Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Effective Communication

Effective Communication artwork

Unlocking Housing in Michigan

May 14, 202629 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Is there something communication-related in your own life that you're struggling with or would like advice on? If so, leave a comment stating your problem that and Phil will dedicate an episode to solving that problem!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Welcome to My Business Matters, the Michigan Chamber podcast.

Speaker 2Welcome to Buy Business Matters, the podcast of the Michigan Chamber of Commerce. This is where we have meaningful conversations on the issues shaping our state's future. I'm Jim Holcombe, President and CEO of the Michigan Chamber, and today we're going to talk about housing. Holiday is a quality of life issue, it's also an economic one across Michigan. Employers are struggling to attract and retain talent and families are struggling to find homes they can afford. Helping to unpack usault today is Brad Ward with the Michigan Realtors, Don Crandall with the home Builders Association of Michigan, and Randy Gross,

Speaker 2our very own Michigan Chamber staffer. He's the lead on our issue for us. Everyone, Welcome to the microphone. Thanks having us for having us, appreciate you coming in. Certainly an issue that's front and centered everybody's mind, as well as the media. Housing it seems like something that a lot of people talk about, but we've never really figured out how to fix or how to make a dent. So that's where you all come in because I know you guys have all the answers, so that'll be good. But we do hear a lot about it, but let's start with what does it actually I mean, what's it look like on the ground for employers, families, workers that

Speaker 2we have a housing shortage. Donal'll start with.

Speaker 3You, thanks. We do have a housing shortage, and it impacts everything from our population to our aging population, to attaining new population and new growth. We are not building what we need to build to just stay steady. So the last time we did a really big build in the state was in two thousand and five, and fifty four thousand per mints were pulled. Two thousand and seven, that number drop to fifteen thousand, two thousand and nine, that number drop to sixty nine hundred. Last year we pulled the fifteen thousand, eight hundred and twenty one. And

Speaker 3this is the first year since two thousand and five that our prediction is actually lower than the previous year, and we're forecasting fifteen thousand, three one hundred and seventy six.

Speaker 2Was there anything special about two thousand and five, was anything happening or was it just an environment that's just all came.

Speaker 3The environment that all came together. But still when you look at the average age of a home in our state, it's fifty years old. So even our last big build, those homes are coming up on twenty one, twenty two years old. We need new housing stock.

Speaker 4Yeah, and I would point out too, this isn't unique to Michigan. I mean this is happening nationwide. Just we as a country have underbuilt for the last decade or so and not met the market kind of where it is. And from our realtor members' perspectives, you know, we talked about pocketbook issues. Housing is a pocketbook issue. So you know, a housing costs are up, mortgage cost up, rent costs are up, it's competitive, you have multiple offers. We're still very much a seller's market. There isn't enough inventory on

Speaker 4the market to meet the demand. I mean, the median home price in Michigan has gone up seventy thousand dollars in the last three years. And on top of that, we have what we would consider like a normal market is about six months of inventory. Is a balanced market where you have supply to meet demand. This state has hovered kind of between two and a half months of inventory three months of inventory for the last handful of years, so we really don't have the inventory that's trying to kind of meet the market. So that really is kind

Speaker 4of what it looks like to our members.

Speaker 2How much of the inventory issue is driven by the fact that we had Citi a little interest rate for a while. People got locked in, maybe locked into homes that were right down the height of their affordability, but with the low interest rates that made it workable that now even if they can sell it for more, they can't get into something and make it an economically viable proposition.

Speaker 4Yeah, it's a great question, and that definitely has we have to that definitely has something to do with it. You know, you hear about that lock the lock in effect of the mortgage interest rate in Michigan, we kind of have like a double almost triple lock in because not only do you have the mortgage interest rates that have increased over the last few years here, but we also have Proposal A, so we have this property tax cap. So if you've lived in your home, you know, twenty twenty year before, just in those last five years, like

Speaker 4I said, seventy thousand dollars in three years, you're uncapping of property taxes. Even if you wanted to go from a large family home because now you're an empty nester and you wanted to downsize, you could be faced with a property tax bill that maybe double what you're paying now. So you got higher interest rate, higher property taxes. And then in Michigan we still have a real estate transfer tax. And so you know, you kind of got these three economic mental hurdles that you have to go out to get over if you want to sell.

