SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! We address Congressman Dr. Greg Murphy's controversial claim about physician shortage and the implications of his statements. We dissect the validity of his statistics, discuss the burden of student loans, and question the future of medical education in light of his proposal for 15-year mandatory practice. FREE DOWNLOAD - 7 Considerations Before Starting Locum Tenens - https://darkos.lpages.co/7-considerations-before-locums LINKS MENTIONED Q&A and Suggestions Form - https://forms.clickup.com/9010110533/f/8cgpr25-4614/PEBFZN5LA6FKEIXTWF SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTER! WATCH THIS EPISODE ON YOUTUBE! Have a question for the podcast? Text us at 833-230-2860 Twitter: @drniidarko Instagram: @docsoutsidethebox Email: team@drniidarko.com Merch: https://docs-outside-the-box.creator-spring.com This episode is sponsored by Set For Life Insurance. What the Darkos use for great disability insurance at a low cost!! Check them out at https://setforlifeinsurance.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1What's good everyone. This is Dr Nidarko. Make sure you hit the subscribe button below so that you're always up to date on the new uploads, as well as alerts on this show. The other thing that you can do to help build this community is make sure you leave a comment below. Let us know what you like, what you don't like about the show and, ultimately, let us know who's winning these arguments, because I need to know that I'm beating Rene in these debates. Run the tape, what's up? Everybody Live from Docs Outside the Box. I wanted to talk about this, renee wanted to talk about this. So there's a congressman, congressman, greg Murphy.
Speaker 1He put out a tweet yesterday, the 28th, and he says the number one reason for MD shortage is med schools admitting students who aren't going to practice. Only 60% of med students today plan on practicing clinical medicine. Med schools need to focus on admitting students who want to take care of patients, not just get their MD. How the hell are you going to do that? But anyway, right.
Speaker 2So he got 60% plan on practicing.
Speaker 1Yeah, so 40, he's no, so he says that 40%. Basically he's saying 40%. Don't plan on practicing and that's the number one reason why there's a shortage.
Speaker 2At what point are they not planning on practicing? Are they not planning on practicing when they're pre-med? Are they not planning on practicing once they get into med school? Like are medical schools asking pre-med students do you plan to practice? And 40 percent are like no, and they're admitting them anyway. Where is he getting this statistic? So, Dr Murphy, tell us where you're getting your statistic from.
Speaker 1I'd love to hear it. Interesting is the next thing he doubled down on it and said it should be mandated that, unless disabled, each medical school graduate should have to practice medicine full-time for 15 years minimum to refund the federal government for the cost of tuition you mean pay their student loans back. I don't get it I think that's the one that got people most like yeah.
Speaker 2Somebody got a free ride to school because maybe mommy and daddy paid. I don't know. Maybe that's the only reason that I can explain Like that's the only way I can explain that you don't that he doesn't understand how federal funds might work. You sure he doesn't understand.
Speaker 1You'd be surprised. I looked him up. He was at I think it was medical school, at Big East Brody School, whatever it is. He's a urologist up until 2017 and I think he started doing some non-profit work or for-profit work and then obviously now he's a congressman. But yo, some of this stuff has got me like he's part of the shortage problem?
Speaker 2He's not. He should get to work what you're doing in Congress, dr Murphy, get to work.
Speaker 1Unless he's trying to say that he's already done his 15 years.
Speaker 2I don't care, because listen, what makes so 15 years is an arbitrary number, right? What if we actually need all doctors to continue working for 25 years? I'm proposing 25 years. Dr Murphy, what you got on that? I think you should go back, leave Congress and go back to work. We need a lot of urologists. We got urology shortage.
Speaker 1So this obviously is problematic. Troll, troll, troll. I don't know where he's getting his statistics from. I don't know where he's getting his statistics from Because if you check Medscape, these numbers don't correlate with Medscape. They're for certain surveys, Satisfaction surveys or med school, what you plan on doing afterwards, type surveys. So that's really interesting, Right? The second part for me, that's the one where I'm just like okay, this is either he's just saying there's just to piss people off. There's no way he can believe that he's not saying it to piss people off.
Speaker 2I don't think. I think he has his own agenda right. Like listen, it's been nine days.
Speaker 1Technically he's not part of the. What do you call it?
Speaker 2I'm just saying it don't got to be part of the cabinet, it just has to be administration driven. It has been nine days Nine Nine days, guys, of what? Since inauguration? It's been nine days since inauguration.
Speaker 1Since this administration has taken nine days, it's been the longest year of my life, I would say this I think someone who is someone who is as educated as he is someone who's a urologist. I just have a hard time believing that he truly believes this.
Speaker 2Just because he went to school doesn't mean he's educated.
Speaker 1I don't think he knows. How can you? How can you?
Speaker 2Just because you went to school don't mean you're educated.
Speaker 1But if you went to school don't mean you're educated. But if you went to medical school in the united states, what thought process would you ever like? What part of going to medical school, applying to medical school, paying your loans or even someone paying your school tuition? Would you think that some, like the federal government, is paying your just?
