Send us Fan Mail Higher ed is facing a defining crossroads: between generative AI, shifting classroom norms, and traditional definitions of plagiarism, the line between academic assistance and intellectual shortcut has never been blurrier. Today, we’re joined by Mortimer Ennis, Division Dean at Lone Star College, to unpack how faculty are navigating this tension, what’s driving students toward these tools, and how institutions can build genuine learning environments without turning classrooms into surveillance zones. All of this on Season 2 Episode 3 of ED. For further information about Ed. Please visit our website at www.ed.buzzsprout.com. Ed. was produced by Andy Luster and Twyla Coy, Music Provided by Liborio Conti.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03We did a campus survey where we asked students about their usage of AI, and I think that that was the number one thing that most students were afraid of using it because they were afraid of those consequences. Welcome to Ed, the podcast where we dig into the evolving landscape of higher education, teaching, and lifelong learning. Higher Ed is facing a defining crossroads between generative AI, shifting classroom norms, and traditional definitions of plagiarism. The line between academic assistance and intellectual shortcut has never been blurrier.
SPEAKER_03Today, we're joined by Mortimer Ennis, Division Dean at Lone Star College, to unpack how faculty are navigating this tension, what's driving students toward these tools, and how institutions can build genuine learning environments without turning classrooms into surveillance zones. All of this on season two, episode three of Ed. And we are here with the third episode of season two of Ed.
SPEAKER_03And we're getting into a topic this time that is a little controversial, but not too heavily controversial as it turns out, uh as it relates to artificial intelligence. We're talking about uh plagiarism and cheating and uh the effect that that has, but also we're talking about how AI fits into that. And we're gonna sort of break this down into three different segments. The first, we're sort of gonna talk about what plagiarism is and how it's changed. Uh, the second thing we're gonna do is sort of move into sort of how educators are fitting into a sort of a dilemma between panic and pedagogy.
SPEAKER_03Uh, and then finally, we're gonna talk about the idea that we need to maybe integrate AI a little bit more rather than sort of jumping away from it and talk about sort of that versus what AI proofing would look like. So uh my guest, or our guest, I should say, because Twil is here, obviously. Uh, our guest this time, is the dean for our division one, which is arts, English, believes uh languages, as well as speech, as well as what am I forgetting?
SPEAKER_03Theater. Am I forgetting any theater?
SPEAKER_02It's it's arts, English, communications, and languages. So those acronyms that uh all of those things.
SPEAKER_03All those. And then he's speaking right now. This is Mortimer Ennis, and I want to thank you for coming on with us. Welcome aboard.
SPEAKER_02Thank you, appreciate it. Glad to be here. Glad to have you.
SPEAKER_04I'm really excited about this conversation because I am too. Maybe a little controversy, but I think it's really relevant to where where we are in higher ed right now.
SPEAKER_03So when I had competed in speech and debate in college, my freshman year persuasive speech was on uh plagiarism and on basically cheating, c collegiate cheating, and how collegiate cheating was sort of destroying the academic environment, was destroying this sort of uh was basically just hurting colleges and universities, but also hurting students and the effect that it had on people. And I did really well with that speech because obviously doing it in front of education people who love, you know, talking about education.
SPEAKER_03But I think like this has definitely always been a subject that I've always been interested in talking about and and sort of discussing. And I think it's important to understand what that idea of plagiarism is at the beginning. And if we define plagiarism, the define plagiarism is basically defined as taking somebody else's work and presenting it as your own. And what that means sort of gets a little blurred in the lines of today. But what it meant in the past was you take somebody else's essay, take somebody else's speech, and you basically put your name on it, you submit it.
SPEAKER_03That's the work. Um, and you know, back in the day you could figure that out pretty easily by figuring I'm gonna do Martin Luther King's I Have a Dream speech, and then present it as my no, it's not gonna fly.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03Um, or you could also patchwork, you could take little pieces from other from from different speeches or essays and put it together and it's your own. Those people were a little harder to detect. And then the third one, which was not as bad, but still required, you know, some scolding, I guess, was incremental plagiarism, basically the idea that you weren't citing your sources, but you still had your own original work. That is not what plagiarism is today.
SPEAKER_04But what I'm hearing is that cheating or plagiarism is not new. No, it's definitely not new. It's always been around.
SPEAKER_02You know, I've been in higher education since 2003, and this is nothing new. Um, you know, it's just it's funny because back in the day, students actually had to work to cheat. Before the internet, you know, they had to go to the library and find, you know, articles or books or whatever to copy and paste from. Um and then with the internet, that just made it easier to find information quicker and simply copy and paste. But now with AI, and this is the reason I think it's so controversial, is the generative AI literally, you know, they can have AI within a matter of seconds write an essay for them.
