Are you curious about the “three buckets of money” strategy? Join Matt Meline as he demystifies this approach in our latest episode. Imagine having three buckets: one for emergencies, another for middle lifestyle goals, and a third for long-term growth. Matt breaks down the benefits - from risk management to effective goal achievement. And don’t worry, he’ll spill the beans on mixing investments (think stocks and bonds) to create a sturdy financial portfolio. Tune in and unlock the secrets to securing your prosperous future! Episode highlights: (1:30) Three buckets of money framework (4:54) The safety bucket (7:02) The middle lifestyle bucket (10:26) The aspirational long-term bucket (12:39) Dangers (13:38) Importance of personalized investment strategies (15:35) Outro and disclaimer - I sincerely appreciate your support. Thank you for being a part of our podcast journey. If you haven't already, please subscribe to stay updated with the latest episodes. Your subscription means the world to me! Want to dive deeper into the 59½ Rebellion? Check out our 59½ Rebellion playlist on YouTube for more conversations, insights, and practical guidance on making the most of the years leading up to retirement. I’d love to hear from you; here are some ways to connect: Web: https://www.prairiefirewealth.com/ Email: info@pfwplanning.com Get a copy of my book: Empty Nest, Full Pockets: How to Emotionally and Financially Prepare for Your Family’s Future at https://amzn.to/3PovUWM
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01So when you see it go down, because the markets will inevitably go down, there's no need to panic. This isn't money that we need today. And even when it goes down dramatically, like it did in 2008, if the buckets were built right, you can allow this to work itself back up. And if you've done that, obviously you've been rewarded finely since that time.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Prairie Fire Podcast, where we will adventurously explore the financial and emotional issues of life's second half. Join Matt Malin, CEO and founder of Prairie Fire Wealth Planning, and author of Empty Nest Full Pockets, as we discuss paying for college, empty nesting, navigating our careers, caring for our aging parents, dealing with taxes, and getting ready for an epic retirement. We will share ideas, special guests, and a boatload of fun to what we believe can be one of the greatest chapters in your life.
SPEAKER_00A Prairie Fire does the necessary work of burning away the old to make room for the new. We are ready to make that concept a reality for your financial future. So grab a cup of coffee or a glass of wine and gear up for some exciting conversations on the Prairie Fire Podcast.
SPEAKER_01Three buckets of money. It doesn't sound very funny. Money needs a wallet, man, not a pail. Let's get into this and bring a hammer to this nail. Hey, welcome to the Prairie Fire Podcast, where we exist to fuse money and meaning. We want to bring real life ideas to help everyone out there have an amazing and profitable second half of life. So for years I've been promoting the idea with our clients that they should have three buckets of money. All right, so when I say that, what does that mean?
SPEAKER_01What do you mean, buckets of money? So, what this came from is a white paper that I read years ago called Beyond Markovitz. And so better hold it up here. What this white paper explained was how modern portfolio theory, or kind of the basics of investing as it was being understood in the late 50s and on, was really designed for institutional investors. And a lot of the philosophies that came from that theory, from modern portfolio theory, were just very, very difficult to apply in real life.
SPEAKER_01And so if you think about having three buckets of money, you know, the whole thing kind of makes sense where we maybe have some safe money, we have some stuff that's growing in the middle, and then we have a longer term, you know, kind of retirement bucket for later in life. And if you think about it, there are a ton of advantages to that. There's some tax efficiencies, you've got the proper risk in the right bucket, you're avoiding some of the whims of the stock market and all those ups and downs. And so what I really like to do today is explain the three buckets in detail, um, why they're important, why we should also expand outside and beyond the bucket.
SPEAKER_01When we're putting together investment mixes, we can think of it in terms of like salsa. So if you're making salsa at home, you know you're gonna need tomatoes and peppers and onions and all the different things that go into that. All the seasoning and spiciness can be uh added at your whim as to the amount that you like. And so when we think of putting investments together, we think about putting things like stocks together with bonds and with different types of other investments like gold that might offset the risk of those other ones. So what we're trying to do is by mixing up these ingredients, we're hoping for a steadier ride over time so that we're not taking big risks in one area.
