Thanks again for joining us today, everyone, on another episode of Epilogues & Epiphanies. Today, we're going to be talking about The Hunger Games with a new friend. I'll let him introduce himself.
Hi, everybody. My name is Jake Rupp. I have been teaching for 20 years. My favorite part of my job, really, among all the classes I teach, is my Young Adult Novel course. And so having the opportunity to be here and teach and talk about The Hunger Games is just a thrill. I've been doing the Internet for a couple of years. And so maybe some people have seen me on there, too, and that's been pretty neat. But I'm excited. I'm glad we got to select this one.
I am kind of curious, like, what made you say yes? Was it the Psych reference that did it?
Psych means a lot to me. I've modeled my entire adult life after Sean Spencer. I watch Psych every single night. And so we get to that. But I've been making these manipulative rhetoric videos and they've been going wild. And I've been invited on podcasts, pretty like large podcasts from people that I've kind of seen around. But they want me to talk about stuff I'm not an authority on. I just know how rhetoric works. So when something comes across to talk about media, now we're in my wheelhouse. And I said no so many times to other people that it was like, this sounds so fun. I want to do this.
That's awesome. Tell me about your first introduction to The Hunger Games story.
So my first introduction to The Hunger Games story, a colleague, she's telling me about this book. Like, I just read the craziest book. These kids killing each other. I was like, there's no way that's a book. So whatever. So she gives me this book and I'm on a flight. And I am so enamored by The Hunger Games as I'm reading it that I completely miss this plain land. And it terrified me. Like it just hits the ground. And I'm right in the middle of this scene, like where they're at the cornucopia. Like I'm just eating through this book. And so when the movie comes out, which is going to be our focus, I am so pumped. But it is in 2012. And my wife in 2012 was like, I don't know, 17 and a half months pregnant. And I wanted to go and see The Hunger Games. I was so excited. Like this is my thing. And she'd never read it. And we get to the movie theater and we're watching it. And we get to this scene where, you know, Rue dies. And I look over at my wife and she's just having a breakdown. And I'm like, I have made a mistake. This was, this was the most...
This was the wrong shared activity.
This was the most ignorant thing that I possibly could have ever done. Like I ignored audience values, needs and beliefs, not even ignored. I overlooked them completely. And I was like that, my wife still talks about it. Like when The Hunger Games comes up, we talk about that moment. That is the thing that defined it. But I've been in love with it. I love it. I think it is flawless in a number of ways. The film does, it makes some choices and we can talk about those. But the books and as a teaching tool, incredible, incredible.
We mentioned this a little bit in our pre-chat. You mentioned it in one of your videos about when the kids first read the books, a lot of times in junior high, they're too young for them. I think Worldview was a little too young for them at that point. And so re-engaging with them a little bit more recently has just been really interesting because I was definitely more outraged by the love triangle details than I was some of the other things and like you know there's things to be mad about there still but like obviously not the big picture of what we're trying to talk about here so yeah I think I think you're looking back at these now too I'm also a lot more empathetic towards the Katniss character than I was then it's really hard to be friendly and likable when there's a lot of stuff going on.
Katniss you know part of she's so authentic which is why she can crumble an entire capital because she's not really paying attention to it always in the same ways that you see like Haymitch be exposed as later on in this series and that's just that's fascinating because yeah she's not necessarily likable but there's been so many likable tributes that have come and gone before her that like her difference is what makes her so refreshing. There's like a line early on in the movie when I think they're on the train Peeta's looking for Haymitch and he says something like I just don't think there's anything wrong with asking for a little help and she doesn't say anything back yeah there's nothing wrong with asking for help if you think you can get some is kind of her vibe in that moment she's gotten so good at surviving that like that's all she really knows how to do and those conversations I mean through those Hunger Games up until she finds him painted as that damn rock those conversations are so guarded because she is fully under the impression because she needs to be that he's going to try and kill her and so it's all kind of part of the act and even though she wants to see through it her skepticism of him is this driving force and so I think a lot of times when we read it you know we know how it turns out like Hunger Games became part of the monoculture like you know Hunger Games like you know Star Wars right and so I think it's really easy especially as a viewer now to watch it and almost overlook how appropriate her behavior is towards Peeta because odds I mean they don't know there's going to be a rule change like even even if she trusts him why get close that's never worked for her before no yeah exactly exactly yeah that's kind of yeah it's really interesting like just to think about her in context like we think about a lot of these characters like in our context and how their behavior fits like what our life looks like but you think about like what she's ever known in thinking about Effie's context a little bit too if we just look at that first film in exclusivity you have Effie Trinket starting to finally question what she's doing in in a way where like it's really tragic that it takes like we might have a winner for her to actually like break through and be like oh there might be a possibility of of a relationship with this person moving forward right yeah and she's never had to consider that because they just get hosed every every games or she's chosen not to consider that like you know I mean there's she does seem like a for her context she seems like she's attempting to be a kind person like for what she knows to be she's trying to be nice I think she just has a very limited perspective of what that means and what that entails and I think for her her relationship with Haymitch even just you know that context too and and all of that and trying maybe even trying not to get attached and that changing her perspective when she actually kind of does she's such a stark contrast and they do that so well in this the capital versus the districts and she seems like the poster girl for the capital you know what I mean so for her to get stuck with district 12 is kind of weird feeling I think a little bit if you would almost imagine like you get your B League or something but there it is it's like it's a starter job right this is this is where we start and then we climb the rung to one of the more desirable ones and that disconnect that you point out you know between the capital and the districts to her expressing pity is kindness that that's what that's where kindness comes from like I up here feel bad for you but look at all this fancy stuff that I can give you because to her that right that that is what affection looks like is just stuff and food and opulence and look at how nice your life is before you go into this thing and die and I don't want to necessarily humanize you Katniss and Peeta but I do really like you and doesn't that mean a lot coming from me yeah isn't aren't I nice like yeah right I'm this is so hard for me Effie Trinket yeah oh my gosh yeah I mean again it's all status right and we can look we as like decent not in the capital people can look at this and be like you send kids off to their death how do you remedy that but the disconnect is so large because these are the Hunger Games why do we do the Hunger Games well as a punishment why do we keep on doing because we always have and that sort of appeal to tradition right where we just like we keep on doing it because it's the way it's always been why we can't change that it's foundational and she's bought into that so hard as somebody who's living not only in the capital but a pretty decent life of luxury but it's it's status it is status and the clothing I think is just attention-seeking consumerism yeah we're just gonna buy it because we have it and they do that even when we get to the second movie and you learn that they're going to these parties and the people are like you can just drink this you'll throw up and then you can just taste everything that part is stuck with me forever and ever I'm like what the part even creepier and I made a post about this years ago because I was watching that movie I watch them a lot if I'm being honest but there's a part where Katniss and Peter walking into that party it's early on and there's the creepiest guy and as Katniss walks by he just like touches her as she goes by like but it it's so zoo animal and pointing to all of the underage things that you know Finnick O'Dare ultimately ends up talking about to about his experience as being a young Victor and what ends up happening to them and you know you even see that with Haymitch in that last book where they put him in cages just to like show him off I mean they're not humans.