Speaker 2How much of this from for any of you to chime in, how much of this is not having the skilled trades to do the building that do we have the workforce that can actually tee up if all the capital was there and the money was there, and hey, let's go, we've got permits. John, you raised a lot of You've referenced numbers earlier about the permits. Is there the builders to fulfill all those permits.

Speaker 3No, So when we look at the housing, we look at supplying demand. So to Brad's point, we don't have the inventory. We don't have the supply to meet the demand. The same is true when you look at the labor in the state. So these are last year's numbers. We just received this year's numbers, but I don't have them with me. The median age of a builder in the state is fifty eight, So go back to the average age of a home being fifty average age of a building being fifty eight. When you look at that, roughly there's about fifty thousand plus licensees in the state, twenty

Speaker 3four thousand of them fall in the fifty six plus range, and when you look at the eighteen to thirty four year range, you're only at about twenty five hundred. So for those going out maybe four, you've got one coming in. And so that's why we, you know, work really hard to get young kids and get veterans and returning citizens into the trades because AI is not going to place a builder.

Speaker 2Yeah, and they're good jobs, are good paid jobs. At there's obviously a market for it. Randy, how much of this housing shortage is impacting members of the Michigan Chamber and another group, you know, just the general business community.

Speaker 1Yeah, you know it. It's had a pretty big impact on a number of members I've talked to. There's several circumstances where we've seen where somebody has come in, they have a new facility, they've they've expanded or located in Michigan and they're trying to find a workforce and they can't find housing within forty five minutes to an hour that is, you know, affordable and within the you know, middle class housing costs. We'll call it, right, I mean, Brad kind of hit on this. A little bit of seventy thousand dollars increase over over the last three years. I mean, that's just not an attainable number to match. So,

Speaker 1you know, we're not raising wages, you know, at the same clip that the cost of housing is going up. We can't do that. So to attract you know, a workforce into an area you know without housing is almost impossible. Some members are busing people in from across the state. They're chartering buses to bring people an hour and a half away because that's the best solution they have because they're unable to build right now.

Speaker 2And then, yeah, the communing problem to cost of gas, and I think it transitions and other issues. Daycare. It's hard to be traveling forty five minutes to an hour back and forth to your job if your daycare is in one right part of the state and you're working in another.

Speaker 1It's probably a different show, but yes, day care's a big issue for our members as well.

Speaker 2Brad. When your members when they're talking in clients, is there are people changing their preferences on what they're looking for and does that impact what gets built or is there a chicken and egg there.

Speaker 4Yeah. You know, the realtor's number one job right now is manage expectations. So you're managing expectations for a buyer saying, look, you are going to be competing against multiple people, and so there are expectations that you have to have no going into that. We've seen situations where people are willing to wave things like inspections, wave appraise. They're willing to make offers that I will pay you know, X number of dollars over a praise value if it doesn't come in. So it's getting very competitive, and you know, when we

Speaker 4talk about some of that downsizing, a lot of it is, you know, people who have cash versus first time home buyers. So it's really about managing those expectations. But I think in terms of the stuff that's being built, that is where we really do have to meet the market. The one thing that always kind of comes up people say well, Michigan's population is relatively stagnant. You know, it really hasn't changed in the last several years. Why do we have a housing crisis. Well, you don't count homes based on

Speaker 4the number of people. You count homes based on households. People are living longer, divorce is higher, people are living separately differently, and we have an aging housing stock and some of that gets aged out. So we do have to continue to build, and there is changing demand in the market. So you know a lot of multi generational So if you look at accessory dwelling units, so in law suites, those are things people you know, where you have two generations living under one roof those are things

Speaker 4that I think help the housing situation but aren't allowed in a lot of our local communities. You know, people are looking for walkable people are looking to age in place. People are looking for you know, locations near transit or their job. So we also have to be you know, cognizant of what the market is looking for too.