SPEAKER_01If you make salsa and you just put jalapenos in it, no one's going to eat it. Because all you've really got there is jalapenos. It's not salsa. So what you're gonna do though is if you love jalapenos, you can put a lot more in there for your salsa, but you're also gonna add some tomatoes, other things, mix, mix it up, that kind of thing. And so taking big risk in the near term can cause a lot of disaster. And so when we're talking about the three buckets, a lot of it has to do with timing and a lot of it has to do with goals because modern investing models, modern investing recommendations, in my opinion, forget the most important ingredient, which is people.
SPEAKER_01If people were rational, we would never have movies, man. I mean, there has to be no interest or drama. So think about this. If people were rational, Rocky Balboa would never have agreed to fight Apollo Creed. And then he never would have agreed to fight uh Kleber Lang in Rocky III, and he definitely wouldn't have agreed to fight Yvonne Drago in Rocky IV. So I prove my point. People are not rational. And thank God, because if they were, we wouldn't have any great movies like that. You know, movies like The Hangover.
SPEAKER_01If uh people are gonna be rational, they wouldn't leave their friend on the roof when they're in Las Vegas, but it happens. So my point is we need three buckets of money because it's the foundation of a good goals-based investing program. And so what I'm hoping to do today is first explain the buckets. I'm gonna discuss the mix that you can put inside of each bucket and then explore when it works well and when maybe it falls short. So the first bucket I want to talk about is the safety bucket. So the safety bucket probably seems relatively obvious. What we want to put in there are assets or investments that are very, very safe.
SPEAKER_01We also want them to be available. We use that the word liquidity in my world, but what that means is that basically those investments are liquid, like water, that we can get a hold of them if we need them. So your safety bucket is designed for the unexpected in life. This could be jobs being uh eliminated. This could mean kids getting sick. This could mean cars breaking down. This could mean parents needing help. This could mean friends needing help. Whatever the case may be, your safety bucket is there to back you up, to protect you in the event that life comes along.
SPEAKER_01And by God, life always comes along in some way, shape, or form. So this bucket is generally made up of cash, savings accounts, maybe short-term certificates of deposit, maybe shorter-term treasury bills, those types of investments go into that safety bucket. It's important that you're able to get to this bucket if there is an emergency. So whether that be a bank account and you've got access via a debit card where you can write checks, whatever the case may be, that safety bucket needs to be not only safe in its investing mix, but available for you to grab a hold of and to get a hold of if you needed it.
SPEAKER_01And so the amount that you need to have in your safety bucket varies by every person. Some people say three to six months of income should be in your safety bucket. In my opinion, it depends on how dangerous your life is. How many risks do you have that you're facing? So if you're like my wife and I, we're empty nesters, the kids are out of the house. I don't have the risk of them likely needing me in a significant way financially. Now, don't get me wrong. They'll still come along for the occasional, how about if we but dad buys us dinner kind of thing? But the longer term, he has to pay my rent, got to take care of college, those kind of days are over for us.
SPEAKER_01Now, if you have young kids, the opposite is true. You've got day tare expense, you've got all the transportation that goes with the kids, if they get sick, all of those different matters are front and center in your life. So maybe your safety bucket needs to be a little larger because you have a lot more near-term risks. Okay, so bucket one, safety bucket. Let's move on to the second, which I call the middle of your lifestyle bucket. And this is one that I when I meet with folks, I they tend to not have a lot in this bucket or have anything even really started in this bucket.
SPEAKER_01And so the difference here is that these are monies that you would ideally use sometime over maybe the next three to 15 years, depending on where you're at in life. So if you're in your 40s or 50s, you want to be thinking maybe three to 10 years. If you're younger than that, you could build out that time frame a little bit further, older, maybe a little bit tighter on your timeframe. But this middle bucket is designed to allow you to reach some goals. So, really, when we're talking about goals-based planning, goals-based wealth, goals-based wealth management, man, that is a mouthful.
SPEAKER_01We want to think about this bucket as something that we maybe want to attach a goal to. So perhaps you want a second home in Florida. Perhaps you really want to really pay off your house in 10 years and you want to save for that along the way versus just paying it down incrementally. College is a good uh example of a middle lifestyle bucket need. A lot of folks, they use this bucket to help acquire some assets to buy a car with cash instead of having to borrow to do that. So things that where you would prefer to have some assets to use rather than borrowing, or things that you've got really attached as a lifestyle goal that you want to achieve.
