Ethan Muse and I critically discuss the evidence around Padre Pio's allegedly miraculous doings, considering whether they amount to good scientific evidence. Get full access to Eugene’s Substack at eugeneearnshaw.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to the podcast, everybody. Ethan's going to be talking with Dr. Earnshaw today about Padre Pio. As with the last dialogue, I'm mostly just going to be hanging out in the background. You know, I'll interject here and there if I just feel the absolute need. Otherwise, just hoping for a fruitful discussion between these two gentlemen. So let's get right to it. Everybody knows Ethan if you've watched my show, so not to be rude, Ethan. We'll just ignore your biography for now. Dr. Earnshaw, it's your first time here. If you wouldn't mind, just a very brief introduction and then we can get right to it.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, sure. So I'm from Toronto, lived here for a long time. I teach at Seneca College, which is just, you know, college in Toronto. My PhD is in the History and Philosophy of Science and Technology. I got that at the University of Toronto. And I was actually like, what I was mostly interested is like evolutionary models and sort of whether I mean, miracles and that kind of thing is not my specific area of expertise, but it is something that we do study in the philosophy of science. I'm kind of interested in that anyways, because
SPEAKER_02In my own superhero backstory, my dad is really, really into aliens and they're also magical beings who are trying to bring us to a higher level of understanding and that kind of thing. And so that was one of the reasons why I became interested in supernatural or paranormal
SPEAKER_01phenomena.
SPEAKER_02Lots of stuff. And yeah, other than that, I don't know, I live downtown, I've got a dog who might bark at some point during this thing, got a couple kids, yeah. Yeah, well that's why I
SPEAKER_01have many kids, so it's a little bit why I was late to this appointment, so apologies for that. Alright, so I'm kind of flying blind, I don't know the total background here, so Ethan, why don't you just sort of introduce us to what this dialogue is about, and then explain how you would like to get it started.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, so I think the reason, I think it was Matthew Adelstein, actually, who suggested that we have this conversation. But I think Dr. Earnshaw, I mean, he's a very staunch naturalist, and he's made some kind of dismissive comments about the miracle case for Catholicism on Substack. And specifically, he's had critiques about my work. And I think this one just happened to occur in the context of him discussing my work about Padre Pio. But I'm sure he has similar criticisms about All the other cases that I like
SPEAKER_00to bring up and that I like to discuss. I mean, really, maybe we're not going to so much play trivia or get into the weeds of all the details of the case, but I thought it might be interesting to think about this methodologically, especially given Dr. Earnshaw's sort of expertise. Specifically, when we were just arranging this conversation, he said that there was something about the evidential standards that I was applying to these cases that was deficient. So I think just to sketch,
SPEAKER_00I'll just sketch briefly, just so the audience has context on what the Padre Pio case is, and then maybe we can kick it over to Dr. Earnshaw, where he can tell us why he thinks the evidence is so gravely deficient for the case. But basically, the idea is... We have like a miracle working priest who receives what are the stigmata, so basically these supposedly miraculous wounds, right, that correspond to the five holy wounds of Christ. So he says he's having this like ecstatic vision of Christ when he's praying
SPEAKER_00after mass in the choir and that he basically instantaneously receives these bleeding wounds on basically like the dorsal And the palmar regions of the hand, the plantar and the dorsal parts of the foot and his side. Okay, so he receives these bleeding wounds. And then over the course of the next 50 years, those wounds are going to evolve and change as a sort of the stereotype for cases of the stigmata. But basically,
SPEAKER_00you're going to have a bunch of medical examinations and they're going to have a bunch of anomalous findings pertaining to these wounds. That are reported by the various doctors that examine them and you're going to have this just continuous abundant effusions of blood coming out from the wounds to where it's sort of anomalous both the etiology of that bleeding as well as how someone would be able to survive without getting like iron deficiency anemia. You're going to have these reports from, you know, literally thousands of witnesses of there being this, like, intermittent, strong,
SPEAKER_00floral perfume that would just fill rooms and then go away and then fill rooms again in these waves. And that seems to actually attach to the blood itself, right? So the blood is scented. And so you'll have like artifacts that come into contact with the blood and like a doctor, like one of the doctors is Dr. Festa. He's going to take these cloths away and he's going to keep them in his office. And they're going to intermittently release bursts of floral perfume that are noticed by his patients. But Dr. Festa is devoid of the sense of smell. So he just, this has to be alerted to his attention by the patients that are sitting there.
SPEAKER_00So you're going to have lots and lots of descriptions Like that, of these massive amounts of bleeding, these seemingly inexplicable chronic lesions that don't become gangrenous or deteriorate but never fully resolve. Et cetera, et cetera, with all of those phenomena. Then you're going to have other crazy things associated with this guy, right? So like healing miracles, where you have lots of reports of that. Like one of the ones that I go into that happens during his lifetime is about Giovanni Savino,
SPEAKER_00where it's basically Padre Pio predicts that the guy is going to be involved in a near-fatal accident. Then the guy goes and he's involved in a workplace accident where his face is disfigured and his eyes are functionally destroyed. And he's admitted to a hospital. And then he has these multimodal, I guess, idiopathic experiences of Padre Pio. And then afterwards apparently his face sort of inexplicably heals and eyesight is restored to his right eye.
SPEAKER_00Okay. And so you have lots and lots of cases along those lines about these like miraculous medically inexplicable healings associated with him. You have other reports which I won't go into in as much depth about bilocation, you know, about him being able to read hearts. So telling lots of penitents who come to him in the confessional telling them specific details about unconfessed sins. So lots of people are reporting that. You know, you have one of the ones I go into in great depth in the post is hyperthermia. So basically doctors and fryers are repeatedly taking axillary temperature measurements
SPEAKER_00from him using bath thermometers, mercury thermometers, that are giving you these insane, like obviously physically impossible temperatures, like 52 degrees centigrade. You know, so we're talking about like he's running like 120 degree fevers if these measurements are to be taken at face value. So anyways, you've got this miracle. And then there's lots of these canonization miracles that happen after he die where people are praying for his intercession. And you have something that's basically tantamount to a resurrection and all these other things that are basically happening. And so it's just a cluster of well-attested,
SPEAKER_00basically anomalous phenomena that are all associated with this guy. And then we look into who this guy is. And basically, at least my impression that I explain why I have that impression in the post is that he has heroic virtue, right? So he's this wise, long-suffering, patient, humble guy who makes sacrifices for others, who lives under these vows of poverty and obedience, who's willing to submit himself to his religious superiors and to be in seclusion and not protest for extended period of time while he's being humiliated and smeared, you know,
SPEAKER_00who's going out of his way basically to do all these sort of charitable acts, even for people who have treated him Very poorly throughout his years, etc., etc., etc. So basically, you've got saintly guy with tons and tons of apparent miracles, with many of them where the only possible explanation is going to involve a pretty elaborate conspiracy that would have to be perpetrated by him, including during periods where he's under strict surveillance. So anyways, that's a sketch of the case. And so now I'm just going to kick it over to Dr. Earnshaw, where he's going to tell us why he's not impressed by the evidence.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, absolutely. No, so I think that was a really good summary, Ethan. And I think it kind of, you know, it highlights something that's very interesting, right? And I mean, part of why I sort of started to engage more with this stuff was because I thought that sort of the discourse around it was interesting, not just, you know, claims about miracles, right? So here we have a situation where, you know, Ethan has done a lot of research, right? There's all of this evidence he's Put together a case that many people have found very convincing, right? I come along and I'm like, eh, that doesn't really impress me, right?
SPEAKER_02It's a surprising kind of disagreement, right? Like what's the basis for me looking at the same evidence that Ethan has and being like, ah, frankly, this isn't even that impressive as far as Miracle Reports go, which was some of the things that I've said online, right? And I think to kind of understand this, we have to think about like Our expectations around evidence and around sort of explanatory frames, right? So, like, one of the things that I think is quite cool about what you're doing, Ethan, right,
SPEAKER_02is that you have this very, like, kind of, you know, like, clear goal that you're trying to do. You want to be able to persuade people who aren't already, you know, believing in miracles, who aren't already Roman Catholics. You want to provide evidence that's going to be good for them, right? Like, that should be persuasive to them. And I mean, that's a challenging task, right? It's not an easy thing to do. Because what you have to do is you have to provide evidence that for your You know, sort of account your theory that, okay,
SPEAKER_02this is a guy with heroic virtue who, as the result of that, receives sort of supernatural gifts, right, in a miraculous way. That's the explanation, right? That explanation has to be more plausible to someone who's coming in and not really, like, expecting that miracles are even real and maybe doesn't think Roman Catholicism is all that good and has perhaps, like, you know, other frameworks that they can use to try to explain this kind of thing. Right. So I think one of the things that I realized kind of when I was thinking about this a bit more and,
SPEAKER_02you know, when I was sort of seeing
SPEAKER_01how people were reacting
SPEAKER_02to things was I realized that actually, you know, a lot of people don't, I think, really understand sort of what the basis for naturalism is, why it is that, you know, sophisticated naturalists anyways are kind of convinced of its truth, where it's coming from. And so the first thing that I'd say is that in your piece on Padre Pio, there are places where you do discuss various naturalistic explanations. So you talk about whether if you are applying carbolic acid,
SPEAKER_02whether that would create inflammation, whether that's a problem, that kind of thing. So there's various naturalistic hypotheses that you discuss. But what we don't get in the Padre Pio What are the things that a naturalist is going to think in response to that?
SPEAKER_02And to be fair, I don't think that's surprising. I mean, you did a ton of work anyways. It's a lot to do. But I think doing that is kind of necessary if you're going to be persuasive to people who are coming like me with a certain amount of background. Because one of the things that's really important to recognize is that evidence that looks one way, given a certain set of Or a certain amount of background evidence will often look quite different when you have more perspective.
SPEAKER_02I mean, maybe the most obvious example of this, and this is something that's actually quite important to know a bit about for these topics, is if we look at magic tricks, right? So like magic tricks, a magician does something that seems incredible, right? It's like that couldn't possibly be done. And you can look at really good magicians and their tricks, right? And you can be like, I cannot possibly think how on earth that just like vanished in front of me, right? When you see the trick, you're like, oh, okay, that's so dumb.
SPEAKER_02There's this thing. This is important because in the history of supernatural events, one thing that was behind, and I'm not saying that Padre Pio was an amazing magician. That's not the theory. But magicians have, and this particularly happened during the spiritualist movement. In the 19th century, in the early 20th century, there was this whole wave of interest in Contacting the dead and psychic powers, and some of it was very religious, right?
SPEAKER_02So people thought that this was like sort of angels and ghosts being after it, and others of it was sort of more just kind of like general spiritualist and stuff that, you know, would seem heretical to a Roman Catholic, right? But there was a lot of it, right? There were hundreds of eyewitness accounts of people floating tables, of people giving information that there was no possible way that they could have known. There was this guy, I talk about him in the most recent Substack piece that I put up, which was sort of about why naturalism is the way that it is. There's this guy, I think D.D.
SPEAKER_02Holm was his name, who was seen levitating by witnesses. He could handle coals in front of people without being burned. He could move things without touching them. What happened was that because naturalists, and also sincere investigators, there was a lot of people who thought that this was probably real, but they wanted to use good standards of evidence and investigate, they came and they investigated these guys, and women too, and what they found was that they were being done mostly via magic tricks, really.
SPEAKER_02There was, for example, there were these mediums who were manifesting ectoplasm, right? And this crazy, gross stuff that was appearing out of nowhere. And it turned out that at least one of them was just swallowing linen cloths and then regurgitating them, and that was the ectoplasm, right? And the thing is, too, is that at least one of these guys, so Didi Holm, who I mentioned, was never conclusively debunked, right? He sometimes was able to fool people under Under laboratory style conditions,
SPEAKER_02I mean not quite perfect laboratory, but scientific investigators who got to set up the apparatus and study it, so he was able to make an accordion play by itself and stuff. But when you look at the whole history And in the history of the spiritualist movement, it seems more plausible to me, anyways, that Holm was just like the best out of the frauds and fakers, right? Good enough that he was never caught, or it was never shown how he was Right. But the fact that so many of the others were suggests that,
SPEAKER_02well, actually, you know, that he was just one more example of this thing. Right. And the thing to recognize about these these spiritualist mediums is that they were able to often like fool investigators who were right there watching them and had a lot of control over the circumstances. Right. They were repeatedly able to to Defeat quite skeptical investigations until eventually someone came along, right? So for example, Houdini, like the famous magician Harry Houdini was involved in debunking a lot of these guys because as a magician, he knew a lot of the things to look for, right?
SPEAKER_02He was aware of what was actually required in order to be able to do these sorts of things. So he kind of had a good idea of what to look at, right? So the thing is when you are Thinking about the whole context of supernatural explanation, a naturalist is coming in with a lot of background knowledge, or at least someone who, like me, has studied this a little bit. First of all, something that seems impressive to an observer is not actually great evidence.
SPEAKER_02And throw ahead to something that we'll probably talk about, right? One of the investigators, Romanelli, I think his name is, right? He's one of the earlier people to look at Padre Pio, right? And he does an investigation of the stigmata, right? And he feels Padre Pio's hands and he reports that he feels a void, right? Is that right, Ethan? Am I reporting that? Dr.
SPEAKER_00Romanelli is a physician that came to examine the wounds and on multiple days he's saying he's feeling a palpable void when he presses both on, so both the palmar and the dorsal side at the same time, he does that on both hands and the feet on multiple days.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so that's an example. We've got an observer who reports a particular observation. He offers an interpretation. That's not a standard of evidence that's impressive to someone who's coming in with my background. First of all, that's just an interpretation that is not supported by very much supporting Evidence that would actually suffice to establish that. It's very easy to inaccurately diagnose things,
SPEAKER_02particularly if you aren't doing an x-ray, if you aren't taking tissue samples, if you aren't actually using some sort of instrument. One of the things that we'll probably talk about is that A very, very well established thing in science is the fact that expectations greatly influence your observations. This is one of the reasons why scientific experiments, when you can, you do them double blind. The person who's doing it doesn't know what they're expecting.
SPEAKER_02The person who is You know, sort of taking the treatment or who is being experimented on also doesn't know what's going on, right? And that's because not that we expect that there's like deliberate fraud typically. I mean, sometimes there is, but like not usually, but just like A person's expectations have a huge effect on what they genuinely observe. This is observed with doctors who have no skin in the game, but over and over,
SPEAKER_02research shows that if a doctor has an expectation of what they will find when they're doing an examination, then they will find that at much higher rates than if they don't have that expectation. I don't want to jump into looking at specific things quite yet, but I want to give you a bit of a sense of where I'm coming from and thinking about these kinds of things. So what I would say is that if you want to make a convincing case that can persuade
SPEAKER_02a naturalist, we have to look at, okay, what is it that your case predicts? And part of it is thinking about, okay, well, what What's the power of the predictions that you have? Is the general theory that you have, does it rule out a lot of things? Is it compatible with most things? Are there things that would be particularly surprising? For example, you were already So I mean, that's great. That gives some sort of substance into like, okay, there's some expectations that we have around what sort of things that we might see,
SPEAKER_02right? And so if it turned out that there was something about Padre Pio that seemed very wicked, then that would be surprising. That would lower my expectations that it's true, right? But it's sort of all through thinking serious about these things, right? Like what really does your Account predict. And then what is a plausible account that I might offer that could predict similar things? Does it do a better job? Is it maybe more restrictive? So actually the evidence supports it more strongly.