SPEAKER_02And if we're being honest, it's it can do a pretty good job of writing that essay. But the cheating itself, I mean, it's it's nothing, you know, nothing new.
SPEAKER_03It's nothing new, absolutely nothing new. But it has, it has changed. The landscape has changed, it's not that way anymore. And now it is just it's become, as you said, easier. So I think the the first thing that I I sort of want to talk about is the college board did a survey, uh, I believe this is last year, where they uh looked at they talked to 3,000 higher education faculty in a lot of different disciplines, and 92% said that they were that the faculty are deeply concerned about plagiarism facilitated by generative AI.
SPEAKER_03Should we be?
SPEAKER_02It's a it's a tricky answer or a tricky question because it's for me personally, it's a it's a no, and but it's also a yes. Wow, where do we even begin with this with AI? I mean, it's such a you know, I I don't in terms of the students themselves, I don't feel necessarily that we should be concerned with uh with it replacing the learning that's taking place. I think where we have to be careful is you know, we have to teach the students how to use AI.
SPEAKER_02You know, if if AI is replacing the end product, then they're not learning. You know, if they're just simply asking AI, hey, write this paper for me. But if they're using it for idea generation, for suggestion, for editing, for you know, the the proper uses, then I don't personally have a problem with them using AI. But again, we have to we have to teach the students how to use it in an academic setting. And I think for too long, you know, at least the last couple of years, faculty have been kind of, you know, let's let's look at how do we catch students as opposed to, you know, well, well, let's think this through in a different way of how can we teach them how to use it rather than just trying to, you know, because I've always felt that my job is to teach, my job is not to police.
SPEAKER_02You know, I've got a class of 25 students, and you know, okay, are some students going to slip through that that use AI that I don't catch? Yes. Am I going to be all up in arms about that? No. I mean, ultimately there it's it's a it's detrimental to the students themselves, and I think over time they will learn that. But I'm more concerned with the 20 students in my class that want to truly learn um, you know, how to write a paper, how to organize, how to think critically.
SPEAKER_04Um Yeah, I really like what you said there about the the policing. So there's there's all of these AI detectors, for instance, but but that's not our that in my opinion, that's not my job. I don't want to have to constantly go through and and police and and look, not necessarily just at the content, but to see was this student using these AI tools in some capacity? And and I know that they're the the detection tools are getting better and and but so are the the quote unquote cheating mechanisms, right?
SPEAKER_04So um reframing and and learning that our jobs are not to police and rather to teach students how to use these these tools that we have ethically, um, I think that's really you know our job.
SPEAKER_03And I th I and honestly, if a student wrote an essay for me or a student wrote a speech for me and they put it into AI and said, Hey, can you change the wording of this to make it sound a little bit better? That's not gonna bother me that much. Because they still wrote the original piece. Like that doesn't make for me, that's not plagiarism, that's enhancement.
SPEAKER_02Right. It's it's more I think, and this is where I think teachers have to kind of rethink this. It's more about the process as opposed to the product. Yes. Because I'm more concerned with did they learn the process? Did they, you know, did they get out of this what I needed them to learn versus the end product, if they run it through AI and ask for, hey, can you give me some suggestions on this? I'm not so much concerned with that. Again, it's it's where the line gets crossed is if they simply go to AI and ask it to generate and take themselves completely out of it.
SPEAKER_02You know, hey, I've got to write this, you know, in your case, I've got to write this speech, write a speech for me. Well, there's no critical thinking, there's no organization, there's no communication that the student's learning, and that's where the line gets crossed. But as far as using AI, you know, in the right way, I'm all for it.
SPEAKER_03Funny, I had a student uh turn in yesterday or no two days ago, turn in their speech on a piece of paper, on rehandwritten. And I just kind of said to myself, I could scold him and say, I asked for it typed, but then I thought he didn't use AI to write this. Like I feel better about this now. Uh, and to be fair, the student was, you know, in in an older student, so they they were they were probably not gonna use AI anyway. But it's still like it still kind of was just like I feel okay about this now.
SPEAKER_03I I don't really feel like it's sort of again that policing thing of I have this policy in place.
SPEAKER_04You're supposed to hand you're supposed to type things, but eh it goes to show that we're really changing with the the things that are that are changing around us, right?
SPEAKER_03And and it's interesting because a lot of a lot of institutions, including uh the ones that I worked at, um really rushed to to jump on that AI detection uh bandwagon. Um but is AI detection AI detection is not the end all be all of of finding out if somebody's cheating.
SPEAKER_02No, it's not. And you know, this was because because my perspective, I have two sides to this, one being, you know, still being an English professor, and then the other being an administrator now. And so I s I've seen it from both sides, and and going into administration, one of the things that you know I would have to to basically get out there is, you know, just because we you know we use Turnitin here, and Turnitin has a built-in AI detector, but suspicion alone is not grounds for you know a violation.
