Project Hail Mary gave me an alien I cared about and a science question I couldn’t stop thinking about: how could something evolve to feed on a star? Expect to learn how my research background in exoplanet atmospheres shapes the way I think about Rocky’s home planet, why a species living without sunlight might rely on echolocation, and why Rocky’s psychology feels much more familiar than his appearance. I also talk about alien communication and our attempts to understand other species here on Earth. Then I work through astrophage, the organisms threatening the Sun: their life cycle, their extraordinary energy storage, and the evolutionary steps that would have to connect life on a planet to life near a star. I loved the movie. Asking where its science works and where it stretches our imagination is part of the fun. Full spoilers for Project Hail Mary. Hosted by Dr. Dakotah Tyler. Lead with curiosity.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Not me trying to pick at the movie or say that the movie was great. Absolutely loved it. For me, I gotta say, probably the best sci-fi in the 2020s. Yeah, in the 2020s, definitely. And maybe I'd have to think about this one a little bit more. Maybe the best sci-fi since Interstellar. Here's what I'm gonna say. The best space sci-fi since Interstellar.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back to the Dr. Star Kid podcast. I'm your host, Dr. Dakota Tyler, astrophysicist, author, curious guy, through and through, lover of sci-fi. And today I want to talk about the most interesting sci-fi and science aspects of the movie Project Hail Mary, which came out earlier this year, I believe, or last year. Earlier this year, I think. Definitely full spoilers. Um, I'm assuming that you've seen it by now.
SPEAKER_00If you haven't, you definitely should and go watch it and then come back and listen to this, or just listen to this. I'm not gonna I'm not gonna spoil the whole plot necessarily. So, generally, what's going on in Project Hail Mary is that something is wrong with the sun. Like something is happening with the sun. They say it's dying, it's like it's getting dimmer. And this is not a good thing, right? Um, we rely on the sun. Uh that should be obvious. Obviously, you know, the entirety of life. Animals eat plants, plants grow from the sun.
SPEAKER_00There's some animals that use the sun. I mean, we get energy from the sun, we get vitamin D production, which is spurred by uh UV photons that come from the sun. There's a lot of like positive mental health benefits from being out in the sun. The sun's very important. And uh, if it were to get significantly dimmer, that would be a huge problem for life on earth. So they go off to another uh solar system, and it's one that is not having this problem with the star dimming, but all the other stars around are.
SPEAKER_00And Ryan Gosling like meets this little alien named Rocky. I don't know how how interesting or how plausible do we think that body type is and you know his characteristics or whatever. And so they like go through a whole thing. It's very cute, it's very good, it's it's good. There's some good sci-fi in there, and then one of the most interesting aspects of the movie to me, which was actually the astrophage, the thing that was causing the sun to die. But I'm gonna talk about the most interesting aspects from that sci-fi angle in like speculative biology, in what types of behaviors or characteristics do we actually expect from planets and stars and that sort of thing.
SPEAKER_00For reference, my PhD was in exoplanet atmospheres. So I'm studying how planets that orbit other stars have atmospheres that evolve over time, like how do they change over time? If you never thought about that, that's something that happens in our own solar system. We suspect that Mars and Venus early on in the solar system may have even been able to support liquid water on the surface. That's not the case for either of the planets now.
SPEAKER_00And the way that you get from being able to have water on your surface to not being able to have water on your surface is by your atmosphere changing significantly. On Venus, the atmosphere is super thick, which isn't really a problem, but it's extremely hot, which really is, because that would just immediately boil any water. On Mars, you have the opposite problem. You have it's it's definitely very cold, but it's the atmospheric pressure is too low. Mars has like too little of an atmosphere.
SPEAKER_00And so if you poured a cup of water on Mars, it would like flash, boil, and freeze. It would immediately start to boil and freeze. And the reason why it boils, you know, boiling is not always uh related to something being very hot. I guess a great example of that is that on Earth, if you go to the top of a mountain, it's easier to boil water, takes less heat. It doesn't have to get to as high of a temperature. Well, why is that? And it's basically because the pressure of the atmosphere sitting on top of water that you have at your house on a stove is keeping it in the form of water.