SPEAKER_02Is it less restrictive? Is it kind of hard to say? Right. So I mean, to kind of jump ahead, right, I think that broadly the explanatory framework that I have that seems to make sense of things to me, right, in a kind of a unified thing, it makes makes Has sort of two components to it, right? So one is the component that Padre Pio was engaged in some actions that caused some of these things, right? And not a lot and not very complicated things, right? I don't think that he was some amazing magician.
SPEAKER_02I don't think he had any like deep sinister plan. I don't even necessarily think that he was sort of insincere. We'll kind of talk about why I think that in a little bit, but basically the two things that I think that he was responsible for producing either kind of Inadvertently or with some degree of foresight are the anomalous thermometer readings and the continued stigmata stuff. So I think that either the stigmata was a partly medical phenomenon
SPEAKER_02that he was sometimes exacerbating, possibly without realizing it. Or he was deliberately causing it and causing it to continue. So that's the one thing. And then the second thing is the temperature things. I think those were probably faked, but we'll get into wine and where that would go. So that's sort of the core of it.
SPEAKER_01Based on those two things,
SPEAKER_02Padre Pio becomes famous. He becomes the center of devotional attention. A large group of people around him become very invested in his holiness and in the miracles and that kind of thing. And that leads to the second thing that explains basically everything else, which is this kind of Charismatic selection effect, where people who already believe that Padre Pio is holy, who already are convinced Roman Catholics, who believe in miracles, all this kind of thing, when they see an anomalous event, they report it and connect it to Padre Pio, right?
SPEAKER_02So, I mean, broadly, that's the explanation for most of the miraculous healings, that's the explanation for the bilocation, that's the explanation for the flowery scent. Although, I will say that the flowery scent, we could add in some, you know, use of perfume and that kind of thing. But the idea then is like, okay, whether or not you think what I've said has like any plausibility to it, right? It's a kind of a unified account that if we look at it, it makes some predictions about like what we might expect and what sort of things are kind of plausible and it offers kind of a way
SPEAKER_02of putting together like all the disparate facts so that hopefully I can be like, okay, I think I know what's going on. I was kind of dismissive about this thing because I looked over the Padre Pio stuff and it seemed to me to fit into this kind of framework pretty easily. When I said things like, oh, he's just kind of like, I forget what I said, like sort of
SPEAKER_01mid-rate fraud or something
SPEAKER_02like that, right? I mean, I was comparing him mentally to people like Didi Holm, right? It basically are associated with more dramatic supernatural effects that were investigated more closely. And I'm not saying like if you add up all of the things associated with Padre Pio, it's not more than home. I mean, fine, whatever. It's like weighing what's more impressive. It's pretty subjective, right? But I mean, to me, It just, you know, that was sort of my honest reaction when I was looking at it. I was like, oh, okay, so the actual surprising things are he had wounds on his hands?
SPEAKER_02I mean, that's not naturalistically very hard to explain, right? Even if you have, like, concerns about, like, oh, well, will carbolic acid do it? I mean, anyways, so that's sort of the framework. I'll give you a chance to respond.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, so first, it sounds like I think we should just start out by acknowledging that if you're willing to posit some combination of elaborate conspiracy and coincidence to explain a set of observations, if you're willing to do an unlimited number of epicycles to any fraud theory to accommodate the set of observations that are made repeatedly by trained observers, including with instrumentation, if you're willing to do that, you could literally be a skeptic about anything.
SPEAKER_00So it's not really a matter of my evidentiary standards. If you just recalcitrantly don't want to accept a phenomenon of a certain type, you would always be able to posit some kind of elaborate conspiracy with, look, there are crazy good fraudsters out there where we don't know exactly how they did it. And so he did that a bunch of times with no specific positive evidence that's sort of proportionate to that. And then we say, and coincidentally... Coincidentally, also, there happen to be these, like, extensively documented one in a million medical anomalies
SPEAKER_00that are happening repeatedly in association with this guy, including, like, out-of-body experience, multimodal hallucinations that are corresponding to the boy with, you know, complete deficiency in nine organ systems sort of, like, So again, we go through this long list of
SPEAKER_00Super crazy medically anomalous things where if you were just thinking about it mechanistically before you knew that it happened, it doesn't seem like the sort of thing that should spontaneously remit. Having these crazy close associations with PO where it's like being prophesied by close associates of PO that the healings are going to occur before they occur with confidence and then this extremely rare thing occurs and then you also have multimodal hallucinations. And so you say, okay, so those are all coincidences. And also he did elaborate conspiracies that we don't know exactly how to do.
SPEAKER_00And also trained physician that wasn't expecting to find palpable voids was just mistaken. And he also happened to be corroborated by another guy who said that he could read text through the transparent lesion that goes all the way through the hand to where if you just set the text on the other side and you just read, you could read, clearly discern what the text said by staring through it during this initial phase. Notice there, that doesn't seem to be an issue with my evidentiary standards. It's just like, sure, there's some story that you can tell to dismiss anything with conspiracy
SPEAKER_00and coincidence, right? And that doesn't mean my evidence isn't strong. It just means if your prior was set so astonishingly low, then you'll resist what we take to be perfectly convincing evidence in every other context, which is repeated independent observations by trained observers by a multiplicity of people.
SPEAKER_02I absolutely agree that a hypothesis that has tons of epicycles and requires lots of coincidences is not a good one, right? But when you're discussing this, I think that you aren't really representing fairly what is going on in terms of this hypothesis, right? So first of all, what we need to recognize is there's a background here that there is enormous amount of I won't say exactly the same, but very similar kinds of cases. There are many,
SPEAKER_02many cases of apparent miracles that the Catholic Church investigated and had similar kinds of stories around them. But that eventually the Catholic Church decided were not cool. If you look back over the course of the past 500 years, the number of miraculous claims is huge. There are hundreds and hundreds of stigmatics, very, very few of which are Accepted even by the Catholic Church.
SPEAKER_02The thing is, around these kinds of phenomenon, you get very reliably all of these quite surprising stories That is, they're surprising up until you start to develop an account of, well, what is it that is going on when you get all of these really clearly false and impossible accounts about things, but that seem to cluster around particular people or particular events?
SPEAKER_00Well, just to step in here. Go ahead. Sure. I think the crucial premise there, so that's the first thing. As to the comments that you made, my point is just that Well, I disagree with that.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so you're saying just if multiple physicians sort of in a multimodal manner, right, visual, through palpation, sort of tactile, you know, olfactory, record series of observations and medical reports, you would say the vast majority of the time that's going to be good evidence that the observations are reliable, right? Really?
SPEAKER_02No, there's a lot more context that we need, right?
SPEAKER_00Okay, wait, so you're saying in general, repeated observation by trained observers is not good evidence?
SPEAKER_02It depends. Because the thing is, is that when you get the specifics, right, the specifics cause you to update, right? So yeah, in general, if a physician is, if all that you know is a physician did an investigation Well, you could get a defeater, but the point is, before you have the defeater, when you have certain types of evidence, you say,
SPEAKER_00Generally speaking, physicians are reliable.
SPEAKER_02Generally speaking, physicians are reliable.
SPEAKER_00When you get multiple corroboration for reports by physicians about observations where it's even hard to imagine because the observation that they're making, they were in conditions that were conducive to the success of that observation. If in those cases, that would at least be strong evidence. Now, it may not be conclusive evidence, right? And it could be possible that when you dig into it, you'll find a defeater. But in ordinary context, we're at least going to say, okay, presumptively that is good evidence. That's the kind of evidence that's good. That gives me a pro tanto reason to trust this observation.
SPEAKER_02I will agree that with no further Sort of facts about the case. If I hear a physician examined a patient and made a conclusion, that's fine. If you go then and say, a physician examined the patient and concluded that they were an alien, then I'm going to immediately have a question, right? Even before I know anything about what the physician actually did, right? Because I have antecedent evidence that suggests that in cases of You know,
SPEAKER_02supernatural alleged effects that there are many cases of physicians being mistaken, right? This is one of the reasons why the spiritualist movement is important here, right?
SPEAKER_00I'm agreeing with you though there, which is, so here's the thing I'm saying. I'm saying this type of observation is strong evidence. Now, it may be- Until you
SPEAKER_02find it a little bit more, sure.
SPEAKER_00Well, no, no, but I'm saying If it turns out that the claim that's being made, so the observations that are being made, are then strongly suggestive of a hypothesis in which you have a low prior, it's both going to boost a lot my credence in that hypothesis that these observations have been made, but if my prior is catastrophically low for the hypothesis that the evidence supports, then my overall credence in the hypothesis could still remain very low after receiving this evidence, and then I'm going to conclude Okay. There's some kind of mistake.
SPEAKER_00Likely the explanation is that some kind of uncommon mistake has been made in the collection or interpretation of the observations. Right. And so then it's about the, it's a really, it hinges on there's nothing wrong with the type of evidence that's being marshaled, because if I didn't start out with this really low trap prior against this phenomena, this would be significantly probability raising. But really the problem is just that because I have such a low prior, And because this evidence, unless there was a mistake, would be so convincing for that hypothesis.
SPEAKER_00Therefore, in addition to raising my credence in that hypothesis, I'm also just going to massively raise my credence that there's been some kind of mistake in the collection or interpretation of the observation. Now, you're giving us an argument for why We should have a low prior in Padre Pio's claim that is basically something like, well, there are lots of stigmatists, and it seems like the vast majority of stigmatists are frauds or that their lesions are self-inflicted. And so I agree if the data on the table was just Padre Pio has lesions corresponding
SPEAKER_00to the five holy wounds of Christ, right? It was observed that those lesions were present, which is how you characterized our case, right? Which, I mean, it was totally not faithful to the case that we make, right? It's not, he has wounds, that's our case, right? Nobody's ever made that argument. But yeah, I agree. If that straw man were the case that were being made, then it would be good evidence that there are lots of stigmatists and that most of them are fake. But then the question is, for those lots of stigmatists that are fake, do we have the same kinds of evidence that we have in the Padre Pio case that points to the authenticity of the phenomena?
SPEAKER_00And so that's the question That is sort of assumed by what you're putting forward, which is that it's fair to lump these together as one reference class, rather than for me, I'm asserting, no, no, no, actually there are two clusters here, right? There's the credible stigmatists and there's the fraudulent stigmatists. And in order to significantly undermine my case, you'd have to dispute my clustering, where you'd have to basically say, look, the kinds of evidence that we have for the credible stigmatists is within distribution for fraudulent stigmatists, where we can establish that there's fraud, right?
SPEAKER_00And so that's a very controversial premise that I would like to see you establish. So I would like to go through the cases that you think have analogous evidence, right? To show that these aren't two clusters, but instead are one distribution.
SPEAKER_02I think that the way that you are characterizing that doesn't really get at how we ought to be analyzing this evidence. So the first thing to recognize is that The way that we evaluate a particular piece of evidence can very dramatically change based on just a little bit more evidence, right? So, I mean, yes, I absolutely conclude that based on nothing further, right? If a doctor does an investigation into a thing and makes a report, I'm disposed to trust that.
SPEAKER_02But any piece of evidence that gets added into that changes my evaluation of whether that evidence is sufficient to establish the specific thing that the doctor is needing to do. So just to kind of cut to the chase about this particular thing, it doesn't really matter to me whether The evidence for Padre Pio's stigmata is better than the average. What matters to me is whether the evidence for Padre Pio's stigmata is sufficient
SPEAKER_02to establish what it needs to establish. And here specifically, what we need to talk about is the conclusion that it has no natural explanation. Different things that you might need to establish have different evidentiary standards to it. If all you're reporting is there is a visible mark on his skin, someone can see that and it's easy to conclude. But if you're making a case about all possible causes of a particular phenomenon,
SPEAKER_02just simple scientific methodology tells us that there's quite a lot that is required to establish that. I was thinking about this a little bit, right? How I could explain this idea. You guys ever watch the show House? Yeah. House MD? Okay, so some of you know. So it's this investigative doctor guy who solves hard cases, right? Things come in and it's like no one knows what's going on with this and he tries a bunch of different hypotheses and he tests
SPEAKER_02and eventually finds some weird explanation, right? And there's actually, I found out, I don't watch it a ton, but I've seen a few episodes, there's a Stigmata episode, right? And Dr. House comes in with someone who's presenting it with Stigmata, and he tests like, I think it's like eight different theories, right? Different possible causes of an allergic reaction and different other things, right? And that gives you kind of an idea of how you might go about trying to establish the hypothesis that there's no natural explanation for this thing, right?
SPEAKER_02Because the thing is about medicine is that medicine began with the Hippocratics, right? And the Hippocratics, what distinguished their methodology from previous medical methodologies was they were naturalists, right? Like the famous sort of like Hippocratic Treatise on the Sacred Disease is famous exactly because it's saying, look, the cause of The cause of what we now call epilepsy is not a curse by the gods. It is too much fun in the brain, right?
SPEAKER_02They had a false theory of epilepsy, but what made it sort of this early, really important sort of starting point for medical practice was that it was establishing the naturalistic basis of medicine, right? So if a doctor comes in, right, and he looks at some phenomenon, okay, and he He examines it carefully with his eyes, and he looks at it with a microscope, and he turns it over, and then he concludes, there's no natural explanation for this, okay?
SPEAKER_02I conclude that that doctor does not know what they are doing, right? Because that is not how you rule out all possible natural explanations. It's just not, right?
SPEAKER_00All we're appealing to the doctor. So there's a problem here, which is what I'm doing is I'm saying, here's a set of observations that are made. I'm inferring that the observations that were made were reliable in establishing the physical facts that they assert about the lesions. So you can question that if you have a defeater. Otherwise, I'm just going to say it seems like the types of errors, so fraud or error on the part of the physician, That would be required seem very improbable to where there's going to be a big evidential hit to deny or to resist the observation.
SPEAKER_00And so the point there is I agree you can just say sometimes rare errors or mistakes happen. Now the accumulation of that of those ad hoc implausible resisting of observations or assertions about the physical circumstances. It's going to depend depending on the nature of the observation and the specific evidence we have about the relative plausibility of the errors that could be made. But I'm just building a case cumulatively. The more times you have to do that, the worse it is for your theory.
SPEAKER_00Now, you're starting out with a thing that's like, Well, I'm building my thing where I say, here's my hypothesis. Here's what is fitting given my hypothesis. Here are a bunch of observations that seem like I don't actually need ad hoc auxiliaries to accommodate these. These kind of go naturally with my hypothesis, right? And that sort of the salient hypothesis when you see these actually is something that is sort of consistent with my theory, right? Meanwhile, you have to go for more debunking explanations to resist in many of the cases for the observations that I'm giving where it's more of these ad hoc auxiliaries.
