What happens when a Will is disputed? Can someone really be left out? And what happens if family members disagree over an estate? In this episode of Ellisons Connects, Solicitors Nicola Weldon and Kay Baker, Head of Private Client and Head of Contentious Trusts and Probate at Ellisons take a look at real questions and common scenarios around wills, inheritance and probate disputes, separating fact from fiction and explaining the legal position in clear, practical terms. Thank you for listening to Ellisons Connects. If you'd like to discuss anything further about any of the topics raised in this episode, or, if you simply want to speak to one of our experts, then please do not hesitate to get in touch via our website - https://ellisons.com/contact-us/ Ellisons is one of the oldest, most established and fastest growing law firms in the East of England having been founded over 250 years ago. As a full-service law firm, Ellisons offers a comprehensive range of services to businesses and individuals across the region and beyond. With a team of over 300 people, and offices located across Essex and Suffolk, alongside an office in London, Ellisons has a proven track record of providing clients with first class service and advice, enabling them to make the right decisions. Any information shared on this podcast was accurate at the time of recording, however, we advise speaking to your usual Ellisons advisor to make sure there hasn’t been any changes since. This podcast is the copyright of Ellisons.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to Ellison's Connects. I'm Kay Baker, I'm head of Contentious Trusts and Probate at Ellison's, and I'm here with Nicola Weldon, who's head of our private client department.
SPEAKER_01I don't know about you, Kay, but I often come across posts on social media to do with our area of law. There's a lot of misguided advice out there about wills and what happens when something goes wrong. In particular, not so long ago, I came across a post on Mum's Net which really grabbed my attention, and I just wanted to share that with you because I think there's a lot that we could unpick. Okay. So you're ready. It's quite a long post. So somebody has put, is it always impossible to contest a will in England? And they've gone on to say, I've been told I will not be inheriting and that my brother will be the sole beneficiary.
SPEAKER_01He has a good, very well-paid job, as does his wife, own their own home and are comfortable. Her mother has a large estate, so that means that brother will inherit a large amount. The person who's written the post says that they live in housing association accommodation. She has one child who's disabled and Sen, plus she has a physical disability which is progressive. She can only work part-time, so she's reliant on universal credit top-ups and will probably end up totally reliant on those benefits when her health deteriorates further.
SPEAKER_01She has said that I know England is difficult with this issue. Is there any chance a court would look at the situation and see that it's ref it's fair to reward me something? I've been told that I won't even be able to get a caveat before probate, as they won't tell me immediately on the death of my mother, so the assets will already have been given. My mother's very low contact with me, so I think they'll absolutely do this. Is there anything now I could do? Do I just have to accept that I will always struggle and my brother gets everything?
SPEAKER_01As a child, as my mother's carer, as she had alcohol and mental health issues, so I feel really used and cast aside. Mother is now 84, she's in poor health, and the only contact I get with her is her telling me how I won't get anything from her. So, like I say, okay, there's quite a lot to unpack in there.
SPEAKER_02Um there really is. Um I think also it's worth saying that some of the comments that we're going to go on to talk about are a bit judgmental, but of course, everyone gets to where they've got to in life as a result of all sorts of things, and this lady is where she is. Um, so there's no judgment in what we're about to say, or indeed in in what we're about to say about the law. Absolutely. Um the first thing I wanted to talk about was her question, is there anything I can do now? So this is while her mum's still alive.
SPEAKER_02Um there's some there are some things you you can do. I mean, one thing is it's um slightly controversial, but you could try to reinstate your relationship with your mum. Um, obviously, if you're estranged from someone, you're much less likely to be in their will. Um I know it's not as easy as saying let's all just be friends, but that is a you know a very practical thing you can do. Um if mum is uh lacking in capacity, yeah, um, you could talk to your brother.
SPEAKER_02Um the more communicating you can do with your family whilst the family members are alive, the better. If you can explain how you feel, um there's a possibility it can be put right. If mum lacks capacity and you have that conversation with your brother, you could potentially apply to the Court of Protection for a statutory will. So what's that? What's a statutory will? A statutory will is a will that the the Court of Protection approve to be signed on someone's behalf when they lack the capacity to make a will themselves.