SPEAKER_00It has to get really energized to be able to escape up into the atmosphere. But as you remove that atmosphere, it becomes very easy, right? It doesn't take as much energy from molecules that are kind of not fighting against as much pressure. So Rocky, he's this, it looks like a rock, but it's sentient, it moves, smart, um, great sense of humor. But Rocky comes from a planet that is very different than the Earth. Rocky comes from what we would call a super Earth.
SPEAKER_00You know, the way that astronomers name and talk about planets, exoplanets, planets out elsewhere in the galaxy, is in relation to what they're like compared to the planets that we know of. So if I sit called something a sub-Earth, then that would tell you that it was a little bit smaller than Earth. If I told you about a sub-Neptune, that's smaller than Neptune. If I said super Jupiter, that's larger than Jupiter, right? So take your pick of any planet, you put sub in front of it and it's smaller, you put super in front of it and it's bigger.
SPEAKER_00You put the word hot in front of it and it's closer to the star and therefore hotter. You put cold in front of it or icy in front of it, then that means it's farther away. Uh, it's you're pretty pretty straightforward, pretty elementary stuff. So Rocky is from a super Earth called Arid. The planet is called Arid. Rocky is in Iridian, and on their planet, it's a super Earth. I think it's about eight or nine times the mass of the Earth.
SPEAKER_00So it's more massive and it's larger, and it has an incredibly thick atmosphere, a super thick and dense atmosphere, which should kind of make sense. Um, when you think about maintaining an atmosphere on a planet, it's easier when you are more massive because you have a stronger, you have stronger self-gravity. So you can you can like keep it, uh, the atmosphere on you. If you think about Mars, why did Mars lose its atmosphere? Well, Mars is actually not very massive, it's pretty small and it's pretty low mass, which means it's hard to hold on to that atmosphere.
SPEAKER_00Something like the sun could kind of just heat the atmosphere up and bake it away, or like the solar wind could blow it off. Conversely, you think about a planet like Jupiter, which is extremely massive, very, very, very hard for the sun or anything to heat up Jupiter enough or energize its gas enough that it would ever escape that gravity that it has. So a super Earth having a really thick atmosphere, I think is not all too surprising.
SPEAKER_00In fact, the atmosphere is so thick that no sunlight reaches through, which is pretty interesting, right? And this is what you would expect also on the gas giant planets. Like when you see a picture of Jupiter or Saturn, you see what it looks like, right? You know, Jupiter has lots of different browns and oranges and reds, but if you were to that that that sunlight that's like bouncing off of the outside, coming back uh to the cameras or you know, whatever took the pictures. But if you were to dive in, I mean you die for a thousand reasons.
SPEAKER_00Um, the radiation would kill you, the temperature would kill you. I think there's like lightning strikes and stuff that happened in there, that would kill you. Uh, the winds can be hundreds or even thousands of miles per hour, that would kill you. The pressure gets incredibly high from all the gas sitting on top of you, that would kill you. But if we just ignore all of those deadly and lethal effects, then what you would notice is that as you got deeper, the sun disappears, light disappears, because it's getting either absorbed or scattered by all of the gas above you.
SPEAKER_00So Rocky and the rest of the Iridians live in darkness, and so they never evolved, evolved eyeballs like we have, um, that can detect sunlight. Like it's weird to I have a thing where I think using words like seeing and hearing and smelling are kind of strange, in my opinion, when it comes to senses, because you know, a shark has the ability to detect electrical fields.
SPEAKER_00Does that mean a shark can see electric fields? Does it mean that it can smell electric fields? Does it mean that it can taste electric fields? Can it hear them? I don't know. I actually don't think it matters. The you you're you're just sensing it, you're sensing it, and so what we call vision that we're doing with our eyes, yeah, we're collecting photons with our eyes, so we can see things, but a bat that's blind and lives in a cave uses echolocation, and it can sense probably through his ears, maybe it does like create an image or something in its mind or something comparable to that, which is what we see in Project Hail Mary.
SPEAKER_00It's that Rocky is using this echolocation and he can sense the world around him, but our interpretation, like the way that you show that to an audience, has to be something that we can see visually, but really it's just like a representation. So it's like, is Rocky seeing? Is he hearing? I don't know. I don't think it matters at all. I think he's just able to sense where things are by um detecting sound waves that bounce off of them. So, you know, he gets a vision. It's not in color or anything, it's kind of like all black and white.