SPEAKER_01Or if there's just something you really want, you know, to acquire down the road that you've set up as a lifestyle goal or something that you really want for your plan, great. This goes in that bucket. Doesn't have to be something that you want to buy. It doesn't actually have to be something that you actually know what you want to do with, but this is a great area to build up these middle dollars that you have for much more flexibility in your plan to do extra things, things that you might want to do down the road. Maybe you really, really want to travel when you're an empty investor or an early retiree.
SPEAKER_01This is a bucket you can really build up so that you've got a big chunk each year you can then take out for those travels and for those trips. So inside of this bucket, we can actually add a little risk. So we're the safety bucket, we're taking virtually no risk. Maybe the only risk is just the time that CDs have to expire or treasury bills. With the middle and lifestyle bucket, we can begin to add things like bonds. We can begin to add things like stocks in a prudent manner that will give us some growth over time. Because we've got more time, we can then withstand the volatility, the ups and downs that inevitably come with the markets.
SPEAKER_01So if you're invested in a middle bucket in 2022, you saw both your bonds and your stocks come down in value. If you held on, you probably saw them seen those recover now nicely in 23 and 24. So what you didn't want to happen is that you need your lifestyle bucket in a significant way in 2022. So the idea here is that we want to be able to invest for a little bit longer period of time, knowing that we've got a kind of a time frame here where we can let this work. So middle lifestyle bucket tends to be in kind of a joint taxable account where you can get access to it just like you can in your safety bucket, but maybe it's in stocks, those kind of things.
SPEAKER_01In that taxable bucket, you don't have the stipulations of Roth rules, individual retirement account rules, those kind of things. You will pay some taxes along the way if you have capital gains and those kind of things. But if you have a good investment manager, they should be watching the tax efficiency of this bucket for you. All right. So safety bucket and lifestyle bucket are our first two. Uh the aspirational long-term bucket is the next. And so when we get into this, we're talking more about definitely your longer-term monies. And so this would be things that many of us would think of in terms of maybe 401k plans, individual retirement accounts, Roth IRAs, Roth 401ks, private investments, alternative investments, things that are designed for maybe that for 10 plus years, once again, depending on your situation.
SPEAKER_01But the idea here is we want this money to grow. We want this money to support and grow above inflation so that we can use it to support our lifestyle when we need it down the road. And so for many of us, if we retire at 65, you could very easily be retired for 35 years. So this aspirational money has to grow to support that lifestyle over time. And so this is an area where we can become more aggressive. We're still going to be making our salsa with a lot of different mixtures and a lot of different components, but we're going to be much more focused on growth here. And this will be primarily through the stock market or some other alternative investments.
SPEAKER_01And so when we build this bucket for clients, we always let them know this is your aspirational long-term bucket. So when you see it go down, because the markets will inevitably go down, there's no need to panic. This isn't money that we need today. And even when it goes down dramatically, like it did in 2008, if the buckets were built right, you can allow this to work itself back up. And if you've done that, obviously you've been rewarded finely since that time. So the aspirational long-term bucket is designed to help you meet the lifestyle needs of what are becoming longer and longer lifestyles.
SPEAKER_01And so there's definitely the ability for our buckets to spill over, to help each other out. And so what I hate to see is frequently we'll meet someone that has, say, a 401k account, but they don't have any safety bucket. They have an emergency where their child is sick, they have to take the money out, and all of a sudden they're paying undue penalties. So each of these buckets have their own tax stipulations. And we'll do a future podcast just on tax planning in the three buckets. But for now, just know if you're in those 401k plans, those longer-term aspirational buckets, they give you some tax advantage, but they will penalize you if you try to break the rules.
SPEAKER_01And so understanding what you have in each bucket and knowing that you may need to spill some over from time to time to help the other bucket is important. But what you don't want to have to do is pull your aspirational long-term money out to meet a short-term safety need because we weren't doing planning up front. The other danger to the three bucket rule is putting a benchmark to it. And when I say a benchmark, I mean some sort of index that you're measuring the bench the uh bucket against. So comparing the safety bucket to the stock market doesn't make any sense because that's designed as a short-term safe bucket.