SPEAKER_00So that's what I'm saying. It seems like you're pushing back first at the outset. I mean, the first substantive argument I really think you're making is, look, there are lots of fake stigmatists, right? And to say there are lots of fake stigmatists, for that to significantly undermine our confidence in Padre Pio, what we would need to show is that those fake cases are analogous to or sufficiently similar to to warrant basically a strong induction from those cases to this case, right? Because in general, the fact that there are lots of fake claims of type A,
SPEAKER_00Doesn't actually undermine our belief that there are any authentic claims of type A, right? When we just hear a claim, the fact that there's a lot of fake claims of type A will make it to where our credence that that particular claim is fake in the absence of any special additional considerations goes way up, right? And we learn there's lots of fake claims about something. Like, for instance, if I learn that there are lots and lots of fake claims that there are a guy as a Nigerian prince, right? And then whenever I hear a particular guy say that, oh, I'm a Nigerian prince, my credence that that guy's faking is going to go up.
SPEAKER_00But actually the fact that I learned that lots of people impersonate Nigerian princes doesn't make me strongly convinced that there are no Nigerian princes in the world, right? So notice those two things being different. That there are no authentic claims of that type versus lots of particular claims of that type turn out to be false. And so one way that I could easily discriminate Is if my evidence for a certain type of authentic claim were just very different from the types of evidence that I get in the cases where the claim is fake, right? So just to give an example, like Father Gemelli investigated lots of fake stigmatists and his claim was
SPEAKER_00that whenever he would bandage the wounds, right, and not allow the people to touch them or to treat them in any way during this period of a few days, that they would always resolve and that the epidermis would heal, okay? And then if I see in the Padre Pio case, when exactly the same procedure is prescribed by Bignami, and then there's a sort of a committee of friars that oversees that, and then we see that there's never more abundant effusions of blood than during those days, and when the bandages are removed, the wounds have the same characteristics that they did at the beginning of that period.
SPEAKER_00So that's showing me, okay, there's a disanalogy between what's happening in these two cases, one where people are self-inflicting superficial wounds, you know, and in another case where, okay, this is a more credible phenomena where there's a disanalogous response to the medical treatments that are applied. Now, you can make what you will of that specific case, but I'm just giving examples of relevant disanalogies, right? Or if I go and I say, okay, is it really true That there are numerous measurements by tons of different independent parties of anomalously high temperatures for these fake stigmatist claims.
SPEAKER_00Or is that additional medical physiological anomaly where it seems like fraud, well, we could get into that about why that seems implausible or at least it's going to have to be an ad hoc auxiliary about some complex fraud that we don't know exactly how he pulled off. If we look at that and we say, okay, well, in these other cases, we don't get similarly good. Or we look at those other cases, do we get stuff as good as Savino, right? Do we get postmortem healings as good as blah, blah, blah, right? Do we get, you know, as testimony as good as we get for the scrutiny of hearts? And so when we start going through that list,
SPEAKER_00when the lesions, do they last for 50 years and never become gangrenous while they remain open? You know, do we get really credible testimony that they're full thickness perforations of the hands and the feet? And so we go and we ask those questions. So the things I'm citing as evidence that there's some kind of anomaly here that seem predicted on the hypothesis of authenticity, do we get those in the analogous cases? And if not, then I don't think it's going to significantly undermine a case that's based off of the special evidence that we don't get in those typical cases.
SPEAKER_02So, I mean, I understand what you're saying. And certainly, the more that you're able to make the case that the evidence for Padre Pio is categorically different from other stigmatists, that supports your contention. But I'm not really saying that You know, it's just about like, oh, these other cases have led us to have a low prior. I mean, it has, but that's not the whole story, right? Really, what the other cases have done is they have led us to have certain standards for evidence that we have in a kind And these
SPEAKER_02methodologies, these standards of evidence, are not ad hoc, and they are not made up, and they are not applied unfairly. They're basically just scientific standards of evidence. They're the standards of evidence that lawyers use to examine testimony, the standards that medical doctors use to try to establish difficult cases. They're the They're the standards that we use in scientific research in order to consider a phenomenon actually proven and established as opposed to just suggestive.
SPEAKER_02So go back to the Romanelli thing. If I could, I think there's maybe three conclusions that we could say that get drawn from Romanelli by Romanelli that we should distinguish between. So one is Padre Pio has What would the word be like? Injuries on his hand. So he claims that. He claims that there is a void inside of the hand that he discovered through palpation. And he also does go on to claim that Padre Pio's wounds have no naturalistic explanation.
SPEAKER_02I understand that he made that claim. I hope I'm not misrepresenting him.
SPEAKER_00Well, he makes an inference from the observations that he makes. Sure.
SPEAKER_02So the first thing that I want to say is that making that inference is not evidentially justified. And we can say that just based on scientific standards of evidence, because for him to say that there's no naturalistic explanation for what he's observed, he would have to test a whole bunch of hypotheses. He would have to doctor house it. He would have to Ideally, he should x-ray the hand and look inside of it. Maybe he could try exploratory surgery and find out if there really is a void. He has to rule out any possible physical cause that could be responsible
SPEAKER_02for those marks on the palm. And the thing is, science is hard. It is not easy to rule out every possible natural explanation for something. I mean, what he did does not even begin to start to do that, right? He doesn't even consider seriously any hypotheses except for, like, it was maybe carbolic acid. He doesn't actually do anything that would be sufficient to prove that it was not, okay?
SPEAKER_00Well, just, I mean, I don't understand. One is we can say, okay, there are specific arguments that he makes that he says, here's what's going on here that seems to be inconsistent with ordinary wound physiology and the ways that wounds heal. He's saying, look, there's basically two facts that he's looking at. First is just the manner in which the lesions have persisted over this period of months, the manner in which they've evolved and developed in retaining the appearance that they had in the months prior.
SPEAKER_00He says that's inconsistent with ordinary wound physiology. And then he says second is the manner and the order in which the skin has healed, leaving the void behind. He says that's inconsistent. He says the fact that he's able to articulate the hands without difficulty, despite having the voids that he's sort of inferring through palpation.
SPEAKER_02Could I just jump in there for a second? So that's a really interesting point, right? The fact that he can still manipulate the hand and there's no impairment in the motion, right? That's an inconsistent observation with his hypothesis, right? If his hypothesis is that there's a void inside of the hand, but Padre Pio can still move it, then that suggests that his inference based on the palpation is wrong, right? Instead of saying, oh, there is contradictory evidence that's inconsistent with one another, right?
SPEAKER_02And perhaps that should lower our confidence that there's really a void there, right? Because after all, if there's a void there, it's weird that he can move it normally. Instead, we get this sort of appeal to a further miracle, an extra ad hoc miracle that we wouldn't expect, right? Where, oh, not only is there a void in Japan, but God also miraculously allowed him to move it completely normally despite this void. Could I just finish this point?
SPEAKER_00Just the class of phenomena that you're putting it in. So you're saying this has characteristics that are atypical of natural wounds, right? Now, Romanelli's interpretation of that as someone who is- Which is indefensible. Well, I mean, that's your impression or your opinion. Yeah, it is. It's mainly dogmatic because what he's saying is- No, it's based on medical standards. He's willing to entertain the miracle hypothesis much more readily than you are because he has a background worldview that's more amenable to it.
SPEAKER_00And so he's willing to distinguish between two types of phenomena, right? One type of phenomena is he's going to say, okay, here's a supernatural wound. Now, given that something's in a supernatural wound, I expect it to exhibit features that are strongly atypical of natural wounds, right? So the expectations that I inform inductively Based off of how wounds ordinarily behave, I'm going to say I'm not going to be surprised at all if those are violated with a supernatural wound, given what my expectations are for supernatural wounds, which is they don't play by the normal rules. Then the first type of wound,
SPEAKER_00the natural wound, it is really hard for that hypothesis to accommodate Basically, the physical observations that he's making about this palpable void. Okay, well, so can you tell us, so when he says, so actually, I'll just read the observation and then you tell us what he thinks is happening. Okay, so here. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So... Sorry, it's just hard for me to find the exact—oh, here it is. Okay. In the dorsal regions of both hands, at points almost corresponding to those just described, the skin presents identical features. Oh, actually, no, no, no. I want to start here. Sorry. Okay. Upon closer observation, one notes that in this area, instead of normal skin, there's an epithelium, or rather a shiny membrane, somewhat raised at the center,
SPEAKER_00forming a very small button-like elevation, from which radiate many fine striations that are darker and tending almost toward black. The entire area's rate was just above the surrounding tissues, which are intact and normal. On palpation, delicately performed, no bony or muscular resistance is perceived beneath. Instead, one notes that this membrane is distinctly elastic and there's no actual opening nor any discharge of fluid. In the dorsal regions of both hands, at points almost corresponding to those just described, the skin presents identical features. Applying the thumb to the palm of the hand and the index finger to the dorsum, thus covering in this manner the two described zones and exerting pressure, which proves extremely painful,
SPEAKER_00One has the exact perception of a void existing between the two fingers, separated only by membranes and by thin soft tissue, which under pressure gives the sensation of sand, while no resistance is perceived either from the bones or from the soft tissues normally present in these regions. All active and passive movements of the hands are performed without difficulty and are perfectly physiological. From this it follows that these pigmented zones are nothing other than membranes covering an opening which originates on one side and terminates on the other, such that there is a discontinuity of tissues through the sickness of the hands. On the dorsum of both feet, there is furthermore noted a circular area about the size of a five-cent coin, likewise covered by a membrane of vivid red color and shiny appearance
SPEAKER_00with well-defined and precise contour surrounded by normal tissues. On palpation, this membrane is likewise elastic and gives the impression of underlying void In the plantar regions, identical areas are observed with the same characteristics. By compressing simultaneously both the dorsal and plantar regions, it becomes evident that an empty space exists and that the foot is perforated, the openings being covered by the described membrane. As in the hands, so in the feet, all the movements of the joints and toes are normal. And then just skipping, note the lesions were observed in different days and at different hours without any modification being detected. Okay. So you're saying this is actually easy for the naturalist to accommodate.
SPEAKER_00So could you just give us a sketch of that? Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_02So this is reporting his subjective impression from palpating a particular part of the person's body, right? It's offering a hypothesis based on unusual sensations, right? So first of all, You've already said, and I think this is amply demonstrated, that Romanelli is not a neutral observer, right? He is extremely convinced of Pio's Holiness. He's extremely open to supernatural observations and possibilities. He's gone in expecting
SPEAKER_02there to be... Oh, really?
SPEAKER_00Clarified, why is that not accurate? What Romanelli said, so you're confusing two things. So one thing is what Romanelli's impression after he performs his medical examination. And the other is what Romanelli went in expecting and the impression he had when he first arrived, right? And those two things are different. What you fail to consider is the possibility that maybe what he saw during the medical examination is what impressed him and convinced him of the authenticity of the phenomena. Now, he's more well disposed than you are as a Catholic to be willing to accept the miraculous when he's confronted with evidence of it.
SPEAKER_00But just like me, I'm skeptical about any random miracle claim that I hear in the absence of evidence, right? Even though I'm ready to posit a miraculous explanation when I'm given convincing evidence by my lights. The same is true of Romanelli. In fact, what Romanelli says is that when his first impression upon meeting Pio was unfavorable because he smelled this floral perfume scent and he thought it was unsuitable for a friar to use perfume. And so he...
SPEAKER_02Did Romanelli, I forget what the exact thing was, I was under the impression that Romanelli took Mass and communion with Pio the same day that he did the observation, is that Roman?
SPEAKER_00No, so yeah, so basically after he does his initial examination, right? I thought it was before. No, no, no. Well, I'd have to go back and check the exact timeline for when they do Mass at the friary, but you don't have to, I mean, obviously you don't have to have a favorable impression or a negative impression of a priest. Sure.
SPEAKER_02Well, listen, I don't want to get too down into the weeds, but I feel as if it's fair to look at the evidence around Romanelli and feel that he was a very favorable observer, right? And you can argue that some of his comments suggest that he was maybe skeptical going in. I'm less convinced of that. But even if he is sort of somewhat skeptical going in, right, he is clearly coming in, right, with priors that are,
SPEAKER_02you know, Open to, and in fact to some degree expecting the possibility of this being miraculous stigmata, right? If I'm not mistaken, let me just see. So Bignami was the more skeptical one, right? Which one of them did the inspection first, Bignami or Romanelli? Romanelli was later, after Bignami?
SPEAKER_00Romanelli was before.
SPEAKER_02Romanelli was before, okay. Romanelli is clearly in a framework where a supernatural explanation is extremely plausible. And the problem with that is that that is not a framework that is conducive to Independent and objective medical inquiry.
SPEAKER_02Medical inquiry presumes a naturalistic explanation. If someone is going in, even if they are religious, but if they are trying to genuinely test this, then they need to approach it gathering more evidence than Romanelli did. In particular, The fact that he is concluding from just palpating these palms and judging that
SPEAKER_02the sensation is weird, that there must be a void inside of it, right? I mean, that's not a valid medical He's clearly influenced in that interpretation by his prior expectation that this might involve stigmata. That in itself is a weird observation, even on your hypothesis, right?
SPEAKER_02Because the expectation going in, if you're dealing with stigmata, is not that you're going to have some sort of weird, soft coverage. Wait, what's the basis for expecting that? Isn't that what stigmata is?
SPEAKER_02I mean, maybe you can clarify what your expectations around stigmata are, right? But the stigmata that Jesus received were transfixing wounds, right? Weren't the stigmata that... Oh, I'm drawing blanks. St. Francis were transfixing? No. What were they then?
SPEAKER_00And again, the deal with stigmata is while there's a symbolic association between them and Christ's wounds, specifically largely because of the spatial location of the stigmata, they're actually highly variable. And oftentimes the stigmata, the cases that are deemed credible historically, And so what I would say is that there's a change in the phenomena that would actually be part of the stereotype for the sticky body.
SPEAKER_00What's my expectation for stigmata is that they will exhibit anomalous behavior and anomalous properties. Now, I don't actually have a strong expectation. I don't have a strong expectation that they'll present in any particular way with any particular morphology.
SPEAKER_02That's fine. That can be your expectation. You expect what you expect. Presentation of stigmata varies, right? Then the less that stigmata in general are You know, confirmatory, right? Because it's just more compatible with a whole lot more different observations, right? And in particular, saying just that, like, I accept as stigmata, like, any weird thing that has to do in kind of, like, more or less the right place.
SPEAKER_02I mean, sure, but it means that, like, it's a lot easier to offer natural explanations of just, like, any old weird thing, right?
SPEAKER_00I'm just specifically interested So you've given us one thing, which is, okay, expectancy can predispose people, especially if you look at, and I've looked into this considerably, specifically with regard to Fatima, the literature on expectation and suggestion, and especially for a trained observer like Romanelli in the context of a medical examination where he's making repeated concordant observations across all of these different appendages on multiple ways. Sure.
SPEAKER_00In that context, what expectancy may do is incline me to interpret something that's ambiguous, an ambiguous perceptual experience, incline me to interpret it in line with whatever my expectation was going in. But what expectancy is not going to do is if I had normal bony muscular resistance and I'm just pressing into my hand like I am right now, To interpret that as there's like this elastic membrane that's uniting and joining to the other side of the void, right, in this cavernous void.
SPEAKER_00That is a highly unexpected observation, and the normal experience that I would get is not one that could be plausibly misinterpreted in that way.
SPEAKER_02It absolutely is.
SPEAKER_00Okay, can you provide another example?
SPEAKER_01Palpating someone's palm offers you some tactile sensations
SPEAKER_02which have a great deal of ambiguity to them. It is not at all implausible, in my view, you may disagree, it is not at all implausible, in my view, that someone who comes in expecting miraculous stigmata, or at least being very open to the possibility, and has perhaps And then he interprets that.