No and it's like it's like look at this like weird creature that survived it's like fetishized like a lot you survive and you win but do you really win like basically they just end up being trafficked you know yes for most the rest of their lives.
Victor's belong to the capital and so they they have the the people they're the citizens the viewers they own them and so then you have these people and I think the movie does this in the book doesn't ever do it because the the book is always first person right and so in the movie you get to see people actually watching The Hunger Games and like observing it and yes they're forced to watch it but ultimately and Snow says this like they need a little bit of hope like there has to be just a little like underlying hope and so if we can tie The Hunger Games to what ultimately is a prize for everybody which is if your district tribute wins then everybody gets extra food for a year and so you get that like you can't help even if you win even if you hate it you're not turning that food down you know you don't you don't have the privilege to protest because yeah because you need to eat it because you will die and so that whole that whole idea of ownership just yeah it takes over everything you know yes they have to watch it but they still reap the rewards of the winning and they are still living in fear if they don't so it's always I mean it's always gonna win for the capital until somebody brings it down this is why I teach it these are the kinds of conversations that a guy gets to have in his class because students start to pick up on these things too and every year there's different parallels and there's these different these different concepts that students point out and they're devouring these books and then I get the pleasure of showing them the second movie which I think is front like the the movie it's the book it's the movie yeah and they get to experience that and sort of the shift from I don't know the stylistic choices that are done in the first one to something that is a bit I think more accurate to the tone of the Hunger Games in its entirety plus they have better source material like that second book is so good.
The second book is so good and I feel like I feel like the first book was still almost trying to be like a kid's appropriate movie somehow like in some ways when the subject matter really never really should be but I feel like in the second one it's like we're kind of okay with being more intense and mature and like even though the whole theme is obviously that but like I feel like there was there was a watering down a little bit feeling when I remember when I saw the first book. I saw the first movie the first time of like just feeling like the it lost a little bit of like the punch in a way but that could have just been my perspective but but I think there's something to it.
I think especially what the movie does that the book kind of is able to cover up is this love this very forced love triangle that my students just like hate and hate more and more every year that this goes on but it's you know if the book came out in oh wait your source material has to it comes from Twilight like that's when the first Twilight movie came out and then that's also the year the last Harry Potter movie came out and so I think that's right and so you have this sort of gap and so we're now these love triangles are sort of starting to it was very much a thing it was such a it's such a thing and I think what the movie does though I guess to my point is the movie emphasizes that Gail is in chapter one and a bit of two and then that's and then he's at the very very end I think like but Gail Gail and Katniss aren't together for 25 chapters of that book and so the movie I think that you can't get away from the distance of it even if she's thinking about him the difference is going to be on your screen so we will see him and we'll see him watching it and we'll see him concerned but he's so far away and like that love triangle just doesn't get a chance to have the tension that you feel when you read it and you get to see Katniss thinking about those her inner monologue for sure about like the conflict that she feels between one and the other and all of that kind of thing like I think was just very yeah it definitely added a layer to that part of the story that I feel like did get kind of hollowed out a lot in the movies for sure.
I think the definitely like if anything felt exaggerated in this how ridiculous people are willing to go in terms of their appearance which is what makes Sinna such an interesting character because he's so like restrained almost.
And we can talk about casting in this movie and like the highs and lows of it but Lenny Kravitz's Sinna is ideal. Ideal.
I don't think they could have found somebody to play that character with the sort of reserve rebellion that Lenny Kravitz was able to and again like you need an alternate timeline for me to prove that I'm right but his care for her is so different than everybody else even his style like we're talking about his style as a stylist is even more subdued in a space where flamboyance is valued and he's bringing restraining all of that and he's not gonna he's gonna yes he's gonna light her on fire and make a scene but it's not a scene because it's like a spectacle of fashion it's a scene on fire she is on fire and so he and I think he plays that super well I think they captured a lot of like the smaller details with like his eyeliner that they discuss in the book and the way that again it's very moderated but it is definitely there because to me it always felt like Sinon was camouflaging himself I just I just need to blend in enough so I can do something to make this situation better and his juxtaposition with Effie Trinket when you see her and she's just all like literally dolled up right like just caked on I mean she doesn't she looks artificial and then Sinon looks authentic and her kindness is pity and his kindness is kindness yeah you can see the difference aren't you gonna congratulate me why would I do that like yeah I mean just like it's just the acknowledgement of the truth after being around people acting like this is a party for you know days on end would just be so stark and I think I think there's something to that like I don't know there's there's something interesting about this like guy that like is in the capital is kind of there but like is like you said just kind of quietly rebelling and like this and he kind of locks in on her like right away like he like and I think that is something that I found really interesting and that is like the authenticity kind of like finds itself like it finds it in other people and I think you know like he knew this was someone I could help tell a story with like you know he knew there was something to tell and like kind of immediately and she she couldn't help it with her you know volunteering for her sister and like that kind of thing like she didn't think that was on the table at all like that was not on her radar Katniss who was prepared for everything was not prepared for her sister being called up like she I mean at least in the movie version. If there's a jaw drop and like and I talked to my students about this a lot so a thing the movie captures really well as best it can is that the Hunger Games and all of those as novels one of the reasons that they're so particularly readable is that the last lines of those chapters are elite like they're so good and so the end of that first chapter is just Prim getting reaped and it's just Primrose Everdeen and you go into that book and you're like well I know Katniss goes in right like obviously I know Katniss goes in and even if you watch the movie and you haven't seen the text which is happening more frequently now you you're like well it's gonna be Katniss well it's not Katniss it's her sister and you know yeah I guess maybe now we know because like I volunteer as tribute and hurt and Jennifer Lawrence just demolishing that line and like that was yeah like it's perfect and so I guess people know that and so even then the mystery is kind of taken away but if you can look at it in a vacuum with no prior knowledge prim getting reaped like you said is the unexpected for somebody who has a lot of who has manufactured a lot of control in her life mm-hmm like Katniss