Aaron Alpeter (00:00) in two thousand twenty-five.
When the tariffs first came out, you had two identical guitars that could cross the same border on the same day. And one of them would pay nothing and the other would pay 25%. And the difference was if a form had been filled out. all musical instruments that were imported in the US would have.
Like an average tariff rate of of 16.6%, which that and of itself was three times what it was in 2024.
everybody, welcome back to e-commerce on tap. I'm your host, Aaron Alpeter. Maybe you're folding laundry, maybe you're walking the dog or at the gym in between sets, wherever you are, thank you for spending part of your day with us. this season we are focusing on Mexico and we are looking at brands and trying to ask the question: Is producing in Mexico an artifact of USMCA and their proximity to the US? Or is it something deeper and something inherent about the Mexican market?
today we're gonna be talking about a company that builds guitars on both sides of the US-Mexico border. And we wanna try to figure out what it actually costs, how how big of an impact the tariffs have. And I'm really excited for my co-host today. we have Daniel Scharff. And so I'll let Daniel introduce himself. But Daniel and I have been in a fantasy football league for the last couple of years. he is the founder of Startup CPG, which if you are not a part of of that Slack group, you should pause the podcast, go sign up, and then come back.
but Daniel, thank you so much for for being on e commerce on tap.
Daniel (01:27) Absolutely. I'm happy to be here. I'm happy to dig into the story a little bit today. as someone who's also a musician, this is just a great topic to explore and as somebody who loves Mexico as well. I've gotten to spend actually a lot of time in Mexico on various projects, mostly before my CPG time, but also a little bit when I was working at Mars Chocolate. So this is gonna be fun.
Aaron Alpeter (01:49) Nice.
Well, I you know, I I know you well, I know your dog. Like, why don't you just give people the the TLDR on on who Daniel is?
Daniel (01:57) Absolutely. yeah, I run the world's biggest community inside this consumer packaged goods industry of ours. And it's something that I just started
very organically. I think I'm a natural community builder. Whatever I get excited about, I like to start sharing with other people and connecting with people over. So I've done that many times in my life, including I remember when I lived in Chicago.
In 2004, I started a Spanish-speaking practice group because I had just come back from a summer in Buenos Aires and I wanted people to practice with. So I actually created this 700-person Charlar
Aaron Alpeter (02:28) No way.
Daniel (02:28) Chicago Spanish group. So I've always done that. And when I went, I was at Mars Chocolate. So my career path was like business school into management consulting. And then I just kind of got bored of these random back office cost reduction things. Wanted to do something that was more tangible, so got into CPG, went to Mars.
That was cool. Love CPG, but just kind of too big of a company and didn't care so much about the actual products there. So then I got into better for you stuff. And I was so excited about the industry. I just wanted to connect with people. I was just some guy at a Better For You company, didn't know anybody. So I started creating meetups and then eventually launched an online community. And it scaled so quickly. And I've had great people on my team working with me. And today it is one of the biggest entrepreneurship business communities.
Out there in the world. We have an online Slack community with 40,000 people in it. and our podcast is super fun. Also, I know you've been on there with me talking about some of the tariff stuff in the past, startup CPG podcast. And then we do 75 events per year. We have not yet done an event in Mexico, although I have actually brainstormed it a few times with people because there is a great community of CPG entrepreneurs.
in Mexico as well, especially in Mexico City and Monterrey. So that is on my vision board is to get to do that at some point.
Aaron Alpeter (03:48) before we get into Taylor guitars, we we have a tradition on e commerce attack where we talk about a tidbit. this is something that has nothing to do with what we're talking about, but just something that's interesting. And I wanted to talk to you a little bit about just these proliferation of the agentic assistance. So Grokbot, Muse, Dots, OpenClaw, Hermes, like all these things are coming through. And what I find is is really interesting, not that they exist, but the same time that we have these
agentic harnesses coming out. There are a lot of founders I talked to who are taking a a critical rethink of AI in their business. And so I remember being at one dinner about a month ago and the CEO basically said, hey, we we took AI out of all of our customer service. And he said, you know, used to have a chat bot, we used to have a thing that we could do there. And yeah, tickets were going down. But now we've we've gone the other way and we we encourage our customers to FaceTime us if they have a question because we're trying to prove that we are
real and human and that we're we're differentiating ourselves because everybody else is going left, we're gonna go right. And so I'm just curious, have you played with Muse or anything like that? Like what's your thought on where that's gonna ultimately land?