Speaker 1That's a good point and I would add on that for perspective, employers who are looking to come to Michigan right they know their workforce are going to be looking for the things Brad is pointing out there, you know, you know, walk wall communities, access to mass transit, stuff like that. Things were you know historically, maybe we haven't focused on as much housing stock because that wasn't the demand twenty years ago, thirty years ago when we were building, fifty years ago, when we were building it was. It was a different demand by the employees that time in the workforce, and that change in the work or something

Speaker 1in what they're looking for in their housing needs to be met if we want to continue to attract you know, large employers or or hot high wage jobs or different sectors. I mean, it kind of goes with that piece of it.

Speaker 2That's certainly an issue when I talked to business leaders across state, an issue and their economic development plans. Am I going to expand here? Am I going to move here? How am I going to satisfy my employees? Because that's a huge component of their successes, making sure that they can get the right talent. We've kind of talked a little bit about some of the negative impacts. What's driving the negative impact? Like we talked a little bit there's a shortage of maybe skilled traits, but don you said there you know you gave the permitting requests. How are locals engaged in this this debate.

Speaker 3Oh, they're engaged.

Speaker 2I would sure everybody has the same goal. We want to thrive in Michigan. Yes, we want.

Speaker 3Also back to Brad's point about you know, households, I don't you know when we're talking talking earlier before we started about you know a group who said Michigan's not a growing population. I think at that point it's not Michigan competing necessarily with people from Ohio that are going to come here. It's Grand Rapids competing with Traverse City or Traverse City competing with Southeast Michigan. And those communities that are on the forefront of being kind of creative in their zoning and allowing for housing and the types

Speaker 3of housing that Brad mentioned, those are the communities that are going to win when you start looking at aging population, right, like, as people start aging in one community that may not be where they necessarily want to retire. They may want to move up north. Well, then you run into the Nimbi's right, not in my backyard. We don't want all those people from downstate to move up to our quiet, little country area. And so you've got the blend of you know, where people choose to live and want to live versus people who are making the decision saying we

Speaker 3don't want that kind of housing in our community.

Speaker 2It seems like we do have that debate on many issues, not just housing. But you know, and I'm not I'm not sure what the right balances we all, I think around this table think about less government, of better government and letting people locally decide their character and community, but also making sure that you're utilizing state resources and we're all in this together. We want to make sure that there's a place for people.

Speaker 4Yeah, you know you mentioned we talked about the labor shortage adding to these challenges. Well in building homes, you know there's the labor shortage, you got material costs, supply chain, tariffs, you know, interest rates. As you brought up, the one thing that the state and local government does have is that rules and regulations, the permitting, the zoning, all of those things that kind of can add cost to housing. So we as a state, we as local governments may not be able to change tariffs or you know, get

Speaker 4involved in global supply chain and you know, we can't build workers or train work overnight. But we can dig in there and look at the rules and regulations that we set up as obstacles to creating new housing or obstacles that add to the cost of housing.

Speaker 2How do we change just is this an issue for the legislature? Is that everything done locally? Do you have to empower locals? Randy, how do you see the policy plane out?

Speaker 1You know, I think it's a combination of all the above. I mean, I definitely think there's stuff we can handle at the state level. You know, I'll look at the tax rate for a little bit, kind of focus on that we've talked about, you know, kind of being trapped in there. There's been proposals about eliminating the state transfer tax. There's been proposals about capping the pop up tax in certain circumstances, you know, maybe incentivizing you know, older generations who are looking to downsize, to provide some protections for them to open up some stock to you know, the

Speaker 1state could make some policy efforts in those positive steps in that direction to open up some stock that would relieve some of that pressure maybe, you know, but they gotta have a place to go. So on the other side of that is you got to open it up, and there has to be some new stock on the market and new builds going on that are smaller. You know, they don't need a twenty five hundred square foot house I want to. I want to a thousand square foot duplex or something that's more manageable for you know, two people, or whatever the case may be. So I do think it starts at the legislature. I think there are definitely

Speaker 1things locals could do to ease this, working with their builders and their communities to go down that path. But I do it's a combination of all the above.

Speaker 2I believe with the local issue. Do you think it's a situation of educating people or they're just hard long drive lines in the sand, Ben draw on that we want this, we don't want that.