has a lot of control she yeah she doesn't have to rely on anybody for food she can rely on herself she doesn't have to rely on anybody to take care of her family she can rely on herself but can't do much when they pick your name out of the bowl yeah that I mean that just like that struck me this time when I was watching it was like this girl has every system like like she knows like this many steps is you know I mean like she's got everything like calculated down but this was so far off of her radar as a possibility she doesn't immediately do it because it takes her a while to process that it's happened like her sister has to start walking and then she like then she screams like it's just like not so far out of her like realm that it doesn't hit her immediately that that's what's happening and I think yeah Jennifer Lawrence I think I had feelings and whatever about it at the time I think she does a really good job I don't know who else could have done it better like honestly so so the big conversation with that takes to kind of answer that is Isabel Fuhrman who plays Clove okay Clove she was trying she had not been cast in but she made it very very deep in the run to be Katniss Everdeen but the problem was that she was she because she looked the part but she looked too young and so when you put her next to Gail in this sort of like romantic will they won't they it didn't look right and so they and so she became Clove and so if you look at them side by side and you look at like well then who could it have been I think Isabel Fuhrman would have been a knockout Katniss Everdeen but casting somebody who just has a bit more of the appearance of age in order to stay true to that like dynamic with Gail I mean I think is the only choice that a person could make reasonably right but I think that's interesting yeah I think that makes sense to like because you do kind of have to pick a teenager or young adult that looks more like a teenager because even in that you get into the second one like we're already talking about themes of like oh we're faking a pregnancy like you know I mean to do that with someone who looks really young like would be weird like it would feel off putting more so than and that's that's the other thing too is like you know I think a lot of people in you know I think about her volunteering and what that would have what that would have done I mean I if I'm in district 12 like thank you for not make me watch Prim fight you know what I mean right you know like they Katniss I'm sorry you have to go but thank you for not making me watch Prim die like you know like there's a little bit of that and so like even that idea of like seeing what she did for her sister but like the the send off that they give her like I think is is also kind of like hey we we all should do this for the younger ones like you know like we I think it feels like part of that too because it would have been a much harder pill to swallow I mean it's not that it's not an impossible one already but like you know to watch this 12 year old like versus like the ones that look more like you know adults per se so to speak like we can kind of at least train our brains out of it in some ways and so yeah it's just it can be it can be less unfair yeah we you know I had a student I had a student point this out and I just I thought I thought about it for the year since but she points out this idea you know kind of like we're saying about how it would be so hard to watch a 12 year old right how it's so hard to watch Rue and you know it's not going to go well and but you know you see her and it's just it's so sad and it's so brutal but the student pointed out you know that people in the capital and even people from other districts look at district 12 and you're like well they're the worst off and they're the type of people that like bad things happen to and so of course bad things are going to happen to district 12 and we can we can be a little bit more at peace with that because like that's just to be expected and her pointing that out as not from her perspective but from the perspective of others that watch district 12 yeah to then have a Katniss Everdeen is now amplified like wait wait wait like they have a shot so now all the ways that we're kind of numb to the tragedy that goes on in 12 all the time yeah now we're even more excited about the possibility I mean the now now we're a little bit thrilled and you throw in a love story that Peeta you know so wonderfully crafts you know I think Josh Hutchett I think I think he gets casted as Peeta specifically because of his ability to have those conversations with Caesar in in the interviews up front maybe more than anything else that's his most shining moment is when he's up there like being charming on those interviews for sure yeah he's charming he's so charming so and it's like he turns it on because he's so terrified and you see him be terrified but you do see him be thoughtful you know on the train and as they're kind of exploring their their new home in the capital for the two weeks they're there but he turns that on with Caesar Flickerman and to me that's where that casting just right away makes the most sense you I thought he was good I think there's like or something you said there with yeah with like people like I mean we see that even you know today like we're just comfortable with like why certain yeah certain these are these are the types of things the bad thing these things happen to these types of people and it is it is somehow less tragic like yes it's horrible but it's also so frequent and like it this is if it's gonna happen this is who it happens to and that's where district 12 lies and yeah I think there's also something too that I just and maybe I'm reaching here a little bit but like it's a concept like I feel like is kind of this an out shoot of like Protestant work ethic of like if you do all the good things and you do and you work the hardest you can outwork bad things happening to you like there's kind of this idea of like this almost prosperity gospel ideal of like you know you can out good your way from bad things happening to you you can work harder you can do this do that the whatever and so then there becomes like this layer of like almost like we don't even think about it because it's subtext but like they could have worked harder and maybe not put themselves in that position or you know I mean like those kinds of things I think sometimes are part of that a little bit like well and in this case it's true like well the districts had it coming because right and they have they've had it coming for generations now I mean we're at the 74th Games at this point this is the way that and and I think the unfairness of the reaping I don't think ever gets subdued and I think you know because if you look at what it takes to like take risks and work hard in a district it's to take out the tesserae and to have your names in it even more the act of working hard is just making you more vulnerable it like it like cancels out the entire principle so and even then you never outgrow it because you end up having kids and now they're taking tesserae out so that you can eat and you have no control over that because like the cycle doesn't stop unless you don't have kids and even then you gotta watch it yeah it's like it's definitely like this control cycle and I think it's like I thought one thing that like kind of back earlier to their the thing that always felt weird to me when I first watched it and when they were kind of describing is like the capital looks like it's in the future and the districts look like they're in the past and like there's this like idea I think that I realize now of like well whenever there's control though like we kind of go back these like authoritarian like kind of structures and like you know girls in dresses and this that and the enemy like it's just very more traditional kind of categories and boxes for everything and how everything operates it's very much because otherwise I don't know how it makes sense that in the future that far that they're like you know how these like high tech clothes and stuff but then they're wearing like these clothes that look like they're from the 40s like it's kind of crazy yeah no it's it's just so yeah I think it's it's definitely it makes choices of like this is a really