Speaker 2because you went to medical school doesn't mean that you're actually educated, but this is what I'm saying that you were exposed to education.
Speaker 1It doesn't mean that you're actually educated.
Speaker 2But this is what I'm saying. It means that you were exposed to education. It doesn't mean that you were actually educated. Okay, because in order to be educated, then you have to say things that really warrant some merit of education behind it. I just wonder where he gets that.
Speaker 1I think he's being punitive on purpose. Of course he is. Yeah, I think he's being punitive on purpose. Of course he is. Yeah, I think he's like well, listen, if you don't practice for 15 years, then you have to. You know the penalty will be you have to pay back all these years in tuition, like. I think he's saying that on purpose because there's no way.
Speaker 2But how many people are getting a free ride on the federal government to medical school, like, let's really talk about that. Is it a lot or a little? I don't know. I don't know the federal government like outside of military folks. I don't think there are that many more people. Maybe National Health Service Corps, which those people already have a mechanism by which they pay back that you can't just jump ship. They make it real expensive for you to jump ship, because then you have to pay three times the amount?
Speaker 1The second thing that I was thinking was is he talking about residency?
Speaker 2No, but that's not tuition.
Speaker 1But then he specifically said tuition. So I'm like, well, what the hell is he talking about? And that's when I was like, ah, he's just being punitive on purpose, right. That's part of this administration. Like we're going to be as punitive as possible, we're going to say things, we're going to force you. You won't even get down. You either go along or you're going to get down, right, and I think that that's cause I can't see how this could be.
Speaker 2So it's disinformation on purpose, right? Yeah, I agree that what he said doesn't actually make sense, but it doesn't matter, because what he needs is to rile people up so that the next thing that he says becomes the thing that he actually wants people to do, right? So this is disinformation on purpose, because you can't tell me a physician a doctor is that stupid that he would actually think that what he said made any sense about. You know, you have to repay the government for your tuition. That's called repaying your student loans.
Speaker 2I don't get it. I don't get it. I'm like who's getting a free ride on the government?
Speaker 1Actually, the government is getting a free ride on you. Essentially, the government gets a free ride on you.
Speaker 2Exactly.
Speaker 1You put down all the sweat equity. All they do is just guarantee the student loan With interest and then you pay back that student loan in full With interest. So the federal government makes mad money off of this.
Speaker 2Exactly, it's a money maker for them.
Speaker 1Right, federal government makes mad money off of this. It's money for them. Like I said, the only thing that I can think of is that you know, when it comes down to residency training, the whole Medicare system pays like half, and then the med school pays the other half for your education as a resident.
Speaker 2But the way how you explained it, explain how residency works like in terms of because you work, yes, so right, it is illegal in the United States to be employed by somebody and not get paid for the work that you actually are doing. Residents are considered employees. They're not considered students. They're not getting money just for education, right? Otherwise what would be the point of resident unions, which we know that there are several resident unions around the country?
Speaker 2So they are employees. They're actually working when they are seeing patients. They generate dollars by seeing patients. So they are actually employees. So you can't say that they would even pay the Medicaid or Medicare dollars that pay for residency salaries. You can't even say that they would pay those back because it's like, well, but then I worked, so therefore you have to pay me.
Speaker 1I'm nervous, though I'm real nervous. You should be nervous, because folks like this. When they start to put up, it's almost like this is like the canary in the coal mine, like is someone working on legislation Of course they are so that, like this, something like this happens?
Speaker 1I don, of course they are Some type of penalty.
Speaker 2I mean, listen, this is what people, I think, need to understand. Like you are at the whim of whatever administration, whatever leader comes about Right, and so the notion of you know well, you know, we just got to, we just got it. It's like, listen, you can fight, you can do all the things you want, but at the end of the day, if an administration wants to see something, there is nothing that you are going to do in order to change a person's mind.
Speaker 2Their value may not be the same values that you have, and so we can't fool ourselves into thinking that you will protest or boycott or I don't know what else people are planning to do. Get enough names on a piece of paper for a petition or whatever to change people's minds who essentially want to see something done. Very specifically, what you have to be able to demonstrate to that person is the risk benefit ratio, because that's how these people work.
Speaker 2You have to show them that, listen, if you do this, it will be worse for you, because and usually that because has a dollar sign in front of it.
SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! I want to begin by honouring Javits Frimpong, the 15-year-old Ghanaian student who was fatally shot on his way to school in the Bronx....
SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! Most people can point to one year that changed everything. For me that year was 2012. I finished my trauma surgery fellowship in Miami....
SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! A first-year dental student posted a video on Instagram that stopped me cold. He's run out of federal funding. He's run out of private...
SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! Twenty years after medical school, I went back to Kansas City with Renee and our boys. Walking through the place where it all began...
SEND US A TEXT MESSAGE!!! Let Drs. Nii & Renee know what you think about the show! A first year general surgery resident slid into my DMs after our previous episode on how GHANA MADE ME BETTER. She’d been following the...