Speaker 4I think there's definitely a role for education. You know, you brought up the Nimby issue, and a lot of times that is people don't like to talk about change in their communities, and a lot of times they don't understand what that change looks like. So you know, there's a bill that's currently before the legislature that would allow due plas in single family residential zones. When you look at those homes. They look just like the home next door to it, but they have two front doors instead of one. So, you know, there is an education process

Speaker 4that changes and always scary. This isn't the end of your community. This isn't ruining the rural character or whatever you want to call it of your community. But so there is an education process. I think there's a role for local governments to play in terms of looking at their own rules, and there's a role definitely for the state to play. The state has permitting that is often involved in these They have building codes states reviewing those. But the state also, you know, gives local governments the power to zone. We have a statewide Zoning Enabling Act,

Speaker 4and the state, like other states, both red and blue, is starting to look at, you know, how can we make changes at the state level that will help get more shovels in the ground, that'll help maybe combat some of this nimbi attitude, that'll help local governments kind of of turn a mirror on themselves a little bit to figure out, you know, how can we be more responsive to the needs of people to in our community that are looking to move to our community. So I think there's definitely a role for both the state and local to play in this.

Speaker 3Yes, I think the one thing to remember is, you know, builders are going to build what their customer, client wants or what the market bears.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 3Builders aren't going to just start going out and building duplexes if there isn't a need or a request for them, because it's not financially smart on a builder's side to do that. And so a lot of the things, and I've heard it as I've talked to legislators and local elected officials, they do tend to go to that worst case scenario, right, like, if this goes through, you know this is going to happen in my community, and builders are truly going to build what the market bears and what their client their customer wants.

Speaker 2Is housing a partisan or a political issue? Everybody seems to have like their own perspective. But does it breakdown on partisan lines or is it more about where you're from or your community than it is r D.

Speaker 1I was going to say, it's a political issue, but not necessarily a partisan issue, So that's a pretty good It's a very political issue, but it's not partisan. I think it's very geographically based. It's your community based. I think. You know, I grew up in southwest Michigan and our view on housing was substantially I remember moving up in the Landing area and the first time I saw the cost of houses up, I'm like, wait a minute, that's not what I was in costs with your people. So I mean, I think I think it is political, but I don't think it's part of.

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean partisan in the sense that you know, I think everyone, we all recognize housing is important. We want people to get into housing. From our association's perspective, owning a home. That's the American dream. The different parties may have different ideas on how to get there, but I don't think it's it's partisan at all when you really get down to it in terms of the goal of opening up more housing opportunities, lowering the cost of housing for Michigan anders, I think that is a shared

Speaker 4goal of both parties. It gets political, I think now with the Nimbia attitudes when you start talking about these things at the state level, and all of a sudden you go to your local township meeting and everyone is furious because it's like this is this is a local control issue, and you know, I want to find someone to run against you.

Speaker 2How much does different generational perspectives impact housing? I know I've read a lot lately that younger people they really don't like you, said, Brad the American dreamist own a home and raise your family, that they're more Hey, I'm changing jobs about every seven years, and I like a different location and I want to be more flexible, and I really don't want to own because then I'm trapped and I get locked in. Are we seeing that play out in the market at all? And does that, don follow up to you would be, does that again impact what is built? So Brad, I'll let you get the

Speaker 2most part.

Speaker 4It's a great question, and I don't know that I have the answer. But you know, rental is a attractive and a lot of times it's attractive because it's a lower cost option than owning. And so I don't know how much of that is driven by, you know, the youth wanting to not necessarily put down roots somewhere and be able to kind of be flexible, or how much of it is driven by well, I just there's you know, that's where the market's leading me to go because I can't get into a home of my own. But you know, the we need housing of all types. We need rental,

Speaker 4we need multi family, we need single family, we need tiny houses.

Speaker 2We need for everyone.

Speaker 4Yeah, you know, everyone has kind of their own opinion of how and where they want to live. You talk about generational we had. You know, there was a time when small houses and density was the way you build. We have a generation of folks who grew up in one thousand square foot you know, bungalows and you know there may have been six people in there, three bedrooms.

Speaker 2So open the window, you can shake care exactly.

