#5 Guest Episode | Compromised Every 31 Seconds: What Nonprofits Get Wrong About Cybersecurity Ft. Trey Tucker
28 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Most nonprofits assume they're too small to matter to hackers - and that assumption is exactly what makes them a target. In this episode of the Executive Thought Partner Podcast, Dr. Dan Freeman sits down with Trey Tucker of ATNET to unpack why nonprofits have quietly become one of the most attractive targets for cybercriminals. They cover the real mechanics of an attack - from AI-sharpened phishing emails that are nearly impossible to spot, to deepfake scams that have cost organizations hundreds of thousands of dollars - and why volunteers and board members, often overlooked in security training, end up being the weakest link in the chain. The conversation moves from the scary stuff to the practical: what cyber insurance actually covers (and where the gaps are), why password managers and MFA are non-negotiable basics, and a rundown of free or deeply discounted tools - from Microsoft 365 nonprofit pricing to CISA's free phishing simulations - that make real protection possible even on a shoestring budget. Trey closes with a stat that reframes the whole conversation: small businesses are compromised every 31 seconds in the U.S. This episode is a clear-eyed, non-alarmist look at what it actually takes to protect your donors, your team, and your mission. Website: https://expertip.net/ LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/trey-tucker/?skipRedirect=true Explanatory Video: https://www.youtube.com/@CyberCastbyAT-NET Support the show π If you're reading this and you're wanting to know if you're Philanthropy Ready, you can take my assessment here. Available for Speaking I'm available for keynotes, leadership retreats, roundtable discussions, and executive panels on fundraising, decision-making, organizational culture, and philanthropic advising. If you're building a lineup for your next event, I'd love to be in that conversation. If you made it this far, I'd love to schedule time to connect with you. β Reach out at dan@fsgventures.biz β Schedule time with me β Connect with me on LinkedIn
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Executive Thought Partner Podcast, where leadership, strategy, and growth intersect. I'm Dr. Daniel Freeman, Executive Thought Partner. This isn't just a podcast about fundraising. It's about how leaders think, decide, and build systems that scale impact across nonprofits, higher education, athletics, and mission-driven enterprises. Here we explore major gifts, governance, culture, and the quiet decisions that determine long-term momentum. If you're leading something that matters and you want clarity with conviction, you're in the right place.
SPEAKER_00Let's get into it. Welcome to the Executive Thought Partner Podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Dan Freeman. Today we have Trey Tucker. We are going to be speaking about security for your nonprofit, for your organization. And Trey's going to hit on some really important pieces because I believe people are not thinking about it until it happens to them. And those are words right out of Trey's mouth. So I'm going to pass it to Trey to talk a little bit about himself, and then we're going to jump right in.
SPEAKER_01Hey Daniel, Trey Tucker with AtNet. Appreciate again you having me on the uh the podcast. Yeah, we're going to talk about uh cybersecurity day and some of the topics that we're going to come up. And I feel like it's kind of undervalued. Everybody's always like, or companies are always like, yeah, we're we're okay until you you get a cyber breach or ransomware, and then it gets really personal and there can be some issues. So it's always good to have these different topics we're going to discuss out there and some uh tips and tricks and some security tools to uh protect yourself against the uh bad bad actors out there.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Trey. Trey, can you tell us a little bit about your background, how you got into cybersecurity and how long you've been there?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I appreciate that. Yeah, I've been with um at net since around December 2024 and got into IT support and cybersecurity actually from Lake Norman and Charlotte IT. I know you network a whole lot and I do, so very loyal to that group and got that from another colleague that uh passed my name along and always wanted to get in IT and cybersecurity. So the power of networking.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's great. Well, let's let's jump right in, Trey. So something that you had mentioned just now, and and I want you to, I can't wait for you to talk about this. Why are nonprofits a hacker's favorite target?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely they think they're a lot smaller than they are, but it's like uh a nonprofit, but the note is you don't have to be the biggest to be targeted because they don't care the uh hackers or the cybersecurity bad actor. They're all about getting your contact information, your banking information, donor information, and you're being a focus. So I think they have their guard down just like hey, we're just uh you know a smaller nonprofit, but they should they should have their guard up even more, having the different tools of cybersecurity, cyber insurance, MFA, some of the other tools that we'll we'll mention.
SPEAKER_01So I believe that's why they're a target because they think they're too small and and not a focus, but that's uh not the case at all.