SPEAKER_00But again, it's like, what how would we why there's no reason that you couldn't have colored echolocation, right? This is in the same way that we have colored vision. Like you could have black and white vision, you could have color vision. Colors are basically just fabricated by our brain to differentiate between certain wavelengths of photons, because apparently that helped our ancestors, I don't know, like make things out, separate things, tell things apart, whatever. And there's no reason that you couldn't have that with sound waves, right?
SPEAKER_00I imagine that a sound wave, when it returns to you after bouncing off of something, will be slightly different if that thing was like rough, or if it was super smooth, or if it had fur and hair on it, or you know what I mean, if it was if it was sticky, or maybe even differences in in color. Like I don't know. I don't have echolocation abilities, but I do know that as long as there's physical information in something out in the universe, there's the potential for being able to differentiate or categorize or bin that information in a way that might potentially help you survive, thrive, escape a predator, catch prey, outsmart something, problem solve, and pass on your genes through reproduction.
SPEAKER_00I think thinking about senses in and of themselves are really interesting. So because Rocky has no sense of collecting photons, um, which is electromagnetic radiation, that's what the um things like the sun are emitting, and and lots of things are emitting, they didn't actually know about radiation, which is a problem later in the movie that the Iridians didn't know about radiation. But it's really interesting because they were clueless about light, you know, the sunlight.
SPEAKER_00And it's that sounds it sounds strange, but only sounds strange because sunlight, you know, bathes our planet. Have you ever thought about why we call certain wavelengths of light visible light? Like why do we call it visible light? Why does the sun make so much visible light? Why can we see it? We can see it, it's visible to us, it's visible to us because the sun produces so much of it. Our sun peaks exactly in the wavelengths of light that we can best detect.
SPEAKER_00It emits tons of light, it emits light that's way higher energy, that's gonna be uh UV light, it emits light that's way lower energy, that's gonna be like infrared, even microwave. And why do we see visible light? Well, we just happen to be able to see the type of light that our sun produces the most of. The only reason it's visible to us is because those photons were everywhere. Like I was saying early, that physical information exists, and if it's everywhere, and we had one and you know, maybe there was like one single-celled ancestor, one single-celled amoeba or whatever it was, and it developed the ability to detect these photons, that would help it out because the photons are bouncing off of everything, right?
SPEAKER_00And I think it's pretty obvious to see how that would be helpful. You just need to think about the difference um between trying to find food or trying not to become food and being able to see or not see. And that's that's one easy way, right? Um, but there's many easier ways. You could also do like the echolocation thing, you could do like a sensing the molecules, like pheromones, like a smelling thing. But I think that's very cool. And I think that it makes a lot of sense to me that life forms that lived on a rocky super earth planet under a super thick atmosphere that didn't allow any light, like why would they why would they be able to see light?
SPEAKER_00Why would they ever evolve eyes? There would be no need for something like that. Kind of think about the um animals at the bottom of the ocean. A lot of them are blind. You don't need eyes. But what do you need eyes for? There's no light. I guess another thing to point out is that this type of exoplanet, Arid, even though we don't really spend that much time there until the very end of the movie, and even then they don't really go, you know, too deep into anything. That's an exoplanet that very believably could exist.
SPEAKER_00You know, we know of planets that are eight to ten Earth masses. We don't really know much about their atmospheres because we haven't um we haven't achieved that level of sensitivity to be able to study things like that, but you know, it's very, very plausible, right? And although that may be an atmosphere in a in an environment that we wouldn't survive in, life forms that evolved with that, uh, and for that, I mean, I'm I see no reason why they wouldn't be able to, and I see what no reason why they wouldn't also be able to get intelligent.
SPEAKER_00Another cool thing is that using echolocation in a super thick atmosphere would actually lead to faster uh communication and faster you know vision if you're reconstructing an image from like a radar echolocation thing than we have in our atmosphere, right? Sound waves, sound maybe I should have said this in the beginning. Sound is just a pressure wave moving through a medium. So um the air is filled with tons and tons of molecules, countless little molecules, and in my mouth there are little molecules.
SPEAKER_00You have to take my word on it, and I am vibrating my vocal box, my throat box in such a way that it's vibrating the air molecules, and then when it vibrates them, they like vibrate the ones next to them. And you know, big picture physically, what that is like is like a pressure wave where they vibrate and they get closer and they expand, they get closer and they expand, and there's this wave of pressure that moves, and when that stuff hits your ear, your brain interprets those vibrations as sound.
