Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Exceptionally Good: Leaders for a Better World

Exceptionally Good: Leaders for a Better World artwork

6. Derek Pierce - Decades of Innovative School Leadership

Jan 21, 202553 minAudio

How do you go from a town hall lashing, go up for a vote of no confidence and turn it around? What’s a leader to do when faced with a moment of crisis? Have you ever wondered how to know it is the right time to step down? In this transcript, Derek Pierce, the founding leader of Casco Bay High School, shares his extensive journey in educational leadership. Derek discusses his early influences, experience in the film industry, and the emotional challenges of starting a new school in a rural community. Highlighting key stories, such as handling a contentious Pledge of Allegiance issue and responding to hate crimes, he reflects on the importance of human-centered leadership. The conversation touches on Derek's leadership style characterized by humor, love, and a focus on student and faculty potential. As he transitions from his role after 19 years, Derek emphasizes the significance of listening, adapting, and continuously striving for improvement in education. This dialogue aims to inspire aspiring leaders committed to social good in educational settings. “Keep tinkering towards better and to keep loving your people with intention relentlessly.” Links: Casco Bay High School https://cbhs.portlandschools.org/ Derek’s Silverberg Leadership Award Speech - (bunny, bunny!) https://vimeo.com/190194953 Derek leaves Casco Bay after 19 years https://www.pressherald.com/2024/02/21/principal-leaving-portlands-casco-bay-high-after-19-years/ Coalition of Essential Schools Design Principles https://web.archive.org/web/20220121202607/http://essentialschools.org/common-principles/ - - - Follow us: @e.g.exceptionallygood https://www.instagram.com/p/DCk8pcourAOm81qleR5vtwQRvSY7emrC0ZARNY0/?igsh=MW0wOWZkNHM3M2Rldg== Recommend a leader to be a guest: https://forms.gle/GzHAYmzueE3UnarY6 Feedback - Help us improve: https://forms.gle/aXempCSq2rvdfrCz9 Help us cover costs - give $5, $10, $25, $50 or $?? at our Donorbox: https://donorbox.org/support-leaders-striving-for-exceptional-good-in-the-world Producer, editor and host: Ryan Maxwell Theme music: Ryan Raddatz Guitar music: Adeline’s Guitar The views shared on this podcast are those of my guests and the host(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of any employer. Support the show •••••••••• About Exceptionally Good: https://www.exceptionallygood.org/about More from Exceptionally Good: 📧 ryan@exceptionallygood.org Work with Ryan on leadership development, strategic planning or Deeper Learning. https://www.exceptionallygood.org/services Exceptionally Good on Substack: https://substack.com/@exceptionallygood Producer & host: Ryan Maxwell Editor: Matt Mitchell Theme music: Ryan Raddatz Guitar music: Adeline’s Guitar Credits/Outro Read by: Adeline, Advice & Jess The views shared on this podcast are those of my guests and the host and do not necessarily reflect those of any employer or client past or present.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00And I started the meeting and I said, Okay, thanks everybody for coming. And we're gonna break up into some groups. And this person raised their hand, like, no, we're not. We're gonna stay right here and listen to it. Oh, you're gonna hear all the things we gotta say. And there was a lot of kind of applauding and head wagging, and I was like, Okay. I sat there for the next several hours and took feedback that was at three and four, where this place stinks. What are you doing to our kids? And then a fourth, every fourth or fifth one was somebody saying, My kid kind of likes it, and I'm excited by the learning they're doing, but it was mostly really rough.

SPEAKER_00And I remember afterwards literally going behind our new red velvet curtain backstage and just sobbing.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Exceptionally Good Podcast, where we bring you in-depth interviews with exceptional leaders who drive towards a different bottom line. Leaders from healthcare, academics, philanthropy, nonprofits, education, rescue services, and more, all who are doing exceptional work for the good of the world. Exploring their origin stories, their leadership journey, and the lessons they learned along the way, sometimes the hard way, we bring you close to understand how exceptional leaders tick. And to help you know that you are not alone.

SPEAKER_01Today in the show, we have Derek Pierce. Derek has been the founding and was the only leader in 19 years of Casco Bay High School before stepping down last summer. One of his longtime collaborators, Susan McRae, said of Derek, The greatest gift of Derek Pierce is that he believes in the possibility and potential of every human to be great, and to do tremendous things, and to transform. In the time I've known Derek, he's been an exceptional leader in how he holds a vision with heart, smarts, and humor.

SPEAKER_01Derek is known for his human-centered leadership, for going after what's most important, and doing it with a signature blend of ambition and service of kids, care for his crew, and a humble humor that greases the skids of the hard work of leadership. In his career, Derek was a teacher in Los Angeles and Maine, a founding dean and leader at Poland Regional High School, a part of the Coalition of Essential Schools, a progressive education movement. The bulk of Derek's career was a two-decade-long run as the founding leader of Casco Bay High School for Expeditionary Learning.

SPEAKER_01Derek is also the winner of the prestigious Silverberg Leadership Award from Yale Education, an award granted only to some of the most powerful school leaders in the world. He's also been a screenwriter in LA. Derek holds a Bachelor of Arts from Brown University in Political Science, his EDM from Harvard's Graduate School of Education, and a principal certification from the University of Southern Maine. But most importantly, Derek is an exceptionally good leader in how he's taken his many, many talents and skills and focused them on solving social problems, particularly for students facing racial and economic injustices.

