There are a lot of changes in the housing industry right now, and with all the layoffs and right-sizing going on, it’s easy to feel like the industry is going through a downturn. But reframe that and think about it as an evolutionary process. In this episode, Joe Welu and industry leader Clayton Collins discuss how the current adjustments are pushing mediocre players out and concentrating the market share to the top players, and how this will ultimately result in better service for the end customer. This is a sensitive topic to talk about as a lot of us know someone who has been affected by these cost structure adjustments. But in reality, lending and real estate companies who were quick to right-size their workforces will find themselves in a better position as the market comes back up. Tune in and learn what’s separating the wheat from the chaff and what essential elements you need to have to be included among the top players in the industry and ultimately the winners of this evolutionary process.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello everyone, I'm Joe Well U. Thanks so much for tuning in to Expert Insights, where we talk with industry leaders across modern financial services to discuss leadership and innovation. Let's get started. Hey everyone, excited to introduce today's guest, Mr. Clayton Collins. Clayton is the founder and CEO of HW Media, the parent company of real estate media and data brands, HousingWire, Real Trends, Reverse Mortgage Daily, and Altos Research.
SPEAKER_00Clayton formed HW Media in 2016 to acquire HousingWire and has grown the company to be the premier information resource for mortgage and real estate professionals across the real estate economy, reaching over 500,000 professionals each month. Clayton also serves on the board of directors for SLM, a real estate agent onboarding and technology support business. He is also a member of the President's Young Leaders Council for Elon University and a member of Young Presidents Organization.
SPEAKER_00Please welcome Clayton Collins. Hey Clayton, good to be with you, man. It's been a while. It's good to have you on the show. And how's life?
SPEAKER_01Joe, it's wonderful to see you. Life is good. Been busy working through this evolution of the housing industry that we're gonna talk about today. Just got back from a trip to Portland where I had the chance to spend some time with some awesome real estate brokers and get some perspective from that side of the market and gearing up to go to NBA Tech right now. I am excited to be face to face with so many lending and real estate brokerage leaders as we kick off what we hope to be a spring home buying and selling season that treats all the mortgage and real estate world well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no question. You have such a unique perspective because you guys are immersed so much in not just the real estate community, but the lending community and then the technology community and how all of those things weave together. And before we got on air, we talked a little bit about all of the changes that are going on out there and how companies and brands practitioners are adjusting. And I want to talk about the evolution of the industry because that's really the best way to describe what's taken place. So let's maybe start there and give me your high-level thoughts.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So, Joe, I think when people talk about what's happening in housing right now, it's really easy to focus on some of the negative things, like the negative or the increase in interest rates, which has resulted a drop-off in refi and a drop-off in purchase and lack of inventory. But what's ultimately going on here, kind of behind a confluence of challenging dynamics, is an evolutionary process where the housing industry has an opportunity and honestly a responsibility to make itself better and build more efficient operations.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, I don't exactly know what the impact of this will be, but we're seeing such a flight to quality. When I talk about flight to quality, I don't just mean a flight to the most efficient lenders. I mean a flight to the best loan originators. We're seeing volume start to consolidate to the top players. This is your phrase, man, but like mediocrity is not being rewarded. It gets punished. Mediocrity gets punished, man. Mediocrity gets punished. And the same thing's happening in real estate brokerage. We're we just dropped our real trends, rankings of the top agents, teams, and brokerages in the country.
SPEAKER_01And guess what? The volume continues to consolidate and concentrate with the top performers. And I don't know that's a tough thing if you're a mediocre agent of loan originator or a part-timer on the real estate side, but it's a good thing if you're a consumer because when volume starts to concentrate, the best get better. I saw a great line a few weeks ago is nobody needs advice from a part-timer. And that's something homeowners should take into account as they're thinking about who they work with from a loan origination or real estate sales perspective.
SPEAKER_00That's such a great statement. And if you think about how many people that were really in, for lack of a better way to phrase it, dabbling in the industry, right? They were looking to make easy money. And what you're describing to me is ultimately those people are not going to be relevant anymore. And we're seeing it show up in the data. Drill into that a little bit for me. And from your seat, which I think you have such a depth in perspective, what is the difference between these people where the volume is consolidating on across the industry in both sectors or in both segments and from the real estate side and the lending side?