SPEAKER_00You know, Trey, I was I was talking to someone today, and we're talking about the term users. And I always thought that organizations like yourself, businesses, focused on revenue. But what I what I started to connect, especially for our conversation today, was it's the amount of people and information that runs through the networks, right? So it could be a small nonprofit, right? They could have three to five people. But if you have a CRM with people's banking information, with their personal information, and you have hundreds of people that are in that or thousands or more, that becomes a lot more valuable to a bad actor.
SPEAKER_00Is that right? That's correct.
SPEAKER_01And another one with the bad actors, a lot of people don't realize that they have sales teams as well, they have sales quotas, they have managers as set up like a system, which is pretty scary. So they're they're out there to close their deals any way they can. So it's uh it's big business out there. It's it's bad and and scary, but it is business.
SPEAKER_00Big business for small business, but not in a good way.
SPEAKER_01That's right.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, you you talked about kind of it sounds like nonprofits are hackers' favorite targets because nonprofits think they're small enough that they're not targets, right? So they're they're not thinking outside of themselves. So one of the next things that I always think about is you mentioned MFAs, right? Multi-factor authentication. I've had to do that so many times, the places that I've worked at, right? And you always talk about protecting donor data is so paramount because there's a trust that comes with how well you do that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. It's uh, you know, there's a donor data list, for example, there's names, addresses, given history, credit reports. So I know that can be very like frustrating with MFA, and for example, you have to do dual mobile, is what we use, or you got to click on that. It's it's annoying, it can be, but it definitely cuts out a whole lot of that, different layers of security to get to that. So I think that's at least some of the basic levels. But your answer question, there's a lot of mid-sized nonprofits, for example, might be a CRM, and there's 8,000 donor records, and there might be a breach, for example.
SPEAKER_01And there was one that was uh like that a while back to a small to medium-sized business, and it ended up being uh losing donations of around$180,000. That's just a small instant, but um that is a big focus is the donor industry list and and information.
SPEAKER_00Trey, would with obviously with with privacy in mind, can you talk a little bit about that scenario? What what you may have seen or what happened? I know you're not you know in the weeds with it, but could you maybe talk to the audience a little bit about what what had happened in that instance, and just so they can get an understanding of maybe it's a little scenario of like how the hacker got in or kind of how it affected them. Could you share any details on that to kind of give an inside look to the people listening?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, usually the number one and the most um popular way is phishing email, and this is how that happened. Send it to the admin, clicked on phishing email, like a trusted email. And then with AI these days, it's getting so accurate that no one can really tell. It used to be back in the day, you would see misspellings, you could see the web address is kind of kind of weird looking, but with with AI, it's getting really kind of scary out there. So it's basically coming from a basic phishing email, which that's what the way a lot of it starts and and always kind of gets the different people.
SPEAKER_01It's also young, it's also younger people or newer people in uh organizations just kind of click on everything because they're not familiar with it. That's another target as well.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a that's a great note. It it makes me think, and not all places do it, but some do. They have bios, right, on their website. I would imagine as as you talk about younger individuals slash people who are newer to the organization, whether they're young or older, age doesn't matter. From what you're saying, it makes me think in those bios, maybe they shouldn't mention some specific information because if they're putting in there so-and-so joined us the equivalent of six months, right?
SPEAKER_00Or maybe even a year, that could be providing information for a hacker that that person could be a good target for them to reach out to. I know that's off the cuff, but that's just kind of what I'm thinking. Do you have any thoughts on that?
SPEAKER_01Yes, that's actually a really good point. They don't have maybe have all the systems and tools and databases and logins all quite familiar with, and they could be an easy target. And that's uh that's a good point. You could put in, you know, chat GPT or Claude. Hey, or who are some of the normal normal or newer type employees at these different roles, nonprofits, and you could kind of target on that. That's actually you know kind of scary, but that is that's a good that's a good point for sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I promise I don't do this on the daily. Okay, uh, you're thinking of that. Yeah, I I have I have been in higher ed for over a decade and I have taken many trainings. And actually, could you just give us a little tip? Obviously, I know what phishing is. Could you tell people like what is phishing? What should they be looking for in terms of not to click on things? Like your view of it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, uh definitely, for example, a popular lance because everybody has this like Amazon, right? So it might be, hey, this is our refund or receipt or something from Amazon. Another one is for talking about back to newer employees, is that even happened with me? And I had to ask my manager at telling me, I got like a text message or an email from the CEO and mentioned his name and goes, Hey Trey, can you pick up these gift cards, for example, or or mail these out or email these out for me, or can you go and do this favor for me? First off, it's it was from uh like a non-North Carolina number, so it was a little weird, but you didn't know because I was new, right?