SPEAKER_01He's a good human, and I'm absolutely delighted to have him as my guest today. This conversation will be undoubtedly full of gems and learning for all those on their own path to leadership for social good. And with that, let's dive in. Thanks for joining, Derek.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for having me, Ryan. That was lovely. I'll try to live up to it.

SPEAKER_01I I think it's all true.

SPEAKER_00We'll find out.

SPEAKER_01Well, Derek, let's start there. Can you tell us a little bit about your career journey? Right? How did you get into leadership roles that you've had? So tell us your story. Not your resume, not your life story, but something in between.

SPEAKER_00So I grew up in a family that definitely valued leadership, and I expected to be a leader from a pretty young age. I was the kind of guy who ran for class officer and things like that in middle school and high school. But I never imagined that schools would be the place where I would try to be a leader. It was, I think, and I grew up in a very privileged suburb outside New York City, and oddly, education as a career was not valued.

SPEAKER_00It was something that never even occurred to me. And it wasn't until I was involved in the film industry for a couple years, right out of college, and I was so disgusted by how people treated one another, and there was this kind of inverse relationship between character and power that was really unsettling to me, even though I loved writing and I loved the creative process. And when I was in my early 20s, I got called back to my high school to help with an event.

SPEAKER_00There was a school centennial. And I was asked, and this is this is like '92, maybe nineteen ninety, something like that. And it was right when Bill McKibben's climate change article came out, except it was called Global Warming, then, um, in the New Yorker. And we did a little seminar as a part of the centennial. I worked with a teacher on it, and suddenly I was like, wow, this is really, this is really fun and interesting. And soon after I decided to kind of shift from a film career into a teaching career, and just fell in love instantly.

SPEAKER_00And then I did that. I moved to Maine after graduate school, and I was really interested in an awesome school. I I was attracted to the school in Gore, Maine, that was called something, it was part of something called Atlas, which was like the super friends of school reform. It joined this guy, Comer from Yale, and Harvard, Howard Gardner, who was a big deal at the time from Harvard, and Ted Sizer. And there were three net there were three districts, I think, in the country that were part of this at Atlas project that was supposed to be a break the mold school system.

SPEAKER_00And so I worked in this place, Gorham, Maine. And I really enjoyed that work and quickly learned how brutal and disappointing school reform can be if all of the wheels are not going in the same direction. And we had a superintendent who was good and that his philosophy that was promising, but there were enough teachers who were blockers to it and who didn't believe and who were a bit scared of all the change embedded in these reforms that it just didn't quite go as far as I in my 26-year-old self felt it should.

SPEAKER_00And so then I got an inkling about God, we just need to start from scratch, and then maybe we can create a a great school. And strangely enough, an opportunity emerged in this rural town, Poland, where Poland Springwater comes from, about an hour north of Portland, and and I had the opportunity to begin to start a school. We had a year to plan the school, and it was my first real leadership role, and I felt woefully underprepared. But what drove me to school leadership was in my last year in Maine, there was such a bad principal.

SPEAKER_00I saw the destruction that a bad school leader could have on a promising school community, and it just it drove me to get my training as soon as I could.

SPEAKER_01When you say a leader makes all the difference, right? That's part of what this whole podcast is about. And you don't have to attribute any names, but you can certainly name what's some of the behavior, what are some of the things that happened during that time that helped you see okay, that's what I want to be the opposite of.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Um it was very clear. There was a kind of crushing of creativity and innovation and ambition. And when I was engaged in some interdisciplinary projects and projects that involved kids presenting to the community and doing research that involved uh experiential learning and interviews, and he literally one time in a faculty meeting labeled it an abomination, which led me and some faculty members to form a band that we called Ed and the Abominations in response to his lack of support.

SPEAKER_00But it was just astonishing to see I mean it was an imposition of his belief that um his way was the right way and not allowing teachers to pursue their own brand of excellence or to experiment and explore in the name of making things better. And it was just so crushing to me, and I know to a lot of colleagues, and led me to flee.

SPEAKER_01I can see yeah, how that would that would drive someone like you out. It could also drive lots of other folks out,

SPEAKER_00right?

SPEAKER_01And the fact that it drove you to name a band after the condition you were in is also tells a lot about who you are. Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_00We crushed it at the talent show, by the way, but it was still a little sad ultimately.

SPEAKER_01So, all right, then how did you end up saying, yeah, I'm in to be a leader? Obviously, there was the I I know what it can be like not to have a good leader, so I'm gonna go in and and try my hand at that. But how did you know that you wanted to take up school leadership?

SPEAKER_00I knew that there was a whole lot I could control in my classroom. And with the colleagues that I worked with, I moved to a team teaching model pretty quickly in my career. And so with my team teachers, I saw the good that we could possibly do for kids and the incredible challenge of it and the joy when kids do more than you thought they could, and when you as adults do more than you thought you could. And it just was clear to me that there was a limit to that because I couldn't control if there was tracking, and I couldn't control if we graded in a traditional way, and I couldn't control the daily schedule, and so there was a limit to my impact as a as a classroom teacher.

SPEAKER_00So, first I've I pursued teacher leadership roles that enabled me to be involved in helping to shape school-wide policy, and I loved that work. But then the possibility in Poland first to start a school from scratch and to really be on the ground floor of setting the conditions for success for kids was just an awesome, life-changing opportunity, even though it was super daunting. It was the first year in Poland, it was me as Dean of faculty and the principal and the dean of students, and we had a year, which is pretty unheard of in school startup world, to just make stuff up and to figure out what was our dream uh school.

