we talk about supply, um, even at this elevated level, 19% higher than last year, historically, meh, like it's not great. Like when we rewind to before COVID and we kind of peaked out in you know inventory, at least in the in the last five or six year measure in August or so 2019, where we had about a million active listings in the US.

SPEAKER_00And today, even at 19% elevated over 12 months ago, we're still just shy of half a million. So we're at half the inventory level that that we'd like to see. Now, um, to square this data out, this is how we track active at Altos and Housing Wire. There's different data sources who choose a different methodology. So you might see from the National Association of Realtors a number reported that's closer to a million. It's just a different methodology. We only track the houses that are actually available to buy.

SPEAKER_00So things that are under contract or pending um aren't included in our methodology. We're just looking at active listings, the house that Joe, you can go call an agent and go do a walkthrough right now and put in an offer on, not the not the pendings, not the under contracts. So we look that's how that's how we look at it, just to kind of square out the data. So um historically, we if and if we go back even further, the housing market has really performed at its best. And we say at its best, it is a market. So we want to see a certain level of listings that transcribes or translates into a certain number of sales size and origination volume for mortgage, while also maintaining a modest amount of upward pressure on home prices.

SPEAKER_00And we found that level around a million active listings. So we'd love to see the housing market make a move back closer, climbing up from half a million to 600,000 to 700,000 and make its way back to a million. We think that'd be a very positive thing for the housing industry. At that level, what we would expect to happen is we'd start to see home price appreciation decline. Um, we would see a stabilization of home prices.

SPEAKER_01You think at a million listings, so if we double the inventory um and probably based on still elevated rates, we're gonna assume that prices would decline a little bit. What what would what would you expect?

SPEAKER_00The most common source of demand for housing comes from sellers. So home sellers are home buyers. They people don't sell their home and decide they're gonna become homeless. They don't decide there very few people sell and become renters unless they're at a point in life where they're moving to a major metropolitan area or making some emptiness decision. But it's just very uncommon for sellers to not become buyers again. So if we were to see, as we see inventory elevate, that helps create more comfort in homeowners to list their homes and be confident they're gonna be able to find the next home they're looking for.

SPEAKER_01I'm not gonna be home unless I can find a place to live, right? Exactly. And one of the things we've heard a lot about, and I would see if you agree with this, there's a whole lot of people in these houses out there that are absolutely just holding their breath, want to move, but just can't get out of that, you know, don't want to make that leap from a 3% interest rate or whatever they have. That's one part. And the other part is there's just not great options out there. At some point, at some point, the the life events, the natural, you know, people getting married, family creation, people dying, job transfers starts to take over.

SPEAKER_01Are we seeing some of that happening in the market, in your opinion, from kind of that pent up demand over the last couple years?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so we definitely are seeing like demand that's less than we'd expect to see right now. And that's driven by the two factors you just mentioned lack of confidence that people are going to be able to find the house they want, um, and find the house they want at the price they want. Uh anecdotally, in like the area that that we live in here here in Dallas, it's you know, it's pretty daunting to think about like the at the new prices where home prices are. Like take mortgage rates out of it for a minute. Home price elevated so much.

SPEAKER_00It's scary to think about taking that next step to add an extra bedroom or jump to a different school district. Um, it's become very expensive. So for people to make that decision, it often is one of the factors that you just mentioned, Joe, whether it's a new job, relocation, adding a kid to the family, death, disease, divorce, the things that prompt someone to have to have to move houses. And what we have in the market right now, what we believe is that not only will those things continue to be natural parts of the housing evolution and the reason homes list and get sold, but I believe we also have some pent-up demand from people who have been postponing those decisions over the last 24 months because home prices have moved so quickly.

SPEAKER_00So one of the biggest learnings we've had at HousingWire in the last two years is that consumer psychology is more impacted by fast change than it is the relative value. So consumers are more freaked out by home prices moving quickly or mortgage rates moving quickly in one direction or another than they are by the absolute value.

