Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Echoes of Empires

Echoes of Empires artwork

Why Were The Crusades So Popular?

Sep 26, 202625 minAudio

The Crusade present us with one of the greatest paradoxes in history. Why would Christianity, a peace-loving religion, condone such aggressive military operations in the name of God? In this episode, I want to examine why the First Crusade resonated so strongly with medieval men and women in the eleventh century. And to understand this, we need to examine the complex and conflicting forces within medieval feudal society where spirituality and the material world were closely intertwined. Support the show For a free ebook, maps and blogs check out my website nickholmesauthor.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hello and welcome back to Echoes of Empires. My name is Nick Holmes, and this is episode 137 called Why Were the Crusades So Popular? The Crusades present us with one of the greatest paradoxes in history. Why would Christianity, a peace-loving religion, condone such aggressive military operations in the name of God? The reason can't be ascribed to the teachings in the Bible. Jesus rejected violence on any grounds, instructing his followers to love their enemies and to renounce aggression in favour of turning the other cheek.

SPEAKER_00St. Augustine of Hippo, the most influential of all the Christian theologians, encouraged Christians to find solace in the city of God, a spiritual city that had no earthly presence when Rome was sacked by Gothic barbarians in AD four ten. In this episode, I want to examine why the First Crusade resonated so strongly with medieval men and women in the 11th century. As I've mentioned before, the First Crusade was unique and set the template for all subsequent crusades.

SPEAKER_00It was the largest military expedition since the days of the Roman Empire. Why did over 100,000 men and women living predominantly in what are now France and Western Germany suddenly decide to travel thousands of miles to Jerusalem through lands they knew almost nothing about on a journey which in medieval times must have seemed a bit like a trip to the moon would seem to us today. To understand this paradox, we need to examine the complex and conflicting forces within medieval feudal society, where spirituality and materiality were closely intertwined.

SPEAKER_00And the starting point is the medieval papacy, which in the Middle Ages was both a spiritual and a secular power, often fighting kings for control of the church. For example, in 1095, when Urban II received the Byzantine Emperor Alexius Comnenus' appeal for help, which I regard as the true catalyst for the First Crusade, he was locked in conflict with the Emperor of Germany, Henry IV.

SPEAKER_00Indeed, Henry IV was backing a rival pope called Clement III, who in 1095 was controlling the fortress, the Castel San Angelo, in Rome. So the city of Rome itself was divided between two popes. And this conflict between the Pope and the German Emperor continued until the Concordat of Worms in 1122, when the Pope won and the German Emperor Henry V backed down and allowed him to appoint bishops.

SPEAKER_00This background of papal conflict with the secular rulers of Europe is essential, I think, to understanding why the papacy wanted to use the First Crusade as a way of raising its authority over the monarchs of Europe. And this conflict was so central to medieval history that I think it's useful to examine its origins, which go back in time several centuries to the later Roman Empire, and specifically to the Council of Nicaea in AD 325, for that was the first council of the Christian Church presided over by the Roman Emperor Constantine, who made himself head of the Church.

SPEAKER_00Now at that time there was no Pope. There was the Bishop of Rome, but he was just another bishop, no more senior than the others. However, the Bishop of Rome regarded himself as above other bishops, essentially because the two most significant apostles, Peter and Paul, had been martyred in Rome.

unknownSt.

SPEAKER_00Peter's Basilica, built originally by Constantine and later rebuilt in the 16th century, stands today in testimony to the Pope's connection with St. Peter just as it did over a thousand years ago. The collapse of the Western Roman Empire greatly helped the papacy's ambition to be independent of lay rulers in the 5th century AD. After AD 476, there was no Western Roman Emperor, and the Pope could claim spiritual authority over the Western Church.

SPEAKER_00This was, of course, checked when the Emperor Justinian conquered Rome in AD 536, but Byzantine power quickly faded and the popes turned to the Franks, who were emerging as the preeminent power in Western Europe as their protectors. This began with the Frankish King Clovis, who converted to Nicene Catholicism in around 496. As Frankish power grew, so a mutually convenient relationship developed with the popes.

SPEAKER_00Frankish kings wanted papal recognition, and the popes wanted protection from the Lombards, who threatened to reduce them to being just ordinary Italian bishops. In 750, Pippin the Short received the Pope's blessing for overthrowing the Merovingian king Childeric. In return, Pippin guaranteed the Pope protection against the Lombards. Pippin also reinforced the Pope's authority by colluding with him over one of the greatest forgeries in history, the donation of Constantine.

SPEAKER_00This was a fictitious document which stated that the Emperor Constantine had conferred on the Bishop of Rome, who was at that time called Sylvester, authority over all the bishops outside Byzantine territory. With that and the backing of the Franks, the papacy became the established leader of the Western Church, culminating in Charlemagne's reign with his coronation as Roman Emperor by Pope Leo III on Christmas Day 800.