Speaker 4And and you know, now we have you know, people watchllion dollars listing and HGTV and the you know, everyone wants a you know, a larger home or no home at all. They want to be, you know, in a cool apartment downtown. So we need something for everybody.

Speaker 3And I think to that point, even as I drive around Lansing, I'm seeing homes that are being built to rent, Like I'm seeing communities where you know, they are houses, but they're not for sale, they are for rent. And there's a couple of them around here. And going back to yeah, your neighbor used to be that was social media back in our They right.

Speaker 2Exactly what's being proposed like on the policy front, and what do you think would actually move the needle And we'll just go left right for Randelle start with you a little bit.

Speaker 1Oh well, I know there are several packages or several bills out there, package aimed at trying to centralize some aspects of zoning. I would say, you know, standardize maybe is a better approach uniformity, uniformity across the state on some zoning pieces, you know, dealing with various things astar as allowing duplex or requirements if if there's established infrastructure sewer and water to an area and you're going to build in that area, like setting some standards across the state, is this this is what you can and can't require.

Speaker 1I think there's interest there. I think that'll continue to be discussed. You know, I don't have a crystal ball out on that one yet, but there's a lot of bipartisan interests in a lot of groups on both sides, non traditional bedfellows that are that are really looking at this because I think to Brad's point, people are recognizing this, like getting housing is an important piece. So that's kind of what I see out there, you know, down on it.

Speaker 3Yeah, but I mean we're seeing the same thing, right, I mean, and it wouldn't be the first time for standardized codes or anything across the state, right, Like we have a statewide building code that is standard for everybody. So you know, when this you know, housing zoning reform package came out, I would hear from legislators. You know, I've got you know, sixteen municipalities, and fourteen of them are calling in their ingrate me and I said, but now, think about a builder that has to build to, like if they're in three or four or five or ten different communities, they're building to you know, ten different zoning codes,

Speaker 3depending in regulations, depending on where they are. So you know, our builders are looking for guardrails and continuity and stability in the market. That makes it easier because every time you add a layer or a regulation that increases the cost of housing even by one thousand dollars. And we just got these numbers from National. We're kicking out over like five thousand individuals that cannot get into the market.

Speaker 2Do we know how much regulation adds to the cost of a build?

Speaker 3So our National has done a study it's an old number. They're coming out with new numbers this fall, but it's about ninety four thousand dollars. So it's not just it's not just zoning. I need to be very clear on this because I've been challenged, But it is like the cost of studies, the you know, land that's given back to the government, setbacks. It is labor, it is materials, it's all the things before you even put a shovel in the ground. That's a huge number, but it is a huge number. And the thing that people don't understand is I was talking to one of my builders on the West Side. He had a plan that was already approved,

Speaker 3one hundred and forty units, and he already approved. He'd gone in to do like one piece of final paperwork, and the township official said, I need you to do a traffic study. It was a county road, not a township road. That delayed the project enough that only forty of those units are going to be built this year and one hundred of them will be built next year. And because builders have carrying costs, it's adding another five to six thousand dollars per unit per year, all because

Speaker 3they didn't they wanted to be able to say, I had him do a traffic study so that when you know, those nimbis came at the elected official, they had something to wave so.

Speaker 1Frustrated brand I know you're going to talk on this too, but just one thing on the zoning piece. I do think there's probably worth some clarification, like this isn't about your character and stuff. Community. They're talking about like some broad based changes as far as, yeah, the zoning like uniformity.

Speaker 4Yeah, I wish you could say that there was one policy that could pass and all of a sudden, we're going to have housing available to us. But it's really about putting tools in the toolbox. It's trying to address pieces of this to get costs to move, to get more homes built. It's interesting as we've kind of looked at these things over the last few years, these zoning changes that are being proposed at the state legislative level, so lot sizes, development studies, parking minimums, duplexes, ad US,

Speaker 4dwelling size like all of those things. They are identified time and time again by local governments, by state governments, by the federal government as being impediments to housing supply and and increasing costs. So I mean, you know, you don't read about things passing the United States House of Representatives with only nine no votes. But we had a housing bill that went through the US House of Representatives that included these changes in directing federal dollars in federal

Speaker 4programs to communities and states that make these zoning changes, and so not a Parson issue.