hard gruesome and like honestly it's such a convoluted way to punish and control that it's like easy to get lost in it even as a viewer of the movie I think of like wait how do we get here why are we here like what's going on and I think I think that's what I think that's the point you know like to kind of just like it's also a distraction like you know like you're so busy worried about all the things that you forget that you're oh this is traditionally you're saying tradition like it's tradition we're not we're thinking tradition not oppression yep so this is it is it's pageantry is what it I mean they it is a literal chariot ride pageant of these kids and we're gonna celebrate them and this is so fun and then it'll be over and then we'll wait for it next year and I remember asking a student and it's a conversation that that always ends up happening and so like the example I bring up is like MMA right like UFC I don't have I don't watch it but so if there was UFC but the top build top build fight was a consented fight to the death like they both agreed to it how many of you would watch it and these kids a lot of the kind of the boys but they're like man they both agreed to it like yeah they both nobody made them do it no they didn't have to do it but they agreed to it there's a massive like eternal cash prize you never have to think about it again they're like well if they both agreed to it like maybe and then it's like okay so let's let's go ahead and break that down and like where does that conversation act like do you really it's easy for you to say maybe it shouldn't be easy but it's easier for you to say than it is in practice to watch on just a live fight to the death like that's that's not gonna happen and I think it's when you I don't know cuz when you're in the middle of reading The Hunger Games I think you'd like to think that maybe you would be able to like tolerate this because you're so compelled by the games as you read it but that's something I wrote down at the end you talk about one of the last prompts here was like big questions and raises and I had two right in a row that was like what does it mean to watch Suffering and is this movie criticizing spectacle while being a spectacle itself yeah and like that it's that part of it it's the same thing when we talk about squid games when I you know you hear students that are kind of like no I'd watch it like would you would like really and you tell people you watched it would you really or are you like I don't know just are you like gut instinct saying no I would do that like sure they both agree but what does that say about the place that facilitates it right like that we're willing to broadcast it was that we're willing to pay people to do it a lot of money we'll pay you a lot of money to do this and that's where these conversations start right like that's where like okay even if you say you'd watch it even if a company was willing to put up the money would this be permitted now by like law enforcement or regulators of anything above the level of somebody being like no I'll give you guys a bunch of money to fight to the death on TV like it depends on how much capitalist industry there could be behind it that would drive jobs because it does shock me yeah and so it's those conversations and so then you know I think there's even something about The Hunger Games as you watch it where you're getting attached to your Katniss's and your Peeta's and your Rue's and you're starting to kind of villainize the careers a bit and they do you know they do such a good job of making them just seems like they're they're just they're machismo all of them is like so pronounced because they really do think they're gonna win and they're all hyped up this is what their life is for is to get here and the glory of it and then they get to that cornucopia and it counts it down and it takes forever for those games to start in that scene and then you're like this is actually terrifying yeah yeah this is a wide-open it's just a field it's just a field and they're gonna just kill these other people in a field yeah right now like at the end of this thing people start dying and I think that's the moment visually where it's where the stakes are so like even though you see the highlights a couple of times like early on in the broadcasts and like you know how great the previous games were but it's that moment where now it becomes a lot it becomes a lot more human visually than I think the books can ever do the books can do that they slow the music down and you see the kids like it's terrifying yeah and I think if you watch that and then you're like no I would watch I would watch that in real life okay now now you have you are then maybe I don't know if I want to keep talking to you because I'm gonna keep my distance here maybe a little bit for sure that would be horrible it's terrifying like you can lie to yourself about it and then you see it even in this fictional cinematic world it's like absolutely not nope yeah no and it should and that's the thing too I think you know you taught you made an interesting point about like this kind of like glorification of violence for entertainment and I do think I mean I I feel like I realize when so when I went through my grad program it kind of felt like so I did my grad graduate work in marriage and family therapy and like there's so much work that you have to do just as part of your coursework as on top of like mandated number of sessions yourself like to be able to do and they're telling us you can only help someone as you can only take someone as deep or heal someone as as as deeply as you have dealt with your own stuff and I'm like okay so we better get to work and so you know there's just like a lot of like introspective papers and things like that and I I just remember it feeling like someone had sandpapered my skin off like every time I was trying to watch anything like it's like everything hurt like I felt everything and it was like it just and it kind of I think we should I mean to some degree like you know like these things should bother us like that's I think that's the problem is like there's so much that's become spectacle and news and headlines and things and it's like it's just noise now it's just the way it always is there's just always something bad happening there's always something bad happening to someone else there's always some problem there's always some political thing there's always some something and it's so easy to just like tune it out and not care and like I think it's just like this is like a good reminder to be like yeah but those are people like you know those were kids and those are people like and so it's just Katniss falls into that in that movie so she's up in the tree early on night one right and she's she's strapped up in that tree and that girl lights the district six tribute lights the fire and she is over there and Katniss I don't remember I get that I've read it and I've seen it so many times that sometimes I get details confused and so I'm sorry if I'm like overlapping too much but in her head Katniss is like I'm gonna kill this girl myself like you're you're exposing me and you're you're compromising my safety would it be better if I just got out of this tree and did it myself so that's part one of what you're talking about is like just even being so desensitized but you know she gets a bit of an out because she's in the games of course right but then the careers go and attack that girl and they're then under the tree and they realize the cannon hasn't fired and the thing that people don't really talk about and maybe this speaks to your point about how sometimes violence can sort of get overlooked even if we want to call it like an act of mercy Peeta's like I'll take care of it and Peeta goes back and kills that girl and and then he comes back to the group like but Peeta goes and does that and so often it's not it's always talked about this idea that Katniss only kills out of self-defense and sometimes that's like one of the criticisms is like we're gonna we're really glamorizing Katniss and making her a hero in spaces where it's almost easier to be a hero because you never really have to do anything bad right like all of her killings are sort of okay yeah yeah all of her killings are always framed as being this acceptable thing in context