SPEAKER_00In return, the Pope was ensured control of Rome and its environs. But after that everything changed, as Charlemagne's empire collapsed in the 9th century under the weight of the Viking onslaught, and France disintegrated into a collection of warring feudal fiefdoms, disdainful of both royal and clerical authority. However, this wasn't the case in Germany, where feudalism had been curbed by a new imperial power led by the Ottonian dynasty.

SPEAKER_00In 962, Otto I was crowned Holy Roman Emperor by Pope John XII in Rome, echoing Charlemagne's coronation 162 years earlier. But this brought a new threat to the popes because the Ottonians wanted to control the Church, at least in Germany. In 1073, this became a full-blown war when a remarkable man, Gregory VII, became Pope. Gregory is essential to understanding the First Crusade because he laid the groundwork for Urban II's call in 1095.

SPEAKER_00He was a product of the powerful Cluniac monastical movement that, like feudal society itself, grew out of the political chaos of 9th and 10th century France. The monastery of Cluny was founded in 910 in Burgundy and grew to become the leading religious organisation in Europe closely associated with the papacy. Right from its founding, Cluny was independent of any lay authority and came under the direct protection of the Pope.

SPEAKER_00It established a strict new code of clerical behaviour involving long hours of prayer and freedom from lay involvement. Most importantly, it was deeply opposed to lay investiture, meaning the appointment of clerics by secular rulers. Cluny was hugely successful, and under the guidance of its most able abbot, Hugh, who reigned from 1049 to 1109, it attracted most of the monasteries in Europe to join it, so that by the end of the 11th century it was a vast organization with over 11,000 monks and 2,000 religious communities.

SPEAKER_00Its opposition to lay rulers appointing bishops created a crisis between Gregory VII and the German king and later Emperor Henry IV, called the Investiture Crisis. This blew up when Henry appointed the Bishop of Milan against Gregory's wishes, and in 1076 he called for Gregory's abdication and commanded the German bishops to sever their ties with Rome. Gregory's response was extreme, even by the fractious standards of the times.

SPEAKER_00He excommunicated Henry. There was now outright war between the Pope and Europe's most powerful monarch. In Carolingian times the Frankish Emperor would have won, but 11th century feudal Europe was very different. France was ruled by feudal warlords who were stronger than the French King Philip I, and even in the more monarchical Germany, the princes were still very powerful. They were shocked by the Pope's excommunication of Henry, and in 1077 they pressurized him to travel to Canossa in northern Italy to seek forgiveness.

SPEAKER_00The story goes: Henry met the Pope in the depths of winter barefoot and wearing a hair shirt in penance. Gregory pardoned him and cancelled his excommunication. This engendered the modern phrase going to Canossa, which means a humiliating submission. But in fact, although Canossa has achieved a legendary status in history, its immediate significance was limited since in 1084 Henry IV repudiated his support for Gregory by backing a rival Pope Clement III, as I mentioned earlier.

SPEAKER_00And he was still backing him when Urban II became Pope in 1088. This conflict is important to the First Crusade because it encouraged Gregory to think in terms of forming a papal army. The direct catalyst was almost identical to what happened in 1095 in 1074, soon after the Byzantine defeat at Manzikert, the Byzantine Emperor Michael VII appealed to Gregory for help, just as Alexius Comnenus did in 1095.

SPEAKER_00Gregory's response established the groundwork for Urban II's call for crusade, since he wanted a papal army, or milites Christi in Latin, Knights of Christ, to fight for a holy cause under the banner of St. Peter. While Gregory initially focused on rescuing Constantinople, his letters reveal he also envisioned the army marching all the way to Jerusalem just as Urban II would later preach.

SPEAKER_00But Gregory's plans came to nothing. He only wrote to secular leaders asking for their help rather than going on a massive public tour and offering indulgences as Urban did. So we get to the six million dollar question, which is why did the Pope's call for crusade resonate so strongly in feudal France, which was where most of the crusaders came from? Let's start by defining feudalism.

SPEAKER_00It is essentially a very simple concept. It means that society is a pyramid with layers of authority, so the peasants at the bottom owe their allegiance to the local knight. The knight owes his allegiance to the local baron, and the baron to the count. The count owes his allegiance to the king or emperor who is at the top of the pyramid. But the difference between a feudal structure and a more normal monarchical one is that the king relies on the support of a small group of senior aristocrats rather than a broader base population.

