It’s a star-studded episode of the Expert Insights podcast as Total Expert Founder & CEO Joe Welu is joined by our in-house industry experts, Chief Lending Officer Dan Catinella and General Manager of Banking James White, to talk about the huge news around interest rates. Join us as they discuss what the Federal Reserve announced, how it will impact the financial markets, and what risks and opportunities this will present for modern lenders, banks, and credit unions in 2024.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, everyone. I'm Joe LU. Thanks so much for tuning in to Expert Insights, where we talk with industry leaders across modern financial services to discuss leadership and innovation. Let's get started. Hello, everyone. Welcome to the podcast. Uh, joined here with my two great colleagues, Mr. James White, our GM and uh resident banking and credit union expert. How are you doing, James? And Mr. Dan Catanella, our chief lending officer. So, gentlemen, want to talk about the risks and also the opportunities that are out there right now for banks, lenders, credit unions, uh as it relates to the move in interest rates and kind of what's happening.
SPEAKER_01And I want to start maybe on the risk side of the equation. I guess in every risk, there's also an angle that can be an opportunity for some. But I want to talk about this thing called EPOs or early payoff and educate the audience on what it is, why it matters, and why that risk is something to think about as it relates to moving rates.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I mean early payoffs are certainly well known by lenders. Um, and it always introduces a level of risk when you, especially when you have a rate movement as quickly as we've seen over the last you know six to eight weeks. You know, we basically, you know, downward trend over 125 basis points in rate in a you know a very short period of time. And ultimately the risk that that introduces is somebody to ultimately engage your customer that you just funded a transaction with in the last six months kind of seasoning period.
SPEAKER_00Um, and they go down the street and refinance with one of your competitors, runs off your servicing portfolio that you sold that transaction to, and ultimately the lender gets hit with a pretty hefty penalty. Um, so it's critically important that you So not let me just let me just ground on this.
SPEAKER_01So not only do you lose a customer, but you also get penalized for losing that customer.
SPEAKER_00That's correct. Yes, like the double, they'll call it double whammy.
SPEAKER_01That's the double whammy, man. Like, you know, I hadn't really spent a lot of time thinking, of course, I know what it is, but I hadn't spent a lot of time thinking about it until you know some of the CEOs that I've talked with over the last week have described, I'm like, what's keeping you up at night? And and they're kind of like, well, if rates go to 575, um, this is keeping me up at night, this early payoff thing, what you just described. So A, I lose a customer, B, I get essentially penalized with with pretty significant penalties, like 3% in some cases, right?
SPEAKER_02Yep. Yeah, it can add up millions.
SPEAKER_01Millions. And so coming on the heels of a of an environment which has been challenging for uh anybody in the lending world, this really matters. And so, James, give me your lens on maybe from a banking and credit union standpoint, um, do they consider early payoffs a risk in the same way the independents do? Kind of why or why not? And maybe why does it matter to them as well?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so uh early payoffs is really about uh how the mortgage uh side of the business handles uh themselves, if they're selling to you know Fannie and Freddie and you know some of the the others, uh the organization is definitely going to get hit to by EPOs. Whether they send that downstream to the LOs or not is according to the organization. But even if they aren't uh worried about early payoffs, maybe like credit unions as an example, uh oftentimes have a mortgage option where you can do a rate change a couple of times during the term, uh, they still need to be managing uh these rate changes because uh one, it's a time that you can engage with your customer or member and show and build loyalty that you're watching it for them.
SPEAKER_02Uh two, your customers oftentimes or members don't remember or recognize that they have that option and they are getting hammered by uh CD shops and things that are buying these lists of recent closed mortgages or recent lock, you know, uh rates.
SPEAKER_01So let's let's let's talk about this for a moment because I don't know that a lot of people realize this, but you have a lot of consumer direct lenders that somehow it's it's still legal that uh these organizations, whether they did a deal with this particular customer or not, uh they can purchase lists, target lists of people that have done a particular type of loan in the last six months, 12 months. Is that that's what you're saying, right?
SPEAKER_02That's exactly what I'm saying.
SPEAKER_01And and so as a banker, a lender, credit union, if I don't think about this, whether I care about the penalty or not, which of course you do if you're gonna get penalized, whether I care about that or not, it's actually important from a uh awareness standpoint and how I need to be communicating with my customer because you really don't want, um, I don't want to lose the customer, but I really don't want somebody else calling my customer and saying, um, oh, hey, by the way, did you know interest rates are a point 1.25% better than they were when you did your loan at 8%.
SPEAKER_01You don't really want somebody else doing that. You should be doing it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. Well, and especially if you're a community banker or a credit union, it's your responsibility to keep your customers and members financially healthy, and you don't know what other kind of hidden fees and other things that are gonna be there. Uh you can obvious uh oftentimes refi them, you know, at no cost to them, you know. Uh, and so uh, and perhaps even do some other debt consolidation, whatever you need to to do to help them. Uh and so uh you can't turn a blind eye to you know these rate changes.