SPEAKER_00What do you see?
SPEAKER_01Ultimately, it's been a good thing that the real estate industry and the loan origination industry have a relatively low bar to enter. It means that people from a diverse array of backgrounds can enter the housing industry in some capacity. They don't have to go to college. They don't have to go to an Ivy League school. They don't have to go through some long training program or medical residency or graduate degree program. You can come from different walks of life and different backgrounds. And one of the reasons that is really important is because the American homeowner comes from many walks of life and many different diverse backgrounds.
SPEAKER_01So when you create high bars to enter a profession, you end up with a much more homogenous category of worker. So the housing industry, by not having this extremely high bar, allows people from all walks of life to enter. Now, the challenge is do you stay once you're in the industry? And if you stay, it doesn't necessarily depend on the fact of like where your education is from. It depends on like what you give it. And like, do you dabble or do you commit? So we're going through this cycle right now. National Association of Realtors is projecting a pretty big drop-off in membership from 2022 to 2023.
SPEAKER_01We're seeing projections that loan originator headcount is going to go down to a degree in 2023. And is that necessarily a bad thing? No, it's pushing out the dabblers, it's rewarding the people who've committed to building careers as housing professionals. And those are the people who can provide the best advice to homeowners. Those are the people that work well with their counterparts. It still blows my mind how many realtors don't think highly of loan originators and vice versa. It's because it's so true, right? Their vision is anchored in a dabbler or a part-timer.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Like working with a realtor who's like working 10 hours a week is not going to be a good experience for an LO. And working for a realtor who's working with an LO who's built his or her whole pipeline on refi, or like isn't like a fully committed professional, that's going to be a bad experience too. So as we go through this kind of like cleansing period and really reward the people who are committed to building careers in the housing industry, we're going to create better working relationships across the industry. We're going to reward the originators who are doing the volume to have the resources to invest in technology.
SPEAKER_01And the people that are left in the industry on that side will be closer to their highest and best use. And I think their highest and best use, if you're a tip of the spear person in the housing industry, working with consumers, is working with consumers and building relationships and giving advice, not inputting data a dozen times, not like repeating processes or spending all your time on paperwork. It is working with consumers and giving advice.
SPEAKER_00And the technology should, from our perspective, of course, should enable them to do more of that, right? And it sounds like you believe the same thing.
SPEAKER_01Oh, 100%. I've never believed the rhetoric that technology is going to replace the loan originator, replace the real estate agent. It's going to help them for like be their highest and best and be like better advisors and sellers on behalf of their clients. Now, I think technology can replace some of the checker checking checkers jobs in the operation side of the housing industry. And, you know, that's tough to see. Like we hate to see the reduction in forces and the headcount reductions that we've seen recently, but ultimately that might help those people get to their highest and best use too and figure out where their intellect and skills can really be rewarded.
SPEAKER_00And the environment that we have recently, the environment where we came from in 2020, 2021 was so exuberant that it wasn't a necessity to have those efficiencies, to have those businesses optimized. And it feels like a lot like organizations are being forced that direction right now. And the ones that are making the choices to optimize workflow, optimize for performance, they're being rewarded. You agree?
SPEAKER_01So I had a really senior mortgage bank CEO on my housing news podcast back in, I think it was a Q2. So about a year ago. And this is an organization where like some other industry participants are criticized for being really refi heavy in a time period when the industry was shifting to entire focus on purchase. And one of the comments really stuck with me that was shared is that if we hadn't pivoted to refi and other lenders hadn't pivoted to refi, millions of American homeowners would be sitting in mortgages at rates significantly above market.
SPEAKER_01And because of the mortgage industry's ability to quickly pivot to serve consumers to refinance their loans at 2.75, 3%, 3.5%, the American consumer and the American economy was served well. And I think there's some power in that statement. But to fulfill that statement, it required throwing human capital into the ecosystem. To the quick pivot to ramp up technology to handle refi volume when that opportunity presented itself would have left money on the table for the mortgage originators and would have left consumers on the sidelines that weren't able to be served.