SPEAKER_00There was a vision that elements of the community had created. There was like a page of bulleted power, bulleted points about um principles that I really was energized by because it indicated a belief in kids doing great things, but we had to figure out how to actualize that and what what did that mean the science curriculum looked like, and who were the people that were gonna bring that to reality for kids? And so then I was totally smitten with that prospect, even though uh about a year into the school's opening, I was almost run out of town.

SPEAKER_01Say anymore.

SPEAKER_00So it was a fascinating process. It's pre-rural communities, and we hired an entire faculty from scratch. It opened as a 712 school. The 912 part of it was entirely new. And when you when you start something, that's when you're at your worst. Like you will never be as bad as implementing new curriculum all at once with kids you don't know, right? So your first couple months in a startup school are when you're, or in a startup anything, are when you're most vulnerable and most inept.

SPEAKER_00And we were trying some fairly radical things and that that there wasn't much precedence for in Maine, with students who had many of them had been at other high schools. So kids were at other high schools for three years if they were a senior and then were given the option to come back. This was the first time there was a high school in this town. Previously, the kids had been bussed elsewhere. So we had kids who had a lot of previous preconceptions from fairly traditional high schools about what high school should be and how it should work.

SPEAKER_00And we were throwing a lot of new stuff at them. We had teaming and interdisciplinary classes and standards-based grading and project-based learning, and our French fries weren't as good as they were at Edward Little High School. So all of those things added up in the early months to some challenges. And there were some parents who were really supportive and wanted a school that was distinct from where their kids had gone previously and really tried to implement educational-based practice practices, and then there were a lot of parents who just expected the school to be the same as where their kids had been and the kind of high school they had always experienced.

SPEAKER_00So there was a huge disconnect, and parents got really nervous. And there was a meeting in February of that school year where there had been some mounting tension at school board meetings, and there was a sense that we needed to have a community forum to reflect on where the school was at. And I remember facilitating this meeting in a packed auditorium, probably three to four hundred people. I remember we had a whole plan about we're gonna break up into groups and talk about the different issues that we've been hearing around tracking and grading and the various things people were concerned about.

SPEAKER_00And I started the meeting and I said, Okay, thanks everybody for coming, and we're gonna break up into some groups. And this person raised their hand, like, no, we're not. We're gonna stay right here and listen to all you're gonna hear all the things we gotta say. And there was a lot of kind of applauding and head wagging, and I was like, Okay. I sat there for the next several hours and took feedback that was at three and four, where this place stinks, what are you doing to our kids? And then a fourth, every fourth or fifth one was somebody saying, My kid kind of likes it, and I'm excited by the learning they're doing, but it was mostly really rough.

SPEAKER_00And I remember afterwards literally going behind our new red velvet curtain backstage and just sobbing because we were shredded and we had so misread the community. We were so focused on the kids and on each other that we just did not pay enough attention to where parents were and the education needed and the trust that needed to be built. We just assumed our ideas alone were gonna win the day because we were and I in particular was so confident and believed so deeply in what we're doing.

SPEAKER_00It never occurred to me I'd have to persuade people who weren't familiar with them about it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's a really tough moment, right? Yeah. That moment to be, hey, we have some concerns. Okay, we're gonna do if we're bringing everyone together and we're gonna talk about them and okay, I got a structure for this so that we can do it what I think is gonna be productively, and instead it's like, nah, you're gonna sit right in that seat and we're just gonna have at you. And uh my guess is well, I I one, just that moment is a pretty brutal one to to be sitting in, right? And any leader, any leader who's trying to do something is gonna get criticism, right?

SPEAKER_01What is the the quote from Aristotle? The only way to avoid criticism is do nothing, say nothing, be nothing, right? And if you're trying to do something ambitious and you're in your head about it or you're like, I got these great ideas, right? Then sometimes people are gonna they're gonna hand it to you. And it sounds like that was the case. Two questions as a follow-up. One, how did you make it through, obviously after the sobbing? And then what did you learn from that?

SPEAKER_00Well, and as it evolved, there was a literal uh kind of recall vote to throw me out and the principal and the superintendent, and a vote about kind of a referendum on do we want to continue with the school as it's currently constituted? And then there and then the supporters of the school put in a equally biased wording that said, don't we want the school for the 21st century to educate our kids to be prepared for the world they will face?

SPEAKER_00So there were these competing ballot measures as well of a vote of confidence. So it kind of evolved from February to June. But over the course of that time, I learned a lot. I was totally humbled and recognized that we had to listen as much as we had to talk, and that I wasn't gonna win people over with PowerPoints and witty retorts, but it was all about hard issues and about addressing people's fears and helping them helping folks realize we're on the same side.

SPEAKER_00We all want the kids to have the best possible education and to go as far as they absolutely can with whatever their dreams are, and so working to find that common ground, and we had absolutely some kinks to work out. We had a very grandiose vision, but it was certain we weren't so good at it in our first six months in implementing it. And what happened was in part that we won the kids, and once we won the kids, we won their parents, and there was sometimes a little bit of a drag, but in terms of the timing of that, I remember a particular meeting where a parent was sitting next to the kid and raised a concern, and the kid right next was like, I don't feel that way anymore.