SPEAKER_02So I imagine that's not very straightforward of a process. It's not very straightforward, and and obviously if you were to make the application without your brother's agreement, um, he's he's going to oppose it and they're going to look at mum's um wishes and feelings as so far as they were known before she lost capacity. Um so probably not a lot during lifetime in reality because you know people tend to be pretty entrenched in their positions, but there's just a few kind of real real practical things to try because communicating if everyone communicated well, I'd probably be out of a job.
SPEAKER_01I suppose the thing is that people don't have to share what's in their will, and they quite quite often don't, do they, until after they've passed away, and then it then becomes um well can become a public document, can't it, if somebody applies for probate. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, yeah. Um I just in terms of when we've been talking about technical terms and the court of protection, in um her post she's mentioned something about a caveat.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so um a caveat is a a block at the probate registry. So if some if if somebody dies and you know there's a problem as far as you're concerned with their will, so it's likely to be that you don't think that will is valid uh for some reason. You think there's a later will, um, we'll come onto why a will may be invalid. But if you've got a reason to believe the will isn't the will that should be going to probate, then you can apply to the probate registry for a caveat, which is a six-month block on anyone getting a grant of probate.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Thank you. Um so what I was gonna do, if you're okay, is I thought I'd just run through the comments that have been made on this blog on um Mum's Net because again, this is where we sort of talk about other people all of a sudden become legal experts.
SPEAKER_02I think we can I think we can skip to the conclusion, which is don't get your advice from Mumsnet.
SPEAKER_01Not on this man's subject matter, anyway. Um so somebody has said, well, firstly, a person's financial situation can compared to other beneficiaries is not a reason for contesting a will which can be very expensive. Is that true?
SPEAKER_02Yes, it can be very expensive. Um a person's financial situation compared to others is a factor. So let let's talk about, let's let's break down what they're saying here. Um there is a way of not challenging the validity of the will, but um making a claim um against the estate for reasonable financial provision. Um that's under the Inheritance Provision for Family Independence Act 1975. Okay. Certain people can make a claim for reasonable financial provision.
SPEAKER_02Um, spouses can make claims, and um other categories of claimant include children. So um this this lady is the child, will be the child of the deceased, so she could make an application, but in her case it would be limited to what she needed for her maintenance. Now, when um uh a judge would would look at this, the way they would look at it was they'd look at lots of different factors. Um, but one of them actually is her circumstances and how those compare to her brothers. So it is it is relevant if she's in dire straits.
SPEAKER_02Um, I mean that was really the reason the act came into um into force in the 1970s. It was to um to put these things right, you know, in a in a world where you're having people live together without getting married and maybe forgetting to make wills, you know, people could end up destitute. And that was that was what this will was um designed to remedy. So it is her financial circumstances are relevant. Oh, okay. So that's not true. No what they've said. Okay. The next post says you can't contest wills on the grounds that you need the money unless she owed you money or promised you money and you relied on that promise, and even then it's hard to prove.
SPEAKER_02If she is of sound mind and it's her money, then that's that really. So, yeah, uh already again, lots to unpick. Um estoppel um is a type of claim where if someone promised you something and you acted to your detriment on reliance on that promise, um, you may be able to have a claim against them. So the classic case is always farmers um who say to one of their sons, if you come back and help me run the farm, I'm not gonna pay you very much, but one day all this will be yours.
SPEAKER_02And then there's a subsequent fallout. So you can see he's the the farmer's promised his son uh the farm, and uh the the son has given up a career or you know what whatever he's given up to come and run the farm, um, and then the promise has been broken, and that is a that is a um ground for challenge, not for challenging a will, um, but for um preventing that person going back on their promise. Yeah, do you see that very often? Yeah, we do quite a lot, actually. Yeah. Um, but it is hard, of course it's hard.
SPEAKER_02It's so vague, and we talk about um you know we're talking about probate claims being expensive, you know, it's it's it's it's really something people should address in advance again. Proper communication, um, and you know, having having written agreements about these things is really, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01People they think, oh we're family, we don't need to have a written agreement, but you particularly in your area of work, you see it a lot where there isn't a written agreement that actually that's when their troubles um get started, don't they really? Absolutely. Yeah, yeah. So we're going back a comment again. Somebody said if a will had been professionally written when she had capacity, she would have been advised to leave you a token gesture rather than nothing at all. Um, so what do you think about that? What is your advice? Because obviously I come from the side of writing a will. So if um we're speaking to a client, and yeah, people do have reasons for leaving out um family members sometimes.