SPEAKER_01So in the actual rate being at 7% or whatever, the fact that we moved faster there than any time in recent history. Yeah, if I could write the book of the system. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00If this was like a fiction novel and I could write the book, yeah, I would pick a lower interest rate than where we are right now. But there actually can be health and stabilization to health and transactions to be found with stabilization. So if we were to see mortgage interest rates level out around 7% and just stay there, people would start to transact at a higher degree.

SPEAKER_01It becomes a reality at some points. Yeah. And the life events that really dictate a lot of these major purchases, these buying a home, selling a home, start to move the market uh slowly but surely, right?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And we talk about this, and and I think someone who's you know jumping in late to the conversation could be confused that we're saying the market is locked up right now. But it is, it is not. Like transactions are happening. So at Housing Wire, we the opportunity to work with and talk to loan origination leaders, but also real estate brokerage leaders. And in many parts of the country, as we enter the spring buying and selling season, we're back into an environment where many markets have multiple offers and homes are going for over-ask. So despite the high interest rate environment, we're seeing a market where there is a category of consumer who is willing to transact.

SPEAKER_00And that's hard information for a lot of people to hear. Like if I go through, if we do a Twitter live or post a video on YouTube, like there is a lot of people who have trouble believing in that a segment of the US population is experiencing the benefits of a strong economy. That it's not universal. It is not happening universal. But for a segment of the population, which in a world where there's only 500,000 active listings, we don't need everybody to be experiencing financial or career success.

SPEAKER_00You only need a couple million. And uh in a in a population where there's several hundred million working US families, it's a uh a small group of the population that can actually drive up home prices and drive transaction volume in the housing market. It's it's pretty it's pretty wild. It's not necessarily a good thing, but it is the dynamic of the market that we operate in.

SPEAKER_01So out of the different predictions that you're seeing uh on home price appreciation this year, kind of just broadly, I know it's very market specific. What what do you see happening, the balance of the year? What kind of a percent increase on average are we going to see in home prices this year in the current state?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So in the last 12 months, we just saw, I think it was the uh January or the December case Schiller numbers came out and had 5.5% home price appreciation as we as we look in the rearview mirror. And that was in a market that had the rapid change in interest rates, set several waves of interest rates coming down. Early about a year ago, we saw interest rates come back down to a five-handle for a hot minute and then shop back up. That movement is traditionally something that scares people out of the market, but still we saw a 5.5% increase in home prices in the last 12 months.

SPEAKER_00Um, I think that the next 12 month home price appreciation number will be highly influenced by what happens with mortgage rates, but we do not know what's going to happen with mortgage rates.

SPEAKER_01Um it's the billion dollar question, Clayton, that every smart person I've talked to, every economist I've talked to in the last probably 12 months, has for the most part predicted wrong. So who knows is the answer, right?

SPEAKER_00I mean, I just had a conversation uh on a podcast conversation with Brian Covey from Revolution Mortgage last week. And Brian and I were talking about he's wonderful. We were talking about interest rates, and um one of the trends we talked about, we call it like the kick the can down the road syndrome, is that we did predict, as an industry, the economists, the analysts, the forecasters predicted a interest rate environment in the second half of 2023. So, like, you know, looking back in the rearview mirror, six to nine months, that had a five handle on it.

SPEAKER_00There's many forecasts starting in the fives. Um, those forecasts got pushed to first half 2024. And now that we approach, you know, that we're in March of 2024, those forecasts have now been pushed back to the second half of 2024. So forecasts haven't changed a lot. The timing of when those forecasts have kept have kept moving out. Now, I don't share that to cast doubt on the analysts and economists who make those forecasts. I share that to bring real truth to the reality that forecasting interest rates is nearly an impossible game.

SPEAKER_00And while the interest rate absolute number might be easily forecasted, like yes, there will be a day where your clients at Total Expert and our clients and readers at Housing Wire are issuing 30-year fixed rate mortgages with a forehand on the front. That will happen. I do just not know what date it will happen on.