Speaker 2I mean.

Speaker 4Over in the Senate, they amended it and the Senate passed it. It is now it's they've mashed the titles together. It's called the twenty first Century Road to Housing Acts. So they took the Senate piece the House piece of measure together, so they set it back over to the House. The House hasn't hasn't brought it back up as of as of yet. But again a recognition that these zoning pieces are again they're included in the Michigan Municipal League's My Home Loan program that they've rolled out. There's is a little bit more menu based and incentivized. They're in

Speaker 4this housing Ready in this package. They're identified in the Michigan Association of Planning's Zoning Reform toolkits. So I mean there's agreement that these policies are harmful to housing, and so it's just getting people together to coalesce around like, stop paying people to build, stop subsidizing this, Just get out of their way and let michigan Anders have homes.

Speaker 2Let the market decide and go forward. We're kind of coming to the end here. I want to go around the horn. Give you an option. Either you have something you want to point to that we haven't talked about, you want to make a point, or if you can articulate, if Michigan gets us right over the next couple of years, what does success look like? Range will start with you.

Speaker 1Yeah. For me, success looks like, you know, getting maybe back to the early two thousands numbers as far as number of homes build, or at least a trend that's showing that way over the next five years. We're seeing it up growth in new construction. And we can go to businesses that are looking to come to Michigan and say, hey, look, you want to come here because look at these are the type of housing and environments and communities that your employees are I don't want to be part of.

Speaker 3I think it puts us on the track to grow our state population wise. It puts us in that that place to say we're open for business. Right to bring these point businesses are going to look at the housings here. I always say housing is economic development. You can't have one without the other. And so as we start looking at being able to put some good housing policies in place and labor for housing in place, you know, it does it sets the stage for conversations. I'm the next governor, and we're going to have a new governor come January one. There's a lot of opportunities and a lot of policy

Speaker 3decisions that are going to take place.

Speaker 4Yeah, I think, you know, a normalization in the market, providing people with opportunities to get into homes, providing opportunities for families to own to rent, you know, and to have some assurance that that you know, that cost is something that they're going to be able to afford. I think is what success looks like from our perspective.

Speaker 2Well, I think list ignore you today, it's clear that housing touches everything jobs, economic growth, community stability, opportunity, and as you've all talked about today, solving this challenge, it's not about one policy or one group. It's going to take alignment across all industries and communities. So thank you again to Brad Ward. He's the vice president of Public Policy Legal Affairs at the Michigan Realtors. Don Crandall is the executive vice president for Government Relations with the home Builders Association of Michigan. Rady Gross is the Senior Director of Legislative Affairs and Associate General Council at the Michigan Chamber.

Speaker 2At the Michigan Chamber, we're going to continue to follow this issue closely, hopefully working to move forward with practical policy solutions. So make sure to stay tuned and thanks for joining us today on my business matters.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Get Through the Grief

    Nov 19, 20265 minAudio

    Is there something communication-related in your own life that you're struggling with or would like advice on? If so, leave a comment stating your problem that and Phil will dedicate an episode to solving that problem!

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Does Your Opinion Have Teeth?

    Nov 12, 20266 minAudio

    Is there something communication-related in your own life that you're struggling with or would like advice on? If so, leave a comment stating your problem that and Phil will dedicate an episode to solving that problem!

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Do Ignorant People Frusturate You?

    Nov 5, 20266 minAudio

    Is there something communication-related in your own life that you're struggling with or would like advice on? If so, leave a comment stating your problem that and Phil will dedicate an episode to solving that problem!

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Making a Tough Decision

    Oct 29, 20266 minAudio

    Is there something communication-related in your own life that you're struggling with or would like advice on? If so, leave a comment stating your problem that and Phil will dedicate an episode to solving that problem!

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. What Are You Teaching Your Kids?

    Oct 22, 20266 minAudio

    Is there something communication-related in your own life that you're struggling with or would like advice on? If so, leave a comment stating your problem that and Phil will dedicate an episode to solving that problem!

    Credit the people on this episode