but then you look at what you know Peeta did to that girl and there's never any clarifying they never talk about it there's like never any clarification on what happened there but he definitely did it and maybe that's kind of going towards this side you know even we watched the movie and it's like are we gonna just overlook what Peeta just did not that we need to judge him for it necessarily but people don't ever talk about that part well yeah I think that's interesting too though it is interesting that of the things that Peeta of the violence that Peeta inflicts it's one where like you said kind of like a mercy killing of like she's not maybe that's what we like to assume we mean I mean I I would assume based on the way it kind of was going like you know and like the canon hasn't gone off and they're like realizing it like we we thought we all but killed her you know I mean like and it seems like we didn't finish the job like kind of thing and so I mean everything about his choices and character makes me think that that's what what his decision would be like if we're thinking about like he's not the violent one in any of this for the most part he's kind of the political one trying to survive in that way but it's just very but yeah to even have to be able to like because I mean what was his choice like not do that and then what what they might do to her like or you know what might happen or if she has to sit out or get eaten by those mutts or something you know what I mean like and that is the question right is when it comes down to it the question PETA probably has to ask himself is who what am I willing to do to make sure Katniss lives and if it comes down to taking the life of this district six-year-old not even to protect himself so he can then carry on because like she's a threat but he needs to protect the ruse that he has created with these careers that he has managed to infiltrate that he knows he's on thin ice with but he also knows that they are hunting her and he is a key to it because he is so damn smart at least in the gameplay within context he recognizes that he can take a bit of power he can do he can do something with that life that you know I don't want this to all be for nothing and so he can actually do something with it but yeah he kills her that that that feels like survival is no one yeah there's no no one gets out clean no of these really I mean and that's the whole thing is like now you are also complicit like you you are yes you won you can't talk about how bad it was and what we did to you because you also participated in it and like and also you like you said earlier you need us for your food and those kinds of things but like I like looking back and like this the way that this ends now though like it was always good but like I think there's something just like personally a little bit sweeter for me of like this girl out like thinking this like whole system of like at the end of like you thought you were smarter than me but I just think I think so much differently than you like you couldn't see me coming like this like it's a pretty fragile system it's a couple of berries can take it out yeah no but that's the thing like there's like not like the thing I think is just like underestimating people like you know like and not thinking not even realizing that like thinking that your way of viewing this whole system that you've built is the only way of viewing it and like not really like recognizing what they might be seeing or interpreting or using or their motivations might be at all like I think it's just so it's like hubris like that is the downfall of this particular game it's just like they didn't see that what if they decide to kill themselves like you know like what if everybody just decided I mean they could have berries or not they could have decided to do that like so so what you bring up is a good point that's like you want to say they wouldn't play but like tributes aren't the only thing they can kill tributes in the arenas so they'll they'll figure they'll find a way to get you like you're not gonna out you're not gonna just outlive it in the bell rings and they're like live in the arena now like this is my home like that's my home in this in the sweet cave yeah right like that's not yeah no that's interesting your point about like this the self-preservation because I do think that is such a we we like to think we're all evolved past it but we're not and and it's so that's that's the one way to get I feel like that we have been the most manipulated and like as a society right now is like to threaten our way of being and say we're the ones that have the answer for it or they're the ones that are threatening it and like that's why you should listen to us or you should do this or that and like you know like the things that people will do or believe when they feel like that like I like to say the bottom Jenga block of their little beliefs tower gets nudged a little bit too much you know like is like they'll do anything to keep that tower together you know like and so it's just you even you see that during these overthrows as this series starts to like continue to progress is I mean think of how many years that they went to that I think one of the most atrocious parts of the pageantry of The Hunger Games aside from the games itself is when they send the victors to all of the or the victor to all of the districts where like the kids have passed away and they put their families up on the pedestals and then they have to address them and people sat through that for 70 some years.
I mean obviously was this the first one that's what the fourth book tells us but for so many years and just just accepted it.
Like this is just the way that it is and like people are there's so many of them and they outnumber all of the people that are enforcing this on them but they still don't do anything and they almost don't recognize their own self-sufficiency in this text or in this film or anywhere right like you if you get rid of them and you take this thing over you could manage just fine but the problem is again more weapons like sure you survive but those bomb you out and ultimately that's what happens to 12 yeah it's it is crazy I think you're bringing up a good point though about the like agency kind of piece like I think people forget that they have it like you know in a lot of ways like I think I think they never knew they did they've never had it you know that's not that's not even anything they've lost yeah it is how it is how it is of yeah how it is but like to Gail's point what if no one watched like what if we just like you know like they're not in our houses turning on our televisions like you know like what if none of us watched like and like you know then they would have to escalate and then it would be more clear that it was more of about oppression and not pageantry and not like voluntary watching this thing you know that kind of thing. I think it's just I think there's a lot of go along just like because we always have and I think Katniss has had to have agency over everything so much that she realizes how much she has kind of in opposition to things as well. Like she's like everything's come down to her good or bad like to solve in a way and so she recognizes I think in a little bit of a way her own ability to affect her environment in certain ways more than other people have. And I think that's the trick here with her is like knowing that there's the choices she can always make they're you know good or bad, but she can still make them. And I think this is like heavy, heavy.
What do we want to talk about in the actual like portrayal of the games themselves? Because I think that that's where people really sign up for this movie and I think people really remember it. Yes, the 12th stuff is interesting. The capital is her crossing over as we look at like, well, that hero's journey and we start to circle through it. Or even if you want to compare it maybe more appropriately to like allegory of the cave and these new sorts of understandings. But I don't know. Did you have any notes on the games themselves? I'm trying to see what I have here.
They trouble me so I don't have a time to go.
Yeah, I think that's fair because they're brutal. I mean by design and movies only is PG-13.
Yeah, no.
Think of what is restrained there.
Yeah.
