Today is a very special episode! Lizz and Andrew start the podcast with a discussion about a Christianity Today article called “The Gen Z Worship War” which leads to sharing their opinions on the need for relationship vs tradition in a life of faith. Then, Andrew conducts his first artist interview with Lizz to introduce her brand new song “Questions.” They and the show by sharing some more new music by ANTHNY and Gable Price and Friends.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02We started with the giggles today. Hey everybody. Welcome back to Letters with Ella. We are each a letter from Christ, and it's a testimony and a story with grace interlaced in every word. This letter is written not with pen and ink, but the spirit of the living God. It's not carved on tablets of stone, but on human hearts. And I'm so excited, and obviously I'm super giggly right now because we just giggle while I giggle, and Andrew does his conjugation of giggling or version of it.
SPEAKER_00His conjugation of giggling?
SPEAKER_02I think I meant to say version, and then Spanish came into my head and like how you conjugate verbs. I thought you could like conjugate a laugh. You thought I could conjugate chuckles?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02See? See, like the way that you would conjugate a laugh is different from Brooklyn and Luke.
SPEAKER_00So Oh bro, I don't know if it's gonna end up on the episode. They got a full Brooklyn snort laugh on her last episode. I listen, uh, this is an audio warning now, because this might come out before that episode, but I really hope we can hear the snort. Uh oh, you will. Oh, you will.
SPEAKER_02I want to. I miss it.
SPEAKER_00It depends on what part of the uh episode it's in. Uh okay. If it's because there were a couple moments, like a couple long breaks that we'll probably cut out. And so if it's between one of those, then we might not, but if it's in like normal discussion, uh yeah, you'll hear it all right.
SPEAKER_02You should totally do like a blooper section at the end. Or or or or you do bloopers in the middle as your transitions.
SPEAKER_00Dude, we've got enough um we got enough like extra footage on most of our studio episodes with Keith that we can definitely that's where most of my original like clips came from, is just stuff we were doing before recording. So yeah, I'll probably I'll probably post I'll probably post some of that eventually.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we can't forget the one with you dancing with the gang.
SPEAKER_00Still my most viewed video, nothing to do with theology. The best one. None of my none of my art takes, just all You're just being a creature.
SPEAKER_02Just me being a goof and is a goofy creature.
SPEAKER_00Yep, that's what they call me back in the streets.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so goofy creature, how you doing today?
SPEAKER_00Okay, alright. Well, I was doing alright until uh known as a goofy creature. Uh but I'm doing alright. I'm doing alright. Uh long week, but thankfully it's almost over. So uh how about you?
SPEAKER_02How about how you doing? Well, I'm really excited because well, uh kindergarten's great. Let me just let's just start off with a caveat. If kindergarten is great, the things that come out of these kids' mouths are kind of hilarious.
SPEAKER_03I bet.
SPEAKER_02Um, no, no, that was a fifth grader. Someone was getting really mad at me one time, and they just looked me in the eyes and they're like, you know, you're not God. And I said, I know.
SPEAKER_03I I'd be really bad. Yeah, that's right. Let them know, Junior.
SPEAKER_01Just remind Liz real quick in case it gets a little mouthy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um that is hilarious, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so that's really the only funny one I have so far. Like, that was directly to me. But then the nice ones that like warm my heart. One person is like, Miss Amos, I just I love you so much. I love you higher than the heavens. Oh. And I'm like, oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_00That's so sweet.
SPEAKER_02In my head, I'm like, what did I do to deserve this? I don't know. So it just warms my little heart. And then they all smother me with hugs, and it's usually right after. No, no, no. It's usually right before I'm about to say, alright, kids, wrap it up, go back to work. So that's they're cute. I like it. I am also doing a gym routine now in my life. Uh-oh. So I I honestly am just doing it to avoid the rush hour.
SPEAKER_02That's the main reason why I got a gym membership.
SPEAKER_00That's valid. How has it been having uh Jersey traffic now? I mean, it wasn't the same in Williamsburg.
SPEAKER_02I I don't love traffic, I just miss New Jersey. So it's really it's a really hard thing to understand. But I just love the aggressiveness everywhere. I audio listeners hear the aggression in my voice come out just a little bit, but like I just I just love when people are a little bit more on the aggressive side of decisive in terms of their driving.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, man, I'll just give I'll just leave that with you, man. I'm glad someone's gotta love it. I know. Leave it to me.
SPEAKER_00And the other thing I love here in the South, thank you.
SPEAKER_02The other thing I love is that my license plate matches, cause I was just I just miss New Jersey and like the yellow license plates. They just were my childhood, and so now I get to relive my childhood driving on the parkway or you know, traffic hour with a bunch of other Jersey. So it's great. They're aggressive for no reason, and it's it's nice. Someone else can be the aggressive one now.
SPEAKER_00That is valid. I think moving back to your uh childhood, like where you grew up, is kind is always uh is always a fun experience. So that makes sense.
SPEAKER_02It's been interesting, it's more fun as I like discover different parts of it. So one thing that I really loved is like my back porch. I never really liked it as a kid, and I don't think it's like I didn't like it where it's like, ew, the back porch, but I never got to enjoy it because I was always in after school activities. Right before this pod, I was sitting on the porch and I was just like sitting, and there's of course a bunch of like traffic on the road, there's airplanes flying over, but there's a lot of crickets and bugs and birds, and I'm just like, oh, this is actually like kind of nice, like just sitting outside.
SPEAKER_02There's low humidity. I can wear a cozy sweater and like not be sweating because of the humidity, finally feeling like fall up here in New Jersey. I don't know what you guys have. I actually have fall weather right now in New Jersey.
SPEAKER_02You're in like um sixth summer or something, right? You have like seven summers before you actually get cold.
SPEAKER_00Uh no, we're we're in like uh we're in late spring right now, I would say.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00As in we're getting no, it's like it's not even that. It's like just a roller coaster. So it's like we'll have a few days of like sixties and then we'll seventies and then we'll hit a spike, a peak of eighties, and then we'll go right back down to 70.
SPEAKER_02I know. I don't know if I miss that life.
SPEAKER_00I don't. I will say that.
SPEAKER_02I like I really do like how cold it's been in the morning. If it's like if it's around 40 degrees, then I'll start wearing a jacket. If it's 45, like I'll just walk a little bit chilly to my car, and I'm like, ah, I'm not sweating. Praise.
SPEAKER_00So oh yeah, I can't wait. I can't wait. My uh my my vanilla pumpkin candle is is waiting to be burned right here, and it can't do that in 86. It just doesn't feel right now.
SPEAKER_02No, it feels like you have to give summer its due, and then the full stage can be 50 degrees and a candle and soup.
SPEAKER_01It's good weather for a pumpkin cream cold brew, though.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yes. Iced.
SPEAKER_00Well, it is a cold brew.
SPEAKER_02Oh, sorry, I thought you meant cold foam.
SPEAKER_00I got confused. Well, yeah, it does have cold foam on it, but it is uh the pumpkin cream cold brew.
SPEAKER_02It's a specific Yes, yes, yes. I I'm not well right now. I obviously missed I don't have an in coffee in my house right now. So I really like coffee beans. Yeah, I'm so uncalibrated with caffeine right now. I'm drinking bubbly water right now to suffice. It is unsufficing.
SPEAKER_00It never was sufficing. Bubbly water is just meant to taste like you're uh tasting.
SPEAKER_02I know. So anyway, that's how I guess our weeks are going. And well, I know this comes out way after we're recording this, but I'm excited because for me, I'm about to have a three-day weekend because of Columbus Day. So I'm excited.
SPEAKER_03You are too. It's it's Indigenous People's Day. Thank you very much. I'm sorry, everybody.
SPEAKER_02I don't I don't keep up with the new calendar names of these holidays.
SPEAKER_01Well, uh you're gonna have to get it get in touch with it because that is what we call it at my organization.