SPEAKER_00This greatly reduced the king's power because, in, for example, 11th century feudal France, the French king Francis I was less powerful than many of the great feudal lords, and essentially relied on them for their patronage. This lack of central authority made feudal France an insecure and violent place. Ever since the Viking invasions had fractured Charlemagne's empire, the patchwork collection of major and minor fiefdoms that sprang up across western Francia were engaged in endemic feuding and bloodletting, often between younger and older brothers who were rivals.

SPEAKER_00So where does religion come in? Before the Crusades, the only truly Christian escape from this violent world was by joining a monastery or becoming a cleric. For those that didn't want to do that, the best way of earning forgiveness for sins was to go on a pilgrimage, which was becoming increasingly popular. But the deal Urban II offered crusaders was more attractive because he promised a general remission of sins earned through the hardship of crusading, termed remissio peccatorum.

SPEAKER_00Known as a papal indulgence, it was immensely attractive. It's important to remember that fear of eternal damnation was real in the minds of men and women in the Middle Ages. Many nobles had killed brothers or dispossessed people of property unfairly, and feared divine punishment. Urban's offer meant medieval knights could carry on fighting and be forgiven their sins. Indeed, it was better than that, in Urban's eyes, they could direct their violence against the infidel, who were threatening Byzantium rather than fighting each other.

SPEAKER_00Urban's call for a crusade was a master stroke that solved several problems. It enhanced the papacy's authority, it helped to curb the endemic feudal warfare, and it offered Byzantium help against the Seljuk Turks, all in one go. Now let's turn to the feudal leaders with whom this novel idea of a crusade resonated so much, and who we'll be hearing much more about in subsequent episodes.

SPEAKER_00First is Raymond of Toulouse, the most powerful of the feudal lords, described by Robert the Monk as quote, immensely rich and loaded with all good things of this earth. Raymond is a perfect example of the conflicting motivations of piety and material ambition common to so many of the crusaders. On the one hand, he was clearly religiously motivated since he'd already made a pilgrimage to Jerusalem, which was no mean feat in those days.

SPEAKER_00On the other hand, he was also land grabbing, as would become clear during the First Crusade, when despite owning considerable lands in southern France, he took personal control of various territories the Crusaders conquered, culminating in his making the so-called County of Tripoli his personal domain. Being the oldest, somewhere in his mid-50s, and the wealthiest of the Crusaders, he regarded himself as the Crusade's natural leader, and this brought him into conflict with the Norman Bohemond of Taranto.

SPEAKER_00Bohemond is a fascinating figure who would prove to be the most significant of all the Crusaders, in my opinion, and without whom there can be no doubt the Crusade would not have progressed far beyond Antioch. He became a legendary figure in medieval Europe, partly because of his sponsoring the writing of The Gesta Francorum or Deeds of the Franks, an account of the First Crusade written anonymously, but almost certainly by one of his soldiers, which extolled his virtues as a heroic leader.

SPEAKER_00However, his reputation was largely justified by his military exploits on the Crusade, which, as we'll discover, distinguished him as by far the best soldier among the Crusaders. He was a charismatic figure, as shown by the impression he made on the Byzantine princess Anna Comnen, who described him thus. Bohemond's appearance was, to put it briefly, unlike that of any other man seen in those days in the Roman world, whether Greek or barbarian. The sight of him inspired admiration, the mention of his name Terror.

SPEAKER_00He had an obvious motive for joining the First Crusade. He'd been disinherited by his father, Robert Guiscar, the conqueror of Sicily and Apulia when he divorced Bermond's mother and fell in love with an Italian princess. Robert made the son born to this second wife his heir, leaving Bermond with nothing. Furious, Beaumond occupied Taranto in defiance of his half-brother. The announcement of the First Crusade presented him with an ideal opportunity to forge a new career.

SPEAKER_00Bermond's reputation even before the start of the Crusade was such that a large group of southern Normans flocked to join him, including his nephew Tancred of Hauteville. Barely twenty years old, Tancred was tall, blonde, and strong. He would prove himself as ambitious as Beaumont, and his tireless energy would make him another hero of the Crusade. With the Southern French and Normans led by Raymond, Beaumond and Tancred, the Crusade also acquired a strong contingent of northern French, when the brothers Duke Godfrey of Bouillon and Count Baldwin of Boulogne took the vow to go on crusade.

SPEAKER_00Like Beaumond, Godfrey had been dispossessed of land and wealth, although, unlike Beaumont, this was simply by virtue of his being a second son. Described as, quote, strong beyond measure, with solidly built limbs and stalwart chest, he would become an important leader of the crusade, as would his younger brother Baldwin, who was described as having darker hair, but a paler complexion than his brother, and with a piercing gaze. Although neither of them can have had any realistic expectation of what they would ultimately achieve when they set out on Crusade, after its victorious conclusion they would become the first and second kings of the new kingdom of Jerusalem.