SPEAKER_01And uh we got a lot of people listening that hope you're right uh with that prediction at some point.

SPEAKER_00There's a couple of things that have to happen. So, like we we understand, I think most mortgage professionals understand why rates are in the have a seven handle right now. So we have a Federal Reserve who's still concerned about inflation and their messaging has been less than consistent. I don't mean that I don't want to imply that that's not strategic. I think there is a lot of strategy in the messaging that that they're giving us right now.

SPEAKER_01Um, I think Don't you think to that point, Clayton, don't you think it has really reaffirmed the importance of a trusted professional uh to help educate the consumer on actually reality versus the headlines? I mean, are are you seeing that with the leaders that you're talking with or really doubling down and leaning into this is an environment more than ever where you have to educate the public on their market and the reality of what's happening.

SPEAKER_01You agree?

SPEAKER_00It's an environment where having a trusted professional advise consumers through a home purchase or sale and home finances scenario is more important than ever. But that trusted advisor can't be a transactional relationship. And that's one of the biggest weaknesses in mortgage and real estate is the lack of follow-through on loan originators building long-term relationships with their consumers and home buyers, and home buyers having either confidence or loyalty to come back to those same real estate and mortgage professionals.

SPEAKER_00Now, I don't say that from like a, oh, it'd be great for loan originators if people were customers for life. I say that because we're entering an environment where the market moves quickly. Home prices move quickly, products change, pricing changes. So if you want to optimize your scenario, your financial outcome as a homeowner, you need someone who can see your situation over a multi-year, multi-cycle scenario. If you buy today at 7.1, there will be an opportunity to refinance, or home prices will shoot up and there will be an opportunity to leverage home equity or you know, some some other product category.

SPEAKER_00So like I believe, I strongly believe that this relationship has to change from transactional to advisory. So you can make different decisions over the course of your life in that home or your life as a homeowner in multiple properties.

SPEAKER_01I I feel that it's it's also one of these environments where you're you're seeing a clear separation in the industry, and probably both uh I see uh more day-to-day in the mortgage side and the real estate side, but they're so interconnected to where you're really seeing a separation uh of the professionals, the ones that really take this business seriously, uh spend a lot of time deeply understanding the interest rates and environment, the housing price environments for their market, understanding data and how it ties into that specific customer that they're working with.

SPEAKER_01I see that separating the ones uh the they're separating from the pack from the people that, you know, they do three or four deals a year and they do their cousins and their brothers. Like let's just ground on a lot of those people just have no business being in the industry, particularly in an environment like this where advice is pretty damn critical. Uh it's always critical, but I think it's even more critical when if you misstep something, you give somebody the wrong type of information and they make a decision that isn't best for their financial outcome, you just set yourself up for really not having a long-term relationship with that customer.

SPEAKER_00It's it's one of the awesome parts of housing is that in mortgage and real estate, the barrier to entry and like the bar to clear is relatively low. And it means that it brings a lot of opportunity to people who come from diverse backgrounds, different educational histories, different career paths. It's really cool how like so many people can enter the housing industry and sell houses or sell loans. The problem with that is exactly what you mentioned. Like, how bad do you feel for the person who used their uncle or their nephew for their like one of the biggest transactions of their life?

SPEAKER_00And that person only does two deals a year. It's just like working out, like reps.

SPEAKER_01And they overpaid, or they got, you know, they did a three-year loan or a five-year adjustable, and they should have done a 30, like all of those things that can impact the financial outcome for that consumer on the real estate purchase and and of course the loan side as well, to your point.

SPEAKER_00So as we see volume, a lot of pressure on volume and real estate and mortgage transaction volume. I think there will be there. I mean, there's not only to say I think there are fewer loan originators today than there were a year ago. That there's a test to that.

SPEAKER_01There are there are a lot, there are a lot fewer, I can tell you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's been a big washout of originators, um, which probably I mean you don't love as like users of your platform. It's there's pressure on that. And we don't love is we like to serve a big audience of housing professionals. But what we do love is that the profession is becoming more professional.