SPEAKER_01And I would say that they don't come easy with those decisions. People, you know, think about those sorts of decisions a lot. I think with the the type of clause she's talking about in a will is a non-contest clause, isn't it, where you're hoping that if you give somebody a gift and say that if you take this money um and don't challenge the will, you'll have it. But if they challenge the will, then they lose the gift. So I suppose you help us sometimes sort of determining what the level of that gift should be.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and also sometimes um I've seen wills drafted where they've given some someone a token amount so that they um they can show they turned their attention to that person, they didn't walk in and forgot they had forget they had a daughter and decide to leave them something so that that you know it may be enough that they don't want to challenge the will, or maybe it just, you know, they they've got this idea in their head that if they leave them a token amount, then they they can't challenge the will. But as you say, you can also then say on the end of that clause, but if you try and challenge my will, you don't get anything.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Now um coming back to this idea of reasonable financial provision, um the only way that you would really, you know, wipe out the chance of a claim is to give that reasonable provision in your will. Um most people don't want to do that in that situation where they really just want to leave someone out of their will. So leaving someone£500 um and expecting them not to make a claim, if they get legal advice that their claim could be worth£100,000, they're not going to settle for the£500.
SPEAKER_02Um so there's there's there's not a shortcut really to to cutting someone out of your will and completely preventing them from making a claim because as I said, the the the 1975 Act was put in place to s to stop people being destitute. Not it's not um it's not particularly generous. So um you you can't just you can't just stop people doing that if they're in in in the difficult position.
SPEAKER_01What sort of regards do the courts have to um sort of letters that are left alongside a will? So we would often advise our clients, you know, if if you really don't want to leave somebody in your will, we suggest it's a good idea to put down your reasons in writing. So if it is challenged um after death, there are some reasons from the person who actually made the will, whether written in a particular way. Does that carry much weight?
SPEAKER_02I think it's really um useful. I I think it's it's if it's logical, if there are some logical reasons why someone's been left out, then they're really compelling. But the other thing that you can do in that letter is go through the different factors that the court will take into account when looking at a claim. Um so um if the person who may make a claim is financially independent, financially secure, um, you don't think there's enough in the estate to go round because the people that you're leaving it to need them, you know, you can go through those um the factors the court would take into account, and that would give the court such an insight so that when you're gone, the court can say, Oh, you know, yeah, I understand why the will was done this way, and um I think that it's really helpful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_02Just one more word on proprietary stoppo. Um, you know, that the this mum's netter has thrown this um really complex area of law in here. Um, you know, uh their confidence is to be applauded, but um again, just get get proper legal advice, I think, on these things.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Um so somebody has also said, well, why don't you just issue a bill for all the care hours and say it will be attached to the estate if not paid, um, and actually then add some interest as well, and then send the bill, and then it'll be part of the estate. Is it that easy?
SPEAKER_02It's not that easy, and I think there's obviously um a line here. I think uh I I said I wouldn't get judgmental, but I'm about to because I think that most care that you give your parents should not be charged for. Um controversial. Um I might I might send a bill to my kids at some point. Um, but um no, you know, obviously when it's within a family, um it's unlikely that um care would be paid for. This was when she was a child as well.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, to suggest that she was providing um paid for services. Paid for services, yeah, it seems uh very unlikely. However, there is a recent case, just in the last year or so, Rogers and Wills, it's a really interesting case. Um the uh the claimant was a retired nurse and she took over looking after her mum, moved her in, was providing 24-hour care. Um, and mum said, You need to be paid for all this. Um, and then at various points the claimant's siblings said, You need to be paid for this.
SPEAKER_02And she's and the daughter said, Yeah, yeah, you know, we'll we'll sort it out. Don't worry about it, we'll sort it out. Um when mum died, um, the claimant thought, well, you know, now's the time to sort that out. And suddenly her siblings weren't so agreeable to the idea of um paying her for the care that she'd given. Um it was a um Paul Matthews decision. Paul Matthews has some interesting decisions, and this was this was really interesting. It's the first time I think we've seen um an intention to create legal relations in a domestic setting.
SPEAKER_02So um he he found that that that had created a contract. Um and if as an alternative, if it hadn't created a contract, then the estate had been unjustly enriched by her providing those care services for free because there were no the the estate didn't have to pay any care bills. Um so the daughter was reimbursed, but the that's quite specific. So, you know, it was it was a lot of care, it was 24-hour intimate personal care.
