Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

EVERYTHING EPSTEIN, with Jay Beecher

EVERYTHING EPSTEIN, with Jay Beecher artwork

EPISODE THREE: Victim or Villain? - The SHOCKING Truth About Virginia Giuffre

Jan 8, 20261 hr 25 minAudioSeason 1, Episode 3
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

WARNING: Adult content. Listen to episode three of EVERYTHING EPSTEIN, in which I go through some shocking highlights of Virginia Giuffre’s troubled life, her false allegations, her unsettling history of recruiting girls for Jeffrey Epstein, and reveal some exclusive audio clips from my interviews with key witnesses. You can listen to past and future episodes on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Substack, and YouTube. Please remember to help get the truth out by sharing this episode on social media. Thank you. Jay Beecher’s Substack is reader-supported. To receive new posts, exclusive interviews, and to support his work, please consider becoming a paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.jaybeecher.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Thanks for tuning in again to my podcast Everything Epstein where I explore every aspect of the Jeffrey Epstein scandal and cover some of my five-year investigation

SPEAKER_00interviewing key witnesses and unearthing new evidence. In the last episode, episode two, I covered Epstein's first arrest, the schoolgirls who led to his conviction and the real recruiters who brought them to Jeffrey's home. In today's episode, I'll be going through the life of the most famous Jeffrey Epstein accuser of all, Virginia Giffray. Without Virginia, there would be no so-called Epstein scandal at all, no claims of client lists, no media manipulation or press pressure against Donald Trump,

SPEAKER_00and Andrew Mountbatten would still be called Prince Andrew. So grab a coffee, get comfortable, and prepare to become uncomfortable as I dive straight in. Loxahatchee sits quietly in Palm Beach County, the kind of semi-rural sprawl that feels sun-bleached even when the sky is overcast, fretted by slow dark water from the river that snakes its way through and past luscious green vegetation. Ranch homes, scrubland,

SPEAKER_00horses behind wire fencing, the sort of place that barely registers to anyone outside Florida except as a vague promise of space. It was here, in and around that landscape that Virginia Louise Roberts grew up. The version of this story that the world has come to recognise tends to begin later, with private jets and court filings and a photograph in the London townhouse. But the roots of it, the roots of the persona and the claims and the contradictions that would eventually swallow entire reputations whole,

SPEAKER_00begin in something far less cinematic, a family home, two parents and a horse. Virginia's father, Sky Roberts, is typically described as a working man, a handyman by trade, a somewhat strange, local Stetson-wearing character-cum-cross-dresser with an affection for horses, someone whose own personal lore reached back to old Sacramento's wooden sidewalks and gold-rush ghost stories. Virginia's mother, Lynn, worked as a bank manager,

SPEAKER_00was by most accounts well-liked and steady and, according to relatives quoted in various reports, came from money. The family lived comfortably. There were holidays. There was a trust fund for Virginia set up by her maternal grandmother. There were expectations that come with being raised in a home where the adults believe, at least for a while, that the future is something you plan for, not something from which you escape. And this matters, not as a morality tale, not as an argument that stability immunises anyone from harm,

SPEAKER_00but because so much of what came later depended on a particular framing, that Virginia was already abandoned, already living in an unbroken spiral of deprivation and chaos long before Epstein ever existed in her orbit. The record and the testimony people have offered about those early years points to a picture that is more complicated than that and in places at odds with the shorthand the public absorbed. However, the first fracture in that early life is described by multiple

accounts as

SPEAKER_00beginning inside the family's world rather than outside of it. Virginia accused her father's friend, Forrest Jones, of sexual abuse. And then there is another allegation, the one that sits like a live wire beneath everything else, rarely handled carefully and too often used as a blunt instrument in public argument, or even not mentioned at all. Virginia had also accused her father of abusing her. She claimed that her father Skye and his friend had been,

SPEAKER_00in her words, swapping daughters, that when her father wasn't abusing her, he traded her for Forrest Jones' daughter, and that both men would then abuse Virginia and Jones' daughter time and time again. Skye Roberts has completely denied this. Virginia's family, despite recently demanding transparency in all abuse cases, have failed entirely to comment on the allegation. In cases like this, an allegation doesn't simply land on a household like a stone

thrown as a window.

SPEAKER_00It becomes the window. It becomes the air. It splits loyalties and rearranges relationships and turns memory into a battlefield where every adult thinks they are protecting the child. but not always in the same direction. The marriage faltered. Sky Roberts briefly moved away to the hometown of his friend Forrest Jones, who was later convicted of abusing another child, and the household atmosphere shifted entirely. At the time, the accusation created a rift, with belief and suspicion pulling at the same rope.

SPEAKER_00The family's sense of itself began to buckle, and as the household destabilised, Virginia was sent to live with her aunt Carol Roberts, a move that was later presented as an attempt to impose order on a life that was already slipping its leash. Carol is consistently described as Mormon, committed to restraint and routine, someone who did not drink, smoke or even consume caffeine. In later retellings, she is framed as a figure of structure and stability, the adult who believed the teenager needed boundaries,

SPEAKER_00not indulgence. The intention, at least as it's been described, was to remove Virginia from a home turned turbulent by accusation and fallout and bring her into a strict, calmer environment. But Virginia didn't seem to want it. What happened next was Virginia ran from one place to another, staying with friends, taking drugs and further spiralling out of control. Her father eventually moved back with her mother and quite soon Virginia herself came back to join them,

SPEAKER_00writing in her unpublished memoir, The Billionaire's Playboy Club, that she enjoyed spending time with both her parents, sitting outside the house with them and her siblings amidst bonfires and carefree chat. The teenage years that followed have been described in multiple ways. But the through line, even in sympathetic accounts, is rebellion, substance abuse, running away, drifting between boyfriends, refusing to be contained. Virginia's early life was not a simple, linear slide from innocence to catastrophe.

SPEAKER_00It was already defined by serious allegations, by family fracture, by adults disagreeing over what was true and what was not, and by a young woman who, long before Epstein, was already moving through a life marked by conflict, defiance and claims and allegations that would later become part of her public identity. And this is where the story begins to acquire its permanent shape. Not, definitely not, as a neat art, but as a pattern. What happened next, after Lot Xahachi,

SPEAKER_00after Forrest Jones, after the allegation against Skye Roberts, Virginia's father, and his denial, was the institutional phase of Virginia's adolescence, the facilities, the rehab environments, the orbit of problem child programs and drifting nights out and the beginnings of a documented pattern that would later show up again louder in court filings and depositions. Rebelling even further, Virginia would often spend days and nights drinking alcohol, taking drugs and prostituting herself for cash.

By the mid to late 1990s, her behaviour had escalated to the point that the People around her were no longer dealing with ordinary teenage rebellion.

SPEAKER_00Friends later described her as frequently absent from school, already immersed in substance abuse, already drifting into a life that didn't require permission. She was taken to a rehabilitation facility and a school of sorts for troubled children, whereby she'd study during the day and head off to foster parents come night time. But Virginia frequently ran away from those too. She lived with boyfriends, with punters, clients, and she couch surfed through the underbelly of Palm Beach County, moving through social circles where older men,

parties and transactional relationships were not the exception but the norm,

SPEAKER_00the atmosphere. Later on, she framed these years as survival, as escape, as exploitation, as a kind of wild freedom that later curdled into something darker. She claimed that she'd spent large chunks of time on the streets homeless. But records and contemporaneous documentation, however, complicate the image of sustained homelessness. When she wasn't with boyfriends, she was in fact placed with temporary foster families. She was also staying with friends, as they've confirmed.

SPEAKER_00It doesn't seem that she was homeless at all. That doesn't make the period safe or stable. It simply makes it less cinematic than the later retellings. Less sleeping under bridges, more moving between friends and adults. And then in 1998 came the allegation that would later loom over everything like a precedent. Virginia accused two teenage boys, her friends Kevin and Josh, of raping her. According to the account contained in law enforcement documentation from that

SPEAKER_00period that I have obtained, Virginia said she had been drinking and smoking marijuana with a group of young people in a wooded area near West Palm Beach. She claimed she passed out and later woke up to being sexually assaulted by Kevin and Josh, describing an ordeal she said lasted for hours. The boys, however, when later located and interviewed by police, maintained that the encounter was consensual and described it as a freesome. One witness I interviewed said that she had engaged in sexual activity with more

SPEAKER_00than just two young men that night. Either way, Kevin and Josh cooperated with police. They didn't vanish. They did not lawyer up and disappear into silence. They spoke. One of them said that after the group had been drinking, he urged Virginia to sleep and that she responded by asking him to keep her awake before initiating further sexual contact. Another detail that sits in the narrative like grit is that she went back to one of their houses after having sex with them. Police continued their investigations.

