Diversity Is Not the Defect. The People Dismantling It Are
29 minAudio
Effenus Henderson - global diversity thought leader, UN speaker, and author of DEI Is Not the Defect, Exclusion Is - predicts a "tsunami" is coming at the polls. In this provocative conversation with Simma Lieberman, he breaks down how the anti-DEI backlash, the targeting of leaders of color, and the rollback of inclusion policies are galvanizing a meta-diverse America to fight back. From the Target boycott to the triangulation strategy weaponized against corporations, Henderson explains why diversity is not the threat - and why exclusion is the real defect in the system. What happens when a country built on diversity tries to dismantle it? Effenus Henderson has spent 40+ years in global diversity work - addressing the UN General Assembly, speaking at international forums from Madrid to Doha, and advising the world's biggest organizations. In this episode, he delivers a stark warning: the anti-DEI backlash is creating a "tsunami" that will reshape American democracy. We dig into: Why "meta-diverse" America is the future - and who's fighting it The triangulation strategy being used to dismantle DEI in corporate America How targeting leaders of color is backfiring at the ballot box The Target boycott and the economic power of Black and Brown consumers Why companies that abandon diversity are losing top talent What every person can do RIGHT NOW to push back This is not a polite conversation about diversity. This is a call to action. Resources: Institute for Sustainable Diversity and Inclusion: https://www.i4sdi.org "DEI Is Not the Defect, Exclusion Is" by Effenus Henderson "The Architecture of Inclusion" by Effenus Henderson (Amazon) Connect with Effenus on LinkedIn (search "Effenus") HendoWorks: https://platform.hendoworks.com "Brown Is the New White" by Steve Phillips Simma: raceconvo.com | simma@simmalieberman.com Take action: Self-reflect - Is your behavior advancing or holding back the country we're becoming? Audit your workplace - Are practices designed for a monocultural past or multicultural future? Read the books listed above Join i4sdi.org Share this episode Start a dialogue group TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 - Intro: Who Is Effenus Henderson? 01:05 - The Tsunami Is Coming 03:18 - What's the Effect? Power, Due Process & Democracy 05:04 - Meta-Diverse America: The Demographic Revolution 10:15 - Targeting Leaders of Color: The Intentional Strategy 11:32 - Triangulation: How Anti-DEI Forces Weaponize the Law 12:25 - DEI Under Attack: What Diversity Actually Means 17:35 - The Target Boycott: When Customers Fight Back 18:42 - Predictions and Hopes: The Bedrock of Democracy 22:54 - What People Can Do: 3 Questions to Ask Yourself 26:37 - Resources and How to Connect with Effenus 28:11 - Closing and Goodbyes WHAT YOU WILL LEARN The "tsunami effect" - how anti-DEI policies and democratic overreach are uniting diverse communities at the polls What "meta-diverse" means - and why America's urban centers (80% of the population) are already there The triangulation strategy - how the federal government uses predicates, fear, and settlements to dismantle lawful diversity programs without winning in court Why DEI was never about quotas - what diversity actually means (it's about the composition of the group, not individuals) The economic cost of abandoning DEI - the Target boycott, lost talent, and sub-optimized systems How straight white men (29% of the population) hold 100% of the narrative - and why that's unsustainable Three questions every person should ask themselves about their role in a changing America What "DEI Is Not the Defect, Exclusion Is" really means - a systems-thinking approach to inclusion SUGGESTED ACTIONS FOR LISTENERS Self-reflect - Ask yourself: Is my behavior helping advance the country we're becoming, or holding it back? Am I curious about people different from me? Audit your workplace - Are the hiring, promotion, and succession practices at your organization designed for a monocultural past or a multicultural future? Read the books - DEI Is Not the Defect, Exclusion Is and The Architecture of Inclusion by Effenus Henderson (Amazon); Brown Is the New White by Steve Phillips Join the conversation - Visit the Institute for Sustainable Diversity and Inclusion at i4sdi.org and join the Community Coalition Connect with Effenus on LinkedIn or at platform.hendoworks.com Share this episode - with someone who needs to hear it, especially someone who thinks DEI is "discrimination against white men" Start a dialogue group - convene people in your community or workplace to discuss these issues Click here to DONATE and support our podcast All donations are tax deductible through Fractured Atlas. Simma Lieberman, The Inclusionist, helps leaders create inclusive cultures. She is a consultant, speaker, and facilitator. Simma is the creator and host of the podcast, Everyday Conversations on Race. Contact Simma@SimmaLieberman.com to get more information, book her as a speaker for your next event, help you become a more inclusive leader, or facilitate dialogues across differences. Go to www.simmalieberman.com and www.raceconvo.com for more information Simma is a member of and inspired by the global organization IAC (Inclusion Allies Coalition) Connect with me: Instagram Facebook YouTube Twitter LinkedIn Tiktok Website Previous Episodes What Happens When You Don’t Belong The 29% Problem: Steve Phillips on Race and Power Dion Lim: The Anti-Asian Hate Story America Forgot Loved this episode? Leave us a review and rating