Daniel (04:57) So I yeah, it's very complex because I definitely use it in some ways. I'm not an expert user, I'm not running Claude co-work on a bunch of stuff. Like I'm not at that level, I think there's so much that you can get out of it. I think also the potential for
Exhaustion with AI is high. So that doesn't surprise me that a company is talking about it that way. Because I will say, when it can be used well, I'm fine. If I need to call into customer service, if they can actually help me, then great. But I feel like if it was such an easy question that AI could help me with, I would know how to help myself with it. And I can get on their website and figure it out. But something has gone wrong, and your frickin' AI bot is not making this any easier. And connect me to the agent.
So I think I feel like it can be so frustrating when they're basically just regurgitating a BS FAQ back to you. You're like, I'm a smart person. I don't need this. I what I need is for you to go in and like actually fix the error that I'm getting. of all the companies that I shop from, I know which ones have a great customer service experience. Just it's not like I think about it that way, but I do think about when I'm purchasing something from them.
Of like, have I had an issue? Have I had to return something? Is that easy to do? If it's not, I may not shop with them again.
the other thing for me that I think about a lot,
all of the pervasiveness of AI and gosh, like I get so many annoying emails now because I think everyone can just blast everybody with the push of a button, like pitching just all sorts of nonsense.
Buyers in our industry are getting that too. And that actually is why we've seen an explosion in interest in in-person events. Because I think
Aaron Alpeter (06:28) Mm-hmm.
Daniel (06:29) it is just really a blessing to get away from all of the pitch slop that you get. And you always know when it's slop, if it's not handwritten to you. You always know because we're humans and we know what a human outreach is like. And I think people, it's just really gonna be an increased reaction against all of the AI out.
outreach that people focus even more on in-person stuff. So even if you are doing an agentic business, think about like how am I actually gonna get this in person to people because all of this automated outreach, I just really can't imagine how successful it would be.
Aaron Alpeter (06:57) yeah, it it's terrible. I mean I I'm on LinkedIn regularly and a couple of weeks ago I had forty messages. I'm like, all right, and thirty eight of them were somebody trying to sell me something that I didn't know.
it's interesting with the Agentix stuff because I think a year ago everybody was building a product to solve a specific problem and they're like, well, you know, I'll I'll take this part of your supply chain, your marketing, off your hands, and this agent will do it. And I'm actually seeing a push away from that. And people are like, no, no, no. I want you to teach me how to build it because you don't have the context of my business that I have. And so I need something that's going to teach me how to accelerate up that AI scale.
And so it's it's interesting.
Daniel (07:31) I know we have a very meaty topic to get into today.
Aaron Alpeter (07:34) Yes.
Let me let me set this table. So imagine that you are in a truck and you're going back and forth between San Diego and and Tijuana and in the back of this truck.
Daniel (07:44) All right. Are my arms bound
in this situation or am I of my own free will?
Aaron Alpeter (07:48) we're gonna go with the
free will piece. We're gonna go with the free will piece. No. but in
Daniel (07:51) Okay, not a kidnapping situation. Okay, good. I hear
I heard I'm in the back of a truck. I'm like, uh-oh.
Aaron Alpeter (07:57) You're in the back
of the truck going to Mexico, right?
Daniel (08:00) Okay, so in this situation I'm a guitar. Great.
Aaron Alpeter (08:03) Your guitar, yeah. And
this truck is going back and forth from Mexico to San Diego every day and it's full of guitar parts. But it's not clear if this guitar is finished or or like if it's gonna be a three hundred dollar guitar or it's gonna be a three thousand dollar guitar. It's just moving materials back and forth. Like and and that's like the the element that we want to talk about is is Taylor guitars and the fact that they have two factories.
Within a short drive of one another that are actually operating as a single factory and just how the border complicates all of that.
Daniel (08:36) That is very interesting. And like if any element of that is to be smart around tariff stuff, then I can imagine there was a very smart consultant at some point who did a deep dive on that project, which is the magic that I used to do and came up with a very intelligent, crafty solution. Okay, so man, I I am a musician, I would say not like an amazing one.
thanks for asking. Yes, I have an album on Spotify. It's super fantastic. So that's two words. My album is called Home. But I play on some of the songs I'm playing ukulele, but I never actually mastered the guitar. I even bought one, but I'm like, I know. It's actually way harder than the ukulele. Ukulele only has four strings.