SPEAKER_00Virginia's mother, according to the investigative notes, told a detective about her daughter's history of drug abuse and claimed she'd simply got in with a bad crowd, accusing local teens of drinking excessively and engaging, bizarrely, in satanic worship. And then the case reached the point most people never bother to read and the press certainly don't put in print because it doesn't make for an easy headline and doesn't fit the narrative. Holes were found in Virginia's story, numerous contradictions.

SPEAKER_00A previous report whereby she'd made an allegation of rape, yet was instead found to have been giving a partner oral sex on someone's front lawn. Prosecutors declined to pursue charges. The stated reason that the court gave was that the matter was mired by inconsistencies and that there was concern about Virginia's lack of credibility and the likelihood that there would be no success at trial. In other words, the state did not simply shrug its shoulders. It investigated, it assessed and it decided it did not have a case it believed

it could prove.

SPEAKER_00It did not believe Virginia Giffray. Years later, Virginia would tell the world that she had been held captive, raped, trafficked to the powerful, the rich, impregnated, forced into abortions, forced into a life that she did not choose, a life in which she was not an actor but a prisoner. The mythology would congeal around that. the public would begin to treat doubt itself as a kind of moral crime. Back in the late 1990s, before Epstein,

SPEAKER_00before Andrew, before Maxwell, the records show something more ordinary and more unsettling. a teenager in crisis making an allegation, allegations that authorities ultimately did not pursue because she was not a credible witness and because the evidence appeared to show that she was lying. That was not the only contradiction that would later appear when Virginia tried to explain her pre-Epstein years. In a memoir draft written much later, long after she had become a global figure,

SPEAKER_00she introduced another storyline into her adolescence, one involving an older man, Ron Eppinger. In that narrative, that story, she described being abused, being sold onward to an associate, and a police raid that supposedly occurred whilst she was present. It reads like a scene designed to prove, retroactively, that she had already been trafficked before Jeffrey Epstein, that the world had already marked her. But the problem is that the details do not neatly connect to verifiable records,

and her own interviews and statements over the years completely contradict each other.

SPEAKER_00In one version, she claimed she'd been raped at gunpoint, walked to the beach dripping with blood, and that Ron Eppinger bundled her into a white van. In a second version, she made no mention of the rape or the gun and said that she'd been sitting on the beach begging for money to buy food and that Eppinger appeared in a stretch limo and invited to take her back to his apartment. In yet another version, she claimed that Eppinger trafficked her to a man named Charlie, that she was laying in his bed and that suddenly his home was raided and Charlie was arrested. But there has been no clear trace of the Charlie figure

described in that story.

SPEAKER_00No police records, no such arrests found on any database. And while a man named Ron Eppinger did exist and his case was high profile and he was later imprisoned, the charges associated with him make no mention of Virginia. Even Virginia's own aunt, Carol, whom she remained close to and who has spoken in other contexts about Virginia's life, reportedly indicated that she had never heard this allegation from Virginia at the time and only became aware of it years later through the press

after the Prince

SPEAKER_00Andrew narrative had begun to dominate the headlines. Again, it's proof of a pattern that a pattern where the past is rewritten in later drafts, where new convenient villains appear long after the fact, where timelines grow more dramatic as the stakes grow higher, where the story expands and expands and expands, and where Virginia attempts to insert herself into other people's timelines to portray herself as a victim. By the end of the 1990s,

Virginia was no longer simply a troubled teenager bouncing between adults and

SPEAKER_00institutions – She was a young woman with a documented history of instability, substance abuse, false accusations, prostitution, and at least one major allegation that the state declined to prosecute on credibility grounds. She was also, by multiple accounts, charismatic, sexualised in presentation, and already learning the power of narrative, the power of attention, the power of being the person in the room whose story takes up all the oxygen. Philip Guderian was one of Virginia's former friends whom she

dated when they were

SPEAKER_00both in their late teens. The following is an excerpt from an audio recording of him talking to me about Virginia when I interviewed him.

SPEAKER_01I met Virginia first when we were about 14 or 15 years old. It was in a little rehab for juvenile adolescents in Lake Worth, Florida. At that time, we, you know, we messed around in rehab. And when I first met her, she's always been a very sexual girl. Like, anything she does, like just walking and talking, she's sexual about her eyes. She'll flirt with you. Like, she knew what she was doing, too. Like, it's like she used that as her advantage. She would make people melt. know that in groups she talked about sexual things and there

was just some sad stuff she was pretty much taking advantage i'll say that i won't go into detail and that she was pretty much exploited so in that way she learned at a young age what she had and how to use it how to manipulate how to connive you know and uh so she

SPEAKER_01loved to have sex she loved to use sex as her weapon She would love to fuck. She would care. She would two people go over. She loved to suck dick. She would fuck. She would, like, anything. In her ass. She was just, fuck. She was down for whatever, bro. Yeah. Ninfo, it wasn't so much as a ninfo. She had to have it all the time. It was more of, like, she liked different dudes and she liked to try different shit. If she was with you for a minute and she was just fucking you, it's not going to last for long because she's going to fuck

somebody else.

SPEAKER_01So there's no loyalty there and shit. She just liked to have multiple sexual partners, I guess. Virginia knows me real well and so does her boyfriend, Anthony Figueroa at the time. And I was selling him some weed and she was there. And she was there and we were just bullshitting talking. She said, hey, I got a billionaire. And I said, yeah, right. Like, we get millionaires all the time because we're from Palm Beach, you know. I know a lot of strippers and all kinds of girls. So I didn't believe her at first. And she came out and showed me a nice amount of money.

SPEAKER_01And I started believing it. Nothing had to have been said. We looked at each other and I seen the amount of money. You don't just massage a man for $20,000, $30,000, you know. You don't. Rubbing oil. I don't care if you're naked or not. You know what you're required of you to do. She didn't have to say anything. I knew she was doing it. That was her only tool. That was her only skill she had. She had no other skill about trying to please a man. That's what she was brought up and taught to do. I made a comment when they're both right there,

SPEAKER_01like, ah, you got to fuck the old man with wrinkly balls, huh? And she was like, they're not wrinkly, you know, she's not that old. And I was like, oh, cool. So that says it. Yeah, she definitely had to fuck them. I mean, and she would use her sexiness or whatever. She was like a sexy little kid. I mean, that's what she was. I wouldn't doubt that they would all want her.

SPEAKER_00In 1999, the next pivot came in Virginia's life. Her father, Sky Roberts, got her a job where he worked. And the stage that would later become... In 1999, the next pivot came in Virginia's life. Her father, Sky Roberts, got her a job where he worked. And the stage that would later be presented as the origin point of everything had a name that would make the story feel preordained, even though it wasn't. Mar-a-Lago. Mar-a-Lago is the kind of place that makes ordinary people feel

like they've

SPEAKER_00accidentally walked onto a film set. Palm fronds, manicured gravel, white columns that pretend the 20th century never happened, the ocean nearby, the money very, very close, the rules mostly for the staff. It's not a nightclub. It's not a back alley scene. It's a workplace with uniforms and time cards and the quiet hierarchy of who gets to be seen and who is paid to disappear into the background. And that matters because everything Virginia later claimed about her origin story

SPEAKER_00depends on Mar-a-Lago feeling like a gateway to something sinister, something covert, something that could swallow a girl whole in broad daylight without anybody noticing. Yet the version of events she offered over the years did not stay fixed. It mutated, it shuffled, it contradicted itself in ways that weren't just minor memory slips, but structural changes to the same key scenes. In the simplest, earliest framing, Virginia's father helped her get that job.