SPEAKER_02I mean, you you can't just look at that and say, well, Turnitin says this was AI generated. Well, that doesn't mean the student didn't, you know, didn't write it. And and this is where it becomes important for as faculty members to build the rapport with the students. Know your students well enough that you can have a conversation with them. Because nine times out of the out of ten, if you built that rapport and you talk to the student, they'll admit to, you know, hey, I just I ran out of time, you know, I I just I ran it through AI and had AI write it for me.
SPEAKER_02They'll admit to it. But it's if you haven't built that rapport with the students and they don't feel comfortable talking to you about it, it's going to be an issue. But from an administrative standpoint, if if a faculty member came to me and simply said, hey, this student plagiarized or you know, used AI and I gave him a zero, I'm like, okay, well, what's your what are you basing that on? And well, it it just looked very suspicious. Okay, well, that's not, you know, that that's that's not grounds for you know failing the student or giving them a zero. There has to be more than just that.
SPEAKER_02And you know, the AI detectors, it's even that, I mean, there's AI rephrasers now. Um, I mean, there's ways around it. It's always an ongoing battle. And it's like Twilight, what she said, you know, is is when I'm teaching a class, I don't, I just never felt it's my responsibility to police everything.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02You know, if if I notice something and it raises a red flag, then yes, I'm gonna have that conversation, but I'm not gonna nitpick every single sentence of an essay to figure out, did you use AI to write this?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. You know, it it brings me to the thought about our our syllabi, right? All of our syllabus policies in AI. So I allow a lot of different types of AI. And in certain of my certain projects that I'm doing, I encourage AI because I think it's something that we need to, as I mentioned earlier, we need to teach our students how to use it responsibly and and when it would be appropriate to use in different opportunities. So I have verbal reviews, but one of the things that I've noticed about myself is I I crave that authentic voice in papers and discussions and things like that.
SPEAKER_04Um, but also when something is written with professionalism and with um a quality that I haven't seen in some of my other students, I I will double read it. I'll I'll be like, ooh, is this AI? And then I'll have to check it against some of the other writing that that student has done. And that that's not necessarily fair, but it it's a reality of you know where we're at. I I don't necessarily run every discussion post through an AI checker, but I I do unfortunately, if I see something that's very well written, I automatically think sometimes, ooh, was this written by AI?
SPEAKER_04You know, and that's that's not a good thing necessarily, but it is my reality.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and it's interesting because you know, I've been I've been teaching English now for 23 years, and you know, it used to, even before AI or anything else, before the internet, I mean, I could look at an essay, and if it was writing better than what I could produce, it would it would raise a question, like, this is really good. Um, you know, and so I might have a conversation with the student, but even then I I I hate because then that's almost saying, well, the a student's not capable of producing that kind of writing.
SPEAKER_02And so I think it's a double-edged sword, you know, in terms of I I never want to accuse a student, you know. I tell them, I I hope I get a student that can write at a PhD level.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_02And and I think we kind of get into some some tricky ground there when we just start assuming that, oh, this is too good. It must have been written by AI. And and that's where I personally, as a as a teacher, I have an issue with because I think that's demeaning to our students in terms of, you know, oh, well, they're not capable of producing this kind of writing. They must have used something else.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And I have to, I have to check myself. I have to be like, okay, no, let's let me look at some of the other things. Uh, but I I know that implicit bias that I have in myself, and I I want to I want to be aware of that. So um I I know that we always like to talk practically as well about some tips that we can we can do. Um, but in this segment, we were really talking about defining plagiarism. And I think that sometimes even what like you were talking about, Andy, the the absence of a citation.
SPEAKER_04So sometimes our students will use it for for grammarly or in telewriter or something like that. So without that citation of I used AI to help me clean things up or something like that, we're really encouraging our students to make sure that we're citing AI if we if we're allowed to use it and we did use it in this way, make sure that we're citing that as well.
SPEAKER_03And I think that there are some instructors who don't realize that you can just you can create a form, just create a form and have your students fill it out and say, this is what I did with AI. Especially if you allow AI in your classroom, which I think is important. Or we're gonna take a break and we'll get to uh discussing sort of the panic that has begun to uh take over after this. We're back. And I think that uh in the second segment, we're gonna sort of shift and and talk about I I we're talking about ethics, I think, a little bit more here, because plagiarism itself is ethics, but I think we're talking more about the ethics of you know, when when are students making these decisions, but also when are faculty members making decisions that maybe are poor decisions as it comes to AI.