SPEAKER_02As, oh, there's this weird void which fills a theory that he already has, but which is interpreting an ambiguous observation in this way. And I'd also add, all of the surrounding information here suggests that that is what is going on. Because, correct me if I'm wrong, was Padre Pio subsequently x-rayed not that long later? Or am I misremembered?
SPEAKER_00It was decades later.
SPEAKER_02Okay, it was decades later. Okay, so at least decades later, there's no evidence of this, right? And of course, yes, if you're already very, very, very favorable to the miracle hypothesis, you can say, oh, well, then the explanation for that is that they miraculously closed up. Of course, there's no reason for us to expect that miraculous wounds ought to close up on the Catholic theory, but it's compatible with it, fine, right? But it's also... Gives us evidence to suspect that the original diagnosis was wrong.
SPEAKER_00Let's take proximate observations. You're saying that it's actually not unexpected that if a person, and I guess a surgeon, is going and palpating And that he's getting the impression that you're uniting the two membranes in the void where they're meeting each other in the center of the void, right? And that there's no bony or muscular resistance of any kind that he's pressing down. And he's doing that repeatedly across these things. And this is someone who would have a familiarity with what to expect given this type
SPEAKER_00of observation, right? Well, I mean, it's unlikely he
SPEAKER_02had any familiarity with anything similar. I presume he'd never, ever examined someone previously who had a void in their hands. So he is clearly making a sort of like a guess, an informed guess about what might explain. It's not as if there's like a existing like sort of system by which people are used to finding these and like the procedure by which one identifies a void in one's hand.
SPEAKER_00If you had a superficial chemical burn, okay, and you press on it, I think the doctor is going to understand that that's not a giant transfixing lesion with a palpable void in the middle when you press on a superficial epithelial scraping on the top.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I don't concede that at all. Okay.
SPEAKER_00So there's one thing which is, okay, we both have intuitions about how likely it is for a person to make that perceptual mistake, and apparently our intuitions are conflicting, and I'm sure the audience will form their own impression about how likely that mistake is. Then, in addition to that, There's inductively, so how common is it for doctors to actually make this mistake, right?
SPEAKER_02Well, this is an unprecedented observation because doctors never make
SPEAKER_00this observation.
SPEAKER_02The obvious reason that it is absurd to make that conclusion based on that Methodology that he used, that's completely insufficient to establish something like that.
SPEAKER_00I'm just asking the sort of the perceptual interpretation that's being supposed that Romanelli offered based off of the tactile data that he collected, if it was something that's actually very plausible, that that's the type of perceptual mistake that people would make, then we would imagine that there would probably be analogous examples of doctors making that type of mistake, right? Of mistakenly concluding that there's voids in people's hands because they thought they had stigmata? I don't think that's fair. Okay, so just concluding,
SPEAKER_00so if people think that there's a stigmata on a guy's hand, it's not actually very likely that when the doctor walks in to examine them, they're going to erroneously conclude that there's a void. That doesn't happen generally when doctors examine people with stigmata, right? So there's lots of doctors out there that believe in miracles, right? But it turns out that when doctors examine people with these types of wounds, even when there's some claim that there's this stigmata, it's actually extremely uncommon for them to make the claim that Romanelli made.
SPEAKER_02Because there's no sample at all. The question that we should be asking here is not out of all the samples of doctors who have come in and palpated hands in these circumstances, we don't have the evidence for that. We're just making it up. What we should be asking is, Is the methodology that Romanelli used the sort that would be sufficient for medical professionals generally to conclude that there was a void in
SPEAKER_02the person's hand? The answer is no.
SPEAKER_00It is not sufficient. Okay, wait, that's your assertion. Now, I dispute that assertion. Now, right now, what we're getting at is, okay, this perceptual evidence that he's acquired through the tactile data, how probative is that, right? And so how probative it is is going to depend first on how probable is the perceptual mistake that you're attributing to him, right? Notice,
SPEAKER_02I'm not attributing a perceptual mistake. I'm attributing an interpretive mistake. He perceived something. It's perfectly compatible with my understanding of the case, that either he sincerely felt a bit weird and he interpreted because of his background assumptions that this must be a void because he was predisposed towards it. He accurately exaggerated it for reasons that he had a desire to support this.
SPEAKER_02Now, I'm not saying that's necessarily the case, but it is certainly plausible, right? We have many, many cases of Catholics and people from other religions exaggerating and or falsifying things because they thought it would support the
SPEAKER_00faith. So I'm trying to talk about the plausibility of the perceptual error. But it's not a perceptual error. It would constitute a perceptual error, given that what he's saying is there's elasticity, absence of resistance, and then the two different membranes are uniting within the void, and so he's meeting a resistance when he's pressing both simultaneously, but he's not meeting when he's not pressing both simultaneously, when he's just pressing down on one, where he's getting no resistance going in. So those are the sets of tactile observations that are being made,
SPEAKER_00is basically there's the elasticity, right, where it seems like it's bending down, There's the absence of the resistance when he's doing that indentation or exertion of pressure. And then there's the meeting right in the center when there's the simultaneous compression of both. Okay. Okay.
SPEAKER_02We do not have, we do not even have good evidence that that is what happened. Okay.
SPEAKER_00Well, I'm just saying, so that's his account.
SPEAKER_02Yes, that is, that is his account of the experience, but much of that is interpretive and it is presented through the frame of a hypothesis that he already had.
SPEAKER_00These are tactile observations about physical facts that would be minimally interpretive, right? One of them is the tactile impression of elasticity. The second is the absence of the bony or muscular resistance when there's the strong indentation into the void.
SPEAKER_02That is an interpretation. That is an interpretation of what he felt.
SPEAKER_00The absence of the felt sense of resistance is part of the data.
SPEAKER_02But we have only a subjective account of that. There's no quantitative measure whatsoever. There's no instrument that was used. The evidence around The investigation of both medical and scientific phenomenon strongly indicates that the perceptions that we have, the observations that are recorded, are extremely influenced by bias.
SPEAKER_02Setting aside everything else, just the fact that
SPEAKER_00this was this one guy's observation, he's very He's very biased.
SPEAKER_02He's coming in in a situation of having strong expectations, certainly of the people around him, of what he's going to find. Is not going to be sufficient.
SPEAKER_00There's no evidence that's been presented that he had a strong expectation that he would find a void when he palpated. It's a plausible hypothesis though. To the extent that there's evidence, I think there's counter evidence to that he would have a strong expectation that he would make that finding. There's positive evidence
SPEAKER_02as well.
SPEAKER_00Okay, well we can go back to that later. Then, okay, I'm just trying to say, I grant that expectation has an influence, right? Now, there's still errors that are plausible and errors that are implausible, even given expectancy effects, assuming that some expectancy were to be established with regard to this particular case. Okay, so then I say, to me, it seems like given what we can infer were the tactile observations from what he directly reports in the medical report, It seems like actually it's a very coherent and plausible interpretation of those tactile observations and it seems like the errors,
SPEAKER_00for there to even be errors in the vicinity of the error he's making, there would have to be something very anomalous about the lesions. Now, even if the interpretation were ultimately erroneous. Now, I think it lends credibility to his hypothesis that it also coheres with proximate observations that were made with different sensory modalities. For instance, the preceding observation that we have is by Father Benedetto, who describes these wounds when he looks at them as perforations,
SPEAKER_00and then he clarifies to Dr. Festa that that involves visual transparency, to where you would be able to see through it at the time that he observed, where if you set text on the opposite side, you could clearly discern in all of its details what the writing on that text said.
SPEAKER_02That's rather overstating what he said.
SPEAKER_00Well, no, I actually will just read exactly what he said. If I were questioned by the higher authorities on this particular point, I would have to respond and confirm under oath, such as the certainty of the impression received, that by fixing one's gaze on the wounds of the palmer regions of his hands, it would have been easy to discern in their details a written text or object previously placed on the opposite side of them. Okay, fair. So if we look at that observation by Father Benedetto, that's in conjunction with the tactile observation that was just reported by Romanelli. Both of these observations point towards, okay,
SPEAKER_00a coherent interpretation, which is these are full thickness perforation of the hand. And just between the one observation and the other, the only difference is that there's this sort of epithelial lining or this thin elastic membrane that's formed to cover. Okay.
SPEAKER_02So there's another relevant observation, which is Bignani, right? So if we were genuinely trying to investigate this in a scientific way, right, we would want There are multiple observations that are concordant, right? So if there was genuinely a void that could be perceived by palpation, then we would have expected Bignami to find it. Now, of course, you have a hypothesis to explain why Bignami did not find a void on palpation. You think it was miraculously healed.
SPEAKER_00Well, no. So wait, wait, wait, wait, sorry. What evidence is there that Bignami palpated it?
SPEAKER_02Is the account that Big Nami gave not include some description of him feeling the hand? I was on the impression that it was, perhaps I'm mistaken.
SPEAKER_00What did Big Nami say about it? Here's what Bhiknami says about his palpation observations, which he does palpate it. But the evidence we have specifically about him palpating it says this. Here we go. Similar and perfectly symmetrical lesions are found on the left hand. On careful palpation, the metacarpal bones are felt to be perfectly normal in volume and shape on
SPEAKER_00the right as on the left. The same applies to the soft parts, subcutaneous tissue, So he found normal muscles and bones on palpation, no? Is that not what I said? Well, he found normal metacarpal bones on palpation.
SPEAKER_02So he didn't find a void. He didn't find just a thin skin that was hollow. He found normal bones and tissue on palpation. Is that, you know, we have these two observations which are discordant, okay? And it is not at all uncommon for there to be weird findings by doctors, especially in these kinds of circumstances, right? So, I mean, to give you one example, I forget if it's Maria de la Visitation or whatever, right?
SPEAKER_02But this was a stigmatic back in the 16th century and there was an inquiry and people looked at her and they found That she had stigmata.
SPEAKER_00Can I finish that? The point I wanted to make about what Big Nami found, right? Sure. The reason I bring this up Is because it shows you that there wasn't an anomalous observation that he's making, like Romanelli, that would lead him to, that would even be plausibly misinterpreted as the complete absence of bone and muscular resistance. But that leads me to suppose, and there's independent evidence that there's changes, right? Now, it's not true that, I don't think Bagnami is right that they are superficial at this point in time,
SPEAKER_00and I don't think he actually rigorously investigates that, which we can get back to With this subsequent observation that's made by Festa, where once the eschar is removed from covering it, he then finds that it's extended in depth during the subsequent follow-up examination by Festa and Romanelli. But specifically, if we go back to what Bignami is saying there, doesn't that suggest to us that there's been some kind of change in the morphology of the lesions? Because if there were just completely normal bony and muscular resistance, wouldn't we expect Romanelli not to be interpreting that as a void?
SPEAKER_02No, it puts doubt on Romanelli's interpretation. It makes us wonder whether Romanelli actually did a good job or whether he was maybe biased.
SPEAKER_00Here's two interpretations of the facts. Here's the interpretation I have. Padre Pio says the wounds change. The witnesses throughout all the times are noticing different morphologies. Even the shape of the wound on the side is changing. We know there are different observations about depth at various points in time. But about these lesions going all the way until the end of PO's life. So one hypothesis that I have is that there was a lot of variability in the morphology of these lesions over time. And I have lots of independent evidence that there was variability.
SPEAKER_00So now I have two conflicting reports from these physicians, or they're not really conflicting because their observations made at different times, right? And as I said, the hypothesis of temporal variability can unify those reports. But what I'm saying here with Big Nami is If Bignami's observation is that it's completely normal bony and muscular resistance upon palpation of the lesion, this is strongly suggestive that there would have to be some kind of change in morphology to reconcile both Bignami and Romanelli's interpretations,
SPEAKER_00because it doesn't seem plausible that Romanelli would sincerely make an error of the kind that he did if it were completely normal with respect to the bone and the muscles.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, first of all, it's not at all certain that Romanelli was sincere, but assuming that he was, there are many, many, many cases of doctors making observations that were subsequently disconfirmed, right? This is not an uncommon thing. I don't want to spend enormous amounts of time litigating this, but the key thing here is I have an account which,
SPEAKER_02it seems to me, offers a Unified and reasonable set of ideas that nicely unify and explain what is going on. So my account is that Romanelli, expecting to find stigmata, perhaps also willing to exaggerate in order to protect the Catholic Church, but not necessarily, I'm just saying that's not something we can rule out as impossible, goes in and he makes these observations. He palpates the hand, something feels odd to him, right?
SPEAKER_02We don't know exactly how odd it felt, right? And he interprets it into there's being this void because that's his expectation, okay? Then when Big Nami comes along, he doesn't find that, right? Which is exactly what we should expect, okay? So, I mean, yes, of course, if you are very, you know, sort of like, yeah, it can be miracles anytime, right? And that can be very, because variability can be anything, right? Like almost any observation, like the, The stigmata going away for a while is compatible with my theory. The stigmata becoming fully penetrating is compatible with my theory.
SPEAKER_02The stigmata just having a weird little cover over an internal hole, that's also compatible with my theory. I mean, that's fine, right? It's not very confirmed then by all the different observations because anything else that could have happened would also be perfectly compatible with the variability theory. But just let me finish. And also the point is that it doesn't show that the explanatory framework that I have, that it seems to me, as I've been explaining, perfectly well accounts for the observations and which is supported by Evidence that
SPEAKER_02to me is convincing, right, about what our expectations should be about what happens when a very famous, charismatic, miraculous figure is examined by someone who is from their own faith, right, you know, it all Okay.
SPEAKER_00Well, so first is he's not famous at this time. He's locally famous. It's subsequent to Romanelli's examination that there would be like a real cult of personality that we would expect to impress Romanelli with respect to Pio.
SPEAKER_02My understanding is that there's already a cult of personality around him that's local in the... No, no, no.
SPEAKER_00What I'm saying is for a guy like Romanelli, for a physician like Romanelli, He's not going to be under Pio's spell or think that it's really important to the Catholic Church's reputation that Pio not be a fraudster. If anything, what Romanelli would expect is that if this guy is faking the stigmata and then he lends credence to it, that what's going to happen is it's going to come out that the guy's faking it in various ways, and then that's going to discredit both him and the Church. That's probably the more likely thing that Romanelli, so he's not saying,
SPEAKER_00oh, the Catholic Church already has a huge reputational investment. We can create any stories that we want about how biased or not biased these people are. Hold on.
SPEAKER_02But the whole reason why in scientific methods we want investigations to be blinded, we want investigators to be as neutral as possible, is exactly because we can't really predict and understand what these effects will be. Like, yeah, maybe Romanelli was totally objective, and he just, like, that was what he did. But we certainly can't be sure. And we have a lot of contextual evidence to suggest that he probably was not entirely biased, right?
SPEAKER_02Let me give an example.
SPEAKER_00So you were just saying, well, look, almost any set of observations would be consistent with my theory. No, no, no. Actually, it goes the other way, which is you would dismiss almost any observations that were advanced by the positions that were made Basically, on the same basis, no matter what Romanelli had asserted, you could make the same thing. He's, oh, it's just expectancy and bias and possible lying.
SPEAKER_02No, not at all. So if he had done a better investigation, that would be more impressive.