SPEAKER_01Because it takes time to improve processes and implement technology. Now, Joe, the question is now, the last six months, as lenders have had more time, have they invested in technology and have they helped start to build more elastic and efficient lending ecosystems that can scale as volume ebbs and flow and as interest rates move?
SPEAKER_00So I want to talk a little bit about the elastic, sustainable business models that we believe you have to get to right now, right? And are you seeing the organizations making the investments from the conversations you're having?
SPEAKER_01Kind of going back to the same talking points we see with loan originators and real estate agents, there's a bifurcation. And the bifurcation is sits with the resources in the organization. Did lenders preserve cash on their balance sheet in 2022? Did they access the public markets, which gives them some public market pressure, but also access to relatively access to capital, just leave it there, access to capital to invest in their business. Or do they distribute all their cash or pay ridiculous sign-on bonuses at the wrong time?
SPEAKER_01Like there's a bifurcation in resources. And the lenders on the right side of bifurcation who came into the second half of 2022 with cash in the balance sheet and weren't afraid. I mean, this is this is the callous side, but like I think the lenders who weren't afraid to act quickly and right size their workforces are in a significantly better position today. And those are the lenders that, even though they right size certain roles, improved their resources and their ability to invest in technology. So, Joe, I see a clear bifurcation.
SPEAKER_01There are still lenders that are sitting on the sidelines unable to invest because they don't have the cash and their cost structure is not in the right place. And those are the lenders who are losing market share right now and are likely going to be consolidated in in some form or fashion, or they just keep their head in the sand and like keep costs low until the market returns. But that will be a time when their competition is so far ahead because they've been investing in technology for two years, while like the guys who didn't have cash, didn't have the balance sheet, didn't have the access to credit, sat on the sidelines.
SPEAKER_01So bifurcation.
SPEAKER_00So it's almost like a slow death for the half or the quarter or whatever the industry that didn't take action quickly, right size of the business, didn't or is not making the investments for whatever reason, whether they hang on for a bit or not. I think your statement on the people that have, as the industry volumes come back to more normal levels, they're going to just be so far ahead with data and technology that they're just going to continue to take market share. I mean, that's been my observation.
SPEAKER_00You're selling enterprise technology. So what do you see? Yeah, I see the same thing. I've been on site with a lot of customers, and it's there's really two camps, right? You have the camp where they are, I would say, in some cases, kind of paralyzed by fear, or they're paralyzed by inability to take action because of ownership structure or executive teams. The companies that cut early in the cycle, right-size their cost structure as much as they could early in the cycle, that have gotten to within striking distance of profitability.
SPEAKER_00Those organizations right now, we're just seeing great momentum in those organizations and in their ability to be strategic and identifying deal flow, identifying new referral opportunities, identifying ways to optimize their middle performers and get them up, sort of all of the above. It just seems to be the ones that were taking action early are now you're just seeing them starting to make progress in a lot of ways.
SPEAKER_01Isn't that such a phenomenal like entrepreneurial like or operator case study? In that it is.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, remember, and everybody was like, a lot of those people, they wait a second, you guys made so much money and now you're laying people off. Yeah, that's not fun to do. But you gotta hand it to them at this point. It looks like they were really thinking long term. And they're like, wait, if I don't do this, the health of my company, my ability to serve consumers is going to be in jeopardy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's such a tough topic to talk about, Joe, because I know when you publish this episode, and I know when I publish our housing news episodes, there's someone listening that's been impacted by a reduction in force. And I think it's really important to talk about this topic with like humility and knowing that like there are people at all levels, from the most junior to very senior roles that have been negatively impacted here. And you and I sit here from a really fortunate position, both leading our organizations and still employed and still propelling in the right direction.
SPEAKER_01I know there's people who aren't like, you know, aren't as fortunate as where you and I sit right now, but there's the whole lens of looking at this through like the entrepreneur and like business operator perspective. And exactly like you just said, those leaders who acted swiftly and made smart decisions for their organizations last summer are in a better position today. And ultimately, that creates a better company for the people that are still part of it. And those companies will hire again. They will grow again. Hopefully they do it more efficiently and more focused and in the right roles and people that can implement technology and build more efficient, sustainable ecosystems.