SPEAKER_01So I was being targeted. So just fit phishing emails, maybe getting asked out of the ordinary by someone. Um, another popular one is like deep fakes. So you know, there was uh deep fakes where someone from the organization might sound like they're in higher leadership or in that, and do uh do a video call or say, Hey, I want to connect with you about something. That's another one that's uh really scary. There's been a lot of like ransomware and everything from deepfake of actually, I think it happened in Japan where they came in and it was all people like this, and we thought we were talking to each other and they were asking for money, and they thought it was real, and they ended up doing transferring over um the money and everything, and um kind of scary that's out there, but they I think it ended up being like over 500 grand or something, which is crazy.
SPEAKER_00Wow, it you know, when you think of the people who are probably the most susceptible, I would say are volunteers and board members because they are not going through the normal trainings that a team would be going through. So that makes me think maybe they should be. Can you talk a little bit about how to view volunteers, board members, and kind of the the insider risk of those people maybe being around your organization, but not necessarily getting the training like someone else would get who's in the organization?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. They're maybe kind of more part-time or just kind of jump in and help when they can, but definitely them having also they probably use their own personal email, Gmail, Yahoo, and don't have the certain training, and they're an easy target because maybe they don't think they're being targeted, they're not using some of the basic tools like MFA. So just be in that kind of part-time and and volunteering and not training on the different cyber um tips and tricks and everything, that's that can be a focus or an easy target because they're not in the day-to-day systems and and everything with the nonprofit that kind of just kind of coming in as needed.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a that's a great point, Trey. And I don't I think that the lines get blurred sometimes for nonprofits, especially smaller ones, where you know, I I I'm imagining like quite small ones have you know their nonprofit name in gmail.com, right? So it's not they don't have an actual domain for their work. So they're doing emails like that, or they're using their personal email, right? And that's one of the biggest faux pas in in the work that I've been in in in higher education with security, is that you shouldn't be sending emails from your personal email.
SPEAKER_00And I just want to get uh you know your thoughts from your experience. Uh like how detrimental could that be? Someone using their personal email and blurring those lines, especially because they're receiving way more at their personal email than they would be at their work email. I would assume. Do you have any thoughts on that? If fundraising is your job, this show is your edge, the executive thought partner podcast delivers real strategy, real decisions, real conversations and results.
SPEAKER_00That sweet spot where theory meets the real world. Practical insights you can use before your next campaign or conversation, hosted by fundraising experts like myself and my guests, backed by the team at Donorbox. Subscribe wherever you listen for the Executive Thought Partner podcast. You'll thank yourself later.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely with personal emails. First off, you can be exposed yourself with all your login information, contact information, banking information, so that can be exposed. And then also when you use Gmail, Yahoo, or some of the other personal the tools that they have for cybersecurity breaches or anything, they're really MFA is very, very basic, and that can be hacked or breached at any time. So just using that Gmail like Yahoo is not anything compared to, you know, an Outlook or another type email.
SPEAKER_01So you're you're being exposed using the personal email.
SPEAKER_00You know, Trey, that's scary, right? And I know your job is always like I don't want to make it scary, right? I don't want to scare people, but but there are a lot of people who can do bad things. And something that I'm thinking about that I hear occasionally, probably one of the lesser topics they've talked about in cyber training, is password managers, right? How to hold your information. Can you talk a little bit about that? Like what you know, are there browsers that you recommend? Like, where should people keep their passwords? Not on a sticky note on the top of their desk if anyone goes in their office.
SPEAKER_00But can you can you talk to that a little bit?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely a password portal. If anything, even the personal own that it keeps everything in there and it keeps that layer of defense, plus it does keep that password because everybody's always creating passwords, right? They can be annoying. And then what a lot of people do just because they get kind of lazy is they're just going to create the same password just and they can remember it, and that's a target. And if a bad actor uh gets to that, then they're gonna log in and get all your logins and everything if you use the same one. So I know it's annoying, but if you can at least have a unique password that you can save to the password portal, for example, that would be ideal.
SPEAKER_01And then make it as long as you can and try to put you know exclamation for or special character with capital letters. Don't and don't have really anything generalized. So don't do you know, Daniel Freeman and maybe your year you're born or something very one, two, three, very basic. Have maybe something only you would know, only you would know that they couldn't know, just some very basics. I know it's annoying because there's a hundred emails, logins for each person with all the accounts and apps and everything, but to be safe, it'd be good to have some unique and unique ones with a password portal would help.
SPEAKER_00So so what you're saying, Trey, is we have to fight the urge of being consistent. We need to be inconsistent with our passwords, they all need to be totally different, and we need to be totally out there with things that are disconnected from us completely, right? Because the goal when you're making those passwords, like you said, special characters and the breaks and the differences in them, right? Like has to be random.