SPEAKER_03Um, so let's let's talk about students first and then we'll jump into the faculty aspect of it. Because I think the faculty aspect is a little bit more interesting, but the student aspect I think is is sort of the same old, same old that we can sort of jump through real quick.
SPEAKER_04Right, because you said in in segment one, we said that sometimes AI is is a good thing, right? We need to teach our students how to use AI in a in a way that is appropriate and ethical.
SPEAKER_03And I think that when when you know, and Mortimer had brought this up, the idea of using it to enhance, using it as a way to uh give you ideas, idea generation. I mean, I sit and I talk to my AI about philosophical issues. Um, but but using it to to do those things is an ethical process. It is an uh uh and does there's I would say there's no real gray area there to say, hey, chat GPT, I'm interested in these things.
SPEAKER_03Can you give me a speech topic? Hey, uh, hey Google Gemini, I'm really interested in being able to write a um essay on tornadoes. Is there any information about tornadoes that you can give me that I could use as a uh a stepping stone to be able to begin coming up with ideas for my main points?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and those are all good examples of the right way to use, you know, AI. And and and the problem is in terms of talking about ethics, is that you know, I think a lot of times we just look at this from an administrative or a faculty standpoint versus the student standpoint of they've grown up with this. This is not, you know, we can sit here and say, well, don't use AI. It's impossible because it's integrated into everything. And I think a lot of times, and this is why I think it's important to teach them how to use it, is because they don't think what they are doing is necessarily wrong.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. And that's not on them, that's not their fault. They just nobody's told them that, hey, that's not your you're you're you're shortcutting there, and you're it's gonna be detrimental to you long term. Um, and that's where the AI teaching on our part comes in is to show them, you know, if you're gonna if you're gonna say, well, I allow AI in my class, what does that mean to the student? You know, it's not just about the policies, you actually have to spend time in class showing them, hey, this is how you can use AI, this is what's acceptable.
SPEAKER_02And you know, the same goes, I know that there's some instructors out there that don't want to use AI. And I don't have a problem with that. But if you're gonna say AI is not allowed in this class, you need to provide an explanation as to why, and then you need to tell them exactly what that means. You know, because if they're using Microsoft Word and it's coming up and correcting their grammar, is that I mean, that's not generative AI, but that's AI. I mean, is that not then or are they I mean, how do you handle that?
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_03And every professor, no grammarly. That means no nothing of anything, exactly.
SPEAKER_04Right. And every professor's policies are different, and so it can be very confusing as to what is allowed and what isn't.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I don't think because this has come up a lot, is should there be a standardized policy? And I don't think that there should be. Um, you know, here we have several different they can choose a no AI policy, a limited AI policy, or they can use AI. You know, again, I think it's up to the instructor to um define exactly what they mean, uh, you know, and let and ultimately let them, but whatever your policy is, make sure the students understand that, teach them what you mean, and then just abide by your own policy.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. I think that's that's the ethical approach. And I think if students take that ethical approach, then they're they're doing things correctly the right way. And if you're using it as a prompt, if you're using it to to come up with ideas, if you're using it to maybe uh and as I said before, enhance. Like if you submit your outline and put it into Chat GPT and say, can you can you tell me like where I can make this a little bit stronger in terms of like usage of language? That doesn't bother me as an instructor. That doesn't, that doesn't it doesn't take away to the fact that you still wrote that speech.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02You wrote it again, it's the process, and it's that process.
SPEAKER_03And and I would love, and then that's for me, I'd be like, Oh, show me what it did because I'm interested. Because every time that I've asked it to write an outline, it doesn't know how to write an outline, which is interesting.
SPEAKER_04So, what about those times when the students feel like there is no Option. There is absolute panic, and they feel like that's their only choice. There's panic, right?
SPEAKER_02Again, I think, and there are students because of the just time crunch or or outside work or or just life in general, that those situations are going to come up. But again, I think that's the importance of building the rapport with the students, of being able to sit down and and talk with them. And I will say that that is much easier in a face-to-face class than an online setting, which I know a lot of faculty, me included, you know, I never taught an online class until COVID hit.
SPEAKER_02And I will not teach an online class. Um, if I had to teach it, yes, I would, but I I prefer to have all my classes face-to-face. And it's not necessarily because of the AI or anything like that. It's the communal aspect of, you know, interacting with the students. I mean, for me, that's what teaching's all about. And you just can't capture that in an online setting, no matter what you I've tried everything, and it's just you don't get the same experience. And so I would rather just be in a face-to-face setting where I can have these conversations with students of, you know, hey, they just ran out of time and and you know, used AI.
SPEAKER_02And we're gonna sit down and talk about that and talk about why that's not acceptable. And um, you know, we're gonna work, you know, how do how do we fix that going forward, you know?