Aaron Alpeter (09:15) Is it okay?
Daniel (09:16) It's so easy to play. You can play a song the first day you get it. Guitar is more complicated. Your fingers cramp. But can you I wonder, could you just start and tell me a little bit about Taylor guitars? Like what's the background of the company? How to get started? How big is it?
Aaron Alpeter (09:30) Yeah, so it started in nineteen seventy-four. So there was somebody named Bob Taylor, who was just an eighteen-year-old kid that was working at a small San Diego guitar shop. called American Dream. And the owner decided that they didn't want to be in the guitar business anymore, and so they were gonna sell their business. And so this eighteen year old kid pulls together with co-workers, Kurt Listug and and Steve Schemmer.
And they decide to buy the company. And they decide to rename it to Westland Music Co. And they started to do like their own sort of retail distribution in 1976. It's still a private company. and they they got into actually making guitars. And so they build about 700 guitars a day between these two factories in in Mexico and in San Diego, and these guitars are sold in about 65 different countries.
specifically
the cities are El Cajón in California and Tacate in Mexico. And it's about 45 minutes drive from one to the other, including a border crossing. And so we think about these things, it's not really like two separate factories, but it's just like two rooms in a building that happen to have a 45-minute hallway.
they build their their baby Taylor, the big baby and the GS Mini, and a lot of the lower end guitars in Mexico. And then the higher end ones, the 300 series and up, are built in California and they also have a custom shop.
Daniel (10:45) how did they actually create the facility in Mexico? Do you know like when that happened, why they decided to do it? What like were there tariffs then at all? Or was it really just about them trying to get some more efficient
Manufacturing on some components of the guitar, or do they originally manufacture the whole guitar there and then just change some of this stuff later?
Aaron Alpeter (11:06) Yeah, it it's really interesting. And we'll kind of see in this that the tariffs were kind of a non-starter. Like it they it really wasn't a thing that they considered. And they started doing this around 2000. they didn't move any guitar manufacturing, they actually moved case manufacturing. So like the the actual cases that you use to carry your guitar in. And so they said, all right, we're gonna try this, we're gonna set up case manufacturing in Tijuana. it's still close enough that we can hold our quality standards.
We can flex our leadership to be down there, but we're gonna start with cases first and we're gonna figure out in a product that, you know, if we stock out, it's not the worst thing, we can fix these sorts of things and and then we'll eventually dip our toe into instruments.
Daniel (11:42) if you're talking about manufacturing in Mexico, there are gonna be a lot of questions that you have. Like a lot of it is gonna be around certifications and
like a quality and I think just a lot of unknowns what do you think are some of the benefits then for them about being able to manufacture
in both places or in Mexico versus US
and and
Aaron Alpeter (12:02) Yeah.
Daniel (12:03) vice versa.
Aaron Alpeter (12:04) Well, first and for foremost, I am a huge advocate of Mexican manufacturing. I think like the talent, the quality, the proximity, everything is awesome there. And for Taylor, they've kind of gone through and said, well, you know, first we we have to look at cost. And it's just inherent that the labor cost in Mexico, even if you're just south of the border, is lower than what you'd have in Southern California. And so just the access to to that labor to
different wage structures and things like that was really good. And the fact that it was so close meant that they could take advantage of those cost savings without sacrificing quality because if they needed to, their leadership could wake up in San Diego, go to Tijuana, work with the folks there to make sure that they understood what the quality things were, and then come back. when Apple moved to to China, for probably 10 or 12 years, they were sending their entire engineering team to China.
For weeks at a time. And so like that's a just a very difficult, very expensive thing to do. It is so close to the US. I remember when when I was at Mirror it was a huge benefit for us to s to say, all right, I can be on the same time zone or roughly the same time zone, have a call. if I need to go to Mexico, it's not the end of the world. Whereas you know, some of my friends over at Peloton, they were waiting for twelve hours to talk to somebody in Taiwan or they're
you know, on a 15-hour flight to go fix things. And so it's just much easier to look at this. And I think the last part is, there is an inherent tax advantage with USMCA, where, a lot of these products, if they are captured and produced in this in the right way, can enter duty free. And so you get all these benefits of of the cost and the labor quality and and the proximity. And you're able to actually come in with with it effectively being the same as if you produced it in the US.