SPEAKER_00Just allow me to finish one point, which is, The point I want to finish here is that, meanwhile, I have lots of things that would be disconfirmatory for my hypothesis that weren't observed. So one thing that would be easily disconfirmatory for my hypothesis is if these lesions deteriorated over time and became gangrenous or infected. That would be disconfirmatory. If the lesions completely healed over and scarred, Okay, and then they weren't renewed or reopened. Okay, that would be disconfirmatory for the hypothesis that I'm advancing.
SPEAKER_02Why would that be disconfirmed? Why would that be disconfirmed?
SPEAKER_00Because if the lesions are behaving in a way that is perfectly consistent with natural explanations of the wounds and the expectation for ordinary wound physiology, that's less expected under my hypothesis, more expected under the rival hypothesis, right? Meanwhile, if the way that they develop over time is anomalous and apparently inexplicable, That's more expected under my hypothesis, less expected under yours. And so that's the contrasting set of observations. If these wounds behave the way we expect wounds to behave, that's better for a natural theory that these are natural wounds.
SPEAKER_00If these wounds behave in ways that we don't expect natural wounds to behave, that's better for a supernatural theory. These are not natural wounds. They're from a different distribution of phenomena.
SPEAKER_02Okay, I understand
SPEAKER_00what you're saying. So there are lots of ways that things can behave unexpectedly, right? Just like if a guy flies, right? Let's say Padre Pio flies, right? It's consistent with natural inexplicability of his levitation, that his levitation be six feet off the ground or 50 feet off the ground or 100 feet off the ground. It's consistent that he'd be flying like where there's vertical and translational motion or that it's just he's hovering fixed above the altar. There's lots and lots of possible observations and I don't strongly expect or not expect any of those particular sets.
SPEAKER_00But what I do know is that all of those observations by large numbers of credible witnesses would be totally incompatible with the natural theory.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, sure. Absolutely. So, I mean, The thing to recognize here is that the hypothesis that just says any time that you see evidence, you're just dismissing it because you're kind of closed-minded and you can make anything work. That's not at all what I or naturalists are saying. As you just said, there are plenty of things which would count as good evidence.
SPEAKER_02For example, If Big Nanmi had actually found the same void, that would have been in favor. If there had been an x-ray that had been done around the same time that had showed it, that would also have been in favor, right? If there had been other examinations that had looked more in depth to this kind of thing. So the thing to recognize, right, is that the standards that are required in order to establish something
SPEAKER_02To scientific standards are higher than anything that we have for these
SPEAKER_00stigmata.
SPEAKER_02Could you please let me talk? I'll let you talk. If we look at the whole story here, what we have is we have a phenomenon where a man has wounds on his hands that probably last for most of his life. They're investigated a few times. A few times they seem weird and anomalous, as with Romanelli. Other times they seem, you know, like they're wounds, they're in the right place.
SPEAKER_02This by itself, I mean, sure, if you are Roman Catholic and the specific location of the wounds is very special to you and you take seriously that these guys were making accurate observations, sure, that can confirm your priors and that can make you believe in the miracles. The actual evidence that we have is completely compatible with the idea that this was some combination of him applying caustic substances to his hands,
SPEAKER_02a few biased observations that reported things So one of the things that I think is quite interesting, and again, you'll know more about this than me, so correct me if I'm saying this wrong, but my understanding is that there was an early newspaper story where there were monks who were administering injections and And Padre Pio was one of these and they spilled like carbolic acid on themselves.
SPEAKER_02And what was sort of remarkable was that the carbolic acid that was spilled on Padre Pio didn't heal. Am I reporting that right or am I misremembering?
SPEAKER_00So that's not exactly right, though. There's a particular, I mean, Substack note that came out that gave an excerpt that sort of, it's understandable that you would have that impression of what the story was. Yeah, that was just the worst. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But what the story was, my understanding of it is it pertains actually to the initial discovery of the wounds. So there was a guy who had been using carbolic acid and they had used too much of it and he had caused burns on himself. And those burns healed within a few days.
SPEAKER_00But then, so then, when Padre Pio's wounds were initially discovered, coinciding with that time period, his assumption was, oh, no, no, he doesn't have the stigmata. He must have just had carbolic acid burns. But then he realized something anomalous was going on when they didn't heal like everybody else's did. You know, so he's presumed. The origin of the stigmata was from the spilling of the carbolic acid.
SPEAKER_02And I'm not committed to the idea that it was. But the reason why I raise it is that, you know, what if there,
SPEAKER_01you know, we know that Padre Pio had
SPEAKER_02He had pretty bad health during this time period. He kept on getting medical exemptions from the army and things like that. He's not a particularly healthy person. What if he just had some sort of physiological condition that meant that he didn't heal as well? Perhaps he spilled carbolic acid on his hands and it didn't heal as a result of that, right? Here we're getting into sort of the like, let's investigate it in a naturalistic way. Think about it the way that House MD might, right? Like what could possibly explain this somewhat strange thing, right?
SPEAKER_02So there could be a medical component. It's certainly not impossible, right? I myself tend to more think that likely Padre Pio was involved in Maintaining these, right? We know that he reapplied iodine at least some of the time, and I'm not saying that he always was, right? But I tend to think that Padre Pio was deliberately engaging in fraud at least sometime. And setting that aside, I think that it's clear that all of the Sort of things that he is directly involved
SPEAKER_02in are not very difficult to explain if there was fraud, right? I mean, the marks on his hands, for example, right? The marks on his hands could be caused by a variety of different caustic substances, right? The mark on his side could have been self-inflicted. The temperature stuff, it is not hard to get a To get a thermometer to give a high reading, even to break, right? There's an interesting case from 1923 of a woman who had these incredibly high temperatures, and then she was caught increasing the temperature of the thermometers
SPEAKER_02with these hot water bottles, right?
SPEAKER_00Those examples are, so we can go through talking about the plausibility of fraud. Given the nature of the observations, the measurements that were made of Pio's temperature, I want to step back for a second, though, just to maybe put more structure, because we have spent a lot of time nitpicking the plausibility of this one observation about Romanelli, but maybe we do want to have a little bit more of a big picture look at this. The way I see it is, okay, we've got two hypotheses that are on the table here. One is that there's a constellation of supernatural charisms That are associated
SPEAKER_00with Padre Pio because he's a Catholic saint. And so he just fits the stereotype of a Catholic saint as what you would expect given the Catholic worldview. Okay, the second hypothesis is that basically There's some kind of fraud involving Padre Pio, at least involving self-inflicting these lesions and completing them in their symmetry and all of that. And that in addition to that, he's probably responsible for keeping the wounds open over this entire period of time.
SPEAKER_00And in addition to that, basically he's probably fraudulently manipulating these anomalous temperature readings that are being conducted on him. And basically that all the rest of the phenomena associated in proximity with him are just because with that initial core there, it creates an environment of like religious expectation and suggestion that then leads to all these knock-on like claimed healings and all the rest, right? Exactly. Yeah, yeah. So that's the natural theory that's being posited, which basically we can sort into two bins.
SPEAKER_02Could I just add in one thing? So that's the theory that seems plausible to me. But I'd add that in order to really establish that there's no natural explanation, we have to rule out all of the possible natural explanations, or at least show that they're very improbable. I find that one most persuasive given the evidence that I have, but it's certainly not the only possible one. But anyways, yeah, continue.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, so, I mean, we can also get into whether it is the only plausible one, because I do believe, I'm not convinced that there is really any plausible choice that doesn't involve fraud. So patient deception for hyperthermia and the... Basically some kind of self-infliction and artificial maintenance of those lesions. So I think that probably what you're saying is what the naturalist should say. And I think it gets more desperate, actually, if you try to avoid that. But then I say, okay, so the next step,
SPEAKER_00once we've laid out these two theories of the case, is then to say, okay, what would be discriminating observations given the sets of evidence that we have? So not this like, let's not create like a wish list of what evidence we wish we had, right? But instead, let's say, okay, given the sorts of evidence we actually have, what sorts of observations are going to be discriminating? Okay. Well, so first, let's start with the two legs. So the conspiracy horn and then the coincidence horn, right?
SPEAKER_02Well, can we not call it a conspiracy? Because it's not much of a conspiracy, right? It's just fraud, right?
SPEAKER_00Okay, so if you're going to deny that he has accomplices, I was just assuming the natural theory is going to have him having at least a few accomplices.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I don't know that I need to really have a strong opinion on that. I mean, if we get into it and it seems like, yeah, sure. But ultimately, right, the thing that I find persuasive for the fraud idea is Is that in particular, I think the temperature things is best explained by that. And I don't think that the people doing the measurements have to have been in a conspiracy. I mean, if they were, that would explain it. But I think they just have to be kind of trustworthy, sorry, trusting and not be paying that close attention. And that's good enough.
SPEAKER_02And similarly with the stigmata, right? I mean, I don't think that the doctors were part of the big fraud. I think that they just trusted him and they observed their things and they made their observation. But yeah, continue.
SPEAKER_00I did like conspiracy coincidence just because of the alliteration. I do think there's going to need to be accomplices, but we'll maybe get back to that in a second, especially at the stage Where we're focusing on the lesions themselves. As for the temperature measurements, we can come back to that. But I agree, it's not going to be a good strategy, given the diversity of people that perform the measurements, to try to say that each one of them has to be an accomplice, you know?
SPEAKER_00So you probably are going to say, no, he's deceiving lots of the people that are performing the measurements, rather than sort of reading them in on the conspiracy, if we say fraud in that case. But okay. But so for coincidence and conspiracy, Let's now just try to get a handle on what are going to be discriminating observations between these two theories. Okay. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And I just say that that's exactly what we need to do, right? Like the thing that I think would make your case much stronger, right? It is exactly kind of more thoroughly going through, like, okay, but in a fair way, right? More going through, like, if we consider fraud, what might we expect? What are the things that are most difficult to handle, right? That's what I felt was sort of missing from the treatment that you had, which, you know, fair, you can't cover everything all in one place.
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, a lot of what I'm trying to do is... I'm laying out what the facts are, the hard facts, sort of, what I take to be the hard facts for the naturalist, and then I'm almost leaving it to the reader. Obviously, I'm framing them in such a way that I'm hoping that it's sort of like there's an immediately obvious intuitively impeccable inference to what I'm going to say about why fraud has trouble accommodating some of these. But yeah, ideally, I also want to draw that out more.
SPEAKER_00But regardless, so let's just go into some of the discriminating observations. Can I just interrupt for one second?
SPEAKER_02My iPad is almost out of batteries, so can I just run in?
SPEAKER_01Play some elevator music here in the meantime because I'm not editing this. Too much post-production work. Timestamp will say, skip this.
SPEAKER_01This is good. Take all the time you need, Eugene. Soak up that monetization on YouTube here. Get like four more ads in this little segment, right? Beautiful. All good? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay, cool. Back to you, Ethan.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I was just about to get into what I take to be discriminating observations between the two theories. Okay, so first type of evidence, basically we'll sort it into two broad categories, right? I'll call it like moral circumstances and physical circumstances. So for moral circumstances, we're talking more about what we'd call character evidence, which will be plausibility raising for fraud if you found evidence of duplicity or mendacity by PO. So for instance, some of these plagiarism allegations would fall into that category.
SPEAKER_00And then meanwhile, on the opposite side, If what we see is instead a bunch of evidence of heroic virtue and him behaving in ways that would be sort of unexpected or anomalous given that he was doing simulated sanctity, then that will point the other way, right? And then the second category, and then I'll let you get in or jump in with whatever caveat you want. The second category is just going to be physical circumstances. So basically, these will go towards, here's practical infeasibility of fraud, right?
SPEAKER_00So these are aspects that would not be expected for a fraudster to be able to pull off, or they would even make it to where it was very likely he would be caught or exposed if he were trying to execute the fraudulent conspiracy. And basically, So those I would take to be discriminating observations with respect to conspiracy porn, and then we can talk about discriminating observations for coincidence, but you wanted to get in on the moral circumstances.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So I really don't think that moral considerations are particularly discriminating in this case. And the reason is just that the thing about fraudulent individuals is they are often very good at appearing to be not fraudulent, right? It's one of the kind of selective things It is an absolute cliché that when a fraudster is revealed, everyone is like, oh my god, I never would have believed it was him. This is true of evangelical preachers. It's true of many, not all of the spirituals.
SPEAKER_02Some of the spirituals had pretty bad reputations. But they always are able to build a group around them that is like, this is the most amazing person ever. They're so good. It's true of cult leaders, right? Even Sai Baba and guys like that, right? I mean, it's not uncommon for people to be able to be quite deceptive about what their character is. And on top of that, I'll say, you know, in terms of what seems plausible to me, I don't actually think that Padre Pio was a bad dude, right?
SPEAKER_02I don't think that he was cynically manipulating people because he wanted money or fame or anything like that, right? My thought... Is that he started faking the temperature thing because he wanted to get out of military service. And I think that he was influenced by the expectations of others to do and maintain the stigmata thing. But I am even willing to credit that the stigmata thing might have been
SPEAKER_02to some degree You know, inadvertent in the sense that he developed these sores and he treated them in a way that can cause them to continue to be sores, right? I think that's plausible enough, right? So I just I mean, I don't really think that I mean, sure, if if we Found evidence of him being very sinister, that might count against him, your theory. So in a way, your theory has the advantage that it makes slightly stronger predictions.
SPEAKER_02But I don't think it's at all incompatible with my theory that he has a reputation for kindness and that, in fact, he's very positive in a lot of aspects of his life. That's actually quite common for fraudsters, to almost want to redeem themselves in other aspects.
SPEAKER_00One way you're describing the argument is underselling it because you're making it about reputation. Now, what I'm saying is there's diligent investigations into particular facts about his psychology and his moral temperament that could strongly bear on the plausibility of fraud, especially when you attribute Certain fraudulent motives to him, because then we can see whether those are consistent with his pattern of conduct. And it's a similar type of argument that we'd make. Like for instance, if I were arguing against a 9-11 truther, a bunch of arguments I would make would be, okay,
SPEAKER_00here's why it would be like irrational and inconsistent with the MO of the government officials that you're saying would be complicit to execute the conspiracy in the way that you said they would execute it, right? Those would be sort of natural considerations that would jump to my mind. I would say Yeah, a bunch of the things you're saying are just not plausible given all the context I have about who these people are, what their motives are, what they foreseeably would have thought would have advanced their motives or not advanced them. So let me give an example. And we can just say a lot of this is an inductive generalization from the typical ways in which people behave, right?