SPEAKER_00He was by then employed at the club as a maintenance manager, well-respected, embedded in the machinery that keeps a rich place running, the plumbing, the wiring, the repairs people never think about because everything just works. Donald Trump, Mar-a-Lago's owner, even wrote him a glowing reference, and Sky arranged for his daughter to work part-time there as a spa attendant. Though it was just sitting at a desk and occasionally making teas and coffees and folding the end of toilet rolls into neat triangles, it was nonetheless a real job.

SPEAKER_00It was legal, paid. It was a routine, a chance, at least in theory, to pull her life back towards something normal. At this point, when she went to work at Mar-a-Lago, Virginia was 17. That number is not a footnote. It's a load-bearing beam. Because later, as the Epstein narrative hardened into global mythology, Virginia repeatedly changed and shifted that age downward. She lied that she had been 14. Then she said that she was 15.

SPEAKER_00Then 16. A child, not a teenager, on the cusp of adulthood. The difference is not cosmetic. The difference changes everything. In her unpublished memoir, The Billionaire's Playboy Club, she wrote that she had spent her sweet 16th birthday on Epstein's island, receiving designer makeup as a present, being told she'd soon be too old for Geoffrey's taste. It reads like a scene, it plays like a scene, it also, as a matter of chronology, is a complete lie. Then there is the moment she described as a fatal encounter.

SPEAKER_00Virginia's standard telling goes like this. She was on duty, outside a locker room, reading a book about massage techniques. Glenn Maxwell approached her. Maxwell struck up a conversation. Maxwell offered to introduce her to Jeffrey Epstein for work. It's neat, isn't it? A perfect little hinge in a story. A wealthy, glamorous woman plucking a girl from the worky shadows of a luxury club. A casual conversation that becomes a lifetime's headline. But the problem is that when Virginia told this story across time,

SPEAKER_00she couldn't keep the same architecture standing. Start with the trip to Epstein's Palm Beach home. The so-called first visit, the interview. In one version, she claimed that she was driven by her father. In another, she claims she was driven by her mother. In another version still, she claimed her father waited outside and that she went in alone before being abused by Epstein and Maxwell. In another version, she claimed that her father was greeted by Epstein himself. In her own memoir draft, The Billionaire's Playboy Club,

she wrote a very specific sequence. Her father drove her there, walked her up to the front door, they rang the doorbell, and an older man in a butler uniform greeted them and asked them to wait because Ms.

SPEAKER_00Maxwell would be arriving any minute. And yet, later under oath, She admitted that that didn't happen at all. Later, she insisted that Maxwell answered the door. That is not a small inconsistency. That is a completely different cast, a different staging, a different scene. First it was Epstein. Then it was a butler. Then just Maxwell. Waiting in the entryway versus being led by Maxwell. Father present versus father not present. Mother present versus mother not present.

SPEAKER_00These are mutually exclusive shapes for the same moment. Her father's testimony created another crack. Sky Roberts, in the version he offered, said he'd never met Maxwell at all, and Virginia was forced, in later litigation, to accept that her father did not meet Maxwell. The phrasing in the court context is blunt. Virginia did not contest his testimony, that Epstein came out, greeted him, and that he never met Ghislaine Maxwell.

SPEAKER_00And then Maxwell, in her own deposition, offered yet another account, one that undercut Virginia's most dramatic claims about what could have happened in that time window. Maxwell said Virginia was driven by her mother, not her father. Maxwell claimed she was outside speaking to Virginia's mother during the visit and that the events Virginia later alleged could not possibly have occurred as described if she was outside the entire time. So there you have three irreconcilable versions of the first visit. each linked to the same supposed origin moment,

SPEAKER_00each pulling the story in a different direction. And then there's what Virginia originally told the press when her story first became a commodity. In the 2011 Daily Mail piece, the one Sharon Churcher, a journalist from Britain, paid for. Virginia is recorded as describing being told to go upstairs and being led by another woman, not Maxwell, another woman. The phrasing matters because it anchors the story before later lawsuits made Maxwell a more convenient target.

SPEAKER_00In that original telling, Virginia confirmed that Maxwell did not engage sexually with her. The person who instructs her, who leads her up the stairs, is unnamed and clearly identified as not being Glenn Maxwell. But later, as legal strategy and public narrative shifted, Maxwell becomes the door opener, the upstairs guide, the presence in the room, the one implicated in hands-on wrongdoing. despite Virginia beforehand not accusing Glenn Maxwell at all, and despite there being no evidence that Maxwell was involved.

SPEAKER_00This is the heartbeat of the problem. The story's most crucial elements, the elements that should be solid if they are true and Virginia was telling the truth, have changed depending on the needs of the moment. The contradictions did not stop, though, at who answered the door. Virginia claimed that after that first meeting she returned to Epstein time and time again, that she worked as his travelling masseuse, and that she was kept essentially as a sex slave. Initially, Virginia repeatedly claimed she was Epstein's sex slave for four years,

SPEAKER_00a phrase that became part of the public incantation. Yet the same record she relied on elsewhere shows she ceased contact with Epstein by September 2002 when she left the United States and went to Thailand. Even if you take Virginia's highest contact timeline and squeeze it until it hurts, you cannot possibly get four years. You get at the very, very most two years that she was in Jeffrey Epstein's orbit. Virginia lied that she was 14 to further exaggerate her story,

SPEAKER_00falsely present herself as a naive, impressionable child, to make her story more saleable to the press and to get sympathy from the public. Other accounts suggest that her total time in Epstein's orbit was just a matter of mere months. And there's reason to believe this, because threaded through her ever-changing claims is another quiet contradiction that doesn't get the attention it deserves. The fact that she omitted jobs from her timeline. When questioned later about her employment history, she stated that Mar-a-Lago was the first job she could recall

ever holding. But employment records and other accounts clearly show that she was in fact holding a string of jobs before and even during the period she falsely claimed to be in

SPEAKER_00exclusive captivity of Epstein. One example that appears in the surrounding material is her working at the Roadhouse Grill in Palm Beach, where she was accused of stealing money from her employer. She also worked at KFC, at Taco Bell, and as a receptionist at a veterinarian's office. The reality that she was not a sex slave at all, nor was she some sort of prisoner, she lived in her own apartment, she went out with friends, and she freely and willingly went to Epstein's house whenever she wanted to make some money. Now that

Life is hard to reconcile with the cinematic portrait of a girl held captive,

SPEAKER_00isolated, controlled in the way the word slave suggests. At first, Virginia was actually engaged to a boy called Michael Ostrich. They rented an apartment in Palm Beach, paid for by Epstein, and they planned to get married. They planned a future together. And now we arrive, however, at Tony Figueroa, because the story is never just the rich people. It's the boyfriends, the friends, the messy ordinary relationships that don't behave like a tidy

victim narrative.

SPEAKER_00Whilst she was engaged to Michael, Virginia started having an affair with drug dealer Tony Figueroa. She then kicked Michael out of the apartment and during the entire time she knew Jeffrey Epstein, she lived with and was in a relationship with Tony. She and Tony shared the same social network of friends. They smoked weed together. They partied together. And when Virginia wasn't heading off to make money from Epstein, they spent every day in each other's company. Soon, Virginia was 18, a legal adult.

She'd left her job at Mar-a-Lago and she was working at a restaurant whilst occasionally going back to Epstein to make quick money by prostituting herself.

SPEAKER_00The Virginia to fray the world was sold. The one preserved in the language of captivity and omnipotent control is hard to square with a young woman who had boyfriends, who freely came and went, who kept returning to familiar people, who had a mobile phone, a car, and who smoked weed, headed out to prostitute herself, and then came back again with stacks of cash. I know that this is hard to understand, and it's hard for me to say because I get a lot of abuse for it, but this was not captivity.

SPEAKER_00nor was it sexual slavery. Virginia, by her own choice, had become a prostitute. Virginia's relationship with Tony Figueroa sits alongside other accounts from people around her who described her not as someone chained to a basement, but as someone who moved in and out of Epstein's world, sometimes for a day or two at a time, and then returned to the life she was living in Palm Beach. That's not a moral defence, it's not exoneration for Epstein by any stretch of the imagination,

SPEAKER_00but its structure, it's a map. Another boyfriend of Virginia's, Anthony Valadere's, said that she would brag about briefly going to, as she put it, the millionaire's house and then coming back with cash. She wrote in her original memoir that she considered Jeffrey Epstein a boyfriend of sorts. And when I interviewed Tony Figueroa, he touched upon something even more shocking, something that Virginia herself admitted to, but that the media and press refused to report.