SPEAKER_00This is what I mean when I'm like, what are senses really? It's like we we we are we're calling it hearing, but a bunch of molecules are vibrating, and then they're they're hitting your biological ear vibrator detectors, and your brain is like making that into something that we call sound. It's weird, like the more you think about our senses, in my opinion, the weirder they get. It's almost I like that, but you know, okay, I I feel like it just kind of gets confusing after a while.
SPEAKER_00So the uh thing is is that on a thicker atmosphere, sound waves can travel faster. And this should make sense. A denser, thicker atmosphere has more molecules that are closer together. So that means that like when one is vibrating, it doesn't have to go as far to vibrate the next one, right? And so this is also why there's no sound in space, right? Why is there no sound in space? Well, there's no molecules, you can't send a pressure wave that's vibrating a bunch of molecules if there is no molecules, and so follow that logic in the other direction.
SPEAKER_00And the more dense a medium is, the faster those waves can travel. So, in a thicker atmosphere, that stuff is going to travel faster. You go to something even thicker and more dense, like an ocean, water. When sperm whales and dolphins do echolocation, those sound waves travel way faster than sound waves through air because there's more stuff there. So it can quickly translate. And then let's take it to the extreme. The fastest sound waves travel through solids, like the earth, you know, earthquakes, um, a table, right?
SPEAKER_00Steel, whatever. And so the speed of sound increases when you increase the density of a medium. You because you're increasing the amount of stuff basically that you have, so the molecules don't have to go that far to vibrate to whatever. I think that that's pretty cool. Now, this was something that I um had to look into because I watched the movie first before, and I didn't read the book. I'm not not before reading the book, I never read the book. And in the movie, it seems like Rocky is a silicon-based life instead of carbon-based, because he's a rock.
SPEAKER_00A lot of rocks are silicates. A lot of rocks also have carbon. And it turns out that Rocky was written to be carbon-based. So even though he's a rock, he's still carbon-based. And I think that that's interesting because people bring up silicon-based life a lot, but you really don't need to. I think I talked about this in the last episode. Carbon is so common. I mean, it's one of the most common things in the universe, element-wise, and it's also one of the most flexible when it comes to connecting different atoms and different molecules together, which is what you need in chemistry, right?
SPEAKER_00You want something that can connect a bunch of different pieces together, right? And so carbon is everywhere. I think carbon-based life is probably the most common. There's probably other things, but Rocky is carbon-based. You may not think that just by watching it, because you know he's a rock, that seems like it could be silicon-based, but he's definitely carbon-based, which I think is pretty cool. The next note that I had about Rocky specifically in the Iridians is they do seem very humanoid.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, they look like rocks. They seem very humanoid in their psychology. Like there are some slight differences, but but they do seem very human. It's like, it's almost like there's a human brain in there somewhere. I think that that's interesting. And I think that, you know, from a storytelling perspective, you it makes sense that you do something like that, right? Like in the movie, Rocky is very, it's a rock, right?
SPEAKER_00And it's like, how do you get the audience to care about a rock? Well, it it needs to demonstrate some very human-like qualities, right? Like it needs to demonstrate, like they want to make a good movie. Andy Weir wanted to tell a good story, and you gotta be able, when you're telling a story, you gotta be able to get the audience to connect. And so it's like, well, how alien can you make this thing and still have that impact or or that storytelling ability? So I understand that perspective, but I think another interesting thing to think about is how much of what we're calling human-centric, anthropocentric, you know, humanoid psychology, whatever, how much of that is just kind of what would happen for an intelligent species, or how much of that is completely different?
SPEAKER_00And I feel like that's a good question. I don't know. Like, if you know, Rocky's Rocky's people were able to build a spaceship, Rocky's people, Rocky's, yeah, they're I mean, they're people, the peoples of Arid. You know, if if you can build a spaceship, would you have a lot of the same qualities as humans? I mean, they're like better at math, they can kind of do math themselves, they're like master engineers, they're really good. at manipulating uh elements and you know doing chemistry engineering that sort of thing it's like I don't know I think it's a cool I think it was a cool exploration do we really want to watch a movie where the these these like aliens just cannot communicate at all side note another movie who I think does that really well is Arrival where you really in the movie Arrival where a couple aliens just pop up all over the earth there's like a bunch of these ships they really can't communicate it's really the entire movie is basically trying to figure out what they're saying.