SPEAKER_02Okay, Angie's call what it can you say it again. Indigenous People's Day. Okay, Indigenous People's Day, October 12th. Is it is it actually October 12th or is it just the second Monday of October?
SPEAKER_00I have no idea. And Loki, if if I'm an Indigenous Peoples, you could have given me like the day after. Like if you're gonna switch the day up, like change up the day at least give us a four-day weekend.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, don't like give me his day. He's the guy who jacked us up. Why would you like give me the day before him or some crap? Change it up entirely.
SPEAKER_02I am excited that I'm having a three-day weekend. So I'm grateful. I hope that's okay to say that I'm grateful to have a three-day weekend. I'm just gonna say my kids in kindergarten need to play at home. The teachers need to lesson plan and have a little bit of time, and then we can launch back into the school season.
SPEAKER_00Girl, I don't think there is a teacher in life that will ever say it's a bad thing to be happy about a four-day or four-day three-day weekend.
SPEAKER_02Three-day weekend, four-day work week. Let's go. Woo-woo.
SPEAKER_00Heck yeah. Heck yeah.
SPEAKER_02Heck yeah. All right. You want to dive in?
SPEAKER_00Let's do it, Liz. What you got for us?
SPEAKER_02I'm jumping off the springboard into the pool. Splash splash.
SPEAKER_03Splash.
SPEAKER_00Splash splash, indeed.
SPEAKER_02All right. I I actually never told you this. I just did this before the um the pod. I finally bought my subscription to Christianity today, so I'll get the articles in print now.
SPEAKER_00Did you really?
SPEAKER_02Uh-huh. Wait, so did I.
SPEAKER_03Wait, today? No, not today, but I uh this weekend. This past weekend, I just subscribed to Christianity today. This mod is not sponsored, but could be. Hey. Just a little side book.
SPEAKER_02Hey. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00If you I'm just saying, we talk about y'all a lot, if you wouldn't mind. 70 years. Seventy years. Wait, have you seen the new like uh creator series they've done with Inkwell?
SPEAKER_02Mm-mm. Wait, is that on um Substack?
SPEAKER_00Uh I'm not sure if they have it on Substack. Uh they're doing interviews, so it's on YouTube. Oh. But they'll they'll have clips of it on uh IG. Oh. And so Josh Nadeau does one and then uh is it John Guerrero or something like that? It's uh he's a singer, and so it's like these young Christians talking with like Christian creatives and just kind of having a conversation on how to be a creative in Christian. It's so cool and it's vibing too. It's very aesthetic.
SPEAKER_02Glad to shout it out. We'll definitely take a look into that after our next or after this recording, and maybe we can talk about it next pod. So excited about that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, if I see any clips, I'll have to like uh repost them or something like that.
SPEAKER_02Love that idea. Um, anyway, Christianity today, get the print in digital because I didn't realize you can only view the website so many times before they kick you off it to see a little summary of it. But it has a lot of yeah, it has a lot of great articles, and I'm really excited because we're gonna about dive into one that kind of is a piggyback off of a piggyback pod from this episode or this whole Eternal Creatures theme. I'm so excited. Which um, for the record, thank you, Eternal Creatures, for hosting me.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, Andrew. I never shouted you out in the beginning, working on it. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00All right, so shout out eternal creatures like it's like it's this big brand that's like, thank you guys so much for hosting us. No, it's literally you, me, and Luke, and a couple of our other buddies.
SPEAKER_02We gotta keep it up. I just I just like to shout it out because credit is due where credit is due, and I just want to say thanks. I'll take it. I'll take it. Thank you. Speaking of one of our friends, one of our friends brought up the question about like femininity and masculinity in the church, right? Men are too feminine. Was that the original question?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was our uh episode with Jaclyn.
SPEAKER_02Hey Jaclyn, what's up, girl? And then in Jesus is Metal, you and Luke kind of like followed up on like what men desire and more of that like part two of that conversation, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Alright. So shortly after that podcast came out, I came across this article, and I don't remember if I saw it. I think I saw it on Facebook, and I was able to like read the whole article. It's by Luke Simon, and it's called The Gen Z Worship War. And it's specifically talking about the divide in Gen Z between male and female, and just how the faith and how people worship and what they are feeding on between the two genders are starting to like separate a little bit further and further.
SPEAKER_02And I thought it was a really good way to verbalize what um Jacqueline was bringing to the table. What I hear Luke kind of saying of like the heart of discipline, how to be a man, how to seek those things of structure and truth and how to be a Christian man without lending, without only offering feminine like solutions, not solutions, but like approaches, like catering towards the two different like sides.
SPEAKER_02And I thought it was a really great article. And so maybe we just talk through it and then I'd love to share like our thoughts on it. Because I know both of us spent some time like, oh, like this stuck out to me, or I'm curious, because we both have different takes on it as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure. Um I'm interested, just starting off, like where um I don't know, what was your first impression of it? Like what made you when you read it, what made you inspired enough to bring it to the pod, I suppose.
SPEAKER_02Well, I just I think it's just been really hard to understand just like the different needs that women and men have in terms of when approaching worship. And when we're talking about worship, we're not only talking about the music portion of the service. I think we're talking about how we engage and relate to God, which includes theology, it includes community, it includes discipline and uh different like things that we can engage with.
SPEAKER_02It's not just music. Um and I think this article just really put a lot of things to words that I've been seeing over the last like few years, from being in and around the church to being on staff at a church to um even observing like what's happening in like the music scenes and like social media platforms. It's just been really interesting to like see and then to do like a mirror check on like okay, like do I fall in line with what the stat I don't know if it's really statistics or people he's been interviewing, but the tendencies and the favorings of what women want.
SPEAKER_02I'm like, do I line up with that? Do I see things in the other side that I also want as well? Honestly, when I first clicked the article, I thought the worship war was gonna talk about like generational things. Like, are we in a new generation like of another like approach to worship from like millennial to Gen Z that way? But I was really excited to see that it's split it on like guys versus girls.
SPEAKER_02So what were your first thoughts when I sent it to you?
SPEAKER_00Um well for I would say I would say mine was also interested. I thought it was gonna be um stylistic, kind of like you were saying. Like I thought it was gonna be maybe more of a generational style or like topical even. Because I've kind of heard a lot of criticism of like modern CCM music and um especially coming out of some of the big houses, Hillsong, Bethel, that kind of stuff. Like um and comparing it to like the scriptural density, but also the um God forwardness of the hymns uh as opposed to you know what we kind of make now in CCM, or I won't say entirely, right?
SPEAKER_00That's a bit unfair, but but um what a lot of CCM can become, which is more about me and my personal journey or my personal experience with God. So I thought it was gonna be that, and it kind of was, but not musically whatsoever. It was about just how Gen Z worships. And right, worship is not just music, like you said, it's our whole life, and so how we perceive our relationship with God and how that's dividing church. So I I actually just to kind of overview a little bit of what we are of what the article said, because I think it might be nice for the audience to kind of explain, I think it broke down that like men and women are sort of div in Gen Z are sort of dividing in in how they worship and the kinds of churches that they're attracted to as a result.
SPEAKER_00Men in general tend to be head seem to be trending toward more traditional, um, liturgical styles, Orthodox, Catholic, um like churches, and then women tend to be skewed more towards CCM, evangelical, uh non-denom kind of churches. And it's based on a few different things. One of them was based on like their platforms that they're that these messages that like men and women use. Men tend to be more on like Reddit, YouTube, that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_00Uh women tend to be on Instagram, TikTok, which has a very big evangelical base, whereas YouTube has more space for long-form content um and deep theological discussions, which seem to be drawing men in. And then it's also kind of priority-based as well, like the things that men are looking for, which seems to be a lot more structure and um discipline. Um yeah, structure and discipline as opposed to like relational um relationship or yeah, just a relational uh style of religion with God and community that women seem to tend to be skewed toward.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, it was interesting, it was really interesting observations all the way around.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I just really appreciated like seeing, and now again, we can't speak for all people, right? And this guy can't like obviously be like, ah, there's like a bunch of outliers, and if you fall in the outliers, you're wrong. But I think it's cool to see the trends, seeing what people are gravitating towards, and it does, I feel like, resonate and make sense to what I've seen, and I've definitely related to it in several seasons of my life. You know, I think what's really important over the years being a super like type A logical person, I remember the first time I went to a young life camp.