SPEAKER_01And it gets elevated. The quality, the quality, the benefit, the silver lining. And these I always think of these environments, and this has been really a head-on collision for our industry in the last 24 months to what's happened with rates and everything. But these environments, there's always equal parts sort of pain and equal parts opportunity. And the opportunity is the ability to really elevate the quality of the professional, and it almost is a survival of the fittest.

SPEAKER_01And the ones that get smarter get better every day are going to win, and the ones that don't are probably not going to be in the industry.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00I spend a lot of time as an entrepreneur thinking about how do I not make long-term decisions or short-term information and like remember and remind myself that we chose to operate in a cyclical industry, an industry that has seen ebbs and flows since the beginning of time. And it's these changes in volume where opportunity is revealed. And if we operate in an ecosystem where in 12 to 24 months we have fewer competitors or fewer loan originators or fewer real estate agents, and volume is back at a level that's similar to what we saw pre-COVID.

SPEAKER_00Now, I don't want to hang my hat on 2021 peak origination volume, but it will hang my hat on a level that's higher than today. That is an opportunity to consolidate market share. The best loan originators will be doing more loans per month than they were doing four or five years ago. And part of that That is fewer people fighting for uh like more consumers. And the other part of that is getting reps in in this hard market makes these LOs and real estate agents that much better. And that's where the pipe is.

SPEAKER_01It's just forced it. It just forced them to get better, right? I mean, we see the engagement with the tools. I talked to other technology CEOs, and they're seeing the same things. Like people are leaning in more to technology, not because they want to spend time playing with technology, but because the environment has forced them to level up to your point. So those are some of the good things.

SPEAKER_00It's forced them to understand tech and play with tech. It's also forced them to understand the housing data that shakes consumer knowledge and sentiment. And so, like, it's really like if you were to look at, you know, the the uninitiated journalist view on home price cuts. So far in 2024, we've seen 30 and a half percent of home prices be reduced. Somebody who doesn't understand the industry can say, ooh, that smells like a bad thing. We actually like to see markets where that number is about 40%.

SPEAKER_01And so it's like 40 to 50 percent because people overprice properties all the time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, if there's no home price reduction, then that means agents are scared and they're underpricing and pulling value away from their consumers. The more reductions there are, that means there's some gusto in the agents and brokers as they price properties and they're saying, hey, I actually do have some demand for this. I think I can drive a really good outcome for you, Mr. Home Seller, Mrs. Home Buyer. Like that is like that's a healthy thing. So being the loan originator that can explain what's happening in the data to the home buyer and also be a source of knowledge and intelligence for the agent partner that you hopefully have a strong referral relationship with.

SPEAKER_00Super powerful toolkit.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, man. Well, Clayton, I deeply appreciate uh your point of view and perspective on what we're seeing in the markets, the environment, uh, all of the data points you make are just really valuable information for the audience. Um, I would love to just hear from you really quickly. I'm I'm super excited. You guys are putting together what is turning out to be a pretty epic event here coming up uh for the housing industry, and maybe share some detail uh with our audience on the gathering and what it's all about and why people should attend.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you for asking me about the gathering. So I'll uh a little bit of backstory because everyone loves the history, right? So the story is at Housing Wire, we're trying to provide the full picture. Three years ago, we bought Real Trends, a leading publication and data provider for the real estate brokerage team and agent ecosystem. Real trends have been putting on an event for 30 years for the top real estate brokers in the country. This year, in 2024, we are merging the Real Trends event with Housing Wire Annual, our Housing Finance event, into one singular event, our single Housing Wire tent pull event called the Gathering.

SPEAKER_00So we are bringing together the leaders of real estate brokerage and the leaders of the mortgage industry into one event and one venue. The reason we are doing that is because the biggest, most popular topic at the real trends event for the last five to 10 years has been core services and home financing. Mortgage is the top topic that people want to, real estate brokers want to talk about. And then we have this whole ecosystem of mortgage professionals who keep telling us we want to meet all these real estate agents and brokers that are also part of the housing wire ecosystem.