SPEAKER_00These five men became the leaders of the crusade, not by a written agreement or even because of a premeditated plan, but simply because they were the most powerful leaders with the most knights and retainers following them. So what can we say about these mainly anonymous retainers, the thousands of knights and foot soldiers and sometimes their wives who accompanied these men? A study of the charters left behind by the everyday crusaders has proved one of the most insightful sources into what motivated people to go on crusade.

SPEAKER_00Charters were legal documents which most middle ranking knights compiled to set their affairs in order before departing on the most challenging adventure of their lives. Many crusaders sold property to the church to fund their journey, and even if they didn't dispose of property, they made legally binding agreements on inheritance and the administration of their properties and assets. What these charters show is a large group of upwardly mobile middle-ranking nobles who were attracted to Urban II's idea of a penitential war, both to save their souls and to participate in a movement that offered improved social status and the possibility of financial reward.

SPEAKER_00However, the original impact of Urban's sermon in 1095 went beyond the knightly class, to the common man and woman. And this was one of the most extraordinary features of the First Crusade. Historians still struggle to understand what really happened, but there's no doubt that what's been called the People's Crusade began its march towards Constantinople before the official papally sponsored launch of the Prince's Crusade began on the 15th of August 1096.

SPEAKER_00The Prince's Crusade referring to the march of Raymond of Toulouse and the feudal lords I mentioned. The People's Crusade was led by one of the most enigmatic figures in crusading history, Peter the Hermit. Little is known about him, partly because he was probably seen as an embarrassment by the great lords of the Prince's Crusade, but the fact that he led a huge gathering of peasants to Constantinople, who were subsequently annihilated by the Turks before the real crusading army arrived, is attested to by the vivid account of the People's Crusade in the Byzantine Princess Anna Komnena's breathtaking history, The Alexiad.

SPEAKER_00Peter was a lowly priest at Amiens, but his place in history was secured by the success of his fiery eloquence as an itinerant preacher. Dressed as a pauper, quote, outdoors he wore a woolen tunic which revealed his ankles and above it a hood. He wore a cloak to cover his upper body and a bit of his arms, but his feet were bare. Nevertheless, he captivated his audiences, quote, for he was sharp-witted, his glance was bright and captivating, and he spoke with ease and eloquence.

SPEAKER_00What he said hasn't been recorded, unfortunately, but he encouraged tens of thousands of peasants, accompanied by a few knights, to embark on what can best be described as a frenzied march east. So in conclusion, the crusading fever that gripped Western Europe in the aftermath of Urban II's Sermon at Claremont must count as, I think, the single most extraordinary event of the entire Middle Ages.

SPEAKER_00The lack of coordination between the many and varied participants in this crusade might suggest that it was likely to fail on an epic scale. It's testimony to the vitality and skill of the men who would emerge as its leaders, that it would become one of the most successful military expeditions in history.

SPEAKER_00And that ends this episode. Thanks so much for listening, and I hope you enjoyed it. And in the next episode, on the 10th of October, expect some surprises as I examine recent research which puts a whole new perspective on the Crusades from the angle of climate history. Was the success of the First Crusade due to a change in climate which favoured Western Europe and devastated the Middle East? Find out in two weeks' time. And can I ask a special favour, please? If you like the podcast, would you mind clicking the rating in Spotify or Apple or whatever podcast app you use?

SPEAKER_00That helps me so much to get this podcast out to more people. Thank you so much, and see you next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Byzantium and the First Crusade

    Nov 7, 202623 minAudio

    In 1097, hordes of crusaders converged on Constantinople, the fabled city of gold that sat between Europe and Asia. The Byzantine emperor, Alexius Comnenus, had called for help to fight the Turks. But now he had tens of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The People's Crusade and the First Holocaust

    Oct 24, 202622 minAudio

    The First Crusade got off to a terrible start. The initial armies, referred to by historians as the 'People's Crusade' and the 'German Crusade' were little more than bands of brigands and discontented peasants and minor...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Does Climate History Unlock the Secrets of the Crusades?

    Oct 10, 202623 minAudio

    In this episode, we look at something called the Medieval Warm Period. This first came to our notice a long time ago in the writings of a medieval monk and historian called William of Malmesbury. Writing in around 1120,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Secrets of Ancient Nicaea

    Sep 12, 202622 minAudio

    In this episode, I tell you about my travels to Ancient Nicaea, a city that changed history from the famous First Council of Nicaea in AD 325, foundational for the Christian church, to the siege of Nicaea, a pivotal...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Alexius Comnenus: The True Story

    Aug 29, 202622 minAudio

    Alexius Comnenus is a well-known Byzantine Emperor not least because his daughter, Anna, wrote one of the greatest works of medieval literature about him called “The Alexiad.” It’s a cracking read, full of vivid...

    Credit the people on this episode