SPEAKER_00Virginia wasn't content with just making money by prostituting herself. she wanted to make even more. Jeffrey Epstein had casually suggested that she bring him new women to provide him with sexualised massages to satisfy his degenerate, out-of-control lust. For each new woman she brought him, she would be paid a few hundred dollars as a finder's fee, and Virginia, of her own volition, decided to become Jeffrey Epstein's recruiter.

SPEAKER_00But although Epstein had mentioned nothing about underage girls, he did not ask Virginia to bring him underage girls. Virginia took it upon herself and decided that the easiest females to exploit in her local area were the local school children, girls around 14 and 15 years of age. She stalked them out with Tony in local schools. She offered them a way to make quick cash by massaging a local millionaire. She dressed them up in more adult clothes, she put makeup on them,

SPEAKER_00and then she drove them to Epstein's home. And this truly is the shocking part and another thing that the media refuse to tell you. Virginia Giffray is well documented as having told each of these children that if Epstein or his staff members asked their ages, they had to lie and say that they were over 18. Until this point, there is no evidence at all to suggest that Jeffrey Epstein had ever been involved in any illegal activity with underage females.

And that is a hard pill to swallow because it's the complete opposite of what we've been told.

SPEAKER_00On the contrary, all of the women whom he surrounded himself with and who provided him with sexualised massages and daily company, sleazy as it was, are completely and clearly documented as being legal adults, usually in their early 20s. But Virginia Giffray chose to change that, and despite now being presented to the world as a victim, she was in fact the very first recruiter who created victims. Another voice reinforcing this pattern was Crystal Figueroa,

SPEAKER_00Tony's sister, who recalled Virginia asking if he knew any, in her words, slutty girls who she could recruit and sell to Jeffrey Epstein. The language itself is telling, not because it's crude, but because it reflects a mindset in which recruitment had become normalised, even casual to Virginia. And in the following audio clip from when I interviewed Philip Guderian, he touches upon how Virginia even allegedly trained the underage girls whom she groomed and recruited.

SPEAKER_01She was definitely the head, when I say the head bitch, because I walked in the apartment one time, and there was four or five girls on the couch, and she all had them with dildos, showing them how to suck dick and how to jack off. That's not, doesn't seem like the actions of somebody's sex trafficking. They're at a place, an apartment where it's a rich area, like people can come and go. She really felt like she was a sex tracker, all this shit. She could have walked to the police station. She could have went outside and waved a red flag. I mean, come on. None of these girls were sex-smoking slaves. Hey, the girls had to be anywhere from 15, 16, 17 years old that, uh,

SPEAKER_01She had their teaching and training to come down to massage. They were supposed to just massage and walk around topless. That's what they were paid for. It was just eye candy.

SPEAKER_00For money, and without any care about the victims she was creating, Virginia groomed and recruited a long list of underage girls, sent them to Epstein, duped him into believing that they were over 18, and then left. with wads of cash. Later, when Epstein was arrested for engaging in sexual activity with some of the girls whom Virginia had trafficked to him, all of those girls admitted that they had been told to lie about their ages and that they had indeed lied about their ages to Jeffrey Epstein. Police made Epstein even take a lie detector test.

SPEAKER_00He was asked if he knew that any of the girls were underage. He answered no. And surprisingly, the lie detector test examiner concluded, that Jeffrey Epstein was telling the truth. Now this is not to say that Epstein was entirely innocent. In fact, his brother Mark Epstein told me that Jeffrey was not innocent. But it does highlight another uncomfortable mitigating factor in this entire scandal that the media have been hiding from you. A fact that debunks the claims that Epstein was a prolific

paedophile and proves

SPEAKER_00that Virginia was, in reality, not a victim, but a recruiter. A woman who, whilst a legal adult, groomed schoolgirls, got them to lie about their ages, duped Epstein into believing they were over 18, and, for money, she chose to create those victims. One of the schoolgirls who Virginia recruited, one of her victims, was named Carolyn Andriano. Carolyn was not an abstract figure or a marginal footnote.

She was a real child whose life intersected with Virginia's at a moment when

SPEAKER_00Virginia was no longer a minor herself. Following her usual MO, Virginia groomed Carolyn when she, Virginia, was over 18 and Carolyn was either 14 or 15. Virginia even admitted to doing this, yet never faced any legal consequences. The consequences of duping Carolyn into placing her trust in her, however, were devastating. Virginia told her, that she could help her make some extra money. She dressed her up in adult clothing.

SPEAKER_00She put makeup on her. She gave her drugs. She drove her to Jeffrey Epstein's home, told her to lie about her age, and then she led Carolyn up the stairs into the massage room. And while there, Virginia straddled Epstein and began to engage in sexual activity with him before coercing Carolyn, a child, to join in. Carolyn's later life was marked by instability, addiction, trauma and repeated attempts to regain control. When she died in 2023,

SPEAKER_00sadly found in a West Palm Beach hotel room, her death was treated as an isolated tragedy. It was not connected, in most reporting, to the chain of events that preceded it. Her mother, Dorothy Andreano, refused to accept that revisionism. She was and still is appalled by how the media have intentionally lied and have falsely presented her daughter's recruiter and abuser as a victim while ignoring Carolyn because her story undermines the established narrative.

SPEAKER_00Dorothy has spent years trying to tell her daughter's story, not as an addendum to someone else's narrative, but as a case in its own right. She has heavily criticised Virginia Giffray of grooming and exploiting Carolyn, of knowingly placing her in harm's way, and of later attempting to silence her with money when the possibility of legal action arose. I've interviewed Dorothy multiple times over the years, and she has provided a sworn witness statement to me, signed by a notarye,

and which I'll be publishing in full along with our interviews and my interviews with many of the key witnesses in the Epstein scandal in my upcoming book,

SPEAKER_00Naked Lies. Dorothy has always been consistent. She has named names and she has largely been ignored. I've travelled to see her. I've sat across from her as she recounted the same events again and again. Not because the story changes, but because she refuses to allow it to be buried. She is not polished. She does not self-edit. She speaks in long, impassioned bursts, sometimes stopping mid-sentence to apologise for shouting at me before continuing.

SPEAKER_00But she has a right to shout. The following is a short clip from one of my long interviews with Dorothy, in which she gives her opinion of Virginia Giffray.

SPEAKER_02She recruited young women. I used to get my daughter high. They were buying her cocaine. They were buying her alcohol. And I could see the difference in my daughter's attitude changing. Virginia, I think she should be behind fucking bars. She victimized my daughter. She victimized her. She's the one that recruited my daughter knowing what the fuck she was involved with, what she was doing, and knowing it was wrong. And she was getting paid good fucking money to do it.

SPEAKER_02Why is that girl still fucking walking around like a princess? You know what? I lay awake at night thinking about my daughter. At night thinking about all the shit that has happened and the people that are wrongfully accused. And the people that should be fucking accused and suffering are like living in paradise. Virginia Giuffre was never charged for her role in recruiting minors like Carolyn.

SPEAKER_00That fact remains unchanged. Her death, as sad as it is, does not alter it, nor does it erase the consequences borne by the families of her victims. The tragedy here is not singular, it's layered. Virginia Giuffre may have suffered some harm, but Carolyn Andriano unquestionably did suffer harm at the hands of Virginia Giuffre. The public, however, was told one story and shielded from another. Sympathy was directed upward towards Virginia,

while accountability drifted out of view.