Daniel (13:45) Okay, so because when you set this up, I I thought what you were gonna be setting up is like, because there are these high tariffs, they're actually doing something a little bit complex where it's like, you know, they're trying to play a game around when is it a finished product or what exactly is gonna get tariffed on what basis, or you know, like a lot of complex tax strategy or tariff strategy stuff there. But it sounds like, I mean, one, that is actually amazing the way you're describing it. Cause I think if you could
have a factory that feels like your factory, which it sounds like it does in this case, because they're like 45 minutes away. Like that just feels like home and they're part of your team at that point. That's awesome. That's a really ideal situation, especially just because there, yeah, it's gonna be a huge labor difference in Mexico versus California. So that's very cool. But sounds like what you're saying is given the way that the regulations are right now and tariffs, it may not even be as much of that because they actually could import finished product, finished guitars.
without triggering a lot of the tariffs.
Aaron Alpeter (14:42) Exactly. we will talk about tariffs and tariffs do have a big story to tell, in the last couple of years. But I'm just trying to set the baseline here where, for twenty years of their existence, this is just what it was. And and crossing the border was the same thing as as, you know, going to the next town hour. We don't think about
how difficult it is to go from one city to the next city or even crossing state lines. And that's really how they were thinking about this. And, just tacos were better on one side than the other.
Daniel (15:07) That is that is pretty interesting to think about. When I ran a beverage company, we were actually very interested in trying to figure out how to find a manufacturing partner in Mexico. And honestly, I couldn't figure it out. Like I'm a pretty well-networked person inside of my industry. And I would ask all sorts of people, because like we really needed those, we needed cost savings from with a quality manufacturer. And it never even got to the point where somebody could tell me the name of a company that I could reach out to. It was like
Aaron Alpeter (15:33) Mm.
Daniel (15:34) honestly very
like frustrating 'cause I'm like, like hey, does anyone know? And I would like I even I knew people in the beverage industry even from like Central America and South America and like, you know, not just outside of the US and like just no one seemed to know the names of those companies. It wasn't really available online. I'm a little jealous that they figured out how to really have a strong partner in that way. but
Aaron Alpeter (15:57) Yeah. Well, I mean, I
I would imagine some of the difficulties that that you were facing was just one, there are very few maquiladoras and I think there are even fewer food and beverage maquiladoras. And so I think that the the universe of folks you could look at were pretty small there. a lot of times you're seeing things based around like the auto industry or or metals or electronics or things like that.
So that's a little bit easier to do here. I think in their case, they set up a factory and they said, we're just gonna, form or buy a maquiladoras and we're just gonna operate ourselves versus finding a partner who's gonna do it for us.
Daniel (16:29) That seems very smart in retrospect. We did not have the money or wherewithal knowledge to do that ourselves, but that seems like it would make a lot of sense. Cause there is a lot of manufacturing that happens obviously in Beverage and Mexico. Like there's a lot of like the CBG industry does very well there, but that that makes a lot of sense. can you tell me a little bit more how the tariffs work for this kind of a product? Like how come they would be, they would qualify.
to avoid some of the tariffs. Like who like I don't even know the status of the tariffs right now, which is kind of embarrassing. But like what is the status? How come they would qualify? Who might not qualify? What's going on?
Aaron Alpeter (17:04) Yeah, well, I mean, you gotta check Twitter, although like I think it's
Daniel (17:07) Ha ha.
Aaron Alpeter (17:07) it's a little bit more stable at this point. I mean, right now there are tariffs in place. We still have USMCA. so the free trade agreement is still in force. but it's one of these things where the US has said that they're not opting to renew it automatically. And so there's like six years of negotiation before they turn off completely. and so it'll probably get sorted out at some point here in the next couple of years.
and it there'll probably be some version of a free trade agreement, it'll just be different than what it is today,
in two thousand twenty-five.
When the tariffs first came out, you had two identical guitars that could cross the same border on the same day. And one of them would pay nothing and the other would pay 25%. And the difference was if a form had been filled out. this is when the US put an extra twenty-five percent tariffs on goods coming from Mexico. all musical instruments that were imported in the US would have.