SPEAKER_01It's just two very different lenses, but it's like neither is wrong. But like they're it's just two things you have to think about.
SPEAKER_00These environments, as you see layoffs, I mean, it's never lost on any of us that lead organizations that when those things happen, like you're really impacting people's lives. And it's the last thing anybody wants to do for the most part, right? The leaders that I talk to that have been through those significant things, like you can tell it's heavy. They wear that on their shoulders in a lot of cases, right? And so, but at the end of the day, it's about the long term. And I think that's you know, we've clearly identified some of what we're seeing out there.
SPEAKER_01Joe, I think it like another thing that's really worth paying attention to it's not just capital and cash that is differentiating players in the industry, it's also mindset. I think that the players with the right mindset, all the way from the C-suite to the originator to the broker, like across the organization, that like facing tough markets with the right mindset that there's market share to be had. And this is when companies differentiate themselves, and this is when professionals differentiate themselves, is so important. And running a news org, it's like we cover like the good and the bad.
SPEAKER_01And there's been some bad headlines.
SPEAKER_00You do, by the way. Sometimes I'm like Clayton, like you might get some nasty grams from that post or that piece that you did, but you cover all of it. So you can't pick and choose, right?
SPEAKER_01How much worse this industry would be if everyone stuck their head in the sand and didn't ignore like some of the negative economic news or challenging industry news. Like, I mean, like, yeah, you get the nasty grams, but I like strongly believe that we're playing a role in moving the housing market forward. Our mission is moving markets forward and arming people with information to make better decisions. So, like, yeah, I do like to think that last summer, when we were pointing at some of the inventory challenges and the rate challenges, we were sighted in a board deck when people are talking about their strategy for the next six months and we helped our audience make better decisions.
SPEAKER_01But that's not really the vein I was going down. Like the vein that I was focused on is how do you take information and use it to motivate your team and keep people in the right mindset and actually talk about the challenging market so people don't just fall in like the USA Today headlines and think the world is crashing and don't have the context that we do as market professionals.
SPEAKER_00Contest. Okay, let's talk about that. And I think context, in my opinion, if you can get context, that will help inform your mindset. And we both agree strongly, and we see this in addition to the other trends we talk about. The difference between the half or the top quarter that's really winning right now is they've got that growth mindset. They're driving that into their organizations and they're saying, I know things are on fire, they're burning, but there's opportunity, and there's really big opportunity on the backside of this. But talk to me about you guys put out so much education-centric content for lack of a better word, that provides context.
SPEAKER_00How important do you believe it is that context layer is for professionals and companies to translate that down to the consumer?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, so our strategy is to provide information and news and data and research for the housing professional. Now, we don't write it through the lens of like, hey, copy and paste this, screenshot it, share it with the consumer. Some of our folks do that. We love and appreciate it, but we want to give the professional context so they can flip it into the story that their consumer needs to hear. I just got back from the thousand watt turn-on conference in Portland, and the thousand watt team is really creative. They prepared a video that was from the vantage point of a consumer.
SPEAKER_01Like the video said, I am not a lead, I am not a contact, I don't know what HMDA is. Like, don't talk to me about amortization.
SPEAKER_00I'm a human, I'm unique. I have a financial world that's unique to me, right? And I'm guessing that's what I'm saying.
SPEAKER_01The most important person is me. I'm buying a house. I'm gonna live in it. There's another speaker who talked about less facts, more feel, and talking about how content makes people feel. So, like, I'd see our vantage point as like housing wire, real trends. Like, we're gonna give you the facts. Now it's your job to turn that into a message that helps your consumer feel and feel about what the decisions they're gonna make in their housing journey. So they need to humanize it. Yeah. And I know like one of your recent guests on this show talked a lot about education and how he, as a top originator in the country, leverages information and knowledge to educate not only his originators and team, but like the real estate agents and consumers that do business with them.
SPEAKER_01And I know this gentleman well, and like he's a master at like bringing feeling and context to the information.