SPEAKER_00Because by the spring, kids were starting to see results in their own learning and and they had positive relationships with the teachers who were an awesome faculty. And so those relationships paid the dividends over time that saved us, and we listened and we learned that we had to build trust with parents and we had to involve parents more because it was their schools, their community school. Um, and we couldn't just impose because it was in a brilliant research article we'd read.

SPEAKER_01That's important learning right there. This idea of like it doesn't matter that you read it in some article or like cool new theory, or even I've got data to back it up, right? If the people that are your main constituents, right? Well, in this case, it's the parents and kids, obviously. And uh but the parents are like, I don't I don't care about any of that. What I want is my kid to have XYZ.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01And I want it to fit into what I think that I think they need, and I don't see it.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01I don't care what the data says. I want my kid to have a good experience.

SPEAKER_00Right. And an X work for me, so why want to work for my kid? And and fearful that what uh the Y that we were proposing may not work, and how do we know it's gonna work? And and so by the way, we did we did win the vote of confidence by spring, and and interestingly, both of the initiatives that were conflicting passed. So the board was given a bit of mixed results, but they by then had enough faith in us as an institution and as leaders that they kept going. And soon enough we doubled the percentage of kids going to college, and it we were it was clear that we're all on the same team.

SPEAKER_00But it it was a brutal first year, excruciating.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And you're also in a place where it sounds like there was no school, and then you were like, hey, we're gonna bring a school to you.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01It's gonna be here, and then people don't have a they don't really get to vote with their feet. And it's like, you brought me to a school that you said was gonna be here, and now what if I don't want it? Like, what do I do? That that sounds like a really important leadership lesson in disguise,

SPEAKER_00as much

SPEAKER_01as it was really hard.

SPEAKER_00Yes, no, it I I was grateful for it, and it and it helped me tremendously in my leadership henceforth. And

SPEAKER_01yeah, you know,

SPEAKER_00and Derek, where

SPEAKER_01did where did you take that lesson? Like, so tell us where you where it went. Yeah, so

SPEAKER_00then uh you know, so I eventually there was another really excruciating leadership challenge for the school a couple of years later, where it was a fairly conservative community, and this is about 2000, and there was a a student who left uh home in a tuxedo for prom and arrived in a dress and was named prom queen, was elected prom queen, and was happy with that, but there are a lot of students who were not particularly, it was like an equity issue for females because those who identified as female couldn't be prom queen, and then the word got out in the community, and then the sense that we were turning kids gay and and somehow promoting that agenda in this rural community was super intense and led my predecessor to leave, and then I kind of came, I was appointed that spring as that was going on, and it was a really another time where I had to do a lot of conversations and listening to work through the super powerful emotions that come with change and that come with generational changes.

SPEAKER_00And I was in Poland for a couple of years, and then the opportunity came to start uh a new school in my hometown, a portal. Should we

SPEAKER_01pause in that last moment? Just before we move from there, we don't have to spend a long time here, but I am curious to hear about one. What did what what did you do to connect and move as a community through that phase? And were the moves you made and what did you learn? What did you take with you?

SPEAKER_00I remember one particular conflict in my first year, kind of a cultural conflict around the Pledge of Allegiance that was super contentious and challenging, where I had a fairly uh liberal faculty that was not interested in doing the Pledge of Allegiance and found it kind of offensive for various reasons to have it be required. And then I had some particularly students and parents who cared a whole lot about it, and it was state law, and that you better be doing it and show some respect for our country and our flag.

SPEAKER_00And it felt like two irreconcilable parties, and I wanted to honor those who did not want to participate, and I wanted to honor those who did want to participate. So we had this group of students and parents and um teachers that we called our vision keepers at the school, and we went through a lot of brainstorming and came to this idea that we would offer the pledge as uh an opportunity for anybody before school started to gather in this kind of central place.

SPEAKER_00It was the big hall of the school and stand up on a podium with a microphone, and all those who wanted to participate could participate, and it felt like it was an elevated occasion for those who wanted to participate, but then those who didn't could volunteer to not do it. And that felt like a a real solution where when the issue first came upon me that I didn't think was possible. So I think I learned that as a leader, sometimes you gotta be patient and you're strapped into the roller coaster and it's gonna go up and down, and it's gonna do some loop-to-loops, but if you stick with it long enough and you listen hard enough and people listen to each other, that that solutions can emerge that can make a community stronger, even when faced with pretty deep rancor.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I no, I also hear what you're doing is the work there's a lot of work of democracy right in what you're working on, right? And schools are this place where we bring community together. They're one of the only mandatory places in America where everyone has to interact.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01And yeah, go ahead.

SPEAKER_00And I think as a as a leader over time, I I think by nature, I'm fairly conflict diverse. I'd love for people to get along. As a leader, I've had to become more conflict-facing, if that's the word. And recognizing that a lot of the best learning happens when you go head on into the hard stuff. And particularly at Casco Bay, the school I went to next in Portland that you referenced in the beginning, where I've been or where I was for the last 19 years, we were, I got much better and more comfortable having what we call the courageous conversations that a lot of schools and leaders and institutions want to avoid, but are precisely the issues that we need to be talking most about as long as we're doing it in structured, civil, purposeful ways that lead to new insights and actually bring people closer together, even though they're super divisive at face value.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And Derek, could you tell a story about that? I know one because it was well sort of documented, reported around an issue that happened in the community to some of your students, and then how you all responded, or most importantly, how your students responded.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I think you're referring to, I don't know, seven or eight years ago, there was Portland is uh refugee resettlement city. So the population of BIPOC students is primarily, primarily first-generation immigrants and refugees and asylum seekers, often from Africa and the Middle East. Um, and one time after school, several of our students were at the bus stop, and there was a hate crime incident where some passers by who weren't a part of the school community and were above school age shouted racial epithets and said, Go home to your home country, those kinds of things.