SPEAKER_02And um mum had said you need to be paid for this. The siblings who I think um had a power of attorney said you need to be paid for this. Um, and it was all of that together that had created a contract.
SPEAKER_01I suppose that's the thing, and the sister is providing the care, she probably just thought, oh, just sort this out at one point, and it's another example of not having it in writing, isn't it? Yes, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So absolutely the best thing in that case would have been for her to sort that out. When mum said you need to be paid for this, she should have said, All right, well, I'm gonna charge this amount an hour and you know, and and and got it up and running, not waited.
SPEAKER_01And that's another thing about communication, isn't it? Because I suppose you'd probably feel a bit awkward, wouldn't you? Well, actually, yeah, Mum's gonna charge you, you know, what's the rate and everything else.
SPEAKER_02But it's like all that conversation.
SPEAKER_01Yes, is it is much easier to have the difficult conversations earlier. Yeah, yeah. Somebody's uh made a comment a little bit similar to the comment we spoke about at the beginning about um your own income and capital resources have nothing to do with making a claim against the estate, which we found out was wrong, you you know, it does have a bearing. Somebody said your income will have sweet FA to do with it, it's not a benefit form. Um gone on to say, if she hasn't said that she has knowingly excluded you, you could say she must have forgot and probably would get a portion.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we have covered, we've touched on a couple of those before. So um if she if she hasn't said she has knowingly excluded you, you could say she must have forgotten. So this is kind of what I said, you know, this idea of going in and leaving them something so you can show that you've turned your attention to that person and you've thought about what you want to leave them and left them an appropriate sum. I'm not really suggesting that if you don't do that, you can say she forgot she had a daughter. Um that's you know, that's the other extreme, really.
SPEAKER_02It's very unlikely that someone will go in and and and forget that they had a particular relative. Um and to go from there to saying that you know, you would if you could show that she'd forgotten you, you'd you'd get something again, that's a big jump. You need to show that you need it under the the clauses of the 1975 Act for your maintenance. Um the we we've said why her income is um important if you know if her brother's so much um better.
SPEAKER_02But it does pose the court some challenges because if you're on means tested benefits and the court give you an award, um you could lose those benefits. Yeah. And there's not an easy answer to this, and the the courts have um grappled with this a lot. Um bearing in mind your going your your award is going to be limited to what you need for your maintenance, taking all the circumstances into account as an adult child.
SPEAKER_02Um now, if you're an able-bodied, um, independent adult child, then you're unlikely to be successful. But if you're if if for some reason you are successful, it's only, as I say, what you need um to to top up your income for your maintenance that you would that you would receive. It's not it's not a huge windfall. Um so bearing that in mind, you you have to grapple with this idea that you could lose your benefits.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And do they take that into account then? So when they're looking at maintenance, they think, well, actually, if this person gets this award, we'd have to take into account the fact they're not gonna have benefits. Yes. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um well, it's it's not even a question. This is some really clear legal advice here. Um if you get inheritance, give it to your child so it won't affect your benefits. And clearly your relationship with your own parent is bad, so you should pass it on, not have it.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So I think the the thing there is about um if you are receiving benefits and you receive some inheritance, can you just then pass it on to your children? Um, so the answer to that is no, it's not that straightforward. Um, it would be um likely to be treated as deliberate deprivation of capital um by the Department for Work and Pensions. So what that would mean is that you'd probably still be assessed as actually owning that asset, even though you've given it away. So then you're likely to um not be able to receive any means tested benefits, and you've given the capital away um perhaps to the children or or whoever.
SPEAKER_01Um, there are other legitimate ways that people can um provide for um perhaps vulnerable, not necessarily vulnerable um beneficiaries or people with a disability or people who are reliant on means-tested benefits. So it's about getting advice early on again because um when somebody's writing a will, they can do it in a way which is going to um protect that person's entitlement to means-tested benefits whilst also making provision for them.
SPEAKER_02What what about a deed of variation if they did it via a divariation? Would that be the same?
SPEAKER_01It is the same, yeah. So um, like you know already what deed of variation is, but I'll just explain. So d de variation is where um somebody who's um received some inheritance from a will or under the intestacy, if somebody dies without a will and they're full age, they've got capacity, and they want to pass that inheritance on to somebody else. Um so quite often it's done for tax planning reasons, um, or sometimes to make things fairer. People might think they want to um equalise an estate or something like that. Um, it shouldn't be done for um, in effect, avoiding um paying, oh sorry, but it shouldn't be done for um avoiding that capital so it doesn't affect your means tested benefits.