SPEAKER_03Which I think is also another podcast episode talking about online learning. Um I think the the the biggest I think that so so let's shift and talk about faculty use. Because I think there's also an ethical uh ethical discussion need that needs to be brought up with this as well. I I use AI to come up with rubrics, I use AI to uh enhance like when I put when I when I create a um an assignment, I might put it into AI and say, hey, can you enhance this to make it seem uh more logical or or things like that and and aspects of that?
SPEAKER_03That's sort of where my and I'll use it for idea generation too, but that's sort of where my beginning and end point of AI is. Like I will not ask AI to grade for me. Yeah. And I know that there are instructors out there who do. And I think that that is where the ethics start to become a little bit more tricky.
SPEAKER_02That's that's a big ethical and moral issue because yeah, I mean, it's like why you know, if you're gonna have AI grade the student essays, why are you even teaching the class? Correct.
SPEAKER_03Just just turn it over to AI at that point, and there are AI classes now. There are there are campuses that are putting completely AI generated classes where the AI grades, creates the class, runs the class.
SPEAKER_02And you know what? But as a student, if I know that, that's fine. You know, they know that going into it that hey, this is gonna be, you know, AI is gonna be running this, AI is gonna be doing the grading. But if I'm taking a class face to face and you know, I'm I'm expecting feedback from my professor, I want the feedback from my professor, not from AI.
SPEAKER_04Wow.
SPEAKER_03And I think the the other the other jumping off point of that is if if you are using AI as an instructor, you need to tell your students that you're using AI.
SPEAKER_00Right. Models.
SPEAKER_03You need to tell them that, hey, this model or this uh this rubric was created with AI.
SPEAKER_02Just be transparent about it. But the irony here is that for those teachers that have a no AI policy, I'm curious as to how many of them, if they're themselves actually using AI to because I I use AI all the time. You know, when I'm teaching, I'll, you know, again, like you said, I don't use it to to generate my entire lesson plan, but I will I will tell it, you know, hey, here's what we've been covering, here's what we're talking about next week, here's ideas that I have. Do you have any suggestions?
SPEAKER_02And then, you know, I still have to look through, and ultimately it's my choice, but I have to look through and determine, oh, well, that that's not a good idea, that's not gonna work, or hey, you know what? I never thought about this. I want to try this. And and it was AI that came up with the idea. It's still up to me to implement it and then figure out, did this work? You know, sometimes things work, sometimes things don't. Yeah. But uh, yeah, when you when you especially being an English professor, I mean, uh one of the things I love about it is reading the student essays and and giving comments because you know, people always ask, don't you ever get bored of teaching the same thing?
SPEAKER_02And I'm like, no, because they're different students every semester. Right. So it's different ideas, different perspectives. And I love, even though it's very time consuming, you know, that's that's what I love the most is reading about their ideas. So turning that over to AI to provide feedback is a huge ethical issue. Yeah. It sounds great.
SPEAKER_04It sounds like the the the similarities between a student just handing over and having AI write the paper and then a faculty just handing over the paper to let AI grade the paper. Those are very egregious AI uses, right? We wouldn't want either of those.
SPEAKER_03Similar egregious, in my opinion.
SPEAKER_04I think either of those things to to occur. So we could utilize, so in uh as a faculty member, I will sometimes uh employ AI to um to let students practice and get that AI feedback. So we're we're practicing, we're in a interviewing unit right now. And so the official assessment will be done by me in a live or in a in a WebEx interview, but we can utilize AI to get feedback on resumes, or we can utilize AI to get feedback in uh in an interview setting.
SPEAKER_04Um, but that's for their practice, right? Before the actual assessment. So I think that would be appropriate, sort of like we could, you know, they could get run it through uh grammarly, right?
SPEAKER_03And Twila's talking about a program actually that's really cool that actually has them do an interview to the AI and the AI gives them feedback.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03And I think that's great. I think it's fantastic. But if you were using that as the final assessment of it, then they wouldn't need me. That's it, right? That's where the issue comes in. Right. And that's where the final that's where the issue comes in. But if you're using it as practice, yeah, I don't have a that's not a problem. That's that's that is a good use of artificial intelligence.
SPEAKER_04But I I think it makes me sad to think that that faculty would then use that as a as their the final grade, right? Because we can't then reflect on it and we can't grow from that.
SPEAKER_03Well, and if you go back uh a few episodes back to the the one from January where we talked about artificial intelligence, my my colleague, my friend, he actually talked about how one of his his colleagues came up to him and said, Oh my gosh, I've got this great, I've I've been able to get Chat GPT to actually grade my papers. And he turned to him and said, No, no. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So I I actually tried this before because I was just curious because I had heard professors were using it. So I input the rubric, uploaded a student essay, you know, took off all their identifying information, and I just simply asked it, hey, provide feedback on this. And I didn't even ask it to grade it. I just said provide feedback on this. And I mean, instantaneous. It, you know, it provide, and it was, you know, some of the some of the comments were a little off for the majority of the feedback.