SPEAKER_00And so fraudsters, one typical way they behave is trying to, at least people who are real pathological liars who are going to commit to the bit over really extended periods of time. One thing that's not unexpected Is that they would put a lot of work into and be really successful at impressing people into thinking they were a great guy, right? That's actually a common goal of fraudsters is to give off the impression. And it's something that helps facilitators conducive to fraud. It helps you prey upon people that you gain their trust, right? So that's why I wouldn't point to,
SPEAKER_00for exactly the reasons you're mentioning, I wouldn't point to his really relevant moral evidence that there are lots of people who love Padre Pio and think his demeanor is great or think he's a great guy, right? But there are other, but just let me give an example just to illustrate of the types of moral arguments that I think are more telling, right? So for instance, It appears a lot of what Padre Pio is doing throughout his life, the most plausible fraudulent explanation for it is going to involve a fraudulent motive of simulated sanctity,
SPEAKER_00where he's trying to seem like he's been supernaturally graced by God in all these extraordinary ways. And he likes actually kind of the attention and the reputation that he develops in connection with that. So that's what I would say is a fraudulent motive. And so I think it would be disconfirmatory for fraud If we found patterns of behavior for Pio that were inconsistent with that type of personality that would lead him to that. One of the strongest examples that I would point to is just compare and contrast
SPEAKER_00as match controls. There's one example where when he's under investigation by the Holy Office and where he's being visited by Bishop Rossi and all these depositions are being conducted over days. For him, at that point in time, he readily presented himself with the lesions at the least impressive form that they were ever in across any of the series of observations that were made by any of the physicians, any of the friars over years, to where they appear like they're basically about to disappear at this point during
SPEAKER_00the Rossi examinations, right? There are lesions there because we see the pigmentation and we see the blood at the spots. And so there's some kind of exudation of blood where the lesions are supposed to go. But basically, it doesn't even seem like it perforates or tears into skin at the moment of the rosy observation. And meanwhile, he has plenty of forewarning. And to account for the rest of the observations, he basically needs to be able to induce these impressive lesions at will and maintain them at will. And so him allowing, at the time when it's the highest stakes for him that the lesions be impressive, Him allowing them to give off the least impressive appearance when he's examined
SPEAKER_00by Rossi. Now, contrast. He goes in for hernia repair surgery with Festa years later, okay? And Festa and Merla are taking him in and he refuses anesthesia, okay? Because he knows that Festa is going to want to take a look at the wounds, okay? So he's willing to endure the excruciating pain of doing the surgery without the benefit of anesthesia in order to prevent an inspection of the wounds. Now, he passes out during the surgery because the pain is too much, okay?
SPEAKER_00So he passes out unconscious and then Festa examines the wounds. And Festa's report is that the wounds had exactly the same characteristics as during Festa's last examination. And so the wounds are impressive, okay? And then Padre Pio is outraged by this and prevents Festa from ever examining him again after he unconsensually looked at the wounds during the surgery, even though Festa's report is entirely favorable at this juncture. And Festa is going to be one of the biggest medical proponents of his authenticity, defending him from critics, right? And so notice that. He's willing to make extremely costly sacrifices in terms of physical pain
SPEAKER_00to conceal the wounds when they're going to be observed as impressive. And he puts no effort into making them impressive When they're being examined in a really high stakes adversarial examination by Rossi. So if a lot of the reason he's going out of his way to fake this evidence and to simulate this phenomena is that he likes the reputation that there's all these credible charisms that are attached to him, which is the opposite of the public persona that he's putting on where he's trying to be humble and he's embarrassed by this and he's trying to downplay and minimize it. This is exactly the opposite sort of pattern of behavior that I would expect.
SPEAKER_00So that's an example of the type of consideration that I would take to be evidentially weighty.
SPEAKER_02Don't think that these psychological considerations are especially weighty anyways. What I would say is, when we're trying to anticipate the motives of people, particularly when we are dealing with a lot of complex counter-pressing motives, we can tell just those stories like, oh, if he was thinking of this, then he would do that, and then it would make sense. We don't know. I'm not going to argue that none of this can possibly
SPEAKER_02make any difference, but the extent that we should put weight on it is very, very small. People are complicated. There's just so many different things that might have been going on. Who knows whether he had regrets in I think that one of the things that's very hard for
SPEAKER_02For us to wrap our heads around for, you know, these sort of unusual cases is that people have an incredible ability to rationalize things to themselves and to kind of live through circumstances with a very unusual interpretation of it, right? Like the thing that always sort of like blows my mind with this regard is the quite sad cases of women who, you know, usually when they're teenagers, right, they become pregnant. And they carry the child to term and they give birth all the while denying
SPEAKER_02that they're pregnant, right? Never accepting it, right? And then sort of treating the birth as like almost like a hallucination and then sort of denying it to themselves after the fact, right? Like the fact is, is that the ability of people to kind of rationalize things, make it make sense to themselves, tell stories where they kind of end up being not the bad guy, right? It's just, it's so strong. It's so remarkable. That I just feel that these attempts to kind of like sort of figure out, oh, well, it wouldn't make sense for him to do this or it like would make sense.
SPEAKER_02It just, it can't carry very much weight. Like we just, we don't know what would, sorry, go ahead. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So again, this seems to be like one of these appeals to possibility where, um, but that's the whole point is sometimes people do weird, unexpected things conceded. Okay. That there are two predictions that are made where this behavior is very surprising and the opposite of what you'd expect under one model and is exactly what you'd expect given the other model still is evidentially weighty, right? So there are There are generalizations that we can make about how people are expected to behave
SPEAKER_00in certain situations, and depending on whether their behavior is inconformity or out of conformity, we often update on the relative plausibility of different hypotheses to explain their behavior, okay? And so just making psychological inference is possible, and depending on specific facts, sometimes the inference will be stronger or weaker, right? Yeah, sure.
SPEAKER_02I'm perfectly willing to concede that some of his behavior supports the idea that he wasn't seeking fame, right? And that's somewhat anomalous on the idea that he was a fraud. But it's not just that he's not seeking fame.
SPEAKER_00Here's the things that are going on. So these are two very strong observations. One is he's making extremely costly sacrifices that any psychologically normal person wouldn't. Which is basically being willing to go into surgery without anesthesia, specifically to downplay the stigmata and to prevent a favorable physician from making favorable observations. He's then so outraged that the favorable physician made favorable observations that he's cutting that favorable physician off from continuing to make positive observations in the future. And then contrasting that to when he has the strongest incentive to mislead Rossi
SPEAKER_00with this phenomena. That's when he doesn't put any effort into confusing him or to deceiving him, right? And so that's when his wounds are at their least impressive while he's simultaneously maintaining all the testimony about concerning what has occurred. And so when you look at that fact pattern, I would say, for my model, it makes perfect sense to me that a person would behave that way. And in fact, it's fully consistent with my model of who Pio is that he would behave that way, which is his whole line the whole time has been that he's super humble, That he doesn't like the attention, that he was praying for the stigmata to go away,
SPEAKER_00that he doesn't like it when people are coming and basically promoting the stigmata, right? And that he's fine even with being resigned to people forming these negative impressions of him. Then meanwhile, on this rival model where he's going out of his way and committing to the bit over 50 years of executing this fraud under the noses of everybody in the entire convent, That he's putting minimal effort in the highest stakes adversarial investigation and presenting in an impressive way, and then depriving himself of favorable testimony that improves his credibility intentionally in ways that are extremely costly.
SPEAKER_00So when I look at those- Are they
SPEAKER_02extremely costly?
SPEAKER_00I mean- To have surgery without anesthesia?
SPEAKER_02But the thing is, that's- The report, right, that we get from...
SPEAKER_00Festa and Rua.
SPEAKER_02From Festa, yeah, in giving this context and telling this story about what was going on, right?
SPEAKER_00But there's an atheist that's present with him that can verify the facts and where he's naming him and he's available to... So he's publishing the claim about a joint
SPEAKER_02experience. It's a published claim that is part of a much larger narrative that is presenting a particular story about Padre Pio, right? And there is not any... There's not any clarity that that is actually what the motives are. There's not any clarity that an observer who was seeing that from the outside would have understood that that was what happened. And on top of that, it's not even clear, right?
SPEAKER_02If Padre Pio says that, you know, I'm not going to allow you to do this For this particular reason, we don't know that he was necessarily telling the truth. Perhaps there was some other reason, right?
SPEAKER_00But we look at his behavior and we see that it's fully consistent. So we see, like an example is, Festa never examines him again after that day, and he's never involved in his medical care again after that day. So Pio cuts him off after he examines the lesions and forms a favorable impression of how they are presenting at that time, right? And that's the point when Pio cuts him off. And then Festa tells us a story about why that happened, And to corroborate his story about all the facts that have just occurred, he says it's happening alongside here's a hostile guy who's there, right? And we're naming him and we're putting it in print.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So that idea, I think it's very credible that that story is veridical, that that story happened. And I think the interpretation of it that presents itself to the mind is sort of immediate and obvious of, And it makes perfect sense within the PO authenticity narrative. And it's clearly baffling given the inauthenticity narrative. And so those are the types of discriminating observations.
SPEAKER_02So, okay. So we've identified some things that you are saying are weighing in favor of the one narrative and the other. So there's these psychological things. What was the other class of a thing that you suggested weighed in favor?
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. So the physical circumstances. So basically that it would be practically infeasible. So here's an example, right? Which is to just go with the blood, since that's one we haven't talked about much, right? So one thing that we're getting from the testimony of lots of people that are constantly in Could you just clarify for me something?
SPEAKER_02So what's the documentation that we have of the quantities of these bandages and the amount of blood that's coming? What's the basis for you making this claim about the extended end quantity of the thing?
SPEAKER_00Because I'm curious about that. Unfortunately, it's hard to summarize because it's so many observations that are being synthesized in order to give rough estimates. But here I give you a sketch of the types of observations we have. So we have descriptions from observers about during a bunch of separate particular incidents, the amount of blood flow that's coming out of Padre Pio. We have similar observers who are constantly seeing him during certain periods of times, giving us retrospective accounts of, okay, here's the amount of blood That was typically coming out,
SPEAKER_00that this is basically representative. We then have people saying, okay, for instance, Festa being like, okay, he had lots of diapers that are soaked in blood in his room, and I took one of them home to do a microscopic examination of it. There's people making observations of like, okay, I'm seeing half a liter of blood coming from the side wound. You have those types of observations that are being made. We have descriptions by the physicians about the appearance of the blood. It's like this fresh red blood that sometimes it was semi-clotted.
SPEAKER_00Those are the types of observations that we're putting forward, which is basically, we've got lots of blood-stained stuff that's associated with Padre Pio. We've got lots of witnesses saying, yeah, he was bleeding all the time. Then we've got particular episodes where we have people describing particular rough estimates of quantities of blood that are coming
SPEAKER_02out. Here's what I would suggest about that. The inference that one develops dealing with these kinds of cases periodically is that when you look into the evidence a bit more, it becomes less impressive upon further examination. I haven't looked into these stories about the quantities of blood, but two things.
SPEAKER_02Making estimates just by observation of blood is very, very difficult. A small quantity of blood, and I can verify this because I get nosebleeds all the time, a small quantity of blood can create a big stain. It can create a thick, large patch that looks as if you're bleeding to death. Quite small quantities of blood are very scary. So that's the first thing. The second thing is it is certainly not at all difficult to produce bloodstained bandages if you're trying to put on a fraud.
SPEAKER_02So the thing that I kind of want to step back and say is that there is no doubt going to be various things that militate in favor of your theory. There's going to be evidence that supports it more than my theory. But what's required for a naturalist like me to take this stuff very seriously is
SPEAKER_02very scientific standards of evidence. So you, for example, produced this estimate of how much blood he was losing every day. It's like 100 milliliters, which is quite a lot.
SPEAKER_00Well, just for context, like if you were talking about your nosebleed where you described that as a little bit of blood, that's probably 30 to 50 milliliters of blood that you would lose during a nosebleed.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So the point that I'm making is that for me to take seriously this idea that he was losing so much blood, That he must have got anemia and him not getting anemia is miraculous. I just need measurements. I need much better data than what you have provided. It's all subjective impressions. It's stories of things that could be faked by Witnesses who don't have any quantitative handle on what they're looking at,
SPEAKER_02aside from a few dramatic things like, oh, there's this jar full of blood that apparently poured out of his stigmata, which is weird and gross, but there you go. I sympathize with the idea that if you are already on board with this being miraculous, that this stuff feels like it should be persuasive. If you are familiar with the lengths to which frauds have gone to try
SPEAKER_02to verify themselves, and if you are familiar with how difficult it is to make accurate quantitative estimates based on the kind of evidence that you're looking at, you can't take this kind of evidence too seriously. It's just not persuasive.
SPEAKER_00The whole point here Is I'm trying to establish very conservative lower bounds, okay? And I want to get a lower bound that's way above the threshold for inexplicability, right? For the inferences that I'm drawing about inexplicability. And I'm also helping to corroborate my lower bound by saying, okay, let's assume that there has to be repeated reinfliction, right? Then with different assumptions that we have, we could also say there's a certain amount of blood loss that's just going to be collateral to that,
SPEAKER_00that we could also try to use that to help corroborate the bound that we're establishing. But yes, obviously these are rough estimates. There's rough estimates that are way more favorable to me of him losing 500 milliliters a day, like half a liter of blood a day. So there's people who give observations that are way higher than mine. I'm trying to say, look, here's the sorts of things that I want. So I'm going to say for every 100 milliliters of blood, it's going to be like 50 milligrams of iron that he's going to lose.
SPEAKER_00Here's what his daily iron intake without supplementation is going to be. It's going to be like six milligrams very favorably if he had exactly the right diet. We know he actually has very poor nutrition. So let's say he had optimal dietary intake without iron supplementation. Let's say six. So then we say, okay, How long can I run an iron deficit of dozens of milligrams of iron? How long can I run that without developing iron deficiency anemia?
SPEAKER_02But the problem is that the estimate that you're working with isn't based on a quality of evidence that can support that inference, right? It could be much less, right? We just don't have enough evidence about the consistency of the blood, about how much it was. It's just totally inadequate for what you're trying to conclude from it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I don't know how you know the evidence is inadequate if, as you can see, you haven't looked at it, right?
SPEAKER_02Well, because from what you've described, it is visual reports of impressive circumstances of people saying, oh, there was a lot of blood on his bandages. We don't know how regularly observe the bandages. The people are also seeing the hemorrhages.
SPEAKER_00So we can go look and we'll go look at the... It is anecdotes spread over 50 years.
SPEAKER_02It's just not So again,
SPEAKER_00repeated observations of, and we're looking at, okay, here are wrappings that are saturated. They're distributed across these five lesions, the five lesion sites. We're seeing, okay, here's what's being described by trained medical professionals as abundant effusions or hemorrhages of blood. Okay. Then we're going and we're looking and we're saying, okay, Here are people describing, here's what the typical flow looks like. Let's assume minimal flow from each of these. Let's just assume very minimal flow, so the bottom end of what's plausible given the perceptual reports
SPEAKER_00that are being given. I even start to concede, let's just start assuming That there's non-bloody fluid that's heavily diluting this, and let's try to establish some bounds there, right? So at the point when it feels, it looks the less bloody, so when you're not getting the clotting observations, when it doesn't seem like it's the bright red, fresh blood, during that period where you had an interruption in the flow, and then you're at least there, you're having 12% content, okay, I think was the inference that was made from blood work that was done. So then I say, okay, let's establish that as just our really conservative lower bound where we know
SPEAKER_00the true content is going to be higher.
SPEAKER_02Can I just interrupt for a second? Because, I mean, I get, you know, you had your methodology that used to do this. Now, I haven't looked at the methodology, right? So what I'm just going to say is, okay, so sight unseen. What I expect is that if you share, you know, the thorough details of how you came up with your 100 milliliters a day thing, And people like me look at it, what they will conclude is that you made assumptions in there that to us seem incredible, or at least we don't have to credit. And consequently, we don't accept your 100 milliliter thing, right?