Like an average tariff rate of of 16.6%, which that and of itself was three times what it was in 2024. And a lot of the other guitar makers were trying to scramble and figure this out. they went to Washington, tried to lobby people. You know, you had people from Fender and Gibson and PRS and Martin that were trying to to figure these things out. And as IEEPA was was overrolled, the 25% tariff went away, the 10% came back.
And there's been a 10% tariff in place for Mexico since July of 2026. that's the baseline tariff, but they still may not be paying that depending on if they're on USMCA or
Daniel (18:30) Okay, and remind me again, like what would qualify a product for a USMCA exemption?
Aaron Alpeter (18:38) Yeah, so a lot of it is is paperwork, honestly. So USMCA is is the big free trade agreement between US, Mexico, and Canada. it's called Cuzma in Canada because Canada has to be first, and it's something else in Mexico because Spanish. but the the basic idea is to look at the country of origin to determine what's going to cross through. if we think about where tariffs used to be, they were about four or five percent on on like musical instruments coming in.
if the products were sourced from North America and a significant amount of the value was created in North America and you're able to file the paperwork, then you could say you're duty-free exemption. what they want to avoid is someone buys ninety-five percent of the product from China, brings it in, puts it together, and say, hey, you know, it's a product of Mexico. and so they they would push all that stuff out.
Daniel (19:25) And so I mean the impact of tariffs can be a lot bigger than you think, right? at least in the CPG world, it's not that's just not affecting only the consumer price.
Because you have things like retailer margin and the way the retailers work. So if you imagine like going to Safeway, they have a standard percentage that they are looking to make off a product that you sell them. And by the way, there's a distributor also that has a similar percentage they're going to look for to take your product and then take it to the retailer. if you as the company are seeing, don't know, let's say it's a 16% or 20%, whatever tariff on the product.
Like that's impacting you and how much you need to sell it for, but then you have to sell it at a higher price. And then they're taking a percentage on a higher price at that point. getting import tariff of let's say 20% could actually increase for the consumer the price, I don't know, by 30%. I'm just making up all these numbers, but it would be actually an exacerbated increase on the consumer price. So
then all my friends who would love to have one of these lovely Taylor guitars, in s all of a sudden they were budgeting two thousand dollars for it, but now the price has jumped to three thousand dollars and they're, back trying to save up for it.
Aaron Alpeter (20:32) it was interesting with tariffs and COVID, if you listen to what the Fortune five hundred earnings calls, they would talk about how much pricing power they had. And so whether it was COVID or inflation or tariffs, a lot of people saw this as an opportunity to right size their margins. it's difficult if there's no external factor,
that you can blame to say, hey, we're just gonna increase our prices by 30%. but if you can point to and say, you know, it's the tariffs or it's COVID or it's something else here, maybe you needed to increase your prices by 10%, but you're gonna go take that full 30% because you've got the opportunity to do that. The market will bear it because everybody else is doing it to some extent. let's suppose that Taylor was paying the customs value was like 200 bucks for a guitar crossing the border.
If they had to pay a 25% tariff, that's $50 a guitar. And like the compounding effect of that is yeah, it's not $25% off the sales price, but a wholesaler or retailer is going to look at that and they're going to, fix their margin along the way. And like you said, the consumer may end up with a 30% or a 40% increase when all said
and done.
Daniel (21:34) Yeah, that is that is really tricky. one thing I wanted to ask you is like, okay, so the components can come from different places, right? The various parts of guitar, sometimes there's specialty wood that they're bringing on. And I think that can come from all over the world. So, like, what are impacts of something like that on a supply chain, with the tariffs and everything? If, it's all getting sent to the factory.
the part that's in Mexico, but they're like ordering from all over the world and then that's coming into the US. Like, what are some of the dynamics there?
Aaron Alpeter (22:05) Yeah, it it's a it's a great question because Customs and Border Patrol does a lot more than just tariffs. And I think most people don't understand. Like they're they are making sure that companies tied to people on like terrorist watch lists don't get to sell or interact with the US. so you gotta be worried about that. there are certifications that need to happen in terms of health concerns or environmental quality or labor concerns.
anybody who's been importing anything that's cotton has obviously had to deal a lot with like cotton coming from the the Uyghur region of China. it's more than just tariffs, it's trade policy, is what they're enforcing. And what what's interesting is in 2017, Taylor actually got shut down because of a tree. And so rosewood is is kind of a key specialized wood that is used for just the sound of
of guitars, it's called a tone wood. there was a law that was passed that basically said we're going to protect endangered species, insane trees. And the entire genus of rosewood was put in an appendix that basically said, hey, we don't want to import rosewood because we want to tamp the demand.