SPEAKER_02Now, it wasn't like specifically run by young life, but it we use their facilities for like a three-day weekend in middle school, and my church joined a bunch of other churches for like a three-day weekend conference. And I just remember singing these songs, and I'm like, these are not like the songs we sing in my hymnal growing up. I grew up in a reform church, which was heavy on doctrine, heavy, heavy on like the knowledge in the word, which I think is honestly been such a blessing to grow up in that environment to really be grounded in what the word says.
SPEAKER_02But I remember the first time like I sang like modern worship songs, and I was like, why aren't all songs like this one? I was like fun to sing, like I want to raise my hands more when I sing this style music, and I was like, it just feels And like to quote the article or reference the article, like more honest and authentic, where like this God sees me, this God loves me, I can bring all that I am to him. And I think that's one part of faith that is so important on the like not just saying it's only feminine people seek that, but like, you know, like that just relates a lot to the relational aspect that I think a lot of women tends to value.
SPEAKER_02I think on the other side of it, as I've been in this hub of authenticity, like honesty, grace, my heart is like, all right, we can't just live in grace land forever. And that's not to say I don't value grace. I love grace. But it's like, okay, what is grace pointing me towards? And I think this is a good word that maybe like Luke and some of our guys, our friends, might relate to, which is like guys really prioritize like agency, like the ability to overcome.
SPEAKER_02This is what the article says, the ability to overcome inner and external obstacles to grow stronger and achieve purpose. Now, if you want to go down like this line of very like definitive, liturgical, like boom, boom, boom, bullet point and stuff, like there's a lot of cool, like, um what is it called? Catechisms? Oh, yeah, of the like the Westminster faith. And like the first one, like my friends from college drilled me in is like, what is the chief end of man? It's like to enjoy God and to delight in him forever, I believe, or to know God and delight.
SPEAKER_02Something about the really relational stuff, but it's like that's the chief end goal of man. And I feel like for people, like I also resonate with this. Like, I can't just live in ambuge ambu what's the wordic. That one. Thank you. I struggle. Um, I can't live in just like the jello of life if I don't have a little bit of like structure around it. Like I am a structure girl. And so it's just like I can live in grace, but like at the end of the day, what is the grace pointing me towards?
SPEAKER_02Like, I can't be stagnant in grace. And I'm not trying to say, like, oh, my life is all performative. I never really know what it's like to rest. And I'm like, yeah, I just like to know the purpose going forward of it. And I'm grateful that going forward, like, I can't get there without grace, and it is achievable by grace, but I know that there is a greater, like, there is a direction for grace to move us towards.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Was there anything that surprised you? Because I feel like some of the I don't know. I it was it was interesting to watch. I don't know. Well, there might have been one thing that surprised me. So, like, what was there anything about like the article or like anything that they were talking about that kind of surprised you?
SPEAKER_02I don't think anything really surprised me. I think it it makes just like a lot of I think it just felt like surprising to be like, oh, like people can put words to this. And um for me, I would say like I tend to lean more on the guy side of like the preferences, like valuing the traditions, valuing like I do really appreciate God meeting me in the mess.
SPEAKER_02Um, before we started this pod, like we were just reading about how God encounters us and meets us in our deep deepest grief and sorrow. And like we wouldn't want a rigid army general yelling at us about how to move through grief. But I also know that at some points, like I need I need like the foundational facts and truth at the end of it to be the thing that does actually get me through it. Um like I love when people sit with me in grief.
SPEAKER_02I also need at the same time that one person to be like, hey, let's get up, let's get going, let's make a step towards your goal, let's talk about like some of the anger that you've been feeling. Um one of my friends and I, like, we sat in a car recently after we hung out and we just talked honestly, and she was like, I think you just need um to define the mechanics of everything that you just walk through so that you're able to feel everything and then you can move through it. She was very logical with my grief, and I was like, I needed that because it helps me move forward.
SPEAKER_02Um I I don't know again if it's anything shocking, but I am very grateful for like the defining it and like not labeling it, but obviously like putting notes to like, oh, I can see this trend, I can see this. Um, and obviously if you zoom zoom like all the way out, like you can see like, oh, like God is actually a genius, like making men and women like to help one another. Obviously, like not only women desire communion, and not only men desire purpose and structure and direction, but you can see how God has gifted the people to be wired to desire different parts of him and approaches to him more, not approaches, but you know, structure and appreciation for beauty and relationship, communion, drive, and all those different things, and he will like bring other people into your life that have other ratios of those things to bring out the best in you.
SPEAKER_00You mentioned um feeling more drawn to what I guess the men were looking for. Do you think that is seasonal? Do you think it's personality? You um, you know, is it upbringing? You mentioned being in the Reform Church. And I will say one of the words you used interestingly was authenticity. And it didn't feel solely like the guys were looking for authenticity as much as they were looking for structure and like something that is long term as opposed to like modern and like something that makes them feel like it's a fad almost.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and this is not to criticize other people in that. The the first article point that they were talking about is how Gen Z men and Gen Z women relate to the faith. And in that first point, the men said, or he found that men tend to crave stability over reinvention, and women tend to value personal devotion, a sense of honesty alongside the truth.
SPEAKER_02So I think obviously both of them desire the whole picture, it's just the emphasis on what. And so when it relates to me, like when I read that like stability word, I'm like, oh, I love that word. And I think that has to do with like personality upbringing, life experiences in general. I like really love the idea of stability and I love the idea of feeling secure. Those words just bring me a lot of peace and safety.
SPEAKER_02Now I know that sometimes that those words can feel like very rigid, they can feel trapping to other people, and that's how God designed you. So I'm not here to like condemn anyone or criticize anyone who's like, but I value authenticity more. I'm like, okay, that's awesome. I love that you value authenticity and God can show up in your greatest mess. And I need that in my life in so many different areas. I think just I'm so grateful that you know, in a world that is ever changing, everything needs an update.
SPEAKER_02Your phone needs an update, like program, let alone buying a new phone every four years. Like something that just resonates with me is the simple Bible verse in Hebrews. The author writes, Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today, and forever. Thank goodness. Because like I would not be super happy if Jesus had an update like every like five months, and I'm like, I have to learn a new version of Jesus. We are not learning a new version of Jesus, we are getting to see Jesus deeper and fuller with less scales on our eyes.
SPEAKER_02There's a way different thing because in that second scenario, who's changing? Jesus isn't changing. We're being transformed into the likeness of his image. And so, with eyes that are less distracted by things of this world, less obsessed and idolizing our pain and our pride, because I've struggled with that, we actually get to see Jesus for who he is with pure eyes that he gives us. And so that's more that's more of like the the foundation of thank goodness you're stable.
SPEAKER_02Cause like I need someone to be the anchor, because it's I know it's not for me. I'm not my own anchor. I don't want to be. And so I just I think it's honestly just life experiences that I've walked through. I'm like, I'm thankful that God's faithfulness is secure, that nothing can thwart his hand. I I'm so thankful that his love is continually before me, even in the midst of my egregious sins and shortcomings and disobedience.
SPEAKER_02Um that that assurance, when they say blessed assurance, Jesus is mine. Thank goodness. There's so much beauty in that because I can admit the authenticity he's meeting me in and go right back to thank goodness, it's assured. Like I don't have to question it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, when we were talking about this, you mentioned how you and I, even though we're obviously um our own like male and female, we have a uh we tend to have a some level of bend toward the other, what the other gender at least is ta labeled as desiring in this article. And I agree with that.