SPEAKER_02So maybe I'm wrong, right? Like maybe if when we present, could you just let me finish? Maybe when you present the thing, maybe when I look at it, I'm like, actually, you know what? Those assumptions are totally reasonable. They're super minimal, right? If when we look at it, we're like, oh, actually, you know, he's assuming this, he's assuming that, the evidence is that, right, if we go in, then what that suggests is that, yes, once again, the evidence upon further examination kind of collapses. So we can't, like, figure this out there.
SPEAKER_02You're not going to be able to explain it to me in enough detail. I'm not going to be able to understand enough that I can be like, oh, yes, definitely. Or I'll be like, oh, no, definitely not, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I'm just saying, let's just look at this. To say that there's continuous bleeding with occasional but frequent hemorrhaging, okay? But we don't really know that there's continuous bleeding. no, but I'm just saying for bunches of witnesses to be described, this is what the blood flow seems like coming from all these wounds that this guy has. Then we just say, okay, let's just take your nosebleed example. If you're talking about one of those really brief ones, that could be a few milliliters of blood coming out of your nose.
SPEAKER_00If you're talking about one of those big ones, that's probably more like 30 milliliters of blood from a big nosebleed, which is what I imagine you had in mind. But the basic idea there is, Imagine you have that more minimal amount, right? Where we're dealing with like five milliliters of blood, okay? And for there to be any kind of visible seepage coming out of the wounds over the course of a day on both the dorsal and the Palmer side and then the side wound,
SPEAKER_02That's why I'm saying okay
SPEAKER_00Just minimal is if there were trivial seepage from these wounds at multiple points throughout the day, and if we're assuming just a few milliliters from each site where there's being this seepage that's visible, then I'm saying let's aggregate that and just trying to sustain that over extended periods, especially if you had periods where there was way more substantial, it's going to start to become very perplexing about how this guy isn't becoming anemic.
SPEAKER_02I understand that that's the argument. I'm just saying that my expectation is that when people look into it, they will find that it is unconvincing. So maybe it's great. Maybe that will become an anomaly, at which point the problem then becomes, is there a natural explanation for how there could be that much blood loss? And then there's this one test where he's not anemic.
SPEAKER_00The test that he's not anemic is he's not dead.
SPEAKER_02People can't live with anemia?
SPEAKER_00No, no. The thing that people can't sustain is once you get past a certain level of iron deficiency anemia, the guy is going to need medical treatment for anemia or he's going to die as long as he's sustaining this iron deficit.
SPEAKER_02Sorry, I'm mistaken. I thought maybe the evidence was better than it is. I thought that there were blood tests that showed that he was healthy.
SPEAKER_00Well, there were blood tests that were performed in the 50s, right? Okay, but the 50s is pretty early. Well, the 50s is late because he's dying in like 68.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so there's some blood tests in the 50s.
SPEAKER_00But the point here is once a person, just if a person is losing lots and lots of iron over time, there comes a point where the person's iron deficit is substantial enough that it's, so first is, okay, there's a certain threshold you're going to meet where you're just inevitably going to become anemic. And then there's going to be conspicuous signs that a person has become anemic that are just like clinically immediately recognizable that were not observed. But in addition to that, if you continue to sustain the blood losses after that point, There's going to come a point where you can't keep running the iron deficit
SPEAKER_00that you're running and that be compatible with life, right? So let's say I'm saying, okay, my replacement rate is like six milligrams per day. And let's say I'm running a deficit consistently of just like net, let's say negative 15 milligrams per day iron. Okay. Well, if I accumulate that over years or decades, running an iron deficit like that, There's just going to come a point where it's incompatible with life.
SPEAKER_02I will just say that it seems very unlikely to me that a medical doctor is going to find that logic a convincing case for this. For one thing, the fact that when he's tested, he has no anemia is evidence that your estimates are wrong. Right? When we have these estimates that are based on qualitative observations, they're based on subjective impressions, they're based on particular anecdotes that are not consistently spread over a whole long period. And then we get a test that shows the opposite.
SPEAKER_02Someone of a scientific bent is going to say we should trust the test and we should expect that there's some sort of problem with their estimate. Estimates are hard. You had to make tons of assumptions about how consistent this was, how much blood is seeping out of these things. What this suggests is that, yeah, he wasn't anemic and consequently probably wasn't losing that much blood. The thing is, if we had better evidence, if we had a chance to do actual measurements and look at this more quantitatively,
SPEAKER_02then yeah, that could start to provide a convincing case that a naturalist is like, oh, that's weird. And of course, then we can still try and doctor house it and be like, well, this is an unusual case. Perhaps it is an unusual circumstance or whatever, right? But we're not even there yet, right? We're not even at the point where we have to start thinking like, oh, maybe this is actually naturally somewhat anomalous, right? No, what we have is we have a bunch of qualitative estimates based on Reports spread out all of this stuff that gives us an anomalous result that's contraindicated by measurements.
SPEAKER_00What I've tried to do is create a situation where there's not much sensitivity of my conclusion to the plausible estimation error that I'm making. I'm just trying to get a handle with this. If we threw out the 100 milliliter argument, an argument of the same structure that I'm making without that sort of quantitative anchor for what the lower bound was could similarly be convincing without that estimate. That estimate just helps understand how much we're overshooting, even on some more minimal assumptions about what the blood loss from each lesion is.
SPEAKER_02I don't think it's profitable for us to debate right now whether and to what extent your estimates were based on reasonable things. Ultimately, it's pretty complicated. We have to look at the details. I'm not set up to really think about it right now. Estimates like this are difficult to do well, right? And I wonder, like, suppose I mean, I don't even know enough about this, right? To know like what sort of blood loss has been clinically observed in people over
SPEAKER_02a long time and what sort of effect that has on iron. Like I'm sure there's studies, right? But I don't know. So for me to evaluate this kind of methodology that you have, I'd have to go out and do a bunch of research and I'd have to look into what doctors have actually found about long-term blood loss. And there are probably cases of people who like have a lot of long-term blood loss and we can look into that, right? And you know, maybe what? Maybe it'll turn out that you did a great job and this is convincing and it's a real problem. I'm just saying my anticipation is when I look into it, if I don't, I probably won't.
SPEAKER_02But if someone does, and perhaps they will, they will find that, oh, actually, here's where Ethan went wrong. Either actually there are ways that this level of blood loss is capable of being We can see exactly where if you change some of the estimates, then you get a figure of 10 milliliters instead of 100 milliliters. And then 10 milliliters, we have strong evidence that shows that people can survive that.
SPEAKER_00I want to notice something kind of funny that's happened, which is so the claims that were being made on Substack that provoke the conversation that we're having now are basically like, Oh, well, my evidence sucks. This is easy for the naturalist to accommodate, you know, like, whoa, what credulous dupes these guys are for falling for this stuff, right? And then what we're getting now is, okay, I haven't looked into your evidence. I'm not going to look into your evidence. The argument that you're sketching right now, potentially if you aren't making big mistakes that I am not in a position to know whether you've made or not made, could work.
SPEAKER_00But I basically assume that you're wrong. Well, then notice, if we turn around and we say, I don't know what the evidence is, I don't intend to find out what the evidence is, but I know the evidence sucks, and I'm going to go publicly tell everybody about how much it sucks. Do you see why that's not epistemically responsible and it's not really scientific?
SPEAKER_02Well, I actually have a whole argument about this, and there's a good reason. And I can understand your incredulity, right? That, you know, I did all this work. Like, I came up with this thing. Why is this guy not taking it seriously, right? But the reason for that is that there is a... A lot of inductive evidence, right? And the inductive evidence, I go into this in the last piece that I wrote on my Substack, right? Is that when you investigate these things, they fall apart. And the starting point for this, right?
SPEAKER_02Is that what is the core of the claims that you are making, right? They are claims about mysterious Stigmata, their claims about anomalous temperature readings, their claims about miraculous healings, right? Are any of those typically difficult for naturalists to explain? No, they're not. Right? I mean, so yes. When you are actually going into looking at a particular case, you have to approach it with objectivity, right?
SPEAKER_02But the thing is, and this is one of the reasons why this strategy is necessary, right? Is that miraculous, seemingly miraculous phenomena are so, so, so, so common, right? Conspiracy theorists and, you know, supernatural explanations are everywhere, right? And so there's this sense that the naturalists get, right? Which is that it's a case of whack-a-mole, right? Put down one explanation. You're like, okay, here's why this one is. Then they come up with another one. And then they bring that. And you're like, you have to go through. So yeah, sure.
SPEAKER_00In this case, for me, I'm a supernature guy. You're a conspiracy guy for me. That's how I view it. And there's similar sorts of reasoning that I meet with people. I talk to conspiracists all the time. And actually, they sound exactly the same way you do if I try to refute their conspiracy theories. And so just obviously those are, that's how we're coming at it. But I think it would be helpful and sort of epistemically responsible if rather than saying, oh, this evidence sucks when you don't know what the evidence is and you're not really in a position to
SPEAKER_02evaluate. Well, no, I can tell you broadly what the epistemic situation is because the evidence that you're using for this does suck because it's qualitative, right? It's based on People's impressions and observations, it's not systematic or scientific at all, right? And so necessarily for you to construct this estimate, you'll have had to make assumptions that are defeasible, right?
SPEAKER_00And so we have to ask. So what would be the argument for why it's impossible to exclude the natural explanation without a
SPEAKER_02quantitative measurement of the blood flow? Because for us to exclude the naturalistic measurement, we need to have good reason to think that the estimates and the projection over the whole time are accurate.
SPEAKER_00Let's just say I had video. Of constant outpouring of massive quantities like a gallon of blood every day. And I had video of that and I just went through and I said, okay, here's 50 years and every day a gallon of blood is coming out of the moon.
SPEAKER_02Sure, that would be great.
SPEAKER_00That's not quantitative, that's qualitative, okay? Yeah. I don't have a measurement. So notice your premise was mistaken. So now there's some kind of qualitative evidence that could be sufficient to warrant the claim, right? Ethan, don't play these rhetorical games here.
SPEAKER_02Qualitative measurements are the sort of evidence that would be convincing, okay? Let me rephrase. It is possible to have qualitative evidence that rises up to scientific standards, right? But, I mean, this is why it's hard, right? It's like you can have videos of blood pouring out of people, right? I'm sure that there are impressive magic tricks where blood pours out of people.
SPEAKER_02The point that we want is we want Evidence that meets scientific standards, okay? And so, yeah, I was speaking casually, talking as if no qualitative evidence meets scientific standards, right? But I certainly didn't mean to get that impression. We were just talking, you know, in an informal way. The point of referring to quantitative evidence is to point to the idea that for us
SPEAKER_02to establish with confidence an estimate that will override A actual measurement of the guy's blood, right? We have to be very, very confident that it's accurate, okay? And, you know, I could be wrong about this, but based on what you've said about what the basis for your estimates are, it seems to me very unlikely that the evidence is sufficient to give us good confidence in your lower bound.
SPEAKER_00Okay, well, so the point here is just there are certain types of qualitative evidence that we could use to establish certain thresholds for how much blood plausibly was lost. Then we say, okay, given those thresholds, do those thresholds exceed basically where we would have non-anomalous blood loss from the wounds, both ideologically and in terms of survivability or sequelae that were observed, consistent with those. So I think qualitative evidence in principle could be good enough. Then there's a question about the nature of the different lines
SPEAKER_00of qualitative evidence that we're bringing to bear here to establish those estimates and how much air we can have baked in to the estimate. To try to basically to try to be concessive to a skeptic. So we're trying to say, okay, let's assume gross misestimation. But let's say here are the bounds that are sort of minimally consistent with these qualitative observations. And then let's say, let's determine whether that's still anomalous. Now, I think in principle, that's fine. I think you say, I assume if I looked into it, it would see that there were problems, right?
SPEAKER_02Well, you get that that's not an assumption so much as an informed inference, right? Setting that aside for a second, the problem is even more than that. We're dealing with a situation where at least one of the hypotheses is that there's fraud going on. Observations that we're looking at, the qualitative observations, can't even be seen to be entirely reliable. I have looked into this and I think some of the other people, but I remember reading accounts where people are talking about the claim
SPEAKER_02that there was blood that flowed out and filled up a jar. If any of those things were faked, then that again, it throws the whole set of estimates out the window.
SPEAKER_00So even if that anecdote were completely lost, actually the basis, the evidentiary foundation for my estimate would remain completely intact. That's just an example to show there's episodic bleeding where if we just concede the observation that you're losing bloods in even those quantities on individual episodes, then basically that's giving us an idea of, okay, you couldn't suffer over 50 years, even a few of those types of hemorrhages without some kind of intensive care to replenish. The losses that you would be accumulatively suffering,
SPEAKER_00especially if there was something persistent that was even preventing you from just being at neutral in terms of the replacement.
SPEAKER_02Out of curiosity, when you're doing this research, which I'm curious about, I'm interested in more, did you look into medical research into people who suffer from blood loss over periods of time?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I even cite it in the article, but there's also a certain extent to which, and I've got friends that are very skeptical. I've got a guy who's a pathologist that I talk to all the time, who's a big atheist guy, and he roughs me up a lot of the time, because his medical knowledge is way more than mine, so he kind of beats me up when I try to enthusiastically make certain types of arguments. Or over-enthusiastically make certain types of arguments. I do try to look in to see what's plausible, what's implausible,
SPEAKER_00and whether there are extreme outlier cases in the medical literature, in which case my inference will have to be weaker. Obviously, it would still be evidentially probative if you would have to be alongside being this crazy fraudster person. There was also the fortuitous coincidence that you had a one in 10 million blood condition or something.
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I think there is evidence to suggest that there's something weird going on with him medically, right? In the sense that he has these health problems, right? But I mean, so... The point here, I think, though, that's important, is that even if I look at this stuff for this particular thing, I'm like, oh, you know what? Actually, those estimates are really great. At that point, we're still just back at, well, at that point, we have to doctor house and we have to think a little bit about what could be
SPEAKER_02an explanation of this. I don't expect that we would get there, but it's possible. Stepping back, right? So we've seen some attempts to explain the difference between the two hypotheses in terms of like, oh, well, psychologically, it's less likely based on this particular piece of evidence and the other, right? And then we have these attempts to show that some of the characteristics of
SPEAKER_02the case are naturally inexplicable, right? And I mean, It seems to me that when we look at where we're at right now, there's certainly nothing that is even strongly convincing to a naturalist. There's some things that I'm like, Maybe that point is somewhat in favor of this hypothesis and that point is somewhat in favor of those, right?
SPEAKER_02But, I mean, we haven't even really started talking about some of the things that might favor my hypothesis over yours, right? So, I mean, I don't want to And I have to go in about 10 or 15 minutes, so we are going to have to wrap things up a little bit. I've got to pick up my kids from school. So talk about the heroic virtue thing for a second. I mean, I'm not a Roman Catholic, and I don't know what is expected of saints,
SPEAKER_02but to me, One of the points that seems to me to be countering or moving against the idea of heroic virtue is the fact that he is active in Mussolini's Italy, and during the period of his fame, He's not in favor of Mussolini publicly or anything like that, but he also doesn't condemn Mussolini. He doesn't condemn fascism. He doesn't act in any kind of way as an example
SPEAKER_02that might rally people around resisting fascism. I mean, honestly, if I think about... If I'm imagining the one person that God is choosing in order to give these miraculous... Abilities in the middle of the 20s, the 30s, the 40s, what I would expect to happen is that they get executed by the fascists, right? Because to be virtuous enough to deserve God's grace, right, above everybody else,
SPEAKER_02Don't you think you should at least be anti-fascism to a certain extent? And I'm not saying that it can't be explained. Of course, you can accommodate it. But that's what heroic virtue would look like to me. So the fact that a lot of his buddies are fascists and the fact that he's part of this kind of conservative Catholic thing that is serving as an institution to prop up fascism in the 20s and 30s, to me, that's a point against him. So, I mean, I don't know. It seems to me as if you're at least a long way away from the goal, right?