And we don't w don't want to do that. And because it was so broad, it meant that moving rosewood, even if you already had it in the country, between Mexico and the US was now illegal. And most of the stuff came from India. And so it was it was a couple years where it was completely shut down before they could come back. And so this is something where it wasn't even like a treaty or a tariff that impacted Taylor. It was just a ruling that came through and said, hey.
We don't want to have this stuff coming into the country. And so even if you're taking it out and coming back in, you gotta find something else to do.
Daniel (23:45) How do you think the supply chain differs for a company like Taylor versus another industry? I mean, it could be food or beverage How what do you think that supply chain looks like and the challenges compared to other kinds of businesses and what they source to make their finished products?
Aaron Alpeter (24:02) To some extent, there's a lot of principles that are the same. you need something that is consistent that you can get on a regular basis and you can get as much as you need. whether that is sourcing lemons or, rosewood or microchips, you're kind of building your business and the way that you make money off of some assumptions that you're going to be able to get access to the things that you need at a price that you can afford. 80% of the problem is
the same across industries. I think what's really interesting is there are sometimes decisions that people will make that they just make because everybody else is doing it. And so with Taylor, there's this really interesting story about the ebony that they were searching. ebony is a wood. it's very dark. most of it comes from from Cameroon. And what the industry had basically done is say, hey, we we only want completely black fingerboards.
And so we, you don't know if the ebony tree is gonna be completely black until you cut it down. And so what happened a lot in in Cameroon is that they would cut down these trees, they look at it, maybe there was a brown grain in it or something like that, and it was just thrown away. And so it was estimated that about 90% of the ebony that was cut in Cameroon was thrown away, not because the wood was bad, but because it wasn't black enough.
if they can come back and take a look at these sorts of things, maybe they can say, all right, we're gonna we're gonna loosen that spec a little bit. And so what they ended up doing is they they bought their own mill and they said, okay, we're gonna instead of going from like one out of ten trees being good enough, we're gonna take it all and we're gonna like lean into the streakiness or things. I mean, it kind of reminds me of like Misfit Foods, if you remember that company where
Daniel (25:36) For sure.
Aaron Alpeter (25:37) even in the food system, there's all this stuff that you're, you know, kind of sourcing and throwing away and it's not quite working.
And we do that because we think a strawberry should look a certain way, a tomato should look a certain way. And you know, we just don't see that there's all of this variation in nature that comes through it.
Daniel (25:53) That's cool. It reminds me a little of like, yeah, definitely the kind of ugly produce or improper perfect produce and like figuring out how to make a good use of it. But also maybe something like Codopaxi, if you're familiar with that company, where I think they do some super cool stuff where you're like, yeah, I want that backpack. They're like, yeah, we cannot guarantee you what color it's gonna be or what it's gonna look like, because we are just taking whatever materials we are finding, recycled, whatever, and we're gonna stitch together something rad, but you're gonna like it.
I think with something like coffee, it's the same thing. Like I expect when I'm buying coffee, maybe I don't know, maybe naively. I just don't know that much about it, that it's always, it's gonna be the same thing every time. But there there are, even if you're buying the same brand that's sourced from a single place in a specific country, it's gonna actually have differences. And maybe I can even pick that up and but probably not. But interesting to think about their supply chain that way. But then also on top of
The wood, which you like, you really probably are spending a lot of time trying to get that right. Then they're gonna have a lot of other vendors in the supply chain that may have really tiny things that they're contributing to the overall finished good, but that are also essential. Cause I think it's like that in food and beverage as well, where like you may be making a beverage, maybe the last ingredient on your ingredient panel is like some really specific thing. And maybe it has a function, maybe it has a color, like whatever it's doing. But
In the end, if that thing doesn't arrive to your manufacturing facility, you cannot make the final product.
Aaron Alpeter (27:19) you're mentioning coffee and I think I'd throw cacao in there too. businesses in general want consistency. They want something to be the exact same every time. And so in large mass CPG, there are kill steps that are introduced into like coffee roasting or coffee or cacao. And so I remember being in Costa Rica years ago.