SPEAKER_00I think I have a much more it's not that I'm not knowledge it's not not knowledge based. It's not that I'm not looking for what the men are looking for, right? I think a lot of what I want like I do want, and I've been questioning this recently, like, okay, what what do I really want? It seems like in my church recently it's come up this idea of Jesus being the thing to want in Christianity, genuinely wanting Jesus. And I was I've had to ask myself, what is it that I want?
SPEAKER_00And I find that as a church kid, I think sometimes bending toward the stability of what Christianity seems to offer and like the person that you become on the end of it, this moral, this good, this pure person um who is loved by many and all this sort of thing, but uh stands up for what's right, like I think that is a person that I want to become. Um I don't know if it's inherent, I don't know if it's just because I've been raised in the church, but I don't I relate to that.
SPEAKER_00And yet right now I would say I have a much stronger bend toward the relational aspect of Christianity. And the reason is because I the stats don't make Christianity true. And so I want to know God. I want if Jesus is someone to know, I want to know him, right? Like I don't I I want to understand God, Christ, the Holy Spirit.
SPEAKER_00I want to understand them and know them if uh as much as I can, because that to me is what makes all of this not just a a fad. It was interesting that they brought up John Mark Homer um as a big thing for Gen Z. And I read a whole article on him afterwards that they linked to the article um about like people's modern view of or many people's view of John Mark Homer because he's really drawn in Gen Z.
SPEAKER_00And I think he has done an incredible job of like really making following Jesus and you know, still being present to earth, but also living separate from him, like being an apprentice to Jesus, he makes it seem accessible and it makes him seem historical. That's something that's interesting about him as a modern person, is his books reference saints. They reference saints from from the old um from Catholic tradition, Orthodox tradition, like they the Desert Fathers in his most recent books, like um like they they they have a tie to history, but also this modern practical nature that makes it so um that makes it so accessible and yet it's easy to follow Comer and still if you don't feel like God is here with you existing among you, it can still feel fake.
SPEAKER_00And so as much as I like the idea of the structure, there are easier structures to follow. There is a journey that seems to be placed before me in following Christ, and it seems to only happen if I am unified with him. And so that's why I want the relational aspect because I want the whole thing, I want everything that Christianity has to offer if and the and the it only seems to work if I know this God person.
SPEAKER_00So Yeah, I think that uh it was interesting it was interesting in the article seeing that men want this structure, but for some reason women seem to be the one chasing the relationship aspect more.
SPEAKER_02I think it's just how God wires brains and different personalities, right? So, like I love again that word agency. Like, I'm a very logistical person. That's not to say other women aren't logistical people. Everyone can be logistical, however, God wants to make them to be, and however he your personality bends towards things, but that idea that it's just really awesome to know that there's progress being made.
SPEAKER_02And I'm not saying I'm putting my faith in works, but it makes me feel like the structure gives me an idea of who God is because it's not I find hope in the standing up and sitting down. It's not hope I find in receding creeds. It's just these certain aspects where it's a creed, whether it's a hymn, whether it is like honestly, like I might just like want to spend a little bit more time in communion and understanding like maybe it's not just a symbol, you know, maybe this actually is the bread and the blood, which we can go down that route another time.
SPEAKER_02And like there have just been different things that different brothers and sisters from generations ago have participated in the faith. And I'm not saying it's wrong that we're in this like new expression of faith. I think it's great that we're bringing in that more vulnerable, authentic, relational aspect. There's something grounding about non-negotiables that have lasted in so many traditions of faith beforehand.
SPEAKER_02And I think what I really appreciate about the article is this idea of retrieval theology. I forgot the name of the person who talked about it. Yeah, Government. I think it was Ortland. Yes. Okay. And he was saying, like, it's not to say that the new abolishes the old, right? That these newer approaches um and meditations like cancel out everything that we've done since the resurrection of Christ and ascension of him into heaven. But it's the idea that how can we, and I want to answer or ask you this question, which is like, how can how can the never changing God of like the past, not the past, but like in history and tradition, how can that knowledge and that knowledge of him, right?
SPEAKER_02Because we can, if he never changes, like those parts of him still are knowable. How can that enrich the God who is doing a new thing? Right? We often hear the new preachers are like, hey, stop, behold, do you not perceive it? I'm doing a new thing. And I think this new emphasis, this new prioritization of, hey, like God meets you in your mess, hey, God is very relational, hey, like it's about knowing God. How can they complement each other rather than this divide?
SPEAKER_02Like, what do you see one enriching the other with?
SPEAKER_00As in how does that relational focus meet the other focus? Like, I guess rephrase the question.
SPEAKER_02Instead of saying instead of saying, ah, I can only desire authentic authenticity and um vulnerability over structure, like what can that bring to structure? And then I would love to talk about what structure can bring to beauty and authenticity and the relational side. What can the approach of beauty like deepen for knowledge for you? Of Jesus, obviously.
SPEAKER_00It's uh It's n I don't know, it's a weird it's not a weird question. It's a weird divide to me. Because I guess for me the goal is authenticity. Right?
SPEAKER_02Like relationship and structure Can I can I replace structure with non-negotiables? I guess I mean like who God's been throughout the years. They're traditions. I don't want structures to seem like, oh, we only have systems and we have to follow rules. But like, you know, traditions, I guess. Sorry.
SPEAKER_00So relationship and traditions, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I like that.
SPEAKER_00Um they feed they feed off each other. I mean I guess my my point is we have to have our our guiding star to be correct. Because if it is, then we recognize the need for both. And so, like for me, I think um my pastor once said that the goal is not just to do good for God, it is to be close to it.
SPEAKER_00And so when you are trying to be close to God, theology and truth, timeless truth, helps you learn who God is, right? You mentioned before, God doesn't change. And so if you understand who God is and you understand what hinders our relationship to him, then you start implementing and this is and this is where the saints and stuff come in.
SPEAKER_00You start seeing the traditions of old as ways of training ourselves in a life that allows us to remain close to him, but it is the relationship that fuels the desire to keep going. And it's not an easy relationship to understand. But I was listening to um there's a podcast called The Deep End um by Taylor Welsh, and he was talking about having how to build a hunger for God.
SPEAKER_00And he's he gave this really interesting idea. I suggest you all go watch the episode um or listen to it, but he was they he was talking about stats that actually show that if something is too predictable, it we actually lose our interest. Like it we lose our motivation. There is a level of um there is a level of like variety of mystery that keeps us. motivated and so yeah like the mystery of relating to a spirit and this god is what keeps us doing the traditions the traditions aren't they're training right it's not as it it's it's not as simple as like they're not just things we do in other words we are practice we are kind of training our body and our mind in a way that is necessary to relate to God and so yeah I don't know I think maybe I maybe I view this as I view the article as explaining maybe earthly desires that we are trying to satisfy through Christianity but in pursuing our earthly desires we gain a different desire which is like a desire for God which is beyond it's so unique.
SPEAKER_00It ground it both grounds us to this earth in a present way but it also frees us from the natural rules that we create.
SPEAKER_02I don't know it's it's a completely different way of thinking that goes beyond what many of us initially step through the doors of a church for yeah I think exactly what you said like the idea is to know him and I'm grateful that God knows each person and knows what works for them. And so in the more hey how can God show up in my like honesty and my authenticity and like not just the vibes and not just a more grounding approach or not just even in the the longstanding traditions that I've upheld from the beginning of the early church like the everything whether it's the vehicle of authentic authenticity or it's the vehicle of traditions is the goal to what you said know him at the end.
SPEAKER_02And something that I was like mulling over recently I I love my grandma and hear me out for the loop um in this time moving back home like I get to have dinner with her about four times a week which is so awesome. She just turned 88 grandma is doing great her blood tests look awesome she's gonna stick around hopefully until I get married is the goal. And I'm just so grateful to spend time with her.