SPEAKER_00So master. And the gentleman we're talking about, Sean Benozian, who's on a recent episode, and he's world-class at that. And his phrase on the show was education attracts, right? And we were talking about marketing and growing the business, and he really made it clear. And I'm like, there's a reason. Obviously, he's led the best in the country, and you can clearly see that, but it just resonates. And I think there's a lot of people can learn from those types of statements and how they approach the industry.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and bringing it back to the beginning where we kind of talk about a consolidation of market share to the full-timers, not the people who dabble. Like, Sean lives this industry. He is a housing professional. So it's a big part of his identity. And I see that across top performers across this industry. I consider myself a housing professional. I there is no like personal Clayton and housing Clayton. Like I am, like, this is me. I think there's a lot of people in this industry who've dedicated themselves to housing, to selling houses, to financing houses, to participating in some way.
SPEAKER_01And I think that those people embrace that message that shared that education attracts. And you have to know this industry inside and out to understand how like each economic move is going to impact your clients and how it's gonna make your clients feel. We've recently seen so many headlines. Like I heard someone joke recently, like I missed the days when the Fed chair's name wasn't on the tip of my tongue. Like 90% of the country should not know who Jerome Powell is. But right now, a lot of people do.
SPEAKER_00He's like one of the most famous people in the country right now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like he's got memes, he's got like he's J Pal to a lot of people. Like that should not exist. Like, we should not know who the Fed chair is. Like, maybe you and I, Joe, but like 99% of the country should not know who Jerome Powell is. And that is a and we definitely shouldn't tell our consumers about J Pal. We shouldn't be telling consumers about a 25% rate increase because it does not mean a 25% mortgage rate increase, which we all know. Everyone Listens to this show understands the difference between the Fed funds rate and mortgage rates.
SPEAKER_00But the average consumer doesn't. I mean, they shouldn't have to. In our company, when you see a 25 basis point increase from the Fed, they automatically assume that their mortgage rates are going to go up, right? And so I think to your points earlier, Manny, you really have to get the context and connect at a human level with people to help them understand.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I saw a real estate agent post on Instagram yesterday that her consumers should have locked over the weekend because rates just went up 25%. And I'm like, ooh, like, okay, not my job to correct you, but like a dabbler just messed somebody up.
SPEAKER_00Give me your perspective on the amount of consolidation that you're seeing in the originator side and the real estate side. If you have data you're willing to share or a thesis. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So we published an article with a source from a couple of investment banks that IMB consolidation could range like 30 to 40% in 2023. But this was a couple of months ago. I think that thesis was a little bit flawed, the assumption that consolidation would be the result of mergers and acquisitions. And as fast as this market changed, the definition of consolidation and real estate brokerage and mortgage origination has changed. There's a term that's being used really regularly in real estate right now. They're called walkover acquisitions, where you're consolidating two local independents or an independent in the franchise, and no one's getting paid.
SPEAKER_01You're just getting a new home. And like in the tech world, we call it an accu hire or a rescue, but that's happening in real estate, and that seems to be the trend that's happening in mortgage. I recently got a behind the scenes look at an IMB acquisition and headline might look okay. Reality is all the comp is deferred in contingent. And the retention agreements and agreements that LOs have to sign to come over are hairy and not pretty. So some of the MA that gets announced isn't really what it looks like.
SPEAKER_00The packaging around it doesn't tell the full story in many cases. Yep.
SPEAKER_01So I think there might be a few more good deals to be had, but there will be a lot of consolidation that is a result of failed shops and kind of acquiring over the origination of talent and bringing that volume into a lender who prepared their balance sheet in 2022 to muscle through the hard times. Then there's the consolidation through recruitment. And there are some fierce recruiters out there who are pinning down their competitors through recruiting efforts. And I think a lot of the consolidation will be the result of the strongest players out competing their competition.
SPEAKER_00The one thing I would mention that I see, and I'm curious as to your feedback. We do see people hyper-aggressive on recruiting. And some of them are successful at retaining those folks. But it's like there was a gap. They got really masterful at the recruiting process and not really masterful at onboarding, wrapping their arms around those people, making them successful once they moved over. And we're seeing really a bifurcation there in some cases. And you're starting to see some of those people go back the other direction. Do you hear things about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. A lot of it comes back to the theme of technology. So some of the consolidated companies are lenders who had not invested in technology and they're coming into organizations that had, and you have originators who aren't tech native or tech-centric, suddenly being asked to change their processes and use new tools they've never used before. And the learning curve is steep. So like you look at this as a top-performing origination shop, and you're like, wait, this guy doesn't know how to use our LOS, or this gal won't use our point of sale, or she's still using like her own like CRM and like, come on, come into the fold.