And we went to visit a cacao plantation and I learned that, when you're making a a Hershey's bar you basically take all of the cacao beans from from wherever you're getting it from and you you basically burn off all the unique aspects of them. you're kind of making them all the same is the idea.
And that is nice in the perspective of when you get a Hershey's bar, whether you got it in Milwaukee or Manhattan or Madagascar, it's gonna taste about the same, right? Like there's there's a high dependency of of quality, there's a s certain perception of what's gonna be there. So that consistency is what people pay for. but when you look at this and you say, all right, well, I want something that's unique and has the the the nature and the tone, you're gonna get that variation. So I feel like
In food in particular, it sounds like in guitars, that there's always this this tension of, well, how much is what makes our product special? Just the happy accidents, like Bob Ross would say, in terms of things that are being unique and and having that natural variation, versus being able to promise that a Big Mac tastes like a Big Mac wherever it is, and it's it's just, always manufactured that way.
Daniel (28:43) And I can almost see two sides of it. Cause one, like, okay, if you're one of these successful professional musicians and you're playing on stage and you just like sometimes your string breaks, sometimes whatever, like you want the thing to sound the same. You don't want to be surprised by the sound of the replacement instrument. But also on the other hand, I don't know. I I remember I feel like I just have seen in movies or just some friends who are musicians picking up somebody's guitar, like, whoa, that has a really unique sound to it. Almost like you might get a really special cut.
the guitar that comes out and maybe there's some cool thing about it that actually you like even more. So I don't know. I guess probably they want the consistency, but still I can see s a very cool thing into just the individual snowflake that arrived on your doorstep.
Aaron Alpeter (29:26) to tie it back to like our AI discussion earlier, I think what's really interesting is that AI makes everything the same, right? It is is an average of everything going on the internet. And everybody is gonna sound exactly the same if they're using if they're all using Claude or Chat GPT, right? We're gonna revert to the mean. And so there are times and places where it's like, yeah, like that's acceptable. I want it to be there. But just as we were talking about people saying, hey,
I I care about that variation. I care about what makes it uniquely you. I feel like there's a part here where brands and people are both going to recognize that, you know what? No, I actually care about, the effort that went into this. I care about the craft, whether that be the craft of writing the email or making your your latte or, you know, making a a guitar. and so I think it's just this really interesting thing where perhaps the reckoning that's happening right now is that people are.
recognizing where they actually care and want to pay for effort and personalization and and where they just don't it doesn't matter.
Daniel (30:25) It's very interesting. I wanted to ask you a little bit more just about Taylor, the company, because it sounds like they've been on quite a journey. I noted at one point that they became employee owned, I think in 2021.
Aaron Alpeter (30:38) Yeah, you know, so they they went through an ESOP, an employee stock option ownership plan. they did this as a reaction to what the other major guitar players were doing in the space. Gibson, who was actually in bankruptcy, they came out of bankruptcy and were purchased by KKR, the big private equity firm, in 2018. they see that private equity is getting in and buying these things and
either we're gonna need to exit or find somebody take it over. And so in 2021, they decided to become a 100% employee owned.
the reason that they did this was because they wanted to protect the company's independence, their values, their culture. And they didn't say anything about, making change or or making it more dynamic. And in fact, Bob Taylor and Kurt Listug are still a part of Taylor today. so this was more of a, I think, a succession planning that they were doing.
the way that an eSOP works, the employees own it, but what happens if the employee retires or they need liquidity? you have an independent firm that comes through and audits the business every year and says that you know, Taylor is worth $200 million, whatever it's gonna be. And so
You know how many shares exist. And basically they will say that okay, the share price is it was nine dollars last year, this year it's eleven dollars. And that's what the share price is. And part of everybody's compensation, part of their bonus goes into purchasing more shares or buying into it. And so you've got this liquidity thing where let's suppose you get a bonus of twenty thousand dollars this year, 10K of that is gonna go into the purchase thing that goes there. the business is
First able to allow existing shareholders to sell shares that they have. So if I've retired or, I just need liquidity or whatever, like I can say, hey, 11, $11 is a great price for me. I bought into it when it was $4. So I'm gonna sell it and do it that way. if there are no buyers, then basically the business is going to issue new shares. But so you have kind of this liquidity that goes through there. And then when people retire or leave the business, usually there's something where it's like five or seven years where they have to sell.
all of their shares. if the business continues to do well, it is a fantastic wealth creation opportunity for for the employees that work there. And so you're gonna have a lot lower turnover. You're going to have people who are really focused in protecting the business as opposed to protecting themselves. if you've got a culture that's worth protecting like Taylor had,
Then it makes a lot sense to lock that culture in place.