SPEAKER_02It was actually really good. I that's the only time I've ever done that because I'm like, no, this would, yeah, I could grade, you know, it literally takes me, you know, a class of 25 students, and I'm having to grade 25 essays, I can usually get three to four done an hour. You know, so it's taken me quite a few hours to go through just one class and then multiply that by five. But if AI could grade 125 essays in literally probably 10 minutes, you know, but then again, it takes the human aspect, it takes me out of the equation.
SPEAKER_02And and that's yeah, I I just I again it gets back to the ethical, you know.
SPEAKER_04Right. You know, it's interesting though, because I had a student this summer who said that's what they did for their own paper. And it they ran their paper through with my rubric through an AI and said, give me the feedback that my professor would give me so that I can make the edits before I turn it in. And then whenever I ran it through an AI checker, because that's just one of the things that occurs whenever they do turn it in, um, it came back as 100% um AI.
SPEAKER_04But I knew based on because I had him in an in-person class, I knew this was the same kind of language that he used in class. Sometimes it was not um great professional writing and things like that. I was like, hey, let's have a conversation because I know that this is your writing based on our face-to-face conversations, um, but it's 100% AI. Talk me through your process. And he's like, Oh, yeah, I ran it through with your rubric and it blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And it was just really interesting perspective.
SPEAKER_04So I think that again, when we were talking about the AI checkers, when we're talking about the processes, if you have that rapport with students, it it can give you some really interesting insight. But to hand off the grading, that would just break my heart.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Lighten your load, yes, but unethical for sure.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. All right, let's take a break and we'll get to talking about proofing versus integrating next. And we're back, and we're gonna talk about uh AI proofing uh versus AI integrating. And I think that's something we sort of established at the beginning was that I think all of us feel like integration is something that is very important in today's age. We have students who are going to be graduating, they're gonna be moving off into the workplace, and they're gonna be moving off into the workplace.
SPEAKER_03It's gonna ask them, Do you understand how to use AI? Do you understand how to use AI correctly? And I think a lot of those students are going to, a lot of the students, some of them are going to say sure, and then they're gonna fall into those pitfalls that we talked about before with, oh, it just you know, do this, and not have any way to understand how to talk to AI, how to work with AI. It's just no, you need to do this now and you need to fix this now. I think that we teach our students and move our students more in the right direction, if we get away from this idea of saying no to AI and saying, let's teach you how to use it the right way.
SPEAKER_03I think the first thing that I sort of want to bring up uh is actually something is comes from the uh the workforce uh expects AI competence article uh from actually from Turnitin uh that basically says that 67% of students believe that demonstrating AI proficiency is critical for their postgraduation employability. I think the other 33% are lying to themselves. I think it should be a hundred percent. Uh being able to understand how to use these on how to put together your own creating your own sort of uh talking I don't know how to describe this, but your own rapport with the AI models helps you be able to be better at using that those particular models.
SPEAKER_03And if we're not teaching students how to do that, I think we're doing them a huge disservice. I agree. So I think we're pushing ourselves to a point where I think that we have to sort of get away from this idea where no needs to not be the answer anymore. Instead, it needs to be more along the lines of here's how to do it the right way.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_03We can't just hide in a and put our head in the sand and so what do we do to to to uh do that, but also make it so that students are doing authentic work.
SPEAKER_04Well, what have you done, Andy? What have you done in your courses to show authentic assessments?
SPEAKER_03I've definitely moved away from uh and I haven't should I shouldn't say this, I've done this my entire time teaching, and then I'm gonna sort of equate it to online because I think that's where we're seeing it obviously the most. But I think what I've done is I've turned a lot of my discussions are very specific and they very they ask you very specific questions about your life. Now, generative AI has gotten better at answering those things, but at least like before, I would say maybe the last like six or seven months, it has been very good because it's been very hard to use AI to actually answer those discussion questions.
SPEAKER_03I would say now it's getting because I've even used generative AI, I've tossed my discussions into generative AI and it's it's come up with some pretty good answers.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03Uh but I think that if you if you take those, if you if you're able to just move things to a more specific environment and do those types of things, it gets a little bit easier for or not easier, but it gets a little bit harder for them to sort of push themselves into just say, Hey, Chat GPT, write this for me.