SPEAKER_02And you know there are things that I'm asking her that I've never known about her before and so during these dinners I was just like we were talking about her husband my late grandfather and I was just like did you guys like ever get in a fight like where you were in like a heated argument. And so she tells me like oh well Saturday was our date night and like every Saturday like kids would go down to my parents they lived in the same house and she was like Saturday was our date night well when he signed up for the fire department one night he was like out till 3 a.m on a call and they ended up playing ping pong like actual like table pong like until 3 a.m and she was like don't like I don't care where you are Sunday night, Monday night whatever but like Saturday night is our night and it it just made me laugh and giggle because I was like I've never seen that side of my grandmother before and so and we're doing this over dinner.
SPEAKER_02And so in the midst of something super relational eating a meal like she tells a story about someone I never knew before and exactly what you're saying the knowledge of who she is feeds the relationship and also like me wanting to like spend time with her like I genuinely do want to know more about her the time I spend with her. So I think even like in a relationship like if I was you know with a significant other or a friend and I just wanted to spend time with them all the time but I didn't know anything about them like that's what I that's what I attribute the spending time and then the knowing I guess there's the relationship and then the knowing is I guess what I take away from traditions.
SPEAKER_02Or yeah that's just how my brain thinks is like I'm thankful that in my relationships like spending time with people like you get to know more about them. And then as you get to know them you want to spend more time with them. It's like a feedback loop that keeps going round and round and round. So one maybe it's hard to pinpoint maybe like for like which one is the correct first but I think whichever one you bend towards you will get in that loop and you'll end eventually go from knowledge to spending time and have your spending time be curious to be like what else can I know about this person?
SPEAKER_02And um well more specifically God I guess not person being spirit you know what I mean I I was getting my story mixed up between relating to a person and Jesus and that right now so yeah yeah yeah yeah I think I don't know I think our personal goal as Christians should be authenticity like for me authenticity is it it's not separate from either of these things.
SPEAKER_00Like it I think we've kind of used it as like the grounding point. And the reason I say this is because this is like nothing else. And I think I'm kind of like in my head right now I've been kind of contemplating this. It's like there is nothing quite like this. There is nothing that makes you more present on earth but also more detached from the earth in the same at the same time and so what is nice about what's beautiful about a lot of the the traditions the liturgy the um the Eucharist that was one of the interesting things that came up in the John Mark Homer uh article I read is that he one of his critiques was that the Eucharist wasn't a part of it.
SPEAKER_00Like the the church as a sacrament wasn't a part of it. The sacraments um it it involves your body it brings your body into invites your body as a part of worshiping God. And I think that grounds us in a way that is different. It reminds us that we're supposed to be on earth and it makes us feel a little bit less lost as people. Right? We don't feel like we're trying to escape this world and just live in the spiritual and everything and pretend we are spirits.
SPEAKER_00We are not spirits and so I do think the sacraments and the traditions they remind us that we are physical beings and that our physical body should be engaged in worship. Um and then some of the more spiritual but we're but the spiritual aspects are necessary because God is a spirit. And so yeah there's just there's nothing quite like it and I'm gonna be honest I sometimes am shocked that I'm doing this.
SPEAKER_00Like I sometimes am shocked that I'm Christian because it's such a mind bend trying to authentically relate to God sometimes. And so I find myself flip-flopping between the extremes of one or the other. It's like sometimes I go too spiritual I need to grow reground myself in the fact that saints have followed this tradition for years and that there is a knowable truth in scripture and that there is um and that there are sacraments that we can do physically.
SPEAKER_00But then I have to also remember that like God is not simply the sacraments themselves. God is not simply the Bible itself. You know it that God is someone else that we can interact with and I can't I shouldn't be afraid to interact with him.
SPEAKER_02Well God is the word and God is the word made flesh because of Jesus and God is the sacraments that I mean that's what it says plainly in John 6. He's like I am the bread and I am the those who don't eat this flesh cannot inherit life and those who don't drink the blood like that is where the forgiveness of sins is found. There is this mystery that we were talking about before right traditions can't answer this because it's too high to fathom relationships can't answer this because honestly he's too mysterious and big he discloses who a portion of himself of who he is in the Bible and he's given us the sacraments to celebrate is he only this no but is he this yes it's this mystery of he is this and more I feel like and so maybe maybe the traditions is grappling with the part that he has disclosed with us right and like settling into that more concretedness and then the authenticity spiritual side that you're referencing is like okay pondering what is the more that he has yet to disclose to us and honestly we won't fully understand I don't know if we'll ever get to fully know the end of who God is in heaven because then they always said in like my classes and I I've inherited this which is like if we can find out who God is fully in heaven like is he still God if he's all like if he's un or knowable in heaven he's unsearchable meaning like he's it's not like he's hard to find but he can't be fully understood.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02Because he's so great and grand. But there are things that his word is made flesh he is the living bread he is the resurrection and the life he is the truth like those these are things that his word has told us and Jesus is the word I I love this analogy we we had this today in chapel we were talking about for the kids it's like God spoke the word and into existent then he said let there be light and this goes along with something I've been studying which is they're like God or sorry Jesus is the one who made everything and in through him and for him are two all things sorry that's a terrible like quotation of it but it's in Colossians and people are like where I don't see Jesus in the creation story and it says God spoke and it's cool because the word became flesh and then that's Jesus.
SPEAKER_02So I I'm excited I don't know I get really excited when I see those connections um because it's just like I'm thankful that there's truth in it. You know I'm thankful that that is more than if I feel in a relationship very good with God one day. Like oh my gosh I'm ready to be authentic before God and then the next day I have a hard day or I walk in pride and sinfulness. I'm like I don't feel like being authentic in front of God.
SPEAKER_02And to me that is appealing to me that um that God would choose to relate to us right God would take on flesh and choose to become like us to know us. I this is so cool and we're gonna flip this this is so crazy but like we've been spending a lot of time like thinking about how we can know him how we can relate to him but I think the greatest thing and I don't I'm gonna say this and it's gonna sound funny like I don't want to figure this out I don't think I want to try to explain it away through theology for once or I just want to sit and ponder with it which is like God would choose to take on flesh God would choose to relate to me God would choose to know me and how through Jesus.
SPEAKER_02So I think it's really cool when you also flip the question of like how does God relate to us well he sent his son that he that those who would be those who call upon his name would be saved that those who call upon the name of Jesus as their Lord and Christ and Savior would not be condemned but have life and life everlasting should they profess him. So there's a knowledge of him that is the saving they always say the saving knowledge of Jesus which is eternal life.
SPEAKER_02So there's both aspects of knowledge and being in that gospel statement.
SPEAKER_00Yeah yeah valid I smiled a lot in that last part I don't know why I was very excited good good there's a lot there's a lot to God and so uh yeah I think part of that is joy and is delight so which is great to feel after a while that's not shocking that's not shocking so hey Andrew do you have any questions?
SPEAKER_02What do you mean just about anything that we just talked about?
SPEAKER_00Any final thoughts what would uh what would you say is there any way in your mind that can because they talked a lot about they talked a lot about CCM on the side of the women. I don't know is there any is there anything that you would say to someone or that you just think would help with that divide? Because there was the the article did sort of express a concern in the divide and there is an aspect of the divide that we're not talking about which is that modern anything that's a little bit more modern tends to be I think a little less scary to women as the past has not always been very kind to women and even the church now sometimes holds to some old school beliefs that don't always benefit women uh very well and so I think that's something they they went into but it is a a part of the divide but um uh yeah just as far as this divide as we've talked about it what do you think would help with this?