I mean, I think you make it. I don't think you can make it anymore with kids and nor should you. That's not a thing I'm politicking for. But the games themselves, like the gifts and maybe the sponsorships when we talk about thematic takeaways and like, you know, that's that's Haymitch and Katniss character development and their relationship where they start to see how similar they are and they can communicate in those ways.
Yeah.
Which again, also feels a little bit like really wild technology. And the magical medicine that just like heals.
Yeah, that just heals everything.
The two, the bone burns and like, Yeah. But in that cut in his leg, for instance, Yeah. is so deep that it talks like she can see bone is what it says in the book. And so obviously they can't show that. But let's assume that's the case. And then it's like, no, here's some soup and like, like.
Stuff. Yeah. Some stuff. Yeah.
Here's some witchcraft and then it's just better. It's like, man.
Yeah. And then think of that. And if that's the case.
The most luxury they've ever experienced is in the games. That's their best access to medicine and to like some of the best. She talks about that lamb stew, which I guess she gets on the train, but then also in the games again. Like, that's the best she's eaten. That's better than she's ever eaten at home.
Yeah. I think it's so everything's so artificial. And so like you said, so advanced and so crazy. I think it's too like, it's one thing I find interesting is though, like they built these games for everyone to be out for blood. But like, they, it's like they didn't count on, it's like they forgot they were people too. You know, like they forgot that like they could make friends. They could, not just alliances, friends. And like that could have an impact on how this is gonna work for us visually and story wise and that kind of thing. Like, she's getting to be too likable. Like, you gave her too high of a score. Like, you know, those kinds of things. Like, that whole concept that...
Plutarch moving all those pieces too, right? Like, you see the power that he holds in starting this thing that can't be stopped. That portrayal of him, I think is excellent. That's Philip Seymour Hoffman, right? And the way that he's sort of like moving all of these pieces around and you don't really learn his impact until later on in that film series. But you know, he's moving these pieces around. And then, like you said, the portrayal... You have a Katniss befriending a Rue because she has that maternal sisterly protective instinct that she's already established with Prim. You have Thresh demonstrating honor and demonstrating... I don't want to say grace, but like gratefulness in a space where he very much does not. He has a chance to... I... You... If you have Thresh kill Katniss in that moment, I think Thresh, aside from getting past Cato, almost cakewalks to victory, like Kloves already out. But he does it anyway because he knows it's right. Like these are... They're so humanized in the very few moments that we see them as being like they're just kids. To me, the best pivot, the worst pivot the movie makes as it moves away from the text is that Peta does not lose his leg. And that is silly in the second movie. And like that is such an important point. But I think the best move is giving Cato lines at the top of that cornucopia at the end. Because he doesn't have those in the text. Those don't exist there. And in the power of that, where it's later on echoed. But this, remember who the real enemy is. And you have Cato standing up there just announcing like, this is all we are, isn't it? Like this is what they want. This is what I am supposed to do. And he even then, as he has a very good shot of becoming a victor, is immediately seeing the hollowness of it too. And when we think of the message being put out there about, like we've talked about with agency, with rebellion, with recognizing the power that you have and the rules that maybe people are forcing upon you, like those Cato lines are really strong.
Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I know for sure. It's almost like they didn't, like you talked about the cornucopia moment making everything real and like not, maybe almost not even fully realizing the concept of death until they're there. Like my whole, my parents put me in an academy to train me for my death. Yes. Like the people that are-
And that's the book. That's the book and that's the movie that I, we need a career. If we're gonna, I didn't need Haymitch's story. I need the career one is the compelling story that is not told yet. We just don't like- Or like it's, what's always been unclear is like, is Finick a career?
Yeah, it's not totally clear. Or is he just like really good?
Yeah. And just like young and like just this anomaly of a person, just like Katniss was really. But the career book and the motivation in class, we talk about the careers a lot and being pushed towards these things. And my students, when we talk about parallels, they immediately are like, man, softball dads are the type of guys that would train or would put their kids in these academies. Like that personality would very much still exist.
Yeah, it's yeah. I think that's the whole, yeah, that performance, whatever it looks like, whatever appearances looks like, it shows up somewhere. And I think, yeah, but then like by the end of that, you know, you're talking about Cato's lines, like it's all stripped down and it's like the reality of like, I have like this one or two choices and there's like one or two outcomes here. And my whole life has led to these one or two outcomes and they all suck.
And as a viewer, as a viewer, it's the moment where if you hadn't caught on to it already, there's the recognition that like Cato isn't the bad guy.
No, yeah.
He wasn't the bad guy. He was threatened.
He didn't ask to get put in here.
He was threatened. Well, right. He didn't ask to be put into a world where he like got manipulated into thinking this was a good idea. But he wasn't ever the bad guy. He was just the most threatening and the most, he was just the most fooled.
He was just the most prepared.
Yeah. He was, he fell for it so hard that that moment of clarity even there at the end makes him tragic in a way where that, you know, the tragedy is only expressed in the text when he falls off. And then, you know, she has to, she has to ultimately like mercy kill him with those, with the arrow. But because they make her, because they make her, the game makers make her do.
Yeah. It's, yeah.
And we get those berries at the end.
Yeah. It's, yeah. I think it's just, it's very interesting. And I think there's a lot of, I think it's, yeah, I mean, Peeta has the political, like you were talking about, like, he's kind of got this smoothness and this, this social intelligence that like, kind of couldn't happen. Like, Katniss couldn't have happened without that. Like, she couldn't have gotten there. But like, but at the same time, there was something about her. It may not have gone, it wouldn't have gone unnoticed. It may not have gone as far without him.
It's a testimony to the power of rhetoric, even when rhetoric is accidental. Like, you have Peeta who very much recognizes a capital audience's values, needs and beliefs. And he appeals to them. And he appeals them over and over again with a series of decisions that moves them towards an understanding, that moves them towards feeling sympathy and feeling charitable and keeping them alive and wanting to celebrate them. Katniss doesn't make those choices, but ends up being even more effective. Like rhetoric doesn't have to be this like mastermind thing. What if you just being you happens to be the thing that appeals in some sort of dynamic, very much previously unperformed way. There hasn't been a Katniss before. And they make her, you said it, they make her seem kind of dumb. And they kind of dress her up in this big dress and she spins around. She's like, oh my God, I'm so dizzy.