SPEAKER_00After Virginia's death, the investigation did not end. It narrowed. It sharpened. It moved away from spectacle and toward documentation. That is where this story now resides. Not in slogans, not in mythology, but in records, testimony, and the voices that were never meant to be heard, that the media didn't want you to hear. If Carolyn Andreano's story exposes the human cost of what was left out of the public narrative, then the accounts provided by Virginia Giffray's former

partners and associates

SPEAKER_00explain how that cost accumulated over time, quietly, repeatedly, and largely without interference. Taken together, these accounts form a picture that is difficult to reconcile with the image later presented to the public, that of Virginia being a sex slave, a victim, or an innocent individual who was in complete total captivity. They depict, in fact, a young woman navigating a morally compromised environment with agency, intent, financial incentive,

SPEAKER_00and a criminal mindset. As Dorothy rightly says, Virginia knew what she was doing She knew that it was illegal. She knew that it would create victims of innocent young teenagers. But caring only about cash, she did it. None of this absolves Jeffrey Epstein. But it does matter. Because agency changes responsibility. And responsibility changes the story. The reluctance of the mainstream media and press to examine this aspect of Virginia

SPEAKER_00Giffray's life is not accidental. It destabilises the binary on which so much of the Epstein narrative depends. It forces uncomfortable questions about complicity, consent and exploitation within a system that was neither simple nor symmetrical. Carolyn Andriano

SPEAKER_00trusted Virginia, and so did many other miners. They saw a young woman, older than they were, who told them that they could make easy money and that everything would be okay, who drove them to Epstein's home and led them up the stairs. Yet Virginia had manipulated them, had groomed them and betrayed that trust, had sexually abused some of them while she was a legal adult, had coerced them into being abused by Epstein, and led them down a road in life that they could never come back from. And when the lives of those girls,

SPEAKER_00Virginia's victims, unravelled, they did so far from the cameras, far from the settlements and far from the moral certainty the public was offered. Put simply, prosecutors and the press ignored Virginia's victims and Virginia's crimes because they were inconvenient witnesses, inconvenient parts of the story. Witnesses who could fully prove that the public were being lied to about the entire Epstein scandal and, most importantly, that journalists were helping Virginia Giffray. a proven recruiter, falsely present herself as a victim.

SPEAKER_00Initially, however, Virginia avoided the spotlight. After ending her transactional relationship with Jeffrey Epstein in 2002, she fled to Thailand. She did this to evade an active warrant that had been put out for her arrest after she'd allegedly stolen money from the restaurant she was working in. In Thailand, she met and married Robert Giuffre, moved to Australia, had children, and moved on with her life. When the FBI began reinvestigating the Jeffrey Epstein scandal many, many years later,

SPEAKER_00they contacted Virginia to ask her to provide testimony, but Virginia, fully aware that she had in fact been a recruiter, not a victim, refused to cooperate with them. It wasn't until she saw other women filing lawsuits and saw that they were receiving huge compensation payouts and was then put in touch with lawyers who protected her and who wanted to represent her and who wanted to get money from her and for her, that she decided to come forward and try her luck at claiming

that she too was a

SPEAKER_00victim. The timing was perfect. The Me Too movement was in full swing, accompanied by its slogan that demanded that the public believe all women. Jeffrey Epstein became their biggest focus. Virginia, using lawyers, social media and the press, could now step forward, rewrite history, and become a multi-millionaire. But that rewriting of history, that revisionism, needed to not only downplay and whitewash her own role in the Epstein scandal, but invent parts of it completely to dupe the world into

believing that she was an

SPEAKER_00innocent victim. And so, in rewriting her story, it became something more. It became a monetisation. And if Mar-a-Lago is the hinge in that story, the British journalist Sharon Churcher is the cash register. In 2011, eight years after Virginia's last confirmed contact with Epstein, Churchill, through the mail on Sunday, paid her $40,000 for her story and a further $80,000 for the photograph of her with

SPEAKER_00Prince Andrew. Those numbers matter because they establish something that the public conversation pretends not to notice. Virginia's allegations did not arrive as a spontaneous act of conscience. They arrived as a transaction. buyer's story. It shapes the temperature of it. It encourages the sharpest angles. It rewards the most sellable and sensational details. It makes the difference between a human, real, true account and a product.

SPEAKER_00And when that product first hit print, it contained something that should have stopped the world from later speaking in absolutes. In those first articles, Virginia clearly did not accuse Prince Andrew of having sex with her. She did not claim any sexual contact at all, in fact. The Daily Mail piece, based on Virginia's own account, stated that there was no suggestion of sexual contact between Virginia and Andrew. Church's Australian Telegraph version reinforced the same message.

SPEAKER_00No sexual contact. No sexual relationship. Virginia's early story about London, as recorded there, reads like a strange social encounter with but not a criminal one. Meeting a prince, having dinner, dancing in a nightclub, a return to Maxwell's house, a photograph requested by Virginia herself, and then leaving with the photograph as a memento to show her friends and family that she'd met a prince. A souvenir moment, a look who I met moment, and her aunt carol roberts corroborated the family's reaction

she said that they were thrilled ecstatic amazed that virginia had met a prince and that virginia too was ecstatic and thrilled the photograph was treated like a bizarre little trophy

SPEAKER_00not evidence of an assault When I interviewed Carolyn Andreano's former long-term partner, Sean Hort, he in fact told me that Virginia went on to use that photograph to groom other victims and convince them that should they come with her, they too would be able to have their photographs taken with the rich and famous. Now, whether we believe that or not, whether we even believe that the photograph is genuine, I will go more into that and more in my upcoming book.

SPEAKER_00And yet, That's where the ground shifts under your feet, because later the world will be told that the photograph was taken seconds before Virginia was raped. But the earliest printed version doesn't say that at all. In fact, it says the opposite. Virginia clearly said that, yes, she'd met Prince Andrew, but no, she did not have sex with him. Which leads to the inevitable question, what changed? The answer is that after the first articles came the next ambition, the next potential money-making opportunity, a book deal.

SPEAKER_00Sharon Churcher convinced Virginia to write a book, a memoir, and promised her that she would serialise it in the mail on Sunday so that both Virginia and Sharon Churcher herself would financially benefit from it. In May 2011, Virginia emailed Churcher asking for help, remembering names of who she could claim she'd slept with and who Epstein sent her to. This is the kind of detail you don't scrub clean. It reveals the mechanism. An alleged victim asking a journalist to remind her who she was

trafficked to so

SPEAKER_00she could name drop properly in a book proposal. Virginia wrote in a recent memoir that she could never forget the face of someone who had raped her. Yet years earlier, here she was asking a journalist to tell her what names to mention because she had no clue whatsoever who she was supposed to claim had raped her. And Churchill replied in a way that is chilling precisely because it's so casual. She encouraged Virginia to use the term trafficked.

SPEAKER_00She suggested names and she specifically suggested Trump's former lawyer, Professor Alan Dershowitz. She wrote to Virginia that he is, and I quote, a good name for your pitch. But she acknowledged that there was no proof that Dershowitz had ever done anything wrong. Virginia's response was gleeful. She wrote, Sharon Churchill then bought her a thesaurus. She told Virginia,

to write the book in the style of a Roman eclef, which contains part fact, part fiction. She told her to add big names to make the book more sensational and saleable,

SPEAKER_00but then, when they pitched the book to agents, they shockingly presented Virginia's fictionalised story as being 100% fact. I got in touch with the main literary agent, whom Churcher and Virginia wrote, were trying to get to represent the book. He confirmed to me that at no point did they tell him that the book contained any fiction or false allegations. He told me that they pitched the book to him, and I quote, And yet it wasn't fact at all.

SPEAKER_00The memoir titled The Billionaire's Playboy Club was riddled with life-changing false accusations against powerful men and women, written selfishly for no other reason than to make the book more sensational, to make headlines and to make Virginia and Sharon Churcher a lot of money. And Churcher, as the unsealed email exchanges prove, egged her on all the way, encouraging her to add big names into the manuscript. From that moment, the cast expands. And from that moment, the Prince Andrews story begins to transform from no sex into

sex and then into rape and then into multiple alleged sexual encounters and then into an alleged orgy and then into a weekend with the prince in Santa Fe and then into contradictions under oath where she disavow or forgets the very details she once wrote in vivid

SPEAKER_00prose. The early version, the first version of her story, was neat because it was limited. It had boundaries. It had a photograph and a night out and a social weirdness that didn't automatically become a felony. A photograph of Virginia Giffray allegedly standing beside Prince Andrew and grinning like a Cheshire cat. But Virginia and Sharon Churcher didn't want the story to end there, because if the story ended there, then so too did the money. The next version of Virginia's story needed escalation to keep

paying dividends,

SPEAKER_00and that escalation did not happen in a vacuum. It happened alongside a book pitch, alongside coaching, alongside name suggestions, alongside the economics of headlines. This is where Virginia took Sharon Church's advice and added Alan Dershowitz into her book, despite never having even met him. And when shown photographs of friends of Jeffrey Epstein, including a photograph of Dershowitz to point out anyone whom she claimed she'd been trafficked to, she was unable to point Dershowitz out or even know who he was.