SPEAKER_00Like I know you know, Google, Google suggests strong passwords, right? When you save a password in there now, and those things are just random as all get up. Like you gotta say, you have to save that for yourself. So you know, nonprofits think that they're small, but they're not really thinking about the deeper issue of how many users they have, how many people are in their database, and how attractive that is for a potential hacker.
SPEAKER_00They people need to be looking at the donor data because there's a trust that comes with it. I remember we used to talk about when I was in Collegiate Athletics, they were like, you don't write down the credit card number. Like they had sheets, and it was like, okay, you write down all this information, but you have to shred it afterwards if you're gonna do that, right? And it shouldn't be in general, you should just put it on the website, like done it on the website while you're on the phone with them instead of writing it down. And then, you know, we talked about how volunteers and board members are the weak point.
SPEAKER_00Right. I mean, if you really think about it, they're using personal emails, they're not there, or even part-time, right? There are people that haven't been through these trainings, people that aren't part of them, people that aren't even considered to be part of these trainings, they're that weak link that could really hurt you. So I want to ask you though. I've been through this experience with an organization. Cyber insurance, what does it cover?
SPEAKER_00What does it not cover? Can you just give us some real in-depth about what that looks like and why people should have it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so cyber insurance is very like baseline, as I mentioned, and it's very it's very nuanced. I believe it might have been like right after COVID or even the last four or five years, it's gotten to the it was very popular at first, and everybody rushed to it and it was very expensive. But now it's kind of went in more uh downstream, as they call it. Like it's almost been getting to the point of like auto insurance, but in a good way. But you want to at least have some type of uh policy if you're a small and medium-sized business, in case there's a ransomware, because even when there's a ransomware, some of the statistics you only get maybe 50% of it back, which still helps.
SPEAKER_01But back to it is just is is very important to get that and maybe even get an IT provider, like an MSP like myself, for example, to at least do a review each year of the security controls. And then I I believe even from what I've heard, if you do have at least an IT support company, it helps with um uh helps with the coverage, which is uh which is a good thing, because you have all those security cool tools already implemented, so that can help with the uh different coverage and everything for the cyber insurance.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, it's funny, it sounds like car insurance, which you mentioned, right? Because if you have the safety features in your car, your car insurance is less, right? And there are certain things that can change and make your car insurance more affordable. And to your point, it sounds like having the back-end support makes it even cheaper because they know that you're doing your due diligence and you have kind of safety lines in place already. Can you can you talk about?
SPEAKER_00I know you talked a little bit about for that cyber insurance, but like what what scenarios would nonprofits or organizations need that cyber insurance for? I know I know you talked specifically about kind of the phishing attacks. Do they help with trainings? Do they help with getting the MFA set up? Like what kinds of things can that insurance help with? Or let's go a little deeper, not just the insurance, which keeps you safe, but like if they were to work with AtNat, like what kinds of things could you help them with, or could your team help them with to make sure that they've got everything inlined and streamlined?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely. The MFA is the first we mentioned that usually helps on like over 90% of it. Also having an endpoint detection or response plan. Also, we help with regular backups and employee security training. Like, for example, we send that out each uh each week, and I'm a part of it too. You get micro trainings, so let's just say it's a two to three minute video and it's usually like an acted out scenario, but it gives you tips and tricks, and you get like four questions, it's usually like three, three to five minutes.
SPEAKER_01So that helps with different training and scenarios of a phishing email or a cyber threat. And then also checking your your policy where if you have a policy of let's say$250,000, it sounds like a lot, but if you get hit with a ransom where$500,000 it's not really covered. So it's good to have a IT or MSP like my like myself who I work for to do a renewal of it. So that's another one that really helps out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a that's a really great point. And you know, I mean, I've had to do some long trainings, and I I love the fact you talked about kind of like weekly. I mean, the goal is with people who have never really used uh security training, uh for them to go sit there for three hours or two hours, even one hour is just not digestible. But in a way, uh getting a weekly email that takes three to five minutes and just keeps you fresh, but doesn't make you lose a part of your day, I love that.
SPEAKER_00I love that I love that your group does that. Now I think the last thing I'm curious about is Let's be honest, right? Some some nonprofits are going to look at this and be like, no one wants my information. I still don't believe you. And we we know that's not true, right? People people take anything. But I'm I'm curious. Tell me about cybersecurity on a shoestring. Like what you know what free and low-cost tools are there that actually work? Like, can you walk through maybe a few of the a few of the tools that everyone should be using?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, definitely for sure. So Microsoft 365, for example, and nonprofits, they're always really good on giving discounts. If you qualify for as a 501c3, you'll get a deeply discount. Also, this will include like enterprise email security, like MFA and device management. Also, CISA Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency offers free scanning and other phishing simulation tools to nonprofits at no cost.