SPEAKER_01You know, you have to report any changes to your circumstances um to the Department of Work and Pensions, so that includes your savings, investments, and any money that you come into. Um so obviously if somebody doesn't declare their inheritance, they could be taken to court potentially, um, could be seen as benefit fraud. So it's you know, it's a serious issue.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. So you could use a deed of variation for tax planning. So you might be able to reduce inheritance tax, for example, but not to um avoid losing your benefits. Yes, yes. That's right, yeah, yeah. Actually, this was this is our last one. I like the song. Yeah, I'll let you want to go through it. The the comment is I suspect under English law you don't have grounds to contest it because it would be normal for the son to inherit the lot. What? Yeah. I don't know. Um I don't know if this is an American lady commenting, um, who maybe has watched too many English period dramas recently.
SPEAKER_02Um so I just want to be very clear that the oldest son does not get the lot. Um there is no difference between um the age of siblings or the gender of siblings when it comes to inheritance. So there is no false airship in this country. So, subject to all the things we've said about um providing for people and not leaving them destitute, you can leave your estate to who you want to. And if you don't make a will, um if you're um if you're a a parent with no spouse, um it would go to your children equally.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_01So I think, you know, this is an example really, I suppose, of how I started off um this podcast, or just saying there's a lot of information out there. Um, I suppose, especially with AI now, because I mean I don't really know exactly how it works, but it pulls in information from other sources, doesn't it? So I think the moral has got to be take specialised legal advice, which that lots of these comments say anyway.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, they seem to give some really definite legal advice and then say, definitely get your own legal advice though. So um yeah, uh absolutely. And of course everything turns on the facts. So um is this mum has this mum done a decent decent will? You know, because we haven't really talked about that. We haven't talked about ways to challenge an actual will. So if a if she didn't have um capacity, uh mental capacity when she prepared her will, then it could be challenged if she was forced into making the will.
SPEAKER_02Um, you know, we we have some cases where the the will's actually been forged. Um there are you know lots of ways to to challenge a will itself. So I think it's only you know when you draw that out of a client, a potential claimant, that you can really assess what the best claim is, um, if any at all. And also, of course, if if someone like me thinks you don't stand a good chance, you you've had full information, you've had full advice and can can have some closure.
SPEAKER_02Because, you know, as lots of these comments say, there is an argument that if you're estranged from your parent, then then then maybe you shouldn't inherit. Um, and um by having that full legal advice you can then have closure on the subject.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, which I think that's really important for lots of people, isn't it? Because it's really emotive, isn't it? This this area, somebody's passed away. There's a lot of emotions involved. Yes.
SPEAKER_00Any additional guides and insights we've mentioned today will be available on our website. We hope you found this episode insightful. If you would like to discuss anything further on this subject, then please do get in touch with our website, www.lison solicitors.com. Please don't forget to subscribe to our podcast and follow us on our social channels to keep up to date with the latest news and insights. Any information shared on this podcast was accurate at the time of recording. And remember, we had my speaking to your usual Ellison's advisor to make sure there haven't been any changes since.
SPEAKER_00Thank you very much to Punch Studios for producing this podcast series.
Can divorce really be amicable? In this episode of Ellisons Connects, Anna Cross, Legal Director, Sally Ward, Senior Associate, and Samantha Chase, Associate, from our Family Law team discuss Resolution Together - a...
Can divorce really be amicable? In this episode of Ellisons Connects, Anna Cross, Legal Director, Sally Ward, Senior Associate, and Samantha Chase, Associate, from our Family Law team discuss Resolution Together - a...
Personal Injury Lawyers Steve Stratton and Bernice Spurgeon discuss the realities of making a personal injury claim and why the process is about far more than compensation. Drawing on their legal experience, and...
In this episode, Managing Partner, Guy Longhurst and Partner & COO, Lizzy Firmin, have an open conversation about what truly drives Ellisons as a firm. Investing in people isn’t just something we talk about - it’s...
In tech, a strong idea needs more than momentum. It needs protection, structure and a clear route to funding. In the latest episode of Ellisons Connects, Partners Ryan Cracknell and Phil Slater discuss how tech...