SPEAKER_02I'd also like to say as we go more future I think there are some things that men are scared about in the church too. So that's why they might cling to tradition not saying it's right or wrong. Oh for sure. They need to cling to everyone needs to cling to Jesus is my caveat. Um my takeaway was probably somewhere in the middle of our discussion where I said thank goodness God makes us differently like the amount of times that I'm talking to the viewers right now, the listeners lol uh to those who are engaging with this podcast, however you are um I have benefited so much from Andrew in terms of his desire and appetite for beauty of God in this world and whether it's conversations like these where it's the the books he has been so gracious to share with me we've sat outside it like outside anonymous I think a couple times I'm trying to think like where else we've done things where I'm just like oh yeah these are really beautiful moments.
SPEAKER_02Our concert we went to that one time in Norfolk like there are a bunch of times where Andrew and his appetite for beauty has reminded me hey God shows up in these areas in addition to what you're looking for. Not greater than not less than in addition to I think is the best way that I've seen it and it's like if I didn't have friends like Andrew in my life like I would be missing out on a lot more of the beautiful sides of it.
SPEAKER_02And I hope something that I can bring to relationships is like hey like this God who is beautiful is able to be known and here are some long lasting well obviously the Bible's true so here are some truths in the Bible that are so true that you are seeing align with what you're experiencing. Like it's not just this wave of emotion you're gonna feel it's not just this beautiful sunset you're gonna see and go away. It's not only like there are very tangible definitions that can like I feel like there's sometimes like a peace art excitement in knowing how things work or knowing in who someone is and like that the person of God that you just experienced can I tell you more about him through a story?
SPEAKER_02Can I tell you more about him through this tradition of communion can I tell you more about him through any other things in the traditions that maybe maybe you haven't heard of before and then I think what's cool is like you even said there are beautiful traditions and there are such beautiful things to know in beautiful things of God. They're very intertwined like you said. So um God knows what he's doing when he's making all of us and all these things and all these appetites I like it I like it there's more to talk about with that but I think uh we'll we'll leave it there.
SPEAKER_02We'll move forward yes all right so um next you got an announcement for the people I can't roll my tongue I can only roll my I can do a lip trail I yeah I couldn't roll my tongue for the longest I still can't so anyway uh hi guys um at this point hopefully if I did everything right if I did everything right please Lord I just want to do this right um my single should be out by now you're saying is your single I have a single like a song like a song what yeah crazy work I know we have been alluding to this probably since uh when was our last in studio pod yeah we've alluded to it since your The All About Liz episode yeah yeah yeah that was the that was the thing that I tried to bring up and she was like and she just kind of pissed off it yeah I just said I love Keith Keith is cool which he is I love Keith Hey man shout Keith Keith from ModCon Studios Moments of Worship podcast heck yeah um what's the book note oh what is it uh oh shoot it's right over there on my bookshelf but I can't read it from here that's okay it's the knowing him one yeah anyway we were just talking about it anyway we love Keith please go check him out uh Bethel Baptist Church in Yorktown Virginia if you I'm sure if you look on the website you'll be able to find some of his resources as well oh yes and Abide in God Studios um yeah so Keith and I record well I recorded a song with Keith that day and it took honestly a whole year for me to decide to actually record it and because actually our first pod was when I first showed it to him and the boys.
SPEAKER_02Was it that book? Yeah you showed it to him the first day we met him yeah really I don't I forgot about that yeah and then like I just never did anything for a whole year and I've decided to do it the last week I was in Virginia record it. So and then it was probably finished in about August September with school coming up and everything. So I said all right I need to just sit on it for a little bit um instead I got sick and eventually I just said I'm just gonna do this at 1030 at night with no sleep for tomorrow and we're gonna figure out how to put a song out.
SPEAKER_02So release on 23rd of October which if this is released after that hopefully you can listen to it again.
SPEAKER_00No it's gonna be this is definitely going to be released after that.
SPEAKER_02So it would be really great and I would be curious to hear like everyone's thoughts on it. Yeah right now I'm planning to release this a week after so hopefully people will have had some time to sit on the song and you know listen to it a little bit and um yeah what all right man I don't even know where to I gave this whole segment to Andrew because I just uh I just really love when he asks me questions. Also I'm gonna just chuckle with Andrew really quick for a minute.
SPEAKER_02Remember how I randomly said hey Andrew do you have any questions earlier in this podcast?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02That was gonna be my segue. But anyway here we are I thought it was about this about the last topic I'm still a baby potter guys so we are I'm excited.
SPEAKER_03Anyway Andrew It's cool man is cool you do good work.
SPEAKER_02Um Andrew has seen a lot of behind the scenes work behind the song He hasn't known me throughout the whole song, but I'm just yes I like being prompted by him.
SPEAKER_00So tell people when you actually wrote it. Because I've you know, I I play like I've like, oh what you released a song. I've had this demo since very soon after I moved to Williamsburg. So very soon after we became friends, you shared the demo with me because we had been going through similar stuff at the time. And at the time that I listened to it, it was really impactful. So um I just want to uh know a little bit more like when you actually wrote it and you know, to whatever degree you can explain why.
SPEAKER_02Sure. I actually forgot I shared it with you earlier on in our friendship, so I'm really I'm excited that it blessed you. Um so I wrote this song uh March of 2024. So this was about six months into my job at the church, and I was one of 12, I think, on staff. And I I wasn't anyone, I was just like support staff.
SPEAKER_02I was on the worship team, I would help with events, like I wasn't actually like supposed to be any big leadership position. And there were other things going on in my life, which included um just some family stuff going on, which is so like heart-wrenching. Like, you know, family just family stuff is hard for everyone, right? So everyone has their story of it, and I'm like, man, like we were just going through it a little bit at that time. Um, I'm six months into not just a new job, but I'm six months into moving away from my then community.
SPEAKER_02Um, shout out to anyone in Lynchburg and YoPro. If you listen to this, you rock. Um because they were my people at the time. And when you, and I know you've experienced this, when you pick up and move and you lose that community, those first few months are just stink. Like I can't even explain it. Like, I'm not only trying to figure out a new job and a new apartment. It's like I don't know like where people go to hang out. I don't know how to awkwardly ask people to hang out.
SPEAKER_02I don't know if I'm like even welcome in the group chats because I feel so new to the scene. And I'm like, man, like six months into this, this new job, some other challenges in my life, and I'm I'm not sure why God has brought me into this season. Um, funny enough, I don't want to really sound like Taylor Swift, but I wrote this song when a guy rejected me on a third date. Um just like the song has nothing to do with dating life. Let's just put it that way.
SPEAKER_02But that was like the 10th question that I had to God, where I was like, hey God, like if you knew this was gonna fizzle out and he was basically gonna give me a two-hour lecture at the end of it, explaining how it was my fault. Like, I I don't know why you led me down this path. And then that question led to another, I don't know why you had me move here. And it's like, God, like, I don't even know what's going on in my life, which I don't know if I'm the only one who loves to ask that question to God, but I feel like for once in my life, I was willing to actually say that question out loud to God.
SPEAKER_02So in the in the song, I am processing, which is actually true, the first verse and the first chorus and the bridge, I think. I just was singing on a guitar and I kind of just sang it all together. I didn't just like sit down and was like, I have all these words and all these chords, but it was like I'm just playing my guitar and I'm just trying to relate honestly before the Lord in some song and some music. And then later on, I write the later lyrics and stuff, but I was just like, I don't have anything to tell you right now.
SPEAKER_02I can't name anything I'm feeling. Like, I don't understand how you're gonna see me through this mess. Like, if I can't see it, can you even comprehend it? Like, these were these types of like frustrating questions, and like maybe you have a plan for this. I don't have an idea of how. So just like taking a bunch of painful things in my life, reducing it down to the really hard questions you really want to ask God, and it's not like I made this song to be like, oh, it's so applicable to everyone, and therefore I'm gonna release it as a single.