SPEAKER_01Now, comparing your longer-term bucket to the stock market might make some more sense, but you also want to look at global diversification and lots of other different components to this. So just because you hear the SP is going up or you hear NVIDIA is going through the roof, doesn't mean that's what you should be benchmarking your buckets to, because these are specific to you. And so specific to your goal, your safety goal, your lifestyle goal, your aspirational goal. So putting them up to a benchmark doesn't make any sense and can make you be irrational if all you want is that benchmark, because that's not what we're going for here.
SPEAKER_01And more and more we like the three bucket rule because investing and retirement planning are now up to us. Many of us are not getting pensions any longer. And so putting money into 401ks, doing things longer term on our own, saving aggressively while we're still working, is that onus is on us now. And so while that's going on, having a good philosophy like this can help you feel a lot safer as you're making those investments and feel like, all right, I'm really working towards something here. All right, no question that the bench, the uh the three bucket rule has got some shortfalls.
SPEAKER_01I'll be the first to admit it. There's folks that have concentrated their wealth like Warren Buffett in specific companies and really grown. We all know business owners that have done outstanding over time by putting all of their wealth in one bucket, which is their business. And so I'm not going to say that that can't happen. For many of us that are looking to build a balanced life or want to save over time, this can work great. For those that want to concentrate their wealth, but they have the personality of a strong risk taker, absolutely, they can overweight these buckets and make that work. But just understand when the bucket tips over, if there isn't some backup, everyone can benefit from some safety money, that kind of thing along the way.
SPEAKER_01So we feel like the three bucket rule is a great framework and foundation for a healthy financial plan. So I appreciate you listening in today. I will uh leave you with some information about how you can reach us if you want to learn more about the three buckets of money and how we operate with inside prairie firewealth planning to do that. If you also want to uh join our email list, it's info at PFW planning. I send out a weekly message and just information about markets, planning, all of this kind of fun stuff uh as you make the most of your second half of life.
SPEAKER_01Also, if you want to email us at the same address, we will send you a free copy of my book, Empty Nest Full Pockets, which talks about the emotional and financial wranglings of becoming an empty nester, getting your kids to launch, all that fun stuff, which we help four kids do. So, all right, I started with a rhyme today, I'm gonna finish with one. What is up with this guy and his awful rhymes? He can't help because he's busy taking care of his clients' dimes. Hang in there for more ideas and fun. Prairie Fire is a burning under the creative three bucket sun.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, everybody. Have a great one.
SPEAKER_00Thank you for being a part of the Prairie Fire Podcast. Please subscribe on your favorite platform so you're notified when we drop new episodes. Also, check us out at www.pfwplanning.com, where you can access all of our content and get a free copy of our book, Empty Nest, Full Pockets. Thanks again for joining in. And we'll catch you in the next episode.
SPEAKER_01Registered Representative of Sanctuary Securities Incorporated and Investment Advisor Representative Sanctuary Advisors LLC. Securities offered through Sanctuary Securities Inc. member of FINRA, SIPC. Advisory services offered through Sanctuary Advisors LLC and SCC Registered Investment Advisor. Prairie Fire Wealth Planning is a DBA of Sanctuary Securities and Sanctuary Advisors. This podcast is for informational purposes only. It is developed from sources believed to be accurate. No statements should be interpreted as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase of or sale of any security.
SPEAKER_01Information provided is not intended to be a substitute for specific individualized tax or legal advice. The views expressed herein are not necessarily representative of Sanctuary Securities Inc. or Sanctuary Advisors LLC and should not be construed as investment advice.
In this episode of Empty Nest Full Pockets, Matt Meline sits down with Rob and Debby to talk about what happens when one spouse retires while the other continues working. Debby retired first, while Rob, who runs his own...
In this second half of Julie’s retirement journey, she shares what life looks like after leaving a decades-long career behind - and why the reality has been even better than she expected. From joining a fitness...
In this episode of Empty Nest Full Pockets, Matt Meline sits down with Julie to hear the story of her transition from a decades-long career in real estate to retirement. After working since she was a teenager and...
In this episode of Empty Nest Full Pockets, Matt Meline and Will Schroeder tackle one of the most important questions you'll face once the paychecks stop coming: Where should your retirement income actually come from?...
In this episode of Empty Nest Full Pockets, Matt Meline and Will Schroeder explore how your investment strategy needs to evolve as you transition from working and saving to retirement and spending. Many people assume...