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
If you've ever wanted to have a conversation about race but were afraid of saying the wrong thing and getting attacked or of being ignored or trivialized, this podcast is for you. This is Everyday Conversations on Race. I'm Simma Lieberman, the inclusionist. For more than 35 years, I've helped organizations get people talking across the lines that divide them. Here, real people tell their own stories in conversations
that feel comfortable and human. Today, my guest is Effinis Henderson, a global diversity leader with more than 40 years in the field. He's spoken at the United Nations General Assembly and at international forums from Madrid to Doha. He's the author of DEI Is Not the Defect, Exclusion Is, and he is the founder of the Institute for Sustainable Diversity and Inclusion. You're going to enjoy this conversation, so let's get started.
The tsunami is coming. I mean, that's very different than, than your music Yeah, that particular- But you get the word, but you get the message out through the music. Exactly. And well, let me talk about the tsunami, um, because I think it's tied to what I call, uh, the changing, uh, representation of American democracy. And, um, what I've observed and what I believe is going to happen is that because
of the way the current administration has treated a, a variety of people, uh, in terms of their experience, uh, by cutting out programs like diversity, by chastising and belittling a variety of people, by snatching up people without due process and so forth, and shipping them out of the country, that ha- is having a, a, an effect of galvanizing across different communities, including working class Americas with the tr- with the tariffs and so forth.
Those things, because I grew up on a farm, and I know when the farmers say, uh, diesel prices are gonna cut into my profits and will cause some perhaps to lose, um, you know, their, their, their farms and so forth. And so I think there is an awakening that most people aren't seeing yet clearly, and that awakening is that there is a, there is a common thread across difference that is occurring, uh, and that is finding its, uh, its power in, in, in the votes.
And so my, my theory is that that tsunami, uh, is being created by that, uh, that shared, uh, vision about what's happening and how, how they've gotta stop it. And so that's why I'm, I'm predicting, I could be wrong, I've been wrong in the past, that, that you're gonna see a fairly significant, uh, I call it tsunami effect, uh, brought about by this, this upcoming election results.
And what do you think that is? And what's gonna be the effect? I mean, I, like, for those who haven't had time to read your paper or haven't, don't know about your paper- Well, I think- Break it down … I, I think what's happening now is that power has been concentrated fairly tightly by a very small group of people. And I think what is going to happen is you're gonna, you're going to see people being called to the carpet for things that five years ago, 10 years
ago, would've been characterized as anti-democratic or anti-American. Just in, in, in the way when you, um, ignore rules and policies and due process, you're, you're actually challenging, uh, the democratic principles upon which this country was founded. And I, and I think people don't like that. They don't like you messing around with our country, right? And, uh, and, uh, thinking that you're above of above that.
And so to me, the, um, uh, you know, that is, that's galvanizing and, and you see it in the Indivisible W- Marches and, uh, just how people are showing up all across the country. And I think that same visual effect of, of voting, uh, this time will, will, will be, uh, be seen in terms of what you saw out in the streets. I think you'll see that same thing, uh, at the polls, uh, th- this week. And it's already, if you look at the data, it's showing a significantly
higher level of participation already. And I think it's, um, I think the issue here in my mind is that America has become… I- my word for it is meta-diverse. And what that means is, is if you look at the demographic composition of the country, it is representing a variety of backgrounds, experiences, sexual orientations, everything that, uh, is, is, is who we are becoming. And what you're seeing is an opposition to that, that inclusive,
uh, approach to a democracy. They, they're saying that, "I, we don't want that. We don't want this. These people should not be here. Let's send these people back to shithole countries." Those are disparaging- Labels and remarks, and, uh, I don't think most Americans appreciate that kind of language and, um, you know, that kind of leadership, uh, in the country. And, uh, and, and so I think you're gonna see that in the voices that show up at the polls, uh, and are showing up in the polls this week and, and next week.