SPEAKER_01We know how to do this. I think in a market where there's so much pressure on volume and divide between someone who's a cost center and a profit center is pretty thin divide, makes some of those recruiting conversations challenging. But one like kind of reassuring thing I have seen in recruiting is I think some recruiters and origination shops are getting better at knowing who they are and who they work for. There's a few shops I've seen out there who said, hey, we are the home for like kind of the later career originator who wants to like dabble and push a few loans through once a month.
SPEAKER_00That's okay. At least they're being honest.
SPEAKER_01We do. We're good at that. Like, come hang your license with us. There's other shops who have more aggressive sales cultures and mediocrity will be punished. And as long as you know that going in, I think that's a good thing. There needs to be a home for originators who have different aspirations and different goals and different styles. The scary part is when people aren't honest with themselves about their organization or their own skill set and join a company that has entirely different culture than they've spent their career building.
SPEAKER_00That's such a great point. And we see that all the time. People, A, they're not honest with themselves on their ability to change and evolve. And we talked at the beginning of the episode, this is an environment of really rapid change and evolution. And they're not being honest with themselves on, like, hey, am I willing to do the work to become type of professional that I've never been before? And then ultimately, there's a lot of scenarios where they don't maybe examine the company they're at and say, is what they're doing, the investments they're making, does that match what I want to do with my career?
SPEAKER_00Right. Does it line up? Well, Clayton, I really appreciate your perspective and the unique position you have in the industry. Thanks so much for the time today.
SPEAKER_01Joe, thank you so much. I love the direction the conversation went and talking about how education attracts is a big part of our mission here. And always encourage loan originators to check out our lending life newsletter. You can find it easily on Housing Wire, which we curate specifically for loan originators. And but Joe, we hope you and the Total Expert team and everyone who listens will join us at Housing Wire Annual in October. We're doing a lot of effort to bring together the mortgage and real estate ecosystem under one roof. It's a big part of why I founded HW Media is to look at the housing sector in totality and help build relationships across this really important sector.
SPEAKER_01So Housing Wire Annual in October.
SPEAKER_00Housing Wire Annual in October. And I want to make one more point on the fact that you guys are bringing lenders and real estate practitioners together in the same environment. Don't you think there's just tremendous unrealized opportunity for lenders and the real estate side to work better together to serve the end customer?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And I think as we keep coming back to that theme of consolidating the volume around the top performers, that will become more and more obvious. It's really shocked me how differently real estate and mortgage professionals think. They run at different paces and they kind of see themselves as part of different communities and different ecosystems. And I have the thesis that I'm making big bets on that these two sectors are going to realize how much they mean to each other and how much the relationships can be improved by coming together under one roof, even if that's just once a year.
SPEAKER_01But we want to be a factor for change in that arena.
SPEAKER_00I think that's fantastic. And ultimately, the best part about it is the end consumer generally is going to have a better outcome if those two sides of the transaction are in sync. So 100%. Thanks so much, Clayton. We'll see you soon. Thanks so much for joining us today. Be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
American Pacific Mortgage is on track for $15B in production volume this year. What does it take to lead an organization of this size through the biggest technology shift in history in the most challenging market in a...
Ever wondered how one loan officer can build a billion-dollar business? In this episode of the 10x Lender Series, Total Expert Founder & CEO, Joe Welu, sits down with Shant Banosian of Rate to pull back the curtain on...
At the core of Prosperity Home Mortgage, they are hyper-focused on communication, which includes everyone in the homebuying process. That includes the real estate agent, the lender, and the borrower. For President and...
The technology conversation of GenAI has moved so fast since OpenAI and Chat GPT burst into the public eye. But are businesses just buying into the hype of AI, and does it really benefit their goals and needs? For...
The technology buzzwords for the last few years have been AI analytics, data analytics, and automation, but businesses are still unsure how to leverage those advancements in their systems. Leveraging data and connecting...