SPEAKER_01You can also get Cloud Fair for Teams, which is kind of a free tier. So some of those are just some of the some of those as well. And also Google workspace, even though it mentions the target, that can be a free Google workspace for for that as well, to at least have that. And there's also um business Google workspace as well. So there's a lot of uh benefits to nonprofits at discounted rates. I know it's it's all about money at the end of the day, so that that could be some things for some different nonprofits.
SPEAKER_00That's great. You know, Trey, I before we before we finish up, I would love if you could send me a link that I can put on this podcast description for people to look at that kind of show the things that you offer through AtNet so they get a better idea. Because I think what what you offer, right? Uh whatever it is on the baseline, people should really be considering that. Similar to business insurance, right? You hope you never have to use business insurance, you hope you never have to use cyber insurance, but for the amount that it usually costs, it is worth it.
SPEAKER_00But then also to have someone dedicated to you for all of the cyber needs, not cybersecurity necessarily. I mean, but all that back-end work is is really helpful to make things streamlined in and in space, especially for the trainings and the updates and the information and things that I believe that nonprofits should really be diving into the fractional side. I would I would consider you know your team's work kind of fractional IT, right? Because you're not working inside, right?
SPEAKER_00Fractional IT, fractional fundraising, fractional marketing. Maybe you have one person doing that role internally as well that's working boots on the ground, but they're not strategizing. I think there are just so many benefits to that. Now, Trey, before you before we we finish off this podcast, is there anything else you share you're thinking you would share with us for nonprofits or organizations to know about? If there's one, I call it one hot take that you have in the cybersecurity world, something you're thinking about, something that's common right now that people aren't thinking about till it comes to them, what what is that hot take that you'd share with people to make them think a little bit more about why they should be investing in this and why it's so necessary for them to be on top of this work?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm gonna go back to it. My manager always uh mentioned it and he he always makes this a great stat that small business is compromised every 31 seconds in the US. Which so at least have the basics MFA. If you can't have cybersecurity, also just be on the really read your emails if it's more internal, being a nonprofit phishing emails, so just be real diligent on that.
SPEAKER_01So it's a MFA. If you can do cybersecurity, just read your emails closely before doing anything, yeah. Because it can it's not uh if it's gonna happen, but when is what we like to tell. But at least have these certain cybersecurity tools set up.
SPEAKER_00That's that's really great. Like we said, point of this is not to scare people, it's just to make them aware because we've seen it happen. It does happen. And when you are dealing with so many other people, not just the database, but people you're trying to serve, the populations you're trying to serve through your mission, but also the people you're trying to serve who are supporting your mission, you've got to do everything possible to keep both of them safe and their information safe.
SPEAKER_00So, Trey, I really appreciate you coming on to the Executive Thought Podcast. I'll include your LinkedIn and any link you share with me for AtNet, I'll put that in the podcast description. This was really important to me because, as I've told you more times than I should, I think cybersecurity is huge for nonprofits. And I've just seen bad things happen when people don't think about this net as part of the work that they're doing, this safety net. So thank you for coming on today.
SPEAKER_00We appreciate it. We'll put that information in there and looking forward to having this podcast come out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, appreciate you having me on again, Daniel. Look forward to it.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for listening to the Executive Thought Partner Podcast. If today's conversation helped clarify your leadership or expand your thinking, share it with someone navigating meaningful decisions. Until next time, think clearly, lead intentionally, and build what lasts.
Send us Fan Mail PSA: The information provided is for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice Most small nonprofits donβt have an endowment, and many that think they do...
Send us Fan Mail Why don't the classic change models (ADKAR, Kotter, Lewin) quite fit nonprofits? Dr. Tristan Moore, a change leader and board member with ACMP Texas, set out to answer that question in his doctoral...
Send us Fan Mail What do you do when someone slides a blank check across your desk and asks you to fix a grade? For Dr. Fay Niewiadomski, a former university dean, founder and CEO of ICTN since 1993, and an...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode of the Executive Thought Partner Podcast, Dr. Daniel Freeman sits down with Bradley Harris, a strategic advisor whose career took him from a high-ranking government role at a Secretary...
Send us Fan Mail In Episode 14, Dan breaks down his Three R's framework - Reach, Revenue, and Relationships - and makes the case that it's not a strategy, but a diagnostic. Most leaders unconsciously over-index on just...