SPEAKER_02Because the evidence that we have that is supposed to distinguish between these two Theories is, you know, maybe there's a bit of probative points in some aspects of it, right, here and there. But I mean, nothing that at all has been like, oh, you've ruled out a naturalistic explanation. And remember, I'm coming in with an enormous prior that is based on a lot of evidence, right, that says that Most, I think all, but certainly most,
SPEAKER_02and I think you'd agree with me that most miracles, most claimed miracles, most stigmatics are not real, that the evidence for them is poor and that we should not believe in them. So, I mean, for you to rule out A naturalistic explanation of something that pretty clearly seems to be naturalistically producible, like some marks on your hands. I mean, yes, the strategy of trying to prove that, you know, there's enough blood loss that something weird must be going on.
SPEAKER_02I mean, that makes sense, right? That's a plausible direction to go. But even then, right, that just brings up the idea that there might be a medical thing, right? So I just feel like That's why, to me, the hyperbole of this is impossible to explain, it's billion to one odds, the theory that you'd need to make this has all these epicycles and so forth, there's some weird things about yours too. I don't want to go back and relitigate it.
SPEAKER_02It seems to me that a lot of the details of how the stuff is coming and going and the details of Padre Pio's life, you know, there's a certain amount of massaging that needs to make it to fit in what we would really expect from a miraculous saint. Like, again, going in, And maybe this is ridiculous, you know, based on Catholic experiences. But remember, most of these guys were frauds anyways, right? We agree that most of the stigmatists were fraud. I would kind of expect a real stigmatist to have, you know, like actual penetrating moves.
SPEAKER_02I mean, maybe that's silly, but that's what I think, right? And so I just feel like the evidential situation here is one where a naturalist does really not feel very threatened, you know?
SPEAKER_00Okay, so, I mean, what I'll say there, I mean, first, by way of just a few thoughts on the moral.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and since we're time, limited time, maybe just like one or two more back and forth and we'll wrap it up. yeah, yeah, I think we'll basically wrap it up.
SPEAKER_00So I'll just treat this more as like some concluding thoughts. But on what he just said regarding fascism, I mean, it's actually not that surprising to me. That a holy saint who's in a monastery, whose job is primarily to be a spiritual father to all of these millions of pilgrims that are coming and he's hearing their confessions and causing their moral transformation, that within the Catholic value system where the spiritual good is so much more important than the temporal good, that he would be sort of politically apathetic or politically indifferent rather
SPEAKER_00than becoming like a political agitator, political revolutionary. Especially when that may even impede him in exercising the spiritual care for the community that's part of Italy and make him polarizing in a way where he probably can't do nearly as much good as a political figure as he can do as a spiritual figure. And for us, those spiritual concerns are categorically very important. So for him, if you had it, he's out there and he's a fascist propagandist, or he's clearly got tons of sympathies for the problematic aspects of fascism rather
SPEAKER_00than Like the sort of sanitized version of it or whatever, right? If that were what you were showing, I think that would be more evidentially relevant. But just to say that he's politically apathetic and he's primarily concerned with being like a spiritual guy, within the Catholic worldview, that seems like a perfectly morally prudent course. So I wouldn't count that as something like harder.
SPEAKER_02Can I just ask you a question though? Because like, I feel like if he had He had been an outspoken opponent of fascism, that you would have counted that as pretty strong evidence that he's a moral exemplar. He had actually been executed by Mussolini by standing up for the Jews when they were deported or something.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, if a person is willing to suffer for persecution for their political... It's the same thing, though. If I flew off to Palestine to go beyond the ground, Basically resisting the idea for providing humanitarian assistance. A lot of people I know would think, oh, wow, he's a great guy. But not a lot of people are like, because I'm not doing that, oh, I must not be a good guy for all this other stuff I did. You notice there's two different standards there. One is there are certain things that are supererogatory that you could do that would show virtue if you did them.
SPEAKER_00And then another thing, which is it's actually acceptable for a very moral person to concern themselves with some forms of doing good and to refrain from others.
SPEAKER_02I feel like with what's claimed to be an unprecedented sate with miraculous powers that extend beyond almost anyone that we know, we expect supererogatory moral good myself, right? And so insofar as you can see that...
SPEAKER_00But you don't expect every supererogatory thing, right? That's a pretty
SPEAKER_02relevant one,
SPEAKER_00though.
SPEAKER_02And I mean, I will also point out that there's plenty of Roman Catholics who stood up against, you know, Political corruption of various types. And, you know, it's not, I mean, yes, of course, the spiritual thing is, is, is important, but there's plenty of examples of people doing that. So the thing is, it's a little bit having your cake and eating it too, right? Like you would definitely count it in favor of him if he did it, but the fact that he didn't, you know, oh, well, whatever.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think that is a genuine asymmetry where it's like the fact that someone is not martyred doesn't mean they're a bad guy, but, and, and a person can be a very holy saint who's not a martyr, right? But there are other people who are martyrs and it does sort of scream virtue when a person is martyred, right? And so it's, I think that that's not actually an unusual asymmetry where, and we expect people to have different moral concerns and to do different things depending on what's prudent in the circumstances. Now, for Pio in that case, I think he had an outstanding level of moral impact,
SPEAKER_00and he did suffer a lot of persecution, right? So he both had an outstanding level of moral influence on the communities that he was a part of, and he brought about all these conversions and transformations and sort of repentance of people who were sinners. And there's so many examples of that, too many to enumerate. And so he did a lot of good through the ministry that he chose. There were other ministries that he could have chosen to be like a political agitator or something. Now, I don't think it's anomalous or it's evidence against him being a saint that
SPEAKER_00that wasn't his thing. It seems like throughout his life he just wasn't concerned with politics.
SPEAKER_02Sure. And that's fair as far as it goes. But just one of the things to recognize is it's not as if there's exactly an asymmetry that you can get away with. If there's some degree to which engaging in a thing is very good and expected on And just one other thing, with regard to talking about all the good he did and the ministry and the conversions and so forth, that's actually, I think, an important aspect of the fraud story.
SPEAKER_02Because the thing is, is that for a devout Roman Catholic, which I'm sure that he was, who sees that he's doing all this good in the world and connects that to helping the Roman Catholic Church, if the origin of this was some sort of fraud that he engaged in, perhaps not even intending this to happen, that provides a very strong motive to keep it up. Right. Because you don't want to disappoint people. You don't want to shake people's face. You don't want to cause people who have come to their face because of your intervention to then be disillusioned as a result of the exposure
SPEAKER_02of your fraud. Right. So I think that that's a very important part of the plausibility of the fraud story. Right. That we actually do have a very good motive for why he would maintain it strongly.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think it goes the other way. If he's devout, which is that he's a student of moral theology, he has to be to be a confessor. And we know he did study moral theology of the church. And he explained it accurately. So for instance, he's saying he wouldn't commit one venial sin to stop World War II. He's saying he wouldn't tell a lie, even the slightest lie. And he understands that to be the moral theology of the church. He also would understand that if he were perpetrating this pious fraud, That would be damnable.
SPEAKER_00That would be mortal sin. He would go to hell unless he repented of this. He knows this. He's in a position where he obviously knows this and he even explains the principles behind it to people. It's hard to see him as sincere and pious and a devout Roman Catholic Who's constantly living in mortal sin as an enemy of God and being massively hypocritical in the morals that he espouses versus the morals that he practices.
SPEAKER_02I mean, to me, that's actually quite plausible. I mean, bear in mind, he could well have been, you know, confessing this and felt bad about it and felt conflicted, right? There's nothing stopping that.
SPEAKER_00No, but he also understands that moral theology, if he continues to perpetuate the fraud, then he knows he doesn't have a sincere purpose of amendment, which means all his confessions are invalid.
SPEAKER_02When I was looking into this stuff, there was an interesting case, and I'm sorry, I'm terrible with names, I'm going to butcher the name and I don't know it, but it was back maybe the 16th century, I'm sorry, I don't have it in my notes, where it was this case of visitations to this guy and then it was investigated and it turned out that That it was false. The guy himself was probably innocent, or may have been innocent,
SPEAKER_02but three Dominican priests were convicted, and I think executed, for faking these visions and visitations. And the interpretation by the scholar who looked into this was that they were, to some degree, motivated by a doctrinal dispute with the Franciscans. They had their own version of the Immaculate Conception, then they were arguing with the Franciscans. You'd probably know more about this than I would. And so they were using these miracles to vindicate the reputation of the Dominicans
SPEAKER_02and in particular their doctrines that were in dispute at the time. The fact is, is that Roman Catholics have, and this is the tip of the iceberg, justified doing things like this before, right? The attachment that Roman Catholics have to the body of the Church, to its necessity for salvation, to the And the fact that he can explain that it's wrong certainly doesn't show
SPEAKER_02that he might not have been conflicted and been motivated by this, I think, very real motive, which is incredibly plausible that he would have, of having gotten himself into this situation, of not wanting to damage the church by extracting himself from it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, there's lots of things that I would say to push back on that, but I do probably want to say, just since we said we were going to stop, I'll just make this my last word in closing on everything we've talked about, rather than focusing on these comments in particular, which is just the way I see the dialectic is, So obviously you're coming into this with priors that are strongly biased towards naturalism. Now a thing I want to explore is whether the way that you formed those priors was
SPEAKER_00Unfairly unfair or sort of prejudice towards arriving at the naturalist conclusion with the way that you were forming this induction that you keep citing that like when you look into miracles, they all they turn out to be bunk. So therefore, I form this strong inductive expectation that even when there's a miracle that's apparently credible, That basically even the sorts of natural theories that you've been developing and devising, we should prefer those to like crediting the sort of salient hypothesis to explain the data that's the more miraculous interpretation. And so that's one thing I would like to explore with people is a lot
SPEAKER_00of times I think there's actually, it's unfair, which is there are lots of things that we all believe in where there's also lots of fraudulent examples of that thing. So if we look at the credible examples and we suspend belief on those, And then we look at the fraudulent examples, then we're always going to wind up forming this inductive expectation. Oh, it's either a tie or it's a fraud. So therefore, I'm going to conclude it must be fraud, right? Now, no, cheap frauds are often very recognizably different than the very credible phenomena. And there's many characteristics that differentiate them.
SPEAKER_00And then in addition to that, There's all these things that couldn't possibly be explained by fraud that we didn't have the chance to get into in this discussion, which I put into the coincidence category, where we can go and say, let's try to form estimates about, okay, given the base rates for, for instance, this guy with nine organ systems failing, and given the base rates for the type of idiopathic visions that both he and his mom reported, what's the probability that you'll get the double coincidence of those And then that those would happen to be associated with the PO cult.
SPEAKER_00So how many people would be doing the types of prayers and petitioning with PO expectation? And so how surprising is it that we'd get a case that good? And then we just do that with the rest of the cases. So how likely it is we get a case this good with this good of a tie to PO, given the rate at which we were sampling. And then we say, okay, those two combinations. How atypical is this of frauds and how much of the discriminating evidence seems to be going one way versus the other way? Too friendly with Mussolini is our discriminating evidence against.
SPEAKER_00All this reports by doctors of abundant hemorrhages and all the witnesses describing soaked bandages over this extended period of time without developing iron efficiency anemia. And like the blood being scented with perfume and intermittently releasing perfume and strong waves and doctor offices and all that. So that's on the other side, like where are we leaning if we were just being neutral? And so, you know, what type of evidential, what base factor are we putting on the evidence without importing our priors? And then, so then I'll say last thing before letting you get in.
SPEAKER_00But so that's sort of how I'm looking at the case, which is the way I'm looking at the case is to me, I'm getting lots of observations from doctors where you seem to be thinking that just saying expectation makes certain types of errors, interpretive errors that I don't find plausible, plausible. That it seems like the errors that they're making are independently corroborated by other testimony that it's hard to see how it would be wrong. I've got stuff that we didn't go into about why I don't think it's plausible that these people are lying or exaggerating. Then I see it's corroborated by observations later in life.
SPEAKER_00And then I see it's healing without a scar in a way that's inconsistent with previous reports about its depth, even ones that are less profound than that. I see all the blood stuff. I see all the perfume stuff. I wish we had gotten into the hyperthermia stuff to talk about how plausible that is as fraud. I see then this coincidence network, right, of, you know, oh, the scrutiny of hearts and the bilocation and the healings and all of this stuff, including the postmortem ones. And I look at that whole constellation, I say, Yeah, really it seems like a lot of the evidence is there's just a confluence
SPEAKER_00of it that's militating very strongly and discriminating in favor of a miraculous direction. And the types of priors, the catastrophically low priors in miraculous authenticity that I would have to have to avoid giving the salient interpretation of that evidence, it just seems to me that it's like just unwarranted prejudice to assign priors of that kind, even granting that there's lots of fake cases that don't have analogously good evidence.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I mean, I think that it is important to not come in and just have a bias that means that you dismiss the evidence. And in fact, what the history of the repeated collapse of supernatural explanations under investigation suggests is that you just need to have Evidential standards, right? And the evidential standards have developed over hundreds of years, right?
SPEAKER_02They are independently motivated. They are not just scientific, although science was the inspiration for a lot of them, right? They're the same sort of standards that we use in legal testimony. They're the same sort of standards that we use in medicine to establish different sorts of things. And so the way out of this problem, which I agree is a real problem, we don't want to throw out any So the way to do that is, yes, you come in sort of expecting that probably nothing will happen if you have those priors, but, right, what you do is you've already preconceived and you've already
SPEAKER_02And then you try to do it fairly, right? So when I look at the evidence that you have around the stigmata, Around the thermometers and things like that. I'm just like, okay, by the scientific standards of evidence that I'm going to use,
SPEAKER_02this is not enough to establish something that would be convincing to me, right? And I mean, you know, we can maybe talk about it more at some point. You know, I enjoyed this. It'd be fun to do some more. I would say, you know, I've written some things on Substack that are mostly about these kinds of questions, right? Why is it that naturalists sort of have this explanatory pattern? What does that amount to? Where does it come from, right? I mean, certainly, you know, my sort of intellectual hero, Socrates, right? I'm a very normie philosopher, right?
SPEAKER_02I think that it's really, really important not to prejudge that you're right about things. And the thing to do is to have standards that are high enough that you can avoid the Very common frauds that can be quite convincing in a variety of different ways.
SPEAKER_01Cool. Okay. I want to thank you both for the lengthy, spirited, but fruitful discussion. Both of you have relevant Substacks. I will link those below for those who want to follow this up a little bit further. Perhaps at some point we can arrange a part two here. But either way, Eugene, I want to thank you for taking the time. Ethan, you as well. Yeah, my pleasure.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. I had fun.
SPEAKER_01Yep. If you like what you see here, you want to see more dialogues such as this, just like, subscribe, leave a comment. We'll catch you guys next time. See you.