I hope so. Well, do you know who Steve Phillips is? Steve Phillips. He wrote the book, um, Brown Is the New White and Are White Men Smarter Than Everybody Else? And he's the founder of, uh, the organization Democracy in Color. Okay. Okay. Well, I'm, I'm gonna have to connect you, 'cause he w- he was on the show, and in his last book he talks about the fact that in this country, straight white men only make up something like tw- I think 29% of the whole country.
That's correct, yep. So they're not the majority. That they hold, uh, a monopoly on the power and the money to- Yeah … to a large degree. And I don't think people are necessarily seeking the level of wealth that they have, but they are seeking, uh, things that makes life more affordable for them. And most people can see it's in your face corruption, as, as you hear a lot of the people talk about today. You know, it's… That's the thing that people don't like, the corruption and
the disregard for people, you know, in, in decisions that are being made. So for example, in DC for example, the, the issue with the, uh, the s- the, the reflecting pool, the issue with the golf course and the trees just being cut down because one individual, without consulting with other, uh, parts of the Congress just says, "I don't like it, I want it cut down." Or redecorating the Oval Office in- … in gold things that, it makes it look gaudy
and not what I think a lot of people would see as the, the people's house. It doesn't reflect… It's, it's moving away from reflecting what, what the people would want. I mean, that's kind of my perspective and so forth. And so this diversity is, you know… My theory is if you look at the most, uh, populated urban centers around the country, uh, what you'll see is that those communities have already become meta-diverse.
You know, if you look at San Francisco, if you look at Seattle, if you look at Atlanta, if you look at New York, Chicago. Well, define meta d- d- But define meta-diverse for people. Okay. Meta-diverse to me is, uh, meaning that y- you're moving to a point when there's no predominate- Identity based group driving everything. That there has to be more collaboration and integration with a variety of cultures and backgrounds. And, and you're seeing that, that's what-- why I see people in New York,
Chicago, Detroit, Atlanta, actually DC, you've got a range of people, more so than in small town rural America, right? But they represent, those urban centers represent over 80% of the US population. And s- and they're l- and they're led by, uh, people from various demographic groups. Um, you know, if you look at Los Angeles, l- right? Um, if you look at Seattle, if you look at Atlanta, if you look at Chicago, New
York, I mean, you have a different group of people, uh, rising to levels of power. And if you, even if you look at, uh, at the state level, particularly at like, um, attorney generals, you know. Uh, I know, uh, the attorney general in, uh, California, I know his brother. And, um, if you look at the attorney general here in, in Washington State and in New York, they're increasingly represented by women and people of color. And so meta diverse means that in order to get things done and to
reinforce your license to operate in those communities, you have to tell a story and, uh, present a business case that reflects c- an understanding of this broader based diversity that's occurring in those, in those communities. What I felt, uh, happening with the Trump administration and his targeting of, of people like Karen Bass and targeting of people like, um, Letitia James, Fani Willis, uh, even Lisa Cook, uh, at the, uh, Federal Reserve, was an intentional
targeting of, of, of women of color and, and men of color in that case. Uh, and he was trying to-- He was targeting those highly populated urban centers. And part of it is to say that, "See, those people can't lead, can't manage. I have to step in and fix it, you know, because I alone can fix it." I mean, that kind of philosophy, which is quite, um, quite different from kind of the, the society we are evolving to.
And I think most people are beginning to realize that. And again, that's why I think you're going to see more of a tsunami effect in this election because people don't like that. Most people are, are honest, they're ethical, they're, uh, th- they're not liars. Uh, they tell the truth. The other thing I would tell you, um, I, I've been doing-- Part of what I'm writing about here in the last five or six months is this concept of triangulation And triangulation basically is understanding how things are happening.