And trying to make her like a frilly little girl kind of thing. And that's just so not her. Like it's, yeah. It's like, I thought about this too. Like the way she kind of reacts in the movie to like the idea of having to put on a dress. I'm like, what's worse? I have to go maybe die today or I have to put on a dress. It's kind of the vibe a little bit. Like, and it's like so that that character's personality. I think it's just like she's reacting almost as strongly to that as she is at the prospect of what they have to go do that day.
Well, and she is so, so early on, you know, the transformation with her is that she very early as she's accepted her death. Once she volunteers, once she sees her mom, she's telling everybody how to take care of them. And Gail's trying to say, you could win this. And she's like, just shut up and take care of my mom. And then she starts to move towards believing it. But until she does, she can focus on, like, the inconvenience of being a tribute and, like, having to get her legs waxed and, like, how much that hurts and, like, being annoyed by the design, the styling team and, like, how preposterous they are until she finally starts to believe it. And then those things start to fall by the wayside and she starts playing this game before it even starts. You know, when she's in the, what do they call it, the training sessions and she starts, it's such a well-done look at what personal understanding can lead to once you recognize the power you might be able to hold in a given situation. Might be able to. Like, what happens if I try in these ways?
What could occur? Yeah. I think you said something interesting too, though, earlier, kind of back to Katniss, showing up as Katniss. Like, I think everything about this whole universe is so, it's so contrived. It's so forced. It's so pageantry. It's so survival. Like, it's so shaded in whatever it needs to be for a very particular reason or purpose that she shows up kind of like in obstinance to all of that. Not even purposefully, but just like she just is. Her existence is just that way. She's authentically incapable of being anything but herself. And that resonates so deeply.
And it's so, it's so natural. You know, if you go and you look at how many of those tributes names she actually learns, it's not even, it's like a third. She barely even knows their names, right? She has, she has no idea. Once she just calls Foxbase, I'm like, we're good there. Like that's enough. And I think that is an excellent thing. I believe in that situation, you come up with these names for people and you're just gonna stick to them.
Just mental associations, yeah.
You look at Haymitch in Book 5, every tribute's name. Every single tribute's name is in that book. Every one of them is named. Because he's paying more attention, because he's looking at it in a different way, because he is different. And you know, Katniss' perspective isn't this accidental, this thing that's just portrayed by happenstance. Like that might actually be part of her strength, is just being so singularly focused.
Yeah. I think it really is in her particular case. And I think too, like a... Yeah, I think there's some different things there. And like, I think she just hasn't had the... Like almost the... It sounds like this is gonna sound a little bad. But almost the privilege of developing a personality. Like a little bit...
That she has not had the privilege? Is that what you said?
Yeah, she has not had the privilege of developing a personality. Because like, she's... She's eldest daughtering to the max. Like in a world of like... I mean, she is just... You don't have... And it's something like I didn't really realize until I was older. But like, you don't have the time to be fun and be entertaining to everyone and be like, you know, like having a good time and be the fun one when you're worried about like keeping it together. You're keeping everything held down. And she's very much like doing that in every room that she's in. So she has not really, she hasn't socialed at all. Like she has not...
Think, I don't think I've taught this ever, where a student has him pointed out. And one student put it best. So maybe I'll just quote her. But they said, it's not that Katniss has very low emotional intelligence, it's that it's somehow absent. Like this idea, like this, this, she's like you said, she's never had the privilege of caring about these things or understanding her feelings for Gayle necessarily and what those look like, or having any aspirations aside from like, if you're Katniss Everdeen, you have already achieved the thing that you would have as a goal, which is a sustainable way to feed your family until they like naturally die. She's already hit the apex in District 12. Like this is, what goal is there? And so anything else would potentially then compromise it, you know, even though she's starting to get to that point with Gail, but she's 17 years old and like, she doesn't understand how she feels about Peeta. It doesn't, it doesn't even, she doesn't get it, you know.
Yeah. No, she just has not had any...
I love the way you said that. She hasn't had the privilege to do that.
Yeah. I mean, she just has, like, it's just this like, this like overriding, like sense of duty that's just like at the forefront at all times, this like survival mode that she just has, it's just superseding everything. And so I think that's, that's why her character is the way she is. And I think that, like you said, it's kind of her superpower of like, being so completely unique in that way of like, you said something and it was interesting to me. So there's like two ways of winning, kind of. It feels like there's, there's rhetoric. You were talking about like, like Peeta's way of rhetoric, which is like, yes, the really intelligent, really deliberate, really intentional, very intentional. And then there's the, and that resonates because you're worried about what resonates with those people and you're focusing on it. And you're thinking about all their individual particularities and their, their specific situation. But then there's Katniss', which is just base humanity at its fullest display, that just kind of cuts through all of it in a way. It's like...
That cuts through all of it in a way that appeals because within that, so now we're like going into rhetoric class, but like within that rhetorical situation, when you then consider the different factors of that context, she is from District 12, and she is female, and Peeta has set her up to be somebody who is loved. And so, Peeta, she like inherits this ethos from Peeta, whether she wants to or not. She can't get over, and they like her before, because of how authentically she, you know, she achieves pathos with them. The second that she volunteered for her sister, in a place where they don't do that, and in a way where people don't volunteer for others, they volunteer for themselves. So now she's like way different, right? Like the kind of thing that people might like to think that they would do for their siblings, but she actually does it. And so Peeta then, by saying that he loves her, and they become the star-crossed lovers of District 12, Peeta now set her up as like whatever she does, they like him, he desires her, and so she takes in some of that likeability too. It's so... These books, I keep saying books, this story is so well done. It's like that element, I buy it. I buy that the capital buys them.
I think it's interesting though, like you did say though, she volunteered and that was already resonating before Peeta ever hit anything else. So like even before without that, like I said, it probably wouldn't have gone as far, it wouldn't have gone the exact way that it went, but like there was something about her showing up as her, like that was cutting through the noise immediately and already like putting her on people's radar in a way that just was like... And I think that's just like really interesting to think about like...