SPEAKER_00She then wrote in her manuscript that she had met Dershowitz, but she did not claim she'd ever had sex with him. But then, years later, When the book deal came to nothing and she needed to invent more stories to sell to the press and media, suddenly, out of nowhere, she filed a lawsuit falsely claiming that she had been trafficked to Epstein, to Alan Dershowitz, to Prince Andrew and to foreign presidents. This is where Church's later reversal becomes so important because she didn't just quietly drift away.

SPEAKER_00In a phone call to publisher Tony Lyons, she condemned Virginia, called her coverage of the story as checkbook journalism described virginia as a liar as a prostitute and framed her lawsuits as something close to open blackmail church has said that virginia lied about her age that she was older than the 15 story suggested and that she'd been on the game before recruitment she said she didn't believe the dershowitz allegation pointed out his name wasn't even in her original stories and speculated that virginia's lawyers had pushed it

SPEAKER_00But unethically, you will likely have never heard or read about Church's condemnation of Virginia. And shockingly, Church continues to make money by writing articles praising Virginia and further promoting her false allegations, despite calling her a liar and a prostitute. She wants you to ignore the reality that she in fact knew full well that Virginia was lying and Churchill wants you to be kept in the dark about how she knew that Jeffrey had lied and that one of those lies revolved around her allegations

against Dershowitz. During the investigation I've been carrying out for well over five years now,

SPEAKER_00I've interviewed Professor Dershowitz a few times. Here is what he had to say about Virginia Jeffrey and the false allegations she made against him.

SPEAKER_03In front of a very distinguished person from Yale, David Boies said to me in front of witnesses, why don't you just get some rich Jewish rabbis to come up with a million dollars and pay Virginia Goofre and then she'll go away. And then we have a tape recording of me with David Boyce, in which he said if Jeffrey Epstein would just pay her a lot of money, she would go back to Australia,

SPEAKER_03not write a book, not say anything about Jeffrey Epstein. So clearly... she was seeking hush money she wanted hush money and and she got paid probably lots of hush money we know she's been paid uh over six million dollars and probably closer to ten million dollars and she wants to get even more and so this is a witness that the united states government would never ever use uh because they couldn't vouch for her credibility

SPEAKER_03And the real question is, why was she even considered as a witness? Why isn't she a defendant? Why wasn't she in the dock? She has committed the same crime that Maxwell was accused of committing. And in some respects, worse, a 13, 14-year-old girl who she trained and brought to Jeffrey Epstein for money. And she was well above the age of consent when she did this. She was old enough to serve in the armed forces.

SPEAKER_03She was old enough to sign a contract. She's old enough to be in America, under American law, charged with murder if she committed a murder and executed. She is an adult. And there's no evidence that she was compelled to bring Carolyn to Jeffrey Epstein to satisfy his sexual presence. Do not believe anything, anything Virginia Goufray says about anybody. Nothing should ever turn on the word of that serial perjurer and that trafficker and

that woman who has

SPEAKER_03based her whole life on earning money for sex. Let me again repeat it. She started her life by earning money by engaging in sex. Then she moved to becoming a trafficker and she earned money for bringing young girls to Jeffrey Epstein. Then she earned money by falsely accusing people of having sex with her. She continues to do that. She has accused some of the most prominent men in the world of

having sex with her.

SPEAKER_03They have all denied it. Her own lawyer Brad Edwards said on television that she did not have sex with Leslie Wexner. She swore she had sex with Leslie Wexner between five and 10 times. Her own lawyers have said she was wrong, simply wrong in accusing me. That's on tape too. And yet there's no investigation. And the worst part of it is the media will not permit this side of the story to be told. Let's go back to the accusations,

the history of the accusations against you by Virginia.

SPEAKER_00Well, the timeline, if people were allowed to hear the timeline, which they can now, they would seriously not just question it. I believe that they would believe that Virginia Frey is discredited because she began... Never mentioning you at all, did she? Until she received an email from Sharon Church of the Daily Mail suggesting that she include you into a book that she was actively seeking to sell and get an agent for. She mentioned your name even in that book.

She didn't then mention that she had been assaulted by you, had sex with you in any way.

SPEAKER_03Or even met me, even met me. She said in the book, she never met me. She just once saw me. Let's remember this, that in the beginning, she speaks to the FBI. The FBI shows her pictures, including a picture of me. And she doesn't identify me as somebody she had a sex with. She basically tells the FBI she did not have sex with Alan Dershowitz. Then she tells Sharon Churchill she did not have sex with Alan Dershowitz. And then Churchill writes her an email saying, but you ought to put Dershowitz in your book because he's famous.

SPEAKER_03He represented Klaus von Bülow. He was in the movie Reversal of Fortune. It will help you sell your book to put Dershowitz in your book. So she puts me in the book. But as someone she did not have sex with. She said she had sex with George Mitchell, the former peacemaker in Northern Ireland. She said she had sex with Jacques Cousteau's granddaughter, Alexandra, who never met her. She said she had sex with a bunch of other people. Another Harvard professor named Stephen, I know who he is, but his name is under seal.

She says all those things, but she says she did not have sex with Alan Dershowitz. and she makes a deliberate decision to commit perjury and submit a false affidavit,

SPEAKER_03suddenly making up the story that she met me, she had sex with me, including in front of my house in Cambridge, including on an airplane with two women and in a car with two women, including in places I've never been since the time that she met Jeffrey Epstein, including in places I couldn't possibly have been during the relevant period of time. So she made up the entire, entire story. She had a premeditated attack on me and my family.

SPEAKER_03I am the victim of her perjury, her extortion plot, and her attempt to shake down people for money. I must note here that in yet another massive blow to Virginia Defray's credibility, Virginia later revealed to the world that she had not been truthful in her

SPEAKER_00allegations against Alan Dershowitz. Dershowitz proved with financial records and travel documents that her story of meeting with him couldn't possibly be true. Her own lawyer, David Boyes, admitted that she was, in his words, wrong, simply wrong, and Jaffray begrudgingly issued a carefully worded statement that was intentionally barely covered by the press. She claimed she was mistaken in accusing him. The press didn't want to promote this statement too much because they knew that we'd all be able to easily read between the lines and

understand the truth.

SPEAKER_00Virginia Giuffre had lied, and Alan Dershowitz was an innocent man. By the time Virginia Giuffre's account reached its most public form, the version that would harden into a global morality play, the story had already begun to behave less like memory and more like revision. Not revision in the sense of clarification, but revision as escalation, with each new retelling adding detail, certainty, new twists and gravity where earlier accounts had been narrower, vaguer or explicitly absent.

Nowhere is this clearer than in the evolution of the Prince Andrew allegation.

SPEAKER_00As I've already mentioned, in the earliest paid-for accounts, including the Daily Mail and the Australian Telegraph articles written by Sharon Churcher, Virginia did not allege sexual contact with Prince Andrew. The articles were explicit about that absence. They described a social evening in London, a dinner, a visit to Tramp Nightclub, dancing, a return to Glenn Maxwell's home and a photograph allegedly taken at Virginia's request. The language mattered. There was no suggestion of sexual contact. Churcher herself later reiterated that this was what Virginia

told her at the time.

SPEAKER_00When this changed, and for Cash, she started claiming that she had had sex with Prince Andrew, she couldn't get her story straight because it's harder to invent a believable lie than it is to simply recall the truth. Virginia alleged that she and Prince Andrew shared a bath together in Maxwell's London home. She described the room as Victorian in style, with a large freestanding Victorian bathtub in the centre of the room that the two of them comfortably lay in together. Subsequent inspections of the bathroom,

SPEAKER_00however, showed that no such bathroom even existed, that there had never been a large Victorian bathtub within it, and that the small modern bathtub attached to the wall not in the centre was unlikely to accommodate two adults, let alone a man of Andrew's build. This is not a matter of interpretation, it's simply a matter of scale. Virginia also claimed that Prince Andrew provided her with alcohol at Tramp nightclub and that he drank vodka. This claim persists despite Andrew being widely documented as a lifelong

SPEAKER_00teetotaler, a fact corroborated by former partners, by staff and by decades of public record. The photograph itself remains a problem. The original has never been produced. Virginia initially said she did not know where it was. Later, she claimed it was in the garage of a relative in Australia. She then said she could not afford to retrieve it despite having earned millions by that time from media deals and settlements. The absence of the original in a case so dependent on proof has never been adequately explained.