And what's happening here, triangulation i- i- is, it's where you have an actor. It could be the federal government, I call that, that the actor, or it could be a person. Uh, you have a predicate, right? And the predicate is kind of what they're advancing in terms of a notion or an idea, and you've got a targeted group. And what I see happening with, um, with diversity, equity, and inclusion is that the strategy has been not necessarily to win and to put, uh, solutions in the hands
of the people that are being impacted. So if, for example, if you take the case with, uh, IBM, the case with, uh, uh, Deloitte, the case with, uh, Accenture, and- Well, so could you say what that was? 'Cause a lot of pe- a lot of people listening to the show don't even know that DEI is diversity, equity, and inclusion. So could you- Yeah, well, what- Uh, yeah … what that means is that they were, um, they were challenging certain practices of these corporations around their diversity, uh, practices. And, and generally the things that they were doing were part of what
I'd characterize as good faith efforts that had been underway under prior administrations and under Title VII, most of which are, are still legitimate, uh, practices. But, um, you know, this idea that was promulgated, uh, DEI, anti-DEI, for example, these things are anti-DEI. The things that they targeted were the things that were already, um, against the law, right? In terms of quotas and things like that, but they gave the impression
that those things were, were not. And they also went after c- those companies for some of, some of the things that they were doing, whether it was with their pay policies or their, uh, you know, creating diverse candidate pools and so forth. They were challenging those things. And rather than go through the process of adjudication, uh, and, and evidence-based solutions, uh, the companies basically settled with the government with no finding of guilt, uh, no finding of fault, which basically had the effect
of causing others that, um, had not been approached or, or contacted about their practices to kinda get a little bit nervous and start to pull back. When in reality- Well, uh, uh, wasn't some of the issue- Go ahead … was though that they were saying that the c- the concept of diversity, equity, inclusion was discriminating against white men? That's, that was, that was the predicate, yes.
Yeah. Yeah. But- 'Cause I think it's important for people to understand that Yeah, but, but, and it is also important to under- uh, for people to understand- What the- to understand the concept of diversity. Diversity is not about individuals. Uh, diversity is the collection of individuals. So- No matter where you're at, if you have more than one person in a room, you've got diversity of some sort, right? So I mean, I think, uh, a lot of folks saw it as a code word against Black people or
marginalized communities, uh, the LGBTQIA community and so forth, but diversity basically is the composition of the group. And the companies that got it right basically looked at their markets, they looked at their customers, they looked at the communities that they do work in, and basically said, "As part of our business strategies and our commitment to c- communities in which we operate and serve, we wanna reflect those communities." And so they had very, very, um, uh, targeted strategies to increase
representation, uh, to reflect those communities and so forth. And, and companies like Costco, you know, integrated into everything that they, they do and, and were able to justify it and so forth. So, so- Don't mess with Costco. Don't mess with Costco. No matter how cheap prices… To do s- to that, uh-uh, people aren't having it. Yeah, exactly. Uh, so I mean, that's, uh, I think that's part of the whole issue with kind of some of these strategies. And the triangulation thing says that the actor is identifying a predicate that
takes time to respond to or is costly. And rather than go through the process of, uh, litigation and adjudication, a lot of organizations, because they are federal contractors, w- will say, "Okay. We'll, we'll settle this. We won't admit any guilt, but we'll settle it with you just to get it behind us." But what that does is it creates fear in the minds of the companies that weren't attacked directly, and so they naturally start to pull back on things
that are technically lawful and so forth under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Uh, but it also hurts them, because- But it, yeah … then when they say, "You know, we're not g- we, we're not gonna r- really w- if we have too many people of color or too many women or whatever, it's gonna look bad, so we just have to w- go back to having a bunch of white people," and in fact what then they're doing is they're not hiring the, the most talented people. That's correct. Because they're eliminating seeing all these people of color and women of all
colors and different people other than straight r- white men, and they're sa- and so they have a bias against those people, so they're, they're actually missing out on a lot of talent by thinking, "We just gotta have these straight white dudes." I mean, nothing wrong with straight white men, but we need a lot more than just straight white men to be able to do good business. And, and that's your, that, that's a very good point. And, um, if you're taking in, in- into consideration what happened to Target.