SPEAKER_00And there was a bit of a altercation that ensued. And these were ninth graders too, who were the victims, and it was super upsetting to the community, and there's this sense of powerlessness, and when will this stop? And how can it be? Whatever the year was, 2017, and we're still having these conversations, and we talk all this stuff about social justice at school, and we can't even experience it at our own bus stop and be safe, be our full selves. And so the kids decided, gather with some student leaders, and we were figuring out how to best respond, and we decided to have a march and the march to our own bus stop.

SPEAKER_00And then we stopped school, and the whole school, the students and staff marched out in solidarity to the bus stop in support of these kids and um kind of took back our community and and asserted that we want safety for each of our kids. And it was one of those moments where conflict and pain can lead to some triumph and greater strength if kids uh are given a careful, carefully supported opportunity for that to happen.

SPEAKER_01And was there a moment when, say you learned about the incident, right? The hate crime that was it happening, and had to say we're gonna take this on, we're gonna make this a central thing that we do. Were you drawn to that? Were you pushed to that? Was it something you started? How did you get to that place?

SPEAKER_00I think through conversation, I mean, I think as a leader, I try to act unilaterally as little as possible. And also I find with especially hard and naughty issues, that it just takes some processing time, that it's dangerous to act too quickly. And so I think as a leader, your first reaction is in a situation like that is to be compassionate and caring and listening. And as much as you want to go act and do something dramatic right then and there, it's probably not wise.

SPEAKER_00It's first wise to just be there for the victims or the people hurting in any way and listen and take ideas from other folks and sit down with the people most impacted, and then formulate a plan after you've responded as a human first, and then act soon after.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's a danger in acting too fast. There's probably also a danger in acting too slow. How do you balance that or or how when have you learned how not to do that right or wrong?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think it's in part really understanding your community and really listening um to your stakeholders, in the school's case, students and teachers and parents, to get that read of what's too soon and what's too cautious. And I always felt that as a leader, I'm only as good as my perceptions of what students are experiencing and teachers are experiencing is in fact accurate.

SPEAKER_00Right? So if I think one thing but my students and teachers or parents are experiencing other things, as happened in Poland, that's where the problems are, right? So I think you make that judgment based on, you know, and if you don't know, then you ask people, what do you think? How are how are people feeling? How important is it that we do this thing tomorrow, or should it wait till Monday when we have a little more time to plan and think it out, right? Um it's really reading the room in the deepest sense.

SPEAKER_01I I'm hearing one area that is the sort of idea that you don't have to you shouldn't figure it out by yourself. You don't have to figure it out by yourself, you're probably gonna get it wrong. And you shouldn't try to figure it out by yourself. That if you listen to the people who are most closest to the issue or are closest to the need for action, they're gonna give you the quote unquote right insights. Absolutely. Would you describe it that way?

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Yeah. I mean, I think oftentimes I would draft something in response to January 6th or 9-11 or any major event in the world, or more recently in Maine, there was a shooting in Lewiston that shut down our state for several days. And in those kinds of and then obviously there are crises that happen within a school. There's a fight, or there's somebody uses a racial epithet. And oftentimes I would draft and share.

SPEAKER_00I think rather than an open conversation of what do we do, I think people found it helpful because often these issues are so time sensitive. You can't kind of start from scratch. What do we have a big brainstorm with chart paper? But you can lay out here's what I'm thinking before it's goes to the entire school community, and you share it with your teacher leaders or your administrative team to make sure you're not missing something. And inevitably the feedback I get would make I was missing something because I'm human. So it was important to have other people uh help me uh write the ship.

SPEAKER_01Uh embedded in that is this idea of I'm human, so I'm gonna get something wrong. And that takes a while, I think, for some leaders to get to, right? To realize that and in fact, my my telling everyone I'm not gonna get it 100% right is a strength, right? My ability to say, hey, I'm probably gonna miss something. Will you look at this and make sure that I'm give me the feedback that's gonna make it better? Like embedded in that, there's a little bit of an ego dance, right? Where you have to sort of drop your own ego that you're gonna figure it all out or that you're gonna get it right.

SPEAKER_01And and I'm curious about how do you grapple with that or have you grappled with that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I mean, I think it's super important for leaders to apologize whenever necessary. And I think it's a sign of strength. And it's also just good human behavior, and it often I think the human frailty and human foibles that are a part of all of us can just help others who maybe less I'm I'm a pretty confident person in my abilities, but I also am confident I'm gonna screw something up in the next five minutes, too. But I think if if I as a leader can admit, hey, I'm sorry, I went too far with that, or I didn't do enough with that, that also frees up other folks to admit their vulnerabilities, and that helps us all to grow.