SPEAKER_00So we're bringing everybody together in the words, in Joe's words, this will be fertile hunting ground for both sides to develop business opportunities. So we think it's a strong opportunity for people to learn from each other, network, and hopefully walk away with some ideas and commercial opportunities to build out these purchase by bonds that we know are gonna be incredibly important as we look at the next few years in the mortgage industry.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, let's let's uh obviously realize that purchase transactions for so many of the lenders is is the key to long-term business, right? And uh if you're if you're in the lending game and you want the opportunity to have some um networking opportunities with the who's who of the real estate world, brokerage world, and strategize and brainstorm on ideas on on how to come together and uh and do business. Uh this is a great event. Uh I'm totally impressed with what you guys and the Housing Wire team are doing.

SPEAKER_01So um, I'm looking forward to coming and so hopefully April 21st uh through 24th.

SPEAKER_00It's a uh three and a half day event, Scottsdale, Arizona, awesome venue at the Camelback In. Um, and one of my favorite parts is like just how much bringing a lot of like power and influence to the stage. There's also a lot of power and influence in the audience. So people are coming, like, and I I'm going to a media event in a few weeks. And um, I I just said, heck no, I'm not speaking, I'm not moderating. I want to be there in the audience and like do deals and talk to you. You want to learn and you want to learn, right? I'm just pumped seeing like how many executives we don't usually see kind of sitting in like the general session room that are that are signed up and and there to like go listen, learn.

SPEAKER_00Maybe they're recruiting, maybe they're working on deals, maybe they're working on JVs, I don't know. But the they are going and uh it's gonna be a different feel than I think we've seen at our past events, and I think most mortgage and real estate leaders have seen at other events that they've frequented for years.

SPEAKER_01Well, we're excited about it. My team's excited about it, and looking forward to the gathering in April. And uh to wrap up the conversation, Clayton, thank you so much for sharing your point of view and um congrats on all the amazing work Housing Wire is doing and uh keep it up. We're we're huge fans.

SPEAKER_00Joe, thank you. Huge fan of you in the business you're building, a total expert. And thank you for being a you know a fellow executive peer. We can share with each other not just housing market and industry information, but also you know, the trials and tribulations and opportunities of building a business and in this pretty amazing industry.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's always fun, bud. All right, Clayton. Thanks again, bud. Take care. Thanks so much for joining us today. Be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Leading from the Front: AI and the Future of Lending with Steve Majerus

    Nov 20, 202631 minAudio

    American Pacific Mortgage is on track for $15B in production volume this year. What does it take to lead an organization of this size through the biggest technology shift in history in the most challenging market in a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Shant Banosian: Building a Business Without Limits and Reimagining What's Possible in the AI Age

    Nov 5, 202656 minAudio

    Ever wondered how one loan officer can build a billion-dollar business? In this episode of the 10x Lender Series, Total Expert Founder & CEO, Joe Welu, sits down with Shant Banosian of Rate to pull back the curtain on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Respecting Transactions by Humanizing the Homebuying Journey

    Aug 6, 202434 minAudio

    At the core of Prosperity Home Mortgage, they are hyper-focused on communication, which includes everyone in the homebuying process. That includes the real estate agent, the lender, and the borrower. For President and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Incubating AI Specifically Designed for the Mortgage Industry

    Jul 16, 202426 minAudio

    The technology conversation of GenAI has moved so fast since OpenAI and Chat GPT burst into the public eye. But are businesses just buying into the hype of AI, and does it really benefit their goals and needs? For...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Activating Data the Right Way for a Targeted Purpose

    Jun 11, 202428 minAudio

    The technology buzzwords for the last few years have been AI analytics, data analytics, and automation, but businesses are still unsure how to leverage those advancements in their systems. Leveraging data and connecting...

    Credit the people on this episode