Well yeah, and just to, you know, there's a strength and a softness and she established her strength, she cannot establish her own softness. So we might like her, but we're afraid of her and that... Oh, that's another thing we can talk about. But we might like her, but we're kind of afraid of her and then you bring in Peeta, charming, thoughtful Peeta and Peeta can then add that dimension to her that is like constantly reinforced. She can not add to herself. Have you seen the TikToks? I can't... God, what is their name? The username is Banshee and they talk. It's like this five minute video about like, have you ever considered how absolutely terrifying Katniss Everdeen is to the other tributes? You know, that she volunteers and then she like, she shows off these arrow skills, but she doesn't talk to anybody except the little kids. And just like, the way that she operates, if you are viewing her as another tribute in both, then she sets herself on fire. And then she acts like a girl, you know, like this young, very stereotypical young woman, just spinning around and being like, Oh, look at me.
After they saw her with that arrow.
Yeah. How like, how terrifying. And then she goes into it. Yeah. And the whole, I don't know, just the write up or like the way it was spoken in that post, I thought was fascinating because that I've never considered that. They must be horrified. Of course, they're hunting her. It's not a vendetta. They need, they need to get to her while they have the numbers.
Yeah, they need to get to her before she gets to them because she's erratic at best.
And she doesn't even have the bow and arrow. Glimmer has it. And so.
Crazy. Yeah. This movie is, yeah, I think like, I guess like, it's like, I think what's fascinating to me is these stories of rebellion and how many people, my goal is to help people do this, but it's mind blowing to me at the levels at which people sometimes cannot connect through lines of parallels of stories that they love and what's happening in the world sometimes. And that blows my mind as someone who just has always done that. And I try, I think what I try to do here is I'm like, if you only are able to even connect with just the parallels that we make and draw on this conversation, then great, then you've gotten something from it. But like, hopefully you learn to see, you know, things in things you watch outside of these episodes a little bit more. And I've had a few people talk to me about that they have started looking at things differently. But like, I think that there's just so much to be gleaned from this source material about like, you know, what is right and like what, you know, treating other people as humans and like, what propaganda can tell us and how can other people and make us okay with things that shouldn't be okay. And just like, I think it's just, it's a really, it's more relevant than I would like it to be. But like, it's, it's really, yeah.
As somebody who's taught now for two decades, I think my biggest takeaway from a book like this is that it is so important for us to have some kind of text or some kind of source material that fosters all of these different conversations. And so I don't have necessarily like a specific takeaway that I value maybe over other takeaways from The Hunger Games. But you put this text in front of a kid in the same way that I go pick up my daughters from elementary school and you'd see a fifth grader walking down the stairs and she's reading The Hunger Games. And I know right now she's thinking like, bow and arrows, cool. Like, yeah, like Gail has gray eyes, man, I hope she wins because this is a really interesting, dangerous story. And this seems fun. But then, you know, you get into a high school space and now whatever's, and this speaks to the sadness that you seem to be feeling. And I agree with you, is contextually, there's been something to talk about with this book, not just in 2026, but when I started teaching this class in 2018, we had things that we can talk about. But what's valuable is that this is a text that I know that I can, that I can speak on and have any conversation that is in front of me. If I can then have a book like this or a film like this in front of students, and we can have those conversations. Because knowing that text and the more of these conversations that I have, the more that I think those... And so then they can go and watch Catching Fire now, because if they're watching Catching Fire, they're going to watch Hunger Games. And now we can talk about these things. But we're not talking about how cool or crazy it is. That's not the conversation. We're not talking about how good it is. We're talking about how bad everything it's about is. And that is so meaningful.
I think that's huge too. And I think that's what's part of the benefit of writing and art in general. I think it's just that we are able to continue to have a medium for conversation, to bring conversations and thoughts up to people before they are needing to, you know, like for the rubber meets the road kind of so to speak. Like you're giving them some framework to hang some values on. And just like teaching is a hard job. My mom was a teacher. And so like, I just appreciate so much that people like you are trying to do it thoughtfully and trying to, you know, like teach these kids like, yes, English rhetoric, whatever, but like also just like, hey, good humaning is mixed in there a little bit, you know, and like, that's so important. And so thanks for taking the time to talk about this. And like also just like what you do in general, like seriously, it's so cool that it's encouraging to me as a human being to know that there are people like you out there talking to the next generation of kids about these kinds of things. So yeah.
You might make a guy cry. Like I really like my job. I love it. That's awesome. I love it so much that I've, you know, that I've started to then do my job after work on the internet for people, because I not only love it, because I love, it's the kids. And like, I've always loved that part of it. But I also really believe in these things that I teach. And so, yes, I make my posts about rhetoric, but like young adult literature is like, that's my bread and butter. I mean, that's, I don't, I just don't want to be a book talk guy. It's really what it comes down to. And so I don't, and so like, I just don't make those posts. But being able to present these ideas and have spaces like this, where like people want to talk about it. That like we can have this conversation is so important. And I hope these films continue to reach their audiences. And I hope that a sixth book gives us a career insight, because that.
That would be cool.
If there's a career book, the thing I'm going to then push is read The Hunger Games when we read The Hunger Games. But then afterwards, jump straight ahead and watch the career movie. Because you know what's going to come out. And like, and then that's going to be the move, because I think it's that dynamic where it's like, it is so easy for us, maybe this is my takeaway. It is so easy for us to look at other people who are on our level and within the same station as being the enemy, as being like the problem, as being the villain. And maybe we're looking inside a fishbowl a little bit too much. You know, we made a whole Hunger Games podcast here, and we didn't even talk about Peeta as a rock.
Well, you know, it was a little... It was one of those, one of those situations where...
I'm proud of us.
Yeah, that was weird. That moment, yeah.
With him as the rock or me bringing it up?
No, him, him as the rock. It was just like, what in the world is like, literally, what are we doing right now? Like, what are we doing? That's kind of my feeling that.
The enduring impact of the film, I think is Jennifer Lawrence, you know, I volunteer as tribute. I think that, I think the scene with her and Rue, as Rue passes away is the enduring moment there. But then that damn rock just like never will go away.
Friggin rock, man.
Friggin rock. The damn rock. Thank you so much for having me. This is really meaningful.
I'm glad. I appreciate you being on. Like this is seriously fun. Maybe we can do it again sometime.