SPEAKER_00And with in the world of teachers, teaching is just could not be more it's just you screw up every day, hundreds of times a day. There are a million decisions you have to make as a school leader and as an educator every day about how you interact with kids, how you interact with adults in each particular moment. Some of it's prepared, most of it's improvised, and everybody gets 20% of those million decisions wrong or not quite right or just missed. And so as a leader, you have to, I believe, cultivate a sense of that's fabulous.

SPEAKER_00Like that's that's how we get better, talking honestly, crying in the teacher's room with one another, laughing hysterically in the teacher's room with one another when when a lesson goes terribly wrong. But unlike that principle I had back in Gorham that almost drove me out of the profession, I want teachers to take risks and I want them to feel comfortable to do great things with kids because kids can't do great things in schools unless teachers let them and teachers give them the opportunity to do so. So I think it's super important that teachers feel the power to explore and experiment and just screw up royally in the name of trying to do something awesome, because otherwise that awesome won't happen.

SPEAKER_01We often have this real big sort of growth mindset for our kids, right? To say, yeah, kids need to make mistakes and learn. And if we only hold it there, then what happens if you're not modeling that I'm making mistakes and learning? Then you're teaching your staff, they're gonna make mistakes, right? So then you're teaching them to hide their mistakes if they can't bring them. They're gonna keep happening. It's a question of whether or not you can know of them, help them move through them and all that. And I hear your moves of modeling.

SPEAKER_01Look, I'm gonna get this wrong and give me the hard feedback and let me learn from it. And I I would go back to your town hall as a good moment of learning that too,

SPEAKER_00right?

SPEAKER_01You're gonna you have to there's like a building up of one's tolerance, right? I think to take it, right? And in fact, taking it, like getting everyone to give you the hard feedback, is really a gift. Because then you can, oh, I was getting it totally wrong. Thank you for telling me. And now I can make a better move.

SPEAKER_00And I think another piece, and this may sound strange, but I consciously or unconsciously celebrate my own ineptitude in certain ways, and that has been a part of my leadership for since I ran for office in sixth grade. Like, I there are certain things I am really not so good at. Like I'm scared of water and I'm inept, hammering a nail, and I'm open about that and often poke fun at myself. And I I think that's part of what makes people comfortable coming to see me because leaders, they're the no matter what your persona or what vibe you try to give off, there's there's um there can be elements of inaccessibility or people feel intimidated or they don't want to come talk to you.

SPEAKER_00And again, like if if uh people aren't coming to talk to me about whatever's on their mind or whatever their concerns are, I'm gonna be a much worse leader. So I need people comfortable laughing at me, you know, yeah, laughing and laughing with me so that we can have real conversations about the things that are that they struggle with. So

SPEAKER_01yeah, so Derek, I to that point, not everyone knows you. And how would you describe how other people would describe your leadership?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think it's become more about love. I think when I was first leading in Poland, I was more leading with ideas, and I had kind of a dogma of progressive practices that I was really determined to implement. And and now I think I've evolved to a place that it's those practices are a reflection of deeper values that I have about and hopes that I have about how humans interact with one another in a loving, generous, empathic way that supports people, adults and kids, to do things they never thought they could do.

SPEAKER_00So I would hope that the people that work with me r recognize how deeply I care about them as humans and their well-being and their happiness and their ambitions because I see the role of the principal as kind of a facilitator of other people's pursuit of their own greatness. And that fundamentally is about loving them and believing in them and trusting them and trying to get whatever opportunities and resources are necessary for those folks to achieve that individualized greatness.

SPEAKER_01I think that when I think of how people would describe your leadership, they would definitely go to the center point of love, right? How you really love your staff and you love your kids uh and the people you're serving with. I think they would also describe your ability to make things happen, right? To say, we're gonna do this ambitious thing, we don't know how we're gonna get there, and we're gonna figure it out together. Let's go. I also think that they would talk about your sense of humor. I do I think it's one of your leadership traits that a lot of people would name and recognize.

SPEAKER_01How do you think about that? How would you describe the way that your humor shows up in your leadership?

SPEAKER_00Well, I think ideally every educator, every student is bringing their full selves to school every day, and that they feel comfortable bringing their three-dimensionality and all of their identities and all their beliefs and loves and hangups to their place of work and learning. Um, humor has always been for me a tool to connect with people, um, to be relatable, to break tension, to get me in trouble oftentimes when I cross lines that I shouldn't, but also then a key to bringing reconnection when I have gone too far or I have hurt somebody in ways that I shouldn't have and caused harm.

SPEAKER_00I depend on humor as a salve for certain. I think I can I use it also in an in a satiric way, sometimes to make up a political point. Not a political point, but you know, maybe help people who might disagree with me see a different perspective in a new light. And sometimes humor's a lot more effective in helping people see new perspectives than a factoid um or an attempt at reason.

SPEAKER_00I don't know. That's an interesting question, Ryan. I'd have to think more about that too. But it it's something that I also think schools fundamentally need to be places more often of joy, and I think our school community in Casco Bay, really post-pandemic, made that a priority because it it felt like the joy was siphoned from so many of our lives during that year behind screens, and it was psychically for so many kids and so many adults. And so making joy a priority, and then it's okay, it's great if kids are laughing in a classroom and laughing in a hallway.

SPEAKER_00That isn't uh misbehavior. That's in fact uh really healthy human behavior that we as adults should not only celebrate but model ourselves.