SPEAKER_02Obviously, it's gonna increase your your new uh borrower volume, but it's not just that, it it's the the recent borrowers as well.
SPEAKER_00If you don't engage your customer, somebody else will.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, yeah. That's so true. So if you think about on the risk side of the equation, uh, and I look at this one as this early payoff scenario that matters, particularly when we have big swings in rates like we have. Um, it also really is an opportunity uh as well, an opportunity for you to kind of prove to your customer that you're on top of their, you know, their financial picture as it relates to the products and services your organization uh sells to them.
SPEAKER_01And you get a chance to deliver uh communication and engagement, education that actually adds some kind of value, even if it is literally, hey, by the way, I want to just keep you informed on uh the fact that rates have now adjusted. Uh this may not be something you're thinking about today, but just wanted to make you aware, right? Like that's an opportunity to build some trust and engagement with a customer that I didn't have yesterday, right? Like that opportunity is something you should grab if you guys, I know you guys agree, but yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, there's there's a a couple different layers of that. One, obviously at the top of the funnel. We saw a lot of consumers leave the market when rates hit 8%. Um, so ensuring you're re-educating those consumers of the change in the market fluctuation and bringing them back into the market. Um, obviously, your referral partners, your real estate agents love that. Um, you're bringing buyers into the back into the market for them. Um, and then you're there's also a lot of risk right now with lenders for their locked pipeline. A lot of them have pipelines that have been locked at 7.5% to 8% range from you know October to November.
SPEAKER_00Um, and they're concerned that a lot of those consumers, they're gonna have a significant amount of fallout because a lot of those consumers are gonna go down the street and go lock in with another lender at six and a half today.
SPEAKER_01Um so making sure that that could be like the triple whammy. If uh so if you think about if you don't have your early payoff kind of playbook dialed in, uh you're gonna get hit with losing a customer plus an early payoff if you don't have the ability to really manage your pipeline and stay ahead of anybody in your pipeline that may be out shopping. Now I lose pipeline, plus I lose past customers. Is that like the triple whammy? Maybe we call that, I guess.
SPEAKER_00It could be a triple whammy, yeah. Yeah, I mean you really need to operationalize every part of your funnel uh in this type of rate environment to make sure that you're mitigating risk and also seizing all the opportunity right now. And obviously, we're you know, purchases are gonna be down right now. We're going into the holiday season, probably won't pick up back up till mid-February, as you know, it does every year. Um, so you know, making sure that you can seize this, you know, this good down positive downtrend in rates and and bring some refines into your book of business is super important for lenders to lean into right now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, if you're an LO, uh, I hope you didn't wait till the last minute to buy all your uh holiday gifts because you need to be making phone calls. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_01It's a good suggestion. All right. Anything on the risk or opportunity bucket that is worth talking about, other than the kind of those two pieces today that you guys think we should cover really quick?
SPEAKER_02Uh no, I mean the the rates do seem to have leveled off, you know. Uh it'll be interesting to see, you know, what happens in the news the next few uh weeks to see if we have another dip or I think it'll stay flat, honestly.
SPEAKER_00I think it'll stay flat until January and some more data comes up, but we'll see.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, I think so too. So, guys, I I you know, I think in short, this was really helpful to just clarify uh the risks as well as the opportunities for banks, letters, credit unions uh in this environment as rates are moving. And so if you're out there in the audience and you're having some anxiety or you're wondering, hey, is my organization really well positioned to both mitigate our risk and maximize our opportunity in what we believe is a new environment this next 12 months, um, reach out to one of these two guys, um, James White, Dan Catnella.
SPEAKER_01We'd be happy to have a strategic conversation, give you a point of view, uh, share some best practices on what we see working, uh, on how to operationalize some of these playbooks. And of course, I'm always happy to happy to have conversations as well. Uh, we really do enjoy interacting with the industry. So reach out to us anytime, guys. And uh, gentlemen, thanks again and uh look forward to catching up again soon.
SPEAKER_02Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Thanks so much for joining us today. Be sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcast.
American Pacific Mortgage is on track for $15B in production volume this year. What does it take to lead an organization of this size through the biggest technology shift in history in the most challenging market in a...
Ever wondered how one loan officer can build a billion-dollar business? In this episode of the 10x Lender Series, Total Expert Founder & CEO, Joe Welu, sits down with Shant Banosian of Rate to pull back the curtain on...
At the core of Prosperity Home Mortgage, they are hyper-focused on communication, which includes everyone in the homebuying process. That includes the real estate agent, the lender, and the borrower. For President and...
The technology conversation of GenAI has moved so fast since OpenAI and Chat GPT burst into the public eye. But are businesses just buying into the hype of AI, and does it really benefit their goals and needs? For...
The technology buzzwords for the last few years have been AI analytics, data analytics, and automation, but businesses are still unsure how to leverage those advancements in their systems. Leveraging data and connecting...