Uh, Target basically backed away and, um, the communities, uh, particularly underserved communities, Black and brown communities said, "We're not shopping at, at Target because of that." So there is a, there is a shareholder, a stakeholder. The customers are rising up and saying, "If you can't do that, we don't wanna shop. We don't wanna buy your product." So there is an economic bene- impact. And, uh, if you look at the d- the, the data, uh, in terms of Target's, uh, oper-
uh, ROI and so forth over the last couple of years, they've lost a lot of ground. And I th- and a lot of it is because people are becoming, becoming organized and are pushing back on that. And particularly in these high meta diverse communities where these organizations are located, either their stores or their corporate headquarters. So what's your prediction? What's my prediction? My… I, I won't call it a prediction, I'll call it a hope. One, I believe that people have been, I think the word is, my dad's name
was Snook, but I don't wanna say that. My, I think people were snook- snookered in, into, um, into a belief that, um, the current- the way things are currently headed, uh, were the most helpful things. But there were things that they did not want. Uh, you know, they didn't want a war. Uh, they didn't want the cost to go up. They didn't want the Affordable Care Act to be, uh, you know, marginalized in terms of, uh, premiums and so forth.
Um, they didn't want, and felt probably that, uh, uh, the killings of people because of ICE raids and so forth, uh, was just unacceptable. And not allowing people who were legitimate, uh, residents of the country, you know, here legally to be scooped up and, and carried out, it, it shows a viciousness, a meanness, and a, uh, um, hostility that is not American. And I think most people are honest, they're fair, uh,
and, um, they want the truth. And I, I, I believe that people are pushing away from anything and anyone who's advocating for truth, I mean, for, who are advocating for, uh, dishonesty, uh, deceit, uh, corruption and so forth. And, um, I think that's what… That's the broader issue because I think at the end of the day, it is the fundamental r- uh, uh, bedrock of democracy. And, um- We, you know, it, it, it's something that I think everyone should
be caring about and thinking about Well, and also we've lost a lot of talent. By all these deportations, we've lost, we've lost a lot of labor that's really important, 'cause people work, and money too, because a lot of people, a lot of immigrants, like if you talk about people who are undocumented, they pay taxes, but they… A lot of people didn't get any, didn't file to get taxes back. So the government had all that money.
Mm-hmm. And then we had people, also people who needed the work of people, and then we have a lot of other people, like a lot of people who have higher education who didn't wanna stay in this country anymore because they, they c- they can't get the funding, they can't get what they needed. I m- I was reading that there's like a, a lot of scientists have left the United States 'cause, and, and educators, because they're being offered more money outside of the country. Mm-hmm. And I think, you know, l- like we're, we're going through a fairly substantial
transformation about relationship and about, uh, borders and so forth. And I think with, uh, technology, AI, and so forth, people around the world are learning more about us, and we are learning more about them. And it's a lot easier to navigate the world than it was five or 10 years ago. So people are, are much more comfortable. You know, you hear people saying, "Well, I'm gonna move up to Canada," or, "I'm going down to Panama," or somewhere to live.
Uh, but I think there's a level of interconnectedness, uh, around the globe that, um, uh, you can't, you can't, uh, halt. Uh, that it, it is grow- it's growing, and technology and, um, you know, artificial intelligence and so forth, all of those things are, are, are, are, are pushing us in that direction. So I'm looking at the time. I know I have to let you go, but I really wanna do another show with you, 'cause I
want to also wanna talk about you and who you are and how you got where you are. So I'd, I'd love to have that discussion too. Sure. If you're willing to come back. Sure. And what do you want people to take from this discussion? What do you want people to know? What do you want people to do? What I'd like, uh, people to understand is to, to understand that diversity is not a threat. And diversity is not the defect, exclusion is. In fact, I wrote a book about it, uh, DEI Is Not The Defect, exclusion is.