SPEAKER_01That's important to think about the way that one, I certainly think coming back from the pandemic for anyone in any field was uh a time to really bring back the human side of things. And people are people are people, and and that means that they're full of all sorts of complexities and quirks, and I know I certainly am. And I I think if you're gonna work with folks and we're the real people, like you you're gonna have to hold some level of sense of humor about yourself, about each other, about the ridiculous the absurdity of just what it means to try to make a change in the world.

SPEAKER_00And I think teachers and educators so often um focus on the kid they haven't reached and what they haven't done rather than all the good things they have done in the day and all that they have achieved with a whole bunch of kids. And so it's an incredibly humbling profession each and every day. But humor also helps alleviate some of that um tendency to that can lead to cynicism, that can lead to feeling demoralized if you just laugh at yourself and it's just part of the game, and that um again, you're gonna you're gonna take five steps backwards for every six step forward.

SPEAKER_00And it it isn't a one-to-two ratio. Sometimes you go back many more than one step to get forward three or four.

SPEAKER_01Right. Very true. All right. I've uh a question that I'm gonna try to prompt you to tell a story. Okay. I'm only gonna use two words and we'll see if you can tell the story. And I got to hear in person. The two words are bunny bunny.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So one of the great joys and essential parts of my leadership time at Casco Bay High School is that I got to I had to run an advisory and we met what you know in Expertin' Learning World, they call crew, and we met for about a half hour every day, four every day of the week, and I'd stay with the same group sometimes for four years. And as a school principal, it was great for me to have to actually be with kids and help manage and help kids learn and grow every single day that I couldn't just be kind of wagging my feet fingers at teachers.

SPEAKER_00Why don't you do this or that? Because I it was very real for me. And I had kids who were awesome and kids who were super challenging for me. And just because I was the principal, they didn't all sit and behave and do everything I asked them to do. So it was actually it was a classic educational experience. Like in the same part of my career where I was getting lots of super lovely attention, like you mentioned in the beginning. I had a new advisory group, and on the first day of school, we'd do lots of get to know you games, and I'm kind of an extroverted guy, as maybe you can tell.

SPEAKER_00And I love games and I love doing all sorts of silly stuff, and my silly tolerance has endless. I have no shame, I don't get embarrassed. It's a sad, scary trait. And sometimes I forget that adolescents might have slightly different dispositions. And so I just, yeah, there was a particular year where in the start of the year, I was just going whole hog on some games where you're you're wagging your arms and you're making silly noises and you're jumping up and down, and it just kid after kid in my advisor group were just.

SPEAKER_00Statues and just looking at me like, when will the misery stop? When will the overzealous chimpanzee in front of me please go to sleep? It was like one of those kind of organ grinders that a monkey kind of clapping my hands and making lots of noise. And the kids were just not buying it. And it was just one of those reminders as a leader was like, you got a long way to go, brother. You may, you may have some good days, and I think you're pretty good at what you do sometimes. But it just brought me down to size and reminded me of every day is a new challenge.

SPEAKER_00And the kids you're working with today don't care at all about how great you did with the kids you had yesterday.

SPEAKER_01That's true.

SPEAKER_00You gotta re-earn it each and every day. And you gotta meet the kids where they are, right? And it was also a situation, I think, as I recall that I had had a group that loved doing these games. And so you think, oh, sure fire. This worked with last year's group, and then was that recognition, oh my God, every kid is of course different, and every kid has different buttons that you gotta push to motivate them, and I gotta not just impose it because I'm loud principle man, but I have to meet the kids where they are and figure out their particular paths of success.

SPEAKER_01That's really fascinating. I think the idea that every different group of people you're gonna encounter is gonna be the alchemy, right, between you and those other people. It's not just I do this every time and it's a winner. There are some go-to moves that tend to work lots of times, and then sometimes they're just not people aren't having it that day. Or they're you just have to know each other, right? It's not about being good, it's about being good at each other.

SPEAKER_00Right. Oh, that's so sad.

SPEAKER_01I will I will add a more of the bunny bunny story for anyone who's listening and wants to uh get into the weeds of that story. Uh in the show notes, you will find a video um of of more conversation um from Derek uh and it will help illuminate more about what is the bunny bunny about. Um I have one last question, and then and my question for you is you recently stepped down from your leadership role at Casco Bay after 19 years uh as a founding leader and someone who this is the bulk of your career.

SPEAKER_01I don't know if you describe it that way, but it it certainly is the biggest rock. Um and you said something in the Portland Herald Press. You said, it's super hard to leave something you love. I may never have a job that is as fulfilling, as important, as meaningful as what I have now, you said as you were on your way out. But I knew it had to happen, and the school is in an excellent place right now, and I feel the timing is right. It's ready for new leadership. And my question for you is how do you know, or how did you know, that it was the right time to pass on the baton and to take on a new chapter?

SPEAKER_01It can be hard to make that choice, especially when things are good, or when you're in a place you feel comfortable or you've it's called home. How do you know when it's time to move on?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thanks for asking that. It was super hard, and it and it took several years of thinking about it, and thinking about it from two lenses. One, when's the right time for me, and when is the right time for the school. I had a deep fear of being a guy that other people would whisper out, like it used to be a good principal, you know, as I was like carrying on with the same joke that I told six years ago and in a school assembly or something.