SPEAKER_04Right. One of the things that I've done, now I think uh we have a little bit of a luxury because we're in a communications course, but one of the things that I've done is have more verbal discussions. So even though they are low stakes, we will I'll instead of having them write a discussion, I want to, even in my online and especially in my online courses, I want to see them with a video. I want to see and hear them having a discussion about whatever it is that we're talking about. So it could be just a minute or two, but I want to have them have an academic conversation on video and or audio about whatever the content is.
SPEAKER_04And it doesn't have to be very long, it doesn't have to be super formal, any more formal than it would be in a a short discussion post, but they've actually really enjoyed it. Even in my face-to-face classes, I'm making them do this just to get in the practice of let's let's record, let's have a conversation with each other. And instead of just writing something, because I want them to not use the generative AI, because it's sort of like a journal, anyways, when we're doing some of those discussions and reflection type prompts.
SPEAKER_04What have you seen?
SPEAKER_02So, yeah, I'll I'll talk about this from the perspective of an English professor, is you know, and part of this is just I've always taught my classes in a more practical approach. And what I mean by that is I tell my students day one that even though this is an English class, this is not about a right, this is not about writing. You know, and I and and they're kind of taken aback by that because they're like, well, wait a minute, this is this has nothing, yes, you're gonna write essays, but that is not the purpose of this class. And again, if we're being honest, uh, you know, AI can can write the essay for them.
SPEAKER_02So I'm not trying to teach them how to write an essay. AI can do that. What I'm concerned with is the is the process. Again, and I keep coming back on that, but it's the process, it's being able to formulate your own ideas, um, organize them, uh, be able to structure them and then communicate efficiently and effectively and and really kind of hone in on that critical thinking, because you know, yes, AI can give us an answer, but is it is it a good answer? Is it the right answer? And they need to even be able to think about that of what AI is generating.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, I honestly I've never had a huge issue in in the face-to-face setting with even with the advent of AI, because all of the essays that I have my students do, again, focusing on the process, we they do most of the work in class. I give very little homework. And it's not because I'm against homework, it's just because I, you know, again, it's that communal aspect of teaching. We're gonna talk about everything in class. So I might let them come up with their own topic, but they have to talk to me about it.
SPEAKER_02It's not just tell me what you're, you know, write it down. You've got to come and talk to me and say, hey, here's my topic. Okay, great. Why do you want to write about that? They have to be able to explain it, they have to give me details. We work through the outline. And again, we're doing all this in class so that when they get to finally turning in that that essay, I already know what the essay's about because we've been working on it and discussing it in class. So then the whole AI thing, you know, if I get an essay that was not what they told me, right, you know, in terms of what we've been working on in class, then that's that's obviously a red flag.
SPEAKER_02It's like, hey, this is not what what you've been working on for the past two or three weeks. Where did this come from? So, you know, I I it's not I'm it's not that I'm trying to AI proof my classroom because you know, I'm I'm all for them. If they want to, that final paper, which is their rough draft, if they want to run it through AI, like you mentioned, and say, hey, can you give me some feedback on this? Um, you know, are there any areas that you think I should improve on or run it through grammarly? Have it look at the grammar. And again, this is all based on the context of of the class.
SPEAKER_02You know, if I'm teaching a grammar class, I obviously don't want them using grammarly because that defeats the whole purpose of what I'm trying to teach them.
SPEAKER_04But yeah, yeah, that makes sense.
SPEAKER_03And I think that you know, that it's funny because that's sort of what all these community college system advocates have put together in this idea of the process, process-based grading, localized and hyper-specific prompts, which is what I try to do, more localized and hyper-specific prompts, and then oral defenses, oral defenses and demonstration or presentation of them. And I think we've sort of covered all three of those gamuts right here, right, with the three different ideas that we've brought up. So I think, hey, we're doing the right thing. Um I hope so.
SPEAKER_02We can only try.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. But I think we also uh in that in that process, we need to teach. We need to teach them how to use AI. Right. We need to teach them how to do it in the classroom, and and that needs to be part of the process too. Right.
SPEAKER_04I I think that's really a valuable thing that you're talking about. And and one of the things that that I try to do is whenever I'm I'm using a a tool, like for instance, notebook LM, um, I use that. I I use some of the um the PowerPoints. I show them this is this was created by, or some of the podcasts that I'll supplement in my online classes. These are created by certain PowerPoints uh certain AIs. I'll say, why don't you guys check this particular one out or the designer feature in PowerPoint?
SPEAKER_04It's sort of an AI tool because there are certain things that they should be aware of that this is an appropriate use of AI. And why not go ahead and play with it in this safe space, in this classroom with encouragement? Because a lot of our students are terrified of using AI, of playing with AI because of the they've been told, you know, you'll get kicked out of school and then getting accused of you know, and getting a zero or failing the class and there's a lot of fear there.
SPEAKER_03And we did a campus survey where we asked students about their usage of AI. And I think that that was the number one thing that most students were afraid of using it because they were afraid of those consequences.