SPEAKER_00What are they trying to communicate? What are they here for? What are their intentions? Phenomenal movie but a very different type of movie than Project Hill Mary right um I don't know if we wanted to sit and watch and you know three hours of Ryan Gosling trying to figure out how to talk to a rock. So they just kind of hacked it a little bit and did you know uh Ryan Gosling whose character he he plays um Grace uh Dr. Grace and they they're able to use LLMs and just do like some AI translator thing.
SPEAKER_00And it's like okay you know I don't think there's no way you would be able to do that so quickly but I would prefer that they just did that and didn't make us suffer through them not being able to communicate with each other. You know and this we're actually trying to do this with other species on earth Project SETI which I've talked about before is trying to decode using large language models the communication these codas that sperm whales use to communicate and dolphins also communicate using these these clicks like this um echolocation style uh communication of you know pushing these sound waves back and forth to each other orcas do it whale like all I'm I think pretty much all whales do this that's very interesting and it just wouldn't surprise me if eventually we are able to communicate I think that would be really cool that would set like a crazy I think that would be awesome um for like animals rights as well protections for the ocean it like if we could if we could demonstrate you know beyond doubt beyond reasonable doubt that these are highly I know that whales and cetaceans are highly intelligent.
SPEAKER_00I know that a lot of animals are highly intelligent but if you can demonstrate that they can like communicate with language with us I feel like that'll push it over the edge to where the people who don't care about animals or who are like you know what I mean like people who are who who are not worried about conservation and stuff would like have to um respect it. Like that that's almost at the stage that that's almost like them being peoples right like these are whales they they're like talking to each other they have names for each other you know they have they have wills um you know that uh you know they have like goals they have things that um are important to them and we can communicate I just feel like that would go a long way because I know how people are it shouldn't have to be like that but I feel like I just knowing how people are something like that would go a long way.
SPEAKER_00Okay so the astrophage which are these little organisms that are basically eating the stars they're consuming energy from the star which blocks out the light so they're not actually eating the star right you almost think about it uh like just like blacking out the sun because you're covering all that light because they're eating it okay so they eventually they figure out that this these little molecules that eat sunlight and then they're able to do some sci-fi movie magic where they convert um the light from the sun into neutrinos uh which are these little particles there's hundreds of trillions of them pouring through your body every second uh they don't really interact with matter like that they just pass right through your body and nothing ever happens and so it's a bit far-fetched to think that these little molecules evolved to be able to contain those when they don't interact with matter but I feel like that's you know take your liberty when you're making a cool story I you know I respect it and the author Andy Weir has talked openly about like yeah you know I just kind of like hand way I kind of invented this and then anyways they can like use the neutrinos and convert them to energy that they like blast photons so that they travel like to a new star.
SPEAKER_00Okay so what'll happen is they'll consume a star and when I say consume they're just like covering it and taking the energy and then they go they have to have a planet in that solar system that has carbon dioxide in the atmosphere because they reproduce on the planet. So they'll go to a star then they'll go to the planet and there'll be this line they call it the Petrova line which is really cool it's like just a line of these astrophage going to you know millions and millions and millions of miles to a planet that has a lot of carbon dioxide in its atmosphere and then when they reproduce they can you know go to the to the star and then you know when they've completely covered it then they'll you know they'll go travel on to another one so this is like some really good and interesting world building but one of the things that I think is very strange is how that life cycle evolves in the astrophase I'm not I'm not too confused about a small organism maybe it that has the ability to like you know move around the atmosphere that needs carbon dioxide to reproduce.
SPEAKER_00That feels pretty straightforward to me but how does it get to the point where it's like going to the surface of a star and then coming back realize that sunlight like there's nothing special about getting right next to the sun if all you're trying to do is collect light. The sunlight that you get when you stand outside is not that different from the sunlight that you would get if you were closer. Now you get a lot more of it it would be a lot more intense if you got closer but it's really the same stuff you know and so it's like why how do they evolve to get to the surface of a star it makes sense to me that maybe you know we could imagine an evolutionary track of the distant astrophage ancestors where they evolve to go higher and higher in a planet's atmosphere let's say their home planet that they started from they go higher and higher in the planet's atmosphere and when they're up in the high parts of the atmosphere they are getting more sunlight uh they're able to like compete with each other and like get higher up and absorb some and but more importantly atmospheres of planets do block a lot of light um the earth has an atmosphere with something called ozone which is just oxygen high up in the atmosphere probably heard of the ozone layer and what happens is it ends up eating up a bunch of the UV which is higher energy sunlight that turns out to be good for us because UV is very energetic and it can hurt you.