And what I mean by that is if you think about it from a total quality, um, standpoint, uh, if you've got some inefficiencies or defects in your system, that means you're excluding something that's fundamental to it operating correctly. And I come from a systems perspective, an ecosystem. And so as you look at things that are designed defects, and I'd say not expanding the, the, the market for all talent, um, not ensuring that processes
and practices are fair, you then, uh, are suboptimizing the output of your system. If you're not considering the fullness of your customer base, you're suboptimizing. You know, if you're, you're, um, if you're not considering that in your strategic plans and so forth. And I know that's another conversation, but that's what I'd like people to leave is, uh, leave with, is that, um, this is, uh, a time when, uh, people have to c- continue to be, uh, learners. Um, that, uh, what you may have known and the processes and the strategies
that you may have employed, uh, 5 or 10 years ago w- were probably good then, but you now have to calibrate them such that they reflect, um, kind of the customers, the clients, the employees that are showing up today. And in order to do that and to do that effectively, you've gotta build relationships, coalitions, and, uh, you've gotta continue to learn and think of new ways to, to, to reach people. So what… If somebody listens to this show and they're excited, what's one thing
that they could do after they, a- after they turn, as they turn off the podcast, what's one thing that somebody could do? Um, what's one thing they can do? To take a moment and self-reflect, uh, about, um, if I think about the country that we're becoming Is my behavior, uh, helping advance and move us in that direction? If I reflect on it, do I know and do I learn, you know, and am I curious
about other cultures and people that may be different from, uh, me? And, uh, what's, uh, the downside of not asking or trying to inquire or learn about others? And I think the third thing would be, as, as, as I think about the organization that I'm in or the systems or the practices, uh, that are, are being used, uh, and do they fit in a, a growing and more diverse world? Uh, because from selection to hiring to, uh, promotion and development,
succession, tools that perhaps worked in a monocultural society but don't work in a multicultural one. So w- my, my advice would be to think of something that you can do, uh, on your own. May- maybe it's having a conversation, a dialogue, maybe it's convening a, a dialogue group to talk about these things and talk about things to do. Um, we've just built, um… The Institute for Sustainable Inclusion has just built
what's called the Community Coalition for Sustainable Diversity and Inclusion. It's an online plat- sponsored, I mean, h- hosted by Circle, and it's an opportunity. We're building it out, creating spaces for people to have conversations, providing resource, uh, and, and tools, and we're inviting people to share data and information. Uh, and if you wanna learn more about that, uh, just look us up at www.i4sdi.org, and I'll give you more information.
Just a sec. Can you repeat that? W-I-4, the, the number four, S-D-I dot O-R-G. Right. And we'll put it in the, on the website also. Oh, great. Okay. So if somebody wants to get in touch with you, where, what can they do? Um, I'm, uh, feel free to check me out on LinkedIn. I'm, you just type my first name. There not too many people that have that name around, Effiness. And, uh, or if you want to check my website, HenderWorks, uh, my
platform is platform.henderworks.com. Uh, and, uh, the work that I've been doing over the last year, in fact, my most recent book is called The Architecture of Inclusion. It's available on Amazon. And, uh- The Architecture of Inclusion. The Architecture of Inclusion on, on Amazon. Those are ways, uh, that you can reach me. Well, Effiness, thank you so much. I have so enjoyed this conversation, and you have to be on… I have
to have another show with you. I mean, it, this just has to happen, so- Thank you so much All right. Well, thank you and, um, have a great weekend. Uh, and, um, we'll talk to you later. Thank you for listening to Everyday Conversations on Race. If this conversation meant something to you, please share it with others and help us grow. And if you lead a team, an organization, or a community group where people don't talk to each other the way they need to, that's the work I do.
I help leaders unite their people around a shared mission, improve communications, and keep their best people. Go to simaliberman.com and book a free 20-minute conversation with me. This show runs on listener support. To donate or sponsor an episode, go to raceconvo.com. It's tax-deductible to Fractured Atlas. Now, go have a conversation
Episode Summary Dr. Angela Cleo Smith, sociologist, conflict mediator, restorative justice practitioner, and author, joins Simma for a thoughtful conversation about identity, belonging, and communicating across...
In this episode of Everyday Conversations on Race, Simma Lieberman sits down with Steve Phillips - national political leader, three-time author, Guardian and New York Times contributor, and founder of Democracy in...
In this powerful episode of Everyday Conversations on Race, host Simma the Inclusionist sits down with Emmy award-winning journalist and author Dion Lim to confront a question too many are avoiding: "Why has the...
Frank Carbajal grew up the son of Mexican migrant farmworkers in California's Imperial Valley, where summer temperatures hit 115 degrees and his mother worked the fields through her third trimester. Today he's the...
For most Black Americans, the family tree stops at a wall built by slavery. Dr. Gina Paige co-founded African Ancestry to tear down that wall. In this episode, she explains how her company uses DNA to trace Black people...