I think that the the benefit and the challenge of an ESOP is that things are slow to change, which again can be a tailwind or a headwind depending on where the business is pointed.
Daniel (33:04) that also made me wonder what what actually are they seeing as the impact of AI? Because you have like AI music now.
taking into account some of what's possible now. And it would make me very sad if people weren't learning instruments because it honestly has been such a great joy for me to actually like learn an instrument and like
get to make music. But what do you think about like valuation and some of these factors?
Aaron Alpeter (33:26) Well, it's fairly straightforward, is the business gonna be around in a hundred years? I think those are important conversations that you need to look at. but in reality, whether you're buying the company or you're just trying to value it, get a sense of what are the free cash flows coming off the business.
how dependable do we think those cash flows are gonna be? And so if you take the case of of Taylor, they don't really publish anything because they're private and they don't they don't need to, but people estimate that they're doing anywhere from 120 to 200 million dollars in revenue. And if you look at Fender, which is public, their eBIT margin is around seven and a half percent. And so let's just assume it's it's roughly the same. they're gonna look at Taylor and say, all right, your margins are about eight percent.
Let's suppose you're doing 160 million dollars in revenue. That means that your operating profit is about 14 million. And so now you're looking at these multiples in terms of a $14 million EBIT business. at the end of the day, they're probably, going at anywhere from eight to twelve X, the EBIT multiple.
Is is what they'll be going for. So they that's how they value the business.
yeah.
Daniel (34:22) It's interesting.
So they're, I mean, they're selling, then it sounds like, from the numbers you just gave, like hundreds of thousands of guitars per year,
Aaron Alpeter (34:27) yeah.
Daniel (34:28) which is that is encouraging to me. I'm glad to hear that. Very happy that people are out there buying tons of guitars, having a good time with them, playing them around a campfire with their friends. Aaron, last question to you is what is a classic guitar riff or solo that you love? And I will go first to give you time to think about it. I will tell you, I will never forget. I think I was 12.
I had bought at a used CD store Van Halen, a Van Halen album. And I think track eight or something on there is a song called Man on a Mission. I think it was the same album that maybe had right here, right now, you know, the Clister Crystal Clear Pepsi song. But this one had the sickest. I mean it definitely it's electric guitar, but
It was just so sick, like did it was so good. I really encourage everyone to listen to it. When you're like twelve, it was the most powerful guitar hook ever. Any any that you particularly love?
Aaron Alpeter (35:26) when you said that, I instantly thought back to when I was like twelve or thirteen and Metallica's Master of Puppets comes to mind. And it's not necessarily the rip. I I
Daniel (35:33) You have to sing it also.
Aaron Alpeter (35:35) I will not do that. May maybe maybe if we get more subscribers, maybe I'll I'll have you on and you can sing. That's what we'll do. But no, just like what what got me was was the precision that they were working at and just kind of, you know, doing everything they're doing, and then just the pauses and like that's the part that's just like, man, that is
That is impressive. And I think that that made an a big big impact on me when I was young getting into guitar music.
Daniel (36:00) As we're wrapping up here, I also have to thank you, Aaron, for being our grand commissioner in our fantasy football league that you and I have played in for many years now. It is often a thankless task.
And so I really appreciate not just you stepping up and being commissioner, because at Startup CPG, we are this huge community, but I like for us to do fun things that build community within the community and are just kind of fun. And so we've had a fantasy football league forever. and we want people to get to participate who want to, because then you like make friends in the league in a different way. And so Aaron, for many years now, has been the grand commissioner, which means he doesn't just
serve as commissioner for one league, but actually for many. we have a bunch of leagues that everybody gets to participate in. And you make it look very easy as well to to do the whole thing. So thank you for that.
Aaron Alpeter (36:44) I'm I'm happy to do it. You think I'd be better at fancy football though,
Well, Daniel, this was great. You're so easy to talk to. I really appreciate you coming on and talking about Taylor guitars with me. please join Startup CPG if you're not doing that already. And we'll have you back on the next episode of e commerce on top in a couple weeks. Thanks.
Daniel (36:59) Thank you.