SPEAKER_02It's just turned out to be a song that had very little detail of my life to really get to the heart of the questions of like, God, like, do you actually have plans for this? Do you care that I'm hurt? Do you care about my desires? And those types of questions.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I I know I like the song because of really what I was talking about or what I was trying to get across in the last um segment of authenticity. Right? I don't think authenticity for me is just this is me doing this honestly and presently. Right? Like when I do the physical stuff, when I do the sacraments, when I do scripture, when I do all that, I know why I'm here.
SPEAKER_00Even if I don't fully understand my my even if I don't understand fully why I'm still here maybe out of frustration, but I know why I'm here. And when I pray and when I try and connect to you outside of what I can what I understand you will say back, or even knowing if you will say anything back, I know I am here and I'm choosing to do this, and it is genuine to who I am, and and this song for me just was that, right?
SPEAKER_00You're not you're not just singing like worship. And I find an interesting thing with a lot of musicians nowadays that authenticity really seems to be their thing. There are a lot of musicians who will like make a worship song or worship album early on in their career, and then a little later in their career make an album about their actual path with God, and you're like deconstruction, finding my way back, yeah, being confused, having questions, and so I think that's so important because everyone goes through it to some degree.
SPEAKER_02It's yeah, exactly what you're saying.
SPEAKER_00And so this song is just for me, it's it's that, and it's incredible that you shared it with that you've shared it now, but I love that it was personal for a while, and I love that you didn't share it for a while, and that was just your communication with God. But um how does it feel, I guess, going f have how did it feel, I guess, be like even beginning the process, making the choice of transitioning it from this is my personal prayers and my personal journal to oh, I'm gonna give this to people now.
SPEAKER_02Um making it with Keith was fun. I got to share it once at a songwriting retreat with him. I don't know if I talked about that on the podcast. It was in January of 2025. Me and Brooklyn went with some of his people for a songwriting retreat, and one of the things we got to do was we got to share one of the nights any personal stuff we were working on. And I just was like, hey guys, like this song has a lot of doubts, and it might sound like I'm questioning my salvation or this, that, whatever.
SPEAKER_02And I'm like, I just don't I lean a preface to them that was like, this song is meant to sound messy, like not in composition, but like in content. And so I just remember sharing it with them, and Keith's daughter like looked at me from across the room and she just was crying, and she was like, This song is just so and she when she said sad, like she didn't mean like it's like pathetic. She's like, it's just so sad because I can relate to it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And she's like 15 or 16 at the time, and I'm like, oh my gosh, I hate that she knows what these questions feel like at 16. And like actually, I remember asking these questions at 16. And when you talk about this song being personal, like I wrote it over right, I wrote it over boy, whatever. But like two months later, in like June or three months later, sorry, in June of that year, I'm singing it over when like a bomb dropped on my world.
SPEAKER_02I'm singing it a year and a half later after that bomb jumped or like dropped on my life. Is it a year? No, I'm dropping it like a year later. So like March, a year after I wrote it, I'm singing it because my dad gets injured for the first time. And I'm like, this is pretty confusing. I'm singing it a year and a half later when the Lord tells me, hey, like your time at this, like this season of your life, it's about to change.
SPEAKER_02So like enjoy the last moments of it. I'm singing it packing up my apartment. I'm singing it at my first open house coffee show. Like, and it it meant different things. Like, I had questions about different things in my life. I've sent it to friends who've been going through divorces. I've sent it to people who have had really hard questions about raising kids. I've had it sent it to people doubting their faith or going through like, man, I'm just like struggling, like the everyday struggling level.
SPEAKER_02And when I've shared it, it was just like a little like MP3 recording, nothing special. But I think the sweetness of this song, and I don't boast in it, right? But like I'm I'm stunned at how relatable it is just in my life every single day for a different reason. And then I'm even more stunned by how it's being related to different people and then several of their seasons. So I think I'm just my my songwriting professor had this saying that was like, some songs are meant for your prayer closet, and then others are meant to be shared with people.
SPEAKER_02And so I think as I was telling my one friend at school I was releasing the song, she's like, Can I hear a snippet of it? I was like, No, you have to wait just a little bit because I want a little bit more time with the song with myself before I like send it, send it out. And she's like, Okay, but but can I listen to it when it comes out? I'm like, Yes, please listen to it when it comes out because like I want you to I want you to tell me like what the Lord told you in it.
SPEAKER_00What does the what is the what what what and this is an theater kid question?
SPEAKER_02Am I walking with a purpose on stage?
SPEAKER_00No, no, just the interpretive aspect of it. What does the music communicate? Especially in the final edition, right? It's you have the guitar strumming, and by now most people who are listening to it can have heard it at least. And um, but there's also this underlying uh this un these underlying sounds that Keith uh keyboard keybo interesting keyboard sounds that Keith uh and you worked on.
SPEAKER_02And so uh I don't know if it necessarily means anything right now to me. We were talking as creatives a while ago where it's like I would do so many things differently and add different things.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um like I'm listening to it now. I'm like, dang it, I would do something else. Or what if we added this? And so creatives keep creating, just do alternate versions later down the line and keep releasing it. Um first of all, guitar. I would just like to point the elephant out in the room that I play guitar as my third instrument. I don't say that to boast. I say that as this was a challenge for me. Um when I go back to the story about praying to God, I found myself in that season of my life not wanting to worship on the piano.
SPEAKER_02And this was in 2023 for the last three years, I would say. I didn't relating to God in my quiet time on piano was very difficult because it felt like my job or my primary instrument. Like it's it's what everyone else saw me doing, like from a platform or in public. And I was like, I when I sit behind a keyboard right now, like I feel a little less like myself, my authentic self to go back to that, right? So I was like, I'm gonna be a little bit more like with the Lord on my guitar, and it was just easier because I could sit on my couch, this couch actually, um, and just sit and play a couple different songs.
SPEAKER_02It's not to say like I couldn't have written this song on piano, but it came out on guitar. So I think the fact that it's on guitar and the fact that it's me playing on the guitar is kind of wild because I never thought that my first song, let alone ever releasing a song, would feature like the guitar. So that's something huge for me. Um I just wanted the music to feel like as you got more in the song, like you could ask harder questions for God and feel safe.
SPEAKER_02And you eventually come to this resolution at the end, um, where I don't know if I created the sense of safety or peace, but it's just like at least you feel like you're willing to call out to him. It's not like over-productionized, like I didn't have a bunch of time or a bunch of resources, or I would have loved to bring like other people into it. I just, you know, I procrastinated, I didn't have a lot of time, but I I did, I thought I I want to just pray that I served this song justice and um just created a demo or in the song that took you through like honest questions, harder, more honest questions, calling out to God, and then feeling like resolved at the end.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'll I'll I'll say to myself what um what the song like the feeling the song gives, and then I'll kind of let you cap us off. I have one more question for you. But um for me it sounds like dwelling. It sounds like dwelling with God. Um in my personal experiences, usually in my um it's usually in the times when I'm the most confused, the most vulnerable, and I'm the most willing to be honest, right?
SPEAKER_00Like all my all of my um care to be polished is gone. All of my desire to be theologically accurate with God is gone, right? I'm just in psalms mode. I don't care if it's right or if it's true, I'm just praying. Um I'm a worm. God, I'm a worm. Um it'll st it'll start off as feeling like it's just me talking and just saying whatever I want.
SPEAKER_00And then God eventually meets me in my in my sadness, in my emotions, and whatever it is. And it's almost like we go on a journey for this mode uh mode. Sometimes it involves Bibles, sometimes it involves a sermon, it involves music, it involves other things, but in this mode it's like God is typically answering questions, journaling. But now I'm going from simply asking a question to almost having this conversation and truly having this moment with God.
SPEAKER_00And the song kind of builds up in that way for me. And so um it does. It feels like, you know, at the end of it, it's like you can ask whatever you want, and it feels like you're really having this moment. It sounds to me almost like you're playing it like lying on the grass, strumming the guitar with the stars going above.