SPEAKER_00But to me, it's a red herring. Even if it were real, even if that photograph is real, All it proves is her original story, that she met a prince and asked for her photograph to be taken with him. And then comes the Pizza Express alibi. In his Car Crash BBC interview, Prince Andrew stated that he was at home with his children on the night in question, having earlier taken Princess Beatrice to a party at a Pizza Express in Woking. The interview was widely mocked,

and Andrew's demeanour did him no favours.

SPEAKER_00But mockery is not refutation. Family diaries reportedly corroborate that his movements that day were limited and recorded. Even critics have acknowledged that a brief social visit to Maxwell's home earlier in the day could explain the photograph without supporting the allegation of a late-night sexual encounter. What is often lost in public discussion is that Virginia's earliest accounts are compatible with that explanation. It is only the later versions that are not. The escalation, though, does not stop with London.

Virginia would later claim that she had sex with Prince Andrew on two further

SPEAKER_00occasions, once in New York and once on Epstein's island in the US Virgin Islands. In one telling, however, the third encounter involved an orgy with multiple unnamed girls. In another, it involved a private weekend in Santa Fe, New Mexico, complete with horseback riding and extended intimacy. These two versions cannot both be true. In her memoir, The Billionaire's Playboy Club, Virginia provided detailed prose describing the Santa Fe trip, including the setting. She claimed that she had spent a weekend completely alone with

Prince Andrew at Epstein's Zorro Ranch after being sent there by Jeffrey Epstein and Maxwell. She wrote in vivid detail that they had both ridden on horseback through the dry,

SPEAKER_00picturesque landscape together, that she and the Prince had downed champagne and shed baths and had intimate sexual sessions. And yet, under oath in 2016, Virginia acknowledged that no such encounter had ever happened. She had made the entire thing up. She had lied. This is not a minor discrepancy. It is a complete reversal of a central claim. The Santa Fe account is particularly revealing because it shows

how narrative

SPEAKER_00detail increases with time and incentive. The memoir version is rich, cinematic and emotionally charged. The sworn testimony version is abrupt, uncertain and dismissive. When pressed, the story, Virginia's story, collapses. Here we have another clear example of when Virginia was willing to completely lie, to falsely accuse Epstein and Glenn Maxwell of trafficking her to Prince Andrew, and to falsely accuse the prince of being the recipient of that mythical trafficking. Here she falsely accused three individuals of crimes that she

knew full well they

SPEAKER_00did not commit. And just as with the school children she'd groomed and abused, she didn't care about what impact her actions had on their lives. All she cared about was money. Virginia's other claim, that she engaged in an orgy with Prince Andrew on Epstein's island, also doesn't stand up to scrutiny. In fact, in her original memoir, she had written about the alleged orgy, but had clearly written that it involved Jean-Luc Brunel, not Prince Andrew. The only person to partially support the island allegation was

Epstein's former

SPEAKER_00employee, Steve Scully, who claimed to have seen Prince Andrew at the pool on Epstein's island with a topless young woman. He later identified that woman as as virginia geoffrey based on a photograph shown to him years later but scully placed the event at 2004 a time when virginia was already married was already living in australia and no longer in contact with epstein netflix did not fact check this timeline had it done so the claim would have been immediately exposed as

SPEAKER_00impossible and this pattern repeats elsewhere It repeats in her false allegations against Alan Dershowitz and the later public revelation that she had lied. It repeats in her false allegations against Prince Andrew. And it repeats in her false allegations against multiple other innocent individuals. But perhaps the most damning moment for Virginia's credibility came not in the press, but under oath, during questioning about her claim that she had been trafficked to foreign presidents. In her 2014 legal filings,

under oath, she had clearly claimed that she had been trafficked

SPEAKER_00to Dershowitz, to Prince Andrew and to foreign presidents. Now, we know already that she'd been proven to not have been trafficked to Dershowitz. In fact, she'd never met him at all. And it's unlikely that she even had sex with Prince Andrew. But the foreign president's claim has never been tested. It was an extraordinary allegation designed to convey scale and severity. But it was, in fact, also a lie. And in 2016,

SPEAKER_00again when under oath, Giffray not only admitted that she had never been trafficked to any foreign presidents, but she admitted that she had never even met any in her life. This was not confusion. It was a lie recorded in black and white. The effect is cumulative. Each individual inconsistency might be explained away, but together they form a pattern of intentional deception that is impossible to ignore. The story that the world absorbed was one of absolute certainty.

SPEAKER_00The record tells a different story, though, one marked by shifting timelines, incompatible accounts, vanished evidence and allegations that expand and retract depending on context, platform and potential reward. And this is before considering the wider constellation of names Virginia later accused, many of whom issued categorical denial supported by records or the conspiracy theories she later embraced and promoted. As the Prince Andrew narrative continued to mutate, it did not do so in isolation.

It became entangled with a broader ecosystem of claims that followed the same

SPEAKER_00trajectory, dramatic introduction, rapid amplification, minimal verification, and eventual quiet retreat when confronted with evidence. This phase of Virginia Frey's story is where exaggeration hardens into something more dangerous, not merely to individual reputations but to the integrity of the entire Epstein case itself. The claim about being trafficked to foreign presidents sits at the centre of this unravelling. When Virginia first made the allegation in a 2014 legal filing,

SPEAKER_00it was framed deliberately to convey gravity and scale. The phrase itself was designed to shock. It implied geopolitical power, international secrecy and crimes so vast they transcended borders. The media repeated it uncritically. Headlines carried the phrase as fact, not allegation. It and the client list myth that it spawned became part of the accepted mythology. But mythology does not survive sworn testimony. Yet the press did not retract the earlier headlines.

SPEAKER_00The phrase foreign presidents continued to circulate, it continues to circulate even, detached from the testimony that completely destroyed it. So too did the false allegations against Alan Dershowitz. Virginia's lies being allowed to dominate the public's understanding of the entire scandal because journalists continue to refuse to report the truth. Another claim that quietly evaporated under scrutiny involved Heidi Klum. Under oath, Virginia stated that Klum had travelled on Epstein's private jet,

but Flight Log's later release showed conclusively that Klum had never been on

SPEAKER_00Epstein's plane whatsoever. Klum issued a public statement denying any connection to Epstein, and the allegation was found to be false. Similarly, Virginia alleged sexual encounters with Alexandra Cousteau, the granddaughter of the famous explorer Jacques Cousteau. She claimed that she'd been trafficked and had sex with Glenn and Eva Tubin, Paris Hilton's father, Senators George Mitchell and Bill Richardson, and a string of celebrities and famous faces. In each case, the pattern repeated.

SPEAKER_00Dramatic claim, denial by the accused, supporting records contradicting Virginia's claims and Virginia eventually abandoning her lies but leaving them to fester online and in the public imagination until they helped spawn the myth that Epstein was operating a global sex trafficking operation and there existed a client list of powerful names. The final phase of Virginia's public life would see the tension and scrutiny of her story intensify. Claims would become more extreme, personal circumstances

SPEAKER_00would deteriorate. The insulation once provided by sympathy would begin to crack, replaced by legal proceedings, custody battles, and renewed scrutiny. By the time Virginia Giffray reached the final stretch of her public life, the distance between the image presented to the world and the reality unfolding behind closed doors had become impossible to ignore. The protections that once surrounded her, the reflexive sympathy, the unquestioning amplification, were no longer automatic. What replaced them was something colder and far less forgiving.

SPEAKER_00Court records, custody filings and consequences that could not be managed through interviews or carefully worded statements. It was during this period that Virginia made another extraordinary claim. She announced that she had been involved in a serious car crash with a school bus and that she had only days left to live. The claim spread rapidly online. Social media accounts sympathetic to her story treated it instantly as fact. messages of support poured in. Once again, emotion moved faster than verification,

SPEAKER_00but as with so many of her previous assertions, the story did not withstand even basic scrutiny. There were no police reports, no hospital records, No corroborating medical documentation. No evidence of catastrophic injury. The story appeared, performed its emotional function, and then quietly disappeared when questions were asked. In reality, as the police, multiple witnesses, and the driver himself later confirmed, Virginia had once again simply made up a story to get sympathy

and attention.