SPEAKER_04So I really pushed them into that in a in that safe space where it's a non-graded, but I I introduced them and and really encouraged them to play with it um with it within the confines of a non-graded assignment, um, to improve something or to to do something in the classroom, but just to to empower and to uh incite curiosity because I think that that's important.
SPEAKER_02And that's I I think there's been a shift too, because I remember when AI, you know, ChatGPT first came out a few years ago, and there was all this fear and panic about, you know, and there was all this professional development about, you know, talking about the AI integration. There was all this professional development specifically for faculty of how do we use this to catch students. And there's been a shift now, which is a good thing because, you know, but I think there needs to be more teaching, not just for the students of how to use, you know, AI ethically, but also for faculty.
SPEAKER_02You know, how can faculty use it? And and I'm not saying that they have to, and that's why I said I don't think there should be a standardized policy across the board. If you don't want to use AI in your class, that's fine. But for for those faculty that want to use AI, I do think there needs to be more professional development in terms of how can I use this? How can I use it to look at my syllabus, my rubrics, help me with classroom um, you know, ideas and generation and prep and use it the way it's supposed to be. But then also, at least from from an administrator standpoint, is to take it even one step further.
SPEAKER_02And then how can staff use AI? Because I mean, if we're being honest, if we're talking about preparing students for an AI workforce, well, we need to train our own workforce on, you know, how can they use AI to help them and they're not to you know, to replace them or not to supply what they're doing, but how can you use AI in your daily um work activities to make it more efficient, to help you, you know, which I I think is what AI is there for.
SPEAKER_03It's about increasing productivity and accuracy and making your job less tedious. Like it's about it's about reducing the tediousness of the positions, yeah, and more human so that we can do the things.
SPEAKER_04Exactly. And so we can do uniquely yes.
SPEAKER_03So we can answer so we can when you know a student comes to you, you can answer the student instead of having to sit there and and do work while you know it's taking place and be able to like have those in a one-on-one interactions. Right. I think that's where we need to move our focus.
SPEAKER_02And I think and the the the other thing about this is that you know, I I will admit I use AI, I mean, not extensively, but I use it quite a bit, even in my administrative role as dean. Um, you know, I'll chat with my chatbot and you know get ideas and suggestions, but ultimately, and this is where I think even for students teaching them that, where that critical thinking comes in, because the the responses I get back, ultimately the responsibility is on me for the final decision. So I need to have those critical thinking skills where I can look at what AI is providing and determine whether or not is this good, is this bad?
SPEAKER_02Because if anything happens, it's gonna come back on me.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02They're not gonna go after my chatbot to say, oh, well, they made a mistake and you're in trouble. No, it's gonna, it's my responsibility. Right. And I think this is what we have to teach students is that critical thinking of, you know, the answers you do get, are they worth what's being provided to you?
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_03And a lot of people have said that AI is gonna be the death of critical thinking. And I think it's the exact opposite. I think it it eliminates all of the other stuff that you don't have to worry about, so you can start thinking critically and doing coming up with creative ideas and more creativity and things like that. I think that yeah, AI does those things, but not well. Um but but it does it does open yourself up for more time to be more creative and have more creative ideas.
SPEAKER_04If you choose to do so.
SPEAKER_03If you choose to do so, exactly. Uh, I want to thank you for coming on, and we appreciate it. And we will have next month. This has been Ed, a frank discussion about topics that matter in education. The views expressed in this episode are those of the host, co-host, and any guests. They do not reflect the views or values of Lone Star College.
SPEAKER_03For further information about Ed, please visit our website at www.ed.buzzsprout.com. Ed was produced by Andy Luster and Twila Coy, music provided by Laborio Contefe.
Send us Fan Mail Welcome to Ed. - the podcast where we dig into the evolving landscape of higher education, teaching, and lifelong learning. Today, we’re stepping into the daily reality of the classroom - not the...
Send us Fan Mail Welcome to Ed. - the podcast where we dig into the evolving landscape of higher education, teaching, and lifelong learning. Today, we’re looking past the traditional four-year degree to explore how...
Send us Fan Mail This month on Ed. Andy and Twyla sit down with Jeremy Coffman, Speech Professor at Prairie View A & M University to talk about the concept of speech communities, what they are, how they effect us, and...
Send us Fan Mail This month on Ed. A special educational biography episode. Detailing the 33 year career of Eric Skiles, Professor of Theatre and Humanities and Artistic Director of Theatre at Lonestar College-...
Send us Fan Mail This month on Ed. Andy and Twyla are once again joined by Nicole Foley Nelson to discuss Transitions in the academic setting. How transitions are dealt with going from high school to college, within the...