SPEAKER_00And I also know that as a leader, even as I tried to be ever growing and evolving as the school did, that I had blind spots and I had habits and I had kind of lazy thoughts or patterns that cause harm over time. And every institution needs a new perspective and new leaders to keep it growing. And so I felt like I owed it to the school at a certain point to make sure they had the opportunity to grow and not there is a weight under me because I'd been there forever and people didn't want to disappoint me, or they thought it had to be this way because I wanted it that way, or something.

SPEAKER_00And and that's not healthy for the school if the leader is taking up too much of the school culture or the school's identity, because this the school needs to live on way beyond me and continue to evolve and grow in ways I couldn't imagine, and in ways that the institution are good for the kids and the people in it, and not necessarily consonant with whatever I might think or not think. So it felt right, it felt I I I you know during the pandemic, I felt like, oh god, I I it would not be a time to try and bring in a new leader during that. So I really wanted to make it through the pandemic and help the school not only rebound but grow to a new place.

SPEAKER_00And once that had transpired, it felt like it was time for me to step aside. And for me, it it was scary because I can't imagine work more meaningful or work where I felt more a part of a kind of beloved community in an omnidirectional way. But I knew that I have to challenge myself to try and grow in ways that just as we ask kids to leave high school and head to this new thing. It's fun. My my younger daughter just graduated from college and we're helping each other with LinkedIn, and she's she's teaching me ways to interact with the new job-seeking world in ways that I've haven't had to do in uh 30 years.

SPEAKER_00But that's healthy. And one of my friends was counseling me that just to make sure that learning is a part of my everyday as I begin thinking about this next chapter, and that's been super helpful to realize that I have had this label of high school principal for the last 23 years of my life, but I'm more than that label. I'm a series of dispositions and experiences and beliefs that can be applied in all sorts of ways. And my challenge is to find a way where I can use who I am to be of most service in some new venture.

SPEAKER_00So that's that's my current challenge.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a pretty great challenge to have in front of you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I feel super fortunate

SPEAKER_01to be

SPEAKER_00able to have that challenge.

SPEAKER_01Well, Derek, I feel really fortunate to have had this chance to talk with you over the last hour.

SPEAKER_00That's so fun, Ryan. Thank you. Thanks for making the space to do this. It's really really lovely.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Derek, you said this thing. You said keep tinkering towards better and to keep loving your people with intention relentlessly. And I can't think of a better way to end the conversation than with your own words.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much, Ryan.

SPEAKER_01Derek, thank you so much for joining us and for giving us the gift of your leadership story and the insight.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much, and thanks for sharing these stories. And I look forward to listening to uh other folks' tales.

SPEAKER_01They're pretty good, and I know that this is one of those stories that's gonna really help others in their own journey to lead for exceptional social good. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Thanks, Ryan.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for joining us today and collecting gems for the work that you are doing to lead for good. A reminder that you are not alone. There are hundreds of thousands of leaders who are striving in the work of leading for social good. Often, like you, they are doing that work uphill, under-resourced, and all too often without the systemic structures that would make that work easier. But I know you didn't sign up for easy. You signed up to make a difference. So when you're having that day, when you think you should throw in the towel, when you think it's too much, when you think, who am I to believe that I can move this mountain?

SPEAKER_01Please know these three things. One, you can't do it alone. Two, you're not alone. And three, you don't have to move the mountain. You just have to climb it with us. Exceptionally good is a passion project coordinated, constructed, edited, and published entirely by me with musical help from the brilliant and generous Ryan Raditz. We offer this content free of charge and with no limits to access. We do seek to cover our costs, not for profit, because that's not the point.

SPEAKER_01Money is money, reputation is gold, but impact in the world is everything. Here's three ways you can help. Donate on our donor box, become a patron of the show, or nominate an exceptionally good leader to be a guest and join us to talk about their story. Those links are in the show notes and on our website, exceptionallygood.org. Yours for the good, Ryan.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 36. David Adams — From Echo Company to Emotional Intelligence

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    This week on the show, I’m delighted to welcome David Adams, Chief Executive Officer of the Urban Assembly. David is one of those leaders who has spent his career asking a simple question with a complex answer: What...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 35. Daneen Keaton - On Leading Liberated

    Nov 10, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    Our guest is Daneen Keaton, Founder & Executive Director of Lead Liberated, whose bold vision is working to reshape how educational leaders reckon with equity, power, and anti-racist practice. Daneen’s work as an...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 34. Morgan Blum Schneider — Director of the JFCS Holocaust Center on Memory, Courage, and Confronting Hate

    Oct 27, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    This week on Exceptionally Good, we're joined by Morgan Blum Schneider, Director of the JFCS Holocaust Center in San Francisco - a leader who has spent more than two decades turning the hardest chapters of history into...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 33. Ron Berger, a leader in the Rebel Alliance: Why Not Give People Important Work to Do Now?

    May 4, 20261 hr 21 minAudio

    This episode, I have the immense pleasure and privilege of talking with a mentor and a friend - Ron Berger. Ron is a powerful voice and leader in education as an author of best-selling books such as A Culture of Quality...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 32. Ryan Maxwell: The Host Becomes the Guest - The Table Is Turned (and So Is the Mic!) - Feat. Felicia Lee

    Apr 27, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    This week, we're turning the tables - or in this case, the microphone. I'm Ryan Maxwell, and today, I'm the guest. Guest hosted by Felicia Lee, founder of Campana Leadership Group, who leads executive coaching. Years...

    Credit the people on this episode