SPEAKER_00She had lied, not caring one bit about the impact it might have on the lives of other people, including the innocent bus driver, whom she did not collide with. What it revealed was not merely dishonesty, but desperation. Because behind the scenes, Virginia was losing ground in ways that could not be disguised. She'd lost custody of her children, a development that rarely occurs without substantial judicial concern. Family court proceedings are not governed by public narratives or political symbolism. They're governed by evidence, patterns of behaviour and credibility.

Whatever sympathy she once enjoyed in the court of public opinion did not carry the

SPEAKER_00same weight in an actual court of law. At the same time, further legal exposure loomed. An upcoming court case involving Rena O, whom I've interviewed and will soon release my interview with on Substack, threatened to introduce fresh scrutiny into Virginia's conduct and credibility. Unlike earlier challenges, this one did not come from journalists, bloggers or critics she could dismiss as hostile. It came from within the legal system itself, where testimony is constrained by rules and contradictions do

not evaporate through

SPEAKER_00repetition. Those close to the situation would later describe a woman under immense pressure, not from a shadowy force or conspiracies, but from the cumulative weight of her own false claims. Each new assertion had been layered atop the last. Each contradiction buried further than resolved until the structure itself became unstable. There was no clean way to unwind it. Retreat meant admitting falsehoods. Persistence meant escalating financial risk.

When Virginia Giffray died by suicide, the response was immediate and uniform.

SPEAKER_00She was mourned as a survivor who could not bear the burden of trauma. Her death was framed as the tragic end point of abuse rather than the culmination of years of unresolved contradictions and mounting legal consequences. The timing, the context, the unanswered questions were largely set aside. Death, in this case, functioned as closure for a narrative that had long resisted scrutiny. But death does not retroactively confirm truth. the weeks that followed there was an expectation explicit in

some quarters and implied in others that questioning virginia's story should now be completely off limits that to do so would be cruel that the appropriate response was silence yet

SPEAKER_00the claim she had made did not vanish with her They remained embedded in lawsuits, settlements, reputations and public belief. They continued and continue to shape how people understood and understand the Jeffrey Epstein case and the individuals caught in its orbit. And so that has made silence impossible. It was after her tragic death that one aspect of Virginia Giffray's life began to receive renewed, if still limited, attention.

SPEAKER_00Not the allegations she made against powerful men, but the admissions she made about her own actions. Admissions that had existed in the record for years, but had rarely been examined in full. The fact that Virginia Giffray was not a victim, but a villain. Not a survivor, but a recruiter. and that, chillingly, some of her victims are still out there now, completely ignored by the press because their stories of victimhood debunk the many myths that journalists have been writing for over a decade, and because they,

SPEAKER_00and the newspapers and media outlets they work for, continue to make a fortune from printing sensational fictions rather than serious facts. For more than half a decade, I've been investigating that neglected strand of the story. Virginia Defray's false allegations and history of recruiting and abusing underage girls. After Virginia's death, the willingness to confront this reality has increased slightly, but not enough. The focus remains upward,

towards power rather than outward towards consequence. The recruitment narrative was acknowledged in passing, if at all, and then swiftly abandoned.

SPEAKER_00Yet it remains there, embedded in testimony, interviews and personal writings waiting to be reckoned with. This is not about rewriting history to protect the powerful. It's about refusing to flatten history to protect a narrative. At the end of this story, there is a temptation to look for resolution in the familiar places, a verdict, a confession, a villain finally unmasked. But the Epstein scandal has never worked that way, and the Virginia-Guffray narrative is no exception.

SPEAKER_00What survives is not closure, but residue. Claims embedded in court filings, reputations reshaped by headlines, lives altered and destroyed by accusations that can never be fully walked back, even when the evidence underneath them completely collapses. The most uncomfortable truth is this. The version of events the public absorbed was, simply put, not the truth. It was curated. Certain facts were amplified relentlessly while others were

treated as radioactive.

SPEAKER_00Contradictions were excused as trauma. Demonstrable falsehoods were reframed as confusion. And where the record became too difficult to defend, attention simply shifted elsewhere. The effect was cumulative. Over time, belief hardened into certainty and certainty into orthodoxy. Virginia Giffray became untouchable. Not because every claim she made was proven, it was in fact the opposite, but because questioning her became socially impermissible.

SPEAKER_00And yet the truth never stopped speaking. It's just that journalists refused to listen to it. It spoke in depositions where she corrected herself under oath. It spoke in medical files that contradicted her harrowing memoir passages. It spoke in emails where names were suggested rather than remembered. It spoke in journalists' private conversations, where the same reporter who launched her story later described it as checkbook journalism and openly questioned its truthfulness. It spoke in flight logs,

employment records and timelines that refused to bend to narrative convenience.

SPEAKER_00It also spoke in silence. In the silence surrounding Carolyn Andreano. In the silence surrounding girls who were never given documentaries or book deals. in the silence surrounding admissions that did not fit the template of a perfect victim. The Epstein case did expose monstrous behaviour, that is not in dispute, but it also exposed something else, something less dramatic but no less corrosive, how modern scandal is constructed,

how stories are monetised and how truth becomes negotiable once it is entangled

SPEAKER_00with profit, politics and moral signalling. Virginia Giffray did not invent this machinery. She learned to exploit it and to operate within it, and for a time she operated it very effectively. But by the time her story collapsed under the weight of its own contradictions, it was too late. Settlements had already been paid. Accusations had calcified. Entire chapters of the public record had been written in ink that could not be erased.

SPEAKER_00Her suicide was tragic. It should never be trivialised. But tragedy is not a substitute for accountability and death does not retroactively validate falsehoods. After she died, there was an opportunity to pause and reassess, to separate sympathy from certainty, to revisit the record without fear of being labelled cruel or disloyal. And that opportunity was largely missed. Instead, the narrative was embalmed.

SPEAKER_00What remains now is the work that should have been done many, many years ago, the slow, thankless work of reading everything, of lining up dates, of asking why certain claims were made when they were made and who benefited when they were believed, of listening to voices that were never supposed to compete with a symbol. For more than half a decade, I've been doing that work, not because it is comfortable, but because it's necessary. Not to rehabilitate the powerful and not to diminish genuine victims,

SPEAKER_00but to insist that truth does not belong to movements, headlines or myths. It belongs to evidence. Carolyn Andreano deserved better than silence. The public deserved and deserve better than a curated reality. And justice deserves better than belief without scrutiny. This story was never about one man, one woman or one awkward photograph.

SPEAKER_00It was about how narratives are built, protected and sold and about the cost paid by those who fall outside the frame. But the Epstein scandal is not finished. It simply entered the phase where myth resists examination most fiercely. That is precisely why examination matters now more than ever, and exactly why, despite it costing me my job, I'll continue to dig for the truth and to expose one of the biggest media lies in living history, to raise awareness of how naked lies and the Me Too movement

were weaponised to

SPEAKER_00make millions, and to reveal and give a voice to the real victims in this entire sordid scandal.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. EPISODE SIX: Virginia Giuffre - The Troubled Teen

    Aug 25, 202647 minAudio

    In this episode, Virginia Roberts enters Epstein’s orbit, with devastating consequences for all involved. You can listen and watch as we go through her early life - accusing her father of rape, being allegedly...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. EPISODE TWO: The Recruiter, The Schoolgirl, and the Lie Detector Test

    Dec 8, 202521 minAudio

    Thanks for joining me for the second episode of my podcast, Everything Epstein. Last week we explored how Epstein made his millions, from early shady business deals, allegations of theft from Victoria’s Secret owner...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. EPISODE ONE: Theft, Fraud & Tax Loopholes - How Epstein Made His Millions

    Dec 3, 202527 minAudio

    Thanks for listening to the first ever episode of my podcast, this time going through Epstein’s early shady business deals, allegations of theft from Victoria’s Secret owner Leslie Wexner, how he used his island as a...

    Credit the people on this episode