SPEAKER_00It can like damage your skin it can damage your DNA can literally damage your DNA so it's so damaging that humans evolved melanin that has the specific use case of protecting from too much sun damage. A cool thing that I learned from Dr. Ade who is a uh medical he's a medical doctor a dermatologist he was teaching me I had him on a a few weeks ago you can go back and listen to that episode and but he was teaching me about how there's actually melanin a melanin response when you go outside where as soon as the sunlight hits your skin all of the melanin in your cells will pull to the surface of where the sunlight is coming from and that happens within like minutes.
SPEAKER_00It's not a true tan that you've gotten yet it's just the melanin your cells is going to the surface to block out the sun I thought it was pretty cool. And all people with like fair skin like you see a white person has been in their in the sun their entire life and their skin is like super blotchy. They have like those little melanin spots and it's like this repeated it's it's a repeated response of having all the melanin in the cell congregate to the surface to protect you.
SPEAKER_00And I was like damn that's that's pretty cool. Anyways I say that to say it can be very damaging. It's good for us we need some of it but it can also be very damaging. And so there is a lot of energy there. It's damaging because there's a lot of energy but so you could imagine that these astrophage ancestors they were they benefited by going higher up in the atmosphere because they're able to access more and higher energy light from the sun that's good if if you can control that you know if you evolve the ability and then they evolve the ability to withstand lower pressures they evolve evolved the ability to withstand those higher energies and deal with the UV and I can see how that happens but I it's hard for me to to picture how they're able to make that jump to going to the surface of a sun of a or of a star because they don't really need to right like you're getting you're high up in the atmosphere you're getting lots and lots and lots of sunlight you're getting the visible light you're getting infrared you're getting UV why do you need to get on the surface of a star and that requires such extreme levels of protection of heat of energy uh you know the magnetic fields around the sun are insane there's there's plasma whipping around there's flares it's like the difference between being able to exist even at the even at the edges the outskirt the very outskirts of an atmosphere of a planet yes it's a very extreme environment you got radiation coming from space you've got freezing cold temperatures there's almost nothing out there you have super low pressures you got radiation coming from the star even that environment is orders of magnitude tens hundreds thousands of times easier to survive thrive persist maintain sustain than being damn near at the surface of a star I mean it's such a and so for me it's like how did they make that jump right because you know evolution typically doesn't ever come in big steps like a big magic thing never happens.
SPEAKER_00You kind of just repurpose what happened before right you see a a um a giraffe with a long ass neck a a giraffe didn't just wake up one day and they used to be yellow and brown horses and then it just woke up with a long neck one day that's not what happened. The neck grew very very very very slowly because all it could do was show slight variation on the neck that came before it this is something that takes a very long time but the step process is clear.
SPEAKER_00A giraffe that has a three foot neck doesn't really take much to with genetic variation produce a giraffe that has a three foot and one inch neck. You see what I'm saying? It's a very slow thing and if you just follow that slowly if there's a pressure nudging in that way eventually you get a neck uh for a giraffe that's I have no idea how long giraffe necks are five feet six feet whatever it is but it's a you can see how that happens though because it just happens slowly piece by piece by piece you know think in another way think about the bottom of the ocean you may think well before we knew that there was life down there maybe we would assume that those pressures were way too high to have life I don't I feel like that would be a a a reasonable objection um okay it's like well yeah we know there's life in the shallow parts um we know there's life on land or whatever but maybe the pressure is too high down there for life because none of the organisms that we know that live at the surface could live down there at least not that we know of still I think it's different because you know there's a pathway towards evolving to be able to live in those pressures right if you take an animal or a bacteria or anything that can survive in the shallow ocean to get a deep to be able to survive a deep a foot deeper you just need to like move a foot that way you know what I mean like there's a pathway there and over like thousands and thousands and tens of thousands hundreds of thousands millions of years if you just keep taking a step every hundred years that direction then I can I'll believe it like I'll believe that it's possible that you could have evolved to exist at the bottom of the ocean you know and by the time you do you would be very different than the thing that you evolved from but there's a clear pathway there.