SPEAKER_02Like it's a first-gonna say lying on the ground crying, and I was like, Well, there was that night too.
SPEAKER_00So you know, it does sound like that as well, but I was going for the more poetic version. Thanks. But no, it's it's a beautiful song, and I will say I'm very proud of you for um putting it out just because it's something we had talked about for quite some time as we got into Well, yeah, it's quite some time. Um as we as we all were kind of exploring our creative endeavors, and you know, I can I some have seen in myself sometimes a tendency to push uh people in ways that don't necessarily they don't necessarily need to be pushed to create at times, but I love that not only did you end up doing it, but you took your time, right?
SPEAKER_00You didn't let my encouragement push your timeline further. I think it it's it's coming out when it needed to come out. And so um I'm just happy that you've done it. I'm happy that you've uh that you've leaned into your musical gift in a way that is outside of obviously your worship leader, but in a way that is authentic to you and unique to you and does not have to be um dictated by anybody else's opinions or you know, the congregation.
SPEAKER_00It can be you and God and your gift. And I I I I think it's beautiful and yeah, really, really proud of you for doing this.
SPEAKER_02Thank you. Hey, um my whatever I'm okay. So October, what is this? Today's the eighth. Um, my artist page, for those who are trying to find it, is Elizabeth Longley. This is me, my first time releasing one of these things. So I'm like trying to figure out claiming an artist page, claiming this, claiming that, and I'm like, Lord, I just I just need your help. So hopefully you can look up Elizabeth Longley after October 23rd, which it's obviously after October 23rd right now.
SPEAKER_02So go listen. Um, Elizabeth Longley. It's called Questions with a period. Ooh, artsy.
SPEAKER_00Um, anything else you want to tell people about the song before they go and listen to it?
SPEAKER_02Okay, shout out Keith McMahon and Abiding God Studios for producing and being another cheerleader alongside everyone. Always. Um, thank you to my friend Richie Hall and Randy Poole for doing some mixing and mastering and editing my vocals. They are all credited on my um, you'll see in a couple like posts coming up out and stuff. Um thank you for this. Sounds really funny, everyone.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, everybody who came to that one random October picnic in August of 2025 for a young adult's dinner, because that is going to be um the cover art, and none of you are in it, but you were all in the background behind the camera. I took some pictures of some buildings and I was like, oh, I like this photo. So thanks to everyone who came out to that. Um, I have a bunch of cheerleaders that um who have walked, that's what I call it. I have like, this is such a funny thing, Andrew.
SPEAKER_02I'm gonna tell you on my post when I announce it. Um, I have like the cover photo, I have like a credits page, and then I have a cheerleader page, which is basically people like you, Luke, Brooklyn, Caitlin, anyone who's like supported me through this, seriously. Anyone who who who's heard the demo that one night at a small group where we all said, What's the favorite song that's like helping us understand God better right now? Or why is this your favorite song right now? I played it for a few people there. Or like people who came to like my open night or open mic night at Anonymous Coffee, like that was so fun.
SPEAKER_02Like, they're just a bunch of people who, if they weren't by my side, like this song wouldn't mean as much. So that's who I also want to thank is all my cheerleaders, and you all know who you are. So I love you all.
SPEAKER_01Yay! First song.
SPEAKER_03Hopefully there'll be more.
SPEAKER_02I'm hoping so too. So um, I would love to uh what is it like do a speed run of music if you want to talk about yours, and then I'll sp fire through mine and then we will wrap things up.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, let's do it. Um I think the only I only have one album to shout out. I think it's was it Diary of a Worship Leader or something like that?
SPEAKER_02Worship Leader's Diary.
SPEAKER_00Worship Leader's Diary. By uh artist named Anthony. Uh really, really cool, really cool project. Um I it I don't know, it it's it is the authenticity of a worship leader. And I think now having known a worship leader, it's like it's very interesting. Like hearing the things you're concerned about in like how much you care for worship, it's interesting to hear somebody else who is in ministry um write songs from a place of caring about how they show up uh as a worship leader, as seeing themselves as a leader and being um and asking for some of the things like uh there's one song, Slow Down, um, just asking for some of the things that they know it takes to be a good uh a leader that represents Christ uh in their in their own way.
SPEAKER_00And so I uh as someone who, you know, am using this platform and I kind of see myself in that way, not that I'm necessarily a leader in that way, but that once I decide to talk about God, like I want that level of seriousness that anybody in ministry and full-time ministry brings to their craft because they know who they're representing. And so um amazing, uh amazing project, uh pretty quick and easy listen, I would say.
SPEAKER_00Um definitely RB or RB gospel. I would say it's got uh a bit of flavor from the new got new style of gospel, old style of gospel. Um, and it's got some interesting flips of like classic songs. So uh yeah, yeah, man. Uh go check it out. Worship Leader's Diary uh by Anthony. Anthony. No oh. No oh. For some reason, the O, because because he's cool, he he capitalized all the letters and left out the O.
SPEAKER_00Shout out Anthony.
SPEAKER_02Love it. Um, the thing that's been on repeat for me is this new album. There might be a part two coming out later, uh, is by Gable Price and Friends, Moving Target. I just wrote in my description notes, Woot. Uh, this song, honestly, not this song, but this is a great album that honestly I was telling Andrew, I did not understand this when the singles were coming out. I like the songs, but I was having a hard time piecing all the singles together. I didn't know what order they were coming out in.
SPEAKER_02But when I listened to the project from head to toe, like I just really appreciated like just the words he used, it feels really relatable. Um, Christian, indie, folk, I feel like they're all just words thrown around these days. It's not something you're gonna hear on a Sunday morning, but you're gonna be glad you're listening to it Tuesday morning driving to work or at the gym. It's a great word after the gym. I, you know, it's not for the sanctuary, but it's for the shower, baby.
SPEAKER_02You know, I'm there are other parts of the city. It's for the drive through. Yeah, it's for Sonic.
SPEAKER_00Anyway. This album sounds like a Freddie's cheeseburger for sure. I'll rock with it.
SPEAKER_02Two things, two songs I like off of it is Why Do You Love Me and Looking for You. So those are some of my favorite tracks. And don't listen just listen to the project from top top to finish. You know, it's a great experience that way. So I think it's a great one if you're looking to expand your musical taste outside of the traditional or the traditional CCM sounds. It'll be enriching for you all. So with that, I just wanted to say thanks again for Andrew.
SPEAKER_02Jazz hands!
SPEAKER_03You can't see it, you can't hear it. Yeah, but the video will be out. I'm putting videos out now, baby. Woo!
SPEAKER_02All right, guys. Um, until next time, remember that eternity is for the beautiful, eternity is for the timeless, eternity is for those who walk with God, and all are welcome. Good night, everyone, or good morning, or thanks for letting me join you on your little break throughout the day. We will catch you next time. See you later. Adios. Bye, Luke's mom.
In Today’s episode, Andrew and Jacqueline welcome the return of Luke! The three start off discussing another Word of Wisdom from Fred Rogers and then move on to giving their Artists of the Week. Jacqueline expresses her...
In today’s episode, Andrew and Jacqueline introduce a new segment to the podcast called “Words of Wisdom”. Andrew then pays tribute to Keith McMinn, producer and owner of Abide in God studios, as he announces some news...
Today the boys are in the home studio! Andrew and Luke come together to have some real dude discussion. Starting with Luke’s apology to megachurches and a discussion on some of the deeper concerns with certain church...
In today's episode, Lizz and Andrew discuss the passing of music icon Dolly Parton. This conversation leads into one about true beauty and the difficulty of cultivating a beautiful life. Lizz shares some thoughts about...
The first episode of a new show hosted by Eternal Creatures. After Lizz’s recent move to New Jersey, she is back with her own series based on her Substack name ela.ink. In this series, Lizz brings you her personal...