SPEAKER_00For me there is not a clear pathway from the edge of a planet to the surface of the star right because there's nothing there. There's nothing in between them in the example that I did with the astrophage ancestors that evolved to exist higher and higher in the atmosphere there's a pathway there. It's lit there's a physical there's like a local direction. Yeah it's like bacteria can float around in the atmosphere sure it can right and so it can evolve to go higher it can evolve to go lower because all of it is it's it's an environment that has access to you don't have access to the surface of a of a star.
SPEAKER_00And so it kind of seems like they all at once had to have some weird thing happen. Anyways super harped on that I think that that's actually a very aware astrobiology take is how would these things have um evolved obviously I love the movie this is not me like this is not me trying to pick at the movie or say that the movie wasn't great absolutely loved it for me I gotta say probably the best sci fi for me in the 2020s yeah in the 2020s definitely and maybe I'd have to think about this one a little bit more maybe the best sci-fi since Interstellar here's what I'll say the best space sci-fi since Interstellar guaranteed you know Interstellar is like one of my favorite movies all time one of my favorite sci-fi's of the past decade for sure uh very cool very I I like Andy Weir's work he does he does a good job of trying to incorporate real science he does a good job of I think being explicit in his publicizing of things that he knows are like eh you know not you know not real science is like where he took a um liberty or whatever also I think like when I talk about these things in movies it's not ever to be like oh screw this movie they didn't get the science right it's always just from a point from like curiosity right like huh well could that happen like Project Hail Mary was a very cool movie.
SPEAKER_00What aspects of that are things that we with what we know now we think hey this aligns with the science what aspects are like I would never happen like that and then what aspects are like huh interesting it's an interesting thing to think about. And so I think Project Hail Mary you know in that respect was was awesome and I guess also just because I'm sitting here saying that I can't um determine or or think of some obvious pathway for something like the astrophage to evolve that doesn't mean that they wouldn't you know the universe is a big place even if we got into the nitty gritty of how humans evolved you have to start there's a lot of things that you would have no way of knowing would be important and ultimately leading to humans I mean placental birth live placental births for not just humans like lots of tons of mammals most mammals actually happened because I made a video about this not a short form video not long ago actually happened because our distant distant mammal ancestors way before humans way before primates had a virus that infected their cells somehow inserted its DNA into their reproductive cells and that led to a mutation that fused together lay ultimately over time the placenta and allowed for animals to develop in utero with this placenta that's like giving them oxygen and taking out waste and giving them nutrients and all this stuff and having a live birth and it's like if a virus didn't infect our mammal ancestor from 40 50 60 million years ago there's a high likelihood that you changed the drastically changed the course of evolution of all mammals like that's insane.
SPEAKER_00And that's just one thing that we know about how many other viruses had to insert their DNA which means that they infected just the right individual that had just the right or wrong response depending on how you think about it. And it's like you know bacterial DNA get you know gets inserted in our bodies and I say our bodies but I'm talking about literally the evolution of life. There's so there's so many so many crazy things. So I mean you know it's could something I I I don't see how something like that could happen but you know what I I'm you know I'm not the arbiter of what's evolutionarily possible and we see insane things all the time.
SPEAKER_00Anyways really appreciate y'all tapping in uh see y'all next week join my Patreon Dr. Starkid if you'd like to support the Dr. Starkid podcast and just me in general my platform overall appreciate y'all being here as always lead with curiosity
Could we recognize life that looks nothing like us? Before we can answer that, we have to decide what counts as alive. Even here on Earth, that question gets complicated quickly. Expect to learn why movement, growth,...
What has science confirmed that people once understood as a spiritual belief? Someone asked me that recently, and it turned into a much bigger conversation about what I believe and why. Expect to learn how the elements...
Could something alive on Earth survive in the ocean beneath an alien moon’s ice? Researchers tested that question by recreating some of the conditions thought to exist on Enceladus, a small moon of Saturn. The archaea...
Elias 2-24b is already several times Jupiter’s mass, yet its star system is estimated to be less than a million years old. This episode follows the discovery and asks how a gas giant can grow so massive, so quickly. We...